Juno News - September 21, 2023


Trudeau tries to sell his carbon tax at the UN

Topics
Mentioned
Parental rights protesters and gender ideology activists square off New centrist party seeks to act as counter-weight to Poilievre

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

182.86

Word count

8,858

Sentence count

359

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Andrew Lawton talks about the Million Person March, Justin Trudeau's trip to the United Nation's Summit in Davos, and the ongoing Tamara Leach and Chris Barber trial in the Supreme Court of Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to Canada's most irreverent talk show
00:01:16 this is the Andrew Lawton Show
00:01:19 brought to you by True North
00:01:20 hello and welcome to you all
00:01:27 we made it through another week
00:01:28 it is Thursday, September 21st, 2023. This is Canada's most irreverent talk show. Although I
00:01:36 should say if you're not careful and you're typing it out, autocorrect will sometimes shift to
00:01:41 irrelevant. But no, I'm not Rosie Barton. This is not CBC. We are highly relevant and very irreverent
00:01:48 at times, which every now and then some people take issue with on our side of the spectrum. And
00:01:53 they say, well, why do you want to be irreverent? And I would say because we challenge the orthodoxies
00:01:58 of our era, which right now, as we saw last week, so very much need to be challenged.
00:02:04 Not that last week, yesterday, I guess I should say.
00:02:07 Speaking specifically of the Million Person March, which I was very proud to be part of
00:02:11 the True North team in covering, it was easy for me because I did it from here.
00:02:15 But Harrison Faulkner was out there in the midst of the protests in Toronto.
00:02:21 We had Ellie Kenton-Nantel in Ottawa.
00:02:24 We had Cosman, Georgia, and Lindsay Shepard out in British Columbia at the Vancouver one.
00:02:29 We had other folks from our team at various points.
00:02:32 I realize that you can't list everyone, so you have to not list most, because if you
00:02:36 list most and not all, you offend the one person you left out.
00:02:40 So apologies if I did that to any of my own colleagues here.
00:02:43 But the reason I bring that up again is because, and I would stay tuned to True North on this,
00:02:48 there's going to be a bit of a wave, as we're seeing, of really unhinged reactions and
00:02:55 breakdowns of what happened there as the media really just distills this down into an inaccurate
00:03:01 and very unfair caricature of the people that were there. And it's just like I was talking about
00:03:06 when you have union activists that are saying it's far right and racist. And then you like
00:03:11 pan to an image of a bunch of like happy Muslims and Sikhs that are saying, you know, love,
00:03:15 diversity, children. It's like, oh, wow, the face of white supremacy is a little weird right now,
00:03:22 but that is the way the media is framing this. We're going to be talking later on in this show
00:03:27 with Dominic Carty, who is an MLA in New Brunswick and the interim leader of a new political party
00:03:33 that posits itself as a radical centrist voice in Canadian politics. That is the party that was
00:03:41 created by the folks behind Center Ice Canadians.
00:03:44 It is called Canadian Future.
00:03:46 We'll speak about what that is
00:03:48 and what it is they're doing in our political landscape later on.
00:03:52 Also, Trish Wood will join us for a wrap-up of the third week 0.96
00:03:56 of the Tamara Leach and Chris Barber trial,
00:03:59 which is coming to an end in the next couple of hours here in Ottawa.
00:04:03 But first, I want to talk about Justin Trudeau's visit to the UN.
00:04:07 I know, I know, it's like the epitome of dog bites, man.
00:04:10 Justin Trudeau goes to UN. I think if he had his way, he'd be able to spend all his days
00:04:14 at the UN and Davos and not have to worry about the pesky parliamentary process in Ottawa. But
00:04:20 Justin Trudeau went back to the House of Commons for one day. He was there for Monday and then
00:04:25 like hightailed it out of there so quickly to hitch his plane or hitch a ride on his plane
00:04:31 to New York City, where he's spent a few days reveling in the world of sustainable development
00:04:37 goals at the United Nations. Now, Trudeau has done this in a way that we shouldn't be all that
00:04:44 surprised by. Let's be real here. He's going and not talking about anything dissimilar from what
00:04:49 he talks about when he's here. But I want to just begin by setting the stage for this, because this
00:04:55 SDG consortium here, presided over by the UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres, sounds all
00:05:03 nice and benign, but it really isn't. This is a clip from Secretary General Gutierrez.
00:05:09 Eight years ago, member states gathered in the hall to adopt the sustainable development goals.
00:05:17 With the world watching, including 193 young people in the balcony, holding blue lamps of hope,
00:05:25 you made a solemn promise. A promise to build a world of health, progress, and opportunity for
00:05:32 all a promise to leave no one behind and the promise to pay for it
00:05:41 oh yes that's the key caveat they're saying the quiet part out loud the countries didn't
00:05:46 just agree to the vision they want for the world they agreed to pay for it but that means that
00:05:52 they agreed for us to pay for it they often leave out that last part which is that canada
00:05:58 is not paying for anything canadians are paying for things now antonio guterres a literal socialist
00:06:05 is the guy that gets up there and talks about how the world's burning and the only thing that can
00:06:08 save it is if everyone comes together and does his bidding and that of the united nations agenda
00:06:15 more broadly now this is an agenda that your prime minister our prime minister justin trudeau has
00:06:20 all too willingly adopted this is a a little quote from him talking about how the sdgs are
00:06:27 pretty darn important. Co-chair of the Secretary General's SDG advocates, why are the SDGs so
00:06:35 important to you and for Canada? Well, I think they're just important, period. What we're seeing
00:06:42 right now everywhere around the world is a level of anxiety about the future that I don't think
00:06:48 we've ever seen at this level before. I mean, whether it's the real impacts of climate change
00:06:53 are increasingly felt by everyone whether it's the spreading of conflicts and instability in
00:07:00 terms of food in terms of energy all around the world whether it's a pandemic that knocked us all
00:07:05 for a loop people are worried and people are worried that they're you know going to be able
00:07:10 to offer a better future to their kids and that's not obvious even in wealthy places where that had
00:07:17 always been the story um people are really not certain about the future so showing that as a
00:07:23 world we can focus on the basic building blocks of success the the the sdg goals are what is
00:07:32 necessary to create a successful planet full stop over the coming decades not just a list of nice
00:07:41 to haves they are necessary that was a comment in an interview in march it dovetails on this other
00:07:48 one now where justin trudeau is lamenting that uh we are off track on these things we're not doing
00:07:54 enough to meet these have pointed out the 2023 special edition of the sdgs report is sobering
00:08:03 The fact that nearly 50% of SDG targets are moderately or severely off track is alarming.
00:08:13 We need an immediate course correction and acceleration of progress.
00:08:19 But as many have said, it's just half time.
00:08:23 We can do this.
00:08:27 We can do this.
00:08:30 We can.
00:08:31 We really, really can.
00:08:33 I really mean it. We can do this. These SDGs, let me just take a step back. These are 17 goals that
00:08:40 United Nations member states all came together in 2015 to agree on. Now, I should say to point
00:08:47 out the elephant in the room, it was a conservative government in Canada that signed Canada onto this
00:08:52 at the same time they were doing the Paris Climate Accord. And I know this is a criticism that you
00:08:57 often get from notably PPC supporters towards the conservatives, and it's a fair criticism.
00:09:02 And the only real argument that you could use to defend this is, well, it's just what every
00:09:07 country does. That's the only real defense. Well, we just went along with it. And we didn't really
00:09:12 mean it, but we said what we had to do. And if you look at the website for the SDGs, they're
00:09:17 very seemingly benign. Number one is no poverty. Well, who's going to stand up and say, well,
00:09:24 I actually, you know, I know it's not politically correct, but I like poverty. The second is zero
00:09:29 hunger i i hate being hungry and you know i'm making light of it there is a very serious hunger
00:09:35 issue in the world i do not like that people are going hungry number three good health and well
00:09:40 being i am in no position to lecture anyone about this but it is a very good goal quality education
00:09:47 most of these things are very normal and acceptable and palatable things the problem of course is when
00:09:55 you drill down and look at the mechanisms that the un believes are necessary to get to this point
00:10:02 for example we look at let me just pull up the number here 13 goal 13 is climate action there
00:10:10 is obviously going to be a significant bit of politicization here it's take urgent action to
00:10:16 combat climate change and its impacts you look at the targets and indicators and 13.2 is to
00:10:23 integrate climate change measures into national policies, strategies, and planning. So this means
00:10:29 that when countries have signed on to this, they're not just signing on to the theoretical
00:10:34 goal of ending hunger, ending poverty, ending climate change. They're committing themselves,
00:10:39 it's not binding, but they are choosing to bind themselves to this pledge to integrate measures
00:10:45 into national policies, strategies, and planning. And I share that with you so that you have the
00:10:51 context for what's happening when Justin Trudeau gets up there today and makes this call at the UN.
00:10:57 We all know that pollution has a cost. We're seeing that every day.
00:11:05 Together, we can make sure that pollution has a price too. In Canada, our price on pollution
00:11:14 not only ensures big emitters pay their fair share, it also returns money collected directly
00:11:22 to families through rebates. In fact, the rebates put more money in people's pockets
00:11:29 than the vast majority pay into the system. So here he is, first off, blatantly telling a falsehood
00:11:38 about the nature of the carbon tax. I mean, the way he describes it, we all make money from it.
00:11:43 Like, did you know that, that you actually make money from the carbon tax, that when you have
00:11:48 to pay more for groceries and pay more for gas and pay more to heat your house, that you're
00:11:52 actually coming out on top? Because that's the argument he's making there. When you get that
00:11:56 little piddly climate action payment or climate action incentive, as they used to say it, that's
00:12:01 supposed to just make you forget about everything else. So, goody, the carbon tax is actually a
00:12:06 great gift to us. Well, if people are making more from this, how is it doing all the things the
00:12:11 government claims it's going to do and claims it's doing. It's not. But here's the problem.
00:12:17 The carbon tax is one of the single biggest contributing factors right now to the rising
00:12:21 cost of living that is directly within government's control. Inflation has a government role,
00:12:27 yes, but the carbon tax, the government could literally flip a switch and the prices on all
00:12:31 of those things, the carbon tax effects would go down. And then the indirect costs, for example,
00:12:37 the price of shipping a cauliflower to your grocery store, that trucker had to pay more in
00:12:43 carbon tax to get the fuel. That is an indirect cost, which would come down conceivably as well.
00:12:49 But he is now calling for every country around the world to follow Canada's lead. At a time when
00:12:57 global inflation is pushing more and more people into poverty, he gets up there and says to the UN,
00:13:03 And, you know, forget about the fact that people in my home country are losing their homes and can't afford to buy groceries.
00:13:09 We all need to do this.
00:13:11 We all need to learn from Canada's example right now.
00:13:14 And this is the problem.
00:13:15 The SDGs get a bit of a conspiratorial rap sometime.
00:13:20 Canada is not beholden to these things.
00:13:22 Canada agreed, but Canada still has the authority to decide what policies it wants to enact.
00:13:28 The problem with Justin Trudeau is not that he's bound by these things.
00:13:31 It's that he wants to be bound by these things.
00:13:34 He's actually the great evangelist for the Sustainable Development Goals.
00:13:38 I don't know if it's possible to put a screenshot of it up, but if you saw that clip that I
00:13:42 just played from Justin Trudeau speaking, he's wearing a pin that looks like a trivial
00:13:47 pursuit board with, you know, the little colored pie wedges.
00:13:51 Well, that is the official logo of the UN Sustainable Development Goals.
00:13:55 Each one of those wedges represents one of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals.
00:14:00 So you go up there and wonder, why is this guy wearing, why is he, when did it go out of vogue to wear a Canadian flag when you're representing Canada at the United Nations?
00:14:09 Because when Justin Trudeau speaks at the United Nations, he is not Canada's representative in New York.
00:14:16 He is the United Nations representative to Canada.
00:14:19 And that is such a crucial point here, is that he wants to represent the global community, the so-called global community in Canada, instead of representing Canada itself, which should be his job. 0.87
00:14:33 And that's one of the great contrasts between Stephen Harper and Justin Trudeau.
00:14:37 We have that image up.
00:14:39 Correct me if I'm wrong.
00:14:40 I don't recall Stephen Harper ever wearing that Sustainable Development Goals pin.
00:14:46 Now, admittedly, he was out of office not long after the SDGs were cemented, so maybe the UN
00:14:50 branding department hadn't made the pins yet, but I don't think he ever would have worn a pin like
00:14:56 that. And I may have told this story previously when my producer, Sean, and I were walking around
00:15:01 in Davos, you'd like walk up to someone and you'd say, oh, wow, this guy must work for the UN. He's
00:15:06 wearing that UN pin. And you look at his name tag and it's like, oh, that's Brad Smith, the CEO of
00:15:11 Microsoft? Like, why is he wearing a UN pin? Shouldn't he be representing Microsoft? Why is
00:15:17 Justin Trudeau wearing a UN pin? And these things are incredibly important for people to take note
00:15:24 of here, because we have as a country national sovereignty. The United Nations, people who
00:15:29 defend it against critics will say, well, hang on, the UN doesn't have an agenda of its own. It only
00:15:35 has the agenda that is given to it by its member states. That's kind of true. I would argue it's
00:15:41 untrue when you look at how the UN Secretary General takes such a prominent role in shaping
00:15:48 discussions and when the UN is putting out policy resolutions and agendas and all of that.
00:15:53 But at its core, Canada could look at this and say, no. Canada could look at this and say,
00:15:58 you know what, screw this. We're representing our national interests. And yes, we're committed if we
00:16:03 can be a part of the solution to reduce hunger and reduce poverty and all of that stuff. But we
00:16:08 are not going to bankrupt our country because all of these people are clinging to you know
00:16:15 UN SDG number 13 as being some trump card over sovereign countries and their national interests
00:16:24 and uh it's really interesting because you look at these discussions and you'll see like the head
00:16:29 of the Maldives or the head of Tuvalu get up there and say we're drowning we're drowning everyone
00:16:33 needs to have a carbon tax so we can get rid of this and then you look at these ribbon cuttings
00:16:38 they're doing for these waterfront resorts. And you're like, well, you know, if you think your
00:16:42 country is going to be underwater, maybe you shouldn't be investing in waterfront property.
00:16:46 There's a little bit of an issue there that I have in understanding the logic and rationale
00:16:51 behind this. So thank you for coming to my TED Talk, as we say. We will move now to a story
00:16:58 that's been brewing in Ottawa for now three weeks. It is the criminal mischief trial of Tamara Leach
00:17:05 and chris barber and what's interesting about this we haven't been able to cover it from the
00:17:10 courtroom because i you know can't broadcast live from you know courtroom number three or whatever
00:17:14 they're in but we've been keeping an update and i've been keeping tabs on it and there's been
00:17:18 some great reporting that's been taking place uh some of it from robert krychuk of rebel and also
00:17:24 from trish wood who we had on alongside jacqueline vine and a couple of weeks ago about a documentary
00:17:30 they're putting together on Tamara Leach called the Trials of Tamara Leach. But I wanted to bring
00:17:36 Trish Wood back onto the show for a bit of an update on how things have been going. Trish,
00:17:40 good to talk to you. This week has been a bit interesting because we've seen
00:17:44 some double speak from one of the witnesses from what he said during the Public Order
00:17:50 Emergency Commission and what he's now saying in the prosecution of Chris and Tamara. What's going
00:17:56 on well it's quite interesting because well let me just say um you're lucky you're not covering
00:18:02 the trial because it's one of the most boring things i've ever been involved in as a journalist
00:18:06 and most trials as you know andrew are full of drama they create their own culture they create
00:18:12 their own stories remember oj and you know if the glove doesn't fit you must quit and all that
00:18:17 wonderful stuff that happened this trial is a huge drag on one's attention i mean maybe it's the you
00:18:25 know the the air flow problem in the courtroom or something along those lines but generally it is a
00:18:33 case the crown's case is a case in search of a narrative the crown has not explained in any
00:18:42 sensible way exactly why he's leading the evidence he's leading in the order he's leading the
00:18:48 evidence he and she he has a second chair young young woman he's leading and the whole thing has
00:18:54 turned into and I don't want to be disrespectful to the court I quite like this judge and I've said
00:18:59 so before I think I said so the last time I was on she's pretty interesting tough smart doesn't 1.00
00:19:04 miss a trick and is managing a whole bunch of really crazy stuff that's going on quite well
00:19:09 but I it's becoming a big kind of evidentiary blob you know you you're not being trained as they
00:19:18 as a good lawyer will kind of put it out day after day to start thinking about the case in a certain
00:19:24 way and you're like oh yeah well that could you know that maybe that could be true maybe they
00:19:29 did do it or maybe they didn't do it it's just kind of throwing spaghetti at a wall and hoping
00:19:34 it's going to stick that that feels like what's going on and i don't get it i do know i'm sure
00:19:39 you know too that this is not the first crown this is not the original crown um that he was
00:19:45 removed and i don't exactly know what happened there i i know that he was pretty zealous and
00:19:51 was seen to be zealous, which is not necessarily a good look in a trial that's already being
00:19:56 accused of being political. So they brought these two in. Tim Radcliffe is the lead chair.
00:20:03 I don't know. Maybe it's a last minute thing. Maybe they're just not up to speed on their
00:20:07 own evidence. But I am not hearing anything bad about Chris Barber and Tamara Leach day after
00:20:14 day after day after day. I mean, it's kind of crazy. And I don't think even like I've been
00:20:20 following Canadian press a little bit because they've been sort of okay. I don't think even
00:20:25 the people who are inclined to look at, mainly the legacy media, the people who are inclined to look
00:20:32 at Tamara and Chris in the worst possible way, even they're playing it kind of straight because
00:20:36 there's not really anything going on. The nub of it, I think, is the phrase, hold the line.
00:20:42 And how will that be interpreted? And what did it mean? And what did it mean when various people
00:20:46 said it i also think it will be about at the end of the day uh the interpretation of the phrase
00:20:53 mischief because that can be legally interpreted multiple ways too but we don't even have a
00:20:58 framework of language in this case yet so it's a really really strange thing to be participating
00:21:06 and sitting there in the gallery yeah yeah and just to talk about the pace of this there were
00:21:12 initially 22 witnesses the crown was planning to call yeah i believe there was talk about adding
00:21:17 more but just for context here we are about to wrap up the third week of trial there are
00:21:22 under the original schedule three days left and they've gone through three witnesses yeah so
00:21:30 here's what's going on there aside from the fact that the witnesses are not saying anything
00:21:35 inculpatory about taking a long time to say nothing is that they're taking like well they're
00:21:39 they're not even saying bad things about the defendants, right? Which you would think the
00:21:43 crown witnesses would be. But there's a lot of procedural stuff that I don't quite understand.
00:21:50 And I, look, I give, trials are really, really hard work, Andrew. I mean, you're in trial all
00:21:57 day, on your feet, working really hard, and you go home at night and you prep more. It's a really
00:22:02 tough gig for both sides, actually. So I have some sympathy for them. But what I don't understand is
00:22:08 why the Crown Attorney, primarily Tim Radcliffe, who is the lead chair, was not better prepared
00:22:15 because a lot of the reasons that we're seeing this slow going with the witnesses is that
00:22:22 simple rules of evidence don't seem to have been being adhered to. So we'll just get going
00:22:29 and they'll get three questions and answers out from one of their witnesses. And then there is
00:22:34 an objection, which the defense is perfectly entitled and should be doing on behalf of their
00:22:39 client. And then a long, long discussion on simple things like I know with Mr. Ayotte, who's on the
00:22:46 stand now, one of the issues was, did he have notebooks? What notebooks can buttress what he's
00:22:51 testifying to in court? And my understanding from when I was there the other day is that he didn't
00:22:57 have any. So that then becomes a big thing. How do you know what you know? And how do we know that
00:23:01 you're saying, what you actually know, you know, like there are reasons that they do all these
00:23:05 really specific things, these rules of evidence in a trial, and they don't, it's not that they're
00:23:11 not being adhered to. That's maybe not a fair thing to say. That would be perhaps for an appellate
00:23:16 court to sort out later, but they seem to be coming to Mr. Radcliffe as a bit of a surprise.
00:23:22 So I don't know if, if, if Justice Perkins McVey is being a stickler or if there really is something
00:23:31 hinky about the way they are bringing the evidence to court and some of it makes you know the
00:23:36 complaints about it makes sense to me obviously if you're defending your client you need to know
00:23:40 exactly what the crown's going to lead so you can prepare your defense and your you know arguments
00:23:45 i mean court really is about arguing right and in order to to prepare yourself you need to know what
00:23:51 they're going to lead and whether it's credible and where they got it and all that stuff and
00:23:54 that didn't seem to be being happening so this is dragging and i will say that the judge
00:24:00 is saying that you know she looks kind of irritated at times and not yet irritated with
00:24:07 defense now they're not leading evidence yet but but uh she does seem somewhat irritated with it
00:24:13 with this crown and with the process no one wants this no one wants to be a judge in charge of a
00:24:19 proceeding that's sort of crawling along the eyes of the country you know are on this and um i you
00:24:26 know, I'll say this, Andrew, I'm not a purely objective observer. I was a journalist long
00:24:30 enough to know that I, you know, I do have sides a bit in this. I can sort out truth from non-truth,
00:24:37 but I do wish these charges hadn't been laid. And I, you know, I kind of favored the convoy.
00:24:43 I think people know that. But putting that aside, I feel like everybody involved in it,
00:24:49 including the judge, wants this case to be decided on the facts as they're presented,
00:24:55 whether you think the charges should have been brought or not and uh i think it's going to be
00:25:00 really really difficult for the crown to prove its case in this maybe you know maybe that's wishful
00:25:04 thinking on my part but yeah some of the clips that i was told were played earlier on in this
00:25:12 trial had nothing to do with tamara leach and chris barber and and you know it's funny because
00:25:18 the crown made a point of saying early on in his opening remarks you know we're not this is not
00:25:22 trying them for their political beliefs. And I believe he had also made a comment about it not
00:25:26 being about the convoy itself. And yet his case has involved trying to basically put the convoy
00:25:33 on trial. Well, I almost want to put my hand up and say, Mr. Radcliffe, so why did you lead that
00:25:40 clip? What am I supposed to glean from that? Because I'm not getting it. There was a guy on
00:25:44 from the Sûreté to Quebec. This is how kind of absurd some of the evidence is. And he was part of
00:25:52 what they were calling the Green Squad.
00:25:54 And if you remember when they brought the convoy down
00:25:57 and by this time, bear in mind,
00:26:00 Tamara and Chris had already been arrested.
00:26:02 They weren't even there.
00:26:03 This was-
00:26:03 Yeah, just for the audience to be aware,
00:26:05 they were arrested before the major police operations
00:26:09 took place.
00:26:10 So, I mean, anything that happened after that point,
00:26:12 I mean, yes, you could argue maybe
00:26:14 they had encouraged it before,
00:26:15 but they weren't there.
00:26:17 They weren't involved.
00:26:17 They were in a cell.
00:26:19 They were in a cell, yeah.
00:26:20 so so the certee quebec is doing this i guess it's called a clearing operation or at least
00:26:25 that's what the military calls it and then he was with the green squad and there was a point where
00:26:30 he's kind of talking about what they're doing you see this i believe it was body cam footage
00:26:35 and this is kind of heartbreaking too that here are these far right you know terrorists according
00:26:43 to some people including legacy media all these guys kind of military age guys uh chanting love
00:26:50 over fear right they're not misbehaving they are they're standing calm and true and chanting love
00:26:58 over fear in the face of this really overpowering police presence i think at that point the police
00:27:03 were behaving as well and not not dumping on them but here they are they're all on their black block 0.98
00:27:08 and it's you know very scary and we don't know what's going to happen and then there was kind
00:27:13 of a moment where this um this uh police officer from from the sq says well and then we went for
00:27:19 lunch and so of course the defense council lawrence greenspan says something like well you went for
00:27:26 lunch so so there's this big moment of we've got to you know secure the area from these scary people
00:27:33 but we're going for lunch so i mean there are moments that maybe are not like intended to be
00:27:40 really representative of what's going on they actually were like it wasn't they weren't so
00:27:45 scared that they couldn't go to the chateau laurier for lunch he clarified he wasn't eating
00:27:50 at the chateau laurier no one can afford that they took their lunches to the chateau laurier
00:27:54 so that's the kind of stuff we're seeing right i mean i haven't seen anything in the videos
00:28:00 that did anything but really uh act as exculpatory evidence for the fence except there are chance of
00:28:08 hold the line i know that's going to be discussed forever and ever but it is showing um some
00:28:15 pretty how can i put subdued behavior on behalf of the protesters and i don't know if you remember
00:28:20 this if i said this on the last show but when they first started showing these these videos
00:28:25 and you're like oh what's going to be in them they're going to be so terrible and and what
00:28:29 happened was the the protesters looked pretty responsible but also in these clips there were
00:28:37 photographs and images of the police beating protesters in the head and and the judge noticed
00:28:43 that you know she noticed so whatever they're leading it always seems it's kind of like dare i
00:28:50 say um the roadrunner and the coyote like they keep dropping the anvil on i maybe i'm overstating
00:28:56 it but do we know when they're going to settle the trial schedule itself just to get back to the
00:29:03 housekeeping side of this because i again the dates that were originally planned they were going
00:29:07 to i believe run tomorrow as well i i they weren't running fridays but i believe they're scheduled to
00:29:12 to go tomorrow and then they were going to take a two-week break and finish off october 11th to
00:29:17 13th and i know they've talked about needing to add more dates has that been settled yet not as
00:29:23 far as i know but i came back yesterday so i don't know if there's been movement on that i
00:29:28 i get the sense that they've still got a long way to go with this and and it's also interesting too
00:29:35 because covering it then becomes a problem right it costs money to be in ottawa you know i'm paying
00:29:40 hotels and la la la as you all know and you're like nothing's really happening you're waiting
00:29:46 for the big trial moment and nothing is happening it's all almost all procedural none of it's making
00:29:55 very much sense and you kind of go home at the end of the day thinking man what am I going to
00:29:58 write about so I've been writing about how bumpy the train ride was going down to Ottawa
00:30:03 I was writing about other trials I've covered I mean there's not all that much to say and yet
00:30:09 But this is a massively important trial in Canadian history, isn't it?
00:30:13 And if they are convicted, then we better know why it happened.
00:30:17 And that's essentially why we're all there and still kind of hanging in with something
00:30:21 that even a lot of the protesters have disappeared at their point too.
00:30:25 Trish Wood is the host of Trish Wood is Critical.
00:30:28 And you should always follow the work she does because you are never going to be disappointed
00:30:32 if you do.
00:30:33 Trish, thanks so much, as always, for coming on.
00:30:35 Thanks, Andrew.
00:30:36 Have a good day.
00:30:37 All right.
00:30:37 Thank you very much.
00:30:38 yeah and i mean i had initially planned to go up for the last few days i figured i'd sit in for
00:30:43 closing arguments come out do my show go back into the now i don't even know when the final days will
00:30:48 be like i could go up for october 11th to 13th and actually my birthday is the 14th so maybe i'll
00:30:54 just spend my birthday alone in a courtroom in ottawa or something but uh the the reality is
00:30:59 this is not going to be a particularly enjoyable uh experience if this goes on for weeks and weeks
00:31:05 and weeks and as Trish says they're not really getting anywhere with it so that's the point of
00:31:11 it I know we get periodically people asking why are you not covering the we are covering but you
00:31:16 know you can't film in courtrooms nine times that will actually like 99 times out of 100 in this
00:31:21 country so this is one of those ones where we have to just pop in from time to time but I do want to
00:31:27 talk about this story that came about this week which is a bit of a deviation from what we've been
00:31:33 talking about the rest of the show, which makes it a good note to end on for the week. A new
00:31:37 political party. Now, I should say that there are a great many political parties in this country.
00:31:42 You've got the Communist Party, the Marxist-Leninist Party. You've got, I think there was a
00:31:46 Marijuana Party at one point. So you've got a bunch of parties that don't really do anything
00:31:51 and are kind of just existing on paper only. And then you have parties that come on and they want
00:31:56 to make a splash because they feel they are filling a void that the status quo is not addressing.
00:32:02 And that is what this new initiative seeks to do.
00:32:05 It is a party formed by the folks behind Centre Ice Canadians, which was formerly Centre Ice Conservatives.
00:32:11 It is called Canadian Future and is being led in the interim by New Brunswick MLA Dominic Carty, who joins me now.
00:32:18 Dominic, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today.
00:32:21 Hey, thanks for having me on the show. Appreciate it.
00:32:23 So let me just ask first and foremost, I know this is being presented as a centrist party,
00:32:28 which is a term you often hear kind of appropriated by both sides. Do you view this
00:32:33 as a party for conservatives that don't like Pierre Polyev or liberals who don't like Justin
00:32:38 Trudeau? We'll take both and lots of other people who are fed up with politics in general. We've had
00:32:43 some support coming even from other parties because there's, I think, a feeling that we've
00:32:48 ended up with kind of a mushy politics where you've got this kind of sterile debate about left
00:32:53 versus right based on a 200-plus-year-old idea about how we should run our economies.
00:32:58 We've got 100-plus years now of ideas and evidence about how to run mixed economies.
00:33:03 We know that's generally what works.
00:33:05 To me, the big fight right now is about do we have an open society or a closed society?
00:33:09 Do we fall in line with the models of governments that we're seeing pushed by the Chinese and 1.00
00:33:13 the Russians around the world, clearly trying to influence Canada directly and indirectly?
00:33:17 And do we have a party based on evidence?
00:33:20 Because I think that's something that all the parties have slipped away from as the years of left-wing postmodernism made truth somewhat relative.
00:33:27 And that's now being a mantra embraced by the right, where we have, unfortunately, Mr. Polyarov out campaigning Max Bernier, talking about the World Economic Forum and how apparently it's running our lives, which has got to be one of the daftest things I've ever heard.
00:33:39 And I'm getting kind of fed up with people saying that Canadians aren't responsible for what happens in Canada.
00:33:44 We're not subject to shadowy foreign influences.
00:33:47 We're a sovereign country.
00:33:48 We can make this place better.
00:33:48 We built it.
00:33:49 we can fix it. Oftentimes when people call themselves centrist, they usually kind of cloak
00:33:56 it in saying they're fiscally conservative and socially liberal, which I find is somewhat
00:34:00 counterintuitive because it still sort of falls into that left-right dichotomy here. How do you
00:34:06 define what a centrist is in the context of what your party seeks to be? Yeah, although I think
00:34:10 that these definitions change, right? And you look at the Soviet Union, it was pretty damn left when
00:34:15 it came to the economy, but it was also pretty right-wing when it came to social structures.
00:34:18 It was not the land of free love and progressivism that some of its modern day young adherents like to imagine that it was.
00:34:27 So when I say center, I'm talking about being a radical centrist.
00:34:31 So I'm not talking about some mushy middle with softened down versions of policies taken from the old lines, supposedly left, supposedly right parties.
00:34:38 I'm talking about the sharp end of the arrow, getting some really aggressive policies in Canada that will help to fix some programs that we have,
00:34:46 but also really changed the direction of the country because I think people are kind of tired
00:34:49 after a number of years of Mr. Trudeau's cheerful of somewhat empty ways. And I think that's why
00:34:55 Mr. Polier is doing well in the polls. But I'd have to hope again that at some point,
00:34:59 either he shapes up and stops spreading conspiracy theories and starts actually
00:35:03 sharing some real solutions or that we'll be there to help try and fill that void because
00:35:07 there's got to be something better than having two parties, neither of whom accept that there's
00:35:11 such a thing as reality. I wonder how true that is, though. I mean, Pierre Polyev won the
00:35:17 conservative leadership with a resounding margin. I mean, greater than in, I mean, even Stephen
00:35:21 Harper, who was the founding prime minister and founding leader of the party, he had 69%
00:35:27 of the supportive members. You also have the conservatives polling right now at 40 some
00:35:33 odd percent, which in Canada is a pretty significant margin. So I just, where is the
00:35:39 political homelessness that you're describing of people that are uncomfortable with the
00:35:43 conservatives as an alternative to the liberals? Well, uncomfortable with the conservatives and
00:35:47 the liberals. We did a big poll about five months, I think, ago now, and over 2,000 people across the
00:35:54 country. And the numbers came back pretty much evenly on the both liberal and Tory side, people
00:35:59 saying they felt their parties were both of them becoming more extreme, less representative of their
00:36:03 values, less interested in talking about actual plans to fix the country's problems, more interested
00:36:08 in scoring points off of their opponents. And the sentiments about that were just about even
00:36:12 on both sides. You had stronger core base support for Mr. Polyev, which makes sense because I think
00:36:18 in the end, he became leader and not to compare him too closely, but through the same sort of
00:36:22 process that Mr. Trump became Republican nominee in the States by reaching out to a lot of people
00:36:26 who've never been involved in politics before, which on the one hand is great because we need
00:36:30 to get people engaged. And one of the things that kills democracies is when people give up on it.
00:36:34 But at the same time, when you use social media and the algorithms that drive increasing divisiveness, conflict and extremism, which is literally built into the algorithm because human beings like seeing fights and battles and arguments and people being grumpy with each other, that when you fall down that rabbit hole, it's hard to know when to stop.
00:36:51 And I assume that's how we had a Mr. Polyarif starting off pretty calm and reasonable, a guy with years of parliamentary experience who I know a lot of his colleagues have great respect for him, and now is out there out looning Max Bernier talking about the World Economic Forum and vaccine conspiracies and other things like that.
00:37:10 We're not going to be able to hold our...
00:37:11 What vaccine conspiracies has Polyarif spoken about?
00:37:14 uh what fact let's go through the list he has actually officially said that regardless of the
00:37:20 conditions under no circumstances would canada ever introduce the measures that we saw during
00:37:25 the covet uh pandemic how is that a conspiracy theory though let's let's see you can disagree
00:37:32 with it but if he's saying he's against vaccine mandates i don't see how that's a conspiracy
00:37:35 theory let's let's imagine a world where mr polyarver's prime minister and we have an outbreak
00:37:40 of a disease with, let's say, five times the fatality rate of COVID, 10%. You honestly think
00:37:45 he's not going to put a mandate in place? You honestly think that's an honest statement about
00:37:49 what he intends to do if that situation comes up? Of course not. So lying to achieve political
00:37:54 points is something that I personally really believe is at the heart of why we're seeing
00:37:59 populist movements rise up around the Western world, because people are mad about elites lying
00:38:03 to them. But if you try and replace those same disconnected elites, which the Liberal Party and
00:38:08 Mr. Trudeau represent absolutely pitch perfectly. But if you try and replace them with just another
00:38:13 set of adjustable facts that aren't necessarily grounded in reality, we're just contributing to
00:38:18 the problem and it's going to make things worse. And he'll have a lot of supporters if he doesn't
00:38:22 get in and follow through on some of the things he's campaigned on as opposition leader. And I
00:38:26 think that any party that doesn't campaign in opposition the way it intends to govern
00:38:29 is being fundamentally dishonest and contributing to degrading democracy.
00:38:33 Political parties, I think, generally tend to be followers more than leaders on a lot of issues
00:38:37 in general i mean you even mentioned that your initiative did polling you wanted to see where
00:38:41 canadians were before you took a particular course which i think is reasonable a lot of
00:38:45 the things you're talking about that you don't like about the conservatives are things that
00:38:49 there is a constituency for that is supporting the conservative so is your problem not with
00:38:55 where canadians are rather than where the conservative party of canada is i know because
00:38:59 there's no other option right now that if we've got this large chunk of the population that say
00:39:03 that they've traditionally voted liberal or conservative in some cases going back and forth
00:39:07 as lots of people do or with the other smaller parties that they're saying that there is no
00:39:11 option that brings together people who just to list a couple of examples believe that climate
00:39:16 change is real want to fix it don't believe that throwing money at problems is the way to fix it
00:39:22 following down on that policy we have a real not a lead anymore because we gave it up but we have
00:39:28 an established nuclear industry if we're talking about a climate crisis why aren't we aggressively
00:39:32 building nuclear power plants and exporting them around the world so that we can make canadian 0.98
00:39:35 jobs, make Canadian money, help do our part to reduce carbon emissions and help other countries
00:39:40 that contribute way more than we do to the carbon emissions to cut them down. I don't care what the
00:39:44 cause of climate change is. It's happening right now. And if the basic science says that reducing
00:39:49 carbon is going to help mitigate it, I'd rather have a slightly cooler planet where we can figure
00:39:52 out how to handle the swimming, usually nuclear power plants, creating a minuscule amount of
00:39:58 nuclear waste. All the waste in the world, I think, would fit into two Olympic-sized swimming pools,
00:40:02 All of it created since the 1940s. So right there, no one's talking about that in a serious way.
00:40:08 That's got to be something that happens in the next mandate if the people who are most
00:40:12 pessimistic about climate change are wrong. And if people believe they're right, regardless of
00:40:17 whether you do or not, in the end, that means that there is an opportunity to make money
00:40:21 and an opportunity to address people's fears in something that's going to make the world better
00:40:25 by actually reducing the emissions and hopefully reducing the horrible summer that we had with
00:40:30 the floods and the fires raging across the country. Let's make some money off this,
00:40:35 make the world a better place. But to have a party that's fighting against the idea that we
00:40:39 should transition to a new post-petrol economy, it's like campaigning 100 years ago against
00:40:43 transitioning to the petrol economy. I mean, it doesn't make any sense. If you were generally
00:40:49 someone looking to advance your country 100 plus years ago, and you're saying, you know what, guys,
00:40:52 I think the Amish have got the right idea. Let's stick with the horse and buggy. Let's avoid those 1.00
00:40:56 fancy newfangled cars humans are supposed to progress and innovate let's put money into 0.96
00:41:00 research and development to deal with the climate issue bring scientists to canada that sort of
00:41:04 industry always has a knockoff and helps us in all kinds of other sectors that's just one example
00:41:08 then we could talk about defense and international yeah well just on the climate though for a moment
00:41:13 if your belief is that this is the the hole in canadian politics right now one issue one issue
00:41:20 yeah but but this party and this movement and this radically centrist approach how do you explain the
00:41:24 2021 election when Aaron O'Toole did exactly what you're describing on climate. He came out with a
00:41:30 conservative answer. He said, climate change is real. It's a problem. And here's what we're going
00:41:35 to do. There was going to be a cost associated with that. He really kept a lot of the conservative
00:41:41 policies that the conservative flank of the party were trying to push forward at bay. And he
00:41:47 completely fell short in winning the election. So how do you explain the 2021 election when the
00:41:54 Conservatives really did exactly what you're saying they needed to do? Because no one trusted
00:41:59 Aaron O'Toole because he campaigned one way when he was campaigning to be leader in opposition
00:42:03 and then tried another way when he was campaigning to be prime minister. And I think Canadians are
00:42:08 smart and they could tell that he wasn't being consistent in his messaging. So there's a real
00:42:13 fear that when the Conservatives are saying one thing that sounds a little bit more moderate,
00:42:16 that they're actually talking about something much more extreme. And when you have the Conservative
00:42:21 Party candidate outlooting the Bernier candidate in the Winnipeg by-election, Manitoba by-election
00:42:27 recently. By opposing vaccine mandates? No, by in that case saying that Max Bernier was a tool
00:42:32 of the globalists who went to WEF meetings and Pierre Polyarif would never allow that to happen.
00:42:37 I'm sorry to keep on going on about the WEF. But since you do, let's drill into this because
00:42:43 Justin Trudeau this morning is at the UN talking about the virtues of a carbon tax. I've covered
00:42:50 the world economic forum i've been there reporting on it uh you'll oftentimes hear people talk about
00:42:54 all the great things they need to do on pardon me did you get the microchip implanted you all set
00:42:59 no no i didn't i needed to stay a day late for that but but they talk about all of these very
00:43:04 aggressive and i would say very radical environmental proposals so is your position
00:43:08 that you cannot criticize that without being loony you can absolutely criticize it and let me let me
00:43:13 start right now the wf is an expensive talking shop of rich people trying to make themselves
00:43:18 feel relevant in a way that is, in terms of the way it actually impacts power politics around the
00:43:22 world, nearly completely meaningless. Anyone really think that anyone's going to listen to what
00:43:27 Iran has to say about women's rights or that Somalia has to say about climate change? It's 0.95
00:43:33 a talking shop that allows occasional serious work to happen. I'm talking about the UN in this case,
00:43:37 but most of the time it's a vast waste of time and money and is controlled by dictators.
00:43:41 And the WF-
00:43:42 How is that different from what Polly Eva said about the WEF?
00:43:44 How is that different from what Pierre Paulieva said about the WUF?
00:43:48 Because Pierre Paulieva goes on about globalists, which is code for anti-Semitism.
00:43:53 Pierre Paulieva said that he will not allow his ministers, you talk about freeing people to do what they want.
00:43:57 Hold up, hold up. Are you accusing Pierre Paulieva of being anti-Semitic?
00:44:01 Let me finish. If I can finish my answer, I'll come back to that quite often.
00:44:04 Okay.
00:44:04 That the WUF, he's not going to allow any of his ministers or government officials to attend any of the meetings of the WUF.
00:44:10 That's his great stand against the globalist threat that's threatening all of Canada.
00:44:13 it. This is rubbish. Canada is not broken, and we are not under the sway of some shadowy foreign 0.99
00:44:20 tentacled octopus that's trying to dominate our lives. Anything wrong in Canada, we can fix.
00:44:25 We've fixed things before. We've built this country out of the ice and the snow. We can
00:44:29 do it again to face these new challenges in the 21st century. What we don't need is people
00:44:34 dog-whistling anti-Semitic tropes. And anyone who doesn't think the attacks on George Soros and the
00:44:39 WUF, don't have an anti-Semitic tangent to them, needs to go and read a little bit more
00:44:43 about anti-Semitism.
00:44:44 So do you, do you believe, okay, let me be perfectly frank.
00:44:46 Do you believe Pierre Polyev is anti-Semitic?
00:44:48 I have no idea.
00:44:49 I know that his party is peddling tropes that have their roots in anti-Semitism.
00:44:53 His party, which has been one of the most stalwart defenders of Israel for the entirety
00:44:58 of its existence, you think is going down the road of anti-Semitism.
00:45:01 I would ask you how you, the folks in the Republican Party who were similarly stalwart
00:45:06 supporters of Israel for most of Israel's history, and have now become infected with 0.66
00:45:10 populists who are largely influenced by ideas coming in from other countries, namely Russia,
00:45:16 who are spreading a radical anti-Western agenda in the guise of traditional Western values.
00:45:21 And unfortunately, we're seeing that picked up by elements of the Conservative Party. And it's why
00:45:24 a lot of people don't feel comfortable with the Conservative Party. And one of the reasons Andrew
00:45:28 Scheer didn't win in 2021, despite people being increasingly fed up with Justin Trudeau.
00:45:33 I think I will get a lot of angry emails from Jewish supporters of the Conservative Party that 1.00
00:45:39 don't see what you're describing there. I can, again, go and look at the tropes,
00:45:44 the stuff that's being shared around the WF, globalism and George Soros. Go and do a tiny
00:45:49 bit of reading produced by B'nai B'rith and the other Jewish advocacy organizations talking about
00:45:54 how this is part of the global rise in anti-Semitism. And then those folks are
00:45:58 welcome to contact me and I'll happily debate them on the subject. Just getting to the forward
00:46:02 looking part of your party here as we're already over time, are you planning to field a full slate
00:46:07 of candidates in the next election? We'll see. I mean, that's my job the next year is to build up
00:46:12 the party as the interim leader. I had some background doing that and work overseas. I've
00:46:16 worked with dozens of different parties in different countries. If I can get the party up
00:46:20 and running and we're able to be prepared with a full slate, that's awesome. Our goal is on
00:46:24 quality more than anything else. We want to try and restore the idea that becoming a member of
00:46:28 Parliament's a serious business. Make sure that we offer candidates a lot of training on how the
00:46:32 parliamentary system works, the people who are going to try and rip them off, scam them and the
00:46:36 public. There's a lot of things that can be done to make sure we have a better legislature rather
00:46:40 than pretending our institutions are broken. Dominic Cardi, Interim Leader of Canadian Future.
00:46:45 Thank you for coming on. Thanks. All right. Thank you very much for that. What a way to end the week
00:46:51 there. But my thanks to Dominic and to Trish for coming on and for all of you tuning into the show.
00:46:56 We will be back on Monday with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North.
00:47:02 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:47:05 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:47:07 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:47:26 We'll be right back.
00:47:56 We'll be right back.