Juno News - March 28, 2024


Trudeau's team doing damage control on online censorship bill

Topics
Mentioned
Chestermere responds "We definitely like Mayor Colvin" Liberal bill would give MPs tens of millions in extra pensions

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

163.71

Word count

7,139

Sentence count

381

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Supriya De Vetti is a senior advisor to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. She left her career at the Toronto Star to become a digital media strategist for the Prime Minister. She's a lawyer, she's a former talk radio host, and she works for Justin Trudeau's digital media centres. And yet... she thinks the PM is trying to stifle free speech online.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here at the andrew
00:01:29 lawton show on true north on this thursday march 28th the day before good friday and this is
00:01:37 obviously a very solemn and somber occasion for christians a category in which i count myself a
00:01:43 very proud member. But it is followed by a very celebratory and joyous day on the weekend. So
00:01:50 if Easter is your jam, as the kids say these days, I actually don't know if the kids say that.
00:01:55 Actually, I don't know if anyone says that. But at some point, I believe people used to say that.
00:01:59 Then I wish you a very happy and blessed Easter this weekend. But alternatively, if you are in
00:02:06 the Jewish tradition, it's not quite Passover time. So I will wish you a blessed Passover.
00:02:12 in I think it's about a month from now.
00:02:15 No, about three or four weeks.
00:02:16 Anyway, nevertheless, my calendar on my computer
00:02:20 always reminds me of holidays
00:02:21 that I like don't even know exist necessarily.
00:02:24 Like it's apparently Tartan Day on April 6th
00:02:29 and it's in my calendar.
00:02:30 And then Vimy Ridge Day, I knew about that one.
00:02:32 I probably always forget what day it is,
00:02:34 but that's on April 9th.
00:02:35 And then as we all know, Louis Real Day,
00:02:38 it was trying to get me to celebrate a few weeks back
00:02:39 and I wasn't having any of that.
00:02:41 But we will never, Easter is a lot more important than Louis Rial Day, I will tell you, despite what Louis Rial maybe thought of himself as being some sort of prophetic figure.
00:02:51 But I'm offending all the Manitobans again. Okay, I got to stop doing that. 1.00
00:02:55 Welcome to the show. We're going to be talking a little bit later on with our good friend Franco Terrazzano on the eve of the Great Tax Hike Day, April 1st.
00:03:03 Not just the carbon tax is going up, but the alcohol tax is going up. Member of Parliament's salaries are going up.
00:03:10 April 1st is proving to be a bit of a momentous day and not one that is treating taxpayers all
00:03:17 that well. I also want to speak a little bit more about the Online Harms Act. Now this is
00:03:22 Bill C-63. This is the piece of legislation the Liberal governments have done that they purport
00:03:27 to be a panacea for all that ails internet users. They want to with just one big broad brush deal
00:03:35 with child sexual exploitation, revenge porn, the terrorist content that we know is pervasive
00:03:42 on the internet, and also online hate.
00:03:47 One of these things is not like the other.
00:03:51 The online hate provisions are incredibly dangerous.
00:03:54 They're also doing criminal code reforms, which I believe are incredibly dangerous.
00:03:59 And one of those has become front and center in a little bit of damage control slash political
00:04:04 spin being done by the Toronto Star. The Toronto Star ran an op-ed from Sabria DeVetti, who
00:04:12 is a longtime media figure in Canada. She says, have you heard the one about Justin Trudeau
00:04:17 attacking your free speech online? Trust me, that's just rage farming. Now, Sabria DeVetti,
00:04:25 I have known for many years. I have always gotten along with her. Even today, I asked her,
00:04:30 because I said I was going to be doing this on the show today. I asked her if she wanted to come on.
00:04:33 She said she was tied up in meetings, so couldn't join.
00:04:36 I've got a good relationship with her.
00:04:37 We were colleagues back when I worked in traditional media at Global.
00:04:42 I would occasionally guest host for her on 640 Toronto.
00:04:46 So I get along with Supriya, even though I disagree with her on a lot of things.
00:04:50 This is not, in my view, however, a case of disagreeing with her opinion.
00:04:55 This is a case of her being flat out wrong, in my view.
00:04:58 But we'll get to that in a moment.
00:05:00 Let's talk about that Toronto Star P.
00:05:02 Let's put that up again, Sean.
00:05:03 Have you heard the one about Justin Trudeau attacking your free speech online?
00:05:07 Trust me, that's just Rage Farming by Supriya DeVetti, contributor.
00:05:12 Okay, now what's unique about Supriya DeVetti?
00:05:15 She's a lawyer, she's a former talk radio host,
00:05:19 but you scroll way down in the bottom of the article there,
00:05:23 you get the key part here.
00:05:25 Supriya DeVetti is a senior advisor to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau
00:05:29 and was a former columnist for the Toronto Star.
00:05:33 ah she is a Trudeau staffer she left her career she was working I believe at McGill University
00:05:41 in one of their uh digital media centers but she left that to go and work for Justin Trudeau okay
00:05:45 that's fine I don't know why that's like boarding the Titanic when you're about three quarters over
00:05:51 the Atlantic it's already hit the iceberg but hasn't gone down yet and you're like well that
00:05:55 the food on that ship looks great so let me get on board but nevertheless Supriya decided she
00:05:59 wanted to go on to Justin Trudeau's team. She wanted to be a part of the Prime Minister's
00:06:03 office. She is a senior advisor. Nothing wrong with that. Our system relies on people advising
00:06:09 the government. But she is also now the spin doctor of this piece of legislation, which I find
00:06:15 very, very strange. Political staffers are typically not the ones putting their bylines
00:06:21 on columns. Political staffers are not typically the ones doing interviews to sell or champion
00:06:26 legislation. I mean, my thinking, and I mean no disrespect to Supriya on this, was there no
00:06:31 Liberal member of Parliament that wanted to put their name on a defense of the Online Harms Act
00:06:36 in the Toronto Star? Was the Justice Minister who is selling this bill perhaps unavailable or
00:06:42 uninterested in doing this? But she talks about criticism of this bill being rage farming. Rage 0.96
00:06:50 farming. That's the term she uses. Rage farming, which is basically just trying to gin up hatred 1.00
00:06:55 online. She talks about this as though there are no legitimate critiques or criticisms of the bill
00:07:02 because she's defending, I mean, she's appealing to authority here. She's defending the bill. When
00:07:07 we talk about the hate speech stuff, it prohibits speech, which is fomenting or likely to foment
00:07:12 detestation or vilification. The language comes from a Supreme Court decision, but that is not
00:07:19 the defense that she and other defenders of this bill seem to think because the Supreme Court
00:07:23 left a very confusing decision there
00:07:26 that doesn't actually give much in the way of clarity
00:07:29 when you want to see how a human rights tribunal
00:07:31 is going to adapt that decision
00:07:33 to individual expressions of speech.
00:07:36 But let's get into where I believe she is factually wrong.
00:07:40 Again, I am not a lawyer.
00:07:43 I cover legal issues.
00:07:45 I interview a lot of lawyers, but I am not a lawyer.
00:07:48 So I was fully prepared to admit
00:07:50 that I might have been misreading something
00:07:52 or I might have been getting something wrong.
00:07:54 The more feedback has come from other sources,
00:07:56 the more I am convinced that is not, in fact, the case.
00:08:00 Because Supriya said this on Twitter.
00:08:03 After one user said the bill threatens life in jail
00:08:07 over nasty comments to politicians,
00:08:09 DiBetti responded by saying,
00:08:10 that's not what the bill does.
00:08:13 A max of life imprisonment for hate
00:08:15 has to accompany an underlying act
00:08:17 that is also punishable by max life imprisonment.
00:08:20 so if you attempted to murder someone on the basis of their race religion sexual orientation etc
00:08:24 so what is at stake here is the amendment to the criminal code that the online harms act puts
00:08:30 forward which says if a criminal offense is motivated by hate that criminal offense could
00:08:37 carry oh oh you gave it away sean you gave it away no no take that away take that away yeah okay i i
00:08:42 that was i was gonna like just bombard people with that at the end to make the point dramatically
00:08:46 it's a little less dramatic now, but we'll work on it. The bill says that, you know, if you add
00:08:51 an offense, it, or if you add hate motivation to an offense, it carries a life sentence. Now,
00:08:56 Supriya was very clear that no, no, no, this will only apply to things that already have a life
00:09:04 sentence. Now, she also criticized Andrew Coyne, making the same argument I've made on this on the
00:09:09 show. He made it in a Globe and Mail column. Supriya said this about Andrew Coyne's contributions
00:09:14 to the matter. Probably unhelpful to the discourse when our national newspaper let's columnists just
00:09:20 make all sorts of stuff up about the bill. Coyne is demonstrably wrong here. So that is again her
00:09:28 saying that if you make the claim that this bill could theoretically put a life sentence on someone
00:09:35 who vandalizes the side of a mosque or the side of a synagogue, again wrong, I'm not defending the
00:09:40 act, that that could carry a life sentence. Now, we've talked about this on the show. Judges are
00:09:45 unlikely to give a life sentence to someone who does that. But the point is that the criminal
00:09:50 code will, if this bill passes, make that possible. Critics have said, including me,
00:09:56 that is my reading of the bill. Supriya says in her point, that is just wrong. Now is time,
00:10:03 Sean, for the dramatic reveal. Let's consult with the legislation. Everyone who commits
00:10:09 an offense under this act, this act refers to the criminal code, or any other act of parliament,
00:10:16 if the commission of the offense is motivated by hatred based on race, national, or ethnic origin,
00:10:22 language, color, religion, sex, age, mental, or physical disability, sexual orientation,
00:10:25 or gender identity, or expression, is guilty of an indictable offense and liable to imprisonment
00:10:31 for life. If you commit an offense that carries theoretically a sentence of less than two years
00:10:38 or not even a jail sentence, this bill says that that will be, if motivated by hate, an indictable
00:10:46 offense, which means you're talking about a prison term of two years or more, up to life in prison.
00:10:51 That is what the legislation says. Now, I very politely pointed this out to Supriya. And again,
00:10:57 I loaded my tweet up with caveats because I said, I am not a lawyer here. I could be wrong.
00:11:04 If I'm wrong, show me.
00:11:06 And I just said, please provide a citation.
00:11:08 This was her response to me.
00:11:11 She says, it's a more than fair question.
00:11:13 The answer is that you and others are reading the legislation
00:11:16 in complete isolation from the binding principles of common law
00:11:20 that apply to sentencing and bind sentencing judges.
00:11:23 Not to mention section 718 of the criminal code,
00:11:26 which she shared a screenshot to,
00:11:27 which basically says sentences must be proportionate.
00:11:30 But no one is talking here about proportionality.
00:11:33 we're talking about, does this bill fundamentally alter the maximum permissible sentence based on
00:11:39 motivation? The legislation says, yes, Supriya is saying no. She says that we are actually not
00:11:48 allowing this to change anything that doesn't already have a life sentence. Now that raises
00:11:53 the obvious question, which I put to her because we were having a very civil exchange on X. And I
00:11:58 said, okay, well, what's the point of it then? What's the point? This was her response. She says
00:12:03 here, the honest answer is that it explicitly denounces hateful conduct. The standalone hate
00:12:09 crime provision will make it much easier for law enforcement to track hate crimes across jurisdictions
00:12:14 because right now when it's only considered an aggravating factor at sentencing, it's very
00:12:18 inefficient. I've never heard this argument champion before. It may or may not be correct.
00:12:23 I don't know. But it doesn't fundamentally change that this law is being misrepresented
00:12:28 by the prime minister. Well, again, I don't know if the PMO sent her out to write that op-ed,
00:12:34 but by someone who works for the PMO and has written an op-ed trying to defend this bill.
00:12:39 It's just fundamentally wrong. Now, other people who are far more learned, who are themselves
00:12:43 lawyers, have weighed in and mercifully have agreed with the plain text reading that I had
00:12:49 of the bill here. Howard Anglin wrote that Andrew Coyne was right. It's exactly what it does and he
00:12:55 just says your response is trust judges. Yeah and that's basically the PMO's response here. They're
00:13:01 just saying well judges aren't going to give a life sentence for something minor. The point is
00:13:04 that this will override the current provisions on this and will give them that option. I want to
00:13:12 welcome into the show Christine Van Gein who is the litigation director of the Canadian Constitution
00:13:17 Foundation. We've talked about some of these concerns on the show in the past. Always good
00:13:22 to talk to you, Christine. All right. Who's right here, Supriya or yours truly? You're right,
00:13:28 Andrew. And so are all of the lawyers who are on Twitter with Supriya, I guess, explaining
00:13:36 the law to lawyers. As far as I know, is she a lawyer? I don't know. I don't know if she's a
00:13:42 member of the bar. I believe she was a lawyer at some point or at least went to law school. I don't
00:13:46 know for sure, though. Okay, so I take that back. But I have something that I think will entertain
00:13:54 you, which is, I mean, I read this this morning and was quite irritated. I wrote to the Toronto
00:14:00 Star saying that if they're going to publish Supriya, who is a government mouthpiece, I mean, 0.89
00:14:07 she's... Yeah, literally. I don't even mean that in the way that we often talk about some left-wing 0.98
00:14:11 columnist like she's literally yes she works for the the prime minister um if they're going to
00:14:16 publish that then they should and allow the critics of this bill who are careful and thoughtful in
00:14:22 their criticism then they should allow a rebuttal uh and and they've agreed and they're gonna they're
00:14:26 running my rebuttal today i've written one uh and and all credit to the star for agreeing to run a
00:14:32 rebuttal to supriya's piece so uh i'm excited that they're gonna run it but i'm a little worried that
00:14:37 she's gonna her meltdown will continue and i will now be part of the meltdown but i mean i think
00:14:44 someone needs to set the record straight that criticism of this bill is not rage farming it
00:14:51 is not bad faith i think the government would do well to remember that freedom of expression in
00:14:57 canada and is a fundamental right it is actually a precursor to peace and security and democracy
00:15:06 it is not a threat to our society, it's what makes our society possible. And the government
00:15:12 should, instead of attacking critics of the bill, which include academics from across the political
00:15:18 spectrum, the more than 6,000 people who have written to their members of parliament through
00:15:25 the Canadian Constitution Foundation's online platform, expressing their concerns with the bill,
00:15:30 The Canadian icons like Margaret Atwood, who have expressed concerns with this piece of legislation, as well as lawyers and academics who actually will be the ones engaged with applying this law.
00:15:45 All of that criticism is something that the government should be listening to, not attacking and saying we're rage farming.
00:15:52 I mean, no farming is necessary.
00:15:54 People are angry and it kind of springs up naturally.
00:15:58 like I don't need any fertilizer for this. Sean, can you put up tweet four for a second again?
00:16:06 This is the common law, the principles of common law one from Supriya. I want to get your take on
00:16:12 this, Christine, because one of the points that Supriya raises here, she said, no, no, it's the
00:16:16 other one. The principles of common law one. She says here, no, no, we'll keep going. We'll get
00:16:23 there eventually. There we go. The honest answer is, no, no, sorry. Go back to the other one.
00:16:28 this is the great thing about live media. So she says here that basically that you can't look at
00:16:36 the legislation as a standalone or a separate from principles of common law is basically the
00:16:42 thing. We don't have the tweet, but that's fine. You can't look at it separate from common law
00:16:46 principles. And as I understand it, and please correct me if I'm wrong here, because as I've,
00:16:50 you know, caveated up the wazoo, I'm not a lawyer, but statute kind of overrides common law, does it
00:16:55 not? So I do think that Supriya has a point here in saying that judges will apply principles of
00:17:04 proportionality that are already in the criminal code. Section 718.1 of the criminal code deals
00:17:13 with sentencing and there's proportionality sentences. There's also common law application
00:17:18 of sentencing, that you wouldn't have a disproportionate sentence. But I think that
00:17:24 that's true. The legislation does make the things that we're all saying possible. So it certainly
00:17:33 would be possible that if you peg on a hate as the motivation to any of these offenses,
00:17:41 that the government, the crown, the prosecution can argue for life. They're unlikely to get it.
00:17:47 it will relate to the underlying offense, but it's certainly possible for them to argue it.
00:17:54 And I think that that's a really important point because what we're not talking, the risk isn't
00:18:01 just in whether a court will sentence someone who engages in, for example, mischief motivated by
00:18:09 hate or vandalism motivated by hate, it seems unlikely that the courts would give them life
00:18:18 imprisonment. But what this legislation does is it allows the Crown to add the hate motivation
00:18:28 onto any offense, including a minor offense like mischief or vandalism. And that gives the
00:18:35 prosecution the power to threaten far, far, far higher penalties for minor offenses that they can
00:18:43 then use to pressure a defendant to plead out, including in cases where a defendant shouldn't
00:18:49 plead out because perhaps they are poorly represented. The hate threshold isn't met.
00:18:56 This is most likely actually to happen to people who are marginalized in our society who are less
00:19:04 able to afford a judge. So it's actually going to end up hurting the most marginalized people
00:19:09 in society. And look, I'm not saying that vandalism or mischief, if it's motivated by
00:19:15 hatred, and I think some classic examples are the desecration of cemeteries or spray painting
00:19:22 offensive symbols onto religious places of worship. I mean, those things, the people who
00:19:28 commit those offenses should have an intervention. And a criminal prosecution could be a part of
00:19:33 that. But allowing the Crown, the prosecution, to hold this threat of huge penalties by tying
00:19:43 the prosecution to a hate offense, really, that's the on-the-ground application of this law.
00:19:51 that's really dangerous someone on twitter also pointed out to me that by tying uh adding a hate
00:19:59 offense if the person is uh has a is an immigrant has immigrants um some type of uh permanent 1.00
00:20:08 residency if it could be used against them in a deportation proceeding even if the charges are
00:20:13 not made out but by um having a minor offense moved into a more serious offense category so
00:20:20 So there's all kinds of spillover effects that Supriya is frankly ignoring that good 1.00
00:20:25 faith critics of this piece of legislation are pointing out.
00:20:28 So I'm glad the star is running my rebuttal because I have a lot to say about it.
00:20:32 No, so am I.
00:20:33 And yeah, I think your point about the, it's easy to focus on judges.
00:20:37 And again, an argument that hinges on trust judges is not, in my view, the most compelling
00:20:41 one.
00:20:42 But even if you do-
00:20:43 I mean, the headline of Supriya's article is trust me, trust the government.
00:20:46 Trust the government.
00:20:47 Trust the PMO.
00:20:48 Oh, that's the, but you are right too.
00:20:51 I mean, when you talk about that categorization of offenses,
00:20:55 it isn't just about the possibility of a life sentence.
00:20:58 It's also about taking things
00:20:59 that would normally be dispatched with a fine
00:21:01 and putting them into indictable offense territory.
00:21:05 Yeah, and it's the threat.
00:21:06 It's the threat, even if the person,
00:21:10 perhaps they have not made out the threshold for hate speech,
00:21:14 that they have the threat now to plead out because there's this thing hanging over their head that
00:21:23 there's a much more dangerous offense that they could be convicted of that comes with a much more
00:21:28 serious penalty. So, I mean, Supriya's article makes a huge number. A lot of these are just
00:21:34 straw man arguments, right? Throughout her article, one of the big things that she focuses on
00:21:39 is this criticism a lot of us have of peace bonds and she says that uh you know peace bonds the
00:21:48 critics of the peace bond provision is that members of the public with the consent of the
00:21:53 attorney general can seek a peace bond to put restraints on people for future speech so if
00:22:00 there's reasonable grounds to believe that a person will commit a hate engage in hate speech
00:22:06 in the future, a court can order all kinds of restraints on speech, including things related
00:22:14 to access to the internet. They can even impose house arrest or electronic monitoring, like an
00:22:20 ankle bracelet. And people have raised a lot of concerns about this for obvious reasons. And
00:22:27 And Supriya says that critics of the peace bonds are misguided, that we're rage farming because peace bonds are not a normal mindset.
00:22:38 She blames the right-wing online ecosystem, first and foremost.
00:22:42 I think that's you.
00:22:43 I think that's me.
00:22:44 I think that's me.
00:22:45 I believe I'm part of that because she mentions people invoke minority report.
00:22:49 And I literally did that like three days ago.
00:22:51 So I think I might be obliquely or directly in the crosshairs on this one.
00:22:55 I mean, the reality is that no one is no serious critic of this bill is suggesting that the liberal government invented peace bonds in this piece of legislation.
00:23:06 We know that they exist. The critics, including us, are saying that the problem is a peace bond for future speech because that in itself is inherently speculative.
00:23:17 And in her article, she compares these peace bonds for future hate speech with peace bonds for shocking or terrorism.
00:23:28 And I just don't think that this helps her argument at all, because terrorism, you know, courts can be a lot more certain about the risks involved.
00:23:37 It's really obvious if someone has bought materials to buy a bomb or build a bomb.
00:23:42 And there's also a lot more certainty about what terrorism looks like, whereas with hate speech, the court needs to speculate and get into the mind of a person about what they may say in the future and whether it meets the threshold for hate speech.
00:24:00 And that threshold, which comes from a Supreme Court decision in Whatcott, is a really squishy, speculative, and subjective definition. So hate is defined as detestation and vilification. And I mean, frankly, these are synonyms for hate. So hate is defined by reference to itself. It's not especially hate helpful.
00:24:24 And I think when you've empowered the public to seek peace bonds against fellow citizens, using a definition they're unlikely to understand, you really are creating a chill on speech. And this is what the critics of the bill are saying. We are not saying that a peace bond is a new creation by Justin Trudeau. We're saying this is a bad application of a peace bond, and there are serious risks associated with it.
00:24:52 We're going to attempt to do a tweet again.
00:24:55 Maybe we should just avoid it here.
00:24:57 But this is a Supriya tweet starts with the honest answer is that it explicitly denounces.
00:25:02 So this is in response to me saying, if your claim, there we go, if your claim is that this will only apply to things that already have a life sentence, what's the point of it?
00:25:12 She says that it will make it easier for law enforcement to track hate crimes across jurisdictions because it's inefficient when it's only considered an aggravating factor.
00:25:21 I'm having trouble following the argument here, but I was wondering if you could weigh in on this
00:25:25 at all. I have no idea what she's talking about. I think the goal that the government has
00:25:32 is they want more prosecutions for hate offenses, and this is the way to achieve it.
00:25:39 So right now it is treated as an aggravating factor, but there also are stand-alone hate
00:25:45 offenses already in the criminal code, right? There's provisions about public incitement of
00:25:52 hatred and willfully promoting hatred. And they're not, especially on the public incitement,
00:25:58 there have not been a lot of prosecutions because the threshold is really high. And it's supposed to
00:26:03 be high. I mean, we're talking about criminalizing speech here, which is something that's fundamental
00:26:08 to our functioning as a democracy uh so i don't really i think what she what the government wants
00:26:15 is more prosecutions for hate offenses this is their way of attempting it but i don't understand
00:26:20 her her justification here um i i just don't know what she's referring okay no that that helps me i
00:26:26 wanted i thought i was the moron for not being able to figure it out but uh let me just ask you 0.57
00:26:31 about the problems with this because the the government you know they always do the oh yes 0.87
00:26:35 well we'll talk about this in committee but for the most part they aren't really admitting that
00:26:40 they've got anything wrong here they've had years this was first put forward or a version of it in
00:26:45 2021 shortly before the election they've been promising it uh basically since that election
00:26:50 they were first promising it within the first hundred days uh it's now uh four years well
00:26:54 three years after it was first tabled so do you think this is sloppy or do you think everything
00:27:00 in there is very deliberate and that's exactly what they wanted. I think that there is zero
00:27:06 consideration for how this will actually be applied on the ground. And I think, Andrew,
00:27:13 you should interview some criminal defense lawyers to talk about their concerns with the law,
00:27:18 because they're the ones who are going to actually be representing people who are now going to be
00:27:24 facing this sledgehammer from prosecutors to increase the severity or the potential range of
00:27:32 sentences for otherwise minor offenses. Supriya says this is something that we don't need to worry
00:27:38 about. Perhaps the government hadn't thought about how this law would be applied on the ground
00:27:44 because bureaucrats, including in justice, in the Justice Department, they're not the ones who 0.52
00:27:50 actually work and engage with you know people who get charged with crimes so they might not
00:27:58 really understand how this could play out if you give the prosecutors this massive tool yeah very
00:28:04 well said look forward to your response op-ed in the toronto star not written by someone from the
00:28:10 prime minister's office blissfully uh christine van gein litigation director at the canadian
00:28:15 constitution foundation always a pleasure have a great easter weekend thank you all right
00:28:20 Thank you, Christine. Well, it is on April 1st, the big, great tax hike day. The carbon tax revolt,
00:28:28 as I've been calling it, has been underway now for several, I mean, really years, but in particular
00:28:33 several weeks. We have seven of 10 premiers who have joined the call with Manitoba Premier Wob
00:28:40 Canu, kind of just, you know, figuring out where the wind is blowing before he says anything
00:28:43 publicly. But I think we can say his silence is speaking volumes here. But we also had a few
00:28:49 premiers testifying before committee this week premier scott moe of saskatchewan had a great
00:28:56 interjection that i wanted to share with you here this is a one of the policies and they are stacking
00:29:02 that is making life more unaffordable for not only saskatchewan residents but all canadians
00:29:07 as a whole it's making industries less competitive those are industries that
00:29:11 employ people in my community and and quite likely in yours as well and it is really showing no
00:29:16 measurable impact when it comes to reducing emissions. And I would just point to the
00:29:21 inflationary aspect of the carbon tax specifically today. And that was when the latest consumer
00:29:26 price index came out. Saskatchewan today is at 1.7%, down under the 2% projected target
00:29:33 that the Bank of Canada had hit, one full point lower than the Canadian average. And
00:29:39 Statistics Canada had said specifically that was due to a decision that the Saskatchewan
00:29:44 government made to remove the carbon tax from home heating. And so you can imagine what would
00:29:48 happen to our CPI nationwide if we were to pause, first of all, and then remove the consumer carbon
00:29:53 tax on Canadians. That was, again, a very dispassionate, fact-based approach to this.
00:30:01 Scott Moe has taken a very heavy hand. He had the benefit of having a tool in his toolbox that other
00:30:07 provinces didn't have, and that he could just stop remitting the carbon tax on home heating,
00:30:12 on gas to the government. Danielle Smith, the Premier of Alberta, also appeared before committee.
00:30:18 Very similar, took a fact-based approach to this. I'm here on behalf of Albertans and Canadians who
00:30:25 are struggling with severe financial pressures. They're increasingly desperate because they're
00:30:29 facing a cost-of-living crisis not seen in decades. Over the last two years, inflation and high
00:30:34 interest rates have driven up prices on everything from food to gas to housing, things that Albertans
00:30:39 rely on every single day. Families are being forced to make tough choices just to put food
00:30:44 on the table. Businesses are having to make sacrifices to keep the lights on. Social services
00:30:49 are under intense strain as more and more people reach out for help, many for the first time in
00:30:54 their lives. Albertans and all Canadians need common sense, compassion and responsible government
00:30:59 to prevail. That's why I'm urging you today to heed the calls of Canadians across the country
00:31:04 and suspend the increase in the carbon tax on april 1st the carbon tax has contributed to and
00:31:10 worsen canadian stress and financial pain despite the federal government's claims that canadians
00:31:15 benefit from rebates the carbon tax on a net basis will cost albertans more than 900 this year if the
00:31:22 tax is implemented the federal government's own parliamentary budget officer has also said that
00:31:27 that the cost to each Albertan will more than triple in the next six years
00:31:32 to a staggering expense of $2,700 net by 2030-2031.
00:31:38 This isn't just reckless, it's immoral and it's inhumane.
00:31:41 And the added pressure will ruin countless lives, futures and dreams.
00:31:44 It's a weight that Canadians can't bear.
00:31:47 A weight that Canadians can't bear.
00:31:50 Truer words have not been spoken by anyone at the federal level.
00:31:55 but as we have talked about time and time again, Justin Trudeau has put the blame back on the
00:32:00 Premier saying, well, you guys didn't come up with any ideas. Now, incidentally, some tried to
00:32:04 but the government said, no, no, no, that's not a high enough tax. It's not a high enough tax. No,
00:32:09 no, no, that doesn't count. Go back to the drawing board. Blaine Higgs in New Brunswick,
00:32:14 he was also a Premier who testified and was able to get a hearing from him. Now, what was interesting
00:32:19 in the case of Blaine Higgs and Scott Moe faced this as well is that the Liberal MPs really didn't
00:32:24 want them to be able to speak. These are premiers. Whatever you think of them, they are elected heads
00:32:29 of government in their respective provinces. And my goodness, Liberal MPs did not like that Canadians
00:32:34 were getting a chance to hear from them. This was what happened when Blaine Higgs was giving his
00:32:39 testimony. So my plea here is across party lines to say, let's think bigger. Let's look at Canada
00:32:48 as a solution to world environmental impact and changes.
00:32:52 Point of order, Chair.
00:32:53 As opposed to us being exactly focused on our internal affordability
00:32:58 and the cost every day of our living.
00:33:00 I apologize, Premier Higgs.
00:33:02 I just have a point of order.
00:33:03 Mr. Long, please make it brief.
00:33:09 Thank you, Chair.
00:33:11 I'm just, again, Chair, I'm confused on relevance.
00:33:14 This is an opening statement Mr. Long, please show respect for the Premier.
00:33:21 You may have disagreements with us, but please show respect for the Premier of your province.
00:33:25 Chair, I certainly do respect the Premier of the province, but again I'm just wondering
00:33:31 the relevance and I'm also wondering Chair if you can explain again which of the votable
00:33:38 items referred to in the committee contains the Canada Carbon Rebate.
00:33:42 I'm confused.
00:33:43 you able to let us know that explained that yesterday mr long mr premier higgs go ahead
00:33:49 that's not a point of order mr higgs go ahead thank you mr chair
00:33:53 that was rather interesting uh it's irrelevant to hear from the premier of new brunswick about what
00:34:01 people in his province are dealing with and again similar criticisms of danielle smith and scott
00:34:07 mo being there but even if the federal government is not listening that doesn't mean canadians
00:34:11 aren't. Pierre Polyev was in Edmonton yesterday. Again, you think Alberta equals conservative,
00:34:16 but that's not really the case in Edmonton. He still had over 3,000 people out. We had one of
00:34:21 our reporters, Isaac Lamoureux there, and Danielle Smith was one of those 3,000. She actually took
00:34:26 the stage as well, and I don't have the video of it, but I believe got her own
00:34:30 Axe the Tax t-shirt that she sported while she was on stage with Pierre Polyev. But let's talk
00:34:37 about really what's all happening here specifically on monday franco terrazano federal director for
00:34:43 the canadian taxpayers federation uh joins us once again april 1st is a big day not a good one for
00:34:49 taxpayers though is it franco what what's happening that day first off because it's hard to keep track
00:34:53 of it all well april fool's day hey and like so many other times taxpayers are the punch line
00:35:00 in ottawa okay you've got carbon tax going up alcohol taxes going up and member of parliament
00:35:06 pay going up. So you're going to pay higher prices at the pumps. You're going to pay higher
00:35:11 prices when you go to the bar and restaurant and your tax bill is going up to fund even more
00:35:17 bloated salaries of our members of parliament. So a bad day to be a taxpayer. Let me tell you.
00:35:23 Yeah. And I wanted to ask a little bit about the momentum here. I know there are some rallies.
00:35:28 Well, not some, I mean, quite a large number of rallies and these mini convoys that are being
00:35:32 planned for Monday. Pierre Polyev himself has been bringing out thousands to his
00:35:37 Axe the Tax, Spike the Hike events and whatnot. I know your colleague, Chris Sims, I think actually
00:35:43 right now or in like 30 minutes is doing a press conference in Alberta. So there is a groundswell
00:35:47 here. It's just not translating into action at the one level of government that can do something
00:35:52 about this. Well, and that's at their own peril, right? If liberal MPs and NDP MPs want to keep
00:35:58 voting to raise people's carbon taxes, that's at their own peril. Because here's the thing,
00:36:02 Canadians are absolutely united against these carbon tax hikes. Canadians are sick and tired
00:36:08 of the federal government not only making our lives more expensive, but making the necessities
00:36:13 of our lives more expensive. Canada's a big place. You know, people have to fuel up their car to get
00:36:18 to work. Well, the carbon tax makes that more expensive. Canada is a cold place. People have
00:36:24 to heat their homes. Well, the carbon tax makes that more expensive. And one more point, right?
00:36:29 We all know that the grocery prices are high. Well, let's think about that for a second because
00:36:33 the carbon tax will cost Canadian farmers a billion dollars by 2030. So the carbon tax makes
00:36:39 it more expensive for farmers to grow food. It makes it more expensive for truckers to deliver
00:36:44 the food. And it's also making it more expensive for Canadians to afford food, right? So Canadians 0.82
00:36:50 absolutely united against this carbon tax, not only Canadians, but also provincial politicians
00:36:55 of all political stripes. So the only ones who are tone deaf and late to the party
00:37:00 are Trudeau, his ministers, his liberal MPs, and also NDP MPs.
00:37:07 Let me ask you here, Franco, about really the two bits of information that the government has
00:37:14 been giving to sell the tax that I feel are confusing to Canadians, and I'm hoping you
00:37:19 have the numbers on this number one most canadians are better off with the tax than without it now
00:37:24 that on the surface sounds ridiculous but the government touts this rebate and says no no no
00:37:28 most canadians are getting more in the rebate than they're paying so that's claim one uh claim
00:37:33 two that all of the experts agree the carbon tax is not a significant driver of inflation it's just
00:37:39 one you know itsy bitsy tiny teeny little fraction of inflation and not a significant driver go
00:37:45 All right. I'm getting the football and I'm going for a run, ladies and gentlemen. So on the rebates, wrong, magic math. Okay. Now I think I heard the prime minister say something along the lines that the premiers are spreading misinformation. Well, there is a bunch of misinformation, but that is coming from prime minister, Justin Trudeau, his cabinet ministers, and his liberal MPs.
00:38:06 Because the parliamentary budget officer, the government's own independent nonpartisan budget watchdog, shows that the carbon tax will cost the average Canadian family up to $911 more a year than what they get back in rebates.
00:38:22 Hundreds of dollars more a year than what they get back in rebates.
00:38:26 Well, let's just set that data aside for a second, okay?
00:38:28 Let's just think about it logically.
00:38:30 They charge a carbon tax, then they charge their sales tax on top of the carbon tax.
00:38:34 That tax on tax alone cost Canadians about $500 million this year.
00:38:40 And then it cost the government about $200 million to hire the bureaucrats to administer the carbon tax.
00:38:47 So there is no way that a government can impose a carbon tax, charge its sales tax on top of the carbon tax,
00:38:54 skim a bunch of money off the top to pay for a bunch of bureaucrats, 0.50
00:38:57 and somehow make the vast majority of Canadians better off with rebates.
00:39:02 That is impossible.
00:39:04 But Andrew, only a couple months ago, by his own actions, Trudeau proved that the carbon tax does make life more expensive.
00:39:12 Remember, he was surrounded by his Atlantic caucus and he announced relief by taking the carbon tax off of furnace oil.
00:39:20 Now, why would he do that?
00:39:21 Because he knows that the carbon tax does make life more expensive.
00:39:26 Now, Andrew, that's the rebate shenanigans busted.
00:39:30 Let's talk about this letter from The Economist.
00:39:32 You hear economists talk about efficiency all the time. Well, Andrew, it doesn't sound that
00:39:38 efficient to me to make it more expensive for Canadian parents to fuel up their cars to get
00:39:44 their kids to soccer practice with a tax that won't solve a global issue. It doesn't sound
00:39:50 efficient to me to make it more expensive for Canadian seniors to stay warm during the winter
00:39:55 months with a tax that won't solve a global issue. It doesn't sound very efficient to me
00:40:02 to make it more expensive for a Canadian single mom to put food on the table with a tax that won't 1.00
00:40:10 solve a global issue. And not only that, you know who Trudeau should actually be listening to?
00:40:16 The people he's supposed to represent, Canadians. And the vast majority of Canadians do not support
00:40:22 his carbon tax hikes. So he should listen to Canadians. And at the very least, he should
00:40:26 cancel the carbon tax hike. All right. April 1st. Are you going to be out in the streets as well on
00:40:33 Monday? Well, we're going to be so busy. All we're doing is talking carbon tax, alcohol tax,
00:40:40 MP pay raise. You know, you talked about Chris Sims doing a press conference today. I did a
00:40:44 press conference in Ottawa today. And I know a lot of my colleagues all across Canada are going to
00:40:48 continue to bang the drum with press conferences of their own all right well we look forward to
00:40:53 that as well have a great long weekend uh and enjoy the little bit more affordability you get
00:40:57 between now and monday i guess that's the have a little tax-free rumspringer this weekend uh
00:41:02 franco terrizano always good to talk to you sir have a good weekend thanks andrew happy easter
00:41:07 all right thank you very much if you are looking to do some easter shopping may i remind you i have
00:41:13 a new book coming out in exactly two months, two months to the day. It comes out on May 28th. It is
00:41:19 called Pierre Polyev, A Political Life, a biography that I hope is, well, it's certainly not exhaustive
00:41:26 in the sense that he's still got some life left in him, but maybe he'll have to do a sequel in a few
00:41:31 years time. But that is available for pre-order. And thanks to all of you who have done your part
00:41:36 to shoot it up to number one on Amazon the day and to that we announced it. And certainly I hope
00:41:42 it'll be a number another number one bestseller when it's released but uh if you want to get your
00:41:46 bid in early that is available for pre-order now and you will be here speaking of beating the drum
00:41:51 i'll be beating the drum about that one for like three weeks when it comes out so uh please forgive
00:41:55 me uh that is it for today we will talk to you all on tuesday with more of canada's most irreverent
00:42:01 talk show have a blessed and happy easter everyone thank you god bless and good day to you all
00:42:07 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:42:09 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:42:36 We'll be right back.
00:43:06 We'll be right back.