ManoWhisper
Home
Shows
About
Search
Juno News
- July 15, 2022
The Toronto Star really hates the Canadian flag
Episode Stats
Length
30 minutes
Words per Minute
197.94229
Word Count
6,009
Sentence Count
4
Misogynist Sentences
4
Hate Speech Sentences
3
Summary
Summaries are generated with
gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ
.
Transcript
Transcript is generated with
Whisper
(
turbo
).
Misogyny classification is done with
MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny
.
Hate speech classification is done with
facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target
.
00:00:00.000
hello everyone and welcome to another edition of fake news friday true north preeminent show
00:00:16.400
detecting the lies the smears the misinformation the miscues the mistakes the hot takes all of
00:00:23.080
that even the cold takes every now and then i am andrew lawton in for candace malcolm joined as
00:00:28.680
always by harrison faulkner host of the fantastic true north podcast ratioed harrison how was the
00:00:34.660
week pretty good pretty good we've got some we've got some usual suspects in the show this week
00:00:40.180
andrew we've also got some got some things we've always touched on which is this weird hatred of
00:00:45.460
the canadian flag so you've got quite the lineup that we're uh we're gonna get into so looking
00:00:50.240
forward to it yeah and it's also i should say calgary stampede week which is home to most of
00:00:56.000
the fake news of everyone trying to pretend that they are in fact albertans or even like that they
00:01:02.000
like westerners so you'll see all these politicians and uh folks wearing cowboy hats do not be deceived
00:01:08.160
though here on fake news friday we will ourselves stampede through the hearts and minds of canadians
00:01:13.740
as only we try to humbly of course uh let's actually start off on the stampede though because
00:01:19.280
ctv did this thing where a headline says a lot sometimes about an outlet more than about a story
00:01:26.660
they used two photos to i would say misrepresent trudeau's calgary stampede one is from 2018 and this
00:01:37.020
is one as as people have pointed out here of trudeau just you know moseying about doing his thing
00:01:42.500
through the crowds the other is from a liberal fundraiser uh and then well what happened here
00:01:48.120
harrison so so what we have here andrew is is actually perfect for this show it is the absolute
00:01:54.640
definition of fake news and this trudeau trip to the calgary stampede really i think it was straight
00:02:02.180
out of a movie skit it was a total disaster from start to finish so they understood that right away
00:02:07.140
and all of a sudden the liberal spin doctors had to really kick it into high gear and get going so
00:02:12.960
what we have are two perfect examples of fake news the first one as you said andrew is ctv using
00:02:19.140
photographs of trudeau pointing out to the crowd looking all famous and looking like a star
00:02:23.660
but those turned out to be years ago those photos are from one of them is from 2018 and what we then saw
00:02:30.980
was perhaps the most absurd propaganda headline i've ever read uh and of course it was from the
00:02:38.740
canadian press as a wire service so when it gets written in the canadian press all these legacy media
00:02:43.500
outlets buy the article and then publish the exact same article in their on their website so what we had
00:02:50.480
were headlines coming out of the calgary stampede that read trudeau mob by admirers happy stampede trudeau
00:02:58.660
mob by throngs of admirers as the national observer wrote and the globe and mail and the toronto star
00:03:05.120
and ctv news they all wrote this they all republished this canadian press story andrew that said trudeau
00:03:11.320
mob by admirers at stampede breakfast only one outlet got the message the day later it was the globe and
00:03:17.820
mail they very quietly changed the headline and the headline change went from trudeau mob by admirers
00:03:24.760
at calgary stampede pancake breakfast to trudeau references inflation and ukraine at the calgary
00:03:31.700
stampede so really just a slight change there andrew nothing too drastic i don't think anyone noticed
00:03:36.780
yeah i mean just as far as trudeau admirers go here here's one clip that i think shows all that
00:03:42.900
admiration you can just hear and sense and feel the admiration uh shouting down to justin trudeau
00:03:49.100
will you take my hand home in a freedom play
00:03:52.260
thank you thank you you had your 20 seconds there was a pleasure
00:03:56.440
are you 20 seconds you common ass go trudeau you're nothing but a commonest pig
00:04:03.320
that's what you are you're disgusting
00:04:06.720
political prisoners
00:04:09.840
ah yes you had your 20 seconds i'm moving on that's what you say to your admirers isn't when
00:04:17.440
people are shouting at you with their cheer and their joy and their love and their adoration
00:04:21.860
that that i know that's what it sounds like in fairness to trudeau that may be about as
00:04:27.060
admiring as it gets as of late uh but it's the media covering for it and that's i think the big
00:04:32.960
story here always is that you know politicians are going to get heckled politicians are going to be
00:04:37.500
met generally speaking with i think similar crowds wherever they go trudeau when he goes to alberta
00:04:43.200
in election campaigns he he does like an 11 30 p.m rally because he doesn't want to waste time in
00:04:48.880
the daylight in places where he's not going to win any votes i mean he's got that one mp there that
00:04:54.240
is i think a disgraced mp at this point george jahal that he was at uh flipping pancakes and all that
00:05:00.640
but this was not a friendly place for him and when when media says that i'm like i didn't even need
00:05:06.160
to look at the videos to know i'm guessing he wasn't met by a mob or a throng or even a gaggle
00:05:13.040
of admirers in the general public at the calgary stampede i didn't like i i knew that was wrong
00:05:18.080
before i even saw the footage and that so it's no surprise they ended up having to backtrack a bit
00:05:22.480
there well it was i mean the article is still up all over the internet andrew so it's only really the
00:05:27.040
globe and mail that we have found that have actually you know changed their headline to be
00:05:31.440
somewhat representative of the truth because it's always as if these these journalists aren't
00:05:36.560
thinking about the fact that everyone is recording everything especially when the prime minister shows
00:05:41.280
up in their own backyard they're going to have their phones out they're going to record these so-called
00:05:45.680
admirers and if you're hearing that video clip uh it sounds as though in one of those clips those
00:05:51.760
admirers might be calling him a traitor i'm not sure andrew that that doesn't sound like total admiration
00:05:57.680
to me but then again i'm not a canadian press journalist so i don't really know what their
00:06:03.520
definition of admiration uh you know what their definition of admiration means because it almost
00:06:09.840
sounds as though i can hear the word traitor being used at justin trudeau uh and you know like i said
00:06:15.360
this this whole calgary trip this whole stampede trip was a total disaster from the beginning he not
00:06:20.960
only did this pancake breakfast at a public library kilometers away from the stampede grounds when
00:06:27.520
the conservatives were in the heart of the stampede and then again it is alberta so it is sort of
00:06:32.400
their their province where they have more most of the support but it's pretty ridiculous to say that
00:06:37.920
trudeau was met by admirers or mobbed by admirers at the stampede when he's not even at the stampede
00:06:42.800
grounds and to be fair to trudeau he actually did go to the stampede but when he went there he went
00:06:48.640
there when there was no one around so he went into he toured an empty stadium he toured empty grounds
00:06:55.280
and they did their absolute best to make it look as though trudeau was mod by all these admirers i
00:07:00.160
mean that headline is straight out of like a china people's daily article andrew it's ridiculous mod
00:07:06.240
by admirers it's it just honestly i think at this point we should all recognize that there really isn't
00:07:13.680
a depth too low for these canadian press these legacy media journalists to go and some people made
00:07:18.720
the comment on twitter that it was almost like an inside joke that someone made a joke about making that
00:07:24.480
the headline of the article and then all these legacy media outlets didn't recognize it was a
00:07:28.880
joke and they just went with it and all of a sudden there there we go there's this propaganda like
00:07:33.680
pravda like headline of of trudeau and his admirers in alberta it's it's just ridiculous and i will make
00:07:40.000
one more point about the stampede and about how all these politicians dress up and they put on the
00:07:45.920
they put on the cowboy attire now i i understand i'm not an albertan but it seems very bizarre to me to
00:07:52.640
have someone like trudeau play dress up as a cowboy uh you know it's it's almost like it's
00:07:59.440
almost like making a caricature of albertans and being like hey look i'm like one of you guys i'm
00:08:03.920
just like a regular albertan look at me in my white cowboy hat with all my rcmp wearing the exact same
00:08:08.960
hat it's it's so ridiculous to me i just i don't understand it i i think look i i'm gonna give him
00:08:14.560
some i'm gonna give him some slack on that one because as far as trudeau's costumes go this seems like
00:08:21.520
one of the less offensive ones he's done like we're talking about a guy that did like brown
00:08:28.320
face and a turban so as far as cowboys and indians go he's done the indian costume and that offends
00:08:34.080
everyone and the cowboy costume i feel is is a little bit less offensive but nevertheless one
00:08:39.840
thing i will say he used the opportunity not just to do the glad hand but also to do what i'm gonna call
00:08:45.280
pancake pandering because while he was uh flapping flipping flapjacks he was flapping his gums and
00:08:53.040
talking about ukraine and inch by very dramatically inch by inch step by step he was talking about the
00:08:59.280
progress that justin trudeau was making on saturday this is a piece in the globe and he says this is a
00:09:04.720
moment to gather and to celebrate being together once again and then he talks about ukraine he said
00:09:10.240
we're facing more challenges with the war in ukraine with the global inflation crisis so i believe he
00:09:15.360
was solving those uh one flip at a time uh around the mob that never was uh let's talk a little bit
00:09:22.240
about another i'll say non-admirer and that would be patrick brown's spokesperson vis-a-vis true north so
00:09:31.520
true north has been really leaning into covering the conservative party of canada leadership race we have a
00:09:36.000
lot of people in our audience who are conservative members or at the very least interested in
00:09:41.680
conservative politics so i've been on my show doing these long-form interviews with all of the
00:09:46.800
candidates we've been talking to as many of them as we can we've been covering their policy
00:09:50.880
announcements and we we had a lot of difficulty getting an interview with patrick brown he was the
00:09:56.240
only he was our last candidate uh to speak to in this race and it was very difficult and now he's
00:10:02.000
been disqualified from the race i'm not saying the two are connected but i am saying that we were
00:10:06.240
actually trying from the get-go to uh cover patrick brown and we have covered all the races well we
00:10:12.240
wrote yesterday a story noah jarvis at true north wrote a story that was a very solid story about how
00:10:18.560
even though he's been disqualified he's still fundraising for his leadership campaign to the
00:10:24.480
conservative party of canada membership list so he's still well being disqualified fundraising this is
00:10:30.320
the story we'd write about any candidate and in true good journalistic faction noah reached out to
00:10:35.760
patrick brown's campaign and specifically his campaign spokesperson chisholm pothier and
00:10:42.000
the statement we got back is absolutely fantastic here can quote me so this is the entirety of his
00:10:50.400
official response maybe you guys should stop being a newsletter for polyev and do some actual journalism
00:10:57.440
or maybe just organized another of the worst conservative leadership debates ever dealer's
00:11:02.480
choice we received the list that was given to us at the time to communicate to the members on that list
00:11:08.160
we continue to do so are you diligently exploring rumors of full-time consultants being paid by their
00:11:14.720
companies to work on polyev's campaign because that would be actual journalism so by the way this is
00:11:21.440
the first time i've heard this rumor so i can diligently explore the rumor all i want but the
00:11:26.640
story that noah was writing was not about a rumor it was about a fact which chisholm pothier confirmed
00:11:34.320
in the third and fourth lines of this statement which i think can best be characterized as a rant and
00:11:42.160
it's funny because when we've criticized pierre polyev whether it was on you know bitcoin or just pushing
00:11:47.760
back on some of his statements on on various policies people say oh yeah you're shilling
00:11:52.400
for this candidate or that one so this is like not the statement you give to endear yourself to
00:11:58.000
any media outlet is it harrison no it's not and i wonder how many media outlets have interviewed all
00:12:03.120
of the candidates given them and being very careful to make sure that we give them all the same amount
00:12:07.680
of air time and not to favor one or the other so obviously we've done our part but there's so many
00:12:12.560
ways you can go into this this statement it's it's pretty much just gold uh from start to finish
00:12:17.920
starting with can't quote me and ending with uh you know some some rumor that would be actual
00:12:22.880
journalism if we investigated it but it's kind of interesting because part of me thinks that at this
00:12:28.480
point in the patrick brown campaign they have nothing to lose they're out of the race they've already
00:12:32.480
he's already endorsed john charay right at this point it would be kind of fun almost you could just
00:12:37.120
really throw anything you want out and and attack we want to attack make jokes so part of me kind of
00:12:42.080
understand maybe they're just letting loose uh but also this is pretty fiery from patrick brown's
00:12:48.160
spokesperson it would almost be kind of interesting to see if patrick brown would have used this sort of
00:12:52.960
language and attacked his opponents or attack the attack justin trudeau or attack the left in the
00:12:57.280
campaign with this kind of energy i think that'd be kind of entertaining it would have would have
00:13:00.880
probably spiced up his campaign a little bit don't you think well i mean certainly his fundraising emails
00:13:05.680
like patrick brown was going after pierre pauliev in all of his recruitment emails i i did a search once
00:13:11.120
and i at some point in the campaign i can't remember when it was it was like of the 20 emails
00:13:15.920
he had sent out like 17 of them were about pierre pauliev it was pretty crazy but the funny thing is
00:13:21.360
like patrick i've known patrick brown for many many years and he's always very friendly and amiable in
00:13:26.400
person so like i i ran into him after the debate in edmonton the first uh official conservative
00:13:32.400
leadership debate and i've been like trying now for i don't know a week or two months or however long to
00:13:37.280
get him on the show and then he's he like comes up he's like andrew when can i come when am i coming
00:13:41.360
on your show and i'm like you tell me like how about right now so he's always very friendly so he
00:13:46.240
wouldn't even do this in person uh but you know he you have the hatchet men who work on campaigns that
00:13:51.280
are either moonlighting as you know just anti-true north renegades or whatever or perhaps this is an
00:13:58.080
official you know campaign position that we are supposedly a pauliev newsletter but i think one thing
00:14:04.640
you'll find is that there are no outlets in the what what you know we hear as the legacy media that
00:14:11.120
are covering the conservative leadership race on the issues that matter to conservatives and i think
00:14:16.240
there's there's something quite telling about a campaign that doesn't seem to see the value in that
00:14:22.240
a campaign that wants to use cbc and globe and global to get out its message while trying to woo
00:14:28.640
conservative members and it we know it just doesn't work no exactly and and if we we have to
00:14:34.560
talk about this point about the debate the worst conservative debate ever uh that's okay hang on
00:14:40.880
which one i don't know if he was talking about like the independent press gallery debate from 2020
00:14:47.040
or if he's talking about like the canada strong and free debate that candace malcolm and jamil javani did
00:14:51.520
i'm i'm trying to figure that out no exactly and and what are we are we going to consider the actual
00:14:56.960
conservative party of canada debate the one that they put on where the moderator the moderator was
00:15:01.760
asking all the candidates about their favorite books their favorite food their favorite music
00:15:06.240
or are they going to talk about the one in which the candidates actually let loose actually had some
00:15:11.360
you know had some actual dialogue and real debate it's ridiculous so are we are we do are we to assume
00:15:16.160
that the debate put on by the party where they were asked questions about their favorite books and
00:15:21.840
their favorite tv shows to binge is that better or worse for members than a debate that acts that
00:15:27.440
asks the candidates real questions i mean that that debate was a was a total mockery of the process
00:15:35.200
of the conservative party itself and the membership whereas the the debate hosted by the canada strong
00:15:40.640
and free network was a legitimate debate and then the ipg debate was a fireside chat because the
00:15:45.600
candidates didn't even end up going i mean what yeah and brand yeah and brown turned down this year's one yeah
00:15:52.240
no exactly it's it's a very bizarre very bizarre line to take and and i think there's probably
00:15:57.120
there's there's better ammunition better targets for them to go after than to talk about the debates
00:16:02.000
in which i think if you were to poll and every conservative member i think the overwhelming majority
00:16:07.520
would side uh on the side that says no the canada strong and free debate was a legitimate debate
00:16:12.480
the conservative party english debate was a total joke it was a total farce of a debate
00:16:17.280
yeah no i i think you're you're very right on that let's move to this one here i'll let you take the
00:16:23.840
lead on this one uh the toronto star again not i would say always in touch with canadians this story
00:16:30.240
it seems they're not particularly in touch with canada either well it's it's that's one way to put it
00:16:35.680
they're not really in touch with canadians andrew i think some people might have uh more you know
00:16:40.800
more serious language to uh to use about that but the toronto star has for some weird reason spent a
00:16:48.240
long time talking about why they hate the canadian flag why the canadian flag needs to be you know
00:16:54.240
needs to you know we need to stop flying the canadian flag or talk about the issues with the canadian flag
00:16:58.480
they do seem to have an issue with it and this latest op-ed by them it probably takes the cake
00:17:05.040
as the number one piece of lunacy that they've published about the canadian flag i i hang on
00:17:10.480
that's that's an ambitious that i i would not say that because they've probably uh published loony
00:17:15.840
things that you know compete with this certainly for a tie well i mean andrew this op-ed is telling
00:17:21.600
us that the way to reclaim the canadian flag is to fly the pride flag beside it so i mean we can say
00:17:27.360
the you know we we've heard the left talk about the canadian flag being a symbol of those evil nasty
00:17:33.600
truckers we've heard the left talk about how the canadian flag is is this it's been co-opted by far
00:17:40.400
right groups this is i think to me this is this is pretty serious to say that actually the best way to
00:17:46.960
reclaim the canadian flag is not to fly the canadian flag with with more you know excitement or to fly it
00:17:54.480
you know in different places no no it's to fly the canadian flag beside the pride flag
00:17:58.880
in order to reclaim the flag we need to fly it beside the pride flag this is what it says uh about
00:18:05.040
this it says one possibility is the co-display of flags whereby co-branding is exercised the idea
00:18:11.280
to seek symbols that can be perceived as strong compliments and signal the values desirable to be
00:18:15.600
aligned with yes so not only do we want to fly the fly the pride flag beside the canadian flag we're
00:18:21.360
trying to take on the the meaning of what it means i want to take on that pride flag meaning into our
00:18:27.200
country in practice such an approach was observable when walking past the canadian embassy in seoul korea
00:18:32.640
during july 1st holiday weekend a more sizable rainbow flag was visible along to the canyon flag so
00:18:38.320
it's great andrew our embassies in other countries on canada day are flying the pride flag a more sizable
00:18:46.320
pride flag on the canadian buildings just a great direction i think we're all heading in
00:18:51.360
you know one of the things i find fascinating so this year for pride i i didn't actually see many
00:18:57.040
pride flags because the old pride flag of the rainbow colors has been replaced by a new pride
00:19:03.040
flag which i had never seen before you know two months ago so i i might my position on this is fly
00:19:08.240
your pride flag fly whichever version of it you want i mean canada's flag has changed over time so
00:19:13.200
we can add more colors to the pride flag but i i vehemently reject this idea that the canada flag
00:19:18.960
cannot stand on its own and fly on its own without needing to be qualified by something so the idea
00:19:25.680
that we would need to have the canadian flag next to the pride flag to be happy with the canadian flag
00:19:30.960
at that point like just change the canadian flag then i mean because clearly you don't think it's
00:19:34.800
something worth flying and you know when people like justin trudeau supported lowering the canadian
00:19:42.400
flag to half mast indefinitely over canada day throughout the election it was something that
00:19:50.160
people like me were bothered by because symbols matter flags matter and what he was saying is that
00:19:56.400
this is not a country we can be proud of and this is not a flag we can be proud of and this is the
00:20:01.120
direct consequence of that because you're telling canadians that your country is broken and i don't
00:20:06.720
mean broken in the sense of it's doing all these policy things we want to change but fundamentally
00:20:11.120
structurally a bad place and this is i think what's happening now so the idea that there are people
00:20:17.520
like the toronto stars reporters here cbc's reporters some pollsters that say yeah this is
00:20:22.960
actually offensive anyone who flies the canadian flag is is doing something offensive and the only
00:20:27.840
way i mean a canadian flag well if you if you put up a canadian flag you're probably a trucker
00:20:31.760
sympathizer unless it's a canadian flag next to a pride flag that's how we know you're really inclusive
00:20:36.720
it's like at what point do we just say you know what screw the whole thing canada doesn't get to be a
00:20:40.720
country anymore no and and the article actually says andrew exactly the point you just made the
00:20:47.040
article in the article the toronto star writes while the rainbow where pride flag is a symbol of
00:20:51.840
the lgbt community the commonly associated proclamation love is love has wider applicability
00:20:58.640
the co-display of flags near the building's front entrance cues that canada aspires to be a nation of
00:21:04.240
diversity and inclusiveness so canada is aspiring to be a nation of inclusive inclusivity and diversity
00:21:11.920
uh do we have to aspire to that or is canada probably one of the only countries that does that
00:21:18.160
in the way that we do i mean maybe we should try to be you know better should we try and emulate the
00:21:22.720
middle east or some asian countries that maybe maybe that would be better for us you know through
00:21:27.680
co-branding the canadian flag can be effectively reclaimed is what they say now constant attention must turn
00:21:33.280
to providing passports so they put that spin on it as though they're not really they're kind of
00:21:37.280
pretending not to be so serious but of course they're serious andrew this is what they actually
00:21:40.560
believe this is what people like this really believe that if you don't if you fly the canadian
00:21:45.280
flag on its own you must be some nationalist some evil nationalist someone who's proud of the country
00:21:51.840
that they shouldn't be proud of because we're not we're not inclusive enough yet we're not diverse
00:21:55.440
enough yet the only way that they think it's acceptable to fly the canadian flag is if you
00:21:59.840
fly it beside a pride flag and who knows at this point the rainbow flag sooner or later might become
00:22:04.720
a hate symbol because it doesn't have that weird south african style uh pride progress flag with the
00:22:10.720
with the triangle in it now you know so it's just absurd and i do believe based on the other headlines
00:22:17.520
that toronto star has written about the flag see john k over a quillette tweeted a photo of all the
00:22:23.520
different toronto star op-ed headlines about the flag you know we've got the freedom convoy
00:22:27.840
convoy occupation of ottawa besmirched the canadian flag the innocuous canadian flag the ottawa occupation
00:22:33.920
move was to step away from that naivete when i see the canada flag now it hurts my heart as freedom
00:22:39.920
convoy returns was a tug of war over the maple leaf so it's all i told you they had loonier stuff there
00:22:45.120
in the archives well it depends what it depends i mean it's all it's all these people talking about
00:22:49.440
the op-ed regarding the freedom call about you know freedom convoy related stories this is now saying
00:22:54.560
unless you fly the canadian flag beside the pride flag you are you are promoting racism you are
00:23:00.720
promoting uh some sort of nationalism that you're not that we're not allowed to that we're not allowed
00:23:05.360
to uh i don't know what's worse andrew we're gonna have to perhaps agree to disagree or leave it up to
00:23:10.480
the audience to see what they think about what's worse uh the the stories about the the freedom convoy
00:23:16.880
and the flag being a representative of the freedom convoy are having to fly the flag beside the pride flag
00:23:22.640
something that i think is just absolutely ridiculous something that i think you know we
00:23:27.040
should all say we've we've gone a bit too far here we're not flying a rainbow flag beside the canadian
00:23:32.320
flag on all of our government buildings don't tell that to justin trito though because it will happen
00:23:37.920
i just like that they use the word co-branding so now the idea is for the government to use like
00:23:42.560
instagram influencer language and corporate jargon so we'll be doing synergies we'll be doing co-branding
00:23:47.920
we'll be doing partnerships we'll be doing it all and it starts at your local government office
00:23:53.120
uh let's let's close things off with a fun one here this was one you found harrison
00:23:57.200
yeah so this is another a great cbc news story keeping canadians informed and really living up
00:24:02.080
to their mandate andrew because with a price tag of 1.4 billion dollars a year 1.4 billion dollars to
00:24:07.360
give canadians timely factual news to make sure all canadians are in the in the know about what's
00:24:12.880
going on in our country so of course thank goodness the cbc feeling a little like they
00:24:18.080
were perhaps not keeping canadians informed enough on wednesday wrote an article by this uh
00:24:24.800
by this woman see it's getting very confusing these days andrew but i'm gonna go with woman
00:24:29.440
because the name is renee renee yoxon uh this they wrote an op-ed from renee yoxon who is a let me just
00:24:36.720
get this right here renee yoxon is a voice coach a gender affirming voice coach excuse me not just a
00:24:43.920
voice coach a gender affirming voice coach and the cb this op-ed is talking about how people have the
00:24:50.160
ability andrew to feminize or masculinize their voice while they're going through their gender
00:24:56.080
transition so there's a video of this cbc news published this video because it's important to
00:25:01.200
remind canadians this is what your taxpayer dollars are going to when you see this stuff this is where it's
00:25:05.760
going so of course they write they write this long op-ed about feminizing or masculinizing your voice
00:25:10.400
but who really reads those these days they put out a video for us a tick tock andrew and we're just
00:25:15.360
going to watch this and i want to get your reaction to it as you're watching it let's play this video
00:25:20.000
my name is renee yoxon and i'm a gender affirming voice teacher from montreal today i'm going to prove
00:25:24.560
to you that you already have everything you need to create a speaking voice that you love using one
00:25:29.040
quick exercise everything i need start i'm going to have you say a small cute key key key key key key
00:25:38.560
now try a big relaxed one minute andrew come on oh oh oh oh if you're trying to masculinize your
00:25:47.040
voice i want you to say that big relax what am i doing and then memorize that shape and use it when
00:25:52.240
you say it big and relaxed okay so oh is the masculine word oh oh okay i got to do the hands
00:25:59.040
key key key now if you're trying to feminize your voice i want you to say that small and cute key
00:26:04.960
memorize that shape and then hold it when you go and say oh oh like a woman oh i can't say oh the way
00:26:12.240
like key and oh are different oh creating a speaking voice that best represents your gender identity is
00:26:17.200
something that the pitch isn't even changing like i don't even do like out okay i'm just trying to
00:26:21.280
figure out how i'm supposed to like keep my mouth the shape of when i say key while i say okay key oh
00:26:30.240
they're different words this is like this is like miles above my head this is like a level of complication
00:26:36.880
that i i have not mastered yet like i i just thought you could just raise the pitch like i can go oh or i
00:26:42.720
can go key like that i didn't i didn't need an exercise for that are you saying andrew that renee
00:26:48.880
has not taught you how to feminize your voice properly yet because it is in it's in all of us
00:26:54.240
we have the skills in all of us andrew so you got to keep working on it we'll have to come back to
00:26:58.960
it next week i think when you've had some time to practice you've worked on your keys and your o's
00:27:04.720
uh memorize the shape that's what she says and i think you know this is the kind of content that
00:27:10.960
without without it i don't know where we'd be as a country andrew yeah i mean i'm fearful
00:27:16.320
but this will just demonstrate to cbc that they need to do like a longer video that i've
00:27:20.240
i've not sufficiently grasped this uh so i i need to go back go back to the drawing board so i okay
00:27:26.400
can you do the key o thing because like i like i just thought if you wanted to sound like a woman you
00:27:31.040
raise your voice if you want to sound like a man you lower your voice that like the keo thing just
00:27:34.720
confused me more no well i i'm also in the same position i i'm not exactly sure when she says
00:27:40.560
memorize those shapes you know say it big and loud or say it cute like key is a cute key i i i
00:27:48.080
i'm not there just yet either i think we have some we have some we have some some studying to do
00:27:53.920
some cbc studying to do yeah and i feel like when i do the o i've just like called a crow to my
00:28:00.720
house door i feel like i feel like i'm doing this eventually you're just gonna hear birds
00:28:03.920
slapping up against the window because my o is not as a renee did a better o than i did my key was
00:28:09.040
pretty strong renee renee is clearly the expert here and again i just that's why she's the coach
00:28:14.720
that's why she's the coach exactly i i do worry about you know there's a lot going on these days
00:28:19.920
in the country you know there's a lot of news but this is the kind of thing that keeps us all sane
00:28:24.560
right it keeps us all on a level playing field when we see this we go okay we're we're still living
00:28:28.640
in regular times things haven't totally gone nuts uh our our public broadcaster is teaching us
00:28:35.440
how to masculinize and feminize our voices i mean that's just really at this point it's just par for
00:28:39.920
the course of the cbc you know i i'm told that true north has started a tick tock recently i feel
00:28:45.040
like we need to get like the key o challenge going and get all of our you know true north fans to like
00:28:50.480
let us know how they make out on that but if you guys do better than i do we maybe have to do a
00:28:54.960
follow-up next week and we'll play your your masculine your masculine o's and your feminine keys
00:29:00.800
and you're we and there's got to be like a non-binary word in the middle there that we can do
00:29:04.720
as well we don't leave out the non-binary yeah masculine feminine that seems kind of like one
00:29:08.560
or the other i didn't know that that's where we were i didn't know that's where we were i thought
00:29:11.600
we were past that but we were a few at least a few months past that that we can we can be whoever
00:29:16.560
we want to be we can find some place in the middle that fits us best yeah i mean my whole thing
00:29:21.600
here is that the old ethos that i used to be told and that i used to hear told to other people was
00:29:29.040
be who you want to be so the idea that now it's have performance that if you want to be who you
00:29:33.920
want to be you have to like fundamentally change yourself is i think moving in the the opposite
00:29:38.560
direction of progress but nevertheless i will uh we'll work on my phonics uh my phonics sounds and my
00:29:45.280
phonemes and all of this and we'll we'll have to get back to you later on this thanks for making me
00:29:50.400
subject myself to that harrison it's all you've got some work to do with that andrew i i have to say
00:29:54.800
uh harrison fulkner host of ratioed on true north and yours truly host of the less creatively titled
00:30:01.280
andrew lawton show on true north andrew lawton we will be back next week with more fake news friday
00:30:06.960
here on true north thanks everyone have a great weekend and we'll talk to you soon
Link copied!