Juno News - August 30, 2019


This week's most biased news!

Topics
Mentioned
LAWTON: Stop With The Social Issues Litmus Test Official bilingualism has gone too far

Episode Stats


Length

17 minutes

Words per minute

181.53

Word count

3,146

Sentence count

167

Harmful content

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A bunch of billboards with a picture of the People's Party candidate Max St. Bernier were put up across the country with a simple message: "Say No to Mass Immigration." There was a lot of outrage and talk about how the message was racist and anti-Canadian. After a backlash, the billboards were taken down and a new message was put in their place.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi everyone, welcome to another segment of This Week in Fake News. I'm your host Candice Malcolm,
00:00:16 founder of True North and a columnist over at Post Media with the Toronto Sun.
00:00:21 There are a couple stories that I want to break down for you this week, and they're going to be
00:00:26 hitting on some of the similar topics we've been talking about for the past few weeks. So let's
00:00:31 just jump right into it. The first story that everyone's been talking about this week are these
00:00:36 billboards. As you probably know, as you've heard, a bunch of billboards were put up across the country
00:00:41 with a picture of Max St. Bernier, the leader of the People's Party of Canada, and the billboards
00:00:47 had a pretty simple message. They just simply said, say no to mass immigration, with a picture of Max
00:00:53 St. Bernier, big word that said vote, and then the People's Party logo. We've learned that these
00:01:00 billboards did not go out under the People's Party. It was a third-party supporting group that put them
00:01:05 out. The group is called True North Strong and Free Advertising. It has no connection whatsoever with
00:01:11 this organization, with True North. Just obviously a very common name given that the words right there
00:01:17 are in our national anthem. Anyway, there was a huge uproar over these billboards. People were
00:01:23 outraged. There was a series of just ridiculous, ridiculous headlines. The Toronto Star headline said 0.99
00:01:29 it was a deceptive billboard. The Calgary Herald headline said that it was hurtful. And probably the
00:01:35 silliest headline that I saw was right in those Sun papers in the Edmonton Sun. An activist said that
00:01:41 these billboards were very racist, very racist to say no to mass immigration, according to these
00:01:49 politically correct Canadians. So after a whole bunch of complaints and people, you know, the mob,
00:01:54 the mob mentality that we see so often, complaining the organization that owns the billboards,
00:02:01 Patterson, they decided to take those billboards down. So billboards are gone. Apparently we cannot
00:02:07 have a conversation about immigration levels in this country. And it's interesting because most
00:02:13 of the political parties all sort of agree that we should continue to ever increase the number of
00:02:19 immigrants that come to Canada. Maxime Bernier and the People's Party take just a very slightly
00:02:24 different view, which is that we should cap it at about 250,000 new permanent residents a year,
00:02:30 which I'd like to point out is the number of newcomers that we welcomed in 2015. So it's not like
00:02:36 we're going back to like historic levels. It's not like we're going back to like the 90s or earlier
00:02:41 and trying to kind of even out. No, we're just going back like three years to the beginning of
00:02:46 Justin Trudeau's tenure as prime minister. And somehow that is just beyond the pale, say no to
00:02:52 mass immigration. So as you would expect, the mainstream media found a whole bunch of leftist
00:02:57 activists to dissect this message and accuse Maxime Bernier of saying something that he's not saying.
00:03:04 This is their favorite thing that they do. They will accuse a politician of only on the right,
00:03:10 accuse a politician on the right of so-called dog whistle politics. So that's when you blame a
00:03:16 politician for saying something that they didn't actually say. I get accused of this all the time
00:03:20 by the sort of deranged regressive left. They can't point to anything controversial that I've
00:03:26 actually said or that Maxime Bernier said. But then they accuse us of saying things that we haven't
00:03:30 said. And so they call this dog whistle politics. So you have to sort of read between the lines
00:03:34 and invent a new message from not the message that's actually put out there. So apparently
00:03:39 say no to mass immigration is dog whistle politics. And there's an embedded message that really just
00:03:44 says we hate everybody or we don't want any immigrants or we want to deport people or something
00:03:49 like that, which is clearly not what Maxime Bernier is saying. In fact, he constantly, consistently
00:03:55 has a message that Canada needs to lower its immigration levels to just what we had three years
00:04:01 ago, focus more on integration, that is making sure that the newcomers to Canada, you know, are involved
00:04:06 in the community, get a job, that they learn to speak English or French and that they develop a Canadian
00:04:12 identity and join the Canadian family, which I think every Canadian on the left or the right would agree
00:04:17 with that, I hope, and that we should focus on the economic needs of the country. And so this is obviously
00:04:23 in contrast to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who has taken the opposite approach. He has lowered the
00:04:28 relative level of economic immigrants and increased the number of family reunification people, the
00:04:33 number of elderly parents and grandparents coming to Canada, and the number of refugees and asylum
00:04:38 seekers. So, you know, Bernier's position is just different. It's a policy position. And it's a
00:04:43 legitimate debate that we should be able to have in this country. But heaven no, the leftist
00:04:49 establishment does not want us to have this conversation. So here is an article on the CBC.
00:04:55 And it actually has a pretty decent headline. It says removing anti-immigration billboard is
00:05:01 censorship, says columnists. And so they quoted a Quebec based writer, Lise Reverie, who is with the
00:05:08 Montreal Gazette, who said that this is just pure censorship, that we shouldn't be taking down
00:05:13 a billboard, just because we don't necessarily agree with the message in it. And again, the message
00:05:19 is just super mundane. You know, it didn't say no, no immigrants or send people back or, you know,
00:05:27 anything like that. It just said no to mass immigration, a pretty simple message that I imagine
00:05:32 most Canadians would agree with. In fact, polling shows that only 6% of Canadians want more immigration.
00:05:37 And that's what Trudeau has done. So Trudeau's doing what only 6% of Canadians want. Bernie is talking
00:05:43 about what the rest of us want. And somehow, you know, it is beyond the pale. So here, the CBC has
00:05:49 found a person to, again, say that basically having free speech is wrong. So this person says,
00:06:00 Journalist and Human Rights Advocate, Amira Al-Gabari, said to claim the issue was about free
00:06:06 speech is absolutely wrong. Quote, free speech is not a ticket to demonize and marginalize,
00:06:12 says this person who serves on the board of the Canadian Anti-Hate Network. She called the billboard
00:06:17 an example of dog whistle politics to get attention of voters who hold anti-immigrant views. Mr.
00:06:23 Bernier can claim that this is him wanting to have a debate. But what it actually is, it's him
00:06:29 signaling to those people who, again, are holding these views that if that this is what's going on,
00:06:34 that he's going to be the one to, quote, unquote, save Canada. So somehow this woman claims to know
00:06:42 what Bernier is saying and what's in his mind when he hasn't actually said those things and we don't
00:06:47 know that that's what's in his mind at all. So she's saying that somehow she understands Bernier
00:06:52 better than he understands himself. And that this is really just about finding those racist Canadians 0.96
00:06:57 and getting them to vote for the People's Party. And then we found another person that the CBC quotes,
00:07:04 no mass immigration in Canada says an expert. And as I've talked about before, this is the media's
00:07:10 favorite thing to do is to go find an expert. And that expert, that quote, unquote, expert believes
00:07:16 exactly what they believe. They hold the like classic paint by number left wing view on an issue. And then
00:07:22 the unbiased journalist, instead of having to insert their own opinion, they just insert their own
00:07:27 opinion. And then they say, says an expert. And so then that's how we get this bias in the news. So
00:07:34 this expert says that there is no mass immigration in Canada. So here we go, contrary to the wording
00:07:40 scrawled on the billboard, there is no mass immigration to Canada, points out immigration expert
00:07:45 Usha George. Canada is one of the few countries in the world which has a very organized immigration
00:07:50 system. Says this person who is the director of the Centre for Immigration and Resettlement at
00:07:55 Ryerson University. The government operates a point system, she explained, which prioritizes immigrants
00:08:02 who contribute to the economy. Yes, but as we pointed out last week, only about 20%, 20, 25, 26%
00:08:09 of people who come to Canada as permanent residents are coming as economic immigrants. The rest are all 1.00
00:08:14 family members or extended family members or refugees or asylum seekers. And again, when we're talking
00:08:21 about permanent residents coming to Canada, that's again, only a small portion of the number of the
00:08:26 total people that come to Canada because we have a temporary foreign worker program, we have a large
00:08:31 student visa program, we have people who come as long-term visitors, and then we also have those
00:08:37 asylum seekers. And none of those are included in the government's official count. So when you look at the
00:08:42 broader number of people who are coming to Canada on a more permanent basis, it's closer to a million
00:08:47 people a year. It's closer to a million people. So keep that in mind. And only a very, very small
00:08:51 portion of those people come for jobs. Okay, but this person who is somehow a total expert from
00:08:58 left-wing Ryerson University says, no, no, that's not the case. She says that, you know, that we prioritize
00:09:06 immigrants for the economy. It's only partly true. Our family immigration is much smaller, and 0.99
00:09:12 our refugee immigration is even smaller than that. It's true that the economic class of 0.99
00:09:18 immigration is the largest, but only a portion of that is actually the people who hold the
00:09:22 visa and the rest of them are their family. And then there's a separate family immigration
00:09:26 class and a separate refugee, which Trudeau has increased both of those levels. So it's 0.63
00:09:31 true that they're smaller, but the ratio is changing. And again, it's only a small portion
00:09:36 of the people that are in that economic class. Okay. Last, here we go, we'll keep reading
00:09:42 from the CBC article. Last October, Immigration Minister Ahmed Hassan announced a multi-year
00:09:47 plan to increase the immigration target to 350 per year by 2021, a figure that's close to
00:09:53 1% of the country's population. So that is the highest level that we've had in any point
00:09:59 in recent history. And the Trudeau government admits that it's the most ambitious immigration
00:10:03 plan that we've seen recently. And again, that's only the number of people who are coming permanently.
00:10:08 It doesn't include the temporary foreign workers. It doesn't include the asylum seekers. It doesn't 0.97
00:10:12 include the student visas or the long-term visitors. So it's just really like a portion of the people
00:10:17 that are coming to Canada. And then they show a couple of different polls that show that Canadians
00:10:25 are kind of souring on immigration, that we used to really be open to immigration. And every year,
00:10:31 basically, since Trudeau's been in power, the number's gone down lower and lower of the people
00:10:35 who accept immigration. And then here we go. So it comes from the fact that more and more of the
00:10:42 immigrants who come to this country these days are from countries that are non-European.
00:10:46 So there we have it. It's really just because Canadians are just so intolerant and racist. That's really 1.00
00:10:51 the crux of it, according to this so-called expert. The sentiment comes from a lack of understanding
00:10:56 about how immigrants contribute to the system and about negative propaganda about immigrants.
00:11:02 The diversity of the immigrants coming in also incites fear among right-wing groups and really
00:11:08 conservative kinds of individuals who feel like Canada is changing. So that's really what the CBC
00:11:12 wants to say. If you oppose immigration of any kind, if you even want to have a conversation about
00:11:18 Canada's immigration system, or if you just have the very subtle position that you want to go back
00:11:23 to the numbers that we had three years ago, really it's because you're racist. It's because you hate
00:11:29 people who are not European, and that's the bottom line. So that's really what this story is about.
00:11:34 They just kind of slid it in there. Instead of, again, saying it's their own opinion, they just found
00:11:40 some expert to say exactly what they think. And that basically is that all these Canadians who don't want 1.00
00:11:45 large numbers of immigrants who feel unhappy about the integration program, don't feel like
00:11:50 newcomers are really joining the Canadian family like they used to, or that people aren't learning
00:11:54 English as much as they used to. If you have any of those feelings, it's really just because you hate
00:11:59 everyone and you're a racist. So way to go, CBC. That's pretty much exactly what we can expect from 0.77
00:12:06 them. There's a story in the Toronto Star that pretty much echoes the same thing the CBC story says.
00:12:13 Immigration in Nova Scotia, not a yes or no question. Experts say. Again, these experts.
00:12:19 It's such a lazy trick for journalists to find someone who agrees with them, put their super
00:12:24 biased opinion in, and write it up as straight news, and just say, you know, it's an expert.
00:12:29 And so this whole article is pretty similar to the last one. It's just basically about how Bernie's
00:12:34 wrong, and really the main point of our immigration system is to boost the economy, and then it talks
00:12:44 about how Canada doesn't really have mass, we don't really have mass immigration, and that this issue
00:12:52 just conflates the topics, and it's really an American issue. It has nothing to do with Canada.
00:12:56 I mean, I don't know how you can study immigration and look at the issue, and just ignore the fact
00:13:02 that Canada has a record number of people illegally walking across the border and making asylum
00:13:06 claims, that asylum claims are about four times higher under Trudeau than they were under Harper,
00:13:12 and somehow just like look at that and just say, no, no, we don't have a problem. Mass immigration
00:13:18 doesn't describe the Canadian context, is what this other expert says here, and just pretend that,
00:13:24 you know, this is a problem in the US, and Europe has nothing to do with Canada, so people who are
00:13:29 talking about it are just wrong, and they're far right. I mean, that's basically the view of the
00:13:33 people in the mainstream media in Canada, the elites in this country, and pretty easy for them to write
00:13:40 that into the news, and just pretend that they are straight reporters, just saying it like they see
00:13:45 it. Okay, let's move on here. I want to just quickly touch on this other topic, because I talked about
00:13:51 it a couple weeks ago as well, and I just find it amusing, so everyone knows that the liberals dug up
00:13:57 this old video of Andrew Scheer, a 15-year-old video of him making a case against a same-sex marriage
00:14:03 bill that was being debated in the House of Commons, and so, you know, the whole, there was a whole uproar
00:14:11 over it, and everyone was talking about how, you know, intolerant it was of him. Comically, Ralph
00:14:19 Goodale, the Liberal MP, who also voted against the bill in 1999, was the one that was pushing the fact
00:14:25 that Andrew Scheer has these outdated views. Anyway, there is a CBC article today, and it says that Scheer
00:14:34 doesn't belong at Ottawa Pride, LGBTQ author and journalist says. So, if you remember the whole 1.00
00:14:41 hoopla over this controversy, everyone was calling on Scheer to go and attend a Pride parade. They
00:14:47 were saying, you know, he needs to apologize for his past views, and he can really show that he's a
00:14:51 changed person or whatever by going and marching in these, like, far left-wing Pride parades, which,
00:14:57 again, it's not really about, the Pride parades are not really about supporting gay people. Like,
00:15:01 most people in Canada support gay rights, and most of us have friends that are gay or know people
00:15:07 that are gay, and we don't hold anti-gay positions or bigoted positions. We just might not want to go
00:15:12 to a Pride parade because it really represents this sort of, like, left-wing culture where they're
00:15:17 promoting all kinds of just far-left issues, and as we've seen recently, they don't allow people
00:15:23 who have any slightly different views. Like, they banned the Toronto police from marching in the Pride
00:15:28 parade. The Vancouver Pride banned UBC and the Vancouver Public Library from marching in the
00:15:35 parade. So it's just sort of this, like, leftist authoritarian cult that happens every year, and
00:15:39 somehow all the politicians in the country are expected to go and march in this. Well, you know,
00:15:45 that's not, not all Canadians are interested in that, and you don't all have to have the same
00:15:50 view and the same priority. So after all that, all that urging to have Andrew Scheer march in the
00:15:56 Pride parade, one of the leaders of the community basically said that Andrew Scheer is not welcome
00:16:02 at the Pride parade. So after all of that, he wouldn't be welcome there anyway, which you could
00:16:07 kind of picture. You could kind of picture Scheer showing up at a Pride parade and, like, getting
00:16:10 booed and him not being welcomed anyway, because it's not like the Pride parade itself is this, you know,
00:16:16 bastion of, like, openness and liberalism. No, they're very closed as well, and they also have their
00:16:22 hatreds and their, you know, bigoted views towards people. Case in point, they don't allow police to
00:16:28 march in these Pride parades often. They, the Pride parade in Chicago banned Israeli people from going.
00:16:34 Someone had an Israeli Pride parade, Pride flag, and they got kicked out of the parade. So not exactly
00:16:41 the most welcoming, open-minded people, and I think this article pretty much sums that up. So I'm going
00:16:48 to leave it at that. Those were my two most glaring, those were the two most glaring, biased stories of the
00:16:56 week. Thanks so much for watching. If you see something in the news and you think it's biased, just send it on over and
00:17:01 I'll take a look and try to dissect it next week. Thanks so much for watching. If you like this video, don't forget to
00:17:07 subscribe to the channel, like the video, share it, and check us out, tnc.news. We have new stories every day, a new video
00:17:15 every day. So check that out. Thank you so much for watching and have a great weekend.