Juno News - March 04, 2024


Trudeau's "online harms" bill is an all-out assault on free speech

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Fixing Hungary's fertility crisis - Miklós Szántó, CPAC Hungary chairman Canadian Police FAILED to protect an event with G7 Leaders

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

164.74

Word count

7,486

Sentence count

378

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Andrew Lawton returns from his trip to the Mark Stein Cruise and talks about Bill C-63, the government's proposed legislation that could see Canada outlaw all forms of hate speech on the internet.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show
00:01:15 this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true north
00:01:20 hello and welcome to you all i was gonna say welcome back but i guess i'm the one
00:01:29 coming back. So I hope you are all telling me welcome back or you're wondering who the heck
00:01:33 is this guy. This is The Andrew Lawton Show, Canada's most irreverent talk show here on
00:01:38 True North. I am, of course, as the name of the show would suggest, Andrew Lawton. I was
00:01:43 away last week. I don't even know if I want to tell you what I was doing because you might just
00:01:47 hold me in deep contempt or have some resentment. But I was doing the very heavy, very difficult,
00:01:53 very tough assignment. I was speaking on a cruise ship. Yes, I had the great privilege of being
00:01:58 aboard the Mark Stein cruise. Conrad Black was there. Mark Stein was there. Some English
00:02:04 commentators, Leilani Dowding and Samantha Smith, Phelan McAleer and Anne McElhenney, the Irish
00:02:10 podcasters and filmmakers that we've had on the show, they were aboard as well. Tal Bachman,
00:02:14 the rock singing legend, was there. We had a great time. I know some of those shows that we
00:02:20 recorded on board are going to be available via Mark Stein in the coming weeks, but it was a lot
00:02:25 of fun. And as it happened, I met a number of True North fans, both in the Mark Stein group and this
00:02:31 foursome from Sarnia, Ontario, that I kept running into on the ship that were just so hugely
00:02:37 supportive. So Paul, if you are watching, it was great meeting you and your wife and friends on
00:02:43 the, what was the ship called? The New Amsterdam, I believe. So anyway, I am back in the thick of it.
00:02:48 And of course, this is what happens. I don't want to have too much of an inflated sense of
00:02:52 self-importance here. But I note that Justin Trudeau waited until I was in international
00:02:56 waters and out of the country before he tabled this online harms bill. Again, it could have just
00:03:03 been coincidental. I don't know. But I was in international waters. And to be honest, I almost
00:03:08 wanted to stay in international waters because at least out there, I could perhaps circumvent the
00:03:13 online harms bill and talk about things that I wanted to talk about. This came out on Monday.
00:03:19 But this has been an issue I've been covering for well over a decade,
00:03:21 so I wanted to hit it with full strength and full force upon my return.
00:03:27 We'll be speaking about it a little bit later on in the show
00:03:29 with Christine Van Gein of the Canadian Constitution Foundation.
00:03:33 But I want to begin by sharing some of my own thoughts on this.
00:03:37 So if you have not followed this from last week, the bill is Bill C-63.
00:03:43 It's called the Online Harms Act.
00:03:46 Now, this bill does a lot of different things.
00:03:49 It amends the Criminal Code.
00:03:50 It amends the Canadian Human Rights Act.
00:03:52 And it talks about all of these different supposed online harms,
00:03:57 some of which are bona fide online harms.
00:04:00 But it talks about them as though they're all one particular thing,
00:04:05 as though they're one particular aspect.
00:04:08 Now, this is why the bill is so dangerous.
00:04:10 I'm going to read the bullet point list provided by the federal government
00:04:14 on what this bill purports to do.
00:04:18 It targets seven types of harmful content.
00:04:21 This is the government's language.
00:04:23 It would specifically target seven types of harmful content.
00:04:26 Number one, content that sexually victimizes a child
00:04:31 or re-victimizes a survivor.
00:04:34 Number two, intimate content communicated without consent.
00:04:38 Number three, content used to bully a child.
00:04:42 Number four, content that induces a child to harm themselves.
00:04:47 Number five, I'll get back to.
00:04:49 Number six, content that incites violence.
00:04:52 Number seven, content that incites violent extremism or terrorism.
00:04:57 And then we circle back to number five,
00:04:59 the one that I'll be spending most of the show talking about,
00:05:02 content that foments hatred.
00:05:05 So we have one bill that is trying to deal with child pornography
00:05:11 pornography, trying to get young people to kill themselves, terrorism content and extremist
00:05:18 content, non-consensual sexual images, so naked photos that are shared in confidence with one
00:05:26 person and then republished online, all of that under the same banner as so-called hate speech.
00:05:32 Now, how does the government define what hate speech is? Because as always, the devil is in
00:05:38 the details on this. I will give you the definition. It is the same one they used in Bill C-36, which
00:05:43 came out in 2021, just before the election. It is content that is likely to foment detestation
00:05:52 or vilification. Detestation or vilification. Now, the bill says there are a couple of things that
00:05:59 don't count as hate speech. And I'm going to read the definition of hate speech. Hate speech means
00:06:04 the content of a communication that expresses detestation or vilification of an individual
00:06:09 or group of individuals on the basis of a prohibited ground of discrimination. So this is
00:06:14 basically race, gender, sexual orientation, and so on. Number nine of this law is a clarification.
00:06:22 For greater certainty, a communication does not express detestation or vilification solely because
00:06:28 it expresses disdain or dislike, or it discredits, humiliates, hurts, or offends. So you've got that
00:06:36 if something foments, sorry, if it is likely to foment detestation or vilification, it's hate
00:06:43 speech. But if it's just disdain or dislike or discrediting or humiliation or hurt or offense,
00:06:50 it is not hate speech. Are you confused? Do you know what's happening? Because I'm sure as heck
00:06:57 confused. Where is that line going to be drawn? At what point does a missive, does a communication
00:07:02 cross from disdain to detestation? At what point does it go from hurt and humiliation to vilification?
00:07:10 Let's take a couple of examples of this. The Ontario Human Rights Commission says that
00:07:16 misgendering someone is hate speech. The Ontario Human Rights Commission says that misgendering
00:07:22 is, in fact, hate.
00:07:24 Now, this is, to me, tremendously dangerous
00:07:25 because we already see that beauty-like hate
00:07:28 are in the eye of the beholder.
00:07:31 If the commissars at the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal
00:07:33 decide that it is hate speech,
00:07:35 then your life will be miserable.
00:07:37 You don't even have the right to face your accuser.
00:07:40 Complaints can be made anonymously.
00:07:41 A complainant who makes one of these claims
00:07:43 could get $20,000 from the government.
00:07:45 So we have the emergence of a new grievance industry
00:07:48 where you could just go through Twitter,
00:07:50 find a bunch of people that have said things
00:07:52 you don't like that may apply to your demographic group. You can file complaints and, oh, what do
00:07:57 you know? 20,000, 40,000, 60,000, 100,000, 20,000, 220,000, all of these different amounts that
00:08:03 could be paid out under the scheme that the government says is making the internet a safer
00:08:09 place. But I go back to where the line is drawn. Now, as it happened this morning, I was scrolling
00:08:15 Twitter. I don't usually recommend that as a pastime, but I was away from the world for the
00:08:20 last week, so I was trying to get caught up. And I saw this tweet from a gentleman whose CV I will
00:08:27 read in part in a few moments. His name is Mark Kirsten. Now, he was making a comment about Lisa
00:08:33 McLeod, who's a member of the provincial parliament in the province of Ontario. This is what he said
00:08:38 about Lisa McLeod. Let's put that tweet up there. This is racist and potential hate speech from a
00:08:45 sitting provincial legislator. Now Lisa McLeod was tweeting about an incident that took place
00:08:51 over the weekend. Protests in, again, protests that we've seen that are of an anti-Israel or
00:08:57 in many cases anti-Semitic flavor. I think we have a clip from one such protest.
00:09:15 intifada we are the intifada now if you are a little bit unclear on that intifada translates
00:09:32 to uprising intifadas in the middle east have been very violent ordeals so when a bunch of
00:09:38 people are standing outside a speech or a meeting by georgia maloney the prime minister of italy and
00:09:43 Justin Trudeau declaring themselves the Intifada. I realized that if you're a Jewish person, you
00:09:47 probably are crossing the street to get away from all that. Now, I believe that is protected free
00:09:53 speech. I believe that unless you are being very explicit with your call to violence, you should
00:09:58 have the right to express your opinions and express your positions. And I have the right to
00:10:03 condemn them. I'm consistent on that, whether it's pro-Israel or anti-Israel rhetoric. Now, Lisa
00:10:09 McLeod said this about those protesters in the city of Toronto. She said, though they aren't
00:10:16 pro-Palestine, they are pro-terror. Now, you can disagree with that. You can say it's perhaps
00:10:20 unbecoming of a legislator. You could agree with it. You can do whatever you want. That is what
00:10:24 free speech and debate are about, the ability to share opinions. But Mark Kirsten says that is
00:10:33 potential hate speech. He doesn't go all the way to indict her, but he says it is potential
00:10:38 hate speech that she is guilty of. Now, I want to make very clear, he is not saying we should
00:10:44 throw the Human Rights Commission book at her, but his determination is that Lisa McLeod's comment
00:10:48 is potentially hate speech. Now, why am I focusing so much on this guy you'd never heard of and I had
00:10:53 never heard of before this morning and something he posted on Twitter? Because he is a human rights
00:10:59 lawyer. He is a law professor at the University of Fraser Valley in British Columbia. It's not
00:11:06 the Canada version of an Ivy League university. Associate professor, Sean says. He's on the
00:11:12 faculty. He's on the faculty. Associate professor notwithstanding. He has a PhD. He's very well
00:11:18 educated from the London School of Economics. This is a guy who is supposed to know the law.
00:11:24 He's supposed to know the situation. And he is saying that this is potential hate speech. Now,
00:11:29 is this just his own academic opinion or is this a legal opinion? I don't particularly care.
00:11:35 What I'm saying here is that already we have,
00:11:38 within a week of legislation being announced,
00:11:40 a law professor arguing that speech
00:11:43 from a provincial politician in Ontario
00:11:46 is potentially hate speech.
00:11:47 Now, what if a guy like this ends up being appointed
00:11:51 as an adjudicator or member
00:11:53 of the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal,
00:11:55 which is going to be the body tasked
00:11:57 with adjudicating and determining these matters?
00:12:01 Now, all of a sudden,
00:12:02 if you say that a group of anti-israel protests are protesters are pro-terror you could be held up
00:12:08 as guilty of hate speech you could be maligned and of course censored now when i said that the
00:12:14 federal government through bill c63 had reintroduced something that was repealed back in 2013 they have
00:12:20 supercharged it they've added to this takedown powers where social media platforms like facebook
00:12:25 and twitter or x as it's now called google will have to take down all of this content so now
00:12:31 you have a mechanism by which you can not only say to the Canadian Human Rights Commission or
00:12:36 subsequently the tribunal that these bodies should go after that guy for saying that thing I don't
00:12:41 like, but you can now go to the social media companies and say you should not allow this to
00:12:46 exist. So we will have big tech being deputized by big government to censor your speech. And the
00:12:53 guy with his finger on the trigger of all of this right now is Justin Trudeau. Now I want to play
00:13:00 a clip of the Justice Minister, Arif Farhani, claiming that, oh no, your charter rights are
00:13:07 going to be fine and none of this is going to attack or assault your charter rights. Take a look.
00:13:13 The other thing that's really critical to understand, David, is that people talk to me
00:13:16 about freedom of expression. I'm duty bound to defend that and always will. It is a charter
00:13:20 protected right. I swore an oath to uphold the constitution. But what I also explain to people
00:13:24 is that right now, a lot of what you put out to the world and also what you receive in terms of
00:13:29 your feed is being decided for you not by a government but by a private company that private
00:13:34 company is making decisions behind closed doors we don't know what decisions they're taking or
00:13:39 why they're taking them that will change by forcing them to provide a digital safety plan
00:13:43 that exposes and provides transparency about the decisions they're taking that affect your and my
00:13:48 free speech so he's saying that government should be the one making that decision on what you say
00:13:56 and see online. You can't trust big tech companies to do it, which I, by the way, agree with. But
00:14:01 the result of that is not trust government instead. But the justice minister in Canada
00:14:06 says, no, no, no. Government is going to be the body that's going to look after you. You can't
00:14:10 trust Facebook and Google. We'll be the ones. We'll be the censors. We'll be the authorities.
00:14:14 We will manage the algorithms. All your speeches are belong to us. That's what the government
00:14:19 is saying to Canadians right now. Do you feel better about it? Because I sure as heck don't.
00:14:25 I've said that big tech is a malign alliance, the big tech companies, on your free speech.
00:14:32 Government is forming its own malignant force against your free speech.
00:14:37 You put those two together, and it is an all-out assault on free speech,
00:14:41 especially when you combine this with all of the other internet regulations to date.
00:14:45 C-18, that has effectively restricted where you can access news content online.
00:14:52 The Online News Act, Bill, what was it, C11 or C10?
00:14:56 I get the numbers all mixed up now.
00:14:57 I think it was C10 and then it was reintroduced, C11.
00:15:00 The bill that's effectively mandating a podcast registry.
00:15:04 So government has been setting the groundwork.
00:15:06 It's been laying the groundwork all this time for the coup de grace,
00:15:11 which is now government saying these places that have now been licensed,
00:15:16 these places that have now had authority delegated to them,
00:15:19 these places that government has now brought into its regulatory ambit, they now have to take down
00:15:25 your content if the government says so. If the government says so, they now have to take off
00:15:31 all your content. So Bill C-11, Bill C-18, all of that was just the appetizer. It was the palate
00:15:39 cleanser. I realize those are two different dishes, but one was the appetizer, one was the palate
00:15:43 cleanser. And here we have the main course of Justin Trudeau's censorship desires. Now, we're
00:15:49 going to talk about this with Christine Van Gein in just a couple of moments time here, because
00:15:53 one of the points that I think is incredibly necessary to stress is that a lot of what the
00:16:01 government has brought into this bill is already captured by other laws. They're regulating things
00:16:06 that are already illegal. They're regulating things that have already been prohibited.
00:16:12 Hate speech is a great example of this. The criminal code of this country already prohibits
00:16:17 hate speech. If something is illegal hate speech in the criminal code in your local deli or on a
00:16:24 street corner, it is also illegal on the internet. So when the government has brought this online
00:16:30 hate speech component, what they've actually done is created a new threshold. They have lowered the
00:16:35 bar. The criminal code threshold, I don't have the exact wording handy, but the criminal code
00:16:40 threshold is so insanely high a bar that what it requires is that you must prove to convict someone
00:16:47 of hate speech that they have effectively been inciting, usually violence or a call to genocide.
00:16:53 That's typically what is being dealt with here. But when you then bring it into the context of
00:16:59 here, we've talked about that category that doesn't quite make sense. It has to be likely
00:17:04 to foment detestation or vilification, but it can't just be merely causing disdain or humiliation
00:17:11 or dislike. Well, I would venture to say that one person's dislike is another person's detestation,
00:17:18 that something, for example, misgendering, that's the example I brought up in Ontario,
00:17:23 that misgendering will be at some point subject to a complaint. And it is very reasonable. I mean,
00:17:31 if you look at the issue that launched Jordan Peterson to fame, it was Bill C-16 that was
00:17:36 amending the Canadian Human Rights Act to put gender identity in the list of prohibited grounds
00:17:42 of discrimination. So the fight that Jordan Peterson was waging against Bill C-16 has a
00:17:48 direct line to what is now human rights law in Canada. But just look at this. It's absolutely
00:17:54 insane. If you are found guilty of violating the online hate speech section of Section 13,
00:18:00 you will not only have an order to cease the discriminatory practice
00:18:04 and take measures in consultation with the Human Rights Commission
00:18:08 to redress the practice or prevent the same or a similar practice from occurring.
00:18:14 So your future speech is going to be affected by this.
00:18:17 Not just your current speech, but you have to prevent it from the future.
00:18:22 So you have to essentially be enjoined to this plan
00:18:25 that the government is going to come up with with you
00:18:27 to not offend people's sensibilities in the future.
00:18:30 You have to pay the victim up to $20,000
00:18:34 for any pain and suffering that they experienced
00:18:38 as a result of the hate speech
00:18:40 to which the complaint relates.
00:18:42 And I'm gonna venture a guess to say
00:18:44 that there won't actually be a huge rigorous test
00:18:49 on whether you had hate,
00:18:53 whether your so-called hate genuinely caused any problems.
00:18:56 I just don't see that happening.
00:18:58 And also, it's not just enough that you pay the person that you may have,
00:19:02 I don't know, misgendered or something, $20,000.
00:19:05 You also will have to pay a fine, if not more than $50,000,
00:19:09 to the Receiver General if the Human Rights Tribunal decides this.
00:19:13 So that is stand-in for the government.
00:19:15 You will have to pay the government.
00:19:18 Pay the government if you are found guilty of this.
00:19:22 So you could be out $70,000 if you post a tweet
00:19:25 that Justin Trudeau's censorship law decides was just a little bit too offensive. It went a little
00:19:31 bit higher than disdain and dislike and all the way to detestation and vilification. Now, let me
00:19:38 play a clip. This was of the justice minister, not the one we played earlier, but this was him
00:19:43 explaining why this bill is the direction that the government apparently needs to go.
00:19:48 This is what the Online Harms Act will do. Under this bill, major online services will have three
00:19:55 overarching obligations a duty to protect children a duty to act
00:20:00 responsibly and the duty to remove the most egregious content this bill targets
00:20:06 the worst of what we see online content that sexually victimizes children or
00:20:11 revictimizes survivors intimate content shared without consent content that
00:20:17 incites violence extremism or terrorism content that incites violence or
00:20:22 or foments hatred and content that is used to bully a child or induce a child to self-harm
00:20:30 this bill will establish a new digital safety commission to make sure that online services
00:20:35 comply with their new obligations as well as an ombudsperson to advocate for users
00:20:40 and victims of online harm again the way that they're viewing all of these things as the same
00:20:49 problem, that take an issue that we could all agree on, which is the sharing of non-consensual
00:20:54 images, which is child sexual exploitation. All of that we could agree is a bad thing. No liberal,
00:20:59 no conservative, no new Democrat is going to stand up and say, you know what, maybe you should be 0.97
00:21:05 able to share revenge porn online. No, but they put it all together so that if anyone does what
00:21:11 I'm doing, which is saying that this bill is a problem, this bill is bad, if anyone does that,
00:21:16 they are going to get hit by criticism from the Liberals on,
00:21:20 oh, well, the Conservatives are just trying to keep children unsafe.
00:21:23 The Conservatives are okay with the internet being a dangerous place and all that.
00:21:27 This is exactly what's going to happen.
00:21:29 It's what I called months ago and years ago when this issue first came up.
00:21:34 We were supposed to have Christine Van Gein on the program. 1.00
00:21:37 We've had some technical issues there, so we'll try to get her in a little bit later on.
00:21:41 But I want to welcome into the show Chris Sims on this,
00:21:43 our regular Monday fabulous contributor.
00:21:46 It's fabulous any day,
00:21:47 but on our show,
00:21:48 she's fabulous on Mondays
00:21:49 from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:21:52 Chris, always a pleasure.
00:21:53 Thanks for coming on.
00:21:54 Likewise.
00:21:55 And thank you for holding on the fort
00:21:57 on Mr. Stein's cruise.
00:21:58 I hope it went really well.
00:21:59 It did.
00:22:00 It was a lot of fun.
00:22:01 I said we were in international water,
00:22:02 so I was free of any of these
00:22:03 so-called hate speech complaints.
00:22:05 Not that this,
00:22:06 I mean, this is an issue
00:22:07 from a constitutional perspective,
00:22:09 but one of the things
00:22:10 that I would point out also
00:22:11 is that they're bureaucratizing
00:22:13 this process. The idea that we need all of these different roles and bureaucrats that are now 0.94
00:22:18 adjudicating the online process. What could possibly go wrong, right? Yeah, exactly. So
00:22:23 they're going to balloon the size of government as if we don't have a big enough government already.
00:22:27 And I hope Christine manages to log in here because she's absolutely brilliant on these issues. 0.89
00:22:33 And of course, it was partially her team that had that big win at the federal court level very
00:22:38 recently on the invocation of the emergencies act so she really knows her stuff we've known her for
00:22:44 years from the taxpayers perspective one of our key elements is accountable government and i need
00:22:51 to stress to folks here that you won't oh i think you've gotten now a complaint against you from the
00:22:56 government chris your camera just went off my goodness we've been having some really funny
00:23:00 technical issues here this is bill c63 in action once christian starts criticizing the government
00:23:06 the uh the camera goes off well uh oh there we go we got you back i haven't i'm not joking i'm not
00:23:12 touching anything this makes no sense that this happens anyway i'll try to will my camera to stay
00:23:17 on the point here is and you described it brilliantly andrew is with free expression that
00:23:24 is up to someone else's judgment right what you say or what i say may offend other people may not
00:23:31 offend others and may cause detestation in others and may not cause detestation in others. The point
00:23:36 here is that this is a freedom for exactly this reason. And you do not want, folks, you do not want
00:23:44 the state deciding whether or not misinformation can be construed as hate speech or whether or not
00:23:52 if I calmly explain to a young person that you know what, the carbon tax, if we crank it up,
00:23:59 is not going to stop the planet from ceasing to exist in 18 months. Like here's maybe some other
00:24:05 data. I'll walk you through some of the things that I've lived through and look back through
00:24:09 a history book. Some folks who are really into this climate stuff might consider that to be
00:24:15 hate speech. It may be attacking their identity. Like this is the weird slippery slope that we
00:24:21 could go down here and we can't do this. We should not be growing the size of government
00:24:25 and we should not be impinging on people's free expression because otherwise we won't be able to
00:24:31 hold the government to account. And again, I try to explain this to everybody who might be thinking,
00:24:36 oh, well, I don't mind if Justin Trudeau decides what is and is not hate speech and whether or not
00:24:41 I'm allowed to express myself. Okay. If you're totally fine with Justin Trudeau deciding that,
00:24:46 are you also fine with Pierre Polyev deciding that for you? If the answer is no, we shouldn't
00:24:52 be changing these laws. Yeah. And that was, I don't know if you were on when I played that
00:24:56 clip from Marie Farhani, the justice minister, but when he was saying, oh, no, no, we can't trust big
00:25:01 tech companies to adjudicate what you can say and see online. Government is the answer to that. I
00:25:06 mean, I'm like, hang on, how about neither? How about we do, how about we delegate that authority
00:25:10 to neither of them? Is that an option? Apparently not. And you are absolutely right about this
00:25:15 because it's very difficult in this day and age to do the principled stand that I'm doing and
00:25:20 you're doing here and saying no i don't believe government should regulate hate speech online
00:25:24 because you're you're necessarily taking a stand in support of your ability to say things that
00:25:29 i would firmly believe people shouldn't say but the governor of that should not be the government
00:25:35 it should be civil society it should be your own conscience it should be the friend that says hey
00:25:41 you should probably delete that tweet and and we've just completely abandoned that in society
00:25:45 and you're right there are so many people that would love to put a bill like this in
00:25:48 to stick it to conservatives but the second you get some trigger happy conservative government
00:25:53 that wants to go after let's say anti-israel speech now this brings us to the canadian or
00:26:00 the center for israel and jewish affairs a group that has done tremendous work on anti-semitism
00:26:05 and i think is a very important voice they've come out in favor of this and i i understand why i
00:26:10 understand why they look at anti-semitism as a problem and saying we want to go after this but
00:26:15 but that would be used if they had their way against a lot of speech that right now people
00:26:20 on the left are quite fond of exactly and to your point that you made earlier a lot of this stuff
00:26:26 that you described off the top of the show is already illegal it's already illegal in real life
00:26:32 it's already illegal on the internet now the one i did find this interesting correct me if i'm wrong
00:26:38 but i think they've shifted this now from culture over to justice which is really interesting because
00:26:44 the last two times they tried pushing this thing through they tried doing it through the auspices
00:26:49 of culture so they're getting a little bit smarter because they're putting it through justice i'll
00:26:53 put it this way i just want to take my taxpayers federation hat off slightly here um but it's still
00:26:59 to accountable government okay it's still about accountable government and smaller government
00:27:03 anybody who's followed the hill for the last 20 or 30 years or so has not just fallen off the
00:27:08 turnip truck. We can see what they're doing here. They're repackaging things like protecting
00:27:15 children who wouldn't want to do that, protecting people from hideous images, the revenge p-word 0.90
00:27:22 as you've said before. All of that is understood. All of that's already illegal but then they're
00:27:28 putting this little thing in there about hate speech which is widely defined, really variable
00:27:35 and we've seen it play out before they could easily separate this bill now i'm not a lawyer
00:27:41 hopefully christine will be able to explain some of that if she has time but if they could split
00:27:45 this bill i'm guessing that this would be a lot easier to manage why link it to something that
00:27:50 every decent person would want to outlaw anyway yeah i very agree i mean for starters it over
00:27:56 complicates the bill and it also slows down what could be an easy slam dunk i mean the conservatives
00:28:00 I think would probably be on the front lines of pushing that forward and saying, let's just get
00:28:05 that done in weeks. And I also just to put your taxpayer hat back on here, Chris, I wanted to ask
00:28:10 about this Digital Safety Commission of Canada, because the bill creates this body, it creates
00:28:15 this bureaucracy to manage online safety. Now, we can look around the world and see what the
00:28:22 government is going after there. And one of them, I should have pulled the clip today, that they've
00:28:26 looked at when they were crafting this was in Australia, which has a woman by the name of Julie
00:28:30 Inman Grant, who is the eSafety Commissioner of Australia, who I have run into on the streets of
00:28:35 Davos and who famously said at Davos that we need to recalibrate things like freedom of speech
00:28:41 because she believes they are anachronisms in the internet age. So it's pretty clear that the
00:28:47 government is creating a bureaucracy that's going to just put censorship into this perpetual motion
00:28:52 here. And bodies like that do not like to stay in their lane. Bodies like that are the ones that are
00:28:57 going to come out in three years and say it's not enough to go after hate speech we need to go after
00:29:01 misinformation as well yes exactly when you grow government that's like purposefully planting
00:29:07 invasive species it is it will choke out the sunlight it'll take up all the soil it'll eat
00:29:12 up all the oxygen and it will put a chill on free expression and free speech and they tried
00:29:18 a last time i'm curious to see that they've kept this now in this new incarnation i didn't see that
00:29:22 that they're going to keep the so-called censorship or free expression czar. So that
00:29:28 position is still going to be there. And under that person, they're going to build an entire
00:29:33 bureaucracy. Folks, we are more than a trillion dollars in debt. We have un-money. We cannot pay
00:29:40 for one more person to be hired by the federal government. If you and I started counting to a
00:29:46 trillion right now, it would take us 30,000 years. So in no way should the Trudeau government be
00:29:52 expanding the size of a government, much less in order to make themselves less accountable to the
00:29:57 people. All right. Well, thank you so much, Chris Sims. Always great to talk to you. We will see you
00:30:03 next Monday. Likewise. Thank you. All right. And as promised, we have our long-awaited legal eagle
00:30:10 herself, Christine Van Gein, who is the litigation director for the Canadian Constitution Foundation
00:30:15 on the program. Christine, always good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today.
00:30:20 Yeah, thanks for having me on, Andrew.
00:30:22 So, I mean, we've covered a lot of, I think, the basis of why I'm concerned as a non-lawyer free speech advocate on this.
00:30:29 But let me just ask you about that point that Chris had alluded to there and that I spoke to earlier, which is that the government has gone after a lot of things here that most people would assume rightfully so are illegal.
00:30:41 I mean, even on the non-consensual images stuff, I understood a lot of that already existed in law.
00:30:46 certainly on hate speech, we already have a criminal prohibition on hate speech, which
00:30:50 applies to the internet. So this new definition has a lower threshold. Am I missing anything here?
00:30:57 So I think that the definition, the statutory definition they're proposing seems like it's the
00:31:01 same definition as exists in the what caught decision, which is where that previously the
00:31:10 definition came from. The problem is that it's by its very nature amorphous that they are
00:31:16 increasing the penalties and they're creating a standalone offense of an offense motivated by
00:31:21 hatred and that it can apply to all federal laws. So all federal statutes are included.
00:31:29 So anyone who breaks any other federal law motivated by hate can be found guilty of a hate
00:31:36 crime and subject to a maximum life sentence um so that's not just limited to the criminal code
00:31:42 they're also increasing the statutory maximum for the crime of advocating genocide up to a maximum
00:31:49 of uh currently five years they're increasing that to uh to life imprisonment and look obviously the
00:31:57 problem with criticizing this bill is that advocating for genocide is abhorrent and terrible
00:32:02 a lot of there's a lot of political challenges in criticizing legislation like this the a big
00:32:09 part of it is that for some reason politically uh the government has tied completely unrelated
00:32:15 things to this bill so they're trying to solve completely unrelated problems of sexual abuse
00:32:20 imagery whether that's sexual abuse of children or the non-consensual disclosure of intimate images
00:32:27 to things that are already criminalized or tying that to hate speech which is a inherently amorphous
00:32:34 and subjective uh problem and obviously hate online is wrong and bad but the way the government
00:32:44 has proposed tackling this is unconstitutional i think that this law is going to be subject
00:32:49 to an immediate charter challenge and we don't want the parts of the bill that deal with sexual 0.94
00:32:55 abuse to be struck down. If this government actually cared about sexual criminals, they would
00:33:01 not tie increased penalties or improved reporting for sexual abuse to a constitutionally vulnerable
00:33:11 proposal. Explain to me if you're able to, because I know a lot of this would come from regulations
00:33:18 that would have to be passed after the bill is passed and enacted, but how this would even work
00:33:23 when you're talking about the relationship
00:33:25 between these regulations and internet platforms
00:33:28 like Facebook or Twitter,
00:33:29 because they would have under this an obligation
00:33:31 to remove content that would be in violation of this.
00:33:36 But I mean, what would that mechanism even look like?
00:33:40 My fear is that Facebook is either going to
00:33:43 do the non-compliance thing that they did with C18
00:33:45 and say, you know what, it's too much of a hassle.
00:33:47 We're just shutting down our platform to Canadians.
00:33:49 There's no point in being the adjudicators.
00:33:52 or if they want to play ball, the worst thing is, all right, well, we'll come up with these
00:33:57 terms of service to encompass what we think the Canadian government is after. And all of a sudden
00:34:02 you have Facebook preemptively zapping content because they don't want to deal with the digital
00:34:07 safety commissioner of Canada. Yeah, I think that's absolutely right. It's going to create
00:34:12 a chilling effect where content will be preemptively or proactively removed when it doesn't
00:34:19 actually meet the threshold that's being outlined in this proposed statutory definition of hate
00:34:26 speech. And look, it's because the definition is inherently subjective, and I specialize in
00:34:34 expression and freedom of expression law. And it's difficult for lawyers like me to explain
00:34:40 where that line gets drawn. So I think it's going to be incredibly hard for regular Canadians who
00:34:47 now will the the bill proposes this automatic reporting mechanism so ordinary canadians can
00:34:54 report content that they think meets this threshold we're going to see just an inundation
00:34:59 of reporting that comes with if it does meet that threshold huge financial penalties for
00:35:06 the platforms i think it's um i think it was 10 million dollars in fines or six percent of global
00:35:16 revenues, whichever is higher. And for platforms like Facebook or Meta, Google, Instagram, these
00:35:22 are, that's a huge amount of money. They obviously are going to be incentivized to take content down
00:35:29 proactively. And then the other part of this is that the creation of this civil remedy, where
00:35:35 people can complain about speech that they think is hateful to the Canadian Human Rights Commission,
00:35:42 people are going to soft paddle their own speech and not say things that they that they might
00:35:48 otherwise say and I wanted to give you a couple of examples because I think that we we are talking
00:35:54 about this in a very um like high level way without actually putting our teeth in what some
00:36:00 of these terms mean so hate speech is defined in the case law it's now going to be put in the
00:36:06 statute as words, uh, like detestation or vilification. It doesn't include speech that
00:36:13 is just offensive, or, um, it has to be at a higher level, even though these are kind of
00:36:18 synonyms. Yeah, more, it has to be higher than disdain. It can't just be disdain. Yeah. So to
00:36:22 try to put some teeth in that, in the what caught decision from the Supreme court, the court gave a
00:36:28 few examples of what they call the hallmarks of hatred speech that has the hallmarks of hatred.
00:36:34 So an example is blaming a whole group for current problems in society, alleging that that group is a powerful menace. Now, I can certainly imagine that type of language being used in a way that blames some racial group.
00:36:51 But frankly, Andrew, I've been to some women's meetings where you are the problem. 0.99
00:36:57 It's men. 0.99
00:36:58 It's white men. 0.77
00:36:59 I've been to DEI trainings where those are the groups who are blamed for the problems
00:37:06 of society.
00:37:07 And look, I don't like DEI training, but I don't think it should be illegal.
00:37:12 Another example is describing an entire group as, quote, pure evil.
00:37:19 This is another hallmark of hatred. And certainly I can imagine examples we're calling an entire race or religion as pure evil.
00:37:28 But I'm not sure if you're familiar with the group, the Westboro Baptist Church.
00:37:33 This is a notoriously awful church based in the United States that famously holds signs at the funerals of war veterans celebrating the death of those veterans. 0.92
00:37:49 and attacking other religious or sexual minority groups. 0.97
00:37:53 This is an awful group.
00:37:57 And if you Google Westboro Baptist Church and the term pure evil,
00:38:01 you get a lot of hits.
00:38:03 Is that hate speech?
00:38:04 Well, it certainly is calling a religious group pure evil, 0.99
00:38:09 which is a hallmark of hatred.
00:38:10 But under C63, do we want to subject people who say that that church is,
00:38:18 quote, pure evil to criminal penalty, or even to civil penalty. I don't know that that's an
00:38:25 outcome that we want. So these are just a couple of examples to put some colour, some flavour to
00:38:31 what this might look like, and why it's such a problem when we criminalise speech. We want these
00:38:39 ideas to be fleshed out and debated. And frankly, a lot of the things that might, you know, you can
00:38:45 think a hallmark of hatred. Well, of course, using these terms will always be hateful, but it won't
00:38:51 be. It just won't. And we don't want to criminalize that. And I know that I mentioned a little bit
00:38:56 before you came on, there's this $20,000 that if you're a successful complainant, you could
00:39:01 theoretically get up to, and it's dependent on what you've endured on this. But really, to make
00:39:07 a complaint, it doesn't look like you need to have suffered anything from it, or it even needs to
00:39:12 have been targeted to you. I mean, if I am a member of some group, and I don't like your post
00:39:18 that affects my group, even if you didn't direct it at me, it sounds like I would have standing
00:39:23 to bring that to the Canadian human rights stars, would I not? Yeah, I mean, some of these details
00:39:29 haven't been fleshed out completely yet. But certainly, that's sort of how the old Canadian 0.97
00:39:34 Human Rights Commission Act that had Section 13, where you could make these civil complaints,
00:39:41 That's how it used to work. And that provision was famously repealed after it was abused to 0.67
00:39:49 bring these claims against author Mark Stein. So it was right for Parliament to remove that
00:39:56 10 years ago and to bring it back now just doesn't make any sense. It shouldn't happen.
00:40:03 And keep in mind that these civil penalties will be proven at a lower threshold than the criminal
00:40:09 penalties. To prove the criminal offenses of hate speech, it's beyond a reasonable doubt. And under
00:40:16 the civil penalty, it's on a balance of probabilities. And in many ways, look, there's
00:40:22 going to be a lot of frivolous complaints. I mean, I'm willing to take bets. I'm sure there's some
00:40:27 vagus odds on who's going to have a complaint first, you or me, Andrew. I'm getting one on
00:40:34 day one. I think you're too nice on that. No, people have already been saying I can't wait
00:40:39 i'm christine charged some tech person's gonna make some script that you just like you know 0.61
00:40:46 select your right-wing hater and you just like autofile complaints it'll be like on twitter when
00:40:51 you report something it'll like give you 10 sample tweets and it's like check the boxes of the ones
00:40:55 you might also want to complain about yeah so in many ways like these might these complaints might
00:41:01 not be investigated as but as chris sims your previous guest explained they're going to need
00:41:07 have a whole bureaucracy to be investigating these complaints and dismissing them and then
00:41:12 some of them that perhaps aren't even close to the threshold are still going to be investigated
00:41:18 and once you're investigated the process becomes the punishment because you need to defend yourself
00:41:23 in that process and even if it's not a criminal charge even if you have not um even risen to the
00:41:30 level of of civil hate speech you still are going to pay the costs of of defending yourself through
00:41:36 through a lawyer, or socially, the costs of having your name dragged through the mud.
00:41:42 Well, we'll certainly be unpacking this in more angles as things progress. The liberals have been,
00:41:48 I mean, the thing is, it's taken them about three years to come up with this. So the idea that there
00:41:53 was something they overlooked is very unlikely. They're very aware of what's in this. They've
00:41:58 chosen this all deliberately. And I think that should be very concerning. Christine Van Gein,
00:42:02 I know you'll have lots of commentary on this on your podcast over at the CCF.
00:42:07 Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts as always with us.
00:42:09 Thank you, Sandra.
00:42:10 All right.
00:42:11 Thank you, Christine Van Gein.
00:42:12 Just before we get things rolling into ending the show,
00:42:17 I guess that's stopping the rolling,
00:42:18 but before we start gathering moss on the program,
00:42:21 I wanted to share a bit of an announcement with you.
00:42:24 I've teased this in recent weeks,
00:42:26 and anyone who tried to email me over the last few months and didn't get a response,
00:42:30 you've probably been aware that I've been working on something here.
00:42:32 I can finally tell you what that is.
00:42:35 I have my second book coming out in just a couple of months.
00:42:39 We're putting the finishing touches on it with my publisher in the next couple of days here.
00:42:44 But we can certainly share with you the cover of it.
00:42:47 This is Pierre Polyev, A Political Life.
00:42:50 It is the first biography of Conservative leader Pierre Polyev,
00:42:55 a man who may well be Canada's next Prime Minister.
00:42:58 This is not a memoir.
00:43:00 It's not written by him or even with his cooperation as he did not agree to be interviewed for it.
00:43:05 But it is a book that I'm very proud of that goes to the very early years of his life through his childhood, adolescence, his involvement in politics, and all that he's done as a politician.
00:43:17 And it was a bit of an interesting process to write about.
00:43:20 I followed his career, obviously, but I didn't know a lot of what I ended up learning during the writing process.
00:43:26 That book will be coming out in May.
00:43:28 if you are interested in pre-ordering it
00:43:30 you can do so at Amazon
00:43:31 or also through the publisher
00:43:33 which is Sutherland House
00:43:35 so you can head on over to
00:43:36 SutherlandHouseBooks.com
00:43:38 and hopefully we'll be able to do some events
00:43:40 in your towns across this great nation
00:43:42 when it comes out in May
00:43:43 but wanted to share those details with you now
00:43:46 that does it for us for today
00:43:47 we'll be back in just 23 hours and 15 minutes
00:43:50 with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show
00:43:52 here on True North
00:43:54 thank you, God bless and good day to you all
00:43:56 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:43:59 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:44:26 We'll be right back.
00:44:56 We'll be right back.