Juno News - September 02, 2020


Statues, Funeral Crashers and Taxes

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Maxime Bernier on Conservative leadership and future of PPC Canadians spending more on taxes than basic necessities

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

184.16

Word count

6,357

Sentence count

290

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Vandalism is the language of 2020 to the left, how government always screws up a good thing, and why your taxes are just too darn high. The Andrew Lawton Show starts right now on the True North Network.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:06 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:12 Coming up, why vandalism is the language of 2020 to the left,
00:00:17 how government always screws up a good thing,
00:00:19 and why your taxes are just too darn high.
00:00:24 The Andrew Lawton Show starts right now.
00:00:30 We are back. This is another edition of The Andrew Lawton Show here on True North Wednesday, September 2nd.
00:00:37 Yes, I know. I remember just in March when the pandemic began and everything was locked down and shut down.
00:00:43 And it was only going to be for a couple of weeks to flatten the curve.
00:00:46 And now here we are in September. Can you believe it or not?
00:00:50 I tend to side on the or not aspect of things, but you may have a different experience.
00:00:55 I don't know for parents whose kids are going back to school as some of them are as many of them are
00:01:00 you may be very grateful September is finally upon us. I wonder where has 2020 gone but again I know
00:01:06 that's an unpopular view as most people just desperately want 2020 to be over so whatever
00:01:11 you may feel about this month this day this year thank you very much for spending a little bit of
00:01:16 time with me here on Canada's most irreverent talk show. I spoke on Monday at a fair bit of length
00:01:22 about the decapitation of John A. McDonald's statue in Montreal.
00:01:27 And I got a lot of really good feedback from that show.
00:01:30 And it's still a couple of days later,
00:01:33 and we have no arrests, no prosecution,
00:01:36 despite the condemnation from all of the leaders,
00:01:38 including Justin Trudeau and Francois Legault
00:01:41 and all of the other people involved, politicians.
00:01:44 We have condemnations from all of them about it.
00:01:47 They all say, oh, vandalism's wrong,
00:01:49 and this isn't how you express yourself and all of that.
00:01:52 But still, where's the arrest?
00:01:54 Where are the prosecutions?
00:01:56 Where is the, for lack of a better term, witch hunt for the statue vandals?
00:02:00 They were caught on video from numerous angles.
00:02:03 Lots of people there would be able to identify them, but no, nothing.
00:02:08 And it may be that they were really, really good, you know, when they were up there,
00:02:11 they may have been covering their faces and all that.
00:02:13 But I've seen how police can identify masked protesters with very little evidence.
00:02:19 How they managed to do it.
00:02:20 They put out the all call.
00:02:21 they put out the shots and say these are the people we're looking for and a lot of the times
00:02:26 they as the old saying goes for the RCMP they get their man but that hasn't happened here and it
00:02:32 isn't just the John A. Macdonald statue on the very same weekend there was and this is in many
00:02:38 respects worse but we'll say as bad at least there was a statue of the Virgin Mary decapitated
00:02:44 outside a Lebanese Christian church in Toronto the Our Lady of Lebanon parish on Queen Street
00:02:51 And this happened on Sunday. The statue that adorned the church's exterior of the Virgin Mary had its head removed.
00:02:59 Not only that, but taken away. No one even knows where the head is right now.
00:03:03 Police in this case have put out a surveillance still that's very grainy of someone they believe was the decapitator.
00:03:10 But no one is clear on where the head actually is or why.
00:03:14 why this small church in Toronto was targeted in this way in a manner that would be a hate crime
00:03:22 were it to happen to any other denomination any other religious institution and again when
00:03:28 Justin Trudeau has spoken out repeatedly upon vandalism of mosques and synagogues in the past
00:03:34 I have to wonder where is the formal big long production of a statement for this where is the
00:03:41 support for the people of this church. And that's the part that's really shameful here is that when
00:03:48 other religions and other religious groups are faced with these same sorts of acts, it is a
00:03:54 federal case, it's a national case, and everyone is to talk about it. Whereas when it happens to
00:03:59 a Christian church, even a Lebanese Christian church, by the way, no one is speaking up,
00:04:04 no one is sounding the alarm. And it's actually just been people who are in the conservative
00:04:10 parties of Canada that seem to be speaking up as far as elected politicians go. Why is supporting
00:04:16 religious institutions who have been vandalized, why is that something that's exclusive to the
00:04:20 right? It certainly shouldn't be. And in many respects, this is unsurprising because the
00:04:26 culture that's created or that has been created, the climate that's been created by the left
00:04:30 is one that says decapitation of a statue is the way you express yourself. This is all
00:04:34 just a legitimate form of protest. And it's unsurprising because this is the culture we're
00:04:41 in now where the way you express yourself is by damaging things, by destroying things, by
00:04:45 vandalizing things. That is just political protest now. That's not vandalism. Take a look at an
00:04:51 interview that appeared in NPR last week. It's an interview in the Code Switch series with an
00:04:57 author named Vicky Osterweil or Osterweil who wrote a book called In Defense of Looting. Now
00:05:04 this book just came out. Osterweil is a self-described writer, editor, and agitator
00:05:10 who's been writing about and participating in protests for years, the interview write-up says.
00:05:16 And this book says that vandalism and looting is basically your God-given right if you are
00:05:22 protesting, that the rioters who smash windows and take items from the stores are engaging in
00:05:27 a powerful tactic that questions the justice of law and order and the distribution of property
00:05:34 and wealth in an unequal society. And if you look through this, I mean, there's a lot in this that
00:05:41 just makes it very difficult to stomach your way through it without just smashing your head into a
00:05:46 wall 19 times. So I'm giving you a fair warning or perhaps even a trigger warning there. But when
00:05:51 you look at the interview what she says is that looting is all about resisting the whiteness of
00:05:58 law and order basically because it's white supremacy and whiteness that's all happening 0.60
00:06:03 and that's why the black uprising is important and looting is the way that you accomplish that 0.94
00:06:08 and when you ask her as the interviewer did well what do you say to people who are concerned about
00:06:14 essential places like grocery stores or pharmacies being attacked and then she says well you know
00:06:20 they're not providing worker protections. It's a Republican myth that small business owners need 1.00
00:06:25 to be respected. That's a right-wing myth. So this is, again, one book from one radical. And I would
00:06:31 encourage you to actually look through this interview if you can manage to do it with keeping
00:06:36 your sanity in check. The reason is that this is, despite being just one book, a mindset. A mindset
00:06:44 that needs to be revealed here to be understood, if it can be understood, which is that when we
00:06:49 say, well, you can't vandalize because it's wrong. We're speaking a totally different language
00:06:54 than that of the rioters and the vandals who think that this statue is a monument to white
00:07:00 supremacy and who think that property rights are a monument to white supremacy and who think that
00:07:04 respecting the rule of law and public order is a monument to white supremacy, because that's the
00:07:10 problem. So none of the arguments that we're using are working on them, which is why I criticize
00:07:15 Justin Trudeau's line on this from the other day, which is that, well, vandalism's wrong and we
00:07:21 shouldn't take things out this way and there are proper channels and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah,
00:07:25 because I said that is not going to do anything to the protesters because he's not actually
00:07:29 addressing the very root concern, which is the historic revisionism and the malignment of
00:07:36 historic figures and of Canada's history and of Canada itself. So this is what you're up against
00:07:42 here. And I want to read another point where she says, you know, there's a reason that Trump has
00:07:48 embraced the white anarchist line so intensely. She said there, even when you're criticizing the
00:07:55 protesters, if you point out that most of the so-called Black Lives Matters protesters are
00:07:59 white, you're actually making the black people who are in the movement invisible. So she wants
00:08:04 more credit to the black looters, I guess, even though most of the videos and pictures I've seen 1.00
00:08:08 of looting is actually from white anarchists, not people who are genuinely speaking out 0.97
00:08:13 on anything about racial injustice. And I mean, a lot of people are jumping on NPR for allowing
00:08:20 this interview to be published and for having its writer go through the process and doing it.
00:08:26 I'm generally of the mindset that showcasing a perspective should not be seen as endorsing it.
00:08:32 I mean, in this case, NPR really does seem to be trying to give a red carpet treatment to this view that looting is something to be defended and something to be protected.
00:08:44 And that is, I think, a big danger because now all of a sudden there's like a moral justification.
00:08:49 If you want to go and burn buildings and destroy things, there's a moral justification to do that.
00:08:54 And that is just plain wrong.
00:08:57 But the reason I share this is, again,
00:08:59 to instill why we are going to see so much more
00:09:02 of what happened to John A. MacDonald,
00:09:04 what happened at the Lebanese Christian parish,
00:09:07 what happened at all of these statue sites
00:09:10 across the United States and several in Canada as well,
00:09:13 and what will continue because this is now the norm.
00:09:18 This is now the norm.
00:09:19 These protesters are no longer outliers.
00:09:21 This is, in many cases, a roadmap
00:09:23 for how they're going to view every single thing
00:09:25 they don't like take a look at this one story and this is actually predating the john a mcdonald
00:09:32 statue in montreal by a couple of weeks the john a mcdonald hall at queen's university
00:09:38 queen university being in kingston where john a mcdonald once served as the member of parliament
00:09:43 and in the next few weeks an advisory committee is deliberating on whether to rename the faculty
00:09:50 of law building from Sir John A. Macdonald Hall to some other name. And the rationale is, as you
00:09:57 guessed it, because there are questions about Macdonald's legacy. Well, there are no real
00:10:02 questions about Macdonald's legacy. There are activists and, you know, shrieking, shrill
00:10:06 protesters that are screaming about it. No one is actually concerned about Macdonald's legacy in any
00:10:12 substantive way. But oh no, because you have to capitulate to the mob and bend the knee.
00:10:17 Now John A. MacDonald's hall at Queen's University is now under the microscope and probably not
00:10:23 going to survive, even though the people of Kingston were once represented by this guy.
00:10:28 He helped create the country and he himself was a lawyer.
00:10:32 So this is now the norm.
00:10:35 Nothing is safe from the scourge.
00:10:36 And at the end of the day, everything's going to be just named with a number.
00:10:39 You know, this is going to be building 9247.
00:10:42 This is going to be building 3192.
00:10:44 And this is just going to be the way things go.
00:10:47 I mean, if you do a full complete top to bottom, east to west, north to south audit of street names in most Canadian cities, you're probably going to find that a lot of the people after whom these streets have been named are problematic, as they say, especially all of those streets named after English dukes and earls like, you know, Wellington, York and Trafalgar and all of these other ones.
00:11:09 so this is a Trafalgar is not a duke but you know what I mean so this is going to be where
00:11:14 this goes and we need people who are going to be strong leaders to stand up against it
00:11:20 and push back and in the case of the John A. Macdonald statue I said on Monday this is an
00:11:27 attack on history itself you look at the Our Lady of Lebanon parish and it's an attack on the people 0.99
00:11:33 of that church. It's an attack on people of faith, but the impetus behind it is the same, which is
00:11:42 that we now have a generation of people that feel this is the way you express yourself, and that
00:11:48 isn't to say they're victims of their culture because they're still making a choice. They should
00:11:51 be knowing better. They're old enough to know better, but they are themselves part and parcel
00:11:57 of this cultural shift that says
00:12:01 we no longer talk about our differences.
00:12:04 We no longer discuss our differences.
00:12:06 We no longer have disagreements.
00:12:07 If I don't like you, I destroy something.
00:12:10 And that is that.
00:12:10 And I have the right.
00:12:11 And if you try to stop me from doing that, 0.99
00:12:13 oh, you're just a white supremacist. 0.99
00:12:16 We've got to take a break. 0.99
00:12:17 When we come back,
00:12:18 more of The Andrew Lawton Show here on True North.
00:12:22 You're tuned in to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:12:24 you know there are a few certainties in the world of the few one of them is that government will
00:12:31 always choose the least convenient most nonsensical and most indefensible position whenever given the
00:12:38 option in this particular case it is Toronto's ban on what are called secondary suites forcing
00:12:44 a man to kick his father out of his home essentially if you look at this story it's
00:12:51 actually just one that makes you shake your head for many many reasons. It involves Rod Wilson
00:12:56 who decided he would do the right thing and be very kind and very nice and Rod Wilson had his
00:13:04 father come live with him at a little building on his property. Now I'm going to show you some
00:13:11 pictures of this because I think that this is very relevant to the story here but the rationale
00:13:15 now behind it is that Bill Wilson was two years ago losing his wife and daughter in a very short
00:13:22 period of time and Rod Wilson had a home in Toronto and said hey you know what why don't you come live
00:13:27 with me dad and it was a match made in heaven everyone was happy the reason is because Rod had
00:13:32 in his backyard something that from the outside looks like a barn of sorts but on the inside is
00:13:39 actually quite beautiful it has a kitchen it has a living room it has a bathroom it has two stories
00:13:45 So this is like a fully furnished loft in Toronto, which is very rare and very hard to come by.
00:13:52 It had electricity, it had heating, it had all the things you'd need, and his father was going to live there and he was going to be a good son and that was that.
00:14:00 But oh no, then the NIMBYs come around and the busybodies come around and someone in the neighborhood complained to the city who did an investigation and found that this is illegal because you can't have a separate living space on your property.
00:14:14 unless it backs onto a public laneway.
00:14:18 And given that this was in the backyard,
00:14:20 that would not meet the criteria
00:14:22 because the backyard is not a public laneway.
00:14:24 So this is one of these things
00:14:26 that actually does not make any sense at all.
00:14:30 This comes after the city of Toronto
00:14:31 had amended a zoning bylaw to allow for laneway suites.
00:14:35 So it used to be that the laneway wasn't even allowed.
00:14:38 But right now, anything in the garden, a backyard,
00:14:41 a tiny home that you might wanna plop in the backyard,
00:14:44 not allowed under the rules in Toronto.
00:14:48 And in a city that is one of the most expensive
00:14:50 real estate markets in Canada,
00:14:52 the idea that you are turning down someone
00:14:55 who is solving a housing problem for someone 0.99
00:14:58 and saying this is illegal is absolutely asinine. 0.98
00:15:01 Shame on the neighbor that ratted out the Wilsons, 1.00
00:15:04 by the way.
00:15:04 It just goes to show you how snitch culture
00:15:06 is alive and well all over the place.
00:15:08 But I'm looking at this and I'm like,
00:15:10 I realize that yes,
00:15:11 you don't want something turning into like a clown car.
00:15:13 You don't want, you know, your little quiet, idyllic Rosedale backyard to be something
00:15:17 that ends up having like 19 RVs shoved into it because everyone's living there.
00:15:22 Even then, I don't know if RVs are banned or not because they're on wheels.
00:15:26 But the point is that I get you don't want to be turning into a portable apartment complex
00:15:31 like for the old school portables.
00:15:33 But this is where you have to look at, as I said at the beginning of this, government
00:15:37 screwing it up for absolutely no reason.
00:15:39 There is zero rationale for this guy not being able to live in this little barn, which looks
00:15:45 nicer than a lot of people's houses, certainly in Toronto. No excuse for that at all. And this has
00:15:51 been an ongoing problem. Secondary suites or garden suites and laneway suites, I've heard
00:15:56 them all before. And every time they're discussed, the resistance to it is always completely
00:16:02 nonsensical. The resistance to it never makes any sense, but still nothing changes. And I don't know
00:16:07 who the lobbyists are that are keeping politicians from doing the most painfully obvious thing
00:16:13 when it comes to letting someone allow an aging relative to stay with them but regardless it is
00:16:19 just something that everyone needs to push back against and you know like we said at the COVID
00:16:24 lockdown beginning of the crisis when people were ratting out their neighbors and everyone else on
00:16:29 the street for playing at this park and going to this facility it's like just get a life get a life
00:16:35 If this is what you think passes for justice every time you see the most minor infraction
00:16:40 that doesn't affect you calling the authorities, you've seriously got to give your head a
00:16:44 shake.
00:16:46 I wanted to just talk about this story here, which I find amusing more than anything else.
00:16:51 Bill Edgar is an Australian guy who has managed to make himself a little career that is
00:16:57 unconventional, but I think is certainly deserving of entrepreneurial awards.
00:17:02 For $10,000, he will go to your funeral or graveside and reveal the secrets that you wanted your loved ones to know once you've died.
00:17:14 So Bill Edgar has no respect for the living.
00:17:16 He says his loyalty is to newly departed clients who hire him as a coffin confessor to carry out their wishes from beyond the grave.
00:17:26 And he said, you know, the departed need to have a voice.
00:17:29 he lends his voice for them. For a flat fee of $10,000, he will share juicy secrets. And he has
00:17:35 so far made, it sounds like $220,000, having crashed funerals and graveside services for 22
00:17:42 clients. Now he is a private investigator. This is on top of this. He said the idea came when he
00:17:48 was working on a case for a terminally ill man. And the guy had said, well, you know, there's
00:17:54 something I'd like you to do. And it ultimately ended up where he was crashing the guy's funeral
00:17:59 at his request. And now he has done 22 of them. Now, I'd like to know what the secrets are.
00:18:06 He said that he dresses in tailored pants and vest. He blends in with the mourners. He sits
00:18:12 in the middle. He sits with friends and family. And in one case with the first client, he was
00:18:17 instructed to interrupt the man's best friend when he was delivering the eulogy. I was to tell
00:18:23 the best mate to sit down and shut up. He said he knew that the best mate had been trying to have
00:18:29 an affair with his wife so in this case it got a little bit messy the client didn't want people
00:18:35 at the funeral so this guy was forced to for 10 grand discharge his duties and cause all the people
00:18:42 that were problematic to leave and this is the best line he said despite the confronting nature
00:18:48 of the job once you get the crowd on your side you're pretty right because mourners were always
00:18:53 keen to know what was left unsaid so this is like uh the wedding crashers sequel funeral crashers
00:18:59 although not in the way that will ferrell was in wedding crashers but in a new way and i don't know
00:19:03 who's going to change them play them in the movie maybe owen wilson can but hey you know what if
00:19:08 there is a market that is being unserved and untapped and you're able to find your way in
00:19:13 there and fulfill that void and fill that niche then power to you i don't know what 10 000
00:19:18 australian dollars is in canadian dollars i think it's a little bit uh i think it's a little bit less
00:19:22 But either way, I could look it up, but, you know, it's easier just to go on not caring.
00:19:27 So good on Mr. Edgar for coming up with a winning business proposal.
00:19:31 I hope he gets many awards for this contribution.
00:19:35 The anti-business mentality from government, though, is now extending to celebrity photo ops,
00:19:40 where one member of parliament, Dr. Luke Evans, is introducing a bill or proposing a bill
00:19:46 that requires anyone to advertise with a disclaimer
00:19:52 if they've posted a photo or an image that has been retouched.
00:19:56 The bill would do this,
00:19:58 quote, require advertisers, broadcasters, and publishers
00:20:01 to display a logo in cases where an image of a human body or body part
00:20:05 has been digitally altered in its proportions.
00:20:10 Now, this was torqued a little bit out of control by the Daily Mail
00:20:14 that said an MP is proposing a ban
00:20:16 on airbrushing Instagram photos or whatever
00:20:20 that it was going after Instagram influencers
00:20:22 and celebrities creating a warped view of beauty. 0.99
00:20:25 They aren't actually banning it.
00:20:27 They're just forcing disclaimers to be posted
00:20:29 if someone's, you know, thigh gap has been enhanced
00:20:32 or their ankles been shrunk or in my case,
00:20:35 I mean, who knows how much retouching we'd need to do
00:20:37 to get me presentable.
00:20:39 But he's saying that, no, no, no, it's not a ban.
00:20:41 It's just a disclaimer.
00:20:42 However, the rationale behind it is something he very much stands behind,
00:20:47 that the airbrushing and Photoshopping is creating a warped sense of beauty
00:20:51 that no one else is able to uphold.
00:20:54 And I'm thinking, wasn't this battle like 20 years ago
00:20:57 before people knew about Photoshop and how ubiquitous it was?
00:21:00 I feel like you're a little bit behind the curve now.
00:21:02 I think everyone understands that people on TV
00:21:04 are creating an unreasonable standard of beauty.
00:21:07 Again, in my case, I just don't even try, and that's how I'm confident.
00:21:10 but this just seems to be a little bit of the nanny state going a tad too far but hey let me
00:21:16 know what you think in the comments perhaps i'm in the wrong on this one we've got to take a quick
00:21:20 break when we come back more of the andrew lawton show here on true north you're tuned in to the
00:21:27 andrew lawton show welcome back to the andrew lawton show i know the most riveting subject
00:21:37 on the face of the earth is monetary and tax policy and I say that without sarcasm I actually
00:21:42 find that riveting and even if you don't like getting into the weeds on economics and the way
00:21:46 that the government taxes you it is certainly relevant when you learn exactly how much you're
00:21:51 being taxed a new Fraser Institute study says the average Canadian family spent 42.6 percent of its
00:21:58 income on taxes annually in 2020 that's more than housing food and clothing combined this is an
00:22:05 annual report that the Fraser Institute does. But even so, I mean, it tells a very stark portrait
00:22:10 every single year. Jake Fuss is an economist at the Fraser Institute and co-author of this year's
00:22:15 study, the Canadian Consumer Tax Index 2020. Jake, good to talk to you. Thanks very much for coming
00:22:20 on today. Thanks very much for having me on, Andrew. So let's talk about the number here,
00:22:25 because a lot of people, when they think of how much they're getting taxed, I don't think they
00:22:28 look at it all in one basket. They'll think, OK, my income tax rate is X or my property taxes are
00:22:34 this many dollars and when you combine it all is that where we're getting that 42.6 percent figure
00:22:40 from yeah absolutely like you said it can be extremely challenging for families to calculate
00:22:45 all the various taxes they pay you know we have things like sales taxes income taxes property
00:22:50 taxes liquor taxes fuel taxes and the list goes on so what we try to do every year is tabulate all
00:22:57 these different taxes that the average family pays and then what we come to is that the average
00:23:01 family actually pays about almost $39,000 in taxes every year, and that's almost 43% of their annual
00:23:09 income. And like you said, that's more than the basic necessities of food, clothing, and housing
00:23:13 combined. So it's quite a substantial expense. Is the result that you get from that simply that
00:23:20 the number is too high, or is there going to be a target in mind that you think that number should
00:23:25 be at? Yeah, I mean, that's a good question. Ultimately, it is up to individual Canadians
00:23:29 to decide if they're getting value for their tax dollars. But what we do see is that we're
00:23:34 uncompetitive with other OECD countries, particularly the United States, on things
00:23:38 like personal income tax rates. So we're uncompetitive at the levels like $50,000,
00:23:43 $75,000, and $150,000 of income. So we're kind of uncompetitive across the board on personal
00:23:49 income tax rates in particular. And then we also see a declining competitiveness on corporate
00:23:54 income tax rates as well with the United States. So these are certainly dregs on economic growth
00:23:59 and productivity in Canada, and that can certainly be harmful.
00:24:03 So, you know, we are seeing that tax rate increase over time in Canada.
00:24:07 We are becoming less competitive with other countries around the world.
00:24:10 And just to take it out of the percentage realm and put it in dollar figures,
00:24:13 the average family, according to this index, earned $91,535 last year,
00:24:19 and of that paid $38,963 in taxes.
00:24:24 So if someone just kind of takes that figure and digests it a bit,
00:24:28 That's nearly $40,000 paid to the government.
00:24:31 And I don't want to say it's for nothing because, yes, there are services that people avail themselves out of.
00:24:35 But did you get $40,000 out of value from the government as a family last year would be the question I'd ask a lot of people.
00:24:41 And I'm not sure the answer is going to be yes.
00:24:44 Yeah, I mean, ultimately, that decision is up to each person.
00:24:47 They can weigh how much they get in services and the quality of services versus how much they're actually paying.
00:24:52 But what we do see is, you know, just because you're spending a whole bunch of money doesn't necessarily mean that it's the most effective, efficient way to do that.
00:24:59 There is plenty of potential for government waste.
00:25:02 I mean, there can be handouts to corporations at the expense of taxpayers.
00:25:06 What we're seeing, you know, health care spending has increased a lot over time, but we're not necessarily seeing wait times come down.
00:25:11 In fact, Canada actually performs quite poorly compared to other universal health care countries around the world on wait times and on number of doctors and hospital beds and other categories like that.
00:25:22 So just because you're spending a whole bunch of money doesn't necessarily mean you're getting best results.
00:25:27 But ultimately, it is up to people to decide if they're getting good value for those tax dollars.
00:25:32 I know you mentioned the comparison between Canada and other OECD countries.
00:25:36 How has the track been in Canada historically?
00:25:38 Is this number staying relatively constant?
00:25:40 Are we seeing it going up or, dare I say, even down?
00:25:44 Yeah, so for the tax rates for Canada, so we go back all the way to 1961 in our report.
00:25:49 That's when the data was first available from Statistics Canada.
00:25:54 And what we saw at that time is that the tax rate was at about 33.5% for the average family back in 1961.
00:26:01 And basic necessities actually amounted to over half of your income for the average family.
00:26:06 But that's remarkably shift over time now.
00:26:09 So now we see basic necessities taking up about a third of your income at about 36%, whereas the tax rate now is at about 42.6% for average families.
00:26:18 So the tax rate has generally been increasing over time.
00:26:22 So that has been a remarkable shift that we've seen, particularly in recent years.
00:26:26 We've seen things like payroll taxes and the elimination of certain tax credits, and that's certainly increased the tax rate for average Canadian families.
00:26:34 And that's something that we'll keep our eye on moving forward as well.
00:26:37 And you mentioned tax credits.
00:26:38 These are these credits are historically factored into these numbers, because I know that can make it in many cases even more complicated to try to calculate.
00:26:46 Yeah, tax rates, tax credits, things like that, they're all incorporated into our calculation.
00:26:53 Like I said, you know, we have a whole bunch of different categories like income tax rates,
00:26:58 corporate income tax rates, property taxes, and so on.
00:27:00 So we do calculate, you know, various things into those calculations every year.
00:27:05 I know there have been a number of policies in the last few years that have forced there
00:27:09 to be more transparency on credit card bills, on phone bills, on hydro bills.
00:27:13 A part of me thinks when I look at this, the Canadians could benefit from a breakdown of exactly how much they're spending in taxes every time they do something.
00:27:20 Because certainly it seems like just given the total sum here, the individual places where people are being taxed would probably shock a lot of people.
00:27:28 Yeah, and that's ultimately what this report aims to do.
00:27:31 I mean, when we look at housing costs, for example, we look at that in the study, you know, amounts to about $20,000 per year or about 22% of your annual income for the average family.
00:27:42 but when you actually consider how much taxes amount to it's nearly double what actually is
00:27:47 in housing so you know as a lot of canadians are concerned about paying their rent or paying their
00:27:51 mortgage right now they should also consider you know how much they're actually paying in taxes
00:27:55 it's the single largest expense for canadian families right now and that's certainly a big 1.00
00:28:00 consideration for them when they're considering their budgets every year what are the areas if
00:28:05 any where people might not realize they're getting taxed or where the number might be higher because
00:28:11 I know that I mentioned at the top of the interview here, your personal income tax, your sales tax.
00:28:17 I mean, these are things that people see a lot more.
00:28:19 You must be factoring some numbers here that people might not realize are there or might not realize are as high as they are.
00:28:26 Yeah, that's a great question.
00:28:27 You know, I think a couple of things here.
00:28:29 Corporate income tax rates is not something that people necessarily think of being taxed to themselves.
00:28:34 And same with payroll taxes.
00:28:36 But what we actually see with corporate income taxes and payroll taxes is that a lot of this, the burden is actually passed on to employees in the form of lower wages.
00:28:45 So it's not necessarily something that people will think of.
00:28:48 They think it's kind of just a burden on the employer, for example.
00:28:52 But we do see that there are results for lower wages for employees.
00:28:56 And it can also have higher unemployment effects as well because you're increasing the costs for businesses and they're going to pass on that cost to employees.
00:29:04 So that's something that we see out in the empirical research, that this can be passed on to employees, and it usually is.
00:29:11 I know predictions are always tough, especially when you're talking about a study that's really data-focused,
00:29:16 but when you do this for 2020, looking at some of the changes that we've seen in the economy this year,
00:29:24 do you think when you do the next version, looking back, it's going to be a bit more challenging,
00:29:28 just given all of the factors that I think Canadian families are dealing with with job losses?
00:29:34 Certainly. I mean, one thing that we're thinking about going forward, you know, is right now we're running a federal deficit of about $343 billion.
00:29:41 So we're having a lot of today's spending that's not necessarily being financed by today's taxes.
00:29:47 So we're likely to see deferred taxation into the future where, you know, tax rates are likely to increase in the future.
00:29:53 So, you know, going forward, we could actually see the tax rates in this study start to increase more.
00:29:57 I mean, we could see a lot more challenges for Canadian families moving forward as well as we start to have that tax bill start to increase.
00:30:06 Yeah, and I just have to clarify, I think at the beginning, I may have messed up the year.
00:30:09 The study is 2020. The data in the study are from 2019.
00:30:13 So obviously, you're looking back to the data that are available, given this year's aren't in yet.
00:30:17 So I just wanted to clarify that for those listening.
00:30:19 And I do think to the point that you just brought up, a lot of the concerns that we may see if people are finding that, yes, their job losses are happening and income's going down, that the percentage people are spending on taxes, even if the dollar figure isn't higher, may actually be quite significantly inflated.
00:30:36 So perhaps there's going to be a bit more awareness when we look at these numbers.
00:30:40 Yeah, that's certainly an important consideration.
00:30:43 Ultimately, this study is about informing Canadians of how much their tax bill is.
00:30:46 And, you know, it has increased by over 2,000 percent since 1961.
00:30:51 Even when we account for inflation, it's about 169 percent increase.
00:30:55 But ultimately, that percentage of income number is probably the most important one.
00:31:00 Just seeing that general increase over time where we were at about 34 percent of income back in the 60s,
00:31:05 and we're now at about 43 percent of income.
00:31:07 And this is likely to increase as well in the future.
00:31:09 So that's certainly an important number that I think Canadians will be informed of.
00:31:15 Jake Fuss, economist with the Fraser Institute,
00:31:17 joining me on the line now.
00:31:18 The report, the Canadian Consumer Tax Index 2020.
00:31:22 Jake, thanks very much for your time.
00:31:23 Really appreciate it.
00:31:24 Thanks very much for having me on, Andrew.
00:31:26 Like I said earlier, I know nothing is as riveting
00:31:28 as talking about tax policy,
00:31:30 but there is a significant question there.
00:31:32 Anytime you're spending more for something,
00:31:33 you have to ask,
00:31:34 are you getting that much more value out of it?
00:31:37 And when he said that's gone up 2,000% over the 1960s,
00:31:40 I don't know how many of you listening
00:31:41 were around in the 60s,
00:31:43 But if you were, are you getting 2,000% more value from government now than you were then?
00:31:48 And you especially see this on property taxes because property tax bills will go up consistently
00:31:53 in most cities every year.
00:31:55 And maybe it's a couple of percent here and there, but it's like, well, hang on, you're
00:31:57 not picking up my garbage 2% faster.
00:32:00 You're not picking up my recycling 2% faster.
00:32:03 I know recycling is a bit different, but you're not doing any of these things better.
00:32:06 You're not giving me 2% more services.
00:32:08 You're just paying more.
00:32:09 and in many cases with property taxes you're getting a tax rate increase and also if the
00:32:15 value of your home is going up you're actually paying more for that reason as well same as
00:32:20 inflation the if the price of a widget goes up by a few percent your 13 or 5 or 8 sales tax
00:32:28 is actually going up as well and a lot of the time people do not realize just how buried a lot of
00:32:34 these taxes are if you do any air travel or anything like that you're paying taxes on taxes
00:32:40 or gas you're paying taxes on taxes a lot of the time and it is absolutely insane so these reports
00:32:46 are good transparency is key and again I know that Aaron O'Toole has just taken the helm of
00:32:51 the Conservative Party of Canada but it would be great if he could actually take this seriously
00:32:55 and start promising not just a reduction in taxes but a simplification and streamlining of them
00:33:01 That's my wish for the Conservative leader or any political leader moving forward.
00:33:05 I just don't think it's going to come from the Liberals.
00:33:08 My thanks again to Jake Fuss and to all of you for tuning in to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:33:12 We've got to wrap things up, but we will be back next week with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show.
00:33:18 This is The Andrew Lawton Show on True North.
00:33:19 Thank you, God bless, and good day, Canada.
00:33:22 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:33:24 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.nones.
00:33:31 We'll see you next time.
00:34:01 Thank you.