Juno News - April 03, 2024


Trudeau admits he's bungled the immigration file

Mentioned
Trudeau made life more expensive yesterday NDP MPs are bailing

Episode Stats


Length

52 minutes

Words per minute

171.88

Word count

8,994

Sentence count

378

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew takes a look behind the scenes at the making of this week's show, including a major announcement from the Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, about immigration and his plan to increase the number of temporary foreign workers in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 this is the second day in a row this has happened it happened yesterday where we have this nifty
00:01:31 little plan on all the stuff we're going to talk about and then like i don't know 30 seconds before
00:01:35 the show goes on air justin trudeau drops a bit of a bombshell we had a little bit more lead time
00:01:40 today and it's not as big a bombshell but erin o'toole appeared before the foreign interference 0.91
00:01:46 Commission this morning and he made some comments that I'm like okay I let me just rearrange some
00:01:53 stuff I'm gonna get it in there so it will be a bit of a packed show welcome everyone to
00:01:57 the Andrew Lawton show on this Wednesday April 3rd 2024 Canada's most irreverent talk show here
00:02:05 the big story I wanted to legitimately follow up on what did come out just before we started
00:02:11 of the show yesterday see a little bit of a look behind the scenes we do this show live and part
00:02:16 of the reason for that is that it is far much more fun to do the show live because if something
00:02:21 happens you just roll with it and you have some fun with it if I just lose the ability to speak
00:02:26 as happens from time to time believe it or not I just have to laugh it off I'm not like oh well
00:02:31 maybe edit out that second syllable or oh I don't like how I pronounce that word and then you just
00:02:35 I have again you just have your opportunity one time and one time only but also in a breaking
00:02:41 news context it's useful we used to do the show pre-taped and part of that was just because it
00:02:46 was a podcast and podcasting is generally not an immediate type of format and Sean is a very
00:02:52 diligent editor so I'd record this great show at 7 a.m and think okay I've got the day off let's
00:02:57 just go and you know tend to the lilies outside I don't know if we have lilies and if we do I've
00:03:02 never once tended to them but anyway and then she would oh yeah we'll edit it and then uh you know
00:03:06 at 2 30 we're about to hit publish and oh what do you know the core premise of my show has now been
00:03:12 uh has now been see i'm losing the ability to speak has now been trumped by something that
00:03:17 happened in the interceding hour so we do it live we have fun with it and i hope you enjoy it as well
00:03:21 but you don't have to listen or watch live you can catch us in the podcast on the youtube on
00:03:27 on facebook at a certain point if you're in like a foreign country you might be able to
00:03:31 but you can't in Canada because of Bill C-18 nevertheless let's talk a fair bit about oh yes
00:03:39 or the Andrew Lawton page on Facebook they haven't yet banned us on that and I don't want to give
00:03:43 them ideas but if you subscribe to Andrew Lawton on Facebook which I hope you do hello that's me
00:03:48 there is an opportunity you can catch the show there so yeah thank you for that Sean so let's
00:03:55 talk about this immigration thing so Justin Trudeau yesterday had that remarkable little
00:04:00 bit of candor that we shared a clip from this is a more truncated version of it we cut out all the
00:04:06 fluff and left just the essence of it here that you need to see to get what he's saying take a look
00:04:12 it's really important to understand the context around immigration every year we bring in about
00:04:18 450 now close to 500,000 permanent residents a year and that is part of the necessary growth
00:04:27 of Canada. It benefits our citizens, our communities. It benefits our economy. These are the levels
00:04:34 that we have stabilized and grown steadily over the past years because that's what Canada
00:04:40 needs to continue to have a strong economy and strong communities. However, over the
00:04:46 past few years, we've seen a massive spike in temporary immigration, whether it's temporary
00:04:53 foreign workers, or whether it's international students in particular, that have grown at a rate
00:05:00 far beyond what Canada has been able to absorb. Ooh, a massive spike in immigration, and it has 0.71
00:05:11 been far beyond, not just beyond, not just a little bit beyond, far beyond what Canada has
00:05:16 been able to absorb. Now, this is the guy who, as there was an illegal migration crisis underway,
00:05:24 he puts out this tweet. We should just have this tweet. To be honest, we should just have it ready.
00:05:28 We used to use it so often that says, hashtag welcome to Canada, a tweet that my colleague
00:05:34 Candace Malcolm has found through access to information documents. Legitimately, the department
00:05:39 understood was causing people to go to the border illegally because, oh, well, the prime minister
00:05:45 of Canada said that there's basically this red carpet waiting for us at Roxham Road, so let's
00:05:49 just go on in. And this was legitimately spiking illegal immigration in Canada. So this idea that
00:05:56 immigration is something that comes with consequences for a country, they can be good
00:06:00 consequences or bad consequences, depending on the type of immigration, is something that Canadians,
00:06:06 apart from Justin Trudeau, have always understood. If you do the Stephen Harper thing and you
00:06:11 prioritize economic migration, people that are willing and able to integrate into Canadian society,
00:06:16 people who have, oh you're not allowed to say the word anymore, Canadian values, those people
00:06:22 will enhance and improve the fabric of the country. That is when diversity can be your strength as a
00:06:29 nation. If you're talking about people that are going to be, for whatever reason, drains on the
00:06:34 public system, people that are not going to contribute to Canadian society, people who do not
00:06:38 share the fundamental values that Canadian society requires, they will create problems in a country.
00:06:44 This is the path available, or the two paths available, when a country is looking at immigration.
00:06:50 And there are economic barriers, there are economic considerations, and there are also, of course,
00:06:56 considerations that go beyond pure economics. And this is the criticism people have had,
00:07:01 even about some of the things that Conservative leader Pierre Polyev has said on this issue.
00:07:05 But right now, this is just on the economic side alone.
00:07:08 Justin Trudeau is admitting that we have seen an influx in immigration
00:07:12 that has been more than Canada can absorb.
00:07:15 More immigrants in this country than we have houses for, 1.00
00:07:19 than we have jobs for, than we have social services for,
00:07:23 than we have healthcare resources for.
00:07:25 And all of this, he describes as though it's just sort of happened.
00:07:29 You just wake up one day and, oh, what do you know?
00:07:31 We've had 1.2 million people come into this country every year,
00:07:35 including permanent residents and temporary residents. And of course, I mean, the share
00:07:40 of the country that is temporary residents has skyrocketed up. It was a few years ago at I think
00:07:46 2%. Now it is over 7%. And this has happened on Justin Trudeau's watch because he actually did
00:07:53 not believe or did not accept that there would be adverse consequences to doing this in such a
00:07:59 dramatic way. And I know that all the press progress losers are going to take like little
00:08:04 bits of discussions like this out of question. This is not a rant against immigration because
00:08:08 it's actually immigrants to this country who are the most poorly served by an immigration system
00:08:14 that is as broken as the one over which Trudeau has presided for two reasons. Number one, because
00:08:20 they're coming to the country and this bounty that Canada has been able to offer them or has told it
00:08:25 that it will offer them is not there for them. And also because when people start to see fractures
00:08:31 in the community, what do they do? They start looking at immigration and its role.
00:08:37 And when you have a government that is as aggressive on immigration numbers and turning
00:08:42 it into a game, how high can we get the number as this liberal government has, it turns Canadians
00:08:47 against immigrants. It turns Canadians against the immigration system. Because if your choice is
00:08:54 the status quo or no immigration, a lot of people are going to say, well, this certainly isn't
00:09:00 working. And if these are the only two alternatives, then I'm going to go with this immigration averse 1.00
00:09:05 position. And that's a very dangerous position because we have a birth rate that is absolutely
00:09:10 in dismal territory. Canada's only population growth has come in the last several years
00:09:17 through immigration. So let's discuss where this consensus has gone. Half of Canadians,
00:09:23 according to one poll, this was, I believe, a Leger poll, say immigration is simply too high.
00:09:30 39% of those polled say that this was something that has attributed to exacerbating housing issues.
00:09:38 21% say immigrants are draining societal resources.
00:09:41 Again, this is not about whether these people are right or wrong.
00:09:44 It's that that's the perception and you can't have a pro-immigration consensus in a country
00:09:49 when half the population is thinking immigration is too high.
00:09:53 You also then have polls of immigrants.
00:09:56 This one also alleged 84% of immigrants.
00:10:00 who came to Canada in the past decade say their life is significantly or somewhat more expensive
00:10:06 than anticipated. Now, more expensive doesn't mean worse, but it does mean that these people
00:10:11 came to this country thinking life was going to be one way and have found that it hasn't actually
00:10:16 panned out in that manner. So this is an incredibly important issue. Now, I go back to Justin Trudeau's
00:10:23 comments and the critical question, the million dollar question, why is he throwing himself under
00:10:29 the bus. Well, for starters, he's not actually throwing himself under the bus. He's doing the
00:10:34 Trudopian thing that we know and love because it is so entertaining where he says it's society that
00:10:39 has a learning opportunity. Society has to learn from this. We all have to learn from this. We all
00:10:44 have to look in the mirror. He does blackface. It's a learning opportunity for everyone. He 0.99
00:10:49 gropes a reporter. We all have to do better. It's the same old song and dance. This is an issue
00:10:54 where he says Canada has done this.
00:10:57 No, your government did this.
00:10:58 Your government was the one that made this call.
00:11:02 But I think there's a reason that is very deliberate.
00:11:05 This was not a gaffe.
00:11:06 This was not a slip of the tongue.
00:11:08 This was not a mispeak.
00:11:09 This was Justin Trudeau carving out
00:11:11 a very deliberate position on immigration.
00:11:14 And I think one reason that stands out
00:11:17 is that he sees this as actually a wedge issue
00:11:19 for the Conservatives.
00:11:21 He sees that the Conservatives
00:11:22 are not all in agreement on this issue.
00:11:25 You have Pierre Polyev doing very, very well
00:11:27 among members of a variety of ethnic communities,
00:11:30 people who in some cases are very pro-immigration,
00:11:33 in some cases are more skeptical of it.
00:11:36 But there's a reason that Pierre Polyev
00:11:38 has been a bit reticent on his own beliefs on this.
00:11:41 Exactly what number the conservatives
00:11:44 would put as their target
00:11:46 is something he has not answered.
00:11:48 This was a clip, I've shared it before,
00:11:50 from my year-ender with Pierre Polyev back in December.
00:11:55 Immigration, it isn't just housing that needs to be taken into consideration.
00:11:58 It's also jobs, social services, just geography here.
00:12:02 So knowing what you know about the country,
00:12:04 do you think those targets from the Liberal government are too high,
00:12:07 that 500,000 per year target?
00:12:09 Well, it's not 500.
00:12:10 As you know, it's 1.2 million now.
00:12:14 The answer is that we have to bring the numbers in line
00:12:17 with the number of houses that are built,
00:12:20 The growth in immigration should not exceed the amount of housing stock we add, the number of doctors we add, and the available jobs.
00:12:30 But if you were Prime Minister now, what would that number be?
00:12:32 What would your projection be?
00:12:33 I don't have a target for this year, but what I would say is when I launch my platform, it will explicitly link the population growth to the growth in the housing stock to the growth in the number of doctors and nurses.
00:12:50 and to the availability of jobs.
00:12:52 So it could be lower.
00:12:53 It will be mathematically driven,
00:12:55 not by arbitrary targets to generate virtue signaling headlines,
00:13:00 as we have right now.
00:13:01 It will be mathematically driven by the growth in the housing stock,
00:13:05 the growth in the supply of doctors and nurses to treat people,
00:13:09 and the availability of jobs.
00:13:11 But if I were to say to you just the number,
00:13:13 a term that you yourself have used in exchanges of this,
00:13:16 you can't give one.
00:13:17 Well, of course, I can't because I'll be forming government at this rate in 2025.
00:13:23 And we'll have to set the numbers based on the conditions in that year.
00:13:29 So it was interesting, actually, the fallout from this.
00:13:32 There was a lot of Rorschach-ing going on.
00:13:35 You know, the Rorschach-ing plot test where you look at it and everyone sees what they're going to see.
00:13:40 Where, you know, conservative supporters were saying,
00:13:42 ah, yes, this is a thoughtful, very devoted, clear answer on immigration.
00:13:46 and people that are a bit more critical of Pierre Polyev
00:13:49 looked at it and said,
00:13:49 oh yeah, he's dodging, he's not saying the number.
00:13:52 I see both sides of it.
00:13:53 On one hand, he doesn't just want to put a random number
00:13:56 on the board and say, that's the target.
00:13:58 But he's saying, these are the factors
00:13:59 that we will use to get to that target.
00:14:01 But again, it's an issue where the Conservatives
00:14:04 have had a bit more trepidation
00:14:05 than they have on many others.
00:14:07 And I've talked about this on the show in the past.
00:14:10 It's something that they'll need to deal with.
00:14:12 And I think that's why,
00:14:13 to go back to Justin Trudeau's motivation,
00:14:16 That's why Justin Trudeau is approaching this issue the way he is, because he is seeing that
00:14:22 the conservatives don't actually have one cohesive position on immigration. So if Justin Trudeau can
00:14:28 actually outflank the conservatives on immigration, it will form a bit of a wedge in the conservative
00:14:34 base. The conservatives will have to somehow scramble for the votes of the ethnic communities
00:14:39 that might be pro-immigration, very pro-immigration, and people that are a bit more immigration
00:14:43 skeptical. And again, I'm distilling this down into a very crude dichotomy and binary here,
00:14:49 which is not. I mean, you can be very pro-immigration and not pro-unfettered immigration.
00:14:55 That's what I am. That's what I think most sensible Canadians are of whatever ethnic or
00:15:00 racial background, be they native Canadians or be they people that got here 10 minutes ago.
00:15:05 But I think that's what Justin Trudeau is doing. I think he's trying to create a wedge
00:15:09 in the conservatives that they will have to do, that they will have to take, put the issue back
00:15:14 on Pierre Polyev, force him to give a number, and the second Polyev takes the bait, the second Polyev
00:15:19 says that that number will be lower than 500,000, Trudeau will have to say, oh, and then all of a
00:15:25 sudden we're going to see that flip once again. But if I were Mark Miller, the immigration minister,
00:15:29 I'd be wondering, you know, what exactly is Justin Trudeau saying about your performance there? That
00:15:36 is something or if I were I guess Sean Fraser who had the file before he got pushed into housing
00:15:42 I would say this is not exactly a ringing endorsement for him so I want to talk about
00:15:48 this Aaron O'Toole business and I'm going to get to that very shortly but I want to talk about the
00:15:52 firearms file first and foremost here we had news from Saskatchewan they've appointed a new
00:15:58 chief firearms officer which is increasingly important in an era in which provinces are
00:16:03 finding they've got some tools in the toolbox to not go along with the federal government's gun
00:16:08 grab. Now, I talked about this on the show last week. You may recall the federal government has
00:16:13 spent tens of millions of dollars on this buyback, which they announced four years ago and have not
00:16:20 yet taken a single gun. Now, from a taxpayer perspective, I say, oh, this is waste. I don't
00:16:25 like it. It's inefficient. From a firearm zoning perspective, I'm like, oh, that's great. Just keep
00:16:29 it going. Keep the boondoggle underway. This was something that we heard from Premier Danielle
00:16:35 Smith in Alberta on this. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's government has splurged $42 million
00:16:41 on its firearm buyback program without confiscating a single firearm to date. Should the federal
00:16:47 government try again to implement the program, would your government consider invoking the
00:16:51 Sovereignty Act in a bid to protect the property rights of law-abiding Albertans? Well, I call that
00:16:56 a success that they haven't been able to seize a single law-abiding firearms owner's gun. So
00:17:00 I wish them continued success at being able to achieve zero compliance with their program. And
00:17:06 we are not going to do anything to help them. We believe that the issue is the illegal firearms
00:17:11 getting into the hands of gangs and organized crime coming across the border. And the federal
00:17:16 government should be focused on that, not focusing on taking guns away from sport shooters,
00:17:20 duck hunters and and farmers i'd love to see more of this in every province across the country
00:17:28 provinces often have taken the view that oh well firearms law is criminal it's federal but
00:17:33 provinces have a fair bit of authority on there whether it's a loophole or explicit rights you
00:17:40 could debate and discuss but when alberta said that it would not use police resources to go after
00:17:46 firearms, the federal government was kind of screwed because they didn't have another card
00:17:51 to play. All they could do was finger wag. And I would say, all right, finger wag all day long.
00:17:56 Rod Giltaka is joining us once again. He's the executive director of the Canadian Coalition for
00:18:01 Firearm Rights. Yeah, Rod, this must be a bit conflicting for you too, because on one hand,
00:18:05 you're a taxpayer paying for this program. But on the other hand, your guns are still safe for now.
00:18:11 Well, we're certainly in good company with everyone that's angry about a Rive scam as well,
00:18:15 right? So everyone is feeling the taxpayer pinch when it comes to the Liberals' incompetence and
00:18:23 their corruption. Yeah, it's going to be like ARCan is the new government app where you have to
00:18:28 log your AR-15s and whatnot. But let me talk to you first and foremost about the provincial
00:18:35 response here, because oftentimes I think even firearms advocates have many, it seems like,
00:18:41 really just focused on the federal government. And if you get a liberal government like we have
00:18:46 now that's very hostile to gun owners, they kind of just say, all right, well, we're in for a rocky
00:18:49 ride here. But this has been a relatively recent advent, it seemed like, where provinces are really
00:18:54 stepping up their game and saying no to this. Well, they are stepping up their game, at least
00:18:59 Alberta and Saskatchewan have lined up behind the CCFR and the other applicants in our lawsuit.
00:19:05 We're in the appeals process right now, and they are stepping up as interveners.
00:19:11 So we're really happy to not be going it alone.
00:19:15 And those two provinces are really making a statement,
00:19:18 I think, for their citizens.
00:19:20 And they're saying, you know,
00:19:21 what the federal government is doing is unreasonable,
00:19:24 not only just in the firearms file, right?
00:19:25 But in this case, you know, about guns.
00:19:28 And we're not gonna stand for it because, you know,
00:19:30 we work for you.
00:19:32 So I don't know, like I say,
00:19:34 I'm really happy that we're not standing alone.
00:19:36 I'm really happy that governments are doing things
00:19:39 in the interest of their citizens.
00:19:41 And yeah, we're really happy.
00:19:43 I've had on the show Alberta's chief firearms officer, Terry Bryant, who's been like just a tremendous advocate for the sport and a tremendous administrator as well.
00:19:53 When I was, you know, waiting like four months for my handgun to clear, Alberta was like processing these things in like a week, it seemed like.
00:20:00 Now we have in Saskatchewan a new CFO appointed.
00:20:04 I don't know if you've had any dealings with Murray Cowan before.
00:20:06 I think we're going to have him on the show next week.
00:20:09 But what are your expectations there from what Saskatchewan's doing with that firearms
00:20:13 office?
00:20:14 Well, my expectations are they're going to continue on doing the great things that they're
00:20:17 doing.
00:20:18 I had the opportunity to spend a couple of hours with Robert Freeberg, who was their
00:20:24 CFO in Saskatchewan, who is now the commissioner of the Saskatchewan firearms office.
00:20:31 And I tell you, it's just here's a bureaucrat that is thoughtful.
00:20:36 and I think the most important thing is
00:20:39 he doesn't believe that he's at war
00:20:40 with his own citizens
00:20:41 and in particular people
00:20:43 that would subject themselves
00:20:44 to the process of obtaining
00:20:47 and maintaining a firearms license.
00:20:49 So they've done, I think,
00:20:52 in that province as well as Alberta,
00:20:53 focused on the most important aspects
00:20:55 of the firearms office
00:20:57 or the duties of the CFO,
00:20:58 which is to increase compliance
00:21:00 with the act and regulations
00:21:02 and work towards increased public safety.
00:21:05 That's really the mandate, not in enforcement and prosecution of licensed gun owners, which
00:21:14 is what the federal government right now is focused on.
00:21:17 So at the end of the day, we think that owning firearms legally is really important and that
00:21:25 there's a regulatory framework around that and ensuring the public is safe in light of
00:21:32 that, but focusing on where violent crime really comes from, which is gangs. There's a domestic
00:21:37 violence aspect to it. And it's a lot of that stuff is fueled. Almost all of it is fueled by
00:21:42 smuggling and illegal manufacturing. Now, when we talk about provinces appointing their own CFOs,
00:21:47 just to go back to the civics of this for a moment, what is it that a CFO can do differently?
00:21:53 Because yes, the core regulations, the core law is federal, but we see wildly different experiences
00:21:58 in different provinces, depending on their CFO.
00:22:01 So what is it that they can really do
00:22:03 that is more favorable to people like you and I?
00:22:06 Well, in the case of Saskatchewan,
00:22:08 they passed their own Firearms Act.
00:22:11 And what it did, so I'll give you one example.
00:22:13 It's quite complicated.
00:22:15 I don't claim to know everything,
00:22:17 but I'll give you one example.
00:22:19 In the Firearms Act,
00:22:20 if you store your firearm in a way
00:22:23 that is in contravention with the Firearms Act,
00:22:25 it's a criminal offense.
00:22:26 it triggers a criminal code charge immediately so that will basically for a law-abiding citizen
00:22:33 destroy their lives basically it's a weapons charge and that might be as you know as innocuous
00:22:39 as you know my guns are in the safe but i may not have were in a locked case but i may not have put
00:22:45 a secure locking device on the firearm or i forgot that or i left a magazine in a gun in a gun safe
00:22:50 like those are those result in life destroying criminal charges so saskatchewan has said you know
00:22:55 what maybe it's maybe it's a um a case of making sure people are in compliance and providing
00:23:01 education and some motivation for them to make sure that they're storing their firearms correctly
00:23:07 and in the case of let's say handguns these are these are registered firearms held by people that
00:23:12 get a criminal record check every single day electronically right so this is not this is not a
00:23:17 criminal enterprise so that's so what the with the firearm saskatchewan firearms act does is it takes
00:23:22 that offense that was a federal criminal offense in the criminal code and turns it into a regulatory
00:23:28 offense so they'll face a fine or maybe even seizure of their firearms until they take a
00:23:32 course or what have you so there's there's reasonable remedial action in incorporated
00:23:38 into that and people don't get their lives destroyed for an administrative oversight so
00:23:43 these are some of the things that a a forward-thinking reasonable chief firearms officer
00:23:48 can get going in their own province and reside over a regime that's far more reasonable and
00:23:55 proportionate, I would say. You mentioned the lawsuit that the Saskatchewan and Alberta
00:24:01 governments have joined as interveners. Now, I should say, when you're David going up against
00:24:05 Goliath, an organization which may be a very robust organization, but you're going up against
00:24:11 the government, it's good to know at least you have some governments on your side, at least in
00:24:15 some way here so that's in the appeal what's the what's the essence of the argument on this case
00:24:19 well probably the most important one is the administrative aspect of our argument so
00:24:24 in the criminal code uh it clearly says that the government can't ban firearms that are
00:24:31 appropriate for hunting and sporting use and it's it was written in there for a reason it's not an
00:24:35 accident that it's in there the government decides well you know what we're going to violate that um
00:24:40 and we think we had the administrative authority just to override the criminal code using an order
00:24:44 council we're not even going to you know we're not going to need legislation or anything for
00:24:48 that kind of stuff we're just going to do it especially when it's on the heels of something
00:24:52 like the spree shooting in nova scotia that's they thought well you know what nobody's gonna
00:24:56 nobody's going to push back against us and we're just going to do this thing so we sued the
00:25:01 government for that reason the um federal court judge in the case said oh yeah well the government
00:25:07 can pretty much do whatever it wants even if it's doesn't have the authority to do what it's supposed
00:25:12 to do we disagree with that ruling our our legal team which is one of the best in the country said
00:25:19 we should have won on this there's no reason why we should have lost there are a lot of independent
00:25:23 people out there that said you absolutely should have won this we're appealing it because we might
00:25:29 think we might suppose there's all kinds of monkey business going on there and at least we have the
00:25:34 department of justice in two canadian provinces that agree we should have won that administrative
00:25:38 aspect. So they're lining up behind us. So, you know, it was the government overstepping its
00:25:44 authority. Not the first time we saw this government doing that, but hopefully we get
00:25:48 a proper resolution this time. All right. Well, we'll keep our eyes peeled on that as it works
00:25:53 its way through the process. Rod Giltaka, always a pleasure, sir. Thanks for coming on. Thank you.
00:25:58 All right. I mentioned, so it's actually a good segue here because I want to talk about the 2021
00:26:03 election. And Aaron O'Toole, a name we probably haven't heard for a little while, he was the
00:26:09 leader of the Conservative Party of Canada. Before that, he was the true blue, rock-ribbed, iron-clad
00:26:14 conservative that was going to be the unflinching conservative, true blue, as he said, against the
00:26:20 squishy, moderate, red Tory Peter McKay. That was the narrative of the 2020 Conservative Leadership
00:26:25 race. Aaron O'Toole wins. And in 2021, he forgets everything he said in 2020. When he campaigned in
00:26:33 the leadership on defunding CBC, he campaigned in 2021 on, well, maybe we just commission a report
00:26:40 that's going to look at the business model of CBC and see if there are ways to modernize it.
00:26:44 When he said in the leadership, he would be unflinching in conscience rights for members
00:26:49 of parliament. In 2021, he said, if you're running on this platform, you better fall in line. When he
00:26:54 said in 2020 that he was the pro-freedom candidate. He said everything the opposite of that when
00:27:01 COVID and vaccine mandates came. You may recall in 2022 when the Freedom Convoy, this is after
00:27:08 he had lost the 2021 election, the Freedom Convoy was on its way to Ottawa and Aaron O'Toole was
00:27:13 asked about these demands that truckers were making to lose the vaccine mandate and he said
00:27:18 all right we support truckers. Here's what we're going to do. We're going to set up vaccine clinics
00:27:23 at truck stops. Yeah, you really got him there. So this was Aaron O'Toole. Now Aaron O'Toole
00:27:30 made some profound just blunders in that 2021 election. He flip-flopped on policies. He flip-flopped
00:27:39 on his position on guns. He was pro-gun and then he was pro-gun control. He flipped on so much in
00:27:45 that election, much of it within the span of just like a few questions from reporters. That would be
00:27:51 enough to get him to roll on policies that were literally in the printed, bound, glossy, laminated
00:27:56 platform books. And then he gets asked, but he's like, oh yeah, no, no, no, we're going to take
00:28:00 that. Literally, they took out a section on firearms from the platform that had already
00:28:04 been sent out because he got a couple of nasty questions from, I don't know, the Toronto Star
00:28:08 or whatever. So this is all the lead up to this morning when Aaron O'Toole took the stage before
00:28:14 the Commission on Foreign Influence in Canadian Elections. And he said why it is that he really
00:28:20 lost in 2021. Take a look. So what was your understanding then based on the modeling
00:28:26 on election day of where the conservatives would end up in terms of seats that day?
00:28:35 Yeah, reliving those last few days of the campaign. We went from winning the seat count
00:28:40 a week before the election with a small modest minority to on election day losing the seat count
00:28:49 and still winning the popular vote. We saw the vote changing largely on the vaccine
00:28:54 and the vaccine mandate issue. But on election night, when we knew we were going to lose,
00:29:03 my campaign manager had said, our models and how the vote goes, you should end up with about 127, 0.99
00:29:11 128 seats, which will be a historic level for opposition. And when you consider it was a
00:29:17 pandemic election we we were largely on the wrong side of public opinion on on the vaccine mandate
00:29:23 issue which is in my view why the prime minister called the election um that was being briefed to
00:29:29 me to say calm down you did okay um you'll you'll be able to live to fight another day and and stay
00:29:37 on as leader so i went in that night feeling okay we're going to end up with 127 128 seats
00:29:44 and as returns were coming in that night not that I asked for any detail but that night
00:29:51 there was already clear indication that a number of ridings were vastly outside of our modeling
00:29:57 window and the the ridings were the same ridings that we had been complaining about
00:30:03 so the the interference stuff is is by the way completely accurate yes the conservatives were
00:30:11 targeted by the Chinese regime in 2021, in the ridings in which there is ample evidence to
00:30:17 suggest that interference took place, it was not enough that it would have swayed the overall
00:30:22 result. But it would be very easy. It would be very convenient and nice and probably help
00:30:27 Aaron O'Toole sleep at night to say that, oh, his loss was everyone else's fault. His loss was
00:30:32 China's fault. His loss was the vaccine mandate's fault. He says in that clip that the conservatives
00:30:38 were on the wrong side of the vaccine mandate issue. Now, what he means is that the conservatives
00:30:44 were wrong to oppose vaccine mandates. Now, there's a premise embedded in that, which is that
00:30:49 the conservatives really did oppose vaccine mandates. Now, yes, technically, when Justin
00:30:54 Trudeau came out and said that he wanted vaccine mandates for the civil service to get on planes,
00:30:59 the conservatives did take a softly critical position of that. But when they criticized it,
00:31:05 they weren't dealing with the essence of the issue.
00:31:08 They weren't actually saying, this is fundamentally wrong.
00:31:11 You can't deny people's civil liberties.
00:31:13 You can't force this on people.
00:31:15 No, they were pussyfooting around it.
00:31:17 They were saying, well, yeah, you know, we don't like it.
00:31:19 Same as when the trucker mandate came in.
00:31:21 They weren't saying this is fundamentally wrong.
00:31:23 They were saying, well, I mean, supply chains are already pretty rough
00:31:26 and, you know, it's the grocery store shell.
00:31:28 Like, they weren't dealing with the issue in the way that it needed to be dealt with.
00:31:33 And if anything, the Conservatives just went along with this line that, well, he's politicizing vaccines. We don't want to talk about them. They shouldn't be political. It's too important. So he was accepting the Liberal premise on a lot of these very damaging and very dangerous COVID policies.
00:31:50 Now, let me be perfectly frank when I point out that I think a lot of Canadians did support
00:31:55 what Justin Trudeau was doing.
00:31:57 I've lamented that fact on a number of occasions.
00:32:00 Canadians were calling bylaw enforcement officers on their neighbours.
00:32:04 Canadians did re-elect Justin Trudeau, but the problem was not that the Conservatives
00:32:09 were too anti-vaccine mandate.
00:32:11 If anything, the problem was that they were not anti-vaccine mandate enough.
00:32:15 But moreover, I don't buy the fact that the change in fortunes for the Conservatives was largely or even minimally because of the vaccine issue.
00:32:25 No, it was because the Conservatives had a leader which could not articulate what the Conservatives believed, what he believed.
00:32:32 They had a leader who would flip on anything he had said even a year and a half earlier about what he would do if he were elected Prime Minister.
00:32:39 and more importantly, the amount of daylight between him and Justin Trudeau had just shrunk
00:32:45 to a tiny little sliver of a glimmer by the end of the campaign. So this idea that we could just
00:32:52 look everywhere else but inward to figure out why the Conservatives lost the election
00:32:58 is a very convenient, very convenient path for Aaron O'Toole, but it is historic revisionism
00:33:04 at its worst. This is an issue. I'm ambushing my next guest because I didn't say that I was going
00:33:10 to talk about this, but I feel Tom Marazzo's up on this. He's a retired captain with the Canadian
00:33:15 Armed Forces and author of the book, The People's Emergency Act, and joins me now. Tom, you must
00:33:21 remember that when O'Toole comes out, the trucks are on their way to Ottawa, and he says, all right,
00:33:25 all right, I got this, guys. Vaccine clinics at truck stops. That's the answer to the mandate.
00:33:30 oh you're muted there
00:33:34 nope we're still uh still can't hear you there
00:33:39 all right we'll get to we'll get that sorted out in just a moment uh but so what i was going to
00:33:45 talk to tom about and we'll get to this as well is this uh story actually quite a dismal story that
00:33:51 we have talked about in the past soldiers are increasingly reliant on food banks these are
00:33:57 soldiers men and women who put on a uniform to serve their country and do so incredibly
00:34:03 courageously not for a huge amount of money but Canada has not even provided the bare necessities
00:34:09 to these people we've had reports uh one in the Ottawa Citizen that came out where Canadian
00:34:15 Forces personnel had to rely on food donations while undergoing training in Ottawa because of
00:34:21 high living costs there and a lack of support from the military we also see that in New Brunswick
00:34:26 demand has been doubling at food banks in large part because of the Canadian Forces base in
00:34:33 Gagetown. The food bank there has reported a doubling of the number of military personnel
00:34:38 seeking assistance. This goes back to the beginning of COVID. I think I hear rumblings
00:34:43 from what sounds like Tom Marazzo's microphone there. So we'll get Tom back on here. Tom,
00:34:49 I think I can hear you now. So we'll get to the food bank stuff, but just, I mean,
00:34:53 Aaron O'Toole's revisionism, that the Conservatives, first off, took a strong position against vaccine mandates in 2021, but then that they lost because of that is just baffling to me.
00:35:04 Yeah, that was extremely frustrating to me personally, but also a lot of people that I know.
00:35:09 And, you know, going back to the convoy itself, I remember, and I was quite surprised by it, the fact that the Conservative Party used the actual convoy protest in Ottawa as a means to dethrone Erin O'Toole from the party.
00:35:27 So initially we took that as a very, very positive action on behalf of the Conservative Party.
00:35:35 And then Candace Bergen became the interim leader. She did a photo op with a couple of truckers. The next day went into the House of Commons and said, basically, OK, truckers, you've proved your point. Now go home. Right. Which we saw as a massive slap in the face. And, you know, I'm not here to bash conservatives overall. I've done enough of that, you know, as of late.
00:36:00 But, you know, it was very frustrating because we thought that there was going to be an opportunity where the Conservative Party, the official opposition to the Canadian government, were going to get our back.
00:36:12 And that's not what happened at all.
00:36:14 In fact, they used us for their own personal political gain.
00:36:19 And I think the convoy itself was an opportunity for the Conservatives to dump the leader that they really had a lot of buyer's remorse from.
00:36:27 but we weren't the beneficiaries of that so in a sense my takeaway is that the convoy itself was
00:36:34 very convenient for the conservatives but it wasn't overall helpful to the rest of Canada
00:36:39 at that time especially not the six million unvaccinated Canadians yeah I take I take a bit
00:36:46 more of a sympathetic view of Candace Bergen's position than you did and again I don't know
00:36:51 what's in her mind on that but what I took from what she was saying was that you guys didn't have
00:36:56 a champion in the political system, now you do. And again, you could debate and haggle over whether
00:37:02 that was an accurate position, but I think that the convoy showed that there had been no real
00:37:09 leader in the political system. And I've given credit to Maxime Bernier for being the only
00:37:13 political figure in that election that was doing it. But when I say in the system, I'm talking
00:37:17 about the fact that no PPC member of parliament had been elected, and that includes Maxime Bernier.
00:37:22 and you know the problem is is that you had this groundswell that caused the convoy and then you
00:37:29 had the convoy itself which caused a lot of other people to look around and say oh yeah yeah these
00:37:34 guys these guys are right and what's fascinating there is that it was only then that the conservatives
00:37:39 started to take on this issue is that old you know line about you know i need to know where my people
00:37:44 are going so i can lead them and that was really where the conservatives were on this so i think
00:37:49 you're right to point out that they only took that position when other people, including you,
00:37:54 had laid that groundwork and showed that, hey, there is actually a movement here.
00:37:59 Yeah. And I, you know, a lot of frustration people had, and this is a comment,
00:38:04 and I'm going to be fair to Pierre Polyev. You know, when he does things I don't like,
00:38:08 I call it out, but I have to be fair to him. A lot of people attack him because they say,
00:38:13 where were you during the, the mandates, the lockdowns and all that stuff.
00:38:17 But the thing is, you know, people like him, he was not the leader of the
00:38:22 conservative party, he was the, the finance critic, and he did an absolutely
00:38:27 exceptional job at his portfolio, which was to criticize Trudeau in the finances.
00:38:32 Had he been maybe the critic for, you know, health Canada, or maybe one of the
00:38:38 other departments, then you could kind of say that, right?
00:38:41 So, so we had this sort of glimmer of hope that maybe when he came in, he was
00:38:46 going to be, um, you know, more, more of that fight that he has had, but he's
00:38:52 become more sort of, uh, fixated on sort of smaller issues, not necessarily going
00:39:00 back in time and looking at, you know, issues to me that are important, like,
00:39:05 you know, investigating what happened during the COVID lockdowns, investigate
00:39:09 several of those things, all related specifically to COVID-19, I would like to see more of that
00:39:16 stuff. So, you know, I think Canadians expect a lot from conservatives. You know, I think what we
00:39:25 need is somebody as intelligent as Pierre Polyev, because he's a very intelligent person, very
00:39:32 articulate, can get his point across much better than what I'm doing currently at the moment.
00:39:37 But at the same time, you know, we want somebody who's bold, somebody who is strong, somebody that can say, you can look at that, that person and say, yeah, that guy's got my back.
00:39:50 Like that guy is the guy that I'm going to go stand behind when it comes to something really, really difficult.
00:39:56 But I think that they've been overly cautious.
00:39:59 I don't think they've been bold enough until recently.
00:40:02 I think people like Larry Brock, Larry Brock, without a doubt, is my favorite conservative
00:40:07 member of parliament because he's tough, he's bold, he's very decisive, he's aggressive
00:40:13 in his pursuits.
00:40:15 That is what I would imagine to embody conservative politicians right now in this time.
00:40:22 But we're seeing a little bit, you know, I think it's changing.
00:40:27 I'm seeing some signs of changing.
00:40:30 I just don't see that they came at the right time.
00:40:33 I think the Conservatives have been too conservative in moving forward with things that are important to average Canadians like myself.
00:40:42 No, and that's fair.
00:40:43 And again, you actually were incredibly good on that, considering I gave you zero notice until I asked the question that I was going to ask you about that.
00:40:50 But the issue I wanted to talk about leans on your experience as a veteran in the Canadian Armed Forces.
00:40:57 We've had, I mean, just a couple of more reports. This is not a new problem by any stretch of
00:41:02 veterans relying on food banks. And listen, I mean, there is a big place in my heart for men
00:41:09 and women who serve and, you know, notwithstanding issues that I've talked about on the show with,
00:41:13 you know, morale in the Canadian Armed Forces and lowering standards and all of that. People
00:41:17 that do that, for whatever reason, deserve commendation, but they're not even getting
00:41:22 the bare minimum, which is the ability to buy food. Why is this problem happening, first off?
00:41:28 Well, I would definitely say it's the same experience right across Canada. It is this
00:41:34 inflationary pressure that has been brought on by, you know, the government. I mean, the government
00:41:41 controls monetary and fiscal policy, and the things that we've seen over the last eight years
00:41:46 are horrendous now this like you said is not a new problem i can remember back as far as 1999
00:41:53 so i had joined the regular force military in september of 1998 and mclean's magazine put out
00:42:01 this very scathing review on the the uh the the state of the canadian military they did a story
00:42:08 about a young uh second lieutenant he was going through to become a pilot but he was working in
00:42:14 the mall in Saskatchewan as a part-time security guard because he was trying to feed his family.
00:42:21 You know, there's somebody who wants to serve, but they can't afford to serve. Now, even in my own
00:42:27 case, you know, there was a time I was just desperate. I wanted to join the regular force
00:42:32 military and I was thinking seriously about joining as an enlisted non-commissioned member.
00:42:38 But I looked at it, I'm like, I can't afford to do that because of all the student loans that I
00:42:42 I have, and this is going back into the late nineties and I was already an
00:42:47 enlisted person in the reserves at the time, you know, but that McLean's
00:42:52 article that came out saw sweeping change across the, the, the, the pay
00:42:57 in the compensation for the Canadian military.
00:42:59 You know, my rank level at the time that that article came out was also
00:43:02 second Lieutenant and that, that April, I saw my pay go up just over 14%.
00:43:10 But, you know, many of the other ranks had much smaller pay increases.
00:43:15 So, you know, the, the attempt or the justification at the time was to say,
00:43:19 oh, we want to make it sort of on an even playing field as firefighters
00:43:23 and maybe police officers. 0.79
00:43:25 But I don't think that the Canadian forces has ever been able to meet
00:43:29 that, that standard.
00:43:31 And there's one big, big reason why that, that happens.
00:43:35 And you know, that article you're talking about in New Brunswick, I lived
00:43:38 Oromocto. I lived in military housing in Oromocto in the late 1999 and up to 2001. I lived in
00:43:48 Petawawa. But there's something that does happen. Okay, so imagine you're a young soldier in New
00:43:57 Brunswick, okay, where the cost of living in New Brunswick at a certain time was much, much lower
00:44:02 than say Toronto. Well, I was posted to Toronto, uh, in 2008, I was posted to Toronto and it,
00:44:10 there's no military housing in a place like Toronto. Okay. So you have to live on the economy.
00:44:17 So the government came up with this scheme or the military where they were, they were paying
00:44:21 people something called PLD. It's your, it's a cost of living differential. And it was about
00:44:26 fifteen hundred dollars if you were posted to toronto on top of your pay but it was also taxed
00:44:32 right it goes on to your gross income so really what it comes down to is you're getting about
00:44:37 nine hundred dollars uh maybe eight hundred dollars to live in somewhere around the gta
00:44:43 okay years ago and it just and that would have to cover a housing differential and also food
00:44:49 you know cost correct yes absolutely it does that was an all-in oh wow yeah so so a lot of
00:44:55 people were reluctant to say hey i don't want to get posted to toronto from say petowall where the
00:45:00 cost of living is is pretty uh decent where i could live in military housing so when i lived in
00:45:06 gage town i was in military housing my rent on a military we call them pmqs uh private military
00:45:13 quarters was 400 a month plus utilities okay and that's controlled by uh cfha which is canadian
00:45:21 Forces Housing Authority or association, whatever it is, I don't know what the agency. So CFHA was
00:45:28 controlling that. But then the Treasury Board got involved eventually with CFHA and they said,
00:45:34 hey, these are government assets and according to Treasury Board rules, you need to now start
00:45:41 charging fair market value for that housing. Okay, so this puts another pressure on soldiers
00:45:49 and their families because now they have to pay fair market prices for those those homes in those
00:45:56 areas now it's very very difficult to do that when you know you go from a place like petawawa
00:46:03 where you're you're paying local prices on homes or or a mock to new brunswick where i was
00:46:08 now all of a sudden you're getting sent to calgary or you're getting sent to edmonton or you're
00:46:13 getting sent to large cities what about to quebec city where you're posted now you have to pay those
00:46:19 local like military housing is no longer a means for you to equalize your federal pay across the
00:46:27 country because the cost of living is very different from different military base to
00:46:33 different military base to different base so you're either going to move into very old and
00:46:40 not so great military housing and pay fair market value prices or you're just going to go buy a house
00:46:46 in the economy in the local area right and now if you purchase a house two three years later you
00:46:51 could be posted to another place and have to sell your house and get a new mortgage and do all that
00:46:57 so it's it's you know very difficult for canadian forces members to make these rapid changes every
00:47:05 three to four years if they're being posted somewhere because housing in canada affects
00:47:09 not just soldiers who don't have affordable military housing anymore they they have the
00:47:15 same fair market prices that everyone else has so it's difficult when your pay isn't increasing very
00:47:20 much yeah and you're right to point out that a lot of these are general issues i know there are a lot
00:47:26 of people who aren't in the military listening saying yeah i'm using a food bank i i'm having
00:47:29 these difficulties and absolutely i'm sympathetic to that soldiers are in a very different spot
00:47:34 though because the demands that are being placed on them because of the job i mean in the private
00:47:38 sector if you're getting moved around a lot oftentimes you're able to bargain for something
00:47:42 in that that's going to cover uh that expectation one of the other considerations as well if you've
00:47:48 got a spouse that spouse is being carted around the country as well which means they're less
00:47:54 likely to be able to build up their own career which will earn enough of an income to offset
00:47:59 this because they're getting relocated as well so uh you know very few military spouses are able to 0.99
00:48:04 do what they would have to or be able to do if their spouse were anything other than a soldier
00:48:10 And, and that's a very, very important point.
00:48:13 So if you were to go to a place like CFB Petawawa, which is, you know, uh, not too
00:48:18 far, I think it's about two hours, uh, Northwest of, of Ottawa, that is a very small community.
00:48:25 The next community over the biggest one is Pembroke, Ontario.
00:48:28 And that's where a lot of the spouses would go to try to find employment. 1.00
00:48:32 Okay.
00:48:33 But guess what?
00:48:34 The, which has 14,000 people in Pembroke, by the way, I just looked that up as you said
00:48:38 that.
00:48:39 Yeah. And you know what? Pembroke, great little town, but the issue in Pembroke is nobody in Pembroke changes jobs. The joke used to be you either retire or you die in the position you've got in Pembroke. Nobody, no employer wants to invest time hiring a military spouse, knowing that in, you know, two to four years, they're going to have to replace that person. And this is a real, very, a real phenomenon.
00:49:03 So the only people I knew that ever got hired, like spouses, were if they were lawyers and if they were teachers, because, you know, there's a teacher getting posted out with her military spouse, male or female, or a lawyer, and then a new one is coming into town.
00:49:21 So the jobs were very, very difficult in a place like Patawawa to get employment.
00:49:26 Now, if you're in Oromocto, New Brunswick, you've got to drive 20 kilometers and hope you can get a job in Fredericton.
00:49:32 If you're in Toronto, it's a little bit different because it's not a military town.
00:49:38 Edmonton, St. Hubert, I think, is the area that's around CFB Edmonton.
00:49:44 These are the different dynamics at play.
00:49:47 And you're right, it really does harm the career opportunities for a spouse.
00:49:53 I mean, look at the effect it would have on a pension for somebody who has to quit their job every two to four years.
00:49:59 and if you're an officer's wife it could be a lot shorter than that you know my average posting was
00:50:05 I did 12 cities in 24 years you know so you're you're really moving around quite a bit and it's
00:50:12 hard for spouses to earn a long-term pension you know that's another dynamic to this yeah no very
00:50:18 very well said Tom thank you so much as always for coming on always good to talk to you thanks Andrew
00:50:24 Thank you.
00:50:24 All right.
00:50:25 Tom Marazzo, author of the book, The People's Emergency Act.
00:50:28 And he rolled with the punches there, took on another topic, which I appreciate on the fly.
00:50:32 That does it for us for today.
00:50:34 We'll be back tomorrow with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:50:38 See you in, what are we at?
00:50:39 23 hours and 10 minutes by this point.
00:50:43 So we'll talk to you tomorrow.
00:50:44 Thank you.
00:50:45 God bless.
00:50:45 And good day to you all.
00:50:47 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:50:49 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:51:19 We'll be right back.
00:51:49 We'll be right back.