Juno News - June 26, 2023


Trudeau's internet takeover is well under way

Topics
Mentioned
Inside AHS’ bid to rehire Deena Hinshaw This will end badly for Toronto

Episode Stats


Length

35 minutes

Words per minute

180.55

Word count

6,448

Sentence count

235

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A rare Monday edition of The Andrew Lawton Show, where we talk about a proposed class action against the Canadian Armed Forces over the use of vaccines by the military, and the takeover of the internet by the government of Justin Trudeau.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:12 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:14 This is Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, the Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North.
00:00:19 On this Monday, June 26, 2023, a rare Monday edition of the program.
00:00:25 I am going to be off to cover something tomorrow.
00:00:29 so we rejigged the schedule and I thank my colleague Harrison Faulkner for being his
00:00:34 flexible self to make that happen you'll get ratioed on track tomorrow instead of the usual
00:00:40 spot today but I am going to talk a little bit later on about this big news story that has
00:00:45 emerged in the past week a proposed class action filed against the Canadian Armed Forces over the
00:00:51 vaccine mandate we spoke with Valor Law lawyer Catherine Christensen about this a couple of
00:00:57 months back it was when this was first floated and now we have a statement of claim that's been
00:01:01 filed so we will have Catherine back on the show and talk about that in a fair bit of detail I also
00:01:08 want to delve into the takeover of the internet which I do not say lightly I'm actually contrary
00:01:16 to what some of our critics on the left may think I'm not prone to exaggeration I try to be very
00:01:21 reasoned and nuanced and measured with my words, but there is no other argument for what is
00:01:27 happening right now than that Justin Trudeau is attempting a broad-scale takeover of the internet
00:01:34 and of the way we use the internet in this country. I said this when C11 passed a couple of months
00:01:39 back. This is the bill that allows the government to manipulate the algorithms of your YouTube and
00:01:45 your netflix and your spotify and i restate it with more support now that bill c18 has passed
00:01:52 now c18 is the government's attempt to subsidize the media without taxpayer money that's basically
00:02:01 the argument here so what the government has done is they've said uh okay uh facebook twitter
00:02:07 youtube you guys are stealing news content you're stealing it you're thieves how well you know when
00:02:14 people go on Facebook and Google and Twitter and they see links to news articles, that's apparently
00:02:22 theft. Hmm. Yeah, I'm not sure how that works. But that was Heritage Minister Stephen Gilbeau's
00:02:30 argument. This is what the government has committed to. This is what the News Media Council of Canada
00:02:36 has committed to. This idea that there is rampant theft of Canadian news content. Now, frankly, I
00:02:41 cover a lot of news outlets in Canada and there's not much worth stealing there but nevertheless
00:02:47 the arguments are a little bit hollow so what Facebook did is called the bluff they said okay
00:02:53 if you think we're stealing what we're going to do is if you pass Bill C-18 that says we have to pay
00:02:59 for this content that we aren't even asking for that other people are posting we'll just block
00:03:05 it all together no theft here none not in this fine establishment so Facebook said this and what
00:03:11 did Stephen Gilbeau say? Well, you're thieves. You're bullies. You're bullies now. You were 0.99
00:03:16 thieves. Now you're bullies. The news media industry was saying, oh, you're bullying us. 0.99
00:03:21 Hmm. So which is it? Are they stealing from you when they allow news content or are they
00:03:28 bullying you when they block news content? It stands to reason if you think that someone is
00:03:33 stealing something from you and you tell them to stop and they stop, like they are actually giving
00:03:37 you what you wanted or maybe all of this is a roundabout way a roundabout way of not actually
00:03:45 preventing any sort of theft but just extorting money extorting money from the government and
00:03:52 that is what exactly what's happening here but instead of the government giving another 600
00:03:56 billion dollar bailout or you know the 1.4 billion cbc gets the government said all right facebook
00:04:01 Google you guys have got a lot of money we'll let you just fund the bailout for the media so
00:04:07 as it stands Facebook has said it's going to make good on this promise there is going to come a time
00:04:12 when a switch is flipped and if you share a link to a news story on Facebook it will not go there
00:04:20 remember when the New York Post article about Hunter Biden's laptop was being blocked by
00:04:26 Twitter. Yeah, it may actually be like that for any news you want to share. Now, what this will
00:04:32 look like, I don't know. There is a big question about what Facebook decides to categorize as news.
00:04:38 One idea that I would love to see, and I don't know if this is an option, but I would certainly
00:04:42 for my own sub stack, I don't speak for True North, do this, is go to Facebook and say,
00:04:46 I would like to opt out of this whole thing. I will waive any claim I have to money from you
00:04:52 just to be allowed to post.
00:04:56 And imagine if all of the independent media outlets in Canada did that
00:04:59 and all of a sudden on Facebook the only media outlets allowed to post
00:05:02 are the ones who aren't trying to extort from them large sums of money
00:05:06 like the Toronto Sun and the Toronto Star and the National Post,
00:05:10 even Post Media is included in this, are trying to do.
00:05:14 That would be my little dream on this
00:05:16 and we'll see if that is something that might be brought into fruition in the coming months.
00:05:21 But Facebook is not backing down and it's not particularly surprising because I think that they need to send a shot across the bow before any other country, including the US, the European Union, starts to try the same stuff that Canada is doing when there are going to be far more zeros after whatever that sum ends up being in a Canadian context.
00:05:43 So I've said time and time again on this show, I do not love big tech.
00:05:47 I actually have grave concerns with big tech.
00:05:49 I have been shadow banned on Twitter.
00:05:52 I have had, even on this very show, strikes from YouTube on a number of things.
00:05:56 We had the MyPillow guy, Mike Lindell, on, and we were talking about faith and pillows.
00:06:03 And YouTube gave us a strike because, you know, Mike Lindell happened to have been a bad guy that week or something.
00:06:09 I had an interview with Danielle Smith when she was running for the leadership of the UCP, which months later, and by this point she was already the premier, was retroactively given a strike because in that interview she made an innocuous claim that I'm nervous about repeating right now, which was that there are some people who are pro-life activists that don't like the COVID vaccine because they have an objection to something that if I say this episode will be vaporized,
00:06:39 because that's the reality of YouTube.
00:06:42 So I understand the perils of big tech censorship
00:06:45 better than many other people
00:06:47 because we have to, as an outlet that wants to share our work
00:06:51 and uses as part of that strategy,
00:06:54 Facebook and Twitter and by extension also Rumble
00:06:57 and all of that and YouTube,
00:06:58 all of this is to say I get it.
00:07:01 But even so, in a battle between big government and big tech,
00:07:05 I am going to side against the government.
00:07:08 I want the government to lose because the very worst thing that can happen is when those two
00:07:13 forces coalesce. And what Facebook is doing right now for all of its faults as a company
00:07:18 is saying that it doesn't want to play ball with the Trudefication of the internet. And why that
00:07:25 is so crucial is because the Trudeopian takeover of the internet is nowhere near over. It started 1.00
00:07:31 with Bill C-11. Now we have Bill C-18. There are two other bills that will be coming down the
00:07:37 pipeline that the government has promised that don't yet have numbers, that don't have names,
00:07:41 but we know are coming and we know are going to be even more dangerous. One is a bill that
00:07:46 amends the Canadian Human Rights Act to institute the return of Section 13, which is a bill that
00:07:53 allows for the government to prosecute for online hate speech. But I put it in quotation marks
00:08:00 because the criminal code already has a definition of hate speech and it has, as it should, a very
00:08:07 very high threshold which the Canadian Human Rights Act definition lowers. It becomes a lower
00:08:13 threshold for hate speech and it allows specifically for the prosecution of so-called
00:08:19 hate speech disseminated online. Now this is a culture in which using the wrong pronouns
00:08:24 is positioned by some to be hate speech. This is a climate in which we have a whole of government
00:08:30 approach to reigning in quote-unquote Islamophobia. All of this stuff is not a question of whether
00:08:36 certain forms of expression are bad or uncivil or impolite or even offensive, but whether we want
00:08:43 the government to be regulating this expression. And no, I do not trust government to come up with
00:08:48 a definition of hate that does not censor mere disagreeable speech. So that's one. And the other
00:08:54 is tied to that very intricately, a so-called online safety bill that will put the purview of
00:09:01 safetying the internet, to use a verb that I'm making up here, in the government's hands.
00:09:08 And they talk about this in the most agreeable way possible. They'll say, well, we need to
00:09:13 protect the internet. There could be, for example, terrorist beheadings and child pornography. And
00:09:20 I'm like, yeah, those things are terrible. Don't like those, don't want those. And hate speech.
00:09:23 Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Why are we talking about all of these things as though they're the same
00:09:29 thing because generally speaking, you're going to find 100%, well, 99.99% of people in this country
00:09:36 that will support doing everything possible to rid the internet of child pornography. Those who
00:09:42 don't support that are the ones that need to be reined in most. You will have a fairly broad
00:09:48 consensus on getting rid of terror propaganda on the internet. Again, you have to be very careful
00:09:53 about how you define it and how you characterize it
00:09:56 and what free speech is and when it is no longer that.
00:09:59 But when you start to go on hate speech,
00:10:03 you get back to that very same problem I was just describing
00:10:06 where a murky definition that means different things to different people
00:10:09 and will necessarily involve government becoming the arbiter
00:10:14 of what you can say and do online.
00:10:18 So when government gets its way,
00:10:20 it will not just control the algorithms,
00:10:23 it will control the business models, and it will even control the boundaries of online discourse,
00:10:30 the bounds of debate. So you can have government-approved content, you can have government-approved
00:10:34 words, and government-approved opinions. And this is not conjecture on my part. This is even
00:10:41 becoming heavily criticized by advocacy groups on the left, like Open Media, which is not a fire-breathing
00:10:47 conservative group. In fact, I disagree with the folks at Open Media on a lot, but they understand
00:10:53 fundamentally what Justin Trudeau doesn't, which is that the internet is meant to be an open
00:10:58 environment, not something with a government gatekeeper controlling it. So Bill C-18 is not
00:11:04 just about propping up dying legacy media outlets whose business models have not adapted to the
00:11:10 modern era. It is one step of a multi-step process of Justin Trudeau taking over the internet and do
00:11:17 not let anyone tell you otherwise least of all those who are invested in this power grab and
00:11:22 i'm looking at you justin trudeau and stephen gilbeau want to move to the other issue i
00:11:27 mentioned a couple of moments ago which is a very big one and well we can look at the situation in
00:11:32 canada and say oh yes the lockdowns are done the covid mandates are done that's all the past
00:11:38 for people who were targeted by these things it is not at all over and there is one group
00:11:44 in particular who had a hugely offensive and insulting treatment by the government on this
00:11:52 and that was Canadian soldiers members of the Canadian Armed Forces who were subject like
00:11:58 everyone else in the public sector in Canada to vaccine mandates but it was particularly
00:12:03 stinging for this group who have given so much and continue to give so much in pursuit of Canada
00:12:09 to fight for Canada.
00:12:11 They wear a uniform and put their own lives on the line
00:12:14 to fight for their country and the ideas and ideals
00:12:17 that this country represents.
00:12:19 But Justin Trudeau looked at the military and said,
00:12:21 you guys are not fit for service if you don't get the COVID jab.
00:12:26 This was the decision that they had to make
00:12:28 to either get vaccinated or leave.
00:12:31 And this was not an easy decision.
00:12:33 And again, it's not just exclusive to the military.
00:12:36 It was also true of airline pilots, of federal public servants, and frankly, of anyone who wanted to get on an airplane or a train.
00:12:44 But for members of the Canadian Armed Forces, I'm reminded of that exchange when Justin Trudeau told, I can't remember if he was a soldier or a veteran.
00:12:52 I think he had left the military by then at a Q&A that veterans were asking for more than the government could give them.
00:13:00 And it's amazing when you remember that, remember that exchange,
00:13:05 remember that line that the government had, that Trudeau had,
00:13:08 how unsurprising it is to see the broader treatment of members of the military.
00:13:13 But as we talked about a couple of months ago on this show,
00:13:17 there are some that are not prepared to just ignore this and move on.
00:13:21 There is now a proposed class action lawsuit that has been filed,
00:13:25 and the lawyer representing the class is Catherine Christensen,
00:13:28 who's the founder of Valor Law and joins me now.
00:13:32 Catherine, it is good to talk to you again.
00:13:33 Thanks very much for coming back on the show today.
00:13:36 Hi, Andrew. It's great to be back.
00:13:38 So let's just start here.
00:13:40 You've got 330-some-odd current and former members that are in this right now,
00:13:46 but the number you're actually representing is much larger than that, is it not?
00:13:51 There is.
00:13:51 Now, one thing I want to clarify is this is not actually a class action.
00:13:55 It's a mass tort.
00:13:56 Okay, I apologize.
00:13:57 I was going based on a media report that got it wrong there, but I thank you for setting that
00:14:02 straight. What is that difference actually for people that don't know? Yeah. So a mass tort is
00:14:06 seeking relief. So what we're asking for from the government, just for those people that are named
00:14:13 in the lawsuit as plaintiffs, a class action on the other hand has a example plaintiffs that if
00:14:20 you match that person, then you're part of that class and you can get compensation through that
00:14:25 without ever actually taking legal action yourself um so this is a mass tort 329 i know
00:14:33 there was discussion previously of a class action there was uh the reason that we decided to go this
00:14:39 route was because these people were the ones that stood up in october of 2021 uh they have stayed
00:14:46 hard and fast that they wanted to hold the chief of defense staff and and the canadian
00:14:52 our forces to account uh for abusing their power and so the decision was made by the group that
00:14:57 they would do it as a mass tort versus a class action now we're talking about hundreds of
00:15:03 people that are known right now there is still a group out there that we don't yet know about
00:15:08 and what i'm hearing from them pardon me i'm hearing from them well you are and what bothers
00:15:14 me so much about this is that there are two well more than two but two in particular types that
00:15:20 stand out here there are those who were faced with this mandate that for whatever reason didn't want
00:15:25 to get vaccinated and did and kept their jobs and that was the only way they kept their jobs and
00:15:30 continued to serve and and those who still wouldn't and said okay i i have to leave and and the
00:15:36 government views by design that first group as being a success they view that as being great
00:15:42 we we told them they had to do this and they did it well here's the thing is that the people that
00:15:49 left the canadian armed forces they were some were forced to leave they chose to leave under a
00:15:54 voluntary release but there's a large group of them that were released under what's called a 5f
00:15:59 unsuitable for further service this is the release category that if you are a drunk or a drug addict
00:16:05 who won't get rehabilitated you're a domestic violence offender your sexual you've been found 0.87
00:16:13 to be guilty of sexual assault this is the category they released those people under
00:16:17 So it wasn't just a fact that they chose to lose their jobs. When they lost their jobs,
00:16:22 they lost them under what used to be called a dishonorable discharge. And in fact, several
00:16:27 members of the chain of command told them it was a dishonorable discharge and that there's
00:16:32 implications for it. Like for instance, they can't re-enroll in the Canadian Armed Forces without
00:16:36 the Chief of Defence Staff permission and they have to wait five years. They cannot apply for
00:16:41 any federal government job because they're not going to get it for being released under this.
00:16:45 they call it honorable now but like i said it's it's it's a real black mark on their record so
00:16:51 it was a big choice they had to make because it limited what they could do even out of the armed
00:16:56 forces well and also what i find so troubling about all of this is that it would be one thing
00:17:03 if the military had this rule that you have to be vaccinated against covid to join the armed forces
00:17:08 and i would still oppose that but they would at least have some transparency there about what the
00:17:13 rules are when you join in this particular case you have people that are being threatened their
00:17:19 careers are being threatened and jeopardized for non-compliance with a rule that never existed
00:17:23 when they joined and hadn't existed for the however many years they'd been in service but
00:17:28 one day with a stroke of a pen did and it's as though you're right they've committed some heinous
00:17:33 act in uniform if they don't go along with this rule that they never could have conceived of when
00:17:38 they first joined right so under the national defense act section 126 the chief of defense
00:17:43 staff has the power to uh force a vaccination on on members of the forces however they are allowed
00:17:52 to say no they then face face a court martial and if they are found to have a reasonable excuse for
00:17:59 not taking it then they're acquitted and they're they're then have to be accommodated he chose not
00:18:05 to use section 126 and he has been reprimanded for that by the review grievance review committee
00:18:12 because they first of all they couldn't have withstood three to five thousand courts martial
00:18:19 the jag office just isn't that big and the other is they couldn't risk one win because one win
00:18:25 would put it into law that he can't do what he just did so they chose an administrative route
00:18:30 which is how we end up with 5F releases, remedial measures that were accelerated far beyond anything
00:18:38 they had ever done before. But he had been told in a briefing note that I discussed last time I
00:18:44 was on your show that he couldn't do what he is about to do and the external grievance review
00:18:50 committee has actually come out and backed me up on that and said no he couldn't do what he did and
00:18:55 that he breached the charter section seven of the charter uh that freedom to say what happens to
00:19:01 your body and uh he under the national defense act he cannot issue an order that violates the
00:19:07 charter so this is an unlawful order that he issued and that has consequences in the courts
00:19:15 there was i remember it was in august 2021 so the mandate wasn't in effect yet but we
00:19:20 were certainly hearing a lot of discussion about it and i i happened upon this and i
00:19:24 I can't remember how, but on the Department of Defense website, there was a page.
00:19:29 And on this page, it said that the Canadian Armed Forces, quote, cannot require a public servant to get a vaccine, nor is mandatory vaccination supported under Canadian law.
00:19:41 And it added the same thing for members of the Canadian Armed Forces.
00:19:45 And I reported on this on August 18th, 2021.
00:19:48 Two days later, the page had been entirely scrubbed and had none of this.
00:19:53 So, you know, obviously a government website is whoever wrote its perspective of the law,
00:20:00 but it does suggest that the Canadian Armed Forces had been operating up until this mandate
00:20:04 came into effect with this idea that you've just shared, which is that mandatory vaccination
00:20:08 is not just not a policy of the Armed Forces in Canada, but not even legal if they wanted to.
00:20:14 Right.
00:20:15 So there were members who have never taken the flu vaccine, for example, with no repercussions.
00:20:21 I there's a member of the lawsuit who had never had a vaccination in her entire life
00:20:26 and she was serving in the Canadian Armed Forces without any issue until this came along.
00:20:31 So this is why the lawsuit isn't a COVID-19 lawsuit. What I've done is it's I've been
00:20:38 watching the forces for a while there's been a lot of corruption and abuse of power in the ranks
00:20:43 and when he issued this in October 2021 he handed me a perfect example
00:20:49 of how they abuse their power in the chain of command because I've got a nice concrete start
00:20:54 to it October of 2021 and here's what all these people did to their troops along the way until
00:21:00 to the present day and it continues to this present day because the mandate still exists
00:21:05 they still have are required to be vaccinated and the people that are still in who somehow managed
00:21:12 to escape being released through all of this they're now being punished all over again they're
00:21:17 being sent to postings that are going to bankrupt them or are places that they don't want to be
00:21:25 uh we've got pilots that are being sent to fly desks instructor pilots we need instructor pilots
00:21:32 to fulfill well trudeau says he's training uh uh ukrainian pilots but he's got a whole bunch
00:21:39 of instructor pilots that are sitting at desks instead of flying so i'm not sure how he's going
00:21:44 going to accomplish that. Well, for years, the military has had increasing difficulty in
00:21:50 recruiting. And we know that a lot of the standards that have long been established in the military,
00:21:56 I mean, on tattoos, on grooming, on facial hair, on dress, all of these things are being relaxed
00:22:01 because the argument is that, well, you know, we can't afford to discriminate against people with
00:22:06 face tattoos because, you know, there's slim pickings in the recruitment offices. And here
00:22:09 you have people that are not just willing to serve but have been serving and want to even in
00:22:14 spite of this want to continue serving that are being told no because you won't get this vaccine
00:22:20 which has whatever you think about it limited efficacy this long after uh if not negligible
00:22:28 efficacy this long after the mandate required them to have been vaccinated so it's of zero benefit
00:22:34 Right. And these were people at the peak of their careers. We've done kind of a rough calculation. Just of the 300 some people in the lawsuit, they've lost over $3 billion in training and experience from this group that are just in this lawsuit.
00:22:49 So I can't imagine an administrative costs for doing all these releases, people who aren't going to renew their contracts because they didn't like what happened. And now they're seeing that, you know, it was an unlawful order. What else are they going to ask me to do?
00:23:04 billions and billions of dollars have been lost through this whole thing for what is essentially
00:23:10 an unlawful order. And we've got a military right now that says that they're not accountable to the
00:23:15 law. I was in the court, federal court, in February, and the Crown stood up and said,
00:23:20 this court has no jurisdiction over the chief of defense staff in military matters. And I watched
00:23:26 the justices' eyebrow rise, and I thought, oh, really? Well, let's settle that question, because
00:23:32 in my world, the rule of law applies and no one's above the law. I don't care who you are.
00:23:38 So this is part of the questions that are going to have to be answered.
00:23:42 Let me ask you about the morale aspect of this, because, you know, again, I tried to address this
00:23:48 earlier on when I was talking about this before I brought you in, Catherine. The fact of the matter
00:23:53 is, well, I believe the mandates are wrong in general. I do have a particularly smaller
00:24:02 tolerance for jerking around members of the military. And I think in general, Canadians
00:24:06 left and right have, for the most part, supported members of the armed forces. We all really embrace
00:24:14 Remembrance Day. We all really embrace veterans' causes. I remember when the Afghanistan mission
00:24:19 was on, you'd see those yellow ribbons just everywhere on cars and corporations would get
00:24:24 involved. It's one of the safest causes to take up support for the military and support for
00:24:30 veterans, despite, you know, little, you know, squabbling you might get on the fringes on the
00:24:35 left. So when we're talking about something like this to people who have served and continue to
00:24:42 serve, it really stings a lot more than the mandates in some other contexts. And I was
00:24:47 wondering if you just had any reflections on that and how that's been for the people who wear these
00:24:52 uniforms and in some cases would love to still be doing that after all this. I have to tell you
00:24:58 the morale is low um in the canadian armed forces it's and the number of broken people that we have
00:25:05 with mental health issues is uncountable uh i know that in our group of of people uh we've had some
00:25:13 attempted suicides we've managed to save everybody because we've created this really strong group
00:25:19 that we're looking out for each other uh but there ha there has been a real price to this
00:25:26 whole thing uh because there's a lack of trust between the chain of command and people their
00:25:32 troops uh and they were already suffering with some of the changes cultural changes that
00:25:40 the people that were signing on the dotted line to volunteer to serve canada didn't agree with
00:25:46 and were being forced to adjust to it and yeah no uh i'm just seeing more and more broken people who
00:25:54 who even the ones that are still in that took the vaccine, they regret.
00:26:01 They have big, big regrets.
00:26:03 And now since the lawsuit is launched, they're coming forward and we're hearing from them.
00:26:10 And the vaccine injured, I've been getting more and more calls from them as well.
00:26:15 Now, is that a separate legal fight or can that actually be addressed under this same mass tort that you filed here?
00:26:22 I'm going to bring the vaccine injured one separately.
00:26:24 uh because we have to go through veterans affairs canada first they have to see if they can be
00:26:29 uh covered they are not being covered right now by veterans affairs canada they're being told it's
00:26:33 not service related i disagree even though they weren't even though this was a condition of their
00:26:39 service to exactly that otherwise they might not have you don't take it you're out of the military
00:26:43 i'd say that's a service related injury so that battle is ramping up uh we have some quite severe
00:26:49 injuries, there have been some deaths associated with the COVID vaccines. I can tell you officially
00:26:55 that the COVID-19 vaccine killed more troops than COVID did because COVID killed none, zero,
00:27:01 zero people died. Even the ones that were on the front lines in the nursing homes,
00:27:06 nobody died of COVID in uniform. So that's to me, that says a lot. We forced something on people.
00:27:16 i mean they have their own policy that they're not supposed to vaccinate pregnant women and they
00:27:20 they were still i had women that were one day away from maternity leave being pressured 1.00
00:27:25 to uh take to take the injections so uh you know they didn't stop well and i think when you
00:27:33 mention that and it's absolutely horrific and i i followed in particular a lot of the the the
00:27:38 vaccine injury cases in the united kingdom where i think they had a larger problem because of the
00:27:43 the particular vaccines they were pushing there and how widely they were. And in a Canadian context,
00:27:48 we certainly don't hear these stories. And I think it all goes around to the idea of why
00:27:53 choice is so central and why choice is so pivotal here. And if, you know, someone wants to look at
00:27:59 the situation and say, you know, I'm balancing this, I'm weighing this, and here's what I decide,
00:28:04 we should be encouraging that. And I wanted to ask just because we sort of glossed over it
00:28:08 earlier, but accommodations, because anytime these mandates were in place, the argument that was put
00:28:13 as well, yes, of course, you know, if you absolutely need for medical reasons or religious
00:28:18 reasons to get an exemption, you'll be able to, but it's never been as easy as they make it seem.
00:28:23 And I know in universities and the public service, they fought tooth and nail against this.
00:28:28 I'm assuming from your nodding that that was the same in the Canadian Armed Forces, that exemptions
00:28:32 were basically not easy to get, if at all. That's very true. There were very, very few that were
00:28:38 are actually granted. And lots of times it was because maybe they were a couple months
00:28:44 out from a Tarabi medical release. So they were being released for injuries. And so they
00:28:50 all will accommodate you for a couple months while you're in the transition center type
00:28:54 of thing. We had here in Edmonton, CFB Edmonton, Rutland, he was a colonel at the time. He's
00:29:01 a brigadier general now. He's one of the named defendants. He set up a board to review every
00:29:07 single accommodation request because he wasn't happy that some of his CEOs were granting
00:29:12 accommodations so they all had to go through this board and one of in one of his decisions he has
00:29:18 written that on a balance of probabilities your religion won't be harmed by taking it
00:29:23 and I'm looking at this and I'm thinking what so he's thrown a legal term in there balance
00:29:29 of probabilities but how how is he in a position to decide if someone's faith has been injured
00:29:36 or harmed by taking this.
00:29:41 I mean, it's gibberish,
00:29:42 but it's also showing you the arrogance of it.
00:29:45 Well, this won't harm your faith.
00:29:47 Well, that's not his call to make.
00:29:49 That's the individual's call to make.
00:29:51 And our Supreme Court begs to differ with him
00:29:53 about what you're supposed to do
00:29:55 with someone's religious beliefs.
00:29:58 You know, and this is the military
00:29:59 that has long embraced
00:30:01 a specific dress issue turban.
00:30:04 If you're a Sikh, you can wear your hijab in your uniform if you are a Muslim.
00:30:09 So this idea of religious accommodations is not new.
00:30:13 But it's amazing that all of a sudden it's, well, maybe we get to decide how your religious practice really needs to manifest here.
00:30:20 I mean, I don't trust these people to be theologians any more than I trust them to be charter interpreters at this point.
00:30:26 Right. Well, and I mean, the chaplain general basically came out and said that there are 25 recognized religions in the CAF.
00:30:34 Oh, really? I didn't know we were putting limits on what religion was what in Canada. That's not
00:30:41 what the Supreme Court said. So I found that a very interesting piece of information as well.
00:30:46 And these are things that they put in writing. This is the problem, Andrew, is the arrogance
00:30:51 and the feeling like they're absolutely untouchable. If this lawsuit does nothing
00:30:57 else, I hope it shows them that they're not as untouchable as they think they are.
00:31:00 Now, you mentioned earlier the loss here of billions of dollars in lost wages and training.
00:31:07 What is the ask? What is it you want to get out of this?
00:31:09 So in total, we are asking for approximately $500 million for 329 people.
00:31:17 There is a $1 million ask for each person and then some other asks as well for special damages.
00:31:25 But we have also got several other claims.
00:31:28 there's 30 claims here, and some of them are declarations. The ask for funds is maybe three
00:31:35 of the 30. The rest is all asking for, for instance, for the order to be declared unlawful
00:31:41 by a court so that the release category can be changed, so that people remove that black mark
00:31:48 of a 5F, asking for them to take another look at their grievance system, because how can you have 1.00
00:31:55 the guy who wrote the order and and demanded the order being the same guy that decides if you've
00:32:00 been grieved or not because that's what happened cds issued it he's the one you have to grieve
00:32:07 to say it's wrong but he's the one that makes the decision on whether it was wrong
00:32:11 so there's things like that in there where uh my my people are saying that the money is one
00:32:18 thing but that's not the main focus of this it's culture change they want to change what's happening
00:32:23 in the Canadian Armed Forces
00:32:24 and they're willing to stand up
00:32:25 and put their names on paper
00:32:27 and say, this has got to change
00:32:29 that the abuse of power
00:32:31 at the top is over.
00:32:34 Catherine Christensen from Valor Law.
00:32:36 Thank you so much for coming on today.
00:32:37 Great to talk to you again.
00:32:38 Great to talk to you too, Andrew.
00:32:39 Thank you for having me on.
00:32:41 All right, thank you.
00:32:42 That was Catherine Christensen.
00:32:43 Do follow this.
00:32:44 We will keep you up on it
00:32:45 in the course of our work at True North
00:32:47 and let you know how that navigates
00:32:49 its way through the justice system,
00:32:51 which as we talked about
00:32:52 a couple of weeks ago
00:32:53 with Bruce Party is not perfect.
00:32:54 It has a lot of flaws and a lot of faults,
00:32:56 but I do think we need to be fighting these battles
00:32:58 on multiple fronts.
00:32:59 One is in the media
00:33:00 and one is certainly in the courts
00:33:02 and you have to win hearts and minds,
00:33:04 but you also have to win in the legal front as well.
00:33:08 So let's just, before we wrap up here,
00:33:10 I got to talk about this
00:33:11 and I try not to put too much stock
00:33:14 into what the Toronto Star is putting out
00:33:16 on a given, on a daily basis,
00:33:18 except insofar as it makes for good comedy.
00:33:21 This column is a bit of a fun one.
00:33:23 Chantelle Berry yesterday writes,
00:33:25 Pierre Polyev is becoming a liability to conservatives.
00:33:31 Pierre Polyev is a liability to conservatives.
00:33:33 Now, this is a little odd for a guy who won the most decisive mandate from conservative members
00:33:40 and has continued to enjoy increased popularity since becoming leader
00:33:43 while Justin Trudeau's popularity is in the toilet.
00:33:46 Now, I know some people watching the show are Polyev fans.
00:33:49 other people are not, but surely we can agree that people who have never voted conservative in
00:33:55 their lives, and likely never will, are not the ones that we should be listening to when it comes
00:34:01 to defining what a conservative is supposed to be. She is doing this whole sort of like weird
00:34:08 palace intrigue horse race thing about how the conservatives are not exactly able to return to
00:34:15 the government benches, and Pierre Polyev is the reason why, because these people's ideal
00:34:20 conservative is Aaron O'Toole. And we know that if Aaron O'Toole were the leader of the conservatives,
00:34:25 they would actually win a majority government against Justin Trudeau. Wait, what's that?
00:34:31 Oh, he lost. We did that. Okay, but he must not have been running as like a left-wing guy, right?
00:34:37 No, he was. Oh, weird. So they want Pierre Polyev to be more of a red Tory so that he could do as
00:34:44 astonishingly well as the Red Tory, the Conservatives ran in 2021 on the carbon tax
00:34:50 plan did. Well, that is sure to win us over. So let me just tell you, anyone who takes their
00:34:56 cues from the Toronto Star on how to be a Conservative is not actually a Conservative
00:35:01 at all. And you can take that to the bank. It's worth a little more than an issue of the Toronto
00:35:06 Star you take to the bank. So that does it for us for today. I want to give a big thank you to all
00:35:10 of you who tuned in we will be back on
00:35:12 Wednesday from an undisclosed
00:35:14 location I'll disclose it on Wednesday
00:35:16 and I'll tell you all about it
00:35:18 I'm overselling it it's not that great but
00:35:20 we are going to get a little bit of coverage out of it
00:35:22 so that's all coming up in the week
00:35:24 ahead and we are going to on Friday
00:35:26 have a special pre-Canada Day
00:35:28 edition of the show we are going to
00:35:30 talk to a couple of great folks about the
00:35:32 uncancellation of Canadian history
00:35:34 following up on the chat we had with
00:35:36 Mark Milkey last week so lots of good stuff
00:35:38 planned. We will talk to you soon, folks. Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.