Juno News - November 09, 2022


Trudeau told Ford police didn't need more "tools" to deal with protests

Mentioned
The government should leave the internet alone Canada is not a serious country

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

180.95

Word count

7,093

Sentence count

268

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton is joined by Jamil Jumaane to talk about his controversial exit from Bell Media's flagship radio station in Toronto, the Public Order Emergency Commission, and the return of masks.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:13 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:16 This is another edition of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show,
00:00:20 The Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North on this Wednesday, November 9th, 2022.
00:00:26 A happy birthday to my brother.
00:00:28 I don't know if he's listening or watching.
00:00:31 If he's not, then I guess it was just a good way of telling you all that happens to be my brother's birthday today.
00:00:37 But let no one say I don't acknowledge the important moments.
00:00:40 I'll send him a text once I get off air, just in case.
00:00:43 But I do want to talk today about, we have a lot.
00:00:46 Jamil Jumaane is going to be here in just a little bit to talk about how he failed to rise up to Bell Media's expectations of him
00:00:54 being the token black man on their flagship radio station in Toronto and it ended up costing him his
00:01:02 job. He's now suing Bell Media and we will talk to Jamil about that now. He certainly has landed
00:01:08 on his feet. He's the president of the Canada Strong and Free Network and is doing fantastic
00:01:13 work over there. Also going to talk a little bit later on about the potential return of masks.
00:01:19 We're already seeing little bits and pieces of it here.
00:01:22 The University of Waterloo has plunged its classrooms back into mask mandate paradise.
00:01:28 And we are seeing some health units start to talk about masking.
00:01:31 So that'll be something that we need to definitely keep an eye on.
00:01:35 It's the only thing that is not covered when there's a mask mandate.
00:01:38 You can see out of your eyes and that's about it.
00:01:41 And we are also going to talk about the Public Order Emergency Commission.
00:01:45 Now, let me say, first off, there was a bit of an unexpected turn of events today, and I'm not in Ottawa, so I didn't see it in person, but I saw the clip going around just like all of you did, where one of the lawyers who represents the commission, he represents the Public Order Emergency Commission, actually collapsed midway through his examination of the witness.
00:02:08 Now, this gentleman, Monsieur Poliquin, is not clear actually what condition he's in right now.
00:02:15 The commission has said to protect him and his family or out of respect for him and his family,
00:02:21 no details will be released about his health.
00:02:24 That is something that we are going to respect.
00:02:27 And I mean, obviously, these things happen and not often.
00:02:30 And we hope he's OK and send our thoughts and prayers.
00:02:32 But it was an interruption in the proceedings.
00:02:35 That witness is going to testify tomorrow.
00:02:37 and the commission has reconvened I think as of about an hour ago but they've done it with a
00:02:43 different witness so they've just rearranged the schedule a little bit but again when you have
00:02:47 something going on like this this is the inevitable byproduct things will come up you have to work
00:02:53 around them what I'm very interested in is what happened yesterday when a document was put forward
00:03:01 to an OPP representative and this document contained a rough transcript and more of a
00:03:08 summary I guess of a call between Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Ontario Premier Doug Ford
00:03:14 when it just to contextualize it here it was February 9th so we're talking about five days
00:03:20 before the Emergencies Act was invoked and it was a call specifically dealing with the blockade at
00:03:26 the Ambassador Bridge, which we know from sworn testimony was not connected to the Ottawa protest
00:03:32 in any direct way. It was certainly inspired by and perhaps a copycat of, but it wasn't being
00:03:39 quarterbacked or coordinated by Tamara Leach or any of the folks in Ottawa. And they were talking
00:03:46 about this, and I'm going to let this clip speak to it. This is a lawyer, Alan Haunter, with the
00:03:51 Democracy Fund, reading the relevant part of this document to the witness from the OPP.
00:03:58 Lieutenant, you will not have seen this document before, but it's a readout of a conversation
00:04:04 between the Prime Minister and the Premier of Ontario. In the first big paragraph, Premier
00:04:09 Ford says, the bigger one for us and the country is the Ambassador Bridge and the state ground
00:04:18 there what i think is we gotta stop the spread of these protests he goes on to say that the
00:04:26 attorney general is looking at legal ways to give the police more tools do you see that
00:04:32 the prime minister says first of all they're not a legal protest they're occupying a municipal
00:04:40 street and are not legally parked you shouldn't need more tools legal tools they are barricading
00:04:47 the Ontario economy. And then later in that paragraph, he says, we got to respond quickly.
00:05:00 So that's a little bit interesting. Justin Trudeau, first off, makes a declaration that
00:05:06 I'm not sure is rooted in law because no one else has been able to say when this became
00:05:11 the case that they're not a legal protest. This is the interesting thing. They're occupying a
00:05:16 municipal street and are not legally parked so that is the extent of the convoys lawlessness
00:05:23 they were not legally parked so you can just go around and issue a bunch of parking tickets
00:05:27 and i guess that is the extent of the law enforcement required but what justin trudeau
00:05:31 said to premier doug ford on this call pmjt you can see it if you look at that summary there
00:05:36 that you shouldn't need more tools legal tools they are barricading the ontario economy and
00:05:43 doing millions of damage a day.
00:05:45 I'm assuming that's millions of dollars of damage a day.
00:05:47 Or to discuss the metric yesterday,
00:05:50 millions of Disney Plus subscriptions a day
00:05:52 and harming people's lives.
00:05:55 And this is, I think, incredibly revealing here.
00:05:58 So if this was in fact the case
00:06:01 that Justin Trudeau was telling Doug Ford,
00:06:03 you do not need more legal tools.
00:06:08 You do not need more than existing laws,
00:06:10 existing powers, existing authorities
00:06:12 to deal with the Windsor blockade, which was by all accounts, and certainly by economic
00:06:17 counts, far more disruptive than the Ottawa protests, then why was the Emergencies Act
00:06:24 invoked five days later?
00:06:26 And there's a lot in this exchange that was put forward in evidence yesterday, this readout.
00:06:33 It was, I should say, the government put this forward in its disclosure.
00:06:36 So this is a readout that came, and if you look at the email addresses on it, internally
00:06:40 from the Prime Minister's office, and in this discussion, what they're talking about is the fact
00:06:46 that Justin Trudeau seems to want Doug Ford to move in and direct police. Like, Justin Trudeau
00:06:52 is so used to just directing police operations himself, apparently. He's surprised when Doug
00:06:58 Ford says, I can't do that. And I want to read this one line here, if I can find it, where a PDF,
00:07:05 which is not a document in this case, it's Premier Doug Ford, says, I'm just as frustrated as you,
00:07:10 And if I could direct the police, I would.
00:07:14 There is one thing to have a protest in a city,
00:07:16 but when you are impacting the economy and costing jobs, it's a problem.
00:07:20 PMJT says, are you saying the OPP can't help?
00:07:24 Premier Doug Ford, I can't direct them. 0.99
00:07:26 I can't call them and say, get your asses in there. 0.97
00:07:29 I don't know if that means we lose our explicit tag, 0.99
00:07:31 but get your asses in there, or we have to have the explicit tag, 1.00
00:07:34 and kicking ass. 1.00
00:07:37 It's up to the OPP. 0.99
00:07:38 so then Justin Trudeau says does the mayor have to direct local police so in this exchange Trudeau
00:07:46 is basically asking which politician is able to direct the police if not you is the Windsor
00:07:53 mayor that has to do this so you can tell there's a bit of an attitude here where Justin Trudeau
00:07:58 seems to think that this is a political role and a political responsibility to tell police what to
00:08:04 do. And the two are commiserating about what seems to be their frustration with the OPP
00:08:09 not getting in there and in Doug Ford's words, kicking ass. And I don't think they mean that 0.97
00:08:14 in like the saying way of just doing a really good job. I think they mean actually going in there
00:08:19 and cracking skulls. So this is incredibly important. So I believe wholeheartedly from
00:08:26 reading this that Justin Trudeau knows the Emergencies Act was not necessary, that he knows
00:08:32 the Emergencies Act was not required to deal with what the government wanted to do, which was clear
00:08:37 these protests, whether they were in Coutts and Windsor, in Ottawa and Emerson, Manitoba, in Surrey
00:08:43 and Cornwall. And I think he knows that. I think he wanted to find a way to put police officers
00:08:49 more directly under his thumb. Now, technically, when the Emergencies Act came into play, the Ottawa
00:08:55 Police Service was still the agency in charge. But we know it got a lot more complicated, the command
00:09:01 structure. We had RCMP playing more of a role. We had OPP continuing to play a role. Ottawa Police
00:09:06 Service, of course, goes through that change in chief. And it's going to be very interesting to
00:09:12 hear what Commissioner of the RCMP Brenda Luckey says when she starts testifying, I believe next
00:09:19 week, maybe in two weeks. And it'll be interesting because it sounds like Justin Trudeau believes
00:09:23 wholeheartedly that it's the responsibility of politicians to direct police. So I want to know
00:09:29 what orders he was giving to or suggestions he was giving to Commissioner Lucky if he's so
00:09:36 baffled that Doug Ford isn't in there telling the OPP what to do and saying yeah why don't you go
00:09:41 there and why don't you clear that and arrest that person and it's very revealing into the mindset
00:09:46 and I think it's also revealing to the fact that he knows what police have been saying which is
00:09:51 that the emergencies act wasn't required and I want you to juxtapose this line of his and I'll
00:09:59 reiterate it one more time. You shouldn't need, this is quoting Justin Trudeau, you shouldn't
00:10:04 need more tools, legal tools. They are barricading the Ontario economy and doing millions of damage
00:10:11 a day. Now let's take a look at this montage that my fantastic producer prepared of Justin Trudeau
00:10:18 when he's speaking into a microphone and into a camera saying a very different thing about the
00:10:22 necessity of the emergencies act. Invoking the emergencies act has been necessary. Law enforcement
00:10:30 agencies relied on it to set up secured areas in downtown Ottawa and at border crossings. Right now
00:10:37 the situation requires additional tools not held by any other federal, provincial, or territorial
00:10:46 law. It prevented foreign money from continuing to fund illegal blockades and it's making sure
00:10:54 our borders remain open. It has been the responsible thing to do. From the very beginning
00:11:01 I offered to the commission to appear at that commission so that Canadians could understand
00:11:07 exactly why we had to do what we did, why we didn't enter into those decisions lightly,
00:11:12 but why it was necessary to restore order to Canada.
00:11:17 We didn't want to use the Emergencies Act.
00:11:20 It's never something to turn to without serious consideration.
00:11:23 But after weeks of dangerous and unlawful activities,
00:11:28 after weeks of people being harassed in their neighbourhoods
00:11:31 and small businesses forced to close,
00:11:34 after billions of dollars were stalled in trade,
00:11:38 putting people's jobs and livelihoods at risk,
00:11:41 after the National War Memorial was desecrated,
00:11:46 after evidence of increased ideologically motivated violent extremism activity across the country,
00:11:53 after a flood of misinformation and disinformation washed over Canada, including from foreign sources,
00:12:01 after these illegal blockades and occupations received disturbing amounts of foreign funding
00:12:09 to destabilize Canada's democracy it became clear that local and provincial
00:12:16 authorities needed more tools to restore order and keep people safe today in these
00:12:25 circumstances it is now clear that responsible leadership requires us to do
00:12:32 this oh my goodness so we've gone from yeah you don't need it you have all the powers there's
00:12:45 nothing additional to this is important we didn't want to do this we need to do this this i don't 0.99
00:12:49 want this this is not my choice i have to do it we have to do it because of foreign i don't even
00:12:54 know what they're talking about with foreign misinformation i think most of the misinformation
00:12:58 was coming from Marco Mendocino and Justin Trudeau.
00:13:01 All of the evil, scary financing.
00:13:03 Yes, because, you know, Gladys Pippins in Wallisburg,
00:13:07 who gave the convoy $10,
00:13:08 has been such a nefarious and sinister figure.
00:13:12 We must freeze her bank accounts 0.99
00:13:13 if she gets out of line again 1.00
00:13:15 or threaten to freeze her bank accounts.
00:13:18 And on it goes, this idea that this was necessary,
00:13:21 that law enforcement asked for it,
00:13:22 when even Justin Trudeau himself
00:13:25 in his conversations with Doug Ford
00:13:27 was saying something remarkably honest, which it doesn't sound like he was doing
00:13:31 in those clips, and saying that you have all of the powers and authorities you need.
00:13:36 And no one from the government has yet acknowledged what changed between that call
00:13:42 on February 9th and February 14th when the Emergencies Act came into play.
00:13:48 And quite to the contrary, we do know for a fact from the sworn evidence
00:13:52 that there had been progress in negotiations between convoy organizers and the City of Ottawa
00:13:59 in that time frame, which Justin Trudeau's office knew about, which Marco Mendicino's office knew
00:14:05 about, and Marco Mendicino personally knew about and was being briefed on. So if Justin Trudeau
00:14:12 is claiming five days before he invokes the Emergencies Act, four days before he discusses
00:14:17 with his cabinet and the premiers that it's not necessary it's almost as if this was a move that
00:14:23 the government knew it didn't need to do but contrary to its claims to the media it wanted to
00:14:29 do because they wanted that power to go after people's bank accounts they wanted the ability
00:14:34 to make an example of all of these protesters that had embarrassed the government by bringing
00:14:39 this message of freedom a message that was unifying people from across this country
00:14:45 a message that went beyond left and right and actually spoke to people in a very real way
00:14:50 that that message those people who brought that message had humiliated the government and they
00:14:56 couldn't stand for that justin trudeau couldn't stand for that and it's a shame it's a shame that
00:15:03 we don't get to see in real time how the government and the cabinet ministers and all of the staffers
00:15:08 are responding to this testimony every single day the testimony that comes out further proves
00:15:16 the lack of necessity behind the emergencies act all of these people police officers career police
00:15:22 officers well respected by government and by public and by their peers in law enforcement are
00:15:27 all saying that they aren't backing it up they aren't backing the government up the most support
00:15:33 government has gotten on this is from police saying yeah when they offered it to us we used
00:15:38 it, but we didn't really need it. And I think that's very telling. And I also don't think
00:15:43 that's the bombshell that the Emergency Zacks defenders think it is, because it's like if you
00:15:49 give someone a big Maserati to drive from home to the office, they're going to use it, even if they
00:15:55 didn't need it, even if they could have made the same trip on a bicycle, because, well, it's a tool
00:16:00 that's been given to them, so you might as well make use of it. And I think that is so pivotal
00:16:07 to this because the emergencies act is very clear it can't be something that the government could
00:16:13 have dealt with or law enforcement could have dealt with using existing laws and i i restate
00:16:19 that point almost every time we discuss this inquiry because i think it is paramount for
00:16:24 people to understand that the police incompetence disagreements different ideas on how best to do
00:16:30 it. These are not grounds under the legislation to invoke the Emergencies Act. These are not laws
00:16:37 that are not working. These are perhaps human failings, bureaucratic failings,
00:16:44 government shortcomings, sure. But it's not evidence that existing laws are unable to deal
00:16:49 with the crisis, whatever the crisis is. And I think more fundamental to that, I'm not even
00:16:54 convinced. In fact, I'm convinced that there was no emergency in the first place. And I don't mean
00:16:59 that just by saying that, well, I personally, Andrew Lawton, don't think bouncy castles are
00:17:04 an emergency. I think that the government's legislation guiding this is very clear on what
00:17:09 constitutes a public order emergency. And there weren't any of the criteria that the Canadian
00:17:15 Security Intelligence Act sets out. There weren't the criteria that the Emergencies Act sets out.
00:17:21 So for the most part, we are seeing no emergency to begin with. And I think that beyond that,
00:17:29 people need to realize that Justin Trudeau is not going to be able to get away with this if
00:17:36 folks are paying attention and that's the big if I've said yesterday that there is never going to
00:17:42 be satisfaction from people that really don't like Justin Trudeau there's never going to be
00:17:48 satisfaction from people that just think you know what he shouldn't have done this that people that
00:17:52 think he should be I don't know brought up on charges before the hag or whatever I'm not
00:17:56 entertaining that. What's going to happen is we will get a clear cut decision from the commissioner
00:18:01 or not even a decision, a clear cut report from the commissioner. And that report is going to list
00:18:07 all of these things that the commissioner has noted. It may not be satisfactory. It may not
00:18:12 come to the conclusion that yes, the emergencies act was right or no, the emergencies act was wrong.
00:18:18 He doesn't need to make that decision. But even if he says it's unjustified or certainly makes
00:18:24 that case without saying it directly. It doesn't result in anything resembling charges. It doesn't
00:18:31 result in anything resembling civil liability. It doesn't mean Justin Trudeau is forced out of
00:18:35 office. I think he should resign if that is what the decision comes back as, if for no other reason
00:18:41 than the standard that he set when he was defending this in the House of Commons. But I think that
00:18:48 what's key here for people to realize is that we're starting to see evidence that even the
00:18:53 government itself knew this wasn't necessary. From Justin Trudeau point blank telling Doug Ford that
00:18:59 to what we also saw last week or two weeks ago in the text messages exchanged between staffers in
00:19:06 Trudeau's office and staffers in Marco Mendicino's office saying that we need to just lean into the
00:19:11 narrative. They wanted this as a media opportunity, not as a national crisis needing some massive
00:19:18 public safety response. So we'll have more of that in the days and weeks ahead. We are on the
00:19:24 back half of the commission, but there are still a couple of weeks left to go here. I want to talk
00:19:29 about one of my favorite topics, which is talk radio. I've been a longtime talk radio fan. I
00:19:35 really cut my teeth in the media industry doing a daily talk radio show. And I know a lot of you
00:19:40 who listen to this show used to listen to me on the radio, whether it was in London and Toronto
00:19:44 in Calgary. And I thank you very much for that. But the talk radio of today is very different than
00:19:51 the talk radio of yesterday and two days ago and several years ago. And I say that with a fair bit
00:19:59 of sadness because talk radio used to be like the bastion of unequivocally irreverent speech,
00:20:06 of being able to challenge conventional orthodoxy, being able to have debates,
00:20:10 air controversial opinions, not for the sake of controversy, but because they are discussions that
00:20:15 need to be had. And it has gotten increasingly woke in Canada. And I would say there are few
00:20:21 better able to attest to that than Jamil Javani, who hosted a fantastic show on Bell Media's News
00:20:28 Talk 1010 in Toronto, although his management seemed to want it to be a lot less fantastic.
00:20:35 And I want to bring in Jamil to talk about this. Now the president of the Canada Strong and Free
00:20:40 Network. Jamil, good to talk to you, sir. Thanks for coming on today. Yeah, thanks for having me,
00:20:45 Andrew. I certainly share your passion for what talk radio used to be. And I mean, it's great we
00:20:50 have platforms like yours where we can still have some of these important conversations.
00:20:55 Well, we'll blow the minds of our former employers, both of whom fired each of us. But
00:21:00 let's talk about this because you hosted a great show on News Talk 1010. You talked about a lot of
00:21:06 things you introduced yourself to a lot of people who didn't know you and it was fascinating when
00:21:11 they fired you and and you know it was i'd say there's a bit of a purge going on in radio at the
00:21:17 time danielle smith i know in alberta was having some issues around the same time frame not connected
00:21:22 to you or your case but uh there were there were these changes and we've started to see a little
00:21:26 bit more about this in court documents because you are suing bell media for your termination
00:21:33 And the one notable one that I really want to talk about here is this accusation that Bell has made to you that you, who, as I understand it, were the only black man on the station, were insufficiently diverse for them.
00:21:47 That's exactly right. It's very confusing exactly what diversity means to a company like Bell, because they say they want people from different backgrounds, but they don't seem to want anyone to actually bring their perspective to their job.
00:22:00 So they want to celebrate, oh, this person's from this community, this person has this identity. But then when you want to talk about what's happening in the world, all of a sudden, they'd like for everyone to sound the same, which doesn't sound like diversity and inclusion to me. And I think one of the key examples of this was around all the COVID stuff.
00:22:19 You know, I hosted my show last year when, of course, COVID was the main thing on the news every single day.
00:22:25 And, you know, I'm a black man.
00:22:28 I come from a community where because of history and because of other reasons, a lot of people were hesitant to get the vaccine.
00:22:35 And Bell, like, wanted me to talk about that if I was willing to deliver the message that they wanted.
00:22:41 They wanted me to come on the radio and shame people and hate people and say, you know, mean things about people who wouldn't be vaccinated.
00:22:48 And my point of view was like, look, I mean, part of diversity is recognizing people have different life experiences. And I'm not going to attack people who make a different decision, even if it's not the same decision I made. And that was where so much of our conflict came from. And you can see even in the court documents, which I encourage people to check out on my Twitter page, I posted a link to where you can read them yourself.
00:23:10 they basically say like I didn't shill the Liberal Party's lines on COVID-19 and that's
00:23:17 one of the reasons they fired me which is kind of a mind-blowing thing to say out loud they say
00:23:21 on the record like I was very surprised to read it to be honest yeah in a way it was weird because
00:23:27 I read your initial filing and you're making all these claims which of course I should say haven't
00:23:31 been tested in court about why they fired you and then in their defense they basically reaffirm
00:23:37 everything you accused them of doing and try to put their own spin on it of course like
00:23:41 and one of them they say point blank in their defense filing here that you were not committed
00:23:48 to their diversity and equity and inclusion policies and all of that and some of the other
00:23:53 things they included as your alleged transgressions I found ridiculous like one of them was you had
00:23:58 an interview with an MP Kathy Wagenthal who didn't tow the government's line on vaccination
00:24:04 And you say you were supposed to be more aggressive or assertive in shouting down whatever she was saying.
00:24:10 And it's like Kathy Wagenthal, I've interviewed her before.
00:24:13 She was offering the unorthodox position. 0.93
00:24:17 She was challenging the position you could get anywhere else. 0.92
00:24:20 So the idea that you then need to silence her or rebut her, I find ridiculous.
00:24:26 And again, really a rejection of what talk radio used to be.
00:24:29 yeah i mean uh you know mp wagenthal is a duly elected member of our parliament for her to be
00:24:38 given an opportunity to share her perspective on an important issue seems like exactly what
00:24:42 the media is supposed to do we're supposed to bring forward perspectives that are influencing
00:24:47 public policy influencing the way politics and government work and yet bell seemed to want just
00:24:54 one perspective to be allowed on their airwaves which is just i mean as i said i'm surprised they
00:24:59 admitted it i mean they behaved that way they tried to punish me they certainly conducted
00:25:03 themselves like a group of people with a bias toward the liberal party but for them to actually
00:25:08 come out and admit it is a whole other story i mean i was very surprised and to your point also
00:25:13 andrew about um you know the me not sort of complying with diversity like let's be specific
00:25:19 about what what they wanted these guys put out last november about a year ago today they put out
00:25:25 a plan that was about segregation, that was about putting together diversity groups that would have
00:25:32 meetings based on all the Black people get together, all the Indigenous people get together,
00:25:36 all the white people get together. That's not diversity. That's segregation. That's literally 0.86
00:25:40 the opposite of diversity. You're telling people that in order to have important conversations 0.69
00:25:45 about our workplace as employees of Bell, we cannot do that with people who look differently
00:25:50 than us we have to be separated from one another and i'm i'm against diversity by saying i don't
00:25:56 want to be part of that like this is nuts you you know these businesses want to get into the world
00:26:02 of micromanaging people's identities and then when someone whether you're black indigenous a woman
00:26:08 part of the lgbt community whatever it is even if you're a white guy they want to tell you how
00:26:14 you're supposed to think about yourself and the political views you're supposed to have that's not
00:26:18 business that's creepy weird approach to diversity and the idea that i was a problematic employee
00:26:26 because i thought as an individual i should be treated with respect that's nuts and that's really
00:26:31 at the crux of the lawsuit which is like our business is allowed to treat people this way i
00:26:35 believe it's against the law and i believe it's illegal and you know we're that's exactly why
00:26:39 i'm taking them to court when you were hired was there ever a sense that you had in your discussions
00:26:46 with them, either formally or informally, of what they wanted you to be and what they wanted you to
00:26:51 say, whether it was a particular position or a particular issue? Or did they just look at you
00:26:56 and, you know, based on a couple of interviews you'd done and perhaps your book and things
00:27:00 you'd written, just assume that they had you figured out and they knew where you were going
00:27:03 to go once you were on air? Yeah, I mean, I think there were a lot of people there who I would say
00:27:09 have a very simplistic sense of how to work with people who come from a different background or
00:27:14 perspective than them. And so some of those people, like there's one particular manager named
00:27:19 in the lawsuit and Bell names her in their statement of defense, Hillary White, ironically
00:27:25 named, who had a very big problem with me and was constantly trying to, in my view, intimidate me 1.00
00:27:32 and try to like force certain perspectives on me. And when I tried to speak up for myself and you
00:27:38 can see the dysfunctional workplace at Bell in other examples, like with Lisa Laflamme, for
00:27:43 example. Danielle Graham is another person who's got a lawsuit against Bell over some of these 0.82
00:27:49 issues. They try to punish you into submission, into compliance. And I don't think that's actually
00:27:56 what a healthy workplace is supposed to be like. So it was very difficult. There was a manager
00:28:01 there who did, I think, try to have a genuine, honest understanding of diversity. His name was
00:28:07 Mike Bendixon. And he was fired a couple months before I was. And I don't know exactly why. But
00:28:13 I can tell you that when they let him go, you know, it just the one manager who seemed to have
00:28:19 a healthy view on these issues was gone. And all of a sudden, the place just started to fall apart.
00:28:24 And that's, you know, and then they blame the employees for that. And it's like, well,
00:28:27 maybe management should take some responsibility for some of this dysfunction.
00:28:31 now it's funny because in bell's response they talk about the diversity issues and the fact that
00:28:38 you misgendered demi lovato or something and they they go on with some of these other things we've
00:28:43 discussed and then they say oh yeah and his ratings were bad was that ever something that
00:28:47 was brought to you no in fact you know as i mentioned i only had one ratings period that i
00:28:54 was uh able to uh do the show for before uh i was fired and suspended and all these other things
00:29:01 went on so that one ratings period they gave me a bonus for because of the the performance of the
00:29:07 show and i actually have an email from my boss saying congratulations so the ratings thing is
00:29:13 very weird i mean the reality is as i'm sure you would imagine you know ratings for all radio went
00:29:18 down during covid because people weren't commuting to work in their cars as much so i think what
00:29:24 Bell's trying to do is act like that was sort of my fault as a way to justify the firing. But here's
00:29:29 what I would say to you, Andrew, if there was a business reason to let me go, why are they bringing
00:29:34 up all these other things? Like if it was just about business, why couldn't they just say his
00:29:38 ratings are bad? We had to let him go. Most people would accept that. And if that were the honest
00:29:42 reason that I was fired, I, you know, why were we having these arguments? Like they mentioned all
00:29:47 these other things about diversity and Justin Trudeau and Kathy Wagenthal because it wasn't
00:29:53 about ratings and that they felt the need to address all these other issues because their case
00:29:58 based on ratings is so weak and you'll even notice and again i encourage anyone you can read bell's
00:30:03 statement of defense in their own words go on my twitter page and you'll and i post it there and
00:30:08 you'll read it and see they actually present no evidence to back up their claim about ratings at
00:30:12 all it's literally they just say it there's yeah it's just like a line basically that they just
00:30:17 sort of just throw out there and see yeah there's no quotation there are no numbers there's no
00:30:21 actual information given. Where do they have information? Well, they've got quotes when it
00:30:25 comes to me not defending Justin Trudeau. They've got quotes when it comes to me not taking their
00:30:31 position on Demi Lovato and her journey in self-identification. They've got examples for
00:30:37 that, but no examples to ratings, right? So it's a very bizarre approach they've taken. And it
00:30:42 seems to me, in my personal view, they've underestimated how much Canadians expect media
00:30:48 to have some sort of credibility some uh objectivity some effort to be middle of the road
00:30:54 i think a lot of canadians expect that i don't think that bell is offering them that in their
00:30:59 media coverage radio is a cartoonishly precarious industry i think like the line when i started out
00:31:06 is that you hadn't made it in radio until you had been fired like some of those old time radio guys
00:31:11 would you know get fired on monday morning and they'd be somewhere else tuesday afternoon
00:31:14 And I think stations have the right to put whatever they want on air.
00:31:18 And I know you're a free market guy, so you'd agree with that as well.
00:31:22 Let me just ask then, what is the core of your issue?
00:31:25 Is it, you know, the fact that they, you know, canceled you for these reasons, or is it something more fundamental?
00:31:33 Yeah, I mean, the core of the issue is they created certain expectations of me as an employee based on my race,
00:31:40 based on my the community i come from based on you know the color of my skin or you know my my name
00:31:48 all these things they created unique expectations on me and then punished me when i didn't meet
00:31:54 those expectations that is i think by most uh definitions racism it is racist to say because
00:32:02 of what you look like you have to do your job a certain way and when you don't stay within the 0.97
00:32:06 boundaries we give you, we punish you for being the wrong type of black person. That is what the 1.00
00:32:12 crux of the issue is for me. As I said before, I do believe that in businesses, I do believe in
00:32:18 capitalism. A lot of the good things about our country are the results of us embracing free
00:32:24 market economics. At the same time, I'm also a believer in people being treated as individuals.
00:32:30 I'm a believer in equality before the law. And you cannot, whether you're on the left in this
00:32:36 case or you're on the right, whatever the example would be, decide you're going to treat people
00:32:41 differently based on what they look like. And that is fundamentally wrong, in my opinion. And
00:32:46 that's why I decided to bring this case forward. I think that we've gotten to this point where we
00:32:51 believe liberals and people on the left, like the management at Bell Media, are allowed to get away
00:32:57 with racism. And then they accuse everyone else on the other side of being the racist. And I'm
00:33:02 saying no no you guys are the racists you're treating me differently because of what I look
00:33:07 like because of who my father is because where my father comes from and that's not right and we're
00:33:12 going to deal with that through the court system you know this may shock people in this colorblind
00:33:17 world but I'm not black so I don't have the uh you know the experience of being a member of that
00:33:21 community but and again I don't even like talking about people in in terms of communities because
00:33:26 people are individuals and that seems to be the issue they had with you that you were an individual
00:33:31 And that, you know, your community certainly colors and shapes your perspective, but it doesn't confine you to one particular perspective.
00:33:40 And I feel that it's just so laughable that this idea of diversity, this idea of having more voices represented from a variety of backgrounds, which is important, only extends when those voices say certain things.
00:33:55 Yeah, and that's exactly the problem.
00:33:57 i mean i have email documentation of bell encouraging me to talk about vaccine issues
00:34:04 in the black community they brought me on ctv news to talk about the issue
00:34:09 but they wanted you to do a psa basically they wanted to promote vaccination to people in the
00:34:13 black community exactly but as you said andrew i'm a human being so i know that when i take that
00:34:18 responsibility on i have to do that with integrity and part of doing that with integrity is showing
00:34:24 respect to people in my community who have a different point of view. And then when I go on
00:34:28 the radio and show respect to people who make a different decision, then I'm being punished for
00:34:34 it. Well, you can't control a person that way. That is fundamentally wrong to say, we're going
00:34:39 to use your race when it's convenient to us. But then when you want to show respect to people with
00:34:45 the same identity as you, we're going to punish you for it. That is a kind of manipulation that
00:34:50 is only possible when you have a business like bell who thinks that they are so above any kind
00:34:56 of moral expectation any moral standard that they can get away with anything they want and the
00:35:02 reality is no matter how big and rich you are in this country no matter how big of a business you
00:35:07 are no matter how much power you have as a bell executive you're still beholden to the law and
00:35:12 that's exactly why a lawsuit is necessary here they can't get away with treating people this way
00:35:17 You are taking on the machine and I couldn't be happier for you, Jamil Javani.
00:35:22 So thank you for that and best of luck.
00:35:24 And just on a purely unrelated topic here, I know you've written in the past about your friendship with J.D. Vance.
00:35:30 You went to law school with him at Yale.
00:35:32 Any thoughts on his big victory last night in Ohio?
00:35:35 You know, I'm just happy for him.
00:35:36 Like, I know a lot of the coverage has sort of pointed to the fact that Republicans did not have the quote unquote red wave as many expected.
00:35:44 A lot of these Senate races and congressional races were more competitive than people thought.
00:35:49 But I knew J.D.'s wasn't going to be that competitive because he's been working his butt off.
00:35:53 He's been connecting with people in Ohio.
00:35:55 He's from there.
00:35:57 He's got a story that you can read about in his book, Hillbilly Elegy.
00:36:00 You can watch the movie on Netflix.
00:36:02 People know where he comes from, and he's lived through the issues that a lot of people in Ohio want solutions to.
00:36:09 So I'm happy for him.
00:36:10 I think he's going to be fantastic as a senator.
00:36:12 You know, I think of him as my big brother.
00:36:14 Like, I love the guy. And so nothing but positive vibes for me. I mean, I can't wait to see what he does when he's, you know, actually in the Senate being able to use his voice for good.
00:36:24 Well, perhaps you'll be able to get Senator Vance at one of the Canada Strong and Free conferences coming up.
00:36:29 I hope so.
00:36:30 All right. Pull any clout you can. Jamil, always a pleasure. Thanks very much for coming on.
00:36:35 Thank you, Andrew. Take care.
00:36:37 All right. That is Jamil Javani, president of the Canada Strong and Free Network.
00:36:41 And again, I should say the documents we were talking about from his court case has not yet been resolved.
00:36:47 The allegations have been not tested in court, but they are, as you can read for yourself in many cases, pretty much not refuted, but rather affirmed by Bell in its reply.
00:37:00 They're the ones that bring up the fact that he misgendered Demi Lovato by not referring to them as they or her as she, they, whatever it is.
00:37:09 And again, by interviewing Kathy Wagenthal and insufficiently being critical of Kathy Wagenthal when interviewing her about her views on vaccination.
00:37:19 So, you know, it was actually a little bit triggering for me as someone who went through this with a mainstream media company working in talk radio and finding that this place that used to be the bastion of irreverent commentary was all of a sudden becoming very much narrowed and constrained to something else.
00:37:36 So I'm glad to be here at True North.
00:37:39 And I think there's a serious point here, which is that the legacy media is not the
00:37:45 answer.
00:37:45 And I think a lot of the times people get really hung up on this belief that, you know
00:37:50 what, we can get the newspapers to write about this and get the TV stations to report on
00:37:53 this and the radio stations to do this.
00:37:56 And to some extent you will, because again, these still have influence, they still have
00:38:00 audiences, but increasingly people are supplementing their mainstream media consumption with
00:38:06 alternative media or getting rid of their mainstream media consumption altogether and
00:38:11 focusing almost entirely on independent media. So I think it's never been a more influential time
00:38:16 for people in alternative media or online media in general. So if you are a part of our True North
00:38:23 family here, we thank you so much and would encourage you if you want us to keep doing this
00:38:27 to financially contribute either with a one-time donation or you can become a monthly subscriber
00:38:33 and join our Insiders Club.
00:38:35 You can do all that at donate.tnc.news.
00:38:38 That does it for me for today.
00:38:41 I just want to give a very, very special acknowledgement
00:38:45 to our veterans out there, those of you who tune in.
00:38:49 I know that Remembrance Day is about the fallen,
00:38:51 but I also think we need to thank the living as well
00:38:53 and certainly thank the fallen for their sacrifice.
00:38:56 So I'm a couple of days early, but I will say lest we forget.
00:39:01 Thank you, God bless, and have a good weekend.
00:39:03 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:39:06 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.