Juno News - March 14, 2023


Serious countries want nothing to do with Canada

Topics
Mentioned
Sending a strong signal over Roxham Road Liberals won't say how much Volkswagen battery plant is costing us

Episode Stats


Length

30 minutes

Words per minute

173.14

Word count

5,239

Sentence count

261

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton takes a look at why serious countries don't want to do business with Canada, and why it's a good thing that Canada isn't part of them.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:13 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:16 This is another edition of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show,
00:00:20 the Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North on this Tuesday, March 14th, 2023,
00:00:25 just after 4 o'clock Eastern, what is it?
00:00:28 No, Eastern Daylight Time now.
00:00:30 It's no longer Eastern Standard Time.
00:00:32 So for, I believe, everywhere but Saskatchewan,
00:00:35 the clocks have changed in this great dominion of Canada.
00:00:39 If you read the line, which is the online publication
00:00:43 started via Substack by Jen Gerson and Matt Gurney,
00:00:46 they had like dueling columns this week about daylight savings,
00:00:50 which I feel are a bit of a perennial thing that,
00:00:52 well, actually more than perennial,
00:00:54 because they come twice a year.
00:00:55 Wait, no, that's annual.
00:00:56 You can tell I'm not a gardener.
00:00:58 I don't know.
00:00:58 Even now, I have no idea the difference
00:01:00 between perennial and annual.
00:01:01 I believe perennials come back automatically
00:01:04 and annuals you have to plant every year,
00:01:08 which always struck me as a bit odd
00:01:10 because you'd think annual would mean
00:01:11 it comes back every year.
00:01:12 But if you tune in for the gardening advice,
00:01:15 I assure you, you are horrendously disappointed
00:01:17 most days and especially now.
00:01:18 So we'll move on to the stuff
00:01:19 we have a bit of a better grasp on, sports.
00:01:23 No, wait, not really much of a grasp of that either.
00:01:25 Politics, I can give you, though.
00:01:26 I'm going to be speaking very shortly with Christine Van Gein
00:01:30 from the Canadian Constitution Foundation
00:01:32 about this absurd and incredibly, incredibly, I would say, illegal bylaw
00:01:38 that's being proposed in Calgary to make it illegal by, again, by bylaw,
00:01:44 by municipal fiat to protest if city councillors don't like you.
00:01:49 So it's undoubtedly unconstitutional,
00:01:51 but that doesn't mean they're not going to try it.
00:01:53 So that's going to be something we'll talk about very shortly.
00:01:56 But I want to start with a bigger picture look at a question
00:01:59 that I think should be top of mind for Canadians,
00:02:02 but I'd say isn't always, which is Canada's place in the world.
00:02:07 Now, let me preface this by saying that the world is not this idealist place.
00:02:12 The world has challenges, the world has threats, the world has risks.
00:02:16 And the world has all of these things to such an extent
00:02:19 that countries need to find a way to combat them.
00:02:22 And I've been guilty of this in the past myself.
00:02:24 If you try to view things too simplistically
00:02:27 or too black and white and you miss the nuance of it,
00:02:29 you are not going to get a whole picture.
00:02:31 That being said,
00:02:34 I don't believe anyone in the world of serious countries
00:02:39 right now believes that Canada is a serious country.
00:02:43 And the title of this episode on social media
00:02:45 is that serious countries want nothing to do with Canada.
00:02:48 And I think there's a voluminous amount of evidence supporting this, but it keeps growing.
00:02:54 The most recent example this week is the Australia-United Kingdom-United States Security Pact called AUKUS.
00:03:03 Now, despite how silly the name is, AUKUS is a security and intelligence partnership between three nations.
00:03:10 Now, let me just look up the population of Australia.
00:03:14 Now, Australia, 25 million people, so not insignificantly smaller than Canada, but still has a seat at this table.
00:03:22 Now, I realize that geopolitically, Australia is more front and center on the Indo-Pacific.
00:03:27 Canada is a Pacific country that kind of forgets it's a Pacific country.
00:03:31 Pacific strategy is pretty much an afterthought for Canada, and we've just unveiled a few months ago our grand Indo-Pacific strategy,
00:03:39 and everyone's forgotten about it because we really don't have an Indo-Pacific strategy in
00:03:44 Canada. But Australia is not more suited to be a part of any alliance of this nature than Canada.
00:03:52 Yet the difference between Australia and Canada is that Australia has a seat at the table and
00:03:56 Canada does not. I touched on this a little bit last week that the AUKUS partnership needs to be
00:04:04 viewed in context. It's a subset of the five I's. The five I's countries, which are the United
00:04:10 States, the United Kingdom, Australia, plus Canada and New Zealand, has existed for many years so
00:04:16 that these five countries that have shared interests, shared language, shared culture,
00:04:21 that are all military partners, that are allies in trade and economics and military, that all of
00:04:26 them could come together, share intelligence, and tackle together the big threats facing the world. 0.62
00:04:33 Increasingly, that is China. There is no doubt about that. 0.96
00:04:36 Even the Liberal Member of Parliament, John McKay, said that China poses an existential threat to Canada
00:04:42 and to Canadian democracy and institutions and values, if you extend the point he's making to its logical ends.
00:04:49 So when Canada is on the sidelines, as three countries that share goals on that get together,
00:04:57 this is something that should bother Canadians. This is something that should bother the Canadian government.
00:05:03 so what's happened here is this partnership which has been talked about for quite a while
00:05:07 is moving to the next stage you had a meeting and i believe it was uh point loma the point loma
00:05:13 naval base in san diego between uh anthony albanese in australia joe biden in the united states
00:05:20 rishi sunak in the united kingdom they're all sitting down at the table there and they are
00:05:24 talking about the importance of getting together they're talking about helping australia develop
00:05:29 a fleet of nuclear-powered submarines.
00:05:32 They're talking about all of the threats 0.96
00:05:33 that China's Navy is posing to Western interests, 0.67
00:05:36 to Australian interests.
00:05:38 They are talking about all of this stuff.
00:05:40 And then Canada is sitting on the sidelines.
00:05:43 This is the tweet from Foreign Policy Canada on Twitter.
00:05:46 Canada welcomes the AUKUS announcement
00:05:48 supporting rules-based international order
00:05:51 in the Indo-Pacific.
00:05:52 As part of our Indo-Pacific strategy,
00:05:54 we're committed to working with partners
00:05:56 to promote peace, resilience, and security in the region.
00:05:59 including through an enhanced naval presence.
00:06:02 Naval gazing is more like it.
00:06:04 But Canada, I think, just basically shoved a few inputs
00:06:08 into one of those artificial intelligence chatbots
00:06:11 to generate that tweet,
00:06:12 because they have all of the keywords and the buzzwords
00:06:14 without saying anything.
00:06:16 So because Canada has been excluded from this,
00:06:19 Canada's only role, really, is to downplay it and say,
00:06:22 oh, yeah, AUKUS is fine. 0.65
00:06:24 That's that little, you know, that little side hustle going on.
00:06:27 I mean, it's got Joe Biden on it.
00:06:29 So in fairness, you shouldn't take it too seriously.
00:06:31 This is a guy that couldn't tell the difference between a submarine and an elephant most days.
00:06:35 So again, the fact that he is one of three partners here should probably concern us for different reasons.
00:06:41 But if I take this in a Canadian foreign policy context, the big question, where is Canada?
00:06:47 And I don't think Canada's exclusion is because Canada decided it didn't want to be a part of this.
00:06:52 I think other countries look at Canada and say, I don't see a real nation there.
00:06:57 I don't see a serious nation.
00:07:00 I mean, you look back at when Stephen Harper wanted to, I'd say, and this was probably
00:07:04 a miscalculation, get a Security Council seat at the UN for Canada.
00:07:08 And he failed.
00:07:09 He failed.
00:07:09 Other countries around the world did not want to vote for Canada.
00:07:13 Justin Trudeau tried even harder.
00:07:16 Was it two years ago?
00:07:17 He really aggressively pushed.
00:07:20 He campaigned. 0.99
00:07:21 He was like hanging out with African autocrats trying to get their votes at the United Nations 0.99
00:07:26 to put Canada on the Security Council 0.98
00:07:28 and still lost, still lost.
00:07:31 I think we lost, was it Ireland or Norway?
00:07:34 But they were the ones voted in
00:07:35 and I forget which one was the one
00:07:37 that we thought we were going to get
00:07:38 and Ireland and Norway were ultimately the victors.
00:07:41 So Canada has been rebuked as a serious player
00:07:44 that's deserving of a seat on the Security Council.
00:07:47 Canada has been excluded from this intelligence partnership
00:07:50 and all of this is that Canada is not a player
00:07:56 on the world stage in a meaningful way.
00:07:59 Now, one of my colleagues, Phil,
00:08:01 who is apparently listening to the show,
00:08:03 has decided to actually plug this in to ChatGPT,
00:08:07 which is the service that lets you spit out AI.
00:08:10 I don't know what he put in,
00:08:11 but this is what he got out of it.
00:08:13 The government of Canada is committed to ensuring
00:08:16 the security and prosperity of our country and our allies.
00:08:19 We closely monitor developments in global security
00:08:22 and defense cooperation.
00:08:23 The AUKUS Security Alliance between us.
00:08:25 This is basically what the AI has given him is exactly what Foreign Policy Canada tweeted
00:08:32 or almost exactly what Foreign Policy Canada tweeted.
00:08:35 And then, of course, it ends with the kicker.
00:08:38 Canada values its longstanding relationships with all three nations
00:08:41 and looks forward to continuing to work with them on shared security priorities.
00:08:46 So Canadian foreign policy is a bit of a point of interest for me.
00:08:50 Now, as far as topics of scholarship go, it's a pretty easy one
00:08:53 because we don't have, I'd say, a foreign policy to speak of.
00:08:56 So there's not much to know about it.
00:08:58 I think Canada did a very good job under Stephen Harper
00:09:01 when it came to foreign policy, largely.
00:09:03 There were some issues.
00:09:04 But the reason is because they understood the limitations.
00:09:08 They didn't try to be something greater than what Canada was.
00:09:12 They hitched themselves to largely the United States
00:09:15 and found areas where Canada could fill the gaps.
00:09:18 We did a lot of very good work in Afghanistan, for example,
00:09:21 and that was liberal and conservative governments combined. 0.94
00:09:24 I'd say that, I mean, the Afghanistan legacy is a failure across the board,
00:09:28 but at the time, Canada saw a gap, saw a role, and tried to fill it.
00:09:33 The term you hear from people like Justin Trudeau and his colleagues there is middle power.
00:09:41 This idea that Canada's not a great power, we're not a United Kingdom,
00:09:45 we're not a United States, we're not a China, but we're a middle power.
00:09:48 We have a role and we get to play it. 0.55
00:09:50 And Melanie Jolie gave that just asinine comment a few months ago
00:09:54 about how Canada's role is to be a convener.
00:09:56 That's our great contribution.
00:09:57 We can convene.
00:09:58 So we can set out our table and all of the great powers will sit at that table.
00:10:03 Except no one wants to sit at Canada's table.
00:10:06 No one wants to sit.
00:10:07 No one cares about a table that Melanie Jolie is at the head of.
00:10:11 And that's why Michael Cooper, the Conservative MP,
00:10:14 got absolutely railroaded last week when he made that comment
00:10:16 about how Melanie Jolie looking into the eyes of the Russian foreign minister,
00:10:22 which was her comment, was, you know,
00:10:24 apparently not going to have him trembling in his boots.
00:10:26 And then, of course, all of the liberals were like,
00:10:28 oh, that's sexist, that's offensive.
00:10:30 It's like, okay, well, did it work?
00:10:32 Did Melanie Jolie staring into the eyes of the Russian foreign minister do anything?
00:10:36 No.
00:10:37 Or the Chinese foreign minister, rather.
00:10:38 I'm conflating conflicts here.
00:10:40 I'm conflating great powers.
00:10:41 But no, it didn't do anything.
00:10:44 Melanie Jolie staring into the eyes of China's foreign minister
00:10:46 did not actually cause China to back down.
00:10:48 It didn't cause China to get out of Canadian elections.
00:10:51 It did absolutely nothing.
00:10:53 So it was not an unfair comment,
00:10:56 not an unfair comment.
00:10:57 And then he gets pilloried as, you know,
00:11:00 misogynistic and sexist and all of that.
00:11:02 But you hear this from liberals all the time
00:11:05 that Canada is this great power in waiting.
00:11:08 One of my favorite articles about Justin Trudeau of all time
00:11:13 was one by Kate Bolingaro of Bloomberg.
00:11:16 now she's no longer at Bloomberg, writing about the NATO, it was a NATO EU summit or NATO G20
00:11:23 summit. They were back to back and they were in Brussels. And Justin Trudeau's people were going
00:11:29 around trying to position Justin Trudeau as what he called the dean of the G7. It was G7, not G20,
00:11:36 the dean of the G7, because they determined that with Angela Merkel, the former chancellor of
00:11:40 Germany stepping down. Justin Trudeau was the longest serving head of government of the G7
00:11:46 leaders. Ergo, he should be the de facto chair of the G7, as though it's a seniority game and not a
00:11:53 question of relevance from different countries and influence of countries. And he had decided
00:11:59 that he could get involved and help solve the EU-UK dispute over Northern Ireland. So he was
00:12:07 saying that yes we can get the european union and the united kingdom together and no one cared like
00:12:12 none of them wanted to sit at the table that justin trudeau was at the head of because canada
00:12:18 is not a serious country canada is not a serious player and there are i think two fundamental
00:12:24 reasons for this one of them is that canada has never been and will never be a great power we
00:12:30 don't have the size we don't have the economic might we don't have the legitimacy on the global
00:12:35 state. And the second part, and I think this is the more critical part, is that Canadian governments
00:12:41 often misrepresent Canada's role. If we knew what we were, we knew our size, we understood our
00:12:48 limitations and worked within that, we would be taken a lot more seriously than we are. But instead
00:12:54 you have Justin Trudeau that thinks he can go toe-to-toe with Donald Trump and take him down.
00:12:59 You've got Chrystia Freeland that thinks she can go toe-to-toe with Vladimir Putin and take him
00:13:03 down. You've got Melanie Jolie that thinks she can go toe-to-toe with China and take China down.
00:13:08 And then you have all of these grandiose claims by these leaders that, whoa, we're a nation of
00:13:12 peacekeepers. Canada has, I think, like 23 peacekeepers deployed right now. It's in and around
00:13:18 there anyway. So we are not, and never have been, with the exception of a bit of a flurry of
00:13:24 peacekeeping missions in the 1990s. We've never been a nation of peacekeepers. But we have this
00:13:29 mythology about Canadian foreign policy that is such a mismatch from the reality of the situation.
00:13:37 And we'll certainly revisit this soon enough, but the big challenge here for a lot of people
00:13:43 is that we have to check our expectations. Check our expectations. And to go back to this
00:13:49 AUKUS thing for a moment, you know, look, if the US, the UK, and Australia think that the three of
00:13:54 them have shared interests that are distinct enough from what the Five Eyes Partnership does
00:14:00 that they need this alliance, then power to them. But if you understand the dynamics of this region,
00:14:06 the dynamics of Indo-Pacific policy, you'll understand it's not that simple. New Zealand
00:14:11 has completely capitulated to China. New Zealand has completely sold out to China. They have
00:14:17 exported so much of their trade, and I would say by extension of their sovereignty to China, 0.99
00:14:23 and they refuse to push back against China
00:14:25 because China has become such a dominant player
00:14:27 in the New Zealand economy.
00:14:29 So I understand why New Zealand gets carved out of this.
00:14:32 Canada gets carved out because we have a leader
00:14:34 that has decided to capitulate to China at every turn,
00:14:38 a leader that doesn't want to take Chinese interference
00:14:40 in our election seriously,
00:14:42 a leader that doesn't want to take China's fundamental violations
00:14:46 of human rights seriously,
00:14:48 a government that has been co-opted, it seems like,
00:14:51 by people who are beholden to the Chinese regime
00:14:55 or at the very least start singing
00:14:57 from the same songbook as the Chinese regime.
00:15:01 And that's why this is such an important issue
00:15:02 to continue to talk about.
00:15:04 And it's not about being a global police officer.
00:15:07 It's about understanding
00:15:08 what you are capable of doing as a country,
00:15:12 doing it, doing it well.
00:15:14 I mean, I used to like that political show
00:15:16 that was on Netflix.
00:15:18 Well, it was on Danish television
00:15:19 And then Netflix picked it up called Borgen, which was basically Danish West Wing.
00:15:24 And it was interesting, though, seeing a political show about a country like Denmark, which is, I'd say, I mean, it's smaller than Canada.
00:15:31 But it's a country that is not particularly relevant in the global picture.
00:15:36 But there was an interesting little arc about this where the leader that they had put in, who was meant to be the bad guy because he was the conservative.
00:15:45 So he was like the leader of the conservative party, was in this debate.
00:15:48 And he said, we're Danes.
00:15:49 We don't need to be Americans.
00:15:51 We don't need to be Brits.
00:15:52 We don't need to be Australians.
00:15:53 We're Danes.
00:15:54 We do what we can, and that's that.
00:15:56 I think that understanding our limitations, which is the term I keep going back to, needs to be front and center for Canadian governments.
00:16:04 And it doesn't mean accepting ourselves as being a failed state.
00:16:07 It doesn't mean saying that we're nobodies. 0.75
00:16:09 It means just that we have to accept and understand that we are never going to be one of those P5 nations, one of the permanent five members of the UN Security Council. 0.95
00:16:20 And we, I mean, we had an option. 0.95
00:16:22 If you look back through Canadian history, I mean, we could have been a nuclear power.
00:16:25 But Justin Trudeau's father, Pierre Trudeau, decided to turn his back on that.
00:16:30 And here we are today.
00:16:31 So moving from the global to the local, I want to turn to a debate that's ongoing in Calgary right now.
00:16:38 At least I think it's ongoing.
00:16:38 Someone tell me if they've voted on this, but Calgary is debating a bylaw, Calgary city councillors, that has been derided online by civil liberties advocates.
00:16:49 And if you look at the fine print of it, it's not all that surprising why.
00:16:52 This is basically a municipal ban on protesting if city council doesn't seem to like who you are and what your protest is.
00:17:00 And I am putting it in an uncharitable light, but we'll get to the details of it here with Christine Van Gein, who is the litigation director for the Canadian Constitution Foundation.
00:17:10 Christine, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today.
00:17:13 It's always great to talk to you, Andrew.
00:17:15 So, OK, so let's be a little bit more perhaps objective than I was.
00:17:19 What is City Council trying to do here?
00:17:21 I actually don't disagree with your characterization.
00:17:24 what city council is trying to do is restrict protests around city libraries and recreational
00:17:34 buildings so like community centers for protests but it's they actually are only for specific types
00:17:43 of protests and they define which protests cannot be around these buildings by i think it's a hundred
00:17:49 meters. You can still protest, you just have to go 100 meters away. So the protests that they
00:17:54 want to ban are protests that are aimed towards objection or disapproval towards an idea or
00:18:04 action related to race, religious belief, color, gender, gender identity, gender expression,
00:18:10 physical disability, mental disability, age, and trustee, place of origin, marital status,
00:18:14 source of income family status or sexual orientation so um those are this the uh terms
00:18:21 from human rights legislation but basically what it means is if you want to have an environmental
00:18:27 protest uh you know a climate extinction march thing in front of a library that's totally fine
00:18:36 but let's be clear what they're trying to ban here this is very clearly about the protests
00:18:44 at libraries around drag queen story hour and you know people can have whatever their views on that
00:18:51 are you may think that they're totally benign and family friendly or you may think that it's
00:18:56 objectionable to have um that type of performance art for children so whatever your perspective
00:19:04 you are no longer going to be allowed to protest this this would be uh prohibited under this bylaw
00:19:10 to have a protest like that um in front of a library where it's taking place and look i'm not
00:19:16 i'm not exaggerating the the topic of it is about the drag queen issue because there have been a
00:19:21 number of these protests in calgary recently and i've been watching the debate it is not over
00:19:27 they're currently in a closed session but it is about that it is just about that issue yeah you're
00:19:34 right they have to add all of these other categories just so it doesn't look like it's
00:19:37 about that one issue. I think they would make it just about Drag Queen Story Hour if they could.
00:19:42 Yeah. Now, you've looked at this, and I know you've been commenting quite intelligently,
00:19:47 as always, on Twitter about this. Your view is that it's completely and utterly unconstitutional,
00:19:51 correct? Of course. The courts have long applied the principle of content neutrality
00:19:59 in defining the scope of our protections for freedom of expression. The content of the
00:20:06 expression, no matter how offensive, no matter how unpopular, no matter how much it might disturb
00:20:13 you, that content does not deprive you of your right to expression. So the specific targeting
00:20:21 of a very clear type of speech is a big problem here. How would you reconcile what you've just
00:20:31 said with the Ontario bubble zone law about restricting protests around abortion clinics,
00:20:37 which is very targeted to a particular type of protest. Yeah. So, I mean, I take issue with that
00:20:43 parallel vision as well. I'm pretty clearly in the camp of freedom of expression, but even
00:20:50 this is much further. This is just much, much, much further than abortion clinics or hospitals.
00:20:57 there's a bubble zone around around hospitals as well and you could make an argument on the
00:21:03 balancing you could make some argument that a health care facility should be treated differently
00:21:08 than a community center where political debates are literally hosted between candidates so you
00:21:15 know if you if you disagree or disapprove of a candidate a political candidate and a debate is
00:21:21 taking place in that community center and the grounds of your objection or even disapproval
00:21:27 um is is one of those categories you would not be able to protest and i'll give you an example
00:21:33 and i'll give you an example of how there could be unintended consequences and i'm not giving
00:21:39 i'll just give you an example so jk rowling is a very famous author and she uh would i'm sure many
00:21:48 libraries would love to have her come and speak but she has also been very critical of radical
00:21:53 gender ideology and her criticism comes from a place of feminism and sex-based rights and her
00:22:01 if someone came to protest JK Rowling speaking at a library because they disagree with her views on
00:22:08 gender her views on gender are actually couched in her gender they're they are form a part of her
00:22:16 sexual identity and her sex and her gender. So those protests could actually also be prohibited 0.99
00:22:24 under this bylaw. And I guarantee you, the people at City Council would be all in favor. These
00:22:32 people who support this bylaw restricting protests around libraries, they'd be all in favor of a
00:22:37 protest with J.K. Rowling. But they are opposing the protests by these individuals who oppose
00:22:43 drag queen story hour. And I want to be clear that I think that there's been some conduct by
00:22:48 some of the protesters opposing drag queen story hour that I don't think is very civilized conduct.
00:22:55 But the Supreme Court has affirmed that our right to expression includes the right to offensive
00:23:02 expression. Well, and the other thing too, is that protest against an event that you don't like is
00:23:08 the very embodiment of free speech so drag queens have a right to go and perform as drag queens 0.88
00:23:14 people that don't like drag shows around children can protest those and as long as they're not
00:23:19 barricading the doors people can come and go they hear both sides ideally this is free speech in
00:23:24 action people can make up their own minds and we see this unfolding all the time so this idea that
00:23:29 on something that is a contentious issue has a city council of all bodies trying to shut down
00:23:36 one side of it is particularly insane here. And you're right. I mean, they're very deliberate
00:23:42 about what they're doing with this. Yeah, look, it's very clearly about this topic that the city
00:23:49 councillors who are in favour of it are very short-sighted if they don't see how this could
00:23:54 cause an adverse, unforeseen consequence to someone who's engaging in speech that perhaps
00:24:02 they support. And, you know, I think it's so important for us to remember that it is just not
00:24:09 for government to tell Canadians what we may protest and what we may not protest, that an
00:24:16 environmental protest is acceptable, but a protest over what publicly funded arts activities are
00:24:24 acceptable for children, you're not allowed to engage in that protest. That is not something
00:24:29 for government to decide i don't know if uh ccf has already planned its response to this uh beyond
00:24:36 kind of comments that have been made now but but if they do pass this bylaw which i hope they don't
00:24:41 but if they do does someone have to be charged under it to challenge or can it be challenged
00:24:46 just based on what it is right away it could theoretically be challenged without charges it's
00:24:53 always better to actually have charges but we've successfully challenged legislation for example
00:24:59 there was federal legislation about what the government calls misinformation and we've
00:25:05 successfully challenged that legislation and had it struck down under the elections act it was
00:25:11 elections act legislation we had that struck down without anyone ever being charged and in this case
00:25:17 the charges are serious right the proposed penalty under this bylaw is ten thousand dollars ten
00:25:22 thousand dollars for exercising your constitutionally protected right to protest in public
00:25:29 Yeah, and I think with all of these things, it's meant to have a chilling effect. They don't want to, I believe, find people. They just want people to know it's illegal and to just put their tail between their legs and go home, which is, I think, how these things are most damaging. They just try to shrink the bounds of discourse.
00:25:45 Well, I think they're also, I mean, I don't, what they're trying to do is move the protests away from the entrances, but that actually moves them onto roads, onto the sidewalk, into residential neighborhoods.
00:26:01 But it defeats the purpose of the protest. I mean, like, I don't protest what, you know, the premier of Alberta is doing by going to Saskatchewan because I'm far away from Alberta. I protest it where it's happening if I want to protest.
00:26:13 Of course, of course. So it would make the the protest sort of irrelevant. If you're trying to protest them, you're trying to express yourself, and they would not be very effective expression if you were only allowed to have your protest in this designated protest area.
00:26:33 But your question about what are we planning?
00:26:36 I mean, my hope is that they do not pass this.
00:26:39 I always would love to see a good precedent for freedom of expression.
00:26:43 And I think that we could get one here if we could successfully have this legislation
00:26:46 struck down.
00:26:48 But, you know, we are preparing right now, if it is passed, that we would participate
00:26:52 in a challenge.
00:26:54 And we would work with individuals who might be affected by this bylaw.
00:26:59 so city of calgary residents who like to engage in public protests things like that so if you're
00:27:06 a person who cares about freedom of expression and you care about this issue and you might want
00:27:11 to participate in a challenge if this passes send me an email send me a note on twitter
00:27:16 our website's theccf.ca and all of my contact information is there it's always best to challenge
00:27:22 with not just as an organization but with a real face to the people who are affected by that and
00:27:27 that's the citizens of Calgary. And just lastly, Christine, I know that municipalities are
00:27:32 creations of the provinces in which they exist. Is there anything that the province could do on
00:27:37 this? Or is this within, I mean, constitutionality aside, is this within the municipal domain solely?
00:27:44 That's a good question. So I think that's something that Daniel Smith could certainly
00:27:49 look at. As you said, municipalities are creatures of statute. They are created
00:27:55 by provincial legislation but I'd like to remind everyone we all you know complain about the big
00:28:02 guys in Ottawa but it is often our municipal politicians the petty busy bodies who have the
00:28:10 most authoritarian tendencies and often have the most direct impact on our lives so don't stop
00:28:16 paying attention to municipal politics because those people once they get a little bit of power
00:28:22 They like to exercise their authoritarian instincts in ways that affect us perhaps the most.
00:28:30 Yeah, and I mean, just by virtue of, you know, let me just pull it up now.
00:28:34 2021 Calgary election had 40% or 46% voter turnout.
00:28:38 And I think that was elevated above previous years because Alberta had a referendum at the time.
00:28:42 But municipal voter turnout is sometimes a third of the eligible voters.
00:28:46 So a lot of these things do, as you mentioned, get they sneak in there.
00:28:50 So we'll keep an eye out.
00:28:51 hopefully it doesn't pass. But if it does, I'm glad to know there are people that support freedom
00:28:55 of expression standing by to take aim at it. Christine Van Gein, litigation director for the
00:29:00 CCF. Always a pleasure. Thanks, Andrew. All right. Thank you, Christine. That does it for us for
00:29:06 today. I should get Stella Ambler back on the show. She's launched that think tank, Municipal 0.75
00:29:10 Watch, which takes aim at municipal governments that are drastically overstepping their bounds
00:29:16 as Calgary is doing here.
00:29:18 But again, if you were to ask people
00:29:19 what is the most conservative province in Canada,
00:29:24 they're going to say Alberta.
00:29:25 If you were to ask people
00:29:25 what's the most conservative city in Canada,
00:29:27 I don't mean town or village,
00:29:29 but the most conservative city,
00:29:30 they're probably going to say,
00:29:31 well, I think it's Cal...
00:29:32 Maybe they'll say like Red Deer or something,
00:29:34 but they'll say Calgary.
00:29:35 And Calgarians are like,
00:29:37 no, just look around. 0.99
00:29:38 But this is the problem
00:29:39 is that even in conservative provinces
00:29:41 in generally conservative cities,
00:29:43 you get these municipal governments that do not care about your freedoms and actually hold them
00:29:48 in contempt and hold you in contempt so let that be the cheery note on which we end today
00:29:54 that does it for us my thanks to all of you we'll talk to you tomorrow with more of the
00:29:58 Andrew Lawton show here on true north thank you god bless and good day to you all
00:30:02 thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton show
00:30:05 support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:30:13 You