Juno News - May 16, 2023


Public library bans "free speech" event

Mentioned
Justin Trudeau is LOSING in Toronto! Maxime Bernier wants to "reopen the abortion debate"

Episode Stats


Length

32 minutes

Words per minute

186.02

Word count

6,029

Sentence count

208

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton is joined by a guest from Nova Scotia, Canada, and a special guest from London, Ontario. They discuss the growing problem of repeat offenders being released on bail and re-offending, and how the revolving door of the justice system is to blame.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:16 Hello everyone and welcome to you all.
00:00:19 Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here on True North.
00:00:22 It is Tuesday, May 16th, just after 4 p.m. Eastern Daylight Time.
00:00:27 And for those of you like me who relish knowing what it is in individual time zones,
00:00:32 that makes it 9.02 in British summertime.
00:00:35 Again, if you are like me and have no life,
00:00:37 and time zones are the bit of trivia you cling to.
00:00:40 Nevertheless, we've got a busy, busy show today.
00:00:44 Sean is telling me I have to do Saskatchewan,
00:00:47 but the problem is I actually never know what time it is in Saskatchewan
00:00:50 because like half the year it's on central time
00:00:53 and the other half is on mountain time and I forget which is which.
00:00:56 So I think it's on Central Time right now.
00:00:58 I think Saskatchewan is one hour behind.
00:01:00 We have a guest from Saskatchewan today.
00:01:03 So my hope is that we got the time zone right.
00:01:07 But we are going to be talking about lots of good stuff in the show.
00:01:11 We don't have a Saskatchewan guest today, do we?
00:01:13 No, that's tomorrow, isn't it?
00:01:15 Yeah, we have a guest from Nova Scotia today.
00:01:18 We have a guest who is from Ontario, but is in England today.
00:01:22 And this is like five minutes of the show.
00:01:23 You'll never get back.
00:01:24 And Sean, you're fired.
00:01:25 I mean, after the end of the show, though, we got to get through to the end before you pack up your virtual bag.
00:01:30 Today, we are going to talk about this case that I've been following, which is a local case for me in London, Ontario, but has much broader implications.
00:01:40 And that is the decision to ban a speech being put together by the Society for Academic Freedom and Scholarship made by the local library.
00:01:49 The London Public Library, committed to intellectual freedom, says free speech is a cornerstone and libraries should be upholding it.
00:01:56 But when a lecturer from overseas wants to come and talk about free speech, that's just a little too controversial to allow on library property.
00:02:06 So we'll talk about that with the president of the Society for Academic Freedom and Scholarship, Mark Mercer, in just a couple of moments.
00:02:13 Also going to delve into the wonderful world of corporate welfare.
00:02:17 You may remember that case we discussed a couple of weeks ago with Volkswagen getting bajillion dollars from the government.
00:02:24 And now all of a sudden another automotive manufacturer is saying they want more money too.
00:02:28 So they've halted construction on a plant until they get more money from the government.
00:02:33 So it's almost as though we saw this one coming.
00:02:37 But first off, I want to just talk about this clip that's making its way around the internet right now, which is just a delightful, delightful clip.
00:02:45 So Justin Trudeau today came out and his government promised some new bail reform, which is supposedly going to make it a little bit more difficult for violent offenders to get bail.
00:02:54 But a lot of people think this is kind of window dressing, that this problem has been going on for quite some time.
00:02:59 Police have been warning about it. People in the community safety sector have been warning about it.
00:03:04 And there has not been a solution from the government.
00:03:07 And the conservatives have been talking about this. They don't like the revolving door of the justice system.
00:03:12 And Pierre Polyev, in particular, came out against this.
00:03:15 And there was one particular reporter that just didn't get quite grasp the issue.
00:03:21 Take a look.
00:03:22 When you talk about bail, the crime has already happened, or the alleged crime has already happened.
00:03:28 So how can you attribute bail to this increase in crime?
00:03:34 And should there not be more supportive measures to prevent the crime in the first place?
00:03:38 If you're talking about someone being on bail, they've already allegedly committed
00:03:46 the crime.
00:03:47 They're committing crimes on bail.
00:03:52 That's the problem.
00:03:53 The problem is, I'll give you an example.
00:03:55 In Vancouver, the same 40 offenders were arrested 6,000 times in a year.
00:04:05 That's 150 arrests per offender per year.
00:04:09 Why?
00:04:10 Because they're arrested in the morning, then they're released on bail by noon, they re-offend,
00:04:15 they're back in jail by 2 in the afternoon, and then they're released by the evening
00:04:19 so that they can commit their final crime before they go to bed.
00:04:21 The failure of the system to not support people who have committed crimes, gone to jail, served
00:04:28 their sentence, you know, and then they're committing another crime.
00:04:33 So is this not a failure of things like social services and support for people who have committed crimes?
00:04:38 Are you serious?
00:04:39 I'm asking a question.
00:04:40 Are you serious?
00:04:42 Come on.
00:04:43 You're telling me.
00:04:44 No, excuse me.
00:04:44 Let me answer your question.
00:04:45 Are you honestly saying that it's society's fault if a repeat violent offender commits 60 or 70 offenses?
00:04:56 I think that criminal is to blame for his own actions.
00:05:00 He is personally responsible.
00:05:02 We're not talking about some kid who made one mistake when he was 19.
00:05:05 We're talking about people who do 60, 70 violent offenses.
00:05:10 And then they're because they're criminals.
00:05:13 But why are they criminals?
00:05:15 Because they do crime.
00:05:16 Why do they do crime?
00:05:17 Because we let them out early on bail.
00:05:24 I've seen that like four or five times.
00:05:26 If you're wondering why I was like delayed on the show today,
00:05:30 Well, maybe you didn't know that I was, but I was slightly because I just like had watched that for like 12 minutes.
00:05:35 And my goodness, like it just at a certain point, I like Pierre Polyev just breaking the idea of, you know, being polite and civil and courteous.
00:05:42 And it's just like, are you serious? Like that face has got to be a meme until the end of time.
00:05:46 So we'll talk about this a little bit more tomorrow.
00:05:48 But I wanted you to see the clip and be able to enjoy it and bask in it as I could.
00:05:52 Going back to the story of the London Public Library, which is London, Ontario, not London, England,
00:05:58 which has been especially confusing because the speaker at the center of this is a speaker from
00:06:04 england so i was like getting retweeted by all these brits that were like taking out their anger
00:06:08 at the library in london england uh which admittedly would probably do something like
00:06:13 this too but in this particular context it is the public library down in my neck of the woods
00:06:18 in southwestern ontario which has barred an academic freedom group of which i happen to be
00:06:24 member the Society for Academic Freedom and Scholarship from booking out its theater from
00:06:29 paying to rent its theater to host a talk by British author Joanna Williams the talk unironically
00:06:36 was to be titled sex gender and the limits of free speech and this was evidently too controversial to
00:06:41 hold at the London Public Library despite its stated policy its official policy committed to
00:06:49 intellectual freedom. And I just want to put up on the screen here for a moment the Statement
00:06:55 on Intellectual Freedom in Libraries, which is from the CFLA, the Canadian Federation of Library
00:07:01 Associations. And this statement has actually been adopted by the London Public Library as policy.
00:07:07 And there's a line in here that you should read, a couple of lines, that all individuals have the
00:07:13 right to access the full range of knowledge, imagination, ideas, and opinions, and to express
00:07:19 their thoughts publicly, only the courts may abridge free expression rights in Canada. The
00:07:25 policy also says that the right to intellectual freedom includes the right to seek, receive, and
00:07:31 impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers, and it also affirms
00:07:36 that libraries have a, quote, core responsibility, unquote, to support, defend, and promote the
00:07:44 universal principles of intellectual freedom and privacy. So we have this policy committing the
00:07:50 London Public Library to intellectual freedom, but when the rubber hits the road, they say that
00:07:55 a talk on free speech is evidently worthy of being deplatformed. The president of the Society for
00:08:02 Academic Freedom and Scholarships. SAFS is a professor from St. Mary's University by the name
00:08:07 of Mark Mercer, and he joins me now. Mark, it's good to talk to you again. Thanks for coming on
00:08:13 today. Now, I mean, the one gross sort of or perverse irony here is that your organization
00:08:21 exists to combat this, and you're getting proof of the very point that Joanna Williams was going
00:08:28 to be speaking about, which is that there are these limits on free speech that exist.
00:08:32 Well, yes, but do you think that irony is appreciated by the people who denied us our space?
00:08:42 Well, no, and I guess that's where I want to just talk a little bit about SAFs for a moment, because this is not, and again, I mean no offense to you and to others, because I'm a member as well, but this is not a fire-breathing organization, I'd say.
00:08:54 Any meetings I've ever been to have been very respectful.
00:08:58 You and I were corresponding this week.
00:09:00 There's never been any disruptive protest added.
00:09:03 And, you know, one member of SAF said, you know, it's a bunch of stuffy academics sitting around.
00:09:08 It's not, you know, this controversial lightning rod.
00:09:11 So why do you think that this ban has been issued by the library?
00:09:16 Well, I'm not sure, but I want to take issue with some of the things you said.
00:09:19 I was just quoting one of your speakers from this year as far as stuffy academics go.
00:09:24 but carry on well we there's lots of controversy but uh yes we we discuss um things civilly and uh
00:09:33 uh because we we want to uh to understand how things are we want to talk with each other
00:09:39 uh so uh very many controversial uh things have been said at staffs meetings but but it's always
00:09:45 done in a respectful way not to right i guess that's more where i was getting at there that's
00:09:50 right no no fisticuffs no pushing people into the hallways or anything like that yes so it is
00:09:59 strange to me that a group whose record has been one of civil discourse is now
00:10:08 denied space in the library and some of the reasons I don't think I understand them but
00:10:13 that we would deny um the library patrons um uh use of the facilities or something like that
00:10:21 what what are we going to do uh take um uh pea shooters and and shoot at library page patrons 0.72
00:10:29 so i really don't understand where where they're coming from yeah we're not blocking entrances
00:10:36 no and if anyone's familiar with the layout of the library which most people listening wouldn't be
00:10:42 It's not even in the library itself.
00:10:44 It's in a dedicated area across the hall.
00:10:47 So it's like, you know, someone going to check out Fifty Shades of Grey or whatever
00:10:51 wouldn't even have to, you know, be in earshot of your event.
00:10:54 So this idea that it would be disruptive to other library patrons.
00:10:59 One of the other policies they quoted was risk or likelihood of physical danger to participants.
00:11:05 And also workplace harassment and sexual harassment prevention policies were, quote unquote, engaged.
00:11:12 Yeah, well, maybe there's a rock band called SAFs and they have,
00:11:16 but they got us confused with some bands been trashing hotel rooms for the last decade.
00:11:22 Yeah, it's absurd.
00:11:24 I had no idea how one could think that a group of stuffy old academics, 1.00
00:11:29 who do talk about controversial things, but stuffy nonetheless,
00:11:32 would be a threat to a property or person.
00:11:37 One of the challenges with the no platforming approach,
00:11:41 which we've seen and you know full well on university campuses is that oftentimes people
00:11:47 will use the language to say that they're supporters of free speech, but they want to
00:11:52 make it very difficult for some people to speak. They'll say, well, just because you have the right
00:11:56 to speak doesn't mean you have the right to a platform. And the problem with this is that the
00:12:00 very places that should be platforms for controversial speech, evocative speech are
00:12:05 places like libraries and universities. Yet they're the ones that seem to be the most susceptible
00:12:10 to this idea of saying that this speech
00:12:13 is going to go against unspecified policies?
00:12:16 Well, we do have a right to a platform
00:12:19 in the sense that we have a right to line up
00:12:22 and pay our money at venues
00:12:24 that are responsible for allowing people
00:12:29 in the community to come together and talk about things.
00:12:33 So, you know, we do have a right to a platform,
00:12:36 just in that we have a right to pay for this space at fair rates.
00:12:43 And so that's being denied us.
00:12:45 And this is why I think the thing is deeply disturbing.
00:12:48 I think the only grounds that seem to make any sense for denying us the space
00:12:55 is that they don't like what they believe Joanna will say.
00:12:58 It can't be that we are a threat to property or persons.
00:13:05 so that must be it but they do have an obligation as you noted by reading the intellectual freedom
00:13:12 statement to to grant us that space one of the things that that strikes me about that statement
00:13:20 is that there was a big push a few years ago in ontario for example to have universities put these
00:13:26 commitments to academic freedom and and freedom of speech these policies in place and i was a
00:13:31 a supporter of that because I think it's better to have than not but I think that what this episode
00:13:35 is illuminating and some of the other issues from the academy in the last few years is that you can
00:13:40 have the words on the paper all you want but if the people in these institutions are not committed
00:13:45 to free speech or maybe they are nominally but are too scared to follow through with it it actually
00:13:52 doesn't really mean all that much that's been one of my central themes for 15 years or so in my
00:13:59 writing that it's it's the culture that matters and if we have a culture of intellectual endeavor
00:14:05 a culture of uh uh free uh freedom of expression freedom of inquiry uh then you know we don't have
00:14:11 to worry too much about uh what the uh what the words on the paper are uh words on the on paper
00:14:16 are good when things um become difficult but unless there is that commitment no they don't
00:14:24 mean much at all. Universities can get around government-imposed policies. Another problem
00:14:31 with the government-imposed policies is that there's no better way of galvanizing the anti-free
00:14:37 speech people than to threaten government action against the university. I'm still on the fence. I
00:14:45 think there are good arguments for governments taking a more active role than they are,
00:14:52 but really it does come down to the professors and the students the professors and the students have
00:14:57 to be in favor of freedom of expression in order for the university campus to be a place of freedom
00:15:02 of expression um you probably haven't seen this yet but i'm gonna have a story about it at five
00:15:08 o'clock today this just came about this afternoon and i i'm still giving the library the opportunity
00:15:13 to respond to it a memo that was sent out uh internally by the ceo of the library about this
00:15:19 incident but but one part that i i can raise with you is that the ceo says that the library policies
00:15:27 have to be uh filtered through the lens of i'm going to pull up the exact wording here
00:15:32 exceptional customer service and a commitment to anti-racism and anti-oppression and and those
00:15:38 words in an academic setting i i think are they're loaded terms and they may be on the surface sound
00:15:43 great yes anti-racism is good anti-oppression is good but what strikes me in the library case
00:15:50 clearly and in universities is that the idea of academic freedom seems to be secondary to these
00:15:55 things it's yes academic freedom but we have to balance this against our commitment to diversity
00:16:00 or we have to balance this against our our commitment to anti-racism and these things
00:16:04 don't really balance so much as be subject to a veto it seems well and that's right and really
00:16:11 a lot depends on what one wants from a democratic, multicultural society, individualistic society.
00:16:19 And I think the equity, diversity, and inclusion initiatives and ideas have a basis in a sort
00:16:29 of collectivity or collectivism where the group is somehow supreme. And if you are concerned
00:16:38 about the individual, you think the individual inquire, the individual discussant is what's
00:16:45 most important, then you won't see a conflict between academic freedom and anti-racism.
00:16:53 But it's only if somehow the group, however it's defined, is the arbiter of what is oppressive
00:17:06 and what isn't oppressive, that we find conflicts between freedom of expression or academic freedom
00:17:11 and anti-racism. Now, as I indicated in my reporting, and as you've said elsewhere,
00:17:18 the event is going on. You've had to find another venue, and the talk by Joanna Williams, which I'll
00:17:24 be at, and I would encourage anyone else in the area to be at, is preceding Friday at the Delta
00:17:28 Hotel. But in general, where do you go from here? I know you indicated when we spoke earlier this
00:17:34 week that you're trying to get a sense of internal processes and deliberations here.
00:17:39 I know I've also filed a Freedom of Information request on my own independently of you, but
00:17:44 what do you want to do moving forward with this?
00:17:47 Well, I want people to know about this and to approach their libraries and say that this
00:17:54 is inconsistent with the library's mission, what the library should be doing.
00:17:59 I think if people don't know that we were turned down, then it looks like, you know, everything's fine with the library.
00:18:08 So, you know, I want people to know and people to say, well, you know, if they can do it to the Society for Academic Freedom and Scholarship, which is just a talking shop.
00:18:22 We like controversy, we like to talk about it, then anyone could be turned down.
00:18:29 There just don't seem to be any grounds for denying us space, and then that's an arbitrary decision by the library, and everyone is affected.
00:18:43 So that's why we want to know more about it, yes, even though we're having the talk and we'll be doing this for a number of years coming.
00:18:55 good well that's I'm looking forward to it and anyone who is interested can learn more
00:19:01 at the SAF's website there Mark Mercer Professor Mark Mercer and President of SAF's always good
00:19:07 to talk to you Mark thanks and we'll see you on Friday thanks Andrew yes looking forward to it
00:19:11 see you there all right thank you very much and yeah Joanna Williams she has never been cancelled
00:19:16 she's had a call in the UK at one point to cancel one of her talks but it's never happened
00:19:21 The odd thing, I didn't mention this with Mark,
00:19:24 SAFs actually had an event at the very same library in 2019,
00:19:29 which I was at, and I had introduced the keynote speaker,
00:19:32 who is a University of Chicago historian, Rachel Fulton Brown.
00:19:36 And again, no protest, no controversy,
00:19:37 except for sort of the controversy that rigorous debate and thought can sometimes provoke.
00:19:43 But the idea that we have libraries which are fighting tooth and nail
00:19:48 against so-called book bans from the, you know, evil, scary conservatives in the U.S. or whatever.
00:19:54 They talk about the importance of free exchange of ideas, except if they don't like your idea.
00:20:00 And then all of a sudden, it is not all that important.
00:20:03 I want to move on to the idea of corporate welfare here.
00:20:06 And we talked a few weeks back on this show about the slippery slope,
00:20:10 which you didn't even need to look that far down the pipeline to see coming,
00:20:13 and the implications of the federal and provincial governments bending over backwards
00:20:18 to give billions and billions and billions in subsidies to Volkswagen
00:20:23 to build an electric vehicle battery plant in St. Thomas, Ontario.
00:20:28 Again, I'm sticking with local news today, but there's a bigger picture aspect of it.
00:20:32 $13 billion was what we found out Volkswagen was getting.
00:20:35 And now you look just a couple hours down the 401 and Stellantis,
00:20:40 An auto manufacturer building a plant in Windsor, Ontario, has halted because it wants more money from the federal and provincial governments.
00:20:50 And now the great story here, Philippe-Francois Champagne, the federal cabinet minister, says Ontario needs to pay its fair share to the company to end the stalemate.
00:21:02 So all of a sudden, it is companies shaking down the government at all levels for money.
00:21:08 And this is just the way business is done in Canada.
00:21:11 Aaron Woodrick is the Domestic Policy Director for the Macdonald-Laurier Institute and joins us now.
00:21:16 Aaron, it's always good to talk to you.
00:21:18 Could we have seen this coming from a mile away that now every company is just wanting more and more cash
00:21:23 now that they've seen how much is coming out of the government taps?
00:21:27 Boy, if only someone could have predicted this, like you and me and a lot of other people,
00:21:32 who said you know I do have to confess though Andrew I didn't see the chickens coming home to
00:21:36 roost quite this quickly no I thought maybe like years not weeks yeah I mean it is really something
00:21:41 here and look put yourself in Stellantis's shoes right I mean what they're doing is perfectly
00:21:45 logical perfectly rational they're saying they're saying hold on a second you just gave VW 13 billion
00:21:50 what are we doing here I mean we can clearly get more they're clearly prepared to pay more
00:21:55 so now they're they've they've stopped constructing their plant um and you know the thing that really
00:22:00 the real kicker here Andrew is I'm absolutely certain that nobody in the Ford government or
00:22:05 Trudeau government when they were busy trying to you know get seduce VW with billions of dollars 0.52
00:22:10 none of them put any thought into what it would do to Stellantis none of them put any thought
00:22:13 into what it would do to other companies watching and learning how to play the game so that's the
00:22:18 real uh tragedy here is this is a mess entirely of their own making now you've got Ford telling
00:22:24 the feds to do it and you've got the feds telling Ford government to do it and I'm saying guys
00:22:28 before you were you were climbing over each other for a chance to offer the subsidy now you're
00:22:33 saying oh no no it's not my problem i mean the irony is pretty rich here yeah and that's the
00:22:38 problem i mean they were just bragging about the 13 billion dollars when i would have seen that as
00:22:44 a confession more than a boast and and now you know they've decided volkswagen is the beneficiary
00:22:49 everyone else should just be satisfied with what they got but but again if you're a company like
00:22:54 this and i mean basically you're holding jobs over the government's head here i i get it from
00:22:59 a business perspective it makes sense because free money is better than no money and they know
00:23:03 it's being dished out sure but that's that's exactly why these things are dangerous precedents
00:23:08 once you're a government that hangs a sign in your window saying we will we will give free money away
00:23:14 what do you think is going to happen to every any company andrew that's thinking of coming to
00:23:18 Ontario um is going to stop at Queen's Park first and say and hint and say hey we were thinking of
00:23:24 building this plant here we might build it somewhere else what have you got for me I mean
00:23:27 this is the situation that they have created for themselves and it's it's just not sustainable
00:23:32 we're going to see how tough they are I mean you'll recall on the day of the VW announcement
00:23:37 Andrew the Prime Minister uh very explicitly said oh well you know other companies shouldn't expect
00:23:42 this this is a one-off well it's only been a few weeks and he's about to be tested if he's going
00:23:47 to keep his word on that. Yeah. And I know it's difficult to pull up a metaphorical crystal ball
00:23:53 here and see what's going to happen. I mean, if you're Stellantis and you've already invested
00:23:56 in starting this plant and you already budgeted for it, it stands to reason that if the government
00:24:02 were to call their bluff, I would assume they would proceed rather than cut their losses. But
00:24:08 you never know. And I think the government may not want this if the Stellantis folks end up 1.00
00:24:13 having better pr than the government does sure and you know you might be right but uh we've seen
00:24:18 in the past we've seen automakers that already have plants in ontario that were up and running
00:24:23 play this game and imply that you know what if we don't get more subsidies we might have to leave so
00:24:28 um it would be nice to see a government try and call their bluff on it for once i mean of course
00:24:33 a lot of governments are terrified that their bluff would be called and they'd have to wear it
00:24:36 but if you never call their bluff i mean for from a company standpoint what have they got to lose by
00:24:41 trying to do this all the time you had a great piece in the hub i think it was i think it came
00:24:46 out yesterday i read it this morning and when you talk about there being smarter ways to strengthen
00:24:51 canada than with corporate welfare but one of the angles that you discussed here which i think is
00:24:55 important is how certain jobs can be sentimentalized and i think you know factory jobs are
00:25:00 that because it really is to a lot of people this hallmark of a bygone era where everyone in the town
00:25:05 works at the same factory and around that factory there's a sense of community and i i don't think
00:25:11 that that sentimentalization for lack of a term is worth the 13 billion dollars no and look there's
00:25:16 nothing wrong with as i write in the piece of course you should be focused on working class
00:25:21 families and communities that have lost their employers but what my argument is that you know
00:25:25 corporate welfare is just creating the illusion of bringing back those old times it's not real
00:25:30 i mean these are not companies that have an attachment to the community um they're only
00:25:34 coming because they're getting a big subsidy it's a bit like saying i i've developed this new
00:25:38 friendship when really you just paid someone to be your friend i mean that's what's going on here
00:25:43 and i think particularly for conservatives they need to be careful that they're not sort of um
00:25:48 you know they're not kidding themselves because this is this is not real these are not real jobs
00:25:52 i mean if you pay someone um to to to hire you um or is that is that is that a real job i mean that's
00:26:00 most people would find that a bit bizarre is that but that's exactly what's happening here and so i
00:26:03 I think people need to remember that there's a massive cost involved in something that would
00:26:09 otherwise just be celebrated as a pure gain to the community. Yeah, and I think there are
00:26:14 examples of that. I mean, Chapman's, the ice cream factory up in Markdale is a really community
00:26:19 oriented factory. I think the Savage Arms plant, which I toured a couple of years ago up in
00:26:24 Peterborough, an American company, but really ingrained in the community. But a lot of these
00:26:28 automotive manufacturers, it's not to say that they don't have roots in the community in some
00:26:32 ways. But I don't believe for a second that if BW could do things for more cheaply in Seoul,
00:26:39 that they wouldn't in a second just shut down overnight and move everything over there,
00:26:42 because we've seen these big international conglomerates do that. So they aren't really
00:26:47 invested unless the subsidies keep coming. Sure. And the other thing, when we romanticize
00:26:53 the sort of one company town, we have to remember how those stories ended most of the time. They
00:26:57 ended very badly, precisely because companies were at the mercy of a single company. I think
00:27:02 if you want to build communities that are resilient, that are diversified, you can't have
00:27:06 one employer. The goal shouldn't be one big employer. It should be a, you know, a range of
00:27:10 employers so that you don't sort of have all your eggs in one basket. And so if anything, I mean,
00:27:14 we're trying to recreate a situation that made a lot of these communities vulnerable. And that's
00:27:19 not something we should aspire to. We should be aspiring to situations where when one company
00:27:23 goes out of business, it's not devastating to the whole community. And you do that by having
00:27:27 a lot of smaller employers instead of just one big one i know your focus aaron is on the policy
00:27:33 over the politics of this but i but i was wondering if you had any advice on how politicians
00:27:37 could actually criticize this when it becomes very difficult when they have to basically say no
00:27:44 to an immediate promise of you know 2500 jobs in a particular town i mean in the case of the
00:27:50 the saint thomas plant it's in a conservative riding and i know there was a bit of an awkward
00:27:54 encounter there with the local conservative mp karen vecchio when she was standing beside trudeau
00:27:59 taking pot shots at pierre polly for not supporting corporate welfare sure i mean well there's a few
00:28:04 things and you can see that the the federal conservatives have done this by referring it to
00:28:08 the parliamentary budget officer i think that's their way of sort of signaling we're concerned
00:28:11 but they don't want to sort of give the strongly worded letter approach sure but they don't want
00:28:16 to give the liberals the clip of them saying that they are against these jobs or things like that
00:28:21 right but you know i think one thing that uh that uh you know people who want to criticize this can
00:28:26 just be honest about is saying yeah sure it's going to be good for the people who get those
00:28:30 jobs uh but let's be honest about the cost i mean this is not an ideal situation we shouldn't have
00:28:35 to to get jobs this way um and and there's a real cost i mean there are a million other priorities
00:28:40 there's so many other things canadians expect their tax dollars to go to um and the 13 billion
00:28:45 is is is not exactly chunk change so um there's an opportunity cost here and you're right andrew no
00:28:51 Nobody wants to sort of be the Debbie Downer and point out the bad stuff, but somebody needs to do it.
00:28:57 Thankfully, I'm not an elected official, so I have no hesitation in calling it out.
00:29:01 Yeah, and I mean, when you look at the math, we looked at the math last time you and I spoke about this on how much it costs per job.
00:29:07 But even if you just look at the tax burden, $13 billion divided by 40 million people, that's $325 a person.
00:29:13 I mean, that's not an insignificant amount of money that if you were to ask Mike in Canmore or Joe in wherever,
00:29:20 about they'd say yeah my family could use that sure and this is for one plant in one community
00:29:25 i mean if this is your if this is your sort of industrial policy generally how many times can
00:29:30 you afford to do this and how many communities and how many sectors right is it really going to
00:29:34 be the one-off uh you know color me skeptical that this is going to be the last time they do this
00:29:39 aaron woodrick domestic policy guru over at the mcdonald lorie institute always good to talk to
00:29:44 you aaron thanks for coming on today thanks a lot andrew i imagine we'll probably have aaron back on
00:29:49 when the government caves to Stellantis,
00:29:51 as I assume slash fear is inevitable in some form.
00:29:55 But it is interesting.
00:29:56 So yeah, when they're giving out the $13 billion,
00:29:58 you've got Trudeau and Ford
00:29:59 doing their buddy comedy shtick,
00:30:02 which only ever goes one way.
00:30:03 Like Ford will literally bend over backwards
00:30:05 for Justin Trudeau,
00:30:07 who just like, you know,
00:30:08 spits all over him at the first opportunity.
00:30:10 And here we have another example of that
00:30:12 where Francois-Philippe Champagne is saying,
00:30:14 yeah, this is the Ontario government's problem.
00:30:16 They need, they're the ones that are preventing it.
00:30:18 They need to pay up more.
00:30:19 where like Ford, who's been doing the, oh yeah, he's my best friend and I'm not going to lift a
00:30:23 hand to help the conservatives. And Chrystia Freeland's my best buddy. And yeah, I want
00:30:26 Justin Trudeau to be my best man. Like all of that is basically meaningless because the federal
00:30:31 liberals actually do not hold Doug Ford in any sort of respect. They look down upon him, yet he
00:30:37 still keeps giving them everything they want at the expense of what Doug Ford would normally in
00:30:43 his position be doing to help the conservatives federally but all of that is aside from the main
00:30:49 point here which is that this was an entirely predictable problem and once uh Stellantis get
00:30:54 there's a reason that the u.s policy that's been like parodied in film time and time again
00:30:59 is do not negotiate with terrorists because the whole point is if you give five million dollars to
00:31:04 a terrorist to free some hostage they're going to say wow this is a really great way to get five
00:31:08 million and then they're just going to start taking hostages left right and center in this
00:31:14 particular case it is the taxpayers of Canada who are paying the ransom here and it is not going to
00:31:21 end when this proves the concept so yeah I hope just for the future aspect of this that the
00:31:27 government says to Stellantis no we're not playing this game but I don't think it's going to go that
00:31:32 way because the government loves to play this game then they're going to show up with the big giant
00:31:35 novelty-sized check on the front lawn.
00:31:38 It wasn't Ed McMahon.
00:31:39 I forget who it was that showed up with the checks,
00:31:41 but everyone says it was Ed McMahon.
00:31:43 But does anyone know who Ed McMahon is now?
00:31:45 I was going to say I'm dating myself,
00:31:46 and then I realized I wasn't even alive
00:31:49 when Ed McMahon was doing his thing.
00:31:50 But whatever the case is,
00:31:51 they're just going to do that
00:31:53 and start claiming that this was all part of their big
00:31:56 Made in Canada strategy
00:31:57 until someone better comes along,
00:32:00 and then the companies will pull up stakes and go there.
00:32:03 That does it for us for today.
00:32:04 We will end things there.
00:32:05 My thanks to all of you for tuning in to today's edition of the show.
00:32:09 We'll talk to you tomorrow with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:32:12 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:32:16 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:32:19 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.