Juno News - October 26, 2019


Tax dollars fund "Muslim voting guide"

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Trudeau's re-election unleashes western alienation Trudeau's olive branch to the west?

Episode Stats


Length

6 minutes

Words per minute

154.87

Word count

987

Sentence count

60

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A new report from the Islamophobia Industry Research Project at Wilfrid Laurier University gives the major parties in Canada a grade on issues that the report contends are relevant to the Muslim community: Islamophobia, boycott, divestment, sanctions, broader foreign policy, immigration and refugees, and religious freedom in Quebec. And if you look at the final scorecard, the leaders of the right-of-center parties, Andrew Scheer and Maxime Bernier, did not fare well.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Canadians, your tax dollars went towards telling Muslims not to vote for Conservatives. 0.51
00:00:16 This sounds baffling, and the reason for that is very simple.
00:00:20 It is baffling.
00:00:21 The federal government gave a grant to a group of researchers at Wilfrid Laurier University
00:00:26 to publish a report specifically to guide and steer the votes of Muslim Canadians.
00:00:33 The report, published by Wilfrid Laurier University, has a very simple mandate,
00:00:39 Canadian Muslim Voting Guide Federal Election 2019.
00:00:43 In the guide, which was prepared by a specific Islamophobia industry research project at Laurier University
00:00:51 and funded by the government, we'll get back to that in a moment,
00:00:54 was there to give politicians, the leaders of the major parties in Canada,
00:00:58 grades on issues that the report contends are relevant to the Muslim community.
00:01:04 These issues are Islamophobia, boycott divestment sanctions, broader foreign policy,
00:01:10 immigration and refugees, religious freedom in Quebec.
00:01:13 And if you look at the final scorecard, the leaders of the right-of-center parties,
00:01:17 Andrew Scheer and Maxime Bernier, didn't fare too well.
00:01:21 Just take a look at those. An entire row of fails for Maxime Bernier on every issue.
00:01:26 Almost an entire row of fails for Andrew Scheer.
00:01:30 He got one needs improvement on religious freedom.
00:01:33 No one did well on that category, as you can see.
00:01:36 And what do you know?
00:01:37 Green lights for Jagmeet Singh, green lights for Elizabeth May,
00:01:40 and a combination of green and orange for Justin Trudeau.
00:01:46 Now, when you go through the point of it, there are a number of issues here.
00:01:49 Incomplete research, conclusions drawn about not only how the Muslim community,
00:01:54 which is not monolithic, thinks about certain things,
00:01:57 but also shoddy research on a lot of the positions that the party leaders have actually taken.
00:02:03 They've distilled down into these five different areas what are more broadly disagreements.
00:02:08 But if you think the wrong thing, according to this report, it's a fail.
00:02:12 One of the most egregious examples of that is boycott divestment sanctions.
00:02:16 The report accepts as a premise that BDS against Israel is a good thing. 0.98
00:02:22 And anyone who criticizes or condemns BDS therefore gets a failing grade.
00:02:28 So anyone that says, hey, BDS is unfair to Israelis and Jews, they get a fail just for that.
00:02:34 And if you look at the premise of the report as it lists its purpose,
00:02:37 it actually blames far-right Christians and Zionists for peddling Islamophobia.
00:02:43 This is the basis of this report.
00:02:46 Now, this shouldn't be a surprise that a group of academics got together and decided to
00:02:51 write out a bunch of mumbo-jumbo and start calling people racist and Islamophobes.
00:02:55 But again, the most significant part of this report is on its cover page.
00:03:00 More than any of the substance in the report, this is the big red flag for me.
00:03:06 Literally, the red flag, the Canadian flag on this report.
00:03:10 As you can see there, made possible by a grant from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada.
00:03:19 Yes.
00:03:20 Now, what's interesting is that this initiative at Laurier University,
00:03:24 the Islamophobia Industry Research Project,
00:03:27 which again is trying to say that it is there to dismantle the industry of Islamophobes that exists in the country,
00:03:33 is something that partners with the National Council of Canadian Muslims.
00:03:37 But take a look at the rationale for why this project exists in the first place.
00:03:43 The website says that the study supports M103 through its objectives to analyze, document,
00:03:50 and map the Islamophobia industry in Canada.
00:03:54 The Islamophobia industry perpetuates fear and negative stereotypes about Islam and Muslims,
00:03:59 leading to hate, violence, and discrimination.
00:04:01 It is comprised of media outlets, political figures, academics, think tanks, far-right groups and ideologues,
00:04:09 and the donors who fund their campaigns.
00:04:12 These individuals, groups, and institutions comprise a network that supports and engages in activities
00:04:19 that demonize and marginalize Islam and Muslims in Canada.
00:04:23 So this is something that is basically telling Canadians, we're all racists, we're all Islamophobe.
00:04:30 The media, academics, think tanks, we're all part of this problem.
00:04:33 But even if there is a research initiative, there's a difference between researching something
00:04:38 and telling people how to vote.
00:04:41 This study was done because of M103, the anti-Islamophobia motion that when it passed,
00:04:47 and people like me were saying it would threaten free speech, we were told,
00:04:51 no, no, no, you're just being crazy. 0.52
00:04:52 It says non-binding. 0.93
00:04:54 It's symbolic.
00:04:55 Well, now that symbolic and non-binding motion is justifying tax dollars going towards telling people
00:05:02 how to vote, and specifically telling them not to vote for conservative parties.
00:05:07 Now, we don't know what the impact of this was in the election, and we never will.
00:05:11 People get to make up their minds based on whatever criteria they'd like.
00:05:15 But this is egregious that tax money is going towards peddling identity politics
00:05:19 for a specific partisan outcome.
00:05:23 Now, I tweeted about this as soon as I learned it, and a Conservative member of Parliament,
00:05:27 Karen Vecchio, had tweeted out her condemnation in response.
00:05:31 She says the government should never have funded a guide like this.
00:05:34 It's partisan and not in the best interest of all Canadians.
00:05:38 Pits Canadians against Canadians. 0.73
00:05:40 Stop with the identity politics, she says.
00:05:42 B'nai B'rith has also come out and condemned specifically the BDS component.
00:05:47 This government-funded report contending that BDS is a good thing, 1.00
00:05:51 and anyone who disagrees with it is peddling Islamophobia.
00:05:55 But this is what we're up against in Canada,
00:05:57 which is why it's so important to stop identity politics.
00:06:00 When you have a resolution like M103 being put forward,
00:06:04 remember it is never benign.
00:06:06 This is what it leads to.
00:06:07 If you can support True North's efforts to stand up and fight back against identity politics,
00:06:13 push back against this, and fight for free speech,
00:06:15 do head on over to tnc.news and make a contribution to support our efforts.
00:06:20 For True North, I'm Andrew Lutton.
00:06:22 Thank you.