Juno News - July 21, 2018


True North's Andrew Lawton with Tanya Granic Allen

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Plastic Straws! True North's Andrew Lawton with Barbara Kay

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

215.91

Word count

3,152

Sentence count

201

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, First Educators and Parents President Tanya granik-allen and former PC leadership candidate Tanya Granik-Allen talk about the controversial sex ed curriculum in Ontario's public schools. They discuss the role of parents in shaping the curriculum and the role they played in helping to elect Doug Ford as premier.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm joined by Parents as First Educators president, Tanya Granik-Allen, also a former
00:00:09 leadership contestant for the PC Party of Ontario. Tanya, good to be with you. Thanks very much.
00:00:13 Thanks for having me, Andrew. So you really, before entering politics as a leadership
00:00:19 candidate, had set the tone for discussions about the sex ed curriculum. And when you first brought
00:00:23 up that issue, you were speaking to a PC Party that not only didn't want to listen on that issue,
00:00:28 but had really turned its back on people after promising one thing, doing another. And you look
00:00:36 at the PC Party today, you were instrumental in getting Doug Ford elected as leader. The issue of
00:00:41 the sex ed curriculum was discussed at great length during the campaign. The government has already
00:00:45 taken some action on that that we'll get into the details of. But did you envision this would be the
00:00:51 road that Ontario would be going down even a year ago? No, a year ago, we were, I guess, hot on the
00:00:57 heels of Patrick Brown's flip flop from his commitment to repeal the sex ed. And I think most
00:01:02 common sense Ontarians and common sense conservatives were a little concerned with the direction the
00:01:07 party was taking, not just with the sex ed, but also with questionable nominations and potentially
00:01:13 corruptive practices and whatnot. So, but with this, the sex ed file, yeah, we had no idea.
00:01:19 My colleague, she said, no, Patrick won't be the leader going into the election. And she had this
00:01:23 idea, but I said, no, no. I mean, we're just a few months away. And then all of a sudden things
00:01:27 happened in January and we have a completely different premier than I think we thought we
00:01:31 would. And that shows a lot of things. I mean, first off, you can never take anything for granted
00:01:36 in politics. A lot can change. I know that you weren't gearing up for a leadership race until you
00:01:39 were. I never in my life thought I would ever run for politics in general, let alone the leader of a
00:01:44 party. Because I had interviewed you on my radio show when you were the PAFE president the first
00:01:49 time around, and you were not gearing towards political office. You were trying to get politicians
00:01:54 to respond to a constituency that was being ignored at the time, which was parents. Now we have a
00:01:59 government that has said it's going to listen to parents. I was a candidate in the election. So I was
00:02:03 hearing from a lot of people that the sex ed curriculum was a problem. And I wanted to ask you
00:02:09 why you think that issue gained such traction? Because I was not hearing about it from the usual
00:02:14 suspects of social conservative causes. I was hearing about it from people that had never
00:02:18 been politically engaged, new Canadians, Christians, Muslims, non-religious people.
00:02:24 Of all the social issues, why do you think the sex ed curriculum was the one that really gained so
00:02:28 much traction? Well, the curriculum per se was just so, it's just so terrible. And we're talking
00:02:33 about the Kathleen Wynne radical sex ed curriculum. There were just so many elements that were terrible.
00:02:38 And I think we've had about three years now of this curriculum in the classroom. And parents know
00:02:43 they're sitting down at the dinner table and children are coming home from school and discussing
00:02:46 things that parents didn't think in a million years they would hear come out of their kids' mouths.
00:02:50 So parents understood that there's something going on in the classroom that they didn't like.
00:02:53 You mentioned new Canadians. Most new Canadians, they come from other countries where they may not 0.88
00:02:58 be able to exercise their democratic freedoms, like freedom of speech or freedom of religion.
00:03:03 And they come to Canada in search of those freedoms and hope to be welcomed in a society like that.
00:03:08 And they want to impart those potentially traditional family values to their children.
00:03:14 And to have a school system that's running completely against that is shocking for a lot
00:03:19 of new Canadians. And they found their voice and they're using it. And I'm grateful for them.
00:03:23 And I think it's important that people have that opportunity to exercise those freedoms.
00:03:28 And what's most important to most families is their children. You go and attack children or you
00:03:32 try to go and sexualize children, you're going to hear from a lot of angry parents. And I think we saw
00:03:36 that in this election. That's a good point. And more than any other social issue, sex ed really
00:03:43 cuts at how children are being raised because it is the state that is by many measures trying to
00:03:51 replace parents when it comes to different belief systems and different value systems.
00:03:55 And when you look at even the name of your organization, Parents as First Educators, I think
00:03:59 that the curriculum entering the political discussions was a wake-up call for a lot of parents to actually
00:04:04 reclaim that. And I think that parents, by and large, many of them didn't know the rights that
00:04:09 they did have to get involved in their kids' education. And that was something that was
00:04:13 really encouraging to see. Even outside of how people voted, just parents that are actually
00:04:16 stepping up and being a lot more engaged. Because that now is the battle. If we say parents
00:04:21 weren't consulted, parents need to make sure that they are participating in the consultation.
00:04:24 Precisely. And I think, you know, parents are busy. Sometimes you have double income,
00:04:29 both mother and father are working. They send their children to school with the good faith and trust
00:04:34 in that the government is instructing teachers to educate them properly. But when we're teaching
00:04:38 elements like the unscientific gender theory to children and using the classroom more as a vehicle
00:04:44 of social engineering, the red flags go up. So, yeah, I think parents are waking up. And I'm glad
00:04:51 many organizations, including my own, that are sounding alarm that, you know, parents, you are
00:04:55 the first educators. You will always be the first educators for your children. So pay attention to
00:05:01 what's going on and make sure that they're learning what they should be and avoiding what they shouldn't
00:05:05 be learning. Let's talk about where we are now. You were not a candidate by the time the election
00:05:10 rolled around. The PC party was very clear that it didn't signal any change in policy. They were still
00:05:15 committed to repealing the sex ed curriculum. You were very swift to say it needs to happen by September,
00:05:20 which the government has done. Are you happy with the direction we see from the government now as
00:05:26 far as what they've committed to do by September? Well, so last week I was ecstatic and I said this
00:05:31 was a terrific victory for parents and children. But unfortunately, just a few days ago, the issue
00:05:37 of repeal has been evolving. And I always said repeal and replace. And it was the Ford government that
00:05:42 brought in the restore. And it seems like that's where they're tripping up because there's been a lot
00:05:45 of attacks from the left, big surprise there, saying, oh, you're going to take people back to
00:05:49 the dark ages and whatnot, which is completely not true. But the Minister of Education this week
00:05:55 mentioned that the children will still be learning gender identity theory, or she suggested that. And
00:06:00 I'm asking for clarification. Will children learn this theory or not when they return to school in
00:06:04 September? Parents want to know. The society wants to know. And I think we need a little bit more
00:06:08 clarity on that. I think Premier Ford has tried to clarify a little bit that parents are the first
00:06:14 educators. He came up with some excellent language on that yesterday. And I'm happy to see that.
00:06:18 But I think that the government needs to really make their position clear. And considering the,
00:06:23 again, the recent, I guess their gaffe, they need to clarify, will that controversial material be
00:06:30 taught or not? We've seen a number of teachers, isolated examples, but still it's been part of the
00:06:36 discussion on this that have said they're going to, you know, still teach all of these other things
00:06:40 anyway. And we've had some that have said they'll do it outside the school system, to which I
00:06:44 say, power to them if they want to do it. Teachers who don't want to play ball on this, I mean,
00:06:51 is there a proposed remedy to that?
00:06:53 Well, I think it's absurd, first of all. Teachers are great, and we're happy to have them,
00:06:59 and they serve such an important role. But the role is very clear. You are to teach the prescribed
00:07:04 curriculum. And if the curriculum, and if you want to go outside that scope, if you, you know,
00:07:09 really want to instruct your classroom on masturbation, or teach that class on, or introduce 0.86
00:07:13 the topic of oral sex in your classroom, or you really want to introduce the six genders to your 0.97
00:07:17 children at age eight, which is what we have now with the Kathleen Wynne sex ed curriculum, 0.92
00:07:23 that's, and our curriculum doesn't have that, then that's crazy. If that's not what we have laid out,
00:07:27 then you cannot teach that. And I think parents, again, put their good faith in the teachers to
00:07:31 teach the prescribed curriculum. And let me be very clear, we hear from lots of teachers. Yes,
00:07:35 we're parents as first educators. That's our organization. But teachers call us all the time.
00:07:39 We received so many messages saying, thank you, that I don't have to teach this awful curriculum.
00:07:44 I don't have to sexualize my students in the classroom. Because let's face it,
00:07:48 what teacher really wants to talk about gender theory to eight year olds? It's confusing for us,
00:07:52 most of us adults, let alone a child in grade three. The media and the opposition have come at this
00:07:58 issue by saying we're going back to the stone age, like you indicated earlier, by going back to the
00:08:02 1998 curriculum. They say Doug Ford's rolling back the clock 20 years. In actuality, we're rolling
00:08:06 it back three years. I mean, that curriculum was working right up until a few years ago. But I do
00:08:11 have to ask, I mean, there are legitimate grievances that people raise that that curriculum didn't
00:08:15 address a lot of the modern realities like the internet, like cyberbullying, like sexting.
00:08:20 Do you think that there is going to be something missing when those are not part of what's being taught?
00:08:25 Look, I agree with Premier Kathleen Wynne, the former Premier, that yes, this curriculum needed to be
00:08:29 updated 100%, especially given what she said in light of technology advances. That was the excuse
00:08:34 she used to update the curriculum. And I agree. But she pulled a bait and switch. She used that excuse 0.97
00:08:40 as an opportunity to actually advance her social engineering and the gender theory. Why do I say 0.96
00:08:45 that? Because she failed to not once address internet pornography in this curriculum for elementary 1.00
00:08:52 school students. And that is terrible. Now, I know people said, well, that's because, you know,
00:08:57 the deputy minister of education at that time was is now a convicted child pornographer. Maybe that
00:09:01 had something to do with it. I don't know what I do know that if she truly wanted to update the
00:09:05 curriculum because of technology, she failed. So, yes, we must have elements that keep up to date.
00:09:10 The curriculum must be updated, but it must be done so in a responsible manner. And Kathleen Wynne,
00:09:15 unfortunately, to simply use that as an opportunity to advance her social engineering. 1.00
00:09:19 But with that reversion that we believe we're headed towards in September, and I agree with you about
00:09:23 the need for clarity. Do you think we're going to be missing out on something significant if
00:09:27 those cyber elements are not included? Look, I think there are certain themes are woven throughout
00:09:33 all sorts of curriculum. I think parents are the first educators, and I think they in their home
00:09:38 are instituting those those limitations. For example, you know, parents monitor what their
00:09:43 children do on the internet, or at least they should be doing that. And, you know, I know kids are
00:09:47 sometimes accessing things on their school Wi-Fi that they shouldn't. There are overarching policies
00:09:52 within a school that kind of regulate what children should or should not be accessing. I think that
00:09:56 needs to be toughened up. Look, I don't know how long this consultation will take to bring up a new
00:10:01 curriculum. I hope it happens in a good, timely fashion, and I hope the Minister of Education,
00:10:06 you know, updates those those important areas. We saw very legitimate concerns about how little
00:10:12 consultation there was. And I know the government loved to point to the 4,000 number for parents,
00:10:16 but there was very little insight, even among a lot of critics of people like you, that were saying
00:10:22 they didn't know how those 4,000 were selected, didn't know that they were handpicked, it was one
00:10:25 per school, it wasn't really a representative of the entire cross-section of parents that we have.
00:10:32 But at the end of the day, they're going to be parents that have differing beliefs on what should
00:10:36 be taught. And the government's going to have to pick a side, and they're going to have to pick,
00:10:40 you know, the parents that want a really permissive progressive curriculum,
00:10:43 or they're going to have to pick the parents that want a really conservative, pared-down one.
00:10:47 And at a certain point, you can't compromise between these two groups, you need to pick a 0.98
00:10:51 side. How should a government navigate that? Okay, so just to clarify, even though Kathleen
00:10:56 Wynne made the claim 4,000 parents were consulted through a Freedom of Information request, it
00:11:01 turned out that just over 1,600 were handpicked by principals. Just to clarify that, because I
00:11:05 know that's what's been going around. At some point you said they're going to have to pick a side.
00:11:10 Well, actually, it's very simple. We just need to get back to basics curriculum. We're doing it with
00:11:14 math. We should do the same with sex ed. We don't expect unscientific, unproven things like gender 0.94
00:11:19 theory to be taught. That's reasonable. You know, do we need to keep current? Of course we do. Things
00:11:24 get updated from time to time. This is the time. I don't think one side should win or the other side
00:11:30 should win. I think we teach children the basics, and if parents want to seek extra education for
00:11:34 their children, look, if a parent wants their kids to learn karate, they take them for karate class. If there's a
00:11:38 parent who really wants a child to learn eight genders, then perhaps they can hire a gender 0.99
00:11:42 expert to come into the home and explain that to them there. But the classroom must teach the basics
00:11:46 and must not be used as a tool of social engineering. You touched on something very important, though,
00:11:51 which is that all of these parents that are concerned that the sky is falling about this
00:11:55 need to be stepping up, and if they think it's so essential that their children are taught certain
00:11:59 things, teaching it. And I wonder where we've gone so wrong as a society that because your family
00:12:05 thinks something is good, the government should make that the case for every family. And there's
00:12:10 such an inconsistency because eventually those parents are going to find that there's a government
00:12:13 in power that stands for different things than they do. And they're not going to like when that
00:12:17 government turns around and says, well, actually, no, we're not doing it your way. We're doing it our
00:12:20 way. Well, that's why I've always been very clear. We need a science-based sex ed that, like I said,
00:12:25 teaches the basics. You know, I think, for example, the words love and marriage ought to be
00:12:29 mentioned in a curriculum. It's not currently mentioned once in the curriculum. The word love on a
00:12:33 curriculum on sex ed. It's shocking for many. But no, I think the government needs to always respect
00:12:38 parental rights. Parental rights in direction of their education of their children is enshrined in
00:12:42 the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. So this is an international right. And I think the government
00:12:48 must know its place. So I'm optimistic that the forward government will respect that and will
00:12:53 always enshrine parents as the first educators and respect parental authority. Let's say you get a
00:12:57 win on this. At the end of the day, we get a curriculum that you're happy with, that your members are happy
00:13:01 with. Do you hang up your hat and go home? Well, a win on this will always, I'll just understand a
00:13:06 full repeal of this curriculum must always include always advanced notification of sexual education
00:13:12 lessons and allow the parents to opt out. Because like you said, not all parents will be happy with
00:13:16 it. So let's always respect those parental rights. Let's always give them an opt out without
00:13:20 repercussions from the principals. But what do I do once we move on from this issue? Well, you know,
00:13:26 there are so many more areas that we need to work on to undo the damage of the Kathleen Wynne government.
00:13:32 For example, Bill 89, which regulates Children's and Youth Services. We know right now children are
00:13:38 being removed from homes if their parents do not agree with them and switching sexes and engaging and
00:13:44 accessing sex change procedures, be it hormonal therapies or other medical therapies. That would be
00:13:53 considered a form of abuse according to this previous government and they are removing kids.
00:13:57 We need to fix Bill 89. There are many other things that need to be done to undo the damage from that
00:14:02 last government. And I think to go back to where we started off this discussion, what's happened to
00:14:07 the PC party and now to Ontario in the last six months, really, that's how long it's been since
00:14:12 Patrick Bown stepped down, I think really reinforced why you should never give up a cause. Because had you
00:14:16 just given up and said, you know what, we're not going to get what we need in this party,
00:14:20 the course of what happened in the months following that would have been very different than they
00:14:25 were. So good work. They certainly will. Thank you, Andrew. Thank you very much.
00:14:27 Tanya Granik-Allen, President of Parents as First Educators. Thank you so much.
00:14:31 Thanks. All right. For the True North Initiative, I'm Andrew Lawton.
00:14:33 Thank you.
00:14:34 Thank you.