Juno News - March 29, 2023


So much for "modest, short-term deficits"

Topics
Mentioned
Roxham Road is closing, but what took so long? The woke takeover of education (Ft. Ari Blaff)

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

169.53

Word count

7,087

Sentence count

252


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

I went to a rock concert and there was a weird thing that happened at the end of the show that had me wondering if it could be a regular occurrence at all concerts. I don t get out much, so I sometimes forget what life is like outside the house.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 We'll be right back.
00:01:30 Hello everyone and welcome to you all Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North it
00:01:42 is Wednesday March 29th 2023 hope you are all having a wonderful day it is hump day if you are
00:01:50 a Monday to Friday worker you are past the midway point of your week if you are like anyone else
00:01:56 that is having to embrace the gig economy because it's the only way to keep up,
00:02:00 then it's not hump day for you, but I hope we can give you a little bit of insight
00:02:05 and perhaps even entertainment on this program today.
00:02:09 I attempted, I will say, I don't get out of the house much,
00:02:13 so I sometimes forget what life is like outside the house,
00:02:16 but I was attempting to be entertained yesterday.
00:02:19 I went to a concert with my lovely wife.
00:02:22 There was a singer, well, is a singer, who's a friend of ours.
00:02:26 and he was performing and sent us an invite and said,
00:02:30 yeah, I'll give you guys some tickets, give you some backstage passes.
00:02:32 You can come by after the show. It'll be great.
00:02:34 So we went there, and it was out of town, so a little bit of a road trip,
00:02:39 and I'm getting ready to sit down at a rock concert.
00:02:43 Now, I am ready to rock out.
00:02:45 This is as rocky as I get.
00:02:47 I was wearing a collared dress shirt,
00:02:49 so don't think I was wearing my Guns N' Roses cut-off tee and had the hair long.
00:02:53 No, no, no. This is as rocky as I get.
00:02:56 But I was ready to rock out. I was at a rock concert, and I'm sitting down. I'm in the venue. The lights go off. We're about to get started, and on comes the guy who works for the venue to do the land acknowledgement, which, again, I don't get out much, so I don't know if this is a thing at, like, every live event you go to now.
00:03:15 There was a little poster in the hallway that I thought sufficed for the land acknowledgement by saying we were in Oakville.
00:03:21 So it's like we were on the traditional territory of the Mississaugas of the Credit First Nation and all that.
00:03:26 And again, but it's not, here's the thing that got me is that I'm used to the regular land acknowledgement.
00:03:31 I'm used to the, we are on the traditional territory.
00:03:34 And then, you know, ladies and gentlemen, the concession stand is open outside.
00:03:38 Enjoy the show.
00:03:39 this was a weird one because the guy said where we were and then he started talking about truth
00:03:46 and reconciliation and then he said we were all lied to if we grew up in the 1960s and 70s and
00:03:53 our government tried to destroy their culture and we need to tell our elected officials to stop
00:03:58 breaking treaties and then he started talking about drinking what he started talking about
00:04:02 boil water advisories and again you look there's a time and a place for political stuff this was
00:04:07 neither of those things, I would say. And then, you know, he's just depressed everyone, or in some
00:04:13 cases, fired them up to, you know, give truth to power about Indigenous politics. And then at the
00:04:18 end of it, and ladies and gentlemen, here is the, I don't know, I'm not going to name the performer
00:04:23 because they had nothing to do with it. And I actually asked one of the singer, one of the
00:04:27 guys backstage after this, singer that I know, I said, I said, what did you think of the land
00:04:32 of Knoll? And he's like, the what? I was like, didn't you hear? He's like, oh no, I was, I was
00:04:36 downstairs getting ready for the show. So if this is a thing at all concerts, please let me know
00:04:42 because it got to it. The sense that I got was that the venue guy like actually wanted the
00:04:48 applause himself. Like he just wanted to get the crowd all fired up instead of just doing the
00:04:52 obligatory. Like he believed it at least. So maybe it's a step in the right direction. I was at an
00:04:57 event once where someone did a land acknowledgement and then someone else did an acknowledgement of
00:05:04 their acknowledgement because they wanted to do the land acknowledgement so I'm not entirely sure
00:05:09 if we're just letting the politics of this get away but plenty of time to talk about this because
00:05:13 apparently they're happening at every event you go to now let's talk about the real story of the
00:05:18 week here which is the federal budget and in this particular case the federal government is on track
00:05:25 to run up a deficit of $40.1 billion.
00:05:30 That is a billion with a B if you were keeping score at home.
00:05:35 Now, these numbers at a certain point are abstract and meaningless to people
00:05:39 because if you are $200 away, as many families are in this country,
00:05:43 from having to put everyday expenses on your credit card,
00:05:46 $40 billion is a number that is such an abstraction,
00:05:49 it is meaningless in your life.
00:05:52 And again, I can tell you that when government is spending outside its means, it does negatively affect every other Canadian.
00:05:59 And I think governments around the world have had a bit of cover because COVID required spending.
00:06:06 But they've used that to justify spending far beyond what COVID necessitated and also as a bit of a shield for the fact that in this particular case,
00:06:14 we had a government that was running up billions in deficits even before the pandemic came along when the economy was doing quite well.
00:06:20 and their rationale was well we're doing okay as a country so we can afford it and then the
00:06:25 rationale became well things are terrible so we need to do it and as i've often remarked you kind
00:06:30 of look and say well hang on if good times and bad times warrant deficit spending when is the time
00:06:36 that we don't run deficits and there doesn't appear to be to this government one of those
00:06:40 things so let's talk about one specific aspect of this the federal government promised there would
00:06:45 be some relief for families if you have been to a grocery store in the last year you know full well
00:06:50 what the problem is you don't need politicians to tell you their solution for this is to give
00:06:57 every family in canada a one-time grocery rebate oh wait it's actually not every family in canada
00:07:04 they're going to give some families in canada a grocery rebate of sorts and they're going to run
00:07:09 this through the existing GST rebate program. The average family could make about $467. I shouldn't
00:07:16 say make, could receive $467 from this, but many people will get less than that. And if you are
00:07:25 buying groceries, you'll know that for a family, $467 might well be one, or maybe if you're really
00:07:32 lucky, two grocery bills, and then you're back to groceries that you cannot afford. So is there a
00:07:38 solution the government could have put forward here and is this something that is at all even
00:07:43 resembling a solution i want to talk about just this aspect of the budget alone for a little while
00:07:48 with professor sylvain charlebois one of the brightest minds in food policy in this country
00:07:53 from dalhousie university professor good to talk to you again thanks for coming on today
00:07:58 nice talking to you as well andrew so let's start start off with talking about this rebate here i
00:08:04 mean obviously it is a band-aid and i don't think it's pretending to be anything more than a band
00:08:08 But if you look at grocery bills, it's almost laughable to think of just how little that $200 or $300 a family might get will go on this issue.
00:08:19 Pretty much.
00:08:20 I mean, when you look at what's going on with food inflation, the average family of four will likely pay about $1,100 more for their food this year.
00:08:30 So that family would probably receive an extra $467 if they qualify.
00:08:36 if they qualify and that's a one-time payment and so just to contextualize that professor that's
00:08:43 half of the increase so so they're still out five hundred dollars a year more yeah it's actually
00:08:49 less than half of the increase over one year but Andrew I mean food inflation is a lingering
00:08:54 challenge for everyone it's not just over the next six months we are we are looking at some
00:09:01 nasty numbers for 2023 2024 as well so there's no long-term plan here this is really about
00:09:10 politicizing food inflation really i mean we've seen it in many provinces and ottawa basically
00:09:17 decide to do the same by setting out checks it's the easiest thing to do by just changing the name
00:09:23 of a program gst rebate and and make it a little bit more sexy if you will and i call it a grocery
00:09:31 rebate but it doesn't mean that people will actually use that money to spend on groceries
00:09:36 unfortunately. Yeah and of course the blatantly obvious issue with this is that it's not dealing
00:09:41 with the underlying causes so it's not a sustain I mean if you can even call it a solution it's
00:09:46 certainly not a sustainable solution so let's talk about what some of those could be because I don't
00:09:52 like oversimplifying issues here if we're looking at the the food costs and the increase that you
00:09:57 just mentioned can we trace this back to one or two concepts or are we talking about many many
00:10:04 inputs that are contributing this to this oh that's a tough one because you have you know 18 to 20
00:10:11 000 skews in a grocery store and they all have a story uh of course uh or there are we we can
00:10:19 actually identify overarching factors like supply chain weaknesses due to covid and the aftermath
00:10:29 there's ukraine of course ukraine made everything more expensive almost overnight and and there's
00:10:35 and there's climate change i mean right now i can tell you in six months from now beef will be more
00:10:40 expensive because there are many parts of the u.s where there are droughts and cattle ranchers are
00:10:46 just getting rid of their inventory so my guess in six months from now your beef at the grocery
00:10:51 store will be more expensive and that's due to a drought california is north america's garden
00:10:58 it ran out of water for a while now it has too much water and so they don't know exactly what's
00:11:03 going to happen there there's been some crops ruined over 300 million dollars worth of crops
00:11:08 a lot of that product was supposed to go to canada it won't so chances are vegetables will be more
00:11:14 expensive in a few weeks from now so there's there's lots going on at once but i would say
00:11:18 that those are the top three factors impacting most of the grocery store yeah and then you can
00:11:24 look beyond that and if we are sort of analyzing this through the perspective of multiple inputs
00:11:30 you know five percent from one thing two percent from another thing it all does add up i mean you
00:11:35 i know i've spoken elsewhere it's the the sacred cow pardon the pun in canada but supply management
00:11:40 is driving up dairy costs and poultry you have carbon taxes which i think are also contributing
00:11:46 because it adds to shipping so it becomes very difficult when you start layering all of these
00:11:51 things to find one ready-made solution does it not no absolutely so it's it's hard to uh to look
00:11:58 at uh all of the factors and as as a government how do you tackle all these factors so i i've
00:12:05 always advocated for measures that would be meaningful and that would change the cost
00:12:11 structure of the entire industry right now what you're looking at Andrew uh is is a new baseline
00:12:17 2022 was an historical year when it comes to uh management in the food sector uh there is a new
00:12:24 baseline wages are way up packaging costs everything is costing more so when people are
00:12:30 asking me if food prices are going to drop anytime soon i i kind of laugh because i i don't we don't
00:12:37 see it we don't see how food prices will drop so we are hoping for a lower food inflation rate and
00:12:43 that's probably going to happen during the second half of 2023 you know i i imagine just from what
00:12:50 you're describing about ukraine and weather conditions and all of that that food prices
00:12:54 can be a bit of a lagging indicator so even if some changes were put into effect now how long
00:12:59 does it actually take to start seeing the effects of these things or does it to go back to your
00:13:04 comment about the number of shoes depend on the product yeah it absolutely depends now when you
00:13:09 look at uh central banks and and they're all trying to actually bring down uh the inflation
00:13:14 rate even though canada actually has one of the lowest inflation rates in the world by the way
00:13:18 andrew i don't know if you knew this but if you look at the g7 uh canada is number three after
00:13:23 the u.s and japan japan is at 7.5 the u.s is at 9.4 we're at 9.7 but people in canada won't care
00:13:33 they won't care what's going on in germany or france or the uk they care about what's going on
00:13:38 in their own grocery stores and so you have to kind of wonder why are prices still too high
00:13:46 given the fact that we do grow a lot of food here in canada and that's really the one thing that's
00:13:51 bothering a lot of people and the answer to that question is pretty simple i don't think there's
00:13:56 been any greedflation going on we actually did look at financial statements of grocers there's
00:14:02 no evidence margins have been pretty stable however margins are double of what they are in
00:14:07 the u.s if you look at operational margins if you look at metro loblaws and sobeys for example empire
00:14:14 and you look at uh say kroger's and albertson they're they're double so it's been cozy for them
00:14:19 in Canada really we need more competition but here's the thing Andrew and this is what I was
00:14:25 expecting in the budget yesterday Canada's not all that interesting to invest in Canada doesn't
00:14:32 attract investors Aldi and Little for 20 years they've been in the U.S. well Aldi actually
00:14:39 entered in 2017 but Aldi has been around for a long time they've looked at Canada they've never
00:14:46 invested because they saw companies like Target leave in a nanosecond. They saw Sears leave,
00:14:52 Lowe's leave, Nordstrom is leaving in a couple of months. It's a hard market to service because of
00:14:59 inter-provincial barriers. Our fiscal regime is incredibly cumbersome. And I was expecting
00:15:07 yesterday in the budget to see some really meaningful measures to make our market more
00:15:13 competitive but I didn't see anything unfortunately. Yeah and I mean one example that I recall coming
00:15:18 up and I don't know if it was overstated as to how influential it was but when Target came to
00:15:24 Canada however many years ago bilingualism on packaging so it's they had to in many ways
00:15:30 recreate their supply chain they couldn't just take the products that were on the shelf
00:15:34 in the United States and plop them on the shelf in Canada so it it does I think for a lot of
00:15:39 companies bring up this question of is it worth the hassle to do all this extra work for a country
00:15:43 a tenth the size. And a lot of people a lot of companies I do look at the the supply chain
00:15:49 economics of Canada and it's it's hard it's really really hard in the U.S. de facto the number one
00:15:58 grocer is Walmart okay Walmart's market share in the U.S. is about 20 percent which is not a whole
00:16:06 lot but it's 20 in canada the number one grocer is lobla they own 32 of the market so that's
00:16:14 market dominance along with uh sobe's and metro so there there is there is some coziness that needs
00:16:21 to be broken up and so that's why i've been advocating for a code of conduct for example
00:16:26 to protect independent grocers because independent grocers are disappearing i mean they're just
00:16:31 gone they're disappearing everywhere in the country and we need to protect them a little
00:16:35 but they have no chance against Walmart and Loblaw negotiating with processors,
00:16:40 and they are fewer than in the United States, so it's hard to get a good price.
00:16:45 The stop sell last year, I don't know if you remember with Frito-Lay and Loblaw,
00:16:50 do you remember when Frito-Lay, Pepsi actually just left the table and decided not to sell to
00:16:55 Loblaw? That's what I'm talking about, the code of conduct. Pepsi was big enough to basically just
00:17:01 walk away for a month many sme companies like many small companies family-sized companies out there
00:17:08 can't afford to do that and that's due to the fact that lobla and walmart have too much power
00:17:15 so we're agreed professor that the one-time grocery rebate is essentially meaningless for
00:17:21 for a lot of people at least in the long term past the the first couple of months of receiving
00:17:26 the check if there were one actually i would say one thing i think it's actually can be a problem
00:17:33 when you see when you see a government invest in the economy it's only 2.5 billion but still
00:17:39 you do not want to see a state a government uh pour more money uh more fuel onto the inflation
00:17:48 fire because you may end up raising prices for everyone so they're trying to help 11 million
00:17:56 people but at this time they could actually hurt potentially well 39 million people no that that's
00:18:03 a very very fair point i'm glad you raised that i guess just in closing i'd say you know if there
00:18:08 were one singular policy that would make in your view a difference if such a thing exists in the
00:18:14 budget what would that be right right away yeah if you were if you had the misfortune of being
00:18:21 canada's finance minister and you had you had one policy you could put forward that would make a
00:18:26 tangible difference what would it be i would eliminate all sales stacks on food immediately
00:18:31 retail right now because of shrinkflation a lot of packages were groceries are now snacks and if
00:18:39 you're a snack, like for example, granola bars, if you bought a box of five bars of granola bars
00:18:45 instead of six, that's a snack. You pay tax on that. Okay. If you're buying a container of ice
00:18:50 cream like Ben and Jerry's and Agandaz, if it's below 500 mil, you're paying tax on that. It's
00:18:56 five to 15% depending on where you live in this country. That's more money. That's a lot of money
00:19:02 and families would appreciate a discount there. The same products in different sizes. I got to
00:19:07 of science and evidence in policy making.
00:19:10 Professor Sylvain Charlebois,
00:19:11 your insights is always appreciated.
00:19:13 Thank you very much, sir.
00:19:14 Take care.
00:19:15 Thank you.
00:19:16 Yeah, it's so absurd.
00:19:17 And I had actually forgotten about the snack meal divide
00:19:22 or the snack food divide.
00:19:23 So when you're going, it's like trying to understand,
00:19:25 well, why is this thing taxed?
00:19:26 And why is that not thing taxed?
00:19:28 And I mean, for a guy who looks like me,
00:19:29 it's dangerous because it means it's actually fiscally sound
00:19:32 to buy more ice cream than to buy less ice cream,
00:19:35 which is like hardly the message that the government should be sending with its Canada food guidance.
00:19:41 No, no, no, Andrew, if you buy one ice cream, that's just a snack.
00:19:44 You need to buy like the whole Costco-sized crate of ice cream.
00:19:47 In fact, I only look like this because of Justin Trudeau.
00:19:50 Okay, may or may not be true.
00:19:51 In any case, one thing I will say before we get on to the climate war waged against, I'd say,
00:19:58 well, pretty much everyone in this world by governments and the global elites.
00:20:02 I just want to talk about the NDP here.
00:20:05 And I said last week when we were doing the show live from the Canada Strong and Free Networking Conference that you should never make the mistake of ascribing relevance to Jagmeet Singh.
00:20:15 It's just a rookie error in politics.
00:20:17 I mean, even when I was covering the election debates in 2021 and I had a question that I was able to ask to Jagmeet Singh, I'm like, why do I care?
00:20:25 Why am I even going along with this?
00:20:27 He's like just Elizabeth May with, you know, two or three more members of Parliament in his caucus.
00:20:32 But nevertheless, Jagmeet Singh is the guy who is single-handedly propping up Justin Trudeau's government right now,
00:20:40 going along with things that even the Bloc Québécois will not go along with.
00:20:45 And Jagmeet Singh, of course, has said that he is totally backing the budget.
00:20:49 Now, here's a little clip to explain how he rationalizes supporting the Liberal budget.
00:20:56 This is the clip where he talks about how the NDP really forced some concessions out of the Liberals.
00:21:06 Will you trigger an election if the Liberals don't meet the Pharmacare plan by the end of the year?
00:21:11 That's not a decision we're making today, but we want to make it very clear
00:21:14 that there are certain things that the government has to deliver by the end of this year.
00:21:18 And the Pharmacare is one of those.
00:21:19 We want to make sure that's absolutely delivered by the end of this year.
00:21:22 In this budget, we have forced the government to deliver meaningful things
00:21:25 that are going to make people's lives better,
00:21:27 save people money and help them with their health care needs,
00:21:30 like their dental care needs.
00:21:31 That's something that we're proud of
00:21:32 and we force the government to do that.
00:21:34 There's more things that we're going to continue
00:21:35 to force this government to do by the end of this year.
00:21:40 It's kind of funny how the concessions
00:21:44 he says he got out of Justin Trudeau
00:21:46 were all things that were like literally
00:21:48 in the liberal platform, irrespective of the NDP,
00:21:51 that had nothing to do with the NDP.
00:21:54 And I think I go back to Stephen Harper's line when he was on stage with Preston Manning on, I guess it was a week ago today, yeah, in Ottawa.
00:22:02 And he was saying, you know, only Jagmeet Singh could walk into a negotiating room with Justin Trudeau and come out with absolutely nothing.
00:22:08 Like that takes a particular level of incompetence.
00:22:12 But you look at, again, Jagmeet Singh on Twitter throughout the year and he's saying, oh, the Liberals have failed Canadians.
00:22:17 Grocery store CEOs are getting rich and it's all happened on Justin Trudeau's watch.
00:22:21 And then budget time comes along and he's like, I vote yay, I vote yay, I don't want to have an election, I'm going to lose everything else and then I'm going to be ousted as leader.
00:22:32 So here we have it continuing along and indefinitely, of course, the Conservatives voting against it and the Bloc Québécois, the Green Party, again, no one really cares.
00:22:42 But the one thing I will say, that's not true.
00:22:45 We have like 40 minutes of show left.
00:22:47 So one of the many things I will say this show,
00:22:49 but specifically about Jagmeet Singh and his support for the Liberals,
00:22:54 is that do not believe that anything has anything to do with principles.
00:22:59 It's absolutely not.
00:23:00 It is purely a political calculation.
00:23:03 It's purely brinksmanship when it suits him, saber-rattling when it suits him,
00:23:07 and blind support like a little lost puppy following around someone
00:23:11 that looks like they might have jerky in their pocket or something.
00:23:14 That is all that they are doing because they are trying to avoid the polls.
00:23:18 And when they have enough in their war chest that they believe they could justify going to an election
00:23:23 or when, you know, really, really they get pushed into a corner,
00:23:26 then maybe they'll pull support, but it's never going to happen.
00:23:28 Not over China, not over ethics scandals, not over inflation,
00:23:31 not even over this little paltry pittance to Canadians on a so-called grocery rebate.
00:23:38 One thing that I will now turn to, which we have not covered a lot,
00:23:42 and I should say Canadian media has not really covered this a lot,
00:23:46 but it's incredibly important because these sorts of reports
00:23:48 that come from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,
00:23:52 which is the consortium of official alarmists around the world
00:23:56 propped up by the United Nations,
00:23:59 their reports tend to be very influential when it comes to the COP treaties,
00:24:04 when it comes to, or the COP agreements rather,
00:24:06 when it comes to climate policy in countries like Canada,
00:24:10 which has been very deferential to the United Nations.
00:24:13 And if you ever saw that just like weirdly preachy
00:24:17 and terrible movie with Jonah Hill and Meryl Streep
00:24:21 called Don't Look Up,
00:24:22 the whole premise was that an asteroid
00:24:24 is hurtling towards Earth.
00:24:26 And there are a couple of scientists
00:24:27 that are warning people to look and see it.
00:24:31 And, you know, the elites, the media, the politicians, they're not paying attention.
00:24:35 It was like, it was the blunt force approach.
00:24:38 No subtlety, no nuance, no symbolism.
00:24:40 It was the hit you over the head with it approach.
00:24:42 But it's amazing how the official science-based reports from the IPCC are just as blunt and
00:24:49 ham-fisted and I would say fear-mongering.
00:24:52 So the latest report, this is a sixth assessment or the final part of the sixth assessment
00:24:58 report which came out less than a couple of weeks ago and it has been now issued as a final warning
00:25:05 it's now or never we either deal with what they want us to deal with now or it'll be too late and
00:25:11 the world will go to hell in a handbasket we have to keep warming to 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial
00:25:17 levels this has been this thing that countries have just not really been willing to go along
00:25:22 with, even going back to Paris. And since then, Donna Laframboise is a tremendous journalist
00:25:28 and researcher in Canada who has, I believe, done more to debunk the IPCC than the entire
00:25:36 mainstream media in this country ever have and ever will. She joins me now. Donna, great to talk
00:25:42 to you and have you on the show finally. Thanks for coming on today. Thanks so much for the invite.
00:25:46 So, I mean, what is the thesis of this latest report here from the IPCC?
00:25:53 I mean, basically, it's we're all going to die unless you do what we want.
00:25:57 Yes, and that is not, as you mentioned, that is not a new message.
00:26:01 In fact, that has been the message of environmental activists since Earth Day, which is like 52 years ago.
00:26:08 So every year or every few years, we are told this is the last call, the last chance.
00:26:15 This is the last generation that has any hope of saving the planet.
00:26:19 And it's gotten a bit repetitive.
00:26:22 The IPCC is a UN body.
00:26:26 It is part of the UN.
00:26:29 It is run by UN bureaucrats.
00:26:32 And, you know, I have, thank you for those kind words about the work I've done on the IPCC.
00:26:40 I've spent more than 10 years now studying this organization that I'd never even heard about before.
00:26:46 And I didn't start this way.
00:26:49 I thought it was important to be open-minded and to be fair and to look very carefully at what they were doing.
00:26:56 But I have come to the conclusion that it's the UN.
00:27:00 And because it's the UN, we need to just close the door and say, thank you very much. You're not legitimate. We don't recognize your authority. Because the problem with the UN is that it is not accountable to anyone. And it is not democratic.
00:27:16 If we have a concern about how a UN body is behaving, we have no ability whatsoever as members of the public to vote those people out, to get rid of them, to tell them to change course or pull up their socks.
00:27:29 So this is a UN body.
00:27:31 It is, you know, it's, and so, yeah, thank you very much, but we're not going to pay attention to you.
00:27:39 That is my conclusion.
00:27:40 That's the best way to respond to these people.
00:27:42 I want to just don't give away where I'm going with this because I think you're shrewd enough
00:27:46 to detect where I'm going with this but I want to read a bit from an Associated Press report about
00:27:51 the United Nations a senior UN environmental official says entire nations could be wiped
00:27:56 off the face of the earth by rising sea levels if the global warming trend is not reversed
00:28:01 in the next 10 years governments have a 10-year window of opportunity to solve the greenhouse
00:28:07 effect before it goes beyond human control that was in 1989 so you are you are very correct that
00:28:16 the the overarching goal has not changed the rhetoric has not changed but we give them well
00:28:22 we not you and I but I think society the media governments give them a pass when none of these
00:28:27 doomsday predictions actually materialize we do we do and we have a very short memory so we forget
00:28:34 that just last year they told us it was the last call and and five years ago they told us it was
00:28:39 our last chance we forget and the uh the media uh turns out you know the mainstream media turns out
00:28:45 to be very good recyclers they're just repeating the same things over and over again so um you know
00:28:50 and once you once you clue in and you notice that um you know i think that can be very liberating
00:28:55 um but but you know perhaps it's it's useful for me to say just a few words about how the ipcc
00:29:01 operates. People call it a scientific body. This is the science. The science has spoken.
00:29:07 In fact, it's not. What the IPCC does is write reports. They are literature reviews. So they
00:29:15 recruit a bunch of scientists and ask them to survey the published scientific literature and
00:29:21 write a report about what that literature says about, you know, sea level rise or about soil
00:29:27 degradation and then they put it all together and they say the science has spoken but it's not
00:29:31 science it's it's it's it's kind of journalism in fact it's you know what what is it yeah so
00:29:37 just as shoddy as a as a lot of journalism carry on so so that's what's happening so when people
00:29:44 say oh this the ipcc is scientific it's not it's not and in fact some amount of trouble has been
00:29:51 taken to to mislead us to tell us that well the scientists are writing it but the scientists are
00:29:57 not in charge. The scientists are told you're going to work on chapter five and you have 300
00:30:03 words to talk about this topic and you have 500 words to talk about that topic and the one over
00:30:08 there the governments really are keen on that so even if there isn't any research you kind of just
00:30:13 have to wing it and tell us something because governments want to know about that in the report
00:30:17 and in fact scientists have so little control that in one report they said we'd like to change the
00:30:25 title of our chapter because the feedback we received says that it's got it talks about
00:30:32 systems in the title and that's confusing for people we'd like to change it to ecosystems they
00:30:37 wanted to add three letters to the title and they were basically told oh you don't have the power
00:30:43 to do that we would have to go through a whole series of meetings through the ipcc bureaucracy
00:30:50 to get that change approved so it's not a scientific document scientists are not in charge
00:30:58 and it's really the un bureaucracy using scientists to as kind of a shield or kind of
00:31:07 you know put on the white lab coat and dress up our agenda and we'll say it's scientific
00:31:12 there are i mean despite the vaunted uh and so-called consensus of scientists there are some
00:31:18 dissidents, you know, people like Willie Soon and Ian Plymer and many others around the world,
00:31:24 especially in Australia, that do push back against this either in full or in part. People like them,
00:31:31 what happens to them in the IPCC process? Are they just excluded altogether? They're not let
00:31:36 in the door? Are they allowed to contribute and perhaps their stuff is just like shoved down to,
00:31:41 you know, footnote 3072 on page 5072? Like what happens to the people that do exist in
00:31:48 the academic community that are skeptics as they say? Well in some cases they're frozen out from
00:31:54 the beginning. Their views are well known and so the IPCC doesn't even recruit them. In other cases
00:32:01 they participate in the IPCC, they raise their concerns about the IPCC process and that's when
00:32:08 they're frozen out. You know technically anyone can or anyone you know with some credentials
00:32:15 can comment on drafts of the IPCC reports as they're developed, but there is no, there's no
00:32:23 obligation for the authors to pay attention to those comments. So, you know, some of those
00:32:28 dissident scientists have taken a great deal of time to write out their concerns, to document
00:32:34 their concerns, to point to published literature, and it basically disappears, you know, down a
00:32:40 black hole and it has no effect whatsoever. So yes, there are a great number of scientists with
00:32:46 very impressive credentials who beg to differ, who have a different analysis, but the IPCC is
00:32:53 not a welcoming place for them. A mutual friend of ours, a retired professor from University of
00:32:59 Western Ontario, Christopher Essex, I invited him years ago on a debate. And I thought I would do
00:33:05 a really good journalistic job and have him and someone else on. And he had said, you know,
00:33:09 there's no point because he said, you can't actually debate science in these forums. You
00:33:13 end up debating politics and debating these things. And, and it was a fair point. I mean,
00:33:17 I'm a journalist. I'm not a scientist by any stretch. So if someone actually starts speaking
00:33:22 in scientific language, I don't really have the ability to push back as much as that I may on,
00:33:27 on some other things. And, and that's the one thing that I find very striking is that a lot
00:33:31 of the times the proclamations you get are not actually scientific language. The ones you get
00:33:36 from the IPCC, from the United Nations.
00:33:39 And you are right.
00:33:40 It's sort of shielded as this being part
00:33:42 of the scientific process.
00:33:43 And then somehow it translates to things
00:33:45 like final warning and, you know, irreparable harm.
00:33:49 Real scientists, if you speak to them,
00:33:51 don't actually use absolutes like that.
00:33:54 Absolutely.
00:33:56 See, you and I can use absolutely.
00:33:57 But yeah, real scientists,
00:33:59 when they're talking about research,
00:34:00 in fact, like I've interviewed researchers
00:34:02 about so many things and they're always so cautious
00:34:04 when you say something with a level of certainty
00:34:07 because that's not what science is.
00:34:09 Exactly, exactly.
00:34:11 So, you know, that's another alarm bell.
00:34:13 That's another red flag for us as members of the public to notice
00:34:17 that scientists are usually very cautious
00:34:19 and they're very careful and they qualify what they say
00:34:23 and that's not what the scientists who are talking about global warming
00:34:27 in the mainstream media do.
00:34:29 They behave very differently.
00:34:30 They behave much closer to political activists
00:34:33 because in fact that's what they are. So explain to me the danger of this because you know there
00:34:40 are lots of agencies and organizations that publish reports and they get you know acknowledged they
00:34:45 get received into a library they plopped on a shelf and they're never seen before but
00:34:49 the IPCC's reports are not that. No in fact the whole purpose of the IPCC reports is to facilitate
00:34:57 the UN treaty on climate change. So without that treaty, the IPCC wouldn't exist. And it makes a
00:35:07 certain amount of sense that if you're trying to get 185 countries who belong to the UN to be all
00:35:14 on the same page and to start some negotiations, it's good to have a base document, sort of an
00:35:20 agreed statement of facts is what the lawyers would say. This is what we think is the state
00:35:25 of of climate so um so that's the that's the purpose of those reports they're not scientific
00:35:32 they are they're they're a document intended to facilitate un negotiations you know we're talking
00:35:41 high test international politics here that that's the whole purpose of the sign of the ipcc report
00:35:48 So the process is such that the governments of the world participate in helping the reports to be written, and then they're sort of held to them.
00:36:01 And so we have governments all over Canada at the municipal level, at the provincial level, at the federal level, who point to the IPCC report and say, well, this is what's happening.
00:36:11 This is why we need carbon taxes.
00:36:13 This is why we are now having to persecute our farmers and make rules about nitrogen because the IPCC says so.
00:36:24 But it's all a house of cards once you start looking at it carefully.
00:36:29 So, yes, it's governments point to this and say, you know, this is what we must do because the IPCC says so.
00:36:36 But the IPCC is just a political construct.
00:36:39 So what's the next step of this?
00:36:41 Because obviously this was the final part of the sixth assessment report.
00:36:45 Do they just go immediately into the seventh report now?
00:36:47 I think they will.
00:36:48 That's what they've done always so far.
00:36:50 So, you know, there are summaries of the reports written because the reports can be 7,000 pages long.
00:36:58 And who's going to read those is certainly not politicians.
00:37:00 So they end up doing a summary that's 20 or 30 pages.
00:37:03 So what just came out last Monday is a summary of several other previous summaries.
00:37:11 so they have to summarize the summaries now it's so dense and long okay um so you know they this
00:37:19 is a because because part of the the negotiations for the climate change accord is that there have
00:37:26 to have a meeting every year that's the cop meeting right at the end of the year cop 27 or
00:37:31 whatever we're on now it's it's part of the the regimen the the doctrine you must have a meeting
00:37:37 every year and so then you know it's guaranteed that people are going to fly around the world and
00:37:43 there's going to be all this press another climate meeting so it's very much established now
00:37:50 you know in our governments and I'm not quite sure how we're going to dislodge it because
00:37:55 I'm told that in Germany they still have parts of the government that are working on acid rain
00:38:00 which was kind of a scare back in the you know the 1980s and it's it's once once government
00:38:07 takes on these agendas it's very difficult to get rid of them again yeah they perpetuate their own
00:38:14 existence i mean that's the thing like you know cop the you know cop 15 and cop 20 and all of
00:38:19 these things everyone sees and then you look and there's like a parallel track of cops about
00:38:23 something else and they're like so there are all these like you know different uh conferences of
00:38:27 of the organized parties every year and you're looking around i'm like no one's even paying
00:38:30 attention to these ones anymore they just someone just set it in motion 20 years ago and it just
00:38:35 you know goes on in in perpetuity so i'm glad you are not letting this fly under the radar donna
00:38:40 laframboise you're doing great work where's the the best people for people to get up to speed the
00:38:44 best vehicle for people to get up to speed on this issue if they haven't followed your work on it um
00:38:49 well i have a book on amazon it's called the delinquent teenager who was mistaken for the
00:38:55 the world's top climate scientist. It's a few years old now, but it's still, people tell me
00:39:01 who've just read it in the past month, this is really, really eye-opening. I didn't know all
00:39:07 of these things. So on Amazon, that's a good place to look. I'm on Twitter. Under my handle
00:39:14 there is no consensus, at no consensus. And this was not about Greta Thunberg. This was like long
00:39:21 before Greta Thunberg was the delinquent teenager that ran the climate world. That's true. That's
00:39:25 indeed true. Yes. All right, Donna, thanks very much. Great chatting with you. Thank you. All
00:39:31 right. She has just such an incredible wealth of knowledge on this. And it was actually
00:39:35 Christopher Essex, who I mentioned earlier, that had said, you know, Andrew, you should get Donna
00:39:39 on your show. And I realized I actually don't think I've ever interviewed her. I followed her
00:39:42 and we've corresponded. And she also has a great substack that has followed some of the stories
00:39:48 related to the trucker convoy and she wrote some very kind things about my book when that came out
00:39:53 and I'm very grateful to her for that as well. So that does it for us for today. We will be back
00:39:59 later this week with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show. Hope you enjoy the rest
00:40:04 of your week. Thank you, God bless and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew
00:40:10 Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:40:18 We'll be right back.
00:40:48 We'll be right back.
00:41:18 We'll be right back.