Juno News - April 29, 2024


Trudeau tells Liberal MPs not to worry because everything is fine

Topics
Mentioned
Ottawa spent $2.2 million unsuccessfully defending Emergencies Act use Poilievre hints at using notwithstanding clause to pass tough-on-crime laws

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

178.83

Word count

8,204

Sentence count

375

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Andrew Lawton Show, host Andrew Lawton talks about his trip to the Civitas conference in Vancouver, which was a lot of fun, and a story about a Liberal MP who leaked details of a caucus meeting with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here the andrew lawton show
00:01:29 on this monday april 29th 2024 hope you are having a wonderful start to the week so far i saw some of
00:01:37 you not a huge number it was a smaller gathering by design at the civitas conference in vancouver
00:01:44 over uh the why i shouldn't say over the weekend it was on well i guess it was friday saturday so
00:01:48 I guess that was pretty much over the weekend. But that was done with the very, very great work
00:01:54 by my colleague, Lindsay Shepard, who put her organizational prowess to the test and I think
00:01:59 passed the test with room to spare. So that was a lot of fun. And one of the things that was
00:02:04 interesting about it is I was able to speak to a couple of the people that were involved in
00:02:10 politics that I interviewed when I was writing this bad boy right here, which I've got to do
00:02:14 the shameless plug on. It comes out in exactly one month, less a day. Pierre Polyev, A Political
00:02:20 Life. It is a book-length biography of the leader of the Conservative Party of Canada, who, again,
00:02:26 things can change in the next year and four months. But at this point, the polls are showing
00:02:32 is likely to be the next Prime Minister of Canada. Now, one of the things that I, there was an old
00:02:36 joke. I forget who did it. It was in an American context, but it was, you know, if the election
00:02:41 were held today, voters would be confused because that's not when it's supposed to be.
00:02:45 Something to that effect. So if the election were held today, you can't necessarily extrapolate or
00:02:49 project forward. But if the election were held today, the Conservatives would be on track. Let
00:02:55 me pull up the latest projections here. Most likely to bring in 211 seats. That is about 40
00:03:01 seats more than they need for a majority. The Liberals will be down to 67. The Bloc Québécois
00:03:07 at 39, the NDP at 24, and the Green Party with their lowly two seats. Those are the latest
00:03:14 projections courtesy of 338 Canada, which has a pretty good batting average on this. I mean,
00:03:19 pollsters always, you have to take their projections and forecasts with a bit of a grain of
00:03:23 salt. But all of this is a lead into this fascinating story in the Hilltimes that I
00:03:28 wanted to get to here. The Hilltimes has gotten a Liberal Member of Parliament who's leaked the
00:03:34 details of this caucus meeting that Liberal MPs had with Justin Trudeau. And he's telling them
00:03:41 not to worry. No, no, no, don't panic. Everything's going to be fine. You can't expect a dramatic
00:03:46 boost in public support until next year. So yeah, don't look at the polls this year. You've got to
00:03:52 wait until next year. That's when we're going to get them. And this is what the Liberal MP,
00:03:56 and not named, but this is what they are quoted as saying to the Hilltimes. Don't expect us to
00:04:02 be neck and neck in two months or six months time even. Instead, Trudeau is downplaying
00:04:08 expectations. It's like treading water when you're drowning. He was telling us to not freak out while
00:04:14 you're drowning, that you stay calm and you can get back to the top for a lot of the members who
00:04:19 are below water. So this is this MP who is clearly not too thrilled with what Trudeau was telling
00:04:24 them, trying to paraphrase it. But effectively, what this MP is saying that Justin Trudeau was
00:04:28 telling his caucus members, okay, I know it sucks now. I know it's going to suck in a couple of 0.95
00:04:34 months. It's going to suck in six months, but wait until 2025. He's basically that friend that we all 0.84
00:04:39 have when everything's going wrong that says, guys, guys, wait, I have a plan. I have a plan.
00:04:43 And everyone around is kind of wondering if I think that the plan is probably going to be worse
00:04:48 than what you've been doing up until this point. Because again, when you have been at the helm
00:04:53 for eight years as it is. It doesn't matter what your plan for the future is. You've already been
00:04:59 the one who created this mess. Now, what's interesting is the Hilltimes went to the PMO.
00:05:03 They went to Justin Trudeau's office and said, why were you telling MPs not to expect any uptick
00:05:10 in support over the next year? And this is the statement they got from the Prime Minister's
00:05:16 Press Secretary. The priority of our government is ensuring fairness for every generation of
00:05:22 Canadian. The government is focused on building more homes, making life more affordable, and
00:05:28 growing our economy. So I wasn't even hearing like a remote attempt at an answer to the question
00:05:36 that was asked. It's about fairness for every generation. They're still doing the, every time
00:05:40 they say generational fairness, you have to take a drink. You'll be passed out drunk by, you know,
00:05:45 9.30 a.m. on a Monday. But you know what? That is the rule that Justin Trudeau and Christia Freeland
00:05:50 and all have put out here. Now, the polling, interestingly enough, is showing that Canadians
00:05:55 are not going on board with the budget. They're not going along with the spending, even the capital
00:06:00 gains tax, which the Liberals thought would be really good at driving that wedge against the
00:06:04 so-called wealthy, the 1%, all of that. Even the capital gains tax hasn't really attracted the
00:06:10 level of support that the Liberals want. 74% of Canadians polled in an innovative research study
00:06:17 done the other day, said the budget will have a negative impact on the economy. 74%, 16% say it'll
00:06:24 be positive. So when you put out your flagship budget that you think is going to be the piece
00:06:29 of legislation that will turn around your flagging fortunes, and you get 16% of people in the country
00:06:36 to say, yeah, I think that'll make things better, you have got a massive, massive problem on your
00:06:42 hands. The Conservatives are on track to receive well over 40% of the vote. And this is distributed
00:06:48 across the country. This isn't just in Alberta, Saskatchewan, Upper BC. This is in parts of the
00:06:55 country that the Conservatives will need if they're going to have a majority. Now look,
00:06:59 the Conservatives have snatched defeat from the jaws of victory in the past. The 2019 election
00:07:04 was a winnable one. This was the Justin Trudeau blackface election. The 2021 election was a 0.91
00:07:11 winnable one. This was the so-called unnecessary election. So yes, conservatives could absolutely
00:07:16 bungle this, but if they have the right team of candidates, if the leader stays on track and stays
00:07:22 on message, that part is especially critical, then we are able to, I think, turn things around a
00:07:28 little bit. But what's fascinating about all of this is how unwilling Justin Trudeau is to look
00:07:34 in the mirror. And I am not in the business of giving liberal members of parliament advice,
00:07:39 And I should say they're not in the business of listening, even if I were to.
00:07:43 But liberal MPs have a tool in their toolbox that we never hear discussed.
00:07:47 They could give Justin Trudeau the old Aaron O'Toole.
00:07:50 They could give him the bum's rush out of caucus. 0.95
00:07:52 They have something called the Reform Act.
00:07:54 As MPs, they are able to initiate a vote on Justin Trudeau's leadership,
00:07:59 and they could have him out the door in one single caucus meeting.
00:08:03 They could have a letter on a Monday or a Tuesday.
00:08:06 they could send the letter if it was signed by, I forget the threshold, but a certain number of
00:08:10 MPs, then they could put this to a vote at a caucus meeting. And Justin Trudeau could literally
00:08:15 be out the door as leader in nothing flat. But they're not doing that. They're not doing that.
00:08:22 And I wonder how long liberal MPs are going to sit down and accept what Justin Trudeau is telling
00:08:28 them here, which is, no, no, I have a plan. We're going to turn it around. It's going to work out
00:08:32 great. Don't you worry, guys. It's all going to be fine. Obviously, the MP that leaked the details
00:08:37 of this caucus meeting to the Hilltimes wasn't satisfied. We know there have been a couple of
00:08:42 other little ones that we are going to see here as well. But what's fascinating to me,
00:08:49 fascinating to me in all of this is that we have not seen more liberals just for self-preservation
00:08:56 alone, for self-preservation alone, say, you know what? We want to lengthen our careers.
00:09:05 We want to lengthen the time that we have around here. Some of them may have just thrown in the
00:09:09 towel and they say, look, we know we're not going to win again. We know we're done. Let's just ride
00:09:12 this out until the bitter end. Other ones though are not so easily hoodwinked, you'd think. There
00:09:19 are some MPs. Let me just go back to those 338 projections for a moment. Liberals could go to
00:09:24 67 seats. Now there's a range there, anywhere from 50 to 94, but 67 is kind of the sweet spot right
00:09:31 now that the 338 projections are saying. So if you're one of those 67 and you want to make sure
00:09:37 you get reelected, you need a liberal party that's going to put its best foot forward.
00:09:42 And I've always maintained that Justin Trudeau's biggest threat is going to come not from Canadian
00:09:47 voters, but from his own caucus. That was my theory. I've started softening on the theory a
00:09:52 little bit because there has been no movement in that caucus. But my goodness, for just their own
00:09:58 survival, the liberals need to get rid of this guy. Now, that would probably not be what Pierre
00:10:03 Polyev wants. If you're Pierre Polyev and the conservative team, you're probably champing at
00:10:08 the bit to get a liberal led by Justin Trudeau, a liberal party led by Trudeau, because then you
00:10:14 can be the change party. You can be the anti-Trudeau when clearly this guy is not resonating.
00:10:20 If you caught my show last week, I was talking about how hilarious it is that Justin Trudeau
00:10:24 thinks the problem is that Canadians haven't heard from him enough. So he's been going on
00:10:28 this podcast tour. He was doing the podcast with Vox last week. He did one with Freakonomics.
00:10:35 I should have actually pulled something in his interview with them that I found hilarious. He
00:10:43 called himself a social activist a social activist this is what he said the exact quote here i'm
00:10:52 ultimately a social activist who's going to look to how i can have a positive impact on the world
00:11:00 you are the prime minister of canada you are the head of government of this country
00:11:04 you have won three elections you've had a tremendous opportunity to put whatever change
00:11:08 in place that you want and he is still trying to say oh i'm just this left-wing progressive activist
00:11:13 type which i mean look maybe you want to say he is but the thing about activists is that activists
00:11:18 are not actor i mean he's an actor in the the sense of you know drama teacher but uh the thing
00:11:23 about him is that he is in a position where he could be actioning things that he wants and the
00:11:29 progressives i think were fed up with him even before people on the right were because the
00:11:33 progressives had such high hopes for him that he didn't deliver on it's like okay he gets in
00:11:37 he legalized his pot. Everything else just kind of goes by the wayside. He hasn't reconciled with
00:11:42 Indigenous people. He hasn't fixed gender inequality. He hasn't done all of this. It's
00:11:46 just been window dressing, and people have absolutely tired of it. Now, I do want to do,
00:11:50 just before we move on to our next guest here, I want to do a little bit of an I told you so
00:11:56 moment. So last weekend, this past weekend, Vashi Kapelos on CTV did a sit-down interview
00:12:03 with, or sorry, she did a, she's CTV, yeah, I think she's CTV, sorry, I mixed it up.
00:12:08 She did a sit-down interview with the president of Poland, and she asked a question that I think
00:12:14 is a very well-suited one for leaders of European nations. This is that clip.
00:12:19 I want to ask you a bit about your visit specifically here to Canada. You mentioned
00:12:22 defense spending. I'll get to that in a moment. You're here at an energy conference, and I have
00:12:27 spoken to a number of other European leaders in the past few months about Canadian energy in
00:12:32 particular and efforts underway in Europe to wean itself off of any kind of
00:12:36 dependence on Russia. Poland has been largely successful in that so far. I'm
00:12:40 wondering though when it comes to in particular liquefied natural gas, if that
00:12:44 is a Canadian product Poland is interested in? Of course, yes. If only 0.91
00:12:51 Canada is ready to supply its energy gas to Poland, we have got our energy
00:12:57 terminal in Świnoujštje right now. It has got reloading capacities. We're extending them. We
00:13:03 are extending the terminal and we also have plans to set up another LNG terminal in the part of
00:13:11 Gdańsk. If Canada offered its LNG to us and if this gas could be bought attractively at attractive
00:13:21 prices, well, we have been receiving gas from US companies. We have been receiving gas also from
00:13:26 Qatar. In the same way, we would be ready to negotiate, to talk and to accept Canadian gas
00:13:33 as well. Even more so that there is an investment connected with one of the LNG terminals on the
00:13:40 eastern coast of Canada. And there is our PKA Arlen, our concern, our company participating in
00:13:46 that. So he's saying there, oh, absolutely. Yeah, we love Canadian LNG. We'd like to buy it right
00:13:53 now we have to get some from the US but also some from Qatar we'd rather buy from Canada let's get a
00:13:58 good market price if only the Canadian government were willing to offer it and this is a great
00:14:03 question it was a phenomenal answer not all that a surprising answer energy independence and energy
00:14:08 security are crucial in Europe countries that don't want to have to be reliant on Russian oil
00:14:14 and gas will be able to buy from elsewhere if only elsewhere is willing to sell it so Justin
00:14:20 Trudeau, he's the guy that gets up there and says, oh, there's no business case. But why I found that
00:14:25 interview with the Polish, the head of Poland so fascinating is because I had said something two 0.77
00:14:31 weeks ago at the Canada Strong and Free Network conference that proved eerily prescient.
00:14:36 I must say, I've been quite surprised that Justin Trudeau keeps inviting European heads of
00:14:42 government and state here, because every time they come, they all do an interview with, you know,
00:14:46 Vashy Kapelos or something and say, oh, I'd love to buy LNG. And then Justin Trudeau has to come
00:14:50 out and say, oh, there's no business case. Am I right or am I right? I even got the interviewer
00:14:57 right. I said, oh yeah, every time the European heads of state come, it's Vashy Kapelos they sit
00:15:01 down with and say they want to buy Canadian LNG. And not two weeks later, here we have
00:15:05 the Polish president coming. And he's the president, right? Not the prime minister.
00:15:11 I get them mixed up in these new fandangled republics and all of that. The constitutional
00:15:16 monarchy is the right one. He is the president. But the fascinating thing is this is literally
00:15:22 happening. Every time one of these European heads of government or heads of state comes here,
00:15:27 they're asked the very obvious, very sensible question. They give the obvious, sensible answer.
00:15:31 And in the end, we are all forced to deal with the fact that Canada is the one putting barriers
00:15:36 and roadblocks here. I want to shift gears to an entirely different topic. You may have seen
00:15:42 in Montreal that the very worst of American academia has been imported to Canada in the 0.82
00:15:49 sense that there is now an encampment at McGill University in Montreal that is inhabited and
00:15:55 occupied by these anti-Israel protesters that are making all sorts of demands, among others,
00:16:01 that the university divests its endowment funds from anything connected to Israel, that it severs
00:16:06 ties as a school with Israeli enterprise. And we've also heard reports of very anti-Semitic
00:16:12 rhetoric and statements, students being harassed for no other reason than their Jewish identity
00:16:18 and in the values that a lot of Jews, most Jews have of supporting the state of Israel's right
00:16:25 to exist. And what was fascinating about this is that McGill has kind of just said, oh, well,
00:16:30 oh, I don't know, all shocks. They've given very little in the way of any sort of pushback as we
00:16:36 have an encampment that is now entrenching itself and will soon I suspect balloon to other campuses
00:16:41 Barbara Kay is a columnist with the National Post and the Epoch Times and actually got to see her
00:16:46 over the weekend briefly at the Civitas conference Barbara always lovely to see you thanks so much
00:16:51 for coming on today a pleasure a pleasure Andrew oh we uh you're muted there oh perfect I got your
00:16:58 audio now let me ask you Barbara first off about whether you're surprised by this I mean you've
00:17:02 lived in montreal for i don't know about all your life but certainly for many years and you've seen
00:17:07 what's happened since october 7th was this unexpected at mcgill no not at all because
00:17:14 uh this is kind of like a meme right now uh in fact i can't believe there would be a university
00:17:19 campus um anywhere in north america that would consider itself uh respectable if it didn't have
00:17:26 something like this going on an encampment uh because that's what uh that's what is done to
00:17:31 show what a great social activist you are and especially uh it would be especially uh
00:17:37 anticipated at universities where there's a large jewish presence as there is at mcgill so
00:17:42 no it doesn't surprise me at all how about mcgill's response to this because they've basically
00:17:50 in a lot of ways it looks like they've washed their hands of it and we had uh students that
00:17:54 were sent out through the student association which is supposed to be i don't know advocating
00:17:58 on things like tuition fees instead send out students the death toll in Gaza, which based on
00:18:04 very, very sketchy numbers from the Gazan Health Authority, there we go, just basically pinning
00:18:10 the deaths of 31,000 people on Israel. And this is the type of rhetoric that students at McGill
00:18:17 are being bombarded with. Well, you're right. They're not specific about who's dying or how
00:18:25 many, it might be that 30,000 have been killed, but what they don't specify is that according to
00:18:31 Israel, 13,000 of them have been terrorists and Hamas has not denied that. So the ratio of those 0.96
00:18:38 killed to civilians killed to militants is actually in urban warfare of this kind quite low.
00:18:46 But, you know, they'll tell you all kinds of things because they get their information from
00:18:51 sources that are not reliable. They are determined to make their case for support against Israel,
00:18:59 that's their main concern is to call Israel out as an evil nation and that's the message. 0.59
00:19:06 And they're delighted to be active like this on campus. This is what students do. You may remember
00:19:12 in 1968 there were similar demonstrations against the Vietnam War and they were also taking over
00:19:18 the campuses in fact that was our first experience of students actually taking over campuses and uh
00:19:24 the administration losing control of the uh of what was happening on their own campuses
00:19:30 of course in those days the message was peace and love and now it's intifada and hate so that's
00:19:37 changed um but um i did expect it and i agree with you that the administration is acting in a very
00:19:43 namby-pamby way because they're not quite sure what to do and they're afraid to take muscular
00:19:49 action as is required. Well and one of the things that and again you always end up when you're
00:19:54 talking about any display of this nature with this whataboutism and you know a lot of people
00:19:59 that had no issue with the Freedom Convoy in Ottawa are saying they've got they want police
00:20:03 to come in and crack skulls here and the flip side people that wanted police to crack skulls
00:20:07 in Ottawa with the Freedom Convoy are saying oh no no this is the right to protest so I think 0.52
00:20:11 there's hypocrisy all around. But the one point I'll stress here is that universities have a
00:20:15 demonstrable track record of treating different demonstrations differently. Like I bet if the
00:20:20 McGill University Pro-Life Society were to stage a, they would be gone in no time. And here we have
00:20:28 an encampment of this nature. It's very anti-Israel, bordering on, depending on the rhetoric of the
00:20:33 individual person, anti-Semitic. And McGill is saying, well, we'd like to come up with a resolution.
00:20:37 we'll try to talk we'll try to engage and that's not a group that they afford to other or right
00:20:41 they afford to other groups no they're afraid of this group uh they're not afraid to act as you say
00:20:47 uh with politically incorrect groups such as pro-lifers um and uh they certainly wouldn't
00:20:54 tolerate for one second uh you know people that that are saying were that were anti-immigration
00:21:00 or uh in any way in any way asserting themselves as as white canadians or anything like that uh
00:21:06 There's a set menu for who is considered racialized and who's considered the victim, and the Palestinians are one of them, and it does not occur to them that these expressions of hatred for Jews, because Jews are not on the victim list, to say, you know, for this one time, we have to agree, the numbers of anti-Semitic incidents and hate incidents are so high,
00:21:35 I think we're going to just have to include this group of Jews on our campus as amongst the racialized and we can't let this continue to happen. In the United States, we have seen states, Florida and Texas, where the governors have said, no, this just isn't happening. 1.00
00:21:54 You private universities have codes of conduct.
00:21:58 You're not applying them.
00:21:59 And by the way, of course, McGill has a code of conduct, just like all the other universities.
00:22:03 They are not applying their code of conduct.
00:22:06 Their code of conduct does not allow for harassment on the basis of nationality or affiliation of any kind.
00:22:14 I mean, they may not like Zionism.
00:22:17 That's too bad for Jews, for most Jews.
00:22:21 I think you froze there for a moment, or at least it did on, oh, I got you back now. Sorry, I might be on my end here. This is the glory of doing things live. But I'll ask you about the, well, okay, let me take a step back here. If we talk about what's led us to this point, there have been people sounding the alarm about the increasing rhetoric, the ratcheting up of language.
00:22:42 At first it was, not at first, but early on we saw people protesting businesses, especially in Toronto, that happened to have a peripheral connection to Israel or no connection at all.
00:22:52 It was just connected to someone who was Jewish.
00:22:54 And then you go to this protest against McGill.
00:22:57 Of all the people complicit in what Israel is doing, if you want to believe that Israel is in the wrong here, I put McGill University very low on that list.
00:23:05 So the idea of targeting your ire at McGill when you have an issue with Israel and the IDF and the Mossad and all of that is absurd.
00:23:14 And even if they got what they want or what they say they want and McGill were to divest its funds from Israel, which is not even handled by the university.
00:23:21 They have an external fund there and sever ties with Israeli academics.
00:23:25 You're changing nothing.
00:23:27 So that's the issue is that it's not even like it's an effective protest because their issue, they claim, is with Israel.
00:23:33 And I think when you look at it through that lens, it becomes apparent their issue isn't with Israel.
00:23:38 Their issue is much broader than that.
00:23:40 I think it is broader, of course.
00:23:42 It's very anti-Western as well as anti-Israel.
00:23:46 And they know that they're probably not going to change the boycott.
00:23:50 All their efforts at boycotts of Israel have failed because it's not in their gift to tell the university where to place their funds.
00:23:59 And they know that.
00:24:00 But they are going after hearts and minds.
00:24:03 they have been very successful in that endeavor and the more noise they make uh on the campuses
00:24:09 and and it's a central place it lends itself uh to you know big open spaces to encamp uh the
00:24:16 universities could end this very quickly by uh by taking the ringleaders and expelling them that's 0.77
00:24:22 what they have done in in florida and and in texas and it's been very effective that's the end of the
00:24:27 protest. They could expel a hundred students or suspend a hundred students. They could end this
00:24:35 very easily. So these students are activating either knowingly or unknowingly for a revolution
00:24:43 and to do that they have to change what's acceptable to what is unacceptable. They have to
00:24:51 turn Jews into pariahs. We saw that at Columbia that Jews were advised to go home, they weren't
00:24:56 safe they caused the university to have to go on to online classes this is a big victory for them
00:25:03 because they they are showing a lot of muscle and uh you know people get the message uh we
00:25:11 we had better start appeasing these people or uh things could get violent and and out of control
00:25:19 i i think it to me it's very obvious what is happening and the only way to combat it is very
00:25:25 swiftly and very and to enforce your own codes of conduct and it's it's at a certain stage it's easy
00:25:31 to do and later on it isn't so easy to do uh why they have chosen the path of appeasement perhaps
00:25:38 it's because the message from the top from our prime minister is non-messaging uh and he doesn't
00:25:44 seem to care about uh the rampant anti-semitism that that uh finds finds its ground zero at the
00:25:51 universities but but spreads with the demonstrations all through society uh it it creates a mood it
00:25:56 creates a mood it creates a feeling that well maybe you know if they're that angry maybe they're right
00:26:02 um and it does change hearts and minds so they they are winning the propaganda war by uh with
00:26:08 these tactics and so i'm sorry to see it and i'm sorry that so many intelligent people in the
00:26:13 administration are failing to do their duty sad one one of my very sad indeed one of my favorite
00:26:19 Canadian columnist Barbara Kaye always a pleasure Barbara. Thank you Andrew. Thank you and this is
00:26:25 going to get worse before it gets better and by that I think the first step is that we'll see this
00:26:31 balloon at other university campuses. I think it was uh Ottawa U which has preemptively said yeah
00:26:36 we're not going to stand for this. I mean if you want to try it at Ryerson, well you can't say
00:26:40 Ryerson anymore, if you want to try it at Toronto Metropolitan University you have to like get there
00:26:43 already are like basically like a homelessness encampment on the streets of downtown Toronto
00:26:48 know, so you might have to move over some tents to build yours. But, you know, at other schools,
00:26:52 I don't see this as being all that out of place. Now, I mean, how many students want to stick
00:26:57 around once exams are done? I don't know. And in that sense, it's a little bit less disruptive than
00:27:02 had they done this during the school year. And I wonder if that's going to be the excuse we hear
00:27:05 from the schools of, oh, well, you know, where our campus is pretty much empty anyway this summer,
00:27:09 some nonsense like that. So I'm not, by the way, taking the anti-free speech view. I believe that
00:27:15 you have a right to express your opinion. I do believe that at times you can be disruptive in
00:27:21 doing that. I also believe that you have a right to enforce your property and that's what these
00:27:26 universities are only selectively doing as we see. So with that let's pivot back to the topic we kept
00:27:34 us going on last week which was plastics. We had the big UN plastics conference in Ottawa. The
00:27:39 federal government announced the forthcoming plastics registry. Countries around the world
00:27:44 including Canada, working towards a plastics treaty. Now, I should have done the plastic 0.91
00:27:49 straw gag again. I don't know if, Sean, we have that photo we can pull for later on, but
00:27:53 you may recall when the Supreme Court struck down the federal government's plastics ban, I celebrated 1.00
00:27:58 by a big, giant batch of plastic straws that had been, you know, hidden away because I didn't want
00:28:04 the plastic police to come knocking and collect them. And then we saw a lot of Canadians very 0.86
00:28:11 happy about that because canadians hate no one likes paper straws not even the people that make
00:28:15 them don't like them no one likes paper straws they're terrible but stephen gilbo said this
00:28:22 i i feel that there's large consensus on the fact that we we need to ban certain single-use plastics
00:28:28 we need to do better and increase recycled content for for the fabrication of of of plastics and i
00:28:35 I've even heard some very large multinationals tell me we want to have access to recycled
00:28:42 plastics so we don't need to use virgin plastics anymore.
00:28:47 We need to do a better job in designing plastics so that they can be more easily reusable or
00:28:53 recyclable.
00:28:54 We need to do a better job on labeling.
00:28:57 And I think all of these things, or many of these things, we can agree that we all need
00:29:01 to do that, everyone around the world, so that there is a level playing field and we
00:29:06 don't end up with a patchwork of policies and measures around the world, and that even
00:29:10 the private sector is calling for. Large multinationals are saying we need a legally binding plastics
00:29:17 treaty, which is obviously in stark contrast with the position of the Conservative Party
00:29:21 of Canada, who just issued a petition saying we need to bring back plastic straws because
00:29:26 there's no environmental problem with plastics where there are 200 countries in the world
00:29:32 Unilever, Pepsi and Coca-Cola who profoundly disagree with the Conservative Party of Canada's
00:29:37 position on plastic pollution. A consensus maybe there's a consensus among the types of people
00:29:45 with whom Stephen Gilbo cavorts you often find them scaling buildings and getting arrested
00:29:50 maybe there is a consensus among those people but there's not a consensus among ordinary Canadians
00:29:56 that the plastics ban is the way to go and that plastic straws should be just relegated to exile
00:30:03 here. I want to welcome in our old friend Chris Sims, our Monday correspondent and the Alberta
00:30:07 Director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. Chris, what about you? Are you hearing this
00:30:12 rumored consensus around the plastics ban? Of the ban on plastic straws, you probably saw,
00:30:21 of course, the famous now picture of Premier Danielle Smith, your co-host. Is she still
00:30:25 your radio co-host are you i don't know i've never been technically just relieved of my guest hosting
00:30:31 duty so i'm not sure andrew is always on standby at any moment to step in as alberta premier so just
00:30:36 in case he throws down the microphone and leaves that's what he has to go do so premier daniel
00:30:40 smith had a pretty funny joke where she had i think she was drinking a ginger ale and she had 0.98
00:30:44 two plastic straws shoved together and she was drinking it like this and it's one of those things
00:30:49 right? Where I think it's more than just it being silly to have this kind of gross paper straw
00:30:56 that's disintegrating in your drink. I think it's because this has really gotten up into people's
00:31:01 faces, right? Like what you're choosing to eat with, right? What you're choosing to eat, that
00:31:06 sort of stuff. That's really kind of a domestic personal choice. And I think the plastic straw
00:31:12 thing versus the paper straw thing really bugged people. And so I think it's emblematic really of
00:31:18 how this government is operating. What I found interesting is that it sounds now like he's trying
00:31:23 to make noise that perhaps a global treaty on plastics and everybody agreeing on plastics
00:31:30 might be too complicated. That's the first time I have ever heard that minister tap the brakes on
00:31:37 anything. Now, I could be misinterpreting him, but some of the tone that was coming from Minister
00:31:42 Guy Bo there, I found a little bit more slowed down than he usually is. I'll also point out that
00:31:49 people just don't want these sorts of bans. So in the city of Edmonton, for example, there's now
00:31:55 this big bag fee. It's 15 cents per bag, and then it's going to be going up to 25 cents per bag.
00:32:01 Pretty soon it's going to be $2 per reusable bag. You know, those things that are filling up all of
00:32:07 our sink cupboards and all of our pantries, at least speaking for myself. And so that's really
00:32:12 costing people a lot of money and people are pushing back on it. They push back on it so hard
00:32:17 in Calgary, Andrew, that they've had to repeal it. So Calgary tried doing this whole, you're going to
00:32:22 have to pay every single time you use a bag. And now they've had to back off on it completely. So
00:32:27 I think they are getting some serious pushback on this. Yeah. And I mean, my view on the plastic
00:32:32 straws thing has never been that plastic straws are my hill to die on. It's that a government
00:32:37 that's going to regulate something so small and so minor will also regulate the big things that
00:32:42 do matter. And I think you need to push back against these small incursions. And to be fair,
00:32:47 a lot of companies now are keeping with the plastic straws. Now, I don't know if that's
00:32:51 just because they're buying into the environmental argument or if it's just because they're not
00:32:56 exactly confident that the ban won't be reimposed or they had to invest so much in all of this
00:33:01 inventory and redo their supply chains around it, whatever the case is. But I've never been
00:33:05 against individual companies doing that.
00:33:07 It's always been when government is the one
00:33:09 that manages it and manipulates it.
00:33:11 And absolutely, if they're going to,
00:33:13 because that's how regulation comes.
00:33:15 That's how government grows.
00:33:16 They regulate the things that people are already doing.
00:33:19 And then they start encroaching
00:33:20 a little bit more on other things.
00:33:21 And at a certain point,
00:33:22 the regulatory regime has gotten so large,
00:33:25 you can't really dismantle it.
00:33:27 Yes, exactly.
00:33:28 And before you know it,
00:33:29 you're trying to balance all of your groceries
00:33:31 leaving the store.
00:33:33 In fact, just this past weekend,
00:33:34 when I managed to go get our groceries I was watching this lady and she clearly you know 1.00
00:33:39 I don't know if she didn't have the money to buy another bag on top of another bag that she must 1.00
00:33:43 have forgotten in her car but she was trying to leave and you know those little roast chickens 0.98
00:33:47 that come in like the plastic container thingy and they've got the little cardboard sleeve
00:33:51 she had three of them in her hand like she grabbed like this like without the bag and she's trying to
00:33:58 get past the lottery counter and they're about to fall out and so luckily one of the checkout ladies 1.00
00:34:03 ran after her and just gave her a paper bag, like, shh, don't tell anyone here, right? And she
00:34:09 managed to make it to her store. And this is what I'm getting at is, yeah, is that the hill to die
00:34:13 on? Well, logically, no. But that's such a personal thing, right? They're right up in your grill,
00:34:18 right at the grocery store counter all the time. They're right there for your meal with your family
00:34:23 at the restaurant all the time. And to your point, I think that then is what gives them
00:34:28 more incursion into your life. And further, on the idea of a global issue when it comes to plastics,
00:34:35 a couple of years ago, it was in the New York Post, and I'm trying to recall from memory here,
00:34:40 I think they reported that nine out of 10 of the plastic polluting rivers in the world were in
00:34:47 Asia and in Africa. Meaning this is not a problem, you know, that terrible idea of the garbage patch 0.99
00:34:54 and the big floating amount of plastics pollution in the ocean,
00:34:57 it's not coming from North America and it's not coming from Europe.
00:35:01 So why the strange impositions on Canadians?
00:35:04 I have never seen someone pick up a coffee cup and throw it into a river.
00:35:10 People would have a stroke in Canada if you watch somebody do that.
00:35:14 Further, I often see volunteer organizations from every walk of life,
00:35:20 that's often what they'll go do is pick up litter in the spring
00:35:23 and make sure our shorelines are nice and clean.
00:35:26 And so it would be probably smarter for the Trudeau government
00:35:29 to encourage that sort of behavior instead of always with the stick,
00:35:33 which doesn't result in anything.
00:35:35 Yeah, and a lot of it, I mean, it's funny because the government
00:35:38 will always use moments where it believes it has political capital to do big things.
00:35:43 So in Canada, we've seen firearms law that have done this.
00:35:46 A lot of the push for a plastic span came after that viral video of a sea turtle,
00:35:50 a poor sea turtle that had a plastic straw suck up its nose. 1.00
00:35:53 it was tragic it was difficult to watch it also was not canadian's problem and it was not canadian's
00:35:58 fault this was the you mentioned it earlier this was the danielle smith uh picture uh where she 0.67
00:36:03 celebrated the plastics ban and uh engaged in a consumption of ginger ale there i i still like
00:36:10 mine better though this because i was a bit more celebratory i think than the premier was there we
00:36:15 go. Yeah. That was mine. Take that sea turtles. Take that sea turtles. No sea turtles were harmed
00:36:23 in the making of that gag. But again, it's the little things that matter. Yeah, for sure. And
00:36:28 you know what? The sea turtle picture, and I remember it because it was very impressionable,
00:36:32 right? And it's awful. It reminds me, I grew up in the eighties. It reminds me of this video
00:36:37 footage that all of us eighties kids saw of, you know, those six ring plastic things that go around
00:36:42 a six pack oh yeah yeah yeah the um yeah it showed a duck i was gonna describe them and i
00:36:47 realized you already did i know exactly what you're talking yeah it showed a duck and this
00:36:51 poor bird this waterfowl don't remember what kind of duck sorry but this waterfowl had this around
00:36:56 its neck and i remember this video was everywhere and this is way before the interwebs kids but it
00:37:01 really made an impression and so now you can find like any gen xer if you watch them with those
00:37:06 things they're snipping them into little tiny pieces before my wife does that as well and i 0.96
00:37:10 always wonder maybe she got the video. I guarantee you she saw the video of this duck and so this is
00:37:15 my point is that people who are in a position to care do care and they take efforts to make sure
00:37:23 that they aren't endangering the environment and I think that's what annoys people a lot is when
00:37:28 they see something like this coming from the Trudeau government saying you know what guys
00:37:32 I've got this how about you guys figure out how to balance the budget or maybe run the passport
00:37:36 office in town. I can figure out my recycling in my own home. And on top of this, if they start
00:37:43 getting into something like a plastics registry, I just shudder to think at how much money they're
00:37:47 going to spend on this. To your point earlier, with the failed long gun registry, we wound up
00:37:53 blowing almost $2 billion on that thing. And it didn't make Canadians any safer from the lawful
00:37:59 duck hunters here in Canada. Same thing going with this current gun confiscation. Again, taking
00:38:04 firearms away from law-abiding firearms owners, they haven't seized a single one yet and they've
00:38:10 already blown millions of dollars. So just imagine what kind of money they could burn with the
00:38:15 plastics registry here in Canada. So I wanted to move to your old province here for a moment,
00:38:20 British Columbia. British Columbia is a useful test case for a lot of things. I think for drug
00:38:25 policy, it's been a useful test case now because this is what happens when the decriminalization
00:38:31 harm reduction left gets its way uh but also on the carbon tax because bc had a carbon i was
00:38:35 going to say before it was cool it's not cool now but bc had a carbon tax before the federal
00:38:39 government pushed one so we've got a fair bit of runway in bc to see what a carbon tax does and
00:38:46 shocking answer is chris emissions have gone up up not down with a carbon tax and thank you for 0.77
00:38:54 giving me a chance to highlight this because this is something that was brought up i did a debate
00:38:58 sorry I talked to another show host but it wasn't for very long and I didn't all right get lost
00:39:02 I did a debate on TVO with Steve Bacon I wasn't debating him but I was debating a University of
00:39:10 Ottawa professor and he said something to the effect of and I'm paraphrasing well emissions
00:39:14 in British Columbia have gone down no they have not and in fact if you pull up the government
00:39:20 website and you can pull up the actual data I don't know if you guys have the screen captures
00:39:25 there it looks like a super boring website but you can click on something called provincial inventory
00:39:30 and it pulls up this spreadsheet and it goes way back to like you know the 1990s right so there we
00:39:36 go so this is the british columbia government website if you click on the provincial inventory
00:39:43 there where you see that hyperlink and it pops up into an excel sheet and from there you can take a
00:39:49 look at the data. So the BC Liberal government, led by then Premier Gordon Campbell, introduced
00:39:55 the provincial carbon tax in British Columbia back in 2008. So it came into effect in fiscal year
00:40:02 2008-2009. Back then, just to note, they introduced it as being revenue neutral.
00:40:08 On paper it was because they did do a corresponding income tax cut that year,
00:40:12 but very quickly it became just a huge tax grab. So spoiler alert. But if you go to the actual data
00:40:18 site and you take a look starting in 2009, you can see how many total megatons of carbon CO2
00:40:26 was emitted that year. Then if you follow along 10 years, okay, so 10 years is usually a good
00:40:33 data set. Go from 2009 to 2019, emissions went up, Andrew, by more than 7%. Even if we wanted to
00:40:45 include the terrible years of when people were locked in their homes or businesses were shut
00:40:49 down and they weren't allowed to travel, right? During the pandemic and the lockdown years of
00:40:53 2020, 2021, it still went up by nearly 2%. So this is the whole point. When the BC government
00:41:01 first hatched this carbon tax back in 2008, which by the way is the model, the Trudeau government
00:41:07 has said out loud that British Columbia is their model for the carbon tax. So what you see there,
00:41:12 they're the canary, right? So they promised back in 2008 that their carbon tax would stop at $30
00:41:18 a ton, be revenue neutral, reduce emissions, and that they would provide a whole bunch of
00:41:24 alternative affordable energy sources. None of those things is true today.
00:41:30 The problem that I have with this is that the sensible response is that someone says,
00:41:36 oh, wow, I guess this isn't working. But that's never the way they go. The way they go is, wow,
00:41:40 we're not doing it aggressively enough, or it would have been worse if we didn't. And that's
00:41:47 the most challenging part of this is that you're making an incredibly valid point that will be
00:41:52 completely reversed in meaning by the people that brought us in here in the first place.
00:41:56 You're right. And that is often what they say. So on the first one, wow, that means we're not
00:42:01 doing it hard enough. Okay. What do you guys want? Like you already see record lineups for food
00:42:08 banks, okay? You already see people not being able to afford to heat their homes. So the average
00:42:14 Alberta family, for example, is going to be out more than $900 this year, net, with the carbon
00:42:21 tax. That's caused by the carbon tax. The folks in British Columbia, they're getting screwed even
00:42:27 more, frankly, Andrew, because by the time a two-person working family hits around $72,000 a
00:42:33 year around there out there, they get zero for a rebate. So if you are a hairdresser and you're
00:42:40 married to a grocery store manager, you're not getting any rebate in British Columbia.
00:42:45 Like all of the middle class there is getting completely screwed on the carbon tax. So my 0.91
00:42:49 question to them then would be, okay, what do you want? You want people freezing to death in the
00:42:53 dark? What do you mean do it harder? And secondly, the idea that, oh, well, if we hadn't done it,
00:42:59 would have been higher than it would have been. That's magical thinking because we can't know.
00:43:04 We cannot know that. And what's interesting here is that politicians will promise you all sorts of
00:43:09 things. Like I mentioned, they said it was going to stop at $30 a ton, be revenue neutral, reduce
00:43:14 emissions, all that great stuff. And then when their scheme doesn't work out, they run out onto
00:43:19 the pitch and they move those goalposts really fast. I've also heard people say, oh, well, you
00:43:24 know, there's more people there now. Okay, so what then? You want to shut down immigration to British 1.00
00:43:28 colombia is that your plan because none none of this makes sense every single time they try to
00:43:33 set something up it doesn't work and it doesn't make sense and what's super frustrating is that
00:43:37 when you give them a mathematical solution of okay tackle the big end of the arithmetic problem
00:43:42 sell natural gas to your point with the with the polish leader there sell natural gas to india
00:43:48 reduce their super heavy duty emissions they don't like that answer they're clinging to this
00:43:53 carbon tax in almost a religious way even though it's not working yeah very well said all right
00:43:59 well great points all around chris we will check oh no i'm off next monday so we'll check in with
00:44:03 you in two weeks oh but uh thank you so much as always for coming on always great to talk to you
00:44:07 chris from the canadian taxpayers federation safe travels all right thank you and that does it for
00:44:13 me don't worry you got me the rest of the week still folks uh we will be back tomorrow in just
00:44:16 23 hours and 15 minutes here on the andrew lawton show canada's most irreverent talk show with true
00:44:22 North. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to the Andrew
00:44:27 Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:44:52 We'll be right back.
00:45:22 We'll be right back.