Juno News - November 14, 2026


SHOCKING report exposes Canada's worsening maternal healthcare crisis

Carney wants to bring MORE immigrants to Canada’s small towns Canada is importing more immigrants as crime spirals out of control

Episode Stats


Length

15 minutes

Words per minute

177.34

Word count

2,831

Sentence count

124

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Another indicator that Canada's health care system has been deteriorating over the last
00:00:10 few years, a new report has found that maternal deaths in Canada rose 18% between the years
00:00:18 2015 and 2023.
00:00:21 When it comes to physical injuries related to pregnancy, labor, and childbirth, Canada's
00:00:26 record also seems to be getting poorer. Incidents of obstetric trauma are four times higher in
00:00:34 Canada than the Netherlands. Women and children are facing adverse outcomes due to Canada's
00:00:40 healthcare woes. That's the finding. Anyway, our guest today is Bacchus Barua, author of a new
00:00:46 report on the subject. He is research director with SecondStreet.org, joining us from Denman
00:00:53 island off the coast of BC. Welcome, Bacchus. Thanks for having me on the show. Okay, tell us
00:00:58 about this report now. This is quite a striking statistic, the deterioration, the numbers of
00:01:07 maternal deaths. This is something that we normally associate with third world nations, 1.00
00:01:13 but here it is in a first world country, which has supposedly one of the best healthcare systems
00:01:21 in the world. How do you account for this? You know, I think everybody knows that Canada's
00:01:26 healthcare system is in a crisis. And a lot of the solutions over the last five years has been
00:01:33 really directed towards family doctors. We're hearing more about issues in the emergency
00:01:38 department, and those are all very, very valid. But one of the things that happens is that we
00:01:44 start to overlook some of those very, very vulnerable areas. And the area that we looked
00:01:49 at was maternal care, care from mothers and newborns. And the data was really troubling.
00:01:54 We were looking at news stories over the last one or two years where doctors were raising concerns,
00:02:00 patients were raising concerns. And the data, when you put it together, were showing that these were
00:02:05 not isolated incidents. There's something really happening over here that's going on. And you did
00:02:11 a wonderful summary about the overall picture of concerns. And I would say that it really starts
00:02:17 with the availability of the maternal care workforce in Canada. One of the things that
00:02:22 we looked at was just a ratio of OBGYNs, obstetrics and gynecologists in Canada, and midwives,
00:02:28 and we found that Canada has one of the lowest ratios of OBGYNs, 34 out of 36 in the OECD.
00:02:34 Midwives, absolute loss, 24 out of 24. And even the OECD is a complex combination.
00:02:41 So when we just looked at 10 pure countries, countries like Sweden, Norway, the Netherlands,
00:02:45 so on and so forth we found that canada was at the bottom of that for the combined workforce
00:02:50 obgyns and midwives sweden for example has 11 times as many um obgyns and midwives compared
00:02:59 to canada and so this is really a structural problem uh that's um that i would say has been
00:03:05 there for a long time and it's really we've just been pushed over the precipice over the last five
00:03:10 five or six years.
00:03:12 I mean, we spend enormous sums of money on healthcare in Canada.
00:03:16 And so the idea that the number of maternal deaths is rising, and I
00:03:22 realize your numbers go to 2023, what does your gut tell you about how
00:03:27 things have gone since then?
00:03:30 Do you think that the deterioration has continued or has there been any
00:03:34 improvements in the last three years?
00:03:37 So the 18% figure that you mentioned, that's actually from a Lancet study that we quoted.
00:03:43 And what we did is we actually took a much longer perspective and looked at what's been happening since about 2005.
00:03:48 And we found something really, really interesting.
00:03:50 Between 2005 and 2015, in general, Canada was following the OECD trend with maternal mortality sort of improving a little bit.
00:03:58 And then it just completely diverged after that.
00:04:01 The OECD improved its maternal mortality rates whereas Canada's deteriorated so that now it's actually about 12.6 deaths per 100,000 live births, which is seven times as many in Norway. Now, I should put a caveat, you know, these are very, very rare events. They translate to a small number. But the thing is something like maternal mortality is something that really should not be occurring in developed countries at all.
00:04:25 And when you contrast that with Norway, which has seven times less maternal deaths per 100,000 live births, that's telling us that there's a systemic difference.
00:04:35 And it's sort of like the red alert sign.
00:04:38 Like this is the red flag that, you know, something's really wrong if that's happening.
00:04:42 And you start to look at other indicators of what else is going on.
00:04:44 And then we see things like obstetric trauma.
00:04:46 This is trauma while giving birth, and it's 16.1% in Canada, which is four times as much obstetric trauma compared to the Netherlands, which is only about 3.8%. Same thing happens when you look at infant mortality. We're at 4.5 per thousand, which is twice the amount that is the rate in Sweden.
00:05:08 And this is the problem, you know, so, you know, even if these are small, small numbers on their own, when you put it together, it's showing us a picture of a system that's really, really crumbling and in many cases, likely failing mothers and children, which are really, you know, the most precious vulnerable areas of our population and really the future of our country.
00:05:31 Now you've compared, when you're talking about the Netherlands, you're talking about a much, much smaller, densely populated population.
00:05:38 more urbanized nation than Canada. We're massive. Do you see any issues around rural versus
00:05:48 urban numbers? Is this an issue that maybe affects some of the poorer areas, maybe rural areas that
00:05:57 don't have the same kind of access to healthcare as say people in Calgary or Vancouver or Toronto do?
00:06:05 Yeah, that's, you know, that's a great point.
00:06:07 It's not something that we looked at in this report, but I'm sure is actually the case.
00:06:11 You know, when you start to look at stories of hospital closures in places like, you know,
00:06:16 Kelowna or Kamloops in BC, or even, I believe, Coal Lake in Alberta, you know, you do see
00:06:22 the effect of, you know, one less OBGYN makes a huge, huge difference in a rural area.
00:06:27 That being said, we need to remember that, you know, the majority of Canada's population
00:06:31 lives within about 100 miles off the US border.
00:06:33 so it's very very concentrated at the bottom and we have contrasting countries like australia that
00:06:38 kind of have a similar population dispersion um so i what i would say is that you know my my guess is
00:06:44 that um these issues will be worse in the rural areas but this is still a pattern that's a problem
00:06:49 right across canada even places like vancouver general hospital was was starting to have to
00:06:53 divert some some some patients over there um so this is a real problem it's a structural problem
00:06:59 it's probably exacerbated in rural areas um but but it's certainly we're trending in the wrong
00:07:04 direction you know just just to just to give you give one important point those challenges with
00:07:10 with with rural care existed a long time ago as well right our geography hasn't changed but our
00:07:15 mortality our maternal mortality rate was better in the past than it is right now all right and
00:07:21 that's adjusting for population that's and with the same geographic population so we we ourselves
00:07:26 know that we can do better and we're just we're just not there we're going in the wrong direction
00:07:31 it's time to modernize canada's rules on nicotine alternatives to cigarettes like heated tobacco
00:07:37 vaping products and oral smokeless products don't burn tobacco or produce smoke now they aren't
00:07:43 risk-free but the growing body of scientific evidence shows that they have the potential
00:07:48 to be substantially less harmful than smoking cigarettes now despite this canadians are banned
00:07:55 from accessing this critical information and sometimes even banned from the products nicotine
00:08:00 pouches remain banned in convenience stores across the country and current laws ban communication
00:08:07 about the risk of these products compared to cigarettes it's absolutely ridiculous the
00:08:12 evidence is here the tools exist canadians deserve to have the freedom to know about them to learn
00:08:18 about them to even just understand them it's a free country we should be able to have this
00:08:23 information so learn more about this campaign and our friends over at unsmoke by visiting their
00:08:29 website unsmoke.ca and thank you so much to unsmoke for sponsoring this episode i mean we've
00:08:36 brought in a lot of people i mean our population has exploded um really in the last i want to say
00:08:43 six to seven years we've always had kind of a you know a reasonable level of immigration and then
00:08:50 And during the Trudeau period, he brought in millions of people.
00:08:57 We opened the floodgates.
00:08:59 There was a bit of a pause in that by the current government, and now he's going to
00:09:03 wrap it up again.
00:09:04 Does it have anything to do with our health care system just not keeping up with the
00:09:09 numbers of people coming into the country? 1.00
00:09:13 Yeah, you know, it's a good point worth looking at.
00:09:15 We haven't looked at it in this report.
00:09:17 I'm sure that it's a factor.
00:09:19 absolutely it cannot not be a factor but but I would say that the the
00:09:24 indicators that we're looking at over here are actually usually adjusted for
00:09:28 population so all the these things are rates you know they're per thousand
00:09:31 population etc etc so even accounting for all of that we're going in the wrong
00:09:36 direction and and importantly these were structural issues that I would say have
00:09:41 existed for a long time we know we've we've for decades talked about a low
00:09:47 physician to population ratio, particularly with specialists. What we've identified over here is
00:09:52 that that's particularly true. Very, very low number of OBGYNs and midwives per thousand
00:09:57 population. Again, that's adjusted for the population compared to other countries.
00:10:04 And so when you have those things being low as a structural issue, absolutely, when you have
00:10:09 more people come in, that obviously puts more pressure on something that's already ready to
00:10:15 break, and what we're seeing is we're seeing a break all over the place.
00:10:19 I mean, some people are going to look at this and think, I don't feel that safe.
00:10:23 I mean, you know, you might have women pregnant or couples and thinking, you
00:10:29 know, is Canada the best place really to go through the birthing process?
00:10:34 I mean, not everybody has the money to go someplace else, to go to the Netherlands
00:10:39 or some other location, some other country, perhaps even areas of the United States
00:10:46 that may have a better record.
00:10:48 I don't know.
00:10:50 It's not going to instill a whole lot of confidence in our system, your report.
00:10:55 Has the government responded to these statistics?
00:10:59 Have you reached out to them and asked them, you know, what's going on here?
00:11:05 Yeah, not yet.
00:11:06 You know, this is a report that was just released this morning.
00:11:08 And I would say that, that being said, physicians, OBGYNs in hospitals have been ringing the alarm bell for like the last two years.
00:11:18 They've been trying to get the government's attention, which is what got our attention.
00:11:23 You know, we have situations where you have almost entire OBGYN departments resigning en masse because they're not feeling like they're able to give that level of safety and quality care to their patients.
00:11:34 And they want to make a statement and make people pay attention.
00:11:36 Well, you know what?
00:11:37 We're paying attention.
00:11:39 We put the numbers together.
00:11:40 We're connecting the dots over here.
00:11:42 And hopefully, governments pay attention.
00:11:44 The one caveat I would say is that, you know, this is obviously a very, you know, an important
00:11:49 and vulnerable area.
00:11:50 But my guess is this is not the only one.
00:11:52 I'm pretty sure if we start to, you know, look at other areas, you know, cancer care
00:11:56 or something, like, I'm sure we're going to start to find other concerns over here.
00:11:59 So the things that we see, you know, in the media talked about generally long wait times,
00:12:04 absolutely true.
00:12:05 We're seeing long wait times over here, which, you know, as you mentioned, with our population increase has gotten worse.
00:12:10 It's a 174% increase between 2005 and 2024 in terms of wait times just to see a gynecologist.
00:12:17 We have doctors calling up and telling us there's a problem.
00:12:19 We have doulas.
00:12:20 I mean, the last interview I gave literally had a doula call up and say, hey, look, we've been trying to alert the government about this and nobody's really done anything.
00:12:27 And this is the thing, you know, something has to change and it's going to have to be at a fundamental structural level.
00:12:33 Because as I mentioned, I would say most of these things have been concerning for a long time and have now just kind of really, really cracked and crumbled.
00:12:42 Do you have any recommendations?
00:12:45 Yeah, I mean, the first thing I would say is the government should probably look at countries that are doing a better job.
00:12:51 So countries in the EU, we definitely saw some trends in terms of Sweden and Norway doing a much better job, even the Netherlands as well.
00:13:00 And of course, Australia is also always a sort of comparable example.
00:13:04 But just in terms of pure data, number one, absolutely, we just need to increase our stock.
00:13:09 We need to have more OBGYNs per capita.
00:13:11 Number two, we need to think about the organization of our model.
00:13:15 One of the surprising things to me was that I found that not only did other countries have more OBGYNs,
00:13:21 they had significantly more midwives and they structure their healthcare system quite differently.
00:13:26 So any gaps that they have with OBGYNs is filled by getting in more help from midwives who can kind of help with kind of the safer, the safer, less concerning pregnancies.
00:13:35 Canada has a relative shortage of both, which is highly, highly unusual.
00:13:40 The second thing, sorry, the third thing I would say is that we need to, I think, rethink the way hospitals are funded.
00:13:46 And I know this sounds like, you know, a little bit of how is this connected.
00:13:51 But one of the things that we've looked at for a long time
00:13:53 is the fact that Canada's hospitals are funded according to global budgets.
00:13:58 So this means that the government basically gives a check,
00:14:01 says here's your budget, and every time a patient comes in,
00:14:03 every time a mother comes in, every time a child comes in,
00:14:06 every time a doctor is hired to give care,
00:14:08 that actually costs the hospital money.
00:14:11 Most of these other countries with universal health care
00:14:14 fund their hospitals according to activity.
00:14:17 That means every time a patient comes in,
00:14:18 the hospital is given the money and the resources to treat that patient this has nothing to do with
00:14:23 public health care or private health care although it has other consequences as well but this is
00:14:28 something that should be you know common sense every government government should be getting
00:14:32 behind this um and i think it would make it would change the incentive structure to say hey you know
00:14:37 if we need more obgyns and that will bring in more patients well that's not going to be a pressure on
00:14:42 the hospital it's actually going to bring in more resources and money to actually treat those
00:14:45 patients. So it's really a fundamental
00:14:47 rethink of, I think, how maternal care is
00:14:49 structured, but also how our healthcare system
00:14:51 is structured. And of course, there is
00:14:53 also the fact that all
00:14:55 these other countries also just do universal healthcare
00:14:57 differently. They have
00:14:58 private pressure valves, they have private
00:15:01 partnerships, they have cost sharing with
00:15:03 exemptions for exactly these kinds of populations,
00:15:05 which is where you don't want to have cost sharing.
00:15:07 But you have cost sharing for other situations so that people are
00:15:09 taking more rational
00:15:10 use or more careful use of
00:15:13 these scarce resources that we have, which
00:15:15 again we get pressure points in with with increasing population so um i think this is just
00:15:19 you know another another alarm bell ringing we're trying to connect the dots over here and say hey
00:15:24 this is a particularly concerning alarm bell but our system is really collapsing on all fronts
00:15:29 okay a sobering view thank you very much for that though bacchus i appreciate it thanks hopefully
00:15:36 i'll have better news next year and somebody will listen to what we're talking about bacchus
00:15:41 Barua, SecondStreet.org.
00:15:43 Appreciate it.
00:15:44 If you enjoyed the show and appreciate independent journalism,
00:15:47 please consider becoming a premier member of Juno News
00:15:50 by going to junonews.com backslash straight up.
00:15:53 Helps us do what we do here.
00:15:55 Thank you so much for tuning in.
00:15:56 We'll see you next time.