Juno News - December 26, 2019


The Candice Malcolm Show: Ask Candice Anything!

Topics
Mentioned
Adam Vaughan doesn’t know anything about guns Trudeau wants to mandate Canadian content on Netflix

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

195.15

Word count

2,616

Sentence count

163

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Candice answers a mailbag of questions about the Prime Minister's mandate letters, Ben Shapiro confronting his own kids, and why political figures should be left alone with their families. If you'd like to have a question answered in a future episode or future podcast, you have to be a member of the TNN Club, where you can submit them on air in future episodes.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi everyone, Merry Christmas. Hope you had a wonderful Christmas day with your family,
00:00:08 with your friends at church, wherever you were to celebrate it. Today for the Candice
00:00:12 Malcolm show, we are doing a very special episode where we're doing a extended version
00:00:17 of Ask Me Anything. We're not going to talk about any news. We're just going to go through
00:00:20 the mailbag and answer all the questions. If you'd like to have a question answered
00:00:24 in a future episode or future podcast, you have to be a club member in order to get a
00:00:29 question asked. So you can head on over to tnc.news, sign up as a club member, and then
00:00:34 you can submit your questions and I will read them on air in a future show. So let's jump
00:00:38 right into it. First question. Hi Candice, Merry Christmas to you, your family, and the True
00:00:43 North family. I've been seeing some media exposure on the minister's mandate letters purportedly
00:00:47 prepared by Trudeau to give the tasks and directions for each minister to accomplish,
00:00:52 from the minister of everything to the minister of nothing. Given the cranial capacity of PM
00:00:57 Trudeau, it is not possible he had the acumen to produce these documents other than probably
00:01:01 contributing his signature. Who really prepares these mandate letters and how are they vetted
00:01:06 to suit the Liberals' agenda? Kindest regards, Gordon. Well, thank you so much for the question,
00:01:11 Gordon. Yeah, of course, Justin Trudeau, I mean, he doesn't even do his own prime initial
00:01:15 jobs anymore. That's why he appointed Chrystia Freeland to be his deputy. So we know that he's
00:01:20 not really doing the day-to-day kind of business aspect of the prime minister. And so when it comes
00:01:25 to these mandate letters, basically they are prepared by the PCO, by the Privy Council Office,
00:01:30 which is sort of the bureaucratic office that's adjacent to the prime minister's office. The
00:01:34 prime minister's office is full of the political staffers that are appointed by the liberal
00:01:38 government. And then the Privy Council is the permanent bureaucracy that is there. So the PCO
00:01:44 creates these documents sort of as an outline based on the liberal party platform. They pass it
00:01:49 over to the political side in the prime minister's office. The staffers who are appointed by Trudeau would
00:01:54 go through and sort of change the wording, add certain things, and then those letters would go
00:01:59 off to the minister themselves. So no, Justin Trudeau didn't sit down and create these. Although I will
00:02:05 say that under the former prime minister, Stephen Harper, my understanding is that he was really big
00:02:10 into these kind of memos, into producing these kind of documents, and that he would, if he received
00:02:15 a memo, he would stay up. He would read every single thing that came across his desk, and that he had a
00:02:19 larger part in crafting these kind of things. But as far as the liberals and the bureaucracy,
00:02:24 you know, the liberals and the bureaucracy, they basically all agree and believe the same stuff.
00:02:28 So it's easier for the liberals because they can have the bureaucrats do part of their job. 0.99
00:02:32 Okay, next question. Dear Candace, this is specific to U.S. politics, but it relates to Canadian politics
00:02:38 as well. Could I get your thoughts on Nick Fuentes confronting Ben Shapiro while Ben was with his
00:02:43 wife and kids? I personally think Nick crossed the line, and that political discourse in both the
00:02:48 U.S. and Canada has reached an all-time low. This reminded me of when Trudeau was almost attacked
00:02:53 when he marched in a climate march with his kids. When political figures of all parties are with their
00:02:58 families, they should be left alone. Yeah, so, you know, this is a really good question. I was watching
00:03:04 this footage the other day of Ben Shapiro. He is walking into a hotel with his family when he is
00:03:10 confronted by a conservative sort of political activist who had a beef with Shapiro. Here,
00:03:15 let's play part of that clip. Ben, it's great to see you. Why did you give a 45-minute speech about
00:03:21 me at Stanford and you won't even look at my house? Hey, hey, hey, he's with his kids. Come on,
00:03:25 I'm right here. I'll just say that, you know, Ben Shapiro handled this like a pro. He obviously showed a
00:03:31 lot of self-control to ignore this kind of heckling that was happening. And, you know, I have a kid as
00:03:37 well. I have family and the idea of someone confronting you in an aggressive, negative
00:03:42 way when you're with your kids is just completely out of line. It's completely offside, in my
00:03:47 opinion. When someone's with their family, they should be left alone. I've been confronted a couple
00:03:53 times, many times, just, you know, when I'm visiting Calgary or Edmonton, sometimes in Toronto,
00:03:58 sometimes in Vancouver. Someone will recognize me and come up to it. Fortunately for me, it's always
00:04:03 sort of been a positive encounter. People negatively see, if they see me and they have a negative
00:04:08 feeling about me, fortunately they've left me alone. But I can't imagine having that kind
00:04:14 of confrontation when you're with your family. And I think that this activist who confronted
00:04:19 him really lost a lot of his support because no one likes to see that. And the same thing
00:04:23 goes, whether it's Andrew Scheer with his children, Dustin Trudeau, I think that families should
00:04:29 be left alone and should be left out of the political debate. And I'll just say one more
00:04:34 thing, especially for Ben Shapiro, because Ben Shapiro is not only an outspoken conservative,
00:04:39 a very effective communicator, but he's also an Orthodox Jew who stands up to the far right,
00:04:44 to the sort of white supremacist fringe on the far right. And because of that, he gets a lot
00:04:50 of death threats. He gets a lot of threats. My understanding is that he has security detail.
00:04:55 Now, you know, he is just, he's a political commentator. He's a podcast host. And yet he
00:04:59 has to have round the clock security because of the amount of threats that he gets. So just,
00:05:03 again, another reason why people should just be left alone when they're with their family.
00:05:09 All right, next question. What do you think is the biggest international threat to Canada?
00:05:13 Many would argue Russia or China or even Islamist terrorism. What do you think? Well,
00:05:19 it's kind of interesting because, you know, Canada isn't really a big global player. So we don't
00:05:23 really have threats in the same way that the United States is. I think that whatever is a threat to
00:05:27 the United States is a threat to Canada. So all of those examples that were listed are threats.
00:05:32 I think that there's a real concern that in 50 or 100 years, China's economy will be much,
00:05:38 much bigger than the United States and they'll be able to assert so much more power around the world.
00:05:43 So, you know, right now we sort of have this peaceful liberal global order that's based on the
00:05:48 United States being the dominant superpower, basically the only superpower. And a lot of people
00:05:53 hate the United States for that. But if you step back and you consider what the alternatives are,
00:05:57 imagine if the world's biggest global superpower was a, you know, corrupt human rights abusing
00:06:04 communist dictatorship. And instead of the U.S. spreading sort of goodwill around the world and
00:06:10 promoting peace and democracy and free markets, you had a global menace promoting communism and
00:06:17 authoritarian regime around the world. I think that we would live in a very different kind of world.
00:06:21 That's the concern with China. But look, here's what I will say about Canada. The biggest threat, 0.95
00:06:27 I believe, to Canada and the future of our survival as a country is our ability to stay united. So I
00:06:33 would say that all of these are a threat insofar as Canada is opened to being manipulated by right
00:06:39 now mass migration, mass immigration, people coming to Canada with no expectation that they adopt any kind
00:06:44 of Canadian values, identity, join the community, learn our local languages, that people are just
00:06:51 allowed to come and settle and kind of create their own closed communities. So that could be any of
00:06:55 those groups. That could be a closed Islamist community where they believe in Sharia law and
00:06:59 promote a jihadist ideology. It could be a closed community of people loyal to the Chinese communist
00:07:06 government or any number of other communities. But people coming here, not becoming Canadian and instead 1.00
00:07:12 bringing their sort of values and tribal hatreds or their ideology that's counter to our free and democratic
00:07:19 society to Canada. And what will that look like 50 to 100 years from now if we have all these little
00:07:25 closed communities? I think Canada will be a society at war with itself and it won't be strong enough to sort of stay
00:07:32 united and fight against any external threats that could happen at that time. So that would be my
00:07:37 fear of the biggest threat to Canada. Next question. This is a good one. There has been so much talk about
00:07:43 impeachment here in Canada, but I really don't think the media or the average Canadian understands
00:07:47 what's going on in the States. Can you clarify to your viewers what this is actually about? Newsflash to
00:07:53 Canadians, Donald Trump is still President of the United States. So I'll have to be honest, I haven't really been
00:07:57 watching much of the Canadian coverage of this just because it's so mind-numbing and I don't think it's very
00:08:02 fair or accurate. So impeachment is an accusation. Impeachment isn't a ruling. It isn't something
00:08:10 that is finalized. It's basically the House in the United States. There's two there's two houses.
00:08:15 There's the House of Representatives and then there's also the Senate. So the House are the people that
00:08:20 can impeach a president and impeachment again is just an accusation. So because the Democrats control
00:08:25 the House, they have accused Donald Trump and then in order for him to actually get removed from
00:08:29 office, it would have to get confirmed by the Senate. Well, the Senate is controlled by the Republicans
00:08:34 and so it's not going to happen, just as it didn't happen under Bill Clinton when he was impeached.
00:08:40 So just because someone's impeached doesn't mean they're removed from office. That would have to
00:08:43 require the Senate confirmation. The Senate is not going to impeach Donald Trump, so he's going to
00:08:47 remain president. Now this is all just a political show, essentially. Like so much in Washington,
00:08:53 it's political theater. It doesn't really have any kind of impact. If you look at the polling and the
00:08:58 data in the United States between Democrats and Republicans, you'll see a nation that's very,
00:09:03 very divided. Most Democrats want Trump removed. They want him impeached. Most Republicans don't.
00:09:09 Even when you look at independents, the split is almost down the middle. 47 percent of independents
00:09:14 want Trump removed from office. 46 percent want him to remain in office and let the voters decide
00:09:19 in November 2020 election. So again, just because someone's impeached doesn't mean they're removed
00:09:24 from office. And I think this does set a bit of a dangerous precedent. I know it happened under Bill
00:09:28 Clinton with Republicans doing the impeachment, but essentially what you can have is anytime there's
00:09:34 a president who is from an opposite party of the party that controls the House, the president can be
00:09:41 impeached. So I think what we'll see in the future as the country remains very divided and a very stark
00:09:46 partisan divide is that when there's a Republican-controlled House and a Democrat president,
00:09:51 that president will get impeached. When there's a Democrat-controlled House as there is right now
00:09:55 and a Republican president, that president will get impeached. It really doesn't really mean much.
00:10:00 Okay, let's move on. Okay Candace, I have a question. It's about the TMX pipeline and the economics of
00:10:07 the project. I would like to know what the financing arrangements are for the construction. We all know
00:10:13 the Fed's paid $4.5 billion for ownership of the present line, including presumably the Kinder Morgan
00:10:18 cost to the point of the expansion preparations. Now the line is in construction phase, incurring and
00:10:23 paying presumably costs. Normally such a big project requires contractual commitments for borrowing or
00:10:30 otherwise providing the construction phase. That commitment normally is made on an agreed upon
00:10:35 settled basis of repayment or borrowed funds along with financial plan for the investor of the
00:10:41 distribution and or handling of profit or loss. In the TMX case, we the public are the investors. I
00:10:47 hope the government has a business plan. I haven't heard or seen a word of this. If information, if this
00:10:52 information is available somewhere, my engineering curiosity would like to see it. Can you help?
00:10:57 Regards, Bob. Well, thank you for the question, Bob. So this is a pretty complicated question.
00:11:01 I've looked at it a while and I can't actually find any contractual commitments for the borrowing
00:11:06 on any basis. But basically this is what the finance department says. It is not, however,
00:11:12 the intention of the government of Canada to be a long-term owner of this project. At the appropriate
00:11:17 time, Canada will work with investors to transfer the project and related assets to a new owner or
00:11:23 owners in a way that ensures the project's construction and operation will proceed in a manner that protects
00:11:29 the public interest. Many investors have already expressed interest in the project, including
00:11:33 indigenous groups, Canadian pension funds, and others. Basically what happens is the $4.5 billion
00:11:39 went to just what was the existing cost of the pipeline and what had been done to that point. Now that
00:11:44 the pipeline is now back in the construction phase, it is the federal government, aka funded by Canadian
00:11:50 taxpayers. That's the money that's going to be invested into building the actual pipeline. So the $4.5 billion
00:11:56 was just the very baseline, the very start. We're continuing to fund it and the government of Canada still has
00:12:02 this pipe dream that they are going to be able to eventually sell the pipeline to a private investor.
00:12:07 I wouldn't hold my breath on that. The whole reason why the federal government had to purchase this
00:12:12 pipeline in the first place was because the private sector wasn't really interested in doing it anymore,
00:12:17 given the lack of certainty about the future of pipelines and the oil industry in Canada. So
00:12:23 that information was all available just through the finance minister's website over in the government of Canada.
00:12:32 So the idea is basically that the government of Canada is going to be able to find a private investor.
00:12:36 I wouldn't hold my breath about that given the fact that the government had to buy this pipeline in the first place
00:12:42 because the private sector was no longer interested in holding such a project given the
00:12:48 grave uncertainty about the future of pipelines and the oil industry in Canada. So I think that's going
00:12:54 to be a long-term boondoggle that we will keep an eye on. All right, so I'm going to leave it at that.
00:12:59 Thank you so much for everyone who submitted questions. And again, if you would like to be part of the
00:13:04 Ask Me Anything, sign up for one of our clubs and you can send a question over and I will read it on air.
00:13:09 Thank you very much and we will be back next week. Thank you.