Juno News - November 29, 2018


The True North Report: Justin Trudeau's Franco-virtue signalling

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Canada's media is being corrupted by the Trudeau Liberals Trudeau didn't budget for cost of illegal border crossing

Episode Stats


Length

29 minutes

Words per minute

170.92

Word count

5,117

Sentence count

342

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Andrew Lawton talks about the impact of GM's announcement that it's closing 5 plants across North America, including one in Oshawa, Ontario, Canada, and the political response from Doug Ford and the NDP government in Ontario.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good afternoon, or I should say good morning for the next 29 minutes if you are in Canada's West Coast time zones today.
00:00:08 My name is Andrew Lawton, fellow with the True North Initiative, here to talk about all that is happening in the world
00:00:15 and hopefully in true True North Initiative fashion, try to put some solutions on the radar for you.
00:00:21 It's been a very busy week for news. I want to get through a few different stories here that have been happening.
00:00:28 And actually, I'm finding there is a common thread throughout them, and a lot of that comes down to priorities from the government.
00:00:38 I got the first reaction actually a minute ago, and it's an angry face.
00:00:41 I don't know if that's an angry face about me bombarding your screen or if it's an angry face about what the actual text of the live video is saying,
00:00:51 which is thousands of autoworkers are facing unemployment, and Justin Trudeau decides to wage a bilingualism war with Doug Ford.
00:00:59 Well, I guess I told you what we're talking about today.
00:01:01 It's huge, though, because we had just a few days ago the news from GM that it was shuttering five plants across –
00:01:09 I got another angry face. Okay, I'm just going to assume you are all angry at Justin Trudeau and not me,
00:01:14 and I'm sticking to it here. But we have the news that GM is shuttering five plants across North America,
00:01:21 two in Michigan, and one very significantly for Canadians in Oshawa.
00:01:26 Now, it's not GM's only facility in Oshawa, but it is a large one,
00:01:31 and it has been manufacturing Chevrolet products for the last century.
00:01:36 And it's as much a part – and I said this in a Looney Politics column today –
00:01:41 it's as much a part of the economic fabric of Oshawa and Durham region and all of this stuff
00:01:46 as it is about the community fabric in Oshawa.
00:01:50 Like, I've always, my whole life, I've known of GM and Oshawa as just being synonymous with one another.
00:01:56 I mean, that community built itself, as so many automotive sector communities did, around the plant.
00:02:03 And that is so key. And I know that Jennifer French, who we'll talk about in a few moments,
00:02:08 the NDP provincial representative there, the MPP, had said that, you know, GM didn't build Oshawa.
00:02:15 Oshawa built GM. And quite frankly, the two go hand in hand.
00:02:19 Whenever a plant closes, you see the ripple effect it causes.
00:02:24 And look, I've spent a lot of time in Detroit.
00:02:27 And what's fascinating in Detroit is when you see these plants that have closed down,
00:02:31 like the Packard plant or the Fisher plant, these giant plants,
00:02:35 you see for blocks and blocks and blocks, all of those abandoned houses of, quite frankly,
00:02:42 the people that used to work at that plant.
00:02:44 So, yes, these communities become very much defined by their largest employers.
00:02:50 And that is so true when it comes to Oshawa.
00:02:54 It's true with the automotive sector in general.
00:02:56 So I want to preface everything I say here by pointing out that I am with the workers
00:03:04 who are finding themselves facing unemployment at GM Oshawa.
00:03:09 I get it. And I understand the concerns.
00:03:11 And there are some people that I think have a tendency to shrug and go,
00:03:15 oh, well, that's the free market at work, you know, ta-da.
00:03:17 No, just because it is the free market at work and just because this is part of a natural cycle
00:03:22 of economics and employment and unemployment doesn't mean that it's good to watch.
00:03:27 It doesn't mean that it's nice to see.
00:03:29 And it doesn't mean that we should be celebrating it.
00:03:31 We can say this is reality, but that doesn't mean that we have to be happy about it.
00:03:37 And where I want to jump off from with this particular video is the political response to this.
00:03:43 Because I put a little video out the other day that was taking aim at this incentive
00:03:48 that governments are trying to talk about to how can we make them.
00:03:51 It's not an incentive. It's how can we force GM to stay here.
00:03:55 And Jennifer French, that NDP member of provincial parliament,
00:03:58 was saying that this decision must be fought.
00:04:01 Well, you can't fight it.
00:04:03 Government can't force a company to stay where it doesn't want to be.
00:04:07 But again, there is still a significant issue at stake when companies like GM
00:04:13 or any other large employer decides to pull up stakes.
00:04:16 This is an issue that's going to impact thousands of people.
00:04:19 It's an issue that's going to impact the fabric of that entire region
00:04:24 and of the manufacturing sector more broadly.
00:04:27 And it's one where governments still have to respond to it,
00:04:31 but their response has to be dealing with things that are within their parameters.
00:04:36 So government has to stay in its lane, so to speak.
00:04:40 And that's what Doug Ford has been doing in Ontario.
00:04:42 He's been saying, look, it's done, it's gone, we can't bring it back.
00:04:45 But what we can do is put the infrastructure in place for the workers who are displaced.
00:04:50 So he's looking a year down the road and saying, what can we do about EI benefits?
00:04:54 What can we do about retraining potential?
00:04:56 What can we do about making it so there is an economic climate for this company,
00:05:03 X company, not the spy agency X company, but company X, to say, all right,
00:05:08 we're going to move to Oshawa because there's a facility there.
00:05:10 We think we can do good.
00:05:11 And that Ontario province is open for business.
00:05:14 That's what's on all the signs now when you come into Ontario, thanks to Doug Ford.
00:05:19 So that's what the government's response should be.
00:05:22 Justin Trudeau similarly has to look at what is in his lane, which is how the federal government
00:05:28 can make things better for people without pushing it to the point of corporate welfare.
00:05:33 And that's not what Justin Trudeau has done instead this week.
00:05:39 So you've got a full-blown economic crisis at a local level, and that's what it is at
00:05:44 the local level.
00:05:45 It's not a national recession or anything like that, but you've got a significant economic
00:05:48 issue, and Justin Trudeau decides that he is going to instead take aim at Doug Ford over
00:05:57 bilingualism.
00:06:01 Yeah, and I bet all of the workers that are going to be losing their jobs in Oshawa soon
00:06:05 care so much about whether Franco-Ontarians can go to a university.
00:06:10 This is, if you're not from Ontario, you're going to absolutely love this story.
00:06:13 So in Ontario, which has 13.5 million residents, 600,000 of those, so if anyone in the comments
00:06:20 section wants to do some quick math and tell me what percentage of 13.5 million, 600,000
00:06:25 is, I think it's at, I'm not even going to try, I'm just going to embarrass myself, but
00:06:30 you've got 600,000 Franco-Ontarians.
00:06:34 Most of them, by the way, are in a few select pockets of the province, and Northern Ontario
00:06:40 is one of those, and one of the big issues that Doug Ford has found himself facing in
00:06:46 Ontario is whether he is going to follow through on spending commitments that were made to appease
00:06:52 Franco-Ontarians by the former Liberal government, the Liberal government he defeated in the June
00:06:57 election.
00:06:59 And this is so key here, because what's happened is he's taken a look at the books in Ontario
00:07:06 and find that there is a $15 billion deficit, $15 billion that the province just doesn't
00:07:12 have, that it is still on the hook for, that ultimately has to go to debt.
00:07:16 So he said, all right, what we can do is we can roll back a few different policies and
00:07:20 programs here.
00:07:21 One of them was what was going to be millions, tens of millions of dollars spent on setting
00:07:26 up a French language university in the province's capital of Toronto.
00:07:32 A French university in Ontario, which is technically a unilingual English province, even though there
00:07:39 are Franco-Ontarians, it is a bilingual province only in the federal context.
00:07:45 It specifically to the province is unilingual, and that is so significant right now.
00:07:51 So this was going to cost tens of millions of dollars.
00:07:54 A French language services commissioner, which is basically a government bureaucrat to make
00:07:58 sure that everyone is offering, you know, things in French to the extent that they can
00:08:02 and must, would be there.
00:08:04 And this was something Doug Ford came in, he's like, yeah, we don't need that, we don't need
00:08:08 that, we don't need that.
00:08:09 And by the way, I have been like clamoring for years to find a provincial leader in my
00:08:15 province that's just going to come in and say, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope, nope.
00:08:18 Like that's so key right now.
00:08:21 So of course, the outrage from the Franco-Ontarians was very swift.
00:08:25 There's all of this identity politics nonsense we see with them, where they define themselves,
00:08:31 and you even see this in the media coverage about them, the minority, the Franco minority,
00:08:36 the French language minority.
00:08:38 So they're starting to characterize themselves as a minority, because once you have put minority,
00:08:45 and it's mathematically, yes, it's a minority.
00:08:48 I mean, I could say people that walk around with cheese graters on their heads, though, are
00:08:52 a minority, because there's only three of them.
00:08:53 But the, and all of them are in the NDP caucus, I mean, that's the downside.
00:08:58 But the fact is that, yes, they're a minority, because it's a small group.
00:09:02 And once we start catering to that minority, we are deliberately setting a policy objective 1.00
00:09:08 where we cater to the few, and only to the few, and then we'll have to cater to everyone. 0.66
00:09:16 And to illustrate the absurdity of this, I wanted, the French language university was ridiculous.
00:09:21 And I want to read a comment here that was in a news report by, I think it was CBC that
00:09:28 did the report here.
00:09:29 I have a few tabs open, so bear with me.
00:09:32 Yes.
00:09:33 So Carol Jolin, who's the president of the Francophone Assembly of Ontario, which apparently
00:09:38 exists, said when Doug Ford made the decision that it was a black day for Francos.
00:09:44 And she said about the French university, this line, quote, the French university was more
00:09:52 than just a French university.
00:09:54 It's a symbol for the province.
00:09:57 And it was a fantastic step forward.
00:10:01 Francois Legault, who is the new premier of Quebec, who's actually supposedly conservative,
00:10:07 said, I want French in Ontario to be protected as much as possible.
00:10:11 And Trudeau, of course, weighs in on this by saying he's deeply disappointed by cuts to
00:10:18 Ontario French services.
00:10:20 And Trudeau also commissioned like an emergency crack panel of all the party leaders to talk
00:10:25 about how the federal lawmakers and policymakers can respond to, you know, the egregiousness
00:10:31 of what Doug Ford is doing to Franco-Ontarians.
00:10:34 I mean, the level of response to a policy that impacts so few people in Ontario, but costs
00:10:42 money to the entirety of the province has been so fascinating to watch here.
00:10:47 And this morning, the French, I forget her exact title.
00:10:52 She was the parliamentary assistant to the minister of Francophone Affairs in Ontario.
00:10:56 The minister is Caroline Mulroney.
00:10:57 The parliamentary assistant was Andrea Simard, resigned from the PC caucus.
00:11:04 So, or Amanda Simard, rather.
00:11:07 Amanda Simard, who was just elected in June, resigned from the PC caucus over this.
00:11:12 Now, what's just emerged in the last hour is that she was about to be kicked out of caucus.
00:11:18 These two things were happening simultaneously.
00:11:20 The caucus was meeting.
00:11:21 She never showed up to the meeting.
00:11:23 And they were in the middle of a vote to get rid of her.
00:11:26 And in the middle of that, her letter was published.
00:11:30 The two happened independently of one another.
00:11:32 And then she ended up resigning.
00:11:33 But they were about to kick her out because she's been stirring up a fuss about this, 1.00
00:11:38 saying Doug Ford needs to, you know, roll back these cuts to French language services.
00:11:43 And it's actually quite astonishing.
00:11:46 Now, I don't know Amanda Simard.
00:11:47 I mean, she was just elected.
00:11:49 By all accounts, she's a hard worker and earned her election in Glengarry Prescott Russell.
00:11:54 But she is clearly not a conservative if her commitment to fiscal responsibility is overshadowed by her belief in tokenism
00:12:06 and really a handout culture that seems to be promulgated by her for Franco-Ontarians.
00:12:15 And this is not to say that Franco-Ontarians have a culture about handouts.
00:12:19 It's to say that that's the attitude that the lawmakers saying, we have to give them this, this, this, this, this.
00:12:24 That's the idea they're putting forward.
00:12:27 And I want to put this in context here because a French university in Ontario that that one spokesperson says is a symbol.
00:12:35 It's a symbol.
00:12:36 Symbols are expensive and they do nothing.
00:12:37 It's not a symbol for me.
00:12:38 But let me actually tell you how many Torontonians there are who speak French as their first language, who are Francophone Torontonians.
00:12:48 1.3%.
00:12:50 1.3%.
00:12:52 That's it.
00:12:54 So of the people in Toronto, 1.3% of them identify with French as their mother tongue.
00:13:01 And by the way, not all of those are French Canadians.
00:13:04 Some of them are actually like actual France, French people.
00:13:10 But this is what we're looking at here.
00:13:12 1.3%.
00:13:13 And this is the list in the 2016 census data that says the top languages of Toronto.
00:13:21 French is 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12th on the list.
00:13:30 So of all of the languages that are people's first language in Toronto, French is number 12.
00:13:36 Let me share with you the first ones.
00:13:39 English, Cantonese, Mandarin, Tagalog.
00:13:42 Tagalog is number 4 at 3.1%.
00:13:45 Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, Tamil, Farsi, Urdu, Russian, and then French.
00:13:51 So if we are to put a multi-million dollar university or college in place in Toronto for the French language minority, where's the Russian university?
00:14:03 Where's the Tagalog university?
00:14:04 Where's the Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, Tamil, Farsi?
00:14:07 I mean, at a certain point, we're going to have a street where all of the universities are basically just the United Nations because we've had to appease every single minority group possible for the sole purpose of buying votes in three or four different ridings.
00:14:21 And that's so absurd.
00:14:23 And I wish Doug Ford hadn't walked back the French languages commissioner thing.
00:14:29 That was one where he said, all right, we'll keep the French language services commissioner in place, but the university college still gone.
00:14:35 I mean, we can't afford it.
00:14:36 He wants to do it.
00:14:37 He says, look, this is something I support down the road, but we have a $15 billion deficit right now.
00:14:43 This is a luxury item, and it's one that we can't afford.
00:14:46 And that is so entirely reasonable.
00:14:49 Right.
00:14:51 If the French want a university so badly, or a college, rather, I keep using the two interchangeably here, then let them pay for it. 1.00
00:14:59 And there are schools, by the way, already in this space.
00:15:02 This wouldn't be the first example of someone being able to get French language education.
00:15:06 The University of Toronto offers French language studies.
00:15:09 You can go out of province.
00:15:10 There are places like Collège-Barre-Léal.
00:15:12 There are options for you to get a French language post-secondary education.
00:15:17 But why does this need to be something that we have in downtown Toronto with a multimillion dollar price tag for what is 600,000 people across the province and 1.3% of the population in Toronto? 0.58
00:15:32 That is ridiculous.
00:15:33 But it's Trudeau who, while we have people flooding across the borders, while you have thousands of Oshawa residents that are facing unemployment, decides he is going to devote his efforts to waging a bilingualism war against Doug Ford and the province of Ontario.
00:15:54 And I feel bad here for Andrew Scheer, because Andrew Scheer has to be the conservative leader that's not going to alienate Quebec, because Quebec cares not just about the French language in Quebec.
00:16:06 Quebec cares about the French language everywhere else.
00:16:10 So this is great.
00:16:11 Quebec, which wants every other province in...
00:16:13 This actually is making me mad.
00:16:15 It really is.
00:16:16 Because Quebec, which wants every other province in Confederation to leave it alone, has the gall to start telling Doug Ford and the Ontario government all the things they have to do to keep the French language alive and well. 0.99
00:16:30 Quebec, open up your damn wallets. 1.00
00:16:33 If you think other provinces need to do what you've decided is your job, to protect and preserve this French language culture within Canada. 0.99
00:16:41 Quebec should start giving money.
00:16:42 If Quebec wants to start, you know, colonizing French language pockets across the country, they should pay.
00:16:49 They should pay.
00:16:49 Let Quebec's government give a grant to the Ontario government to set up this college.
00:16:54 This is ridiculous that this is the discussion we're having in 2018.
00:16:59 That because the French language minority comes together and says, you know what, we think we need this, this, this, this, this, this.
00:17:06 In a unilingual province that has been, for too long, I think, pretending it's a bilingual province, why should it be incumbent on everyone else to pay for it?
00:17:19 And by the way, this is not a lack of appreciation for French culture.
00:17:23 It's not.
00:17:24 I'm not fluently bilingual, but I have a passing knowledge of French.
00:17:27 I love French Canada.
00:17:29 I love going to Quebec, Montreal, Quebec City, and I like that we are a country that has that.
00:17:35 But I only like that to the extent that it happens organically and naturally, not when the government tries to force it.
00:17:43 I mean, can you imagine right now the Quebec, let's just flip this, the Quebec government, which is so resistant to English-speaking operations, even private businesses.
00:17:52 If someone went to the Quebec government, if Doug Ford went to the Quebec government and said, I'm angry that you're not opening up an English university in Quebec.
00:18:01 Anglos are a minority in Quebec.
00:18:03 English-speaking Quebecers need to be protected because they're a minority.
00:18:07 No, if you were to say to the Quebec government, you know, we're concerned that the English pockets are eroding and the English minority is getting smaller, they would throw a parade.
00:18:18 They would cheer about that.
00:18:20 So I will not take any marching orders on how to deal with language harmony from a province that is hell-bent on eradicating its language minorities. 0.98
00:18:31 Quebec needs to butt out of this.
00:18:33 But Justin Trudeau is doing the same thing, where he's going to a province in Ontario and saying, we need to come up with a federal government response.
00:18:41 Look, bilingualism is a federal issue.
00:18:45 Bilingualism is a federal issue.
00:18:46 So if there is a concern with how language minorities are being treated, let the federal government pony up its cash. 0.54
00:18:53 And this is, by the way, what the Ontario government said a while ago, that if the federal government is going to make this an issue, it has to be prepared to put its money forward.
00:19:03 It has to be prepared to put its money where its mouth is here.
00:19:06 And the fact that Justin Trudeau is now deciding to come up with issues facing the Canadian francophony with Jagmeet Singh, with Elizabeth May, with Andrew Scheer, and with Mario Beaulieu, who's the interim Bloc Québécois leader, like that's his priority this week.
00:19:23 That's all. If you were to send someone to look at all the headlines across the provinces and the country and all of that and say, what are the biggest issues right now in Canada?
00:19:32 They would say, well, based on what Justin Trudeau is doing, it sounds like this is the one, the language issues.
00:19:41 And yes, I get that he can walk and chew gum.
00:19:44 I get that Justin Trudeau is able to look at multiple issues and do that.
00:19:49 But right now we've got a very significant challenge that involves the Prime Minister of Canada and Doug Ford, and that is the government's response on employment insurance and other social services and retraining and all of that stuff.
00:20:03 And instead, Justin Trudeau is picking a fight on bilingualism.
00:20:07 And this discussion, I fear, is never going to go away in Canada.
00:20:12 I don't think it will.
00:20:14 And this bugs me so much.
00:20:16 If you haven't been able to tell, and it's funny, I didn't think that I would get all worked up about this.
00:20:21 But I do because of the arrogance in so many of these people right now that are saying, Ontario has to pay for this, this, this, this, this.
00:20:30 The money simply isn't there.
00:20:33 And you know where else the French are a minority?
00:20:35 Alberta, B.C., Saskatchewan, Manitoba.
00:20:38 And I would love to see how this discussion would go over in Alberta.
00:20:42 And I get that Franco-Ontarians are a group, and I'm not denying that.
00:20:48 Franco-Ontarians are a legitimate demographic group.
00:20:51 600,000 people is not an insignificant number, but it is, by definition, a very small subset of the population.
00:21:00 That's less than 5%.
00:21:01 That's less than 5% of the population.
00:21:04 And, you know, even that I find to be a little bit hard to believe in most parts, because I could go down the street in London, Ontario, and 1 in 20 people are not going to be Franco-Ontarians.
00:21:16 1 in 20 people are not going to be French-Canadians.
00:21:19 It's going to be, I think, in the city of Toronto, well, 1.3%.
00:21:22 So, you know, 1 in 90 people you'll meet there will be French as a first language.
00:21:28 It's in cities like Ottawa.
00:21:30 It's in cities like Timmins.
00:21:32 It's in ridings like Glengarry, Prescott, Russell.
00:21:35 But I actually wanted to put some numbers to you here.
00:21:38 And this came about from a report that CBC's Eric Grenier did.
00:21:43 And it's about the, it's about the riding math, basically, when you look at some of the numbers here.
00:21:51 Because the reaction to Doug Ford doing this, LeJoy called it a black day for Francos.
00:21:58 And, oh, I forget the line that Le Devoir, Le Devoir, oh my goodness, that was such an Anglo way of saying it.
00:22:04 Le Devoir.
00:22:05 I don't have their line here.
00:22:07 But, I mean, the media coverage from outside of Ontario was bad.
00:22:11 But here is the math on this, if I can find it in this story.
00:22:17 So, outside of Quebec, there are four ridings that have majority Francophone populations.
00:22:24 This is nationwide.
00:22:26 Outside of Quebec, four ridings.
00:22:27 Three of them are in New Brunswick, which is actually Canada's only officially bilingual province.
00:22:33 And one in Ontario.
00:22:34 There are 14 ridings where Francophones make up 10% of the population.
00:22:42 New Brunswick, Ontario, Nova Scotia, and Manitoba.
00:22:45 So, in the entire country, outside of Quebec, there are just 14 ridings.
00:22:52 14 political ridings in the country where Francophones even make up 10% of the population.
00:22:59 And half of those voted Conservative in 2011.
00:23:03 So, the Conservatives don't want to rock the boat on this much.
00:23:06 But we're looking at, in Ontario specifically, a tiny, tiny, tiny number of ridings that are impacted by this.
00:23:15 And it's not to say that decisions like right and wrong should be made based on the political math.
00:23:20 But we know that politics is going to be the driving force behind a lot of these decisions and whatnot.
00:23:27 But it is actually so tremendously upsetting to me that we are entertaining these discussions where someone says, a group says, I want my French language college.
00:23:40 Therefore, you've got to pay for it.
00:23:42 And let's look, I mean, you can find other languages that are spoken by similar numbers.
00:23:49 And these groups, like I said, in Toronto, which is where the school will be going, Tagalog.
00:23:53 Okay, let's bankroll the Tagalog University on Yonge Street.
00:23:56 And then we'll go after the Urdu University.
00:23:58 But, oh, no, you don't want to alienate the Farsi.
00:24:00 So, the Farsi University and then the Tamil University.
00:24:03 And like I said, you've got the United Nations of government-funded post-secondary institutions here.
00:24:08 Just because we've got groups that have this political clout.
00:24:13 And Amanda Samard, who, again, I don't know.
00:24:16 I've never met her.
00:24:17 Even though I thought I had met most of the PC caucus members, I've never met her.
00:24:22 And that she would step aside from a career that she could have had for a very long time.
00:24:27 She's, I think, 20, 29 years old or something.
00:24:30 She was born in 89.
00:24:31 So, she's one of the younger MPPs.
00:24:33 And she could have been there in that riding, Blengarry Prescott Russell, probably for the next 25 years.
00:24:38 If she wanted to.
00:24:40 And the fact that she would resign from caucus.
00:24:43 Because a woman who got elected, and I was a candidate in that election. 1.00
00:24:46 I know the message that we were telling people was, we've got to start tightening our belt.
00:24:51 We, as a province, have to live within our means.
00:24:53 We, as a province, can't spend money on luxuries and can't waste money.
00:24:57 She would have been selling that same message to voters in her riding in June. 0.59
00:25:01 But that all of a sudden, when it comes to a handout that specifically targets her and her community, all of a sudden, she throws that out the wind and says, we want it.
00:25:12 We want it now.
00:25:13 And this is the problem.
00:25:16 Anyone who takes that attitude of entitlement is someone for whom I have very little time.
00:25:21 And we're seeing a lot more of that.
00:25:23 And after this, I think we're going to see that become the norm and the normal response from anyone.
00:25:29 I mean, we've got Sikh MPPs, and you've got Muslim MPPs, and you've got Jewish MPPs.
00:25:36 I mean, all of them now.
00:25:37 Okay, we need a Jewish university.
00:25:38 We need that.
00:25:39 And none of those have the constitutional protections and the national identity ingrained like the French language does.
00:25:45 I realize it's not an apples-to-apples comparison.
00:25:49 But we are talking about, and the way this issue is framed, protecting the French minority.
00:25:56 That's how it's termed.
00:25:58 That's how the Quebec premier discusses it.
00:25:59 That's how Justin Trudeau discusses it.
00:26:01 And that's how the media discusses it.
00:26:03 And when they frame it as protection of the minority, that logic or lack thereof is what makes it a launching point for any group imaginable that wants to take that minority status to say, all right, well, now we need to protect our minority.
00:26:21 And before you know it, we are more defined by our differences than we are by our similarities.
00:26:28 And there is no way that the cultural fabric of a province or a country can be maintained with that.
00:26:35 And more importantly, it's just not economically viable, nor is it practical, to make that the way that you govern yourself.
00:26:43 So most people, and this is the rationale here that I think is interesting, is that 95% of the province does not care about this.
00:26:53 95% of the province of Ontario, for whom the French language is not their first language, are hearing this story and being like, what the heck?
00:27:01 Like, and especially people in my city in southwestern Ontario, people in Toronto, people in Windsor has a bit of a French population, but not huge.
00:27:09 People in these cities are like, I don't, who are these people?
00:27:13 And they do exist.
00:27:15 They exist in and around Ottawa.
00:27:17 They exist in Glengarry, Prescott, Russell.
00:27:18 They do exist, but they are now hijacking this national discussion, despite occupying less than 5% of the demographic makeup in Ontario.
00:27:33 And for Amanda Simard, look, if she made this decision on principles, power to her.
00:27:38 But I question her principles when it becomes more about getting a targeted handout than actually sticking to the values that she was elected to champion.
00:27:48 We've got to wrap things up here.
00:27:50 If you want to reach out to me for this or anything else, my email address is andrew at andrewlotton.ca.
00:27:57 And thanks to all for your comments here.
00:27:59 I'll read a couple of them before we wrap up here.
00:28:02 Maluska writes, I apologize if I didn't get that.
00:28:05 See, Maluska sounds like a non-English origin name, so maybe you can get a university.
00:28:10 How about we think about paying off as much of our deficit before we add more debt?
00:28:14 Yeah, that's huge.
00:28:15 That's the whole point of this thing is that we can't afford it in Ontario.
00:28:20 Karen writes, divide Canadians even further.
00:28:23 Yeah, that seems to be the attitude.
00:28:25 And Dave writes, just give them directions to Quebec.
00:28:28 Done.
00:28:29 Well, yeah, and quite frankly, if you are a Franco-Ontarian and it's really, really important that you protect your French language, go to a French school.
00:28:37 Or go to one of the existing ones, go to Ottawa U, which is Ottawa you walk around and the population of English speakers versus French speakers there seems very similar to one another.
00:28:48 And let's see what else we have here.
00:28:50 Mike says, go after Wynne to pay the debt back.
00:28:52 Yeah, I mean, that's the thing.
00:28:53 Doug Ford's first year in office will just be undoing the damage that Kathleen Wynne did.
00:28:58 And Rennie writes, it's called diversionary politics.
00:29:02 They must think we're all a bunch of herded sheep.
00:29:04 Well, I think they have very cynical views of the Canadian voters.
00:29:09 Certainly that's how Justin Trudeau is managing this.
00:29:12 All right, thanks everyone for tuning in.
00:29:14 We'll be back next week and have a little video commentary as well.
00:29:17 On a programming note, we've launched a new little mini campaign here that we're telling people about, a new video every day.
00:29:25 So we are supported by people like you.
00:29:28 We don't get the government bailout.
00:29:30 We don't get the $600 million.
00:29:31 We don't get the CBC pension plan.
00:29:34 We get support from people like you that are viewing our content.
00:29:37 So we're going to have new stuff every day for you.
00:29:39 We're trying to keep this discussion going.
00:29:41 But I do think that it is so important that if you do value what we're doing that you throw in, it can be a couple of bucks one time.
00:29:48 It can be $10 a month or it can be even more.
00:29:51 And we've got some goodies for you if you do.
00:29:53 So thanks very much to all.
00:29:54 Thank you.
00:29:54 God bless.
00:29:55 And good day, Canada.