Juno News - March 04, 2025


Trade War reaction ⧸ Trudeau LIVE press conference ⧸ Are the polls legit (ft. Hamish Marshall)

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Canada wants to kick Trump out of the G7? Canada ESCALATES the trade war

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

178.14

Word count

8,700

Sentence count

464

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

14

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Today, Canada is in the middle of a trade war with the United States. President Trump has imposed 25% tariffs on $50 billion worth of Canadian and Mexican goods, starting today, and they are set to rise to $155 billion on March 25th. We talk to Hamish Marshall, a pollster at One Persuasion, about the situation.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, I'm Candice Malcolm and welcome to the Candice Malcolm Show. We've got a big show for you today,
00:00:12 lots happening in the news right now. We're going to jump right into it. As you probably saw,
00:00:17 we are now in the middle of a trade war. So as of 12.01 a.m. Eastern time today, March 4th,
00:00:23 the United States, citing national security reasons, started taxing all Canadian and Mexican
00:00:29 goods at 25%, except for Canadian energy, which will be taxed at a lower rate of 10%. So immediately
00:00:36 following that, the Canadian counter tariffs have been also put into effect. They will be placed on
00:00:42 $30 billion worth of products starting today. And then we are told that they're going to rise
00:00:48 to $155 million on March 25th. So here we are in the middle of a trade war, and we are waiting
00:00:56 for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to come and speak to Canadians. He was supposed to be on
00:01:01 an hour ago at 10 o'clock, but we are still waiting for him. They bumped it to 10.30 and
00:01:06 here it is 11.05 Eastern Time. Still no sign of the Prime Minister. Nothing says urgently
00:01:11 addressing an emergency like the Prime Minister just strolling into a press conference an hour
00:01:16 late. Well, folks, as soon as that goes live, we will throw to it. But in the meantime, I'd like
00:01:20 to welcome our guest for the program today. Pleased to be joined by Hamish Marshall. Hamish is a
00:01:25 pollster. He is a partner at One Persuasion, which is a government relations and strategy firm
00:01:29 in Ontario. Hamish, welcome to the program. Whoops, I don't think your audio is working there,
00:01:36 Hamish. Well, you know why it's funny? Because today is Shrove Tuesday. It's pancake day. My 0.96
00:01:42 kids and I had like this wonderful morning. We woke up, we made pancakes, we're talking about
00:01:46 Easter. It was just like a nice normal morning. And then I turn on my phone and I'm like, oh yeah,
00:01:51 the world is on fire. And so that kind of quickly imploded there. But so, yeah, basically, Trump
00:01:58 told us this was happening. Yesterday in the White House, he said that it was coming forward.
00:02:03 Here is President Trump speaking about the tariffs yesterday.
00:02:08 Very importantly, tomorrow tariffs, 25 percent on Canada and 25 percent on Mexico, and that'll start.
00:02:16 So they're going to have to have a tariff. So what they have to do is build their car plants,
00:02:20 frankly and other things in the united states in which case they have no tariffs
00:02:26 and then we also uh trump was asked whether there was room uh for a deal to be made was
00:02:32 there going to be an 11th hour deal remember initially the these tariffs were supposed to
00:02:36 come in in february and then trump bumped it um so here's a question uh is there any room left and
00:02:41 trump just closing the door on that and saying no this is happening on the tariffs is there any room
00:02:47 left for canada and mexico to make a deal before midnight and should we expect those chinese 1.00
00:02:51 tariffs the extra 10 percent to take no room left for mexico or for canada no the tariffs uh you
00:02:57 know they're all set they go into effect tomorrow so it's here is happening we've had a few months
00:03:04 warning hamish we knew that this was coming we knew that that trump was serious about it
00:03:08 it doesn't seem like canada really came up with another strategy or plan we didn't diversify we
00:03:13 didn't open up new trading lanes i don't think we made any progress on opening up interprovincial
00:03:17 trade barriers or building new pipelines it just seems like we were kind of caught flat-footed
00:03:21 again maybe hoping that something would change but it didn't and now it's upon us uh what's
00:03:26 your takeaway from all this so far yeah i mean i think the approach of the liberal government has
00:03:30 been just a hope you know the there was tariffs supposed to come in when trump was first elected
00:03:34 then it was february 1st and we kind of got through those hurdles and and you know we thought
00:03:40 appointing a fentanyls are would be would be enough um and apparently you know it wasn't uh
00:03:45 you know, it's still not clear to me exactly what Trump wants per se. You know, he talks about
00:03:52 national security. He talks about trade. Sorry to interrupt you here, Hamish. We have Justin
00:03:56 Trudeau. So we're going to go live to the prime minister, hear what he has to say, and then we'll
00:03:59 come back to you. Let's go live to Justin Trudeau, prime minister of Canada. Today, the United States
00:04:05 launched a trade war against Canada. The closest partner and ally, the closest trade.
00:04:13 At the same time, they're talking about working positively with Russia, appeasing Vladimir 0.99
00:04:21 Putin, a lying, murderous dictator. 0.99
00:04:26 Make that make sense. 0.99
00:04:30 Canadians are reasonable, and we are polite, but we will not back down from a fight, not
00:04:36 when our country and the well-being of everyone in it is at stake.
00:04:44 At the moment, the U.S. tariffs came into effect in the early hours of this morning,
00:04:51 and so did the Canadian response.
00:04:54 Canada will be implementing 25% tariffs against $155 billion worth of American goods, starting
00:05:04 with tariffs on $30 billion worth of goods immediately and tariffs on the remaining $125
00:05:11 billion of American products in 21 days' time.
00:05:15 Encore aujourd'hui, on se voit forcés d'imposer des droits de douane de 25 % sur 155 milliards
00:05:24 dollars américains de marchandises, 30 milliards de dollars de façon immédiate, et dans 21
00:05:34 jours, 125 milliards de dollars de marchandises de plus. Today, we will also be challenging
00:05:43 these illegal actions by filing dispute resolution claims at the World Trade Organization and
00:05:50 through the USMCA. But in the meantime, our tariffs will remain in place until the US tariffs
00:05:58 are withdrawn and not a moment sooner. And should these tariffs not cease, we are in active and
00:06:06 ongoing discussions with provinces and territories to pursue several non-tariff measures. Measures
00:06:14 which will demonstrate that there are no winners in a trade war.
00:06:21 Now, just like I did a month ago, I want to speak first directly to the American people.
00:06:31 We don't want this.
00:06:33 We want to work with you as a friend and ally, and we don't want to see you hurt either.
00:06:41 your government has chosen to do this to you. As of this morning, markets are down and inflation
00:06:51 is set to rise dramatically all across your country. Your government has chosen to put
00:06:58 American jobs at risk, that the thousands of workplaces that succeed because of materials
00:07:05 from Canada, or because of consumers in Canada, or both. They've chosen to raise costs for American
00:07:15 consumers on everyday essential items like groceries and gas, on major purchases like
00:07:21 cars and homes, and everything in between. They've chosen to harm American national security, 0.53
00:07:29 impeding access to the abundant critical minerals, energy, building materials,
00:07:35 and fertilizers that we have and that the United States needs to grow and prosper.
00:07:44 They've chosen to launch a trade war that will, first and foremost, harm American families.
00:07:52 They've chosen to sabotage their own agenda that was supposed to usher in a new golden age for the United States.
00:08:02 And they've chosen to undermine the incredible work we've done together to tackle the scourge that is fentanyl,
00:08:11 a drug that must be wiped from the face of the earth.
00:08:15 So on that point, let me be crystal clear.
00:08:18 There is absolutely no justification or need whatsoever for these tariffs today.
00:08:29 Now, the legal pretext your government is using to bring in these tariffs
00:08:34 is that Canada is apparently unwilling to help in the fight against illegal fentanyl.
00:08:42 Well, that is totally false.
00:08:46 Let's look at the facts.
00:08:48 Our border is already safe and secure.
00:08:53 Far less than 1% of fentanyl flows and less than 1% of illegal crossings into the United States comes from Canada.
00:09:00 But we acted because we know we can always do better.
00:09:07 We responded to concerns, including from the president, by implementing an ambitious $1.3 billion border plan.
00:09:15 A border plan that includes generational investments in new AI and imaging tools to stop the flow of fentanyl in its tracks, stronger coordination and information sharing with American agencies, along with the deployment of drones, helicopters, and additional personnel to keep our borders secure.
00:09:37 now a month ago as part of an agreement with the united states that paused the tariffs
00:09:43 we made further commitments we appointed kevin brusso as our fentanyl czar a man who dedicated
00:09:52 his multi-decade career in law enforcement to combating organized crime networks and drug
00:09:58 trafficking we designated seven drug cartels sick evil groups who cynically profit off the pain and
00:10:06 suffering of people on both sides of the border as the terrorist organizations that they are.
00:10:13 And just yesterday, we launched a new joint operations partnership supported by a $200
00:10:20 million investment between Canada's security and law enforcement agencies, a partnership
00:10:27 that will enhance the coordination of information and intelligence in order to thwart criminal
00:10:33 gangs involved in the illegal fentanyl trade.
00:10:36 and critically our actions are working as the u.s states as the u.s customs and border protection
00:10:47 just acknowledged there was a 97 percent drop in fentanyl seizures from january compared to
00:10:55 December to a near zero low of less than half an ounce seized in January, even with all the further
00:11:08 enforcements and actions we've taken at the borders. In sum, we stepped up. We engaged closely
00:11:17 and constructively with the President and his administration. We did everything we promised.
00:11:23 We stuck to our word, and we did it because we believe in working together to protect our citizens.
00:11:35 Now I want to speak directly to one specific American, Donald.
00:11:43 In the over eight years you and I have worked together, we've done big things.
00:11:50 We signed a historic deal that has created record jobs and growth in both of our countries.
00:11:58 We've done big things together on the world stage, as Canada and the U.S. have done together for decades, for generations.
00:12:07 And now, we should be working together to ensure even greater prosperity for North Americans in a very uncertain and challenging world.
00:12:23 Now, it's not in my habit to agree with the Wall Street Journal. 0.96
00:12:27 But Donald, they point out that even though you're a very smart guy, this is a very dumb thing to do. 0.72
00:12:37 We, two friends, fighting is exactly what our opponents around the world want to see.
00:12:48 And now, to my fellow Canadians, I won't sugarcoat it.
00:12:54 This is going to be tough, even though we're all going to pull together, because that's what we do.
00:13:01 We will use every tool at our disposal so Canadian workers and businesses can weather this storm.
00:13:08 From expanding EI benefits and making them more flexible to providing direct supports to businesses,
00:13:15 we will be there as needed to help.
00:13:20 But Canada, make no mistake, no matter how long this lasts, no matter what the cost,
00:13:26 the federal government and other orders of government will be there for you.
00:13:31 We will defend Canadian jobs.
00:13:34 We will take measures to prevent predatory behavior that threatens Canadian companies
00:13:40 because of the impacts of this trade war, leaving them open to takeovers.
00:13:45 We will relentlessly fight to protect our economy.
00:13:50 We will stand up for Canadians every single second of every single day
00:13:56 because this country is worth fighting for.
00:14:01 Okay. We can cut it there, Mon. So, I mean, Justin Trudeau kind of coming out and giving
00:14:10 the speech of his life, basically, and really like spelling it out. First of all, he takes
00:14:15 kind of an unnecessary jab at the beginning, talking about Putin. I think he's trying to
00:14:19 like insert himself into the dispute that happened last week, calling him an atrocious 0.72
00:14:23 murderer. His tone was kind of condescending at the beginning, Hamish, especially when
00:14:28 was talking to Americans because he was telling Americans that they were going to feel the pain.
00:14:31 And all I was thinking was, no, man, it's the Canadians that are going to feel the pain. Like,
00:14:35 yes, there will be pockets of Americans that will feel this, but their economy is just so
00:14:40 much larger than ours. Ours is such a fraction of it, so much more dependent upon their economy
00:14:44 for trade than vice versa. So the message that he was supposedly giving to Americans,
00:14:47 I felt like it really should have been aimed at Canadians. That moment where he was talking to
00:14:52 President Trump one-on-one, I thought that was actually quite effective, even though I don't
00:14:56 like. I cringe when I hear politicians using first names to one another. I just think it's
00:15:00 really inappropriate. But, you know, we were talking about that with President Zelensky in
00:15:05 the Oval Office, and he kept referring to the vice president as J.D., which I just I didn't like
00:15:09 that. But basically just saying there's no justification or need whatsoever for these
00:15:14 tariffs, spelling out what the Canadians had done to improve the border, to crack down on fentanyl.
00:15:18 I think that those are all really reasonable, good points, Hamish. But to me, there was like
00:15:22 he was missing he was missing the forest for the tree like he some of the just the major takeaways
00:15:27 here it's like dustin trudeau does not have a mandate at this moment president trump does not
00:15:32 like prime minister dustin trudeau part of the reason that we're in here you have to believe
00:15:36 is that these two individuals just don't see eye to eye they don't like each other they they kind
00:15:41 of enjoy making a spectacle of one another because their politics are so opposite so we don't have
00:15:46 a strong government in canada that just came in with a mandate we have a lame duck leader who's
00:15:50 loathed and despised by the people on his way out. He shouldn't be up there, right? He resigned on
00:15:56 January 6th. We could have had a federal election. We could have had an election. He could have put
00:16:00 someone else in. They could have had the election. We could be sitting here on March 4th with a new
00:16:05 fresh mandate and a new leader. But instead, Justin Trudeau has decided for himself to go out
00:16:10 this way, proroguing parliament, having a long leadership review process, and they're going to
00:16:15 put in their new prime minister on Sunday. To me, that's a story that Trudeau just seems to be
00:16:21 completely missing. What's your take on it? Look, I think a lot of this is a result of Trudeau's
00:16:27 weakness and Trudeau's disastrous time as prime minister, right? Canada, the reason Trump is
00:16:31 coming after Canada, you know, in a large sense, and I agree that it's not about specific security
00:16:38 or national defense issues or even drug issues that are sort of the fig leaves for this.
00:16:45 is that he sees Canada as an easy source of places to get jobs.
00:16:49 He wants one of his core promises and what he wants to deliver
00:16:52 is more manufacturing jobs, specifically manufacturing jobs in the United States.
00:16:57 Those are good, high-paying jobs that will go to places
00:17:01 and to the sort of people who are Trump supporters.
00:17:04 That is something he sees he wants to deliver for his people.
00:17:07 And part of that is to bring jobs back from China, but that takes time.
00:17:11 The easier thing to do is to create instability in the relationship with Canada and, frankly, with Mexico, so that if you're somebody who relies on shipping auto parts across the border, even if these tariffs go away in two, three, six months, six weeks, I don't know, to say, I don't want to go through this again.
00:17:29 I'm just going to move my auto parts plant from Windsor, Ontario.
00:17:34 We're going to move it down to Kentucky or somewhere because I just don't want to have to have that sort of disruption.
00:17:38 so the disruption is the purpose and that's what trump's trying to do and when trio is saying this
00:17:47 is going to hurt he's right it's going to hurt americans you're absolutely right it's going to
00:17:50 hurt canadians a heck of a lot more that's also kind of the point he will trump wants that pain 0.92
00:17:55 he wants the disruption so that people say i don't want to deal with this garbage anymore and just 0.85
00:18:00 move my my plants or our factories uh south of the border that's what he's trying to do and
00:18:06 And, you know, we're in a position as Canadians in our Canadian economy that we have less ability to stand up to that today than we did 10 years ago because of persistent decisions Trudeau has made.
00:18:16 You're right. Trudeau is, you know, being a weak leader and that Trump sees him as a weak leader.
00:18:21 And since really since Freeland resigned and then Trudeau has resigned, the weakness has only gotten more.
00:18:29 And that's why Trump's pushing hard today, because, you know, if the liberal, I honestly believe if the liberal leadership had been set that we had a prime minister, you know, two days ago, as opposed to, you know, in five or six days, and we had a new leader, the terrorists would have come in a week ago.
00:18:46 He's coming in when Canada's at, he's hitting us when Canada's at its weakest, and we're the weakest right now with Justin Trudeau.
00:18:52 And it seems like our response, Hamish, is not going to help. Like the whole idea here that we're throwing retaliatory tariffs on the U.S., it's a tax on Canadians. A retaliatory tariff is a tax on Canadians. So the hurt that Canadians are going to feel, it's going to be a little bit from what Trump is doing, but it's a lot more what our own leaders are doing.
00:19:11 So here is Doug Ford appearing on American News last night and NBC News with Aaron Gilchrist, basically saying that they're going to shut down the electricity going to the United States so that the Americans will feel the pain like they've never felt before.
00:19:25 If he wants to destroy our economy and our families, I will shut down the electricity going down to the U.S.
00:19:34 And I'm telling you, we will do it.
00:19:36 It's unfortunate.
00:19:38 I would rather ship you more electricity.
00:19:40 We're the number one trading customer to 28 states, and a lot of them are red states.
00:19:46 They're going to feel the pain like they've never felt before.
00:19:51 So I'm not sure if Canada stops selling electricity to the Americans, I'm sure the Americans will find another way to get it.
00:19:57 I mean, we might feel some pain there.
00:19:58 But to me, there's going to be a longer term pain felt by Canadians because who else are we going to sell to?
00:20:03 It's not like you have an option to go to another market with something like that.
00:20:06 What do you think?
00:20:06 Well, I think actually the non-tariff actions like blocking electricity, and I think the
00:20:13 other thing, the most interesting word the Prime Minister said in the entire speech was fertilizer.
00:20:17 He called out the Americans need our fertilizer. We have enormous potash reserves that are,
00:20:22 it's key to making fertilizer. Much of the modern world depends on, frankly, on fertilizer
00:20:27 and our ability to generate, and the Americans' ability to generate huge amounts of food. 0.56
00:20:32 um being if he says we're going to stop potash exports to the united states that gets very very
00:20:38 interesting because those are things that yes they can buy potash from other places but it's
00:20:43 it's really much much more expensive and it takes time for those to come in and that's even more
00:20:47 true with electricity the potash is shipping it around in containers and you buy it from
00:20:51 australia or somewhere else and it takes a while to trip but you know shipping containers shipping
00:20:56 containers electricity you've got the wires you can't just throw some electricity in a boat and
00:21:00 and move it somewhere else.
00:21:02 So will the Americans be able to make up the electricity
00:21:05 by firing up some old plants and things?
00:21:07 Perhaps, but that will take time.
00:21:08 It will contest a lot of money,
00:21:10 have a very immediate impact on the price
00:21:13 of a lot of things in the United States.
00:21:15 Most notably that have an impact
00:21:17 on those manufacturing plants
00:21:18 because they are enormous consumers of electricity.
00:21:21 So, and frankly, while Canada, you know,
00:21:25 a lot of the electricity that we sell the United States,
00:21:28 particularly from Quebec, but sometimes from Ontario,
00:21:30 generated by hydropower so it's not it's very easy to just to let the water run over the dam
00:21:35 and decide not to generate that electricity so turning that off is actually something we can do
00:21:40 without a lot of impact for us so i think that is ultimately where it's going to be the most effective
00:21:45 is looking at the the non-tariff things that they can only get to canada but from canada because
00:21:52 our economies are so integrated our infrastructure is so integrated is much more effective than to
00:21:57 your point, some tariffs that hurt Americans, but only a little bit. Well, it's interesting. So I
00:22:02 want to play this clip. This is Dr. Ian Lee, who is a professor, I believe, at Carleton in business.
00:22:06 And he was on the CBC explaining what tariffs are and basically saying that when you look at the
00:22:12 studies, when you look at the data, there is no redeeming argument whatsoever for a retaliatory
00:22:18 tariff. It doesn't do what we want it to do. It's not going to impact the Americans. So let's get
00:22:22 Let's play this clip, and then I'll get your response to it, Hamish.
00:22:26 Adrian, can I jump in on that?
00:22:29 You bet.
00:22:30 I want to put forward the other point of view.
00:22:33 Governor Macklem gave an unbelievably superb speech February 21st to Oakville Chamber of Commerce,
00:22:41 and he outlined very empirically and factually the extraordinary destructive impact of tariffs on the economy,
00:22:50 on investment, on inflation, on the price of goods.
00:22:54 And I went through that speech, the written document,
00:22:57 very, very carefully multiple times.
00:22:58 I couldn't find any redeeming arguments to support retaliatory tariffs.
00:23:04 They're going to be very destructive for us.
00:23:07 And so putting tariffs on top of tariffs,
00:23:10 and remember the Canadian tariffs will be on Canadians.
00:23:14 So when the government says $100 billion or $200 billion,
00:23:17 that's a tax on Canadians.
00:23:20 And then the argument is, is that somehow going to cause Mr. Trump to change his mind?
00:23:25 And, you know, it's such a huge economy.
00:23:27 We say these amounts are large.
00:23:29 A hundred billion dollars is a big amount.
00:23:31 The U.S. economy is 20, somewhere between 25 and 30 trillion dollars, depending on how you measure GDP without getting into the weeds.
00:23:40 So, you know, a hundred billion dollars on a 25 to 30 trillion dollar economy is like finding a loony on the sidewalk and thinking you've got to you've made it rich.
00:23:49 It's statistically insignificant.
00:23:53 Significantly, it's statistically insignificant.
00:23:55 I like that analogy of finding a loonie.
00:23:57 So as much as we push back, it's not really going to affect them.
00:24:00 I want to just play one more clip because it did remind me when I had the opportunity
00:24:03 to sit down with Conservative leader Pierre Polyev, I asked him about this because one
00:24:07 of the things that I'm not quite there on is this idea that the Conservatives agree
00:24:11 with this measure, that the Conservatives are there saying yes to Justin Trudeau.
00:24:14 We agree.
00:24:15 We want these retaliatory tariffs because really what they are is a tax-efficient agent.
00:24:17 So I'm going to play that clip and then I'll go back to you, Hamish.
00:24:21 Trudeau said that they would issue retaliatory tariffs against the Americans, 25 percent.
00:24:26 You came out in a basic agreement with that saying that you would also support.
00:24:29 So my question is, a tariff that Canada imposes is really just a 25 percent tax on the goods that we import.
00:24:37 So it's a 25 percent tax on what Canadians pay for.
00:24:40 So why is a conservative leader agreeing with basically a 25 percent liberal tax increase?
00:24:47 Well, I don't agree with any liberal tax increase of any kind ever. But I do believe that if a foreign government attacks Canadian industry, that we have to retaliate. That is the only tool we have to deter. These tariff threats from the United States are utterly unjustified. There is no justification for what Mr. President Trump is threatening on Canada.
00:25:07 so that was back on february 13th but the issue still remains pertinent so i i hear your point
00:25:13 that the other measures that are non-tariff measures might be more effective than the
00:25:18 tariffs themselves i'm not a fan of a 25 tax on canadians and i don't think it's going to work
00:25:22 right like if if we were at the point where you know we we turn we turn on this tax and it actually
00:25:27 has a devastating impact on the american economy and trump wakes up tomorrow morning and says this
00:25:30 is a big mistake i'm going to undo them i just don't i don't see that happening so at this point
00:25:34 I just don't understand why Canada is in such a weak position.
00:25:38 Why are we making ourselves weaker with this tax?
00:25:41 Well, I mean, I agree with Mr. Polly.
00:25:42 I think you have to stand up for yourselves.
00:25:43 I think you have to, there will be an impact.
00:25:45 And as I think one of the commenters made in a lot of red states, which I think will hopefully help when members of Congress begin to start hearing complaints from their constituents, that will filter up to the president, hopefully.
00:26:01 But I also think the other thing Mr. Paglius proposed is a really good idea of saying, if we're going to have these tariffs, let's make sure we take any revenue collected from them and put them into immediate tax cuts for Canadians, so that if we are going to all have to pay more for certain things that are imported, we'll all have a little more money in our pocket.
00:26:21 And I appreciate that will allow people to get ahead to some extent in a very difficult situation.
00:26:32 But I think we do have to stand up for ourselves because the most important thing, I think, from the beginning is that, as I said at the very beginning of this, Trump smells weakness.
00:26:41 And I think if we don't put anything back, he'll just see it as more weakness and he'll say, great, 25 percent, let's make it 35.
00:26:48 So I think we have to stand up for ourselves and say that we are going to have to inflict some pain going the other way as well, while recognizing we can do far less damage to the American economy than they can to us.
00:26:59 Well, here is Immigration Minister Mark Miller.
00:27:02 He was on CBC, and he said that it's OK because Canadians, he says, have a higher pain threshold, apparently, than Americans.
00:27:11 Let's play that clip.
00:27:11 And it will continue to be important to diversify our economies, but we can't replace an economy that is responsible for 80% of our trade overnight and it's going to hurt. My message to Canadians is that we have a higher pain threshold than our partners to the south of us. We can continue to fight. We will have to bring the fight and it will hurt Americans as well.
00:27:34 And not to be outdone, NDP leader Jagmeet Singh was out there last night saying that it's time for Trudeau to basically kick Donald Trump out of the G7 and uninvite him from the upcoming G7 meeting in Alberta.
00:27:52 Let's play that clip.
00:27:53 Given that we are the host of the G7 summit and given that Donald Trump has threatened
00:27:59 our very sovereignty, threatened our economic security, we should not invite Donald Trump
00:28:05 to the G7. It doesn't make any sense to do so. As a host, we should work with other countries
00:28:10 to develop a strategy on how we can resist the very dangerous ideas that Donald Trump's
00:28:16 putting forward. And that should be the focus of the summit.
00:28:19 I mean, forget about Singh's comments there because they're silly, but it will be interesting.
00:28:24 I mean, we have this meeting coming up. Trump will be there and we will have a new prime minister. 0.69
00:28:28 Maybe we'll have two new prime ministers by then, but it won't be Justin Trudeau.
00:28:32 And I think that that will be a meeting to watch. What's your takeaway from some of these reactions we're seeing?
00:28:37 I mean, I think Mark Miller's trying to sort of play to some sort of bizarre version of K-Nationalism.
00:28:43 He couldn't even get through the line about a higher pain threshold without sort of smirking and laughing himself. 0.75
00:28:49 knew he was ridiculous and it was when he was saying it it was just it's just absurd uh and 0.82
00:28:53 it really shows just how the liberals are you know this is serious business and they can't quite 0.96
00:28:58 they can't quite manage to to deal with these serious topics and it's one of the reasons why
00:29:02 we're in that we're in this mess you know you're obviously saying this just being silly and further
00:29:07 proving how absolutely inadequate he is for anything um remotely approaching the leaders
00:29:11 of power um look donald trump's a deal maker he prides himself on a deal maker if there's
00:29:16 anything he sees himself as it's a deal maker um frankly an in-person meeting at a summit in canada
00:29:22 that's an opportunity for something i think i think trump sees this you know the meeting is in
00:29:27 three or four months i believe and that is about enough time that for him trump to make a point
00:29:34 with tariffs and have a new prime minister to make a deal with i think trump might see it as an
00:29:37 opportunity to to make a deal and it could be it could be an opportunity to do so and i think
00:29:42 So Canadians would be foolish to turn back on that opportunity to come up with some sort of deal that will last for the rest of the Trump presidency.
00:29:51 Well, because I have you, I just have to take it over and talk about the polling because we have just seen a spectacular change in fortunes.
00:29:59 Right. Like I started I came back and started doing my show in early January.
00:30:03 I came coming back from maternity leave. And at that point, the conservatives looked like they were going to walk away with the largest majority in the generation.
00:30:11 And it seemed just like a matter of time, like Justin Trudeau needs to step down when
00:30:15 the election comes, we will see this change.
00:30:17 And then you look at what has happened basically since that time, since January, and just the
00:30:23 spectacular change.
00:30:25 I think we have that graph that everyone has been pointing at.
00:30:27 So conservative lead, you know, just in the last two, two, three months there has basically
00:30:33 all but disappeared.
00:30:34 We've had you on the show a few times, Hamish, to sort of help us understand whether, you
00:30:39 the polls were real, whether it was something that the media was manufacturing or somehow were
00:30:44 they overreading a trend. It still confuses me because the latest Ipsos poll, which came out on
00:30:49 February 23rd, shows that the Liberals are actually beating the Conservatives by two points. And that
00:30:55 would be the first time that the Liberals have been ahead in a poll since 2021. Still very close,
00:31:01 but it shows Liberals clearly ahead. But then after that, Abacus data came out and Abacus has
00:31:07 repeatedly found that the conservatives are ahead. David Coletto is a very reputable pollster and by
00:31:13 no means a conservative. Very fair and balanced. And he's gone out into the field several times
00:31:19 to try to see if the liberal bounce is real. He doesn't seem to be able to find it. So his latest
00:31:25 poll shows conservatives up at 41, liberals down at 29. Maybe first of all, talk about the
00:31:31 discrepancy there and which which poll do you think is is more accurate or are they both off
00:31:37 like where do you think we are as a country right now so when i see things like that when i see
00:31:41 multiple reputable pollsters um coming up with dramatically different results it clearly shows
00:31:47 to me that we have an electorate in turmoil that has extremely soft impressions of everything
00:31:52 that's going on what's very very clear to me is that people were very very sick and tired of
00:31:58 Justin Trudeau, and they wanted change. With him leaving, they're getting something of change.
00:32:04 Carney is even newer to the scene in terms of frontline politics than Mr. Polyev,
00:32:12 and people are checking that out. We're seeing Mr. Carney's running into a lot of trouble where
00:32:17 he keeps making things up, and I think things will begin to... The reality of Carney will not
00:32:26 line up with sort of the fantasy version we're getting at the moment but what we're seeing is
00:32:30 that canadians are just saying well thank god trudeau's gone we want change and they're kicking
00:32:34 the tires a bit is this carny guy are the new liberals are they actually change or is it still
00:32:39 the conservatives um so i don't particularly when i see does it when i see two pollsters that are
00:32:46 both reputable coming with radically different results it really is is a function of a great
00:32:51 deal of unsettlingness and that neither of them probably either of the views being measured are
00:32:58 probably too firmly held and we can expect change and almost certainly something will be different
00:33:05 by the time we get through an election so we're going into a period of turmoil we're going to a
00:33:09 period where people want change but we've seen this before right when when Brian Mulroney stepped
00:33:14 down and Kim Campbell became leader of the PCs they got back into they went from being that I
00:33:20 12% of the polls back up to being in the lead. When, you know, Justin Trudeau's father stepped
00:33:25 down and John Turner became the prime minister, again, the incumbent government that had been
00:33:31 extremely unpopular went back into the lead. People were excited about something different.
00:33:35 Just have a different name when you turn on the news and it's not the same person you can't stand.
00:33:40 So that's all been going on. We'll see how it lasts once we get into an election campaign and
00:33:46 people start evaluating, you know, Kearney or whoever the Liberal leader is on their own merits.
00:33:52 And I think we'll begin to see some convergence in the polls.
00:33:56 Well, it is interesting when you look at some of the crosstabs here. So Abacus Poll asks Canadians,
00:34:01 what is the top issue that you are looking at in the election? And it shows, if we can show that
00:34:07 on the screen there, 61% of Canadians still say that the rising cost of living is the top concern.
00:34:13 But what has popped all the way up to second place there is Donald Trump and his administration.
00:34:19 And my guess is that number would be even higher after the news that we're getting today.
00:34:23 The two issues are sort of becoming linked because people will feel a greater economic pain thanks to these tariffs.
00:34:29 And then the next one that I want to show is who do you believe is the party best able to handle these issues?
00:34:36 And so you can see that when it comes to cost of living, 37 percent trust the conservatives, only 21 percent say liberals.
00:34:43 But then when it comes to Trump, it's 29 percent conservatives and 39 percent liberals.
00:34:48 There's a couple of other issues that favor conservatives, including immigration and crime, which are also big issues.
00:34:54 But I think that the two big ones there are sort of split.
00:34:57 So I want to ask you a bit of a strategy question, Hamish, because some people on the political right are upset with Pierre Polyev saying that he shouldn't be taking the same position when it comes to tariffs, that maybe he should try to be seen as more reconciliatory towards Trump and trying to strike a deal.
00:35:14 Now, that probably would seem like political suicide to people who are more liberal voters. And Trump obviously is not a beloved character in Canada. I think most people, the majority of Canadians, overwhelming majority, have a negative opinion on him.
00:35:27 So do you think that part of the issue here is that Polyev doesn't have the right strategy?
00:35:33 No, I think Polyev's got the right strategy.
00:35:36 I think he's moved to, you know, obviously things changed since Trudeau stepped down and these Trump tariffs have dominated the landscape.
00:35:48 And I think he's got the right strategy rolling ahead by explaining how he would do things differently.
00:35:54 a great example really is taking that any money collected from tariffs and using it to cut taxes
00:35:59 to make life more affordable. It's interesting, liberals are just talking about pain. They're
00:36:03 not talking about doing anything the other side to make life in any way more affordable for
00:36:06 Canadians, which has been what they frankly have done for the last three or four years as we've
00:36:11 gone through this inflationary period. So I think Mr. Pauly was on the right approach. I think
00:36:18 sucking up to Donald Trump at this point would be absolute political suicide in this country. 0.50
00:36:21 I think that I know lots of people who are Trump supporters, many of whom are backing away from that now. 0.98
00:36:29 He's showing he is absolutely no fan of Canada and no friend to our country, doesn't value the relationship we have with the United States at any level.
00:36:38 And that while some people might still like some of the things that Mr. Trump's doing in the United States, that there is not a market for that political position in Canada.
00:36:48 And I think a conciliary tone, frankly, Mr. Trump would simply see that as more weakness and more ability to to push even further and to try to get even more of a change deal, whatever that looks like, that's even better for him.
00:37:07 So I think the approach is the right one. Look, the Liberals have a long history of standing up to Americans. It's been part of their brand identity for a very, very long time. So I'm not surprised they're ahead as a party on that issue.
00:37:22 I think it's striking that every other issue except for climate change and Trump, the Conservatives, lead the Liberals, even on things like health care and housing.
00:37:31 And it's it's been it's pretty striking.
00:37:35 But you're right. It's it's certainly a challenge.
00:37:39 And but I think Mr. Polio is on the right track.
00:37:43 He's got further to go, but he's on the right track and we'll see how things play out in time.
00:37:49 Well, so this must have been a gift to Polyev then. Trump was speaking in an interview with
00:37:55 Spectator magazine, a U.S. publication, but an American journalist on Friday. And he said that
00:38:02 basically President Trump took aim at Pierre Polyev saying his biggest problem is he's not
00:38:07 a mega guy, not a Trump guy at all. I think we have an audio clip of this. Let's go to that.
00:38:13 Well, I think his biggest problem is he's not a mega guy, you know,
00:38:17 He's really not. He's not a Trump guy at all.
00:38:21 He's more of a throwback Republican.
00:38:23 He's different.
00:38:25 Yeah.
00:38:26 Making a big mistake. They all make that mistake.
00:38:28 They think they're going to be the tough guy and they're going to knock out Trump.
00:38:35 And they end up getting the hell beat out of him.
00:38:38 So I don't know. I mean, I can't tell you, Pierre.
00:38:40 So this gave Polyev the opportunity to hit back. And did we did we lose our video here? Okay,
00:38:51 we might have to go audio only. This gives Pierre Polyev the opportunity to hit back
00:38:56 and basically just say, I'm not MAGA. You're right, President Trump. I'm not MAGA.
00:39:02 And, you know, he puts out this tweet saying that Mr. President is true. I'm not MAGA. I'm
00:39:08 For Canada First, Canada has always been America's best friend and ally.
00:39:14 We will never be the 51st state.
00:39:16 So, Kamish, what do you make of that?
00:39:20 Do you think that this was helpful to Polyev at all?
00:39:22 Do you think that this will help break the impression that somehow Polyev won't be strong against Trump?
00:39:28 I think it will.
00:39:29 I think that distinction is important.
00:39:32 And I think that there's a certain part of the left who sort of will always see anybody, you know, to the right of Justin Trudeau as sort of a cartoon villain that all gets together in some sort of global right wing conspiracy.
00:39:46 But I think the fact that we that, you know, we can draw the line so close, so clear, so separately between Polyev and Trump, I think will be positive for Mr. Polyev.
00:39:58 You know, he's a fierce believer and fighter for Canada. And I think that will come out, continue to come out. The speech he gave back in the middle of February was fantastic, explaining, you know, Canada's history and the role that we've played in North America and his vision going forward. I think it was phenomenal. And, you know, I think we'll see a lot more of that. And I think that will resonate with Canadians.
00:40:22 Okay, I want to get your opinion on this one, because I think Mark Carney is a front runner.
00:40:25 I think that there are some issues with him.
00:40:27 But I believe that the liberals will, I mean, he's sort of the person that's been selected to come in and save the Liberal Party from destruction.
00:40:36 But Chrystia Freeland is also out there making her case.
00:40:38 She was on real time with Bill Maher over the weekend.
00:40:42 And it was interesting to see Hamish, because first of all, she throws Justin Trudeau under the bus.
00:40:47 Prime Minister Trudeau talks about how virtue signaling and identity politics has been overdone
00:40:52 and talks about why she left Trudeau's cabinet. Let's play that clip.
00:40:57 Justin Trudeau, who's on his way out, used to be very popular. I mean, he still has his fans, three.
00:41:05 And they may be asking, why did you turn on him? Because, you know, you were part of his government.
00:41:09 What was it?
00:41:10 My party, we're actually called the Liberal Party. And I am an old school liberal.
00:41:16 And liberals in Canada win when we are focused on people and on what they need in their lives.
00:41:24 And we lose when people think that we're focused on virtue signaling and identity politics.
00:41:34 So apparently she's an old school liberal.
00:41:36 I haven't seen much of that over the last few years.
00:41:39 I don't know if freezing bank accounts and using the Emergencies Act is really what we consider old school liberals.
00:41:46 She also takes a swipe at Pierre Polyev, calling him Maple Syrup Mega.
00:41:51 Let's play that clip.
00:41:53 And the guy you will be running against, Paul Pierre...
00:41:58 How do we say his name? Pierre...
00:42:02 Well, I call him Maple Syrup Mega.
00:42:05 Or...
00:42:06 So, it's funny because Bill Maher's painting it as if it's a given
00:42:15 that she's going to be running against Parapallia.
00:42:17 I don't think that's going to happen.
00:42:18 But interesting that she's trying to make that happen.
00:42:22 She's been using that nickname a lot,
00:42:23 calling him Maple Mega,
00:42:24 but I don't think it's resonating.
00:42:26 I don't think it works.
00:42:27 No, and I think if you're trying to make someone
00:42:29 sound like they're going to be pro-American,
00:42:32 associating them with the word maple
00:42:34 is probably kind of a poor branding choice.
00:42:38 Look, I mean, it just further shows
00:42:39 that Christopher Freeland's the worst communicator
00:42:42 in the Western world.
00:42:43 and it's one of the reasons why she's not going to be the Liberal leader in a few days.
00:42:48 Well, it was interesting that she, because Bill, sorry, Mark Carney went on with Jon Stewart
00:42:53 and that's how he launched his campaign and then you see Freeland on with Bill Maher.
00:42:57 So it's interesting that they're choosing to go to an American audience, right?
00:42:59 Like the Liberals are this like, hey, they literally fund the Canadian media.
00:43:03 They literally bail them out, fund them, put all this cash into CBC
00:43:06 and then when it comes to trying to reach their audience,
00:43:08 they know that no one's watching the Canadian show so they go on the American shows,
00:43:12 which tells you everything you need to know.
00:43:15 So, Hamish, what should we be looking out for on Sunday
00:43:18 with the Liberal leadership race being announced?
00:43:21 Who do you think is going to win?
00:43:23 Do you think it's going to be close?
00:43:25 And what should we be looking for?
00:43:27 I think it's going to be Carney.
00:43:28 All the indicators seem to be it's him.
00:43:30 Not just, you know, the big endorsements,
00:43:32 but a lot of the behind-the-scenes organizers.
00:43:34 This is a race that's about getting people signed up, 0.97
00:43:38 getting them registered, and then getting them to vote.
00:43:40 It's an on-ground organization that matters a ton.
00:43:44 Carney has the money, and he's got a lot of the good organizers with him.
00:43:47 So that should make sure he wins.
00:43:51 It'll be interesting.
00:43:52 The two things I'm looking out for, number one, is overall how many people actually vote engaged in this process.
00:43:57 There's a lot of media hype about Carney.
00:43:58 There's a lot of focus in the polls about Carney.
00:44:02 But when you look at the pictures of his events, the crowds aren't that big.
00:44:07 His engagement on social media is respectable but not incredible.
00:44:10 um the so the number of people who actually came out and voted is going to be extremely important
00:44:16 you know it's about 400,000 people signed up but then they have to register and then vote
00:44:21 um so we'll see what that number is uh and I think it's going to be quite small when you
00:44:26 compare it to the over 600,000 who voted in the conservative uh leadership race a couple of years
00:44:31 ago or two and a half years ago so overall it's going to be interesting and then I think we're
00:44:35 going to look for other areas, particularly in Quebec. I mean, Mark Carney's French is fairly
00:44:40 appalling for someone trying to be prime minister, especially with a large electoral, a party with a
00:44:45 large electoral base in Quebec. And I'm very interested to see if any of the others, none of
00:44:51 whom are frankly, you know, particularly strong Quebec sympathetic politicians, but if they're
00:44:57 able to do anything there because of that. So that will be very interesting to see if that's
00:45:02 what I'm looking out for. Well, it is just interesting that Mark Carney, I mean, he's not
00:45:07 a politician. He hasn't really done this before. He's never been elected to anything. So if he
00:45:11 becomes party leader and prime minister, he'll be a prime minister without being a member of
00:45:15 parliament, without having a seat. I don't know that they're going to quickly go to a by-election
00:45:19 or just trigger an election. I do want to make a point though, Hamish, that he'll mention that,
00:45:24 oh, I'm not a politician and kind of use that as a plus, which is something that Donald Trump
00:45:28 also says, but for Donald Trump, the thing about him not being a politician was that he was a
00:45:33 little rough around the edges, not politically correct. He would make statements that to the
00:45:37 political ear sounded outrageous, but to the American, maybe like the middle of the road
00:45:41 American, they actually liked what he was saying. And he also had this business background. So he
00:45:45 was going to take business mindset and apply it to politics. I'm not saying that it's going well,
00:45:50 but that was his shtick. With Carney, it's like, what is his career? Well, he's been an
00:45:55 unelected bureaucrat who sort of seems like he tries to take a lot of credit for things that
00:46:01 he may or may not have really been involved in. And, you know, his career is that he's a bureaucrat.
00:46:07 So, you know, I don't think that that is really has the same kind of like interest for the people
00:46:13 to say like, OK, well, he's not a politician. We'll give him a pass because he's been operating
00:46:16 in this political world for so long. I see that as a major weakness for Carney. But I did want
00:46:22 to ask you, you can comment on that, but I also want to ask you, when do you think that the general
00:46:26 election will get triggered? Because we've heard rumors and it might happen immediately, like within
00:46:30 24 or 48 hours. Other people say, no, he's going to want to be prime minister for a month or two
00:46:35 and get the hang of it, maybe even wait until the G7 conference. So comment on Carney and then tell
00:46:41 us when you think the election is going to happen. Yeah, I think politicians say I'm not a politician
00:46:45 is something that nobody believes. The way Trump was able to communicate that is exactly as you
00:46:50 said, but he didn't act like a politician. He didn't sound like any politician anybody had
00:46:53 ever heard in 2015 and 2016, right? It was completely different. And that's how he didn't
00:46:57 have to say, I'm not a politician because he didn't act like one. You know, Mark Carney
00:47:01 acts exactly like sort of an identikit, mass produced politician. And he keeps lying about
00:47:10 being involved in political things, or he claims he helped Paul Martin balance the budget, which
00:47:15 he didn't. But also if you're trying to say you're not part of the system claiming you are,
00:47:20 It was weird, and then claims that he was key to saving Canada during the global financial crisis when it was Jim Flaherty making the tough calls.
00:47:33 And, of course, Jim's not here to defend at all.
00:47:38 But, again, if he's trying to be a politician, he shouldn't be associating himself with all these political-type things.
00:47:43 He's completely, I think, doing it completely backwards there.
00:47:46 But I will say that, you know, the rumor mill in Ottawa, for what it's worth, is that, you know, Carney will get sworn in as Prime Minister a few days after he wins the Liberal leadership, I'm not sure exactly which day, and then call an election about a week later.
00:48:02 That might work.
00:48:04 It prevents him having to go for a by-election to get into the House, obviously.
00:48:08 Although there is bizarrely a by-election that was called on Sunday for Halifax.
00:48:12 It's open right now.
00:48:13 So maybe he could jump in as a Liberal candidate right now there.
00:48:17 But I will say that the last time someone tried this was John Turner, who was not a
00:48:25 member of Parliament, became Prime Minister, and called an election 10 days later and took
00:48:29 his party to the worst defeat in in canadian history so you know hopefully that's what happens
00:48:34 again okay well we'll have to uh have you back amish thanks for joining the show it's always a
00:48:38 pleasure to have you on hear your insights thank you so much for joining us thank you all right
00:48:44 everyone thank you so much for tuning in we'll be back again tomorrow with all the news i'm
00:48:47 Candice Malcolm. This is the Candice Malcolm Show. Thank you and God bless.