Juno News - June 03, 2024


Pride and Palestine protesters clash

Topics
Mentioned
What Doug Ford’s booze liberation means for Ontarians Some MPs are acting for foreign powers. Why aren't they being named?

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

192.91

Word count

8,395

Sentence count

326

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Luck is joined by author and long-time friend Pierre Polyev to discuss his new book, "Pierre Polyev: A Political Life," and to discuss the chaos that was Pride Week in Winnipeg and Philadelphia.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most reverent talk show this is the andrew lotton show
00:01:30 on i was about to okay i was about to get the name of the station wrong uh it's on true north i was
00:01:37 i did a podcast interview this morning with my old uh talk radio colleague craig needles and uh
00:01:43 sitting back behind the microphone it was uh very i brought back all sorts of nostalgia so i was
00:01:49 about to throw the name of the place that I haven't worked in six years. The place that fired
00:01:53 me, by the way. But True North has my back. True North has your back. It is great to have you aboard
00:01:58 the show. Thank you, by the way, to all of you who could launch for me. My new book, Pierre
00:02:07 Polyev, A Political Life, launched last week. We had events in Calgary and Toronto. I've got an
00:02:12 event this week in Ottawa. And I just found out in a couple of weeks' time, I have an event in
00:02:17 Winnipeg on June 20th. Now, this is a little bit bittersweet for me because I have never been to
00:02:24 Manitoba. I have been to every province in Confederation. I've even been to the Yukon
00:02:29 Territory, but I've never been to Manitoba. Again, I got PEI, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick,
00:02:34 Newfoundland, and Labrador, Quebec, Ontario, Saskatchewan, Alberta, British Columbia. I think
00:02:39 I got them all. So I've done all of those, have never done Manitoba. And one of my friends said,
00:02:45 you know what, you've gone this far in your life without going to Manitoba. On principle,
00:02:51 you should see how long you can go without going to Manitoba. Now, one of my colleagues has always
00:02:57 been demanding I go to Manitoba, which has made me want to entrench myself even more on the No
00:03:01 Manitoba. But I had a good offer. So I'm going to go and hopefully we'll have details about that
00:03:05 in the next little while as they are available. I just got the email that that's confirmed a minute
00:03:11 it before I went on air. So I don't actually know all the details yet. But regardless, it is great
00:03:15 to have you on the show. Another Monday, June 3rd. It is, if you care, speaking of Pierre Polyev,
00:03:21 A Political Life, available on Amazon and Indigo, it is Pierre Polyev's birthday. So if you care
00:03:26 about political birthdays, his is June 3rd and Justin Trudeau's is December 25th. So that might
00:03:32 be where he gets that Christ-like complex from having been born on Christmas Day. But we are
00:03:39 going to talk about all sorts of things on the program ahead i do want to begin by discussing
00:03:45 this rather bizarre devolving into chaos of pride events in winnipeg and philadelphia
00:03:54 on the weekend now i don't think speaking of winnipeg there we go winnipeg content it was
00:03:57 meant to be so winnipeg pride month or a pride season as they now call it has kicked off uh this
00:04:03 This is where we celebrate advances in gay rights.
00:04:06 We talk about all of these issues in a number of cases,
00:04:09 and companies will pretend to be all woke when General Dynamics, for example, 0.58
00:04:14 puts up the transgender flag while making tanks for Saudi Arabia. 0.97
00:04:18 So there's a little bit of what they call pinkwashing.
00:04:21 And this was the source of some of the issues raised against Winnipeg Pride
00:04:26 by activists in the Palestinian protest movement,
00:04:30 specifically self-identified queer Palestinian activists. Now, I don't know if they're queer
00:04:37 Palestinians or if they're queers who support Palestinian causes, but the reality is these
00:04:44 people believe that Pride Winnipeg doesn't go far enough. It's not doing enough to advance the woke
00:04:51 social justice cause. So what happened is this Pride event, which was by all accounts a unifying
00:04:57 event, it had police, it had locals, it had gays, it had allies, it had everyone, was blockaded by
00:05:03 people that had a number of demands. The demands were that they do things like divesting from any
00:05:09 company that supports the climate crisis, or I don't know what that has to do with Pride or
00:05:13 Palestine. They were calling on them to ban police, to boycott, basically to boycott any
00:05:20 so-called Zionists. So they don't want any Jews marching in Pride. That was basically what 0.96
00:05:25 happened there. Now, a very similar, although a bit more feisty development happened in Philadelphia
00:05:32 over the weekend as well, where you had in Philly pro-Palestine protesters clashing very violently
00:05:39 with some members of the pride community. Now, I don't know who's on whose side here. We have
00:05:46 two clips for you. This is how it ended. This is just like the Bear Street brawl that took place
00:05:52 in Philadelphia.
00:06:22 Now you see there, police are a little bit outmatched.
00:06:27 I don't know who's on whose side. 1.00
00:06:29 I don't know which of those are the queers for Palestine
00:06:32 and which of those are the gay pride protesters.
00:06:34 You get a little bit more clear delineation in this clip from Philadelphia.
00:06:52 forever
00:07:11 that was the before the second one we played was the after but no pride in genocide that's the
00:07:18 the slogan. So it's not enough just to celebrate gay rights. It's not enough to celebrate that you
00:07:22 have equal marriage. It's not enough to celebrate all of these different achievements in a liberty,
00:07:28 a liberal society. Instead, we have to go after, oh, well, I don't know, maybe the gays are fine, 1.00
00:07:36 but they aren't, not if they have Jews there. That's basically what these people are saying. 0.61
00:07:41 And by the way, I don't have to point out the obvious, but I will, that queers for Palestine, 0.97
00:07:46 Queers Against Israeli Apartheid is one of the most geopolitically devoid knowledge of geopolitics, 0.99
00:07:55 completely void of, there we go, I was bouncing around to it a few different words there, but
00:07:59 it is just so devoid of any knowledge of the geopolitics of the region and so devoid of any
00:08:05 knowledge of what life is like in Gaza. Now, I don't imagine that there is a pride parade in
00:08:12 Gaza. There certainly isn't in the West Bank. I know a couple of IDF soldiers did actually hoist
00:08:17 a rainbow flag when they invaded Gaza a couple of weeks back. The first time, I believe, that a pride
00:08:23 flag has been raised in Gaza. The reason I bring this up is because we have in this country a
00:08:30 tremendous problem when you have groups that are rowing in different directions. Now, it may be
00:08:35 easy to sit back and look at these people and say, oh, well, yeah, it's one left-wing group against
00:08:38 another left-wing group and just enjoy the fight but there's something more concerning happening
00:08:43 beneath the surface here now we can take a look at polling that just came out as well coincidentally
00:08:48 around the same time showing that there is declining support in canada for lgbtq2 rights
00:08:55 and visibility now i'm using that term deliberately because that's the one used in the news coverage
00:09:00 that's the one used in the poll here that was done by ipsos but overwhelmingly canadians all
00:09:06 are tolerant people canadians are tolerant of all different sorts but there is declining support now
00:09:12 there are two explanations for this that i have come up with one is the elephant in the room that
00:09:17 nobody will want to talk about which is immigration when you open your doors as a country to people
00:09:22 from parts of the world that do not have the tolerant pluralistic views of different sexual
00:09:27 identities and orientations that we have in the west you're going to evidently lower the percentage
00:09:34 of people in the country that support these things the other aspect of this and this one is is a
00:09:40 little bit more difficult to prove but i suspect there is an over correction taking place canadians
00:09:45 have overwhelmingly taken a supportive position on gay marriage even if people are personally
00:09:51 uncomfortable with the idea there is no movement in canada that supports doing anything to restrict
00:09:56 that legal right as is correct the marriage is something that should be decided by religious
00:10:02 institutions governments should not be the ones that decide who can get married and who can't i
00:10:07 take a very libertarian position on this but what ultimately is the case here is that canadians are
00:10:13 saying yeah i'm fine with that i'm not fine with my child being transitioned at school and not
00:10:21 learning about it as a parent and these are things that all fall under that broad banner of lgbtq2
00:10:29 rights but are a lot more complicated when you delve into the nitty-gritty of it in fact i've
00:10:34 talked to many lesbian and gay people that have said i don't like the idea of the tea being
00:10:41 included with the lg because the debates the discussions the issues are fundamentally different
00:10:46 i've talked to transgender activists transgender people that have tremendous discomfort with how
00:10:53 things are being pushed on kids from a young age instead of giving them the support to navigate
00:10:58 confusing identities people that are pushing this idea that kids just need to be transitioned put on
00:11:03 hormone blockers and put down this irreversible path the reason i bring that up is because we
00:11:09 are all muddling these things together and if someone says they have an issue with something
00:11:13 in that latter category which by the way includes people who are gay who are trans themselves that
00:11:18 don't like how far the activists are pushing it they're then cast as being overall intolerant
00:11:25 And this is why the pride discussion is so fascinating
00:11:28 because you go back to what's happening in Winnipeg,
00:11:30 what happened in Philadelphia,
00:11:31 what I suspect we'll see at pride events
00:11:33 across the country and across North America
00:11:35 in the coming weeks.
00:11:37 People who are overwhelmingly on the same side,
00:11:41 people who say they want gay rights,
00:11:43 people who say they want rights for sexual minorities
00:11:46 that are all of a sudden telling each other,
00:11:48 no, you don't go far enough.
00:11:50 You're not being intersectional enough.
00:11:52 And others that are saying, whoa, whoa, whoa, hang on here.
00:11:54 I mean, again, Pride events used to be about building bridges.
00:11:58 They used to be about sharing with the community the positive achievements and advancements
00:12:03 and saying, and maybe we could do a little bit more here.
00:12:06 When you want to build bridges, you should be welcoming in police.
00:12:09 You should be welcoming in people that might have been politically against you in the past.
00:12:14 Instead of Pride events, we see people banning conservatives.
00:12:16 We see people banning police.
00:12:19 How are you building bridges if you're starting to make all of these lines about who does
00:12:23 and doesn't belong in something that is supposed to be the paragon of inclusivity and tolerance.
00:12:30 Now, this is me not, I'm not lecturing to anyone. I'm not a member of this community. I'm not
00:12:35 lecturing to anyone about how you should or should not celebrate this season. I think, you know what,
00:12:40 it is absolutely up to anyone to do that how they want to within the boundaries of the law. Again,
00:12:46 I can use my libertarianism to my advantage here. I support free speech. If you want to have a pride
00:12:51 parade, have a pride parade. Absolutely. But I can point out about the societal aspect of this
00:12:56 that right now is clearly not working. And much like immigration, when people see something being
00:13:02 pushed too far or too quickly, they retreat. And we see the consensus on immigration shifting,
00:13:09 even though Canada has always been an overwhelmingly pro-immigration country.
00:13:12 We look at this polling on LGBTQ2 rights, and a lot of people I suspect are frustrated if only
00:13:18 because they don't understand what the q and the two and the t have to do with the l the g and the
00:13:24 b that wasn't meant to rhyme that was just how it worked out so again we don't know what's going to
00:13:29 happen in the future we do know that it wasn't that long ago that you saw the million man march
00:13:33 uh pitting very different cultural groups against each other you had in many cases right-wing
00:13:38 christians and fundamentalist muslims that were all finding support alongside parents that were
00:13:43 not religious or not political at all but then all of a sudden you had the left start to see
00:13:50 a fracture in its coalition the left that says well hang on we've always been pro-muslim we've
00:13:54 always been pro-gay what do we do when these two groups are butting up against each other and i
00:13:59 think that's also influencing in some way what's happening in this pride issue i've seen reports
00:14:05 that attendance in schools is once again going to be challenged this year parents are going to have
00:14:10 their kids walk out because they don't like what's being taught you can say they're right you can say
00:14:15 they're wrong it doesn't matter these are decisions that parents should make and more importantly the
00:14:20 coalition that we have that makes this a tolerant country is one that requires people realizing that
00:14:26 not everyone is going to get along not everyone's going to like each other the goal should not be
00:14:31 forcing everyone to link arms and sing kumbaya the goal should be forcing people to accept that
00:14:36 we live in a pluralistic country they're going to be people whose religions you don't like
00:14:40 they're going to be people whose political views you don't like and that is something that we have
00:14:44 to accept but when you try to make tolerance a one-way street when you try to make tolerance
00:14:49 and imposition it's not whether it's right or wrong it just doesn't work that thank you for
00:14:54 coming to my ted talk on this i i saw the clips in philadelphia i'm like my goodness the whole
00:14:59 thing is about tolerance and love and joy and happiness then you have people ending up in a
00:15:03 brawl in the streets. Hardly the intended message. Thankfully, the Winnipeg one didn't come to that.
00:15:08 It just ended up as a blockade for a time. But they managed to break up the blockade without
00:15:13 the emergencies act coming in. So maybe we are getting baby steps towards the right direction
00:15:19 on the civil liberties front. I am not a sports fan, but I can share in the joy that sports fans
00:15:24 in the audience have that the Edmonton Oilers have made the Stanley Cup final. And what was
00:15:30 interesting is that cbc decided it was going to sit this one out in a way uh chris sims is our
00:15:36 regular monday correspondent she is the alberta director with the canadian taxpayers federation
00:15:41 uh chris always good to talk to you thanks for coming on today well thanks for having us on
00:15:45 this is fun so okay so what what the heck did cbc do here okay so off the top i'm not quite sure
00:15:51 what happened here so i am going to be asking some questions of our state broadcaster maybe there is a
00:15:56 jurisdictional or fee for carriage explanation here. All that being said, I wasn't alone in my
00:16:02 frustration of not being able to watch the Oilers versus the Dallas Stars game. So Andrew, the
00:16:08 Edmonton Oilers were in the Western Conference finals against the Dallas Stars. If they won
00:16:13 this series, they would then go on to the Stanley Cup finals. So just as a bit of an explainer for
00:16:18 background. And they did. They won last night. But on the for game, I think it was game four
00:16:24 or game five, I think it was game five, two games ago, we go to watch the game and it's not on CBC.
00:16:31 Now, to be clear, it's Sportsnet that is producing and filming and streaming the actual game. The CBC
00:16:38 has rights to carry it. And as far as we know, they had the option, we think, of choosing to
00:16:46 simulcast it, choosing to bring it over onto their main net station. But it was nowhere to be found.
00:16:51 They were playing some old just for laughs show or something like that, something that was not NHL hockey, to be clear.
00:16:59 And so you had to rush around and scramble.
00:17:01 And even then you had to upgrade to this like super duper level Sportsnet package in order to be able to watch it.
00:17:07 The reason why I raise this is because Hockey Night in Canada would be far and away the top rated show that Canadians would want to watch at that moment,
00:17:17 especially on our state broadcaster which by the way we pay 1.4 billion dollars for every single
00:17:24 year so the question then is what were the folks who are on super fixed income who couldn't afford
00:17:31 the extra few dollars it was to upgrade their sports net package what about the folks who are
00:17:36 in remote areas that weren't able to watch it why couldn't they watch the game again taxpayers are
00:17:42 paying for the cbc they're the ones that try to use hockey night in canada to promote themselves
00:17:47 all the time. It's the show that everybody would want to watch that evening. So why did they do
00:17:52 this? And they did it again, as far as I can tell, last night. So last night was a big win.
00:17:58 The Edmonton Oilers won, they beat the Dallas Stars, and now they're going to the Stanley Cup
00:18:02 final against the Florida Panthers. But what's weird here, Andrew, is that they were still
00:18:08 carrying the New York Rangers versus Florida Panthers game on the CBC main net channel just
00:18:14 the other day. So it's a real head scratcher why they chose, we think, to not air the two Edmonton
00:18:21 games. Now, again, I want to be clear, there might be some weird fee or broadcast carriage
00:18:26 agreement or something where they weren't allowed to, but we don't have answers on that yet. As a
00:18:31 taxpayer and a hockey fan, I wanted to flag that for people because I wasn't alone. I was seeing
00:18:36 it all over Twitter. So I do have the statement from CBC on this. It sounds like they could have
00:18:42 played it if they wanted. So the statement which I got from Lindsay Finneran-Gingris, who is a,
00:18:49 I believe, a journalist on Twitter, we set our schedule long before the playoffs are determined,
00:18:55 and that schedule includes Canada's ultimate challenge on Sunday nights, as well as the
00:18:59 Canadian Screen Awards Gala. With that context, we knew there would be occasions during the playoffs
00:19:05 when CBC would not be carrying certain games. So their answer is that, well, they didn't know
00:19:09 Edmonton was going to be in the playoffs. So they decided they were going to put the Canadian screen
00:19:14 or the old Canada's ultimate challenge on. And no one thought, oh, wait, me, a Canadian team is in
00:19:19 there. Maybe we should just preempt that a little bit. You are smashing my rose colored glasses,
00:19:24 Andrew, because I don't give them the benefit of the doubt. They don't deserve it. I was honestly
00:19:29 this last little shred of hope inside me was trying to give them the benefit of the doubt.
00:19:34 But you know what makes this even worse, Chris? They paid for the rights and aren't even using
00:19:39 them those rights are not cheap these things cost i would presume in the millions and millions of
00:19:44 dollars and they're not even playing all the games oh yeah we're gonna find out brother i'm putting
00:19:50 in freedom information requests to find out how much we paid for those rights and for them to
00:19:54 choose to not air the edmonton oilers playoff game again something that the vast majority like every
00:20:02 hockey fan in canada would want to watch that even if you're not a huge oilers fan a lot of people
00:20:08 if their team doesn't make it they go for the last canadian team that's still in the playoffs
00:20:13 so they would have had tons of eyeballs on their screen but instead they decide to play some awards
00:20:18 show that i would argue few people outside of the arts community want to watch and some other old
00:20:23 show like that's bizarre so yeah that's that's terrible i was giving them the benefit of the
00:20:27 doubt and that's even worse so yeah we should find out exactly how much we paid for the game they
00:20:32 didn't air now i one thing that's kind of interesting here is i mentioned this i believe
00:20:37 earlier on so we have at true north a pool uh for the the playoffs um where you decide you know which
00:20:44 hockey player is going to get the most touchdowns or something i don't know um but i i don't like
00:20:48 feeling left out so i did i i made what's called a parenth sorry not a parenthesis a bracket right
00:20:54 and uh i you did the bra and you have to like pick who's gonna win and in how many games they're
00:20:58 going to win and by the way so after round one guess who was winning the true north nhl playoff
00:21:04 pool it was yours truly all of these hockey fans were were put to shame because they had no idea
00:21:10 what they were doing and i had no idea what i was doing but they thought they knew what they were
00:21:13 doing so i i came up with like a very weirdly mathematical way i nailed the eastern conference
00:21:19 and i got like all the games right uh you know i you know i i had you know florida and five and
00:21:23 and Boston in seven and Rangers in four and Carolina in five.
00:21:27 I got all the winners right in the Western Conference,
00:21:29 but I didn't get the number of games right on Dallas and Colorado.
00:21:33 So I completely screwed up the second.
00:21:36 So I had the Canucks beating the Oilers.
00:21:38 So that's on me.
00:21:40 Okay, well, you know, I was a little torn because I'm from BC,
00:21:43 but Alberta has embraced me.
00:21:45 So I was definitely cheering for the Oilers against the Canucks.
00:21:48 And I still haven't gotten over my 1994 playoff hopes being dashed by the Rangers.
00:21:52 So I still have the final.
00:21:54 Fair enough.
00:21:55 Yeah, I had the final being Colorado versus Carolina, which is not happening.
00:22:00 So, but again, I knew nothing and I'm still in second place overall.
00:22:03 That's how much they all crapped in.
00:22:04 This is what I mean.
00:22:05 Like, that's not far off.
00:22:07 Like, that's pretty impressive for not knowing what you, did you just like cover your eyes
00:22:11 and pick or what did you do?
00:22:12 No, no.
00:22:13 I looked, so there, there, I, it was, I came up with like my own little system where I
00:22:18 looked at uh the win win loss uh record from this general season and i just picked whichever one had
00:22:23 the highest in the regular season of the two okay that's good so i again i i separated emotion from
00:22:31 it because i don't have a team i actually didn't care i think i think the emotional attachment to
00:22:35 teams is what gets people making bad decisions on these picks but anyway uh speaking of bad decisions
00:22:41 let's talk about government bonuses what happened so very quickly andrew um they do have entire
00:22:46 lottery systems based on sports ball games and even if you don't like sports ball games you
00:22:51 should probably try this because it's i'd rather i'd rather bet on like political outcomes this is
00:22:56 it gets you money though man okay um speaking of money uh remember the bank of canada yeah them so
00:23:02 one of their main jobs is to keep interest rates low so they really failed on that so usually when
00:23:11 somebody really really you know screws up their job and they fail they don't get a bonus not so
00:23:16 fast for government employees uh access to information requests uh by our team there in
00:23:21 ottawa franco terrazzano and ryan thorpe they dug this up apparently the bank of canada handed out
00:23:27 around 23 million dollars in bonuses last year in 2023 so that whole time that people were you know
00:23:35 sweating and having their interest rates going up and all this stuff happening end of the year
00:23:39 before that, they gave them out bonuses. So it doesn't look like they've missed one year of
00:23:43 bonuses, Andrews, at the Bank of Canada. So you can continue to fail upwards as long as you have
00:23:50 a government job, apparently. Yeah, I mean, we're seeing this across departments. I mean,
00:23:55 CBC, I know, has been notoriously evasive on this and actually was a little bit snarky about the
00:24:01 Canadian Taxpayers Federation last week. I don't know if you saw that. They were upset about
00:24:04 basically misinformation circulating about their refusal to hand over data but this is a problem
00:24:11 in other government agencies the departments as well there's just this general chasm between the
00:24:15 way ordinary people in the private sector are and the way people who work for government in some
00:24:20 capacity are yeah exactly and what's weird is that the government will often show us like their
00:24:26 performance like metrics and even what's strange is that they'll show us this stuff they'll show us
00:24:33 these numbers and like where they're trying to hit their target and the targets will be something
00:24:37 really middle of the road, super vanilla, really easy to do. And most of the time, these employees
00:24:43 still aren't meeting their targets and they're still getting bonuses. Like, for example, even at
00:24:49 the top of the CBC, and I didn't see that misinformation thing, I'll have to dig that up
00:24:52 because that's actually a pretty loaded word right now in federal politics. With the CEO of the CBC,
00:24:57 Catherine Tate their viewership is just tanking like by most normal people's metrics she is not
00:25:05 succeeding at her job so their viewership their ratings are tanking they're taking a nosedive
00:25:11 they're taking more and more taxpayers money they're choosing to not air hockey night in
00:25:15 Canada when there's a single Canadian team left in the playoffs like bonehead moves like that
00:25:20 but they still hand out bonuses so regardless of how they're actually performing and how what kind
00:25:25 job they're doing they're still handing out bonuses again if this were a private company
00:25:29 a few would care who cares but this is taxpayers money because these are crown corporations
00:25:36 well and the thing too is that the government i mean the bank of canada has there's an argument
00:25:41 to be made that they shoulder a lot of the blame for the inflation crisis that they are responsible
00:25:46 at least in a way for what canadians are dealing with as far as this cost of living and inflation
00:25:52 issue is concerned so when they're cashing out tens of millions of dollars in in bonuses it's
00:25:57 a particular sting even more than if you know i don't know department of fisheries bureaucrats
00:26:02 were getting big bonuses yeah great point it's not just interest rates it's the fact that they
00:26:06 printed hundreds of billions of dollars during the lockdowns and all of that and that was used
00:26:12 largely to buy up government debt government debt of course if people don't know has now doubled
00:26:18 since 2015. We're now at about $1.2 trillion. And during the lockdowns, especially, they just
00:26:25 fired up the printing press and they used that newly printed money to buy up government debt.
00:26:30 Franco explains this very well because he does have an economics degree or two. And so it again,
00:26:36 it has caused a lot of these critical problems. And again, leading people to think that interest
00:26:41 rates will be low for long. No worries. Don't worry about it. And then all of a sudden they
00:26:45 erupted. And this is particularly interesting. And I did earnestly want to warn people,
00:26:51 they're going to have their rate announcement this Wednesday. So I know that causes a lot of
00:26:55 stress for a lot of people for various reasons with lines of credit and variable mortgages and
00:27:01 all that stuff. It's super important. They are going to be making a rate announcement on Wednesday,
00:27:05 no prediction which way that's going to go. But it does add sting to it when we see them still
00:27:10 taking in these massive bonuses, when by most normal people's metrics, they're not doing a very
00:27:15 good job so is there a policy solution to this could the government and is this something that
00:27:21 the taxpayers federation is advocating for just say hey bureaucracies don't get bonuses yeah
00:27:26 yeah for sure uh if they super wanted to argue that they deserve it then maybe we could start
00:27:32 from there but yeah this should start back at zero for sure and then if we want to argue years later
00:27:37 that hey we are doing an awesome job look at all these metrics look at all these performances that
00:27:41 we've been hitting maybe we can have a discussion after that but as a baseline yeah we shouldn't be
00:27:46 handing out bonuses to bureaucrats and to crown corporations well we're going to be talking with
00:27:51 with aaron woodrick in a few moments about the work from home edict which has become this like
00:27:56 incredible source of offense for much of the public sector but one of the things that aaron's
00:28:01 raised and i think would apply here as well is have pretty clear clearly delineated performance
00:28:07 metrics not things that are done because you know you can clear the bar but things that actually
00:28:12 involve it i mean i'd be fine with bonuses based on how much money you're saving like if hey for
00:28:17 every 10 of taxpayer money you save you get a dollar okay fine we save a dollar less for every
00:28:22 10 but we're still saving the nine buck like like i'm not proposing that as a policy but something
00:28:27 like that because there's right now no incentive to actually pay pay for things to use taxpayers
00:28:32 money responsibly anywhere in government. That's a great point. Reagan had something very similar
00:28:38 to that in the 1980s when he was trying to tackle their deficits. So he brought in people, if I
00:28:43 recall correctly, who were specialists from their field, begged them to come in and take a government
00:28:47 job for a year and find savings. And I think bonuses were given based on the dramatic amount
00:28:53 of savings that were found in different departments. In a reverse way, that's often what balanced
00:28:58 budget legislation does. So for a long time, the province of British Columbia, for an example,
00:29:03 had balanced budget legislation where the minister's department came in with a deficit,
00:29:10 meaning they're spending too much money. That minister took a 10% pay cut. Yeah. So if they're
00:29:16 not doing their job, they get money clawed back. So it's kind of, you know, a different direction
00:29:21 from what you're talking about, but the same sort of incentive structure. So that sounds really
00:29:25 smart. If that's something that MLI is looking into, that'd be great. It's interesting. You're
00:29:29 speaking with Aaron Woodrick, who of course was with the Taxpayers Federation for many years.
00:29:33 They just put out, I'm sure you saw it because I think you signed it, the Ottawa Declaration on
00:29:37 not giving government money to media organizations, which is an excellent thing to see. If people kind
00:29:43 of team up on this stuff and really take a stand, we might actually get some work done here.
00:29:48 Well, that's certainly the hope. Chris Sims from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. Always a
00:29:52 pleasure chris we will talk to you next monday you bet take care all right thanks very much chris
00:29:57 sims the alberta director and star of that uh ai generated song of what was it the voice of alberta
00:30:02 i think that was the name of it uh for crew we won't play it but uh i rachel emmanuel my colleague
00:30:07 at true north she is because i may again i went on like a tear with the ai generated songs admittedly
00:30:13 i i did a little bit more than i probably should have with it because everyone around me was like
00:30:17 just stop with the damn song so rachel i made one for her show and i just did it for her and then 1.00
00:30:21 she put it in the show. And I think it's very polarizing. Some people don't love the AI 0.99
00:30:26 generated theme music. So we haven't embraced an AI generated theme song just yet. That voice you
00:30:31 hear is a real man, a real voiceover guy. The music was made by, I mean, it was probably made
00:30:35 on a computer, but it wasn't made by a computer. I did see something quite interesting the other
00:30:41 day circulating of someone saying, you know, don't let me use AI to make my art so that I have more
00:30:47 time to do laundry. Like let AI do my laundry so I have more time to make art, which was a nice
00:30:51 little philosophical spin on the way AI is going because we're now seeing like AI generated statues
00:30:57 and AI generated this and AI generated music and AI is not doing my dishes on its own I still have
00:31:03 to go and load them in manually and take them out when it's done so all of that notwithstanding a
00:31:08 little bit of a busy day I just want to mention this briefly and I'll do a little bit more on
00:31:12 this as the week progresses in British Columbia politics now I confess fully British Columbia
00:31:17 politics has been an underexplored area on the show because historically there weren't really
00:31:22 great options. You had the BC Liberals, which kind of had like a semblance of some conservative
00:31:28 thought every now and then. And then Christy Clark just took the only bit of conservatism
00:31:32 there out to the woodshed and shot it when she wanted to cling to power. And then you had the 1.00
00:31:37 BC NDP. And it's only been relatively recently that there's been this conservative resurgence,
00:31:41 or maybe insurgency is a better way of putting it, in BC. So we're actually working out,
00:31:46 we're going to have John Rustad, who's the leader of the BC Conservatives, on the show
00:31:50 in the next couple of weeks. And I'm looking forward to that. But another floor crossing
00:31:54 today of a BC United, formerly BC Liberal MLA, joining the Conservatives. There was one last
00:32:00 week as well. There are rumblings that there are going to be perhaps a couple of more. So this is
00:32:05 shaping up to be just the complete decimation of what was once the BC Liberal Party. But
00:32:10 let's get back to the public sector here. Aaron Woodrick is the director of the Domestic Policy
00:32:16 program for the mcdonald laurier institute and joins us now uh aaron it's always good to talk
00:32:21 to you so this story i find just fascinating the federal government says civil servants have to go
00:32:26 back into the office three days a week it's not even like they're being forced in five days a
00:32:31 week like they were up until march of 2020 three days a week and it's as though you've committed
00:32:37 this just grave injustice against public sector unionized workers in ottawa what the heck is going
00:32:43 on here? Yeah, it does speak to an entitlement issue, right? I mean, you got to have perspective.
00:32:49 And I think if there's any allegation, and people will know this from my days advocating with the
00:32:52 Taxpayers Federation, I've been tough on the public sector at times, right? And that's largely because
00:32:57 I don't think sometimes folks in the public sector appreciate how good they have it. I mean,
00:33:02 even when you think about things like defined benefit pensions, which are basically extinct
00:33:06 in the private sector, the level of job security. I mean, these are pretty important things that a
00:33:12 lot of people would give the right arm for. And so I think at times when the public sector
00:33:17 complains about things not being as, you know, optimal for them, they need to recognize that
00:33:24 there's an audience out there of Canadians that don't have anywhere near those things. And so
00:33:28 they, you know, it comes across sometimes a little bit toned out. Yeah. And I mean, look,
00:33:33 I think there are arguments to be made about whether, with work in general, of whether work
00:33:38 can be rethought, whether traditional offices, nine to five jobs can be rethought. But the idea
00:33:43 that government gets something that basically the private sector never will, or government workers
00:33:48 get something that most private sector employees never will, is always the part that rubs me the
00:33:53 wrong way about this. I mean, we talked about this in the context of executive bonuses with Chris
00:33:56 Sims a few moments ago, but it's especially true on an arrangement like this. Like any private
00:34:01 sector office worker that I've spoken to, with few exceptions, so I shouldn't say any, most of them
00:34:06 are looking at this and are like, give me a break. I had to go back to the office a year and a half
00:34:10 ago. Yeah, absolutely. And in a lot of cases, the response I always used to get from, you know,
00:34:16 people in the public sector or the union leaders in the public sector as well, the government is
00:34:21 being the leader in this, right? When I'd say, well, we can't afford to find benefit pensions,
00:34:24 they say, well, it's the private sector should have them too. Well, and the obvious reason,
00:34:28 Andrew, that they don't have them is they can't afford them, is that unlike the government,
00:34:31 businesses don't have unlimited funds, right? They have to stay afloat. And so I think sometimes
00:34:36 Again, in the public sector, they need to recognize that they're not facing the same kind of constraints that those in the private sector have. And that while I never begrudge any group sort of banding together to try and get the best deal they can have, they often have power and negotiating power that people in the private sector just don't have.
00:34:54 And they don't have a lot of sympathy for people that are crying about things and saying, oh, you know, boo-hoo, you have to go in three days a week instead of two.
00:35:02 I've been going back five days a week for years.
00:35:05 It just strikes the ear wrong, I think.
00:35:07 So you offer in the hub what I think is an olive branch, and I suspect the Public Service Alliance of Canada might not see it that way.
00:35:15 But you say federal public servants can get their remote work, but in return, they should expect more rigorous performance reviews.
00:35:22 What do you mean?
00:35:24 Yeah, this is a bit of a contrarian take, and some people were surprised to see me say this.
00:35:29 But I think part of the issue we have right now is this, is that the people in public service, they really like the remote work, just like a lot of people who enjoy the remote work.
00:35:39 Now, does that mean they should always get it?
00:35:40 Not necessarily, but I do think we should acknowledge the type of white-collar work, the type of work at a computer.
00:35:46 That is the ideal type of work for remote work, if you're going to have it at all.
00:35:49 And most of the public sector is that kind of work.
00:35:52 most of the government jobs in Ottawa involve the type of work where you log onto a computer
00:35:56 and type at a keyboard. I think we should be open to remote work in those cases. The other thing I
00:36:02 think is a lot of the thing that is motivating both the government and the public to want to get
00:36:07 public servants back to work has nothing to do with whether or not they need to be there.
00:36:13 It's more a sense of, I think you're lazy and I'd rather have you at a desk. And my response to that
00:36:18 is, first of all, I will defend civil servants on that. Are there bad ones? I'm certain there
00:36:22 are who don't work. But otherwise, I think many of them are happy to do their work. And I think
00:36:28 if your real concern is that civil servants are lazy, well, I can tell you, they'll probably be
00:36:33 lazy sitting at their desk downtown at the office just as much as they will at home. So that doesn't
00:36:36 solve anything. Even worse, because now you've got the social aspect, the coffee station, the
00:36:41 Well, this is it. And Andrew, I almost think like, look, let's be honest, for some people,
00:36:45 It's just about sticking it to them.
00:36:47 It's about saying, you know what?
00:36:48 I don't like you.
00:36:48 So I'm going to make you trudge downtown to the office.
00:36:51 I think that's a poor reason to do it.
00:36:53 The same as way, you know, Doug Ford says they need to get back down there.
00:36:56 So the restaurants, that is not a reason to send people into the office just because it supports the, you know, the restaurants at lunch.
00:37:02 And that's a terrible reason.
00:37:03 But what I am saying is they want this so bad.
00:37:05 Let's make a deal.
00:37:06 Let's make a deal that gives both sides what they want.
00:37:08 You can get your remote work, but you have, we have to talk about your pensions.
00:37:12 We have to talk about productivity and performance measurement.
00:37:15 we want Canadians to get good value for their money. So if you're willing to accept some kind
00:37:20 of oversight, some kind of measurement, something that gives people confidence you're doing work and
00:37:24 you're doing it well, and Canadians are getting value for the tax dollars, then we can talk about
00:37:28 remote work. I think that's a good trade, both for Canadians and for civil servants, and they
00:37:33 should seriously think about that. Yeah, and I think it brings it back to the broader idea of
00:37:37 this that doesn't have anything to do with government or private sector. It's just generally
00:37:41 about remote work and look i i worked remotely before it was cool too i i worked from home before
00:37:46 covet came along and i like it i think there are some deficiencies in it but we have a team at true
00:37:51 north that's scattered around the country so it's just not practical to work anything but remotely
00:37:56 but it comes down to a performance question of you know if if you can perform at the same level
00:38:02 regardless of where you are i don't think it should matter if there is a deficit in some way
00:38:07 of what you're able to do at home that needs to be accounted for in some way whether it's you know
00:38:12 people work a bit longer whether you change i mean you you have to have some way of of addressing
00:38:16 that i understand the convenience i mean you save money on parking you save money on gas you save
00:38:21 just frustration of travel time all of that but but we need to have the discussion of productivity
00:38:26 and there has to be a way to measure that productivity i think exactly and the measurement
00:38:31 historically for the civil service has been did you show up at your desk downtown were you there
00:38:35 at the hour and did you leave? And I'm saying that was always a bad measurement. And we should
00:38:39 take this opportunity now to say, you know what? I'm okay with an arrangement, whether it's public
00:38:44 or private, saying, here are your tasks. You need to perform these tasks well on time by this time.
00:38:50 If you do that, I don't care where you work. I think that can work both in the public and private
00:38:53 sector, but that's not what we have right now. So I think we need to, you know, and it's really a
00:38:58 test here, Andrew, to see just how badly folks in the public service want this. They should be
00:39:03 willing to accept that. I'm willing to bet a lot of them are. The other thing, too, I would say
00:39:07 with remote work, like you, I've long worked remotely. It's certainly been a benefit to me
00:39:12 and my family, but the nature of the work I've done has suited itself to that. I think the
00:39:17 civil service, we remember the headaches with passports, you know, it was taking Canadians
00:39:21 forever to get a passport. That gave people a reason to believe that not being in the office
00:39:26 was a problem, right? And so I think the civil service needs to prove that it can deliver
00:39:30 remotely. Otherwise, you're going to have people saying, hey, if you're not being productive,
00:39:34 I'm waiting forever for stuff because you're working from home. I want to see you back in
00:39:37 the office because in your mind, maybe that will fix the problem.
00:39:41 Well, and also the other thing we've seen this in the context of in a lot of ways is just
00:39:46 the remote work question as a convenience is great, but you can't just make that policy based
00:39:52 on the fact that it's more convenient for you as an individual. You have to figure out
00:39:55 the value add. I mean, there's always the age old problem if you start heaping productivity on
00:39:59 people is that or heaping tasks on people is that we have to rethink the idea of nine to five work
00:40:04 in general. I mean, there are people that are very effective that do a lot. And what do they do? They
00:40:08 finish their work in six hours. So their employer gives them more work to do. Whereas the people
00:40:13 that take the eight hours for the same work end up doing less. So I think in general, we need a
00:40:18 bit of a rethink on these things across the board, not just in government. Yeah, I think so. And
00:40:23 remember, there are other trade offs involved. If you're say, for example, you're someone and I'm a
00:40:27 recovering lawyer, if you're a junior lawyer, it's your first year, you learn a lot of what you do
00:40:33 from the more senior lawyers around you, right? From being in the office next to the senior
00:40:36 partner and just sort of being called in ad hoc. When you do all remote work, you lose some of
00:40:40 that. So as much as I am a supporter of flex work, and in some cases, especially once you're past a
00:40:45 certain level of more remote work, it's absolutely true that a lot of professions, the networking,
00:40:51 the skill transfer, a lot of that comes from proximity, physical proximity to the people that
00:40:56 you work with. So that has to be part of it. Like what does a civil service look like where your
00:41:00 more junior people are never around the more seasoned experts? There's something there. So
00:41:05 I think that has to be part of the discussion. All I'm saying is that, you know, this looks like
00:41:10 another run-of-the-mill labor strife that we're going to have in Ottawa. I think there is unique
00:41:15 opportunity here given the context and we shouldn't throw all that stuff out the window
00:41:19 because this type of situation may not present itself soon again anytime. Very briefly, I'm
00:41:25 pulling you off topic here, but I know True North was a signatory to this declaration, this Ottawa
00:41:31 declaration that McDonnell-Laurie Institute was instrumental in, asking for something that a few
00:41:36 years ago wouldn't have seemed all that controversial, the government not subsidized
00:41:39 the media. But now there's a clear line on this. You have big media companies in Canada, the Toronto
00:41:44 Star, Post Media, the Globe and Mail, who are, as they describe it, entirely dependent on government
00:41:50 subsidies to survive. And these independent players like not just True North and The Hub,
00:41:55 but Paul Wells, who's done a great job on Substack, he signed this as well. Why'd you take this on?
00:42:02 Yeah, look, we just think it's an important issue. We care about democracy and we care about a free
00:42:06 press. And in our view, institutionally, it's simply incompatible for a media organization to
00:42:11 be dependent on government and claim to be independent. It just completely undermines any
00:42:15 claim. And I don't want to suggest that every organization or every journalist that's employed
00:42:20 by an organization that takes government money is like actively trying to suck up to the government.
00:42:25 But what I am saying is it's impossible to get past the impression of a conflict of interest.
00:42:30 Like the average person, all it will take, if you're an organization that covers, say,
00:42:35 the Trudeau government flatteringly, it's very easy for people to draw the link between saying,
00:42:39 well, of course you would say that because you're receiving money from them. So I think if you
00:42:42 truly want to be independent, you have to be willing to say, we've got to stand on our own
00:42:46 two feet. We're very glad that True North is one of the organizations that has signed that
00:42:50 declaration. All right. Well, Aaron Woodrick, always good to talk to you, sir. Thanks so much
00:42:54 for coming on. Thanks a lot, Andrew. All right, Aaron Woodrick, we will be back tomorrow with
00:42:59 more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show. And let me tell you as well, Pierre Polyev,
00:43:03 A Political Life, available on Amazon, available at Indigo, available at your local neighborhood
00:43:08 bookstore generally speaking and if not ask them they'll be able to get it in and you can support
00:43:13 independent booksellers and well by extension authors as well all right well that does it for
00:43:18 us we will talk to you all tomorrow thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for
00:43:23 listening to the andrew lawton show support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news