Juno News - October 19, 2021


True North's coverage of the Alberta Referendum and Local Elections.

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
What's going to happen to Erin O'Toole? The “Let’s go Brandon” meme comes to Canada

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 11 minutes

Words per minute

177.73

Word count

23,405

Sentence count

1,008

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join Andrew and Candice as they break down Alberta's election night, from municipal elections across the province, to referenda, to Senate Nominees, and much more. Plus, find out who our resident Albertan, William McBath, is!

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 Thank you.
00:04:00 Thank you.
00:04:30 Hello and welcome to True North's live election night show.
00:04:49 It is our great pleasure to have you tuned in as we break down a really exciting night for the province of Alberta.
00:04:56 We have municipal elections across the province from Calgary and Edmonton to Red Deer to Grand
00:05:01 Prairie, right down to Bentley and Duchess. And if you have to point those out on a map,
00:05:06 we can get to that as the night goes on. We also have Senate nominee elections. We have
00:05:10 referenda at the provincial level and also at the municipal level. Then we have more importantly,
00:05:15 a great cast of characters to help get us through this evening. My friend, colleague and boss,
00:05:20 Candace Malcolm, True North's founder and senior fellow is here, as well as William
00:05:25 McBath, who normally works behind the scenes as True North's Managing Director, but has decided to emerge from the shadows and join us as our Chief Alberta Correspondent this evening.
00:05:34 William, Candice, thanks for joining us on this great adventure through Alberta's elections. It's good to have you both here.
00:05:40 Great. Well, thank you for that wonderful introduction, Andrew. I particularly enjoyed your description of William, who is our resident Albertan.
00:05:48 It's funny because we have a lot of people on the True North team, some people like myself. I lived in Alberta for many years.
00:05:54 I went to the University of Alberta and I lived in Calgary after I graduated, but I don't live
00:05:58 in Alberta. So William is our sort of token Albertan on staff, and he's here to help us
00:06:03 make sense of everything going on in that wonderful province you live in, William. So it's
00:06:07 great to have you here. Excited for the night. So let's start, William, with the lay of the land
00:06:13 here of what's actually being voted on. I tried to give the top line description here, but we have
00:06:18 a lot of things happening today. You're absolutely right. So across the province and every
00:06:24 municipality, we are having municipal elections. So people voting for mayors and reeves and county
00:06:30 councillors and city councillors. But on top of that, Albertans are also voting in several
00:06:36 referenda. There's a referenda to remove equalization from the constitution. Many Albertans
00:06:43 feel that this is an unfair program that penalizes Alberta and transfers a lot of money to the rest
00:06:50 of the Federation, sometimes inappropriately so. Albertans are being asked to vote on that.
00:06:55 They're being asked whether or not they want to move permanently to daylight savings time.
00:07:00 And I actually think it will confuse a lot of people when they discover that they'll never
00:07:04 really know what time it is in Alberta anymore. But a lot of people feel very strongly on that.
00:07:10 they really don't like that spring ahead. And Calgarians are voting whether or not to put
00:07:14 fluoride back in their water. And so a lot of people don't know fluoride was taken out of
00:07:19 Calgary water about 10 years ago. They're being asked to put it in. Now, on top of that, they're
00:07:23 also being asked to choose Senate nominees. Alberta traditionally has elected its Senate
00:07:28 representatives and has done so for the last 30 years. But the prime minister of the day doesn't
00:07:33 always choose to appoint those people. And it has been not a coincidence that conservative prime
00:07:39 ministers, much more likely to respect the democratic wishes of Albertans than liberal
00:07:43 prime ministers. Well, that's a great rundown of what's happening, William. Thanks for that.
00:07:49 Let me turn to you on this, Candace, from a True North perspective. You mentioned earlier that
00:07:53 we're not all from Alberta here. I know we love the province. We've all done a lot of work in
00:07:57 Alberta, covering Alberta. Why are we doing this show? Why is it important that we have all the
00:08:02 people together that we're going to have tonight? Well, I think there's a couple of reasons. The
00:08:06 First is that we have fun doing these live shows.
00:08:09 We did a couple during the election, and they're just a great way to connect with our audience,
00:08:13 to connect with the country, really, to try to have our finger on the pulse of what's going on out there.
00:08:20 And, you know, during the election, every time we spoke to people from Alberta,
00:08:24 they sort of emphasized that these elections were coming.
00:08:27 And in some ways they were, I will say, more consequential,
00:08:30 because obviously whoever the prime minister and whoever is running the country has a huge impact on everyone in the country.
00:08:36 However, Albertans didn't really feel like they were going to have their voice heard in the federal election.
00:08:41 And they didn't. They by and large voted conservative and we still got a liberal prime minister.
00:08:46 So to many of the people that we were talking to in Alberta, they sort of said, you know, these are the ones that we feel like we'll have we will have our voice heard.
00:08:55 And it's sort of interesting, William, to hear you say, talk a little bit about how Alberta elects its own senators, because you're right.
00:09:02 That's not something that's respected. We don't we don't see Justin Trudeau, the prime minister, appointing the democratically elected senators in Alberta.
00:09:10 He instead chooses to vote to appoint his own independent senators who are really just liberals.
00:09:18 And so it's interesting that there's another element here with the equalization.
00:09:22 I'll say that is another big reason why we want to cover this, because it's so interesting.
00:09:25 I've been writing about equalization for a very, very long time and the system doesn't feel fair.
00:09:30 It never has. It doesn't make a lot of sense, especially in this environment where everyone is suffering from a strained health care system.
00:09:38 Everyone needs more resources, every province. And so the idea that we're still pulling money out of a province like Alberta and putting it into provinces that, you know, have in some ways higher standards of living,
00:09:50 or at least they can deliver their services a lot cheaper. It just doesn't make sense.
00:09:54 So I think there are a lot of really important questions here that do matter to the entire country.
00:09:59 And I think, of course, it is that equalization question that makes us the most interested.
00:10:06 You know, everyone around the country is tuning in to watch.
00:10:09 And we know there won't be a direct impact.
00:10:11 They're not voting to remove the equalization.
00:10:13 They don't have that power.
00:10:14 However, I think it will send such a big signal and it will be such an important dialogue
00:10:19 that we will begin having if Albertans choose to vote yes on that question and yes to eliminate
00:10:26 equalization.
00:10:28 Yeah, that's a great point.
00:10:29 And I will say at the risk of thumping our own chest here, we've been covering Western alienation and the Western independence movement of those two are not synonymous for reasons I'm sure we'll get into this evening.
00:10:40 But we've been covering the Western alienation issue extensively.
00:10:44 And I'd say we're probably one of the only, if not the only non-Western media outlet that has been devoting that attention because we realize for all the reasons that you just mentioned, Candace, Alberta is very important in confederation.
00:10:58 And it's important to have this harmony across the country in the federal system.
00:11:02 And the equalization referendum has always been held up by a lot of people as being that
00:11:07 first step towards a more serious discussion of, let's say we do this, we vote on this
00:11:13 and see how the federal government responds.
00:11:15 And then we can sort of decide from there.
00:11:17 But I wanted to ask you, William, as someone who's actually in Alberta, you live there,
00:11:21 you've obviously had your finger on the pulse more directly than other people have here.
00:11:25 Is the equalization referendum a symbol of something bigger? Or do you think by and large, people are voting based on that very specific question of should we seek to change the Constitution to get equalization out of there?
00:11:39 You know, that's a really interesting question. I think when we see the results start to come in,
00:11:46 I think it may give us some idea of what was in the forefront of Albertans' minds when they voted
00:11:51 on equalization. For some, it is a rallying cry that says, you know, we are tired of being taken
00:11:58 for granted. We're tired of the federal government, particularly under liberal prime ministers,
00:12:02 ignoring the concerns of Albertans. We're sick of policies which seem targeted to harm our economy,
00:12:09 thinking about pipeline bans, the forcing of a carbon tax onto Alberta when it explicitly
00:12:15 rejected that idea. For others, they think it is a legal method that they can use. If the
00:12:21 Supreme Court will have a duty to enforce a negotiation, the federal government will have
00:12:26 to negotiate in good faith. That being said, that's never been tested before. We're not 100%
00:12:31 sure what happens when a non-cessation referendum question comes up for a vote. For others, though,
00:12:39 it's a referendum more on Jason Kenney's leadership. And I think because this was his
00:12:44 initiative, championed by him and his government, for people who are mad at Jason Kenney or who are
00:12:49 disappointed in him, who think that the handling of the COVID-19 pandemic hasn't been as good as
00:12:54 it should have been, some people may choose to vote no just because they don't like the premier.
00:12:59 So it'll be interesting to see how the vote goes as we start to get those results in.
00:13:03 Well, and also we heard from Nahid Nenshi, the outgoing mayor of Calgary, sort of going on a little Twitter rampage, saying to vote against the initiative to vote no.
00:13:14 William, do you think that that will have an impact?
00:13:16 I mean, to me, in my mind, it's like people liked Jason Kenney to begin with.
00:13:21 The reason that Jason Kenney won in such a landslide was because he had this solid sort of fiscal conservative underpinnings and he had that experience in the Harper government and he sort of talked the talk.
00:13:31 And so in my mind, people who even people who have been disappointed with the way that he's governed, you know, they still have that underlying fiscal conservative mindset and worldview.
00:13:42 And so it wouldn't so much be about Jason Kenney. It would more be about what's fair in Canada.
00:13:48 And if Jason Kenney can't communicate that, then what better way to do it directly?
00:13:52 That's my opinion.
00:13:53 But what do you think about that?
00:13:55 Well, you're absolutely right that our soon-to-be former mayor did take a couple parting shots on his way out the door.
00:14:02 Sometimes politicians, when they retire, do so gracefully. 0.84
00:14:05 But that wasn't Nengshi's style.
00:14:07 He basically used his last message to Calgarians to attack Jeremy Farkas, one of the leading mayoral candidates,
00:14:15 and to tell people they should vote no on the equalization referendum to quote unquote spite
00:14:19 Jason Kenney. I don't actually think you should make policy decisions just to spite someone but
00:14:26 I guess maybe the argument could be made that we're doing this to spite Justin Trudeau. I'm
00:14:30 not sure. That being said I think for a lot of undecided voters who may have been on the fence
00:14:37 about whether or not they should vote in the equalization referendum I would vote against
00:14:43 what Nenshi wanted because I'm kind of a conservative so Nenshi tells me to vote no I'm
00:14:47 going to vote yes that was my approach and as mentioned there Nenshi is up to be replaced
00:14:52 tonight in the Calgary elections we've got elections all over the province and one interesting
00:14:58 point I would raise here about the equalization referendum is that we might not know well we
00:15:03 won't know the total results until I believe the 26th what will we know tonight keeping in mind
00:15:09 polls are going to be closing in, I think, 19 minutes, 18 and a half, 19 minutes, as we come up
00:15:14 to 8 p.m. Alberta time. But what's the issue with the count here for the referendum, William?
00:15:20 It's a little bit tricky. It actually took a few days to try and get an answer to that question.
00:15:25 So while municipal elections are very clearly being run by municipal election authorities,
00:15:30 the Senate elections and the province-wide referenda are both provincial issues. Elections
00:15:35 Alberta has said they're not releasing official results until October 26th, but at least the
00:15:40 municipality of Calgary has said they're going to release the unofficial results to both the
00:15:45 Senate elections and the province-wide referendum tonight. Edmonton said they won't. Other
00:15:50 jurisdictions across the province, we don't know. We're going to try and keep an eye on it to see
00:15:53 how it goes. But I think as Calgary goes, it'll be a pretty good indication of where Alberta as a
00:15:59 whole is going to head on those issues yeah there is a divide though is there not between the cities
00:16:07 and the rural parts of the province like how much can you extrapolate from calgary and edmonton
00:16:12 results so i'm sort of thinking if edmonton is voting more one way and the rurals are voting
00:16:18 more of another way calgary is sort of in the middle halfway between big city halfway between
00:16:24 rural south. Its voting behavior tends to be in between Edmonton and southern constituencies when
00:16:32 you look at provincial and federal elections. So I think if Calgary is moving clearly in one
00:16:36 direction, that's going to be very helpful for us to know what the official results are going to be
00:16:41 on October 26th. If it's very, very close, if it's 51-49, then it's anybody's guess what the outcome
00:16:47 of those referendums will be a week later. Candace, we're moments away from our first
00:16:51 guests, but what are you going to be looking out for tonight? Well, it's kind of too bad that the
00:16:56 province couldn't get themselves organized enough to deliver, you know, results on what people are
00:17:02 voting on, not just because we're trying to do a live show here. It'll make it a bit more
00:17:06 interesting for us if we could walk away with that. But no, I think certainly the mayoral
00:17:11 race in Calgary is really interesting. You know, we got a free market sort of small government
00:17:17 guy in Jeremy Farkas, who looked like he had a big lead at the beginning of the campaign. I know
00:17:23 it's hard to keep track of polling in municipal elections because you really don't know until
00:17:28 the polls come in. But I think certainly after, I guess we've had Nenshi for what, 10 years,
00:17:34 William? It's definitely time for a change, I think. And I would welcome someone sort of
00:17:40 young and ambitious and, you know, committed to protecting the taxpayers like Jeremy Farkas.
00:17:48 Yeah, I know everyone tends to focus on the mayoral stuff.
00:17:52 And I think for good reason, obviously, the mayor, especially of a larger city, has the
00:17:56 ability to really set the agenda.
00:17:58 We saw Nenshi, for example, with trying to push an Olympic bid.
00:18:01 One notable example that has probably traumatized William by just mentioning it.
00:18:05 Sorry to bring you back there, William.
00:18:06 But there's also, interestingly enough, in Calgary, a huge number of just general vacancies
00:18:12 right now.
00:18:12 Like there's going to be a significant turnover on this council, isn't there?
00:18:16 You're absolutely right.
00:18:17 In fact, I went back 30 years and couldn't find a municipal election with more open seats.
00:18:23 Out of Calgary's 15 city council and mayor seats, 10 of them are open.
00:18:29 And one of them, Ward 2, there is an incumbent running again, but he's currently the subject of an RCMP fraud investigation.
00:18:36 So I think you can probably treat that seat as an open seat as well.
00:18:40 So 10 or 11 open seats.
00:18:42 It's an unprecedented number of open seats in a municipal election.
00:18:45 yeah i mean it's super interesting but i think that most the thing that most people look at is
00:18:51 the mayor you know that's the sort of bankable figure and again i think that nenshi was really
00:18:57 an outsized character for his role i mean he you know i i don't think that many people in the
00:19:02 country can name uh you know the mayor of of a smaller city i mean calgary's a big city but
00:19:08 even so i don't think most canadians could name the mayor of vancouver the mayor montreal
00:19:12 all. But, you know, everyone knew Naheed Nenshi. And I think that was part because of, you know,
00:19:17 the role that he played during the floods. And, you know, just being sort of an outspoken type
00:19:23 for all the consternation that we hear about, you know, conservatives and Canadians being
00:19:29 what racist, sexist, bigoted, whatever, whatever. You know, here we have Nenshi who comes from,
00:19:36 I believe he's Muslim man. And, you know, there is no problem with that. There was no problem.
00:19:44 Calgarians voted for him and he was, you know, a very public mayor. So I think that it will be
00:19:51 interesting, you know, just just to fill those big shoes. Right. As such a public figure out
00:19:56 in Edmonton. And then, yeah, I don't know what's next for Nenshi. William, have you have you heard
00:20:00 anything? Is he going to run federally? Is he going to run provincially? What do you think he's
00:20:03 going to do next? Yeah, there's lots of rumors. Rumors that he's going to be a federal liberal
00:20:08 candidate and that conversations have already had about him being a cabinet minister if he wins an
00:20:14 election. Rumors that he might go to the United Nations, that he's always had a bit of a flair
00:20:20 for international travel and affairs. I will say, having observed the mayor for quite a long time,
00:20:27 I find it hard to believe he's going to go into party politics because he doesn't particularly
00:20:31 play well with others. He holds himself in very high regard. And to be a minister means to be
00:20:37 kind of under the thumb of the prime minister. And I'm not sure he could ever be in that position
00:20:42 where he didn't get to be the boss. So don't know what his next job will involve, but lots of
00:20:47 rumors. What about the mayor of Edmonton, the former mayor, Don Iverson? What do you think
00:20:53 he's going to do next? Yeah, you know, he was first elected in 2013. So he's been there just
00:21:00 about eight years now. He's got a young family. I'm not sure what his plan is. Certainly, I would
00:21:07 think he's leaving his office in slightly less anger than Mayor Nengshi is. I think there was
00:21:15 a lot of people who were quite fed up with head Nengshi here in his final term. So I don't really
00:21:20 know. He hasn't sort of mused about it, but I would think for any former mayor, there's going
00:21:25 to be a lot of opportunity. I would say more opportunity than for a former MLA or MP, simply
00:21:30 because mayors do have profile in their own cities. This is True North's live election night
00:21:36 show. We've got Candace Malcolm, William Macbeth, and yours truly, Andrew Lawton. Candace, why don't
00:21:41 we go to our first guest here? Yeah, that sounds great. Well, we're very excited to have our friend
00:21:46 conservative strategist Vitor Marciano on the line. Hi, Vitor. How are you doing? I'm doing well.
00:21:52 It's going to be an interesting evening. All right. Well, let's unpack that a little bit.
00:21:57 What do you find interesting?
00:21:58 What's going to happen?
00:22:00 Well, you have literally Edmonton, Calgary, Red Deer, and Fort McMurray all getting new
00:22:06 mayors on the same night.
00:22:09 You've got, you know, one province-wide referendum that's going to set the tone for a bunch of
00:22:15 the politics that will happen in the next little while with the equalization referendum.
00:22:18 You've got this other referendum that will actually kind of change everybody's life on
00:22:23 a day-to-day basis, we think, if they actually implement it on the daylight savings
00:22:27 case. And then you've got a whole bunch of council elections and other items sort of happening all
00:22:35 across the province. So it's actually, you know, it's actually a day that's going to change an
00:22:39 awful lot of things that makes it kind of interesting. No, certainly. And that's why
00:22:44 we're doing the show, right? Because we think that it's interesting, not just to Albertans,
00:22:48 but to all Canadians. So Peter, let's go through, you know, what you said was interesting. Let's
00:22:53 are with the mayoral races so uh can you give us some overview tell us what you think is going to
00:22:58 happen in those in those big cities that you mentioned i can give you three of them i have
00:23:02 to admit that i have not paid as much attention to red dare as i should have so i'm going to leave
00:23:06 that one for for someone else to comment on it uh but yeah in edmonton you've got a longtime mayor
00:23:12 in don ivison who's retiring and you're either going to get um my prediction is that it'll either
00:23:18 be Amarjeet Sohi or Mike Nichols. So you're either going to get a move a little bit to the right,
00:23:24 maybe a move a little bit to the left. Well, I want to stop you right there,
00:23:28 Vitor, because I was a little surprised to hear that Amarjeet Sohi was the front runner,
00:23:31 because my understanding was that he, you know, we remember him from his time as a cabinet minister
00:23:37 in the Trudeau government. And, you know, my recollection was that he left office not being
00:23:43 the most popular guy up in Edmonton? I think that's completely fair. I think something very
00:23:50 odd happened in the Edmonton election, and that is that the Edmonton media decided to completely
00:23:55 ignore it. So I actually pointed this out on social media last weekend. You had the
00:24:01 holiday long weekend just before an election. I went to the Edmonton Journal main page,
00:24:07 the Edmonton Sun main page and the CBC Edmonton main page and none of them had anything about the
00:24:15 Merrill T race so you had a wide open Merrill T race and very very few news stories about it
00:24:22 and the net effect of that is that it massively benefits the people with the highest level of
00:24:29 name recognition and then because Mike Nickel was in the race it became a name recognition on the
00:24:35 right versus a name recognition on the left and my prediction is that tonight the left's going to
00:24:42 win this is Edmonton um it's a complicated mix Mike's probably a little bit more conservative
00:24:50 and a little bit more abrasive in his style than is traditional for Edmonton um and we're going to
00:24:58 get that it was a weird election in the sense that there were some newcomers to politics who brought
00:25:03 up some interesting ideas, but they got no attention. There were past councillors who
00:25:09 were in the race to win the election. Michael Oshry, Kim Crischel, they really didn't get
00:25:18 any attention until the last week of the election. So it really became a nickel-so-he
00:25:25 drag race. And I really expect that that's what we'll see tonight. And the question is,
00:25:31 Has Mike Nichol assembled enough of a coalition, stolen enough voters from Ashri, Khrushchev, Cheryl Watson, who was the newcomer, to beat Amarjeet Sohi?
00:25:44 Or has the fact that the left just didn't show up for this race other than Amarjeet Sohi,
00:25:52 mean that he gets to consolidate all of the liberal voters and all of the new democratic voters?
00:25:56 and, you know, strong support in the new Canadian community
00:26:03 and take it to a win.
00:26:04 So that's what I expect we will see come 8.45, 9 o'clock
00:26:09 when we start to see the votes coming in.
00:26:10 It'll be this drag race between Mike's right-center-right point of view
00:26:15 and Emergeet's left-center-left point of view.
00:26:21 But I say that with some amount of caution because in many ways,
00:26:25 Amarjit didn't talk about the issues very much. He really ran a personality campaign. He really
00:26:32 ran a name recognition campaign. You know, an awful lot of his media availabilities or
00:26:37 appearances at forums and that were kind of word salad-y rather than about anything specific.
00:26:46 So he is in many ways campaigning on not being Mike Nichol, which in some ways,
00:26:54 you know kind of takes us back to what's happening in calgary all right well let's jump to calgary
00:26:59 then what uh walk us through what you think is going to happen up down there calgary had more
00:27:03 media attention in the race than than edmonton so um you know the calgary herald the calgary sun
00:27:11 both covered the race more carefully and more intensely um cbc calgary spent money on doing
00:27:17 polling covered lots of the things in this race calgary to be fair has i think it's nine vacant
00:27:24 council seats whereas Edmonton only had four vacant council seats um but there was a deliberate
00:27:29 effort to um to lift up the race but in Calgary it's also evolved into a uh sort of left center
00:27:38 left race between uh uh Gondek and a right center right race with on the Farkas side
00:27:48 Bradfield, Jan Gomery, Bradfield and Davison were the two candidates that could have been sort of the centrist candidates in it.
00:27:58 They never picked up the steam that would have been necessary to vault them into the race.
00:28:04 Jan Damery, who's the left, the clear left of center candidate in the race, also never picked up the steam that would have hurt the joddy conduct. 0.90
00:28:14 so we're going to see a force race today I think between Farkas and Gondek it's going to be close
00:28:23 from the perspective of your experience as a campaigner because a lot of people if they were
00:28:31 to look at Calgary on a federal or provincial map they'd see the sea of blue with a couple of specks
00:28:35 of red yet on a municipal you have had a left of center mayor for quite some time you have a very
00:28:42 real shot of electing another left of center mayor. How does that square a city that's so
00:28:46 solidly conservative in federal and provincial elections, but not at all municipally?
00:28:51 It actually squares, if you think about it from some of the truths and the truisms that
00:28:57 conservatives talk about all the time, which is that people want more government from the level
00:29:03 of government closest to the people. If you actually think about that concept of subsidiarity,
00:29:06 um people want services and expenses and things paid for and done at the city level the problem
00:29:14 is that when conservatives run municipally they run as if they don't want anything to be spent
00:29:22 or or any money spent and they're anti-building things they they oppose things at the municipal
00:29:27 level and the truth of the matter is that the vast majority of the citizenry says well if you're
00:29:33 going to waste any money wasted on my street wasted on the road that i used to commute wasted
00:29:39 on transit that i might access to commute or to go to a concert or to go to a you know to a
00:29:44 downtown arena and so an awful lot of this is that uh is that folks in the conservative movement are
00:29:51 a little bit more ideological than the voters and the same voter who pretty comfortably votes
00:29:57 conservative at the provincial level very comfortably votes conservative at the federal
00:30:01 level wants a more activist government at the city level. You know, if the city wastes some
00:30:08 money, odds are I can see where they wasted it. It's not money that sort of disappears into the
00:30:13 ether. It's usually spent on things where I can say, well, I wouldn't have built that, but, you
00:30:19 know, we have it now. And an awful lot of conservatives who get involved in politics and
00:30:25 even in municipal politics end up working really hard on their ability to say no. And the truth of
00:30:30 the matter is at the municipal level the voters want people who are going to say yes or you know
00:30:36 your best case is probably a yes but and um you know uh if if jeremy farkas wins tonight he'll
00:30:47 be because in many ways the last month or two of his campaign have refocused and and try to be more
00:30:53 positive and more yes on things and the word no which would be the top word that folks would
00:30:59 associate with Jeremy over the years hasn't really been present in the campaign. If he doesn't win
00:31:05 tonight, it might be because he wasn't sufficiently yes enough to captivate that next
00:31:11 tranche or layer of voters who would swing in his direction because they actually do want to see
00:31:18 money spent on roads and transit and the sort of local services that they think makes a difference
00:31:25 in their community oftentimes as conservatives we you know we just want to say no to big things
00:31:32 at the national level and then we want to say no to dumb things at the provincial level
00:31:35 and then we translate that into saying no to things at the municipal level
00:31:39 and there's a bunch of voters who are prepared to you know to accept those things and and i think
00:31:46 you know good municipal politicians need to learn conservative municipal politicians need to learn
00:31:52 to say yes but or to say i really do care about building things that will make your life better
00:31:58 i'm going to try to do a better job of building them i'm going to try to avoid waste i'm going to
00:32:02 try to um you know look at these important projects that need to be built with a hard
00:32:09 keen eye to making sure that they're done well too often you know the the top conservatives at
00:32:16 city council their specialty is saying no to things and they're very proud of their record
00:32:20 of voting no all the time. One of the lines I always use is in municipal politics, in Alberta
00:32:28 at least, it's extremely rare for the leader of the opposition to be elected mayor. And if you're
00:32:34 always the person saying no, it's hard to get the top job because the voters usually want somebody
00:32:40 who's going to say yes a fair amount. Both Edmonton and Calgary, we have the leaders of
00:32:46 the opposition running today um they both try to do positive campaigns um if they succeed today
00:32:52 it's because they'll have convinced the voters that they are that they're that they're strike
00:32:56 the right balance between being tight with money and delivering the sort of services that they want
00:33:01 well that sort of reminds me of back in the day in toronto with rob ford you know he he was the
00:33:07 guy that was there to respect the taxpayers he had a very simple message but he was also
00:33:11 he was a subway guy he said yes to subways yeah exactly he so he was seen as someone who could
00:33:18 get stuff done but that at the end of the day he was really there for the taxpayer and he wanted
00:33:22 to get rid of the waste which sounds exactly like what you're prescribing there vitor and
00:33:26 before you jump in vitor i want to tell people polls are now closed it is 8 p.m so uh congratulations
00:33:33 you made it through a municipal and provincial election day we'll have results with william
00:33:38 mcbeth of true north in just a few moments but i wanted to let you know we are on top of it
00:33:43 uh polls have closed and i'm sorry for that interjection but it was a momentous occasion
00:33:46 carry on no problem i'm going to say that in big parts of calgary and in big parts of edmonton
00:33:51 the polls are closed and there's now a poll worker at the back of the lineup which is probably
00:33:56 halfway down the block so there's gonna people are going to be voting in a lot of places for
00:34:01 another 40 45 minutes uh i live in a part of edmonton that's got a high voter turnout and
00:34:06 And when I went to vote at like 145, it still took me almost an hour to get through there.
00:34:10 It's that bad today.
00:34:12 There were that many people lined up outside.
00:34:14 You get COVID, you get the six foot distancing, you get extra cleanup procedures inside the room.
00:34:20 It takes longer to vote.
00:34:22 It's a long ballot in Edmonton.
00:34:24 It's a longer ballot in Calgary.
00:34:28 You know, I don't expect that we're going to get very many results coming in very quickly.
00:34:33 So when you say a long ballot, do you mean because there's so many different candidates or because of all the different municipal councillors that are being reelected?
00:34:42 So both in Edmonton and Calgary, you get two ballots.
00:34:45 So there's a municipal ballot and then the provincial ballot with the Senate election and the two referendums.
00:34:52 In, you know, that provincial ballot is fairly long.
00:34:56 There's, I think, nine or ten people running for the Senate race.
00:34:59 You've got to pick three.
00:35:00 And then you've got the two referendums.
00:35:01 But then when you go to the municipal ballots, you've got in Calgary, you've got 20 some people running for mayor.
00:35:09 Now, there's only four or five serious candidates, but we've never built a mechanism for weeding that out.
00:35:15 So the list of people running is really quite long.
00:35:19 Depending on your ward at the council level, you can have as many as eight or nine people running.
00:35:24 then you've got school board and then Calgary on top of that has the non-binding recurring
00:35:30 plebiscite on fluoridation. I'm an Edmontonian so I get to laugh about this you know the rest of the
00:35:36 world has moved past the fluoridation debates of the 1970s Calgary enjoys revisiting them
00:35:42 at least once every 10 to 12 years. Yeah no there's definitely some interesting ones out there
00:35:48 I want to talk to you Vitor though about the equalization referendum because really that's
00:35:52 the big question in the night. That's the reason, part of the reason, probably the main reason why
00:35:56 Trenorth is covering this election, because we don't usually cover municipal elections, but
00:36:01 because this question was on there, it's so consequential to everyone in the country, because
00:36:05 we all, you know, at its core, Canada is a fiscal federation, right? We're here because we want to
00:36:11 be able to trade with each other. We want to be able to have this stable system in our economy.
00:36:16 And so, you know, this question of equalization was in the Constitution in 1982.
00:36:22 You know, I wrote my son column the other day that this is the first time in my lifetime someone in Canada will have to get to have a say on equalization other than politicians.
00:36:33 But I'm not even sure that in 1982 Canadians really had a say or if it was something that was just put in there.
00:36:38 So maybe you can walk us through the rationale, the thinking behind this question, and maybe the deeper question of whether we need equalization in this day and age in Canada.
00:36:49 well i mean that second question is a complicated one and there's lots of canadians who believe
00:36:56 that equalization is really important um you could have questions on the principle of equalization
00:37:02 ultimately the the point is separate entirely from the principle is the fact that equalization
00:37:08 as it is done in canada right now is fundamentally unfair and i and i i lay that out to you by saying
00:37:16 that from 2014 to just before COVID, Quebec ran five consecutive surpluses and set aside
00:37:22 $20 billion while collecting between $11 and $13 billion a year in equalization money.
00:37:30 So they are taking the equalization money and putting it in the bank, and they now have
00:37:36 a rainy day fund that exceeds the Alberta Heritage Fund, which was put aside through
00:37:43 oil and gas money, which is what ends up generating the extra money that the federal government has
00:37:48 for equalization. Equalization is an unfair deal where it takes federal taxes from Alberta that
00:37:56 never come back to Alberta and channels them to the poorer provinces and Quebec. And I say the
00:38:01 poorer provinces and Quebec because the formula is written in such a way that Quebec will get money
00:38:05 regardless. And at some point, something needs to be done about it. This equalization referendum
00:38:11 is in some ways a symbolic vote, but it's a symbolic vote to kick open the door to have
00:38:18 constitutional negotiations. And what will happen if the vote passes with a good number,
00:38:25 and I'm hoping that it will, is that the Alberta legislature will then pass a motion of the
00:38:32 legislature demanding constitutional negotiations premised upon the vote. That gets sent to the
00:38:37 other provinces and to the federal government who have a constitutional conventional obligation
00:38:44 to sit down and talk to alberta about this question um the only people who have opposed
00:38:50 the uh the equalization referendum are political science professors you know other than marin
00:38:56 and she uh everybody who said vote no are poli sci professors rachel notley has not gone on record
00:39:03 saying vote no. She's tried to talk it down in some ways, but she won't actually say that
00:39:08 Albertans should vote against it because she knows that a no vote actually diminishes the
00:39:12 negotiating position of any Alberta premier, of any political stripe for the long term.
00:39:19 What's probably going to happen is that for a little bit, you know, Albertans, I think tonight
00:39:24 are going to vote 58, 60%, maybe 62% in favor of the question, which is to remove equalization
00:39:32 from the constitution that will start the process of constitutional negotiations the federal
00:39:37 government will for a little while try to ignore it the big provinces will try to ignore it but my
00:39:43 prediction for you right now i'm going to get this on the record my my old boss actually wrote a
00:39:47 column about it this weekend is that over the next 18 to 24 months all of the small provinces
00:39:54 in confederation will say covid is bankrupting us we can't afford health care we can't afford
00:40:01 the changes we need to make to seniors care. Nobody wants to buy our debt. We don't have
00:40:06 the ability to print money. The federal government is going to have to change the formula on how it
00:40:11 transfers money for health care. And the net consequence of that is that all of the small
00:40:18 provinces are going to view the opportunity to have constitutional discussions as a net positive.
00:40:23 And they're going to, you know, the Council of the Federation will be demanding these discussions
00:40:26 in 18 to 24 months.
00:40:29 And if Alberta gets a good number today,
00:40:32 that is a good thing for Alberta. 0.91
00:40:34 It makes sure that when we discuss
00:40:37 how the heck this country is going to be able
00:40:39 to afford healthcare and improved seniors care
00:40:42 in a post-COVID world,
00:40:44 that at the same time we're discussing
00:40:46 having an equalization system
00:40:47 that has some level of fairness
00:40:49 where Alberta can't go through five years
00:40:52 of brutal economic impact
00:40:54 and still be paying into the rest of the country
00:40:56 While Quebec is having five years of tremendous economic growth and bringing in 11 to 13 billion extra dollars a year and setting aside essentially four billion a year of that into a little piggy bank of profit that they will use to fund themselves through even more largesse and even more bad spending over time.
00:41:16 It's such an interesting way of framing it, Vitor. And, you know, you mentioned that the big provinces will probably ignore it. Interesting, because I've been talking to Bill Buick, who's one of the people who was sort of the spokespeople for the Yes campaign. And his mindset was that the people who are worse off under equalization are Alberta first, then British Columbia, then Ontario.
00:41:39 And so, you know, you have two of the other big provinces right there that are also bleeding through the nose.
00:41:44 You had a great piece in the National Post, I think it was last week, Vitor, about how Canada's health care is just, you know, COVID is fundamentally broken.
00:41:52 When you compare it to even the poorest of the U.S. states, their ICU capacity is leaps and bounds ahead of ours.
00:42:00 And so it's hard for Canadians to wrap their head around the idea because we're so used to having this concept that we have this great health care system that's, you know, the envy of the of the world.
00:42:10 And it's really it's really shown that that's not true. And so, you know, we are going to at some some point, you know, we're going to be met with this issue of how are we going to pay for this?
00:42:21 How are we going to continue on this path? And I thought you had a great way of sort of summing that up.
00:42:28 So maybe just you can let the listeners know what what it was that you wrote in the National Post and what you think that the future of our health care system will be.
00:42:36 Well, I wrote the column because I'd seen a bunch of conservatives in Canada asking, why aren't we doing what Texas is doing? Why aren't we doing what Florida is doing? Why aren't we doing what a whole bunch of American states are doing?
00:42:50 Which is essentially pushing through the pandemic and saying that, recognizing that, man, you know, COVID zero is not a potential solution for a country that's open and trading with the world, which Canada has to be.
00:43:03 Frankly, we need our borders to be open, if only to bring in the number of immigrants we need to sustain our economic growth because we don't have population replacement to do it ourselves. 0.64
00:43:11 um and the but the reason we couldn't do that is we cannot absorb the punch that comes from
00:43:19 opening up uh society and going full on covid we do not have the hospital capacity in the richest
00:43:27 provinces in canada to get well in alberta we couldn't deal with 18 per hundred thousand people
00:43:34 sick at once. Now, there is no American state, not even the poorest state in the United States,
00:43:41 that couldn't handle 30 or 40 per 100,000 sick at once. And when you can handle that many more
00:43:49 people sick at once, when you've got that many more hospital beds, that many more doctors,
00:43:53 that many more nurses, you can absorb the punch that COVID is going to get you.
00:43:57 But when 18 people per 100,000, that's not 18 per 1,000, that's 18 per 100,000, is more than your hospital system can handle, you've got to do a whole series of policies designed around keeping COVID extremely low, which, by the way, means that you're going to have COVID for a much, much longer time.
00:44:20 and it's going to become a significant impact on society
00:44:25 and on your government finances
00:44:27 for a longer and longer period of time.
00:44:29 And then-
00:44:29 Very well said, Vitor Marciano,
00:44:31 conservative strategist,
00:44:32 always a pleasure as we break down things
00:44:34 that are happening in Alberta
00:44:35 that are tied into much larger themes
00:44:38 in Canadian politics.
00:44:39 Vitor, thanks so much for coming on.
00:44:41 Thank you for having me, Andrew.
00:44:42 Thank you, Candice.
00:44:43 All right, bye, Vitor.
00:44:44 You are tuned into True North's live election night
00:44:47 special for Alberta, municipal elections, Senate nominee elections, referenda galore at the
00:44:53 provincial and municipal level. We've got lots planned for the remainder of the evening. We'll
00:44:57 be joined later on by Danielle Smith. We'll break down the results we have coming in with William
00:45:03 Macbeth very shortly. And if you've watched any of our previous election night shows, you know that
00:45:08 we are here as long as it takes. We aren't going to be here live continuously until the 26th when
00:45:14 results come in we did plan for this so we are going to wrap things up at some point tonight
00:45:18 although that's not something we can take for granted as you may remember our conservative
00:45:22 leadership show uh infamously went i think like eight hours to 3 30 in the morning or so uh but
00:45:28 we are doing these and you know what these are not inexpensive to produce we've got a great team
00:45:32 helping us behind the scenes that makes this happen and more importantly the coverage we do
00:45:37 of these elections between these shows is not inexpensive we have people on the ground where
00:45:42 the stories are and we don't get any of the government money we don't get any of the bailout
00:45:47 funds we're not in that 600 million dollar club that justin trudeau created for mainstream media
00:45:52 journalists we are supported by people who value the work we do so if you're watching this show
00:45:57 if you're a regular viewer listener reader or even if you just pop in from time to time
00:46:02 if you value the perspective and angle that we bring and the coverage plans that we put forward
00:46:07 on all of these things please do support the work we're doing financially if you can by going to
00:46:12 donate.tnc.news. As I said, I mean, this is something that for us is a passion, but we've
00:46:18 got people to pay. It costs money to do this. And literally we're only able to do this because of
00:46:22 the people that value the work that we are doing. So I wanted to, if you are watching, put that plug
00:46:27 in. Candace, you know, the donors we have are always so supportive of the work. And I notice
00:46:31 a lot of them are from Alberta too. Absolutely. I think that it really, you know, the heart and
00:46:37 soul of the conservative movement in Canada exists in Alberta, even, and, you know, even though it
00:46:44 must be disheartening for people in Alberta, vote conservative, and you don't see, you know, a
00:46:48 government that reflects you in any way out in Ottawa, you know, the machinery behind the political
00:46:54 party, behind the conservative party exists in Alberta, that's where the donors are, that's where,
00:46:59 you know, the political sort of, you know, everyone goes and spends time in Alberta in the
00:47:03 conservative movement. Andrew, you go out there and speak all the time. And it's just because
00:47:07 connecting with people in Alberta, you really understand the way of life that they have out
00:47:12 there, the way that sort of freedom and family come first. And, you know, I wish that the rest
00:47:17 of the country thought a little bit more like Alberta and that the values of Alberta had more
00:47:22 of an influence on central Canada instead of vice versa, or in addition to vice versa, I should say.
00:47:28 But really, you know, we are all very interested in what's going on in Alberta. It deeply impacts the rest of the country. And I think it's just been a great opportunity for us to cover this election tonight and to find out what's going to happen, especially with the referendum on equalization.
00:47:46 Like Vitor was just really hitting the nail on the head when he was talking about the whole reworking of our system post-COVID because, you know, everybody's been struggling.
00:47:58 Everyone's health care system is at capacity, every province.
00:48:02 So, you know, some Canadians might be smug looking at Alberta and saying, oh, look at the way that they're handling this fourth wave.
00:48:08 And, you know, after they loosen restrictions over the summer, they're really getting hit hard.
00:48:11 But the reality is that, you know, we can see the writing on the wall.
00:48:15 it's going to happen across the country. As soon as the weather gets colder, we're going to get
00:48:20 that fourth wave is going to hit harder. And, you know, everyone talks about how the Delta variant
00:48:24 is more contagious than previous waves. I mean, you know, it's going to be a big issue for everyone
00:48:30 in Canada. So no one should be smug looking at another province when it comes to their capacity.
00:48:36 But anyway, you know, we think it's an important issue, which is why we're covering it here on
00:48:42 true north and also i should mention that the way that we're streaming this um show tonight i'm
00:48:47 actually able to see all of the comments uh on both facebook and youtube which is really cool
00:48:53 because usually when you're uh doing a live show you know you you've got a lot of things going on
00:48:57 on your screen in front of you but it's it's very cool so i i can actually you know when when people
00:49:02 are commenting we're we're reading it we're seeing it so you know keep us um keep us posted let us
00:49:07 know what you think of the show uh let us know if there's anything you think we should be talking
00:49:10 about. I'm interested in people in Alberta. Tell us what you think about the provincial
00:49:17 government and Jason Kenney. It's sort of the elephant in the room. We haven't discussed it
00:49:20 at all yet, Andrew, but Jason Kenney is the most unpopular premier in Canada. And he's had a
00:49:27 tremendous fall from grace just in terms of his support. You know, he can't really seem to please
00:49:33 anybody at this point. And, you know, seeing his popularity plummet has been disheartening as a
00:49:40 conservative, but also, you know, sort of a cautionary tale of, you know, what happens when
00:49:46 you sort of abandon some of your core principles and, you know, looking at the way that Alberta has
00:49:53 sort of particularly treated pastors, Christian pastors who have carried on with their services
00:50:00 despite really heavy handed COVID restrictions and restrictions that don't apply evenly, like
00:50:07 you have situations where, you know, you can go to a football game, but you can't go to church.
00:50:11 I mean, it's pretty ridiculous. And to see a conservative government, you know, over being 0.73
00:50:20 the one that's running it is just been incredibly sad and unfortunate, I think. So, you know,
00:50:27 some of us have mentioned that, you know, Kenny's unpopularity may, in fact, hurt this equalization
00:50:33 referendum, Vitor, who's much more connected on these things than I am, seem pretty confident that
00:50:38 the equalization vote would go yes, which a yes vote, the wording of the question is something
00:50:43 like, should equalization be removed from the Constitution? So you're voting yes, if you are
00:50:49 against equalization, which is a little confusing, if you don't read the question carefully. But
00:50:54 anyway, yeah, that's certainly something that I will be watching closely.
00:51:00 yeah and i mean obviously i don't knock vtor's knowledge and wisdom on this and i generally
00:51:08 don't make predictions so that i can't be wrong it's actually a great plan you should try it to
00:51:11 everyone tuning in but i will say if the referendum doesn't succeed or is very very close i do think
00:51:18 that those things you just talked about candace jason kenny's unpopularity will have been a huge
00:51:23 huge contributing factor for a couple of reasons i think a lot of people view this as kenny's pet
00:51:28 project. And in some ways that's fair because this was a campaign promise. It's something that
00:51:33 he has personally championed. At the same time, it also is something that he hasn't been able to
00:51:38 promote because for the longest time I was watching, knowing this was coming and sort of
00:51:43 waiting for the campaigns to get going. And there have been a couple. You've had Kevin Lacey of the
00:51:49 Canadian Taxpayers Federation with his fight equalization campaign. Bill Buick, who's going
00:51:53 to be on the show later on. And Fairness Alberta has had their fight equalization campaign.
00:51:58 Certainly, you've had a lot of discussions and interviews and op-eds and all of that.
00:52:03 But Jason Kenney really hasn't been selling this.
00:52:05 He hasn't been out there talking day in, day out about why Albertans should vote yes.
00:52:10 Some MLAs have spoken out about it, but there really hasn't been, I'd say, a lot of attention
00:52:14 given to it.
00:52:16 And even if you look at some of the money that the campaigns are spending, we're not
00:52:19 talking about huge province-wide campaigns here that are spending millions and millions
00:52:23 of dollars.
00:52:24 Like, you know, it's not like it's as hyped as the Quebec secession referendums, just to give it a referenda rather, just to give a comparison to a very large and much vaunted one.
00:52:35 So that isn't to say it won't succeed, but because of all these challenges in Alberta, and I think because Jason Kenney has been having to play defense, there hasn't really been a vocal standard bearer and flag bearer for this movement.
00:52:49 Yeah, that's a really good point. And I think that was probably very intentional on behalf of Jason Kenney.
00:52:54 he knows that he's not popular and that he doesn't want to put his name all over this twofold, right?
00:53:00 He doesn't want to bring down the referendum just because of his own personal unpopularity.
00:53:04 But he also doesn't want to hitch himself to it. If it gets defeated, then it looks even worse
00:53:09 for him. But yeah, I mean, it's been pretty low profile given how much was sort of drummed up at
00:53:18 the beginning. And also remember, Andrew, this was sort of Jason Kenney's alternative to the big
00:53:24 loud Wexit movement that came out of the 2019 election. I know you covered that you were out
00:53:29 in Alberta several times. And, you know, after that election, it was like this huge groundswell
00:53:34 of sort of anger and frustration and this very, very public movement. Wexit, I think it morphed
00:53:40 into the Maverick Party and its profile sort of fell. But, but, you know, the idea was that there
00:53:45 There's a lot of Albertans out there that were angry, that wanted out, including some pretty high profile business people and people in the business community.
00:53:53 And so the referenda was sort of like a, you know, an alternative as a way to keep Albertans sort of focused on the Canadian picture and keeping them focused on,
00:54:03 OK, we can still negotiate a better deal within Canada as opposed to this other movement that was really pushing in in a different direction.
00:54:10 So, you know, I think that that kind of anger, that big burst, that moment has passed.
00:54:16 And now we're sort of in this period where, you know, no one, like you said, no one's really, really heavily campaigning for it other than, you know, the sort of activist people that really understand the issue and that are pushing for it like Bill Buick, who we'll have later on the show.
00:54:33 It is 8.21 Alberta time.
00:54:36 Want to bring back into this True North's own William Macbeth.
00:54:39 I know polls have only been closed for about 21 minutes or so.
00:54:43 And as Vitor was saying, in some of the bigger cities, a lot of lines.
00:54:46 So people may still be voting even past the official closure.
00:54:50 Any early results here, William?
00:54:53 This will be a really quick analysis because there have been no posted results.
00:54:57 So it's a tie. It's neck and neck, you'd say.
00:55:00 It is the closest election I can recall.
00:55:02 we were just talking before you came on about the what seems like and again this may be my
00:55:10 my easterner perspective shining through but it seems like a lack of oxygen to the equalization
00:55:15 referendum outside of the circles that really pay close attention to this has that been your
00:55:20 experience in calgary in alberta that this hasn't been like one of these campaigns that you can't
00:55:26 walk down a street without seeing a sign for no i i absolutely think you're right it has been
00:55:31 very, very low key. You know, there's a few things that I think contribute to that.
00:55:36 Up until, you know, sort of mid-September, we were having a federal election. And I think for
00:55:42 a lot of people, this municipal campaign didn't even really get onto people's radar until after
00:55:48 that federal election wrapped. So they really only had about four weeks to get up and out. But,
00:55:54 you know, I was active on the no Olympics plebiscite vote, and I felt that that had far
00:56:02 more oxygen going into it than this equalization referendum has. And, you know, I think Vitor made
00:56:10 a lot of really important points about why Albertans appear to be voting very conservative
00:56:16 federally and provincially, but that we aren't seeing that reflected in mayoral campaigns.
00:56:22 I think one point he made, which is important, is we don't have municipal political parties, of course.
00:56:30 Anybody who wants to run basically can.
00:56:32 Calgary has 27 people running for mayor right now.
00:56:37 So, you know, how to stand out in a crowd of 27 people is really difficult,
00:56:43 which is why if you look in both Edmonton and Calgary,
00:56:46 the only people who are really getting any oxygen in that mayoral race are current or former city councillors.
00:56:52 who already have name recognition, who already have political infrastructure,
00:56:57 and who already have a base of support from which they can build on.
00:57:01 You know, the second thing I think that's interesting is, and we should talk a little
00:57:05 bit about, is the role of third party groups or political action committees or PACs.
00:57:10 Edmonton didn't see as many PACs as Calgary did.
00:57:14 Calgary saw a large number.
00:57:16 But the PAC that's being run by Alberta's public sector unions is spending upwards of $2 million to elect their preferred candidates in this race.
00:57:28 And given that unions and corporations are prohibited from giving money to local campaigns, that could well be more than what all of the mayoral candidates are spending combined in this election.
00:57:41 So, you know, I'll be interested to see exactly how much money they spent when the when the disclosure reports come out.
00:57:50 But there is going to be a I think a lot of money spent by public sector unions to vote for non fiscal responsibility candidates.
00:58:00 It's interesting that they that they find a way to sneak money into that.
00:58:04 What about the federal MPs or, you know, some of the more high profile politicians in Alberta, people like Michelle Rempel, have they gotten involved in the in the referendum debate at all over the discussion or they kind of left the state out of it?
00:58:17 I mean, a few of them have used their own networks to promote the referendum, the equalization
00:58:23 cause. Michelle Rempel, a prominent MP from Northern Calgary, has posted a few videos and
00:58:29 some other social media content about why it's important to vote yes on equalization. Stephanie
00:58:36 Cousy from the Southeast has also posted on that issue. But overall, not very much. You aren't
00:58:42 seeing a lot of activity from either provincial or federal representatives. I mean, I guess the
00:58:48 federal representatives, maybe you can explain it's just not their area, but you would think
00:58:53 that since it's a province-initiated referenda, that UCP MLAs would be campaigning door-to-door
00:59:00 even to try and get yes votes out for it. I think, though, that, again, the recent poll I saw
00:59:07 had the UCP down below 30% in popular support, they may have decided that this was the wrong time
00:59:13 to wrap this referendum around the UCP government. Let's unpack that a little, William. You know,
00:59:20 you're a conservative and you're in Alberta. What is happening? What is driving the UCP's
00:59:27 plummet in support? Why do people in the province feel so disappointed, dismayed with Jason Kenney
00:59:33 right now? Well, you know, I can't speak for every single conservative, nor would I try. But
00:59:38 I do think there are two groups of people in Alberta who are unhappy with Premier Kenney's
00:59:44 leadership. The first would be those who felt he did not do enough, that restrictions came too late,
00:59:49 that the Open for Summer campaign was a mistake, that we declared victory over COVID when, in fact,
00:59:57 we were not anywhere close to being ready for that. But that being said, I think a bigger
01:00:02 problem is probably the people who felt that Alberta's approach to COVID management was too
01:00:08 heavy handed. And the campaign it waged against religious institutions in particular, churches
01:00:15 and, you know, Christian churches in particular, because those are the ones we saw legal action
01:00:21 being taken up, pastors being arrested, police coming into holy services while they're being
01:00:28 performed by religious personnel. You know, the arbitrariness of some rules, why public gatherings
01:00:36 of some types were banned when others were allowed. A lot of this played very poorly with
01:00:42 conservatives who are always a little bit skeptical of big government anything. We don't
01:00:48 tend to think government is great at doing most things. And the bigger the task, the worse we
01:00:54 think government tends to do at it. So I think there was a lot of people who thought Jason
01:00:59 Kenney should have taken a much different approach to how COVID went. And in the same way that they
01:01:05 were disappointed maybe more wasn't done about Western alienation and Alberta's grievances
01:01:11 against the federal government, they also believe that he seemed to be showing too much aggression
01:01:16 in the enforcement of COVID rules in Alberta.
01:01:21 Well, yeah, that's certainly what I saw.
01:01:23 And I mean, it's one of those things
01:01:25 that the whole country has had that.
01:01:28 And we talked about it a little bit with Vitor,
01:01:29 how a lot of conservatives are saying,
01:01:31 where's the Ron DeSantis of Canada?
01:01:34 Why can't one of the provinces like Alberta
01:01:36 go the route of Texas or Florida
01:01:39 and just say, screw you to all the people 0.95
01:01:42 who are, you know, stressing unlimited forever restrictions, COVID zero, all that nonsense, 0.62
01:01:49 and just say, you know, let's live our lives. Let's get to herd immunity. Let's just like live.
01:01:55 And they wanted a conservative to do that. We didn't see that with Doug Ford in Ontario. We
01:02:00 certainly didn't see it with Jason Kenney in Alberta. The closest we got was that best summer
01:02:05 ever campaign, but then it seemed like they cowered on it right away. And to Vitor's point,
01:02:10 It's because we don't have the hospital capacity. It's like, you know, when you when you have a free society and you have a free country like like they do in Texas and Florida and you have, you know, private competitive hospitals, there's much more room for for people to go.
01:02:28 And unfortunately, the reality in Canada is that we have this very rigid government run health care system that that just doesn't we just don't have the capacity to to have people who need care in.
01:02:41 So I can see how you're kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place.
01:02:44 But boy, Jason Kenney's numbers are really looking bad.
01:02:48 Well, I think, you know, post this referendum, depending on what the outcome is and if the outcome go, you know, if it passes, maybe that's going to be helpful to Premier Kenney.
01:03:01 He'll be able to claim a victory. He'll claim a mandate to be able to negotiate with Ottawa for a better deal.
01:03:08 Certainly, I think Alberta premiers can find a boost in popularity by picking a big fight with a liberal prime minister in Ottawa.
01:03:16 It is a time-tested strategy to boost popularity if you can find a big fight.
01:03:23 And so that might be something.
01:03:24 But if he loses this equalization referendum, you know, he's already facing the prospect
01:03:30 of a leadership review in just a few months from now, in spring 2022.
01:03:35 And this may be another factor that weighs on delegates and voters' minds when they go
01:03:40 to decide if they want to keep him as leader or if they want to replace him before the
01:03:43 next election.
01:03:44 yeah i mean especially if it looks like he was not selling this referendum i mean if people start
01:03:52 to put a defeat at his feet pardon the other redundancy there the perceived redundancy i can
01:03:58 imagine that won't reflect too too well on him we will get back to breakdown results uh from you
01:04:03 william later on in the show go find some ballots though go find some ballots next time you come
01:04:08 back okay i'll go get my shoes and go see if i can find some on the streets all right you can
01:04:12 you can count these things quite easily. Candice, who do we have next?
01:04:17 Right. Well, we're really excited to be welcomed by our friend, Sheila Gunn-Reed,
01:04:20 who is the Alberta Bureau Chief for Rebel News. And Sheila, thank you so much for joining us on
01:04:25 our show tonight. What does your shirt say? I can't see it. Oh, my shirt says Glen Carrot for
01:04:30 mayor, a leader who listens. Now, Glen Carrot is a friend of mine. He's running for mayor of
01:04:36 Innisfail, Alberta. He's a high-profile Fight the Fines client there. He had the cops called on him
01:04:45 by, it sounds like another campaign, when he had the Easter Bunny at a campaign event earlier in
01:04:51 the spring. And he ended up in the Rebel News Fight the Fines ecosystem. But he's run completely
01:04:57 on an anti-lockdown, anti-vaccine passport mandate. And he was the organizer of United We Rule. So
01:05:03 while i generally don't like politicians and i tend not to endorse them except for
01:05:08 andrew you're a recovering politician um glenn is a good friend and he's one of the only candidates
01:05:14 out there running on an anti-lockdown platform so i am team carrot great i will just say just
01:05:21 for the sanity of our managing director william uh god love him we are as an organization non-partisan
01:05:27 we don't endorse so am i sheila sheila has done this all on her own but i do appreciate obviously
01:05:33 the opportunity to cover these people which is our our focus as a news organization no i i don't
01:05:38 want to uh put my endorsement of glenn carrot on true north at all no one can suck the oxygen out
01:05:45 of a uh discussion like i can with a disclaimer so take it away candace well you're gonna have
01:05:50 to keep us updated on uh you know the results as they come in sheila if uh you know if you have to
01:05:55 jump in and say breaking news you know this this this guy's one you can you can go ahead and do
01:05:59 that um so we were just talking a little bit about jason kenney and his sort of big uh massive
01:06:05 unpopularity in alberta which you know for a guy that got elected i think with what 62 percent of
01:06:10 the vote uh not too long ago maybe two years ago uh to see him hovering down sinking down i should
01:06:17 say to what 30 30 percent or less approval the lowest out of all the premiers and for for us
01:06:23 who aren't in alberta we're trying to sort of wrap our heads around that and try to think about how
01:06:27 that might impact this referendum on, on equalization. So, you know, you, you, you've
01:06:33 got your finger on the pulse of the province and, you know, we, we know that obviously your
01:06:38 fight fines campaign is, is really onto something. Same with your, your amazing coverage of some of
01:06:44 these Christian pastors who have had their, their services, you know, stormed by, by police
01:06:50 officers. It's like you're watching a different country. It's, it's, it's so mind boggling,
01:06:53 especially in a province run by a person who used to be one of the foremost champions of
01:06:59 religious freedom in the country. And I'm sure, you know, he still holds those values in Jason
01:07:05 Kenny, but really, you know, it's hard to watch some of the things that have happened in Alberta.
01:07:10 So maybe you can just help us understand what's going on in that regard. Sure. I mean, when you
01:07:17 look at the polling data, it doesn't look like a lot of those votes are swinging back to Rachel
01:07:21 Notley, about 10, 15 percent, maybe, depending on the polling that you look at. A lot of it is just
01:07:27 evacuating the Jason Kenney camp and it's going to other places. It's going to, you know, I'm
01:07:31 never voting again, sort of heading into that territory. But it's also going into some of the
01:07:37 breakaway parties, the sort of separatist parties, Wild Rose, some of those other fractured parties.
01:07:46 And I think that's one of the things about Albertans that sort of makes us unique in the political landscape is that we will burn it all down every few years or, you know, sometimes four decades with the PCs of old.
01:08:00 But we will burn it all down when we don't think our conservative candidates and our conservative governments and our conservative politicians, when we don't think they're conservative enough and behaving like conservatives.
01:08:11 We're not scared to do that.
01:08:13 And unfortunately, that's what's happening to Jason Kenney right now. While, you know, conservative politicians think they are owed our votes by nature of being conservative, for the voter, we really do make them earn it.
01:08:27 And we can't see Jason Kenney in 2021. We don't see the same guy that was elected back in 2018 or that sort of reached across the aisle and united the Wild Rose to the PCs after so much bad blood and and so much contention between those two parties.
01:08:49 He was able to be, for lack of a better term, politically ecumenical and unite those two parties.
01:08:55 We're not seeing any of that right now.
01:08:57 We're seeing someone who doesn't reflect his own conservative past with regard to the Office of Religious Freedom and his defense of religious liberty around the world.
01:09:06 We're not seeing someone who is politically ecumenical with other conservatives.
01:09:13 We've seen Jason Kenney say, if that's my base, I need a new base, referring to the anti-lockdown movement. So, you know, I think, you know, with some of the results tonight, I know Calgary is a very conservative place and Jeremy Farkas, I mean, he was pulling slightly ahead of his more left leaning competition there.
01:09:38 But in Edmonton, it's a complete and total collapse so far of the ability of conservatives to get the vote out.
01:09:46 And I think that has a lot to do with Jason Kenney.
01:09:49 Interesting. We were talking a bit before you said that the 2018 Jason Kenney is not the same guy that's leading the province now.
01:09:56 I think back then there was sort of this hope that, you know, Alberta was going through a really rough economic time with the price of oil falling and, you know, with Justin Trudeau in office killing all the pipelines.
01:10:08 And the idea was like, OK, here's this guy who was in the Harper government and he has a long history of of really proving his conservatism.
01:10:17 And he's sort of an outsider in regards to the provincial politics of Alberta.
01:10:23 He wasn't like in the sort of, you know, like you mentioned, the bad blood between the PCs and the Wild Rose.
01:10:29 And so he sort of came in and and really had expectations that were that were so high that no one could meet.
01:10:37 And so many things are just sort of outside of his control.
01:10:40 And so this this referendum question, to bring it back to that, you know, the idea was that there was so much anger after the 2019 election that the whole Wexit movement.
01:10:48 And I know you covered that really closely, Sheila, this idea that Alberta was going to separate.
01:10:53 I know some people in the comments are still saying Alberta should join the U.S. to be the 51st state, Alberta's succession, Alberta should go it alone.
01:11:00 And we did hear that a lot in 2019. I don't hear it as much. I still hear it occasionally.
01:11:05 But but the referendum question was sort of an alternative to that sort of angrier let's go it alone question.
01:11:13 And so do you think that this referendum really does capture the mood to say, like, let's let's keep Canada, let's keep Alberta in confederation.
01:11:22 let's keep this thing going, but let's try to negotiate a better deal? Or is there still a lot
01:11:26 of anger and this sort of like separatist crowd out there? You know, that's a really good question
01:11:33 and it's a very complex question because I do believe that the separatist sentiment is still
01:11:39 as high as it ever was. Although the two years out from that last election, there hasn't been
01:11:49 that has emerged from that movement.
01:11:52 There's sort of these little fractured parties
01:11:54 and they're having a hard time getting together.
01:11:57 And there's no one person
01:11:59 that has that sort of Ralph Klein mindset of,
01:12:06 you know, somebody once asked Ralph Klein,
01:12:07 what was his key to political success?
01:12:10 And he said, you know,
01:12:12 the ability to see where the parade is marching
01:12:16 and then just get out in front of it and lead it.
01:12:17 There's no one person that's really identified themselves as someone who can sort of take that juggernaut of separatist sentiment and take it somewhere because, you know, there, as you rightly point out, there are different ideas of what separatism means.
01:12:33 is it just a reflex against the unfairness of equality? Is it a rejig of our role in
01:12:42 confederation that we become more sovereign in the sense that Quebec is? Does it mean withdrawing
01:12:48 from confederation altogether? Does it mean joining the United States? There's nobody that
01:12:53 has really articulated what or where the separatist movement in the West should be going.
01:12:59 And furthermore, the fact that Quebec has already gone through this, there's a lot of resources out there that Westerners can just reach into Quebec and grab the expertise and say, what did you do to deal with this issue?
01:13:12 How did you figure out this issue? How did you address that criticism of what you were trying to do?
01:13:18 Nobody's really done that in Alberta, and I don't really understand why.
01:13:21 And I think Jason Kenney's referendum question is sort of appeasing some of those separatist sentiments.
01:13:28 And frankly, as an Albertan who pays pretty close attention to these things, it's kind of my job. I haven't really seen any passion about this referendum question. The Conservatives weren't out there selling it. They weren't campaigning on it.
01:13:48 it was like nobody cared um very maybe it got lost in the pandemic or maybe it was just
01:13:56 lip service to the anger of westerners i can't really tell because there wasn't a lot of
01:14:03 discussion about it at all outside of like really keen political watchers like we are
01:14:07 yeah you raise an important point there sheila and we were talking about that a little bit earlier
01:14:13 and all of us sort of wondered if actually it would make matters worse for those wanting
01:14:18 a yes vote on equalization if Jason Kenney and the UCP were behind it, given their fortunes
01:14:23 right now. But I also think at the same time, when you look at the Fair Deal panel, which was
01:14:28 criticized, I mean, notably by one of the members of the Fair Deal panel, Drew Barnes, who's now
01:14:33 been ousted from the UCP caucus for criticizing Jason Kenney. There were a lot of recommendations
01:14:38 in there. Obviously, some people thought it didn't go far enough. Equalization is just one of many
01:14:44 grievances that the Western alienation mindset people and Western independence mindset people
01:14:50 and outright Western separatists have. It's one issue. And one of the challenges here is that I
01:14:55 feel it has served as a very convenient excuse to not do anything else because it allows the UCP to
01:15:03 say, all right, well, let's just see how this referendum goes. There are a lot of things that
01:15:06 could be done right now unilaterally by the province, such as securing an Alberta police
01:15:10 force, moving on an Alberta pension, moving to collect income tax in Alberta like Quebec does,
01:15:16 downloading a couple of federal provincial programs to become predominantly provincial
01:15:21 in responsibility. There are a lot of things in that list. And that was just, you know,
01:15:25 one off the top of my head that Alberta could do without a referendum, that Alberta could do
01:15:29 without any federal buy-in or constitutional change. But I feel by putting all the eggs
01:15:34 in the referendum basket, you kind of just are able to take everything else off the table for
01:15:39 now politically. Yeah, it feels like they're sort of shuffling deck chairs on the Titanic a little
01:15:45 bit. I mean, we did earlier this year get our own chief firearms officer. So that was one of the
01:15:51 recommendations that came out of the fair deal panel. And then this, but that the chief firearms
01:15:58 officer is really just a sort of symbolic thing. It doesn't really change the gun laws that are
01:16:02 being drafted by the federal government. And you just might feel bad when she's taking your guns 0.78
01:16:07 that trudeau has banned yeah yeah poor lady justin trudeau made her do these things to us but it
01:16:12 really doesn't change you know the the aspect of um the federal law surrounding that so i mean it
01:16:17 was a symbolic gesture that we you know we're going to have our own person i guess confiscate
01:16:23 our guns but yeah i i'm with you on this where it does feel like um like i said earlier just sort
01:16:29 of paying lip service to oh look at us we're standing up to justin trudeau but this comes
01:16:36 after three years of strongly worded letters and not much else.
01:16:41 And we were talking about this a little earlier.
01:16:43 I mean, you mentioned that there wasn't really a lot of steam.
01:16:45 Like we didn't hear much from federal MPs.
01:16:47 Like I was sort of, I know Michelle Rumpel has been pretty vocal
01:16:50 and she had her old Buffalo Declaration that was outlining as well,
01:16:54 sort of different things that Alberta could do.
01:16:55 And I haven't heard anything from her on this.
01:16:57 We didn't hear much from Jason Kenney.
01:17:00 And so it's almost like, I mean, I don't even know what to expect.
01:17:04 we had Vitor Marciano on earlier and he predicted that the people would vote yes somewhere around
01:17:10 55 to 60 percent, which, you know, that would be a pretty strong message. But I don't even know
01:17:15 where that prediction would come from. I don't know if there's been polling out there. But
01:17:18 what do you think is going to happen tonight, Sheila? I think it will be around 55 to 65 percent.
01:17:26 I'm only loosely basing that on my own estimation of just how many people are going to vote in
01:17:32 favor of the referendum question in calgary and then in the rural municipalities it's sort of the
01:17:38 same thing um to become the premier of alberta you have to win edmonton or calgary and all the
01:17:43 rural areas i think that's sort of what's going to happen with the referendum question of course
01:17:48 edmonton being the seat of government and again referring to ralph klein a place with too many
01:17:53 socialists and mosquitoes as he once said um that's going to be you know a lost cause when
01:17:59 when it comes to the referendum question and Amarjeet,
01:18:02 so he is likely to become the mayor there.
01:18:05 You know,
01:18:05 a proponent of Justin Trudeau's carbon tax gun grab and all those bad
01:18:11 things that Justin Trudeau has done to Alberta in the last six years.
01:18:15 That's Edmonton's going to vote for that.
01:18:17 I don't know if you want to talk a place that's culturally incompatible
01:18:21 with the rest of Alberta.
01:18:23 It's Edmonton.
01:18:24 It's Edmonton.
01:18:25 Well,
01:18:25 I lived there for four years and you know,
01:18:27 it's funny.
01:18:28 Most of my friends up there are pretty conservative, but, you know, it's probably just because you tend to attract like minded people when you're up there.
01:18:36 But I will say the University of Alberta was a pretty hostile place to conservatives, which for me, you know, I grew up in Vancouver and I thought, OK, I'm going to go to University of Alberta.
01:18:44 It's going to be super conservative, right? Because you just think Alberta is a conservative place.
01:18:49 University of Alberta is going to be conservative. And boy, was I wrong.
01:18:52 There was there was a lot of emphasis on the university, not the Alberta.
01:18:55 Yeah, I guess so. Yeah, I didn't know that. But I learned. Well, you know, in some ways, it's kind of a sad state of affairs, Sheila. You said that there's no real leader leading the charge on sort of putting Alberta first or if there were any kind of a secession or just more independence movement.
01:19:12 there isn't really a leader of that, even though there are some very articulate, interesting people
01:19:18 that are proponents of it. I'm thinking of people like Barry Cooper, who's a professor down at the
01:19:24 University of Calgary, and many others. But I feel like the state of conservative politics more
01:19:30 broadly is that way. You know, you have a federal party led by Aaron O'Toole, who once told us that
01:19:36 he was a true blue conservative, he was the real deal. And then in the campaign, what we saw was
01:19:42 you know Justin Trudeau with a blue tie on and you know at the provincial level you have a lot
01:19:50 of people who are super disappointed in Jason Kenney super disappointed in Doug Ford out in
01:19:54 Ontario and you kind of look around the country and you wonder where where are all the strong
01:20:00 conservative voices where where are sort of the next generation of leaders in this movement and
01:20:06 And it's sort of slim pickings right now.
01:20:09 I mean, maybe someone like, you know, Jeremy Farkas down in Calgary might be a bright light in the province and conservative movement more broadly.
01:20:17 But why do you think the conservatives have become so bad at producing really, you know, interesting, impressive leaders?
01:20:25 And why don't we have more people filling the void and sort of being that next generation of leaders in this country? 0.99
01:20:31 yeah it's very strange that canadian conservatives like the official conservatives they have a real
01:20:38 tough time um doing the whole youth recruitment thing as much as they'd like to have the youth
01:20:44 wing of the party they don't do a really good job of it and when and they're not doing a really great
01:20:49 job of learning about what happened in the united states you know the the boldest conservatives
01:20:55 there are the most popular and in canada the boldest conservatives end up sort of experiencing
01:21:02 tall poppy syndrome where the other conservatives come along and chop them down and uh you know
01:21:08 they all get ousted from the parties yeah the boldest conservatives are the strongest independence
01:21:12 yeah they go off into the wilderness and then no one wants anything to do with them anymore because
01:21:17 they're splitting the right and it's like yeah well and it's for me as a conservative i think
01:21:24 one of our best qualities but one of our the things that makes us least electable is the fact
01:21:28 that we are independent we have interesting ideas and we don't always go along to get along and we
01:21:35 aren't always just you know interested in winning at all costs which is i it's great because it
01:21:42 fosters this diversity of ideas but at the same time it makes us tough to be elected because
01:21:47 you know there there are conservatives who just won't vote for the sake of gaining power but with
01:21:54 regard to young conservatives, we really don't do a good job at harvesting, I think, the young
01:22:00 angst of conservatives. I have a son, he's, you know, in his early 20s. And, you know,
01:22:09 when we're talking, when he was a little bit younger, I would say, you know, that feeling
01:22:14 where you don't like being told what to do all the time, you don't like me telling you what to say
01:22:17 and how to behave. I'm like, that's how I feel every single day as a conservative. That's how
01:22:21 I feel about the government and we do a really good a poor job at telling young people that you
01:22:28 know it's okay to be conservative it's okay to not want to be told how to talk and and and to
01:22:36 you know say things and young people by nature are really not um politically correct that's you know
01:22:43 it's one of the great things that that my son has going for him but it's really irritating as a
01:22:48 parent but you know like the second we have a young conservative learning how to be conservative
01:22:53 and they say something that's not exactly pc we just throw them out of the party and uh you know
01:22:59 these are our best and brightest and our leaders of tomorrow and we're just sort of throwing them
01:23:03 out like literally throwing the baby out with the bath water i think it's a terrible idea
01:23:06 and it's one thing they do much much better than us in the united states rebel news alberta bureau
01:23:12 chief sheila gun reed joining us live sheila always a pleasure thanks for coming on thanks
01:23:17 for having me on guys you are tuned into true north live alberta election night show i understand
01:23:23 we do have some results coming in so we will get those uh broken down and go to our correspondent
01:23:29 william mcbeth very shortly but first i want to bring into this discussion danielle smith who is
01:23:34 the president of the alberta enterprise group and no stranger to running for office in alberta and
01:23:40 actually holding office in alberta danielle welcome great to talk to you again
01:23:44 oh we are uh still waiting for danielle sorry about that we'll uh we'll get her on in just a
01:23:52 moment as we have some tech issues maybe we'll go to william in the interim here uh william what
01:23:58 results are we seeing so far so we are getting uh some results from both edmonton and calgary
01:24:04 in edmonton um as as was kind of expected amrajit so he is leading by about eight percent 38 to 30
01:24:13 over conservative Mike Nichol, but that's a very early result. Only about eight polls are reporting
01:24:19 so far out of about 200, so I don't think we can call that one yet. But in Calgary, it is starting
01:24:26 to look like we're going to be close to being able to call the mayoral race for Jody Gondek.
01:24:32 She is a one-term councillor. She's presently leading with 45% of the vote and about half of
01:24:39 the polling stations, a little over half the polling stations reporting. Next closest is
01:24:44 Jeremy Farkas, who's at 29%. And so given that it's a gap of 16% with more than half of the
01:24:52 polling stations reporting, I think we're getting pretty close to being able to say that Jody Gondek
01:24:57 will be the next mayor of Calgary. And then in terms of the equalization vote, not as we talked
01:25:04 about earlier, not every jurisdiction is reporting those results tonight, but we are getting results
01:25:08 from Calgary so far. About 57% so far are voting yes on the equalization referendum. That's pretty
01:25:16 close to what Sheila guessed would be the case. 43% voting no so far. And in the Senate race,
01:25:25 we're seeing the three candidates endorsed by the Conservative Party of Canada far out in front
01:25:30 of any of the other candidates in the election. So, and that's with about half, 161 polls reporting
01:25:38 in calgary so far great thank you very much for that update william we'll check back in with you
01:25:44 very shortly i understand now we have danielle smith standing by and just so she doesn't get
01:25:49 short-chained on the introduction she is the president of the alberta enterprise group danielle
01:25:54 always a pleasure thanks for coming on nice to see you one of the things as we just hear these
01:25:59 results that jody gondek it sounds like is on track to be the winner of the calgary mayoral
01:26:05 raise. We're not calling it officially, but she's very much in the lead with a pretty significant
01:26:09 number of the polls in. Similarly in Edmonton, not as many polls in yet, but Amarjeet Sohi
01:26:15 in the lead there. You wrote a great analysis. It was, I think, very sobering for people on the
01:26:21 right in your newsletter on this yesterday. And you said that there really isn't much in the way
01:26:27 of infrastructure for people on the right in municipal politics. And I think we're seeing
01:26:32 this now in the most conservative province in Canada, very poor showings in the biggest cities
01:26:37 in that province. We've got two problems, I think. Well, maybe more than two, but two that I have off
01:26:42 the top of my head. One of them is that we always split the vote among conservatives. And so in both
01:26:48 Edmonton and in Calgary, we ended up with three or four sort of conservative or center-right
01:26:54 candidates, and then one identifiably progressive or leftist candidate. And as a result, the unions
01:27:01 who had strong PAC support in Calgary,
01:27:06 political action committee support in Calgary
01:27:08 and a little bit up in Edmonton as well.
01:27:10 They're able to provide the funding for one candidate,
01:27:14 which allows them to get their signs
01:27:15 and get their message out and get volunteers
01:27:17 and get lit drops.
01:27:19 Whereas the Conservatives,
01:27:21 the ones that I spoke with,
01:27:22 had a really difficult time raising any sort of funding.
01:27:26 That's the other part of the problem
01:27:27 is that we love to have this puritanical idea
01:27:31 that there should be no big money in politics and so at the federal and provincial level we got rid
01:27:35 of union and corporate donations and so they decided to do the same thing at the municipal
01:27:40 level problem is there's no tax receipt to give a contribution to a municipal candidate and there's
01:27:45 no rebates like there is at the federal level and so if you're a brand new candidate right out of
01:27:49 the gate you're trying to get money from friends and neighbors and you're competing with all the
01:27:53 other things that they could be giving money to so we've really starved out our municipal level
01:27:59 of office, of money, of organizers. There seems to be a real lack of interest among conservatives
01:28:04 about municipal office. And I don't understand why that is, because the left has understood
01:28:09 that you can use municipal office as training ground for your candidates for provincial and
01:28:14 federal office. And we don't do that in municipal politics, and we should. Maybe this is unique to
01:28:19 Alberta. Maybe you have more interest, particularly in Toronto, where it's a much bigger representation
01:28:26 base, but I would say generally speaking, we don't do a very good job of cultivating the local level
01:28:31 of office and local candidates. No, and we were talking about this earlier in the show with Vitor
01:28:36 Marciano. He said, you know, there's a conservative instinct to say, we don't want the federal
01:28:40 government to spend anything. We don't want the provincial government to spend anything. And I
01:28:45 mean, unless you want no governments to spend anything, which I think is an entirely defensible
01:28:48 position and probably the one I take on a lot of issues. Conservatives, generally speaking,
01:28:53 are on board with local government, direct democracy.
01:28:57 I mean, the best thing you can do
01:28:58 if you're a diehard conservative activist
01:29:00 is get involved on a school board,
01:29:02 get involved at the local level in politics.
01:29:05 But it becomes very difficult to actually transition that
01:29:08 into a movement and to do it in the way that the left does it.
01:29:13 It's very true.
01:29:14 And I think part of it is that you do have this union dominance
01:29:17 that happens at the municipal level.
01:29:19 For some reason, we always get higher turnout
01:29:22 at the federal level for prevent for elections and then followed by the provincial level and then
01:29:27 municipal and so if you happen to work for the city that you're uh somebody works in transit
01:29:33 or you work as a city worker in permitting or in tax collection or any of the other services cities
01:29:38 provide then you at police fire you've got a vested interest in trying to see who gets elected
01:29:44 on council and so those groups do tend to organize and get their members organized and then they get
01:29:50 get their friends and family organized. And as a result, you do end up with a complexion,
01:29:54 even in Calgary and Edmonton, which should be the most business minded and entrepreneurial
01:29:58 cities in the country, since we're the most conservative province in the country, you would
01:30:02 expect that our two major cities would represent that they've got two thirds of the population
01:30:06 after all, but it doesn't seem to be turning out that way. So this is this is a real problem.
01:30:11 The other side of the other issue, though, is that COVID derailed everything for conservatives
01:30:16 over the last year and a half because conservatives really couldn't find a position that was
01:30:21 consistent with what the majority of their membership base wanted because that's so
01:30:25 offside with what the general public wanted. And I think in Calgary in particular, it's become a
01:30:31 bit of a referendum on who do you trust to get you through the fourth wave and the fifth wave
01:30:36 and whatever other future waves there would be. And the candidate that's in the lead right now,
01:30:41 Jody Gondek is the one who took the strongest and most strident and most challenging position to the
01:30:47 provincial government right from the get-go. And it could well be that that became the ballot
01:30:51 question and the other candidates weren't able to catch up. I mean, it's still early days in
01:30:56 the counting and it could change, but that's a pretty big lead to try to overcome. Let's turn
01:31:02 to the referendum here. Now, this is something that for political diehards like us who want
01:31:07 you know, results tonight, and we would have stayed up till 5am for them, we won't get that
01:31:11 privilege, because for the most part, they aren't going to be reported officially until the 26. So
01:31:16 all we have to go on are the municipalities that are reporting them tonight. And I think Calgary
01:31:20 is probably one of the only ones. But it sounds like again, even though it's a bit early,
01:31:25 the Calgarians are favoring the equalization vote. Do you think we can extrapolate from that beyond
01:31:32 Calgary? It'll be interesting to see what happens in Edmonton because with the Calgary and Edmonton
01:31:38 we'll make up two-thirds of the vote. Calgary had 57% I think was the last time I looked
01:31:42 in favor of taking equalization out of the constitution 43% opposed. If you end up with
01:31:48 roughly similar numbers in Edmonton and I can guarantee you that in the rural areas it'll be
01:31:53 even higher than that may end up pumping over over 60% support and I think that if you are
01:31:58 trying to do the test of do you have a clear question and a strong mandate, then that would be
01:32:04 yes and yes. And so the hope behind that is that it's going to prompt a national discussion,
01:32:11 that the federal government is going to have to take the vote seriously. They can't just shrug
01:32:15 and say, yeah, whatever. I know that you want to change the constitution, but we're just going to
01:32:18 go do other things. The opinion of constitutional experts is that now because of various Supreme
01:32:25 court precedents that we've had. It obligates the federal government to take it seriously and to
01:32:29 negotiate in good faith. And so how that plays out after this is going to be interesting to see. I
01:32:34 suspect from the straw poll of what we see in Calgary, the rest of the country better get ready
01:32:38 because the conversation's beginning. We know, and trust me, I believe you when you say that,
01:32:44 the constitutional precedent from the Quebec case that the Supreme Court weighed in on
01:32:49 is very clear. And I know we're going to be talking to Bill Buick about this later on,
01:32:53 who's done a lot of work on this as well. At the same time, I also am not holding my breath,
01:32:58 given that just earlier this year, for example, Justin Trudeau sat down with Jason Kenney.
01:33:03 Jason Kenney said, you know, hey, we're having these Senate elections coming up. We really would
01:33:07 hope you'd hold off on appointing any. And Justin Trudeau said, well, you know, I don't know. And
01:33:11 then a couple of weeks later, Justin Trudeau announces Alberta Senate appointment. So I don't
01:33:16 think the federal government, this particular federal government has shown a willingness to
01:33:21 play ball necessarily. And I guess I would ask you as someone who's led a provincial political
01:33:26 party and movement, what would your next move be? You have the referendum, you have the mandate.
01:33:31 How would you play that card? Well, I think that you begin the negotiations,
01:33:35 but then you make immediate moves to do what Quebec has done. You say, okay, Ottawa, we're
01:33:41 going to collect our own personal income tax. We don't need your help doing that anymore.
01:33:44 You give notice to the RCMP that you're going to be canceling the contract and establishing an
01:33:48 Alberta Provincial Police that we don't need the RCMP anymore. And you tell Ottawa that we'll be
01:33:53 opting out of the Alberta, out of the pension plan, and we'll be creating our own Alberta
01:33:57 pension plan as well. Those are things that are completely within our power and control to be
01:34:02 able to do. And if the Premier gets the mandate that he has on this, let's remember equalization
01:34:08 is a federal program. To get it out of the Constitution requires 7 out of 10 provinces
01:34:14 representing 50 percent of the population to agree. But I think that this would show that the
01:34:18 premier has enough of a mandate to move on the things that he really does have control over.
01:34:22 And that's what I would hope to see, because those things will those things will matter.
01:34:26 Those things will will will cost the federal government money and it will make the other
01:34:30 provinces pay attention to. But I think that that it would be easy to to ignore or put this on a
01:34:38 slow train to any kind of resolution without a couple of follow ups. So I think the premier is
01:34:42 going to have to move on a few of those things yeah and you're right it also gives premier kenny
01:34:47 i mean it leaves him with nowhere to hide quite frankly because all of a sudden he has this
01:34:52 mandate his base is going to expect him to do something with it he certainly will although
01:34:57 you know i suppose he could say that it's not a strong enough mandate i'm not sure why he would
01:35:02 do that um i am a little bit surprised i want to talk to the 43 of calgarians who still think that
01:35:08 we should be spending $13 billion on Quebec so that they can subsidize hydroelectric power.
01:35:13 I'd love to know why they think that. Who are those people?
01:35:16 It is a good question. Some of them must be federal liberal supporters, although we don't
01:35:21 have that many. Some of them, I would think, would also be those who really do believe that Alberta
01:35:27 should play a leadership role in helping its neighbors. I think that if you asked me, do you
01:35:31 want to help PEI, my answer would probably say, yeah, I kind of want to help out PEI. But if you
01:35:37 asked me if I want to keep on shoveling money to Quebec so they can be hostile to the development
01:35:41 of our energy sector? My answer is hells no. So I think that's maybe the issue is that perhaps
01:35:46 equalization needs to be reformed so that it can support the smallest provinces as it was intended,
01:35:53 but it should not be there so that it creates a slush fund to help the federal liberals win
01:35:59 votes in Quebec, which is I think the way the 57% who said, yes, we need to get rid of this clause.
01:36:05 that's probably how that group sees it. Hey, I'm jumping in right here, Danielle. Nice to have
01:36:12 you on here. Sorry to interrupt you. Andrew, I wonder if Nikit Nenshi, I know he has a pretty
01:36:17 inflated view of himself. So he probably thinks that the 43% is driven by his Twitter rant that
01:36:24 he went on earlier today. But Danielle, I wanted to ask you, you understand Alberta politics
01:36:29 better than most and better than I do, certainly. We've seen Jason Kenney sort
01:36:35 of have a fall from grace recently. And we were talking earlier about how his approval numbers
01:36:39 are just really low. And so what do you think he needs to do, Danielle, to turn things around? I
01:36:44 mean, he's not in any imminent danger of getting removed. It doesn't seem he's got he seems like
01:36:50 he's got, what, seven, eight months until the UCP convention. So, you know, what do you think he
01:36:55 can do to win over conservatives who might have a negative opinion of him right now?
01:37:01 You know, I think the thing he needed to do, but he's disinclined to do it, is he needed to
01:37:05 take a little more of a strategic and surgical approach to how he imposed some of the new
01:37:11 measures, the vaccine mandates, the vaccine passports, the restrictions on various businesses.
01:37:17 There's an appetite for that in Calgary and Edmonton, undeniable. There's no appetite for
01:37:21 that in rural Alberta. And I got the impression, you can correct me if I'm wrong, I got the impression
01:37:27 that the harshest measures in Ontario were not applied across the board, that there was a little
01:37:33 bit more of a surgical application. So I think that's been one of his mistakes. The other mistake
01:37:38 that he's made is just flip-flopping that he, when he makes up his mind, he's a hundred percent dug
01:37:43 in. And then when he changes his mind, it's 180 degrees in the wrong direction. And then he digs
01:37:48 in again, a hundred percent. And people just don't trust now. They don't believe that when he says
01:37:52 that what he's saying now is, oh, well, we'll have vaccine passports only until the first quarter of
01:37:59 2022. I think a lot of people are saying, yeah, I'll believe that when I see it. What I would
01:38:03 have liked to have seen him do is I would have liked to have seen him, if he was going to go
01:38:08 down the pathway of Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, then he needed to do some of the things that
01:38:12 Florida Governor Ron DeSantis did. One of the main things he did was focus protection and make sure
01:38:17 that our seniors in nursing homes are taken care of as the first priority. He needed to have early
01:38:23 treatment options. We have no early treatment protocol in any province in Canada. The treatment
01:38:29 protocol is, gee, go home. And if your lips turn blue, go to the hospital. He could have been a
01:38:33 pioneer in saying, we don't think that's good enough. We're going to make sure we have early
01:38:37 treatment. And he could have made sure that we had monoclonal antibody treatment, which is approved
01:38:41 by the WHO, so that anybody who did get hospitalized would know they were going to be taken care of.
01:38:46 That's where I think he went wrong, is that you can't say, okay, all the restrictions come off,
01:38:51 and then we're going to do precisely nothing. He had to do something. And I think that's where he
01:38:55 ended up with the problem. I don't know that he'll change focus now or change direction now.
01:38:59 but that's part of the reason is that he raised expectations pretty high that he was going to go
01:39:04 down the path of some of those red states, and then he didn't deliver on it. And that's why
01:39:10 he's got such big problems. Danielle Smith, president of the Alberta Enterprise Group.
01:39:14 Always a pleasure. Thanks so much for your insight and analysis, Danielle.
01:39:17 Yeah, thank you. We'll talk again. All right, we'll talk to you soon. And let's now go to
01:39:22 some breaking news to our decision desk, William Macbeth of True North, who's been following the
01:39:27 results very closely i understand we have a key race to call william yeah we uh true north based
01:39:33 on the fact that at 182 of 259 polls reporting jody gondek leading with 45 of the vote to jeremy
01:39:41 farkas uh we can project that jody gondek will be the next mayor of calgary and that uh what was
01:39:48 pulled to be a very close election race within a couple percent ended up not being actually that
01:39:53 close at all well obviously not the result a lot of our audience was hoping for but but what do we
01:40:01 take away from this i mean was this just a rebellion against jason kenney was this a rebellion
01:40:06 against jeremy farkas what was jody gondek actually offering something that people wanted
01:40:11 specifically or was she really just the natural successor to an ahead nenshi to a lot of people
01:40:16 i you know it's interesting i i think there's a mix of reasons for you've talked about some of them
01:40:22 uh nang chi did not endorse gondette formally but he did spend his final moments on social media's
01:40:30 mayor going after jeremy farkas and telling people not to vote for him uh the other thing
01:40:36 that's interesting is uh as i mentioned earlier and i think danielle mentioned too uh the political
01:40:41 action committee with the by far the most money in calgary was the one being backed by the public
01:40:46 sector unions. I just did a quick tally and their endorsed candidates or others who are on
01:40:52 what would be considered the left look like they're on pace to win about 11 of Calgary's 15
01:40:58 city council seats. So the mayor and 10 more seats, which would actually be a pretty big
01:41:05 ideological shift on Calgary city council. And the other thing that I think is interesting
01:41:11 is of the four incumbents, four or five incumbents who are running again, at least three of them are
01:41:17 on track to be defeated so far tonight. We're seeing some councillors who have been there
01:41:23 for nearly two decades actually losing to challengers, which is very unusual in a municipal
01:41:30 election to see an incumbent actually lose. So a lot of factors going on at once right now,
01:41:37 and certainly not a slow night.
01:41:39 And Andrew, I can also just give a quick update.
01:41:41 Here in Edmonton, with 93 of 228 polls reporting,
01:41:47 Amrajit Sohi at 44% and his nearest competitor, Mike Nickel, at 27.
01:41:52 I think we're pretty close to being able to call Edmonton's mayor
01:41:57 for Amrajit Sohi as well.
01:41:59 How is the referendum looking in Calgary so far?
01:42:03 So, actually, it's gotten a bit better for the yes side.
01:42:07 It's climbed up a few points.
01:42:09 Again, with that 182 polls reporting, 58% of people voting in Calgary
01:42:14 have said yes to the equalization referendum, and 42% have said no.
01:42:20 Now, of course, we don't know what's happening in other parts of Alberta.
01:42:24 Perhaps something dramatically different is happening in Edmonton
01:42:26 or perhaps in the smaller cities or in the north and south.
01:42:30 But based on the results from Calgary, it looks like Albertans are voting for change when it comes to equalization.
01:42:38 And as a matter of interest for anybody trying to tell the time in Alberta right now, it looks like Albertans are voting to keep standard time and they are voting 53 percent no to moving fully to daylight savings time.
01:42:51 So that's the other referendum issue that maybe isn't getting as much attention as the equalization one.
01:42:56 Well, if that fails, the time actually of this right now goes back an hour and the polls reopen, don't I?
01:43:04 Yeah, maybe they can wage an extra hour.
01:43:06 Yeah, yeah. If it fails, we go back in time.
01:43:09 Candace, what do you make of this?
01:43:10 That on one hand, you've got Calgarians that are saying, yes, we want to stop bankrolling the rest of Canada,
01:43:16 but at the same time, also voting for the left of centre-mayoral candidates.
01:43:20 Well, it just goes back to Vitor's point, which really does stand out to me, which is that, you know, just because you have a view for Canada of sort of limited government and you don't want Ottawa to have its fingers in your pocket and you don't want the legislature in Edmonton to be able to, you know, push left wing ideology through the workforce and in schools.
01:43:43 That doesn't mean that you don't want, you know, nice, nicely paved sidewalks and roads being cleared when there's a big snowfall.
01:43:52 Like, like I understand the idea that that people would want a more activist local government and that that people who are sort of of the free market conservative side need to do a better job of really framing their issues and talking about, you know, ways that they can make their communities better.
01:44:10 Maybe conservatives need to take a more community centric approach to municipal politics.
01:44:15 You know, that's all sort of ideologically as far as, you know, the individual candidates.
01:44:20 It seems a little odd to me that so many people run in these elections.
01:44:23 Like, why not just have one sort of small C conservative candidate in Edmonton and one in Calgary to sort of rally all the people of that sort of persuasion behind?
01:44:34 So it seems like, you know, a little bit of a mixed bag. But interestingly, I, you know, the whole daylight savings, I wanted to make a point about this because a couple of years ago, California voted in an election to get rid of daylight savings times and they voted in favor of it.
01:44:54 It was 60 percent voted, yes, let's get rid of it, 40 percent, let's keep it.
01:44:59 And they never changed it. Nothing ever happened.
01:45:02 So sometimes these things happen and they don't really go anywhere.
01:45:07 And I think that's the same case with the fluoride in the water.
01:45:10 It seems like Calgary has been having this debate for a really long time as to whether or not there should be fluoride in the water.
01:45:16 It seems like an issue that just won't go away.
01:45:18 I read Colby Koch had an interesting article in the National Post saying that it's been 64 years and seven plebiscites and the city is still debating the merits of putting fluoride in the water.
01:45:31 Now, this is interesting because before the show, before we went live, we're having a little bit of our own internal debate here at True North about what we all thought about fluoride.
01:45:39 As you know, I'm from British Columbia. And so according to Colby Kosh, and I think he's usually correct, he says that 98.8 percent of the population of British Columbia lives with unfluoridated public water.
01:45:54 So so I don't think that there's any reason to put fluoride in your water. I think that a better idea is just tell everyone to brush their teeth. Right.
01:46:01 and and instead of having this sort of like paternalistic nanny state measure of just like
01:46:06 forcing people to have fluoride by sneaking it into their drinking water and making people
01:46:10 ingest it which doesn't have the desired effect you know the idea is that it helps
01:46:14 with your teeth ingesting it might not be the best thing and it's like well maybe it's because
01:46:20 i grew up in a jurisdiction where nobody has fluoride in their water so maybe it's just me
01:46:25 well and i grew up in a city in which the water is and as long as i can remember has been
01:46:30 fluoridated. So I never really thought that was a controversy. I just assumed that was part of the
01:46:36 standard municipal water treatment. It wasn't until there was some city councillor who wanted
01:46:40 to get rid of it and everyone treated him like he was a kook that I realized that this wasn't
01:46:45 unanimous across the board. So I do think where you were born and whether you grew up on 0.93
01:46:50 fluoridated water does weigh heavily on your take on this. How's that referendum shaken up,
01:46:54 William? I realize we skipped past that with all of our excitement about daylight savings time.
01:46:58 We did. Well, I can tell you that the pro-fluoride forces have been victorious, with 61% of Calgarians voting to restore fluoridation to their water, 39% voting to remain unfluoridated.
01:47:15 So that's a pretty clear win there for Team Florida. And I can say that I just did a quick check. And I think at this point, True North is going to be able to project that Amarjeet Sohi will be the next mayor of Edmonton.
01:47:30 with 152 of 228 polls reporting well more than 50 percent average so he has uh garnered about
01:47:38 44.67 percent of the vote to mike nichols 26.58 percent of the vote so alberta has elected two
01:47:46 progressive mayors tonight uh in both of their big cities well quite an interesting development
01:47:53 just to go back to the fluoride referendum for a moment so this is a resounding victory but as i
01:47:58 understand it this has happened before you know candace alluded to it the history of fluoride in
01:48:05 calgary is very interesting we've had endless endless referendums on whether or not we want
01:48:10 to have fluoride in our water and the last referendum that was held uh actually calgarians
01:48:15 voted to have fluoride in the water and then a few years later city council all on their own
01:48:20 decided to remove fluoride from the water even though voters had voted to have fluoride in the
01:48:25 water a few years before that. So who knows what the outcome will be. Just based on who's won the
01:48:33 city council election tonight, I don't see a large number of principled libertarians getting elected 0.81
01:48:39 to Calgary City Council, which tells me that they're going to be going ahead with the fluoride
01:48:44 in the water. So for any of you looking to avoid that, you might want to start stocking up on your
01:48:50 bottled water right now. We're just filtered water. No need to bring plastic into it. But
01:48:56 yes, yes. Yeah, the plastic is going to be illegal soon if the federal government has its way.
01:49:02 Yeah, I think if you're just tuning in, Flo Rida has won the Calgary election with 61% of the vote.
01:49:07 So it'll be a great, oh, no, no, no, sorry. Different results that we're mixing up there.
01:49:12 So William, just, I mean, based on what you've seen, you and I talked about this a little bit
01:49:16 earlier in the show, the breakdown of what we could extrapolate from Calgary's results.
01:49:23 Are you still holding firm with what you said before?
01:49:27 Yeah, I mean, I do think that it is a pretty big win for the unions and the supporters of the left
01:49:36 here in Calgary. They have flipped a number of seats that were previously held by more conservative
01:49:41 counselors. You know, the polling from a bunch of different polling companies showed it to be a
01:49:47 really close race between Jody Gondek and Jeremy Parkas. The outcome, though, of the mayor's race
01:49:53 wasn't close at all, 15 or 16 percent difference between the first place and second place
01:49:59 candidate. And you have to wonder how much two million dollars of PAC money from the unions,
01:50:06 the public sector unions, played into the results that are happening tonight.
01:50:11 Very well said.
01:50:12 Before we go to our next and final guest for the evening,
01:50:16 Candice, how can people support True North?
01:50:18 Well, you know, we really appreciate everyone tuning in,
01:50:21 and it's a lot of fun to do these live shows.
01:50:24 We like to do them almost every opportunity we can.
01:50:26 We did one on election night.
01:50:30 You probably remember we did one on the debate night.
01:50:32 We did one on the night the election kicked off.
01:50:34 We really like doing them.
01:50:35 We also have, you know, full lineup of podcasts.
01:50:39 We put podcasts out every day.
01:50:40 the Candace Malcolm show, the Andrew Lawton show
01:50:43 we have a couple of other colleagues who
01:50:44 do videos and all that kind of thing
01:50:46 you can get news on Canadian
01:50:49 political, on Canadian
01:50:51 politics, immigration
01:50:52 foreign policy, we have an entire
01:50:55 team, a newsroom
01:50:56 and we really appreciate
01:50:59 everyone who tunes in, who supports
01:51:01 us, if you want to support
01:51:03 the work we do, if you enjoy watching us, if you want
01:51:05 to keep it going, if you want to be a part of
01:51:07 True North and the vision that we have
01:51:09 for independent media in Canada
01:51:10 please head on over to donate.tnc.news.
01:51:14 We don't take any money from the government.
01:51:15 We're true independent journalists.
01:51:17 We don't think that journalists should get money from the government,
01:51:20 and we take a very principled stand against that.
01:51:23 So if you support our idea for independent journalism in Canada,
01:51:27 you like hearing the other side of the story,
01:51:28 you want to see news that, you know, we do fact-based news,
01:51:33 but we also have a conservative, small-c conservative editorial position,
01:51:36 which is really rare in the media lineup.
01:51:39 You see a lot of people on the left, center left, pretty much dominates the entire media spectrum in Canada.
01:51:46 And it really has an impact on the country, even as we see tonight with a bunch of left center candidates winning.
01:51:53 You know, if we want to move that needle and push more conservative culture,
01:51:58 party elements of that is having independent media and a small C conservative editorial position.
01:52:03 So, again, if you like True North, please head on over to donate.tnc.news.
01:52:07 consider giving us just a very small donation, whatever you can. It all helps. So thank you so
01:52:12 much. Yeah, I'm glad you said that. And I will say on the point of not being funded by the
01:52:17 government, a lot of the time people say, well, you know, yeah, the government doesn't want to
01:52:21 give you money. It goes both ways. We don't want to receive government money. And I think that's
01:52:25 what sets us apart is that we do not want to be beholden to the government and to the government
01:52:30 narrative. And I think over the last year and a half with COVID, that's been especially clear
01:52:33 how important it is for there to be truly independent voices. So whether it's covering
01:52:38 Alberta elections, we're here for you, or national elections, or even all the things that happen in
01:52:43 between. We're standing by in just a couple of moments, we're going to go to Bill Buick, who's
01:52:47 the executive director of Fairness Alberta. But I want to talk a little bit about the stakes of
01:52:53 this referendum, because I admit, I generally speaking, try to have very low expectations,
01:52:57 because it's very easy to get disappointed with the political culture being what it is from time
01:53:02 to time. But here's the challenge. This is a non-binding referendum. So a lot of what happens
01:53:08 next comes down to how Jason Kenney and the Alberta government play it. And let me ask you,
01:53:14 Candice, we've talked about this with Danielle, with Vitor, with other people that have come on
01:53:18 here. How strong a voice do you think Jason Kenney is going to be in Ottawa going up against Justin
01:53:23 Trudeau with this referendum result if things continue to develop how it sounds like they are,
01:53:28 at least in Calgary. Yeah, well, I think I think we can let Bill Buick kind of speak to that when
01:53:33 he comes on, because he'll probably have a better understanding. But from what I understand,
01:53:38 you know, that there's already a lot of partisan politics at play when a provincial conservative
01:53:43 premier meets with a federal liberal prime minister. And, you know, there's a lot of
01:53:48 posturing, a lot of, you know, talking points and part just partisan politics. And so when Jason
01:53:56 Kenny has and what Albertans are giving, you know, if the referendum goes the way that we think it
01:54:02 will based on the Calgary results, that this is this is an added level of leverage because it's
01:54:08 not just, you know, I'm a conservative, you're a liberal and we're going to we're going to duel
01:54:13 it out. It really is. You know, this is the will of the people in Alberta. The people in Alberta
01:54:18 don't want this in the Constitution. They have told us this. It's not just like a very small,
01:54:24 one or two percent. It looks like an overwhelming majority of Albertans have said that they don't
01:54:30 like the system of fiscal federalism. They don't like the idea of subsidizing to such a great
01:54:35 extent Quebec when Alberta has its own fiscal problems and having its own issues with the
01:54:41 recession and the decline in the price of oil and all the problems with pipelines. You had a
01:54:47 disastrous government with the NDP and Rachel Notley. You've had a disastrous federal government
01:54:52 with the Liberals in Justin Trudeau, and both of those components together has just been
01:54:57 so heartbreaking for so many in Alberta, seeing their industry go in decline, and Calgary wants
01:55:03 just a great, prospering city, you know, sitting with, what, a quarter of its commercial space is
01:55:10 vacant and unoccupied. So, you know, I think what this really does is provide a message to the
01:55:18 elites that are in control in ottawa to uh justin trudeau and his inner circle that it's not just
01:55:23 a matter of you know we're conservative you're liberals you know this is this is the will of
01:55:27 the people in alberta and i think that they would be um very well advised to to listen and and at
01:55:34 least um look into it and then vitor made a great point earlier about how um you know some of the
01:55:39 other provinces might want to reconsider that the whole arrangement when it comes to federal
01:55:43 transfers with health because so many provinces have been hit so hard by COVID, all of them,
01:55:48 the whole country has. So, you know, the idea that we're so limited with a rationed
01:55:53 government-run, rigid government-run healthcare system might be something that we finally have
01:55:59 the maturity as a country to look at and get past the cheap little talking points about us being
01:56:04 superior to our American neighbors and say, you know, let's look at the healthcare system
01:56:11 objectively, not just comparing ourselves to Americans, but say, what's the best system that
01:56:16 we can have and working on together? And I think that this is all the components of them. It's all
01:56:23 aligned here. So I think that that's something that's going to be interesting in the coming
01:56:26 years, Andrew. Yeah. And just on a related note, I mean, it doesn't have to do with the referendum,
01:56:31 but on the note of health care, there's actually a conference next weekend in Calgary being put on
01:56:37 by our friend Danny Hozak and the Economic Education Association that is dealing with
01:56:42 that question because we've seen how healthcare is kind of the linchpin of a lot of things that
01:56:48 are happening right now, whether it's the pandemic response, lockdown measures, some
01:56:52 of the things you were just talking about. I'm going to be speaking at that. Danielle
01:56:55 is going to be speaking at that. And I think that's going to be something that is very
01:56:58 interesting moving forward because, you know, again, this has been a climactic moment for
01:57:02 Alberta, for Albertans, but you have to talk about what comes next. And something Danielle
01:57:07 Smith mentioned earlier really stuck with me. She had talked about the idea that Albertans
01:57:11 oftentimes want to help their neighbors. They think, okay, you know, we've got a bit of wealth
01:57:15 here. We've got a bit of money. We can afford to help PEI. The problem with equalization is that
01:57:21 the application of it is not just to help provinces in need. It actually helps provinces
01:57:29 structure their entire fiscal system around the idea of dependence. And that's especially true
01:57:36 in alberta or in quebec rather quebec is the second largest province in canada quebec has
01:57:41 industry quebec has a lot there quebec could very easily be running its affairs in such a way
01:57:47 that it doesn't need that steady stream of money from alberta but they don't so the result is
01:57:54 albertans subsidizing quebec hydro subsidizing quebec infrastructure doing all of these things
01:57:59 so we'll delve into that now with bill buick dr bill buick i should say he is the executive
01:58:03 director of Fairness Alberta and joins us now. Bill, this is something that you and I talked
01:58:08 about in the past. I know you spoke about it on Candace's show as well. It doesn't change the
01:58:13 constitution if this referendum goes the way it looks like it is, but it does give a strong
01:58:18 mandate. Now explain for people that don't know how this non-binding referendum can actually have
01:58:24 some real force in Ottawa. Sure. I have a column I wrote for the National Post that I encourage
01:58:29 people to have a look at. And it basically says, I mean, someone asked me today, they're thinking
01:58:35 they had a gotcha moment. So if Quebec had a referendum to increase equalization payments,
01:58:41 should the federal government pay attention to that? And I said, of course. I mean, anytime a
01:58:45 province cares enough about a topic to have a referendum that they pass something on, clearly
01:58:52 that's significant. And how could a federal government just ignore any province who passed
01:58:57 referendum on something like that so uh of course they wouldn't though because they wouldn't want us
01:59:02 opening up that can of worms because as you pointed out uh it's basically uh entirely stacked
01:59:07 in their favor so but the the problem is that so there's a common sense uh notion that anytime
01:59:14 the people speak out in such a way that the federal government should pay attention
01:59:17 but then also in 1998 um and it's extremely frustrating because there's there's some
01:59:22 constitutional law scholars who, you know, who wouldn't trust the constitutional law scholars
01:59:28 interpretation of this, they keep insisting there's just no significance to the 1998 Quebec
01:59:33 secession reference to what we're talking about. But the Supreme Court was very clear in a very long
01:59:38 reference case that they were asked by the federal government. Yeah, there was the main focus was how
01:59:44 could a province trigger a separation and breaking up the country. But they also put in a few very
01:59:49 clear general principles that when there's a legitimate expression for a desire for change
01:59:56 from any province, that there's a duty for the federal government and the rest of the provinces
02:00:01 to consult on it. And so the wording certainly didn't help the numbers that we're going to see
02:00:07 tonight and then in a week when they're official. But the wording is there because it made it a
02:00:14 tougher threshold, so that when that passes, it triggers these duties beyond what the typical
02:00:20 political duties would be to address a problem when a province expresses it that clearly.
02:00:26 Yeah, and I'm glad you mentioned political duty, because I would say irrespective of how that
02:00:31 Supreme Court reference case is interpreted, there is a political duty, but obviously a legal duty
02:00:37 has much more force. What needs to happen, I guess, politically and legally for Jason
02:00:44 Kenney and for his government to advance this? I mean, you have the results, you have the
02:00:48 numbers. What's that next step?
02:00:51 To me, the next step, and it's something we've been working on at Fairness Alberta for a
02:00:55 little while now, is getting Ontario on board. Saskatchewan's already said they're on board
02:01:01 with pushing for equalization reform. The other two big contributors are Ontario and
02:01:07 British Columbia. And politically speaking, you know, it might be the case that Alberta and
02:01:14 Saskatchewan tend to be a little taken for granted by one party and kind of written off by the other
02:01:19 parties. So nobody really wants to go out too far on a limb for us, unfortunately. And that's
02:01:25 something, you know, we're trying to get around through this referendum and through the advocacy
02:01:29 we're doing. But really, the serious reforms are going to come when it's folks in Ontario,
02:01:36 when the politicians in Ontario start hearing about this from people, when the politicians in
02:01:40 British Columbia think, or if they just take a good hard look at this and say, hey, we have a
02:01:46 fiscal problem here in our province. It's not that our taxpayers aren't paying enough taxes.
02:01:51 It's that the federal government is taking so many of those taxes and sending them to Quebec
02:01:56 in the maritime. And Quebec in particular is the one. So to me, the next step is to A, you know,
02:02:03 everybody's got a heads up now that this is coming before you go too hard on trying to demand the
02:02:09 changes. Let's see how much support we can get in Ontario and British Columbia. That's 70% of the
02:02:14 country and a whole bunch of the governments are won and lost in Ontario and British Columbia.
02:02:20 If we can get those folks angry about this, frankly, and pushing for these changes to happen
02:02:26 and realizing just how much the federal government is taking of their taxes, giving to other
02:02:31 provincial government, then that's the time I think we can really push for serious changes and
02:02:35 have success. Vitor Marciano was on the show earlier, and he made a comment that I can't
02:02:42 really disagree with, that the only people that have been vocally against the referendum are
02:02:46 political science professors. Now, I don't think they make up 43% of the population of Calgary,
02:02:52 which seems to be last time I checked the number that voted against this. In your experience
02:02:56 talking to people what are the primary objections are they people that object to the specific
02:03:02 question or are they just people that dislike the process dislike some of the players involved and
02:03:07 and aren't really engaging directly on that idea of whether they support or oppose equalization
02:03:12 i haven't run into or heard from or you know we get hundreds and hundreds of people commenting
02:03:20 on our posts because I've been very kind of active on this on this front I haven't really
02:03:26 seen anybody say they disagree that equalization is seriously flawed and needs to be changed
02:03:31 it is a combination of thinking it's just a publicity stunt by the premier or which is you
02:03:40 know a lot of people have said oh he's just doing this because he's unpopular right now he's like
02:03:44 well no this was something that was pushed in 2017 that's when I started supporting it and it
02:03:49 was in the platform in 2019 uh this has been a long time in the making and it's people so people
02:03:55 that are just cynical about the process cynical about the type of question and uh and yeah i i'm
02:04:02 a little surprised at how many academics have come out so full-throatedly and just you know
02:04:11 from all different angles it doesn't mean anything it's it's too radical and it shouldn't be phrased
02:04:18 this way? I mean, kind of pick a lane. Is it insignificant and unmeaningful and symbolic,
02:04:23 or is it something that's going to rip apart the Constitution and cause these massive quarrels that
02:04:29 are going to maybe leave Alberta in the short end after a while? They don't seem to be too logical.
02:04:35 They just seem fixated on very, very narrow looking at this and not understanding that it's
02:04:41 ultimately kind of symbolic, but it also has a piece in there that triggers a threshold,
02:04:47 which will force more meaningful discussions and negotiations yeah i think you're very right there
02:04:53 you know i've paid a close attention to this not as close as you as you've been in the trench on
02:04:57 this but i i've not come across a single person who said well you know uh by by golly i i want
02:05:03 to give quebec more money i i've not met that albertan they met they might be out there but i
02:05:07 have not met them or have not heard from them uh bill buick executive director of fairness alberta
02:05:12 great work on this and thanks for coming on tonight yeah my pleasure andrew and happy to come
02:05:16 on in the future as we start to push this cause in Ontario and British Columbia and across Canada.
02:05:23 And I encourage everybody to go to fairnessalberta.ca and see what they can do to help us.
02:05:28 Yeah, absolutely. Thanks, Bill. We might need to see some fairness offshoots in the days and
02:05:32 weeks to come. Fairness Ontario, Fairness Manitoba, Fairness Saskatchewan, and so on.
02:05:38 Just as we wind down our time together, I want to bring back our All-Star True North team here,
02:05:42 Candace Malcolm and William McBeth. William, I'm not sure, do we have any new results on the
02:05:49 referendum, on any of the municipal elections, or Senate as well is one that I think deserves
02:05:54 a little bit of attention? Sure. I can say that two more municipalities are reporting
02:06:00 equalization referendum results. The two southern cities of Medicine Hat and Lethbridge. Lethbridge
02:06:07 is voting 58.5% yes on the referendum equalization question, 41.5% no. Medicine Hat, though, voting
02:06:17 70% yes on an equalization referendum, 30% no. So a decisive win for the pro-equalization
02:06:25 reform group right there. And then in terms of the Senate elections, I mentioned before that
02:06:31 the three candidates endorsed by the Conservative Party of Canada are leading. Two of them are
02:06:37 leading by quite a lot. One of them seems to be 7 or 8 percent back, though. And not too far behind
02:06:43 them are a couple independent candidates, one named Doug Horner, who was a PC cabinet minister
02:06:48 for 150 years here in Alberta. He comes from a storied political family. And another one who has
02:06:56 backing from both former Mayor Nahed Nengshi and Premier Ed Stelmak. So this one, a doctor,
02:07:04 seems to be spanning sort of the ideological divide. The People's Party of Canada is also
02:07:09 running a slate of Senate candidates, three Senate candidates, and they're earning in the
02:07:15 four to five percent mark, which was sort of what the PPC, I think, was earning at the national level
02:07:20 in the last federal election. But it looks at this point like the three Conservative Party
02:07:27 endorsed candidates are in the lead. That's interesting. I know the PPC had in some Alberta
02:07:32 ridings managed to nab 13, 14, 15 percent of the vote. And I know a couple of those ridings
02:07:38 candidates actually are now the ones running in the Senate, one of them notably Nadine Wellwood
02:07:43 in Banff-Airdrie. So I guess the PBC was probably hoping it could replicate that and build off of it,
02:07:49 but it doesn't sound like that's happening. No, and I think it's just a function of there
02:07:54 isn't as much attention on this Senate election as I think there was on the federal election.
02:07:59 Maxime Bernier did a cross-country tour. True North, of course, reported from the ground on
02:08:04 his election night event. But there was no PPC campaign that Maxime Bernier spearheaded here in
02:08:11 Alberta during this Senate election. So I think they fell back a bit from where they were in the
02:08:16 federal time. Candace, we've covered a lot of ground here. What are your thoughts here as we
02:08:22 wrap up? Well, Andrew, you had a funny line a minute ago when you were talking to Bill. You
02:08:27 said by golly i don't think we should give quebec more money and reminded me of our friend uh norm
02:08:32 mcdonald who passed away a couple weeks ago i know he always used that funny line he'd say by golly
02:08:36 uh so i don't know if you if you were doing a norm mcdonald impression there or not but i wasn't
02:08:41 trying to be but as i was saying it i was thinking of him i realized no i like that no this is uh
02:08:46 i you know i like doing these live shows i've i've enjoyed it i always learn a lot i think having
02:08:51 a roster of Alberta and guests come on and sort of give us the perspective from different parts
02:08:57 of the province. And, you know, it's so important. We kind of get wrapped up in federal politics and
02:09:03 always focusing on Justin Trudeau and the latest shenanigans out of Ottawa. And, you know, it's
02:09:08 important to recognize that there's a whole other country out there that doesn't see eye to eye,
02:09:14 doesn't view things the same way as the people in downtown Toronto and out in Ottawa do. So
02:09:19 it's it's refreshing uh for me and i really i enjoyed i like reading the comments as well i
02:09:24 always get some good laughs um and uh you know some interesting content as well so thanks to
02:09:28 everyone uh who has been uh commenting thanks to everyone who has chipped in uh to help support
02:09:34 true north over at donate.tnc.news really appreciate it and i i guess we'll just have to
02:09:40 stay tuned because you know we have sort of unofficial results i think that the mayoral
02:09:43 races are pretty down pat. But with regards to the referendum on equalization, some of those
02:09:50 other questions, we'll have to do a deeper dive in the coming days and weeks. But yeah, no, I think
02:09:56 it's been great. Really appreciate everyone who's been watching and Andrew for hosting. You know,
02:10:01 we have a whole behind the scenes team that I don't want to forget. So thank you to the team
02:10:08 behind the scenes that are helping us out. Really appreciate it. And yeah, thank you. It's been a
02:10:13 great night. All right. Well, on that note, my thanks to you, Candice, for putting this all
02:10:18 together and everyone else and William for coming on and staying on top of the numbers to the team.
02:10:22 And more importantly, well, not more importantly, but as importantly to all those of you who are
02:10:27 tuning in, you know, this is a lot of fun. And I know all of us like talking to each other and
02:10:31 kicking back and breaking down what's happening in politics, but I don't think we'd be doing it
02:10:35 as fervently without an audience. So thanks to all of you for tuning in. Cover what's happening
02:10:41 in your community and let us know.
02:10:42 Obviously, we haven't been able to cover every town
02:10:44 and every county and every village.
02:10:46 Some of them are not posting their results online.
02:10:49 But if you go to tnc.news in the coming days,
02:10:52 we'll be reporting stories that are emerging
02:10:53 as we see some more of these numbers.
02:10:55 So thanks again to the on-air, to the off-air,
02:10:58 and to those of you watching wherever you are
02:11:00 in the country or around the world.
02:11:02 I'm Andrew Lawton for True North.
02:11:03 We are signing off.
02:11:05 Have a good night, everyone.
02:11:11 Thank you.