Juno News - September 30, 2019


Trudeau promises to spend, spend, spend!

Topics
Hosted by
Hundreds of logging trucks descend on Vancouver to protest government failure in industry Why is Canada celebrating China's anniversary?

Episode Stats


Length

4 minutes

Words per minute

178.96

Word count

824

Sentence count

47

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Liberal Party of Canada has unveiled its platform for the upcoming election, and it's a doozy. The platform is a fully costed wish list of what the government would like to accomplish in the next few years, but it comes with a hefty price tag. In this episode, Andrew Lutton explains why this is a bad idea.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Spend, spend, spend, and we know that's going to ultimately mean tax, tax, tax.
00:00:14 That's the biggest takeaway from the Liberal platform, the fully costed platform
00:00:18 officially unveiled by the Liberal Party of Canada with just three weeks to go
00:00:22 until the election. Now what's interesting is that the Liberals have been in government
00:00:27 for just under four years, which means they've had an opportunity to set an economic course for
00:00:32 Canada, and more importantly, through the most recent budget, they've even had an opportunity
00:00:36 to lay out projections for spending in the next few years. However, the platform that was unveiled
00:00:42 by the Liberals actually deviates from even the budget the Liberal government had been putting
00:00:47 forward. Now this budget, and we talked about this earlier in the year when it was released,
00:00:52 only promised a $19.7 billion deficit in 2020 to 2021, which would fall to a $9.8 billion deficit
00:01:01 by 2023 to 2024. Now this platform is monumentally more in deficit spending. Next year, the deficit
00:01:09 would be $27.4 billion, and the year after $23.7 billion, the year after that $21.8 billion,
00:01:18 and the year after that $21 billion. We're talking about more than $100 billion in deficit spending
00:01:24 over the next four years, and by the way, over $30 billion in new government debt for a government
00:01:31 that will have been in power for eight years by then and racked up billions and billions and billions
00:01:35 in deficit spending. Now what's more concerning than this is that what is really the Liberals'
00:01:41 biggest ticket item in the campaign, Universal Pharmacare, which could run up to $15 billion,
00:01:47 isn't even included in the platform. So that would be an additional expenditure on top of that.
00:01:53 And another development in this that a friend pointed out to me is that all of the revenue
00:01:57 projections, when assessed by the Parliamentary Budget Office, are not guaranteed. They're not set
00:02:02 in stone. The Liberals are banking on bringing in the revenue they expect, but it could be that if
00:02:07 their spending keeps up and the revenue is in fact less than they're projecting, that we are looking
00:02:12 at even more, billions and billions more, on top of the existing billions in government spending that
00:02:18 will be running up deficits. Now we all know the economic harm that deficit spending causes to a
00:02:24 country. For starters, increased debt, and more importantly, less money that's going towards the
00:02:29 services government should be providing. This is an election wish list that the government is putting
00:02:34 forward as policy here. The government right now is very much devoted to trying to tell Canadians this
00:02:41 is what we're going to do for you, but it comes at a cost and it comes with a price tag. When that old
00:02:46 saying, nothing in life is free, was uttered, there's a reason. Even government promises, even political
00:02:51 promises, they are not free. They have to be paid for. But the challenge is that people understand the
00:02:58 promises. People understand the tangible that's provided, like Universal Pharmacare. They don't understand as
00:03:04 much the idea of deficits. They don't understand debt to GDP ratio. And I'm not calling people stupid.
00:03:09 The fact is most Canadians are not economists. And there's a reason for that. Canadians defer to 0.98
00:03:14 experts and yes, defer to politicians to make these decisions. But oftentimes we get captivated by
00:03:20 whatever the promise is without looking at what went into making that promise happen. In this particular
00:03:25 case, spending. And what's interesting is that this is the first election in Canada where the
00:03:30 parliamentary budget office has had to cost projections. And the Liberals have bragged that,
00:03:34 hey, this platform of theirs is costed by the PBO. And yes, that's true. But all that really is,
00:03:40 is to look at whether the math adds up. It's not whether it's good policy. And more importantly,
00:03:44 it's not whether there is a guarantee of revenue. And it was the PBO that assessed these revenue
00:03:50 projections as not entirely certain. So that means that this government will have to make up the
00:03:55 useful by finding a way to add even more revenue into the mix. And you know what that means?
00:04:01 Taxes. We don't know who's going to be taxed or how, but that's the only way the government can make
00:04:06 that up unless it's prepared to scale back on spending. But we haven't seen any indication in
00:04:10 this platform that scaling back spending is what the government would like to do.
00:04:14 I'm reporting right now from New Glasgow, Nova Scotia on my cross-country tour covering the issues that
00:04:21 matter to Canadians and talking to the people that matter in this election. We can't do this alone.
00:04:26 There's a cost to doing this. If you can chip in to our election coverage fund,
00:04:30 please head on over to tnc.news and offer a donation as you're able. For True North, I'm Andrew Lutton.