Juno News - April 19, 2023


Trudeau told NATO Canada would never meet its defence spending commitment

Topics
Mentioned
CBC "pausing" Twitter use after Twitter outs them as "government-funded media" They must think Canadians are stupid

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

181.89

Word count

7,479

Sentence count

283

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

12

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, host Andrew Lawton takes a look at three very important stories that have been leaked by the Washington Post and leaked to the Canadian press. First, Justin Trudeau tells NATO officials that Canada will never be able to meet its 2% military spending target. Then, he tells the House of Commons that Canada is going to continue to invest in the military.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:13 I'm sorry, I just had like a cough at the worst possible moment there,
00:00:18 but I thank you for your indulgence and apologize for the startling noise
00:00:22 if that made it into the show, which I fear it did.
00:00:25 But nevertheless, this is the great thing about live radio.
00:00:28 So it is good to talk to you all. This is The Andrew Lawton Show, Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North.
00:00:36 And I want to just begin by saying we are just going to go around the world in all sorts of different ways on this show today
00:00:43 because I have three very distinct topics to get to, but they are all important.
00:00:48 And I wanted to make sure that we gave each one at least a little bit of time.
00:00:51 I'm told the cough did not go into the live show, by the way.
00:00:54 So I've just like outed myself as being an unprofessional hack.
00:00:58 Better a hacker than a hack, I guess.
00:00:59 So thanks very much to my colleague for telling me that.
00:01:04 Let me first off mention something here.
00:01:07 Oh, now he's saying it did.
00:01:09 The cough was heard.
00:01:09 It was the cough heard around the world.
00:01:11 All right.
00:01:12 Well, after the last three years, if you aren't used to hearing coughing,
00:01:15 I think you are sorely, sorely missing out on what the world has been like.
00:01:20 Although now you don't got like the pariah-like looks.
00:01:22 because I'm actually very weird about coughing, where if someone says the word cough, as I have
00:01:28 like nine times now, I have the urge to cough. So it was like in the time when everyone just
00:01:33 looked around and saw everyone as disease vectors. If anyone like said, do you have a cough? I'd be
00:01:37 like, no, no, I don't. And people were very suspect, even more than they usually are of me,
00:01:44 by the way. Let's start off with the big news out of the Washington Post today, which is actually
00:01:51 coming by way of leaked Pentagon documents, Justin Trudeau told NATO officials that Canada
00:01:58 was never going to meet its spending goal. Now, this requires a little bit of context here. So
00:02:03 countries that are members of NATO have to make a commitment to spend a certain amount of money.
00:02:09 It's not a dollar value because it doesn't make sense to expect the same from the United States
00:02:14 as we expect from, I don't know, Latvia, but it is based on your GDP. So every country must spend
00:02:21 2% of its GDP on defense. Now you could drive a Mack truck through the holes in this commitment
00:02:31 because it doesn't actually say how you spend your money. It doesn't say that you have to spend it in
00:02:37 a particularly responsible way. It says you have to spend 2% on GDP. So you could actually just
00:02:43 spend, you know, 1% of your GDP on diversity training for members of your military. And
00:02:49 theoretically, you've satisfied the 2% requirement. And if you look at NATO's website, which is very
00:02:56 transparent about this, it shows a lot of countries just do not pay their fair share.
00:03:04 And Canada is one of those countries. Canada for years has been lagging, has been paying less than
00:03:10 this 2% commitment, which is not just a pledge. It's not just a target. It's not just a goal.
00:03:15 This is actually the amount that we are committing, committing to spending. There was a time,
00:03:21 I think it was in like 2018 or 2019, when we were one of the lowest in NATO for what share of our
00:03:28 GDP we're spending. I think the last numbers I had were putting us at like 1.4. So it's actually
00:03:35 backslid a little bit in some ways. But the reason this is important is because now we find out that
00:03:40 despite Justin Trudeau's proclamations that we're investing in military, we're going to do it,
00:03:45 we're committed to NATO, we're a global partner and all that, he was telling NATO officials behind
00:03:50 closed doors, yeah, we're never going to get there. That 2% is just a pipe dream. That's been the
00:03:55 basis of the stories that were now released via the Washington Post, drawing from this leak of
00:04:01 Pentagon Papers to Discord. Now, if you want a masterclass in saying nothing with as many words
00:04:08 as possible, this is the Katie Telford School of Speaking. This is Justin Trudeau being asked
00:04:14 about these stories just today in the foyer of the House of Commons. Did you tell NATO officials
00:04:19 Canada will never meet its 2% military defense spending target? I continue to say and will always
00:04:25 say that Canada is a reliable partner to NATO, a reliable partner around the world, and with our
00:04:31 military investments with the support we give to canadians we will uh continue to be doing that
00:04:35 but did you but about the two percent target what did you communicate to me we will continue to be
00:04:40 uh working on investing in uh in giving the support necessary to uh to the men and women
00:04:47 of the canadian forces to deliver whether it's in latvia whether it's uh in nato operations
00:04:52 around the world or u.n operations canada continues to be a partner that is much sought after and
00:04:58 And that's why we're so pleased that we've invested increases in about 70% through our strong, secure, engaged in defense spending.
00:05:06 We've moved forward on modernization of NORAD.
00:05:08 We're going to continue to be there to make sure that the women and men of the forces have the tools they need.
00:05:13 Merci beaucoup.
00:05:15 And then he just, you know, scurries away there.
00:05:19 No more questions.
00:05:20 Can't have any further inquisition on that.
00:05:24 So it's a yes or no question.
00:05:26 Did you tell NATO officials that Canada was not going to get to 2% of defense spending?
00:05:31 We've been telling them that we are a committed partner for peace and glory and, you know,
00:05:37 kumbaya.
00:05:38 And I'm like, that was like not where, that was nowhere near the question.
00:05:42 You know, the Great Wall of China, you could put the question on one end and his answer
00:05:47 on the other.
00:05:48 And you know what?
00:05:49 I actually think there still might be a little breathing room on either side of it.
00:05:52 They were just so far away from each other there.
00:05:55 And I would also point out that this is not a new phenomenon.
00:06:00 And Donald Trump put Trudeau on the hot seat about this.
00:06:03 My colleague Harrison Faulkner reminded me and everyone else of this by tweeting this out earlier.
00:06:09 This is when Trudeau, well, I'll tell you afterwards, but it's kind of funny.
00:06:13 This is Justin Trudeau getting the question, not from, it might have been Stephanie Taylor of the Canadian press, I'm not sure,
00:06:20 but from Donald Trump in the Oval Office.
00:06:23 where would you put canada in that as they're not even like what they say canada but they'll be okay
00:06:27 i have confidence just slightly delinquent canada does not meet the two percent standard should it
00:06:34 have a plan to meet the two percent standard well we'll put them on a payment plan you know
00:06:38 we'll put canada on a payment plan right i'm sure the prime minister would love that
00:06:42 what are you at what what is your number uh the number we talked about is 70 increase uh over
00:06:49 these past years uh including and for the coming years including uh re significant investments in
00:06:56 our fighter jets significant investments in our naval fleets uh we are increasing significantly
00:07:02 our defense spending from previous governments that cut okay where are you now uh in terms of
00:07:08 your number one fourth and and continuing to move they're getting there they they they know it's
00:07:14 important to do that. And their economy is doing well. They'll get there quickly, I think.
00:07:23 I love that there has to be the voice of the staffer off camera telling Justin Trudeau what
00:07:30 we're at because he doesn't even know. Because again, as we've learned, he likes to deal in
00:07:34 abstractions and not reality, especially when it comes to targets he's not living up to. Now,
00:07:39 let me just say that there are a couple of different dimensions here number one is that
00:07:45 as I said you could spend the money very easily and not actually spend it on anything of substance
00:07:52 you could blow a ton of cash and have it not go towards frontline soldiers you could have it not
00:07:58 go towards weapons and equipment you could just spend money like I said on diversity training
00:08:03 and consultants and report after report you could just fly around planes and do training exercises
00:08:09 you know four times a day like you could do this all very easily without actually getting anything
00:08:17 for it and and oddly this is like the one thing that Justin Trudeau doesn't want to spend money
00:08:23 on this is the one thing that Justin Trudeau doesn't actually want to and isn't comfortable
00:08:28 running up a deficit to buy which is baffling and you know years and years ago my first ever
00:08:34 interview with Stephen Harper was about this idea. It was about defense. It was about Canada's place
00:08:41 in the world. Very different time in Canada and in the world. We had the mission in Afghanistan
00:08:46 ongoing. And I had interviewed a couple of weeks earlier, Justin Trudeau. And he basically was
00:08:53 doing the whole, actually, he was doing the kumbaya thing and saying that, no, we shouldn't
00:08:57 be in Afghanistan and ISIS isn't our problem and all of that. And he basically made a comment there
00:09:03 that this was not a situation that we should go there
00:09:07 because there's not a reasonable chance of success.
00:09:09 And that was the line that ended up making headlines,
00:09:12 not just in Canada, but I think in other countries as well,
00:09:16 of Trudeau saying there's no chance of success
00:09:18 for the Canadian Armed Forces.
00:09:19 Now, Stephen Harper latched onto that.
00:09:22 When I was interviewing him,
00:09:23 he had said that Trudeau has a deep dislike
00:09:25 and distrust of the Canadian Armed Forces.
00:09:28 And, you know, I actually don't think that is entirely untrue.
00:09:31 I think Justin Trudeau likes this old mythology of the Canadian peacekeepers, of which there are like 20.
00:09:39 I mean, the Canadian soldiers and police officers and peacekeeping missions now literally double digits.
00:09:45 This is not like the 90s where we had thousands and thousands of Canadian soldiers standing between warring factions around the world.
00:09:53 peacekeeping has fallen out of favor at the United Nations largely, and it is
00:09:57 an inconsequential part of Canada's military operations. But Trudeau likes this idealized
00:10:04 version of what the military is. He doesn't like the actual military and the actual military mandate
00:10:11 and the things that need the Canadian Armed Forces. And it's the same with NATO. He wants to
00:10:16 give more and more money to Ukraine. He wants to stand up and being like, Canada, we're supporting
00:10:19 Ukraine. We're supporting Ukraine. But he doesn't actually want to do for NATO what Canada has
00:10:25 across different governments pledged to do. Now, this isn't just a Canadian problem.
00:10:32 And I don't want you to think this is only a Canadian problem because defense ministers
00:10:36 have all committed to the 2%. This was in 2006. So it's not a new commitment. And only in 2017,
00:10:44 four countries were there. So lots of countries have been freeloaders. The reason Donald Trump
00:10:49 was so frustrated about this is because the United States is the one that is left holding
00:10:55 the bag when all of these other countries don't fulfill their end of the bargain. And if you look
00:11:00 at the NATO countries with defense expenditures and they published the charts, Canada is like so
00:11:06 low, you don't even see it on the top 10 or the top 15 of contributing countries to NATO. So if
00:11:13 the alliance is important, why are we not spending the money on it? If it's not important, then why
00:11:19 are we going through this charade? Why are we going through the pretense of saying that we are
00:11:23 committed to this? And the whole point of this segment here is to say that, yeah, we can have a
00:11:29 debate about defense spending, but Justin Trudeau has been telling Canadians one thing, which is
00:11:35 that, yes, it's difficult. We want to get to 2%. That's the goal. Well, behind the scenes, telling
00:11:40 NATO officials, not only that he has no plan of getting Canada there, but he doesn't think Canada
00:11:47 will ever go there. So he thinks Canada basically signed a check. It has no intention of ever
00:11:53 letting anyone cash. And we wonder why Trudeau expended such political capital and spent such
00:12:01 money campaigning around the world, sucking up to tin pot African dictators, trying to get enough 0.99
00:12:07 votes to put Canada on the United Nations Security Council. And at the end, all of the United Nations 0.95
00:12:13 voting member states are like,
00:12:15 ah, yeah, it's Canada.
00:12:17 And we end up once again being rejected for this
00:12:20 because he likes to think that he has put Canada on the map.
00:12:24 And the only way he's done it is as a punchline,
00:12:28 as a country that no one is particularly taking seriously,
00:12:30 as a country that is not making good on its word.
00:12:33 And more importantly, as a country who views foreign policy
00:12:38 as being an exercise in virtue signaling
00:12:41 more than in actual actions.
00:12:45 Actual actions is a weird thing to say.
00:12:47 So all of this is, I think, a fascinating exercise
00:12:51 in this double standard between the liberal mythology
00:12:56 of what Canada is and of what Canadian identity is,
00:13:00 this liberal mythology of this, of Canadian foreign policy,
00:13:04 and getting down to brass tacks,
00:13:07 what is it in real life?
00:13:09 What is it in reality?
00:13:11 And Canada should be embarrassed by this.
00:13:13 This is not the way that you put your country on the map.
00:13:16 And again, if you've got frustrations with NATO, I am all for you having those discussions. 0.98
00:13:21 But right now he is trying to, I hate the expression, but he's trying to suck and blow at the same time. 0.88
00:13:27 And we are all just supposed to be like, oh, well, he must have a good reason for it. 0.97
00:13:31 There must be a purpose for it.
00:13:32 My goodness.
00:13:33 And, you know, one interesting aside I'll add to this is that as we discuss NATO, and I know there's been a lot of discussion more broadly outside of the show, bigger than the show, about NATO expansion and, you know, the Russia-Ukraine thing.
00:13:51 And I don't want to just, you know, take this very significant concept and conflict and bring it down into like a two-minute observation here.
00:13:58 But I think generally speaking, foreign policy doesn't move the needle in elections. And this is the challenge for people like Michael Chong, where it's actually one of his strongest issues. I think he's tremendously weak on a lot of other things like, you know, he's the only conservative leadership candidate in 2017 that was campaigning on a carbon tax, but he's good on foreign policy. He wants to be foreign minister. That's kind of what he's gearing towards.
00:14:22 Aaron O'Toole I mean you could tell when he ran that he wanted to be a foreign affairs minister
00:14:28 and I don't know if he ever really wanted to be prime minister as much as he wanted to be foreign
00:14:32 minister he wants to be the guy that talks tough to China and he wants to be the guy that wears
00:14:37 the bomber jacket and gets into the Sea King helicopters he wants to do all that and and
00:14:41 that's fine there's a place for that but time and time again we see that voters do not care
00:14:47 that voters do not care about these things.
00:14:51 And it's not to say they shouldn't care,
00:14:53 it's that they don't.
00:14:54 And it's very difficult to get a lot of Canadians
00:14:55 to care about things that are happening a world away
00:14:59 when life is so difficult right in front of them.
00:15:02 And I think that's,
00:15:03 and again, I'm probably contributing
00:15:05 to some of the alienation
00:15:06 because I'm just doing 15 minutes on NATO funding.
00:15:09 But I think there is an integrity aspect of this.
00:15:12 And the reason I bring this up
00:15:14 and that little coda that I added to it
00:15:16 is that even if you don't care about NATO funding
00:15:19 or it's an abstract issue to you,
00:15:21 the political integrity dimension of this
00:15:23 is quite important.
00:15:25 The way that Justin Trudeau presents Canada
00:15:27 and what he's doing to Canadians
00:15:30 and the way he's presenting it
00:15:31 when he thinks no one's paying attention.
00:15:34 And that divide has become abundantly clear
00:15:36 with this report in the Washington Post.
00:15:40 And I'm glad it is American media
00:15:41 that is doing the work.
00:15:42 In this case, Canadian media was not able to do.
00:15:45 I want to pivot to another story here that is taking place, and this is a tricky one to cover because there is a lot of information that cannot be discussed about it because it involves children, and in family law, cases are subject to publication bans and publication restrictions on identifiable details, including names.
00:16:08 But we can talk about what the issue at hand is.
00:16:12 And this is one in the last several years of the COVID era has become particularly acute
00:16:19 with governments trying to coercively induce people to get vaccinated against their will,
00:16:25 to take away their job.
00:16:26 And we've seen this rear its ugly head in family disputes.
00:16:30 Oftentimes when there is a custody battle, maybe one parent wants the child to get vaccinated,
00:16:35 another doesn't.
00:16:36 And we've seen courts land in some ways on a good side in these things and in other cases on a bad side.
00:16:43 I want to talk about one case, which is that of J.N., who is hoping to get the Supreme Court to affirm her right as a parent to stand up for what she thinks is in the best interest of the family.
00:16:57 the lawyer for this case which has details on helpamom.ca is from the Acacia group and that
00:17:06 is Leah Malousis. Leah thank you for coming on today good to speak to you. Thanks for having me
00:17:13 Andrew. So I've tried to give a bit of a primer there and obviously I know you can't identify
00:17:19 your your client by name here but but explain to me what led us here what's actually at hand.
00:17:25 yeah so maybe just stepping back the there was a breakdown of the marriage there are three children
00:17:33 involved um and at the time so this litigation has gone on for eight years i've not been involved in
00:17:39 that um neither has my colleague who is helping me with this case so there there's been this messy
00:17:44 litigation and ultimately the father and the mother came to minutes of settlement and they
00:17:49 were able to resolve every issue except the question of vaccinating the children. And not
00:17:56 all three of the children, just the younger two. The eldest child was 14 years old at the time of
00:18:01 the minutes of settlement, and they concluded that he was old enough to be able to decide on his own
00:18:06 whether he would like the vaccine or not. He ultimately chose to get the vaccine. Both parents
00:18:11 were supportive of that decision. But with the younger two children who are now, now their ages
00:18:17 are about 13 and 11, if I'm correct there. And so now the issue was, well, what about the younger
00:18:24 children? And there was this fight over whether they should be vaccinated. Now, it's important
00:18:28 to understand that these children didn't want to be vaccinated. And so even though they are younger
00:18:33 than their older brother, they indicated their preferences and their views. And the father's
00:18:38 position is that that's essentially, you know, their views are the results of the mother and
00:18:43 and shouldn't be respected and that they should receive this vaccine regardless and the mother's
00:18:48 position isn't that uh she's against the vaccine per se she would just like some additional
00:18:53 information some additional time um and she in particular is wanting to respect the views of the
00:18:58 children who are now very close to the age of their older brother when he was old enough in
00:19:04 the view of both parents to make this decision so that's kind of what led us here um and as you'll
00:19:10 be aware, Andrew, there was a lower court decision that, you know, resulted in the mother being
00:19:15 awarded what's called decision making. And so she was given decision making over the question of
00:19:20 COVID vaccines. Just, you know, to be clear, the children reside with her primarily. She'll, you
00:19:25 know, have decision making for most matters. And so now she was awarded by the motion judge
00:19:32 the ability to make decision regarding COVID vaccines. And then this was appealed to the
00:19:38 Ontario Court of Appeal and they overturned the decision and not only did they overturn the
00:19:43 decision and typically you know it would get sent back to trial for another decision from a motion
00:19:48 judge but they actually implemented their own order and they awarded decision making to the
00:19:54 father. There were a number of reasons of that which for that which I'm happy to go into but
00:19:59 that's kind of that that's what where we're at and that's a little bit of the background of the case.
00:20:05 so let's just i mean talk about the vaccination aspect here because the mechanics of of getting
00:20:12 vaccinated is that you can't as i'm under as i understand it be de-vaccinated so once it's been
00:20:17 done it's done which means i i think the stakes are higher if you side in this case with the
00:20:22 father than than with the mother but but i am sympathetic to the argument that younger kids
00:20:29 are probably getting a lot of their influence on this from their mother i mean i think kids are
00:20:34 smart and kids can make up their own minds but kids are also products of their surrounding and
00:20:38 kids will be products of their their mothers I'll characterize it as as vaccine hesitancy so how does
00:20:43 she answer to that how does the mother articulate uh where the children got their aversion to the 0.99
00:20:49 vaccine from yeah so so there are a few things I would say to answer that question Andrew first of
00:20:54 all there was what's called a view of the child report or two views of the child reports that were
00:21:00 done for all three children um and and that wasn't done specifically regarding the question of the
00:21:05 vaccine but one of the issues touched on in the second views of the child report was about the
00:21:11 question of vaccines and it was in that case um sorry in that report that the social worker who
00:21:16 did the you know the different interviews concluded you know these children these are the views that
00:21:21 they have they seem consistent um the social worker didn't flag any any type of um influence
00:21:28 Now, I think, you know, obviously, children are going to hear both sides. And so I think it's
00:21:35 interesting that, you know, with the with the elder child, there wasn't concern that, you know,
00:21:40 he was just going along with what his father wanted. Both parents respected the child's
00:21:44 decision. And in that case, it was the decision to get the vaccine. But then in the younger,
00:21:48 you know, with the younger two, they're, despite the fact that they're being exposed to the same
00:21:54 kind of voices on both sides. Both parents have, the record says that both parents have spoken to
00:22:00 the children about this issue. The children are very clear about the positions of the parents
00:22:05 and the younger two children have decided that they don't want the vaccine at this point in time.
00:22:11 Now, I mean, the trial judge concluded that there wasn't evidence that the views of the children
00:22:16 were only a product of the mother. There was, so that was a factual finding, but it's also
00:22:22 important to understand um and then there is case law and we we reference to this case law in our
00:22:27 um in our motion to stay because we put forward a motion to stay the order of the onca the ontario
00:22:33 court of appeal um and one of the things that that has been demonstrated in some of the case law is
00:22:38 that even if even if the views of the children are are misguided are you know are only the results of
00:22:44 a parent if they're sincerely held you know if these children really are this opposed then moving
00:22:51 forward with, in this case, a medical treatment that cannot be reversed, is going to have a pretty
00:22:56 severe impact on them, particularly when the person kind of moving that forward is going to
00:23:01 be their father, there are going to be some serious ramifications there. And it's important
00:23:06 that people understand, obviously, when it's the COVID vaccine issue, you know, there are a lot of
00:23:11 a lot of emotions and perspectives that come to play. But really, this is not a question about
00:23:15 the vaccine, whether it's good or bad, whether children should get it or not. In a case like
00:23:21 this a family law case, the only question that the court is supposed to look at with regard to
00:23:26 access or parenting decision-making order is the question of what is in the best interest of these
00:23:33 specific children, not children generally, not people generally, these children. And so you have
00:23:39 to think not just about, you know, who gave these children these views, which according to the trial
00:23:45 court it wasn't um it wasn't clear on the record that it was just the result of the mother
00:23:50 but even if it was you need to think about how how moving forward with a forced vaccine for
00:23:56 these children will impact them um and impact their relationship with both of their parents
00:24:01 and and i think that's something that the ontario court of appeal didn't consider properly let me
00:24:06 drill down further into that best interest of the child bit because one question you've raised in
00:24:10 your commentary on this case is about uh accepting or should a judge be able to accept a government
00:24:16 statement on an irreversible medical intervention as fact so how does the the government's position
00:24:22 factor into this case yeah so the the you know this this from a in terms of how we speak about
00:24:28 it in layman's terms obviously we're thinking about the the children the parents the vaccine
00:24:33 that's what this is about but from a legal perspective this case rests on something
00:24:36 called judicial notice and to kind of fast track and explain this evidentiary concept the idea is
00:24:42 that in a case um the judge has the option it's a discretionary option um to to take what's called
00:24:49 judicial notice of a fact and that's done in cases where the fact is so evident so obvious
00:24:54 that you know reasonable people couldn't couldn't wouldn't disagree about this so for example
00:25:00 applying that here um you know a judge could take judicial notice and many judges have of the the
00:25:05 fact that the covid pandemic happened you know that covid exists um you know there'll be some
00:25:11 people i imagine who dispute whether you want to call it covet or whatever but the reality is that
00:25:15 we know there's been a pandemic we know people have been affected that is a fact now judicial
00:25:20 notice cannot be taken of what's called expert opinion so once you start getting into the question
00:25:25 of um not just facts but what ought to happen or maybe what what the ideal treatment would be for
00:25:32 a child like that's where you start getting close much much further into the realm of expert opinion
00:25:37 so that's the important thing to understand about judicial notice and again it's just
00:25:41 discretionary so in this case so there have been cases across the country regarding vaccines and
00:25:47 children and what's best for the children so um in this specific case the trial judge decided
00:25:52 not to take judicial notice of the government statements that have been put forward by the
00:25:57 father both parents brought uh different evidence they both brought what's called you know internet
00:26:02 downloads they kind of downloaded stuff off the internet and put it before the court um and the
00:26:07 the trial judge concluded that he wasn't going to take judicial notice of the government statements
00:26:12 because the the approval of the vaccine by health canada um he said you know didn't translate to it
00:26:21 automatically being in the best interest of these children um so so yeah i mean government you know
00:26:26 the government approved the vaccine and you know that is a fact but the question of whether it's
00:26:31 now by default safe and effective and not just safe and effective but in the best interest of
00:26:36 these children is a separate one now the courts have been taking very different views on this and
00:26:41 this is one of the reasons we've appealed it to the supreme court because we really think we need
00:26:45 some uh some insight into how to sort through this very messy area of law because basically
00:26:50 um some courts have said you know covet exists vaccines are generally good and that's as far
00:26:55 as they go some have gone a step further and saying you know what the government has said
00:27:00 that this is a safe procedure they've approved it so we're going to conclude without getting
00:27:04 any evidence before us that you know that this vaccine is safe and effective and then others
00:27:09 have gone even a further step and said not only is the vaccine safe and effective but it is in
00:27:14 the best interest of children generally and and the the real issue with that uh andrew is that
00:27:20 is that the the best interest of the child analysis is not about what's in the best interest
00:27:24 for children generally, but about these specific children. And so while I don't think the courts
00:27:29 are trying to kind of undermine what's best for children, and while I don't think the government
00:27:34 intended for their statements to be used this way, what's kind of happened with the clash of
00:27:39 judicial notice and the issue of the vaccines is we've now had kind of government statements
00:27:44 almost substituting in a decision when you think about whether a child should get a vaccine or not.
00:27:50 And basically what the Ontario Court of Appeal said is that when a question like this arises and one parent would like the children to get a procedure that has, like a vaccine, that has been approved by the government, it's basically now the onus, the burden of proof is on the parent who doesn't want that procedure to go forward to prove why it's not fair.
00:28:13 And that's just, that's a huge evidentiary burden for, in this case, a self-represented litigant to bear.
00:28:21 And it's also, it really undermines the best interest of the child analysis, which again is a hyper-individualized, laser-focused analysis about what's good for these children, not what might generally be safe and effective.
00:28:34 Well, I think that's an important point here because, you know, obviously we accept that adults have the right in some ways to do things that may not be in their own best interest. We accept that adults are human beings. They can make mistakes. Maybe it will have a risk to it. And adults can calculate that risk.
00:28:52 And we also accept that adults are the primary caregivers and decision makers for children who don't legally have the ability to make that decision.
00:28:59 And I think the gap between those two things is a little bit perplexing to people because on one hand, we don't want to say that adults have the right to harm children.
00:29:09 But on the other hand, we don't want or shouldn't want, certainly don't want, and people that do and watch and listen to this show don't want, government stepping in to make these decisions for children.
00:29:19 And I think that what I'm struggling with here is that you have two parents that are equally passionate about something.
00:29:29 And I'm assuming probably in good faith, each of them believes that what they are oriented towards is in the best interest of the children.
00:29:36 So assuming this goes on, you know, even further to the Supreme Court, are we starting from scratch every time a case like this comes up?
00:29:45 Or is this, in your view, a precedent setting case?
00:29:48 this could be a precedent-setting case i mean the process is that you know we don't by default get
00:29:57 to go to the supreme court we have to ask permission we have to ask for leave to appeal
00:30:00 so that's what we've done so we'll be waiting for that decision that's where things are at right now
00:30:04 um but i do think it could be precedent setting and i think it's important because um they're
00:30:09 they're like i said there have been conflicting decisions across the country not just at the
00:30:14 trial level but even with courts of appeal where there's this big dispute over what you know like
00:30:19 how far do we take a government statement and and how does it factor into this decision um and and
00:30:27 i think yeah again like this isn't about the vaccine this isn't about saying the government
00:30:31 does you know wrong and health canada is lying or anything like that but it's just it cannot be the
00:30:36 case that we defer or we kind of default to whatever the government thinks is in the best
00:30:44 interest of the children. You know, the government might think that a medical treatment is ideal for
00:30:49 a child, but it really is up to that family to decide. And that's why the role of the court
00:30:55 isn't to, the court doesn't decide, you know, is it best for the child to be vaccinated or not
00:31:01 necessarily. They're often just looking at who is thinking about the best interest of the child
00:31:05 and therefore who should have the decision-making to kind of move forward with that line of thinking.
00:31:10 It's also important to note, and this is a whole other can of worms, so we probably can't get into it in detail,
00:31:16 but there is case law that says it's what's called the mature minor doctrine.
00:31:21 And there is case law that says that, and this came up in the context of Jehovah's Witness children
00:31:26 who were refusing blood transfusions, and the doctors wanted to interject and force the children to get blood transfusions.
00:31:35 And the Supreme Court wrestled this question and ultimately concluded that a mature minor, a minor, so obviously someone under the age of 18, was able to understand the medical condition they had, understand, you know, the treatment, what it would mean to get it, what it would mean to not get it.
00:31:52 That it could be, depending on, you know, what the doctors conclude, maybe the courts conclude, if it gets litigated, it could be up to the child to conclude, you know, what is in his or her best interest in terms of that specific medical procedure.
00:32:07 And so, yeah, I certainly agree with you, Andrew.
00:32:10 We have two individuals, parents who love their children.
00:32:13 And I mean, the evidence on record is that they're both good parents.
00:32:16 They both love their children.
00:32:17 So that's not what this, you know, feud is about.
00:32:19 And you said they've agreed on everything else about their arrangement but this, yeah.
00:32:24 Yeah, exactly.
00:32:25 So it really is, for us, it's not a matter of, you know, these children absolutely shouldn't have the vaccine or not.
00:32:31 It's just, we're really concerned that, you know, a government statement is going to now kind of subvert the ability of a parent to have a shot at kind of making their case to a court about what's in the best interest of their children.
00:32:47 And I don't think anyone intended for government statements from Health Canada about a vaccine being approved to kind of subvert the ability of a parent to act in the best interest of their child.
00:32:59 So that's what I would say this case is ultimately about.
00:33:02 And I think if this gets appealed to the Supreme Court, if we get leave to appeal, I think it would be precedent setting for sure.
00:33:08 You've got a website set up. Explain why that is.
00:33:11 yeah so so um i mentioned i think at one point that we're kind of we jumped in at the later
00:33:18 stage so this the mother has been self-represented for um for you know at the trial level and at the
00:33:24 ontario court of appeal um and that's kind of a separate concern we're worried that um you know
00:33:29 in light of her having six kids and and her resources having been depleted over eight years
00:33:34 of messy litigation that there was just no way for her to make the strongest case she could um not
00:33:40 just for her interest, but also for the preferences and views of her two children. And so we jumped
00:33:46 in and we're helping with this latter stage of litigation, but her resources are still depleted.
00:33:54 And so we have a fundraising page set up for her to kind of get some support. This case has
00:34:02 national ramifications if it goes to the Supreme Court. So it really is not just about her,
00:34:07 but it's about kind of families across the country and their ability to to act in the
00:34:11 best interest of their children and so you can go to helpamom.ca that's all one word helpamom.ca
00:34:18 and make a donation there you can also get some additional information for those who are really
00:34:23 interested and and we didn't have time to cover all the details so if you're curious you can go
00:34:28 there for more information and to help out a mom. Leah Melosis from the Acacia group that website
00:34:33 it again helpamom.ca we did talk about this case in its earlier iteration so i'm glad that she has
00:34:39 an advocate in this as to those children thank you very much leah thanks so much andrew all right
00:34:45 thank you uh we will certainly follow that and i hope the supreme court does pick it up now i just
00:34:50 i think it was last week or two weeks ago the supreme court uh opted not to hear a case that
00:34:55 i think pretty much everyone i had spoken to thought was a slam dunk to get a hearing at the
00:34:59 Supreme Court, which was the Camby case on private health care delivery. And the Supreme Court,
00:35:05 despite having different rulings, one in BC and one in Quebec going against each other, said,
00:35:09 we're fine. So let's hope they won't do that in this case, certainly in these times. We were
00:35:15 supposed to have Megan Murphy of the Feminist Current on the show. And for reasons I'm still
00:35:22 trying to get caught up on, there's like a chat thread on our little in-house show channel. She's
00:35:26 not joining us today which is quite unfortunate because I was looking forward to speaking to her
00:35:30 but I did tease in the text for the show that I was going to talk about this story briefly out of
00:35:36 Windsor which is not far from me Windsor Ontario not Windsor Castle I don't think even the House
00:35:42 of Windsor has gone as far as this case has gone just yet but Windsor police are on were on the
00:35:49 lookout for a woman who allegedly sexually assaulted another woman at a women's shelter. 0.72
00:35:59 Now, let's take a look at the lady they believe was responsible for this. 1.00
00:36:07 Oh, that is the lovely lady there. And you can tell she's a very ladylike lady because of the 0.99
00:36:14 stubble and the five o'clock shadow. That is the lady identified as in the police press release. 1.00
00:36:24 Seriously, Desiree. Yeah, that is Desiree, who also goes by another name, which doesn't sound
00:36:33 as ladylike as Desiree does. And, you know, this is a horrific case. The allegation made by police
00:36:40 is that this person climbed into a woman's bed
00:36:46 at a woman's shelter and sexually assaulted her.
00:36:50 That is the allegation by police.
00:36:51 This individual has turned themself in to police.
00:36:58 And, you know, after all, I don't want to get YouTube
00:36:59 to give us a misgendering strike,
00:37:02 although Twitter today did change its policy on misgendering,
00:37:06 so it's no longer an automatic suspension.
00:37:08 if you go and, you know, mention someone's birth name or real name.
00:37:11 And, you know, I struggle with a lot of these sorts of stories
00:37:19 because you could look at the person who says they're a woman
00:37:23 and has the stubble and say, oh, ha, ha, ha, ha.
00:37:27 You can look at Dylan Mulvaney parading around drinking Bud Light 0.71
00:37:30 and talking about carrying around a tampon after having been a woman for, 0.54
00:37:35 I don't know, it was like, you know, three minutes or whatever. 0.98
00:37:37 and you can say, oh, ha, ha, ha, this is all ridiculous. 0.98
00:37:39 Here we have a woman who was sexually assaulted in a woman's shelter, 0.99
00:37:46 a place that she was because she needed refuge and respite
00:37:50 from something else that happened to her in the world
00:37:52 or was continuing to happen to her in the world. 0.99
00:37:54 For all we know, this woman was a rape victim. 1.00
00:37:57 Maybe she was the victim of a domestic abuse situation. 0.75
00:38:00 Who knows and who cares? 1.00
00:38:01 a woman that was supposed to be in what is by design a safe space. 1.00
00:38:07 And I don't mean like a university safe space 0.99
00:38:10 where you go and you get cookies and play with a puppy
00:38:13 because your exams are too stressful.
00:38:14 I mean a safe space where you literally go
00:38:17 because you could be killed if you go somewhere else. 0.99
00:38:21 So she goes there and then this frigging man climbs into her bed 0.99
00:38:27 and tries to do whoever knows what, I don't know. 0.99
00:38:31 And I don't want to know.
00:38:33 It's ghastly. 1.00
00:38:35 And people who dare to speak up and say that women's spaces are important,
00:38:40 people who dare to say that actually, yes, women should be protected as a group,
00:38:45 are called transphobes.
00:38:47 They're called bigots. 0.72
00:38:48 They have their families threatened.
00:38:50 People like J.K. Rowling are denounced by people whose lives and careers she made
00:38:55 because she, again, a woman who was in an abusive marriage,
00:38:58 stands up and says, you know what?
00:38:59 I actually think we need to protect women's spaces. You can be as progressive, LGBTQI2
00:39:07 friendly as you want to be, and still believe that perhaps women's shelters should be places
00:39:14 that women can seek refuge. And all of these people who for years have said we need to smash
00:39:21 the patriarchy have no issue with men colonizing women's shelters now. It is disgusting. It is 0.96
00:39:30 despicable and it is shameful how many people will be too afraid of calling a spade a spade
00:39:36 because of how rabid some of the activists are in this space. Put up that picture again. Put up
00:39:45 that picture, Sean. This is the person that police have accused in Windsor of this crime,
00:39:52 the person that is charged with sexual assault. You are to look at that person and see a woman.
00:40:00 That is what society tells you you are supposed to do. Is this a healthy society? Do we give 0.97
00:40:09 this individual the benefit of the doubt on their self-identification after what just happened
00:40:16 and people can say oh but yeah men sexually assault women too well clearly the counterpoint
00:40:22 to that is not to allow men to sexually assault more women by allowing men to pretend to be women
00:40:28 and even if this person genuinely believes beyond a shadow of a doubt beyond a five o'clock shadow
00:40:32 of a doubt that they are a woman, do they not perhaps warrant separate spaces? This is disgusting 0.64
00:40:43 and anyone who is silent on this or anyone who turns around and calls out those who speak up
00:40:48 for women's space is complicit in this abuse. That does it for me for today. This is the Andrew
00:40:54 Lawton Show on True North. Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:41:02 donating to True North at www.tnc.news.