Juno News - August 22, 2023


The Liberals think carbon taxes fight forest fires

Topics
Mentioned
Excavation of residential school site finds nothing...what a surprise Jordan Peterson has to go to reeducation camp for his tweets

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

173.46

Word count

7,013

Sentence count

318

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

If you oppose a carbon tax, Catherine McKenna says, you're an arsonist. Is she right or is she wrong? And why does she have a point of view on the matter? And what does it have to do with the devastating wildfires raging across the country?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcribed by ESO, translated by —
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:18 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:30 Hello and welcome to you all. Sorry there was like a dramatic pause there for some reason before the program began and I'm not precisely sure why, but I guess just to heighten suspense for the show here.
00:01:44 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North. It is Tuesday, August 22nd, 2023, just after 4 p.m. here in the dirty, leeching east of Canada.
00:01:59 which is funny. I mean, I spend a lot of time in Alberta and I used to work in Alberta guest
00:02:04 hosting on actually guest hosting for the woman who's now the premier of Alberta, Danielle Smith
00:02:08 on 770 CHQR. And the one thing that I always found so jarring whenever I was in the West is
00:02:14 how they view Ontario as being the East, whereas Ontario views itself as being the center of the
00:02:20 world. It's like, oh no, no, no. East is like Newfoundland and Nova Scotia. But wherever you
00:02:25 are in this lovely nation that we call the Dominion of Canada, at least that I call the
00:02:30 Dominion of Canada. We welcome you very much. And I'm so glad to have you here. I was going to do a
00:02:35 little bit of prop comedy on the show today. And I was going to like bring a lighter of some kind
00:02:39 and maybe set something aflame. But then I realized you don't actually need a lighter to
00:02:44 set anything aflame in this day and age. You can do it with your words alone. So do I have a piece
00:02:50 of paper. I've got a piece of paper. I hope this isn't anything important. It's a, oh no, this is
00:02:55 the phone number of a woman who banged my car in a parking lot, but it's already been sorted out. So
00:03:01 I can burn this. This is okay. I oppose carbon taxes. Carbon taxes are bad.
00:03:13 oh that's unfortunate it was supposed to light a flame when you say that such is the
00:03:20 point put forward by Catherine McKenna the former environment minister of Canada you'd think she'd
00:03:25 know these things she says on Twitter here conservative politicians want to fight about
00:03:31 a price on carbon pollution with the indignation of a question mark you want to make it free to
00:03:36 pollute while Canadians pay with their lives threatened homes destroyed and their communities 0.99
00:03:41 obliterated. So what are you going to do? You are the arsonist. So Catherine McKenna there with your
00:03:49 words, thoughts, and feelings alone, establishing that if you oppose carbon tax, if you do not
00:03:54 support a price on so-called carbon pollution, you are an arsonist. Now she says this as the
00:04:00 wildfires wage on and wage on, and wage on actually, in the West and the North and the
00:04:06 Northwest Territories and in Northern British Columbia. It's tragic. It is horrendous when
00:04:11 you see people that have been displaced from their homes. We've seen in Maui that lives have
00:04:15 been lost because of fires. This is very serious stuff. And it is happening in a context that is
00:04:21 not about politics and shouldn't be about politics. But Catherine McKenna says, if you are a
00:04:26 conservative who opposes a carbon tax, you are an arsonist. Let me just try one more time.
00:04:32 I'm going to think really, really, really hard about why I don't want to pay more at the gas
00:04:37 pumps. No, nothing. Well, I got to say, I cannot believe that Catherine McKenna ever led us astray.
00:04:46 That I did not have foreseen. I could not have foreseen at all. It is quite fascinating to me,
00:04:51 if you think about it here, that we are seeing more and more of this nasty rhetoric, this
00:04:57 catastrophism that we were speaking about a couple of weeks ago with Joe Oliver on this show,
00:05:02 from people that are proclaiming to be guided by science and governed by science,
00:05:08 but are actually anything of the sort.
00:05:10 They are putting political talking points and masking it with science-y sounding language
00:05:16 and speaking about climate and the weather and the environment in these catastrophic doom and gloom terms
00:05:22 with an ask that is attached to it.
00:05:25 And that ask is always about political control.
00:05:28 That ask is always about them wanting us to have to pay more, do less, use less, eat less, travel less, and oh yeah, by the way, pay more.
00:05:38 And if you don't want to pay more, according to Catherine McKenna, you are just an arsonist.
00:05:42 Now, my colleague Elie Kenson-Nantel asked Pierre Paulyev about this in Ottawa just a couple of hours after Catherine McKenna's tweet.
00:05:50 Take a look.
00:05:51 Catherine McKenna, the former Liberal Minister, accused Conservatives of being arsonists over the opposition to the carbon tax.
00:05:58 So what's your response to her comment, and what do you say to climate alarmists or maybe people that say that not having a carbon tax will lead to a climate catastrophe?
00:06:08 What I really worry about is the increased radicalization of rhetoric by Liberals, particularly Justin Trudeau,
00:06:16 but the nastiness and meanness that they're directing at people who disagree with their
00:06:21 policies whether it's Trudeau's nasty comments directed at Muslim parents or whether it is him
00:06:29 jabbing his finger in people's faces and now a former liberal minister saying that anybody who
00:06:35 doesn't want to pay higher taxes is an arsonist. Really? Really? As if if we paid higher taxes we'd
00:06:42 have less forest fires? Come on let's get back to some common sense in this country and let's start
00:06:48 to bring our people together instead of tearing the country apart. It seems like a fairly common
00:06:56 sense position that Catherine McKenna the environment minister once in Canada saying
00:07:02 that arsonism is or arson comes from opposing carbon taxes will be a little bit absurd but
00:07:07 this is what passes for the liberals now and you may wonder if okay maybe I'm punching down by
00:07:12 talking about some former environment minister.
00:07:16 But even though she doesn't have a position in government,
00:07:18 she still is very much a leading voice, not just in Canada,
00:07:21 but around the world on purveying that climate catastrophism
00:07:25 I was talking about earlier on in the show and in previous episodes.
00:07:30 And I would also say she's still very much looked at in some ways
00:07:32 as this sort of spiritual leader on the green file for the Liberals.
00:07:37 It's now Jonathan Wilkinson that has her role.
00:07:40 Stephen Gilbeau, who's I mean, they talk about climate criminals in terms of like the big oil and gas companies.
00:07:47 They all call them climate criminals. Stephen Gilbeau is literally a climate criminal because he was charged with a criminal offense while he was engaging in climate protests.
00:07:56 So Stephen Gilbeau is a literal climate criminal who has bungled a number of files and is now on the transport file.
00:08:02 But Stephen Gilbeau had tweeted, and you can see it on the screen there, that this is about Tracy Gray, the conservative MP for the Kelowna area, that she wants to fan the flames by making pollution free again.
00:08:16 So, you know, make America great again.
00:08:17 The conservatives want to make pollution free again.
00:08:20 Rob, he is taking aim at the fact that Tracy Gray is pointing out that Canadians cannot afford Trudeau's carbon tax and that we should axe the tax and bring home lower prices.
00:08:30 Now, the Liberals claim to be all on board with fighting inflation.
00:08:35 The Liberals claim that they're aware of the inflation crisis.
00:08:38 They know about it.
00:08:39 They're on it.
00:08:39 They're on top of it.
00:08:40 Just who you want running the problems here.
00:08:42 But the reality is that Canadians cannot afford to fill up their gas tanks.
00:08:47 There was a tweet from the Ottawa Food Bank, I believe it was, earlier today that I saw
00:08:52 just moments before I went on air, saying that they are unable to find enough food to
00:08:58 distribute.
00:08:59 So they've had to cancel volunteer shifts.
00:09:01 People that said, you know what, I'll roll up my sleeves and help the food bank.
00:09:05 I'll help you sort food and distribute it.
00:09:06 They said, well, we don't actually have any food to distribute because our donor base
00:09:11 are struggling with increased cost of things.
00:09:13 So people cannot afford to buy groceries for themselves, let alone afford a surplus to
00:09:19 donate food to a food bank.
00:09:21 So absolutely, when the Conservatives are saying, well, perhaps this arbitrary carbon
00:09:25 tax that does nothing to help Canadians but does in fact punish them is something we could cut. So
00:09:33 the Liberals are trying to vilify the Conservatives for opposing a carbon tax that even the most
00:09:40 do-goody Canadians cannot afford right now. And the number of hurdles and barriers and
00:09:46 restrictions they're putting in place in the name of environmentalism is asinine. One that we talked 0.92
00:09:52 about a couple of weeks ago is these electricity regulations that are coming about a federal
00:09:57 government forcing provinces to be net zero by an arbitrary date in ways that will only result
00:10:04 in increased costs to consumers. Now, I've been very heartened to see the Alberta government push
00:10:09 back against this. Premier Danielle Smith has said this is unrealistic, as has her environment
00:10:14 minister, Rebecca Schultz. And Minister Schultz joins me now. It's always good to have her on the
00:10:20 show. Minister, I know you're very kind. You've got to get to a flight soon, but I'm glad you're
00:10:25 here, and thank you for doing this. Now, just to confirm here, you do not believe that opposing
00:10:30 carbon taxes is arson, right? You know what? We're very opposed to the carbon tax here in Alberta,
00:10:38 and we hear it every day. I mean, it was just yesterday, actually. I was speaking to a
00:10:42 constituent about their power bills, and he said, you know, Rebecca, look, as my MLA, when I break
00:10:48 down my bill the carbon tax and inflation you know like this is hurting everyday Canadians so
00:10:54 uh no the carbon the carbon tax especially the consumer carbon tax is not actually having an
00:11:00 impact on emissions or our environment. Talk to me about these clean energy uh these are so-called
00:11:07 clean energy regulations these electricity regulations and why Alberta is standing so
00:11:13 firm on this in a way that right now we haven't really seen many other provinces do what's the
00:11:17 problem in your view? You know, there's a there's a few. First of all, it's affordability and
00:11:22 reliability of power for everyday Albertans and Canadians. You know, I would I would suggest that
00:11:28 the Albertans that I represent and Canadians right across our country, they sure do expect that when
00:11:33 they turn on their light switch that, you know, they actually have access to power. And that's
00:11:39 what's at risk here. The other thing is that these aren't Alberta's numbers. These are independent
00:11:44 numbers, numbers from groups like the Public Policy Forum that have said, look, this is going
00:11:48 to cost $1.7 trillion. At some point, somebody has to pay for that. And that ultimately will
00:11:55 be Albertans and Canadians, whether it's on their bills or through their taxes. So, you know, those
00:12:00 are our two main concerns. But also, in some cases, they are relying on technology that does
00:12:06 not exist, has not yet been tested anywhere in the world. And they also haven't made the
00:12:11 infrastructure investments to get us anywhere near this by 2035. There are a couple of different
00:12:17 dimensions to this. On one hand, there's the, like, does it actually make sense? And is this rooted
00:12:22 in science? And is this rooted in even what the federal government says are its key objectives?
00:12:26 And then there's also the federalism aspect of this, which is that, is it the federal government's
00:12:30 responsibility to come and manipulate effectively how provinces manage their electricity systems?
00:12:36 And I know the carbon tax case when that first went towards the courts was favorable in Alberta, but at the Supreme Court of Canada, not as much.
00:12:45 Is this a similar dynamic here?
00:12:47 Do you think there's even more of a case that, no, no, no, this is provincial domain and Ottawa should butt out?
00:12:52 You know, this is absolutely an area of provincial jurisdiction.
00:12:56 And, you know, when it comes to power generation, that's one thing.
00:12:59 The other thing that this clean electricity regulation does is it really limits the natural gas baseload that we rely on, especially, I mean, in Alberta, but other places across Canada.
00:13:10 In the middle of winter when the sun isn't shining and the wind isn't blowing and we need natural gas baseload, we don't have access to hydro like some other provinces do.
00:13:19 And so that also impacts our energy development, which, again, is an area of provincial jurisdiction.
00:13:25 So you're right. It's not only unrealistic, unachievable, it's also completely unconstitutional and, of course, unaffordable for everyday Albertans and Canadians.
00:13:34 So those are some of our concerns.
00:13:36 I mean, you know, when we look at some of the actual aspects of this bill and or sorry, of these regulations, the biggest concern, you know, maybe to some would be this 18 day limit, 450 hours in terms of how we can use our natural gas to support reliability within the system.
00:13:56 When I think about the month of January here in Alberta, I mean, 18 days, that doesn't even get us through the coldest month of the year.
00:14:03 And after that, it's not going to be legal to provide power to the grid using natural gases generation.
00:14:09 That absolutely doesn't make sense.
00:14:12 And so you're exactly right.
00:14:13 Myself, our premier, we have said absolutely under no circumstances are we accepting these clean electricity regulations here in Alberta.
00:14:20 And then we, of course, have Stephen Gilbeau going over to China, basically, which is always the blind spot in a lot of the climate alarmist discussions on this.
00:14:31 I mean, whether it's John Kerry, who talks about the need to reduce your emissions, but not so much in China.
00:14:37 I mean, here we have China, which is one of the most coal dependent nations in the world, whose emissions dwarf anywhere else in the world, including Canada.
00:14:45 And I know you've pointed this out to him. Have you gotten a response yet with your concerns?
00:14:51 You know what? Not not on this front. And we will be continuing our discussions with the federal government.
00:14:57 Premier Smith has set up some bilateral tables.
00:15:00 So we are going to have discussions about both the electricity regulations and impending oil and gas emissions cap.
00:15:07 And so these will be part of those discussions going forward. But you're exactly right.
00:15:11 I mean, you know, I don't think it's acceptable to pick fights with provinces and, you know, essentially increase the cost of living and risk the reliability of our grids here in Canada while saying, you know, here we need an arbitrary date of 2035.
00:15:26 But for China, it's OK to work on 2060. 0.81
00:15:29 And so, you know, when we look at here in Alberta, our plans are around carbon neutrality.
00:15:34 We have an aspiration to be carbon neutral by 2050.
00:15:37 What we're saying is let us do this in our own way, in a way that doesn't put at risk the affordability or the reliability of our power grid for everyday Albertans that rely on that.
00:15:48 You know, and being a parent of young kids, I do think of what it's like to be up in the middle of the night with a young child.
00:15:54 You know, you flip on the switch, you expect there to be power.
00:15:58 I mean, this is just, you know, I just can't see how this is something that Albertans or Canadians can accept.
00:16:06 And so we're going to continue to defend Albertans and everyday people right across our country from from these types of legislation.
00:16:15 But it's not just that. I mean, the plastics ban is another example that we pointed out to the federal government where, you know, their legislation is having the exact opposite impact.
00:16:24 We have Calgary Co-op here in Calgary paired up with an entrepreneur here who developed a fully compostable bag.
00:16:31 It is not plastic. And yet it is banned by ECCC.
00:16:34 And so, you know, I pointed out to the minister, this doesn't make any sense. You're having the exact opposite impact. Same thing with the oil and gas cap. If you limit the amount of natural gas or LNG coming out of Alberta, coming out of Canada, displacing coal fire generation in other parts of the world, we're having the opposite impact on emissions worldwide.
00:16:54 We have an opportunity right now in Alberta, in Canada, to lead with sustainable energy development, emissions reduction, address energy security and affordability and reliability.
00:17:07 But unfortunately, the federal government seems to be choosing ideology over common sense every single time.
00:17:13 All right. Well, I appreciate you squeezing us in.
00:17:15 I know you've got a plane to catch there, Minister Rebecca Schultz, the Environment Minister in Alberta.
00:17:19 Always a pleasure. Thanks so much for coming on.
00:17:22 Thanks so much, Andrew.
00:17:23 All right. And I should just say, I mean, this whole thing from Catherine McKenna is absurd,
00:17:28 but it really is reflective, I believe, of the government's absurdity on this. And a lot of
00:17:34 these targets that they put out are incredibly arbitrary. I mean, Rebecca Schultz was just
00:17:39 saying there, you've got China that gets until 2060 to go carbon neutral, but these people have 0.95
00:17:44 to do it by 2035. And then, oh, maybe just 2030 and maybe 2050. And these are all lofty aspirational
00:17:50 goals. The one that you hear at all the big UN climate summits is about the need to reduce global
00:17:57 warming to 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial levels. And no one could really agree on 1.5
00:18:03 at the Paris climate agreements because it was all going to require just a complete
00:18:08 de-industrialization, essentially just shut down electricity altogether. And you don't even get
00:18:14 to light candles because they might be a little bit too carbon inhospitable. So they agreed on
00:18:18 two degrees and then work really hard to get to 1.5. And then Glasgow comes along and then the
00:18:25 Charmel shakedown, which was just last year. And all of a sudden it's 1.5. They're all talking
00:18:29 about 1.5 again, 1.5. And if you're a Canadian, whether you're one of Rebecca Schultz's constituents
00:18:36 in Alberta, or you live in Northern Ontario or Eastern Canada, or even in Quebec, which pretends
00:18:41 it's above oil and gas, but is disconnected from the realities of the world outside of the hydro
00:18:48 electric grid, apparently. And all of these people that are saying, listen, I actually don't care
00:18:53 about any of this stuff if my own household isn't looked after. And this is the big flaw in what the
00:19:00 government is doing right now, is that they are imposing something on provinces, on communities,
00:19:06 and by extension on families, without caring at all about the consequences, without caring about
00:19:11 the consequences of the family that can't afford to pay the carbon tax, without caring about the
00:19:16 consequences of the family who can't afford to pay its electricity bill or its home heating,
00:19:22 the family who can't afford the increase in grocery prices that carbon taxes and other
00:19:27 related things are doing, exacerbating existing inflation. And all of this just continues to go on
00:19:34 in a government that just does not care, a government that believes genuinely that it
00:19:40 should be above all of these rules that are for the little people. Now, you know, we talked a few 0.84
00:19:45 weeks ago about Christia Freeland, who's getting up there. You know, Christia Freeland, who says
00:19:48 cutting your Disney Plus subscription is the way you fight inflation. Christia Freeland, who says,
00:19:53 you know, we all need to do a little bit less. And then you look and realize that she commutes 0.99
00:19:57 effectively daily, like three or four times a week from Toronto to Ottawa, taking a plane. I've seen
00:20:04 her on planes in business class before. So this is a woman who knows how to travel and enjoys travel. 0.95
00:20:09 And I like travel, so I don't judge her for that. I judge her for doing it while telling us that we
00:20:14 are all the problem and telling us that we're the ones who need to do less. And, you know,
00:20:18 Catherine McKenna believes that with your thoughts and words, you can cause ours. And when I pointed
00:20:22 this out on Twitter, everyone's like, oh, you don't understand metaphor. Yeah, I understand
00:20:27 metaphors. And I also understand, you know, lunacy masquerading as cogent policy. One thing I want
00:20:34 to talk about here, just shifting gears entirely, is the idea of academic freedom. And the really,
00:20:40 the whole point of this discussion whenever we've brought up free speech and academic freedom
00:20:45 is that there is a value that comes in people being able to disagree in a free society and
00:20:51 to weave this into the climate narrative one of the big problems we've had in discussions of
00:20:57 climate science is that there's often been this very phony and artificial consensus the so-called
00:21:03 consensus I don't know why my air quotes are like sagging one way or another there we go
00:21:07 But because I'm looking at myself back and my camera is tilted, so I didn't quite know where the air quotes were supposed to be.
00:21:14 I need an air quote augmentation to balance them out and perk them up a bit.
00:21:18 But in any case, the whole point of the... I totally lost my train of thought there. Don't mind me.
00:21:23 The point that I was getting at there is that on the climate debate and on the climate science debate,
00:21:28 We've had more often than not this phony consensus in which doctors of physics, of geology, of all of these other things have been told that their perspectives don't matter if they go against the narrative.
00:21:42 And we've had a silencing of debate.
00:21:45 We've had a chilling of debate.
00:21:47 And it's very similar to what we saw on, certainly in Supercharge, in the COVID era, where it
00:21:53 was very clear early on that there was an official narrative.
00:21:55 And anyone, no matter how many letters you had after your name, how many years of schooling,
00:22:00 anyone who diverged from the capital O, capital N official narrative would be silenced.
00:22:06 And it wasn't just that they would be subjected to cancel culture.
00:22:09 In some cases, you had people's regulatory licenses, their ability to practice medicine
00:22:14 be jeopardized, and people were suspended, people were removed from colleges, and certainly
00:22:20 people lost jobs.
00:22:22 They're alleged crimes to be dissidents in an area in which I'd say we needed more debate
00:22:27 and more skepticism and far less deference.
00:22:29 Now, one of the people who stands out as, and I don't use the word lightly, a hero of
00:22:35 the last several years is Dr. Matt Strauss.
00:22:39 Now, Dr. Strauss, you've seen on this program before, he's been a tremendous advocate for not COVID denialism, not anti-vaccine rhetoric of just science and medicine and of taking a very traditional view of medicine, which is that you should try to personalize it to the patient and not paint entire societies and countries with a one size fits all solution when that may not fit their individual needs.
00:23:03 And he's also spoken at great length about the harms, the adverse effects of some of the purported remedies and treatments, such as lockdowns, for example.
00:23:13 And it's his COVID skepticism that Dr. Strauss argues jeopardized his role at Queen's University and ultimately led to him being forced out of that role.
00:23:23 He has now filed a lawsuit against Queen's.
00:23:27 And while we can't talk about this matter because it is before the legal system,
00:23:31 I did think it was a good opportunity to talk in general about the retrospective on this
00:23:36 last few years and where it all went so wrong from an academic freedom, a medical freedom
00:23:42 and a free speech perspective.
00:23:43 So Dr. Matt Strauss joins me now.
00:23:46 It's good to talk to you again, Dr. Strauss.
00:23:48 Thanks for coming back on the show.
00:23:49 It's always nice to talk to you, Andrew.
00:23:50 That introduction was too kind.
00:23:53 Well, it was very much deserved.
00:23:55 And I say that just to not to toot your horn even more, or maybe I am trying to do that,
00:24:00 But I say that because a lot of people didn't realize how much doctors were putting on the
00:24:05 line if they did speak out.
00:24:07 And I would say there were probably some cases where people didn't realize their own power
00:24:12 and they didn't realize that they did have a voice.
00:24:14 But there were a lot of times where people said, look, if I speak up, I lose the ability
00:24:19 to practice medicine, or they feared that was going to happen.
00:24:22 And I was wondering where you sort of land on this now, having seen some of your colleagues
00:24:26 and you've seen people go through this process.
00:24:28 do you think that the negative consequences for those who spoke out are over oh no certainly the
00:24:37 negative consequences aren't over i i and i and that's not just for physicians um you know since
00:24:42 i started speaking out about some of my concerns about pandemic management but especially since
00:24:47 uh unfortunately this news of my uh lawsuit was made public um i've heard from so many canadians
00:24:54 i a real estate agent texted me today to say that she had had a hard time uh being able to speak out
00:24:58 a child psychologist reached out to me, a construction company executive, I've heard
00:25:05 from school board trustees. Like it seems to me that throughout Canada, exacerbated during the
00:25:11 pandemic, but in all areas of public life, people feel that they can't speak their mind. And my
00:25:18 fundamental concern is we're not going to have good public policy if we don't have good public
00:25:22 debates about things um so i i i see in every area that the people are still suffering from
00:25:29 things that happen to them and you know i think you were speaking about wildfires and climate
00:25:34 change before i came on um in some ways we're suffering from it now i want to hear from a
00:25:38 forestry expert i want to hear from firefighter experts about what could be better about our
00:25:43 wildfire response right now so so no i don't i don't think this problem has gone away and i think
00:25:48 think we all need to keep pushing against it and just speaking out for a free open liberal democratic
00:25:52 society where people can speak their mind you know in some cases there is a reason that we have
00:25:59 certain established facts in science and i'd say in medicine there are probably certain things that
00:26:05 are fairly universal and you know certain medical treatments of history that have been lost to
00:26:09 history and probably for good reason so on one hand we don't want the the doctor that's going
00:26:14 to come out and say oh you know what i think bloodletting needs to make a comeback or something
00:26:17 like that. But at the same time, we also need to have room to discuss and to debate. And when the
00:26:22 science isn't clear to say, well, hang on, I, you know, what I'm seeing in my patients is this,
00:26:26 or what I'm seeing in this study is this. And I, I'm curious where that, I mean, how should you
00:26:32 let yourself as a physician be guided in that? Because on one hand, you want to do what's in
00:26:36 the best interest of your patients. And, but on the other hand, if a problem is presenting itself,
00:26:41 you don't always have time to go through that, you know, academic discourse and study when
00:26:45 you're figuring it out and I'm talking of course about the pandemic I believe
00:26:47 that it provided a sense of urgency for doctors but but what was the proper
00:26:52 response to that without you know basically be laboring something where
00:26:56 urgency was required so the practice of medicine needs to be sacrosanct it needs
00:27:03 to be approached with great humility and a lot of caution and professional
00:27:08 bodies do need to govern how medicines practice so if if I were going out
00:27:12 saying, Andrew Lawton, I think that you should treat your COVID with acupuncture. That would be
00:27:19 wrong because acupuncture doesn't treat COVID and I'm not your physician. I haven't done a history
00:27:23 and a physical on you. We're speaking in public. You're not benefiting from physician patient
00:27:29 confidentiality right now. So I really take very seriously the sorts of recommendations that
00:27:35 physicians give to their patients. But that's different than having a concern about public
00:27:41 policy. And again, I don't want to get into the facts surrounding the case, but fundamentally it
00:27:47 was made clear to me that the problem I was having with the administration was that I criticized the
00:27:51 government. And that's very different from practicing medicine. So physicians need to be
00:27:55 able to criticize the government. They need to be able to criticize public policy. But I 100%
00:28:01 agree that physicians cannot recommend quackery to their patients and nor should they be making
00:28:06 medical recommendations to people who are not their patients in public or otherwise.
00:28:09 The funny thing, too, about universities, and I don't want to draw a false equivalence between real science and, you know, political science, which I studied, but, you know, universities pride themselves on being anti-authoritarian in so many other disciplines, you know, they would celebrate a professor who came out with some scathing report that condemned the government's approach on, you know, some national security law or something like that.
00:28:32 And it's weird that that skepticism of academic inquiry and really the purpose of academic inquiry, which in university medicine, I think is incredibly important, is completely gone on this.
00:28:42 The government says it, ergo, we just accept it.
00:28:45 Yeah, I think this is a bit new.
00:28:48 I think it was seen prior to COVID around things to do with, I think, obviously, the Israel and Palestine conflict will be with us forever.
00:28:59 But I know that on both sides of that set of issues, professors ran afoul of their
00:29:04 administration over the last 10 years. But 100%, this idea of academic freedom being sacrosanct
00:29:10 was a foundational principle to universities for hundreds of years. In one meeting that I went to,
00:29:16 I brought up Noong Chomsky, who is, I think it's fair to say, a radical leftist and a very
00:29:22 interesting thinker, was arrested by the government at one point for attending the Vietnam War
00:29:28 protests. And as far as I'm aware, his institution stuck with him through thick and thin. And thank
00:29:35 goodness, because I certainly don't agree with Chomsky and everything, but he's a profoundly
00:29:39 interesting thinker, and I have benefited from hearing his thoughts, and I've come to agree
00:29:44 with him about many of the things that he has said since the 60s in that arrest.
00:29:48 One of the problems with governments, and I'm using that in the broadest possible sense of just institutions in general, is that they are fallible and they know they're fallible in some cases.
00:30:00 They don't often admit it.
00:30:01 One example that comes to mind is Western University, my alma mater.
00:30:05 You went there for med school as well.
00:30:07 This is a university that had, I think it was a one of a kind or maybe one of two in
00:30:12 the country, which was this academic year, putting in place a booster mandate for students,
00:30:17 not just a vaccine mandate, but a booster mandate, which was supposed to go into effect
00:30:21 in September of, I guess it would have been 2022.
00:30:24 And there was a rally held around a year ago at which I spoke, at which you spoke, at which
00:30:30 your medical colleague, Dr. Martha Fulford spoke, and a number of student activists.
00:30:34 And Western eventually backed off that.
00:30:36 Now, they didn't credit it to the backlash.
00:30:38 They just kind of just let it die on the order paper.
00:30:41 And then a few months later said it's no longer necessary.
00:30:43 But there's a case in which Western said one day the science requires a booster for students.
00:30:48 And the next day said the science no longer requires a booster for students.
00:30:52 So this deference that was expected of you at Queens and of people elsewhere is on its
00:30:58 face absurd, because how is that deference supposed to factor into a world in which governments
00:31:03 will change what they believe the science leads them to?
00:31:07 Yeah, thank you for bringing up that episode with Western. And I'm biased. I love Western.
00:31:12 I'll always love Western. I'm glad they did the right thing in the end. And I was so proud and
00:31:19 lucky to be part of that student-led movement. But it is true that whoever was doing the university's
00:31:27 press releases at that time, who I'm almost sure was not a scientist but a communications
00:31:32 professional of some sort or another was was claiming that the science was on their side
00:31:36 and science um science doesn't really take sides science is a process of open inquiry and debate
00:31:41 and evidence gathering and argument synthesis so it certainly wasn't the case in that instance
00:31:47 that the science was on their side um and i'm glad dr fulford and i were able to to draw some
00:31:53 attention to that and i guess i i i like to think that we had some effect on that ineffective and
00:32:02 harmful mandate being withdrawn. I would have liked to have seen maybe a bit of a mea culpa
00:32:07 from the university on that point of view, but I still love them. When you look around at Queens
00:32:13 in your situation, and again, I'm very careful. I know you can't talk about too much of the facts
00:32:17 of the case. So if I'm asking too much, please let me know and I'll back off. But when you look
00:32:22 around and saw the dynamic with your colleagues there, were you just the outspoken one and everyone
00:32:27 else was kind of the same as you were on this, but didn't want to put their neck out? Or did
00:32:33 you really feel like you were alone in this and that everyone else was really adopting that line
00:32:38 that you were expected to adopt genuinely? I certainly am not the only one who felt the way
00:32:44 that I did. I was the only outspoken one who, to my knowledge, I was the only outspoken one
00:32:51 to maybe have a set of views that I had. There were several, I had several outspoken colleagues
00:32:57 who took maybe some views contrary to mine and i would have loved to have had a debate with them
00:33:02 either you know either on a podcast or somewhere at the university um it became clear that you were
00:33:11 became clear to me at many universities that individuals who were towing the party line were
00:33:15 allowed to be outspoken and people who criticized the party line were not allowed to be outspoken
00:33:20 but i um throughout all of this uh like i said i've heard from so many canadians of all walks
00:33:24 of life but many of them were colleagues of mine at the university and I'm not a political person
00:33:31 I'm not a political organizer I never I never thought oh I know what I'll do I'll organize a
00:33:36 demonstration or I'll organize a petition or something like that and maybe that was an error
00:33:40 of mine but I they you know they had careers they were doing work that was really important
00:33:47 they also have mortgages and kids and that sort of thing and I it never occurred to me to ask
00:33:53 ask someone to stick their own neck out um and but and i and i i understand that it's
00:34:00 it i it's a it's a lot to chew off uh and one does not want to bite off more than one can chew
00:34:08 when one of the the challenges i mean you literally had your i i didn't i'd missed this
00:34:12 part of your story and i when i read about it in the national post you had had your belongings
00:34:16 shoved into a cardboard box i mean one of the most sort of depersoning things that you know
00:34:21 an employer can do and and you had that done to you and and at the time if i recall it had kind
00:34:26 of blindsided you in a way because you weren't even aware there was an issue like you weren't
00:34:30 even aware that you had been doing something even purportedly wrong in the university's eyes
00:34:35 um i would i would rather not speak with great specificity about what i thought and when and
00:34:45 what I've seen and when because I that would be a little bit from the hip and
00:34:50 I just want to be really really careful. Let me let me take a different approach
00:34:57 then on on this which is to ask you how you feel about what happened moving
00:35:03 beyond it I know that's sort of a sappy question that I would you know
00:35:06 criticize most hard-hitting journalists for asking but but I'll ask you how you
00:35:09 feel looking back at it because I've never seen from you even when this has
00:35:13 been going on anything resembling bitterness or antipathy to Queens in
00:35:17 fact I've only ever heard you speak highly about your your time at in
00:35:21 academia both as a student and as a as on the the admin side I said a few
00:35:26 things to say about that one is I I it was a great privilege it was the best
00:35:32 job I've ever had getting to teach medical students and you know I still
00:35:37 practice medicine it's always a privilege to get to look after folks
00:35:41 who are having a hard time we're ill so into my former colleagues even the ones
00:35:48 who disagreed with me I honestly have nothing but but love I this lawsuit is a
00:35:55 dispute that with something some elements of the administration but
00:35:59 frankly I received not just from colleagues texts of support but but also
00:36:07 from professors in other departments a professor of law and a professor of bioethics both reached
00:36:12 out to me you know way back when when all this was happening so i i have so much warmth for
00:36:19 the the queen's community that that is not at all what um what this is about i wouldn't want it to be
00:36:26 framed as me having anything other than um warmth for my students and the colleagues and my
00:36:32 colleagues um former colleagues i guess and the other thing i will say is everyone had a really
00:36:37 bad pandemic i had a bad pandemic in some ways but um i i saw horrible things that happened to my
00:36:46 patients both because of covid and all the other ways that um the pandemic and the pandemic
00:36:51 restrictions uh affected their lives so i you know i had folks who were between life and death
00:36:57 in the icu for three months who weren't allowed to have their family visit and i
00:37:00 it was like Russian novel levels of misery and despair so I can't I can't even somewhat feel 0.99
00:37:10 bad about what happened to me I guess like in contrast and so I would say that if I'm
00:37:18 outspoken about these issues and if I'm maybe pugilistic in terms of defending this principle
00:37:24 of academic freedom I hope I'm doing it for these more public concerns and what happened to me because
00:37:30 i'm fine i have a roof over my head i have i have three square meals a day and i have a family that
00:37:35 loves me um so i i can't complain well that's a wonderful wonderful way to put it and i actually
00:37:41 think it's an incredibly thoughtful way of putting it because so much of what we've seen of the edicts
00:37:47 have come from people that weren't affected by what they were doing i mean someone who's married
00:37:52 and has a family at home telling someone who lives alone that they have to stay at home alone and
00:37:58 can't go see their neighbors, someone who doesn't have a family member dying in a care home telling
00:38:03 other people that they can't go and visit their loved one, their grandma or father or whatever
00:38:08 in a care home. So all of these things, I would agree, were absolutely horrible. And I'm glad
00:38:12 you've come through it the way you have. And I wish you well in this lawsuit. Dr. Matt Strauss,
00:38:17 always a pleasure. Thanks for coming on, Matt. Nice to see you, Andrew. All right. Thank you.
00:38:21 That does it for us for today. We'll be back tomorrow with more of Canada's most irreverent 0.84
00:38:26 talk show here on True North. This is the Andrew Lawton Show. And I was about to tell you what we
00:38:31 have coming up tomorrow. And now I've forgotten what we have coming up tomorrow. But I am going
00:38:35 to say on Friday, we have a great show planned looking at the trans issue from all angles, sports,
00:38:40 politics, and a little bit on the back to school front as well, because school is heading back
00:38:45 in just a couple of weeks, which I am sorry to terrorize the poor parents by realizing that. But
00:38:50 hey, at least it's not school on Zoom. We'll talk to you all soon. Thank you. God bless and good day
00:38:55 to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to
00:39:00 True North at www.tnc.news.
00:39:25 We'll be right back.
00:39:55 We'll be right back.