Juno News - May 19, 2023


The Alberta Leaders’ Debate 2023

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Is Canada trying to ELIMINATE the Homeless? Danielle Smith’s Debate Knockout

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 32 minutes

Words per minute

191.71

Word count

29,255

Sentence count

1,135

Harmful content

Misogyny

94

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The first and only Alberta election debate featuring the two major party leaders, Rachel Notley and Danielle Smith, is taking place in Calgary on Wednesday evening. In this special edition of the True North podcast, hosts Andrew Lawton, Rachel Emanuel, and William MacBeth and Rachel's colleague, Rachel Eichenauer, discuss what to look out for in the premier's debate.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Hello, everyone, and welcome to you all.
00:01:19 This is a True North special broadcast.
00:01:22 I'm Andrew Lawton.
00:01:23 We are here for the first and only leaders debate of the Alberta election.
00:01:28 It would not be an Alberta panel without some tremendous Alberta correspondents.
00:01:33 We have our True North colleagues, William Macbeth and Rachel Emanuel here.
00:01:38 It is going to be an exciting night and it's good to have both of you here with us.
00:01:41 Welcome.
00:01:42 Yeah, thanks, Andrew.
00:01:43 Looking forward to it.
00:01:44 It's been a busy week, so I'm sure we'll have lots to discuss.
00:01:48 We have obviously had some coverage of the Alberta election on my show, on True North, on Rachel's show.
00:01:55 So, William, you've been slacking. You haven't done any original coverage, but I know you're going to make up for it with your contributions to the discussion this evening.
00:02:02 But let's just talk about the lay of the land here, because the debate is going to be in exactly one hour.
00:02:08 And this will be, as I mentioned, the first and only time that the leaders of the major parties are squaring off.
00:02:14 But the one thing I should say, and this is, I think, especially noteworthy if you have been familiarized with federal leaders debates,
00:02:21 There are just going to be the two leaders here of Rachel Notley and Danielle Smith.
00:02:27 There's not going to be an Alberta Liberal leader, an Alberta Green leader, an Alberta Party leader.
00:02:32 It's just going to be the two.
00:02:34 And I think that will actually change the dynamic a fair bit.
00:02:37 So let's start with that, Rachel.
00:02:39 I mean, these two women have not really squared off outside of the legislature in this forum.
00:02:45 No, I think this is probably the most effective format for people watching
00:02:49 because this is really an election where people especially moderates in calgary which we've seen
00:02:54 both parties seeking to appeal to they're trying to decide do we think that a ndp not ndp government
00:03:00 under rachel notley would be worse for the province or are we more concerned about danielle
00:03:05 smith's record obviously the mainstream media and the alberta ndp have done their best to paint
00:03:10 danielle smith as crazy you know pulling her old podcast clips taking a lot of stuff out of context 1.00
00:03:16 And so that's really what the election has turned into for a lot of people.
00:03:19 It's a pretty simple ballot box question.
00:03:21 So we're definitely going to see Danielle Smith attempting to just stay on track, get 1.00
00:03:25 her message, not say anything to rile anyone up.
00:03:28 She's the better debater of the two of them.
00:03:30 She's really strong on public policy.
00:03:33 Rachel Notley hasn't been strong on policy during this issue.
00:03:36 She's throwing a lot of slander around, a lot of lies. 1.00
00:03:39 Danielle Smith is going to be right there, able to call her out on that.
00:03:42 So I'm really interested to see how this plays out.
00:03:43 I think a lot of it will depend on the questions that they're asked.
00:03:47 Sometimes these debates can be so tedious when the questions are irrelevant and the format,
00:03:52 how much time they're actually given to debate.
00:03:54 So those are some of the things I'm going to be looking at.
00:03:56 But the fact that it's only the two leaders, I think, is probably the best for Albertans
00:04:00 to decide right now.
00:04:02 Yeah.
00:04:02 And in the 2019 election, which was the previous election, you had four leaders there.
00:04:07 But now, I mean, if you look at the polling, there's basically a near 100% chance that
00:04:12 it's only going to be MLAs from the NDP and the UCP that are elected, and not to get too bogged
00:04:18 down by Alberta political history, but William, how did Alberta become a two-party system in this way?
00:04:24 Yeah, I mean, it is quite interesting. If you look back to 1993, and not to spend too much time on
00:04:31 this, but that was an election where it was the PCs under Ralph Klein versus the Liberal Party
00:04:37 under Lawrence Decor. And Ralph and the PCs won by just a couple percent in that election. It was a
00:04:43 very close election. So to go from that in 1993 to where the Liberals will not win a single seat
00:04:51 in this election, what a sea change in how it's worked in Alberta. And I think the truth is,
00:04:56 is you've seen a consolidation of parties behind the two that are now really contesting the
00:05:01 election. You know, there are some parties on the right, some smaller parties on the right,
00:05:05 but they have seen their support collapse to the UCP.
00:05:08 There are some parties on the left,
00:05:10 but they've been unable to earn any sort of material support.
00:05:14 All of their support's gone to the NDP.
00:05:16 So unlike back in the 90s and 2000s,
00:05:21 where there were three-way elections,
00:05:22 or at least two-and-a-half-way elections,
00:05:24 this is now very much a Republicans versus Democrats type scenario.
00:05:29 You've only got two.
00:05:31 Yeah, and as a result of that,
00:05:32 the NDP in Alberta is not exactly, I mean, this may be a contentious point. It's not exactly like
00:05:38 the NDP you'd see elsewhere. And even on this campaign, Rachel, I mean, Rachel Notley has run
00:05:44 a fairly moderate campaign. I mean, some of the policies she's put forward have really
00:05:48 been things that you wouldn't find uncharacteristic in a conservative platform even.
00:05:54 Well, absolutely. And that's, I think from what I've been hearing, it's caught the United
00:05:57 Conservative Party government a little bit off guard with some of the comments I've heard from
00:06:00 people they're like oh why is Rachel Notley running so to the middle and I think it's because
00:06:04 she doesn't want to scare voters off the economy is just finally back on track after years of the
00:06:09 COVID-19 pandemic we're still in record high inflation but jobs are strong here the economy
00:06:13 is growing and so people don't want to be reminded of what it was like under a Rachel Notley government
00:06:18 when her policies chased investment and chased jobs out of the province so we've been seeing her
00:06:22 appeal to those moderates just as much as Danielle has there's been a lot of parallels between their
00:06:27 campaigns. And so voters are really going to have to look at the policies closely, which often most
00:06:32 voters don't do. There is some people who pay really close attention. Most people just kind of
00:06:35 want a snapshot, a bigger picture. The one policy that we've really seen from Rachel Notley, which
00:06:41 is more in line of what you would think of when you think of the Alberta NDP, is their one promise
00:06:46 that they were going to hike corporate taxes. And we know from assessments that that would chase
00:06:50 jobs out of the province as well. So that's really the one policy we've seen that's very indicative
00:06:55 of an ndp government but on other things she's even been saying that she no longer supports safe
00:07:00 supply things like that thinking that we might have lost our other colleagues here for a minute
00:07:10 i'm not seeing anybody else the ndp federally and i think you know for example we haven't seen
00:07:15 jagmeet singh really pitching in to support rachel notley here have we no we haven't seen jagmeet
00:07:22 Singh come on at all I think someone might have cut it out for a second so sorry if I'm jumping
00:07:26 in and cutting someone off but I'm going to go ahead and jump and answer this question anyways
00:07:29 yeah we haven't seen Jagmeet Singh you know we saw Stephen Harper release sort of a endorsement
00:07:35 for the Conservative Party but even in that endorsement he didn't really talk about Danielle
00:07:39 Smith he kind of just kept it general and said look Alberta's back on track they're what's best
00:07:44 for the province right now the vote for the United Conservative wasn't really an endorsement of
00:07:48 danielle smith and we know that her brand of conservatism isn't for everybody and that has 0.59
00:07:53 certainly turned off some more establishment conservatives so it's interesting that harper
00:07:57 didn't acknowledge her in that video but still you know generally a good thing for the party to
00:08:01 get that kind of endorsement now i mean obviously the big story when danielle smith became the ucp
00:08:07 leader was it was one of the greatest political comebacks we've seen in canada danielle smith
00:08:13 went from losing a very winnable election more than 10 years ago to losing the support of her
00:08:19 own party, losing a nomination. I remember when she started her radio gig, she was just reviled
00:08:24 by Alberta Conservatives, but now has become, I mean, probably one of the most popular figures
00:08:30 in the Conservative movement. So let me talk to you about this, William, for two reasons. Number
00:08:35 one, I think your analysis of Alberta politics is on point, but you were also on that campaign
00:08:40 back in 2012 so how do you or what would you say about the danielle smith of 2023
00:08:46 compared to the danielle smith you worked with yeah and i mean just to harken back to your other
00:08:52 point i'm absolutely certain rachel notley and the new democrats told jagmeet saying
00:08:56 do not come to alberta do not try and help me at all during this election in fact if you could
00:09:02 forget we even know each other that would be the best possible thing for my chances of becoming
00:09:08 premier. Because of course, Rachel Notley, the last time she won, there were two conservative
00:09:12 parties on the ballot. This will be the first time it's ever just been a united conservative
00:09:17 party versus the New Democrats, and we'll see what the outcome is. But talking about Daniel
00:09:21 Smith, you're right. Arguably the most spectacular fall from grace that a conservative politician
00:09:26 has had since possibly the divine government in Saskatchewan, when a lot of them ended up in jail.
00:09:33 but if you would ask me at the time
00:09:36 would she come back to Alberta politics
00:09:38 my answer would have been absolutely not
00:09:39 in fact I recall writing a column or an op-ed
00:09:42 that said the Daniel Smith era of Alberta politics has ended
00:09:47 because I simply did not see a way for her
00:09:49 to overcome the huge amount of anger and betrayal
00:09:53 that people felt about it
00:09:55 so the fact that she not only did
00:09:58 that she took her lumps
00:09:59 she got yelled at for months
00:10:02 She had a radio show where for the first, you know, six months, a year, everybody was piling on about how upset they were about what she did.
00:10:10 And to then go on and win a leadership race, I think, is a testament to her tenacity and the fact that she was willing to suffer through all of those sins and that punishment in order to do something which she believed.
00:10:22 And, you know, I think a lot of Conservatives really appreciate that, that she was willing to take the tough love or the anger and outrage and channel it into something else.
00:10:33 But you, of course, do see, as Rachel said, some division on the Conservative side about whether or not they support Danielle Smith.
00:10:40 You've got Kem Bozenkul and a few others writing op-eds saying that she's not a Conservative, she shouldn't be elected.
00:10:46 You've got endorsements, though, from Stephen Harper and others who say, you know, the only path forward in Alberta is a conservative government.
00:10:53 And I think that's the real ballot question people are facing this time, is what are they more afraid of?
00:10:58 Are they more afraid of crazy Danielle Smith, or that's what her opponents and the mainstream media would have you believe?
00:11:06 Are they more afraid of crazy Danielle Smith or, Rachel Notley's terrible economic policies?
00:11:11 Which one of those two unpleasant choices are they least supportive of?
00:11:16 I don't think anybody's voting, apart from vocal minorities on either side, out of love for these candidates.
00:11:23 It's more about which do you dislike the most.
00:11:26 We are, if you're just tuning in, about 49 minutes away from the start of the one and only leaders debate in this year's Alberta election.
00:11:34 We're going to carry that live here at True North.
00:11:37 But we will talk about the campaign, the race, the themes, the debate, and all of that between now and then.
00:11:43 I'm Andrew Lawton, joined by Rachel Emanuel and William Macbeth from True North.
00:11:48 Let's talk about the overarching campaign theme for a minute, Rachel,
00:11:51 because I know that earlier on, months ago, there was this thought that I had and some others advanced
00:11:56 that this might really be Danielle Smith versus Justin Trudeau in a way,
00:12:01 more than Danielle Smith versus Rachel Notley.
00:12:04 And I think we saw in the leadership race, the Sovereignty Act, which then became the first legislation of this government.
00:12:11 And I think that there is something to that, that the UCP was really looking at Ottawa as being its main nemesis.
00:12:17 But I mean, maybe I've been missing it. I haven't actually really seen that dynamic in the election.
00:12:22 I haven't really seen federal issues become the ones that Danielle Smith has really tried to stake out a place on. 0.99
00:12:28 Have I missed something or is that your read too?
00:12:30 No, and one of the reasons you haven't seen that dichotomy play out is because Danielle Smith is campaigning to an entirely different group of voters than she was campaigning to during the UCP leadership race in which she was really appealing to those voters who felt left behind by Ottawa, who felt hurt by their federal government, who felt frustrated by government overreach during the COVID-19 pandemic.
00:12:50 she came out the strongest against the pandemic policy that we saw you know she was really
00:12:55 outspoken in that and she kind of stood alone in the field a lot of those other candidates
00:12:59 couldn't run against the government's record because they had been a part of the government
00:13:03 during the COVID-19 pandemic and they had sort of stood by while those policies were passed
00:13:07 and then were forced to kind of come out and say well you know I didn't agree with it and I can't
00:13:12 really acknowledge what I said because that would be breaching cabinet confidences but I can tell
00:13:16 you that I wasn't in favor of it but it certainly wasn't a strong argument and I think they know
00:13:20 they didn't have a leg to stand on so we didn't see that same pitch from them that was danielle
00:13:25 smith's campaign during the leadership race it was effective we know she won it was close i think
00:13:30 she won on the last ballot and i think that speaks to the fact that the conservative party still
00:13:34 wasn't sure about her you know not 100 we didn't see her wasn't a peer poly a victory where he went
00:13:39 on the first ballot with about 70 support from the base so we are still seeing a bit of that split
00:13:44 within the party right now people not sure how to feel about her and as a result we've seen danielle
00:13:49 now appealing to the moderates which everyone expected her to do now to her credit she hasn't
00:13:54 turned on her base i think some people are really upset about the decision to remove jennifer johnson
00:13:58 from the ucp caucus if she wins her election which she's 100 likely to do because that is a
00:14:03 conservative safe seat you know some people are upset about that other people understand and say
00:14:07 this is the right decision for people that haven't followed that just because that happened today can
00:14:11 you just give some context on that sure so the other day it came out that jennifer johnson had 1.00
00:14:16 made some comments basically referring to trans ideology as as crap and saying that by teaching 0.98
00:14:24 trans ideology in schools you're you're mixing crap in with the baked goods and so these comments 1.00
00:14:29 were widely condemned people were like this is extremely transphobic this is extremely homophobic 0.99
00:14:33 you know maybe it was about two days ago it just blew up the news cycle it was dominating headlines
00:14:38 for days people across the board were really really upset and saying danielle smith you need
00:14:42 get rid of this candidate earlier this morning the decision came down that if jennifer johnson 1.00
00:14:46 wins her election in lacombe pinocca she will not sit with the usb caucus at this point it is too
00:14:52 late to remove jennifer johnson from the ballot she will be on the ballot this is something similar
00:14:57 that happened with the liberal government when close to the election it came out a candidate had
00:15:01 some done some untoward things and the liberals didn't really want to be associated with them so
00:15:05 they said you know what he's still going to run but if he wins his election he will sit as an
00:15:09 independent candidate so this is sometimes done as a practice when it's too late for a party to
00:15:13 get rid of a candidate that they no longer want to associate with their party so that was a decision
00:15:18 that came down this morning you know some conservatives that really supported danielle
00:15:22 during the leadership race were really upset by this decision i think other people understood
00:15:26 but again this is danielle winning to the general alberta population she's winning to appeal to a
00:15:32 broader group of people she knows that she is to keep some of those mlas in calgary happy some of 0.97
00:15:36 of them feel like they can't win under her we've been hearing reports that they haven't really been
00:15:41 campaigning under daniel smith they've more been campaigning as their own independent mla
00:15:44 that's not similar to what we saw in jace under jason kenney so she is running a different campaign
00:15:49 and i think she's really trying to position herself against rachel notley's record as premier
00:15:53 because a lot of people in alberta are really unhappy during that time period they saw jobs
00:15:57 and investment leave the province and so the ucb has been you know trying really hard to remind
00:16:02 people of Rachel Notley's record as premier. Let's do a little bit of 2012-2023 comparison
00:16:09 again, which I know is your favorite pastime, William. Lake of fire, political history, everyone
00:16:14 knows the incident in 2012 that, I mean, largely people argued cost Danielle Smith the election.
00:16:19 Do you see shades of that in the Jennifer Johnson debacle? Oh, I mean, absolutely. I mean,
00:16:26 I cannot overstate the impact that had on our 2012 Wild Rose election. And I'll tell you something
00:16:34 that I found interesting was we did some polling or some focus grouping after that election to try
00:16:40 and determine like where Wild Rose stood in the minds of typical voters when it came to issues
00:16:48 like, do you think we're extreme? Do you think we're intolerant? And when we talked to people
00:16:52 afterwards they said look no we don't think your party by and large is a party that is extreme we
00:16:58 don't think Daniel Smith is an extremist or is intolerant but what this made us think was she
00:17:05 wasn't up to making the tough choices you have to make when you're a premier they said her decision
00:17:10 to not fire Alan Hunsberger who was the candidate who had made those comments showed a failure of
00:17:17 leadership and therefore they didn't think she was ready for the job of being premier now I would say 0.79
00:17:22 I think if she had fired him or had said that he would not sit in a Walrose caucus,
00:17:27 she would have become premier at the end of that election. And to her credit, I think she learned
00:17:34 that very painful lesson and wasn't about to let it happen again in this time. There is simply no
00:17:39 way you can message around the fact that the very unpleasant analogy used by that candidate was,
00:17:46 you know it's like mixing pooping with the cookie dough and uh i don't think uh there was no amount
00:17:52 of explanation that was going to make that particular analogy come across as anything
00:17:56 other than unreasonable or extreme and so i i think she decided not to make the same mistake twice
00:18:01 let's shift gears here a little bit and talk about the format that we can expect tonight
00:18:08 and i i know that uh we did talk about how it's going to be one-on-one which will certainly be
00:18:13 interesting here but let's also talk about why not that we don't love having you here rachel but
00:18:17 let's talk about why you're here with us and not at the debate yeah absolutely so the parties you
00:18:25 know they plan this debate they gave the rights over to organize the debate to the debate consortium
00:18:29 who handed it over to ctv to organize so we know that the debate is going to be happening at a
00:18:34 location maybe ctv's edmonton office it was sort of an undisclosed location they kept bringing up
00:18:39 the fact that there was major privacy concerns so when i emailed ctv the other day to get
00:18:44 accreditation to attend to attend the event they said to me oh you know sorry this is for alberta
00:18:50 press gallery members only my application with the press gallery has been ongoing for months
00:18:56 the alberta press gallery has no jurisdiction over anything other than journalists in the alberta
00:19:02 legislature yeah absolutely so this is just a very hand-picked small group of people that are now
00:19:08 being invited to attend the debate they said the reason for that was that it was safety and security
00:19:13 issues and I said well you know I've been a member of the press gallery in the past I can assure you
00:19:17 I'm no security threat and they said oh no no we don't think that you're a security threat but
00:19:21 we only have a limited number of security and it's a small space so we're gonna have to limit it and
00:19:25 I sort of explained to them that this would result in most of independent media being barred from the
00:19:30 debate which is probably of course what they were sort of hoping for and they said yes a lot of
00:19:34 people won't be able to attend but this was just a decision to make so I was not able to attend the
00:19:38 debate in person which is less of an issue except that there will be a scrum with both of the leaders
00:19:43 afterwards that i will not be able to participate in which is frustrating it'll be largely mainstream
00:19:48 media reporters at that scrum the western standard might be able to send someone so they might have
00:19:52 a presence there but very frustrating and the one thing that i'm kind of caught up on as well
00:19:57 you know the ucp often champions independent media danielle smith especially has been a big 0.99
00:20:02 champion of independent media she talks about how great it is that all these new outlets are now
00:20:07 working and growing in this space and i think it was an oversight on their part not to ensure that
00:20:12 we wouldn't be given fair access and fair treatment to attend this debate i think that's
00:20:17 something that needed they need to look at in the future and say we'll go to this debate but
00:20:20 this debate but we're going to have some terms of our own that you have to meet
00:20:24 yeah and obviously i mean my my personal desire might be for the ucp to take this principled stand
00:20:30 but i realize in all the issues that they are contending with this isn't necessarily the one
00:20:35 they want to die on, but there are ways around it. Like Danielle Smith could say, you know what,
00:20:40 we're going to have a scrum outside the debate hall and we're going to take questions from all
00:20:43 journalists who show up. And generally the UCP, as you mentioned, has been very good about allowing
00:20:48 all journalists to go there. The NDP has not, and this has actually become independent media,
00:20:53 a bit of a running theme in this election campaign. Now you've just like been elbows up
00:20:58 and you've been getting in there and Rachel Notley has been taking your questions because you
00:21:01 shout them loud enough that she can hear them even without you getting the microphone, but
00:21:05 she's not been as conducive to answering other independent journalist questions this has been
00:21:11 one of the strangest parts of the campaign it has been really weird to see how the NDP have responded
00:21:17 to independent media I have to say that I don't think their tactics have been very successful
00:21:21 and have definitely not been a good look for them so yeah basically they've made a decision to
00:21:26 largely ban independent media reporters from their events altogether the first event I showed up
00:21:32 They just decided they were going to take questions from legacy media journalists in the room.
00:21:37 And the way that that worked was the communication staffer that was running the event would hold the microphone.
00:21:42 He would pass it to a journalist and he would take it back in between.
00:21:46 That's a pretty standard practice, but it also means that reporters can't just sort of casually pass the mic to each other.
00:21:51 It also is a very formal way of doing an event, whereas typically on Parliament Hill, there'll be like a scrum and reporters will just kind of yell their question.
00:21:58 The person who yells aloud gets their question answered.
00:22:02 And so at this specific event, the first one I went to from the Alberta NDP, they just decided
00:22:07 not to hand me the mic. And as soon as they were done taking questions from all the legacy media
00:22:11 journalists, they went to the phones. I knew that was a tactic because they didn't want to take my
00:22:16 question. And so I just decided to yell my question out. It was a pretty small room. They were still
00:22:20 live streaming the event. It would have been impossible to ignore me. Of course, Rachel
00:22:24 Notley could have made the decision just not to answer me. But to her credit, she did answer me.
00:22:28 we have seen other cases where, for example, Calgary Mayor Jody Gondik just decided not to
00:22:33 answer a question from the countersignal editor-in-chief, Kian Bextie, and actually walked
00:22:37 away from the podium when he asked her a question. So to her credit, Rachel Notley did answer my
00:22:42 question and I got a follow-up in. And then at future press conferences, they've simply just
00:22:46 decided to give me the mic. So I've been able to get my questions in on those rare occasions when
00:22:51 I actually am able to find out where the NDP press conferences are happening. They've made it very
00:22:56 difficult and they've kept their location very secret from independent media so we often don't
00:22:59 know what's going on or where to find them but I've been the only independent media reporter
00:23:04 that's had success at getting my questions in. Western Standard is barred from asking questions
00:23:09 until they apologize for a column that they published which they're not going to do let's be
00:23:13 honest. The NDP said that the the column in question was homophobic and hateful and all that
00:23:20 types of things so they're waiting for an apology. Rebel News hasn't been able to get their questions
00:23:24 And on the chance that Keenan Bextie shows up to something like happened on Monday, the NDP actually tried to get him to leave.
00:23:31 And when he wouldn't leave, they called the police on him and had him sort of escorted from the premises.
00:23:35 So it's been sort of all over the place on how they're dealing with independent media.
00:23:39 But it's kind of just created more drama than is necessary.
00:23:43 We actually on the Bextie issue, we actually have a clip, I believe, that we can show.
00:23:48 Let's roll that now.
00:23:54 Thank you.
00:24:24 to that. He was not actually handcuffed. I'll take it up with Kian about why his hands happen
00:24:29 to be in the position they would be if he were handcuffed. But a mainstream media reporter,
00:24:33 to their credit, did actually ask Rachel Notley about this incident, which had ended up delaying
00:24:38 the start of the press conference by a considerable amount. And she wouldn't take
00:24:42 Kian's question, but she took this question about Kian.
00:24:54 Well, you know, it really depends. So I'm happy to present myself to everybody in the media, even those that have a very conservative background and have a very pointed perspective in terms of the questions that they ask.
00:25:12 There is one media outlet that fits that description that I am very clear.
00:25:18 We will not take questions from until they retract the hate speech that they published with respect to one of our caucus members.
00:25:27 The protester today does not fit that description.
00:25:30 The protester today is a protester, has a record of acting like a protester,
00:25:35 regardless of what they may have called themselves, and has a clear association with white supremacist groups.
00:25:41 And so the answer is no. No.
00:25:49 Yeah, that was a pretty pointed comment there,
00:25:53 calling Kian a protester repeatedly,
00:25:56 likening him with white supremacy without offering support for that.
00:26:00 But, I mean, the NDP have dug their line in the sand here.
00:26:03 And I think, generally speaking, the mainstream media, in my experience,
00:26:06 are happy enough to keep their access group small
00:26:10 so they don't actually make us think about this.
00:26:13 I mean, this is something you and I have talked about, William.
00:26:15 It's why independent media is so important
00:26:16 because a lot of the times there are, to borrow Pierre Paulyev's words,
00:26:20 these gatekeepers in the mainstream media
00:26:22 that really like being the only ones that have access.
00:26:26 No, you're completely right.
00:26:27 It's a very clubby environment within the legacy media,
00:26:31 and they really don't like it when outsiders try and rock the boat.
00:26:35 And, you know, but the need for independent media has never been more clear if you simply look at their coverage of politics this week.
00:26:44 They have written endlessly about the fact that this one UCP candidate made an inappropriate and unpleasant analogy about transgenderism policy in schools.
00:26:56 They've talked incessantly about an ethics report that came out today that partly cleared Danielle Smith in the issue related to judicial interference.
00:27:06 But what they've barely talked about at all is the NDP's platform, which is calling for a nearly 40% increase in business taxes.
00:27:13 And that is an issue that actually will impact the lives of thousands of Albertans, not least of which the nearly 35,000 Albertans who, according to economist Jack Mintz, will likely lose their jobs.
00:27:26 if the NDP tax policy is adopted after the election.
00:27:30 So I think the legacy media tend to focus on their little pet issues.
00:27:35 They like to play the inside politics game.
00:27:38 They like to be in the little bubble of analyzing poll results
00:27:41 or talking about, you know, oh, this little pet issue that happened here or there.
00:27:45 And they've really failed at talking about the issues which matter to Albertans,
00:27:50 and that's jobs, taxes, cost of living, housing, all of those issues.
00:27:55 And it's during an election, of course, which is when we should be having important conversations about things like that, not which candidate for which party once said something crazy on their social media, either a week ago, a year ago, a decade ago.
00:28:10 Yeah. No, you're very right. And by the way, are you a bit thirsty, William? You look thirsty.
00:28:15 Oh, well, that's a really interesting thing you say. I am kind of thirsty. I'm just going to take a little sip here from my True North mug.
00:28:25 I happen to have one, too.
00:28:27 A True North mug.
00:28:29 Rachel doesn't.
00:28:29 But we'll get her one.
00:28:31 You guys, that's a really nice mug.
00:28:33 How come I don't have one, and how can I get one?
00:28:36 Well, Rachel, it's funny you mentioned that.
00:28:38 You actually do have one.
00:28:40 You just forgot to pack it, I think,
00:28:41 because you went out of the camp.
00:28:48 There we go.
00:28:49 They took me off while I was doing the pitch. 0.99
00:28:51 Darn it, Sean, I was trying to sell mugs here. 0.95
00:28:53 No, we aren't actually selling them, but we do have a few of them in stock, and the first five people to donate $150 will get their very own True North mug, and if you donate $500, you get the one that William is sipping from right now, but he won't even wash it. 0.98
00:29:11 No, first five to donate $150, get a True North mug.
00:29:17 These are very, very limited inventory, and they are, I mean, they're very hefty.
00:29:22 Like, you could fit, like, two whole cups of coffee in here, which is how I am getting through the show.
00:29:26 And by the way, we did actually give Rachel a mug.
00:29:28 You have one, right, Rachel?
00:29:30 I do have one.
00:29:31 I just didn't pack it.
00:29:32 It didn't seem essential for the campaign trail, and I regret that now.
00:29:35 Also, I believe you can fit, like, half a glass of wine in them.
00:29:39 Someone told me that.
00:29:40 so yeah people think it's me because i did the whole like drinking wine bit on my show despite
00:29:46 the world health organization the other day but i have not uh emptied half a bottle of wine into
00:29:50 my mug i am drinking pure coffee right now i did actually see that bit i know that you accused me
00:29:56 of not watching your show but i did see the wine bit so well no i accuse you because you like saw
00:30:02 the intro and you're like oh wow this is great i've never seen this before i like well we use it
00:30:06 in front of every single Andrew Lawton show so uh but if you watch the archive version you might not
00:30:11 see the the live countdown so I will uh let you slide on that one uh but I do just before we get
00:30:17 back into the the really important stuff not that William drinking from a giant true north mug isn't
00:30:21 important uh we do not get to do the stuff we do without the support of true north nation out there
00:30:27 uh and whether it's the people that give you know two dollars a month or ten dollars a month or
00:30:32 one-time donations of uh in some cases thousands of dollars we we so appreciate it and i mean the
00:30:38 i remember when when true north started and i was one of a very small team that we did a lot of work
00:30:44 we punched above our weight but having rachel in alberta able to cover this election full-time has 1.00
00:30:50 been uh fantastic and i think you know having a team that's spread across the country that lets
00:30:55 us cover these stories and like you were just saying william that lets us uh cover the issues
00:31:00 that matter like I remember when I was on the 2021 uh federal campaign trail and I'm at these
00:31:05 press conferences with with Aaron O'Toole uh which whatever you think about him was the conservative
00:31:10 leader running in an election with a conservative-ish platform uh and you know you'd line up
00:31:16 behind media that are asking about you know things that have nothing to do with the election nothing
00:31:21 to do with the platform uh and and sometimes you'd go there and you'd say hi I'm I don't know if I'm
00:31:26 allowed to ask it but I actually have a question about policy and it was like you were doing this
00:31:30 this radical thing so I mean yeah that the the trivia the anomalies they matter in elections
00:31:35 but there's a dearth of people covering conservative politicians in a way that
00:31:42 matters to a lot of Canadians I think no I couldn't agree with you more I mean
00:31:56 public safety, you are seeing a very wide split between where these two candidates can.
00:32:05 And voters really have to know that who they vote for in an election will determine what
00:32:10 happens in their everyday lives.
00:32:12 You know, if you elect a party, for example, that's going to hike your business taxes,
00:32:17 that could lead to widespread layoffs and a loss of investment.
00:32:20 You could lose your job.
00:32:21 Or if you vote for a party that's going to cut your taxes, you're going to have more
00:32:24 money in your pocket when it comes to tax time. So the fact that the legacy media want to obsess
00:32:30 about their little cadre of pet issues, I mean, fine. But I think it shows more than ever why we
00:32:35 need groups like True North, why we need independent media, talking about the issues
00:32:39 which actually matter to everyday people. Let's talk about the healthcare aspect here,
00:32:44 which was obviously a big part of Danielle's leadership campaign and has, I think, become
00:32:48 pretty central to the general election campaign as well uh what's been the main health court
00:32:55 health care debate rachel well the main health care debate is of course basically what we're
00:33:00 seeing across the country and that is just the immense wait times people are experiencing when
00:33:06 they're at the emergency room if they need a surgery or if they need an ambulance now of course
00:33:11 as a canadian you pay a ton of money to taxes we have a publicly funded health care system
00:33:16 and so I think it's reasonable to expect that if you need an ambulance you're going to be able to
00:33:20 get one in a reasonable amount of time just a couple of minutes if you live in the city
00:33:24 maybe you're going to wait a little longer if you live a little farther away from the city
00:33:28 these wait times have been just immense they've been growing over the past couple of years and
00:33:32 they've really hit a breaking point and people all across the board are feeling the effects of this
00:33:36 and the other main problem is that there's a huge shortage of family doctors right now which is
00:33:41 further impacting our hospital systems because people that don't have family doctors are going
00:33:46 to the ER to get access to see a doctor because they really don't have a lot of options and so
00:33:50 that's been one of the main issues that Danielle Smith approached during the United Conservative
00:33:54 Party leadership race she said we need to over overhaul our health care system and she immediately 0.97
00:33:59 got started on that once she was elected premier she wiped the Alberta Health Services Board whom 0.98
00:34:05 she was very critical of during the COVID-19 pandemic she said they you know there was a lot
00:34:10 of government overreach responsible and she didn't like their decisions she replaced them with one 0.99
00:34:14 administrator and immediately got work to laying out a plan to essentially reduce some of those
00:34:19 wait times interestingly just a couple of weeks ago a some new alberta health services data was
00:34:24 released showing that wait times for ambulances are way down from what they were back in november
00:34:30 and the six months since danielle smith has been premiered looks like her plan is working
00:34:34 even people in the mainstream media you know were forced to kind of admit oh maybe danielle smith is 1.00
00:34:39 right that her plan is working and it's going to take a bit more time so we're seeing her promising
00:34:43 to continue those actions and continue to increase health care capacity the government has also
00:34:49 taking use of surgical charter centers to basically pay them to get rid of some of the surgical
00:34:55 backlog and then what we're seeing from the ndp is just a lot of complaints you know concerns about
00:35:00 privatizing health care they don't like the surgical system they say it's taking jobs away
00:35:04 from the hospitals they're saying that danielle smith is planning to sell the hospitals things 0.99
00:35:08 like that you know very inflammatory language they've also pulled some of her old clips
00:35:12 and they're basically saying oh she's going to make you pay to see a family doctor because you
00:35:15 know danielle smith was a podcast host for years she's discussed a lot of ideas and they're
00:35:20 basically trying to make her run against her record of being basically a talk show host who 0.69
00:35:25 was open to discussion and debate which has been very difficult for her to sort of surpass that
00:35:29 and she's kind of said repeatedly i will not charge you to see a family doctor but that's
00:35:33 just an ndp talking point so you know they've also come out and promised to increase capacity
00:35:38 for doctors. They said they're going to undertake the largest hiring spree in Alberta history to
00:35:43 really increase that capacity of doctors and to fix some of these wait times. So everyone is kind
00:35:48 of admitting what the problem is. There's just slightly different solutions as to how they're
00:35:51 going to approach it. And then of course, the NDP not really being genuine or honest about what
00:35:56 Danielle Smith's plan actually is, is another big problem that we're seeing. You just had like the 0.92
00:36:01 perfect setup on the clip there, but I can set up your clip for you because you actually asked
00:36:05 Rachel Notley about that about her claim that Danielle Smith was going to make people pay to 1.00
00:36:11 see their doctor. Later at the press conference Danielle Smith said she thinks the protests
00:36:19 emerge not from UCP mixed messaging but rather NDP lies. She said repeatedly she's not going to
00:36:25 charge for a visit to the doctor or she's not going to privatize health care. I'm wondering
00:36:30 what your response to that obviously the NDP have been reiterating claims that you will have to pay
00:36:34 for a family doctor, even while the premier is saying, no, that's not the case.
00:36:39 Here's the thing.
00:36:41 Danielle Smith has been seen on film, not once, not twice,
00:36:46 not sort of in response to some unexpected question,
00:36:49 but she has done radio shows, she's done speaking tours,
00:36:53 she's written papers, she has recorded herself over and over and over
00:36:58 saying these things, advocating to get people to pay more out of pocket
00:37:03 for their healthcare and talking in great detail about how she saw the sale of hospitals
00:37:09 as a completely legitimate way to get around the Canada Health Act.
00:37:13 So she's actually been defending her claim that she won't move forward on these things
00:37:19 that she's advocated for so much of her life until very, very recently by saying that she's
00:37:25 barred by the Canada Health Act.
00:37:27 But when it comes to the sales of hospitals in the recording, she's actually describing
00:37:32 that as something that can be done within the canada health act so it is a very troubling uh
00:37:38 revelation and and uh honestly because she's flip-flopped on so many other things
00:37:44 uh albertans don't have a high level of trust that they can count on her uh to protect your health
00:37:50 care our health care
00:37:51 rachel what did we just see there yeah so basically this was at an ndp rally up in
00:38:04 northwest calgary i went to it and i asked rachel notley why are you repeating these claims that
00:38:09 danielle smith is going to charge people to visit their family doctors because danielle smith has 1.00
00:38:15 said repeatedly i think every single media appearance she's given on the campaign trail
00:38:19 she said i will not charge you to visit your family doctor and of course you heard rachel
00:38:24 notley's answers there she said well you know she's discussed it so many times and we just
00:38:28 can't trust her and we don't know what she's going to do so i i'm going to take her out
00:38:32 her word when she discussed these ideas and basically just trying to sow doubt
00:38:36 into danielle smith and into her promises not to charge albertons for a visit to the family doctor
00:38:41 this may be bad political advice but there's a part of me that wonders if danielle smith would 0.97
00:38:51 be better off leaning into it because she is an ideas person and i mean when you host a radio show
00:38:56 and you have the mind that danielle smith has i mean she's always liked thinking about different
00:39:00 solutions to problems and she's never shied away from complex solutions and i know in health care
00:39:05 she's put forward some very novel ideas on on health care and it was actually disappointing
00:39:10 to not see her lean more into that because she has talked about the need for a fundamental
00:39:15 restructuring in health care. And she's talked about it in a very sensible way. She's talked
00:39:19 to experts about it. And that's been the one thing that I think has felt a little inauthentic
00:39:24 is that she's running away because of the political climate on health care, which I
00:39:29 understand, but she's running away from what I think she's made pretty clear in the past 0.98
00:39:32 that she believes. What do you think, William? Yeah, I mean, I would say it's no secret that
00:39:38 in her heart, Danielle Smith thinks we need major structural reform to our health care system. And 0.62
00:39:45 I don't think she's wrong. I think if you read any of the reports that have come out about publicly
00:39:50 funded health care, the fact that with people living longer lives, the fact that medical
00:39:55 procedures are becoming increasingly expensive, the equipment costs, the medication costs,
00:40:00 all of this is leading to a point where we're going to get to where there's just simply too
00:40:04 much demand on the system in order to be able to deliver it and at that point we will hit a crisis
00:40:09 we will be in an actual crisis where we cannot deliver health care to the people who need it
00:40:13 so you know for all that rachel notley pretends to be the guardian of the working people she 0.99
00:40:20 doesn't seem to care at all that a huge number of them could find themselves without an effective
00:40:24 health care system if we don't try and change it now and the time to change is before we reach that
00:40:30 that crisis point there's lots of things out there having a public system partnered with a
00:40:35 private system looking at examples of how they do it in the united kingdom japan western europe
00:40:41 uh the biggest fallacy in health care of course is that there's only two ways to deliver it
00:40:46 how we do it in canada right now or how they do it in the united states and you know the fear
00:40:52 mongering is well we don't want that u.s uh style health care but the fact is that people have you
00:40:57 you know, Western rich countries have grappled with this for years and they've come up with
00:41:02 different solutions. And I would say if anyone is prepared to bite the bullet on changing it,
00:41:07 it would be Danielle Smith. And I hope, I hope she runs with it after if and when she wins the 0.96
00:41:12 election and actually does implement a fairly aggressive reform agenda when it comes to
00:41:17 healthcare. Yeah. Like one of the ones that I remember from the leadership race was healthcare
00:41:22 spending accounts. And her argument was quite sound. She said, you know, Alberta health services
00:41:26 employees have this flexibility in their health care spending why do alberta residents not have
00:41:32 that but that never really made it into the general election platform did it rachel it didn't
00:41:38 make it into the general election platform they ucb has been hosting these evening broadcasts to
00:41:43 kind of do a campaign rundown they have different ucp candidates on the show every evening i'm sure
00:41:48 a lot of our viewers have watched maybe a bit of it here and there i myself have tried to catch it
00:41:51 it when I can. She was asked about her plans for health spending account at one point. And Danielle
00:41:56 said it was something that she was still open to something that she would revisit after the
00:42:00 election. It was surprisingly considered as like pretty controversial when she first talked about
00:42:04 it during the United Conservative Party leadership race. You know, for anyone that has insurance,
00:42:08 a lot of times you'll have maybe 300 or $400 on your health spending account. It's quite wonderful.
00:42:14 You can use it for a lot of different things. You can use it to go to the naturopath or to go
00:42:17 for a massage therapist and most benefits have a limit as to how much you can spend per year
00:42:22 so once you use of those benefits you could use your health spending account to apply to something
00:42:26 like that or usually for like a dentist you know your dentist might cover your insurance might
00:42:30 cover 75 percent of your appointment you pay for the rest out of pocket you could use your health
00:42:34 spending account to cover that remaining bit to have it fully covered so they're usually quite
00:42:38 flexible with what you can do for them very useful you can try different things i don't know why it
00:42:42 was considered so controversial it's actually a really great idea i would love to have a health
00:42:46 spending account again. So she did say she was still open to it. I think once it's introduced
00:42:51 and people understand what it is a little bit better, people will find it very useful. And
00:42:54 sure, you know, $300, which was the amount I think she was initially discussing, isn't a lot of
00:43:00 money. You're not going to get a lot of appointments out of that, maybe three and a half
00:43:03 appointments, maybe four, depending on what you're going to use it for. But it's still just something
00:43:07 to try it out. You know, she kind of introduced it as something that the government would try and
00:43:11 see people like it, which I suspect they would when they see how flexible it is and all the
00:43:15 different things that you can use it for. If you are just tuning in, or if you've been tuning in
00:43:20 for a while and have forgotten what we're doing here, it is the night of the first and only
00:43:25 leaders debate of the Alberta election. I'm Andrew Lawton, joined by Rachel Emanuel and
00:43:30 William McBeth. True North is going to be carrying the debate live when it starts in just over 15
00:43:36 minutes time. Now, it might not be starting right at six o'clock mountain time. There might be a bit
00:43:41 a delay. Will they, you know, to explain the rules and all that, but we'll be throwing to it as soon
00:43:47 as it commences, and we'll have a bit of a post-show analysis. We'll have some highlights, and low
00:43:53 lights, and mid lights, and headlights, and all of these other things, but I do want to just say,
00:43:58 if you have not yet donated, the first five people to donate more than $150 tonight will get
00:44:04 a True North mug hot off the presses. William is modeling it, and if you include a request,
00:44:11 the first donor might actually get William included with the mug.
00:44:14 We're still working out the shipping arrangements.
00:44:16 I think he's local to Alberta,
00:44:18 so it might be easier if you're an Alberta donor.
00:44:20 Actually, we haven't gotten five yet.
00:44:22 I just checked with our website guy.
00:44:24 We still have at least a couple left,
00:44:25 so you can get in on that by going to donate.tnc.news,
00:44:30 donate.tnc.news.
00:44:32 And we also have had some super chats,
00:44:35 so if you're watching on YouTube,
00:44:36 you can chip in a donation in the comments section.
00:44:39 And if you have a question, we will even answer it on air.
00:44:43 And let me just go to one question that I got.
00:44:46 This wasn't a super chat, but I thought it was an interesting question.
00:44:49 So interesting that I've now lost it on my screen.
00:44:52 So I don't have the name of the person who asked it, Andy.
00:44:55 But they were asking, oh, here it is.
00:44:57 They were asking Bit Baldy on Twitter has asked about the Alberta party.
00:45:01 And I know you were talking, William, about the consolidation of the left in Alberta into the NDP.
00:45:07 but this is someone who's saying they are a conservative who is disappointed with the cons
00:45:14 and what they're calling Danielle's coup and this person says I miss the Alberta party so
00:45:19 so was the Alberta party when it was a thing in so much as it ever was pulling conservative votes
00:45:25 because I always saw it as kind of like a big al liberal alternative gosh there there has been no
00:45:31 political party in Alberta political history that has been more things to more people than the
00:45:36 Alberta party. Now, when it first started, it was actually to the right of where Wild Rose was.
00:45:44 It was organized by a lot of old school reform party people, and they wanted it to be this
00:45:51 really quite a right wing populist party. But of course, eventually what happened, there was an AGM
00:45:59 and suddenly it was taken over by a bunch of people who wanted the name, that Alberta party
00:46:06 party name, and it became a centrist party. It became a party that actually was home to disaffected
00:46:13 ex-PC Alberta people who didn't like going with Jason Kenney and the new United Conservative Party.
00:46:21 So it ended up there. And then it sort of languished. They had a leader who did quite
00:46:28 well for them. He was based out of Calgary. He was an entrepreneur, worked in the tech sector.
00:46:32 and then one afternoon they just decided to get rid of him.
00:46:36 They got rid of him.
00:46:38 They replaced him with former Edmonton Mayor Stephen Mandel
00:46:42 and the party went from having a couple seats in the legislature
00:46:45 to losing all of their seats in the next election.
00:46:48 And since then I think they've just really struggled to figure out who it is and what they are.
00:46:53 So don't know what they stand for.
00:46:56 They have a great name.
00:46:57 Who wouldn't want to vote for the Alberta party?
00:46:59 You know, right next door, there's a Saskatchewan party that is very popular, but they seem to really have had identity crises.
00:47:06 Couldn't figure out who they are, what they stand for.
00:47:08 And if you ask me now, I couldn't tell you what they believe in.
00:47:11 Yeah, I couldn't even tell you the leader.
00:47:12 I remember one of my old radio colleagues in Alberta stepped down and ended up running for the Alberta party, Angela Cocot.
00:47:20 And at the time, I was like, well, now I'm even more confused about what you believe, because I couldn't quite figure out what the Alberta party believed at that particular moment.
00:47:27 But I think there's an interesting dynamic in Alberta politics, and I've often looked at Alberta through the COVID era, and I know that we've moved beyond that largely.
00:47:39 But one of the interesting things is that when Alberta, under Jason Kenney, went down the road of COVID restrictions, lockdowns, vaccine passports, there was a really significant wave of concern, I think, in the conservative libertarian movement in Canada.
00:47:57 that if Alberta can't be the holdout, there's really no hope.
00:48:01 And Danielle Smith was a correction. 1.00
00:48:03 I mean, some people who don't like her might say an overcorrection to that.
00:48:07 And I know that the NDP's narrative has been to try to paint her as crazy Danielle
00:48:11 who believes these crazy things.
00:48:13 But to be honest, I don't know if that lands with people.
00:48:16 I think there are a lot of people when they see her and talk to her
00:48:19 that seemed, even if they don't like what she argues with,
00:48:22 don't actually see the evil caricature.
00:48:25 And I'm wondering, Rachel, you've seen Danielle Smith in action on the campaign trail. 0.98
00:48:30 What's been the reception she gets when you move beyond the attack ads and the headlines?
00:48:36 I have to say that I think the Alberta NDP's bid to paint Danielle Smith as someone you can't trust,
00:48:42 to be unsure about, has been pretty effective, especially with those moderates and swing ridings.
00:48:48 I think people are really deciding how they feel about her.
00:48:50 I think that is really going to be the ballot box question.
00:48:52 however when it comes to what we were talking about a little bit of the digging up old comments
00:48:57 from candidates and trying to just throw everything out there that you can and see what sticks
00:49:01 i don't think that has been super effective i think the ndp has spent far too much time on
00:49:06 negative campaigning and just sort of these attack ads not really focused on their own plans on
00:49:11 their vision that they're going to put forward for alberta so i would say that some of that hasn't
00:49:16 really landed and i think we've seen the ucp has been able to still get their message out about
00:49:20 jobs and the economy about health care and especially about public safety so i do think
00:49:25 that is something danielle smith is going to have to face going to the election people still think 1.00
00:49:28 of her back in the wild rose days as being fairly crazy they really were unhappy about the floor
00:49:32 crossing most albertans have forgiven her for that but it's still something kind of there in
00:49:36 the back of your mind so i think that campaigning on the part of the ndp has been fairly effective
00:49:41 i just don't know if it's enough to outweigh what really should be a positive vision they have for
00:49:46 province that's how people should campaign is showing a vision for how they're going to make
00:49:50 things better and what the province would look like under their government so we are just about
00:49:55 10 minutes away from the scheduled start time of the debate let's turn a little bit to uh debate
00:50:01 predictions debate strategy uh well first off do we know much about this specific format
00:50:08 uh well i i no i don't think we do we we do know of course there'll be a leader-to-leader matchup
00:50:14 and therefore you won't have what you have in a lot of other elections which is going to leaders
00:50:19 who who either will elect very few or no people in an election i'm assuming that means almost
00:50:25 every question will be answered by both leaders and possibly with an opportunity to respond
00:50:31 there are some things i do think though that you can look for which is which leader is doing the
00:50:35 better job of connecting with people through the medium of television and there's a few tactics
00:50:42 to this? Are they looking right into the camera? When they answer their question, are they looking
00:50:46 into the camera and making sure they're talking to people? Are they distracted by their opponent
00:50:50 and addressing their comments to them? And I think the winner is whoever comes across
00:50:57 as the most reasonable, calm, measured, sensible, ready to govern person. I think if anybody
00:51:07 flies off the handle, they're the ones who are going to lose. And my money is that Rachel
00:51:12 Notley is more likely to become upset and animated over the course of the debate than Danielle Smith. 0.99
00:51:19 Do you, well, I'll put this to either view. I mean, do either of you anticipate either one
00:51:25 really going for the jugular and going to engage with the opponent? Or do you think they're going
00:51:31 to mostly talk to the audience and talk to the moderators instead of talking to the other?
00:51:37 Yeah, that's a really good question, Andrew. I'm not super sure what to anticipate there. I don't really see Danielle Smith going for the jugular. She's just not really that type of person. And I think during the leadership race, we saw that even when people made very personal attacks against her, as did happen with a couple of candidates, interestingly, some of who were cabinet ministers in her government, she kept it pretty professional. She kept it pretty straight down the line and she was really able to maintain her calm.
00:52:00 You know, while Rachel Nolley and Danielle Smith have both been public figures for such a long time,
00:52:05 Danielle Smith had years of practice on the radio. 0.81
00:52:07 That is really good, concrete experience to be going into politics with, to be facing crowds.
00:52:11 She did it for years.
00:52:12 She talked to all sorts of different people, was able to continue all sorts of discussions and debates with people
00:52:17 and keep the conversations flowing in a way that was effective for the viewers and the listeners.
00:52:22 So she has a lot of really good experience under her belt working in that medium.
00:52:26 Rachel Nolley obviously has a lot of experience as a politician. 1.00
00:52:29 I saw her recently at a rally. She was able to excite the crowd and, you know, draw on a good 0.56
00:52:34 energy and really excite people. But, you know, she also really likes to lie about Danielle Smith 1.00
00:52:39 and throw attacks against her. So I think it'll be hard for her to all of a sudden pull back from
00:52:43 that method, especially when so much of the Alberta NDP's campaigning has been about these
00:52:48 slurs against Danielle Smith and about manipulating the UCP's campaign messaging into something that
00:52:55 it was never really meant to be and honestly just lying about it. So I don't really see how
00:52:59 Rachel Notley could avoid going for the jugular when the whole NDP campaign has kind of been about 0.99
00:53:05 going for Danielle Smith's jugular. Go ahead, William. Sorry. I would say too that I think
00:53:13 it's going to be interesting because Danielle Smith does have a couple weaknesses. One of her 1.00
00:53:17 weaknesses that I have noticed is she has a very big focus on wanting to answer the question she's 0.64
00:53:25 specifically being asked. You can tell you're a former political staffer if you think that's a
00:53:30 weakness. Well, this is true. It's my old life shining through into, because I'm sure journalists
00:53:35 of course would prefer their elected officials to answer the specific question that is being put to
00:53:40 them. But one of the keys for success is moving off the specific question you're being asked and
00:53:46 talking about the issues you want to talk about during a campaign. And I think for Danielle
00:53:50 Smith, it's about the New Democrat economic record, tying Rachel Notley to the federal
00:53:56 Singh-Trudeau coalition on the left, and basically saying we are going to stall Alberta's economic
00:54:03 growth and recovery if we give these people another term in office. But if she's pushed 0.95
00:54:07 into the weeds by the journalists asking her the questions or always responding to Rachel
00:54:13 Notley, she might end up not being able to do that over the course of the night. And
00:54:17 if they're successful in keeping her from talking about her message, then I think that's how Rachel
00:54:22 Notley will come out ahead in the debate. I may have miscalculated when I said that we would read
00:54:28 questions that people share in super chats on YouTube, because the first is someone who wants
00:54:33 Rachel to marry him. So take from that what you will. But thank you for your contribution, JR.
00:54:38 He's taken. She's taken. The first guy that you missed, this guy who got her asked a question
00:54:44 earlier tonight in the super chat um uh then we have a question from jim ross here uh who says
00:54:50 rachel notley is sort of like justin trudeau she's basically just uh grant's daughter who has
00:54:55 a legacy name dad never challenged any government and if it hadn't been for the pc self-destructing
00:55:00 the ndp uh wouldn't have been elected uh obviously as our alberta political historian i'm going to
00:55:06 go to you on on this william but i think i would say i mean sure does has she just been trading
00:55:12 off of the family. And I would say beyond that, has Rachel Notley actually carved out a pretty
00:55:17 positive name for herself in Alberta politics? I would say she's absolutely built a bigger base 1.00
00:55:24 of support than her party has ever enjoyed in Alberta before. I mean, if you look back in the
00:55:31 2012 election, for example, the NDP were nowhere. They would elect the same four or five seats in
00:55:39 Edmonton in an election, and that was it. So the fact that they've gone from that to being a
00:55:44 serious contender is probably a credit to the work Rachel Notley has done, ditching some of 1.00
00:55:51 the more extreme or un-Albertan elements of her party's platform, taking a much softer approach
00:55:58 on oil and gas, for example, being much more pro-business. But all of that being said, I do
00:56:05 think especially in calgary which is where this election will be won and lost there is a real
00:56:10 concern that the four years that had rachel notley as premier were terrible years for calgary there
00:56:17 were there were high job losses there were a lot of people out of work it was tough times and not
00:56:23 all of that was rachel notley's fault of course you know energy prices were very low alberta at
00:56:29 you know in the first part of 2015 was tipping into really tough economic times but certainly
00:56:35 i would say rachel notley's policies did not help uh during that time she she did do several things 1.00
00:56:41 that made people concerned to invest here now the question is are calgarians going to overlook that
00:56:46 are calgarians going to forgive her or say oh she was just a victim of circumstance are they going
00:56:51 to say no the last time we had a dp premier it was bad in this city we're not going back down
00:56:56 that road, even if I don't love Danielle Smith, even if I don't think she aligns with me on every
00:57:02 one of my issues or values, do I believe that a Danielle Smith conservative government will be
00:57:06 better for me and my family than a Notley government? Yeah, and I think that this is where
00:57:13 the contrast that I hope comes out tonight really resonates with people. Because oftentimes, I mean,
00:57:19 when you look at federal debates, for example, that have the Bloc Québécois, which is literally
00:57:23 only winning in one province and the liberals and the conservatives and the NDPs, which are
00:57:29 politically relevant, but, but only in a marginal third party sense. And then you get the green
00:57:34 party. And in 2019, you had the PPC, which didn't win a seat. Like it's, everyone is scrambling to
00:57:40 just get screen time and to be known. And you get these like weird pairings where, you know,
00:57:45 Elizabeth May is, you know, getting to go one-on-one with Justin Trudeau when, you know,
00:57:50 whatever you think of either, they're really not equivalent and relevant. So the idea of two people
00:57:55 that are of equal stature in politics, both of them have a conceivable shot at victory here,
00:58:01 there is really no excuse to not challenge each other on the records and on the policies and to
00:58:08 really force, if the format allows, some accountability for positions and records.
00:58:14 Yeah, and I mean, I'd be interested to know Rachel's thoughts on this too, but I would say
00:58:18 in the case of Danielle Smith, she really has to try and put forward the most optimistic
00:58:25 vision of Alberta she can. I think if it becomes all gloom and doom, that's worse for Danielle than
00:58:33 it is for Rachel. And I think because, you know, Danielle's in government and Rachel's in
00:58:38 opposition. Opposition always has to paint a more dire gloom and doom scenario than government.
00:58:44 And, you know, I once told Danielle that if there was a premier I thought she should emulate in temperament and in behaviour, I said Christy Clark, who, while what you would think of her policies notwithstanding, she was a formidable campaigner.
00:59:00 She bounded off her campaign bus, smiling, waving, shaking hands, looking like this was the happiest she's ever been in her whole life that day.
00:59:09 So I would say, look, you know, you want to see a happy, happy warrior, Danielle, who's excited about the future of Alberta.
00:59:17 And I think if she does that, it's going to paint a great contrast to Rachel Notley, who's going to try and say everything's terrible, when the reality on the ground is everything isn't terrible.
00:59:26 Alberta is doing quite well right now.
00:59:28 Ontarians, my good, you know, people like you, Andrew, are moving here in unprecedented numbers for our cheap housing and job opportunities.
00:59:35 So anybody who thinks that times are bad in Alberta hasn't walked out their front door lately.
00:59:40 I will say last time, so people in Ontario have seen by now the advertisements for Alberta is Calling,
00:59:48 where they are basically running ads on the Toronto subways and radio stations in London, Ontario, and Hamilton,
00:59:54 trying to get people to move to Alberta.
00:59:56 And the last time I saw Danielle Smith was actually at a fundraising dinner in Toronto,
01:00:01 and she gave me the Alberta is Calling pitch personally.
01:00:04 And I was with my wife, and I said, she's the one you've got to convince.
01:00:08 But it's actually been quite brilliant.
01:00:10 And Alberta is seeing a resurgence that really looked like it was lost for many years.
01:00:15 Like, I remember when we produced our documentary years ago with Calgary in crisis, and we looked
01:00:22 at the drug and homelessness issue, downtown vacancy, and it hasn't entirely rebounded
01:00:28 to the glory days.
01:00:29 But Rachel, there is, you know, basically my sense there is that it's all upside for
01:00:33 people.
01:00:34 A close to all upside. I'm going to have to push back on you just a little bit, William,
01:00:38 as someone who just finally found a place in Calgary. The Alberta is Calling campaign is
01:00:43 working far too effectively. Please stop moving here. There's no housing for you. Those of us
01:00:48 who do live here can't find affordable housing. Sorry, we're going to have to cut you off there,
01:00:51 Rachel, not because we're fact-checking you, but because the leaders debate is commencing.
01:00:55 We can go to it live right now.
01:01:00 And Judy Eldis from CBC Alberta.
01:01:03 Now, we have three main topics to cover tonight, affordability, health care and the economy, which, according to our polling, are the top issues for Albertans.
01:01:11 We also have a fourth wildcard round. In addition, both CTV and Global News have been solicited questions from you, the voters.
01:01:18 We've gotten hundreds of submissions and pared them down to two. Aaron and I will put those questions to the leaders.
01:01:25 And there are some rules tonight, and here they are. Both parties have agreed to all of these rules for tonight's debate.
01:01:32 Each leader will have one minute to make their opening remarks.
01:01:36 Over the course of the hour, 10 questions are expected.
01:01:39 Each will be directed at a specific leader who then has 45 seconds to respond.
01:01:45 The other leader will have time for a rebuttal followed by free debate.
01:01:49 And there will be an all-important countdown clock that the leaders can see here in studio
01:01:53 with 30 seconds left in their answer so they know when it is time to wrap up.
01:01:58 And as we near the end of the debate, each leader will have time to make their closing remarks to Albertans.
01:02:04 Well, the speaking order tonight was determined by a random draw and a reminder to Ms. Smith and Ms.
01:02:10 not to talk over one another.
01:02:12 We want to ensure that the discussion can be heard clearly for our audience at home.
01:02:17 And we're not going to hesitate to step in to ensure that that is the case.
01:02:21 All right. It is time to get started.
01:02:22 First up tonight, Danielle Smith from the UCP with her opening remarks.
01:02:26 Ms. Smith, you have one minute.
01:02:28 Good evening. Elections are about making important choices for you and your family.
01:02:33 This election, Albertans have a choice between a UCP government that has lowered taxes,
01:02:38 balanced the budget, and returned Alberta to its place as the economic powerhouse of Canada.
01:02:44 Or we can choose to go backward with the same failed NDP policies that hiked taxes,
01:02:49 drove out jobs and investment, and almost bankrupted our province.
01:02:54 We can't afford to go back. We need to go forward.
01:02:57 If elected, the UCP will continue to make life more affordable
01:03:01 by cutting your personal income taxes and extending the fuel tax holiday.
01:03:05 We'll crack down on criminals with more officers on the ground
01:03:09 and ankle bracelet monitoring of violent offenders out on bail.
01:03:13 And we will continue to invest in health care and mental health addiction treatment
01:03:17 while ensuring no Albertan ever has to pay out of pocket to see a family doctor.
01:03:23 Alberta's opportunities are endless, and I know our best days are still ahead.
01:03:28 Thank you, and I look forward to the debate.
01:03:30 Ms. Smith, thank you so much.
01:03:31 The floor is now yours, Ms. Notley, for your opening remarks.
01:03:35 To begin, I want to thank our firefighters and say that my thoughts are with those Albertans who are out of their homes right now.
01:03:42 Tonight, I want to talk about a better future for Alberta, where we fix health care, lower household costs, and create jobs.
01:03:50 This election is about trust and it's about leadership.
01:03:55 You know you can't trust Danielle Smith, so my offer to you is this.
01:04:00 I will work every day to be the premier you deserve, creating jobs and diversifying for the future.
01:04:07 I won't raise your taxes. I will cap your bills.
01:04:13 I won't fund a war room. I will fund an emergency room.
01:04:19 and I won't ever make you pay to see a doctor.
01:04:22 I'll protect our health care, protect our mountains,
01:04:25 and protect your pension.
01:04:27 And having learned today that Danielle Smith broke the law, 0.98
01:04:30 I will also protect our law and I will never break it.
01:04:33 When I say something, I mean it.
01:04:35 And that's the difference between Danielle and me.
01:04:38 Ms. Nutley, thank you for your opening remarks.
01:04:41 Well, affordability, rising interest rates,
01:04:43 and inflation have been top of mind.
01:04:44 Big issue for a lot of Alberta families
01:04:46 struggling to make ends meet.
01:04:47 The first series of questions tonight are based on that issue.
01:04:51 And question number one goes to Lisa Johnson from Post Media.
01:04:55 Thank you.
01:04:56 This first question is for UCP leader Danielle Smith.
01:04:59 We've been dealing with an affordability crisis for over a year.
01:05:02 We have seen temporary measures put in place, including rebates and affordability payments,
01:05:07 which are only applied to some Albertans.
01:05:11 What will you do to support all Albertans with the rising cost of living as inflation continues to have a real impact?
01:05:17 One of the first things that we knew we needed to do
01:05:20 was address the inflation crisis created, let's be fair,
01:05:23 by the Liberal NDP coalition in Ottawa,
01:05:25 spending too much money, driving up the cost of everything.
01:05:28 And there's only so much we can do here.
01:05:30 So we gave $600 affordability payments.
01:05:32 We gave a rebate on fuel taxes to offset the federal carbon tax.
01:05:36 And we also made sure that we were going to put on electricity rebates
01:05:42 so that people paid less on their power bills.
01:05:44 What we have to do going forward is more than that.
01:05:46 We know we're going to continue to see an increase in the federal carbon tax.
01:05:49 That's why we're going to offer an 8% personal income tax rate.
01:05:53 It brings us pretty much in alignment with Ontario and British Columbia.
01:05:57 It'll give $1,500 per family, and we'll also extend that fuel tax rebate until the end of the year.
01:06:03 Okay, Ms. Smith, thank you.
01:06:04 The same question to you, Ms. Notley.
01:06:05 Well, thank you.
01:06:07 You know, under the UCP, the fact is that most Albertans' utility bills look more like a mortgage payment.
01:06:13 and your insurance costs for your car well that looks more like what you save
01:06:17 up for your whole summer vacation now those costs were under the control under
01:06:22 control when we were in government because we had put caps in place to
01:06:26 protect Alberta families unfortunately the UCP chose to remove
01:06:30 them and now costs are spiraling so we're going to help we're going to put a
01:06:34 cap back on car insurance not a pretend one like Danielle Smith did a couple 0.97
01:06:38 months ago but a real one and we're going to help families produce their
01:06:42 utilities and most importantly we will never ever ever make them pay to see a family doctor
01:06:48 all right Ms. Notley thank you we're going to open it up to the first free debate on this issue
01:06:52 tonight starting with Ms. Smith and a UCB government will never ever make you pay for a family doctor 0.83
01:06:57 either what we also won't do is cause an increase in your power bills Ms. Notley is not taking 0.99
01:07:03 responsibility for the fact that she created the power bill crisis at the time Alberta party leader
01:07:08 said it was the biggest mistake of the NDP government because of their ideological changes.
01:07:13 By phasing out coal early, they added $2 billion to the cost of your power bill.
01:07:17 And as a result, we're seeing the consequences of that today.
01:07:20 And she's not stopped.
01:07:21 She wants to achieve the 2035 net zero target put forward by Justin Trudeau.
01:07:27 That'll cost $52 billion and increase your power bill another 40%.
01:07:31 We can't afford to do that.
01:07:33 Well, you know, here's the thing.
01:07:34 We actually put a cap in place.
01:07:36 And we did that so that people's utilities and their electricity wouldn't get out of control.
01:07:41 And it got out of control when the UCP removed the cap.
01:07:44 But let's talk about something else, though.
01:07:46 Let's talk about health care costs as they impact affordability.
01:07:49 You claim that you won't raise costs.
01:07:52 But, Danielle, you know, I've known you for at least a decade, perhaps more,
01:07:57 and I've watched your career, and you have argued passionately in multiple, multiple settings
01:08:02 for your belief that you care about passionately, those were your words,
01:08:06 making people pay more for their health care so my question to you is why are you not running on
01:08:12 the thing that you believe why are you not being honest with Albertans why aren't you making the
01:08:18 argument that you think having them pay more is what you want because you've said it in video
01:08:23 in papers in speaking tours in the legislature for over a decade. Ms. Smith we're going to let
01:08:29 you jump in here. I know Ms. Notley likes to show grainy videos of things I said while I was on
01:08:34 radio and the reason she does that is she doesn't want to run on her record and the reason she
01:08:38 doesn't want to run on her record is it was an absolute disaster she racked up 70 billion dollars 1.00
01:08:43 in debt more debt than any premier all actually all premiers combined in alberta's provincial
01:08:48 history she talked about deception did you remember running on a carbon tax in the last
01:08:53 election i sure didn't and that increased the cross the cost of everything we eliminated it
01:08:57 but justin trudeau wouldn't let us keep it off and now ms notley has not stood up to her boss
01:09:02 dougmeet singh in ottawa and worked with us to say don't increase that that carbon tax any further
01:09:08 and in fact certainly don't increase it 300 no one has any credibility talking about affordability
01:09:14 as long as they support a carbon tax which is going to increase the cost of everything
01:09:17 miss smith i'm sorry you talk about grainy videos but actually we had high definition 18 months ago
01:09:23 when those videos of you arguing for people to pay for their health care came out and you know
01:09:27 what? We had high definition when you said you wanted to sell our hospitals across Calgary. And
01:09:32 you know what? We had high definition a week ago when your deputy premier said that he thought
01:09:37 people should pay to use the emergency room. We're going to have to leave this right here. We've got
01:09:42 a lot to get to tonight. We've got to move on. And our next question comes from Courtney Terrio
01:09:45 from City News. Thank you. This question is for NDP leader Rachel Notley. Now, no matter the
01:09:52 provider or contract situation, utility costs remain high here in Alberta. Now, I know you
01:09:57 both touched on previous policies but my question is what can government do to bring down the actual
01:10:02 cost of utilities going forward? Well that's a very good question and what we absolutely have to do
01:10:11 is find a way to reduce those costs. A lot of Albertans aren't aware that in the pre-election
01:10:16 period the UCP put a cap on what folks are paying for their electricity just for the last four
01:10:23 months what they don't know is that in fact come june they're going to have to pay that back and
01:10:28 that's going to cost about half of alberta families about 200 million dollars so the first thing that
01:10:34 we will do is we will actually have those families backs and we won't force them to pay back the
01:10:41 of danielle smith's pre-election attempt at distracting people from what ucp policy has done
01:10:48 to their utilities. But then going forward, we have to find a way to keep those costs lower.
01:10:52 All right, Ms. Notley, that's your 45 seconds. A rebuttal to you, Ms. Smith. 45 seconds.
01:10:57 Well, the first thing is that we have to build a power grid based on it being reliable and
01:11:02 affordable as opposed to based on ideology. We have a federal government that is propped up by
01:11:07 the NDP that has put on more natural gas. Our power grid here is almost 90% natural gas,
01:11:14 and yet we have a federal government that wants us to be able to be completely abated on natural
01:11:20 gas by 2035. That is the commitment that Ms. Notley has signed on to. She wants to achieve
01:11:24 that. That's going to cost $52 billion and increase our power bills 40%. The other thing
01:11:29 that's going to happen is they also want us to phase off completely in their new green building
01:11:33 strategy, phase completely off natural gas, which one of the presidents of our large companies has
01:11:39 said would cost another $75 billion. That is not the way to get affordable energy for Albertans.
01:11:44 Okay, Ms. Notley, you now have the floor for your rebuttal.
01:11:47 Well, thank you very much.
01:11:48 Well, let me just say, first of all, that the numbers that Ms. Smith are throwing around are numbers that have been fully discredited.
01:11:54 And they've actually been discredited by the people that the UCP hired to come up with the numbers.
01:12:00 Almost the day after they came up with those numbers, the firm came out and said, nope, those weren't right.
01:12:05 And in fact, the other report that they were relying on were also deeply flawed.
01:12:11 What we know is that there is roughly $16 trillion of international investment floating around out there looking to invest in renewable energy.
01:12:21 And if we are going to be forward-looking, if we are going to create jobs, if we are going to position our economy for the future, we need to go out there and get that investment.
01:12:31 We can't look backwards.
01:12:32 We have to plan forwards.
01:12:34 That's who Albertans are.
01:12:36 Now, when we did the phase-out of coal, and we increased renewable energy in Alberta so successfully when we were in government,
01:12:45 we controlled utility costs for the sole purpose of making sure consumers didn't pay the cost.
01:12:51 And that's exactly what we would do again.
01:12:53 All right, Ms. Smith, shaking your head during much of that, you have the floor.
01:12:56 Well, I know Ms. Notley says she believes in science and she believes in experts,
01:13:00 but somehow the experts at the Alberta's electric system operators, she wants to discredit.
01:13:03 But you notice that she didn't disavow the 2035 target for net zero, even though the Saskatchewan NDP did.
01:13:11 Saskatchewan NDP voted with Premier Scott Moe, saying it is unachievable.
01:13:14 If we want to have a realistic plan, a practical plan, we have to fight back against Ottawa.
01:13:19 This candidate will not.
01:13:21 We have to fight back against Ottawa and make sure that we put a target that's reasonable, realistic and achievable.
01:13:26 And that's carbon neutrality by 2050.
01:13:28 That's the policy of our party, and that is the way that we're going to make sure
01:13:31 that we maintain reliability, affordability, and that we actually achieve our targets.
01:13:36 We'll get you back in here, Ms. Notley.
01:13:37 Well, you know, Ms. Smith, I know you're keen on fighting.
01:13:39 You want to fight with Ottawa.
01:13:41 You want to fight with the media.
01:13:43 You want to fight, frankly, with your former self.
01:13:46 It's actually quite exhausting.
01:13:48 Here's what I need Albertans to know.
01:13:50 I will always stand up for Alberta.
01:13:53 I will always stand up for the interests of Albertans.
01:13:56 I did that when I was premier I made sure we got a pipeline to Tidewater the first one in 50 years
01:14:02 I did that standing up against the BC government I did it standing up with a with a federal
01:14:08 government and that's my record and that will also be my blueprint so uh Ms Smith's um uh you
01:14:16 know I just I just have to say I disagree with so much of what you had to say there one last word
01:14:20 to Smith on this topic well Ms Notley didn't stand up when Justin Trudeau cancelled Northern
01:14:24 gateway she didn't stand up when energy east pulled the plug she didn't stand up when they 1.00
01:14:28 brought in a tanker van off the west coast for our product and she didn't stand up when the no more 0.97
01:14:33 pipelines bill was passed she will not send up in fact in fact you know we know that's not true
01:14:38 you commented on the fact that the admissions to the senate you know that that's what i did on both
01:14:43 of those issues it was too late and i must tell you where do you think justin trudeau got the
01:14:47 idea for just transition and for an emissions cap and for a carbon tax he got it from miss
01:14:52 not late when she was premier and she's going to continue to implement these same kind of policies 1.00
01:14:55 and she's going to walk in lockstep with Justin Trudeau on making sure that they get implemented
01:15:00 and that's only going to harm our economy. All right that is all the time we have for this topic
01:15:04 in fact for this portion of the debates. And when we come back we'll be talking more about
01:15:09 health care and the economy. Please stay with us.
01:15:22 you Charles R, The Making of a Monarch. An intimate look at the life of Charles over his years as the
01:15:29 heir to the throne. Through narration by Charles himself, we learn about his childhood, military
01:15:36 service, public life, and family life. Shitting light on the real personality of the man behind
01:15:44 the crown. Charles R, The Making of a Monarch. See it on CPAC.
01:15:52 A long way from Nashville and Mama, I tell you that.
01:15:55 Perform from Montreal to Boston to Los Angeles.
01:15:59 But Toronto, that's my chosen home.
01:16:01 So when I'm walking down Yonge Street, I see some funny people.
01:16:05 But the nerds want to find a grin and smile and whisper.
01:16:10 Thank you very much for that.
01:16:11 Sorry, we looked at the format and weren't aware they were going to be throwing to commercial break in this.
01:16:18 We will return to this once the debate resumes.
01:16:21 But let's just check in and get some early reaction there.
01:16:24 We get a sense of, I think, what we're probably going to see more of over the rest of the evening.
01:16:30 William, any surprises?
01:16:32 No, no surprises, except that I think earlier I said whoever becomes the most agitated,
01:16:38 whoever really loses their cool is going to lose.
01:16:41 And so far, Rachel Notley coming across far more agitated than Danielle Smith.
01:16:46 I think if you look at that last segment in particular, she almost got choked up on her unhappiness about the facts that Danielle was putting forward.
01:16:55 To her credit, I think Danielle's debate performance so far has been very solid.
01:16:59 And I think in particular, something she hasn't done, but I think she should have, and I'm glad she's now doing if you are on the conservative side, is linking Rachel Notley to Justin Trudeau and making that connection clear.
01:17:13 She did it during the leadership race. 0.97
01:17:15 She's avoided it in the first part of the campaign.
01:17:20 But this debate, she's decided to really make that linkage very clear.
01:17:24 So first few minutes of this debate, I think so far, advantage, Danielle Smith. 0.99
01:17:28 All right.
01:17:29 Well, let's get back to it right now in Edmonton.
01:17:45 .
01:18:16 When I first got elected, I was being told that the AHS system was on the brink of collapse.
01:18:22 You had unions saying that we needed to go back to mandates and start masking kids in school. 0.88
01:18:28 And I said, absolutely not. We are not going back to that.
01:18:31 If the problem is AHS, then let's fix AHS.
01:18:34 So we talked to doctors and nurses and paramedics on the front line.
01:18:37 We listened to them and we implemented their ideas.
01:18:39 And guess what? It's working.
01:18:41 Hospital wait times are down. EMS response times are down.
01:18:44 We have effectively ended red alerts for EMS in both of our major cities.
01:18:49 Ambulances in rural are staying in rural, and we're reducing surgical wait times.
01:18:53 We're going to be able to keep this going.
01:18:55 And if we continue at this rate, we will have completely eliminated our surgical backlog by this time next year
01:19:00 and be the first province in the country to do so.
01:19:02 And your rebuttal now, Ms. Notley?
01:19:04 Well, I will say Albertans have had enough of driving hundreds of kilometres to get the emergency care,
01:19:10 obstetric care, cardiac care, any kind of care that they need.
01:19:13 They're tired of looking for doctors.
01:19:15 They're tired of 15-hour waits in the emergencies rooms.
01:19:17 And they're particularly tired of having the UCP tell them,
01:19:21 oh, the problem's fixed.
01:19:22 There is no problem.
01:19:23 There is a problem.
01:19:25 We've put forward a reasonable, practical solution.
01:19:28 The answer is to get more Albertans access to a family doctor.
01:19:32 By doing that with our costed plan,
01:19:34 we can take the pressure off of our emergency rooms,
01:19:38 off of our surgical wait times, off of our ambulances.
01:19:40 And we can also make sure that nobody ever, ever, ever has to pay to see a family doctor.
01:19:48 All right. Thank you very much, Ms. Notley.
01:19:49 Once again, let's dive back into the free debate portion where you're free to challenge each other's policies, beginning with Ms. Smith. 0.91
01:19:55 You know, I heard of all of the things that Ms. Notley mentioned when I was in politics last time in 2012, and she had four years to fix it, and she didn't.
01:20:03 She didn't listen to the front line.
01:20:04 All she did was continue to build the bureaucracy, and she didn't get to local decision making. 0.80
01:20:08 She didn't get to local control.
01:20:10 we did we heard from paramedics what they wanted us to do and it was very it was actually very
01:20:14 straightforward we had to make sure that they had the ability to drop patients off when they arrived
01:20:19 on the site so that they can get back out and be there for you when you needed them and that was a
01:20:24 very straightforward idea that came from the front lines and Ms. Notley had an opportunity to fix
01:20:30 health care she didn't we're beginning on this pathway we're making great progress and we need
01:20:34 to have another mandate to continue it Ms. Notley will get you in on this yes no well quite honestly
01:20:39 as I said before Albertans are so frustrated when they're told that there isn't a problem and
01:20:43 everything has been fixed the reality is is things have gotten considerably worse over the last four
01:20:48 years the UCP cut funding dramatically they ripped up the deal with the doctors they told
01:20:54 nurses that they that they needed to be laid off they threatened to lay off 10,000 frontline
01:20:59 health care workers and then and then COVID hit so and then and the result unfortunately is is
01:21:07 we've got whole cities without access to family doctors we've got just just last
01:21:12 week we had 15 hour waits in emergency rooms all across Calgary and we've
01:21:19 recently just this year half as many doctors are accepting new patients so
01:21:25 there is a problem it's very real and selling our hospitals and forcing people
01:21:29 to pay for private care is not the solution look we signed a deal with the
01:21:35 Alberta Medical Association our health minister negotiated that we're going to
01:21:39 have 25% of our doctors on an alternative payment system within the
01:21:43 next five years and that allows for team practice it allows for nurse 0.70
01:21:46 practitioners and LPNs psychologists and other health practitioners to work
01:21:51 together in a team practice so that more access will be given on primary care
01:21:55 we put two billion dollars towards this and we're making great progress we have
01:21:59 more health professionals today than we did when Miss Notley left office 8500
01:22:03 more, in fact, including 700 more doctors. And in April, our plan to recognize credentials is
01:22:09 working. We had 1,400 nurses who are now licensed and able to practice in Alberta more than any time 0.98
01:22:15 in the previous three years. The system is working. We've got much more work to do. We know that,
01:22:20 but we've got to continue on the work that we have because I've got the courage. I've got the
01:22:23 courage to talk to the front line, and I've got the courage to be able to implement some of the
01:22:27 suggestions that they make. Ms. Notley has demonstrated. We're just going to leave it
01:22:30 that question because we have another one on health right now. You bet. Our next question is
01:22:34 from Lisa Johnson from Post Media. There is already a lot of private delivery in our public
01:22:39 health care system which has existed under the NDP and UCP governments. What criteria would you
01:22:45 apply to determine when expanded private delivery is appropriate? And we'll go to Ms. Notley first
01:22:51 please. Well honestly I mean at this point what we would always look at is to get the best care
01:22:57 for the greatest number of people in the most efficient and cost-effective way.
01:23:02 Now, as you may know, there was a study that came out today,
01:23:05 just today, on the success of the Alberta government's surgical care initiative.
01:23:10 And what they concluded was that the number of surgeries went down
01:23:15 and the cost went up.
01:23:16 Now, that's not entirely surprising because most often,
01:23:19 when you engage in experimentation with privatization, that's what happens.
01:23:23 It's the same thing that's going on with the lab situation in Calgary right now.
01:23:28 With the UCP's intention to increase private lab services,
01:23:32 we now see Calgarians waiting up to a month to get a simple blood test.
01:23:36 It doesn't work. We need to focus on public health care.
01:23:40 All right, Ms. Notley, that is your 45 seconds. Ms. Smith, over to you.
01:23:43 We need to have publicly funded health care for both doctors and doctor-run surgical centres.
01:23:49 We have 300,000 surgeries being done per year.
01:23:53 60,000 of them are in doctor-run surgical centres that Ms. Notley apparently wants to shut down. 0.96
01:23:58 She hasn't answered the question about how we would be able to replace those surgeries.
01:24:02 And I can tell you what is actually happening because a lot has changed since November when we started making these changes in health care.
01:24:08 What has happened, in fact, is that we identified that there were 39,000 people waiting longer than medically recommended.
01:24:15 We've been cutting that list down by 3,000 surgeries per month.
01:24:18 We're now down to 30,000 people waiting.
01:24:21 And as I said, if we continue at this pace,
01:24:23 those waits will be completely over by this time next year.
01:24:25 And I think that's something to celebrate and continue.
01:24:27 Okay, let's open up the floor now to some free debate.
01:24:30 Let's start with you, Ms. Motley.
01:24:31 Well, thank you.
01:24:32 I mean, again, I think that we need to understand
01:24:35 that there is a very, very serious problem.
01:24:37 And we are not a year away from fixing all these problems.
01:24:40 Ms. Smith, unfortunately, is playing a bit with the statistics. 0.99
01:24:44 Last November, we had a COVID wave and a flu wave.
01:24:48 and she's now comparing statistics to that period of time.
01:24:51 It's a seasonal change that she's trying to convince
01:24:54 is turning into a long-term trend, but it's not real.
01:24:57 What is real is that this year, or this spring,
01:25:00 B.C., Saskatchewan, and Manitoba
01:25:02 filled all of their residency spots for family doctors.
01:25:06 Alberta, for the first time, had 45 vacancies.
01:25:10 And then they offered them up again, and there were still vacancies.
01:25:13 And we don't have family doctors coming to work here in Alberta.
01:25:17 And the reason is because Ms. Smith is doing things like referring to them as tyrants 1.00
01:25:22 and suggesting that people who follow public health orders are Nazi sympathizers.
01:25:27 And these things undermine the ability to attract frontline health care professionals.
01:25:32 They don't feel respected and they don't feel that this government is at all focused on science and having their back.
01:25:38 Go ahead.
01:25:38 Our doctors, nurses, paramedics and other health professionals are the heroes of our health care system.
01:25:44 Everybody knows that.
01:25:45 What I find so interesting is that Ms. Notley isn't running at all on her record from when she was premier 0.82
01:25:50 because she would have to admit that surgical wait times actually went up for nine key surgeries.
01:25:55 She'd have to admit that she didn't actually have the courage to take on the challenge of reforming health care.
01:26:01 I do. I have. We're already making progress. Of course, there's much more to do.
01:26:05 But I am confident that with a new mandate, we'll be able to continue making this progress.
01:26:10 The next step, of course, is building out our primary care system,
01:26:13 building out continuing care and adding more home care
01:26:15 so that people can age in place 0.93
01:26:17 and making sure that we've got that team practice
01:26:19 so that anybody has access to health care when they need it.
01:26:22 Ms. Natalie, get her to respond.
01:26:24 Yes, well, I mean, I think the fundamental problem here
01:26:26 is that Albertans are deeply concerned at the notion
01:26:29 of a Danielle Smith-led government reforming health care
01:26:32 in any way, shape or form.
01:26:34 She claims she's guaranteed that nobody will ever pay for a doctor,
01:26:37 But, you know, Ms. Smith, I was with you in the legislature in 2014.
01:26:42 You stood up and you guaranteed you would never cross the floor.
01:26:45 Three weeks later, you crossed the floor.
01:26:48 Your understanding of the word guarantee is very different than that of most Albertans.
01:26:53 And most people are deeply, deeply troubled at the prospect of you reforming health care
01:26:59 based on your 15-year record of advocating to make people pay out of pocket.
01:27:04 Okay, we are there out of time for this one issue, but we're going to move on.
01:27:09 And economy, definitely something that many Albertans are concerned about as we head forward,
01:27:16 given the historic reliance on the oil and gas sector for jobs and government revenue,
01:27:21 the world beginning to shift away from petroleum products.
01:27:24 Economy and jobs are the key issue in this portion of the debate.
01:27:27 With the first question, here is Courtney Theriault from City News.
01:27:30 Now, both of you have made many promises in this election,
01:27:34 committing to billions in new spending with the price of oil sitting below budget projections at
01:27:40 various times this year and given that volatility how will you pay for these commitments and stay on
01:27:45 budget without steep cuts that first question going to miss smith well i must say i know aaron
01:27:51 in the in the intro talked about shifting away from petroleum products and i would say that that
01:27:57 is the the notly view of the world that is certainly not my government's view of the world
01:28:01 We believe that we are going to reduce emissions, not that we are going to reduce oil and natural gas.
01:28:06 We know that with all of the exciting things that are happening with carbon capture, utilization and storage and all the green technology,
01:28:12 we can continue to have a robust, vibrant oil and natural gas sector for years to come.
01:28:18 What we want to do is make sure that we are finding more opportunities for our products.
01:28:22 Having bitumen be used more for asphalt so it reduces the amount of emissions.
01:28:26 Having LNG export, which creates a brand new stream of income for us.
01:28:30 We know that as long as we keep our energy industry strong, we're going to keep Alberta's economy strong.
01:28:35 Ms. Notley won't do that. I will. 0.91
01:28:37 Okay, we'll leave it there. Ms. Notley, your rebuttal.
01:28:39 Well, you know, there was actually some elements of what Ms. Smith said that I actually agree with.
01:28:44 You know, I want to create jobs producing energy.
01:28:47 I want to create jobs upgrading our energy.
01:28:51 And I want to create jobs reducing emissions.
01:28:54 And reducing emissions is absolutely the focus.
01:28:56 It's not about reducing or production.
01:28:59 It is about emissions.
01:29:00 The difference is that Ms. Smith and her caucus have spent much of their career pitting emissions reduction efforts against economic growth.
01:29:10 And when we do that, we fail on both.
01:29:13 What we want to do is understand the economic opportunity that comes from investing in emissions reductions,
01:29:20 attracting investment from other parts of the world, and growing jobs while ensuring greater markets for our oil and gas.
01:29:26 All right. Thank you, Ms. Notley. Let's go back to our free debate format right now on this
01:29:30 economic question. Ms. Smith, to you. Ms. Notley has so many anti-oil and gas candidates. I have
01:29:35 lost count, including one who compared it to slavery. And I know that he hasn't apologized
01:29:39 yet, nor have you, or condemned his comments. What I would say is that when you take a position
01:29:44 of increasing business taxes, you're creating a lot of uncertainty in our sector. We took the 12%
01:29:51 tax that ms notley had imposed brought it down to eight percent look what happened year over year
01:29:56 we ended up diversifying our economy attracting more investment creating more jobs more people
01:30:02 are coming into this province than ever before and what a bonus we now have more corporate income
01:30:07 revenue than we have in our history 6.4 billion dollars when you reduce taxes you end up attracting
01:30:13 jobs and investment and people when you increase taxes you chase it away she wants to increase
01:30:18 taxes again? We can't let her do that. Ms. Notley. Well, two points there. First of all, I find it
01:30:23 deeply ironic that Ms. Smith is talking about uncertainty and its impact on attracting
01:30:29 investment. This is a person who, well, started by bringing in the Sovereignty Act, an act that
01:30:34 her former finance minister very clearly said was going to chase away investment because it
01:30:40 undermined the rule of law. That, of course, was before she was found today to have broken the law
01:30:46 in an effort to support the private interests of someone accused of wanting to promote violence against the police.
01:30:54 All of that chases away investment because it is such a profound compromise to the rule of law.
01:31:01 But also, let me talk for just a moment about the issue of corporate taxes.
01:31:04 Here's what we're going to do.
01:31:05 We are going to take the lowest corporate taxes in the country and move them to be the lowest corporate taxes in the country.
01:31:15 lower than Scott Moe's, lower than Doug Ford's.
01:31:19 And at the same time, we will have the income necessary
01:31:22 to rebuild our education, rebuild our post-secondary,
01:31:25 and invest appropriately in a stable system of health care.
01:31:28 And all of that creates and attracts investment.
01:31:31 Back to Ms. Smith.
01:31:32 Ms. Notley, it's you and the CBC who need to apologize for Albertans.
01:31:35 You flat out lied for several months saying that I and my office had contact Crown prosecutors.
01:31:40 She said that is absolutely not true.
01:31:41 And she also confirmed that I did not direct or interfere in any COVID-related cases.
01:31:47 I would say that we have increased the amount of investment that has happened in our province.
01:31:52 We have a $760 million renewable diesel project announced by Imperial.
01:31:57 We have $600 million that came in from McCain's.
01:32:00 Our Pathways Oil Sands Group is investing.
01:32:03 We have an increase in the amount of drilling rigs.
01:32:05 That is not a sign that people have lost confidence in our economy.
01:32:09 you know what it is a sign of that when you stand up to ottawa and you tell the industry that you're
01:32:12 gonna you're gonna stand up for them they actually increase their amount of confidence and they
01:32:17 increase their except that we have fewer corporate headquarters in calgary in alberta now than we did
01:32:22 before in 2019 before you announced your incredibly uh uh spendthrift uh corporate handle all right
01:32:30 that's gonna do it for this question we have another economic question coming right now and
01:32:33 And that's coming from Judy Aldis of CBC.
01:32:36 Thank you.
01:32:37 You both mentioned the desire to reduce emissions.
01:32:42 Both of your parties have signaled the desire, in fact, to move towards a net zero future.
01:32:48 So, Ms. Notley, we'll start with you.
01:32:50 Can you outline for us specific actions that you will take to make sure that that happens?
01:32:56 Well, that's a very good question.
01:32:58 So let me first point out, in contrast to what Ms. Smith had said previously,
01:33:02 is that I was actually the first political leader in Alberta over a year ago to speak out on behalf of Albertans
01:33:11 and point out that the draft emissions targets coming from the federal government were unrealistic.
01:33:17 I do, however, believe that we need to come up with a Made in Alberta plan
01:33:21 that includes practical, achievable emissions limits,
01:33:25 and then we need to find and incent the investment.
01:33:29 We have to compete with the U.S. and the Inflation Reduction Act to get that investment,
01:33:33 but there's a lot out there, and we have some of that set out in our platform, but there's more to do.
01:33:41 Okay, Ms. Smith, you're up next.
01:33:42 Actually, what Ms. Notley has said is that she believes we need an emissions cap,
01:33:46 and it needs to be very close to what the federal government is proposing.
01:33:50 The federal government is proposing a 42% emissions cap reduction by 2030,
01:33:55 which we know is a de facto production cap.
01:33:58 And if we have a production cap, it means that we're going to reduce the overall amount of revenues.
01:34:03 She has also confirmed, and not denied it this evening, that she agrees with the federal proposal for a net zero power grid by 2035,
01:34:10 which we know will cost $52 billion, and increase your electricity bills by 40%.
01:34:14 We have seen this newsreel before. It's why she doesn't want to talk about her record.
01:34:19 When she came in, increased the corporate tax, brought through a surprise carbon tax, increased personal income taxes,
01:34:24 183,000 jobs were lost in the first couple of years.
01:34:27 well let me just say first of all when we talk about my record in oil and gas I
01:34:31 think it's kind of hard to forget the big thing which is the first pipeline to
01:34:37 Tidewater in 50 years that's my record so so that's the first thing secondly
01:34:42 your numbers around job losses I think we need to kind of talk a little bit
01:34:47 about that Danielle many many experts have reviewed that and they've said
01:34:50 they're absolutely ridiculous in fact at the end of our term we had after a very
01:34:56 difficult recession we came out about 45 000 jobs ahead and if we were to use your means of coming
01:35:03 up with that 180 000 number the number of jobs lost under the ucp would be over 250 000 so i
01:35:11 think albertans really deserve leadership that will not try to mislead them but will actually
01:35:16 have conversations based on applicable and relevant facts all right sure i'm happy to use the the same
01:35:22 measure because if you look at our measure we have increased our net jobs 136 000 since uh the
01:35:30 ucp got elected so that's uh by my count i guess uh three times what ms notley was able to do and
01:35:37 there's a reason for that is because investor confidence has returned people know that if you
01:35:42 elect a ucp government you're going to get lower corporate taxes we're not going to come through
01:35:45 with surprise taxes in fact we're going to have a tax hike guarantee so that if there is uh ever
01:35:52 a proposal for an increase in carbon tax or personal taxes or sales taxes it has to be put
01:35:57 to the people because these kinds of policies end up chasing away investment and it costs average
01:36:02 taxpayers and costs average citizens the most. Ms. Notley won't agree to that and the reason for 0.99
01:36:07 that is she wants to increase corporate taxes which are going to once again chase out investment 1.00
01:36:11 just like it did last time. Don't want to cut you off but I want to get Ms. Notley in here. 1.00
01:36:15 When the UCP announced their multi-billion dollar corporate handout to corporations here's what
01:36:21 happened we lost 50,000 jobs we doubled the deficit and the economy slowed down
01:36:27 four years later we have fewer corporate headquarters than we started out with so
01:36:32 the fact of the matter is is we have lower we will still under our plan have
01:36:37 lower corporate taxes than Scott Moe than Doug Ford but what we'll also have is the
01:36:42 money to invest in our education system something that's been horrifically
01:36:46 starved under the ucp restore funding to our post-secondary a critical partner in economic
01:36:52 growth is not we're going to have to end this portion of of the debate all right up next our
01:36:57 viewer and wildcard questions we're going to shift gears a little bit you're watching the
01:37:01 alberta provincial leaders debate back in just two minutes
01:37:04 we are back another little break here in the alberta leaders debate you're tuned into true
01:37:27 north's live coverage featuring uh you by featuring it might be a bit of a stretch i'm
01:37:32 here andrew lawton and featuring rachel emmanuel and william mcbeth another little check-in on
01:37:38 what's been happening in the course of the debate let's go to you on this one rachel what's your
01:37:44 read i mean what's been standing out so far yeah things are moving pretty quickly as you would
01:37:49 expect but i have to say that i've noticed that danielle smith seems to be taking william's advice
01:37:54 she has kept things very positive we see her bringing up the positive parts of her government's
01:37:59 record their investment bringing in jobs people flooding to the province as well as the work
01:38:04 they've done to bring down health care wait times as we talked a little bit about in the pre-show
01:38:08 so she's coming across as someone who's very excited about the work that our government has
01:38:12 done and that she hopes to continue doing she's smiling a lot she's keeping it very positive and
01:38:16 rachel notley is really on the attack she's bringing up things about the ucp government
01:38:20 that she didn't like you know things like danielle smith is going to privatize health care you can't 0.97
01:38:24 trust the premier so i think we're seeing kind of what william said in the pre-show we're seeing
01:38:28 danielle smith keeping it really light keeping it really positive looking excited looking enthusiastic
01:38:33 and rachel notley is kind of going for the jugular she's attacking danielle smith and she's attacking 1.00
01:38:38 the ucp's record that's what really has stood out to me at this point and i just haven't i don't
01:38:42 know that i've ever really seen danielle smith so positive so smiley so upbeat in a public
01:38:47 appearance before and we can see that she's putting a strong emphasis on that in tonight's
01:38:51 showing all right let's go to you william have there been any double take moments or any surprising
01:38:57 moments so far for you uh no i mean you know everybody goes into a debate looking for the
01:39:04 knockout punch the the you sir had a choice for a moment with brian mo rooney but that almost never
01:39:10 happens in a debate i do believe danielle brought her a game to the debate tonight though she is 1.00
01:39:16 landing a lot of her points all right great point william let's get back to the debate
01:39:27 that's the increased enrollment teacher burnout increased class sizes and complexity in alberta
01:39:46 school classrooms miss smith we're going to begin with you we have had so much disruption in our
01:39:52 education system in the last three years one of the first things i wanted to do is restore
01:39:57 stability to the learning environment for our kids we know one of the most difficult things that our
01:40:02 young people are facing is social anxiety and mental health and so part of that's part of the
01:40:08 reason why we now spend more money than we ever have in our history on education we have invested
01:40:14 in complexity funding for classrooms so that school boards can decide what the best use of
01:40:18 that is whether hiring more teachers or having education assistants or other psychologists
01:40:24 and we're going to to make sure that we continue to build more schools we've built or modernized 106
01:40:29 new schools and we're going to keep on on doing that the uh under the uh the the notley government
01:40:34 they only built 47 schools okay miss notley so much of that's not true but let me start with this
01:40:41 i have watched for four years with great alarm what the ucp has been doing to our school system 0.75
01:40:47 I imagine a six-year-old child in grade one in a class that unfortunately has 28, 29, 31,
01:40:55 32 children in it and she puts her hand up to get help and she waits for a minute, two minutes,
01:41:02 three minutes and nobody comes. So she puts it down and it happens a few more times and she
01:41:07 stops trying. Over the last four years we've had 35,000 net new children enter our schools and the
01:41:14 the UCP have not hired a single new teacher in fact they fired some and they also fired about
01:41:20 10,000 educational assistants by tweet we have a plan to fix this and I look forward to talking
01:41:25 more about it all right Ms. Notley that is your 45 seconds let's go to free debate now Ms. Smith 0.99
01:41:29 well I think that what people might be forgetting is we did have a lot of disruption over the last
01:41:34 few years and that's part of the reason we need to have stability back in our system I don't think
01:41:39 teachers forget though that under Ms. Notley they got no wage increases zero percent year after year
01:41:44 under UCP government we gave them a much deserved 3.75 percent wage increase and I think that that's
01:41:51 what we're hearing from from the front line they want to be respected they want to be supported
01:41:55 with educational assistance and they also want to have a little bit of stability so that they
01:42:00 have time to deal with the very severe mental health crisis of our kids. There have been profound
01:42:05 funding cuts to our education system under the UCP. We now have the most
01:42:11 crowded classrooms in the country. That was not the case when we left office
01:42:16 but it is the case now. They, as I said, fired 10,000 educational assistants by
01:42:21 tweet on a weekend. They also, in order to cut their budget, they did it on the
01:42:26 backs of vulnerable children with disabilities ages three to six by
01:42:31 cutting hundreds of millions of dollars from PUF funding. What that meant is
01:42:37 that kids all across our province are falling through the cracks. I've been to
01:42:40 schools where teachers and EAs are crying about what they can't get a handle on. So
01:42:45 the stress wasn't COVID, the stress is this government. We have a plan to hire
01:42:50 4,000 teachers to try to catch up over the next four years, 3,000 more EAs and
01:42:56 to restore PUF funding. All right let's get Smith back in there. Well I would say
01:42:59 that ms notley had the opportunity to address class size and indeed she put forward a proposal
01:43:05 to do exactly that a proposal that the auditor general said was so badly implemented they
01:43:10 couldn't actually track whether it was successful or not and didn't actually know where the where
01:43:14 the funding went we know that the very best people to make the decision about what ought to happen in
01:43:20 the classroom are our locally elected school trustees that's why we're giving more funding
01:43:24 for mental health more funding for complexity more funding for transportation making sure
01:43:29 that every school district has the funding it needs to make its own decisions about what the
01:43:34 best mix in the classroom is so that they can meet the local needs all right that is our time
01:43:38 for that unfortunately we have to get to our next viewer question and here it is and this question
01:43:42 comes from alex hamilton from edmonton alex says please tell us one specific policy your opponent
01:43:49 has put forward that you agree with and why miss notley well you know that's a really good question
01:43:55 and I will say this and I've said it before it's actually two I'm gonna go
01:43:59 with two so you know very early on in the UCP mandate it was under the former
01:44:05 premier Jason Kenney they introduced the Alberta Indigenous Opportunities
01:44:09 Corporation as a means to expand indigenous participation in our economy 0.85
01:44:14 we like it we're going to expand it and we're going to expand the number of
01:44:19 opportunities that that would qualify for that kind of support with indigenous
01:44:24 communities across the province another one was they expanded funding of the
01:44:30 film and TV tax credit and that was a good idea it's it's it's brought more
01:44:35 excitement into our industry we will absolutely maintain that and we look
01:44:39 forward to it all right thanks very much Ms. Notley and Ms. Smith once again
01:44:42 specific policies that you agree with for the NDP I'm very proud of both of the
01:44:48 the initiatives that Ms. Notley mentioned the Indigenous Opportunities
01:44:52 corporation has been so successful I think in addressing true economic
01:44:56 reconciliation and the film and TV tax credit brought the last of us here which
01:45:00 I think all of us feel pretty excited when we watch that on the big screen
01:45:04 what I think Ms. Nutley and I would agree with is that we know that there
01:45:09 are a number of doctors who are now wanting to specialize and I completely
01:45:12 understand a lot of time goes into becoming a doctor and so we're seeing
01:45:16 fewer doctors go into family medicine and so we I think we would both agree
01:45:20 that we need to move towards team practice that we need to make sure that we've got team practices
01:45:25 for family doctors to work with nurse practitioners lpns and other health professionals to ensure
01:45:30 everybody gets the health care they need without having to pay for it okay thank you both it
01:45:33 doesn't really lend itself to much free debate that question but we're glad that we got that
01:45:38 one in that because uh we really like that one so let's head to our next question and this is
01:45:42 a wild card question on a theme that's outside of our main topics here's lisa johnson from post media
01:45:47 Thank you. This election may be decided by who Albertans trust more.
01:45:54 Ms. Notley, based on the NDP's fiscal record in government, there are some people who don't trust you to manage Alberta's finances.
01:46:02 And Ms. Smith, you were found today to have broken conflict of interest rules.
01:46:07 Why should Albertans trust you? Ms. Smith, this question goes to you first.
01:46:12 Well, first what I would say is that when Ms. Notley campaigned last time around,
01:46:16 she didn't tell anybody she was going to increase the carbon tax.
01:46:19 She brought in a business tax, and she also ended up running up more debt 0.99
01:46:24 than we've seen of any premier in our province's history.
01:46:28 And the results speak for themselves.
01:46:29 We saw 183,000 jobs lost in the first couple of years.
01:46:33 We had a number of people moving out.
01:46:35 We had 13 quarters of people leaving this province.
01:46:39 In fact, the energy minister at the time said,
01:46:41 well, if you can't find a job in Alberta, go work in B.C. for a while.
01:46:45 That kind of defeatist attitude is not what Alberta is all about.
01:46:48 Alberta is back on track.
01:46:50 We have more people coming in here than ever before.
01:46:53 Our Alberta is calling campaign is working.
01:46:56 We've got more diversification and business investment.
01:46:58 We've got to keep that going.
01:46:59 All right. Thank you, Ms. Smith.
01:47:00 Ms. Notley, the floor is yours.
01:47:03 First of all, let me say, I guess there's two things.
01:47:06 First of all, I was very pleased to roll out a pretty well thought out costing document for
01:47:12 our platform and that document ensures that over three years we would maintain a cumulative
01:47:20 surplus of 3.6 billion dollars. That is on in contrast to what the UCP hurriedly rushed out
01:47:28 today which would actually very possibly go into deficit in the third year and is considerably
01:47:33 smaller surplus than what we're proposing and so that calls into question many of the items that
01:47:39 they're proposing to Albertans the other thing I would say I've been in office since 2008 I have
01:47:44 never actually breached the conflict of interest legislation Ms. Smith cannot say the same well I
01:47:49 guess I guess you're you did have an MLA who hacked our health care system I can I can tell
01:47:53 you do you really want to talk about our candidates and our MLAs like seriously I do not think you're
01:47:59 you're going to win that one. That is not one you want to do. I have to tell you, when I'm putting
01:48:03 together our affordability payments, to have to ask whether it was going to be hack-proof from
01:48:07 the NDP, that's not something that Ms. Notley should be very proud of. What I will also say
01:48:12 is that when she came out with her costing document, it was almost immediately discredited
01:48:16 because Todd Hirsch said he hadn't done the analysis on what kind of impact it would have
01:48:22 on chasing away investment. Others did. Trevor Toome did. Jack Mintz did. There are several
01:48:27 business reporters who did the alberta chamber of commerce did and what they have said is that
01:48:32 would create instability and the instability would chase additional this uh investment out it would 0.64
01:48:37 chase jobs out and we would go back and have a rerun of what we did in the period of time that
01:48:41 ms nutley doesn't want to talk about which was when she was premier all right ms nutley obviously
01:48:45 has thoughts on this back to you um i do yes i mean obviously uh the fact of the matter is is
01:48:50 that many of those people uh back uh peddled on some of that the credit union has actually said
01:48:55 there's not a problem uh with the increase of the corporate income tax to being the lowest corporate
01:49:01 income tax in the country and indeed it seems to work okay in in ontario because heaven knows they
01:49:06 are attracting far more venture capital and business than we are in alberta under the ucp
01:49:12 but i do want to go back to this issue of the conflict of interest legislation this is a
01:49:18 fundamentally important issue miss smith you were found to have broken the law in order to interfere
01:49:27 with the system of justice to assist with somebody who had been charged with attempting to get people
01:49:34 to commit violence against police officers we're going to let you know we're talking about instability
01:49:39 that does not engender trust that more than that it engenders fear on the part of albertans miss
01:49:46 Ms. Notley, the NDP and the CBC lied for months saying that I was calling Crown prosecutors
01:49:51 and my staff are calling Crown prosecutors and it wasn't true.
01:49:55 And that is what the ethics commissioner found.
01:49:57 Look, I'm a non-lawyer and I know that I need to be able to talk to my justice minister.
01:50:02 I'm looking forward to advice on how to be able to do that more constructively in the future.
01:50:06 I think that's important for us to be able to get those kind of rules set out.
01:50:10 But I will say we continue to have this issue.
01:50:13 I am running on my record.
01:50:14 Miss Notley is running away from hers and there is a reason for that. The Global Petroleum Survey
01:50:20 is one of the surveys that looks at what our business environment looks like. When she got
01:50:25 elected in 2015 we were number three in the world. By 2018 we were number 43 in the world. This is
01:50:31 the reason she doesn't want to talk about her record. Forgive us we are running out of time.
01:50:34 We're almost at the end of the debate so we do have to move on. We do. We have one final wild
01:50:37 card question and here is City TV's Courtney Theriault. Well thanks again. Both parties have
01:50:42 insisted they would increase the number of police officers in major centers, but on the surface
01:50:47 that would only allow them to better respond to crimes as they're committed. So in terms of
01:50:52 creating safer communities beyond boots on the ground, what distinguishes your approach from
01:50:57 your opponents? And we'll go to Ms. Notley first. Well that's a really very good question. So you
01:51:03 know I was pleased to see that Ms. Smith made the announcement to restore the funding to police
01:51:10 officers that the ucp cut at the beginning of their term by hiring 150 officers we matched that
01:51:17 and then we also went further and said we would also hire 150 more social workers mental health
01:51:22 therapists those kinds of folks we would to help with with social disorder on our streets because
01:51:29 we know that's worrisome to people very worrisome we also however have committed to restoring
01:51:35 funding for affordable housing under the ucp we've lost 8 000 affordable housing units
01:51:40 and a further 4 000 people were cut off of shelter allowances and that level of homelessness
01:51:46 has created a real crisis contributing to the concerns around community safety all right miss
01:51:52 smith your time well first off we wouldn't defund the police again ms notley has so many defund the
01:51:57 police candidates on her platform on her candidate roster i've lost count of them as well the the
01:52:03 The frontline services are demoralized, and we are giving courage and confidence back to our frontline officers.
01:52:09 We've embedded sheriffs in both Calgary and Edmonton.
01:52:11 We're adding 100 police officers in both Calgary and Edmonton
01:52:14 because we believe that people have a right to take public transit and feel safe.
01:52:19 They have a right to go downtown and be able to have a nice dinner or see a game
01:52:23 and not worry that they're going to be randomly attacked.
01:52:26 And they certainly have a right to walk past an open doorway without having to inhale secondhand crystal meth smoke.
01:52:32 We have an approach that is going to make sure that we crack down on public safety and crime
01:52:37 and make sure that people feel safe again.
01:52:39 All right, thank you, Ms. Smith.
01:52:41 We've got about 90 seconds for this free debate.
01:52:43 Ms. Notley.
01:52:43 Well, I need to start by saying when it comes to defunding the police,
01:52:47 the UCP actually defunded the police.
01:52:50 The money that they used to hire the $150 is a restoration of the money they cut in 2019.
01:52:57 And that's on top of additional police grants that they cut from municipal governments
01:53:02 right when they first got elected so the actual defunding of the police is
01:53:06 something that I think they should take a responsibility for. You know one thing
01:53:10 I'm so proud about with our UCP record is it's the what's being known as the
01:53:14 Alberta model for a recovery oriented system of care because we know policing
01:53:20 is only one side of the story the other is getting people the help that they
01:53:23 need and my chief of staff is one of the foremost experts on the recovery
01:53:27 oriented system of care we got rid of the forty dollar per day user fee that
01:53:31 Ms. Notley-Charge. We've added 10,000 treatment beds. We're building recovery communities,
01:53:35 some in conjunction with First Nations partners, and we are going to make sure that every single
01:53:40 person who wants addiction treatment has access to a treatment bed. Those two things have to go
01:53:45 together. Quickly, Ms. Notley, you've got 20 seconds to rebut. Well, listen, I think more
01:53:50 recovery beds is a great thing. Absolutely. And I actually agree with the fact that the
01:53:55 accommodation charge associated with those beds that's been in place for two decades is now gone.
01:54:00 That's great news, but there's more to it.
01:54:03 There's more about wraparound services, transitional housing,
01:54:07 those kinds of supports, and those remain unfunded right now.
01:54:10 Okay, thank you.
01:54:11 Some spirited debate.
01:54:12 Absolutely.
01:54:12 Love it. I love it.
01:54:13 Okay, we are now going to head to our closing remarks.
01:54:17 Each leader will have 90 seconds.
01:54:19 And this is one final chance for those leaders to make their pitch to Albertans.
01:54:23 We start with Daniel Smith.
01:54:25 I first want to say how much of an honor it's been
01:54:27 to be your premier for these last seven months.
01:54:30 I've been overwhelmed by the generosity and kindness of Albertans that I meet every single day.
01:54:36 These last three years have been difficult for all of us.
01:54:40 And now the wildfires are testing our resolve as a people once more.
01:54:44 But I know that together we will overcome every challenge we face,
01:54:48 whether it's a pandemic, a flood, a fire, or economic headwinds.
01:54:52 We will take care of one another and we will move our province forward to a better future.
01:54:57 my commitment to each of you if re-elected is to serve you with everything i have and to the best
01:55:03 of my ability however imperfect that may be at times i will continue to focus on growing
01:55:10 and diversifying our amazing economy making life more affordable and our communities safer and
01:55:16 improving health care for all albertans and i will carefully listen to you and my ucp caucus
01:55:23 because whatever i may have said or thought in the past while i was on talk radio
01:55:27 albertans are my bosses now and my oath is to serve you and no one else i love this province
01:55:35 and everything it stands for we are a land of entrepreneurs and innovators of pioneers and
01:55:41 farmers of families and communities a place where the best and brightest come from every
01:55:47 corner of the world to join us in building one of the greatest places on earth to live
01:55:52 and work and raise a family from a bottom of my heart thank you and good night okay 90 seconds
01:55:57 over to you ms notley well thank you so much tonight ask yourself who do you trust to build
01:56:04 a better future who will focus on the things that actually matter to you now ms smith has spent her
01:56:11 entire career campaigning for albertans to pay out of pocket for basic health care she's also
01:56:19 campaigned to pull Alberta out of the Canada Pension Plan, something that would create huge
01:56:24 instability in your retirement. Today, she was found to have broken the law by interfering
01:56:31 with our justice system. This is just not how our province should be run. Every day is
01:56:38 a new drama. You just don't need to put up with this. Enough is enough. So my offer to
01:56:44 you is stable, predictable, thoughtful leadership that you can count on. It's time to get back to
01:56:50 the things that matter to people. I will make life more affordable, capping car insurance and
01:56:56 lowering your utilities. I will support our entrepreneurial spirit by cutting to zero
01:57:02 small business taxes and creating more jobs. And because I'm passionate about making sure
01:57:07 your family has health care that you always need without paying for it, I have a balanced
01:57:13 costed plan to make sure you get a family doctor so that is a better future for alberta now you 0.92
01:57:19 may not always agree with me and i may not have always gotten it right but i say what i mean and
01:57:24 i mean what i say if i am premier again i will work daily to earn your trust and to focus on your
01:57:33 priorities thank you thank you miss notley unfortunately we are out of time that does
01:57:37 wrap up the 2023 alberta provincial leaders debate our thanks once again to ndp leader
01:57:42 rachel notley and ucp leader danielle smith for taking part tonight also a big thank you to our
01:57:47 panelists for participating and here's this a reminder election date just 11 days away may 29th
01:57:54 it is your chance to exercise your democratic right to vote thank you for watching and good night
01:58:00 from edmonton epac brings you
01:58:03 welcome back everyone this is true north's live election night well not election i know that's
01:58:17 in 11 days they just said it but our live debate night show for the alberta election the one and
01:58:22 only chance for us to see the leaders in action william i'm gonna need you to take another sip
01:58:27 and turn that around. You did it all wrong. There you go. There you go. That is our True North mug.
01:58:34 And by the way, we just have one left. So anyone who donate the first, well, actually the next
01:58:39 person who donates $150 gets one of those True North mugs, a very limited run. We only had five
01:58:46 and there is just one remaining. And I mean, we thank all of you for your generous support of
01:58:51 independent media. In this case, we're bribing you with a mug, but it's actually a very good mug. I
01:58:56 was drinking my evening coffee out of mine and there was enough room in it for enough coffee to
01:59:00 get through what were at some point a bit of a slog. But let's just talk about format here for
01:59:06 a moment. I'm Andrew Lawton, joined by Rachel Emanuel and William Macbeth. This was the one
01:59:10 chance for these two leaders to go head to head. And it was one hour with commercial breaks. I mean,
01:59:17 did we even scratch the surface, Rachel? Yeah, I definitely felt like it could have been a little
01:59:22 bit longer it didn't feel like we heard from them too much and it was kind of over before i knew it
01:59:27 often by the time we get to the end of these things i'm like oh thank goodness it's over but
01:59:31 in this case i was like oh it's over already so definitely could have gone on for a bit longer
01:59:35 they could have been given a little bit more time for debate i would have been a little bit more
01:59:39 interested to really dig into some of the public safety stuff the ucp is announcing really novel
01:59:45 ideas on how to deal with a mental health and addictions crisis and i know that danielle smith
01:59:50 did get an opportunity to bring up some of those policies but we hardly heard about that we
01:59:55 certainly didn't hear what not least plan on mental health and addictions was and the two
01:59:58 didn't really have an opportunity to go toe to toe on that specific topic which is a very big
02:00:03 topic in the province right now and as i mentioned the ucp is doing really novel things on it and
02:00:08 they have announced some pretty big policies on that so i definitely could have heard from them
02:00:11 a bit more also on format just a personal pet peeve of mine i hate when they have multiple
02:00:16 moderators I hate when they include a million different journalists to ask questions I know
02:00:20 it's because they just can't agree the debate consortium of the journalists who are actually
02:00:24 organizing it they just simply can't agree who's going to be put in charge of it because all of
02:00:28 the outlets want their reporters having face time and to get sort of that credibility but I think
02:00:34 it's better when they just pick one moderator one person's asking the questions and keeping the
02:00:38 debate running smoothly just a personal preference of mine I think it's silly especially when you
02:00:41 know the reasons behind the scenes as to why they felt the need to include everyone but I did feel
02:00:46 like the moderators did a fairly good job of keeping them moving things along and you know
02:00:50 both of the leaders were pretty respectful and didn't interrupt each other too much which
02:00:53 sometimes can be a huge headache when you're watching debates so that part of it i thought
02:00:57 was pretty effective yeah the the questions i i thought were generally fair i thought they could
02:01:02 have been more of them i thought there could have been a little bit more opportunity for i don't
02:01:06 want to say confrontation but certainly for exchange uh between the two candidates i also
02:01:12 realize that I said the next donor to True North who donated more than $150 would get the mug,
02:01:17 but I didn't give you the link again. So that is donate.tnc.news. And even if you're not
02:01:21 chipping in because you want the last mug, you might want to chip in because you value the work
02:01:25 we're doing. And I'll go back to what I said earlier, which is that Rachel Emanuel, who's
02:01:29 been doing a great job covering the campaign, was banned from going to the debate to talk to the
02:01:35 leaders in the post-debate scrum because the mainstream media want to keep their little
02:01:40 protectionist bubble, or I don't even know if you can call it a racket going, which is what the
02:01:45 Alberta Legislative Gallery has basically done to exclude independent media. So we're still
02:01:51 covering it. We're still going to ask questions to Rachel Notley and Danielle Smith on the campaign
02:01:56 trail. But let's focus on the debate in particular here, because healthcare obviously came up. And
02:02:02 I mean, we weren't even like two minutes in before Rachel Notley once again starts talking about 0.99
02:02:08 Danielle Smith wanting to privatize health care. And I fear Rachel Notley might have been watching
02:02:12 the pre-show because she made the exact same criticism of Danielle Smith that I made just a
02:02:18 few moments before the program started. Let's talk about this clip here for a moment of Rachel
02:02:24 Notley attacking Danielle Smith on past support for changing the health care system.
02:02:32 Let's talk about something else. So let's talk about health care costs as they impact
02:02:36 affordability you claim that you won't raise costs but danielle you know you've i've known you
02:02:42 for at least a decade perhaps more and i've watched your career and you have argued passionately in
02:02:47 multiple multiple settings for your belief that you care about passionately those were your words
02:02:53 making people pay more for their health care so my question to you is why are you not running on
02:03:00 the thing that you believe why are you not being honest with albertans why aren't you making the
02:03:06 argument that you think having them pay more is what you want because you've said it in video in
02:03:12 papers in speaking tours in the legislature for over a decade miss smith we're gonna let you jump
02:03:17 in here i know miss notley likes to show grainy videos of things i said while i was on radio and
02:03:22 the reason she does that is she doesn't want to run on her record and the reason she doesn't want
02:03:26 to run on her record is it was an absolute disaster she racked up 70 billion dollars in 1.00
02:03:31 debt more debt than any premier or actually all premiers combined in
02:03:35 Alberta's provincial history she talked about deception did you remember her
02:03:39 running on a carbon tax in the last election I sure didn't not increase the
02:03:42 cross the cost of everything we eliminated it but Justin Trudeau
02:03:45 wouldn't let us keep it off and now Miss Notley has not stood up to her boss 0.99
02:03:50 Jagmeet Singh in Ottawa and worked with us to say don't increase that that carbon
02:03:56 tax any further and in fact certainly don't increase it 300% no one has any
02:03:59 credibility talking about affordability as long as they support a carbon tax which is going to
02:04:04 increase the cost of everything. I've got to say William I think Danielle Smith might have been 0.98
02:04:14 taking your advice because you mentioned earlier that you know the one thing you didn't like was
02:04:17 that she wanted to answer the questions and there she's asked you know how do you account for 10
02:04:21 years of pushing for privatizing or in some way privatizing health care and she says that the NDP
02:04:27 doesn't want to talk about their record. So I thought she answered the question well, but it
02:04:31 was interesting that really the premise that Rachel Notley went to is, listen, we know you
02:04:36 believe this. Why aren't you talking about it now? Yeah, I mean, I think if you are a fair and
02:04:43 objective observer, which we all are in our own mind, there is no doubt that Danielle Smith
02:04:48 came out ahead in tonight's debate. I think she did a better job of landing on the points she 0.93
02:04:54 wanted to talk about, including the progress that she's made on health care, hiring more nurses,
02:05:00 reducing wait times for ambulances, key metrics that she could point to. The trouble Rachel
02:05:07 Notley had, I think, was trying to be critical of Danielle Smith while also not wanting to talk
02:05:13 about her own time in office. And I don't think she was well enough prepared by her team in order
02:05:20 to take the hit from Danielle talking about, well, when you were premier, because that is,
02:05:26 by the way, something she's never had to face in a debate before. Of course, you know, the last
02:05:29 debate she had was in 2015. She'd been an opposition politician. It's the first debate
02:05:33 where she's ever had a record, and she seemed unable to effectively pivot. So when it comes
02:05:38 to health care, I'm sure Danielle Smith would prefer not to talk about it to the degree possible. 1.00
02:05:42 It's what we in politics called a shield issue. The more you talk about it, the more you might
02:05:48 lose votes. But she did what she had to do. And I think ultimately, people are going to look at
02:05:53 that debate and think it was Danielle Smith who came out on top. Yeah, one thing that is
02:05:58 interesting, normally in Canadian politics, if you lose an election after you've been in power,
02:06:03 you're kind of done. You just take that as your cue to retire. Stephen Harper in 2015,
02:06:09 Kathleen Wynne in 2018 in Ontario, and so on. So the idea of running again, of trying to do the
02:06:15 grover cleveland thing it's not without precedent in canadian politics certainly a lot of uh previous
02:06:21 prime ministers were in and out and in and out and whatnot but but it is rare that you get two
02:06:26 people that have both been premier that are that are running and two people that both have a record
02:06:31 and i was wondering what you uh kind of thought of of that dynamic because we didn't hear all that
02:06:36 much of rachel notley wanting to defend rachel notley's record in fact even in her closing
02:06:41 statement she tried to do a bit of cleanup by saying yeah i didn't always get it right 1.00
02:06:45 No, you're absolutely right. And I mean, the fact is, the reason Rachel Notley led this party into the election is because she is by far the biggest asset that the Alberta New Democrats have.
02:06:59 And I mean, even if you're not on her side, you only have to look at who the other senior MLAs are in that New Democrat caucus to know that Rachel Notley is as good as it gets.
02:07:09 And anybody else was going to come across as being incredibly left wing and out of touch with with everyday Albertans. That being said, Daniel only had to defend the last nine months, give or take. It was a period of economic recovery. She came in after the last premier was suffering a pretty low ebb in his popularity. And a lot of things went well over the last nine months.
02:07:33 Rachel Notley had to govern during a time of economic distress, low energy prices, and higher unemployment. 0.98
02:07:39 That was always going to be a more difficult period of time to govern.
02:07:44 That being said, she did a lot of things that made the situation worse. 0.99
02:07:47 And I think Danielle did highlight some of those in the debate tonight and remind people when she was in premier, when Rachel Notley was premier, things were really not good here in Alberta.
02:07:57 And if you think about the fact that this election is primarily targeting Calgary, that's about oil and gas.
02:08:03 That's about jobs and private sector business.
02:08:06 And this is the part of the province that's going to be most impacted by that large tax increase that Rachel Notley and the Democrats are proposing for Alberta businesses.
02:08:15 What stood out tonight for you, Rachel?
02:08:18 I'm just still caught on the fact that Rachel Notley wore the conservative blue to the debate. 0.86
02:08:23 Don't leaders generally wear the color of their party?
02:08:26 i mean i understand like orange is a super ugly color i wouldn't want to wear it either but i
02:08:31 just thought that was very notable especially as we're talking about how rachel notley doesn't
02:08:35 really want to run on her record as premier and she's not really bringing it up and she's not
02:08:39 really advocating for her advertising it and then she fact that we've talked so much about how she's
02:08:44 been appealing to moderates and then she shows up tonight in a conservative blue i just thought that 0.82
02:08:49 was a little bit funny but it was again a very strong performance from danielle tonight i just
02:08:53 don't think I've ever seen her. So enthusiastic, so lighthearted, really positive to be there
02:08:58 looking forward. I think she did exactly what she needed to do during tonight's debate to appeal to
02:09:03 people who, you know, aren't sure how they feel, aren't sure how they're going to vote for her.
02:09:07 We reported on a poll that showed about half of Albertans said they were going to watch tonight's
02:09:12 debate and decide how to cast their ballot based on what they heard. I sort of doubt the number is
02:09:16 that high. Usually not that many people watch a political debate. I think maybe it helped that it
02:09:20 only an hour in that case but i think i think daniel smith did exactly what she needed to do
02:09:25 if she's looking to appeal to those people and you know rachel not only just seemed a little bit
02:09:29 rattled her opening statement wasn't very strong she seemed a bit caught off guard public public
02:09:33 speaking can absolutely be tricky i just don't feel like she ever really caught up to where she
02:09:37 was at and she's had a little bit of a break from doing these types of speeches so maybe she was
02:09:41 just caught off guard but daniel smith was really on her game tonight you know maybe the fact that
02:09:45 that she took time away from the campaign to do those two debates in her local riding which a lot 0.52
02:09:50 of people said is a terrible idea maybe that actually benefited her tonight because she just 0.99
02:09:54 had experience doing two back-to-back debates along with all the debate prep that we know goes
02:09:59 into an event like tonight. Yeah I mean although I hope for Rachel Notley's sake that she's you know
02:10:04 doing better than an NDP candidate in rural Alberta who's never going to win I hope that
02:10:10 but you never know sometimes the local candidates do surprisingly well in in debates I had kind of
02:10:15 But when I ran for office years ago, I had a bit of a home field advantage in the radio debate.
02:10:19 So I kind of went in just completely fine with anything that was going to happen there.
02:10:24 Let's talk about, I mean, when you bring up Rachel Notley trying to kind of be everything to everyone right now,
02:10:30 I have to share this clip.
02:10:32 This is a critique that really goes to be a bit of a blast from the past in Alberta politics,
02:10:37 the way that Rachel Notley takes aim at Danielle Smith here. 1.00
02:10:40 uh yes well i mean i think the fundamental problem here is that albertans are deeply
02:10:47 concerned at the notion of a danielle smith-led government reforming health care in any way
02:10:52 shape or form she claims she's guaranteed that nobody will ever pay for a doctor but
02:10:57 you know miss smith uh i was with you in the legislature in 2014 you stood up and you
02:11:02 guaranteed you would never cross the floor three weeks later you crossed the floor your
02:11:07 understanding of the word guarantee is very different than that of most Albertans and most
02:11:13 people are deeply deeply troubled at the prospect of you reforming health care based on your 15
02:11:20 year record of advocating to make people pay out of pocket okay we are
02:11:25 I mean look it's a legitimate criticism Danielle Smith herself would acknowledge that has
02:11:35 acknowledge that it's a weird one to kind of have Rachel Notley hold up as being so significant
02:11:42 here. It's like, you know, you're a woman of your word, but you crossed the floor eight years ago. 0.74
02:11:47 Rachel, do you think anyone will care about that watching? I mean, the people that were the most
02:11:51 angry about that are not Rachel Notley fans. No, I don't think that Albertans really care
02:11:57 about that anymore. I think the conversation has changed. I think that Rachel Notley is stuck
02:12:02 living in the past a little bit on this the people that were upset at daniel smith for crossing the
02:12:07 floor are the same people that decided whether or not they wanted to vote for her in the united
02:12:12 conservative party leadership race that happened just last summer and guess what she won that race
02:12:17 so we know that albertans by and large have moved on from that and passed it the people that are
02:12:21 looking to decide whether to vote for daniel smith or not that is not the question at the top of their
02:12:25 mind right now maybe a small part of it factors into whether or not they feel they can trust her
02:12:30 but I suspect people have a much more prominent and present concerns when we look at the state
02:12:34 of our economy around us. And I doubt that is something that's influencing their decision
02:12:38 as to whether or not to vote for Smith or Notley on May 29th.
02:12:42 The one thing when you have a one-on-one debate that you always want to look out for is that real
02:12:48 sort of tension, that sparks fly moment. Tonight, that was a pretty clear cut one. There was one
02:12:55 real candidate for that. Let's roll that clip when the NDP's penchant for hacking apparently 0.99
02:13:01 was put front and center. The other thing I would say, I've been in office since 2008.
02:13:08 I have never actually breached the conflict of interest legislation. Ms. Smith cannot say the
02:13:14 same. Well, I guess you did have an MLA who hacked our health care system. I can tell you.
02:13:19 Do you really want to talk about our candidates and our MLAs?
02:13:23 Seriously, I do not think you're going to win that one.
02:13:25 That is not one you want to do.
02:13:27 I have to tell you, when I'm putting together our affordability payments,
02:13:29 to have to ask whether it was going to be hack-proof from the NDP,
02:13:33 that's not something that Ms. Notley should be very proud of.
02:13:36 What I will also say is that when she came out with her costing document,
02:13:39 it was almost immediately discredited because Todd Hirsch said
02:13:43 he hadn't done the analysis on what kind of impact it would have
02:13:47 on chasing away investment.
02:13:49 others did trevor toome did jack mince did there are several business reporters who did
02:13:54 the alberta chamber of commerce did and what they have said is that would create instability
02:13:58 and the instability would chase additional investment out it would chase jobs out and
02:14:03 we would go back and have a rerun of what we did in the period of time that ms not like
02:14:07 doesn't want to talk about which was when she was premier
02:14:09 okay i mean it wasn't like a total brawl i mean we didn't have you know like microphones and
02:14:20 lecterns being knocked over and anything like that there wasn't a lot of shouting but
02:14:24 it was one of the feistier moments here you've got rachel notley going to the you broke the law 0.97
02:14:29 and then danielle smith saying hey and mla was hacking and then rachel notley i mean you just
02:14:33 heard the clip i don't need to give i don't need to do the dramatic reenactment of it although if
02:14:37 we could if you want us to do that. That could be part of the post show here. But William, I mean,
02:14:44 let me just get your take on this here, because a lot of the things that consume media coverage,
02:14:48 we were talking about this earlier, certainly legacy media coverage are not the things that
02:14:52 matter. And in fact, I don't even know if elections are won and lost on the things that matter to
02:14:57 people. I think they're won and lost on what you'd call, if you were putting this debate together,
02:15:01 or the wild cards, you know, this ethics commissioner report, this candidate said this, and so on.
02:15:07 So the stuff that was there, MLA hacking, which I had kind of forgotten about,
02:15:12 the, you know, you broke the law, which is not a particularly accurate interpretation of what happened today.
02:15:19 But does this stuff land?
02:15:21 In my opinion, no.
02:15:22 In fact, I think very few people had any idea what either of them were talking about during this segment.
02:15:29 If you could remember former NDP MLA Thomas Dang breaking somehow into the COVID vaccine proof system, good for you.
02:15:40 Congratulations.
02:15:41 But at the same measure, I don't think a lot of people really understood what the whole Daniel Smith interfered in something problem was either.
02:15:50 I mean, look, how many months did we spend and did media spend talking about Justin Trudeau and SNC-Lavalin?
02:15:56 I mean, it went on forever, and I don't think in the next election anybody's going to have any recollection of what it went about, or if they do, they really don't care.
02:16:05 What do people care about, in my opinion, things like cost of living, how much it costs people to fill up their gas tank, how much it costs people to pay their electricity bill, how much they pay in taxes, and they care about are we safe in our communities.
02:16:17 You know, I'm sick of trying to get on to an LRT or a bus and being hassled by someone who's high as a kite, or I feel unsafe when I take my kids to the park.
02:16:29 And where Daniel, I think, benefited from this debate in particular is the very first question was on cost of living.
02:16:35 And the very last question was on law and order and safe communities.
02:16:39 And that was a perfect lineup, in my opinion, for her because she got to start and end on her very best points.
02:16:45 But you're right. I mean, so much trivia on this MLA did this and that MLA did that. You know what I care about? Who's going to cut my taxes? Who's going to make my electricity bill cheaper? Who's going to make sure I don't get stabbed on the way to work in the morning? That's what everyday people care about.
02:17:02 Let's get your take on that, Rachel.
02:17:04 yeah i think that what william said is exactly what i was thinking in that if those types of
02:17:10 things really landed then justin trudeau would no longer be prime minister in ottawa
02:17:15 but these types of discussions are very complicated you know there's a lot of things to
02:17:20 follow even the report that came down today there were some parts of it that absolved danielle smith
02:17:24 other parts that said you contravene you know the ethics act by having this discussion with
02:17:28 your justice minister very convoluted each side sort of picks the bits that they want to take
02:17:33 from it and they run with that and ignores the rest that's inconvenient to their points and then
02:17:37 everyone in the middle just doesn't pay attention because they're like this side saying it's blue
02:17:41 and this side saying it's yellow so i'm just going to focus on the things that really matter to me
02:17:45 which is exactly what william just said most people are focused on public safety and making
02:17:50 sure that they can pay for their rent every month and that they can afford gas and hoping that their
02:17:54 taxes get cut so they have a little extra money to finally go on that family vacation that they
02:17:58 put on hold for three years because they just simply can't afford it or because they haven't
02:18:02 been allowed to travel so you know these are things that most people are focused on right now
02:18:06 if you're really into politics if you're political you're going to know the history of some of these
02:18:10 zingers that were passed back and forth makes it a little bit funny makes it entertaining but
02:18:14 at the end of the day it's not really going to stick it's just something for the base to kind
02:18:17 of rally around and chuckle around and earlier in in the pre-show i said i wasn't sure who was
02:18:22 going to be lobbing insults one or the other i said i expected rachel notley would certainly 1.00
02:18:26 be lobbing insults at danielle smith because that's what the entire ndp campaign has been 1.00
02:18:30 about but you know that was admittedly a pretty good comeback from smith on her part about dang 1.00
02:18:35 there and it was also just totally unexpected from her because you don't really see her engaged
02:18:39 in that type of politics too much and she did keep things pretty positive today during the debate so
02:18:44 again i just think that whole exchange probably blew over most people's heads because they aren't
02:18:48 really familiar with the history there yeah that's fair and it's one of these things that makes you
02:18:53 know us freaks who live and breathe this stuff like oh and then but everyone else was like what
02:18:57 are they even talking about get back to like what are we'll get happen get back to the tax thing
02:19:00 that you guys were talking about i mean among people that are watching debates and and that
02:19:04 in and of itself is a bit of a challenge because these things uh you know we want to believe that
02:19:09 everyone in the province is just on tenterhooks and that undecided voters are you know just eager
02:19:14 to to make their decision but but in a lot of cases the people that probably could benefit the
02:19:19 most from it are just living their lives and i and i think that's why there's a great opportunity
02:19:23 for a leader who's going to come in and say,
02:19:25 even not with an unabashedly libertarian stance,
02:19:29 but a leader that's going to say,
02:19:30 I'm the premier that's going to make it
02:19:32 so you can go back to not caring about government
02:19:34 and not caring about politics.
02:19:36 And I'm the leader that's going to make it
02:19:37 so you don't need to wonder
02:19:38 if I'm going to write off your job and your industry.
02:19:42 And to go back to what we were talking about earlier,
02:19:44 about the divide between the Alberta NDP
02:19:47 and the federal NDP,
02:19:49 You do not get to, even as a socialist in Alberta, say the quiet part out loud, which is that you don't like the oil and gas sector.
02:19:57 I mean, Rachel Notley has come out against, in a very, very tacit way, the just transition, which I've covered on my show.
02:20:05 I know you've covered, Rachel, which is basically the federal government's desire to transition employment from people in the oil and gas sector to green energy.
02:20:14 Rachel Notley kind of issued like one sort of comment on this.
02:20:18 I think it was back in January.
02:20:20 Yeah, it's not constructive, but has not campaigned against it.
02:20:23 She's not rallied against it.
02:20:24 It's kind of just paying lip service to it.
02:20:27 And Danielle Smith did bring that up with her.
02:20:29 This was the criticism that I thought was a very fair one on Rachel Notley and the just transition.
02:20:35 Ms. Notley didn't stand up when Justin Trudeau cancelled Northern Gateway.
02:20:45 She didn't stand up when Energy East pulled the plug.
02:20:48 She didn't stand up when they brought in a tanker ban off the West Coast for our product. 0.88
02:20:52 And she didn't stand up when the No More Pipelines bill was passed.
02:20:55 Well, you know that's not true, Danielle.
02:20:57 You actually know that's not true.
02:20:59 You commented on the fact that I made submissions to the Senate.
02:21:02 You know that that's what I did on both of those issues.
02:21:05 It was too late. And I must tell you, where do you think Justin Trudeau got the idea for just transition and for an emissions cap and for a carbon tax?
02:21:11 He got it from Ms. Notley when she was premier.
02:21:14 And she's going to continue to implement these same kind of policies. 1.00
02:21:16 And she's going to walk in lockstep with Justin Trudeau on making sure that they get implemented.
02:21:21 And that's only going to harm our economy.
02:21:22 and basically that is danielle smith trying to link the ndp to people and ideas and parties that
02:21:38 are not at all popular in alberta right now and i think something like that is probably
02:21:43 not only valid as far as a critique but i think it's genuinely true
02:21:49 well yeah i mean in politics we always say fight your least popular opponent you know you you have
02:21:56 the choice of fighting your local candidate your your opposing political party or your political
02:22:01 party leader but in alberta of course we have a ready-made opponent who is deeply unpopular in
02:22:06 this province that's justin trudeau and his liberal government and so i think you saw it
02:22:12 tonight danielspeth very consciously making that effort to link justin trudeau to rachel notley
02:22:17 saying how much they agree, how often they cooperated, how much she supported him.
02:22:23 And to be honest, I think they probably would have been better off starting that initiative well before the election.
02:22:29 I think they should have been doing it from the moment that Danielle had become premier.
02:22:33 But as we say, better late than never.
02:22:34 And I think it was an effective strategy in this debate to try and say, look,
02:22:39 Rachel Notley and Justin Trudeau, her best friend in Ottawa, don't like Alberta.
02:22:43 They don't like oil and gas.
02:22:44 They don't want us to be succeed, and they want to shut down our most important industry.
02:22:49 Yeah, Rachel, I know they haven't been getting police to remove you from Rachel Notley's press conferences,
02:22:55 so you've been able to hear what she said and hear what reporters have asked her about.
02:23:00 Does she give a coherent position on where she stands on oil and gas, or is she kind of equivocal about it?
02:23:09 She's been pretty ambiguous.
02:23:10 as she's presenting herself during this election as very pro-energy during the debate she says
02:23:15 she's for energy jobs and she's also saying that she's for you know reducing emissions and the jobs
02:23:19 that would come along with that which ironically is something that danielle smith says all the 1.00
02:23:23 time danielle smith isn't against reducing emissions she often touts different ways that
02:23:28 we could do it in the province while also supporting our energy sector so they would
02:23:32 actually be quite aligned with that during this leadership race or sorry rather during this
02:23:36 election as well but again this is just another instance of Rachel Notley not running on her
02:23:42 actual record as premier and us not even being sure if she's meaning what she's saying or if
02:23:46 she's just saying stuff to appeal to moderates and not to come across as a radical someone who
02:23:51 would be likely much more aligned with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and her federal counterpart
02:23:55 Jagmeet Singh and even at one point during the debate I thought this was particularly funny
02:23:59 Daniel Smith actually said to Rachel Notley oh well Justin Trudeau got his idea for just
02:24:04 transition from you so certainly she was doing her best to sort of stick that to not me we'll
02:24:09 see if it works i'm very curious to see what happens on may 29th both of these leaders are
02:24:14 trying so hard to present themselves as rational trustworthy reasonable minded moderate leaders
02:24:19 and i'm just very interested to see what's going to happen i don't think anyone can genuinely say
02:24:24 they know at this point with the polls being as close as they are but it's definitely a nail
02:24:28 biter of an election. Yeah, let's be a bit more forward looking here. The election is on Monday,
02:24:34 May 29th. And I should tell you right now that we are going to have a very special live election
02:24:41 night show for you on Monday, May 29th. I'll be hosting that from Alberta. We'll have Rachel
02:24:47 playing a very key role. I don't know what we decided for William yet. So let us know in the
02:24:51 comments what we should do with him. I think he's invited on account of he's our COO. But we also
02:24:58 have some other guests and panelists and of course the results and I always get very nervous about
02:25:04 this because you may remember the infamous uh what was it 2021 uh or 2020 no 2021 conservative
02:25:11 leadership race what year was that was that no it was 2020 because the election was in 2021
02:25:15 and it was the like conservative leadership race that was supposed to be an hour and ended up going
02:25:20 until like three in the morning uh before they determined that Aaron O'Toole was the leader for
02:25:24 18 months or whatever. So in any event, we are hoping that the elections will not be as long
02:25:29 because I will need to fill my True North coffee mug with a lot of coffee to get through it. But
02:25:34 that's going to be coming up on May 29th. Let me just ask both of you here, what do you think will
02:25:40 happen in the next little while? Because obviously elections can sometimes be derailed in the week
02:25:48 and a half, two weeks before election day. That's when I think a lot of the times if there's a really
02:25:52 terrible story that's going to drop it tends to come out we also know that leaders will really
02:25:58 focus on those key battlegrounds and I would be surprised at this point and you may have different
02:26:03 thoughts on this Rachel if either Rachel Notley or Danielle Smith really leaves Alberta for the
02:26:07 next 11 days yeah so just before I get into that I just wanted to mention to the viewers that one
02:26:12 of my friends who is a Liberal Party staffer he works for one of the Liberal MPs in Alberta
02:26:17 texted me and said huge win for Danielle tonight so I think across the board people are generally
02:26:22 accepting that she was the victor of tonight's debate for the reasons that we've just discussed
02:26:27 in length. As for what I expect to see over the next week I think that we can expect some
02:26:31 opposition research from the NDP dropping on Danielle Smith and some of her other candidates 0.97
02:26:36 they're going to be trying to make them look crazy and untrustworthy and hypocritical in their 0.99
02:26:40 comments. I think that Danielle Smith is going to have to focus very heavily on pushing the UCP's 0.95
02:26:46 messaging and not getting off topic. Of course any day as a party that you spend responding to
02:26:52 opposition research and attacks it's pretty much a day wasted on the campaign trials because then
02:26:56 simply that disagreement will dominate headlines also daniel smith hasn't really spent that much
02:27:01 time in battleground calgary largely due to the fires that happened up north she had to at the
02:27:07 beginning of the campaign head up north to attend to those fires and that was the appropriate thing
02:27:12 for her to do but she has been removed from calgary for much of the campaign so far and then 0.96
02:27:17 she spent two days in her riding as i mentioned which i know many people in the party thought
02:27:21 wasn't a good idea and we're not too happy about. So now there's a week left I think we're going to
02:27:26 see here coming out and doing some campaigning. I think the party's been a little bit quiet on
02:27:30 some of their campaigns. They've held a couple announcements which were non-announcements just
02:27:34 sort of attacking the NDP's record and their policies. So I think we need to see just a
02:27:38 consistent straightforward campaign. I expect we'll see some basic policies being announced
02:27:43 and maybe one more big one between now and then. But I think really the important thing for
02:27:47 daniela just to come out here and to get some face time with the voters rachel notley has been
02:27:52 campaigning very hard they're doing about two events a day right now they've pretty much just
02:27:56 been in calgary as well a little bit up in edmonton a little bit down in lethbridge but
02:28:00 you're 100 right they the campaign is totally focused on calgary and i think that's where we
02:28:05 can expect to see things dominate in the next week what are you looking out for expecting hoping for
02:28:11 fearing in the next 11 days uh william so this is the period of the campaign that's the worst
02:28:18 it's because you've almost announced everything you've got if you've had to put out your costed
02:28:23 platform you don't really have any more magic things to pull out of the bag and talk about
02:28:29 so now you have wait what's this look under your chairs everyone that's right you get a tax cut
02:28:36 and you get a tax cut but so the problem is you have to be very disciplined at this point you
02:28:42 have to stay on message you have to avoid distraction and i will say this is where
02:28:48 danielle smith traditionally has had some challenges she likes she does get drawn off
02:28:53 her message sometimes we say she wins the debate tonight she didn't she did very good but that was
02:28:58 an hour now she has 11 days that she has to try and stay on message and the democrats are going 0.51
02:29:03 to continue to drop examples of her or her candidates saying things that are going to
02:29:11 rub Alberta voters possibly the wrong way. So if I were her, I would be trying to do
02:29:17 every positive photo op I could think about between now and election day, serving coffee
02:29:23 at a Tim Hortons, planting a tree with a Boy Scout or a Girl Guide troop, whatever she
02:29:29 can come up with and whenever she's asked she has to be disciplined enough to say this election
02:29:34 is about four terrible years of rachel notley just as she was when she was premier last time
02:29:40 or four more years of opportunity and economic growth under under a ucp government and she has
02:29:46 to be disciplined enough not to get pulled off that message so these 11 days are going to feel
02:29:51 like a long time for those two parties well said rachel and william it's great to have you both
02:29:58 tuned in this evening i'll just make one final plug here uh the work we do at true north having
02:30:02 rachel out there covering the campaign having uh william and i here tonight uh doing our election
02:30:08 night show all of the coverage we do at true north is only made possible because of people
02:30:12 who support the work that we're doing and tonight we had our a little bit of fun with donors over
02:30:17 150 getting the true north coffee mug i don't know if we got rid of the last i think we still have
02:30:22 the one more left. So there's a chance to snag that by heading over to donate.tnc.news. Donate.tnc.news.
02:30:31 Well supplies last, William not included. But we do thank you so much, all of you, for your generous
02:30:36 support of independent media and of True North. And I mean that from the bottom of my heart. So
02:30:40 that does it for us. I know we'll have Alberta Roundup on Saturday. We'll have the Andrew Lawton
02:30:45 show tomorrow and we'll have True North's live election night show on May 29th. So whether you
02:30:52 are an albertan or a hopeful albertan or someone in another province for whom alberta might be
02:30:56 calling we invite you to tune in on that for the results the commentary the analysis the jokes the
02:31:01 fundraising plugs and all that a big thanks to sean and harrison and steve and phil for all their
02:31:08 help behind the scenes tonight and for candace malcolm giving us this great platform here at
02:31:13 true north i know she is watching and i know we'll be back soon enough at true north and she
02:31:18 appreciates all your well wishes and kind words. So that does it for us. Thanks again, everyone.
02:31:23 God bless you and have a wonderful night.
02:31:48 Thank you.
02:32:18 Outro Music