Juno News - February 27, 2019


True North Report: Canadians are over Trudeau. Are you?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
More schools must let kids be kids Yazidi refugees are being threatened by their former captors...in Canada

Episode Stats


Length

31 minutes

Words per minute

176.81

Word count

5,618

Sentence count

370

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the True North Report, Andrew Lotton uncovers the latest in the SNC-Lavalin case, the by-elections, the Yellow Vests protest, and the United We Roll convoy.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good afternoon, Canada. Welcome to another True North Report. My name is Andrew Lotton, a fellow with True North, here to unpack the latest and greatest political news hitting the country since, well, yesterday.
00:00:13 Things are happening at a pretty quick pace. We'll talk about as much of this as we can in the next little while here.
00:00:19 I have to apologize in advance. So I used to host, as many of you know, a daily radio show.
00:00:24 And every now and then, the nature of being in radio is that you lose your voice. And when the job is pretty much to use your voice, this can be particularly damning.
00:00:33 Now, I don't host a daily show now, but for whatever reason, I've caught a little bit of a bug. I was traveling over the weekend and into this week as well.
00:00:42 So that may be where someone I met along the way in, like, one of the 27 airplanes I've been on in the last week has given me something.
00:00:50 But I've got, like, a very throaty cough. So I'm just apologizing in advance.
00:00:56 If I start, like, hacking up a storm and I start, you know, sounding more incoherent than Justin Trudeau trying to answer a question about SNC-Lavalin, that's why.
00:01:05 Actually, you know what? No matter how harsh my cough is, I'm pretty sure I couldn't sound that incoherent.
00:01:09 But if I, like, keel over to the ground and the screen goes blank and an alarm siren comes across your phone, that's why I'll pick myself up and it'll all be okay.
00:01:18 But for those of you who can make it through, I do thank you very, very much for your time today.
00:01:24 If you're just tuning in, Andrew Lawton here, fellow with True North.
00:01:29 And we've got some political news taking place at the federal level that I want to try to weave together because we've got a number of different stories here that I think are all part of the same overarching trend.
00:01:43 And truth be told, this is about Justin Trudeau and how much support or how little support he's commanding among Canadians headed into this year's election.
00:01:54 And I've said time and time again, when you are in election year, you have to really acknowledge that everything is an election issue.
00:02:01 We are at February 26th now, the election is less than eight months away, which means that anything that happens in Canadian politics can impact the perceptions and perspectives that Canadians have about the polls and about how they're going to vote.
00:02:18 So we've got a few things I want to cover here.
00:02:20 Number one is the trio of by-elections we had yesterday and the results that aren't particularly surprising but are still interesting.
00:02:28 So we'll talk about those. We've got Justin Trudeau finally, I say finally because we've been pushing for it for a couple of weeks now, agreeing to waive solicitor-client privilege in the SNC-Lavalin case.
00:02:40 And this is going to come to what is hopefully going to be a bit of a climax in this whole ordeal in Jody Wills and Raybould testifying tomorrow before the Justice Committee.
00:02:50 So we'll talk about that.
00:02:51 And then we also have the media coverage about the Yellow Vest protest and United We Roll convoy and the way that this is giving us a fairly good measure of what the Liberals, and I mean the Liberal media's, perspective and narrative is going to be headed into the election.
00:03:13 So that's what I'm going to be talking about today.
00:03:15 We're going to keep tabs.
00:03:16 I've got a few notifications that I'm waiting on just in case things are happening.
00:03:20 So if you see me looking down at my phone, I'm just playing Angry Birds.
00:03:23 No, I'm not playing Angry Birds.
00:03:24 I am doing, you know, important news.
00:03:26 And if something happens that is not related, I will try to bring my attention back to this.
00:03:32 But let's talk about the by-elections first because no real surprise here.
00:03:35 You can get the results.
00:03:36 But if you are not someone who enjoys reading the pages of Elections Canada's website, I don't blame you.
00:03:43 In York, Simcoe, which was a Conservative-held riding for years with Peter Van Loon resigning as MP, went Conservative.
00:03:51 Not even close.
00:03:53 Scott Davidson won with 53.9% of the vote.
00:03:58 Now, in a by-election that's not too many votes, that's 8,929.
00:04:01 Frankly, when I ran in the provincial election in Ontario, I wish that 8,929 votes gave you a win because I had 17,000.
00:04:11 So I still lost.
00:04:12 But, you know, I had double the votes Scott Davidson had.
00:04:15 So that's all percentages can kill you sometimes.
00:04:18 In Outre-Mont, which was Thomas Mulcair's riding, we'll give you the results in a moment.
00:04:23 And in Burnaby South, which was the riding that NDP leader Jagmeet Singh was running in, Singh won, also with 8,800 votes.
00:04:33 But that only, in this riding, amounted to about 39% of the votes.
00:04:37 So still significantly above his competitors and still very much decisive.
00:04:43 But, and here's the big but that comes about in this story, it is going to cause more problems for the NDP down the road.
00:04:51 But Outre-Mont is really interesting one because this was the only case where we saw a riding swing.
00:04:57 It has been a long time NDP riding for Thomas Mulcair.
00:05:00 With Thomas Mulcair's departure, the Liberals picked it up, again, by a very decisive margin.
00:05:05 And that was about 40.4% of the vote for Rachel Bendayan or Bendayan. 0.91
00:05:12 So this is where we've got three ridings.
00:05:15 Two of them stay the same.
00:05:16 One of them switches from NDP to Liberal.
00:05:18 I wouldn't be jumping up and down cheering, if I'm the Liberals, though, on this, for two main reasons.
00:05:25 The first is that, well, quite frankly, by-elections don't matter.
00:05:30 And I don't mean that they aren't important in the makeup of the House of Commons.
00:05:34 But by-elections don't matter in the sense of having any broader narrative that we can extract because they are so odd.
00:05:42 By-elections have very weird things that happen in them.
00:05:47 And this is because you have very low voter turnout in them.
00:05:51 The fact, and Connie mentions this in the chat, I was joking about, you know, the number of votes for a win.
00:05:56 In by-elections, you're lucky to crack like 28, 29% of the vote a lot of the time.
00:06:00 Whereas in the bigger elections, sometimes you can get up to 50% of the vote.
00:06:06 So such a significant swing there.
00:06:09 And I think that this is because a lot of people can barely summon the necessary strength to vote in a normal election.
00:06:16 Any election that happens between that is like, I can't be bothered.
00:06:19 So that being said, I want to crunch some of these numbers here.
00:06:23 Because even if, even if we can't extrapolate a broader narrative from this, we still can look at some of the stories that come about within it.
00:06:32 And one of the big ones here, or actually small ones, I think, is the People's Party of Canada.
00:06:40 Now, I've been not a fan of the party itself.
00:06:44 Because like anything, I like to take these situations on a case-by-case basis.
00:06:48 But I've been a long-time fan of Maxime Bernier.
00:06:51 I think he has the necessary free market bona fides that Canada requires.
00:06:56 I also think that he himself has been a straight shooter on a lot of issues.
00:06:59 If you want to see what I think about the issues themselves, he and I talk about them in a 30-minute long interview he and I did a few months ago in Toronto.
00:07:08 So I would encourage you to look at that interview.
00:07:11 And we're really, he answers in not politician-speak very clearly what he thinks.
00:07:16 That being said, he is being cast as a renegade.
00:07:20 He's trying to split the conservative vote.
00:07:23 He's unabashedly anti-Shear, almost as much, if not the same, as he is anti-Trudeau.
00:07:29 Maybe even more, because there's a bit of a personal issue here.
00:07:32 But the thing is, he goes and attracts this opposition to conservatives.
00:07:41 And what we see here is a really, really poor showing in two of the three by-elections.
00:07:47 I'm going to give you some numbers here.
00:07:48 In the Burnaby, or sorry, I'll do Burnaby South, because that's the interesting one.
00:07:52 But in Outremont, he got 322 votes for his candidate, James Seal.
00:07:58 Now, to put that into context here, I'm looking at the Liberal getting 6,000 votes, the Bloc Québécois getting 1,600, the Green Party getting 1,800, and the conservatives getting 1,000.
00:08:12 So the Greens beat the conservatives in Outremont, and the conservatives, with their 7% of the vote, had more than three times as many votes as the People's Party did.
00:08:23 So the PPC got 322 votes, which is paltry.
00:08:29 I mean, independent candidates will get that few typically, sometimes even more.
00:08:33 In York Simcoe, the People's Party of Canada actually did get fewer votes than one of those independent-esque candidates.
00:08:44 The PPC candidate in York Simcoe got 314 votes.
00:08:49 The Green Party got 451.
00:08:52 The Progressive Canadian Party, which was like a lot, this is like a party that was built in the ashes of the Reform PC merger,
00:08:59 where a bunch of old disgruntled PCers didn't like the idea of them merging.
00:09:04 That party got 634 votes.
00:09:07 So there are more PC Party voters than there were PPC voters.
00:09:12 So this is in two of the three ridings.
00:09:15 But let's look at riding number three, because this is a fascinating one.
00:09:19 In Burnaby South, where there was no Green Party, you had 2,420 votes for Laura Lynn Thompson,
00:09:30 who was the very outspoken People's Party of Canada candidate.
00:09:33 That's 10.6% of the vote.
00:09:35 Now, 10.6% is far and above what the Green Party typically gets.
00:09:40 10.6% is majorly, majorly significant, not because it's going to give you a victory,
00:09:50 but because it will very much upset the balance of power.
00:09:55 Now, in this particular case, let's say that all of those 2,420 votes would have gone to the Conservatives,
00:10:02 which is not necessarily true, but it is a group that spun off the Conservatives.
00:10:06 But that would put Jay Shin at about, I'm just doing quick math in my head here, 7,500 votes.
00:10:13 Now, that still wouldn't have given him the victory, because the winner, Jagmeet Singh, had 8,800.
00:10:18 But if you take 10% of the vote, a lot of the times elections are decided on far less than that.
00:10:26 And elections are, especially in the greater Toronto area, in some key ridings in Quebec,
00:10:31 these things are decided with 2,000, 3,000 votes.
00:10:34 So, 10% could very much be the determining factor in who wins.
00:10:39 And I don't know, I mean, obviously, Maxine Bernier says he wants to be Prime Minister.
00:10:44 But for Bernier, a victory is blocking Scheer.
00:10:49 And if he can keep 10% of the vote in a few key ridings, doesn't need to be all of them,
00:10:54 that could be a game-changer. 1.00
00:10:56 Corey writes, LOL, Berncoat, you suck, Andrew. 0.99
00:11:00 Andrew, well, thank you, Angry Max split the vote in Burnaby to let the NDP win. 0.99
00:11:05 If that happens again federally, Trudeau gets in again. 0.84
00:11:07 Well, I don't know why I suck in this particular context.
00:11:11 I've said I've been a fan of Bernier on policy.
00:11:13 And frankly, any true conservative should be a fan of his on policy.
00:11:17 On strategy, on tactics, that is an entirely different story.
00:11:21 I've said quite candidly in the past and in this show and in my interview with Bernier
00:11:26 that I don't like the idea of the vote split.
00:11:28 I'm talking about these issues right now as an analyst, not as an endorser.
00:11:34 And in fact, I actually was asked individually, not through True North,
00:11:38 to endorse a conservative nomination candidate.
00:11:41 And I was happy to because I know that individual candidate is going to be a great representative
00:11:45 and a great conservative candidate should he be selected at the nomination.
00:11:50 So I'm not at all on the Bernier train, but I'm also not going to cast off
00:11:56 what is a significant player in Canadian conservative politics. 0.84
00:12:01 So if that means I suck, well, tough luck.
00:12:03 But I think that we need someone who's going to do this not from a place of anger 0.94
00:12:09 and not from a place of pettiness, but actually just look at the facts.
00:12:13 And the facts are we right now have a battle about math in the comments here.
00:12:17 Right now, just to remind, because Ron agreed with me on the numbers
00:12:22 and Corey is disputing the numbers.
00:12:24 The NDP would not have won no matter what in this riding
00:12:28 if every single PPC vote went to the Conservatives.
00:12:32 It wouldn't have, or sorry, the NDP wouldn't have lost
00:12:34 if every PPC vote went to the Conservatives.
00:12:36 But theoretically, in other elections that we have moving forward,
00:12:40 those numbers could have been game changers.
00:12:44 And that is the issue here, that those numbers could be game changers.
00:12:49 Dale writes, Scheer is staring defeat in the face and it will be his fault.
00:12:53 So let's talk about this here, because Andrew Scheer has been very quiet
00:12:58 on a lot of key issues for a while.
00:13:00 And there are two reasons for that.
00:13:02 Number one, you don't want to put yourself, when you're in the opposition,
00:13:05 out and say, this is what I think X, Y, Z, because you're going to get attacked.
00:13:09 That's one element of political strategy here.
00:13:13 Which is why I had a lot of respect for Andrew Scheer and Maxine Bernier,
00:13:17 for that matter, speaking at the United We Roll rally in Ottawa last week.
00:13:23 Because we've needed a leader of a Conservative, and I use a small c there,
00:13:29 of a Conservative party to step up and say to these Canadians,
00:13:32 yeah, we've got your back.
00:13:34 You're not fringe, you're not what the Liberals call you,
00:13:36 you're not what Ikra Khalid, did you see Ikra Khalid's tweet to the protesters? 0.94
00:13:41 She called them unabashedly just racist bigots.
00:13:44 And you may remember I had a video out last week exposing the CBC's narrative, 0.95
00:13:48 that this was a white supremacist rally.
00:13:50 That's all CBC seems to think here, that anyone who was in the Alberta convoy,
00:13:56 anyone that rallied on Parliament Hill, anyone that's standing up against a carbon tax, 0.99
00:14:00 that they're all just big, dirty, racist bigots. 0.99
00:14:02 And it's so disgusting that this attitude doesn't just exist in the fringe corners of Twitter, 1.00
00:14:09 but actual mainstream media coverage, 0.86
00:14:12 and elected officials are casting aside Canadians as just being all of the blankophobes,
00:14:19 and insert marginalized group of phobes here. 1.00
00:14:21 And the left in its entirety seems to be eating this up.
00:14:25 And I was glad that Andrew Scheer didn't kowtow.
00:14:27 So what happened was, Andrew Scheer and Maxime Bernier both went to the rally.
00:14:32 There were hundreds of people there,
00:14:34 which in a cold day in Ottawa is not a bad thing at all.
00:14:37 You had, more impressively, hundreds of trucks drive from Alberta to Ontario,
00:14:41 and some picked up along the way from Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and whatnot.
00:14:46 And then they had this big, you know, confab in front of Parliament.
00:14:49 And Andrew Scheer was called on by the media to basically disavow it,
00:14:56 to say, like, you know, are you against or for the Yellow Vest protest?
00:15:01 And this is what he said outside the House of Commons yesterday.
00:15:04 And I'm quoting here from a Canadian press report.
00:15:07 The events of last week were organized by people who have lost their jobs,
00:15:10 who are facing tremendous anxiety about what the future will bring.
00:15:14 I know the Liberals would love to distract from their own failures
00:15:17 by pointing to other elements that tried to associate themselves with the event.
00:15:21 But my message was very clear.
00:15:24 I was there to support energy workers,
00:15:26 those who support our natural resource sector,
00:15:28 and promising hope for the future come October,
00:15:31 when a Conservative government would stand for our energy sector
00:15:35 and champion Canada's oil and gas across the world.
00:15:40 Now, this is a great line in the Toronto Star, by the way.
00:15:43 The protesters' trucks snarled traffic in downtown Ottawa.
00:15:48 You know, I don't see the Toronto Star blasting the traffic holdups
00:15:53 of, you know, of Idle No More protesters,
00:15:56 of anti-pipeline protesters.
00:15:58 But no, no, no.
00:15:58 When a bunch of pro-oil people go in,
00:16:00 and the story is about the political message,
00:16:02 it's how they snarled traffic in Ottawa.
00:16:05 Which, let me tell you, if you've lived in Ottawa at all,
00:16:07 you know that traffic has already snarled there
00:16:09 without the tractor-trailers.
00:16:11 So I don't think they added too much more
00:16:13 than was already the problem.
00:16:15 But again, the media coverage has been very much focused
00:16:19 on making this to be about racism.
00:16:22 They'll find the one or two people
00:16:24 that are not representative of the majority
00:16:26 and say, these people define the masses,
00:16:29 these people define the group.
00:16:31 And the fact is, with a grassroots movement,
00:16:33 anyone can be a part of it.
00:16:35 Anyone can join.
00:16:36 We don't vet people who go to rallies because you can't.
00:16:40 They're outdoor, they're a public event.
00:16:42 Anyone can go to Canadian Tire and buy a yellow vest.
00:16:44 Anyone can put it on.
00:16:45 And if one of them turns out to be a racist,
00:16:48 that does not mean that everyone who wears a yellow vest is racist.
00:16:51 You know, it's like when I took philosophy in school,
00:16:55 there was that syllogism, I think syllogism is the word.
00:16:58 I haven't taken philosophy in a while.
00:17:00 I think it was, yeah, syllogism that, you know,
00:17:02 you'd use where, you know, all balloons are red.
00:17:08 You know, this is a balloon, therefore this is red
00:17:10 or something like that.
00:17:11 And the one that they do to demonstrate logical fallacies
00:17:14 was Hitler is a vegetarian, John is a vegetarian,
00:17:18 and therefore John is Hitler. 0.53
00:17:20 And it doesn't work like that.
00:17:21 But the media will take the one person wearing a yellow vest
00:17:24 and either take them out of context
00:17:26 or find someone who genuinely may have reprehensible
00:17:29 or at the very least incoherent views.
00:17:34 And they will then hold that person up
00:17:36 as the poster boy for this entire movement.
00:17:40 And when you look at the thousands and thousands
00:17:42 and thousands of people who donated money,
00:17:45 supported United We Roll on social media, 0.98
00:17:47 these are not racist, white supremacist bigots.
00:17:50 No, they're people that genuinely want someone 0.99
00:17:52 to get Justin Trudeau's job-killing policies
00:17:56 out of government in Canada.
00:17:58 And I think for the most part,
00:18:00 Conservatives in Canada are going to unite
00:18:02 behind Andrew Scheer and the Conservative Party of Canada.
00:18:06 We saw lackluster by-election results in two ridings,
00:18:10 which have never been Conservative ridings.
00:18:13 Oudermont and Burnaby South have always been NDP
00:18:15 or Liberal ridings.
00:18:17 In this case, one went NDP, one went Liberal.
00:18:20 York Simcoe, though, we saw that the PPC message
00:18:24 is not really in Conservative ridings
00:18:27 peeling away strong support.
00:18:29 But I do think the Burnaby South example
00:18:31 is an interesting one.
00:18:33 Because when that candidate, Laura Lynn Thompson, 0.99
00:18:39 who I've never met, but she seems like a very spunky person,
00:18:42 got over 10% of the vote there, it's no surprise
00:18:45 that this is also the candidate who was making big waves
00:18:48 on social media.
00:18:49 She had a little bit of profile going into it. 0.96
00:18:52 She's been a TV personality.
00:18:54 She's written.
00:18:55 She worked very hard.
00:18:57 She had incredible debate performance. 1.00
00:19:00 I was watching Laura Lynn Thompson's clips
00:19:02 in the Burnaby South debates.
00:19:05 And my goodness, the woman did very well. 1.00
00:19:07 And the media tried to attack her.
00:19:09 They tried to slander her. 0.91
00:19:10 They tried to slam her. 1.00
00:19:11 And she stood her ground and said,
00:19:12 no, this is what I'm about.
00:19:13 I'm about these values.
00:19:15 This is what the PPC is about.
00:19:16 This is what Maxine Bernier is about.
00:19:18 And obviously, it didn't work.
00:19:19 She capped out at 10.6% of the vote.
00:19:23 But like I said, that 10.6%, if it came from Conservatives,
00:19:27 and I don't know if it did,
00:19:29 but if it came from Conservatives,
00:19:30 that 10.6%, if applied to other ridings,
00:19:33 could be the difference between Trudeau getting in
00:19:35 or Andrew Scheer getting in.
00:19:38 And the NDP factor is interesting here
00:19:41 because Jagmeet Singh is not a popular NDP leader.
00:19:45 And I think that may have been part of the reason
00:19:47 that the NDP had such a terrible showing in Outramont,
00:19:50 the riding once held by Thomas Mulcair.
00:19:53 And I say once.
00:19:53 I mean, not that long ago.
00:19:56 So now that the NDP has a leader,
00:19:59 people are going to start seeing a lot more of Singh.
00:20:02 We're going to see him in question period.
00:20:03 And I think we're going to see
00:20:05 that he's not at all how exciting
00:20:07 the media has tried to make him out to be
00:20:10 and how exciting the NDP thinks he should be.
00:20:13 And my goodness, there is a lot of buyer's remorse.
00:20:20 There's a lot of buyer's remorse about Jagmeet Singh.
00:20:23 And had he lost the by-election,
00:20:26 there would have been a much bigger ability
00:20:28 for the NDP to get rid of him
00:20:30 and put someone else new in.
00:20:32 And I don't think that's going to happen now.
00:20:33 So the NDP is stuck with Jagmeet Singh for the most part.
00:20:36 I don't think he's going anywhere.
00:20:38 But what I do think is that there are a lot of people
00:20:40 in that party that don't want him there.
00:20:42 And we've seen a couple of them,
00:20:43 specifically from the Quebec caucus,
00:20:46 get out of it and say,
00:20:48 you know, I don't think I'm going to run.
00:20:50 And I don't think I'm going to run again.
00:20:52 So that's going to be, I think, an interesting thing here.
00:20:56 Someone is asking in the chat,
00:20:58 one word, couches.
00:21:00 I don't understand why we're talking about couches,
00:21:02 but if someone wants to put a giant couch
00:21:05 in front of Parliament Hill,
00:21:06 then have fun at it.
00:21:08 But I will point out that Jagmeet Singh being bad
00:21:12 may be great for the memes.
00:21:14 It may be funny.
00:21:15 It may be great when he implodes,
00:21:17 just to watch with a level of giddiness or schadenfreude.
00:21:20 But it's going to be very difficult for Conservatives
00:21:22 because a dissatisfied NDPer
00:21:25 is more likely to go to a fringe party
00:21:28 or go to the Liberals
00:21:29 than they are to go to the Conservatives.
00:21:32 And it's not to say people won't jump
00:21:34 from the NDP to Conservatives.
00:21:36 You know, if the Conservatives are putting
00:21:37 a moderate alternative to Trudeau
00:21:39 and NDP voters are just,
00:21:42 they're not all socialists.
00:21:43 I mean, people tend to forget
00:21:44 that a lot of them are just regular old blue-collar people
00:21:47 that think the NDP is offering solutions.
00:21:49 That's why we saw the NDP do so well in Ontario in June.
00:21:54 But it's less likely for an NDP voter to jump blue
00:21:57 than it is for them to jump red.
00:22:00 So if you have a really radical NDP leader,
00:22:03 which I think most people believe Singh is,
00:22:06 that will be dangerous for the right.
00:22:10 It will be.
00:22:11 And especially if you put in a Bernier factor,
00:22:13 which is someone peeling votes away from the right.
00:22:15 Like I said, in these three by-elections,
00:22:17 the People's Party of Canada was not enough of a factor
00:22:20 to block any Conservative win,
00:22:23 but it could be in other ridings.
00:22:25 And we've got to talk about those possibilities here.
00:22:28 Now, Dale writes,
00:22:29 the Conservative parties need to merge.
00:22:31 I like Bernier's policies way better,
00:22:32 but we need to win.
00:22:33 There's a lot of that going around.
00:22:35 You are not alone in that, Dale.
00:22:37 And I think that that frustration is understood
00:22:39 by a lot of people on the right.
00:22:42 And what else do we have here?
00:22:43 Michelle saying,
00:22:44 if NDP Feds get in power, 0.99
00:22:46 there goes millions from the India crap 1.00
00:22:50 the turd got us in. 0.99
00:22:53 I feel like I'm reading a haiku here.
00:22:55 Thankfully, I don't believe the federal NDP
00:22:56 is headed towards victory.
00:22:58 I don't even see a way they get official opposition.
00:23:02 Anything can happen,
00:23:03 but I would put a fair bit down on that
00:23:06 to say that the NDP,
00:23:07 in its current situation,
00:23:08 is not going to be headed towards
00:23:11 a victory anytime soon.
00:23:13 What else do we have here?
00:23:15 Alex writes,
00:23:17 we need Trump 2.0.
00:23:19 Well, I don't think that Trump
00:23:21 should be the benchmark
00:23:23 for a Canadian politician,
00:23:25 but I do think that someone,
00:23:28 I do think there is a desire
00:23:29 for someone who's going to not kowtow
00:23:31 to political correctness.
00:23:34 And obviously,
00:23:35 if you want to find who the Trump-like figure is,
00:23:38 if there is a Trump-like figure
00:23:39 in Canadian politics,
00:23:41 it's going to be Maxime Bernier.
00:23:43 But I don't think the comparison
00:23:45 is really all that accurate.
00:23:47 And to be fair,
00:23:48 I don't think that Trump is good
00:23:50 because he's Trump.
00:23:51 I think that Trump fits the mold
00:23:53 of something that politics needed
00:23:55 in the United States,
00:23:56 which is first off,
00:23:57 someone who's not Hillary Clinton. 0.98
00:23:59 Secondly, really,
00:24:01 someone who's not like Hillary Clinton.
00:24:02 And thirdly,
00:24:03 someone who's not like everyone
00:24:04 that Hillary Clinton is like.
00:24:06 And that was a lot
00:24:07 of the Republican field
00:24:08 of presidential candidates.
00:24:10 So I think that
00:24:11 if that frustration
00:24:12 carries over to Canada,
00:24:14 it's not going to be
00:24:15 in the same numbers.
00:24:16 It's not going to be
00:24:18 in the sense that
00:24:18 50% of the country
00:24:20 is ready to say,
00:24:22 to heck with the establishment.
00:24:23 The sad reality is
00:24:25 that a lot of Canadians
00:24:25 are fairly comfortable
00:24:27 with the establishment.
00:24:28 And that's something
00:24:30 that we see.
00:24:31 And there's a lot
00:24:31 of frustration in it,
00:24:32 but it's something
00:24:32 we see time and time again.
00:24:34 Canadians are not as...
00:24:37 And by the way,
00:24:37 I'm not talking about
00:24:38 you individually.
00:24:39 I'm just saying,
00:24:40 when we look at
00:24:41 the grand scheme of things,
00:24:42 Canadians are fairly comfortable
00:24:44 with people
00:24:45 that fit that mold.
00:24:46 Even if a small number aren't,
00:24:48 the majority tends to be.
00:24:50 And that may well
00:24:51 be very frustrating.
00:24:52 And that may well change
00:24:53 in five, ten years.
00:24:54 But I don't think
00:24:54 it's going to change
00:24:55 in the eight months
00:24:56 between now
00:24:57 and the federal election.
00:24:59 So Bernier is the closest
00:25:00 thing Canada has
00:25:01 to a Trump-like figure
00:25:02 because he's a disruptor.
00:25:04 He's launched a new party.
00:25:06 It's not out of the realm
00:25:07 of precedent in Canada
00:25:08 because Reform Party leader
00:25:10 Preston Manning did that.
00:25:13 And he had success.
00:25:14 But remember,
00:25:15 Preston Manning did not have success
00:25:17 in becoming Prime Minister of Canada.
00:25:19 Preston Manning had success
00:25:20 in moving the goalposts
00:25:22 of the Progressive Conservative Party
00:25:24 of Canada
00:25:25 to become
00:25:26 the Conservative Party
00:25:27 of Canada.
00:25:28 And people need to remember
00:25:29 it took 20 years
00:25:31 for that process
00:25:33 to complete itself.
00:25:35 I guess 18 years.
00:25:36 It took 18 years
00:25:37 for the reform
00:25:38 to become the CPC
00:25:40 with the alliance
00:25:41 along the way.
00:25:43 And this is very important
00:25:45 because in that time
00:25:46 we didn't have
00:25:46 the conservative leadership
00:25:48 with a small c
00:25:48 that Preston Manning sought.
00:25:50 We had machinations
00:25:51 that were moving the party
00:25:53 to that point.
00:25:54 And if this is
00:25:56 what Canadians desire
00:25:57 and if this is
00:25:58 what the People's Party
00:25:59 of Canada
00:25:59 is moving us towards
00:26:00 that is not going
00:26:02 to be an eight-month process.
00:26:03 I don't even think
00:26:04 it's going to be
00:26:04 an eight-year-long process.
00:26:07 And right now
00:26:07 I haven't yet seen
00:26:09 evidence
00:26:10 that Maxime Bernier
00:26:11 has succeeded
00:26:12 in creating
00:26:13 what Preston Manning created.
00:26:15 It's still early.
00:26:16 Bernier has proven himself
00:26:18 to be a powerful force
00:26:19 in fundraising.
00:26:20 Clearly he can mobilize.
00:26:22 I mean the party
00:26:22 has 338 riding associations
00:26:24 across Canada.
00:26:25 That will make it eligible
00:26:27 to be in the leader debates
00:26:29 which is going to be fascinating.
00:26:31 So Maxime Bernier
00:26:32 and actually under the new rules
00:26:33 True North Centre
00:26:34 had an article about this
00:26:36 just yesterday I believe.
00:26:38 Under the new rules
00:26:38 debates are going to be organized
00:26:40 by a government bureaucracy
00:26:42 led by David Johnston
00:26:43 the former governor general.
00:26:45 But here's the thing
00:26:46 the criteria they lay out
00:26:48 for who's eligible
00:26:49 seems to exclude
00:26:50 the Gloc Québécois
00:26:52 but include
00:26:53 the People's Party of Canada.
00:26:55 Because there are
00:26:56 three criteria parties
00:26:57 must meet.
00:26:58 One of them is fielding candidates
00:26:59 in more than 90%
00:27:01 of the ridings
00:27:02 in the country
00:27:03 which Bernier will do
00:27:04 because he's got
00:27:05 riding associations.
00:27:06 One of them is having
00:27:07 at least one MP
00:27:08 in Parliament
00:27:09 which Bernier is.
00:27:11 Bernier is a PPC MP.
00:27:13 So is the Green Party.
00:27:14 And the third category
00:27:16 is to have
00:27:16 a conceivable chance
00:27:18 of forming government
00:27:19 based on polls
00:27:20 and past precedent.
00:27:22 So by those measures
00:27:24 two of the three
00:27:25 is all you need.
00:27:26 That would suit
00:27:26 the Green Party.
00:27:27 That would suit the PPC.
00:27:29 Would not suit the BQ.
00:27:32 They can't form government
00:27:33 when they only field candidates
00:27:34 in Quebec
00:27:34 and they don't have 90%.
00:27:37 So 90% of ridings
00:27:39 in the country.
00:27:40 So it's just not possible.
00:27:42 So I'm going to look
00:27:43 to see some other comments
00:27:45 we have here.
00:27:46 A lot of people
00:27:47 arguing about
00:27:48 what they think
00:27:50 of Andrew Scheer.
00:27:52 And I will say
00:27:53 I know Andrew Scheer
00:27:54 not as a friend
00:27:55 but I've met him
00:27:56 a number of times
00:27:57 and I think he's a very decent guy
00:27:58 on a personal level.
00:28:00 I think he is a solid conservative.
00:28:02 I also think
00:28:02 that he's cut from that cloth
00:28:04 of all the politicians
00:28:05 that have come before him
00:28:06 and that he wants
00:28:07 to be likable.
00:28:08 He wants to appeal
00:28:09 not to the fire-breathing conservatives
00:28:11 but appeal to
00:28:12 the middle-of-the-road
00:28:14 Marcus and Fiona families
00:28:17 or Stephen Heather families.
00:28:19 If you've read
00:28:19 Tom Flanagan's book
00:28:20 you'll get the reference
00:28:21 of just those average
00:28:23 ordinary people
00:28:24 that aren't particularly partisan.
00:28:26 And I mean
00:28:27 that's the winning strategy
00:28:28 for Stephen Harper.
00:28:29 In many respects
00:28:30 it's the winning strategy
00:28:31 for Justin Trudeau.
00:28:33 It may well work
00:28:34 if he's the guy
00:28:35 that can sell the message
00:28:36 but he's not a fire-breather.
00:28:39 And to be fair
00:28:39 he's never pretended to be.
00:28:41 He's never marketed himself
00:28:42 as a fire-breather.
00:28:44 It's just important to note
00:28:46 that there has to be
00:28:48 a level of honesty.
00:28:49 So he may win
00:28:51 and I don't think
00:28:52 that he's going to be
00:28:53 just an extension
00:28:53 of Justin Trudeau
00:28:54 like Maxime Bernier says
00:28:56 but I also don't think
00:28:57 he's going to necessarily
00:28:58 be a red meat conservative
00:29:00 because he's not yet.
00:29:02 He's not yet
00:29:03 and he could be.
00:29:03 I want him to be.
00:29:04 I've said time and time again
00:29:06 I would love nothing more
00:29:07 than for Maxime Bernier
00:29:08 to pull Andrew Scheer
00:29:09 to the right
00:29:10 and everyone gets
00:29:12 what they want
00:29:12 which is a solid
00:29:13 and consistent
00:29:14 small-c conservative party.
00:29:16 That's the goal.
00:29:18 I mean that absolutely
00:29:18 is the goal here.
00:29:20 So let's talk about
00:29:22 projections on this.
00:29:24 I don't think
00:29:24 Justin Trudeau
00:29:25 is a lock
00:29:26 for Prime Minister.
00:29:27 I don't think
00:29:28 Andrew Scheer
00:29:29 or Maxime Bernier
00:29:29 or anyone else
00:29:30 is a lock.
00:29:31 I think that this election
00:29:32 has a lot of variables.
00:29:35 The SNC-Lavalin case
00:29:36 I mean I haven't had time
00:29:37 to talk about it too much
00:29:38 but Jody Wilson-Raybould
00:29:40 is going to be testifying
00:29:41 before the Justice Committee
00:29:43 tomorrow.
00:29:43 That may well
00:29:44 set a chain of events
00:29:46 that changes the narrative
00:29:47 but eight months
00:29:48 is still a very long time.
00:29:51 So if you paid attention
00:29:52 to the by-elections
00:29:53 don't think that there is
00:29:54 a narrative from this
00:29:56 that will carry you
00:29:57 to October.
00:29:58 There just isn't.
00:29:59 Trudeau is not guaranteed
00:30:00 to win because he picked
00:30:01 up a seat.
00:30:02 Maxime Bernier
00:30:02 is not guaranteed
00:30:03 to be irrelevant
00:30:04 because he failed to.
00:30:05 No, it just means
00:30:06 that we have a benchmark
00:30:08 of what some things
00:30:10 could end up as
00:30:11 but it doesn't tell us
00:30:14 with any certainty
00:30:15 what's going to happen.
00:30:16 So still be careful.
00:30:18 Keep your powder dry
00:30:19 and more importantly
00:30:20 have a level of openness
00:30:23 about it.
00:30:23 I mean if you have questions
00:30:24 about Andrew Scheer
00:30:25 and you're a potential
00:30:26 Conservative voter
00:30:27 ask them.
00:30:28 Carla says in the chat here
00:30:29 she's listening to Andrew
00:30:30 speak tomorrow.
00:30:31 She doesn't mean me 0.96
00:30:32 unfortunately.
00:30:33 I'm not speaking in Kitchener
00:30:34 tomorrow but Andrew Scheer
00:30:35 speak in Kitchener.
00:30:36 Go.
00:30:36 Go to events like those.
00:30:38 Listen to what he has to say.
00:30:39 Maxime Bernier as well.
00:30:40 This is a guy who probably
00:30:41 would pick up the phone
00:30:42 if you wanted to call him
00:30:44 and ask him something
00:30:44 so do it.
00:30:46 I mean ask these people.
00:30:47 I think as Conservatives
00:30:48 if that's where you identify
00:30:52 you have an obligation
00:30:54 I'd say at the very least
00:30:56 you have a right
00:30:57 to make sure
00:30:58 that you're getting
00:30:58 the best of the leaders
00:30:59 that claim to speak to you.
00:31:01 So take advantage of that
00:31:02 and make sure
00:31:03 that you're listening
00:31:04 to that inner voice.
00:31:04 I mean conscience voting,
00:31:06 strategic voting
00:31:07 that's your choice
00:31:08 but more importantly
00:31:09 know what the stakes are.
00:31:11 And I think that
00:31:11 for the rallyers
00:31:12 and protesters
00:31:13 on Parliament Hill
00:31:15 they figured
00:31:15 we can't afford
00:31:16 four more years of Trudeau.
00:31:18 And you know what?
00:31:18 A poll shows
00:31:19 that many Canadians
00:31:20 are in agreement there.
00:31:21 We're going to keep 0.99
00:31:22 this narrative going.
00:31:23 We'd love to have your support.
00:31:24 We need it
00:31:25 to keep the lights on
00:31:26 because we're not getting
00:31:27 a piece of that
00:31:28 $600 million media bailout fund.
00:31:31 So if you want to support
00:31:31 what we're doing at True North
00:31:33 head on over to
00:31:33 truenorthinitiative.com
00:31:35 click on donate
00:31:36 and from there
00:31:38 look for the
00:31:38 Andrew Lawton Heritage Club.
00:31:40 And certainly
00:31:41 that keeps my lights on here.
00:31:42 Thanks very much
00:31:43 for your support everyone.
00:31:44 Thank you.
00:31:45 God bless
00:31:45 and good day Canada.