Juno News - February 21, 2023


Singer praised for politicizing national anthem

Topics
Mentioned
Why higher spending doesn’t equal better healthcare (Ft. Dr. Shawn Whatley) Trudeau won't take China's election interference seriously

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

174.48

Word count

6,709

Sentence count

320

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, Andrew Lawton talks about the Public Order Emergency Commission's report on the use of the Emergency Order Act in response to the Lac-Megantic pipeline crisis, and why it's not the end of the story.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:12 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:14 This is another edition of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show,
00:00:18 The Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North.
00:00:20 On this Tuesday, February 21st, 2023,
00:00:24 if you are in Ontario or Alberta,
00:00:27 happy belated family day.
00:00:30 I don't know if it's a happy family day
00:00:32 that you wish people on family day
00:00:33 because you don't really see many people on family day
00:00:35 except your own family if you're doing it right.
00:00:37 I believe it was Islander Day in Prince Edward Island
00:00:40 and Louis Riel Day in Manitoba.
00:00:42 But I refuse to wish anyone a happy Louis Riel Day
00:00:46 for reasons that will become abundantly clear
00:00:48 if you've studied the history of Louis Riel
00:00:50 and of Canada itself.
00:00:52 And now I'm going to get more of that Manitoba hate mail.
00:00:54 But we also have Nova Scotia Heritage Day yesterday.
00:00:57 I think we probably had some other holidays that I am missing here.
00:01:01 Let me just scroll through.
00:01:02 I was going by memory.
00:01:04 Let me just go through my list.
00:01:05 It's also Family Day in BC, Saskatchewan, and New Brunswick.
00:01:09 So pretty much everyone gets a holiday except Quebec,
00:01:11 which is, I think, the opposite of how things usually go.
00:01:13 But nevertheless, busy show today.
00:01:16 I want to continue the discussion in just a couple of moments
00:01:19 about the Public Order Emergency Commission's report,
00:01:22 which came down the pipeline on Friday.
00:01:25 I'll talk about that with Christine Van Gein in just a moment here.
00:01:29 And a little bit later, I want to talk about this NBA game,
00:01:33 which I did not watch because it's a sporting event,
00:01:35 and I probably had to confirm before the show what NBA was,
00:01:39 but it's basketball, I'm told.
00:01:40 And the National Anthem was what penetrated from the sporting world into my world,
00:01:46 and singer Julie Black's little ad lib of one word of the National Anthem.
00:01:52 She changed a preposition, but it was a rather significant one.
00:01:56 So we'll talk about that in just a couple of moments too.
00:01:58 But 2,000 pages, ultimately a finding that the federal government was justified in invoking the Emergencies Act.
00:02:06 That's what came away on Friday from the Public Order Emergency Commission and Commissioner Paul Rouleau.
00:02:13 Not a slam dunk, not a complete vindication, but on the core idea of whether the Emergencies Act was justified,
00:02:22 the commissioner sided with Trudeau, and really on the core ideas of how the Emergencies Act was
00:02:28 used, the commissioner sided with Trudeau. And there were a couple of little criticisms he made
00:02:33 that I think were significant, but generally speaking, he supported the bank account freezes,
00:02:38 he supported the conscription of tow truck drivers, and he supported the overall use of
00:02:43 the act itself, albeit with the caveat that, in his words, another reasonable person could reach
00:02:48 a different conclusion. So there are two big takeaways here. Number one is that this is not
00:02:54 the end of the road as far as Emergencies Act accountability goes. There are still federal
00:02:59 court challenges, and as we talked about on Friday, there's still the political dimension of
00:03:04 this. Voters have not yet in any formal way had their say on this chapter of Canada's political
00:03:10 history. And then there's also what the report really said, and going through with a fine-tooth
00:03:15 comb, now that we've had a little bit more time to do so, and start extracting what was actually
00:03:20 said here, what was actually found, and whether it stands up to scrutiny. And for this, we have one
00:03:25 of the best legal minds in the country, certainly when it comes to matters of liberty, Christine
00:03:30 Van Gein, the litigation director for the Canadian Constitution Foundation. Christine, I don't even
00:03:36 want to ask how your long weekend was, because I assume it was in large part consumed by a bulk of
00:03:42 this 2,000-page report? Yeah, it's 2,000 pages when you include the appendices, so it's not all,
00:03:50 it's not, you don't have to read every single one of those pages, but yes, I've spent a lot of time
00:03:53 going over this. It doesn't get better, but you know, this, as you said, is not the final word.
00:04:00 This is not the end of the fight over the Emergencies Act, because we do have a federal
00:04:05 court judicial review that we brought separately, independently. This report by Commissioner Rouleau
00:04:12 was brought by, it was called and convened by the government, funded by the government,
00:04:19 and this judicial review is completely independent and will hopefully reach a different
00:04:25 conclusion. So we have a hearing scheduled for that in April. So just on the scope of that
00:04:31 judicial review let me ask for people that aren't as familiar with the case are you challenging the
00:04:36 invocation of the act the emergency orders and emergency measures that flowed from the act or
00:04:42 both in that challenge both so it's sort of uh two things really it's that the emergencies act
00:04:49 was invoked illegally that the statutory threshold to invoke it was not met and we can talk about
00:04:55 what that statutory threshold means i have a very different interpretation of that threshold than
00:05:00 Commissioner Rouleau does, and that my interpretation is more in line with what most legal scholars
00:05:06 across the country view as a correct interpretation. And the other thing that we're challenging is the
00:05:13 regulations that were enacted under the Emergencies Act. Those would be the measures that froze bank
00:05:20 accounts and that created prohibited public assemblies. And we are arguing that those are
00:05:28 unconstitutional. So sort of two, two, two approaches, two things that we're, we're really
00:05:33 arguing. So when we talk about the statutory threshold, this was obviously a key part of
00:05:39 Commissioner Rouleau's report as well. And do I understand from that, that this is not a
00:05:43 constitutional challenge? It's not about the moral value of the Emergencies Act, it's about whether
00:05:47 they satisfied that test that is spelled out in the Emergencies Act, and by extension, the CSIS
00:05:53 act themselves? Yeah, so that's closer to what you would say is the way statutory interpretation
00:05:59 operates. So it would be an illegal use of the act. That is what we are arguing, that if you
00:06:04 use this legislation when the threshold is not met, that use is illegal, and that therefore the
00:06:10 regulations under it are unconstitutional. But the threshold was important to know for a public
00:06:15 order emergency, it's like the legislation has all these different parts, and they all kind of
00:06:21 interconnected. That's how legislation usually works. But the important thing for your listeners
00:06:26 to know is that for the legislation to be invoked, there needs to be a threat to the security of
00:06:34 Canada. And that is a defined term in the legislation. It's defined through reference
00:06:40 to another piece of legislation called the CSIS Act. And what's fascinating and a huge problem
00:06:47 is that CSIS found that under their legislation, there was no threat to the security of person.
00:06:54 This is, there was no threat to the security of Canada. And if CSIS found that under their
00:07:00 legislation, there was no threat, and there was no separate threat assessment done, how could
00:07:06 cabinet reach a different conclusion? It's not reasonable, in our view, for them to reach a
00:07:12 different conclusion. The thresholds are the same. The definition is the same. It's completely a
00:07:18 strange interpretation, sort of this Hail Mary, let's see if we can make this argument, this
00:07:24 novel legal argument and get it to stick. And somehow they convinced Commissioner Rublo of
00:07:31 this strange interpretation. I know that we've spent a lot of time on the show talking about
00:07:38 this, but I think it is important. And ultimately, it became increasingly clear near the end of those
00:07:43 hearings back in October, November, that this was going to come down to a debate about the
00:07:48 technicalities of the statutes and not about the fact scenario, not about, you know, whether there
00:07:53 was this previously unrevealed threat that was very explicit. It came down to what cabinet
00:08:00 believed and what these thresholds were. And when you look at the CSIS Act, which I've had the
00:08:05 as fortunate of doing a number of times now as I've covered this, it doesn't make any distinction
00:08:10 between the different applications of it. You know, when it's used by CSIS, there's this threshold,
00:08:15 and when it's used elsewhere, there's a different threshold. And the Emergencies Act similarly does
00:08:20 not put a caveat there. It says this is the definition. It's spelled out right there. So
00:08:24 what was the argument that the commissioner found compelling for why CSIS could find there was no
00:08:31 threat to the security of Canada, but the cabinet could. It was this notion that different decision
00:08:37 makers may rely on different inputs. But in our view, the words of the statute mean what they say
00:08:44 they mean. And for cabinet to reach a different conclusion when, in fact, cabinet was lacking a
00:08:51 significant amount of information. They did not have a separate threat assessment from CSIS.
00:08:56 CSIS had concluded there was no national security threat cabinet had not even been briefed on this
00:09:04 novel legal threshold cabinet had not been fully briefed by Brenda Luckey about the existence of
00:09:11 additional other laws that could have been relied on to resolve this situation that that the
00:09:19 emergencies act was not absolutely necessary which by the way is another part of the statutory
00:09:24 threshold. So cabinet reached this different conclusion, even though they were further
00:09:30 removed from the situation and had less information than CSIS did. So in our view,
00:09:38 it is not reasonable for cabinet to have reached a different conclusion. Even if they could rely
00:09:44 on different inputs, they actually had worse, worse information than CSIS did.
00:09:50 And I should also point out that even if that threat to the security of Canada is found, there are still additional layers for the Emergencies Act to be justified.
00:10:02 That threat has to be creating a national emergency, which has its own definition, and it also has to be outside of what existing authorities available under law are capable of dealing with this.
00:10:13 Now, I know your colleague Joanna Barron had a great piece in The Hub that really spells out some of these legal articulations here from the commissioner's report.
00:10:23 But the one thing that I found particularly not compelling from Commissioner Rouleau's findings is that he really conflates what police failed to do or didn't do and what bureaucratic infighting and this sort of territorial control between different agencies did.
00:10:40 and what the act itself says, which is cannot effectively be dealt with under any other law
00:10:47 of Canada. So there seemed to be this conflation of can't do and aren't doing. Yeah, I mean,
00:10:54 that word effectively is carrying a lot of weight in this report. Because what essentially, I mean,
00:11:02 one of my friends, Aaron Woodrick from the McDonnell-Laurier Institute has written in the
00:11:06 National Post is using this interpretation that, you know, police not doing a good job,
00:11:12 disorganization, lack of communication. That is just kind of typical of government. That's
00:11:19 a policing and governmental failure. And incompetence is not the legal threshold for
00:11:26 using one of the most powerful laws in Canada, a law that allows cabinet to create new criminal
00:11:34 law by executive order you can't just hand cabinet that power because the police were incompetent
00:11:44 and look there were a lot of policing failures no one is disputing that we saw that we saw
00:11:49 in the commission we actually saw it throughout the the the protests that the police were not
00:11:55 doing a great job uh i'm not a police officer so i i mean i know it's a very difficult job but
00:12:01 there there's a lot of consensus that the police failed here but that is not the threshold that
00:12:07 what they needed was more help from other police not this extraordinary sledgehammer that is the
00:12:14 emergencies act that in fact they didn't even really rely on the tools in the emergencies act
00:12:19 to resolve the protests they were relied on the criminal code so no one asked for this it wasn't
00:12:27 necessary. Things were ultimately resolved using existing law, and the threshold of national
00:12:33 threat to the security of Canada, that threshold was not met. So I have a lot of problems with
00:12:38 this report, but mercifully, we do get another chance in federal court. And just as a peripheral
00:12:45 note on that, to my knowledge, there were never any charges laid under the emergency orders,
00:12:50 were there? Well, under the emergencies orders, certainly there were accounts frozen. What do
00:12:55 mean by by charge no one was criminally charged specifically using any tool that wasn't already
00:13:01 in the criminal code i guess is the question well i i don't believe so i believe that the charges
00:13:08 were for things like mischief and um maybe resisting some resisting arrests uh but certainly
00:13:15 the power to um freeze bank accounts was used yeah well and that i mean as we've talked about
00:13:21 in the past didn't need charges and any other recourse or anything like that yeah and that the
00:13:26 tow trucks ultimately were were could have been used uh there was a lot made about the availability
00:13:32 of tow trucks and and that all could have been done using uh existing powers as well there was
00:13:37 the word that joanna baron used in in her piece in the hub that i think is a sadly accurate word
00:13:43 is deferential and and we've seen throughout a lot of the covid related uh cases that have gone
00:13:49 before courts, a lot of deference to government, a lot of use of Section 1 of the Charter to say
00:13:55 that the cessation of rights in Section 2, for example, are subject to these reasonable limits
00:14:01 or so-called reasonable limits. And in the case of the Emergencies Act, is there a legal ability
00:14:07 for the government to use this report as a substantive part of its argument, or does it
00:14:14 kind of exist in a box on its own and can't be brought into a JR as justification?
00:14:19 No, so this is not a finding of liability.
00:14:21 This has no legal weight.
00:14:24 I mean, it certainly has political weight, but I would encourage the Prime Minister,
00:14:29 if he popped any champagne, to put the cork back in because we're coming in federal court.
00:14:33 And we are using a lot of the evidence that came up in the inquiry.
00:14:37 So that's one way that the inquiry is relevant to the federal judicial review.
00:14:44 that there was there's a lot of evidence is being incorporated into the JR but the government can't
00:14:51 just table this report and say listen it was very reasonable they've already found it out here
00:14:56 no and they can't bring new evidence at this point anyway so explain to me where you think
00:15:05 the strongest argument is in critiquing the emergencies act do you think it is on that idea
00:15:11 that the threshold wasn't met there was no emergency it's it's and you know we don't even
00:15:16 need to get into the orders because the orders were illegal on that basis alone
00:15:19 yeah so i think that my one of the big focuses that we have in our material we actually do spend
00:15:27 a lot of time on on the orders uh because the orders are a big problem right the notion that
00:15:32 the government can seize your bank accounts because you are involved in a protest that they
00:15:38 disagree with politically that's a huge problem and anyone who supports that type of conduct
00:15:43 I think you need to ask yourself how you would feel about it if it happened to a protest that
00:15:49 you support from a prime minister who you don't support because that's that's really what's at
00:15:55 stake here this is a huge tool that gives the government a tremendous power to use against
00:16:03 protests that they disagree with in the future. But yes, I think that the main, the big thing
00:16:09 that we're going to be arguing in federal court relates to the threshold and whether the threshold
00:16:15 was met, whether existing legal tools would have been sufficient to resolve the protest. We think
00:16:21 that they would have been. And the question of what the legal threshold is, which is threat to
00:16:26 the security of Canada, as defined in the CSIS Act, not as defined in the subjective opinion of
00:16:32 this Prime Minister, and then examining the constitutionality of the measures enacted under
00:16:39 those, under the declaration of emergency, once that's been found to have been illegally invoked.
00:16:47 And what's the timeline for that case? What's the next key date, or key step or date in that?
00:16:52 So we filed our factum last week. The government, I think, is trying to bring some new evidence from
00:16:58 the inquiry, but we are resisting that. And there's a hearing scheduled for the first week
00:17:04 of April. So I'm going to be in Ottawa, looking forward to heading back after those,
00:17:09 those weeks I spent there in November, I miss it already. So I'm going to be back and I'll be
00:17:15 live streaming, following the hearing to explain what happened every day. So if you guys go on
00:17:20 YouTube and subscribe to the Canadian Constitution Foundation's YouTube channel, you can watch
00:17:25 my daily summaries of the hearing that will take place over three days in Ottawa.
00:17:30 I dare you to say under oath that you miss Ottawa. I don't think anyone could ever do such a thing.
00:17:35 I'm not going to be doing that.
00:17:37 Yeah, exactly. Is there a trial date set or a time you're anticipating it being?
00:17:42 Yeah, so it's a hearing date is April. Let me check my calendar. April 3rd, 4th and 5th. Now
00:17:49 that is subject to change. These things can change, but that's currently when I'm planning
00:17:54 on being in Ottawa. All right. Well, we'll look forward to that. Christine Van Gein from the
00:17:59 Canadian Constitution Foundation. Always a pleasure and keep up the great work. It was great chatting
00:18:03 with you, Andrew. All right. Thanks very much, Christine Van Gein. And you can also watch her
00:18:08 show on the news forum in which she breaks down a lot of these really key legal discussions in
00:18:13 Canada. And I know she was like plugging away in the studio on Friday when I know she'd rather be
00:18:18 sitting down with a nice big 2000 page tome instead. Well, maybe not, but it's a labor of
00:18:23 love, I'm sure. Let's talk about this in a little bit more detail here. Well, not more detail,
00:18:28 but I'd say the bigger picture of this and where I approach this, not as a lawyer, but as someone
00:18:33 who's followed the convoy, who's followed the fallout of the convoy, and who followed the
00:18:37 emergency commission in the fall. And I know that just to set this aside here, there's been a ton
00:18:44 of discussion online about this alleged political or familial connection between Commissioner Paul
00:18:52 Rouleau and Justin Trudeau. And let me just say it does not exist. There is no familial connection.
00:18:58 The purported connection would have Paul Rouleau, who's like 10 years older than Justin Trudeau,
00:19:04 somehow be his uncle by marriage. So it was already a bit of a tenuous connection. It was
00:19:09 supposed to, I don't even want to repeat it because it's not true, but the connection that
00:19:13 you've seen is entirely a conflation of two different Rouleau families. So that connection
00:19:20 isn't there. And the view that I take on this is that you can find enough problems in the actual
00:19:27 report if you read it. You don't need to invent new ones. I mean, I think that the commissioner's
00:19:32 report is flawed because of what the commissioner's report says, not because Paul Rouleau was, you
00:19:38 know, once stood on the sidewalk when within, you know, 50 meters was someone else and that made a
00:19:44 conflict of interest. No, you can judge it based on the merits and find enough issues there
00:19:48 to poke holes in this narrative, you don't need to invent new ones. So I don't like this tendency
00:19:53 for people to just immediately flee to corruption when you don't need corruption to go up against
00:20:00 ideology, which is enough of a driving force, I think. And the other aspect of this is that this
00:20:06 is not Justin Trudeau pulling the strings on this. You can't say the fix was in from the beginning.
00:20:12 Canadians heard evidence on both sides.
00:20:15 It did come down to, I think, a very razor-thin margin.
00:20:20 And ultimately, the commissioner sided with deference more than he sided with what I would say the letter of the statute is.
00:20:27 So, again, we don't need to create a conspiracy.
00:20:31 We can just condemn it on its merits and do exactly what I'm doing on this show,
00:20:36 which is work through with someone who knows the law very well, who knows the report, who knows the case,
00:20:40 and explain exactly why it is wrong.
00:20:43 So we'll be following the federal court case.
00:20:45 We'll be following the hearing in April
00:20:47 and we'll be following whatever comes next.
00:20:49 But I also want to tell people
00:20:51 that I'm very pessimistic about this.
00:20:53 And I was kind of pessimistic
00:20:55 about the Public Order Emergency Commission,
00:20:57 if I'm being perfectly frank.
00:20:59 I got increasingly optimistic as it went on
00:21:02 because I was watching this and saying,
00:21:04 if Canadians are seeing this,
00:21:06 then there is going to be no way whatsoever
00:21:09 they can take Justin Trudeau's side. And unfortunately, the way that Canadians viewed
00:21:16 this did not really translate to what became the final report. But the facts are still out there.
00:21:22 The documents are still out there. People like Eva Chippyuk, a lawyer who's worked with the
00:21:27 convoy organizers, formerly with the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, she has been
00:21:32 doing a tremendous job at pulling out and continuing to tweet out documents that in some
00:21:37 cases didn't get nearly the attention they deserved during the hearings. Documents, for
00:21:41 example, from Superintendent Pat Morris of the OPP talking about how OPP intelligence found no
00:21:48 threat to violence. They saw nothing that was not a peaceful, lawful protest. And there were so many
00:21:55 examples of that that I think we need to hold on to. Testimony that was incredibly valuable
00:22:01 because it revealed that they were talking about feelings of violence, not real violence, that you
00:22:06 had police that were really throwing the federal government under the bus saying, no, we had a plan
00:22:11 and the federal government saying, yeah, but I didn't like that plan. Justin Trudeau at one point
00:22:16 said, yeah, I didn't like the plan that I saw by police. Did you see the plan? Well, no, but I heard
00:22:21 about it. And it's like, you decided the Emergencies Act was the path you wanted to go through
00:22:26 without even looking at the plan that law enforcement was saying could have given you
00:22:32 the same objective without going through that extreme process, that last resort, not one of the
00:22:39 last resorts, but in law, the last resort for emergency management, wartime legislation. I
00:22:46 cannot stress that enough. And even if the Emergencies Act broadens the use of the act
00:22:51 beyond what the war measures did, it is still the bill that you would invoke in the time of war.
00:22:55 Sure, a different section, but it is wartime legislation, which gives you an indication
00:23:00 of the caliber of emergency we're talking about here
00:23:04 when the Emergencies Act is to be brought in.
00:23:07 So I said a moment ago, I was pessimistic at the beginning.
00:23:11 I'm very pessimistic about the court case.
00:23:13 Sometimes I think the process can be cathartic
00:23:15 and the process can be a way that we bring some truth
00:23:18 and bring some sunlight to this.
00:23:21 But I also have not seen from the Canadian judiciary in general,
00:23:25 certainly through COVID,
00:23:26 exactly what I would call a ringing endorsement for liberty.
00:23:30 And in Canada, this is going to be a tremendous problem.
00:23:34 So I go back to the political dimension of this, the political angle, and how important it is to educate Canadians, to continue to talk about this, and to, if I can be so bold, take the wisdom that I tried to put forward in my newsletter last week of never forgetting this emergencies act, never forgetting the last three years.
00:23:53 We are now in the fourth year of the COVID era, and while most of it is behind us, these
00:24:01 fights are now continuing.
00:24:02 The possibility for accountability, for justice, for truth, for transparency, it's only coming
00:24:08 up now, and we cannot let that window slip away.
00:24:12 And when I wrote that and talked about it on my show, I had people saying, yeah, I'm
00:24:15 on board, but what does that entail?
00:24:17 Is it writing letters to my member of parliament?
00:24:19 Is it writing letters to the editor in the newspaper?
00:24:21 to which I say yes call your member of parliament actually go and talk to them don't be abusive
00:24:26 don't harass certainly never take out your frustrations on members of parliament's office
00:24:32 staff I think that's a terrible thing to do there are people that
00:24:34 talk to your members of parliament and I'm very curious one-on-one privately how a lot of liberal
00:24:46 members of parliament would speak about this outside of ottawa face to face with a constituent
00:24:52 especially if they don't know if you i mean don't go in wearing your we the fringe hoodie with a
00:24:57 canadian flag on your car because that might give you away but but if you go in and actually put
00:25:01 forward some earnest complaints i don't know how many might break that red line that the liberals
00:25:06 have had i mean just for example uh this week anthony housefather who i've disagreed with on
00:25:11 a number of things. The Liberal Member of Parliament from Montreal tweeted out that Roald Dahl, who's
00:25:17 the late author who's being cancelled now and his books are being posthumously edited to, you know,
00:25:23 make women more empowered or something like that. This is a book about a giant peach that you can
00:25:28 live in. I mean, some of what Roald Dahl has written about. So I really don't think realism
00:25:34 is within the parameters of what we need to strive for in Roald Dahl. But anyway, Anthony Housefather
00:25:39 tweets that Roald Dahl's work and all work should be read as it was originally written. That is like
00:25:44 heretical to the left today. So a little bit of independent thought there. I congratulate him for
00:25:50 it. Joel Lightbound from Quebec, we know, has famously criticized the Liberal government's
00:25:56 handling of COVID. And Nathaniel Erskine-Smith, a very far left member of the Liberal caucus,
00:26:02 went along with it, but not without expressing on the record his criticisms.
00:26:09 So there are some liberals that, again, I'm not going to hold them up as being
00:26:13 these virtuous bulwarks for liberty here,
00:26:17 but they, I think, might be teetering on the edge of realizing
00:26:22 this was not something they should ever have done.
00:26:25 And certainly the NDP, I think it's a tremendous shame
00:26:28 that they've gone along with something that will be used against their pet causes in the future
00:26:34 without a doubt, because now it's been out of the box. It's been taken out of the box. The glass
00:26:38 case has been smashed with the hammer. The big red button has been hit. And now federal governments
00:26:44 have this tool in their arsenal a heck of a lot more readily than they had it before Justin Trudeau.
00:26:50 So we're going to put this to bed right now and revisit it in the future as necessary. Let's talk
00:26:55 about O Canada though, which I believe it's still called O Canada. Who knows? They keep changing the
00:27:00 lyrics now. Julie Black, the Canadian singer, R&B singer, tremendously talented. She's Canadian,
00:27:08 so she's not like a household name, but she's very well known in certain circles. And again,
00:27:13 it's very talented. I've liked some of her songs. She does a cover of that great addict James number
00:27:18 whose name escapes me right now. But she decided she wanted to do a little bit of ad-libbing when
00:27:25 she was singing the national anthem at a, no, not a football game. See, I knew I was going to do
00:27:30 something like this. A basketball game, NBA, National Baseball Alliance or something, an NBA
00:27:36 game in Utah. And this is what she sang in those opening lines.
00:27:55 Our home on a native land.
00:28:04 Our home on, she enunciates that word as if to say, you better make sure you hear what I'm saying.
00:28:14 Our home on native land.
00:28:18 Now, that is not actually the lyric, if you are unaware.
00:28:22 The lyric is our home and native land because it is not native in the noun sense as Canada's native people.
00:28:32 It's native in the adjective sense as if to say it is our home and native land, a very clear meaning.
00:28:40 But she wants to make the political point.
00:28:44 It's our home on native land.
00:28:48 It is now a preposition that that opening line needed.
00:28:52 She's very proud of herself. You can see her smirking at the camera there and normally politicizing the national anthem because she's making a political point. 0.99
00:29:00 She's even said in interviews after the fact, quote, I sang the facts, unquote.
00:29:07 She said to CBC, we are walking, breathing, living, experiencing life on native land, on indigenous land.
00:29:14 Now, she was in Utah. Now, Utah, of course, was once home to Indigenous nations, like most other parts of North America. But again, it's a weird place to stage this sort of protest because, you know, the Utah people don't actually care about Canadian Indigenous policy, I would suspect.
00:29:31 But our home on native land, she makes the point and is given accolades by the media here.
00:29:38 I just want to give you a few examples of the response.
00:29:41 So CBC does that glowing interview.
00:29:44 I sang the facts, they say.
00:29:46 What else do we have?
00:29:47 Toronto star Julie Black's national anthem is making headlines.
00:29:52 What would it take to make the change official?
00:29:55 So the Toronto star is saying, yeah, we really like how she named those lyrics.
00:29:59 We need to make those part of the official lyrics.
00:30:02 CBC Kids has this piece,
00:30:05 because you can never propagandize enough to children.
00:30:08 Julie Black recognized Indigenous land when she sang O Canada.
00:30:13 So we're talking about this being virtuous.
00:30:16 Yahoo News does a roundup here of big reactions to the lyric swap.
00:30:20 And oddly, all of the reactions seem to be positive.
00:30:24 And the ones that are negative are just from a bunch of randos on Twitter.
00:30:28 So everyone in the media is coming out with a tremendous display of support for Julie Black.
00:30:35 Indigenous leaders are saying, yeah, you go, girl.
00:30:37 It's funny, though.
00:30:38 I remember a few years ago when it was a lot less popular to make a lyric change at a sporting event to the national anthem.
00:30:45 Just ask Remigio Pereira of the Canadian Tenors.
00:30:58 sisters all lives matter to the great
00:31:06 now I will say that there's a bit of a difference in changing one word that could be mistaken for
00:31:17 the original word in general and just writing in a whole line that has nothing to do with anything
00:31:22 so I think lyrically speaking Julie Black wins over Remicio Pereira of the Canadian tenors who
00:31:27 are now the tenors because they decided that the Canadian part was holding them back. So they got
00:31:32 rid of Romigio Pereira. They got rid of the Canadian. They're just the tenors now. They've
00:31:37 added a new one. Again, very talented singers, but this guy ruined his, had his career ruined.
00:31:44 This guy was canceled. He was kicked out of the band, had his career just decimated, and he's
00:31:49 never really rebounded because he dared to sing All Lives Matter in the national anthem. And if
00:31:56 you listen to how he described that this is not a guy who was making an anti-black point this is a
00:32:01 guy who was saying that we need to love everybody he was making some hippie piece and love point 0.99
00:32:05 and as i said at the time i thought it was stupid you don't grandstand in that way certainly not 0.97
00:32:10 during the national anthem and i say the same thing to julie black but i'd be remiss to not 0.95
00:32:15 point out the utter double standard between what happens when a guy makes a claim like
00:32:21 Remigio Pereira did and when a woman like Julie Black does and aligns with a cause that is very
00:32:26 much on vogue right now and we see that the rules are that you can politicize the anthem only if
00:32:33 your thoughts are right if you are one of the woke set you can do it you can get away with it and you
00:32:38 know what your career is probably going to be better I was when the Julie Black I interviewed
00:32:43 Julie Black many years ago believe it or not she was a very lovely woman and when this whole thing
00:32:48 happened, I was trying to just go through, hey, what are those big songs of hers? I just wanted
00:32:52 a bit of a primer. And I looked her up on YouTube and on YouTube, like almost the entire, I'm going
00:32:57 to do it again for you right now, just to make sure I'm not leading you astray here. But if you
00:33:02 type in Julie Black with the proper spelling, two L's on YouTube, the first hit is a Shopify ad. So
00:33:10 we go past that one. It's her performance of the national anthem, then a piece from CTV about the
00:33:16 national anthem and then hey this show this show here is number three well that's good good for
00:33:20 true north on there we've uh penetrated the the youtube rankings and then a city news piece about
00:33:26 changing the national anthem uh then an interview she did four years ago with global and a bunch of
00:33:31 other things that have nothing to do with her music so you actually have to get down like halfway
00:33:37 down the page to get a julie black song which is to say that she's getting a lot more intrigue
00:33:43 for her changing of the lyrics to O Canada than she has for her music in a little while. And again,
00:33:49 that's not an indictment of her music. It's that now we are talking about this person who wanted
00:33:54 to use her platform to make a point. But if she did this in any other forum, no one would have
00:33:59 cared. If she just tweeted out, you know what, we really need to talk about Indigenous issues.
00:34:03 No one would have cared. It would have been another celebrity mouthing off. If she had just 1.00
00:34:07 written a letter to Parliament and said, hey, I know you guys changed the lyrics to the national
00:34:11 Anthem a few years ago. Clearly you're open to changing the lyrics. I've got a lyrical suggestion
00:34:16 for you. I'm a songwriter. I'm a Juno winner. You should listen to what I have to say. And they
00:34:20 would have taken it, looked at it and said, oh, okay, fine. Yeah. Next. So she hijacks a sporting
00:34:27 event, which again, I don't really care about it. I'm not one of these people that think sporting
00:34:31 events are these sacred places. I watched the Superbowl and that is the only sporting event
00:34:36 of the year I watched because I enjoy football, but not enough to watch all the other games every
00:34:39 year. I'm wearing right now a Talladega shirt because I went to a NASCAR race with my father
00:34:44 and brother, which I did not because I had a love of NASCAR, but because I had a love for my
00:34:49 father and brother. So I am not one of these people who's offended because she ruined a
00:34:53 sporting event. I'm one of these people who believes you should be called out when you have
00:34:59 this utterly hypocritical approach to when we accept politicization of the national anthem.
00:35:05 And this is not Justin Trudeau's fault, but I think it is the fault of people like Justin Trudeau who have decided that Canadian symbols do not matter.
00:35:16 Remember that Justin Trudeau flew the Canadian flag at half-mast for the better part of half a year because he just held in such contempt the idea of Canada, the idea of Canadian pride, the idea of any sort of Canadian nationalism, and didn't care about it.
00:35:32 It was a lot easier to pander to the woke mob by keeping the national flag and the Canadian flag down indefinitely
00:35:39 than it was to have a real discussion about issues that matter to people in this country.
00:35:46 And the national anthem is the same.
00:35:48 When the former member of parliament, who's now passed away, decided he wanted to change the lyrics to
00:35:55 In All of Us Command instead of In All Thy Sons Command, we decided that we're just going to change the lyrics.
00:36:01 It doesn't matter that it doesn't make grammatical sense.
00:36:03 We have to be gender neutral.
00:36:05 So tradition does not matter.
00:36:08 Canadian symbols do not matter.
00:36:10 And how else are you going to have a country rally around a national identity
00:36:15 if we've decided that all the markers of our national identity
00:36:19 are things that we're to be ashamed of?
00:36:21 That our national anthem is something that should be changed on the fly 1.00
00:36:25 because we want to make a ham-fisted political statement about Indigenous people 1.00
00:36:29 without actually offering any solutions. 0.96
00:36:31 So one CBC thing that they did that I really enjoyed
00:36:36 was a bit, I can't play it on air
00:36:39 because it's copyrighted
00:36:41 and I'd have to play the whole thing.
00:36:42 So it's not a fair dealing,
00:36:43 but it's a bit they did in a show
00:36:45 called the Baroness Von Sketch Show or something.
00:36:48 And it was about land acknowledgements.
00:36:50 And there's someone in a movie theater
00:36:52 that's doing a land acknowledgement
00:36:53 and someone in the audience says,
00:36:55 oh, should we leave then?
00:36:57 I mean, you just said it was not our land.
00:36:59 So should we go? And then the person at the theater saying, no, no, no. I mean, it's the theater's land now. And then the person in the audience says, oh, but just, you know, a little bit of our ticket price go to indigenous people. They're like, no, it goes to the movie theater.
00:37:10 But it was a really great example of how virtue signaling has become the norm in a way that is completely unquestioning.
00:37:18 And it comes at a cost, though.
00:37:21 It comes at a cost because all of these things become a very lazy way of making a point without actually contributing to anything.
00:37:30 So I don't know if Julie Black has really taken a keen awareness of Indigenous issues.
00:37:34 And I don't know if she's decided to contribute some of her earnings, such as they are, to Indigenous drinking water.
00:37:40 I don't know if she's lobbied the government for Indigenous changes.
00:37:44 I don't know if she's advocated for the abolition of the Indian Act. 0.71
00:37:47 And that's not her job. She's a singer. I don't expect those things of her. 0.98
00:37:51 But now she's decided that she's the one that has to solve these issues.
00:37:54 If you want to get in there and solve the issues,
00:37:56 maybe do something more than slipping a two-letter word into the national anthem to get your 15
00:38:03 milliseconds of fame we've got to end things there when we return tomorrow we'll have more of
00:38:08 canada's most irreverent talk show here on true north this is the andrew lawton show
00:38:13 thank you god bless and good day to you all
00:38:16 thanks for listening to the andrew lawton show support the program by donating to true north
00:38:23 at www.tnc.news.