Juno News - June 04, 2024


Some MPs are acting for foreign powers. Why aren't they being named?

Mentioned
Indian students in Brampton DEMAND work permit extensions at protest Justin Trudeau vs. Pierre Poilievre: Who will Toronto residents vote for?

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

171.06

Word count

6,610

Sentence count

215

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A new report from the National Security Committee of Parliamentarians alleges that some members of parliament are working for foreign governments. Who are they? And what are they up to? And who are they working for? And why are they doing it?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here on this tuesday
00:01:28 june 4th 2024 great to have you aboard the program for another day of what i hope lives
00:01:35 up to the irreverence you've all come to know and love not irrelevance you got to be careful
00:01:39 on the autocorrect there we are going to be speaking a little bit later on in the show with
00:01:44 Heidi McKillop who is a filmmaker I believe from Alberta but she's got a new documentary coming out
00:01:50 today. We are going for the breaking news here and that documentary looks very critically at
00:01:56 why so many of these green energy initiatives are not actually green or all that efficient on the
00:02:03 energy question. So we'll talk to Heidi very shortly. Also coming up later on our good friend
00:02:07 Adam Zeevo about the length to which the harm reduction activists will go, harm reduction
00:02:13 activists will go to disrupt their critics and to intimidate their critics, of which Adam Zeevo
00:02:20 has very much cemented himself as one. That's coming up. He'll be on in, I think, 15 minutes
00:02:25 or so. But I want to begin talking about this rather bombshell story that came yesterday through
00:02:30 a group called ENCICOP. Now, ENCICOP is an acronym and what is it? N-C-I-C-O-P or whatever. But
00:02:37 anyway, they call it ENCICOP. It's the National Security Committee of Parliamentarians. And what
00:02:43 this committee had done starting, I think, last year was look into foreign interference in Canadian
00:02:48 elections. Remember that? It was all the rage for about five minutes or so. Justin Trudeau
00:02:52 appointed his old skiing buddy, David Johnston, to lead what was at first a probe. And then the
00:02:58 commissioner eventually said, okay, let's just have an inquiry instead to get himself out of
00:03:03 dodge there. Well, the Parliamentary National Security Committee, which is, again, a committee
00:03:07 dominated by liberal parliamentarians, looked into this. So they found a few little bombshells
00:03:15 here that are now in the ENSA COP report. Now, one of the big ones that came out, and I think
00:03:21 this is shocking for a number of reasons, more what is not in the report rather than what is in
00:03:26 report is that some canadian politicians are to use the word of the report wittingly which means
00:03:33 knowingly participating in foreign interference now the revelation here is that yes china
00:03:41 successfully interfered in canadian politics big surprise right china wanted handong to win
00:03:47 the liberal nomination in dawn valley north china very much interfered in that had a quote
00:03:53 significant impact, unquote, in Handong becoming the candidate. Handong is now an independent
00:03:59 member of parliament. The Liberals have kicked him out of the caucus. Handong was also doing an
00:04:04 run around Canadian diplomatic channels to talk to the Chinese, I can't remember if it was the
00:04:09 embassy or the consulate, but to talk to Chinese agents in Canada about the two Michaels, which
00:04:14 as a backbench member of parliament was not his job. But we go into the details here and wonder,
00:04:21 okay, who is it in Canadian politics that is working for foreign governments? And well,
00:04:28 you look through the report and it doesn't tell you. It says, so yes, some parliamentarians,
00:04:33 that would include MPs and senators. And you better believe I know one senator whose name for
00:04:38 sure is going to be on that list. But all of these members of parliament are now supposedly
00:04:45 working for foreign governments. China is named in the report extensively. India is. There's one
00:04:51 country that is redacted. I have a couple of suspicions. I'm not entirely sure. I know Iran 1.00
00:04:56 has certainly tried to have influence in the diaspora around the world. There are perhaps
00:05:01 Turkey is one that as well, some people have suspected, but I don't know what's under the
00:05:05 redaction there or the old black highlighter to use the onion joke about the CIA. But what I do
00:05:12 know is that the report is telling us that we have definitely people in Canadian government
00:05:17 that have been co-opted and we as Canadians don't get to learn who those people are. If I were an
00:05:24 opposition member of parliament and again I haven't seen question period today I would love to be
00:05:28 hammering the government on that release the names what is it you're trying to hide release the names
00:05:32 of who it is in parliament regardless of party that is apparently working for a foreign government 1.00
00:05:38 wittingly or semi-wittingly to use the options provided but not these are not useful idiots these 1.00
00:05:44 are not people that are being co-opted because they're dumb. These are people that fully knew 1.00
00:05:49 what they were doing when they were engaging with foreign governments. But let's take a look at
00:05:53 Chrystia Freeland's feigned outrage on this at a press conference this morning. We have potentially
00:05:59 MPs still sitting in Parliament who this committee says wittingly participated with foreign governments
00:06:05 to undermine our elections. Does that not undermine Canadian confidence in our Parliament and in our
00:06:12 elections? I think Canadians recognize how lucky we are to be Canadian and how strong our democracy
00:06:24 is. I think Canadians are smart and they recognize there is a very real threat. I think in the work
00:06:33 of this committee, in the measures, the new and enhanced authorities our government has put in
00:06:40 place. I think Canadians see that our government takes this threat seriously and is going to
00:06:47 continue to act. And I do want to emphasize, I see this as not a partisan issue at all.
00:06:57 I see this as an issue of the core national interest and the core strength of Canada's
00:07:05 democracy. That is how our government is going to act.
00:07:10 Sorry, I was trying to get a sense of whether there was something resembling at all an answer
00:07:16 there and I wasn't getting it. So the question, hey, we have MPs who are wittingly collaborating
00:07:22 with foreign governments who might be working against Canada. Well, I think that Canadians
00:07:28 are proud of our democracy. Really? That's your takeaway from that? That Canadians are just proud
00:07:35 and everything's working and the government's going to continue to act? Continue doing what?
00:07:39 you haven't done anything up to this point. What are you going to continue doing? If you're
00:07:43 continuing to do what you were doing before deputy prime minister, then we're going to have more of
00:07:48 the problems that are already underway right now. Governments have, look, I'm a libertarian. I have
00:07:53 a very narrow view of what governments should do. Governments at its core, at their core, need to
00:07:58 protect their citizens from foreign threats, which means at a bare minimum, it's not raising the
00:08:05 asexual pride flag it's not ensuring gender balance in the budget it's not doing any of that
00:08:10 at a core the government should be protecting Canada from threats that is supposed to be its
00:08:16 full and primary priority so when you have other governments that are wanting to infiltrate Canada
00:08:22 in whatever way they are trying to interfere in our elections I saw someone point out on Twitter
00:08:27 yesterday or x as it's called it's a fair point can you even call it foreign interference when
00:08:33 you have members of the Canadian government that are saying, no, no, come on in. Yeah, Xi Jinping,
00:08:37 you want to rig a nomination? You want to help? You want to get a preferred liberal candidate in?
00:08:41 Yeah, come on. I mean, they're not even interfering at that point. You can't open the door and invite
00:08:46 the guy with the balaclava over his head on the sidewalk into your house and then claim later
00:08:52 that he broke and entered. It doesn't work that way. When you're inviting him in, you are the
00:08:56 problem. You are the foreign interferer. You are the one that is crippling Canadian democracy. 1.00
00:09:03 So this idea that Chrystia Freeland gets up there and every Canadian just feels, oh, well, we actually have trust in the democratic process and we have trust in the government.
00:09:11 No, the government is the problem.
00:09:13 The government is the one that let it get this way.
00:09:16 And any time we've gotten information about this through the commissioner's report, through David Johnston's report, we've learned that CSIS raised concerns with the government.
00:09:26 The concerns went to the high ranks of the liberal government, including to the prime minister's office.
00:09:30 and at every stage we're disregarded we're told oh yeah maybe we'll set up a briefing and
00:09:35 why don't you just send a memo and put it in that paper shredder over there it's actually our inbox
00:09:40 we'll get to it in the future oh what do you know we missed the memo we don't know what you want of
00:09:44 us here so this is to me a baffling baffling conundrum in the sense that the government is
00:09:50 trying to convince us that it has the solution when China has seen Canada as having rolled out
00:09:55 the red carpet for their operatives to influence our elections, China being the biggest culprit 1.00
00:10:01 of this. And we're supposed to believe that the liberal government, that the Chinese government,
00:10:05 that the Chinese regime has wanted to invest in, is going to be their way out of this. They're
00:10:12 going to be the ones that save Canadian democracy. Do you feel all that confident about it?
00:10:18 Now, Chrystia Freeland, I mean, we had a silly story at True North this week about how she was 0.99
00:10:22 going door knocking uh well talking about affordability wearing designer sneakers that
00:10:27 were 740 dollars now i mean i used to get uh you know my shoes from you know the discount rack at
00:10:33 winners or whatever because uh you know basically it doesn't even matter what size it is just if
00:10:37 the price is right just squeeze into the size 7 or deal with the floppy size 15 clown shoes but
00:10:42 christia freeland uh she's all sorted out she understands what canadians are thinking because
00:10:46 she's wearing the big designer sneakers when she's going knocking on doors is it a cheap shot maybe 1.00
00:10:51 But perhaps she should spend less time shopping for designer shoes and more time reading the report, reading the dire lengths that the dire straits, basically, of the Canadian ability to protect against foreign interference that her government, that her government has allowed to happen.
00:11:10 There's the old line that's been said time and time again, government is not the solution, government is the problem.
00:11:14 On foreign interference, it's not even the Chinese government that is the problem.
00:11:19 It's not even the Chinese government that we are looking at to blame.
00:11:22 We need to start with the first and primary agents and instigators here,
00:11:27 which are Canadian parliamentarians that are apparently all too willing
00:11:30 to cede Canadian sovereignty to foreign powers.
00:11:35 Foreign powers which are evidently quite hostile, quite hostile to Canada's interests.
00:11:42 So let's just break this down in a little bit more detail here, because when you read
00:11:48 some of what's come out in the report, I actually believe this is a more conservative report. I
00:11:53 believe this is a more conservative report because this is, again, it's been approved and signed off
00:11:59 on by parliamentarians that overwhelmingly are themselves liberals. So let's just deal with the
00:12:06 fact that what's not being said is probably far worse than what is being said. There's probably
00:12:13 a lot more to this, a lot more to this that we are likely to see come out in the future. But
00:12:21 the government right now has had no curiosity, no desire to really get to the bottom of this.
00:12:26 Remember, they didn't even want to have a full independent inquiry into this. They wanted to
00:12:31 have Justin Trudeau's preferred guy David Johnston do this and what is quite frankly shocking about
00:12:38 this shocking about this is how little Canadians seem to care and I'm not admonishing people I 1.00
00:12:44 realize people have big problems in their lives when you can't afford a house you can't afford
00:12:48 groceries you can't afford gas I get all of that but ultimately democracy well it feels and seems
00:12:54 to many people like an abstract concept is actually anything but abstract because if the
00:12:59 democratic process is not intact. Nothing that happens in government is going to solve your
00:13:04 problems. Nothing that happens in government is going to work for you when other governments
00:13:08 have their fingers in the pot of the democratic process, when they're choosing nomination
00:13:13 candidates and they're doing all of this other stuff. So we'll talk about that in a bit more
00:13:18 detail in the future. I wanted to just briefly mention this bizarre announcement from the
00:13:25 immigration minister mark miller so it was really weird a few weeks ago it looked like the liberals
00:13:30 were starting to realize the problems of the immigration system in canada that as justin
00:13:35 trudeau said we took in more than we could absorb in a short period of time that we had too many
00:13:40 temporary residents more than canadian housing could accommodate canadian job markets could
00:13:45 accommodate and everything that the government has done since then has completely completely
00:13:52 shown they actually were not having a moment of lucidity at all because at one point we heard
00:13:57 that the government is entertaining turning uh illegal immigrants into permanent residents
00:14:02 giving them a path to citizenship and now we have a new announcement from the minister this morning
00:14:08 uh which is quite surprising here that if you are brought into canada as a caregiver you're
00:14:16 basically going to have permanent residency upon arrival and the language requirements language
00:14:20 being you know quite important to function in a country are going to be softened as well take a
00:14:25 look i'm very pleased to announce that we are launching new pilots that will provide permanent
00:14:32 residency status for caregivers as soon as they arrive in canada the biggest change coming in
00:14:41 these new pilots will be providing a one-step immigration process before caregivers first
00:14:47 needed to get work permits and then obtain work experience before applying
00:14:52 for permanent residency under the new rules we're simplifying the process and
00:14:56 providing them with a clear straightforward pathway to stay and care
00:15:00 for our loved ones the change will notably provide more autonomy for
00:15:05 caregivers to leave workplaces with abusive situations and seek
00:15:09 opportunities to advance in the care sector and Lord knows I've heard a lot
00:15:13 those stories not only today but in the past as we've been listening and reaching out to people
00:15:19 that have been providing that support and have been in abusive situations i'm also pleased to
00:15:24 share that we are lowering out of fairness the language requirements to canada language benchmark
00:15:29 four benchmark four under these new pr on arrival pilots our aim is to strike a balance between
00:15:35 breaking down the barriers caregivers face to get pr and selecting newcomers who will be resilient
00:15:41 to changes in the labor market lowering the language requirements is a must needed change
00:15:47 that we've heard directly from the community on and will align with other programs in my department
00:15:52 as well as provincial programs creating better consistency and fairness for all applicants
00:15:58 caregivers will still have the needed language skills to work
00:16:02 in the caregiving field let me be clear about that and finally as we look to address the
00:16:08 the desperate need for caregivers who are also expanding the pilot programs from private household
00:16:13 employers now to also include organizations who will directly employ home care workers. This will
00:16:19 allow for and not-for-profit organizations to provide jobs, job offers, and help address home
00:16:26 care needs where labor shortages exist. I like the one person that clapped at the beginning when he
00:16:33 made the announcement. So I was like, yeah, yeah, you go, Mark. That was like his press secretary,
00:16:37 presumably on the side it was a major jeb bush please clap vibes if you remember that from i
00:16:42 think the the 2016 republican primary but again he's saying all right on one hand uh yeah the
00:16:48 language requirements they they have to have the language they need to be caregivers but no more
00:16:52 than that and we're going to give them permanent residency immediately now the government is is
00:16:57 again for a government that claims it understands the immigration crunch not making any decisions
00:17:03 or taking any courses of action that suggest they genuinely understand that problem.
00:17:09 So now someone comes in as a caregiver, they're a permanent resident immediately.
00:17:14 I haven't looked at the nitty gritty yet, but it strikes me that if they decide they
00:17:17 no longer want to be a caregiver after a short period of time, ta-da, they're already in
00:17:21 the country anyway.
00:17:22 So we've now found a way to fast track entry into Canada for people that don't necessarily
00:17:27 have a solid grasp of the English language and people that up until a minute ago wouldn't
00:17:31 have been eligible for permanent residency as quickly so this is not a government that is
00:17:38 definitely showing itself to be at all a credible voice on these issues and I think it's an opening
00:17:43 to have a sensible grown-up discussion about immigration in Canada as I talked about with
00:17:48 Aaron Woodrick who was on the show yesterday but we had this conversation a few months back or so
00:17:54 but let's turn our attention to the wonderful world of harm reduction now this has been a space where
00:18:00 a lot like COVID. On one hand, you get people that say, trust the science, trust the science.
00:18:06 And then you look into what the so-called science is. And the science doesn't actually support what
00:18:12 a lot of the activists say it does. I mean, funny timing on this. Anthony Fauci this week admitted
00:18:17 under oath that he just kind of made up the social distancing stuff and he made up the masking stuff
00:18:23 and didn't really have any science behind it. But in the harm reduction phase as well, you have all
00:18:27 of these activists, very, very heated, passionate activists that talk about what they're doing as
00:18:32 though it is science, but they have, in fact, a religious fervor about it. Now, we've talked about
00:18:37 this with Adam Zivo from the National Post, who has delved into this issue more than any other
00:18:42 journalist in Canada has. And what I found quite surprising, and he was reporting on this last week,
00:18:48 was the extent to which some of these activists that he's covered were trying to disrupt a
00:18:53 conference of their critics. Now, ideally, in a sensible, grown-up world, you engage with your
00:18:59 critics. You debate them. You say, well, actually, I think you're wrong, and here's why. And that's
00:19:03 what people like Adam Zeebo have tried to do, and people like Sharon Koivu and Julian Summers,
00:19:09 both of whom we've had on the show. But these activists had a little secret meeting that Adam
00:19:13 got his hands on, where they talked about dyeing a hotel conference fountain red. They talked about
00:19:19 spraying people with a fire extinguisher filled with paint might have been a bit of a joke but
00:19:24 i'm not sure it's exactly haha funny they talked about intimidating tracking and monitoring all of
00:19:30 these people sounds a little bit mccarthy-esque so why are they not just engaging in the debate
00:19:35 if they're confident the facts are on their side adam zivo returns to the show it's always good to
00:19:40 talk to him adam thanks for coming on oh thanks for having me back on the show uh this we we have
00:19:45 like a yin yang effect going on right now you're in the darkness and i'm in the light so hopefully
00:19:49 you'll be uh your words themselves will be will be illuminating here but let me start on that
00:19:54 point because these people do claim that the science is on their side but they don't want
00:19:59 to debate the facts it seems uh just a quick note i am in ukraine and there is a blackout right now
00:20:04 so i do apologize in advance if i cut out i'm actually tethering to my phone data uh it's
00:20:10 remarkably good connection for a war zone so i'm glad you're making the time so late in the night
00:20:14 Sorry. And the last question, I just, was it about the science on the side of this?
00:20:18 The activists think that the science is on their side, but don't seem to want to debate the science.
00:20:23 They don't want to engage in it. They'd rather, as you learned, dye a fountain red to make their point.
00:20:28 Yeah. I mean, here's the thing is that there are all sorts of important policy debates we had about addiction policy and harm reduction is not inherently a bad thing.
00:20:37 it's considered one of the four main pillars of an effective addiction strategy with the other
00:20:42 pillars being treatments enforce enforcement and prevention so many people who criticize
00:20:48 harm reduction are not against all forms of harm reduction they just want a more thoughtful approach
00:20:53 to it but for many radical harm reduction activists that's unacceptable uh they treat
00:20:58 the most radical forms of harm reduction as sacrosanct truths that cannot be questioned
00:21:03 or discussed even though many of these interventions have only come about within the last 10 years and
00:21:09 have very flimsy evidence bases and so i think it's a sign of there's that uh there's that uh
00:21:19 cut out that uh he warned us about a few moments ago we'll try to get adam zeebo back on the show
00:21:25 here but i i think the point is an incredibly valid one and if you look at the the context
00:21:29 behind this. I mean, I have had a number of times where I have reached out to people on a particular
00:21:35 side of an issue, not just this issue, but other ones as well. And they don't respond. They say
00:21:39 they don't want to talk to you. They come up with all these sorts of excuses of, oh, well,
00:21:43 I don't think it's going to be a good faith interview, a good faith this or that. And I've
00:21:47 never had anyone, by the way, ever accuse me of doing anything that was unfair as far as
00:21:53 interviewing is concerned. So I go back to the details here. And if you read Adam's piece in
00:21:58 the national post about this and you follow him on social media he's he shared the audio recordings
00:22:03 of this zoom meeting they had this this zoom meeting where all of these people planned
00:22:07 on how they would disrupt this conference which was called the the prosper symposium it was hosted
00:22:13 by the foundation for drug policy solutions and again the people in this are scientists the people
00:22:20 in this are dr keith humphries uh dr um uh dr julian summers again we've had on the show
00:22:27 psychologists. So these people are coming up with science-based solutions to these problems.
00:22:35 And I don't know, I wasn't an organizer of this conference, but I suspect they would have welcomed
00:22:39 the opportunity to have one of these harm reduction activists on the stage and say,
00:22:43 let's actually talk about our different approaches here. We have Adam Zivo back,
00:22:47 so feel free to pick up where you left off there, Adam.
00:22:49 i think we have him back can you hear me yeah um perfect yeah just carry on where you left off
00:22:58 there right yeah so so you had mentioned earlier so there was this prosper conference and this
00:23:03 conference was put together by a number of very distinguished experts in the addiction medicine
00:23:07 world you had a number of well-respected doctors who are addiction medicine practitioners who have
00:23:13 been critical of radical harm reduction and have argued for a more balanced approach you had as
00:23:18 mentioned before, Keith Humphreys, who is a Stanford professor who has been a leading figure
00:23:23 in the development of American and British drug policy. You have Kevin Sabet, who was a former
00:23:28 White House policy advisor for both the Bush administration and the Obama administration,
00:23:33 making him one of the rare examples of a bipartisan policy expert in this space.
00:23:39 So this was not some gathering of wackos, right? These were people who knew their stuff
00:23:45 and want to present an alternative recovery-oriented perspective on the addiction crisis in Canada.
00:23:54 Now, when this conference was announced, harm reduction activists across Canada,
00:24:00 but predominantly in BC, decided that this was unacceptable.
00:24:05 So they came together and they organized and tried to find ways to discredit the attendees of this conference,
00:24:13 to disrupt the conference and potentially shut it down.
00:24:16 And so on May 21st and May 28th,
00:24:20 they had two large Zoom meetings,
00:24:21 which included a total of about 20 people
00:24:24 and 20 organizations where they plotted
00:24:26 how they could do this.
00:24:28 And some of the tactics that they described
00:24:30 went beyond normal protest
00:24:32 and got into the realm of intimidation.
00:24:36 So they talked about sending activists
00:24:39 into this conference so they could shout down speakers,
00:24:41 secretly record attendees they talked about dying of fountain red symbolized blood
00:24:47 they debated whether or not that was legal or constituted property damage uh they they explored
00:24:55 the possibility of parking a car right beside the building and honking their horn uh which of course
00:25:02 the tactic that we saw back in 2020 with the trucker convoy uh and and once again i do really
00:25:07 want to stress that people have a right to protest, but this went beyond that. And I managed to get a
00:25:13 recording of these two meetings. And once I reviewed it, I realized that we had a problem here
00:25:18 and that there wasn't, these activists were not interested in allowing a space for reasonable
00:25:24 debate about addiction policy. They were interested in shutting down and silencing their opponents.
00:25:30 Yeah. And one thing I found quite interesting, there was actually a lamentation of sorts of,
00:25:36 if I can find it here, where they basically said, I don't think we have unfortunately a chance to
00:25:43 kind of really shut it down, unquote. So their first instinct was, can we just avoid this from
00:25:48 happen, make this not happen altogether? You're either stunned into silence or frozen. I think
00:25:58 the connection is not cooperating today. We'll get Adam back on the show in the future, but I do
00:26:03 hope he's able to join us when the connection is stabilized. He has done tremendous reporting
00:26:10 on Ukraine. And as you've seen there, he gives up the comfort of a reliable internet connection and
00:26:16 power to do his journalism. So he's in the midst of a blackout now, but I appreciate very much him
00:26:21 coming on there. I wanted to turn to this event that's happening in Calgary today. It's the
00:26:27 premiere of a new documentary called Generation Green. Now if you can make it to the documentary
00:26:34 it is at the Plaza Theatre in Northwest Calgary tonight at six o'clock mountain time but I think
00:26:39 the documentary itself is one that people across the country should be paying attention to as well
00:26:44 because we hear all the time from the activists, the government, many people in the media the
00:26:49 importance of having green energy initiatives we need to subsidize this, subsidize that and all
00:26:55 the like. But the one thing that people often forget to consider is that a lot of this is not
00:27:02 at all based on the science, just like with harm reduction, just like with COVID, what people
00:27:07 present as scientific solutions oftentimes are anything but. So as we delve into this, I was
00:27:14 glad to see this film come to the forefront here. It's called Generation Green. The filmmaker is
00:27:20 Heidi McKillop, who joins us on the line now. Heidi, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on
00:27:25 today hi thank you for having me now i just saw you a couple of days ago at my book launch in
00:27:30 calgary so thanks again very much for uh for coming out to that so so what's the story you're
00:27:35 telling here so basically what we wanted to dive into was this question of what are the pros and
00:27:41 cons of renewables you know i really uh was personally confused when i started to read
00:27:46 articles online and everything was like 100 renewables they're performing at this and i'm
00:27:52 like well if they're performing that high then why are we still backing up everything with coal
00:27:56 hydro natural gas oil you name it every country is pivoting because the energy demand is so high
00:28:03 so obviously there was a discrepancy there that we really wanted to dive into so that was part
00:28:10 of our investigation and what did you find not to give away too much but what did you come away with
00:28:15 so there's a couple key points that we really wanted to address in the film the first component
00:28:21 of the film is really speaking about, you know, solar panels on your roof, you have a direct
00:28:26 connection to that energy source. It doesn't have to go into transmission lines that lose energy.
00:28:33 So essentially, those forms of solar panels are actually not too bad for an average household,
00:28:39 you can debate if you want to, you know, put the investment into it or not. But right now,
00:28:44 with our current federal government, they're heavily subsidized. So we kind of left that
00:28:48 into the pro the con really is though is that the renewable energy movement has basically gone off
00:28:55 of numbers of their install capacity instead of their actual output of what they're performing at
00:29:01 so we address this and we try to make it as simplistic as we can for audience that doesn't
00:29:06 really have an energy background or doesn't have an engineering background another component to
00:29:11 this which is extremely important to me as a new mom as you know a woman in the space is really the 0.98
00:29:18 exploitation of children in Africa for mining extractions that is used for the renewable
00:29:24 energy movement specifically cobalt we were investigating in the Congo and obviously there
00:29:30 is a lot of problems that have been affiliated with cobalt extraction primarily because they
00:29:36 are completely owned in majority from Chinese owned companies this is a huge conversation that
00:29:42 we have to take into the supply chain is that if you are going to demand an energy source and
00:29:47 displace those missions globally is that fair is that really the way that we want to conduct
00:29:52 ourselves as canadians yeah it's an interesting question i remember when i was covering the the
00:29:57 world economic forums meeting in davos i can't remember if it was this year it might have been
00:30:01 last year there was this this one mining executive that's getting up there and saying oh yeah we need
00:30:05 to do battery everything battery powered everything fossil fuels are uh you know a thing of the past
00:30:10 and then you look at his mining operation realize that you know he is his company is doing all the
00:30:14 mining that we need if we're converting to battery everything so it's not this altruistic
00:30:19 environmental message and and people often forget that there there's a cost to everything and you
00:30:24 know it's not uh it's not the case that you know you can get rid of this one energy source and have
00:30:30 another one we haven't yet you know harnessed wind in a meaningful way which is you know the only
00:30:35 form of you know energy that i guess doesn't really have a consequence apart from you know
00:30:39 the construction of the windmills but you're right all of these other ones do and and they're either
00:30:43 ineffective or partially effective or incredibly intensive to produce as in the case of mining
00:30:49 yes exactly and even with the wind turbines what is really interesting we've gone off um we dove
00:30:55 into this very intensively in the documentary as well because we had the opportunity to go down to
00:31:01 southern alberta and talk to landowners about the placement of the wind turbines um specifically this
00:31:07 one project that recently got cancelled but it was due in part because of the the mobilization
00:31:13 of community members in southern Alberta and they were really trying to say like this is a pristine
00:31:19 area of Alberta right by the adjacent to the Waterton Park they don't want to see that land
00:31:25 industrialized by any kind of energy company and they certainly have a right to start asking these
00:31:31 types of conversations um this is a really complex issue we can't just pick and choose
00:31:37 which conversation we want to say is the truth or not it really needs to be foundationally built
00:31:43 around a larger conversation and i'm not personally against wind or solar i think any kind of
00:31:48 technology that we want to diversify in within beans is a great idea but you're going to have
00:31:53 to have the same regulations that the oil and gas faces which is proper decommissioning of the wind
00:31:58 wind turbines, proper disposal sites for solar panels, which we do not have in place right now.
00:32:03 And my understanding is that that really does need to be improved long term.
00:32:08 Yeah, and you're right to point out, and I'm glad you shared your own perspective on this,
00:32:12 because I think there's a knee-jerk reactionary component that even some supporters of the oil
00:32:17 and gas sector have. Whereas if they hear green energy, they assume it's bad because
00:32:21 it's coming from people that typically hate oil and gas. And I think there's probably a lot of
00:32:25 truth to that. But ideally, we should be approaching any energy discussion with the same
00:32:29 conversation, which is, is this efficient? Is this affordable? What does it do for our stated goals,
00:32:34 our needs for energy production, our stated environmental goals, all of that. And you should
00:32:39 be able to have that discussion in a fairly dispassionate way that is focused on the facts.
00:32:44 But all of a sudden, you have people that are just against oil and gas, and they don't actually
00:32:48 care about hearing things that the oil and gas industry is doing in Canada and the United States
00:32:53 to some extent, to deal with the problems that they raise. And this is where we end up where
00:32:58 there is a need for this grown-up conversation about it. When we started to put out documentaries
00:33:06 like this, I get quite a bit of backlash on my personal life. And people will start saying,
00:33:11 you have a sociology background, a social work background, or who are you? You were a receptionist
00:33:16 at one point and a waitress. I'm like, yeah, that's exactly it. I'm really proud of the transition
00:33:22 of being able to be in multi-different faceted industries.
00:33:26 And that collectively, hopefully, will be projected in my films,
00:33:30 basically of having a balanced conversation from a human perspective.
00:33:34 We really focused a lot on the citizens.
00:33:36 We focused on the people in the regions of what their voices and concerns were.
00:33:40 And that's what I care about, is that we have to have that open dialogue
00:33:43 from the ground up, not from the top down.
00:33:46 And I think that's something that I'm really proud about with this film
00:33:49 that we accomplished is really getting the citizens to be at the forefront of the discussion.
00:33:55 So what's, I mean, you've been in this space for quite a while, and I know you've had an
00:33:59 open mind about this. Did anything surprise you? Did you learn much when you were making this?
00:34:04 A lot. Yeah, I think there's a couple things that really shocked me was definitely
00:34:08 the numbers. I feel very disheartened by the fact that certain groups are putting out random
00:34:16 numbers that are so contradictory to what their actual performance is at in terms of industrial
00:34:21 wind and solar plants. That really confuses me. And if I'm confused working in this energy space
00:34:27 for quite a few years, I can guarantee you my mom, my grandmother, my sister, they're all going to be
00:34:32 confused as well. So I think that's really something that I was shocked by and didn't
00:34:38 appreciate. Who's your target on this? Because the challenge when you have these sorts of
00:34:44 discussions a lot of the time is that the people that are going to come out and see it are the
00:34:48 ones that are already on your side are already open to it. There's a tremendous hostility in
00:34:53 certain subsets. I mean, even in Alberta, it's probably the most feisty, the opposition in
00:34:57 Alberta. But so how do you break through that? How do you get it to the people that genuinely
00:35:01 need to see this message? That's a great question, Andrew. And I think with each film that we start
00:35:07 to do, it slowly progresses into getting more viewership. And hopefully over time, you know,
00:35:12 people will start taking me more seriously as a director and producer of
00:35:16 film.
00:35:17 And I do get a lot of backlash because I don't have primarily a film
00:35:21 background. You know,
00:35:22 I fell into it when I was at my waitressing job and just started to hear
00:35:26 people talk about their problems and about the narratives around oil and gas.
00:35:31 And I thought, gosh, like what a great documentary this would make.
00:35:34 And that was my first one, a stranded nation. So since then, you know,
00:35:37 over the last five years,
00:35:38 it's really progressed and I try to challenge myself and my own beliefs.
00:35:42 every time we tackle a subject you know i sit down i i play both pros and cons i weigh them
00:35:47 very heavily in my head and i do a ton of research so i hope over time people will start to slowly
00:35:54 start getting into the idea that even if you disagree with the topic or even me as a person
00:35:59 that you will take the time to actually watch something that maybe will challenge your point
00:36:03 of view all right well uh where can people get details about the event tonight i so it's on
00:36:10 eventbrite and the film begins around six o'clock and doors open at five it's at the calgary plaza
00:36:17 in kensington and we hope to see you folks there and then tomorrow we'll be launching it digitally
00:36:22 online on my youtube channel all right the film is called generation green definitely give it a
00:36:28 look heidi mckillop good to talk to you thanks for coming on today thank you so much andrew all
00:36:32 right that does it for us for today we'll be back tomorrow with more of canada's most irreverent
00:36:38 talk show now i'm actually going to be in ottawa tomorrow hosting a book event uh where uh we will
00:36:43 hopefully have well not hope i we're going to have a lot of people out there so thanks to those of
00:36:47 you who are coming out uh we have a special edition of the andrew lawton show planned in
00:36:51 the interim as i'll be on the road but i do hope you have a great day we will talk to you tomorrow
00:36:56 thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for listening to the andrew lawton show
00:37:01 support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news
00:37:08 We'll be right back.
00:37:38 We'll be right back.
00:38:08 We'll be right back.