Juno News - June 21, 2022


Trudeau's Bill C-11 is a gateway to censorship

Mentioned
CBC stands by their false reporting of the convoy Cathay Wagantall returns to Parliament following end of vaccine mandate

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

183.2

Word count

7,287

Sentence count

275

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show: Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, Andrew talks about the Freedom Convoy, Bill C-11, the single-use plastic ban, and the role of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) in the Trudeau administration.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 welcome to Canada's most irreverent talk show
00:00:04 this is the Andrew Lawton show brought to you by True North
00:00:08 hello and welcome to you all this is Canada's most irreverent talk show the Andrew Lawton show
00:00:18 here on True North Tuesday June 21st 2022 just after four o'clock eastern time two o'clock
00:00:25 Mountain Time, 5.30 in Newfoundland and Labrador. Hopefully you are having a wonderful start of the
00:00:33 week so far. As you note behind me, the Freedom Convoy, the inside story of three weeks that shook
00:00:39 the world, is not so subtly placed in an effort to very overtly tell you to buy the book. And it
00:00:45 seems to be working because a moment ago, our executive producer just sent me a message demanding
00:00:50 to know where his book is. Well, it's right behind me and it can be yours for the low price of $21.99
00:00:55 their unnamed executive producer. Thank you very much for your support. And to all of you who have
00:01:00 sent me very kind messages, letting me know you've pre-ordered the book, in some cases,
00:01:04 multiple copies. What I tell people is buy one for you and one for Justin Trudeau, and I'll happily
00:01:11 sign both of them for you. And you can mail those all the way over to, it's not even called Langevin
00:01:16 Block. I forget what they've renamed it to. It's like they've renamed it to this really boring,
00:01:20 I think, the office of the prime minister. So it's now no longer the prime minister's office
00:01:24 in Langevin bloc it's the prime minister's office in the office of the prime minister
00:01:28 or something unoriginal like that this is like a tangent of tangents a tangent on a tangent so
00:01:35 uh thank you very much for your patience we're going to be speaking later on about this
00:01:39 this new single-use plastics ban that the liberals are reviving which is a great way to just tell
00:01:44 people that you are doing something when you're not doing anything so they don't want anyone to
00:01:49 look at all the other things we're going to be talking about so they say hey think of the baby
00:01:52 turtles think of the baby turtles well i am thinking of the baby turtles and i'm also thinking
00:01:57 of how this single-use plastic thing will only inconvenience canadians and be very harmful to
00:02:03 canadian industry so we will talk about that later on in the show and also i'm not going to do too
00:02:08 much on it today because i haven't had a chance to go through all the documents but this story
00:02:13 that just broke this afternoon from the halifax examiner a story showing how the rcmp commissioner
00:02:20 Brenda Luckey, was running interference, political interference, for Justin Trudeau and for Bill
00:02:27 Blair after the Nova Scotia massacre a couple of years back in Portapique to make it easier for 0.93
00:02:35 them to ram their gun control measures through. This is not the role of the RCMP. It has shades
00:02:41 of SNC-Lavalin all over again. I will mention it later on in the show in a bit more detail,
00:02:46 but I'm going to reserve a full episode for that later on in the week or most of the episodes. So
00:02:51 if I'm not talking about it today in great depth, that's why, because I haven't had a chance to read
00:02:56 all of the source documents. But I do want to talk about another burning issue here first,
00:03:00 which is Bill C-11. Now, I try not to bog people down too much in the legislative numbers,
00:03:07 because these bill numbers do change in the previous parliament to now. This was formerly
00:03:12 C10. It's been brought back as C11. It's the bill that will monumentally change internet regulations
00:03:19 in this country. And by change, I mean vastly expand the federal government's regulatory
00:03:24 authority over the internet. And by the internet, I'm talking about things that people post on social
00:03:30 media, certainly the work that independent media outlets like True North are doing. And as much as
00:03:35 the government says, no, no, no, it's not about censorship. It's just we're modernizing. That's
00:03:39 what they say. We're modernizing the regulations. Well, they can call it whatever they want. They
00:03:44 can put the lipstick on the pig as much as they want. The reality is they're making it so that
00:03:49 the CRTC is the gatekeeper on your speech and my speech on the internet. And even if they don't
00:03:57 intend to use this power for evil, they're giving themselves power over internet content. And it's
00:04:03 not conspiratorial to point that out. The Canadian Taxpayers Federation published a report this week
00:04:09 on C11, a fatally flawed gateway to government censorship. Jay Goldberg of CTF is the lead
00:04:17 author on it, but I was also pleased to see they collaborated with Michael Geist, who's been
00:04:21 sounding the alarm about C11 back when it was C10, even before the conservatives started opposing
00:04:27 the government on this. He's the reason I think anyone knows about this bill, quite frankly,
00:04:32 but it's great to have Michael Geist involved in this and great to have Jay Goldberg on the show
00:04:36 Now, Jay, thanks for coming on today. Good to talk to you.
00:04:39 Great to talk to you.
00:04:41 So let's start with the why you're doing this first.
00:04:44 I don't disagree at all with the premise. I don't disagree with your findings.
00:04:48 The Canadian Taxpayers Federation, though, a lot of people think is out there for balanced budgets and low taxes.
00:04:53 Why is sounding the alarm of a government censorship a priority for the CTF?
00:04:59 Well, it's at the core of our mandate because our priorities are lower taxes, less waste and more accountable government.
00:05:05 Now, it definitely falls under number three. As you said, if we are going to hand over to the
00:05:10 government and bureaucrats the power to filter what we see online and deprioritize things that
00:05:16 the government may not like, and again, you said it properly, they're saying they may not use it
00:05:21 now, but it's definitely there to be used in the future. It's a major accountability concern,
00:05:25 and that's why we're all over this issue. Just looking at it here, let's set the stage for
00:05:31 what you're really delving into is your issue the content of the legislation specific provisions in
00:05:37 it or is your issue the existence of the legislation at all do you think it's just an
00:05:42 unnecessary bill in the first place it's absolutely unnecessary and it's because as we say in the
00:05:48 report canadian content is thriving like never before netflix has hundreds of millions of dollars
00:05:53 invested in cancon and we had six billion dollars of foreign investment in canadian film and television
00:06:00 in 2020 the first year of the pandemic that was a record so the government's out there claiming
00:06:05 this is for canadian content well canadian content is thriving so clearly that's just a red herring
00:06:11 what they're trying to do is regulate free speech and free expression that's why we're so concerned
00:06:16 and so the whole bill needs to be scrapped let's talk about this canadian content cell aspect here
00:06:22 because this is a relatively new talking point that the government wasn't pushing as much when
00:06:27 they were advancing this under its former iteration c10 in the last parliament because
00:06:32 back then they were talking about modernization we're just updating the broadcast requirements
00:06:37 we're updating the crtc rules they were just trying to position it as being this natural evolution
00:06:44 of the regulatory framework in canada surrounding broadcasters namely tv and radio they do seem to be
00:06:51 focusing a lot on this canadian content angle now and maybe it's just me perhaps they've done
00:06:56 polling on this and realize that, yeah, you know, Gladys in Sarnia, Ontario and Jean-Pierre in
00:07:02 Montreal love Canadian content. So that's the way they can shoehorn this thing in. But in doing so,
00:07:08 what they're effectively saying, and JJ McCullough has made this point, who's a YouTube streamer in
00:07:12 Canada, is that, you know, YouTube and Facebook and Twitter and Instagram and TikTok, they need
00:07:17 to showcase Canadian content more. Just as your television and your radio has to showcase Canadian
00:07:23 content so does your internet uh platform service streaming platform whatever you want to call it
00:07:29 and the whole point of the internet is that everything is at your fingertips already
00:07:35 absolutely that's the whole thing about the internet that's why we have the internet
00:07:40 and i think actually sean spear had a really good column where he was pointing out
00:07:44 that the chretchen government the last time these things were looked at explicitly decided
00:07:49 not to regulate the internet because the internet was seen as something different and this is very
00:07:54 different than tv and radio because as you say people have this stuff at their fingertips and
00:07:59 if they want to find canadian content they can find it online anytime it's on netflix it's on
00:08:04 streaming services it's very easy to find so again that's why this was kept separate in the 90s
00:08:10 and so the government's rationale for trying to do this it just doesn't make any sense
00:08:15 One of the things, I mean, again, this may work against the overarching point here because I am
00:08:20 saying and you're saying that Canadian content is already ubiquitous and available. One of the
00:08:24 great things I have enjoyed about Netflix and to a lesser extent, Prime Video is that you get a
00:08:30 window into other countries' content. You can log on and I've found shows from Spain and Denmark,
00:08:36 notably, that I've absolutely loved that I might not find under C11 if all of a sudden I have to
00:08:42 scroll past all the Canadian stuff that the government has made Netflix put on the home
00:08:46 page. And I don't see it, especially if other countries were to follow suit. And that's the
00:08:51 thing. We as Canadians would lose out if Denmark had its own version of this. And they had to
00:08:59 promote Danish content to Danes and Spanish content to Spaniards and Canadian content to
00:09:03 Canadians. And we lose what we're supposed to embrace about Canada, which is all of these
00:09:09 different cultural influences that we have access to. Absolutely. And I've actually been on a number
00:09:14 of radio stations where sometimes they are broadcasting in English, other times other
00:09:20 languages, communities all across Canada that are waking up to these concerns. Whether they want to
00:09:25 watch shows that are from India or China or South Korea, there are ethnic communities here in Canada
00:09:30 that love foreign content. And we are supposed to be a multicultural country that according to
00:09:35 justin trudeau you know that's what we are and that's what we embrace well the reality is bill
00:09:40 c11 would make that content less accessible uh that's a huge concern but also as you said other
00:09:47 countries could retaliate they can promote their own content but even more than that if there are
00:09:52 certain companies that are operating abroad and they're in charge of uh content that's been sent
00:09:59 in from abroad to canada if these companies don't want to deal with all of these regulations that
00:10:04 the crtc can be putting in they can simply block canada as a market altogether so some foreign
00:10:10 content could very well just be blocked we may not be able to see it in canada because these
00:10:15 providers don't want to jump through all the hoops that the crtc is setting up for them
00:10:20 we're obviously talking about this in the context of entertainment content i want to turn to news
00:10:26 and commentary for a moment because this has been one of the big i i'd say inconsistencies in the
00:10:31 the government's messaging on this. In the previous parliament, Stephen Gilboa at one point
00:10:36 said, no, no, no, news will be exempt from this. So all the media got off his back about it because,
00:10:41 okay, we're safe. We don't need to care about this. But the thing about that, that I would
00:10:45 point out as an independent journalist who works outside of one of these mainstream media
00:10:49 environments is that, you know, the government has already said that it does not view True North
00:10:54 as one example, as a journalism outlet. That's the liberal government's position.
00:10:59 okay fine so what are we then are they going to force canadians to watch us i mean okay there's
00:11:05 a part of me that might enjoy that in principle but but or i might enjoy it in practice but not
00:11:10 in principle or are they going to all of a sudden say oh no no you guys don't count you're off the
00:11:15 home page because all of a sudden government's going to have to start making judgments about
00:11:19 which canadian content qualifies as being sufficiently canadian to force in front of
00:11:25 people. And you get into this point, whether it's targeted politically or not, where government or
00:11:31 some government agency or some tech company deputized by government is having to choose
00:11:36 which content Canadians should see and which stuff they shouldn't see. That's exactly right. And I
00:11:42 think not enough of the conversation is in that place. I think that people are just saying on the
00:11:47 government side, well, we need to promote Canadian content. And that's necessarily a good thing. But
00:11:52 there's actually no clear definition of what Canadian content is. And if you look at what
00:11:56 the CRTC is doing, there's a film out there called Gotta Love Trump. It's a biopic of the
00:12:02 Trump presidency, Trump's life. It's considered Canadian content by the CRTC because there was
00:12:07 an American producer. You've got The Handmaid's Tale, which was a TV series that was made based
00:12:12 on the book by the very famous Canadian author, Margaret Atwood. Well, that's not considered
00:12:19 canadian content because the producer was in the united states so already these people don't know
00:12:23 what they're doing in terms of you know figuring out what's can con and so we're going to give them
00:12:28 10 times the amount of power if not more and then figure it out and allow this to filter into news
00:12:34 and other things so it's just very very dangerous this is not something the government should be
00:12:38 deciding upon and the minister has also said pablo rodriguez has come out and said we're not actually
00:12:44 going to tell the CRTC what the regulations should be or how they should define Canadian content
00:12:50 until this is actually passed into law and signed by the governor general that is completely
00:12:55 backwards legislation that is like going to a used car dealership buying the car and then
00:12:59 looking at the inside of it afterwards it's completely flawed but that's what they're
00:13:03 trying to push on Canadians yeah I mean for those who have the good fortune to not have immersed
00:13:09 themselves in this CRTC regulatory environment over the years. The way they've governed music
00:13:15 is they have this system called MAPL, M-A-P-L. And in order for it to be Canadian content,
00:13:21 you have to check off two of the four boxes. And M, I'm just pulling it up here to make sure I
00:13:26 don't get it wrong. M is music. So the music has to be composed by a Canadian. A, the artist,
00:13:32 the music has to be performed by a Canadian. P, performance, the musical selection was performed
00:13:38 or recorded in Canada. And L, the lyrics are written by a Canadian. So if the music and
00:13:44 lyrics are written by a Canadian, but it's performed by a Norwegian in New Zealand,
00:13:49 that's Canadian content. Conversely, if someone records it in Canada, but they didn't write the
00:13:55 music, the lyrics, and they're not Canadian, it's not Canadian content. So you have all of this.
00:14:00 And I remember years ago, Heart, the American band from Washington was Canadian content because of
00:14:05 just this, even though they were not Canadian. And they got a lot of airplay in Canada for that.
00:14:10 So it forces all of these weird rules and guidelines. But again, I think we can talk
00:14:16 about the desires and the goals and all of that. But fundamentally, it's does the government have
00:14:22 the right to curate what we see online? And that really is, in my view, and you may disagree with
00:14:28 this, Jay, but that's like the fundamental question here. That is the fundamental question.
00:14:33 the internet was created so that we can see everything at our fingertips and the government
00:14:37 also keeps trying to roll out this argument that well we have to protect canadians online so whether
00:14:42 you're talking about child pornography or you're talking about hate speech this is all regulated
00:14:48 through the ministry of justice this is part of the criminal code if that's what their concern
00:14:53 is regulating dangerous things online such as those you can look at strengthening the criminal
00:14:57 code other than that there should be absolutely no reason why the government is filtering what we 0.89
00:15:02 can see and share online and in this bill they are handing the crtc the power to do exactly that
00:15:10 and this should also affect and people should realize it affects individuals because the head
00:15:14 of the crtc came and testified he said user generated content is on the table we will have
00:15:20 the power to regulate that so as you said that's youtube videos that's tick tock that's not just
00:15:25 you know what's on netflix this is very personal and it will get down to the lives of every canadian
00:15:30 and it will affect you individually is your fear that this will be used to target
00:15:38 political speech or do you think that is taking the conspiratorial thinking a step too far
00:15:44 well for right now the government says they're going to do it based on whether or not they think
00:15:48 the content is canadian as we've said it's a very flawed process on figuring out what's canadian and
00:15:54 and it'd be very easy for the government to decide
00:15:56 that certain things on certain networks
00:15:58 they don't think should be considered Canadian.
00:16:01 But it also opens the door to future decisions.
00:16:04 You're strengthening the CRTC,
00:16:06 you're giving them the capacity
00:16:08 to filter what we see online.
00:16:10 If they have the capacity to do it for one reason, 0.75
00:16:13 which is Canadian-ness, 0.81
00:16:14 if two or three years from now they come out,
00:16:16 and I'm sure you heard Minister Mendicino
00:16:19 talk about the need to maintain social cohesion in Canada,
00:16:22 If a year or two from now, they decide, well, that should also be our goal, and they give that mandate to the CRTC, then absolutely we should be concerned.
00:16:29 So they're laying the groundwork for that.
00:16:32 Whether or not they do that today is a question, but whether or not they have the capacity to do that is not a question.
00:16:38 Under this bill, they will have the capacity to do exactly that.
00:16:42 The report is over at taxpayer.com, written by Jay Goldberg of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, Bill C-11,
00:16:49 a fatally flawed gateway to government censorship.
00:16:53 Jay, thanks for coming on today.
00:16:55 Thanks for having me.
00:16:57 You know, one thing I will point out here
00:16:59 is that let's use the government's own motivations against them.
00:17:03 There's nothing more Canadian than the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:17:06 I'm Canadian.
00:17:07 I broadcast the show in Canada.
00:17:09 I record it in front of a Canadian-bought studio equipment set.
00:17:14 I have a mostly Canadian audience.
00:17:16 True North is Canadian.
00:17:17 We're as Canadian as maple syrup, poutine, beavers, and hockey.
00:17:22 So if they want to promote Canadian content, we have to demand, demand that True North
00:17:27 is up there on the front page.
00:17:29 Now, I don't support that, but I will say that nothing would make the government move
00:17:34 off of this quickly enough than having to promote Canadian independent media sources
00:17:38 who are telling people why this stuff is so damaging and so dangerous.
00:17:44 So that would be my little PSA here.
00:17:46 you know again even if we could theoretically benefit from this which i don't think we would
00:17:50 because government would draw this line and they'd be like oh no we got we got to draw around there
00:17:54 yeah we got to draw around true north and rebel news and post-millennial and western standard and
00:18:00 all of that other stuff but it points out the inconsistency here that promoting canadian content
00:18:06 is not what they're after what they're after is fundamentally expanding the power of the state
00:18:11 the regulatory power of the government. And we see this happening time and time again in other
00:18:17 areas. We're going to be talking about the plastic span in just a couple of moments here. But I do
00:18:21 want to spend a little bit of time between topics here talking about this story in the Halifax
00:18:26 Examiner that I alluded to at the beginning here. And again, this is very new. I haven't read all
00:18:33 the documents. I'm just going based off what's in front of me here. But the thing is, I'm
00:18:40 I'm not surprised. I'm surprised things are as brazen as they are. The headline RCMP Commissioner
00:18:48 Brenda Luckey tried to jeopardize mass murder investigation to advance Trudeau's gun control
00:18:53 efforts. So what happened here, according to the Halifax Examiner, is that Brenda Luckey,
00:19:00 quote, made a promise to Bill Blair and Justin Trudeau's office to leverage the mass murders
00:19:06 in Portapique, Nova Scotia, to get their gun control ban passed.
00:19:10 Remember, it was just weeks later that they introduced a couple of gun control measures,
00:19:15 including the Order and Council banning the AR-15 and other similar firearms.
00:19:19 And it was Lucky who pressured the Nova Scotia RCMP to release weapon details used by the
00:19:26 killers to justify the government going after it when they normally don't release such details
00:19:33 and they won't because they don't want to compromise the information they have as part
00:19:37 of the investigation. So what happened is the RCMP had found all of this and weren't saying
00:19:45 things because they were going through it. And Brenda Luckey was telling them, no, no, no,
00:19:48 we have to do it. And there's one particular document. And again, I'm going to devote more
00:19:53 time on this later in the week, but there's one particular document I saw here, which has the
00:19:58 money quote, that Brenda Luckey said that the Nova Scotia RCMP didn't understand that the
00:20:03 directive was tied to, quote, pending gun control legislation that would make officers and public
00:20:10 safer by or through this legislation. So directly tying orders she was giving to her subordinates
00:20:17 for political gain for the liberals. The RCMP commissioner, who the government says, oh, no,
00:20:23 no, no, they're independent. We don't direct them. We didn't tell them what to do in the convoy. We
00:20:27 don't tell them what to do about this or that. They're independent. We couldn't order them even
00:20:31 if we wanted to. All of a sudden are releasing or holding back investigative details based on
00:20:37 what's politically convenient for the government. I would encourage you to head on over to
00:20:43 halifaxexaminer.ca after the show and read this for yourself. And like I mentioned, we're going
00:20:48 to get to the bottom of this later this week. But I want to talk about if we're in a theme
00:20:53 show this week and a theme show today about government regulating your lives we talked about 0.97
00:20:57 them regulating your internet let's talk about them regulating your beverages the liberals have
00:21:03 come out this week with announcements of details about their ban on single-use plastics it's not
00:21:09 the first time they've come up with this we've known it was just around the corner although
00:21:14 interestingly enough i didn't think they were going to do it so quickly because throughout
00:21:19 covid single-use items were pretty much the saving grace of a lot of organizations food
00:21:25 service organizations hospitals because of cleanliness sanitation and hygiene rules but
00:21:31 by the end of 2025 the federal government will ban companies from importing or making plastic bags
00:21:38 and takeout containers they'll also go after most single-use plastic straws stir sticks and cutlery
00:21:45 the six pack rings that hold cans and bottles together will get a little bit more time uh in
00:21:51 june 2024 will have their sale banned as well so what we're having happen here by the end of next
00:21:58 year is some of the bands going in place and then adding more and more of them but this is happening
00:22:04 all within within just a couple of years so significant effect not just to the manufacturers
00:22:08 who produce these things in canada but all the businesses who rely on these things and i i think
00:22:14 there's there's two sides to this here there's obviously the consumer aspect of this and also
00:22:21 the producer aspect of this so let's talk about both of those with katherine swift who is the
00:22:26 president of the coalition of concerned manufacturers and businesses of canada
00:22:30 katherine it's good to talk to you thanks for coming on today my pleasure as always andrew
00:22:35 now just before we get into the nitty-gritty of this uh some people are going to say oh my goodness
00:22:40 what am i going to do without my water bottles well justin trudeau has the answer oh you mean
00:22:45 the uh paper box uh water thingies yeah let's let's hear it in his words
00:22:53 yeah we have recently switched to drinking water bottles out of water out of when we have water
00:23:00 bottles uh out of a plastic uh sorry away from plastic towards uh paper um like drink box water
00:23:09 bottles sort of things there we go we've got options don't we
00:23:17 yeah well it's what this announcement is is yet another virtue signaling uh you know policy
00:23:28 statement that will have virtually no impact on the environment that's how it's coached of course
00:23:35 is that it's a great environmental procedure. But the funny thing is, Andrew, and it's funny in a
00:23:44 sardonic sense, not a hilarious sense, is that this seems to all have been driven
00:23:51 by some little kid in grade school in the US who did a project on that poor turtle that we saw
00:23:59 that had a plastic straw in its nose. And of course, it was about the issue,
00:24:06 and it's a serious issue, of plastics in the oceans. The reality, however, is Canada contributes
00:24:12 virtually zero of the plastics that are in the oceans. It comes from a handful of countries,
00:24:18 the usual polluter nations, the Chinas, the Indias, Africa, and so on. And again, this has
00:24:27 been driven by a PR campaign not a tangible need and the plastics industry just to give them their
00:24:36 due has done immense work on recycling there's very sophisticated technology that promotes the
00:24:43 recycling of plastic products and the reuse of them as well so it's it's you know the so-called
00:24:48 circular economy kind of thing and and that of course isn't acknowledged at all so you the
00:24:54 comment you made earlier we just came through a pandemic where plastics basically saved us
00:25:00 in the medical of course in the medical field they're irreplaceable um and in food in food
00:25:06 service they're irreplaceable so one i i saw some quote from someone from the restaurant sector
00:25:12 saying how what am i going to do with soup i can't put soup in a plastic in a paper box or whatever
00:25:20 And what strikes me, though, at a time when we have a pretty dysfunctional economy in Canada
00:25:26 right now, people can't get passports. We have an immigration system that has a waiting list of
00:25:33 over four years, for goodness sakes. We have our airports are dysfunctional. We see governments
00:25:39 in debt up to their eyeballs, notably the federal government. This is going to add to the dysfunction.
00:25:45 The poor restaurant sector that got hammered during the pandemic, they're scrambling to get even plastic containers for takeout.
00:25:54 And of course, takeout is still hugely popular, and part of that is a hangover from the pandemic.
00:25:59 So this is simply going to add to inflation for consumers and add to more dysfunction in our economy for the very important food service sector.
00:26:09 Really, it defies belief that at a time like this, there aren't bigger priorities for our government than some virtue signaling announcement about paper or plastic bags, takeout bags in grocery stores and plastic straws.
00:26:22 Yeah, I mean, you mentioned ocean plastic, Catherine, and that's an important topic.
00:26:27 I looked it up just before the show.
00:26:28 There was a massive study a few years ago, and of all the ocean plastic, 90% of it came from 10 rivers, eight of them in Asia, two of them in Africa.
00:26:38 So not one of them in Europe, not one of them in North America, even South America or Oceania.
00:26:43 It was 90% of the ocean plastic just from those rivers alone.
00:26:47 And others are coming from, again, I mean, I went to Thailand a few years ago.
00:26:51 You look out in the water, abandoned fishing equipment, people dumping garbage.
00:26:54 It's not coming from Canadian, American, European industry.
00:26:59 And then we also look at cost here.
00:27:01 So I've been to restaurants that have invested in biodegradable food packaging materials that look and feel like plastic, but they're actually made of plant starch and stuff like that.
00:27:13 And you think, OK, that's a great idea. Their customers want it and they'll pay a premium for that.
00:27:17 But you look at the cost of those things and some of these things are four to 40 times more than the plastic fork or the plastic container than to buy in.
00:27:27 And so that money has to come from somewhere.
00:27:30 And like everything else, is the business that's serving food absorbing the cost or are they passing it on to their consumers and so on?
00:27:37 And this is not just about flipping a switch and using some alternative that comes in that's just as available and just as affordable.
00:27:45 It simply isn't the case.
00:27:47 No, it's not.
00:27:48 And even if it were obtainable, that's the other problem.
00:27:52 We know that we've got supply chain issues in every sector of the economy right now to varying degrees.
00:27:58 And a lot of these alternatives to plastic packaging are not even available for any amount of money.
00:28:05 No, and they're specialized processes that are still being developed that not everyone is doing.
00:28:10 Exactly. And of course, they're in great demand right now as well as the economy comes out of the pandemic.
00:28:15 So, oh, yeah, there's all kinds of issues.
00:28:17 But once again, though, this government has had a track record of making the big grandiose
00:28:24 announcement. Guibo, Environment Minister Guibo was on a beach in Quebec when he made this
00:28:29 announcement. Well, that was no accident. He wanted to remind everybody about that turtle.
00:28:34 That's why he was on the beach. But there's no follow through. There's no sensible saying,
00:28:41 okay, we have all these plastics that do perform an important role in our society. So what are we
00:28:47 going to replace them with? Should we have some kind of a period of adjustment and so on? And as
00:28:52 you noted off the top, and I don't think this was an accident, a lot of these measures are geared
00:28:58 for late 2025 when, hey, coincidentally, the agreement between the NDP and the Liberals is
00:29:07 expiring. And is this something that maybe the Liberals think, oh, we'll lay this little trap
00:29:12 for a future potential Conservative government, because they'll look like bad guys down the road
00:29:18 if they try to reverse this policy. So this is pure politics. We all want to do something
00:29:24 sensible for the environment. But let's do something that actually has a positive impact.
00:29:30 It doesn't just let some minister stand up and flap his gums and pretend to be doing something
00:29:36 useful. I know your coalition works with a lot of manufacturers. It's in the name. And I should
00:29:41 say, by the way, we were very privileged, True North, to be honored at your most recent dinner
00:29:46 among independent journalists and media outlets in Canada. And I know I mentioned it on the show
00:29:50 a few weeks back, but thank you again for that, Catherine. But I will say, are manufacturers in
00:29:56 the plastic space able to pivot to industrial plastics and move on from this? Or are there
00:30:02 manufacturers that just focus on these sorts of consumer plastics, whose production is basically
00:30:07 being outlawed now? Well, both actually, because there's some, and this is something that I think
00:30:13 a lot of people don't understand, is that we start to ban, and a ban is ludicrous in this case,
00:30:19 but when you start to actually ban outright certain types of plastics, it does affect the
00:30:24 manufacture of other types of plastics that I think your average person would go, well, I can
00:30:29 do without a grocery bag, but boy, that syringe they use, that disposable syringe that's made out
00:30:38 of nice, clean, pristine plastic, I can't do without that. It also affects those other plastic
00:30:44 products because they are manufactured by some of the same companies. But there are also some
00:30:49 manufacturers who only produce some of these limited products. I think too, there's been
00:30:56 quite a lot of investment in recyclable, decomposable plastic products. Plastic bags are
00:31:03 a good example. They are somewhat more expensive, but there's been a lot of progress made. What
00:31:08 happens to those? Are they suddenly not allowed anymore either, even though there's a lot of
00:31:13 science that's gotten into them to ensure that they are able to be composted? So there's so many
00:31:19 aspects to this. It's a simplistic announcement that won't accomplish what it's supposedly going
00:31:25 to accomplish. But again, you've got a nice flamboyant announcement by the minister and
00:31:31 some people that don't know all the nuances of the issue are going to think it's actually
00:31:35 effective. Paper straws, I think, are one of the most absurd creations known to man because
00:31:43 they don't work. I mean, anyone who's ever used a paper straw, if you nurse your drink for more
00:31:48 than 10 minutes, your paper straw will disintegrate in real time and cease to be of value to you.
00:31:53 but I think there's something to that because it shows the shortcomings of what on the surface
00:31:59 might seem like it's a workable idea. But in practice, like you mentioned earlier,
00:32:05 you can't put soup in a paper bowl. You can't, I mean, maybe everyone will have to do that with
00:32:08 Tim Hortons tried to do years ago and serve them in the bread bowls, which are, you know,
00:32:12 soggy by the end of it, but at least, you know, they don't just melt away like the paper does,
00:32:16 but it sounds good on the surface and there's no thought as to the application in there and that's
00:32:25 i think the big problem here is that all of a sudden the government's just signing this fiat
00:32:28 that will fall on everyone else to figure out and it's not going to work no and you're absolutely
00:32:35 right there's some quite unintended consequences i think it was starbucks that to eliminate some
00:32:41 plastic uh in a in a lid design they had they came up with some cup that kind of had almost like a
00:32:48 sippy cup type oh yeah yeah the starbucks sippy cup it makes you feel like you're four
00:32:52 than the original cup was so yeah it when you don't think through policies when you just want
00:33:00 that big pr splash and you don't really worry about how it's gonna be implemented or what the
00:33:06 true impacts are going to be after the fact these are the kind of weird uh weird outcomes that you
00:33:10 get. And I'll guarantee you this policy is going to have a whole bunch of them. There's many,
00:33:17 many better ways to go about sensible environmental policy. And sadly, this isn't one of them.
00:33:24 One thing that struck me, and I don't know when it was within the last year or two,
00:33:29 McDonald's decided they would start doing the paper straw thing nationally in Canada. And
00:33:34 McDonald's is like up there with Walmart as far as just being one of the most hated corporations
00:33:38 in the world. So when McDonald's sold out to Big Paper Straw, I was like, they're never going to
00:33:43 love you. Like the people that hate you are never going to love you. But you know what, if their
00:33:47 consumers wanted it, their consumers wanted it. There was something that struck me about that.
00:33:51 A lot of these companies have flipped over to these things without government intervention at
00:33:56 all. Now, maybe it's because they just saw the writing on the wall and wanted to be prepared
00:33:59 before the regulation happens. Or maybe it's because they feel that there is a value to their
00:34:04 business and doing it. But if it is the latter, and I think it is, because again, I've been to
00:34:09 small independent restaurants that have done that sort of alternative packaging and plant-based
00:34:15 cutlery thing before, and they do that because their consumers want that. It strikes me that
00:34:20 even if this is the way things are headed, society will move business there in a much
00:34:25 more realistic timeframe than regulation will. Oh yeah. And probably with better outcomes as
00:34:31 well, because you'll leave it up to businesses to do the sort of sensible things that are actually
00:34:36 doable and affordable. Because ultimately, yeah, consumers are going to pay for all of this one
00:34:40 way or the other. And we already have enough inflationary pressure right now. Goodness knows
00:34:44 we don't need any more. But it's kind of like what I said at the outset. You have these policies
00:34:50 that are not measured. That's the other thing. You've got to measure them. And societal impacts,
00:34:56 when you look at things like smoking in society, they showed that societal viewpoints had a lot
00:35:02 more impact on people quitting smoking than any kind of regulation or diktats from any government 0.99
00:35:09 or stupid warnings. Of course, they're now increasing our warnings apparently on every 0.96
00:35:13 single cigarette, so I hear. And no, changing views in society. And there's a lot of things
00:35:18 that do feed into that, of course, that do change people's views. But I mean, I've always been a
00:35:24 stickler for measurement. If you want to announce a policy you say is going to accomplish X,
00:35:29 whatever that may be, then let's measure it a couple, three, four, five years from now.
00:35:34 Government never does that. And they never do it for a reason because they know their policies
00:35:40 are not accomplishing the goals they claim they are. Yeah. You mentioned the cigarette thing.
00:35:46 The government wants to know it's not enough now to put the health warning on the box. They want
00:35:51 to print it like on the cigarette itself so you can't like take an individual cigarette without
00:35:55 seeing this you know this thing is going to kill you and then i also saw last week that health
00:36:00 canada wants to slap warning labels on ground beef and ground pork because they're not whole
00:36:05 products so they want to put health warnings on that so anytime you go and get some ground beef
00:36:10 to i don't know make meatballs or spaghetti sauce or your own hamburger patties you're going to get
00:36:14 the government screaming at you that this is going to kill you and i i think we're probably there
00:36:19 near there with plastic like where they're just going to put like you know they're going to like
00:36:23 etch some little warning on the plastic spoon so that just as you're bringing it up to your mouth
00:36:27 you can get a glimmer through your minestrone soup there that you know this is going to kill
00:36:31 a baby turtle and then you just put it down and uh use your hands i mean this is what we're all
00:36:35 headed towards yeah i gotta figure you know the health canada bureaucrats badly botched any
00:36:41 pandemic management they screwed that up royally uh they gotta have way too much time on their 0.95
00:36:47 hands they're not doing the jobs they should do uh but why they're getting into such dumb things 0.89
00:36:52 as labeling cigarettes causing saying ground beef there you know label you have to put it on the
00:36:57 cover of a ground beef package that it's uh it could be harmful to your health at a time when
00:37:02 ground beef is probably one of the more affordable meat products that most families can manage to buy
00:37:07 these days uh also it is a it is a industry based in alberta and let's not forget that alberta
00:37:14 doesn't vote liberal and therefore richly deserves to be punished at every turn so that's another
00:37:19 that's another factor that's attached to that too but once again if we have yeah you know you raise
00:37:25 an important point there and the more i see this like i i file just on a completely unrelated note
00:37:30 i filed over two years ago and accessed information request with health canada about something that
00:37:35 i've now forgotten about and they said oh no no our health canada staff are too busy to process
00:37:40 this with the COVID management. And I'm thinking, well, you're having enough time to start talking
00:37:44 about warning labels on ground beef. So maybe the pandemic truly is over. Catherine Swift joining me
00:37:50 on the line, who is the fantastic president of the Coalition of Concerned Manufacturers and
00:37:56 Businesses of Canada. Catherine, thanks so much for your time as always. Thank you, Andrew. Always a
00:38:01 pleasure, Andrew. All right. That was Catherine Swift. And just before we wrap things out here,
00:38:05 I've had people messaging me throughout the show. I haven't read them all saying, what am I
00:38:10 going to do I don't know how I'm going to live without plastics again I've given you the answer
00:38:14 I will give you the answer again but all is not lost we've got alternatives
00:38:18 we have recently switched to drinking water bottles out of water out of when we have water
00:38:28 bottles out of a plastic sorry away from plastic towards paper like drink box water bottles sort of
00:38:37 things see we laughed at the time but that's all we're gonna get in the next little while is drink
00:38:43 water paper box bottle water bottle bottle bottle drink box things things so that's what we're that's
00:38:49 the only thing that will be legal in canada by 2025 gotta end it there my thanks to all of you
00:38:55 for tuning in to the andrew lawton show a reminder the book comes out on friday the freedom convoy
00:39:00 the inside story of three weeks that shook the world we've been an amazon bestseller since we
00:39:05 announced it, although we've gone up and down in the ratings. So if you haven't pre-ordered your
00:39:09 copy yet, do head on over there and see if we can get back up to where we were and perhaps even
00:39:14 crack number one. We haven't gone higher than number two yet. So I hope you do that. And if
00:39:19 you get the book on Friday, let me know what you think about it. Unless you didn't like it,
00:39:23 then don't let me know. But I hope you like it. With that, we'll bid you adieu and talk to you
00:39:27 later this week, folks. The Andrew Lawton Show on True North. Thank you. God bless and good day to
00:39:32 all for listening to the andrew lawton show support the program by donating to true north at www.tnc.news