Juno News - February 17, 2023


Premiere of The Freedom Occupation

Topics
Mentioned
RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucki is retiring Canada’s pandemic panic: a retrospect (ft. Barry Cooper)

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 50 minutes

Words per minute

167.02

Word count

18,426

Sentence count

609

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On the eve of the release of the Public Order Emergency Commission report into the Freedom Occupation, filmmaker Rupa Subramanya and her co-producer Rachael Emanuel discuss the events that led up to the founding of the Freedom Convoy, and how the government misjudged the moment.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 It became pretty clear that these folks were not going to leave in a day or two.
00:00:15 I think that people were being told to be a lot more worried than the situation warranted.
00:00:21 In fact, it was excessively intimidating.
00:00:30 People were coming out and supporting this because they knew they had to.
00:00:36 And the potential for destruction was huge.
00:00:42 So our original plan was to stay until all mandates were lifted.
00:00:50 The folks who lived in the downtown core were terrorists.
00:01:00 It was clear there was no justification.
00:01:12 Well, they really misjudged the moment.
00:01:16 I think that's going to be a big problem for the government.
00:01:19 It's clear that Justin Trudeau invoked the Emergency Act as a political tool.
00:01:30 It became pretty clear that these folks were not going to leave in a day or two.
00:01:40 I think that people were being told to be a lot more worried than the situation warranted.
00:01:46 In fact, it was excessively intimidating.
00:01:48 People were coming out and supporting this because they knew they had to.
00:02:02 And the potential for destruction was huge.
00:02:08 So our original plan was to stay until all mandates were lifted.
00:02:12 the folks who lived in the downtown core were terror
00:02:19 it was clear there was no justification
00:02:31 well they really misjudged the moment i think that's going to be a big problem for the government
00:02:43 it's clear that justin trudeau invoked the emergency act as a political tool
00:03:01 It became pretty clear that these folks were not going to leave in a day or two.
00:03:05 I think that people were being told to be a lot more worried than the situation warranted.
00:03:10 In fact, it was excessively intimidating.
00:03:22 People were coming out and supporting this because they knew they had to.
00:03:26 And the potential for destruction was huge.
00:03:31 So our original plan was to stay until all mandates were lifted.
00:03:41 The folks who lived in the downtown core were terrorists.
00:03:54 It was clear there was no justification.
00:04:03 Well, they really misjudged the moment.
00:04:06 I think that's going to be a big problem for the government.
00:04:09 It's clear that Justin Trudeau invoked the Emergency Act as a political tool.
00:04:24 We'll be right back.
00:04:54 We'll be right back.
00:05:24 We'll be right back.
00:05:54 Transcription by CastingWords
00:06:24 Hello, everyone, and welcome to a very special presentation by True North.
00:06:36 It's not often that we get to roll out the virtual red carpet and premiere a film.
00:06:41 In fact, I don't think we've ever done that, either the film or the red carpet, virtual or otherwise.
00:06:46 But we are doing exactly that tonight.
00:06:49 and I am so very thrilled to have one of my colleagues in particular taking a front and
00:06:55 center role in telling a story that is near and dear to my heart and to those of many in our
00:07:01 audience and I would say to those of Canada as well and the one thing that I want to just say
00:07:08 before we get into the meat of what we're all here for which is the premiere of the documentary
00:07:13 the freedom occupation is that this is coming coincidentally at on the eve of the release of
00:07:20 the public order emergency commissions report into a lot of the things that are going to be
00:07:25 discussed in the film and discussion that you're going to see tonight so all of that is to say
00:07:29 that we have a fantastic discussion planned for you this evening i'm joined by filmmakers rachel
00:07:36 Emanuel and Johnny Emanuel, who are the producers of this and really the stars of the evening
00:07:43 program, and also my colleague at True North, Rupa Subramanya, who, like me, has the great
00:07:48 privilege of being featured in the documentary.
00:07:52 Both Rupa and I were interviewed for this, although I deliberately have not seen it yet,
00:07:57 and we're going to have a discussion beforehand.
00:07:59 We're going to watch it all together, and we're going to have a discussion afterwards,
00:08:02 and it will be very authentic on my part.
00:08:05 So if they've taken me out of context and photoshopped me into something very weird, I'll be seeing it for the first time alongside you.
00:08:12 But you can watch this all at the Freedom Occupations website, which is freedomoccupation.ca.
00:08:18 And you can see tonight in full, in just about 25 minutes or so, the Freedom Occupation, the movement that fueled a nation.
00:08:26 So without further ado, let's get this discussion going.
00:08:29 And I want to start with you, Rachel, and you, Johnny.
00:08:32 Now, I should say True North is distributing this. We're thrilled to be doing that.
00:08:36 But this was an initiative that you both took on on your own to tell this story.
00:08:41 So I don't know which one of you wants to take this first, but why did you do it?
00:08:46 Well, I'll jump in. And John, if you have anything to add, you can certainly add that afterwards.
00:08:51 Initially, it was just because a couple of months after the Freedom Convoy had ended, I actually was living in Alberta at this time.
00:08:57 And at this point, I started to hear there was a couple of groups that were working on documentaries.
00:09:01 and I was just thinking about all the really amazing footage that I had on my phone I was one
00:09:06 of the arguably few reporters that was at the very front when police actually came and pushed
00:09:10 protesters out of Ottawa and off of Parliament Hill and I had some really incredible footage of
00:09:15 that now I wasn't actually very well known as a reporter at that time I was still working
00:09:19 in the mainstream media for a pretty small and unknown outlet iPolitics and that that those
00:09:25 videos actually didn't get very much traction online if I posted them now with the following
00:09:30 that I had I think they would have certainly taken off and gone viral so they actually hadn't been
00:09:34 seen very much and I just thought man like it would be great if I could do something with this
00:09:38 and conveniently my brother Johnny was studying film and he was just about to finish at Fanshawe
00:09:43 with a degree in film studies which was something that he is very passionate about and had been
00:09:47 learning about for years so I just reached out to him and I said hey would you be interested in
00:09:51 working on this project with me I don't think we really realized how big it was going to get or
00:09:55 how much work it was going to take but it was kind of convenient that he had all this necessary
00:10:00 skills and i had some footage but also a lot of the contact the contacts that we needed to really
00:10:05 get this project underway yeah why was why were you wanting to get involved in this well it was
00:10:13 really convenient in the sense that as rachel mentioned i was just coming out of school i
00:10:16 just wrapped up some solo projects of myself um that i had done in school and i was kind of
00:10:21 thinking like what next what what's the next challenge and it was actually at our end of the
00:10:26 year film festival where rachel shot me a text it was like hey i have an idea like i have this
00:10:31 footage what do you think of making this a possibility and it was just like like the stars
00:10:36 aligned it was like absolutely let's make it happen and here we are i i know that you've seen
00:10:41 this yourself and i've certainly seen it so let's just deal with the elephant in the room right away
00:10:45 the name so as you well know occupation is a somewhat of a loaded term and i've seen some
00:10:51 people that are probably supportive of the convoy that have that have said they they question or in
00:10:56 some cases might not like that choice so what is it you're trying to convey and what do you mean
00:11:00 when you come out with the title the freedom occupation yeah that's a great question andrew
00:11:05 when jonathan and i discussed this project and agreed that we were going to do it it was very
00:11:09 important to us that we get both sides of the story now obviously working in center-right
00:11:15 conservative media you know I obviously have a bias and I don't hide that to viewers or to my
00:11:21 audience it's very obvious where I'm coming from but to me it was very important that we do get
00:11:25 both sides of the story and really talk to people who are impacted on both sides of your people who
00:11:30 lived in Ottawa and businesses and business owners as well as people who had had their
00:11:34 rights stripped away from them and were a part of the convoy so I think for me the name is really
00:11:38 a conversation starter i want people to see this documentary and be interested they know that true
00:11:44 north is distributing it obviously my name is attached to it people know who i am you know some
00:11:48 people not everybody so i think it's a conversation starter i think people look at this name and be
00:11:52 like huh what do they really mean by that and i think the name really pays homage to the fact that
00:11:57 we did want to show both sides of the story i think when you watch the documentary you'll see
00:12:01 that we actually had some people come back to us who watched it and said they thought we were too
00:12:06 too hard on the convoy at times or we portray too many people who are anti-convoy you know of
00:12:10 course we had other people who said the opposite it's been very interesting actually getting
00:12:13 feedback on this project how different opinions people have so far so i'm really excited to see
00:12:18 how it goes over but you know and i think the other interesting thing is also just sort of the
00:12:22 unique word play within the word occupation you know these are people and my brother was actually
00:12:26 the person who pointed this out who said they made it their job to go to ottawa and be heard
00:12:31 for the fact their restrictions and their liberties were taken away and andrew i 100 agree with you
00:12:36 that the term occupation has become a very loaded term but i think it's also worth asking the
00:12:41 question that if we're talking about a breach of civil liberties to the magnitude that we are where
00:12:46 people are actually being forced to put a foreign substance into their body that they were not
00:12:50 comfortable with and certainly we've learned a lot about what that substance is in recent days
00:12:54 and there's a lot of cause to be concerned would an occupation not be worth it at that cost then
00:12:59 to go to ottawa and to be heard so i think really for us it was a conversation starter
00:13:04 and i think the funny thing is that it also kind of annoys both groups because you can't use the
00:13:08 word freedom around people that are left-wing nowadays without them being triggered it's like
00:13:12 a dirty word to them now which is super funny and like you mentioned occupation has become a very
00:13:17 loaded dirty word for people in right-wing circles now yeah that's a great point so by the end of it
00:13:23 you'll have either alienated both sides or perhaps you'll have found the sweet spot and both sides
00:13:27 will love it. Let's discuss this from the film perspective for a moment, because Johnny, you know
00:13:34 better than anyone with your background that there was so much in the way of compelling visual
00:13:39 in the convoy. And you had so many people that were actually filming video that were
00:13:43 just on their own as streamers, as citizen journalists, as people that were there for
00:13:48 that were filming these things. And even in our little pre-roll intro, we have some footage from
00:13:52 my walkabouts there and some other things that happened in Ottawa. And it was just,
00:13:56 so there was so much to see so how do you use that to tell a visual story when there is just
00:14:02 so much that you can choose from as far as available footage plus what you filmed yourself
00:14:07 making it i think it comes down to incorporating the the footage at the right point i mean you gotta
00:14:12 you gotta lead them to it so you'll find we we try to set the stage and like because it's impossible
00:14:18 to recreate that atmosphere that's one thing i definitely caught in the footage it's just
00:14:22 the the magnitude the size of the crowd and the the amount of different activities going on you
00:14:27 know there were stages bouncy castles it was just it was a carnival that just sort of just
00:14:31 flooded the streets and so i mean it was very important that we try to encapsulate the atmosphere
00:14:37 without trying to do so in a way that seemed overly biased in its presentation and so yeah
00:14:42 i think it's just uh you know fluttered in delicately and appropriately the convoy was
00:14:48 three weeks in Ottawa, plus the week it was on its way to Ottawa, plus you had the spinoff events
00:14:55 that took place in Cootes and Windsor and Emerson and Surrey. You had the Emergencies Act. You had
00:15:00 the Public Order Emergency Commission. You have so many different threads here between the legal,
00:15:06 the political, the cultural, the chronological, the media bias. Which angle is it that you're
00:15:12 exploring? And I don't mean in terms of which perspective, but I guess which strain of this
00:15:17 story were you trying to follow yeah that was something we struggled with because there was
00:15:22 just so much to cover and I think initially we went into it a little bit blindly and tried to
00:15:26 ask our sources about a lot of different things we definitely only focused on the freedom convoy
00:15:31 within Ottawa we didn't touch on any of the spinoff stuff those are all well worth their own
00:15:36 you know full-length documentaries there was so much material here to cover we really covered you
00:15:41 know the mainstream media job of covering the freedom convoy and if they did an adequate job
00:15:46 of covering that. We also covered the police's work on pushing protesters off of Parliament Hill
00:15:52 and what that looked like, and also, you know, how that was spurred by the Emergencies Act and sort
00:15:56 of raised the question, was the Emergency Act justified its invocation? So I think really the
00:16:01 mainstream media job of covering the Freedom Convoy and how that went about, and maybe some
00:16:06 of the misinformation or bias that was caught in there. I mean, obviously we'll have some sources
00:16:10 within the docs say they think the mainstream media did a very adequate job of covering the
00:16:14 convoy, as well as some of the violence that we saw in protesters actually being pushed out and
00:16:19 really what the next step is moving forward. Let's broaden this discussion a little bit to
00:16:25 include my colleague at True North, Rupa Subramanya, who also is a co-guest, a co-interviewee
00:16:31 of the documentary. And if you're just tuning in, the premiere is going to be coming in about 15
00:16:36 minutes or so. So you haven't missed it. We're going to have a little bit more in the sense of
00:16:40 pre-discussion. We'll premiere the documentary for you, and then we'll have some post-analysis
00:16:46 as well. Rupa, you and I have spoken about this before. You were one of the only journalists that
00:16:51 came up with this revolutionary concept of talking to people, which before the convoy wasn't a
00:16:58 revolutionary concept, but during it, no one but you seemed to be interested in doing it. So how
00:17:03 do you feel now that this story is being told by more people and in a different way than when you
00:17:08 were just walking around alone having conversations and tweeting about them basically
00:17:13 it's a it's a real uh pleasure that uh you know it's a privilege that we're able to um
00:17:24 premiere this documentary and that i was part of it uh and along with you andrew uh well you know
00:17:30 that's interesting you know basically what i did was you know i was just chatting with people you
00:17:35 I had no agenda. I was just having a conversation with people, and I ended up speaking to a whole
00:17:40 bunch of people over the course of three weeks. And it's important that the story gets told over
00:17:46 and over and over again, especially those of us in the independent media space, because
00:17:54 it was such an important point in our history. It was one of the world's greatest protests,
00:18:04 in my opinion um uh for various reasons and and i think uh the fact that rachel and johnny have
00:18:11 this amazing documentary out is uh as you know you know one important way of chronicling what happened
00:18:18 uh uh in february of 2022 january february of 2022 and uh and i i know there are other
00:18:25 documentaries out there as well i know there are people working on books and documentaries and
00:18:30 films and and that's uh and that's pretty amazing and the more the better in my opinion
00:18:35 uh johnny i i know that there's this perception and i think it's perhaps a little bit deserved
00:18:40 maybe not as much as people think that the film industry is this overwhelmingly left-wing
00:18:45 environment and i'm just curious i know you're starting out your career but if
00:18:49 any of your colleagues in the film industry just kind of had their backs up against the wall when
00:18:53 they learned you were working on this sort of project well i mean i didn't have anyone's back
00:18:59 to the wall but i did try to preview it across a couple of colleagues of mine and unfortunately
00:19:03 those i mean you're not you're not wrong it is a very left uh left-leaning industry
00:19:08 and uh there were some turndowns unfortunately some people just felt too uh you know politically
00:19:15 charged or it was too triggering for them to even reopen the uh the can of worms so to speak so uh
00:19:21 yeah i mean i would say those um those reservations that you have of the film industry are absolutely
00:19:26 accurate is what it is though we're trying to challenge that what do you make of that rachel
00:19:30 that there are some people that whether they're in the film industry or not that just have this
00:19:35 baked in narrative where they don't even want to learn more about it i mean with my book i
00:19:40 encountered that people that said no i know everything i need to know i don't want to read
00:19:43 the book and you know there are going to be some people that say no i already know i don't like
00:19:47 them i don't need a documentary to tell me anything about it but do you think they're the
00:19:50 minority and and that most people actually could have an open mind about this
00:19:55 yes i do think they're the minority and i think that it's important for us not to get so held up
00:20:02 on these people that don't want to give us a time of day and don't want to have discourse and these
00:20:08 conversations that we don't forget that there are a lot of people who are critical thinkers
00:20:12 and are willing to hear both sides of the stories and not forget to appeal to those people as well
00:20:17 and sometimes we can get so turned off by the other side so to speak that you know we kind of
00:20:22 forget to stop trying and just kind of exist within our own worlds but politics is downstream
00:20:27 of culture and I think it's important and this is just I think a general life rule that when you go
00:20:31 around in your society that you're the type of person that is willing to engage with other people
00:20:35 from all walks of life and I think that if we want to see change in our political sphere it needs to
00:20:39 start with us and how we interact in our communities and just to sort of add to what
00:20:43 Jonathan was saying there it was actually quite a funny instance because he had asked someone to
00:20:46 review the project for us and I think they got about seven minutes into it um and then they
00:20:51 turned it off and said they just couldn't watch it it was just apparently too biased um which was
00:20:56 hilarious thinking about it now but at the time I think we were both like what are we gonna do
00:21:00 and I think it actually led to a whole reworking of the intro so um but yeah I mean I think probably
00:21:07 in retrospect I don't know how much it is really worth to appeal to these type of people that
00:21:11 obviously are not interested in having the conversation to begin with let me ask you this
00:21:16 question Rupa because you like me are going into this a bit blind so you don't you know the story
00:21:21 of the convoy through the lens that you've approached it with but you haven't seen the
00:21:24 documentary what are the questions that you would have as a viewer that you would like this
00:21:29 documentary to answer or at least contribute to the discourse around well you know I think I think
00:21:35 you started off by asking a very interesting question and this is a question I've been getting
00:21:40 from many people from you know in anticipation of this of the documentary premiering this evening
00:21:47 is that why the word occupation in the title, and Rachel's answer to that was, I think, struck the
00:21:54 right balance. And I sense that that's what the documentary is going to be doing. I think it's
00:22:00 going to be a conversation starter, which is a great, which is what I would like to happen.
00:22:07 Look, unfortunately, we're all in this echo chamber. We all agree with each other. We all
00:22:13 agree that the Freedom Convoy was one of the greatest protests. It was a legitimate right.
00:22:18 They had a legitimate right to civil disobedience, to protest. They were peaceful. Andrew, you and I
00:22:24 spoke to, you know, hundreds of people during the protests over those three weeks. And since then,
00:22:30 we've spoken to many more and we've covered this quite extensively. So there's no question that
00:22:37 you and I agree that the, you know, what the protests were about. But I really think it's
00:22:42 important for us to get out of our echo chamber um and and and for and invite more people into
00:22:48 the conversation because that's what's lacking right now in my opinion it's become so incredibly
00:22:53 polarized um uh that uh you know everybody seems to just be in their own corner when in fact what
00:23:00 i want people to do is i want them to um you know you know come to the middle uh on the issue uh you
00:23:09 know yes I mean people were inconvenienced in Ottawa I live in Ottawa I live in downtown Ottawa
00:23:13 um I for that first weekend I certainly uh was inconvenienced it was quite loud there was no
00:23:19 question about it I am 100 honest about it uh but at the same time um I think that the right to
00:23:26 a protest and civil disobedience is integral to a well-functioning democracy without that we don't
00:23:32 have anything. And these are people who are standing up for our basic rights, and courageously
00:23:41 so, and I applaud them for it. But I think it's also important, and I'm hoping that Rachel's
00:23:49 documentary, if she says it's going to be a conversation starter, I'm hoping that that's
00:23:54 precisely what it what it does because we need to bring in more people onto it to the middle and see
00:24:02 the protest for what they were these were not a bunch of Jagmeet Singh these were not people who
00:24:07 are here to overthrow the government FYI even the public order the commission into the the public
00:24:13 inquiry into the emergencies act you know all of the top police chiefs the OPP the RCMP every
00:24:20 ceases everybody agreed that this was basically a peaceful protest um and there was no security
00:24:28 threat to the country um and and i think that needs to be established firmly and uh and then
00:24:35 and then and invite more people into the conversation yeah i mean you mentioned rachel
00:24:40 that you wanted to start a conversation about it and my colleague tells me that in the comment
00:24:45 section you've certainly done that because there's a very raucous debate going on about the word
00:24:48 occupation now so before they've even seen it I think you've achieved part of your mission there
00:24:53 I don't know Rachel or Johnny if one or both of you wants to take this specifically but
00:24:58 one question that I would ask because you've been working on this for such a long time the
00:25:02 convoy was 13 months ago that it began you started working on this not long after it so you've had
00:25:09 let's say almost a year here has your perspective or approach either on the event itself or how to
00:25:16 cover it changed in the time that you've been working on it? Oh, that's a really good question.
00:25:23 I wouldn't say so. I think there was a period in the summer where we had done our first half of
00:25:29 filming in Ottawa. I had flown back to Ottawa. I'd already been living in Alberta at this point.
00:25:34 Jonathan met me there. We did our first half of filming and I think that was in the early stages
00:25:38 of the project and things at that point were coming together really well. And then there was
00:25:43 a lull where summer got really busy here in alberta we had the united conservative party
00:25:48 leadership race that i was pretty busy with and jonathan was pretty busy and we kind of like put
00:25:53 it to the side for a pretty long time and i think we both had a moment of is this actually going to
00:25:58 happen is this going to get finished but jonathan had looked over a lot of the footage at this point
00:26:02 and he said no we have something really good here we need to make sure that we use this but it was
00:26:06 extremely complicated and difficult to find sources that were not like pro convoy to come
00:26:12 the documentary i would say that was actually one of the biggest challenges that we had because i
00:26:16 was reaching out and asking people to do the interviews and you know people knew who i was
00:26:21 and there was a lot of people on the left who if i had asked them a couple months earlier while i
00:26:25 had still worked within the mainstream media i'm sure they would have agreed to an interview but
00:26:28 you know a few short weeks later i had made my position known and so that was really challenging
00:26:32 and we had a moment where i think we were going to maybe just do the documentary in a different
00:26:37 style because we didn't think that we could get the interviews and then sort of at the last minute
00:26:41 we were able to secure a couple and get that balance that we were looking for but i think
00:26:45 you know other than that brief law we were pretty focused on what we were wanted to what we wanted
00:26:50 to do and then the only thing was just what footage to include and what topics to cover
00:26:54 because as we've mentioned there was just it was there's so much and i'm glad there's so much being
00:26:58 made about it because there's so many unique aspects to the convoys and so many unique stories
00:27:04 even within this one broader story that needs to be told and you know rupa was one of those people
00:27:08 who was on the streets interviewing truckers all the time and i think it's great we got so
00:27:11 many of those stories out there but there's still a lot we don't know and there's still a lot to be
00:27:15 told does that track with your experience johnny as well yeah it's similar i'd say like you know
00:27:21 when i initially the the mindset has always kind of been the same in terms of why we set out to do
00:27:26 this um but how we wanted to say it i think was what actually evolved in the sense of originally
00:27:32 the idea was to sort of keep our voices out with out of the film as much as possible we wanted to
00:27:38 go with a completely objective approach in order to sort of appeal to both sides but further on as
00:27:43 the project progressed i sort of realized you know like this a that that loses the artistic touch
00:27:48 that uh filmmakers bring to their their craft you know your voice needs to be at least shared in a
00:27:55 in a in a artistic way and you know if you have something to say then you should say it i think
00:27:59 think it's how you go about saying it which is really important so uh yeah i mean originally it
00:28:04 was like try to stay as unbiased and objective as possible but then it sort of came down to it's
00:28:08 like no there's a message behind this and we do stand behind the trucker convoy and that should
00:28:13 be that should resonate with viewers i do think that issue you identified rachel is a fascinating
00:28:19 one of having difficulty finding sources coming that wanted to criticize it i i know justin ling
00:28:25 the freelance journalist is in this and he and I despite drastic different drastically different
00:28:31 approaches to the world have gotten along and have interviewed each other and and without issue and
00:28:36 every time we have each of our respective supporters is mortified that we dare talk to the
00:28:41 other so when he had me on to talk about my book his audience are like I'm unsubscribing you're
00:28:45 platforming that terrible person that convoy propagandist and I had people saying how dare
00:28:50 you talk to him you're a sellout and and I do think that that's been one of the problems with
00:28:54 the convoy is that there have been a lot of people that have their baked in perspective. They refuse
00:28:59 to not even just agree with the other side, but just respect that there is another side. And I get
00:29:06 from what you've said, Rachel, that you're not trying to force people to believe a certain thing,
00:29:09 but do you want people to at least say, you know, I understand the other perspective a bit more. I
00:29:14 understand where they're coming from a bit more. Yeah, absolutely. And as we spoke about earlier,
00:29:19 just that need to still be willing to have dialogues with people that you don't agree with.
00:29:23 And, you know, you mentioned some of your subscribers saying, oh, I'm subscribing, like, I'm disappointed that you would have an interview with Justin Ling. But I think that's kind of what we don't want to lose. We don't want to lose that ability to have dialogue with one another. I don't think we're going to see the progress in our country that we want to see if that's the attitude that we have. And, you know, I actually reached out to Justin Ling on Andrew's sort of suggestion.
00:29:44 I mentioned I'm having a really hard time finding you know someone who's going to be critical of the
00:29:48 convoy and you know Andrew mentioned Andrew suggested Justin and he agreed to it which I
00:29:53 was pleasantly surprised to I think that our viewers will also be you know a bit surprised
00:29:57 I felt that there were I felt he actually gave you know really reasonable at you know at times
00:30:02 really reasonable sort of perspective on things he gave a really good analysis of mainstream media
00:30:08 coverage of it a lot of times so I don't think people will be too I think people might be pleasantly
00:30:13 surprised at times you know there was other things that he said that i know people will be really
00:30:16 upset by but i i felt like he was actually a pretty strong voice um for the middle for the
00:30:22 middle throughout throughout the convoy and maybe you have a different perspective jonathan but we
00:30:26 did have another voice in the project who was much more against the convoy but it felt like justin
00:30:30 did a good job of sort of presenting what people in the middle would have felt jonathan did you
00:30:36 want to pick that up no no yeah i think she nailed it i mean he was a very balanced voice
00:30:41 yeah, no. Oh, you've called Justin Ling balance now. I don't even think Justin Ling wants that
00:30:46 endorsement from True North. Rupa, one thing that we mentioned earlier was your conversations with
00:30:54 people and putting a human face on this. And I think that was always one of the big challenges
00:30:59 for people in the country that wanted to get news about the convoy is that you had the media that
00:31:04 was saying Pat King is the face of the convoy or James Botter is the face of the convoy.
00:31:09 and you had thousands and tens of thousands and if you extend it to people that were just supporters
00:31:14 or observers millions of people who were never in the news their faces were not known their names
00:31:20 were not known their stories were not known but they were a big part of this and I would actually
00:31:24 say they were the real backbone of the convoy the not the people at the top that are the people the
00:31:30 media like to say were at the top but the real people that aligned with this movement and it's
00:31:34 been very difficult for those people's stories to be told. Yeah, absolutely. And that was what
00:31:40 made the protest for me. You know, I did interact with some of the convoy organizers over the course
00:31:48 of those three weeks. I went to some of their pressers. But, and to be fair to them, they
00:31:55 didn't really, they also kind of stayed in the background, you know, and let, you know, the
00:32:03 protests speak for itself and uh and and i thought that was very interesting because oftentimes when
00:32:10 you have um when you have a large protest movement like this you have organizers who
00:32:16 want to just basically hijack the movement and they become the face of the protests and
00:32:20 nobody cares about the protesters themselves or even the cause for that matter but what ended up
00:32:25 happening here was that it was actually focused on the average canadian who showed up to protest
00:32:31 and that's uh those are the people that i spoke to uh from the first day i stepped out of my
00:32:36 apartment here in ottawa uh to the very end to the you know i was there till the very end till when
00:32:42 when law enforcement was you know they were pushing the protesters back i stayed um until
00:32:48 till that that last day and it was all about them it was all about these people who had journeyed
00:32:55 all from all over the country from alberta from new brunswick from newfoundland from quebec from
00:33:00 everywhere and they all spoke one common language and that language was a freedom um you know and
00:33:06 it was an extraordinary moment in this country and uh and what what was um sad and disappointing uh
00:33:13 well there were many sad and disappointing features uh aspects of uh those three weeks uh
00:33:18 one of them being the media coverage of it um you know i didn't think any of it was really balanced
00:33:24 um uh and uh you know they had an agenda right from the get-go and they kept doubling down on
00:33:29 that agenda and of course what led to uh you know and what led to the invocation of the emergencies
00:33:35 act uh which was um unnecessary and uh it was uh highly problematic um but but through through it
00:33:43 all through it all it was a very canadian protest and that needs to be emphasized over and over
00:33:49 again because these were peaceful people um coming you know doubling down on love and joy
00:33:56 and peace and hope and freedom uh whereas the other guys were doubling down on hate um
00:34:04 vilification of the other um and uh and denigration of the other and uh and that contrast
00:34:11 uh was was quite striking to me and that's still going on to this day i mean i
00:34:16 if i say anything positive about the freedom protests um a year later i still get a lot of
00:34:23 hate uh saying that you know this was an occupation and the these were terrorists and they were here to
00:34:28 overthrow the government uh but you know that just shows you how polarized everything has become in
00:34:34 this country how divisive everything has become and this is why uh it's extremely important that we
00:34:40 um you know we we strike a balance somehow and it's great that you and rachel reached out to
00:34:45 justin ling um and you know and and you know and you've had a conversation with him or more than
00:34:51 in a conversation uh here and there but you know i i think that uh that kind of um reaching across
00:34:58 the aisle so to speak is extremely important as we go forward um uh because i i don't think it's
00:35:04 sustainable the way things are right now where you know everybody is just uh hating the other
00:35:10 um i don't think that makes for a good um future as far as i'm concerned all right well very very
00:35:18 wonderful note to uh wind down our pre-show discussion here just before we get to the main
00:35:23 event i'll go back to the filmmakers here rachel and johnny anything you want to say to set the
00:35:28 scene before we roll your documentary for the first time i think is that a no enjoy sorry i
00:35:41 can't actually see you for where i'm looking right now so if you were shaking your head i uh
00:35:44 I missed it, but hearing no comments, as they say in the House of Commons,
00:35:49 it is my great privilege on behalf of the True North team
00:35:52 and the filmmakers from Emanuel Productions here to present for the first time
00:35:56 the freedom occupation, the movement that fueled a nation.
00:36:14 I've got to step away for like half a second, but you can reach me on Slack.
00:36:33 Growing anxiety this morning
00:36:41 about the COVID-19 trend in Canada
00:36:44 as we take a look at the numbers.
00:36:48 The CDC said it is working on new guidance from mask wearing.
00:36:52 Before you go anywhere, you're going to need a poll.
00:36:54 The federal government is warning the rules may change again.
00:36:57 Mayor Jim Watson is declaring a state of emergency
00:36:59 to give the city more flexibility.
00:37:01 Ottawa has declared a state of emergency.
00:37:04 The city of Ottawa has declared a state of emergency.
00:37:07 That's because of ongoing protests there by truck drivers and their supporters.
00:37:10 It's being blocked by truckers protesting vaccine rules.
00:37:13 But what's currently happening there is unprecedented.
00:37:18 So over the last two weeks have tried tactics never seen before in Canada.
00:37:23 People were coming out and supporting this because they knew they had to.
00:37:28 All Canadians must act now.
00:37:31 And the potential for destruction was huge.
00:37:35 The convoy is attracting supporters with a wide range of views.
00:37:38 And I thought to myself, well, they really misjudged the moment.
00:37:41 The folks who live in the downtown core were terrorized.
00:37:50 It was clear there was no justification for it.
00:37:53 You don't just show up with all these trucks and take over downtown.
00:38:00 I don't believe it became illegal until the Emergencies Act was actually put in place.
00:38:05 They needed to use the Emergencies Act to declare the protest illegal.
00:38:30 Yeah, I can describe what it was like pulling into Ottawa with a convoy.
00:38:40 It was unbelievable.
00:38:41 The emotions were crazy busy, trying to be organized.
00:38:46 Not knowing how many trucks, cars were behind you was an awesome feeling.
00:38:51 The excitement level was really high for everybody.
00:38:54 I had my son in the truck with me and yeah, he wanted the horn being honked all the time.
00:39:02 It was just an emotional wow in the fact that there were so many people with flags standing on the bridges.
00:39:10 And yeah, it brought emotions out that my wife and I will never experience again.
00:39:18 It was a beautiful, exciting time.
00:39:24 Thank you.
00:39:54 the freedom convoy happened because you had this growing segment of the population that was
00:40:11 absolutely tired of covid restrictions not just from the federal government and the provincial
00:40:17 government but i think a lot of the narratives around them that we saw increasingly with the
00:40:22 convoy even i mean justin trudeau calling them a fringe minority uh going back early in ontario
00:40:27 to being called a bunch of yahoo so people felt like they were increasingly being excluded from
00:40:32 society and the convoy wasn't just a protest against the restrictions themselves but i think
00:40:38 also the media's depictions of the people that were forming the convoy i'm here because on january
00:40:44 26 2022 i lost my nursing job after 12 years yeah when the truckers first arrived uh it was more of
00:40:53 a novelty and and the reason is is i think most people were under the impression i wouldn't say
00:40:58 to what extent they've been led to believe but they were under the impression that this was going
00:41:03 to last a weekend i really didn't know if it was going to last more than a weekend or not from my
00:41:07 mind it was 50 50. there were folks who seemed a little bit less committed to the cause who wanted
00:41:13 to come out and protest against vaccine mandates,
00:41:16 in cases against vaccines, against lockdowns,
00:41:18 against masks, mask mandates, and it wasn't clear
00:41:22 whether or not the majority were folks who were more dedicated,
00:41:25 more hardcore, more willing to sacrifice,
00:41:27 or whether it was folks who just wanted a big public demonstration,
00:41:30 a protest, some civil disobedience,
00:41:32 but really could have gone many different directions.
00:41:35 A lot of people are losing their jobs and their livelihoods.
00:41:37 That's not okay, so.
00:41:38 I'm here because I would like to see change happen,
00:41:40 and I want to see it done in a peaceful manner.
00:41:42 I think this is a great way to do it.
00:41:44 This is democracy.
00:41:45 This is what democracy is all about.
00:41:47 People believe that the government has overstepped with mandates
00:41:52 and they're here to exercise their democratic right.
00:41:57 Yeah, I joined the convoy because we've been having a frustrating two years.
00:42:03 Society has been, COVID definitely has been tough on society
00:42:06 and the restrictions have been tough as well.
00:42:09 As the information comes out, we can see that they're not working.
00:42:13 They actually are doing more harm than good.
00:42:16 So that's why we decided to join the convoy,
00:42:19 thought it was a protest that we could support.
00:42:22 That was incredible.
00:42:23 It's hard not to look back and just smile about that, right?
00:42:26 There was joy, peace, kindness.
00:42:31 Canadians are just beauties.
00:42:33 I mean, at the end of the day, that was like Canada Day on steroids.
00:42:39 This is affecting all of us, so it's a widespread thing.
00:42:43 It's not just one community.
00:42:45 I think a lot of Canadians are worried about what's happening with our country
00:42:48 and are worried about the direction that policies are heading.
00:42:51 Don't be controlled by the government.
00:42:54 We are the ones that control ourselves.
00:42:57 Because if it's lost, you know, the next generation won't be around.
00:43:01 That's all it is.
00:43:04 This is not what happened.
00:43:05 These people came with very big machines.
00:43:07 They came with huge trucks. Most of them had big, they were transport trucks. They were big and the potential for destruction was huge.
00:43:17 Like I remember thinking that if ever anything happened, if ever any of these people decided that they were going to be violent, the damage would have been enormous.
00:43:28 And what I mean is if you have these trucks, they can easily be destroying buildings, destroying Parliament Hill, they could destroy anything.
00:43:35 Nothing will stop these trucks.
00:43:37 And I remember walking from my car where I was parked
00:43:41 because obviously I couldn't come downtown.
00:43:43 So I was parked in the market and I would walk.
00:43:46 And I was walking and I remember, and it didn't take very long,
00:43:50 that it was tantamount to a war zone.
00:43:56 I don't know if it's fair to say that Ottawa residents were genuinely concerned for their safety,
00:44:02 I think certainly there was an uncertainty when this all started of what it was going to look like,
00:44:08 because you had the media that was advancing this narrative of a January 6th-style insurrection, of some violent protest.
00:44:15 Look at what happened in the States on January 6th, what happened.
00:44:18 A bunch of people decided they were going to storm Congress, which is what they did.
00:44:25 Now, what is the difference between that situation and ours?
00:44:29 At first they came for the pastors, and then the owners of the businesses, and then the frontline workers, and now they have touched the nerve because here are the truckers.
00:44:38 I tend to agree with CSIS' assessment, the Integrated Terrorism Assessment Centre, which is kind of an open source reporting mechanism that reports to police, reports to domestic law enforcement agencies.
00:44:48 It basically said there was no concrete threat, there was nobody proposing an attack, but that the possibility of an individual going rogue, an individual committing attack was present.
00:44:58 At no point did I see any of the organizers, any of the organizations at the core of this
00:45:05 talk about any sort of direct state violence or start putting together the pieces that would
00:45:12 be necessary to carry out an attack like that. Nothing I saw there led me to believe that an
00:45:17 attack was imminent, but the conditions were right for someone to lose it.
00:45:21 Freedom! Freedom! Freedom! Freedom! Freedom! Freedom! Freedom!
00:45:26 And I remember that there were these individuals, these individuals that were on different corners, all of a sudden they'd step out of a car, and their purpose was to intimidate me.
00:45:36 I remember them looking at me, trying to give the impression that they were sort of in control. To what extent did I have a right to be there? And that was scary. It was scary because when that would happen, I was always thinking it wouldn't take much and it wouldn't take long.
00:45:54 And I mean that, because when you look at all the violence that has occurred, great moments of violence in the history of Canada and North America, it all starts with a little something happening.
00:46:06 And that little something could have happened any time, and the consequences would have been huge.
00:46:11 Yeah, the residents of Ottawa feeling unsafe, I just have a hard time understanding where that came from.
00:46:18 I feel like they should have come to the protest and seen it for themselves.
00:46:24 They must have been listening to too much of the legacy media because you couldn't have been there and felt there wasn't a sense of peace.
00:46:35 Lord, we ask that you would undertake. Father, you are able to do it, dear Father. Help her, dear God.
00:46:42 They should have showed up.
00:46:44 When I got to Ottawa, I flew into Ottawa because I just didn't know if I'd be able to drive in or drive out.
00:46:50 with the traffic my taxi driver was nervous about driving downtown because he had heard
00:46:55 and he was listening to CBC radio which may have contributed but he was nervous and said well I
00:47:00 might not be able to drive you up there not because of traffic but because of safety so
00:47:04 I think that people were being told to be a lot more worried than the situation warranted
00:47:09 One of the big frustrations I had is that the media's coverage of the convoy went through
00:47:20 different stages. At first, they just completely ignored it. And then they were speaking about it
00:47:25 in a way that made it clear they didn't really understand what it was about. I mean, some of the
00:47:29 early coverage, anti-vaccine protests, which was never the case. It was an anti-vaccine mandate
00:47:35 protest, and then the violent narrative.
00:47:38 So large sections of the mainstream media failed to cover the protests objectively.
00:47:44 They were pushing a narrative, an agenda, which was contrary to anything that I had
00:47:51 experienced for the three weeks of the protestors were here.
00:47:55 There was a dereliction of duty.
00:47:57 This was an important moment in this country's cultural history, and they were not covering
00:48:02 it.
00:48:03 They were covering something else.
00:48:04 In this current crisis with Russia, I don't know if it's far-fetched to ask, but there is concern that Russian actors could be continuing to fuel things as this protest grows, but perhaps even instigating it from the outset.
00:48:21 So it was clear that they were missing the mark at every stage of it.
00:48:25 When I started covering it and was comparing what I was seeing on the ground with the media coverage I'd see when I went back on my computer, I was astonished at how two people could look at the same situation and draw such vastly different conclusions.
00:48:39 And I think one of the biggest examples of this is the media's focus on these little outliers that really didn't characterize the convoy story, like the Terry Fox statue or, you know, the so-called stealing food from the homeless incident or the stuff at the war memorial or this attempted arson in an apartment building.
00:48:57 All of these things that either did not happen or did not happen in the way that they were reported.
00:49:02 So the attempted arson story was, I think, a turning point in the protests because a few days later, the prime minister decided to invoke the Emergencies Act because the incident spoke to the safety aspects of the protests where residents said that they were afraid of stepping out of their homes.
00:49:26 And they attributed this to the protesters in very explicit terms.
00:49:32 And very quickly, as soon as this post became viral, the politicians, including the mayor of the city, several journalists,
00:49:40 also gave oxygen to this allegation that the protesters were behind this attempted arson.
00:49:48 The police hadn't even begun their investigation at this point.
00:49:50 It was still very early days, but already this narrative had taken hold that residents
00:49:55 of the city were unsafe and that the protesters were going around setting buildings on fire.
00:50:01 Yesterday, we learned of a horrific story that clearly demonstrates the malicious intent
00:50:06 of these protesters occupying our city.
00:50:10 At 5 a.m., and this was captured on the building's video, on Sunday morning, two young guys
00:50:15 in the lobby of the building on Lisker Street, where they proceeded to light fire starter
00:50:19 bricks near the elevators before taping up the door handles so residents would struggle
00:50:25 to get out during a fire when the police concluded their investigation they said that the alleged
00:50:30 arsonist had nothing to do with the protesters or the truckers so that story was effectively
00:50:35 debunked and i can think of several other such stories that just uh you know were debunked in
00:50:41 very similar ways there was a story early on i think it was like the first day or the second day
00:50:46 when the convoy had arrived in ottawa that there was a report that convoy protesters had been
00:50:51 stealing food from a homeless shelter and i mean certainly it's entirely possible that a couple of
00:50:58 people that arrived at the convoy went to a homeless shelter and and caused damage but what
00:51:02 was missing from that story is that as soon as convoy organizers learned that there was a
00:51:08 supposed incident they flooded this shelter with food they brought so much food that uh to this
00:51:14 and other shelters that they said we can't accommodate all of this and then they were
00:51:17 firing up grills on the street and feeding the homeless for weeks and in some cases
00:51:21 even housing homeless people so it was a very significant misrepresentation of the atmosphere
00:51:28 that the convoy supporters and organizers tried to cultivate which was one of giving not taking
00:51:33 oh peace and love out here absolutely nobody's been disrespectful at all you got people walking
00:51:39 around picking up garbage that's on the ground everybody's fun smiling enjoying seeing people's
00:51:45 faces think about the terry fox story what the media did with the terry fox story is just
00:51:51 indescribable really they somebody put a sign on him and a canadian flag how many times have
00:51:57 we not seen terry fox dressed in other protests it's a bit of an unfair yeah i guess description
00:52:09 There was times when the coverage lacked curiosity, where you had reporters who would hear one of the organizers say, I'm not against vaccines, and then the mainstream press would go and say, well, the organizers aren't necessarily against vaccines.
00:52:25 We know that's nonsense.
00:52:26 Without fail, every single one of the organizers, the main organizers, the main influencers in this convoy were anti-vaccines and spread anti-vaccine misinformation.
00:52:34 So I think in some cases, the mainstream media was not critical enough of the convoy, the organizers, the influencers.
00:52:40 But there was also a ton of instances where mainstream coverage was critical to a lazy degree.
00:52:48 You saw this rhetoric that foreign money, that maybe Russian disinformation was feeding the convoy.
00:52:54 There's virtually zero basis for that.
00:52:57 I don't think we've identified a single dollar of Russian money that wound up anywhere around the convoy or the occupation.
00:53:03 I've seen nothing since the mainstream coverage of the media to lead me to believe that what was being covered was not true.
00:53:13 In fact, what I've seen is I've seen more of an attempt by the organizers, and I use the word organizers loosely,
00:53:23 those that were the face of the protest, trying to, in fact, change the narrative
00:53:30 as to what was actually being said and being done at the time the convoy was in place
00:53:37 or was basically anchored here in Ottawa.
00:53:40 There was also instances where it was reported, sort of without caveat,
00:53:45 that the whole movement was leading insurrection,
00:53:48 or that the entire occupation was there to overturn the government.
00:53:52 There's a lot of nuance required when you introduce an idea like that,
00:53:55 because yes, at the core of the convoy was a document that basically sought to supplant the democratic government of Canada.
00:54:03 That is accurate. There are individuals who wanted to remove the government and try them for treason.
00:54:07 there is a running theory inside the convoy that the government was illegitimate or undemocratic
00:54:13 or ought to be deposed. You can report on that. But to just say, writ large, the entire aim of
00:54:20 the movement is to overturn the government, to lead an insurrection, it's not factually accurate.
00:54:24 People give the government the power to act in accordance with their values.
00:54:30 Nobody should be forced to take an experimental treatment. And, you know, it's a matter of
00:54:36 personal choice. The government does not have any independent power. It is us that confer the power
00:54:42 on the government. And where they overstep, the people have a right to voice their opinions.
00:54:47 So there's a lot of questions need to be answered about public health in this country.
00:54:51 And the people have had enough.
00:54:53 When I think about the Nazi paraphernalia that came to the protest is
00:55:08 you're going to have a bad apple in every crew. 0.96
00:55:12 I cannot imagine a single protest where you don't have a goofball. 0.63
00:55:18 I have a hard time believing that it was a true protester.
00:55:24 I believe it was probably a plant.
00:55:26 I'll never be able to prove that.
00:55:28 But they didn't stick around long.
00:55:31 So you have to imagine that it was there for the photo op and carry on.
00:55:37 They're almost under the impression, it seems to me,
00:55:40 and that's what they're trying to portray,
00:55:42 that what we're looking at in this whole,
00:55:44 in the hearings under the Emergency Act,
00:55:46 is we're trying to determine whether or not what they did was justified.
00:55:51 That's not at all what's going on.
00:55:52 It's clear that what they did was not justified.
00:55:54 The question becomes, was it sufficient what they were doing
00:55:58 that was not justified to invoke the Emergency Act?
00:56:01 That's the question.
00:56:06 After discussing with Cabinet and caucus,
00:56:11 after consultation with premiers from all provinces and territories,
00:56:16 After speaking with opposition leaders, the federal government has invoked the Emergencies Act
00:56:25 to supplement provincial and territorial capacity to address the blockades and occupations.
00:56:36 So on that Friday of the last weekend, basically the last Friday of the convoy,
00:56:41 I was quite taken by how slowly it was moving in the morning.
00:56:47 Obviously, police were showing up from all across the country.
00:56:50 They were moving themselves into formations.
00:56:53 And starting a few blocks east of Parliament Hill, down at the Rideau and Sussex area,
00:56:59 police were moving forward, but it was ever so slowly.
00:57:02 They'd advance, you know, maybe six, eight feet every 10 to 15 minutes.
00:57:06 And they would do this all morning, so much so that it took hours and hours.
00:57:11 and they had barely covered any ground at all.
00:57:14 The people who hate you and want police defunded
00:57:16 and they'll Monday morning quarterback every arrest you ever make.
00:57:19 So looking at that, a lot of the protesters were saying,
00:57:22 well, we've got all weekend.
00:57:23 I mean, they're not going to even get to Parliament Hill this weekend,
00:57:27 let alone break it up.
00:57:28 Obviously, we know that wasn't the case.
00:57:30 Hold the line!
00:57:30 Move back, move back, move back, move back, move back, hold down, hold the line.
00:57:39 On the Friday morning, most of the interactions I saw between police and protesters were fairly normal.
00:57:48 Police had their line, they were moving people forward.
00:57:50 Every now and then you'd get a protester that didn't want to move back and they'd get pushed back with a baton at least.
00:57:55 but it looked fairly standard for you know riot policing and I don't mean riot describing it but
00:58:07 just the the way that police call it and that by the afternoon had changed more people had shown
00:58:14 up in Ottawa there had been more tension there was more law enforcement it stopped looking like
00:58:20 a standard policing operation and to a lot of people started looking like a military operation
00:58:25 just because of the formations and the uniforms and the refusal by a lot of police to even,
00:58:30 you know, speak to protesters. There was just this stone-faced approach.
00:58:43 Police in Canada are too quick to use force in crowd control situations.
00:58:56 No, No!
00:59:06 No, No, No!
00:59:22 Thank you!
00:59:22 Come back!
00:59:27 Move back!
00:59:29 Come back!
00:59:32 Come back!
00:59:37 More! 0.98
00:59:41 Move! 0.89
00:59:43 Move, move, move!
00:59:49 I think the use of mounted units, officers on horseback, 0.99
00:59:55 is one of the most stupid and dangerous things a police service can do 0.98
00:59:58 in a volatile crowd situation like this. 1.00
01:00:01 It was incredibly dangerous.
01:00:02 It was done to try and push back a crowd in a way that was completely not warranted
01:00:08 and it led to a woman getting injured. 1.00
01:00:09 Oh, come on through. Come on through. 1.00
01:00:12 What is happening here?
01:00:14 Wow. What is this lady doing? 1.00
01:00:17 Traffling. Traffling horses. 1.00
01:00:18 Stop it! Stop it! 0.99
01:00:20 Stop it!
01:00:22 Oh my God! 0.63
01:00:24 What the hell is that?
01:00:26 I mean, we've all seen the viral video 1.00
01:00:28 of Candace Serrow getting trampled by the horses. 0.93
01:00:32 She had her mobility walker knocked down
01:00:34 and she was trampled and she sustained injuries.
01:00:37 My office is looking into that matter
01:00:39 and there's more details that we have to uncover
01:00:42 before I can comment further.
01:00:44 I can tell you that the police in Ottawa,
01:00:46 Ottawa, while not perfect, used force at a significantly lower rate than I've seen most
01:00:52 police forces in this country use force against large crowds.
01:00:55 I don't think peacefully protesting warrants being pepper sprayed.
01:00:59 I think anyone that was being violent with police, anyone that was pushing back against
01:01:03 police, obviously is fair game for police to respond and try to de-escalate that situation.
01:01:09 But the reality is people who were doing their best to get out of the way were getting caught
01:01:14 up in this.
01:01:15 And that's the problem.
01:01:15 These tactics are supposed to be used when police are trying to clear a space.
01:01:20 If people are already moving, people are already walking back,
01:01:22 there's no justification to deploy them.
01:01:25 Certainly there was police violence and I mean people can argue about whether it was justified
01:01:48 or unjustified but we know from the incident of you know police horses trampling a woman from 0.95
01:01:53 protesters getting pepper sprayed from tear gas being fired into the crowds absolutely there was
01:01:59 violence and i know personally that you didn't need to be committing violence to be targeted by
01:02:04 it it's hard to answer that question because i think the police have their training and they
01:02:10 know how they would normally act but in addition to having their training and their judgment and
01:02:15 their discretion they also have their marching orders from from the higher ranking officers
01:02:20 There was virtually no, in fact, I think zero use of tear gas by the Ottawa Police Service.
01:02:28 In fact, there was tear gas used by the protesters against the Ottawa Police Service.
01:02:32 Pepper spray was used relatively limitedly.
01:02:36 There were instances where officers used, I believe, the butt of the rifles or batons to hit people who were not moving along the front lines.
01:02:44 There were some takedown and arrests.
01:02:46 There were some projectile, I think, bead bag rounds fired into the crowd.
01:02:50 I think each one of those instances should be investigated about whether or not that was an appropriate use of force.
01:02:55 Because I think we should hold the Ottawa Police Service to the highest possible standard and use this event as the baseline.
01:03:00 This isn't about the police. This is about the politicians.
01:03:03 This is about Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his failure.
01:03:06 Not the police's failure, but his failure.
01:03:16 I do not believe that the government had any right to remove protesters at all.
01:03:22 It's a democratic society.
01:03:24 We have the right to protest, especially in our capital.
01:03:28 And the narrative that the government and the media wanted to push that businesses couldn't be open is absolutely nonsense.
01:03:37 There was not a business that was blocked from being open if they had a desire to be open,
01:03:42 other than the police's own concrete barriers.
01:03:51 Where we were at by the second week of February needed serious action.
01:03:58 Was that the Emergencies Act? I think that was the thing available.
01:04:02 I think the way it was deployed was relatively reasonable.
01:04:05 I think the orders the federal government wrote to go with the Act were irresponsible.
01:04:09 They went too far. They allowed far too much latitude and jurisdiction for the federal government to seize and freeze assets.
01:04:16 It was so geographically wide that I think it gave them nearly limitless power to break up demonstrations anywhere in the country.
01:04:24 So I think there's bad things about it. I think at the end of the day we're going to conclude that it was the right thing to do.
01:04:29 I don't believe it became illegal until the Emergencies Act was actually put in place.
01:04:34 They needed to use the Emergencies Act to declare the protest illegal.
01:04:38 because in Canada, a protest is not illegal until it becomes a riot.
01:04:43 And that could have been covered under the Riot Act of the Criminal Code.
01:04:47 The fact that they couldn't use the Riot Act in the Criminal Code
01:04:49 indicates to me that it was not an illegal protest
01:04:52 until they invoked the Emergencies Act.
01:04:54 Also, it's important to note that during the protests,
01:04:57 Ottawa police actually said that street crime had come down in Ottawa.
01:05:01 And that makes a lot of sense to me,
01:05:02 because you had a lot of people walking around in the city.
01:05:06 and it wasn't desolate like it usually is in the dead of winter.
01:05:15 One of the requirements to invoke the Emergencies Act
01:05:19 is that the existing tools, laws, enforcement agencies,
01:05:22 that those existing tools had to be inadequate
01:05:25 and incapable of addressing the so-called emergency.
01:05:28 So there needed to be an emergency
01:05:30 and the existing laws needed to be inadequate.
01:05:32 it and yet every single charge that has come from the arrests laid that weekend have all been under
01:05:39 existing laws and powers that the police officers used were existing powers well to me the the
01:05:48 protest was always legal in the fact that when we first got there that it was the ottawa police that
01:05:54 escorted us onto these streets it was the ottawa police that ensured that we kept roads open which
01:06:02 we did at all times there was always lanes open for emergency vehicles to get through
01:06:08 and even on the monday which i believe was valentine's day i helped with a couple other
01:06:16 of the organizers with the ottawa police escort 15 more trucks up onto wellington
01:06:23 so that was the monday before the friday where they said we were illegal so to me
01:06:29 we were legal the whole time the issue is finished so we now know what happened nobody knew what
01:06:36 happened or what was going to happen when we started when we invoked the emergency act it
01:06:42 ended up being that finally there wasn't as much violence as might have been anticipated but if
01:06:49 when we start when they started when the police started to basically remove the protesters if
01:06:58 If the protesters would have decided to put it in high gear and be as violent as they
01:07:04 could, all of the powers that had been given to them by the Emergency Act would have been
01:07:11 needed.
01:07:12 And that's why, to me, it's clear there's no issue the government had to invoke the Emergency
01:07:18 Act.
01:07:19 Justin Trudeau invoked the Emergencies Act for political purposes.
01:07:23 The purpose of the Emergencies Act, again, is to have a tool when existing tools don't work.
01:07:30 And Justin Trudeau invoked the Emergencies Act basically to appear strong in the public eye.
01:07:36 But as you could see that a few days after he invoked it, he didn't follow through with having the Emergencies Act ratified in the Senate and ultimately withdrew his use of the Emergencies Act.
01:07:47 So clearly it was a political tool.
01:07:49 we were not playing a game but it seemed like the other team was not playing again within the rules
01:07:57 so then there's no use anymore um saturday morning the police started smashing windows on trucks and
01:08:03 really beating people up and we said we've made our point it's it's over there's no use
01:08:10 more people getting hurt so we decided to leave and we did end up having a couple trucks stuck in
01:08:16 and getting towed and window smashed and everything.
01:08:22 I think at the time that the Prime Minister rescinded the Emergencies Act,
01:08:28 it was clear there was no justification for it.
01:08:32 And not that there had ever been a justification, but certainly days later,
01:08:36 the supposed blockades that were in place to justify the Emergencies Act had been disbanded.
01:08:41 The crisis was gone. The money ceased to be an issue.
01:08:44 and I think he was very worried about what the Senate was going to do which hadn't voted on it
01:08:50 at the time and also what Canadians were going to do because it's one thing if you concoct an
01:08:54 emergency to justify all sorts of measures that the government put forward it's another thing
01:08:59 when you indefinitely keep that in place when there's nothing that even resembles a crisis.
01:09:04 More and more often I'm coming to the conclusion that the evidence that the government used to
01:09:09 justify invoking the act is news reports from the public sphere that are public information.
01:09:16 And if they didn't have some sort of smoking gun evidence to justify the use of this act and
01:09:21 we're basing it completely off of news articles, many of which have had to be retracted since we
01:09:27 found new evidence that indicates that it was false information, false allegations,
01:09:32 I think that's going to be a big problem for the government if that's the evidence that they relied
01:09:35 upon.
01:09:39 I think it certainly was upsetting in a country like Canada where, you know, we have a lot of freedoms to see police, you know, pushing protesters out on the streets.
01:10:02 And I think what a lot of Canadians, certainly what I think, is how could we have let this get to this point in the first place?
01:10:07 There was a point where I think a lot of people, myself included, were hopeful that the government would look at the truckers and say, maybe we miscalculated, maybe we misjudged this.
01:10:23 But the federal government doubled down.
01:10:25 some of these people are living in a fantasy land of constructed conspiracies and i don't know if i
01:10:35 hope that maybe they had broken out of some of those between the end of the convoy and today
01:10:40 but they certainly haven't yeah how did i feel driving home to be honest um at that time you're
01:10:51 You're tired, you want to go home.
01:10:55 It didn't feel like the job was done.
01:10:58 Yes, we did accomplish something.
01:11:00 We woke up the world, first of all,
01:11:03 and it actually still was giving people hope
01:11:07 that something would change, that things would get better.
01:11:12 But then the reception that we got in Niagara
01:11:16 was unbelievable.
01:11:21 Yeah, the support that we got from the community meant an awful lot.
01:11:27 Oh, sorry. I can't think about that.
01:11:34 And having all these people on the side of the road standing there waving the flags again,
01:11:40 saying thank you for doing what you did, gave me a little bit of closure,
01:11:43 but you still wish that things would have gone different.
01:11:49 Yeah, I do feel like the convoy accomplished actually more than what we set out for.
01:11:57 Obviously, the mandates, the federal mandates are still there.
01:12:00 But the community, at least here in Niagara region, is super unified.
01:12:07 The support is amazing.
01:12:11 I believe the mandates were there to try to disunify our country and keep people apart.
01:12:16 And it's done the exact opposite with the convoy. 0.71
01:12:19 Thank you.
01:12:49 It's deeply concerning that we have a significant number of people in this country who have
01:12:57 detached from reality, but again, I get why people wind up there.
01:13:02 They lost friends to suicide, they lost family members to illnesses, and they couldn't go
01:13:05 visit them in the hospital, they couldn't go to their family member's funeral, their
01:13:09 friend's funeral, and that was really tough on them, and I get that.
01:13:12 I've been there too.
01:13:13 I think a lot of us have been there.
01:13:14 And they've been looking for explanations for how we got here.
01:13:19 they look at somewhere like the federal government where the prime minister frequently attacks his
01:13:24 critics as being you know conspiracy theorists and frequently belittles and demonize people who
01:13:30 you know are not settled on the science and i think they tend to pull back
01:13:41 our media the health experts they're not interested in what's good for every canadian
01:13:48 they're just interested in what's good for their narrative and there's a lot of things going on
01:13:54 that we as canadians need to realize you can't trust the media let alone your own government
01:14:01 anymore.
01:14:31 I mean, Trudeau, anytime someone has thought that he was just done and going to lose the election, he's won.
01:14:44 So people shouldn't underestimate Justin Trudeau.
01:14:46 He may not have the massive, massive Trudeau mania 2.0 popularity he had in 2015, but he's still resonating with voters. 0.72
01:14:54 And even if you look at the 2021 election, a big part of what he was offering Canadians was more restrictions on the unvaccinated.
01:15:03 He campaigned on firing public servants if they didn't get the COVID vaccine.
01:15:07 He campaigned on banning unvaccinated Canadians from air and rail travel. 0.99
01:15:13 So he's been quite transparent about what it is that he wanted to do, and Canadians rewarded that. 1.00
01:15:18 Now, you can talk about whether this is because the Conservatives didn't put up their best and brightest,
01:15:23 But clearly, the scandal and frustration that a lot of people see in Trudeau isn't necessarily representative of how Canadians as a whole have seen him up until the last election.
01:15:35 And whether that's changed since then is a different story.
01:15:40 You know, that's a good question.
01:15:42 And I think a lot of it is going to ride upon the inquiry and the parliamentary review.
01:15:48 and I think if it can be proven that the government inappropriately used the
01:15:52 Emergencies Act I think it's going to be remembered as as a time when the
01:15:57 government overreached on Canadians rights and it's going to look very bad
01:16:01 on the current Liberal government.
01:16:03 I think the Freedom Convoy is going to be fairly divisive for a lot of people in
01:16:09 how they remember it. Certainly I've talked to a lot of people in my own work
01:16:12 on this that think it was just the greatest moment of their lives. It was
01:16:15 this time when the you know the peasants took over the castle in a way and ordinary people stood up
01:16:20 and said we're not going to take it anymore but still the narratives that were being passed off
01:16:26 by the government by the media are still baked into a lot of people's perceptions of the convoy
01:16:32 and those people as we've seen in a number of other stories that have come up since are still
01:16:38 very committed to this idea that it was a violent protest that it was a lawless rebellion which just
01:16:44 wasn't the case and the facts don't support that, but the stubbornness has persisted among some.
01:16:50 I think the gun boy is going to be remembered very negatively. You know, I think it will be seen
01:16:56 as an outgrowth of the intense frustration and alienation that we all experienced during the
01:17:02 pandemic, right? I don't think this will be our January 6th, right? I think that will be remembered
01:17:08 very particularly in the U.S. I think this is going to be remembered as the sort of culmination
01:17:13 of a kind of, you know, intense anger and disenchantment and disaffection
01:17:24 that, you know, came to a head in 2022.
01:17:30 And that in some cases is understandable, in some cases is really up to lunch.
01:17:34 But I don't think it's even remembered particularly well.
01:17:36 I think the Freedom Convoy will be remembered by most Canadians as a very important moment
01:17:46 in this country's history. But it also depends on who you speak to. The people who obviously
01:17:52 supported the protest will romanticize the protest and the people who oppose the protest
01:17:57 will try to delegitimize it and denigrate it. But I hope that there's a mass of people in the
01:18:04 Center who will objectively sift through the facts
01:18:08 and make up their own minds.
01:18:09 And I personally think that it was an important moment
01:18:12 in the fight for individual liberty and freedoms.
01:18:14 That's what it was all about in the end.
01:18:17 And we've lost a bit of that during the two years
01:18:21 of the pandemic.
01:18:34 Thank you.
01:19:04 Thank you.
01:19:34 Thank you. 0.53
01:20:04 For the first time, that was The Freedom Occupation,
01:20:29 a documentary that was produced by Rachel Emanuel and Johnny Emanuel.
01:20:34 We are very proud at True North to present it to you now.
01:20:39 And I was so glad to see that, like I mentioned at the beginning, I was seeing that for the first time here.
01:20:44 So this reaction is all very authentic.
01:20:47 We'll bring back our superstar panel now with Rachel Emanuel and Johnny Emanuel, as well as Rupa Subramania.
01:20:55 And to both you, Rachel and Johnny, firstly, congratulations.
01:20:59 I went in, I will say with high expectations, but you met them and exceeded them.
01:21:06 So very well done.
01:21:08 Thank you very much.
01:21:10 Too kind.
01:21:11 So let me start with just a question about, I'm not going to nitpick and be like, well,
01:21:15 why did you keep that frame up?
01:21:17 No, it's nothing like that.
01:21:18 But just as your approach, why did you decide to do this without a narrator, without, you
01:21:24 know, perhaps you, Rachel, you are on camera all the time, without you sort of driving
01:21:28 the story along?
01:21:29 Why did you decide to just let your guests be the only voices in there?
01:21:33 Well, I think part of what Jonathan had said earlier in the pre-show was just initially maybe this desire not to include too much of our voices in it.
01:21:40 I think also just the idea of having like a narrator talking underneath is maybe a bit of a, it is a technique that you can use in documentary making, maybe at times a bit more of an old-fashioned technique.
01:21:50 I like the way that we do it.
01:21:51 I think it was really progressive and I think the pace moved really well throughout it.
01:21:55 There was also just so much different types of footage that we had to include, like interviews, but also, you know, some of the standalone interviews that you did while you were in Ottawa.
01:22:03 And then, of course, some of the more aggressive footage when police were pushing protesters out.
01:22:07 So we had had the conversation and we both immediately decided that we weren't interested in having a narrator, so to speak.
01:22:13 There was a conversation about whether I was going to be in the documentary.
01:22:17 We felt like we needed to fill in any gaps.
01:22:20 I think I would have maybe sat down for an interview and filled them in.
01:22:22 but we just felt like we would have lost a little bit of credibility on the bias if I had been in
01:22:26 the film so we had so much footage to use and I really wasn't needed so we decided it was just
01:22:31 easiest to leave me out um because it wasn't needed and I think we would have just lost a
01:22:35 little bit of credibility on that and most importantly when you mentioned that it was an
01:22:39 old-fashioned tactic that was like the kindest way possible for you to say Andrew you're an 0.98
01:22:43 idiot that doesn't know how documentaries are produced in the last 20 years so thank you for 0.97
01:22:46 uh for putting on the uh the kid gloves there but it was interesting and even seeing my own 0.98
01:22:51 comments which i had you know forgotten what i said uh because we sat down so long ago it was
01:22:56 fascinating to see that juxtaposed with things that your other guests were saying like you know
01:23:01 the lawyer kaza or justin ling and same with rupa's comments and and getting the jonkers in
01:23:07 there and and putting those together and having in some cases drastically different perspectives
01:23:12 about the same events and you know at the end of it i was reading some of the comments that
01:23:16 came as the the documentary was going and some people are very offended by
01:23:20 oh I don't like that Justin Ling said that
01:23:22 I don't like that the lawyer said that
01:23:24 but other people I think were very
01:23:26 it seemed like just from
01:23:28 what I was reading trying to keep up with it
01:23:30 very grateful just to have that
01:23:32 balance in it and I hope that if people can
01:23:34 get by their initial reaction
01:23:36 that might be a bit more visceral if they
01:23:38 don't like the convoy they can see that this story
01:23:40 is being told in a very fair way
01:23:42 here
01:23:42 Sure and I think something that we mentioned for people who didn't
01:23:46 tune in for the pre-show was just that
01:23:48 idea of wanting to be able to keep the dialogue open and how much we lose as a society when we
01:23:52 become unwilling to speak to the other side and when I said that I thought you know Justin Ling
01:23:56 some of his comments were very reasonable I mean some of the stuff he said arguably a lot of people
01:24:01 wouldn't agree with I myself wouldn't agree with but he did make some points that I was like you
01:24:05 know what I totally agree with that you were bang on about that when he talked about the use of 0.99
01:24:09 mounted units being used and that was being you know that was an incredibly stupid move I think 0.82
01:24:13 was actually maybe his specific wording um and other things he said those are points of his that
01:24:19 i agree with and i think that i've just become accustomed to looking for things that people say
01:24:23 that i agree with and that being the point of context that we can take the conversation for
01:24:26 there we might not have the same conclusions we might not come to the same outcomes but if you're
01:24:31 so focused on that you'll never be willing to have discussions with people so if you're willing to
01:24:35 hear what they say and you're usually able to find something you agree on or some point of contact
01:24:39 and start the conversation from there you might be surprised with how far you can get in dialogues
01:24:43 with other individuals. At the beginning of this discussion, before the documentary, I had asked
01:24:49 Rupa if she had any thoughts on what she as a viewer would like to see. And I was sort of asking
01:24:54 myself that question as well. And you answered a question I didn't have, and one that I've never
01:24:59 really talked about, even when I was interviewing truckers for my book and on my show and other
01:25:04 points. You asked a question in that documentary that was answered, which I think was a tremendous
01:25:10 one which was about the drive home and i think so often we talk about the drive to ottawa we talk
01:25:15 about what happened in ottawa but for a lot of those truckers they then had i mean in the case
01:25:20 of the jonkers a drive through ontario for other people a drive across the country back to bc and
01:25:25 it was it was actually quite moving to see how he tried to reconcile what he was feeling after that
01:25:32 driving home with in his words a mission not accomplished yeah i felt like that was a really
01:25:39 impactful moment of the dock as well and it was really important to include that because we know
01:25:44 that truckers had a really hard time with that i personally know a couple truckers and that was a
01:25:49 really devastating moment for them i think some of them really felt like they had failed and i
01:25:52 think for a long time the question was should we go back and i love that he gave a little shout
01:25:56 out to niagara there because i'm from niagara and i love niagara moving to alberta you know
01:26:01 people rag on ontario a lot but niagara is truly one of the most incredible places on earth it's
01:26:06 in many ways a little slice of alberta right there in ontario you know great christian community a
01:26:10 lot of conservatives and so the freedom movement there was alive and well throughout the entire
01:26:15 covet 19 pandemic and there is a very strong freedom movement there so when they drove back
01:26:20 to niagara he sort of mentions you know the community was great and there was just people
01:26:23 lining the streets ready to welcome the truckers home the same way they sent them off because
01:26:27 really what the convoy did accomplish it did unite people we didn't lose all the mandates you know
01:26:32 know some of the provinces were a bit more successful in seeing movement than others
01:26:36 but people were united and they realized for the first time in almost two years that
01:26:40 they weren't alone in having these concerns and i think that changed a lot of people's lives
01:26:44 certainly it changed mine you know earlier we talked a little bit about why i wanted to do
01:26:48 the documentary but you know one of the things i didn't mention was i was working in the mainstream
01:26:52 media at the time the convoy happened and i was really i felt very sort of bootstrapped with what
01:26:57 i was able to write about and how i was able to cover things and so this was my opportunity to go
01:27:02 back and redo it in the way that i wish that i had done it while it was actually going on and
01:27:07 maybe set the record straight and also sort of clear my conscience in a sense because i feel
01:27:10 like i didn't do an adequate job of covering it while it was in ottawa and while i was a reporter
01:27:14 in ottawa let's get your first review here from rupa subramania she is untarnished by not having
01:27:22 seen it before although a little bit biased because i think she bears a very close resemblance to
01:27:26 someone who was featured in the documentary but rupa first time seeing it what were your thoughts
01:27:32 uh well um well a flood of emotions uh um you know it came came back to me um um you know i'd
01:27:40 be lying if i said that the freedom convoy protest uh didn't change my life uh it did in in personally
01:27:48 and professionally and i've spoken about that quite quite a bit um and um um congratulations
01:27:57 rachel and johnny i think um you know on a job well done um uh you know i think you brought it
01:28:02 all together um you know people are going to object to um you know having certain voices in
01:28:09 the documentary or even with the use of the term occupation in the title but i think that you had to
01:28:16 you know it goes back to the point that i was making earlier which is you know we don't want
01:28:20 to be stuck in these echo chambers i mean if you want to um do a documentary on the protests i think
01:28:26 it is important to have voices who don't agree with those of us who had a different take right
01:28:34 um and and i think it's important to um i think it's important to include those voices we don't
01:28:40 want to be uh the people on the left you know who are always trying to cancel the other side just
01:28:46 because they disagree with a certain point of view um having said that i will say that i don't think
01:28:51 uh justin ling is balanced um that minor quibble in the uh you know uh when you when you when you
01:28:57 said that i disagree with a lot of what he's saying now see uh someone like uh justin ling
01:29:03 um was was very prominent in promoting this narrative that these people were violent the
01:29:09 protesters were violent that they were here to overthrow the government and he kept that up and
01:29:14 And then he's surprised that the that that that certain things happen later where, you know, the RCMP had to, you know, where, you know, where, you know, there was this law enforcement came out in full force.
01:29:30 Look, you can't have it both ways. Right. You're you're you're you're you're on the one hand, you're saying like this is like the you know, these people are violent and something needs to be done.
01:29:40 And then on the other hand, you can't criticize the excessive use of force.
01:29:45 And that's, you know, you're trying to have your cake and eat it, too.
01:29:49 And I don't think you can do that.
01:29:51 And so that's where I, you know, just a minor quibble there.
01:29:54 But I think it's still important that he was part of the documentary.
01:29:58 And the other voice and the, I think it was a professor or a lawyer, if I'm not mistaken,
01:30:04 who also felt threatened by the protesters.
01:30:07 I mean, that that was that was representative of the kind of sentiment that people who opposed the protests were saying at that time that they didn't feel safe stepping out of their apartment, out of their homes in Ottawa.
01:30:22 So I think that was that it was important to include that voice.
01:30:26 But what can I say? I mean, you know, it just was a very emotional experience for me.
01:30:31 um you know i um i know i know friends who are um you know who who who suffered during the pandemic
01:30:39 in in more than i ever did to be honest with you you know uh these are uh you know people who were
01:30:46 on leave without pay and uh you know and they took this principle courageous position uh to
01:30:52 not take the vaccine and uh and we may not understand their reality but i don't think you
01:30:59 can denigrate their reality and and that's what ended up happening during the protests we um you
01:31:07 know we we we denigrated their reality and we we said that our reality is somehow superior to their
01:31:13 reality but we all live in our you know we we all have our challenges and you know all of that has
01:31:20 to be taken into account and um and i just want to get to johnny here because he's been very silent
01:31:26 since the documentary wrapped.
01:31:29 And just, I mean, this was a very,
01:31:30 I love the pacing, by the way, Johnny.
01:31:32 You kept this moving, Rachel, you kept this moving.
01:31:35 I never felt it was dragging.
01:31:36 You covered a lot of ground,
01:31:37 but I also didn't feel it was lacking.
01:31:39 But I know when we spoke,
01:31:41 it was probably for like, I don't know,
01:31:42 45 minutes to an hour.
01:31:43 I assume it was very similar with your other guests.
01:31:46 You would have had, I mean, 0.98
01:31:47 even just forgetting the B-roll
01:31:48 and the footage you wanted to incorporate
01:31:50 from the protest itself,
01:31:51 just hours and hours and hours of interviews.
01:31:54 How do you decide what makes it in?
01:31:56 I mean, how did you, what, what was the process like to really pare this down and say, no, this is the, this is the essential 30 seconds we need.
01:32:04 That was definitely a challenge.
01:32:06 And there's multiple drafts that we took to, there was like, you know, in the structure of the story, at what point do we want to introduce what events, what is the through line here?
01:32:14 And there's so much stuff that I would have loved to include into the doc, but we just had to sort of like say like, you know, we can't be branching off on little tangents, especially if we can't sort of solidify what we're trying to say about it.
01:32:25 It's more of a, what do we have as concrete
01:32:27 and what are we really trying to put forward?
01:32:29 And so like what really resonated with the stories
01:32:31 and the answers that we had,
01:32:32 it was more or less the mainstream's misperception
01:32:34 of the convoy itself.
01:32:36 I think that's really resonated throughout the film,
01:32:38 just these accounts of what they claimed
01:32:40 versus what it was like.
01:32:41 And I think it's very obvious in the B-roll
01:32:43 that it was just nothing to the degree
01:32:46 of what it was being described as.
01:32:48 And so, yeah, I mean, deciding on what to keep
01:32:51 really just became down to like,
01:32:53 what are the important facts what do we really want to make sure we got through and that was more
01:32:58 or less the the trucker's account of the story the media the media's perception and then how the
01:33:03 violence ensued and what that really um meant for the occupation what it meant for canada as a whole
01:33:09 and so i really like how rupa uh ends the film with that that idea of like you know it's important
01:33:14 that we objectively sift through the facts ourselves and make up our mind not just take
01:33:19 the opinion that is given to us and stated as fact well and i also think on that point ending
01:33:25 with the question of legacy is a really i think it's a fantastic artistic choice but i think even
01:33:31 just in the the current climate in canada it's a valuable one i wanted to read a comment i saw
01:33:36 uh that now in our group chat is like 300 pages behind uh from here it is uh k luciano writes
01:33:44 there will be a bronzed Kenworth on Wellington Street one day market.
01:33:48 So I don't know if like right next to the Terry Fox statue,
01:33:51 they're going to just make a little space and put a statue of a truck there.
01:33:54 I thought that was a beautifully put comment.
01:33:56 So I thank you, Kate Luciano, for that,
01:33:59 because it does suggest that at a certain point in time,
01:34:02 and it won't necessarily be within the next year,
01:34:05 the truckers will be remembered in history favorably.
01:34:09 And I was talking on my show a little while ago about,
01:34:11 I don't want to, this is going to be when the audience tunes out.
01:34:13 so I'll make it very short. The Upper Canada Rebellion in 1837, and William Lyon Mackenzie
01:34:19 goes from being a tyrant living in exile two years later being a member of Parliament. So
01:34:24 the renegades and the traitors and the terrorists eventually can become the heroes in the story of
01:34:31 Canada. And I was wondering if you had any thoughts on even if that dynamic has changed
01:34:36 a little bit in the time you've been working on this, Rachel or Johnny?
01:34:43 it's tough to say i think like we've all kind of talked a little bit about how the emergencies
01:34:50 act commission is coming out at this point you know and i think i'm excited to see how that
01:34:55 what happens with that it's hard to say if you've really seen people's perspective on the convoy
01:34:59 change at this point you know i think in our interview something we felt was people had kind
01:35:05 of dug in and they had kind of come to their own facts already and you know i think there is those
01:35:09 people in the middle who are still kind of coming to their own conclusions but it's tough to say at
01:35:14 this point and I still am interested to see how the convoy will be remembered it's still relatively
01:35:18 recent in Canadian history um and I think there's just as I mentioned earlier there's a lot to know
01:35:23 about it but I don't know if you have anything you want to add to that Johnny yeah I mean I'm
01:35:27 hopeful that it's remembered in a respectful manner just because I mean I want to repeat
01:35:32 something that Rupa mentioned earlier just the the national pride that I felt when the convoy
01:35:37 actually took place that was something that I hadn't really you know felt in a really long time
01:35:41 and I mean we were at the heat of COVID and lockdown so it was really tough but when that
01:35:45 convoy started I remember I was driving on the on the highway I intersected a piece of it and yeah
01:35:51 it was just really rejuvenating I felt that sense of being proud to be Canadian and I really hope
01:35:56 we can you know come back to that point let me go to you on on one part of the documentary Rupa
01:36:02 one of the guests was talking about how it was a war zone and using these really dramatic,
01:36:09 emotive terms. One of the points that you had made as someone who spent a great deal of your
01:36:15 life in India, and you mentioned this back in January of last year, is that this was like a 1.00
01:36:21 pale Mickey Mouse version of chaos. And you had, I believe at one point said to me, just look at
01:36:27 a day on the streets of India and this looks like a cakewalk. So you've seen crisis, you've seen
01:36:32 chaos this was not it um i mean the the you know i have a fairly high tolerance for noise uh having
01:36:44 lived in mumbai a city of 16 million people this that was pretty much my experience every time i
01:36:51 open the windows of my of my apartment and you know you you'd hear cars uh honking all the time
01:36:58 The streets are always bustling with life and that sort of thing.
01:37:03 And, you know, and I've said this many, many times.
01:37:06 I originally come from the land of civil disobedience, the land of Mahatma Gandhi.
01:37:11 And this was, you know, you see a protest like this all the time in India and the farmers protest.
01:37:19 And it's important to bring this in because the farmers protests in India, which went on for a year and a half,
01:37:26 which Prime Minister Justin Trudeau supported, they had a very similar approach.
01:37:36 They blocked highways and roads with tractors and trucks and other vehicles.
01:37:43 And this went on for about a year and a half.
01:37:45 And Justin Trudeau defended the protesters' right to protest, as did I, by the way,
01:37:51 even though i disagreed with um with their cause because i actually believed in the indian
01:37:56 government's uh uh you know uh decision to um uh carry out this reform so my point is that the
01:38:04 what i saw here in ottawa yes it was it was tame it was it was i don't even want to say it was tame
01:38:11 but it was it was not like anything that i hadn't seen before but it was truly canadian it was you
01:38:17 You know, it was it had that Canadian spirit, which was part of it, which and as Johnny mentioned earlier and as many immigrants have mentioned to me that this was the first time in their entire time in India, in Canada, that they felt really proud to be Canadian, that they had a strong sense of what it meant to be Canadian.
01:38:38 And and that that was very, very striking to me.
01:38:42 here's a question that uh may infuriate you rachel and johnny but i'm gonna ask it anyway
01:38:49 because i asked you at the beginning if there was anything you didn't want to talk about and you
01:38:52 didn't take the opportunity to give me something so what almost made it in if there was one more
01:38:57 scene or one more section or 10 minutes more what would have been in that wasn't i would have loved
01:39:04 to dive deeper into the financial aspect of the convoy i think that was a real hot topic that
01:39:09 people really want to learn more about I myself included but we just didn't take the time to fully
01:39:14 polish off that end of the of the narrative and so putting the piece that we had in there would
01:39:20 have felt like it was like just it wasn't enough you know it would have just been a sprinkle when
01:39:25 we really needed the full the full meat so it's funny you mentioned that because when I wrote my
01:39:30 book I had the same thought whereas I really wished that I had had access to a bit more and
01:39:36 I think I did as good a job as I could.
01:39:39 A lot of that didn't really come out until the Public Order Emergency Commission
01:39:44 because there were so many different strains
01:39:47 and tracking the cryptocurrency donations and Bitcoin donations.
01:39:50 So I think on your part, you're forgiven for not doing that
01:39:54 because it's only been so recently that you could even tell that story.
01:39:58 And it is a complex one.
01:40:00 Rachel, what would yours be?
01:40:03 Perhaps very selfishly, mine would be something totally different.
01:40:06 when we were in ottawa filming the second time it was in november and it was one of those days
01:40:11 where it felt like negative 20 with wind chill and we decided for to do a segment for a while we
01:40:16 decided we were going to spend a lot more time on the on the dock of the police being pushing
01:40:21 protesters off of parliament hill so we spent about two hours it was i think like negative 20
01:40:26 with wind chill outside in the streets of ottawa basically filming where basically i had all the
01:40:32 footage and we were going to then go to shots of me basically doing streeters and explaining what
01:40:36 was happening in the tussling and and sort of just throw back to what the streets look like
01:40:40 on a regular day and then throw back to the tussling and so we spent a good two hours out
01:40:45 there like it was painful i was so cold and then of course we didn't even end up using any of that
01:40:49 so all that worked for nothing so selfishly selfishly that was maybe the one thing but um
01:40:56 yeah i guess the other big thing was we didn't spend any time on the public order emergency
01:41:00 Commission, there was a lot of thought and plans that we were going to go back and have another
01:41:04 interview. But it ended up being that we had so much footage and there wasn't really a need to
01:41:09 cover that. So we decided to leave it out in the end. Yeah. And just on the note of my own little
01:41:16 role in this, we didn't talk about it. Well, we talked about it in the interview and it wasn't in
01:41:19 the documentary, specifically me getting pepper sprayed. But the fun fact of that is that it
01:41:24 could have been you, Rachel, because you and I were chatting like 30 seconds before it happened
01:41:29 and you had the wherewithal to get out of Dodge
01:41:31 because I think you had to go back to work
01:41:32 or go to do an interview.
01:41:34 And then like 30 seconds later, I am pepper sprayed.
01:41:37 So if you had any advanced knowledge of that,
01:41:39 you could have looped me in,
01:41:40 but it might've just been fortuitous timing on your part.
01:41:43 But this raises an important point though,
01:41:46 because I was there, I was not doing anything wrong.
01:41:48 Other journalists were there as well,
01:41:50 exactly where I was.
01:41:51 I wasn't there protesting, I was there reporting.
01:41:54 And I ended up getting pepper sprayed. 0.93
01:41:56 Alexa Lavoie of Rebel News got hit in the leg with a canister of tear gas.
01:42:02 This happened.
01:42:02 It's seen on camera.
01:42:04 And that was one thing that I felt in the comments people were really calling out Justin
01:42:09 Ling for, which is saying that there was no evidence of tear gas being used by the Ottawa
01:42:14 Police Service.
01:42:15 Now, I don't know if that was a technicality on his part, because maybe the tear gas came
01:42:19 from one of the visiting police forces, or if he was just challenging that that incident
01:42:24 took place.
01:42:25 But Rupa, what was your thought on that?
01:42:28 My thought on?
01:42:29 Well, on the comment that we get from people that there wasn't tear gas or pepper spray was not used indiscriminately.
01:42:37 Yeah, no, I look, I mean, this is a very difficult question to answer.
01:42:42 I, you know, while I disagree with the invocation of the Emergencies Act for sure,
01:42:46 And I disagree with the, you know, with the kind of, you know, the force that we, you know, the full scale of law enforcement, you know, right here in downtown Ottawa.
01:43:01 I would say that the that the that law enforcement by and large, I mean, it could have it could have ended really badly.
01:43:07 I think it could have been really bad. But I think everybody was, you know, I think I think more or less there was a balance struck.
01:43:15 I do know that that on the final day, there were a few people who had a few hundred people had gathered on Spark Street and they were, you know, just wanting to hang around and party.
01:43:30 And and I remember trying to go to that event, actually, that evening, but I was I almost made it.
01:43:38 But then I saw all of these people coming back from the event, returning from the event.
01:43:42 And they said they'd just been sprayed. They'd just been tear gassed and and rubber bullets had been fired on them.
01:43:49 And in fact, I I one of them even pointed them to me.
01:43:54 You know, he'd collected them in his in his hand.
01:43:57 And so, you know, I think that, I mean, you know, I wasn't there.
01:44:03 I don't know.
01:44:03 I don't know what the full facts are here.
01:44:05 You know, I don't know what exactly happened.
01:44:07 Was there an indiscriminate use of force?
01:44:10 I hope there wasn't.
01:44:13 But, you know, I'm just conjecturing that given just how big the presence was in Ottawa,
01:44:22 how big, you know, you had cops from Quebec, from Calgary, from everywhere.
01:44:26 And it could have gone the other way, but it didn't. In fact, I think a lot of the cops were just, you know, very reluctant to do this. You know, as many of us have pointed this out, they had tears in their eyes. You know, they didn't want to do this. You know, they felt very guilty doing this.
01:44:46 and uh and so there was a lot of restraint i think on the part of law enforcement as well
01:44:51 it's unfortunate unfortunate andrew that you got pepper sprayed in fact i think i was very
01:44:56 close to you and as shortly after you got pepper sprayed you came up to me and you said you got
01:45:00 pepper sprayed and i could i could see how red your eyes had become uh it was right next to the
01:45:04 chateau laurie if you remember and um and and so it's that that's very unfortunate and what happened
01:45:10 to alexa rebel news that was uh equally unfortunate uh but you know um as as far as
01:45:16 protests go and a protest that went on for three weeks um you know it was relatively all very
01:45:24 peaceful uh from both sides i i it's funny you mentioned the law enforcement angle because
01:45:30 one aspect of this that's i think quite interesting and i would love to explore it further is that a
01:45:36 but a lot of protesters genuinely felt like the police were on their side.
01:45:40 And some of them felt very blindsided or very betrayed
01:45:44 when police eventually started moving in and making arrests and whatnot.
01:45:49 We are coming to the end of our time together
01:45:52 in the post-premier discussion of the freedom occupation.
01:45:56 But I want to give the final words to the filmmakers,
01:45:58 especially since they, as we were discussing earlier,
01:46:01 kept their own literal voices out of the documentary.
01:46:05 so any final thoughts we'll start with you johnny and then we'll we'll wrap it up from rachel
01:46:09 well i just want to say thanks everyone for taking the time uh i hope we were able to you know
01:46:14 uh cause you to you know re-evaluate your perceived notion of the doc and um yeah hopefully we have
01:46:22 more projects to bring you guys in the future yeah absolutely i second that i think sort of
01:46:27 to arupa's comments on police violence i think one of the interesting thing that dane lloyd
01:46:31 mentioned was, you know, the responsibility for that really lies with the government at the end
01:46:36 of the day. The police were just doing what they were ordered. So ultimately, you know, that police
01:46:40 violence that we saw or didn't see, you know, that's up for discussion. You can have a debate
01:46:44 about that. But ultimately, you know, that does lie with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. He's the
01:46:48 one that needs to answer to that. But yes, I echo Jonathan's comments. Thank you so much, everyone,
01:46:52 for tuning in. I'm sure over the next couple of days and weeks, we will build up the courage to
01:46:57 read all of your comments. I'm going to have to come up with a much more succinct explanation for
01:47:02 our documentary title to put in the comments because, yeah, my full explanation I don't think
01:47:09 is going to fit. But yeah, thanks so much everyone for tuning in. You know, I would also just mention
01:47:13 I had the fun part of this doc. I got to sort of organize interviews and request people,
01:47:19 but Jonathan was really the person who spent maybe, I don't know, two to three months doing
01:47:23 all the editing work. So, you know, the fantastic visuals that we saw and all the clever editing
01:47:27 that Foley is his doing. So, you know, a big shout out to him who definitely did a lot of
01:47:32 the live work on this project. Well, it is the first Emanuel production and hopefully not the
01:47:37 last. And I think I speak on behalf of Candice Malcolm and the True North team that we're so
01:47:41 thrilled we get the opportunity to distribute this. And again, this is something that we're
01:47:46 obviously connected to as far as the story is concerned, but this took on a life of its own
01:47:50 before True North got involved, and I was just a lowly participant, as was Rupa. And now I get to
01:47:56 be emceeing the premier. So thank you very much for including me and including my good side. I
01:48:02 don't really have a good side, but not the really bad side, I guess. And to all of you who tuned in
01:48:07 tonight, thank you so much for that. And you can check out the full documentary once again. We are
01:48:13 going to upload it as a standalone, so you don't need to worry about me. Well, I guess you do in
01:48:17 the documentary, but not this part of me. And that's going to be at freedomoccupation.ca and
01:48:22 lots more details about the project there. But congratulations again to Rachel and Johnny. Thank
01:48:27 you everyone so much. God bless you and have a great weekend.
01:48:47 Thank you.
01:49:17 Thank you.
01:49:47 Thank you.
01:50:17 You