Juno News - February 10, 2022


Trudeau catastrophically underestimated the truckers (ft. Rupa Subramanya)


Episode Stats

Length

42 minutes

Words per Minute

187.6471

Word Count

7,973

Sentence Count

480

Misogynist Sentences

4

Hate Speech Sentences

3


Summary

Who are the Freedom Truckers and what exactly do they want? Today, I talk to one of the few legacy media journalists who has bothered to go to the protests, to talk to the truckers, and to seek to answer these important questions.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 Who are the truckers and what exactly do they want?
00:00:03.020 Today, I talked to one of the very few legacy media journalists who has bothered to go to
00:00:07.320 the protests, to talk to the truckers, and to seek to answer these very important questions.
00:00:11.940 I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:00:17.900 Hi everyone, thank you so much for tuning into the podcast.
00:00:20.600 So we continue to look at the Freedom Convoy in Ottawa, continue to try to look closely
00:00:25.900 at it and answer some of the questions that are being neglected and failed to be asked
00:00:30.440 by the legacy media.
00:00:31.660 Yesterday on the show, we tried to tackle the question of why the legacy media tried to smear
00:00:36.480 this convoy.
00:00:37.060 Why were they so quick to assume the very worst about the protesters?
00:00:40.880 And why did they fail to cover the protests in good faith?
00:00:43.840 I was joined by Jonathan Kay, who is the editor of Great Interview.
00:00:47.400 I encourage you to go check that out.
00:00:49.020 Today, I want to ask another meaningful question that is being neglected and failed to be questioned
00:00:54.620 or answered by the legacy media, and that is finding out who these truckers are.
00:00:59.000 Who are they as individuals?
00:01:00.780 What has motivated them to get to this point?
00:01:03.020 Why are they at this breaking point?
00:01:04.560 And why are they doing what they're doing?
00:01:06.680 Which is something that's frankly out of character for people who are used to just keeping their
00:01:11.480 head down, working hard, doing what they have to do to survive.
00:01:15.120 They're taking an extraordinary length.
00:01:16.780 They're getting involved in the political and democratic process in a way that they probably
00:01:20.240 haven't ever before in their life.
00:01:21.620 So who are these truckers and what exactly do they want?
00:01:25.700 What is it that they're trying to accomplish by being on Parliament Hill and being in the
00:01:30.180 midst of this standstill?
00:01:31.660 So the media were very quick to jump onto Justin Trudeau's petty, divisive, partisan attacks
00:01:37.720 about the truckers.
00:01:38.480 They assumed that those were true.
00:01:39.660 They assumed that these truckers were dangerous.
00:01:41.580 They were extremists.
00:01:42.460 They were radical.
00:01:43.060 They were racist.
00:01:43.920 They were part of the far right.
00:01:45.260 Well, my guest today is challenging all of those very assumptions.
00:01:48.960 And in a recent piece that she wrote, a beautifully written and beautiful photographs that she
00:01:53.840 wrote for Barry Weiss's Substack, she refutes some of these claims and tries to understand
00:01:59.000 more about these truckers, paints a totally different picture of them.
00:02:02.320 And so I am very pleased today to be joined.
00:02:04.980 My guest today is Rupa Subramania.
00:02:07.840 She is a freelance journalist.
00:02:10.000 She's a columnist over at the National Post.
00:02:12.140 She used to write for the Wall Street Journal, Foreign Policy Magazine.
00:02:16.120 And she is a distinguished fellow at the Asia-Pacific Foundation of Canada.
00:02:20.800 Rupa lives in Ottawa.
00:02:22.200 And like I said, she was one of the few journalists who bothered to go in and take a closer look
00:02:26.900 at these truckers.
00:02:27.820 So Rupa, thank you so much for joining the podcast.
00:02:29.680 It's great to have you.
00:02:30.980 Thanks for having me, Candice.
00:02:32.280 It's great to be here.
00:02:33.820 So you live in Ottawa and you have been covering these protests very closely.
00:02:37.840 So I want to ask you, how did it feel for you to go into the crowd?
00:02:42.480 And what is your impression of these truckers?
00:02:44.720 Well, when I first got there on the first Saturday of the protests, I went with it,
00:02:52.820 keeping an open mind.
00:02:53.860 I'd read all of the news stories about some of the more unpleasant aspects of the convoy
00:03:01.500 that, you know, there are some people attached to the movement who have white supremacist views
00:03:09.060 and, you know, and they wanted to topple the government.
00:03:14.360 And, you know, and so I'd read all of these stories.
00:03:16.460 I went with it.
00:03:17.720 Just, you know, I wanted to check it out for myself as a resident of the city.
00:03:21.960 I wasn't going there as a journalist or as a columnist.
00:03:27.260 You know, I just really wanted to see what was going on and make up my own mind.
00:03:31.980 So my first impressions were that it was like a carnival-like atmosphere.
00:03:37.300 I have never seen anything like this in Ottawa.
00:03:40.820 It was, you know, there were people dancing.
00:03:44.280 Of course, you had the sound of honking trucks, the trucks honking.
00:03:50.000 And, but, you know, it was a carnival-like atmosphere.
00:03:54.420 My first impression was that this looks a bit like Canada Day.
00:03:59.220 You know, I couldn't believe just how many people had shown up, you know,
00:04:03.320 on an extremely cold day.
00:04:05.400 We had multiple extreme cold warnings from Environment Canada,
00:04:11.480 frostbite within minutes of exposure.
00:04:14.700 And I felt it.
00:04:15.560 I have a fairly good jacket.
00:04:16.780 And I, you know, and I, and I, and I'm, you know, very active outdoors in the winter.
00:04:21.780 But that day was bitterly cold.
00:04:23.720 And so that, that was an important part of, you know, of, of, you know,
00:04:28.680 what I'd observed that there was commitment.
00:04:31.920 You know, these were, these were people not,
00:04:34.340 these people were not showing up because the weather was good.
00:04:37.120 The weather was nice.
00:04:38.140 It was warm.
00:04:39.000 And, you know, and, and, and, and, and, but it was, it was cold.
00:04:43.540 And, and you had, and I think Ottawa police estimated that about eight to 10,000
00:04:49.620 people showed up on that first day.
00:04:52.140 And that's extraordinary for, for, for this time of year.
00:04:56.000 And that too, in such extreme weather conditions.
00:04:59.880 And, and I, as I made my way through the crowd,
00:05:03.060 I noticed that there was a fair bit of diversity.
00:05:07.180 Of course, the overwhelming demographic characteristic of this protest is white,
00:05:16.860 but we're overwhelmingly white in this country.
00:05:19.240 There's nothing wrong with that.
00:05:20.940 But there's, there was, I did notice C Canadians.
00:05:25.360 I noticed Chinese Canadians.
00:05:27.440 I noticed black Canadians.
00:05:28.920 I noticed Indo-Canadians I, I noticed first nations and, and, and people from Quebec,
00:05:38.480 people from Alberta, people from Manitoba.
00:05:42.040 These are people who've driven, you know, long distances to get here to make their voices heard.
00:05:49.800 And so I was, so the diversity of it was the other aspect of it.
00:05:53.980 Um, what was really striking was the friendliness of it all.
00:05:59.140 Uh, you cannot walk through those streets without someone making an,
00:06:03.260 making eye contact with you and smiling, uh, or just random people just coming up to you
00:06:08.580 and giving you a hug.
00:06:09.900 Um, there was a woman who had a, uh, hug me placard on her back.
00:06:14.500 I, I, and, and, and, and there was a spontaneous, um, uh, hugging of people.
00:06:19.880 And, uh, and, you know, and it, it was, it was electric.
00:06:23.760 The atmosphere was electric.
00:06:25.040 There was music, there were block parties, um, and, uh, there were DJs spinning tunes.
00:06:31.040 There were people dancing.
00:06:32.880 I, I, I, I, it was, it almost felt like, you know, there was this great unleashing of all
00:06:39.240 of the stress and worries that people had been carrying for the last two years or so.
00:06:43.860 Um, especially those who, uh, have felt ostracized, uh, because of their, uh, uh,
00:06:52.700 vax status or the fact that they're unvaccinated.
00:06:55.480 Um, uh, I, I spoke to people who are vaccinated, uh, but showed up, uh, in solidarity, uh, uh,
00:07:03.820 uh, with, with those who are unvaccinated because they oppose the mandates.
00:07:07.560 They find them divisive.
00:07:08.900 They find them, find it discriminating.
00:07:10.980 I was really struck on the first day at seeing many people carrying a copy of the
00:07:15.980 Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
00:07:17.240 That was very, very, so for me, I was, I was thinking, well, why, why would insurrectionists
00:07:22.700 be carrying the Charter of Rights and Freedoms?
00:07:25.080 You know, what, what, what is up with that?
00:07:27.980 Uh, but I saw a lot of people doing that.
00:07:30.100 And, uh, and I saw messages of hope, peace, unity.
00:07:34.320 Um, I did not see the swastika flags or the Confederate flags.
00:07:38.600 I looked for them.
00:07:39.820 Uh, I'm not, I'm not denying that they were there.
00:07:42.580 Uh, you know, I'm not denying that they did that.
00:07:45.320 They showed up at the protest.
00:07:46.580 I just didn't see, see it myself.
00:07:49.080 Uh, but that quickly disappeared.
00:07:52.080 Uh, look, they've been around since they've been around for 10 days.
00:07:56.080 Um, and apart for those first couple of days where these flags were spotted across the city,
00:08:01.820 was that one truck that kept driving around with a Confederate flag.
00:08:05.700 I, I'm sure you, you've seen that image as well.
00:08:08.200 And there was this other image of someone carrying a swastika flag.
00:08:11.780 Um, those, those images, those people haven't shown up.
00:08:15.040 I, I, I haven't seen anything like that.
00:08:17.300 In fact, what's happened is the movement has gotten really, um, big.
00:08:22.960 It, it, it almost, I hate, you know, I, you know, it almost sounds like it's inclusive.
00:08:27.920 You know, it's, it's inclusive of so many, uh, different types of people it's inviting,
00:08:33.180 uh, their, their, their soup kitchens have, uh, uh, popped up all over, uh, uh, downtown
00:08:39.660 Ottawa.
00:08:40.060 Um, you can, I, I, you know, I just walk, walk around, I can grab a cookie, I can get a
00:08:45.940 burger, I can get a hot dog.
00:08:47.440 It's all free.
00:08:48.580 Um, uh, you know, I see them feeding a lot of homeless people, uh, around here.
00:08:53.780 Um, the, the downtown core is, um, you know, has several homes.
00:08:57.920 Homeless shelters, um, and, uh, some of them have been doing really badly during the pandemic.
00:09:03.600 Um, and, uh, um, and, and so, you know, it was nice to see, um, them being fed and being
00:09:09.420 taken care of, uh, they've joined in, in the protest as well.
00:09:13.420 I've seen them dancing.
00:09:14.620 I've, I've seen them happy, uh, which is extraordinary.
00:09:17.920 Uh, there, there was something nice about that.
00:09:20.620 Uh, you know, we just, uh, and I, and I, you know, I, I, I also say this, you know, as
00:09:26.460 someone who lives in the city, I often just don't even pay attention to them.
00:09:29.960 I just walk by them, but, but, but, you know, the last few days I've, I've, I've stopped
00:09:35.640 to see the expressions on their faces and they seem happy.
00:09:39.220 They're, they're, you know, they're being, you know, people are speaking to them.
00:09:43.620 People are inviting them to their, um, uh, to these block parties.
00:09:47.140 It's, it's all very, uh, inclusive and there's a party like atmosphere every day.
00:09:51.900 Wow.
00:09:52.900 So just to sort of unpack what you just said, because so much of the things that you said
00:09:57.420 in your own experiences, your own sort of eyewitness understanding of the convoys is
00:10:01.700 in such stark contrast to the legacy media narrative and the things that Justin Trudeau
00:10:07.140 says, you know, we hear from legacy media that these people are stealing from the homeless.
00:10:10.640 Um, you're describing that they're helping care for the homeless.
00:10:13.140 Um, you know, the, the media tried to characterize the whole group, um, by a few French people
00:10:18.060 who showed up for one, for one day and didn't come back.
00:10:20.300 Um, so, so it's interesting.
00:10:21.900 I, I want to pick up on some of the things that you wrote about in your piece, because
00:10:25.720 I, I just thought it was so, so powerful.
00:10:27.380 So, so, so first of all, you, you spoke to over 100 protesters gathered in the nation's
00:10:34.220 capital and you, you write that what's happening is far bigger than the vaccine mandates.
00:10:39.300 And one of the themes that I noticed in your piece Rupa is that you
00:10:43.020 you talk about how these people feel invisible, that they feel ignored, that they feel that
00:10:46.780 the elites don't understand them.
00:10:49.280 And I was wondering if you could, um, expand on that one, one of the lines you wrote, um,
00:10:54.260 the elites, the people who have zoomed their way through the pandemic, it's kind of funny
00:10:57.260 because you and I are on zoom right now.
00:10:58.680 And so I think we fit into that later category.
00:11:01.140 Um, however, I think unlike sort of the elites that they're talking about, um, I think that you
00:11:06.900 and I try to have a better understanding of what it's like for other people who haven't been
00:11:10.340 able to have luxury of working from home easily.
00:11:12.500 Like some people have had to work through the pandemic.
00:11:14.900 And so you write the elites had better start paying attention to the fentanyl overdoses,
00:11:18.800 the suicides, the crime, the despair or else.
00:11:21.980 So, so, so, so what else is the, is, is the protest about aside from just wanting to, and
00:11:26.860 the mandates wanting to have their freedom back and, and, and you sort of write the elites
00:11:31.060 had better start paying attention or else.
00:11:32.580 So I wonder, um, if you could expand on that a little bit.
00:11:35.100 Um, well, um, it's, it is, it is principally about opposing the mandates, uh, uh, you speak
00:11:41.400 to anyone here, the truckers, the protestors, they just want the mandates gone.
00:11:45.280 They want to be left alone.
00:11:46.800 They want their, uh, medical status to be private.
00:11:50.280 Um, uh, it, uh, uh, uh, you know, they, they, they see that and, you know, infringement of
00:11:56.160 their privacy, uh, they, uh, they see, uh, this is, uh, they, they, they, they, um, they
00:12:02.500 want to stand up for their body, bodily autonomy.
00:12:05.280 Um, and, uh, what, what was striking about my car is what was striking about the
00:12:10.900 conversations I had with some of these people is that they're not anti-vaxxers, not all
00:12:15.220 of them, uh, many of them have actually taken other vaccines.
00:12:18.480 They've taken, they take the flu shot.
00:12:19.940 They take, uh, tetanus shots.
00:12:21.340 They take travel related vaccines.
00:12:24.340 Um, but they just don't want to take this, this particular vaccine, because for one thing,
00:12:30.160 they, uh, feel that it hasn't been out for too long.
00:12:33.580 Um, number two, they feel that, um, it's, um, the, the messaging around it has been very,
00:12:40.240 uh, has been very confusing.
00:12:42.580 Um, it's, uh, been caught up in politics.
00:12:45.460 The, the rhetoric around us, around it is divisive.
00:12:48.700 Um, and they just feel uncomfortable, uh, being part of that.
00:12:53.280 Um, and, um, and, and then, so, um, you know, it's, it's just, um, um, sorry.
00:13:00.160 I'm just losing my train of thought.
00:13:01.780 So, uh, but, uh, just asking about, you know, like, what, like what, what is it?
00:13:07.480 Yeah.
00:13:07.600 What do they, yeah.
00:13:08.460 Yeah.
00:13:08.720 So they, principally they want the mandates to be dropped.
00:13:11.440 That's what they want principally, but it is, there is something bigger going on.
00:13:15.120 They see that the last few years they have been ignored, that they feel like they're an underclass.
00:13:21.400 They feel that, um, government overreach has reached, uh, has, is, is, um, you know, has been extraordinary over the years.
00:13:32.360 Um, they, you know, they, they find that, uh, they're, you know, increasingly, they increasingly feel like they're a prisoner in their own country.
00:13:41.300 They can't say this is a, the, a culture of political correctness.
00:13:44.920 Um, they get, uh, they're afraid of being doxxed on social media.
00:13:48.400 Several of the people, um, uh, that I spoke to were uncomfortable sharing their last names, for example.
00:13:54.200 And that was very interesting.
00:13:56.000 Um, and I asked them, you know, why, um, you know, why are you, what are you so afraid of here?
00:14:01.380 You're here standing up to the government, which is right there.
00:14:04.760 Why won't you give me your last name?
00:14:06.600 And they genuinely fear, uh, uh, government reprisal.
00:14:10.440 They genuinely fear, um, um, uh, um, you know, people taking their names, reporting them to their employers, getting them fired.
00:14:19.320 Uh, and some of that has been happening over the last few days.
00:14:22.660 Um, and so this genuine concern about, um, you know, uh, a collusion, what they see as a collusion between government, big pharma, big tech, uh, and they're all coming together
00:14:36.300 to, to, uh, you know, to, to, uh, to, uh, uh, gang, uh, they're coming together and ganging up on them, essentially.
00:14:43.720 Um, and so freedom, that's, that's what they're here for.
00:14:48.940 That's, that's what you hear.
00:14:50.420 That's what you hear.
00:14:51.560 Yes.
00:14:51.760 It's, uh, principally about, uh, posing the mandates and, and, and ending all restrictions, ending the mask mandates, um, uh, you know, and no more lockdowns, no more restrictions.
00:15:02.180 Uh, but it's about freedom and that's, uh, that's how I would, uh, distill it down to, because that's what you keep hearing, uh, constantly throughout, um, you know, day in, day in and day out, uh, the flags, it's all about freedom.
00:15:18.900 Uh, we're here for our freedom.
00:15:20.540 We're here for our children's future.
00:15:22.200 Uh, we want our children's future, uh, to, to, to be, uh, you know, to be, you know, to, to, to not have these, to not have this divisiveness.
00:15:31.240 They're here for unity, which is another interesting theme, um, of the, um, of the protests.
00:15:37.480 Um, you know, they, they're tired of the divisiveness.
00:15:40.500 They feel that there's, um, there's been a ratcheting up of that, the rhetoric from our politicians, um, uh, has been, uh, you know, as they, they, they, they, has gone up and it's created, uh, divisions in the country and they want to see an end to that.
00:15:56.820 Um, and, uh, yeah, so that's, that's, that's pretty much, you know, that's, that's, that's how I would, you know, I, I would say that it's bigger than the mandates, but it's principally about freedom.
00:16:07.600 It's interesting. I mean, I mean, they're not the only ones who think that the, uh, the, the, the vaccine policies has become divisive.
00:16:14.980 I mean, uh, two members of Justin Trudeau's own liberal caucus have come out and said the exact same thing in recent days.
00:16:21.280 Um, and, and I'm not surprised also that they fear that they don't want to give their name because they fear repercussions because you have journalists online saying, let's report the license plate numbers.
00:16:31.480 Let's call the insurance companies. Let's make sure that these people lose their jobs and lose their livelihood.
00:16:35.700 So I think that their fear is, is justified, uh, given what is happening in, in this situation.
00:16:41.160 I want to pull one other quote that you, uh, wrote Rupa because it's so interesting.
00:16:45.400 You wrote that if Trudeau sauntered down to the mess of the rigs on Wellington street, if he talked to these people for a few minutes, he would understand it will not stop.
00:16:54.060 What's happening in Canada right now is bigger than the mandate.
00:16:56.240 So what did you mean by it will not stop?
00:16:58.200 I mean, you're, you're in Ottawa right now.
00:16:59.440 We're kind of at an impasse, a standstill.
00:17:01.140 Um, it seems like the police are really cracking down and Trudeau really wants these guys out right now, but, but we, we get the feeling, I get the feeling that this is so much broader than just even the folks in Ottawa, right?
00:17:13.060 We saw the ambassador bridge in Windsor and Detroit completely shut down.
00:17:17.340 Uh, we see another convoy out in Alberta on the Coots border with Manitoba that are doing the exact same thing, uh, over the weekend, last weekend, we saw huge rallies all over the country, Quebec city, Victoria, Calgary, Winnipeg, Toronto.
00:17:30.660 I mean, I get the feeling that this isn't ending and it's not going anywhere, but, um, I'm interested in what you think cause you wrote, it will not stop.
00:17:37.480 So what did you mean by that?
00:17:38.440 It will not stop until the mandates are dropped.
00:17:41.320 That is what everybody has been saying, uh, that, uh, this is, um, uh, this is where they draw a line in the sand, uh, for them, um, this, this divisiveness has to stop the, they see vaccine mandates as discriminating.
00:17:55.540 Um, they, uh, they, uh, they, this, they see the vaccine passport system as, um, as a tool of, uh, tool to ostracize them, uh, as publicly shaming them, you know, what is, what, uh, what is missing from the reportage, unfortunately, are, are the stories of these people.
00:18:14.020 They're real people.
00:18:14.920 They've been hurting, um, they've been bottling up these frustrations, the anger for the last two years, um, and more so in the last few months since we've had the vaccines and the vaccine passport
00:18:25.480 system, um, came into being, um, they, um, they, they, they, they, they've had an awakening.
00:18:33.220 That's how I would describe it.
00:18:34.500 They've had an awakening.
00:18:35.800 Many of these people didn't really care for politics.
00:18:39.100 They didn't really have any time for it.
00:18:41.120 They're too busy, um, you know, driving their trucks.
00:18:44.620 They're busy at their jobs.
00:18:46.040 They're, uh, frontline workers like grocery store workers.
00:18:49.340 They're nurses there.
00:18:51.120 I've even met some civil servants who've been, um, suspended, uh, without, uh, with, without pay, I think, or with pay.
00:18:58.080 I'm, I'm not sure what, what, uh, what that, what that is exactly.
00:19:01.560 I think it's without pay if you're unvaccinated.
00:19:03.680 Yeah.
00:19:03.900 Okay.
00:19:04.400 Yeah.
00:19:05.040 And, uh, they're, they're, uh, they're hurting, um, and, uh, and it's, they're hurting and, and while they're hurting, we're heaping on these, uh, this abusive, um, uh, rhetoric on them by calling them racist,
00:19:21.100 this fringe unacceptable views, uh, what is so annex unacceptable about someone who just wants to dine at a restaurant where she works, uh, someone who, who was, uh, their lives have come to a standstill, you know, they, they, they, they, they were avid travelers at one point, but they can't, they feel like they're a prisoner in their own country because they can't get on a plane, um, uh, and go see their families, uh, in, uh, Greece or Italy or in India.
00:19:51.080 Uh, um, um, some of them haven't seen their families in three years, and that, that is likely going to continue, um, uh, you know, as long as the vaccine, uh, mandate is in place.
00:20:02.080 Um, and so they've had some kind, there's been an awakening.
00:20:06.260 That's how I would describe it, uh, of their, of, of their rights, of, you know, what, of, of their freedom, uh, how important this is to them.
00:20:15.360 Um, uh, and, uh, and that, uh, and that they're going to fight for it no matter what, um, and, uh, but they all, I should say, I've, I've, they, they're all peaceful.
00:20:25.360 They'll, they'll follow all of the processes in place, uh, they're not here, uh, to overthrow the Trudeau government.
00:20:32.360 Um, uh, they're not, uh, uh, that is not their objective.
00:20:36.360 They, they just want the truckers and the protesters, uh, I really just want the mandates to, to go.
00:20:42.360 And then they say, we'll leave, we'll leave.
00:20:44.360 And we'll, we just want to get back to work.
00:20:46.360 Keep in mind that many of these people, um, uh, some of the truckers are actually still working.
00:20:52.360 Um, they're, they're here on vacation time.
00:20:55.360 Um, uh, some people have taken time out from their work.
00:20:59.360 Uh, and, and, and, and so this is, or from their families even.
00:21:03.360 Uh, and, and so they, they would like to go back to their lives.
00:21:07.360 It's not, it's not, not exactly a vacation here.
00:21:10.360 If you're sitting in your truck.
00:21:12.360 Um, I don't know if you've been inside one of these big rigs, uh, but I, and I did there, they're very difficult to get into.
00:21:18.360 Some of them come equipped with the, uh, with, um, with a bunk bed.
00:21:23.360 Um, it's a tiny little space, but imagine spending 10 days, um, in that, uh, day in and day out.
00:21:29.360 You're just sitting in your truck doing nothing.
00:21:32.360 Um, the truckers will say, look, you know, we're used to this, you know, this is what we do for a living.
00:21:37.360 We live in our trucks, essentially.
00:21:39.360 Sometimes our families come with us, but it is quite extraordinary.
00:21:42.360 They're not moving anywhere.
00:21:43.360 They're just stuck in the same spot.
00:21:45.360 Um, and, uh, so, you know, that's, that's, you know, I think that's what they're, they're standing up for freedom.
00:21:51.360 They're their freedom.
00:21:52.360 And they're sitting, they also say that there's, I'm standing up for your freedom.
00:21:55.360 You know, it's not just about me.
00:21:57.360 I'm fighting for all of us.
00:21:59.360 Um, and, uh, and, and, and, you know, and I, and I'm, I'm not going to stop till, uh, till we're heard.
00:22:06.360 And what is extraordinary about this so far is that, uh, Prime Minister Trudeau, um, refuses to meet them.
00:22:12.360 The organizers, um,
00:22:14.360 Um, you know, even yesterday when I, when I, when I attended, uh, their, uh, the, the presser, um, uh, you know, are still open to dialogue.
00:22:24.360 Um, but they haven't, uh, they, they haven't been, uh, they haven't even been acknowledged, uh, uh, by the, uh, by the government.
00:22:34.360 Um, you know, they, they had no one's reached out to them.
00:22:37.360 And, and, and so, um, uh, you know, so I, I think, you know, this is, this is, this is not a good situation in my view.
00:22:44.360 Um, I'm, I'm, I'm all for dialogue.
00:22:46.360 I think, I think the government needs to meet them.
00:22:48.360 I think that should have happened last week.
00:22:50.360 Uh, at least hear what they have to say.
00:22:52.360 Um, my, the, the impression I got on the first day when I came home and I spent all day, um, at the protest and I came home in the evening and I came home and, uh, and I, and I, and I told my partner.
00:23:05.360 Um, you know, this, uh, they've, they've really misjudged this moment.
00:23:10.360 There's something bigger going on here.
00:23:12.360 Um, our political class is, uh, you know, are completely disconnected from what is happening here.
00:23:18.360 Uh, and this is going to backfire and this is going to have political repercussions.
00:23:22.360 It's going to change the political landscape, whether anyone likes it or not.
00:23:26.360 Um, I tweeted this and, uh, several mainstream media journalists pounced on me and said, ah, this is just a fringe.
00:23:34.360 A group of people.
00:23:36.360 It's like a PPC gathering.
00:23:38.360 Um, and, uh, you know, but it just got bigger.
00:23:42.360 Uh, and, uh, and, and, and, and it just got bigger.
00:23:45.360 It got more diverse.
00:23:47.360 Um, and, and, and, and, and, and here we are.
00:23:50.360 And within a couple of days of the protest, uh, Erin O'Toole had to resign.
00:23:54.360 Um, and, uh, and now we have a leadership race.
00:23:58.360 So it, it, it, it, and, and, and, and it's, and it's, and it's, um, and it's happening.
00:24:03.360 You, you've had already two liberal, uh, MPs from Quebec who've, uh, who've spoken out against the mandates and the divisive rhetoric.
00:24:12.360 And I think, I think it's just gonna, uh, keep getting bigger in my opinion.
00:24:16.360 I think you're right.
00:24:17.360 I think that, that anyone who's sort of dismissed this as just another sort of PPC rally.
00:24:22.360 I mean, we've been having, uh, freedom rallies throughout the entire, uh, throughout the entire pandemic.
00:24:27.360 We've seen them in Toronto.
00:24:28.360 We've seen, we saw lots and lots of rallies during the federal election, but what was happening during this convoy just felt different right from the beginning.
00:24:37.360 When you saw Canadians go out on overpasses and you would just see those images of overpass after overpass after overpass.
00:24:43.360 I think that inspired the truckers as well.
00:24:45.360 And they started to realize that, you know, when, when the kids were handing out cookies with handwritten notes and you, you had all the kids calling in and thanking the truckers.
00:24:52.360 Like, I mean, the story went around the world and it, I think it inspired people all over the world to say, look, here you have mild mannered law abiding Canadians standing up and saying enough is enough.
00:25:05.360 When, when, when the Canadians are the ones that are, you know, willing to go to these extreme lengths, um, you, you can tell that they're at their breaking point.
00:25:14.360 And I think that public opinion has sort of shift.
00:25:17.360 I mean, I can point to half a dozen public policy changes that have happened just since this convoy.
00:25:22.360 I mean, you mentioned that we had, uh, uh, the leader of the conservative party replaced.
00:25:27.360 That is a direct result of the convoy, um, and, and his inability to address it in a meaningful way and respect the truckers enough to meet with them.
00:25:34.360 Uh, we had two liberals come out against their own prime minister.
00:25:38.360 I don't think that's happened Rupa since Justin Trudeau was elected, um, aside from the members that he ejected.
00:25:43.360 Um, Jody Wilson Rabel and Phil, uh, Jane Philpott, but, but sitting members of caucus from Quebec, those are his allies, um, speaking out against him.
00:25:51.360 Alberta dropped their vaccine mandate program.
00:25:54.360 Saskatchewan dropped their vaccine mandate program.
00:25:56.360 Manitoba announced that they are, um, loosening restrictions.
00:25:59.360 Restrictions will be eased in Prince Edward Island starting on February 19th.
00:26:04.360 Uh, Quebec planned to lift its pandemic restrictions in mid March.
00:26:08.360 They also eliminated, um, the plan that they had to have an additional tax system.
00:26:12.360 They had to have an additional tax levy on, um, people who were unvaccinated.
00:26:16.360 So we're starting to see this, this tie, uh, public opinion change.
00:26:20.360 There's been a couple of major studies that have come out.
00:26:22.360 One from Johns Hopkins showing the lockdowns didn't really work.
00:26:25.360 Uh, we've also seen a lot of public opinion polling.
00:26:28.360 There was a laser poll that found that 44% of Canadians sympathize with the frustrations of the convoy.
00:26:35.360 We also saw an abacus poll that found really, really remarkably, the overwhelming majority of Canadians think that, uh, Justin Trudeau has handled this situation either poorly or very poorly.
00:26:45.360 Um, and interestingly, I don't know if you saw this, but, uh, Joe Biden's press secretary, Jen Psaki was asked about the truckers.
00:26:53.360 And, and she said that she respected them and that they have a P a right to peaceful protest.
00:26:58.360 And she was, she was quite positive about them.
00:27:00.360 Almost like, uh, it's just such a stark difference with Trudeau.
00:27:03.360 And I think, I think that, that she, she sees the potential of this trucker convoy to come to the U S and wreak havoc.
00:27:10.360 And the, um, American Democrats rely a lot more on working class voters than, than the liberals do in Canada.
00:27:16.360 So I, I thought that was really interesting.
00:27:18.360 And I think that, I think that more and more people see the truckers as sort of a mantle for freedom.
00:27:24.360 And, and they're starting to side with them more than, more than Trudeau.
00:27:27.360 What, what do you think is next for Trudeau?
00:27:30.360 What do you think Trudeau should do?
00:27:32.360 What will he do?
00:27:33.360 Um, and, and how can he sort of salvage a situation that seems like he's, he's in a pretty bad place right now?
00:27:39.360 Um.
00:27:40.360 Yeah, um, he's gotta, uh, you know, um, he has to meet them.
00:27:46.360 He has to try to diffuse the situation, um, because this can't go on indefinitely.
00:27:51.360 Um, um, and, um, and that should have happened last week, as I mentioned earlier.
00:27:56.360 Um, but instead, uh, as recently as a couple of days ago, um, he doubled down on the divisive rhetoric.
00:28:04.360 Uh, he once again mentioned the swastikas and the Confederate flags, which, you know, as I mentioned,
00:28:09.360 they, they, they, you know, they, they, I'm sure they were there.
00:28:13.360 Uh, well, I haven't seen them, but they haven't returned.
00:28:15.360 I don't know about plural.
00:28:16.360 I don't, I don't think that you can say swastikas because from best, I can tell there was one guy with the swastika flag.
00:28:21.360 And I think that maybe there was someone else who drew one on a sign, but it wasn't like that.
00:28:25.360 It wasn't like that.
00:28:26.360 It wasn't like that was what you could classify the entire protest.
00:28:30.360 I mean, there's thousands of Canadian flags.
00:28:32.360 It's like, how can you see thousands of Canadian flags, one Nazi flag, and assume that everyone there holding a Canadian flag is Nazis?
00:28:39.360 It's so absurd.
00:28:40.360 You know, it is, it is.
00:28:41.360 And, um, I, you know, I was struck by that as well.
00:28:44.360 And, um, you know, it's unfortunate that that's how it ended up being portrayed, but, but Prime Minister Trudeau really needs to speak to them.
00:28:52.360 Uh, they're open for dialogue.
00:28:53.360 What is extraordinary about this is that these people are being called occupying forces, rebel forces.
00:28:59.360 I've seen journalists referring, refer to them that way as though, you know, I don't know what occupying force or rebel force would be interested in having a dialogue, but that's what they've been saying.
00:29:11.360 You know, we want to speak to the prime minister, let him, why, why doesn't he hear us?
00:29:15.360 Uh, you know, why, why does he continue to pour scorn on us?
00:29:19.360 Um, so, and here's, here's one thing, Candace, and I wrote this recently for the national post, um, uh, that, you know, there is room for compromise.
00:29:28.360 So we have, Prime Minister Trudeau, um, if you've noticed has doubled down on the vaccines or nothing.
00:29:34.360 Um, um, um, and has doubled on down on vaccines or nothing.
00:29:38.360 Uh, he, uh, we've have, we have therapeutics.
00:29:42.360 We, uh, in this country, we do not recognize recovery from, uh, COVID.
00:29:47.360 Um, uh, Germany does, um, um, um, I think Switzerland does a lot of Europe, Denmark does a lot of European countries recognize recovery from COVID.
00:29:57.360 Uh, but we've taken an extraordinary position here that, uh, vaccines are the only thing that is going to get out of our, uh, get us out of the pandemic.
00:30:06.360 Uh, given the fact that most of us are vaccinated, I'm triple vaccinated.
00:30:10.360 I've also recovered from Omicron recently.
00:30:13.360 And, um, and, and, uh, you know, and, and, but it's, it's, you know, so I'm not, you know, I, I urge people to get vaccinated.
00:30:21.360 I think, I think you should, I think it does.
00:30:23.360 I believe in the science.
00:30:24.360 I think it does prevent you from, uh, it, it, it, uh, you know, it, uh, prevents you from, uh, winding up in the ICUs.
00:30:32.360 I do believe in that.
00:30:33.360 Um, but, uh, but, but we've taken a very, um, um, you know, extreme position here that if you are not vaccinated, you're not going to get out of the pandemic.
00:30:43.360 Uh, given the fact that we're, you know, a country that is, that has had one of, has one of the highest vaccine rates in the world.
00:30:51.360 Um, so, and what is also happening here is that Canada is increasingly an outlier, uh, among, uh, developed, uh, Western countries, uh, where, where, where they're, uh, seeing the end game of the pandemic.
00:31:05.360 Uh, they're, they're getting, uh, so yesterday, New York, um, got rid of, uh, indoor mask use.
00:31:12.360 Um, uh, uh, Europe is getting rid of, uh, some European countries, um, are, uh, you know, are dismantling the vaccine passport system like Switzerland.
00:31:23.360 Um, and, and, uh, and what is extraordinary here is that we're doubling down on these things.
00:31:28.360 Um, and we're not recognizing, um, a recovery from infection, which is, which I think is an important step to take.
00:31:36.360 I think it would be something that should come from our public health officials.
00:31:40.360 I'm not sure why they refuse to do that.
00:31:42.360 Several of the people that I've met at the protests, uh, have had COVID.
00:31:46.360 Um, I, I don't know if you're aware of a recent, uh, CDC study that came out, uh, saying that people who've recovered from COVID have very high antibodies, um, uh, even higher than those of us who've been vaccinated.
00:31:58.360 So why is it that we don't do that?
00:32:00.360 Why is it that we don't recognize, uh, natural immunity, which is as old as time itself?
00:32:05.360 Um, it's extraordinary that we put all, uh, we put everything on vaccines, but we've ignored everything else that could be testing.
00:32:15.360 Why are we so behind in testing?
00:32:17.360 Um, yesterday I, I saw a news report, uh, that, uh, that, you know, uh, if you live in Ontario, you can now finally get these rapid tests by walking into a pharmacy or a grocery store.
00:32:29.360 You know, the rest of the world, including India, where I originally come from, that's been the case for more than a year.
00:32:37.360 Uh, what, what is going on?
00:32:39.360 Who do we, who, who's responsible for it?
00:32:41.360 Is it the feds?
00:32:42.360 Is it the provincial governments?
00:32:44.360 Why are we so, uh, you know, behind on something as basic as rapid tests?
00:32:49.360 Uh, because rapid tests was something that could have been a lot more useful during the previous Delta waves.
00:32:55.360 I'm not even sure that it accurately will let you know whether you have Omicron or not.
00:33:00.360 I've heard really competing stories in my own family.
00:33:02.360 Uh, we had to test my son like five times, even though we knew that he had COVID.
00:33:05.360 We knew he'd be exposed to a swim coach and he was showing the symptoms and he kept testing negative on these rapid tests.
00:33:12.360 And we finally took him in for a PCR and it was positive.
00:33:14.360 I don't even know why we bothered because it was just, I guess, peace of mind to confirm it.
00:33:18.360 But, uh, I've had, I've had just even in my own household, so many weird instances where someone's positive one day and negative the next day.
00:33:25.360 It's like, I'm not sure how, how accurate those are, but I get, I get your point that Canada just seems to be really dead set on vaccines and not looking at even, even sort of the underlying health issues.
00:33:37.360 I, I took issue with a Trudeau, um, for her, his former health minister.
00:33:41.360 I actually, I'm not sure if she's still the health minister, Patty Haju, but she said that she didn't recommend people take vitamin D supplements.
00:33:47.360 Uh, which is, is really, really puzzling.
00:33:50.360 Um, given what we know about the, a number of people who have COVID who also have vitamin D deficiencies and there have been lots of studies.
00:33:58.360 And so the fact that she's telling people not to take vitamin D supplements is just curious because it's like, why, why wouldn't you tell people to do everything they can to be healthy?
00:34:07.360 Go outside and get exercise, get some fresh air, make sure you eat a healthy diet, take vitamin D supplements.
00:34:12.360 We live in the north and we don't get a lot of sun during the winter.
00:34:14.360 Like it just seems like some of those basic messages have never been communicated to the public.
00:34:19.360 In fact, what is striking, um, is that, and I have doctors in my family and they say, you know, what is missing from the messaging here from our public health officials is that, uh, they don't, nobody even talks about, uh, trying to be healthy, trying to stay fit.
00:34:35.360 It's trying to, you know, so you close gyms, uh, which is extraordinary when, you know, that could actually help you, uh, you know, give you the tools to fight COVID if you were to get it.
00:34:46.360 Um, so we've, we've had it completely backwards.
00:34:49.360 For example, gyms in the UK were open during Omicron.
00:34:52.360 We closed everything down.
00:34:54.360 Uh, we, we, we just, we just, we, the first sign of trouble here.
00:34:58.360 We, we shut everything down like the Rideau center, which is, which has been closed indefinitely, but the businesses around it are, uh, are, you know, are open.
00:35:06.360 Um, so, you know, I think, I think it's, it's important that our, our political class, our political elites, uh, uh, uh, principally, uh, prime minister,
00:35:16.360 Trudeau, uh, they need to really think long and hard, uh, about what is happening in the country right now.
00:35:22.360 Um, and, and, and, and, and listen to, you know, and pay attention to the frustrations of these individuals.
00:35:28.360 They are, you're there, you're the prime minister of all Canadians, not just those who voted for you.
00:35:34.360 Um, and these frustrations are real, uh, uh, and, and, and the, and some of the stories are heartbreaking.
00:35:42.360 Um, and, and he really needs to, uh, diffuse the situation, um, uh, go and speak to the convoy organizers, uh, hear them out, uh, chart out a plan.
00:35:54.360 Um, you know, what is, what is, what is happening right now is that we, um, don't seem to have an end game in sight.
00:36:01.360 Um, yesterday, the health minister, uh, in Ontario, uh, refused to tell us when, when we're gonna get out of this.
00:36:09.360 Um, you know, this roadmap is all well and good, but, you know, it doesn't really get us back to 2019, does it?
00:36:15.360 Uh, when the rest of the world is moving in that, uh, direction.
00:36:18.360 Um, so, you know, it raises questions.
00:36:21.360 Why, what, what, what is going on here?
00:36:24.360 What, what, what are we so afraid of?
00:36:26.360 We're, uh, what is it?
00:36:27.360 80% or more double vaccinated here.
00:36:30.360 And Trudeau said yesterday that nine out of 10 Canadians are now vaccinated.
00:36:34.360 So vaccines are, are way out of the pandemic.
00:36:37.360 So what is that going to be now?
00:36:39.360 I mean, 110%, I'm not sure.
00:36:41.360 Uh, and, uh, but, you know, I'll also tell you, uh, Candace that, um, uh, what I've also now seen is that, um, you know, I'm, it's, it's not, it's, it's in, I've been noticing it.
00:36:53.360 This is even before the, uh, protesters on the convoy arrived in Ottawa.
00:36:58.360 Uh, people who are triple vaccinated are living in fear.
00:37:02.360 They're walking around with masks outdoors.
00:37:06.360 I, I never, I never thought that I would see that.
00:37:09.360 Um, I, I, you know, I, I get it.
00:37:12.360 I mean, as long as the mask mandate isn't in place, I'm going to wear a mask wherever, wherever I go.
00:37:17.360 But I certainly will not wear a mask when I'm outdoors because that just, it's, it's just crazy.
00:37:22.360 Being outdoors is what they've been telling us.
00:37:24.360 Being outdoors is better than being indoors.
00:37:26.360 Well, we've known that since the very beginning of the pandemic that, uh, that COVID doesn't really spread outside.
00:37:31.360 I'm not sure about Omicron, but, and we saw that with our own prime minister.
00:37:34.360 He's triple vaxxed.
00:37:35.360 He just recovered from COVID and he's standing outside wearing a mask.
00:37:39.360 It's like, how are we supposed to believe that, that vaccines get us out of the pandemic when you've had COVID?
00:37:45.360 You had, you're vaccinated.
00:37:46.360 You still had COVID like so many other Canadians.
00:37:48.360 I know so many Canadians that are double, triple vaxxed, still got COVID, including everyone in my household.
00:37:52.360 And, and yet here you are still wearing a mask, still imposing all of these things.
00:37:57.360 So it's, it's really hard to believe him when he doesn't even live up to what he's saying.
00:38:03.360 His, his rhetoric doesn't match his own actions.
00:38:05.360 And, and that those images are powerful when you see the prime minister of the country at a press conference outside and there's really no one else around.
00:38:13.360 You know, there's a lot of distance between him and whoever is there.
00:38:17.360 But he's still wearing a mask.
00:38:18.360 He's triple vaccinated and recovered from COVID.
00:38:21.360 That people, people see that.
00:38:24.360 And the, and the triple vaccinated, I find are more fearful than the unvaccinated, which is extraordinary.
00:38:31.360 And you see that here, you, you can spot the triple vaccinated or the double vaccinated and the ones who are unvaccinated.
00:38:39.360 It's the unvaccinated who are dancing and smiling and hugging everybody.
00:38:43.360 It's the triple, triple vaccinated.
00:38:45.360 We're walking around in masks, looking grumpy, their shoulders, you know, stooped and, you know, they're slouching and you can see them, you can spot them.
00:38:56.360 And, you know, so it, it tells me, it tells me that this, this, this, I don't know how big this is, how, how big their numbers are.
00:39:06.360 It tells me that I, some people are just not ready to say goodbye to the pandemic.
00:39:10.360 Now, how much of that is reflected in the decisions that our politicians are making?
00:39:16.360 I don't know, because at the end of the day, they're also humans.
00:39:19.360 They're also, you know, they're also susceptible to the fear and, and concerns about going back to normal life.
00:39:29.360 But, but, but it is quite extraordinary.
00:39:32.360 And, and, and so, you know, I think, I think going back to your question, I do think that Prime Minister Trudeau, it's time for him to speak to them.
00:39:40.360 This is not a good look for the country, Candace.
00:39:43.360 I'm getting messages from people all over the world saying, you know, what is going on?
00:39:48.360 I mean, he's, you know, why doesn't he talk to them?
00:39:51.360 Why doesn't he, why doesn't he, why doesn't he speak to them?
00:39:54.360 Why doesn't he engage with them?
00:39:56.360 What is going on in Canada?
00:39:57.360 And, and, you know, and you mentioned Joe Biden's press secretary.
00:40:01.360 I think, you know, I think there's another element to this.
00:40:03.360 Politicians everywhere else are watching this.
00:40:06.360 And I think they're, and they're, and they're taking notes.
00:40:10.360 And, and, and they, and they're saying, look, I, I don't think it's a good idea for us to double down the way Justin Trudeau has because, you know, we're going to see mass protest movements here as well.
00:40:21.360 And, and that's not something we want to deal with right now.
00:40:25.360 And that I'm sure that's happening.
00:40:27.360 And I think that's, you know, probably because of the truckers and, but again, we're an outlier here.
00:40:35.360 I don't know what, what, what, what the thinking here is.
00:40:38.360 I don't know how Trudeau comes out of this.
00:40:41.360 You know, how this is advantageous for Trudeau politically.
00:40:46.360 I remember early on in the protest, several people were saying, oh, this is, you know, Trudeau is going to get, win a majority in the next election.
00:40:55.360 This is a done deal because these, these people have managed to do that.
00:41:00.360 I'm not so sure about that anymore.
00:41:02.360 I think, I think public opinion, the, the narrative is changing.
00:41:07.360 It's, it's changing.
00:41:09.360 And, and I, and even people who are skeptical, questioning about the, questioning the protests, you know, are tired of the restrictions.
00:41:19.360 They do want to go back to life, normal life.
00:41:22.360 And they want to put this behind them.
00:41:25.360 And ironically, that is what the truckers and the protesters want.
00:41:29.360 They want their lives back.
00:41:30.360 Well, it's so, it's so interesting to hear your perspective, Rupa.
00:41:34.360 And I really appreciate not, not just coming on the show, cause it's great to talk to you, but I appreciate the fact that you go out there, you go against the grain.
00:41:40.360 You don't just do what everyone else in the legacy media does.
00:41:43.360 And you really sought to tell the other side of the story.
00:41:46.360 So it's great to, great to have you on the show.
00:41:48.360 I appreciate your time.
00:41:49.360 That's Rupa Subramania.
00:41:51.360 Thank you so much for joining us.
00:41:52.360 Thanks, Candice.
00:41:53.360 Thanks for having me.
00:41:54.360 Thank you so much.
00:41:55.360 All right.
00:41:56.360 Thank you for tuning in.
00:41:57.360 I'm Candice Malcolm, and this is The Candice Malcolm Show.
00:42:00.360 We're here on two billion�egener.
00:42:03.360 Here we go.
00:42:04.360 All right.
00:42:06.360 I'm Padilla.
00:42:07.360 In this round, it's nothing.
00:42:09.360 One, this is my safety knowledge.
00:42:10.360 I'm given all about the sheep.
00:42:12.360 It's nothing.
00:42:13.360 It's a ministry to get us感覺.
00:42:14.360 There's something left at it.
00:42:16.360 It Totally does.
00:42:18.360 Oh, that's so.
00:42:19.360 You can take us away.
00:42:20.360 And you will, become a device so you can take me.
00:42:22.360 And the system, this is a custom and morality.
00:42:25.360 And it's over, for this human child, because of my husband, I'm globally...
00:42:27.360 You can take us away from my side.