00:01:30.000Hello and welcome to you all. This is Canada's most irreverent talk show, The Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North on this Wednesday, August 2nd, 2023.
00:01:40.600Big news day in Canadian politics, although for a talk show, I'm going to just be perfectly candid here and say that if you are expecting me to dunk on Justin Trudeau or his family in any way, you have come to the wrong place.
00:01:58.460I have, like all of you, seen the news today that Justin Trudeau and his wife, Sophie Gregoire Trudeau, have officially announced their separation.
00:02:07.940They put out joint statements, concurrent statements on Instagram in which they didn't give too, too much detail,
00:02:16.240but ultimately said there that Justin and I, or Sophie and I, would like to share the fact that after many meaningful and difficult conversations,
00:02:24.700We have made the decision to separate.
00:02:27.200As always, we remain a close family with deep love and respect for each other
00:02:32.120and for everything we have built and will continue to build.
00:02:35.420For the well-being of our children, we ask that you respect our and their privacy.
00:02:51.740Sophie Gregoire Trudeau is going to move out of Rideau Cottage, and all of them are apparently going to be going on a big family vacation next week, which I don't know if it was connected to the separation or predated that, and I don't particularly care.
00:03:07.540And if you look on Twitter, you see both the best and the worst of human instincts there.
00:03:14.620Many people that are saying what I think most people would say if someone in their life were to come to them with this news,
00:03:20.300which is, I'm sorry, and I wish them well, and I know it's going to be difficult for your children.
00:03:24.540Their three children are 16, 14, and 9, I believe.
00:03:28.600And while I've never been through a divorce myself, and I've not been through having parents divorced,
00:03:35.020I know many people who have, and I know it's difficult for all involved, certainly for the children.
00:03:40.420And you see people that are setting aside their partisanship and saying,
00:03:43.760you know what, this sucks, I've been there, and I know how bad it is, and I wish everyone well.
00:03:49.060And on the flip side, you see people who understandably have their own frustration and anger with Justin Trudeau,
00:03:55.920who seem to delight in the tumult that is his family life.
00:03:59.940And let me be the first to say, I share many, if not most, of your criticisms of Justin Trudeau.
00:04:05.440And I, at the same time, do not wish harm on him or anyone in his family.
00:04:09.660My belief about Justin Trudeau is that the country would be better off without him as prime minister.
00:04:15.020I would never say nor feel that anyone would be better off without him as a father or husband,
00:07:57.760as I could understand it doing for many, many people
00:08:01.220after having to put up with that for a few years.
00:08:03.500But the one thing I would point out here is that there are a lot of people that I think feel a level of ownership over public figures' personal lives.
00:08:14.100And this is not just true of politics.
00:08:15.780This is true of people who are in the limelight in some other ways as well, you know, Hollywood celebrities and whatever.
00:08:22.760And I've always had a lot more of a sympathetic spot for some people, and I'm not going to name names because there are many of them,
00:08:30.140But some people that have decided they don't want to make their personal life at all part of the public discussion and people that have made that decision for themselves.
00:08:38.040But it's harder to do in politics because in politics, people expect a family unit.
00:08:43.340And that is something that politicians have an obligation to project.
00:08:47.920And I believe that in the cynicism of politics, it's very easy to understand how someone might try to keep an illusion alive for longer than they should.
00:08:57.720And that's a general comment, not one that's directed at anyone in particular.
00:09:02.060The one story I'll tell on this is that a member of parliament that I know, who's no longer a member of parliament, told me when she was first elected that all of the rookie MPs were in this room for some orientation of some sort.
00:09:17.360And one of the longer-serving MPs had told her, rather matter-of-factly, to look around,
00:09:23.780and he said, one-third of the spouses you see here will be out of the picture in the next few years.
00:09:31.480And she thought that was a very odd observation, and then she looked four years later,
00:09:35.440by the time the next election rolled around, and saw that, indeed,
00:09:38.500about one-third of those new members of parliaments were divorced or separated.
00:09:43.040it. And this was a Conservative MP, but the trend is true for Liberals and New Democrats as well.
00:09:49.480And I mentioned yesterday when I was talking about Chrystia Freeland and her flying back and
00:09:54.660forth from Ottawa to Toronto as often as she does. And I said, absolutely, I am fully on board with
00:09:59.340calling out the climate hypocrisy of someone who says we all need to, you know, fly less and then
00:10:04.140who decides to commute daily from Toronto to Ottawa or almost daily. And the comment that I
00:10:09.460made was that I'm not going to begrudge a member of parliament making a decision that lets them
00:10:14.340spend more time with their family and this is actually one of those issues where my principled
00:10:20.360pro-taxpayer stance is at odds with my belief in the institution of family because technically
00:10:27.000members of parliament are able to fly their spouses back and forth from Ottawa to their
00:10:31.540riding and as a taxpayer I'd say well you know they make enough money they should pay for those
00:10:34.840flights themselves. But I also believe that if that helps keep families together, that might be
00:10:40.360a useful investment in the long run. And I would say to conservatives, particularly social
00:10:45.960conservatives, to keep your eye on the prize here, if we believe that the family is the foundational
00:10:50.660building block of our society, then supporting strong families at an individual level should
00:10:57.120always be the goal. Above partisanship, above politics, family should be something that we
00:11:02.340celebrate, and it's very difficult to keep that together for people in this day and age with all
00:11:07.300of the challenges of the modern world, and politics adds many more of those. So yes, I did dip my toe
00:11:14.820into the waters of moralism on today's show, but I also feel it's a bit of an important message,
00:11:20.780and to try to just take that step back and realize that this is not a victory for anyone, nor should
00:11:26.580the dissolution of a marriage be seen as such unless we're talking about one of those horrific
00:11:31.920cases that involves abuse in which case yes you know someone is better off without them but that's
00:11:36.640not at all a comment about this situation this is just a point in which we should probably set the
00:11:42.500politics aside because there are a great many real issues to deal with ones that continue to be a
00:11:47.240problem for Canadians one of which is housing and I must say this has always been somewhat of an
00:11:54.120issue on the back burner for people because for the longest time it seemed to not rise to the
00:11:59.680level of crisis but over the last decade and I think certainly the last few years we've seen
00:12:04.420the price of a house get more and more out of reach for people in which now this headline in
00:12:10.220McLean seems entirely uncontroversial to point out the end of home ownership for generations
00:12:16.860middle-class Canadians have been sold on the promise of home ownership that promise was always
00:12:22.100flawed today it's simply broken that was from june we've seen a litany of news stories from
00:12:29.300all over the map about how canadians are unable to afford new houses this is true of young families
00:12:34.660of people that have been born in canada and it's true of the hundreds of thousands of people
00:12:39.620immigrating to canada who land here and all of a sudden find that they cannot afford to live here
00:12:45.300they can't even afford to put a roof over their head let alone buying any of the other costs and
00:12:50.500It's rather interesting that we have Justin Trudeau's immigration minister, Sean Fraser,
00:12:54.660now becoming the housing minister, tasked with solving a problem that some people say
00:13:00.120immigration has contributed to, maybe not as the primary driver, but certainly as a
00:28:57.060And if I can humbly direct you in some meaningful place, I would say that is probably the case for you as well.
00:29:05.000That it may be politically convenient to score some points off of him, but I hope we don't actually see partisanship dwindle and decline into that.