Juno News - February 22, 2023


Trudeau won't take China's election interference seriously

Topics
Mentioned
Singer praised for politicizing national anthem Did Trudeau win the public inquiry? (ft. Christine Van Geyn)

Episode Stats


Length

38 minutes

Words per minute

176.65

Word count

6,881

Sentence count

269

Harmful content

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

20

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Andrew Lawton talks about China's election interference in the Canadian election, and why the media hasn't picked up on it. He also talks about a story about a man who was charged with second-degree murder in a break-in that took place in his own home.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's most irreverent talk show. This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:12 Hello and welcome to you all. Canada's most irreverent talk show, the Andrew Lawton Show, here on True North.
00:00:20 on this Wednesday, February 22nd, 2023,
00:00:25 coming to the end of the shortest month of the year,
00:00:28 which is a little bit of month-by-month trivia.
00:00:30 Some months have 30 days, others have 31,
00:00:33 and February only has, I believe, four,
00:00:35 or so it's felt like in this little February here.
00:00:39 But we nevertheless proceed,
00:00:41 and it's been a surprisingly busy news week
00:00:44 for a short week that was a holiday in much of the country.
00:00:48 And we'll talk about China.
00:00:50 We'll also talk about the story that I have seen virtually no media coverage of, besides one write-up initially in the Toronto Star, which, again, there's nothing wrong with it.
00:01:00 They did, in fact, cover it.
00:01:02 But I would say that the media has not picked this up.
00:01:05 And even people you'd expect to focus on this haven't really been.
00:01:08 And that is the story of a man who was charged, he's been criminally charged, with second-degree murder after shooting a home invader.
00:01:18 that broke into the house that he and his mother were sleeping in overnight with a firearm.
00:01:23 He shot the intruder dead, and now he's the one who's been charged with second-degree murder.
00:01:28 So we are going to talk about that and a lot of other things on this program.
00:01:34 But let's start off with China, which has been the gift that keeps on giving as far as news coverage.
00:01:39 The Globe and Mail has done a bang-up job on this.
00:01:42 They had this bombshell on their front page, an A1 story on Friday, talking about the lengths through which the Chinese regime, the Chinese Communist Party, went to interfere in Canada's elections, specifically the 2021 election.
00:01:58 In this story, they cite a CSIS document that was given to them privately, that was leaked to them, that deployed a sophisticated strategy by China to disrupt Canada's democracy in the 2021 election campaign.
00:02:13 And China was backing Justin Trudeau.
00:02:16 I think that's something you very much need to understand.
00:02:18 That's a key part of the story, that China wanted Justin Trudeau to win.
00:02:23 Now, is this because Justin Trudeau is a Chinese puppet?
00:02:26 it? I don't think so. I think it's that Justin Trudeau is a puppet of a leader in general, 0.58
00:02:31 and China looks at him and says, that's the kind of guy we want going up against us. And the
00:02:36 contrast was Aaron O'Toole, who, whatever you think of Aaron O'Toole, and there are a great
00:02:40 many criticisms I've leveled about his policies and his leadership. One issue on which he was
00:02:46 unflinching was China. Aaron O'Toole understood China. He understood the dynamics. He understood
00:02:52 foreign policy. And China was clearly intimidated by that and didn't want Aaron O'Toole to win.
00:02:58 So they worked against conservative MPs in general. They specifically worked against some
00:03:03 MPs that were like Kenny Chu, formerly an MP in British Columbia, that were especially critical
00:03:10 of the Chinese regime. And all of this was to the benefit of Justin Trudeau. So this is part
00:03:17 of an intelligence operation that China ran that has been known to Canadian intelligence. Canadian
00:03:24 officials knew about it. The Canadian Security Intelligence Service knew about it. And what
00:03:31 happened there was they informed the Liberal government, who even with this information
00:03:36 has been publicly downplaying the idea that there is an interference issue. They've been publicly
00:03:42 downplaying the idea that this was at all something we need to worry about. They mocked critics who
00:03:48 tried to bring this up and as though they were trying to generate or concoct some sort of
00:03:53 boogeyman. And it was particularly offensive to anyone who looked at just the facts. You didn't
00:03:59 need to be an intelligence official to see this was going on. When the liberals had the audacity
00:04:05 to just downplay that this was a thing at all, to say, oh, well, and even when they eventually came
00:04:10 around to it their line seemed to be well you know there might have been an issue they might
00:04:17 have been trying to influence but they really didn't do a good job at it it didn't work and
00:04:21 all of this is to say that they refuse to accept there is an issue they refuse to acknowledge the
00:04:27 extent of the issue and i think the elephant in the room here is that it was the liberal government
00:04:32 that was benefiting from it so there really isn't an incentive for the liberals to get to the bottom
00:04:39 of an election that may have been an illegal that was an illegally interfered with election when
00:04:45 they were the ones who were beneficiaries now i should say i do not have any evidence to suggest
00:04:50 that if china's interference had not been there the election result would have been different i
00:04:56 am not making that claim the globe and mail's reporting is not making that claim but we'd be
00:05:02 remiss to not point out that it is a minority parliament and justin trudeau didn't win the
00:05:07 popular vote despite winning the most seats. Small changes in one or two ridings could have made a
00:05:13 difference in the overall landscape politically. Really small changes in a number of ridings in
00:05:20 tight races could have made a significant difference. But we know there were a handful
00:05:25 of races in particular that the Chinese regime was targeting, ones that they thought needed to
00:05:30 be the choke points or were the weak links. So if you look at the facts here, CSIS reports on this
00:05:38 were shared with Canada's intelligence partners in the so-called Five Eyes community. So these
00:05:43 are the governments of the United States, Britain, Australia, and New Zealand and Canada. Now of
00:05:49 those five, New Zealand is absolutely a Chinese puppet. New Zealand has been a pathetic and 1.00
00:05:56 shameful shill for the Chinese regime when it comes to foreign policy. But Australia, the US 0.99
00:06:03 and the UK have actually been quite strong on this. So it's no surprise that those three
00:06:08 created a separate alliance that has been somewhat facetiously called the Three Eyes Alliance. It's
00:06:15 formerly AUKUS that cut out Canada and cut out New Zealand. So I think it's very telling that 0.86
00:06:22 these nations that have significant intelligence operations don't trust Canada. So what they saw
00:06:29 is an intelligence report from Canada that suggests the election was being interfered with.
00:06:34 And then they also saw public comments from Justin Trudeau saying, oh, there's no election
00:06:38 interference. What are you talking about? There's no big deal. Democracy is protected in Canada.
00:06:43 And that's actually not the case. So let's talk about today how Justin Trudeau made this problem
00:06:50 so much worse because he gets up, well, it starts off with Jennifer O'Connell, who's a liberal
00:06:56 member of parliament who decides to take the approach that the left loves, which is accusing
00:07:02 anyone they don't like of being Trump-like. This was her comment in the House of Commons the other
00:07:07 day. The information that has been reported in the media is extremely serious, but it's something
00:07:17 that has never been denied by the fact that these reports have been tabled in the house of commons
00:07:25 this is sadly not new information the only thing that's new is the conservatives i guess
00:07:34 are not happy with the other business that proc is doing and they simply want to only talk about this
00:07:41 because they have one candidate in particular that they feel this has been affected by but
00:07:48 foreign interference isn't about one candidate or 11 candidates about it's about canadian
00:07:55 institutions and this is the same trump type tactics to question election results moving forward
00:08:04 when i mentioned earlier that justin trudeau was not a chinese puppet but he was someone that
00:08:15 uh the chinese government clearly thought uh would be preferable to the alternatives i i should tell 0.98
00:08:21 you about this term that came up in the soviet era called a useful idiot now a useful idiot and 0.89
00:08:30 I'm reading the Wikipedia definition here. A term currently used to reference a person 0.60
00:08:35 perceived as propagandizing for a cause without fully comprehending the cause's goal and who is
00:08:41 cynically being used as the cause's leader. Talking about neo-communists that were particularly
00:08:47 susceptible to communist propaganda and manipulation in the Cold War. That was the
00:08:51 origin of the term. But when I hear Jennifer O'Connell speak about that and say that it is
00:08:57 trump style to talk about electoral interference and the conservatives shouldn't be raising this i 0.98
00:09:02 i think useful idiot i mean i think idiot first off uh useful might be a bit of a stretch but i 0.99
00:09:08 think of the term useful idiot and i i don't like being unkind to people and i really don't like 0.98
00:09:14 making comments like that on a show that i feel strives for some level of intellectual heft not 0.96
00:09:21 always do we reach it but we strive for it but how else are you to parse someone that has just
00:09:27 such a blind spot for such a big problem and says well the conservatives only want to talk about it
00:09:33 because they're mad about it but it's not about them it's about democracy uh but if the conservatives
00:09:37 bring it up and no you're undermining democracy then we have justin trudeau taking that point
00:09:43 that perspective that jennifer o'connell puts forward and just running it across into the end
00:09:47 zone today take a look foreign governments and foreign actors are trying to undermine people's
00:10:00 confidence in democracy itself and amplifying and giving reason giving partisan reasons
00:10:11 uh to mistrust the outcome of an election mistrust the experts at elections canada and in our security
00:10:20 services and our top public servants who are saying that the election integrity held
00:10:26 that's something that we've seen from elsewhere is not a good path to go down for society or for
00:10:34 democracy. Okay, so just to make sure I understand this, democracy is important. Okay, we can all
00:10:44 agree on that. Undermining democracy is ergo a bad thing. Okay, we can all agree on that.
00:10:50 When China undermines democracy, we're to believe that's a bad thing. But if the conservatives talk
00:10:57 about China undermining democracy, then they're the ones undermining democracy because people's
00:11:03 faith in democracy is shaken. Okay. So Justin Trudeau is more concerned about conservatives
00:11:12 talking about this than he is concerned about the thing that conservatives want to talk about,
00:11:19 which again, I remind you was to Justin Trudeau's benefit. So they're not even trying anymore.
00:11:27 They're not even trying to conceal that they just don't seem to care.
00:11:32 When they're talking about something very specific and very concrete, where there's
00:11:37 a very tangible effect, we have facts, we have reports from intelligence agencies.
00:11:43 They're talking about it in the abstract.
00:11:45 They're talking about it in generalities, in this esoteric way, as if to say, oh, yes,
00:11:50 you know, in general interview.
00:11:51 Well, no, let's talk about the specifics.
00:11:53 Let's talk about the specifics of China trying to manipulate a certain outcome in Canada's
00:12:00 elections.
00:12:00 And China tries to do this all over the world.
00:12:02 Canada is not special, but all we're concerned about here is Canada's elections, the integrity
00:12:07 of Canada's democracy.
00:12:10 And by the way, the liberals who are getting all pearl clutchy right now at complaints
00:12:15 of Chinese interference would have been the first ones to jump up and down and say, oh,
00:12:19 Trump was influenced by Russia.
00:12:21 Oh, the freedom convoy in Canada was a Russian psy-op.
00:12:25 I mean, these are the people that would absolutely call their political opponents foreign influences without hesitation.
00:12:34 But when it comes to concrete, tangible evidence of interference in Canada's elections by the Chinese regime,
00:12:41 they do not want to talk about it.
00:12:43 And then they start delegitimizing and denigrating those who dare talk about it.
00:12:48 And I mentioned Aaron O'Toole a few moments ago, and I have a number of criticisms with how Aaron O'Toole handled his time as conservative leader, but he was a very strong voice on China. He kept that up through to the election, and it was clear that China didn't want that around.
00:13:03 So the reason these discussions are important to have is because we are going to have another
00:13:08 election at some point, whether it's this year or next year, or I suspect given the fecklessness
00:13:13 of the NDP in like 2037, when they finally decide to just move on from this. But the NDP that is,
00:13:22 but what's happening is the NDP also don't particularly care about this, it seems,
00:13:29 because I think some of them probably have the posters of Mao up in their offices,
00:13:33 probably a couple of them.
00:13:35 But if we look at this, it's only the conservatives that are really talking about China.
00:13:41 And even then, I would say they could probably talk about it a lot more.
00:13:44 It's a very important issue.
00:13:46 It is a country that is going to be striving for and is striving for global domination.
00:13:52 And it's unfortunate that so few people realize what's happening, 0.88
00:13:56 Whether it's the Belt and Road Initiative in which China is economically colonizing the less developed world with this trillion dollar plan where they have new ports and airports popping up in places like Barbados and Eastern Europe that are all Chinese owned.
00:14:12 And then also other dimensions of this that are, I think, incredibly significant for people to be talking about. 0.98
00:14:18 I mean, the way that China is the link between the very worst countries of the world and their 0.92
00:14:27 aspirations, China and Iran, China and North Korea, China and Russia. So China is not just this
00:14:35 emerging member of the liberal order, like Chairman Xi Jinping tries to claim whenever he's
00:14:41 speaking at the World Economic Forum or whatever. China, I mean, to say nothing of the demand for
00:14:46 justice that we need to be seeing from Western leaders about what China has done to the world 0.68
00:14:51 in the last three years. We should also be very concerned about what China is continuing to do to 0.88
00:14:56 the world. And we're all looking up at the spy balloon flying over and it takes a week for the 0.99
00:15:01 United States to shoot the thing out of the air. Meanwhile, let's look at the ballot boxes where
00:15:06 no world leader wants to shoot China's influence out of the ballot boxes metaphorically. So all
00:15:12 of this is to say that right now we are in the midst of this tremendous global geopolitical
00:15:19 gaslighting, where China is incredibly transparent about what it wants. China is very open about what
00:15:27 it wants. China does not hide the fact that it strives for this level of economic and political
00:15:33 control over parts of the world. And they often are able to do this with relative impunity.
00:15:40 and you know it used to be that interfering in a country's elections would be a very significant
00:15:46 thing it is a very significant thing but it used to be that it would be treated as such
00:15:50 and I don't want to say the media has not focused on that I mean that clip I played a moment ago
00:15:55 from Justin Trudeau he was being asked about this by a reporter clearly it is something that is
00:16:01 being handled in some sense but it's not permeating through the political discourse in the way that it
00:16:09 should i mean here was a michael cooper who's going to be on the show in a moment um a conservative
00:16:14 member of parliament accusing trudeau of avoiding answering questions and i think he's bang on if
00:16:19 you listen to what he's saying the prime minister again using carefully crafted words talks about
00:16:28 how the last two elections were not compromised as if to say that anyone is alleging that those
00:16:35 elections were compromised. That's a very different question than what appears to have
00:16:43 happened, which was interference targeting certain ridings and certain candidates.
00:16:51 The fact that the overall result of an election was not compromised does not negate the fact
00:16:56 that there are serious issues of interference that may have had an impact on the outcome
00:17:03 of the election in certain ridings.
00:17:12 I think that's the point here.
00:17:14 We're not actually making a claim
00:17:16 that Justin Trudeau would have been out
00:17:18 and Aaron O'Toole would have been in.
00:17:19 And there were a number of other things in that election
00:17:21 that were driving voters than Chinese influence.
00:17:24 So again, I don't want you to misunderstand my point here,
00:17:27 but I think it is also very important
00:17:29 that the idea of influence
00:17:31 and the concrete examples that it's happening are part of the problem.
00:17:36 They are the problem, regardless of how successful it was.
00:17:39 So Justin Trudeau's approach has historically been,
00:17:41 well, you know, it didn't work, so it's not a big deal.
00:17:44 We can just move on from it.
00:17:46 Stephanie Levitz at the Toronto Star had a great piece this week,
00:17:51 or today actually, I think it came out, or maybe last night,
00:17:53 about how Conservatives debated going public with the election misinformation
00:17:58 and election influence warnings in 2021, specifically information that was spreading
00:18:05 within the Chinese diaspora in Canada, targeting conservative candidates that had been critical
00:18:11 of China. And they instead sent it to the intelligence officials. So they didn't decide
00:18:19 for whatever reason to make a public stink about this. Maybe that wasn't their strategy. That
00:18:23 wasn't the direction that we thought we were going to head as a party was effectively what
00:18:28 they were saying. But it sounds like, just reading through what Stephanie Levitz wrote here,
00:18:34 that the conservatives were seeing this happening in real time. And they had the choice of how they
00:18:41 should do it. And their internal deliberations were basically that they didn't want to raise
00:18:48 this issue and then have it blow back on them to look like, I don't know, they were race bathing 0.73
00:18:53 or something to look like they were being sore losers, whatever the case is. And if you read 0.92
00:18:58 through some of it, so that she has Stephanie Levitt's internal conservative memos, which had
00:19:03 examples of some of the Chinese language materials that were spreading in the election, misinformation
00:19:09 about Motul, misinformation about the conservatives. Some of these apps, there's an app called WeChat,
00:19:15 which believe it or not, when I ran for office in 2018, I used WeChat because we had a large number
00:19:21 of volunteers on my campaign who were of Chinese origin that were very critical of the regime.
00:19:27 They loved democracy. They loved Canada. They wanted to contribute. And WeChat is the app that
00:19:32 the Chinese community uses in Canada and in China. Now, of course, I deleted WeChat the second the
00:19:37 election was over because I did a little bit more reading into it and found that China was probably
00:19:41 looking at all of my messages. So they may have an Andrew Lawton brochure or two that they've
00:19:45 intercepted in which I say have at it. But on WeChat in these groups, it's like Telegram,
00:19:51 basically, they were seeing all of this information spread in the Chinese language and presumably
00:19:58 Mandarin, maybe Cantonese about the conservatives. And it just wasn't true. It just wasn't true what
00:20:05 was being said here. And O'Toole said he would ban WeChat. So, you know, clearly, if you're
00:20:11 communicating on WeChat, you might not like the conservative leader that's saying he's going to
00:20:15 ban that app. And what was also happening is that he had a hawkish stance in general on the Chinese
00:20:22 regime. And I think that what was interesting is that they all tried to draw a comparison
00:20:29 in these groups, the people that were critical of O'Toole, between O'Toole and Trump,
00:20:34 which I find to be hilarious because there are probably a lot of Trump fans that are saying,
00:20:38 I wish O'Toole were more like Trump. So some of this stuff is political discourse. It's not
00:20:43 misinformation, but other parts of this were. And certainly the campaign that was going after
00:20:50 Kenny Chu, I think was a very significant one that people needed to pay attention to. So
00:20:56 all of this is to say that this is an issue in Canada that you'd be foolish to not take 0.98
00:21:03 very seriously. And by that, I do not just mean China's influence in the 2021 election,
00:21:10 but China's influence in the 2025 election, China's influence in Canadian institutions
00:21:15 between elections, China's influence more broadly in Canada and on the world stage.
00:21:22 And it's offensive to me and should be offensive to anyone else who loves liberty and loves Canada,
00:21:28 that this is an issue that seems to attract so little interest from people that should be very
00:21:35 passionate and dedicated about it so what i'm gonna do and we're gonna have to move on from
00:21:41 this i i'm fortunately i'm being told we've been having some technical issues getting uh michael
00:21:46 cooper the member of parliament connected which is incredibly disappointing because i love michael
00:21:50 cooper and the last time i saw him uh was actually in albania where uh one always runs into conservative
00:21:57 members of parliament but he was there with a delegation for a conference uh that i was
00:22:01 covering. And I was hoping to reconnect with him, not in Albania, but this is not necessarily
00:22:06 happening right now. We're going to try to get him on in just a moment for a few minutes before
00:22:11 we go on to our next guest who is standing by. But one thing I will just say in closing on the
00:22:17 China issue is that we are going through a tremendous turn of, I think, public attention 0.94
00:22:26 right now you see the whiplash and I was actually glad to see the balloon issue in this country and 0.96
00:22:33 in the world pop up because no pun intended popping never mind uh but the reason is because
00:22:39 it showed just how fickle people is like at a certain point so if I mentioned balloon now
00:22:46 you're probably like oh yeah there was the balloon yeah the balloon thing but but you know again for
00:22:51 week everyone's looking at it and nowhere else and then you know you pass a week and people are
00:22:57 talking about something else and then next week they'll be talking about something else remember
00:23:00 coney 2012 remember when that was the big moral panic 11 years ago so we all look at the balloon
00:23:06 and then we move on and no one actually cares about why the balloon was there what china was 0.83
00:23:10 doing uh what china continues to do and this is why this stuff cannot be a flash in the pan but
00:23:16 you need leaders and media figures who are going to keep up the pressure on this so i don't expect 0.94
00:23:21 all of us to be the ones who solve this problem, but we can certainly point it to the people who
00:23:25 are supposed to. My sincere apologies to Michael Cooper for the issues here, but we're going to
00:23:31 try to get him on any moment now, or not today, but in general, when we can get our system
00:23:37 functioning. Maybe China is on the system. Maybe China is taking over the Andrew Lawton show. So 0.75
00:23:42 we're not getting any sponsorship money from them, I assure you. Let's talk about this story
00:23:47 out of Milton, Ontario, which is very troubling. And I always have to put an asterisk here because
00:23:55 sometimes you learn more facts about these cases later on that change your perception.
00:24:02 So I'm going on an issue here that is very much focused on a limited set of information. But
00:24:10 I think there's a fair bit of detail here to draw a conclusion about something that's happened that
00:24:16 I find to be very concerning. To go back to this night of February 19th, specifically 5 a.m.
00:24:24 February 19th, a group of suspects, the Halton police say, approached a house in Milton, Ontario
00:24:30 with the intent of committing a robbery. They entered the residence. At least one of them
00:24:35 had a firearm with them. And when they entered, they were confronted by a resident of the house
00:24:42 who had a firearm. Now, this person's lawyer says it was a registered gun, which he used to
00:24:49 shoot the intruder. It was him and his mother that were home. The people that broke in,
00:24:55 allegedly, at least one of them is facing charges of break and enter, as well as
00:25:00 unauthorized possession of a firearm. But the man who lived in that house, who took a gun out
00:25:07 to shoot the intruders has been charged with second degree murder. This is not an outlier.
00:25:15 There have been a number of cases in Canada where people have used firearms in self-defense,
00:25:20 which is legal, yet have still faced charges, even if they end up getting exonerated from the
00:25:25 charges that takes years. They lose their firearms. They use their firearms license.
00:25:31 They have to spend a huge amount of money in legal fees, and they do this while they are, in some cases, being treated more seriously than the criminals that they were responding to were.
00:25:44 So we'll talk about the specifics of the case, but I also want to talk in general terms about self-defense here.
00:25:49 Lawyer Sam Goldstein is with me now.
00:25:52 Sam, good to talk to you.
00:25:53 Thanks for coming on today.
00:25:54 Oh, you're welcome.
00:25:55 It's good to talk to you and see you again, Andrew.
00:25:57 I'm sorry.
00:25:58 I am not hearing you, Sam.
00:26:00 I'm just, that was on my end.
00:26:02 You're in the clear here.
00:26:03 I was paranoid we were having another Michael Cooper issue, 0.96
00:26:06 and then I would have blamed the Chinese government. 1.00
00:26:08 But thank you for joining.
00:26:10 Let's first just explain to me in the clearest possible terms,
00:26:15 what is the law in Canada about using a firearm in self-defense?
00:26:20 Yeah, well, simply put, I mean, you are able to use a reasonable amount of force
00:26:27 to protect a loved one, your property, yourself,
00:26:32 up to the point of lethal force.
00:26:35 That's as simple as I could put it.
00:26:37 It's all about the real black boxes in all the circumstances
00:26:42 and what's reasonable.
00:26:43 That's the real issue here.
00:26:45 And from what you told me, I was reading the story earlier,
00:26:48 and I didn't see the fact that one of the intruders,
00:26:51 or maybe even more than one intruder, had a firearm themselves.
00:26:54 I just saw that they had broken into the house.
00:26:57 Well, I should say they've been charged with unauthorized possession of a firearm.
00:27:00 So that's what I was drawing that from.
00:27:02 Right. So if they had a firearm, it seems to me it raises, you know, the circumstances a little bit more in favor of the of the person who's being charged.
00:27:12 Now, if someone's entering your home with a firearm, I guess it's some extent it depends upon what they were doing with that firearm.
00:27:19 Right. But if they were certainly pointing at the individual and threatening the individual,
00:27:24 even let's go further that they fired at the individual it would seem that you have the right
00:27:29 you know reasonable amount of force to protect yourself from firing back yeah and and i know
00:27:35 that there i mean the famous case that a lot of people uh certainly for me started paying attention
00:27:40 to this issue through the lens of was that one a few years ago in port colburn where a guy fired
00:27:45 warning shots because someone had basically firebombed his house and you know they burned
00:27:50 his dog's house down. I think he even singed his dog. He wasn't even shooting to injure anyone.
00:27:56 And this man is dragged through the ringer for years and years. There was a gentleman I interviewed
00:28:01 when I did a documentary about firearms in Okotok. Same idea. Someone's rummaging around his truck in
00:28:06 the middle of the night. He takes his firearms out. He shoots around at the ground. It ricochets and
00:28:11 hits one of the assailants. And then he's charged. And even though he's eventually exonerated,
00:28:16 it's the process is the punishment here so what i find to be troubling is how we have something that
00:28:22 is uh carved out in law that you're allowed to do that doesn't seem to stop these people from having
00:28:29 to really defend themselves against a charge well i mean let's just take i appreciate your point but
00:28:36 i mean let's just go back for a moment and look at a public policy perspective right you don't want
00:28:42 to allow any person to just simply say oh well they were coming into my house so i shot them
00:28:47 right i think you want the process to take place and i understand the punishment is the process
00:28:52 believe me i'm a criminal lawyer i understand that for my clients but i think they're i mean
00:28:57 i don't blame the the police in this instance or for any instance when there's a firearm being
00:29:03 discharged right to say well okay i know that's what you have to say and i know that i know it's
00:29:08 kind of funny here because the guy's in your home with the firearm you know and it's smoking and it
00:29:12 seems like he's discharged it against you but i think you know it makes some sense for the police
00:29:16 to initially say look we're going to charge you and we're going to let the process determine
00:29:21 what's the reasonable circumstances right now listen you know in this case andrew let's just
00:29:26 step back again for just a moment and look if this person was a lawful firearm owner
00:29:31 um then it would have been uh it would have been um you know there would have been locked
00:29:36 away somewhere right and his ammunition would have been locked away somewhere so it's a little
00:29:41 bit suspicious to me and i know nothing about the case other than what we've talked about is
00:29:45 if someone's coming into your home what i mean did he really have enough time to go and unlock
00:29:51 the ammunition and then unlock the firearm and load it right take maybe the safety lock off of
00:29:58 the fire uh yeah for for a handgun i mean just so people understand the storage laws for a handgun
00:30:03 it has to be double locked, basically.
00:30:05 So it has to be in a locked room or a locked case.
00:30:08 And then the firearm itself has to be locked.
00:30:10 And there are people that practice this, that could do that very, very quickly.
00:30:14 But there have been cases, I'm aware of, where someone has done it
00:30:17 and then police have said, well, there's no way you could have gotten it in time.
00:30:20 So we're going to charge you with unsafe storage and stuff like that.
00:30:23 So I agree.
00:30:24 But I guess my, and I take you at your point.
00:30:27 I mean, if police walk into a house and you're holding a gun,
00:30:30 there's a guy dead in front, you know,
00:30:31 it would be very convenient if just saying, well, it was self-defense was just an automatic
00:30:35 exoneration where there's no further action. But I don't know, is there a way that we could
00:30:43 better enshrine this and better educate police about it? Because I think a lot of the times
00:30:48 when you look at what charges are, I wonder if police necessarily know how you do have these
00:30:55 rights to defend yourself in all these contexts. I think often in these self-defense type of
00:31:00 provisions of the criminal code it's very hard to start trying to narrow like to further narrowly
00:31:07 define them i think the fact that they're broad and they allow the discretion and really hand over
00:31:12 that you know the reasonable circumstances that black box to figure out what's inside or what's
00:31:16 reasonable in the circumstances over to the court system rather than the police i mean i i tend not
00:31:22 to trust the police so i don't know if really defining it further is really going to help you
00:31:26 help you because they may use it against you at the same time but you know let's go to another
00:31:30 point if you don't mind andrew listen to me to take your conversation forward a little bit and
00:31:35 i think you have a really good point about the fact that when people get charged with this and
00:31:39 the guy on colbert he then has to reapply for his you know to get his what weapons back right
00:31:45 and i see that in many cases where you know economist domestic assault where someone in the
00:31:50 the end is acquitted um and they have to go through all these hoops to jump through to get
00:31:56 their firearms back the real issue i mean not the real issue but the problem is that the police
00:32:00 once they try and get your firearm and once they get their hands on them they don't want to give
00:32:04 them back and i think that's another issue that you're pointing out and it's a really important
00:32:09 one right that often what happens is you have to go through all types of applications to court and
00:32:14 so on to try and get your arm your firearms back when in the end you did nothing wrong
00:32:19 So, I mean, what is the process supposed to be?
00:32:23 Because what I would assume is that if your firearms are taken away from you in connection with charges,
00:32:28 that the second you are no longer facing those charges,
00:32:31 your firearms should just be automatically returned to your doorstep with a bow on them
00:32:35 and perhaps not an apology card, but they should be back in your possession.
00:32:39 Is that how it's supposed to be and it's just not functioning that way?
00:32:43 Or is there actually in the regulations a more convoluted process for people to reclaim that property?
00:32:50 Well, another very good question, Andrew.
00:32:52 I can see why you're an award-winning journalist.
00:32:55 Well, thank you.
00:32:56 I'm very popular.
00:32:57 I'm just having trouble getting the word out, but carry on.
00:32:59 Well, I mean, I'm right now in a situation where my client had a firearm.
00:33:04 He was charged with domestic assault.
00:33:06 They took away his firearms.
00:33:07 He's been acquitted.
00:33:08 and despite the fact he's acquitted and this sort of 30-day appeal period is over where the police
00:33:14 or the crown has a right to keep the you know the the um at least the the evidence well this
00:33:19 wasn't evidence i'm having a very hard time getting the firearms back police officers want
00:33:24 to return my calls you know so you know i've got to go to court make some sort of application
00:33:29 to get the stuff back and you can make phone calls up the chief of police people ignore you
00:33:34 So there isn't really a process, right?
00:33:37 And to some extent, they could probably charge a police officer with theft himself
00:33:40 because he's trying to convert it or trying to detain the release of it.
00:33:45 But, you know, those types of things aren't really going to go anywhere.
00:33:48 But it's a problem.
00:33:49 There's nowhere in the – there are sections of the criminal code
00:33:53 which will allow you to go and get exhibits back or evidence back.
00:33:58 But it's mostly sort of in documentary type of issues, not so much in real evidence.
00:34:03 but it's a situation where there is a bit of a gray area and where there's a gray area the police
00:34:07 aren't going to help you out they're not you're not they're not your friends and you can see
00:34:11 the poster behind me right you see the police officer with the uh half the smiley face and the
00:34:17 wings you know and he comes across as being an angel but the reality is is if you look closer
00:34:23 he's got the the gun the handcuffs and so on the police are not your friend i i i have to just i
00:34:31 I have to push back against, I think, that generalization.
00:34:34 I think that in general, law enforcement has a lot of problems.
00:34:38 I don't like painting all police officers with that brush
00:34:40 and even all police services with that brush.
00:34:42 I think some are better than others,
00:34:44 although this veers into a more philosophical discussion
00:34:47 that we should have at another point because I think it's an important one.
00:34:50 But let me just ask in general here about where the change would be made.
00:34:56 I mean, is this something that the federal government
00:34:58 could just pass a single line bill that says when you're acquitted of a charge or charges
00:35:04 are withdrawn, any property seized in connection with that is returned to you? Would that be
00:35:08 enough? Yeah, I mean, certainly you could put in the criminal code, but I think it's actually more
00:35:15 provincial issue because the local police are more falling underneath the province than the
00:35:21 federal government. But look, I haven't given a tremendous amount of thought. All I have is in
00:35:27 many in the 24, 25 years I've practiced as a lawyer,
00:35:31 I'm constantly coming against the problem
00:35:34 with how to get my client's firearms back
00:35:36 after they've been acquitted of their charges.
00:35:39 So it's an ongoing issue,
00:35:40 whether it would be an amendment
00:35:44 in the criminal code federally, maybe.
00:35:47 But the reality is, Andrew,
00:35:48 is what party in Canada
00:35:50 is going to amend the criminal code
00:35:52 to allow an individual to get a firearm back?
00:35:54 well exactly i mean theoretically the conservatives uh might but i i think they're
00:36:03 more focused on just stopping the new regulations that are coming in now i don't actually think
00:36:08 there is a huge political appetite when you start talking about anyone who's ever been charged
00:36:13 with a a crime in canada because it's not a group that on the surface is sympathetic even if
00:36:18 someone's been acquitted of charges or the charges were withdrawn whatever the case is
00:36:22 And I think that you're right to point that out, that it's very difficult and you have people that fall through the cracks as a result.
00:36:30 Yeah. But let me go back to your initial question now about the issue of this individual Milton man. Right.
00:36:36 And I think you have another very good point, which is if these laws aren't somehow bolstered or supported in the courts, right, then you get a bit of, what's the word, like a chill type of factor in terms of people who are defending themselves and they're wondering if they can lawfully defend themselves, then of course they may be injured in an attack upon them, right?
00:36:59 so you make a good point um it's important that we have these laws and maybe it is important to
00:37:04 some extent to try and um uh you know beef them up a little bit uh i'm not a politician so i don't
00:37:10 necessarily know how to go about that's why we like you yeah you know but you just ask questions
00:37:15 i just answer them but uh you know but i think but again to your point it's an important point
00:37:20 i think there has to be some beefing up so people feel more uh comfortable when they exercise their
00:37:25 their lawful right to defend themselves. Yeah, and I put that disclaimer at the beginning of
00:37:29 this discussion for a reason, that I don't know the facts of the case. You know, the police have
00:37:33 released a certain set of information, and I would say just as a result, as a related point,
00:37:38 that home invasions are very, very rare. I mean, home break-ins are common enough, but armed
00:37:44 robbery is not a very common phenomenon, and when it happens, almost always, it's the house of
00:37:51 someone that's known to the assailants, or it's the wrong house, but they were going after someone
00:37:55 specific so uh you can read between the lines there and and see that there may be additional
00:37:59 context that police have that they haven't revealed but i'm also very keenly aware of these
00:38:04 cases in the past where people that were legitimately using firearm and self-defense
00:38:08 have been charged i would say unfairly as a result so we'll certainly follow this uh sam
00:38:13 goldstein always a pleasure sir thanks for coming on today you're welcome good speaking to you all
00:38:18 right thank you that does it for us for today we will be back uh on we'll all be back on friday
00:38:23 with Fake News Friday
00:38:25 and then more of The Andrew Lawton Show next week. 0.52
00:38:28 And Michael Cooper, being a true mensch, 0.73
00:38:30 as my Jewish friends say, 0.98
00:38:32 has kindly offered to come back.
00:38:34 So he hasn't been put off
00:38:35 by whatever technical glitches befell this program.
00:38:39 And we look forward to his return.
00:38:41 That's all coming up next week on The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:38:43 Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all.
00:38:49 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:38:51 Support the program by donating to True North
00:38:53 at www.tnc.news.