Juno News - May 10, 2019


True North Report: Trudeau on the wrong side of another prosecution

Hosted by
Mentioned
Former NDP Leader says Trudeau broke our immigration system Here's what the mainstream media won't tell you about the United We Roll Convoy

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

161.6

Word count

3,287

Sentence count

172

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The case against Mark Norman bears many similarities to the SNC-Lavalin case, in that both involve public corruption charges brought by the government against a prominent executive of a prominent company. And yet, the government has now dropped the charges against him. Why? And why?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good afternoon Canada. Welcome to another edition of the True North Report. My name
00:00:04 is Andrew Lawton with you for the next little while as we talk about how Justin
00:00:10 Trudeau's government has once again found itself in the midst of a public
00:00:15 prosecution of a very high-profile nature and once again Justin Trudeau's
00:00:20 government has put itself on the wrong side of said public prosecution. Although
00:00:26 a little bit different there are a lot of similarities between the case against
00:00:31 Vice Admiral Mark Norman and the case against SNC-Lavalin, the case that we've
00:00:37 been talking about now for some months. And I want to bring this up because we see
00:00:42 the complete and utter hypocrisy from the Justin Trudeau government on this file.
00:00:48 So we'll talk about all that as the stream goes on. If you're tuning in from
00:00:52 wherever in the world it is from which you are tuning, I think that's the proper
00:00:57 way, all of those preposition stuff, all that preposition stuff. Let me know in the
00:01:02 chat what's going on and where you're watching from and what it is you think
00:01:06 about this. Jean or Jean, I think it's Jean, I hope I'm correct, says good
00:01:12 afternoon. Well good afternoon Jean or Jean, Jean rather it's great to have you
00:01:15 tuned in here. And to everyone else thank you very much. You know I want to bring up
00:01:21 the parallel between SNC and Mark Norman because they show that the government is
00:01:28 not above putting itself into these things and doing so despite the
00:01:34 political consequences of it. So SNC, which is still going on, we know Justin
00:01:39 Trudeau tried to pressure the Attorney General at the time, Jody Wilson-Raybould,
00:01:44 to basically intervene in an ongoing prosecution with the purpose of
00:01:51 abandoning it, entering into some deferred prosecution agreement and letting it so
00:01:55 the company could basically get away with its, well get away with its bribing,
00:02:03 get away with its misconduct. That was what Trudeau was trying to get Jody Wilson-Raybould to do,
00:02:09 that was what Michael Wernick on Trudeau's urging was trying to get Jody Wilson-Raybould
00:02:14 to do. And the federal government, which has long-standing ties, the Liberal Party
00:02:18 specifically, long-standing ties to the SNC-Lavalin apparatus, was intervening to
00:02:27 protect this company. So then you go to the Mark Norman case and it's the opposite,
00:02:33 where this prosecution was ongoing up until a couple days ago, and we'll talk about what happened
00:02:38 there, and the government decided to push, I'd say push for it. The government was, it sounded like
00:02:50 politically intervening to drive the narrative that Mark Norman had in some way disgraced his country
00:02:58 and his uniform, which the more we learned, we learned could not be further from the truth.
00:03:04 And it's a complicated case, and a convoluted case, and one that goes back quite a while.
00:03:10 He was charged in March of 2018, so about a year and two months ago, and as of two days ago,
00:03:20 federal prosecutors are abandoning the breach of trust case. They're saying, nope,
00:03:24 they have not gone so far as to exonerate him, though, and I find this part interesting, but they
00:03:31 have said that they do not believe there is a reasonable prospect of conviction. And one question
00:03:39 that I think is incredibly valid here, apart from why drop the charges, is why were they brought against
00:03:45 him in the first place? And this question there's no real answer for that doesn't ultimately go back
00:03:52 to Justin Trudeau. You know, Christy Blatchford wrote in the National Post this blurb that I think
00:03:58 is relevant here. She writes, one of the prosecution's biggest hurdles was improving one of what are
00:04:07 called the essential elements of the offense of breach of trust, in particular that Norman had the
00:04:12 intent of using his office for a purpose other than the public good. That usually translates to having
00:04:18 had a corrupt or dishonest intention, and yet the government has never alleged that Norman personally
00:04:24 benefited in any way from his alleged leaking. The leaking, of course, allegation that he leaked
00:04:30 cabinet documents regarding a $700 million shipbuilding deal, and I think $700 billion is pretty much what
00:04:38 his legal bills are up to now. But there was never any instance of bribery that was alleged, there was
00:04:44 never anything untoward, he wasn't trading secrets, he was alleged to have leaked it, but there's no
00:04:51 evidence that he did so for a purpose other than the public good, if he did exactly what's being
00:04:57 described. And what's so dangerous here is that we have from Norman a long-standing relationship with
00:05:06 the previous conservative government and conservative cabinet, and then the prosecution comes under the
00:05:13 current liberal government. And that's not just, I mean, some cases that's just timing, I get that, but it's very
00:05:21 difficult to not draw a line between what Trudeau may have thought was an allegiance issue, despite the
00:05:29 fact that Mark Norman has never been anything other than a fair and honest and completely capable public
00:05:39 servant. He's exactly what you'd expect of a vice admirable admiral, an admirable admiral, if you will,
00:05:45 and he's exactly what you demand of it. So again, the point that I drive here is that Trudeau has found
00:05:53 himself on the wrong side of another public prosecution. In the case of SNC-Lavalin, he's trying to intervene to
00:05:59 get his buddies off, and in the case of Mark Norman, he's aggressively pushing to get his enemy
00:06:05 prosecuted, tried, and ultimately convicted. And I don't know where he was hoping it would go.
00:06:12 You know, I want to read a little bit about what led to him
00:06:16 getting the charge dropped in the first place. And this is a CBC headline published
00:06:22 on the evening of May 8th. So that's yesterday evening.
00:06:27 Information from former conservative cabinet ministers helped put an end to Norman case.
00:06:32 And the Crown, so the people that were tasked with prosecuting him, said this,
00:06:37 it's a complex legal charge. We didn't have the entire information.
00:06:45 Then why were you doing it in the first place? If you didn't have the entire information,
00:06:50 why were you driving this case initially? And here's what the CBC story reveals.
00:06:57 The Crown's case began to collapse in March, so two months ago, partly under the weight of
00:07:03 information from several former conservative cabinet ministers and staffers. They were key
00:07:08 players in the previous government's $668 million deal to have the Davies shipyard in Lévis, Quebec,
00:07:16 convert and lease a supply ship to the Navy, some of whom were interviewed by a lawyer representing the
00:07:22 former vice chief of the defense staff. So that's Norman's lawyer, Marie Hennon, or one of her colleagues.
00:07:27 But all of these key players that were involved in the case, I want to read a line about this.
00:07:33 These individuals were never questioned by the RCMP or the Crown in the run-up to a breach of trust
00:07:40 charge being laid against Norman a year ago.
00:07:42 So you have these key witnesses, none of whom were asked questions about the police agency responsible
00:07:52 for charging Norman, the Crown responsible for prosecuting that charge. And we're supposed to
00:07:57 believe that this was a charge that was decided on after reviewing all the evidence and determining
00:08:04 it was appropriate. No, it sounds like they steamrolled ahead in this and it took them 14 months.
00:08:10 14 months to be able to say, oh, you know, we didn't have all the information, let's walk this back.
00:08:17 They should have known this right away. They should have known this before charging him,
00:08:24 as a matter of fact. Libby writes, the government is paying his legal bills after having him charged.
00:08:29 Yes, this was something mentioned by Defense Minister Harjit Sajjan when the announcement was made
00:08:34 that the federal government preemptively offered this guy his legal bills. And I want to
00:08:40 explain for a moment why that is more cynical than benevolent. And first off, Norman didn't even
00:08:46 ask yet. He probably would have asked, but he didn't even ask. He actually learned about it
00:08:50 from a reporter. Someone was saying, I heard this on the radio. I haven't heard the clip yet.
00:08:55 But he was basically being asked a question. He was speaking and someone said, you know,
00:08:59 the government's doing this. Oh, really? What? What? Like he had no idea. So he didn't even ask for this
00:09:04 or push for it yet. And the federal government saying, okay, we'll give you these, these legal
00:09:09 bills. And a statement that came from the chief of defense staff suggests that they are trying to
00:09:14 find a way to get Vice Admiral Norman returning to his post, which it's really upsetting. This is a guy
00:09:25 who had had his life destroyed, his life's work put in the, basically down the barrel of a gun.
00:09:33 And thankfully, people that knew him, and had worked with him in the past, were very much able
00:09:40 to attest to his character. And I do genuinely think that helped him. I mean, Andrew Leslie, the
00:09:46 liberal MP, is going to or was going to be testifying on Norman's behalf. And this is the former
00:09:54 Lieutenant General, if memory serves, I might have the rank wrong, I think it's Lieutenant General,
00:09:58 that was going to say, oh, look, I mean, the liberals are against this guy, I'm for him.
00:10:03 Jason Kenney was going to stand up for him as well. This is a guy who had bipartisan support,
00:10:08 a lot of respect across the aisle. And he was basically completely screwed. So there was a GoFundMe 0.99
00:10:16 page for him that raised about $400,000. And now the government's paying for his legal bills,
00:10:22 as Libby points out. But the reason I think the government is doing that is because the government
00:10:29 knows that if it does not preemptively try to make this go away, what's going to happen is he's going
00:10:35 to sue for malicious prosecution, for legal bills, for reputational damages, I mean, there are any number
00:10:43 of things. And I don't think the federal government wants to open that can of worms, knowing that
00:10:48 there's probably evidence of malicious prosecution, there's probably evidence of the federal government
00:10:55 trying to conspire against him, or at the very least, of trying to make an example of him. And I
00:11:01 think that the defense minister is trying to preempt that as much as possible by saying, all right,
00:11:07 just take the lawyer fees. But I truly hope that he continues to fight. I mean, as a taxpayer,
00:11:12 I don't like the idea of the federal government having to shell out money. But in terms of standing
00:11:19 up for what's right, and standing up on principle, I honestly think that this is where the case has to
00:11:24 go. I mean, look, Omar Cotter, for crying out loud, got $10.5 million from the federal government,
00:11:29 and he killed a soldier. Mark Norman is a soldier, and remains a soldier. And I'm not saying he's
00:11:34 deserving of $10 million, but he's deserving of something. And what's so baffling about this case,
00:11:40 and what I find so frustrating about it is that the rationale that the Trudeau government used
00:11:46 when it gave Omar Cotter the $10.5 million was, oh, well, you know, if he was suing us, and we were
00:11:53 defending, and well, if we had kept on defending, then it would have cost more, and we might not have
00:11:59 won anyway. So by their rationale, there's no point in fighting anything, you just have to pay him to go
00:12:04 away. Well, here's one case where I think someone is probably deserving of that happening. And that's the
00:12:09 case of Admiral Norman. Corey writes here, Jason Kenney knows the deal. Yeah, Jason Kenney was in the
00:12:17 government when this was all happening. Dave writes, most people don't realize the dangers of
00:12:23 government deciding who gets prosecuted or not. Dictatorships do that. Yeah, the fact is politicians
00:12:30 should not be in the midst of any of these cases and any of these public prosecutions. But now you can't
00:12:37 have a public prosecution in Canada that doesn't have some level of political oversight. And I want
00:12:42 to read a line from Trudeau here, that I don't think you'll be able to get through without laughing.
00:12:49 He was asked in a scrum at Parliament Hall, about whether the Prime Minister's office was involved.
00:12:56 And he said that the prosecution of the Norman case was, quote, entirely independent of his office,
00:13:04 and that he has, quote, confidence that the work being done by the director of public prosecution is
00:13:11 good. So Justin Trudeau, who tried to get Jody Wilson-Raybould to interfere in the director of
00:13:17 public prosecution's work, is now saying that the PMO is entirely independent of the public prosecutor's
00:13:25 office, and he is complete confident in her ability to make the right decisions. And he expects Canadians 0.99
00:13:31 to buy this. He expects Canadians to believe this, that, you know, the PMO, which just three months ago
00:13:37 was trying to interfere in a public prosecution, has now decided to let these things be completely
00:13:42 independent. So I find that bizarre. And you can't deny the parallels that exist between the SNC-Lavalin
00:13:49 case, and this case with Mark Norman. And no one gets that more than Marie Hennon does, who was
00:13:58 Norman's lawyer, is Norman's lawyer, perhaps. And when she did that press conference, sitting beside
00:14:04 Vice Admiral Norman, she was able to throw, as the kids say these days, so much shade at Justin Trudeau,
00:14:13 it's not even funny. And you should actually watch the 30 minutes of this, because I wanted to watch 30
00:14:18 seconds of it. And then I ended up watching the whole thing here. And what happens is Marie Hennon sits 0.72
00:14:25 down, and I'm going to read the exact quote. Again, you have to watch this. I can't play clips easily,
00:14:31 so I'll just read it. You should see it. But she was talking about the Norman case. But before so, she said,
00:14:40 before we get started, I'd just like to introduce the all-female team that represented Vice Admiral Norman.
00:14:48 And then she said, fortunately, Vice Admiral Norman didn't fire the females he hired.
00:14:55 And she didn't mention Justin Trudeau. She didn't mention SNC-Lavalin. But the prevailing sense is that
00:15:00 she was very much invoking Jody Wilson-Raybould and Jane Philpott, and their terminations by Justin
00:15:07 Trudeau, in taking aim at Trudeau. Because for Norman, this is entirely personal. Trudeau had, for whatever
00:15:13 reason, a vendetta against Norman. Maybe he just doesn't like the military, as Stephen Harper charged
00:15:18 in the past. Maybe he thinks Norman was too cozy with the conservatives. Maybe he just doesn't like
00:15:23 the cut of his jib, or whatever. Maybe he doesn't like the Navy. Maybe the YMCA, you know, traumatized
00:15:28 him or something as a child. But whatever the reason, Trudeau did not want Norman. And this whole
00:15:36 prosecution seems to be a shambolic attempt to force him out of a job for nothing other than petty
00:15:44 political grievances. Carly writes, this is another example of Trudeau having to get his way all the
00:15:50 time. Yeah, but it's one thing to be a petulant child and want to get your way all the time. It's
00:15:55 quite another to treat institutions that are supposed to be independent, like they are your own
00:16:02 personal servants, which is how Trudeau seems to be treating the judiciary, including the supposedly
00:16:09 independent attorney general and director of public prosecutions. You know, when Hennon continued along
00:16:17 this, she said, the decision to stay this prosecution was discretion exercised by prosecutors
00:16:25 and the director of public prosecutions unimpacted by any political considerations, as it should be.
00:16:33 So again, she takes aim at Trudeau's record as someone who has demonstrably manipulated or tried
00:16:42 to manipulate public prosecutions in the past, and says, this is how things are supposed to work.
00:16:49 Politics are supposed to stay out of the prosecutorial process. So Marie Hennon 1.00
00:16:54 gets it. Marie Hennon gets it. Mark Norman gets it. And this is one of these cases where it seems
00:17:00 almost everyone but Justin Trudeau gets it. And that a guy like Mark Norman has such bipartisan
00:17:07 support, from Andrew Leslie to Jason Kenney to Lisa McLeod, a guy who's tremendously well-liked
00:17:13 left and right, but finds himself shouldering the liberal government's very poor approach to military
00:17:21 issues. And, you know, I don't know if the Crown in this case is just utterly incompetent, or genuinely
00:17:31 was operating with political considerations front and center. It sounds like a little bit of both,
00:17:37 quite frankly, when they were able to somehow have a charge leveled by RCMP without any oversight as to
00:17:45 the scope of evidence, without interviewing key witnesses, people that over a year ago would have
00:17:51 been able to say, well, hang on a minute, you've got to pay attention to this. And I don't yet know
00:17:56 what the information is. I don't know if Canadians will ever find out what this exculpatory information
00:18:00 was that was put in front of the Crown. But suffice it to say, whatever it was, would have been available
00:18:07 a year ago. It would have been available a year ago. Remember, he was charged in March, the investigation
00:18:14 started before then. So it's not even just a year and two months, it's a year and three, four months,
00:18:19 perhaps, that this should have been brought up by the people tasked with charging this man. But instead,
00:18:25 it was charged now and figure it all out later. And I'm glad that in this case, Trudeau has lost.
00:18:32 But for the sake of Vice Admiral Norman, I'm glad that he's been vindicated. Remember,
00:18:36 the prosecution tried to be a little bit iffy about this and say, oh, well, you know, we're not
00:18:41 saying what you did was right, but we're saying we can't prosecute you. Whereas the judge was very
00:18:48 much forceful in saying, look, you had a plea of not guilty. In the eyes of this court, you are innocent
00:18:55 and walk away as such. And I think on that, Norman has been vindicated. And you know what, it's a good
00:19:01 thing that his reputation was held in such high esteem and Trudeau's in such a considerably lower
00:19:08 level of esteem. We've got to wrap up. But a big thank you to all who tuned in here. We will have
00:19:13 more to talk about next week. But on a bit of a programming note, I am on Thursday headed to the
00:19:19 United Kingdom for the Tommy Robinson contempt of court hearing. Again, when you talk about abuse of
00:19:25 process and malicious prosecution, some parallels in that case as well. But we're also going to be
00:19:31 at True North trying to cover a press freedom summit that's being held in the UK by Canada
00:19:38 and the UK in July. And I wrote about this and did a video about it last week. It's going to be an
00:19:43 important case. We're crowdfunding our way there because we don't have that CBC $1.3 billion subsidy
00:19:50 or the $600 million media slush fund. So if you care about media freedom, and if you care about the
00:19:55 government not being able to just cast everything it doesn't like aside as fake news, and you can
00:20:01 contribute a few bucks to that, please do. You can find the information at tnc.news or shoot me an
00:20:08 email andrew at andrewlotton.ca and I can get you hooked up with all the right information there.
00:20:12 But in the meantime, have a great weekend, Canada. Thank you. God bless and good day.
00:20:18 you