Juno News - September 05, 2023


Tamara Lich and Chris Barber are on trial

Topics
Mentioned
Alberta court rules against pandemic-related health orders (ft. Sarah Miller) Police officer testifies he was ordered to give "not one inch" to Convoy organizers

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

171.0

Word count

6,452

Sentence count

300

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Tamara Leach and Chris Barber are standing trial for their part in the Freedom Convoy incident in which they led a group of protesters onto the streets of Ottawa to protest the government's handling of the case against them.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:17 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:25 Hello and welcome to you all, Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:29 So here, the Andrew Lawton Show on True North on this Tuesday, September 5th, just after 4 o'clock Eastern Time, where I am in Ontario,
00:01:38 and also where Tamara Leach and Chris Barber, the organizers of the infamous Freedom Convoy, which arrived in Ottawa nearly 20 months ago, are standing trial.
00:01:50 Now, this has been a long time coming in some ways, and I don't take any delight in the fact that Tamara and Chris are on trial,
00:01:58 although I am going to put forward the belief that if they are going to be swifter, justice is better than nothing at all.
00:02:06 And they've actually been denied the right to a speedy trial by virtue of how long this has taken,
00:02:11 when especially in Tamara's case, her life has been put on hold in very real ways by the conditions placed upon her by various judges.
00:02:20 Now, these have eased somewhat in recent months.
00:02:24 You may recall there was a time in which she was not able to speak at all, and since then she's published a book and she's sat down with me for an interview.
00:02:33 Actually, she's been on my show once, once in response to the Public Order Emergency Commission report and another when her book came out.
00:02:40 We'll play a clip of that in just a little bit of time here.
00:02:43 For Chris, he's been able to carry on with his life to some extent, but still both of them have had hanging over them for basically 19 months since the end of the convoy.
00:02:54 this possibility that they will be thrown in jail.
00:02:58 They are facing a number of charges,
00:03:00 the bulk of which pertain to so-called mischief.
00:03:03 Mischief.
00:03:04 That's what they're doing.
00:03:05 They're mischief makers.
00:03:06 You know that little thing that you're accused of doing
00:03:08 when you're a toddler by your parents committing mischief?
00:03:11 That is what these people are on trial for.
00:03:13 Now, I'm not in Ottawa right now.
00:03:16 I'm not in the courtroom,
00:03:17 but I've been following along from some of the folks who are
00:03:19 with what's happened there.
00:03:21 And it sounds as though there hasn't yet been any criminality that's been advanced by the Crown, by witnesses for the prosecution.
00:03:28 They even played a whole bunch of video clips from the convoy.
00:03:31 One of them involved protesters shouting love over fear.
00:03:35 Now, this was a prosecution piece of evidence.
00:03:38 This was a piece of evidence that the Crown thought would really help establish the criminality of Tamara Leach and Chris Barber,
00:03:45 which was a group of protesters in Ottawa with the Freedom Convoy shouting love over fear.
00:03:51 Oh, yes, that is as criminal as it gets in Justin Trudeau's Canada.
00:03:56 This is going to be a long trial.
00:03:58 It's scheduled for 16 days of sitting, but it's not actually 16 days straight
00:04:03 because they're starting and stopping at a couple of points.
00:04:05 So this is going to go into October unless they may have made a change,
00:04:10 of which I'm not aware, although the dates that I have are going to go into October
00:04:14 and at the end of which it may be a considerable time beyond that
00:04:17 before we really fully understand the scope of what's happened here.
00:04:21 But we can take a bigger picture look at what the last 20 months have shown us,
00:04:26 which is that the Freedom Convoy won.
00:04:29 The Freedom Convoy was preaching a message that was, in fact, a unifying one.
00:04:33 And even if there were people in Ottawa that didn't want to hear what they had to say
00:04:37 and people that may have understandably not liked the sounds of honking horns,
00:04:42 which were persistent for the first few days of the convoy anyway,
00:04:46 it was a message that they were sharing that Canadians desperately needed to hear.
00:04:51 It was a message that provincial premiers needed to hear, notably Doug Ford in Ontario,
00:04:56 Jason Kenney in Alberta, Scott Moe in Saskatchewan,
00:04:59 and a bunch of even non-conservative governments in BC.
00:05:04 And perhaps you could also include in the mix there Quebec.
00:05:07 I don't know if you call Quebec's government a conservative one, certainly not in form.
00:05:12 But we also have to look at the implications of the convoy on Canadian politics.
00:05:18 This was the movement that, while there were other things going on, was really what led to the ouster of Aaron O'Toole, the ushering in of Pierre Polyev, a guy who I know people can make any number of criticisms about how he and the Conservatives handled the COVID era.
00:05:33 But Polyev himself was, at least in those early days, a very clear supporter of the convoy's aims.
00:05:40 Now, since then, he's equivocated a little bit on the specifics, like, for example, when he told me in an interview that he thought it would have been better if they didn't bring trucks, to which I'd say, well, then you wouldn't have had a Freedom Convoy.
00:05:53 But here we have the state trying to lay at Tamara Leach's and Chris Barber's feet the humiliation and shame that the state endured because of the Freedom Convoy, the humiliation and shame that Justin Trudeau endured because of the Freedom Convoy.
00:06:08 These were the people that held a mirror up to the status and authoritarians, the people who held the mirror up to those who gave into fear and those who exacted control over every single person in this country, down to what you put on your face, to how you run your business, to if you can run your business, and yes, to what you put in your body.
00:06:28 That was what the Freedom Convoy did.
00:06:30 And what was interesting is that this protest, which began in a fight against mandates, a
00:06:36 fight against vaccine mandates and vaccine passports, morphed into something far greater.
00:06:42 As I remarked in a column at the end of the Freedom Convoy's time in Ottawa, and I have
00:06:46 quoted myself, nothing more insufferable than someone who quotes themselves, but I get like
00:06:50 one good line a year.
00:06:51 So I like to milk it for a little bit.
00:06:53 The quote that I am going to remind you of is when I said that the Freedom Convoy showed the lengths through which those who hate freedom will go to stop it.
00:07:04 And the Freedom Convoy's great victory, I don't think, was it vanquishing COVID mandates, because let's be real, it didn't.
00:07:10 Many of the COVID mandates, in fact, most of them in Canada, outlasted the Freedom Convoy.
00:07:15 Now, whether the convoy set a precedent by which any other statist would be very careful
00:07:20 and very cautious about putting these mandates forward in the future, I think, is a completely
00:07:25 fair discussion to have.
00:07:27 But what the Freedom Convoy did is reveal, reveal in a very legitimate way.
00:07:34 Well, illegitimate, but I mean legitimate in the sense of it was useful.
00:07:38 It revealed in a very useful way exactly what people like Justin Trudeau and Christopher
00:07:43 Freeland will do when they feel their narrative is threatened. I'm talking, of course, about
00:07:48 the Emergencies Act, which moved the discussion about the Freedom Convoy into entirely different
00:07:53 territory. Remember, when the Emergencies Act came into play, even people who didn't like the
00:07:58 protest started to say, OK, well, hang on. No, I didn't want to go that far with it. But right now,
00:08:03 the government has claimed exoneration on the Emergencies Act because they were exonerated in
00:08:09 some way by the commission, the Public Order Emergency Commission. Well, many of those who
00:08:15 have been charged with COVID offenses have had their charges quietly dropped. The prosecution
00:08:20 against Tamara and Chris has persisted and is continuing now, has just started this morning
00:08:26 in Ottawa. And while there are going to be a number of challenges still yet to come, and we'll talk
00:08:31 about some of those this week. Challenges against the Emergencies Act that will go through various
00:08:36 levels of court, continued appeals of other charges, generally speaking, the courts have
00:08:41 sided with the government on pretty much every substantive COVID challenge that's been put
00:08:46 before them. Even when there has been a clear and undeniable breach of the Constitution,
00:08:51 the measures that the governments have imposed have been saved by Section 1 of the Charter,
00:08:56 which is to say the court has found that, yeah, you may have breached people's rights,
00:08:59 but you were reasonable in doing so to crudely paraphrase section one of the Canadian Charter
00:09:06 of Rights and Freedoms, a document which is tremendously powerful, but only when you have
00:09:11 institutions that decide to be bound and governed by it. So I'm keeping an eye on what's happening
00:09:17 in Ottawa right now as being one of the last real stands that the Freedom Convoy is able to make in
00:09:23 court. Criminal law is a very, very high bar. There's a very high bar to be found guilty of
00:09:29 having committed a crime. It's not just the balance of probabilities. There's no section one
00:09:34 that we can see invoked here. It is about, did these people do what the government said they did
00:09:40 and were those actions criminal? I want to welcome into the show here, John Carpe,
00:09:44 who is the president of the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms. Now the JCCF
00:09:49 is representing Chris Barber, one of the co-defendants. And I should also say, by way of
00:09:55 disclosure, I sit on the board of the JCCF, although that has no bearing in this interview
00:09:59 I'm doing today. John, it's good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today.
00:10:04 Glad to be with you, Andrew.
00:10:05 So let's start off by talking about this in the broader context there. I tried to lay it out as
00:10:11 best as I could. This is really the big criminal case that we will see coming out of the COVID era
00:10:17 and more specifically out of the convoy here.
00:10:20 And when you look at the charges,
00:10:21 it's really not clear to me as a non-lawyer
00:10:24 and perhaps it's clearer to you as a lawyer
00:10:26 what the criminality of this is.
00:10:30 Well, this is something that, you know,
00:10:31 we can get caught up in all the excitement and intrigue
00:10:34 and what is the opening statement
00:10:36 of the Crown prosecutor and the Crown's position.
00:10:40 And of course, it's fascinating and thrilling and interesting,
00:10:43 but we must not lose sight of the fact
00:10:44 that this is outrageous that any criminal charges were brought in the first place.
00:10:50 The federal government, Ontario government, the city of Ottawa,
00:10:54 municipal government had ample law enforcement options,
00:10:59 which they did not use.
00:11:02 And we probably don't have time to get into all of them,
00:11:05 but just a few examples, parking tickets,
00:11:08 toying trucks that were illegally parked,
00:11:10 issuing fines and tickets for for municipal offenses for having a an assembly without a
00:11:20 permit there's all kinds of law enforcement and the national emergency support is supposed to
00:11:26 exist under the legislation only if other law enforcement mechanisms are not able to
00:11:33 deal with the situation what we had a year and seven months ago was a peaceful protest that was
00:11:40 certainly causing inconvenience to people living in uh in downtown ottawa and but the regular law
00:11:47 enforcement was not used not applied uh the local police uh and you would know more about this you
00:11:52 wrote a book on it andrew but the local police uh at a local level were in harmony with you know
00:11:59 dialogue conversations communications with protesters police were telling them where to
00:12:04 park their trucks anyway the point is this it's outrageous that criminal charges were brought
00:12:09 against Canadians for doing nothing other than peacefully exercising their charter freedoms of
00:12:15 expression, association, and peaceful assembly. One thing that I find interesting on that note
00:12:21 is that Tamara and Chris, whatever people think of the charges that they had laid against them,
00:12:26 they were not even charged under the Emergency SAC. They weren't even charged under that
00:12:30 authority. They were charged under the Criminal Code of Canada, which I think supports your point
00:12:34 that there was an existing authority
00:12:37 available to law enforcement
00:12:38 when these charges were applied.
00:12:41 Yeah, and then when you look at the heart of it,
00:12:44 well, you look at the mischief charges.
00:12:45 Mischief in the criminal code, section 430,
00:12:49 there's four different heads of it.
00:12:52 One of them is to vandalize or damage property.
00:12:55 That's one form of mischief.
00:12:56 Another one is to interfere with the lawful use
00:13:01 and enjoyment of property.
00:13:03 And on that note, I suppose that if you park your vehicle illegally, it's still quite a stretch to say that you're lawfully interfering with the use and enjoyment of property.
00:13:21 So to have moved that on to a level of a criminal accusation is just reprehensible.
00:13:28 it's also reprehensible that Tamara Leach spent a total of 49 days in jail in respect of a criminal
00:13:34 charge that if she is convicted which she should not be she's entirely innocent but if she is
00:13:39 convicted she's not going to be spending any time in jail after conviction yet she spent 49 days in
00:13:46 jail yeah and I look at that and I see just a I mean the weirdest thing about that is that Tamara
00:13:54 Leach of the two and I'm not saying that what she went through Chris should have gone through
00:13:57 But of the two, she didn't even have a truck. So I mean, her right to protest is as defensible as
00:14:04 it gets, because all of the disruptions that the critics of the convoy brought up had to do with
00:14:09 vehicles, whereas she rode up there, rode shotgun with Chris Barber on the way there. Now, again,
00:14:14 I'm not saying that the charges against Chris are any more reasonable, but it's strange that
00:14:19 she has become the focal point of the state's ire. And I think, you know, ultimately, if I'm
00:14:24 to try to understand why that is it was because she was the focal point as being the inspirational
00:14:29 force of the convoy so uh she is the the head of the snake to the government if you will and they 0.98
00:14:34 think that they can make an example of her it seems but that i mean that may be fine if you're
00:14:39 trying to craft a plot or a narrative but that's not the way the law works well what's also
00:14:44 disconcerting is the blatant double standard uh when we had aboriginal uh protesters i don't know
00:14:50 they're aboriginals or environmentalists or both but this was in march of 2020 and they were
00:14:55 blockading railway lines it was costing millions of dollars in damage and the prime minister's
00:15:02 public statement was that he would like to sit down and meet with them and there are no criminal
00:15:06 charges and there could have been uh based on the fact that that there was a definitely a
00:15:13 interference in the lawful use lawful enjoyment of property when you get into a physical blockade
00:15:19 and you blockade uh you stop trains from moving goods and you have perishable goods that are
00:15:24 rotting you're causing millions of dollars of damage arguably that could have been a
00:15:28 time for criminal charges and yet the prime minister says oh he wants to sit down and
00:15:32 meet with these people um it's the same double standard we saw with with covid if you were
00:15:38 uh you might remember uh queens park doug ford denounced anti-lockdown protesters as a bunch of 0.99
00:15:45 reckless idiots who are endangering everybody's lives no you got to quote him directly john a 0.99
00:15:49 bunch of yahoos that was the line a bunch of yahoos and then and then not long thereafter 1.00
00:15:55 when people are marching in the streets uh against uh racism all of a sudden uh trudeau and ford and
00:16:04 the chief medical officers nobody will denounce a protest against racism which almost makes you
00:16:09 you think, is COVID a political virus that knows that if it's a good cause, it's not going to
00:16:15 spread amongst people. But if it's a really bad cause, like protesting against lockdowns,
00:16:19 it's going to spread. So this is really disconcerting that you have Chris Barber,
00:16:23 Tamara Leach, and many, many other Canadians as well. These happen to be the most famous,
00:16:29 who are criminally charged. When you have another example, the Crown prosecutors in Manitoba
00:16:36 ignored the destruction of a statue of Queen Victoria, which was torn down July 2021.
00:16:45 It's a good thing nobody got hurt. The thing weighs a ton or more. And they topple this statue,
00:16:51 destroy a statue in full public view with police watching. That is criminal activity. No charges
00:16:57 laid. We've seen in the last few months in particular, I mean, long after COVID and the
00:17:03 convoy, we've seen a huge number of stories across the country of, in many cases, violent offenders
00:17:10 that have been released on bail, are rearrested, are released again. We've seen a lot more of a
00:17:16 discussion in the political context about this. I know Conservative leader Pierre Polyev has been
00:17:20 talking about it. I know a lot of provincial governments have. And it really brings around
00:17:24 the point. I mean, you mentioned how long Tamara spent behind bars. Chris was a little bit more
00:17:28 fortunate with his bail conditions. But even so, there have been violent offenders that have had
00:17:34 an easier time staying out of jail than Tamara Leach has. Which makes us a banana republic with 1.00
00:17:40 polar bears. You know, we used to look down our noses at countries where if you criticize the
00:17:47 president or the prime minister, the next day you would suddenly find yourself charged with
00:17:51 fraud or rape or murder or embezzlement or theft, and you'd be in prison. And of course,
00:17:59 everybody knows, well, it's because you criticize the prime minister that you're now suddenly facing
00:18:03 these trumped up criminal charges. And this is what we've descended to in Canada, where
00:18:08 the blatant, willful criminal activity of destroying a statue of Queen Victoria
00:18:13 in Winnipeg in July of 2021, condoned by the police, condoned by the Crown. You've got criminal
00:18:22 conduct by people protesting for the environment and or Aboriginal rights. And there's just that
00:18:29 double standard. But if you speak out against the Prime Minister and the lockdown measures,
00:18:34 you can expect to be criminally charged. It is so nakedly political. And it's very sad that
00:18:41 our country has descended to this point. I know you're not litigating in this particular case,
00:18:48 but are you able to offer any bit of a roadmap for the audience, John, as to the process here?
00:18:53 It's a 16-day trial. I've been following bits and pieces on Twitter today, and I see they're
00:18:58 talking about evidence, and both sides are entering a bit. But what's the roadmap this
00:19:03 is going to follow here? So after the trial is over, in about 99.9% of cases, the judge
00:19:11 will reserve judgment. So the judgment will be forthcoming in what I would predict would be
00:19:17 months, not weeks. If it's a short, simple trial, you know, somebody's accused of shoplifting and
00:19:21 whatever, right? You might get a judgment in a few days or a week or two. I would not be surprised
00:19:28 if it took three, four, five, six months for the judge to sift through all the evidence and write
00:19:36 judgment so we're going to get a conviction or an acquittal in in several months time and
00:19:43 the justice center's involvement is this in this is that we are providing for the
00:19:49 criminal defense for for chris barber and we're also defending tamara leach in a civil action
00:19:57 that has been launched by um ottawa residents actually lee who's suing for 300 million dollars
00:20:04 over losing some sleep due to horn honking at night.
00:20:09 Well, well described, sir.
00:20:12 Let me, I mean, you mentioned the shoplifting case
00:20:14 and let me like bring the shoplifting example
00:20:17 because this is a very simple crime
00:20:19 that people can understand,
00:20:21 which is, you know, a guy is charged
00:20:22 for going into a store,
00:20:24 putting a chocolate bar in his pocket and walking out.
00:20:27 And when you are charged with that,
00:20:28 you basically have, as I understand it,
00:20:30 three real defenses.
00:20:31 You can say, well, actually, no, that wasn't me.
00:20:33 that was someone else entirely that did that. You can say that was me, but I never actually put the
00:20:37 chocolate bar in my pocket. I walked in with a chocolate bar, I looked at it, and I put it back
00:20:41 in and left. And then you get into, you know, I was not, you know, particularly mentally sound at
00:20:46 the time, and I'm not criminally responsible. But, you know, pretty clear, easily understood
00:20:51 defenses there. Either someone else did it, or no, that was me, but I didn't really do it. In this
00:20:56 case, it's something far more complex. There is no, you know, surveillance footage of the chocolate
00:21:00 bar going into a pocket that we can really hinge on here. So what is the defense? Is the defense
00:21:05 that, you know, yes, I did all the things you're saying I did, but they aren't criminal?
00:21:12 Well, to answer it in a roundabout way, what the Crown needs to prove is the mens rea,
00:21:18 which is the guilty mind and the actus reus. So they have to establish, let's pick Chris
00:21:24 Barber as, as one of the two examples, they have to establish that Chris Barber, um, interfered
00:21:30 with the lawful use and enjoyment of property, uh, as set out in section 430, if it's an
00:21:37 obstruction charge, uh, that he actually interfered with the police carrying on their duties.
00:21:44 So they have to, uh, prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Chris Barber did the criminal act.
00:21:51 that depends on how does the wording of the criminal code match up with the reality? Did
00:21:55 he actually do that? If he parked his truck illegally, I don't know if he did or not.
00:22:02 In my view, if he did, he should have just gotten a parking ticket. But was the illegal
00:22:08 parking of the truck if it was illegally parked? Does that constitute criminal conduct? And then
00:22:14 the second, the mens rea, the mental component to be found guilty is that you intended to
00:22:22 lawfully interfere with the lawful use and enjoyment of property. There has to be an
00:22:30 intention there in your mind to commit the crime. Both of those have to be proved beyond a reasonable
00:22:36 doubt and so uh to me it seems the crown has an uphill fight uh if if the judge is is unbiased
00:22:45 and fair-minded and does not want to engage in you know virtue signaling towards the the
00:22:50 the political establishment um every reason to assume that that this judge is is fair-minded
00:22:56 and independent i think the crown has uh an uphill fight is there a constitutional protection for i
00:23:04 I guess what people on the left often call civil disobedience,
00:23:07 where is there a constitutional protection for,
00:23:09 yes, maybe this wasn't exactly following the letter of the law,
00:23:13 but I was doing it because it was a form of political expression,
00:23:16 which is protected under the Constitution, at least in theory.
00:23:20 Short answer is no.
00:23:21 The way that civil disobedience is supposed to function in theory
00:23:25 is that people are willing to break a law,
00:23:29 which they sincerely believe to be unjust,
00:23:31 and thereafter they're willing to accept the consequences uh give you sort of an easy example
00:23:37 that a lot of people could relate to uh you've got bubble zone legislation around abortion clinics 0.95
00:23:42 that in most provinces to my knowledge it's illegal uh as a provincial offense not criminal
00:23:49 but it's it's illegal to protest within whatever 10 feet or 100 feet of an abortion clinic even if
00:23:57 the protest is entirely peaceful. And so it's illegal. Now, civil disobedience would mean that
00:24:02 somebody says, I know that I'm committing an offense against a provincial law. I'm going to
00:24:09 do it anyway. I'm going to get arrested. I'm going to be found guilty. And I'm going to suffer the
00:24:12 consequences of a fine or jail time as a part of a deliberate effort to expose how unjust this law
00:24:19 is. So that's civil disobedience in a nutshell. It's deliberate disobedience with a willingness
00:24:26 to accept the consequences for the purpose of exposing the unjust law, but it is not a loophole
00:24:32 in the criminal process. So the criminal process is still the same. Did you do it? Did you intend
00:24:37 to do it? And why you did it, you know, if it was because of sincere, deeply held, profound
00:24:45 convictions, that's neither here nor there. But again, I'm curious, and I'm glad you answered
00:24:50 that question. I also want to distinguish that from what we're talking about here, because in
00:24:54 this case we do have a real disagreement between the crown and the defense as whether a law was
00:25:00 even broken well the you know speaking of civil disobedience another example of disobedience
00:25:06 would be for truckers to illegally park their trucks with the knowledge that they're going to
00:25:10 get ticket after ticket after ticket because if you don't move it after an hour or two i think
00:25:14 the municipal authorities are entitled to come back and give you another ticket again right they're
00:25:18 not limited to one a day and so the civil disobedience that i think that the truckers
00:25:23 were willing to engage in just if i can jump in on there too and i would say beyond that to tow it
00:25:27 but the reason the cities didn't tow the trucks was because of their own uh bureaucratic incompetence
00:25:32 because they couldn't find tow truck drivers willing to do it so uh that's again they had that
00:25:36 tool available to them the other component at least for some of the trucks is that the police
00:25:41 told the truckers where to park their trucks yeah and so some trucks were illegally parked but it
00:25:47 was with the knowledge and consent of the police which then throws into whole throws into question
00:25:52 completely how illegal was it when you've got police giving you a green light on it.
00:25:59 Yeah, very, very well said. I mean, obviously, we're going to follow this along here. I saw one
00:26:04 report from within the courtroom today that Tamara has been restricted from being unaccompanied in
00:26:10 downtown Ottawa. She had to get judicial permission to go and get, I said a sandwich on Twitter, 0.56
00:26:19 I don't know if she got a sandwich or a bowl of soup or a wrap or a pina colada.
00:26:24 I don't know what it was.
00:26:24 But she had to get judicial permission to go and get lunch in downtown Ottawa without her lawyer.
00:26:30 Now, I don't know if any of this is standard practice in criminal proceedings.
00:26:34 I mean, the big challenge that I see here is that it's very difficult.
00:26:38 And I'm not making a swipe at the judge herself. 0.78
00:26:41 I don't know the judge, and I have no reason to suspect she's biased.
00:26:44 But this is really at stake in the Freedom Convoy cases.
00:26:49 are these dueling narratives of the downtown Ottawa resident experience versus everyone else
00:26:56 in the country's experience, I'd say. And it's very difficult to separate a judge who lives in
00:27:02 Ottawa from an Ottawa resident. And this was a challenge in one of Tamara's bail hearings,
00:27:07 where you had a judge who, as she was throwing Tamara in the slammer, referred to our city. 0.94
00:27:12 this is the this is what makes the job of a judge very difficult and very demanding because a judge
00:27:20 is expected to uh to rise above it uh you take for example uh let's say that somebody in
00:27:27 saskatchewan is is accused of of murder and is going to be tried in saskatchewan even if the
00:27:32 judge doesn't live in the same city where the alleged crime took place there's going to be
00:27:36 media coverage. And so judges are expected as a job requirement to separate themselves as much as
00:27:44 possible to disregard the media coverage and to look only at the facts that are placed before the
00:27:52 court. Now, I think in a murder trial, that might be a little bit easier because you can just
00:27:57 disregard the media coverage. The judge can disregard media coverage as advisable in many
00:28:02 It's advisable. In Ottawa, it could be for this particular trial, it could be more difficult if
00:28:09 the judge was personally inconvenienced because she couldn't make it to a medical appointment on 1.00
00:28:14 a given day because there were a lot of trucks parked illegally in downtown Ottawa. If that was
00:28:20 the case, again, entirely hypothetical, she would have to detach from that and just kind of say,
00:28:25 okay, well, I'm going to put that on the back burner that I was late for an appointment because
00:28:28 of the truckers and just focus exclusively on the evidence that is presented before her in the
00:28:34 courtroom. It's a very difficult job and I wish her well as she evaluates the evidence. All right.
00:28:42 Well, we will definitely keep an eye on this. John Carbet, president of the Justice Center for
00:28:46 Constitutional Freedom. It's always a pleasure, John. Thanks for coming on. Thank you, Andrew.
00:28:50 Have a great rest of the day. All right. Thank you. And again, I'm not holding back from people
00:28:54 the details of the case.
00:28:56 Right now, there hasn't actually been
00:28:57 too, too much in the way of detail,
00:28:59 but we are going to follow this along.
00:29:02 And I'll point out,
00:29:03 there was one tweet I saw earlier.
00:29:05 I want to bring this up again,
00:29:06 if I can find it.
00:29:08 This was a tweet from Robert Kraychik,
00:29:11 who is with Rebel News,
00:29:12 and he's there in Ottawa.
00:29:14 And oh, we even have the tweet.
00:29:15 Okay, great.
00:29:16 I just flagged it for my own reference,
00:29:18 but good on you, Sean.
00:29:20 Tamara Leach's defense attorneys 0.99
00:29:21 both object to the Crown's derisive description of the Freedom Convoy as an occupation of downtown
00:29:28 Ottawa. And Lawrence Greenspun, who is the criminal defense lawyer working with Tamara Leach, he
00:29:34 actually just spoke with reporters outside the courthouse a little while ago. I saw a clip of
00:29:40 that on Twitter, which that one I didn't tell Sean about. So if he doesn't have the clip, that one's
00:29:44 not on him. That's on me. But he was asked and he said, look, we've got, you know, Russia occupying
00:29:48 Ukraine right now, let's not, you know, diminish the word of the word occupation to this protest
00:29:54 in Ottawa. But I wanted to bring this up, because it shows how language matters. Because if you had
00:30:01 a judge that were to say, just nonchalantly, oh, yes, the, you know, the occupation in Ottawa,
00:30:05 well, that's going to impart a little bit of bias there. So the crown is trying to use that word
00:30:11 defense is saying, no, no, no, you're not going to get away with using that word. Now, in the end,
00:30:14 both sides are going to describe this protest the way they want to.
00:30:18 What I can say is that I would be very, very, very nervous
00:30:21 if I were Tamara Leach's attorney or Chris Barber's attorney,
00:30:25 which would be really bad for them because I'm not an attorney.
00:30:28 But if I were to be the attorney for either of them,
00:30:31 I would not want a jury trial on this, just given the pool from which,
00:30:34 I mean, it would be like nine civil servants or something like that.
00:30:38 But in any case, not nine, no, 12.
00:30:40 Why am I shrinking the size of a jury?
00:30:42 It'll be 10 civil servants and two non-civil servants or something.
00:30:45 I had to get to 12.
00:30:46 I was thinking of the Supreme Court, so my numbers were all wrong there.
00:30:50 Actually, it's six for civil, if I'm not mistaken, but 12 for criminal.
00:30:54 So Sean's saying 12 angry men.
00:30:56 That's the way he remembers.
00:30:58 Yeah, but if you got 12 angry men on the jury, it's probably good for the crown.
00:31:02 We are going to talk about this more tomorrow with Eva Chipiak, another lawyer.
00:31:06 We also have on Friday a full-length interview with Tom Marazzo,
00:31:10 a repeat guest on this show
00:31:12 and also a gentleman who is writing
00:31:14 or has written a book
00:31:15 which is coming out tomorrow about the convoy
00:31:18 but before we wrap things up today
00:31:20 it is back to school time
00:31:21 I do not have children
00:31:22 and it's been a great many years
00:31:24 since I have gone back to school
00:31:25 but all of my friends with kids
00:31:27 have been sharing their photographs
00:31:29 of their kids going to like
00:31:31 grade one and two and nine
00:31:33 and 14 in one person's case
00:31:35 but that was a special case
00:31:36 but we also have a little bit
00:31:39 of an odd dilemma in that we can talk about all the weird things that happen in schools. But for
00:31:46 the most part, I think kids, when they go into school, probably have a pretty narrow set of
00:31:50 interests. They're thinking, OK, I don't want to be back in school. I'd rather be away for the
00:31:55 summer again. OK, I'll get to see my friends. And, you know, maybe there's a teacher I like or a
00:32:00 particular class I like. I don't buy into Global News's version of things, though. Global ran this
00:32:07 story that purportedly says Canadian students are kicking off the new school year with climate change
00:32:14 and AI top of mind. Climate change and AI top of mind. Now, I found this to be odd. Now, it's not
00:32:22 a global article. It's a Canadian press article. So I'll share my scorn for CP. But I was thinking
00:32:27 of this and then I was reading the article and I was expecting, okay, maybe they found like, you
00:32:31 know, three or four woke students that are saying, wow, you know, I really hope I learn more about
00:32:34 climate change. So do we have the text of the article, Sean? We do. See, Sean, you're getting
00:32:40 your bonus today. The article actually says nothing to support what the article is about.
00:32:47 It says, many students are likely feeling a mixture of nerves and excitement as they begin
00:32:52 another school year. And then there's a paragraph that says, with disruptive pandemic measures
00:32:57 seemingly behind them, parents and educators say a new crop of issues may affect classroom learning
00:33:02 this year, including AI technology, affordability, and climate change. Then there's a paragraph about
00:33:07 wildfires. Then there's a paragraph about BC saying no schools were damaged by wildfires,
00:33:13 but students will still be affected. And then there are a few more paragraphs about like nothing
00:33:18 to do with anything. So nowhere in this story do they quote a parent, a teacher, a student,
00:33:24 a study, an expert, or anything that suggests there is at all any, any support for the fact
00:33:32 that students are somehow paranoid or nervous or top of mind for them is climate change or AI.
00:33:40 So it's a great example of the media just literally manufacturing a story that has no
00:33:45 bearing in reality. But that is not all. Global News has been going for the big award this week.
00:33:51 I don't know what the award is. We'll have to come up with an award. Maybe we'll bring back
00:33:54 Fake News Friday or something. But there was another one here that was talking about New
00:33:59 Brunswick parents worrying of bullying at school because of changes to the gender identity policy.
00:34:05 Now, this is the New Brunswick policy that basically says if you are under 16 and you
00:34:10 want to change your gender at school, a parent needs to consent to it. This is a very popular 1.00
00:34:15 story, a very popular policy. Parents around the country agree with it. It really is quite modest.
00:34:21 It doesn't out trans students to their parents at all.
00:34:23 It just says they need to provide parental consent.
00:34:27 And if they're not comfortable talking to their parents,
00:34:28 the school will let someone help them out with that.
00:34:31 But you read the article and it is two parents that are in it.
00:34:36 And they don't even quote the parents, by the way.
00:34:38 Sean and Amanda Rouse, parents of a transgender teen in,
00:34:42 I'm not even, I'm going to try to say it.
00:34:45 If you're in New Brunswick, please let me know how wrong I've gotten it.
00:34:48 Quis Pamsis, Kipemzi, I don't actually have any idea. 0.99
00:34:52 So we'll say Q, Q New Brunswick.
00:34:55 Now I'm actually going to look this up later.
00:34:58 Can't you just do like Dildo Newfoundland?
00:35:00 I can say that.
00:35:01 But Amanda Rouse says her 14 year old
00:35:03 has been called slurs and told to kill herself. 0.72
00:35:05 She says the bullying is a heavy burden for her child
00:35:08 and expects it to continue
00:35:10 as schools reopen from summer break.
00:35:12 I think that it is horrible
00:35:14 that the Rouse's child has been subjected to bullying.
00:35:18 I think bullying is terrible, I think it is hurtful, whether it is because someone is
00:35:23 trans or gay or of a particular race or, in my case, fat, that is completely wrong and 1.00
00:35:29 can be very harmful to children.
00:35:31 But I would be remiss to not point out that that has nothing to do with the policy in
00:35:37 New Brunswick at all, because as the mother acknowledges, this bullying predated the change
00:35:43 in the New Brunswick gender policy for schools.
00:35:46 It predated it because this has been a persistent problem.
00:35:49 So the fact that this policy, which doesn't even affect the child referenced in this story,
00:35:55 because there is parental consent, means that it is just fear-mongering
00:35:59 and using children going through whatever they're going through as political pawns.
00:36:03 And the media bought it up.
00:36:05 And what do you know? Not Global News, Canadian Press again after all.
00:36:07 So CP is serving them up. Canadian Press is eating them off the platter.
00:36:12 And we're all supposed to go along with it,
00:36:13 that this is just the shabby journalism
00:36:15 that we're having foisted upon us.
00:36:17 So that does it for us for today.
00:36:19 We'll be back tomorrow
00:36:20 with more of The Andrew Lawton Show
00:36:21 here on True North.
00:36:23 Thank you, God bless,
00:36:24 and good day to you all.
00:36:26 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:36:28 Support the program by donating to True North
00:36:30 at www.tnc.news.
00:36:43 We'll be right back.
00:37:13 We'll be right back.