Juno News - July 28, 2022


True North’s coverage of the UCP Leadership Debate

Topics
Mentioned
Is Iran a nuclear threat? Reality Check: Canada does NOT have the best healthcare system

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 46 minutes

Words per minute

175.87

Word count

29,262

Sentence count

1,061

Harmful content

Misogyny

16

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The United Conservative Party of Alberta is holding a leadership debate this evening, and True North is here to break it all down. In the lead-up to the debate, True North's own Elie Cantin-Nantel and William MacBeth join me to discuss the candidates, the debate format, and what we can expect from the debate.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 ingerjack drum
00:00:00 pm
00:00:22 um
00:00:26 母
00:00:27 We'll be right back.
00:00:57 We'll be right back.
00:01:27 We'll be right back.
00:01:57 We'll be right back.
00:02:27 We'll be right back.
00:02:57 I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
00:03:27 Thank you.
00:03:57 We'll be right back.
00:04:27 Thank you.
00:04:57 good evening and welcome ladies and gentlemen to the united conservative party debate coverage
00:05:11 that true north is launching as you know true north is really here to talk about the issues
00:05:16 that matter to canadians the issues that matter to people voting in leadership races for conservative
00:05:22 parties whether it's the conservative party of canada or the united conservative party of alberta
00:05:27 so we are very pleased thrilled in fact I can say to deliver live debate coverage for you this
00:05:33 evening we'll have some analysis commentary leading into the debate we'll have the debate
00:05:38 itself on this stream so you don't need to go anywhere else and then we'll pick back up on the
00:05:42 other end of it for the debate scrums and also for some post-debate analysis and of course we're
00:05:48 going to be taking your thoughts your comments throughout this as well if you have questions
00:05:52 leave them in the comment section if you have thoughts leave them there one of my colleagues
00:05:56 who you will know well from True North by now,
00:05:59 Elie Cantin-Nantel will be mining for the best comments you have to offer
00:06:03 and we'll be breaking them down here
00:06:04 and really talking about what the people are saying about this debate,
00:06:08 people that are voting in the UCP leadership race
00:06:11 and also people outside of that who might not be members of the UCP
00:06:15 but are nonetheless affected by whoever is going to be the ultimate winner of this race.
00:06:20 So we've got a number of candidates debating here,
00:06:23 Lila Ahir, Brian Jean, Todd Lowen, Rajan Sani, Rebecca Schultz, Danielle Smith, and Travis
00:06:30 Taves. These are the seven candidates in the UCP leadership race. And I just want to give a little
00:06:36 bit of the top line details here so you know the context of this. This debate is being moderated by
00:06:42 a former Calgary City Councillor, Jeff Davison, who is the CEO of the Prostate Cancer Centre. So
00:06:48 hopefully this debate will be more pleasant than a prostate exam in any event. It's being
00:06:53 hosted at the Halo Air Ambulance Hangar in Medicine Hat, which is itself a bit of an
00:06:58 interesting choice here. Two debates sanctioned by the UCP, this one in Medicine Hat and another
00:07:03 in Edmonton, none in Calgary, which is the province's biggest city, at least none officially.
00:07:09 The debate format hasn't been published, but as I understand from talking to a few sources,
00:07:14 it's going to be very focused on interaction. Candidates are going to have a fair bit of time
00:07:19 to do one-on-one which is often a format that necessitates jumping on the front runner and
00:07:25 as we've seen in some recent polls this week and we'll talk about very shortly
00:07:28 the front runner seems to be Danielle Smith and not far from behind her Brian Jean although
00:07:34 anything can happen it's still early days in this contest I want to bring in one of my colleagues
00:07:40 at True North you may not see in front of the camera all that much he keeps things running
00:07:44 behind the scenes but is nonetheless a critical part in the cog of true north and is himself an
00:07:49 Alberta politico he's been very active in conservative politics and Canadian politics
00:07:54 William Macbeth joins me now William first off thanks for being here I know that we just foisted
00:08:00 a camera in your face and said you're going to talk in this but it's good to have you nonetheless
00:08:04 well thank you I'm excited to be here tonight let's just first off talk about the makeup of
00:08:11 this? This is a new party. This is the second time the UCP has ever been through a leadership race.
00:08:17 And I think Jason Kenney, who came in several years ago as being this grand unifier, has gone
00:08:22 out in a rather unceremonious manner. But what would you say has really been the theme of this
00:08:27 race? I mean, I think the context of how Premier Kenney relinquished the leadership, not entirely
00:08:36 voluntarily, he received a passing score, but not a very high one in his leadership review.
00:08:42 I think you're now seeing, does the party want to walk in a very different direction? Does it
00:08:47 want to choose someone who is not associated with it from when Jason Kenney was premier? Or does it
00:08:54 want, you know, to retain more of what it was over the past few years with some tweaks and
00:08:59 modifications? For some people, maybe the issue was Premier Kenney himself rather than the United
00:09:05 conservative government. And for a lot of people, though, and possibly a majority based on how the
00:09:10 polling has gone so far, they want to see real change, absolute change in how the government
00:09:15 of Alberta operates, what its priorities are, how it handles major issues like COVID-19,
00:09:21 how it deals with Ottawa and federal-provincial relations. And for that, you've got two
00:09:26 candidates, I think, Brian Jean and Daniel Smith, who represent more of the big change side of this
00:09:32 leadership race. Jason Kenney's position has been, and he said this in interviews I've done with him
00:09:38 as well as elsewhere, that it was really COVID that was his unraveling. It was COVID and his
00:09:43 government's response to COVID that resulted in all of the things that happened that led to this 0.96
00:09:48 race. We look at the themes for tonight's debate. I'll share them again. Leadership and unity,
00:09:53 health care, the economy, and the environment. I mean, candidates can't just hide behind,
00:09:59 i wouldn't have done this i wouldn't have done this lockdown i wouldn't have done this vaccine
00:10:03 passport they have to have something else to offer here no i think you're absolutely right and i i
00:10:09 would say uh i think premier kenny may be a little bit uh looking at why he he suffered a defeat in
00:10:16 that leadership review or if not an actual defeat a world one a little bit differently if you look
00:10:21 next door to alberta we have the province of saskatchewan led by a conservative premier
00:10:26 Scott Moe. They followed quite a similar path to Alberta, but he's still premier. He hasn't
00:10:33 been ousted by his party and his caucus or by Saskatchewanians at large, whereas Jason
00:10:39 Kenney was. So to say it was all about COVID and the handling of COVID, I think might be
00:10:43 a little bit not the full story when it comes to Jason Kenney. In terms of the issues though
00:10:48 for Alberta, I think there is a lot of unhappiness in Alberta with the relationship with the
00:10:54 federal government. You've got Justin Trudeau, who is widely seen as hostile towards Alberta and
00:11:00 its economic interests, not approving pipelines, not being a champion of Alberta's oil and gas
00:11:06 sector, taking pot shots at legitimate businesses who are trying to grow the economy at the same
00:11:13 time, deal with stringent environmental standards. I think what Albertans are looking for is someone
00:11:18 who's going to be a louder voice in terms of federal and provincial relations, which is why
00:11:22 you're seeing some success I think from candidates like Daniel Smith who have been absolutely right
00:11:29 out there saying the situation is unacceptable and in fact we may not even enforce federal laws
00:11:33 in Alberta if they're to the detriment of the province. We know that being a front runner is
00:11:39 obviously great when you want to portray momentum and energy and scare other people out of the race
00:11:44 and fundraise but on a debate stage being a front runner is a fair bit of a liability. We've seen in
00:11:50 the last few weeks, the media really start to go after Danielle Smith, I'd say, fairly aggressively.
00:11:56 And whether it's fairly or unfairly, people can decide for themselves. Are you expecting to see
00:12:01 that in the debate tonight, that everyone is basically piling on her? Yes. To be honest, 0.96
00:12:07 I'm actually expecting it to be fairly much a Danielle Smith pile on. If you look at who's
00:12:12 running in this leadership race, there are seven candidates, but I would say there are two groups.
00:12:16 There are the quote-unquote frontrunners. Those would be Daniel Smith, Brian Jean, and former
00:12:22 Finance Minister Travis Tate. And then you've got a group of other candidates who don't have a lot
00:12:27 of name recognition or public profile, who I think are probably going to hope to use this debate to
00:12:33 get a little bit more profile, to get some energy for their campaigns. But certainly amongst Brian
00:12:38 Jean and Travis Tate, I think you will see fairly aggressive postures towards Daniel Smith to try
00:12:45 am blunt some of that perceived momentum and of course the membership sales cutoff is is not that
00:12:52 far away it's just about two weeks two weeks and a couple days from now and if that's the case uh
00:12:57 there isn't that much more time for uh regardless if you're a front runner or or one of the others
00:13:02 in this race you're going to have to start to make real progress selling memberships if you
00:13:07 have a hope of winning uh when the vote happens in october yeah very well said the debate is set
00:13:12 to begin in just over 15 minutes time i want to take this opportunity to give a bit of the lay
00:13:18 of the land for our coverage this evening we are going to have the debate carried live on this
00:13:22 stream on this feed starting in 15 minutes time and also we have our own alberta correspondent
00:13:29 who was on my show a couple of weeks ago is a new addition to the team but a tremendously
00:13:33 experienced and capable reporter that is rachel emmanuel and we'll have updates from her very
00:13:40 shortly and she's on the ground keeping us surprised of what's happening i also want to
00:13:44 bring in another colleague elie kenton nantel who's been monitoring the social media desk which
00:13:50 is a name i've just given for whatever desk he's working from now but it's more of a function than
00:13:54 a physical place elie what are people saying online first and foremost are they expressing
00:14:00 a preference in what you're seeing about which candidate or is it a bit of a mixed bag
00:14:04 well andrew it would depend really where you look so i looked at twitter for example and it's mostly
00:14:11 a bunch of left-wingers being like oh i can't wait to see what new conspiracy theory uh danielle
00:14:17 smith comes out with today they they're not a fan of danielle smith clearly there's people sharing
00:14:21 this old article where she apparently was talking about how smoking isn't as bad as they say so on
00:14:27 that end there's not a lot of useful information in our stream a couple of our viewers have shared
00:14:31 different views uh so donna slatter simply said that danielle smith will win uh versus some other
00:14:38 ones like edwin dotzel says that some of these candidates are ridiculous uh rebecca schultz 0.74
00:14:43 number one uh we have some others that are asking uh questions uh diane asks a pretty good question
00:14:51 in my opinion and it's uh she says i've yet to hear where any of the candidates positions are
00:14:55 on the current and future alberta school curriculums especially their views on sexual
00:15:00 education in the elementary schools and beyond, sorry. And, you know, this is a pretty
00:15:05 relevant issue. We're seeing it, especially in the United States. We saw it throughout the
00:15:09 months of June, really, that the parents are getting increasingly concerned as there's more
00:15:13 and more ideology, gender ideology, critical race theory being pushed in elementary schools.
00:15:19 We see it almost every day. There's this account called Libs of TikTok, and they basically just
00:15:24 go and they find TikToks that teachers make. And some of the stuff that these teachers do
00:15:29 do it is simply outrageous so definitely a good point there and you know unlike other provinces
00:15:34 like Ontario or in the east where you have a strong amount of liberals to push back
00:15:39 Alberta is fairly conservative so they they have the levy they have the room to put in place
00:15:43 school curriculums that are fairly conservative without getting widespread backlash the way
00:15:48 Ontario did somebody else brought bring up Shannon says that the imprisoners of pastors
00:15:53 was a huge mistake and I think this too when you look at this race and and the anger is we're
00:15:59 you and william were talking about earlier with jason kenny and kobe sure it wasn't the only
00:16:03 thing that left his downfall but it was a pretty major one uh i remember being in alberta just
00:16:08 after pastor james coates had been arrested and just in the little area i was living it was a
00:16:13 couple of townhouses there were people had signs in the window saying free pastor james like this
00:16:18 this really impacted christians i remember going to church and i went to different churches and
00:16:21 they were all praying like it really impacted alberta's religious community to see these
00:16:25 pastors rested and we didn't see that in other parts of the country so i think that too that too
00:16:30 is something that that is worth mentioning that that's really on my end for now more people
00:16:36 pouring in people saying they like pablo and people saying they want nothing to resign so
00:16:41 yeah i guess a mixed bag as you say people voicing their opinions and then the left
00:16:45 he's on twitter not liking danielle smith similar to how they dislike careful yeah
00:16:49 thank you ellie uh we'll check back in with you in just a few moments time appreciate your update
00:16:54 there let me go to you on that william because i think both of those things that ellie picked out
00:16:59 are really important battles in the conservative movement and i think both of them at their core
00:17:04 touch on social conservatism which i know is an issue that's always a balancing act in the federal
00:17:09 conservative party and in alberta i mean there's a fair bit of baggage on this for danielle smith
00:17:14 personally if you go back to the time that she was the wild rose leader previously and i think
00:17:18 a lot of critics said she she didn't do a good enough job at and she herself i think has said
00:17:23 she didn't do a good enough job at working around that so how if at all has that played into the
00:17:28 race this time around i mean i think it's a it's a very interesting question and i think probably
00:17:34 for uh some full disclosure i i worked for danielle smith when she was wild rose leader for
00:17:39 several years and uh so i remember when those issues happened i think in alberta what people
00:17:46 are looking for is an understanding of what the role of government is and that extends into things
00:17:51 like health care and education. And the role that parents play in education, I think, in Alberta is
00:17:59 particularly important. Alberta is quite different from other provinces in Canada. There has been a
00:18:04 lot of public and even government support for alternative education options to public schools.
00:18:11 And in fact, even when there was a lot of funding and continues to be a lot of funding for public
00:18:16 schools. Public schools compete against one another for students in order to secure funding
00:18:22 for their programs. The funding follows the student. And so in Alberta, you've got charter
00:18:27 schools, you've got private schools, you have a very healthy homeschool sector. And all of these
00:18:34 things, I think, are predicated on the idea that it's parents and not education bureaucrats or the
00:18:40 union who know what's best for students. So with that in mind, I think in this leadership race,
00:18:46 you will see a conversation about things like, you know, what kind of sex ed curriculum gets
00:18:53 taught? What is the role of a school? Is it for them to foist a particular worldview on students,
00:19:00 or is it about having them ask important questions and then having conversations with
00:19:04 their parents and their families about some of these things? And for Danielle, I do think it's
00:19:09 a story of, has a lesson been learned from how some of these issues were handled the first time
00:19:16 around? And if it put in the same position, how will she approach some of these very difficult
00:19:23 issues? I think that's the choice that some Albertans are going to be looking at when it 0.88
00:19:28 comes to Danielle Smith particularly, is are we going to see growth and change, or are we going
00:19:35 to see a repeat of some of the perceived missteps that happened when she was Walrose leader seven or
00:19:41 eight years ago. You mentioned earlier in the discussion the two groups that you saw, the
00:19:47 front runners and the other candidates, with all due respect to them, you have to look at the poll
00:19:51 numbers and take them at face value. There's another breakdown that I see here that's kind
00:19:56 of interesting, which is the insiders and the outsiders in a way, because you have, you know,
00:20:01 a bunch of people in this race that are former cabinet ministers under Jason Kenney, people like
00:20:06 Rebecca Schultz, people like Rajan Sani, people like Lila here. Now, again, there were some
00:20:13 criticisms that were put by Lila here, notably towards Jason Kenney's leadership. You had also
00:20:19 Travis Taves, who was former finance minister, stepped down. You had Todd Lowen, who was a member
00:20:24 the UCP caucus and then was very much on the outs with the core leadership with Jason Kenney and
00:20:32 Brian Jean and Danielle Smith, two people that really got back into politics specifically on
00:20:37 the platform of we are going to oppose Jason Kenney. So looking at the cabinet members or
00:20:44 former cabinet members here, do you think they will basically be just tied to Jason Kenney? Is
00:20:50 Is Jason Kenney unpopular enough to the members voting in this race that looking at Rebecca
00:20:55 Schultz or Travis Taves and being like, they're the Kenney candidates, is enough to keep their
00:20:59 numbers low?
00:21:00 I mean, I think that's a very interesting question.
00:21:03 And one of the things that I think has been very interesting is normally in a leadership
00:21:08 race, the front runners all tend to have held senior positions in the former government.
00:21:15 Cabinet ministers almost always are in the leading spots.
00:21:18 And if you look, I mean, just to jump in there, look at the 2017 federal conservative leadership race.
00:21:23 You had like 13 candidates and of them, I think 50 of them were were cabinet ministers in Der Harper.
00:21:29 Yeah, exactly. So I think the fact that that the two apparent leading candidates, Daniel Smith and Brian Jean,
00:21:35 neither of them were in in Jason Kenney's cabinet.
00:21:40 In fact, up until quite recently, neither one of them were even MLAs anymore.
00:21:45 Brian Jean recently won a by-election in Fort McMurray.
00:21:47 I think that does spell some trouble for those who were members of the Kenney government, in particular, because this was so much a government about Jason Kenney. He defined the united conservative government.
00:22:02 And people used to make this criticism of Stephen Harper, that it was hard to name someone other than Stephen Harper in the Stephen Harper government.
00:22:11 But I would say he actually did delegate a fair amount of responsibility to his individual ministers.
00:22:17 I'm not 100 percent sure that was true with Jason Kenney.
00:22:21 I think a lot of the files still ended up going across his desk and through his government.
00:22:25 And as a result, there isn't a lot of name recognition, even for people who were senior cabinet ministers.
00:22:31 You know, I had to anecdotally explain to my own friends who Travis Taves was, and I said, well, he's been our finance minister for the past three years, and they did not really know that. That was kind of news to them.
00:22:44 So I think for them to break free of the perception that they're simply offering, quote unquote, more of the same, they may have to articulate specific decisions or policies which they disagree with when it comes to the Kennedy government.
00:22:58 I think a lot of people would understand if they said, I had to go along with it because that's what governments do.
00:23:04 They support the will of cabinet.
00:23:07 When cabinet makes a decision, they go ahead.
00:23:08 But here are some things that I had concerns with.
00:23:11 And here's how I would have been different.
00:23:12 And here's how I will be different if I become premier of Alberta in two months' time.
00:23:18 And that's a really difficult needle to thread because you have to be critical of your own record in office.
00:23:25 And a lot of politicians are reluctant to do that.
00:23:28 I do think, though, that if they're going to be seen as anything more than just, you know, more of the same, they are going to have to be specific and not just say we need to do a better job listening or we need to do a better job communicating.
00:23:41 Well, no, I think that that wasn't enough in order to be seen as truly different.
00:23:47 Yeah, I think that's fair. And I will say it is interesting.
00:23:50 At the beginning, a lot of people were telling me that Travis Taves was the frontrunner just by virtue of his role.
00:23:56 You know, a finance minister in a majority government, this seems like an important thing.
00:24:00 And he did, you know, I think shore up a lot of the establishment support.
00:24:04 I don't even mean that in a derisive way, but he shored up a lot of those endorsements that you'd expect.
00:24:08 But really has not been the one that I'm seeing crossing my social media feed.
00:24:13 I know when Ali was on, he wasn't a name that he was seeing in the comments flooding by.
00:24:18 So I don't actually think that he's resonated with people.
00:24:22 Now, again, I mean, a lot of it is how you can get out your vote and do all that.
00:24:26 But let's bring Ellie back on in a moment here or actually for a moment, because I'm
00:24:31 curious, Ellie, what are the issues people are bringing up beyond the candidates?
00:24:35 What are the issues?
00:24:35 You mentioned a couple, but are they are people talking about the issues that we know are
00:24:40 designated as the themes of the debate tonight?
00:24:43 Well, Andrew, first of all, I forgot to point this out earlier.
00:24:46 there is a bit of confusion i noticed from some of our viewers this is not a federal conservative
00:24:51 party of canada leadership debate this is for the alberta united conservative party so there's cpc
00:24:56 which is federal and ucb which is provincial i know it's confusing it's never no it's no it's
00:25:01 not it's never branding for the race when they can't even tell people that there is a race going
00:25:05 on which i think is actually a big problem we don't have usually two races at the same time so
00:25:10 for our viewers like please know this is not cpc but because i think if they don't know and they
00:25:15 to see these random people they're going to be like who the heck are these people right uh sorry
00:25:20 ellie we we used up your moment on that but we will come back to you but i know we're coming up
00:25:25 to uh the time for the debate here and i want to get to an update we have from our reporter in
00:25:30 alberta rachel emmanuel who is coming to us from medicine hat let's take a look at rachel's update
00:25:38 hey guys it's rachel emmanuel true north alberta correspondent i'm here live in medicine hat
00:25:43 where the first official UCP leadership race is set to begin at 5 p.m mountain time.
00:25:47 This is our first opportunity to see all seven approved candidates face off in an official party
00:25:51 debate. So I'm super excited to see what they have in store for us and see how the format will allow
00:25:55 for each candidate to have equal time. Obviously seven candidates is a lot to account for. Some of
00:25:59 the main issues to keep your eye out for this evening is health services. How do the candidates
00:26:04 plan to address AHS? There's been a lot of unhappiness with how they responded to the COVID-19
00:26:08 pandemic so you can be certain that we'll hear some issues on that as well as how candidates
00:26:12 plan to advocate for alberta and ottawa there's been a lot of tension in that relationship lately
00:26:17 so i'm looking really for some specific plans and policies that candidates are going to be
00:26:20 advocating for in terms of how they hope to get alberta a fair deal with ottawa all right looking
00:26:25 forward to it that was true north's alberta correspondent rachel emmanuel in front of the
00:26:33 helicopter that i think we now see standing by for the debate i actually don't know which
00:26:37 candidate the helicopter has endorsed but i think they're going to do that at the end of it and
00:26:42 looking at where those rotors are hopefully no one will hit the on switch during the debate because
00:26:45 i think that'll make for a very very awkward moment on the screen here but that's like an
00:26:50 erin o'toole move by the way doing the the sea king helicopter photo op so uh good they're doing
00:26:55 that here and again if you're wondering where that helicopter came from the debate is being held the
00:27:00 halo air ambulance hangar in medicine hat very important local business there in southern alberta
00:27:07 So this is going to be starting up in just a moment now.
00:27:11 So you can see on your screen, we'll carry it live.
00:27:13 Let me just ask you, William, who are you expecting to be the one to watch tonight?
00:27:18 You know these candidates, you know the players.
00:27:19 Who do you think is the one to watch for?
00:27:22 Yeah, that's a great question.
00:27:24 I think there's a couple of things that, you know, each candidate is going to have their own goals for tonight.
00:27:30 I think Travis Taves has to make a bit of a splash tonight.
00:27:33 I think he has to bring himself out of Jason Kenney's shadow and say, you know, here's my distinct vision for Alberta.
00:27:42 Here's why I'm the best choice.
00:27:44 And at the same time, here's why, say, Daniel Smith is the wrong choice.
00:27:49 Brian Jean, who, in my opinion, has had a pretty low-key campaign so far, which is surprising given that he was second to Jason Kenney in the last leadership race.
00:27:58 And also a very high-profile by-election victory for him not that long ago.
00:28:02 Nope, absolutely true. I think in some ways Daniel has eaten his lunch when it comes to this leadership race. I think a lot of the support that Mike have been seeing going to him, there's a perception it's maybe now going to Daniel instead.
00:28:16 He has to try and define this race in a sexual way that he becomes, you know, the dominant player.
00:28:23 If you are against the Jason Kenney status quo, you have to vote for Brian Jean and not Daniel Smith.
00:28:30 But that also means he'll be taking some tough runs at Daniel.
00:28:33 And for Daniel, I think she has to fend off accusations that her policies are either going to make her unelectable in a general election 0.69
00:28:43 or that voting for her would render the conservative choice,
00:28:49 the United Conservative choice, too unpalatable for Albertans.
00:28:51 So she'll be emphasizing that, you know, she's the voice you need,
00:28:56 the right choice, the smart choice when it comes to standing up
00:29:00 against Justin Trudeau in Ottawa.
00:29:02 I think you'll see her making that point.
00:29:04 Just in a moment here, William, for people,
00:29:06 because I've seen a few folks ask the question here,
00:29:08 how is the actual vote structured?
00:29:10 What's the format for winning the race?
00:29:13 So it's a mailing ballot and with an in-person voting option on election day, and you will end up voting, again, it's a 50% plus one.
00:29:23 So like the federal conservative race, no single candidate is declared the winner until they have a majority of votes.
00:29:29 So in the first vote, seven candidates could be very tough for any one person to get 50% plus one.
00:29:36 If they don't, then the candidate who received the fewest votes, they're dropped off from the ballot.
00:29:41 Their second choices are redistributed to the remaining candidates.
00:29:45 That process is repeated until one of the candidates achieves a 50% plus one.
00:29:50 The addition of in-person voting stations, of course, means, though, that there'll be actual vote counting on election day.
00:29:55 It can't all be done in the lead up to the race, which means it could be a bit uncertain when the actual result gets announced.
00:30:02 But, yeah, it's again, it's not like in an election first, a regular election of first past the post.
00:30:07 The candidate with the most votes wins.
00:30:09 This is someone who has to get second and third choice votes.
00:30:11 maybe that's good news for Travis Tanks.
00:30:14 Maybe he's counting on a lot of support from Rachel Sawney, Rebecca Schultz,
00:30:18 and the other cabin ministers to fall behind him.
00:30:21 I don't know.
00:30:22 And you're saying votes, not points, correct?
00:30:25 That is true.
00:30:26 It is a one-member, one-vote system, all ridings.
00:30:29 It doesn't matter if 1,000 people voting or riding or 10, that's how many votes.
00:30:33 It's 1,000 or 10.
00:30:34 There's no equalizing.
00:30:36 There's no redistributing.
00:30:37 None of those things that Albertans like, by the way,
00:30:39 either redistributing or equalizing we're against both of those things culturally are there any
00:30:44 are there any candidates in this race that really have a proven track record with aggressive
00:30:48 membership drives like in the federal race when patrick brown got in everyone knew okay patrick
00:30:53 brown's gonna hustle and sell memberships is that something that danielle smith and brian
00:30:57 gene who have led a party before were particularly known for uh you know the thing is is danielle
00:31:04 became Wild Rose leader when the party was still very small. We're talking about a few thousand
00:31:10 people choosing a leader, not tens of thousands or even more than a hundred thousand, depending on
00:31:16 how membership sales go here. I would say Brian Jean, probably out of all the candidates, has the
00:31:21 most experience selling memberships in a large pan-provincial leadership race. And of course,
00:31:28 he did it three years ago, three and a half years ago, when he was up against Jason Kenney, who had
00:31:33 quite a formidable sales machine. The next question is, does that Jason Kenney membership
00:31:39 sales machine still exist in some capacity? And if it does, are they moving over to support
00:31:45 Travis Taves? Are they going somewhere else? Are they sitting this race out? That's a big unknown
00:31:50 that we don't know right now. Yeah, Rebecca Schultz had a very high profile endorsement 0.95
00:31:55 from Ronna Ambrose. We know is very popular in the conservative movement, quite a good friend
00:31:59 of jason kenney's as well but i think a lot of the time we tend to overstate the role that
00:32:04 endorsements have in membership sales unless it's accompanied by someone who has a machine who has
00:32:09 a list and who's prepared to put that towards you we are running a couple of minutes behind here but
00:32:15 you can see on this on the screen we'll cut to the debate the second the debate starts up and
00:32:19 i see someone on the stage putting binders down so that seems to be a good start towards getting it
00:32:26 off to the races here. Let me just ask you, William, about preparation here, because obviously
00:32:33 it's a shorter race, but there's going to be another official debate. There's going to be
00:32:37 other opportunities for candidates to speak out, to do interviews. Do you want to hold back some
00:32:43 of your best material for later in this race, or do you want to come out swinging and really make
00:32:48 that splash now? You know, it's interesting. I think for many of the candidates who will be on
00:32:55 station tonight tonight is an important night to give themselves some profile and some differentiation
00:33:00 from everybody else in the race the i always joke the worst place to be in a leadership race is when
00:33:06 the media are describing it and they talk about a handful of the front running candidates and then
00:33:12 they say also in the race are yada yada yada and what you did in like the first three minutes of
00:33:17 this basically yeah absolutely and and it's a real problem because also in the race is are these
00:33:23 people is a really difficult position to be in when you're trying to raise money, when you're
00:33:28 trying to sell a bunch of memberships across the province. So tonight is one of the few times,
00:33:33 I think, when hopefully a lot of UCP members or potential members are going to be watching.
00:33:38 And in which case, yeah, you have to stand out. You have to make a bit of a splash.
00:33:43 The other factor, of course, is that there is about only, I think, 16 or so days until that
00:33:50 membership cutoff happens you are running out of what we would call in politics runway to get your
00:33:55 campaign into a competitive position and so if you aren't really coming out of the gate i think
00:34:01 in a good position tonight you're just going to have such a hard time trying to build a membership
00:34:07 sales machine and sell a lot of memberships in the next two and a bit weeks i think it was the 2012
00:34:12 presidential republican presidential primary where they had so many candidates running they
00:34:17 had two debates. They had like the upper tier candidate debate and the lower tier candidate
00:34:22 debate. And I'm like, how bad would it be if you were just relegated to, you know, debating Carly
00:34:26 Fiorina or whatever? Well, everyone else debates in the big one. So in this particular case, you
00:34:31 know, at least everyone's on one stage. But you're right. I mean, if you're going into this and
00:34:35 certain people in the audience are only paying attention to what Danielle Smith has to say and
00:34:39 what Brian Jean has to say, that's a bit of a problem. And interestingly enough, Rachel Emanuel,
00:34:45 who is our Alberta correspondent on the ground there has said that the UCP is not telling
00:34:50 reporters the format they've not published it anywhere I've gotten little bits of it from
00:34:55 contacts I have on the leadership campaigns but they're keeping the format a secret but what we
00:35:00 do know is that there's going to be a lot of interaction there's going to be a lot of one-on-one
00:35:05 one person said they heard there was going to be like a almost a cross-examination of sorts where
00:35:10 A candidate gets to put another candidate on the hot seat. And interestingly enough, I've moderated debates that have some element of that. And there's a strategy to who you pick, because on one hand, you want to be able to fire the silver bullet that goes towards the front runner that makes them look bad.
00:35:28 But on the other hand, if you ask someone a question, you're also giving them 60, 90 seconds, whatever it is of time to speak to the camera.
00:35:36 Whereas, you know, if you ask a nobody a question or a less well-known candidate, then you don't you're elevating them in a way.
00:35:44 So I think that's the big challenge here. It sounds like we have the debate just about to start here.
00:35:51 We'll throw to that as soon as we have it ready. But let me just say, William, do you have any predictions here?
00:35:57 Who do you think is going to come out on top?
00:35:59 You know, that's an interesting question.
00:36:02 Out of the candidates who have run before, Brian Jean and Daniel Smith have both done debates.
00:36:08 They've both done leaders debates.
00:36:10 Brian Jean, I will say from 2015, wasn't particularly favorably reviewed for his debate performance.
00:36:18 I'm sure that's in the minds of his campaign team, and they've been working very hard on that since.
00:36:23 Daniel Smith, very telegenic.
00:36:26 Sorry, we'll have to cut you off there.
00:36:29 The debate is beginning now, live from Medicine Hat.
00:36:32 medicine hat and cypress madison hat for the inspiration for this event we
00:36:56 we are very pleased to be partnering with them. Also of note is that the questions tonight were
00:37:08 developed from thousands of submissions received from our membership. This leadership election is
00:37:16 an extremely important decision for our party. We are electing a premier and the leader who will
00:37:23 take us into the next election. Best of luck to the candidates with their
00:37:28 efforts here tonight. I would be remiss if I didn't remind you of these important
00:37:34 deadlines. Anyone wanting to participate in this event has to have a UCP
00:37:41 membership by 11 59 p.m. on August 12th. Ballots will be mailed on September
00:37:48 2nd and must be received by october 3rd the new ucp leader will be presented to all albertans on
00:37:57 october 6th in calgary now on with the show i'd like to introduce you to our moderator for this
00:38:06 debate jeff davison jeff is a former calgary city councillor and presently the ceo of the
00:38:21 prostate cancer center take it away jeff thank you cynthia give cynthia a round of applause
00:38:30 Good evening, everybody, and welcome to the first United Conservative Party 2022
00:38:36 official leadership.
00:38:45 Candidates on stage to give us their positions on a series of questions submitted by you,
00:38:50 the UCP Party membership from across the province. Each candidate will be given an
00:38:55 equal opportunity to speak. The order by which we address the questions from our members has been
00:39:01 predetermined by
00:39:25 My only rule for these rebuttals is that candidates can't use them all at once.
00:39:46 So to keep things fair, if a candidate is named in the debate and they aren't an active
00:39:50 participant in it, I'll bring them in and allow them some time to respond.
00:39:54 Okay, and just a reminder to all the candidates. We've got a lot of things to get through tonight
00:39:58 So we're gonna be keeping a sharp eye on the clock. If you go over time
00:40:02 I will ask you to stop if you choose to keep talking
00:40:04 We'll just cut the microphone off and trust me. It's far more embarrassing for you than it will be for me
00:40:09 All right at the end of this all
00:40:11 I'm gonna ask each candidate in order of random draw to give a one-minute closing statement
00:40:15 Which would be their final pitch to you the UCP membership across Alberta and last request
00:40:21 all right this one's for members of the audience okay i ask one thing from you you refrain from
00:40:26 reacting to answers from the candidates please no clapping or cheering or booing or no signs
00:40:31 or placards those just interfere with all of our cameras let's be respectful and remind ourselves
00:40:36 that we're all one party here time is tight and we will not be stopping the clock so please don't
00:40:40 distract the candidates all right everybody ready here we go let's start things off with opening
00:40:46 statements mr lowen you have the floor one minute please hello everyone it's great to be here
00:40:51 today and it's great to be in medicine hat it's been a great campaign so far crisscrossing alberta
00:40:58 and it's great to be here in the southeast part of the province of course i'm from the northwest
00:41:01 part of the province in the peace country and there i'm a husband a father of five a grandfather
00:41:08 of eight and maybe more on the way and so but i'm running for the ucp leadership for one simple
00:41:15 reason to give our party back to its membership to bring back trust accountability transparency
00:41:26 now my campaign is this theme is your alberta your way this is a my focus is to offer the
00:41:34 party an opportunity to reconnect with the broader conservative movement and all albertans
00:41:40 I believe the best way to do this is with a fresh slate of ideas, firmly grounded in principles
00:41:46 and values that we all share. I look forward to sharing any of these ideas going forward. Thank
00:41:53 you. Thank you, Mr. Lohan. Ms. Smith, over to you. One minute. Thank you, Jeff. I'm Danielle Smith.
00:41:58 I'm a business owner. I've been a business advocate. I've been a print radio, TV, and podcast
00:42:04 journalist and I can say I've been in the public eye for about 25 years. I've discussed thousands
00:42:10 of issues. I've been right about a lot of things. I've been wrong about a few things, but that's
00:42:16 okay. I'm not perfect. I do always try to learn from others. I try to consult broadly and I try
00:42:21 to keep an open discussion and a fair mind as I'm listening to people who disagree with me.
00:42:26 And that I think is important to bring to politics. It's important to have that respectful debate and
00:42:31 the broad range of discussion on a whole variety of issues the reason i think we're here tonight
00:42:36 though is because we're trying to choose the best leader for this party we're trying to ask the
00:42:42 question who is going to be the best person to stand up to ottawa who is going to be the best
00:42:47 person to take on rachel notley and win in the next election and who is the best person to give
00:42:52 you back your freedoms and to protect them and i think that person's me i look forward to telling
00:42:56 you why. Thank you, Ms. Smith. Right on time. All right, Ms. Ani, one minute. Up to you. Thank you,
00:43:01 Jeff. Canada is going down a dangerous path and Alberta is being seriously impacted, negatively
00:43:08 impacted by decisions made in Ottawa. We all know that. Decisions made through an ideological lens
00:43:15 without empathy for the communities rely on those industries, the people who rely on those jobs,
00:43:21 the family incomes and the customers who benefit from our products and what are we to do about it
00:43:28 alberta must fight back absolutely but we can't be risky and we can't be hot-headed being premier
00:43:35 is a lot more than being a talk show host we need stable and serious government in alberta
00:43:42 now more than ever before i experienced this in 2007 and again in 2015 during the royalty review
00:43:50 when investment fled the province and that was due to provincial policy and that was tame compared
00:43:58 to the sovereignty act thank you all right thanks miss sonny okay reset the clock miss schultz one
00:44:04 minute i'm rebecca schultz and i'm running to be the leader of this amazing party and the next
00:44:09 premier of alberta because i love alberta we cannot take the future of our province for granted
00:44:17 Albertans I've met say they want a leader who can unite this party and that starts with our team to
00:44:22 take on Rachel Notley and the NDP in 2023. That takes someone who knows that unity starts with
00:44:30 our team and you, our party members. Someone who is disciplined, who won't let you down
00:44:36 with embarrassing comments, but instead...
00:44:47 .
00:45:17 Thank you.
00:45:47 for prosperity, opportunity, and growth.
00:45:56 Thank you, Mr. Taves.
00:45:57 Last but not least, Mr. Jean, over to you.
00:46:00 One minute.
00:46:00 Thanks, Jeff.
00:46:01 Hello, everyone.
00:46:02 I'm Brian Jean, and I'm running to be the leader of the party,
00:46:05 this great party that so many of us did so much work to start.
00:46:10 I'm running for the leadership because I want to make Albertans the happiest,
00:46:13 the healthiest, the most free and most prosperous people in Canada,
00:46:16 and the world. I want to be your premier to help you have more control of your
00:46:21 life, more autonomy. As an Albertan I've strived to serve my community, my
00:46:27 neighbors, whether as a business owner, a lawyer, a community volunteer, a member
00:46:33 of Parliament, a party leader or an MLA. I believe that the United Conservative
00:46:38 Party has the best ideas and the best principles. If the UCP is led in a way
00:46:43 that connects with normal everyday Albertans we will have success and we will serve and lead
00:46:48 Albertans to prosperity for many years to come. This party has wonderful people in it. We only
00:46:53 have to renew the UCP and connect it to the wishes and the needs of Albertans and if we do that we
00:46:59 will win the next election against the NDP. Thank you. Thank you Mr. Jean. All right thank you to all
00:47:04 the candidates. All right we're now going to move into the question round. So the first question
00:47:09 is going to you mr lowen you'll have just a reminder you'll have two minutes to answer
00:47:13 at which point then i'll ask you the question who would you like to debate we'll go from there
00:47:17 all right first topic topic is affordability let's face it the cost of living in alberta and
00:47:24 around the globe is getting more expensive significant price increases for gas food
00:47:29 heating our homes and electricity coupled with skyrocketing inflation have all negatively
00:47:34 affected alberta families and in particular our seniors first nations and other vulnerable
00:47:39 communities if alberta's primary value proposition is an affordable high quality of life how would
00:47:46 you work to ensure this for everyone and what specifically would you do
00:48:09 Thank you.
00:48:40 Hi, let me just chime in here that the issues you are seeing are actually with the feed that
00:48:46 the United Conservative Party is putting out. We're taking our feed from them. And it's
00:48:51 unfortunate because they don't seem to be aware that these issues are going on. So there
00:48:55 are aspects that are being missed. I'm sorry about that. And if you look at other streams,
00:49:00 which I would encourage you not to do, you'll find that it is actually the same issue there.
00:49:04 We can jump back to the debate now in Medicine Hat.
00:49:09 and apparently that was another false start so uh this is an issue and again it's funny we
00:49:35 were trying to do a little live update with rachel emmanuel early you may know at the beginning we
00:49:40 played a video that she was pre-recorded and she couldn't connect because she was in rural alberta
00:49:46 in an airplane hangar and at the time we thought oh well that's unfortunate we wanted to have her
00:49:50 live and didn't realize that this would prevent the ucp itself from being able to put a live stream
00:49:56 of its debate forward so let's hope they're recording the video at least so afterwards
00:50:01 it will be available for people to watch uh we have i know it's just me on the screen right now
00:50:05 but we are waiting for their feed to start and literally the second their feed starts
00:50:10 we'll go back to the debate in progress which is right now
00:50:16 for everyone and what specifically would you do to build upon the alberta advantage
00:50:20 sure affordability is a big deal in alberta right now we're facing a time of inflation that
00:50:25 we haven't seen in decades and you know as minister of finance i was privileged to suspend
00:50:30 the fuel tax in this province saving every albertan 13 cents a liter every time they fuel up number one
00:50:36 i would make that program permanent in alberta we can do that all albertans can benefit from
00:50:41 an owned resource because our revenues are not jeopardized as our royalty income offsets any
00:50:47 tax that we might lose in that program the other thing i will do and that is i will scrap the gdl
00:50:54 for young alberta drivers right now half a million young alberta drivers still have their gdl
00:51:00 that means that program's not providing any safety to our roads what it does do it adds a
00:51:05 150 of cost to every young albertan and requires them to do another road test i would scrap that
00:51:12 immediately i will also bring forward a child tax credit that will work effectively like expanding
00:51:20 the personal exemption on your tax return that will provide every family with two thousand dollars
00:51:26 of additional deduction or tax credit for every child at a time when many families are really
00:51:32 pushed and stretched to make the end of the month that will provide real relief all right okay that
00:51:38 ends the first part of the question we're now going to go into four minutes of open debate
00:51:42 between mr taves mr lowen mr loan kick us off okay so mr taves i guess one thing that i think
00:51:48 is concerning to albertans is the the four million four billion dollars of covet spending that uh
00:51:53 that the auditor jenner wasn't able to figure out so i i think we need to have some answers on that
00:51:57 and when i look at uh this government's record again we we're sitting here in 112 billion dollars
00:52:02 of debt uh i don't see uh that there's been a plan to pay down that debt and uh start cutting back
00:52:08 in that those interest payments so i would like to hear some more uh information on that i would
00:52:13 i think that we we're in a situation now where we've we've watched this this uh train wreck
00:52:18 coming slowly and slowly and now we're in a situation where when you compare our debt compared
00:52:23 to the federal debt and on an individual basis we're just as high or higher and that's i think
00:52:28 alarming for albertans that are that are working hard and and doing their best to to support their
00:52:33 families and living within their means and we have a government that hasn't been living within this
00:52:37 means we complained about the ndp and how often how how their budget was so high and we complained
00:52:44 about their spending when we were in uh in opposition but here we are spending 10 more
00:52:48 than the ndp did i can see you're ready to jump in mr tables feel free to jump in anytime all
00:52:53 right this is open debate good all right well thank you here first thing on the auditor general
00:52:57 report number one there's no four billion dollars that are missing the auditor general gave the
00:53:03 government of alberta a clean audit report for all of you in the room that know what a clean audit
00:53:07 report is that means there are no funds missing, not one dollar. And yes, we have brought fiscal
00:53:14 discipline to the province. I, as the Minister of Finance, brought fiscal discipline to this
00:53:19 province. We had a $10 billion overspend, a spending addiction, inherited from the NDP and
00:53:26 previous PC governments, if I'm honest. We have narrowed, in fact, by this fiscal year, we will
00:53:31 have eliminated that $10 billion overspend. That was job number one in putting this province on
00:53:37 sustainable fiscal trajectory because friends we balanced the budget not on a hundred dollar oil
00:53:42 we balanced it on 70 69 and 66 dollar oil by bringing fiscal discipline to the province's
00:53:50 finances and positioning this province for investment attraction economic growth which
00:53:54 results in expanded fiscal capacity that combination has allowed allowed me as the
00:54:00 minister of finance to present a balanced budget through all three years of the fiscal plan
00:54:07 finally putting this province on a sustainable fiscal trajectory let's let mr lowen jump in
00:54:11 here what do you got to say okay yeah mr tables i appreciate your uh coming on side with the gdl
00:54:16 i think that's actually a really good idea when uh but i think what a lot of people are wondering
00:54:21 when we have a musing about a pst i think albertans are very concerned about that i i am against and
00:54:27 i never have been in favor and never even used about a pst like you have and i think that's
00:54:33 something that should be cleared up right away that uh that this government will not put forward
00:54:38 a pst on albertans i think that's very important that's something we've we've talked about a lot
00:54:42 and i think we we've defended that a lot but now we have a couple couple of candidates up here sure
00:54:48 that have talked about the pst and i think we need to set the record straight and i'll set it straight
00:54:53 all right so go ahead and i will set this the record straight there's only one leadership hopeful
00:54:57 that i'm aware of on this stage that is not only mused about a pst but actually advocated for a
00:55:04 pst and todd lowen that's the leadership hopeful standing right next to you i have never mused
00:55:10 about a pst look if you want to know what i would do as premier look at what i did as finance
00:55:15 minister i balanced the budget by actually reducing business taxes i balanced the budget
00:55:21 by bringing fiscal discipline to this problem let's get a quick rebuttal in here let's get
00:55:25 get let's get going but you did also muse on the the pst and uh as far as the four billion dollars
00:55:31 could you explain where it went i mean we the auditor general said that it was that there was
00:55:36 no records of where where did that go the auditor general gave the province a clean audit report it
00:55:42 was recorded that doesn't tell us where the money was ending full stop it's all recorded
00:55:45 and accounted all right all right all right okay so that ends the first round of open debate
00:55:50 that actually went a little smoother than i thought it would be there was no throwing that
00:55:54 That was perfect. Okay, so we've had a few folks put up their paddle. That means we've got 45 seconds to chime in. 0.90
00:56:00 I have Ms. Ahir, Ms. Schultz, Ms. Ani, and Ms. Smith. Is that the correct order? Anybody else?
00:56:06 All right. Okay, let's go ahead, Ms. Ahir. 45 seconds.
00:56:08 Thank you so much. First of all, there's many people on this stage that were part of government.
00:56:12 There is no I in team. We do these things together.
00:56:15 If we're going to build this team, let's start talking about how we did these things collectively.
00:56:19 Second of all, yes, re-index tax benefits.
00:56:21 We need to catch up for the past years, but you also need to notify the CRA to reduce the tax withholding on Albertans and the paychecks.
00:56:28 That actually leaves more money in your pockets.
00:56:31 Our government has not kept up with pace with inflation, and for that, we actually owe you an apology.
00:56:37 So, we need to re-index AISH, Alberta Seniors Benefits.
00:56:40 We have to catch up and move forward.
00:56:42 I would like to also present an opportunity for small business tax thresholds, index of inflation. 0.94
00:56:47 Women-run, Indigenous-run businesses, farmers manufacturing new Canadians
00:56:51 are growing at amazing rates, including probably faster than Albertans. 0.55
00:56:55 That's 45 seconds there. I know it's fast. Thanks, Ms. Zaheer.
00:56:57 Okay, Ms. Schultz, 45 seconds to you.
00:56:59 I was the first candidate to bring forward a platform on affordability
00:57:02 because it is the number one issue I hear from Albertans.
00:57:05 Invest in kids' activities, yes, I love that idea.
00:57:08 We committed to it first.
00:57:10 Getting rid of the small business tax, starting for two years
00:57:12 so that small businesses know that they're respected,
00:57:15 they're the backbone of our community.
00:57:16 I absolutely think we need to continue fuel tax relief and re-index personal income taxes.
00:57:22 I was also the first candidate to put forward a plan for what to do with a surplus,
00:57:26 35% into debt repayment, 35% in saving for our future, and 30% to address affordability needs.
00:57:34 Now, I would say the same.
00:57:35 One person does not balance a budget as a minister who worked hard to transform every area of her ministry
00:57:40 to do better by Albertans, not only in the types of programs we offer, but the amount of dollars we invest.
00:57:45 That's it. That's 45. I know it's fast. All right, Ms. Sani, 45 seconds.
00:57:48 Thank you. And yes, of course, affordability is on top of mind for most Albertans.
00:57:53 And these issues with inflation hit middle-class, hardworking families the most.
00:57:58 And I had announced earlier on, several weeks earlier, that I was planning to ensure that we index income tax brackets
00:58:06 and we index social support such as seniors' benefits and age recipients as well.
00:58:12 because, again, vulnerable communities are also hit very, very hard with the inflation rate that
00:58:18 we haven't seen these rates since the early 80s. I also want to make a comment about GDL. While it
00:58:25 is a good policy on paper, I would have to say that it sounds like there has been limited
00:58:29 consultation done because driving schools would be impacted very severely with this kind of policy.
00:58:35 All right. Ms. Smith, over to you, 45 seconds.
00:58:38 All right. As I said, as a columnist over 25 years, I've mused on a lot of issues. And I want to put into context my musing. It was when we were at $24 billion in a deficit. We only had $2 billion worth of resource revenue. I think when you have those circumstances, it's no surprise that the Premier and the Finance Minister and I were talking about how do we solve that problem.
00:58:58 Fortunately, resource revenues have bailed us out again, notwithstanding what the former finance minister said.
00:59:05 We have a $4 billion surplus. That's great.
00:59:08 We've got $16 billion with the resource revenue this year.
00:59:11 That means we have a $12 billion structural deficit that we still haven't solved.
00:59:15 I wrote a major paper for the School of Public Policy that had several elements about how we would restructure,
00:59:21 how we would create house spending accounts so that we could address this issue and grow our heritage savings trust.
00:59:26 That's time. There we go. Okay, first question out of the way. No takers on any other things?
00:59:30 All right, okay, we're going to move on. Question two, this question is for you, Ms. Smith.
00:59:35 It has to do with the environment. Conservative Albertans are often villainized as not caring
00:59:40 about the environment despite having a track record of clean and ethical energy production
00:59:45 that supports a healthy Canadian economy. The opposition targets conservatives with
00:59:50 negative rhetoric around ghg reduction decarbonization net zero policies and adaptation
00:59:56 of physical planning all under the umbrella of a climate emergency spending billions without any
01:00:01 defined outcomes alternatively most conservatives would say they care a great deal about the
01:00:06 environment today and what they will leave behind for generations to come albertans value our clean
01:00:12 air lakes outdoor spaces trails and mountains to name a few what would you do to change the
01:00:19 narrative around this negative environmental stereotype and what specific targets would you
01:00:24 strive to achieve in order to create a greener more sustainable alberta you have two minutes
01:00:29 thanks so much jeff i remember getting hit by graham thompson years ago in 2012 when i talked
01:00:35 about how the science wasn't settled on climate change and i can tell you uh what i've come around
01:00:40 full circle on that i am i am now probably the first and early adopter of thinking that we can
01:00:46 hit a net zero target and we can get there faster than anyone anywhere else and i'll tell you why i
01:00:51 believe that number one has been the incredible innovation that we have seen among our entrepreneurs
01:00:57 and in the business community and we as conservatives have always believed that
01:01:01 technology was going to be the answer and i can tell you it is the answer whether we capture the
01:01:06 co2 and bury it underground or whether we turn it into useful products like carbon nanofiber which
01:01:11 can be a replacement for steel cement so we can make a more durable construction material plastics
01:01:17 we can also turn it into industrial minerals that can be turned into soap my favorite one is you can
01:01:22 turn it into alcohol there is a a company called airco that takes a pure stream of co2 and makes
01:01:28 it into vodka you can just imagine the marketing opportunities on that one so when i look at the
01:01:33 at the challenge that we have that is the message that we have to get out there is that we have
01:01:37 immense poor space in Alberta that will allow us to capture CO2. Our conversion of our economy
01:01:43 to a hydrogen economy is already well underway with this government. We're building a hub
01:01:47 in the Edmonton area. If we start building hydrogen fueling stations all over this province,
01:01:52 we'll be able to change over our long-haul vehicles to be hydrogen-based. Then we will be
01:01:58 able to be a hub for the construction of hydrogen vehicles. Why not attract Toyota here so that they
01:02:04 They can build their Toyota Mirais.
01:02:06 Why do we have to wait for Ottawa to be the center of the auto industry?
01:02:11 We can be the center of auto manufacturing here.
01:02:14 But that's not the only issue.
01:02:15 Once we get the issue of CO2 out of the way and people see that we are serious about solving it and getting there faster than anywhere else,
01:02:21 we also have to tackle the issues of air quality, of water quality, of making sure that we're doing habitat protection,
01:02:28 which our farmers and ranchers do so well.
01:02:30 And I can't wait to sell that message.
01:02:32 All right. Thank you.
01:02:32 okay who would you like to debate on this topic i would like to uh debate uh raj ansani all right
01:02:38 miss sani again the question was what would you do to change the negative or the narrative around
01:02:42 this negative environmental stereotype and what specific targets would you strive to achieve in
01:02:47 order to create a greener more sustainable alberta you have a minute and a half thank you well there
01:02:52 are a number of areas that we need to look at but i'm going to talk about energy specifically the
01:02:58 The reality is, is that even Canadians across this country have a very negative perception
01:03:03 of Alberta.
01:03:04 They think of us as rich emitters.
01:03:06 And before we can tackle the issues with security of supply, we need to make sure that we have
01:03:12 more information out all across the nation to ensure that Canadians understand that Alberta
01:03:19 energy is the cleanest, most ethical source of energy absolutely in the world.
01:03:25 Now, the other thing that I wanted to talk about as it relates to energy, because we
01:03:28 talk quite a bit about transition in energy, and there are two aspects that we have to
01:03:34 keep in mind.
01:03:35 We've already talked about hydrogen, that has been mentioned.
01:03:37 We have ample natural gas resources here in Alberta, and that can translate into hydrogen
01:03:44 supply.
01:03:45 We are still working on the demand portion of that equation.
01:03:48 And that was some of the work that I was doing as Minister of Transportation.
01:03:52 Now, going to LNG, I thought that we had missed the boat on LNG, but that's actually not true.
01:03:58 Because of the geopolitical situation that we are seeing right now in Europe,
01:04:03 we know, again, security of supply is on top of mind for everyone.
01:04:07 And Alberta is, again, on the cusp, uniquely positioned to be the supplier of natural gas for LNG.
01:04:14 But what concerns me is when we start talking about things like the Sovereignty Act,
01:04:19 That is the number one thing that is going to drive investment away from our profits.
01:04:23 All right, I've got to cut you off there.
01:04:24 I'm sorry.
01:04:25 I know a minute and a half is tough.
01:04:26 It's all tough.
01:04:27 It's hard to get everything you want to say in a couple minutes.
01:04:29 All right, let's start four minutes of open debate.
01:04:32 Smith, I'm going to start with you.
01:04:33 And if I have to, I'll force back and forth 30 seconds so that we kind of make some points
01:04:36 and allow some time.
01:04:38 You got it.
01:04:39 I'd love to talk more about the Sovereignty Act because it's absolutely essential to getting
01:04:42 our...
01:04:43 Well, let's keep this one on the environment.
01:04:44 It will.
01:04:45 it's absolutely essential to getting our products to market because what I would like to see is us
01:04:50 take the lead on developing economic corridors. We have been waiting since the 1930s for Ottawa
01:04:57 to develop economic corridors. It's been almost 100 years. They are not going to develop economic
01:05:02 corridors for us, but we've got such a huge opportunity to partner with our First Nations
01:05:06 community. We've got the treaty settlements that have happened in Alberta, Saskatchewan,
01:05:10 and Manitoba. There's a group of 14 First Nations that want to take the lead on developing
01:05:15 an economic corridor and it would be 10 kilometers wide and the nice part about it is by making it
01:05:19 wide enough you can take care of your caribou habitat you can make sure that you're doing
01:05:24 your landowner protection you can identify endangered species and habitat and wetlands
01:05:28 and you can take care of that as well but then you can also develop the rail line I just want
01:05:33 to say that yeah we don't need an unconstitutional impractical sovereignty act to develop economic
01:05:39 corridors in fact that work is already underway as the minister of transportation this was one
01:05:44 of my key priorities and I worked with MLS Shane Getson on this because what happened when we had
01:05:50 the BC storms and those highways and bridges were decimated, all the traffic came through highway
01:05:56 number three and that is why one of the first things that I did when I interacted with the
01:06:01 federal government was to tell them that we need to develop that economic corridor, that's an
01:06:07 agri-food corridor and I applied for money through the National Trade Corridor Fund. I'm going to go back here for a minute because the question is on the environment, right?
01:06:13 we're looking for tangible pieces to move forward in terms of how do you change that negative
01:06:18 stereotype right and what specific targets are you going to move forward with to achieve a more
01:06:23 sustainable greener alberta so well part of that that's a big membership question part of that
01:06:28 conversation is ensuring that we're maintaining investor confidence because if we are going to
01:06:33 invest in greener technology and we are going to encourage people from across the globe to
01:06:39 come to alberta for example if we want to invest in high-speed rail that could be powered by
01:06:44 hydrogen-powered locomotive that investor confidence needs to be maintained any work
01:06:50 that you want to do on environmental initiatives requires bringing investment in and it requires
01:06:55 being entrepreneurial and it requires supporting our local residents as well but if we have a
01:07:00 situation where we have a candidate who is inviting a situation of turmoil of chaos and inviting
01:07:07 investors to stay away from our province because we're too politically risky that is the problem
01:07:13 not just for the environment for energy and agriculture ottawa has created chaos ottawa has
01:07:18 cancelled our projects ottawa has caused energy east and tech frontier mine and tens of billions
01:07:24 of other projects to be cancelled the reason these are linked is because part of our strategy
01:07:30 in reducing greenhouse gas emit is exporting our clean lng to displace coal in india and china we
01:07:36 We cannot do that because Ottawa keeps standing in our way.
01:07:40 We need to build economic corridors.
01:07:42 We need to take the lead on that.
01:07:43 We need to work with our First Nations.
01:07:45 We need to take the lead on solving the environmental issues
01:07:47 so that we can get our product to Churchill,
01:07:50 to Thunder Bay, to Tuktoyaktuk, to Port-au-Prince Rupert.
01:07:53 And we have to exert our sovereignty to do that
01:07:55 because Ottawa is not going to do it for us.
01:07:57 We have a fight on our hands with Ottawa, absolutely.
01:07:59 And that fight is long, it's arduous.
01:08:01 There are no shortcuts, people.
01:08:03 There is no Magical Sovereignty Act
01:08:05 any other legislation that is going to let us bypass those very difficult steps the problem is
01:08:11 when we shoot ourselves in the foot with provincial policies provincial policies like
01:08:16 a sovereignty act that is creating a politically risky environment and that is going to impact
01:08:21 everything exactly what i said earlier environmental initiatives energy initiatives
01:08:26 agricultural initiatives this is tantalizing the act it's seductive it draws you in but it is an
01:08:33 illusion and my question is what are you going to do when you can't deliver what you're trying to
01:08:38 sell all right okay that ends our four minutes it's getting hot in here all right as far as
01:08:47 paddles go mr tabes you put up your paddle there i noticed you 45 seconds on the clock for you
01:08:51 all right good thanks jeff i have to agree with miss sonny on this one implementing the sovereignty
01:08:57 act simply we can't wish all of ottawa's obstructionism away by waving the magic wand
01:09:03 on the sovereignty act i agree a sovereignty act the way it is proposed would ultimately bring a
01:09:09 lack of predictability and uncertainty into this province that would drive investment outlook we've
01:09:14 made great progress in the last three years alberta will lead the nation in economic growth this year
01:09:19 and next we cannot unwind that we don't win when we operate from a position of weakness now what we
01:09:25 need to do we need to sell what we do already we have the most responsible energy and agriculture
01:09:31 industries in the world we need to sell their responsibility because the world needs more
01:09:36 alberta energy and alberta agriculture all right thank you right on time were there any other
01:09:40 panels that i missed nobody going once all right twice let's move on here question three is for
01:09:46 miss sani all right it's on health care reform the cobin 19 pandemic placed enormous pressure
01:09:52 on health systems across the country and around the world canada's premiers say it is intensified
01:09:59 pre-existing fractures in health systems all across the country and that we're now at a critical
01:10:04 point the premiers are asking the federal government to increase the canada health transfer
01:10:10 to help ensure we all have access to high quality and timely health services with specifics as leader
01:10:16 How would you ensure that Albertans get the tests, procedures, and health services they need when they need them?
01:10:24 Ms. Ani, you have two minutes.
01:10:25 Thank you, Jeff. Excellent question, because health care is another issue that's been on top of mind for Albertans.
01:10:31 When I launched my campaign, one of the first things I did was to indicate that I will launch a transparent, open inquiry into the pandemic response,
01:10:41 because we have done a number of things right in this response and we have done a number of things
01:10:46 wrong we all know that and there are a diversity of opinions on this matter and we need everyone
01:10:51 to come to the table to discuss that the outcome of that inquiry will show us where the gaps are
01:10:57 in the health care system that arose as a result of the pandemic so that is number one number two
01:11:03 my intention is to repair relationships with doctors physicians health care workers nurses
01:11:10 because we cannot move forward in any significant fashion on any kind of health care reform
01:11:16 if we don't have those who are central and intrinsic to the system at the table many of you
01:11:22 know that your physicians are community leaders as well and we have to stop this war with the
01:11:27 physicians number three i think everybody in this room will agree that there are issues with alberta
01:11:33 health services we know that i was in rural alberta not too long ago in a room full of elected
01:11:40 officials and there was a big screen on the tv with a representative from ahs he told everybody
01:11:46 in that room that there is nothing to see there here you have what you need and you have enough
01:11:52 doctors the data shows it there is a woman several people actually who are crying in that room she
01:11:58 said to me i will die in this community because first of all we won't get an ambulance and secondly
01:12:04 if an ambulance does come there will be no doctor at that hospital so alberta health services is an
01:12:11 inverted triangle it needs to be flipped it's too top heavy and one of the comments that came up
01:12:17 actually from physicians in edmonton was that maybe we need to move back to regional boards
01:12:22 there are many aspects of asia that need to be dismantled all right that's two minutes
01:12:27 who would you like to debate on the health care topic uh miss daniel smith all right miss smith
01:12:32 i'll repeat the question one more time for you all right let's settle down folks with specifics
01:12:38 as leader how would you ensure that albertans get the tests procedures and health services they need
01:12:44 when they need them you have a minute and one sure i just want to take a moment to clarify
01:12:48 a comment i made in a podcast last week about cancer that was misunderstood i know that cancer
01:12:55 can strike anyone at any time without any relation to lifestyle especially kids but not just kids
01:13:02 it happened to my mother-in-law too she was diagnosed with ovarian cancer and only survived
01:13:07 three months after diagnosis and by the time they found out she was so malnourished that they weren't
01:13:12 able to continue her chemo treatments that's why i became such a proponent of early detection early
01:13:19 treatment nutrition and holistic medicine there are so many more options if you diagnose early
01:13:27 then you can treat early and that's what i was trying to say i'll be in very awkwardly but it's
01:13:32 in that vein that is why i proposed health spending accounts because we spend so much money
01:13:38 on the back end when people have a disease that manifests and we spend no money on the front end
01:13:44 on prevention to keep people well and so if we were to establish health spending accounts with
01:13:49 $300 in it. We'd all be able to deal with the trauma of the last two years. Mental health,
01:13:55 counseling, nutrition, dietician, naturopathic doctors, chiropractors, physiotherapists. If we
01:14:01 can start spending some money at the front end, I think it's going to be transformative in the
01:14:05 system. And we will save money as people are not going into the system. And when we get into fall
01:14:10 respiratory virus season, we're going to make sure that we have enough room to be able to handle that
01:14:14 surgeon patient load. That's the first step I take. All right. Thank you, Ms. Smith. All right,
01:14:18 let's start the clock for four minutes of debate. Ms. Soni, kick us off. Okay, thank you, Jeff. And 1.00
01:14:24 thank you, Ms. Smith, for your clarification of your comments. But I'm sorry, I'm not buying it
01:14:30 because you made a subsequent video where you actually doubled down on your perspective. And
01:14:34 the reality is, is that those comments are very hurtful to any Albertan, any Canadian who has
01:14:40 lost somebody from cancer, or anybody who is suffering from cancer right now. There is another
01:14:46 aspect to cancer that i want to talk about right now when i had launched i had talked about mental
01:14:51 health supports it's a reality that many cancer survivors experience debilitating depression
01:14:57 after their treatments so to the comments that were made basically diminishes the experience
01:15:02 of cancer survivors and their families and i want to know when are you going to apologize to alberta
01:15:08 for the comments that you made i did apologize because i was clearly misunderstood uh one of
01:15:13 the main points i wanted to make as well i've been talking with icor blood services they have
01:15:18 i mentioned this in the podcast as well they have a test of thirteen hundred dollars that
01:15:22 would allow us to look at biomarkers in the blood i think every one of us who've had a loved one die
01:15:27 of cancer have always said gosh if only we caught it earlier the reason we say that is because we
01:15:34 know that when you catch it earlier there are far more treatment options that was the intention
01:15:38 of what i i wanted to say i know that the that icor blood services has approached the government
01:15:43 to see if they would fund a pilot program into this 1300 test you know what if i was premier
01:15:48 you bet absolutely i would because i know that if somebody has a pre-existing condition if they have
01:15:54 some kind of genetic predisposition towards cancer if they're beginning to see early symptoms it will
01:15:58 be the very best way for us to diagnose and then we can get them the wraparound services that they
01:16:03 need the nutrition the exercise the additional support as well as traditional chemotherapy and
01:16:09 surgical uh intervention and radiation excellent i'm just going to jump in here because clearly
01:16:14 you've had time to think about this and think it through after the outcry from your original
01:16:18 remarks and if the apology was indeed delivered then that is great but i think it needs to be
01:16:23 clarified because i have doctors and physicians and former stakeholders from community and social
01:16:29 services telling me that this kind of rhetoric is harmful it's harmful to albertans and and
01:16:35 miss smith you have a platform you are an influencer you have people who listen to what
01:16:40 you say those kind of irresponsible comments actually speak to me that there is an issue with
01:16:46 impulsiveness here and there is an issue with somebody who is making rash statements holding
01:16:51 this public platform so let's move on to the healthcare spending account i was talking about
01:16:56 mental health anybody in this room who has ever been to a counseling session knows that 300 will
01:17:03 pay for a session and a half. I actually have grave, I guess I'm very skeptical about this
01:17:10 health care spending account. What do you do when somebody goes to the naturopath and they have one
01:17:15 and a half appointments? That is not enough. You're just getting your consultation and you're just
01:17:19 getting started on your next half of an appointment. What do you do when that health care spending
01:17:24 account is exhausted? Right now, our public service, our government has negotiated with our
01:17:29 public service, they get a $950 health spending account. You bet. I'd love for every Albertan
01:17:34 to have the same level of support on health spending accounts that we give to our public
01:17:38 service. And that's the reason why I'm advocating for it now. Maybe it starts with $300. Maybe it
01:17:44 only allows you to take your child in to get four treatments from a counselor or a psychologist,
01:17:50 but that's going to be a good start. And it's certainly better than nothing. When we look at
01:17:55 what happened over the last two years of COVID lockdowns, and I haven't heard any apology from
01:17:59 any of the cabinet ministers who imposed that on us for the last two years, I'd like to see an
01:18:03 apology there. When we look at what happened over the last two years. What did we talk about folks?
01:18:13 I get it. I get it. But let's not take away time from the candidates. This is about healthcare
01:18:17 reform, not what happened in the past. Okay. So remember, we're all on the same team here. Okay.
01:18:22 All right.
01:18:23 Carry on, Ms. Smith.
01:18:24 Sorry about that.
01:18:24 I'm just going to jump in.
01:18:26 It's easy to make kind of remarks when you've never been in government at that capacity
01:18:31 and you haven't had to make those tough decisions.
01:18:33 I stood up.
01:18:33 But nonetheless, I stood up on your talk show.
01:18:36 All right, folks, settle down or Jeff's going to stand up again.
01:18:38 Mental health should be funded much more than $300 a month.
01:18:42 All right.
01:18:42 That's it, folks.
01:18:43 All right.
01:18:43 Okay. 0.99
01:18:43 We've got a few people that want to jump in here. 1.00
01:18:45 Ms. Schultz, I saw your paddle first.
01:18:47 Then is it here?
01:18:48 Mr. Taves?
01:18:49 You know, I would agree, actually, with a lot of what Ms. Zani had said.
01:18:52 You know, we do have to focus on transforming AHS.
01:18:55 I was the first candidate to release my plan.
01:18:58 I don't believe that going back to regional boards is necessarily the answer,
01:19:02 but what is the answer is going back to local decision-making.
01:19:06 And instead of a government of panel review and committee,
01:19:08 we go back to listening to the front lines,
01:19:10 whether that was in Claire's home where I heard nurses give me ideas
01:19:13 about how we could do better staffing if those decisions weren't made
01:19:16 in Calgary and Edmonton.
01:19:17 physicians in Edmonton who could save us $20,000 a day by allowing them to be innovative instead
01:19:23 of squabbling about their salaries. We do have to be careful of the words that we use because I
01:19:28 would say this, bad judgment, flippant comments erode trust in our government and that is not
01:19:33 helpful in 2023. All right, thank you Ms. Schultz. Ms. is here. Thank you so much. I would like to
01:19:39 bring forward a different thought process. We have an opportunity to triage here. We have nurse
01:19:43 practitioners and we also have something called a physician assistant which has been around since
01:19:48 2013 if we fund these opportunities these folks could actually be a gateway into doctors and
01:19:54 absolutely being able to cover the gaps particularly in rural areas and i think it's really important
01:19:59 when candidates are speaking about rural health you speak to rural mlas and you speak to rural
01:20:04 folks when we're talking about women's care sars nurses domestic violence sexual assault
01:20:10 making sure that we have access to cultural sensitivity there hasn't been one comment up
01:20:14 here talking about the multicultural people in this province and the absolute barriers there
01:20:19 are to folks having health care thank you all right thank you mr tapes good thank you health
01:20:24 care is failing in rural alberta full stop that's my experience in the northwest and that's what i
01:20:30 hear from albertans right across the province now i don't pretend to have all the answers around
01:20:35 health care but i've made some observations in the last two years number one ahs needs complete
01:20:41 restructuring and we have to decentralize their decision-making structure that structure right
01:20:46 now is not only failing albertans it's failing our frontline health care professionals and that's
01:20:52 tragic i have to agree with a couple of the other speakers as well there were some very
01:20:57 irresponsible comments made this last week around cancer and around health care we have to be
01:21:02 accountable for our language our words matter that's the value of a leadership
01:21:06 race right now so conservative I'm gonna stop you there all right mr. gene go
01:21:10 ahead please 45 seconds the system's broken I always find it amusing when
01:21:15 people from Calgary and Edmonton tell me how our health system is going I'm from
01:21:19 Fort Brunner and I'll tell you we haven't had a health care system there
01:21:21 for years and years and years well I'm from the other forgotten corner that
01:21:25 will change if I'm premier we need to do things and we don't need to blow up HS
01:21:29 what we need to do is work with the great doctors and nurses that we have and the
01:21:33 technicians that we have and make things better the Auditor General in 2017
01:21:38 actually set out how we need to fix it specifically said it's not an issue of
01:21:42 cost it's not an issue of money you are not going to fix it by throwing money
01:21:45 at it I've lived it we need to focus on outcomes for patients and have the money
01:21:55 follow them but danielle all right that's very disappointing i'm sorry mr gene comments on
01:22:00 cancer all right okay you know what i'm going to come back to you for 30 seconds after mr lowen
01:22:05 floor is yours 45 seconds thank you very much yes i agree that with others that the system isn't is
01:22:10 broken we need an investigation into what happened with the coveted response i have colleagues here
01:22:15 that were in the coveted cabinet and uh now that it seems the public tide is changing that all of
01:22:19 a sudden they're trying to distance themselves from the decisions that they made there i agree
01:22:23 also that throwing money at it doesn't isn't going to solve the problem we have an ehs system
01:22:27 that needs a severe renovation they've had 15 years to get it right and they've been failing
01:22:31 all the time we have a shortage of healthcare workers we have emergency rooms being shut down
01:22:35 in rural alberta we have a post-secondary system in alberta that doesn't graduate the needs of our
01:22:40 society when it comes to healthcare workers and other other uh other educational opportunities
01:22:47 and we have a college of physicians that isn't helping either we need to get the test done and
01:22:52 the treatment done that we need all right that's zero mr loan thank you all right uh you got called
01:22:56 out there miss smith i'm going to give you 30 seconds to just rebut that and then we're going
01:22:59 to move on to the next question well you know i invite uh people to to listen to my full podcast
01:23:04 this is the reason why even though rajan doesn't think there's value in being a talk radio host i
01:23:09 can tell you there is i can tell you i shouldn't wouldn't be given a snow job by alberta health
01:23:13 services when they tell me i should jail pastors and shut down businesses and mass kids and tell
01:23:18 tell them they can't go to school and create the mental health crisis that they did and bring in
01:23:22 vaccine passports when they said they wouldn't wouldn't do that i would have consulted broadly
01:23:26 and made sure that we didn't make those kinds of mistakes because we will be dealing with the
01:23:30 consequence of that for decades all right okay thank you everybody let's get set for another
01:23:36 question all right stop clapping over here you're gonna make jeff have to stand up again nobody likes
01:23:40 that all right thank you rebecca schultz this question is for you and it is on the federal
01:23:46 government all right collaborative relationships with other orders of government are often the key
01:23:52 to funding large-scale capital programs providing sustainable sources of base funding for projects
01:23:56 such as transit initiatives and are generally beneficial to driving solutions that benefit all
01:24:01 albertans however the majority of albertans feel the federal government is determined to make life
01:24:08 difficult for our economic prosperity and are intentionally causing division between albertans
01:24:14 and other canadians how would you as leader address topics such as bill c2169 and equalization
01:24:23 payments with the federal government in order to affect a better outcome for albertans and i want
01:24:28 to hear specifics here tangible actionable items all right you've got two minutes floor is yours
01:24:34 thank you very much this is something i hear every day in every corner of this province that
01:24:38 albertans absolutely want a leader and a government who will defend our constitutional rights we are
01:24:44 not asking for anything special we are just asking for fairness in the constitution now i am
01:24:49 in fact the only candidate on this stage that has successfully negotiated with the federal
01:24:54 government and justin trudeau was that easy absolutely not it took a lot of hard work behind
01:24:59 the scenes i was not about to leave four billion in albertans hard-earned tax money sitting in
01:25:04 ottawa to invest in parents and families right across this country and not invest in parents
01:25:11 here i don't believe that albertans would have been okay with that and that's why we went toe
01:25:16 to toe with justin trudeau to make that happen in a way that respected small business and
01:25:21 incorporated parent choice i am the only i am the only person standing on stage who is able to do
01:25:28 that and i do believe in collaborative working relationships in fact when i look at my campaign
01:25:32 launch i not only had my local city councillor but my local mp standing there in the room because i
01:25:38 do believe teaming up and working together on issues will get us a lot further than going at
01:25:43 it alone and that would be my approach jeff when you're asking specifically on those bills c21 c69
01:25:49 and overcoming equalization changes that we are not the only province that wants to see changes
01:25:54 to however our approach has been to write letters angry tweets light our hair on fire run around
01:26:01 creating chaos making headlines and not getting results for albertans that's what albertans are
01:26:06 tired of it is and i would rather go at it with an army of other provinces than going at it alone
01:26:13 as what others may see as alberta being angry and you know what for you albertans who are angry
01:26:19 i hope you know that i'm angry too and i hear you i see it in every area where the federal
01:26:24 trudeau liberals are trying to push and infringe on areas of provincial jurisdiction we can't let
01:26:30 them do that when it comes to the emissions cap let's be clear production all right absolutely
01:26:35 provincial. We've got to fight. We've got to stop you there. Okay. Who would you like to debate on
01:26:39 this topic? Danielle Smith, please. All right. Ms. Smith, you're back up. You're going to have
01:26:45 a minute and a half to address the question. How would you, as leader, address topics such as Bill
01:26:50 C-21, 69, and equalization payments with the federal government in order to affect a better
01:26:56 outcome for Albertans? And again, we're looking for some specifics here. I know we've been passive
01:27:00 for so long that we tend to forget that the constitution actually gives us sovereignty
01:27:07 in the matters that are enumerated to us go on to wikipedia and they talk about our parliamentary
01:27:12 system that's what they say about canada is that legislatures in canada are sovereign in matters
01:27:18 that are enumerated to them if you look up section 92 92a 93 94 and 95 and i read them frequently
01:27:26 you will see that we have allowed the federal government to walk all over us in every single
01:27:30 area of our jurisdiction and with due respect to uh to rebecca i know she did a she did a good
01:27:36 negotiation but we still lost we always lose when we go up against ottawa they take all of our money
01:27:42 and they dribble it back with conditions they steal the rest and they use it to win votes in
01:27:46 quebec and atlanta canada and on the child care proposal you probably saw the cbc story a couple
01:27:52 of days ago from our private child care operators they're now forbidden from expanding their
01:27:56 operations when they have a profit it's called an overage and they have to go to the bureaucrats to
01:28:01 get permission on how to spend it they're not allowed to use any of the money for their capital
01:28:05 projects so many of them have invested in buildings and now they're not able to use any of the money
01:28:10 for that i don't look at that as a win implementing justin trudeau's socialist daycare system and
01:28:16 squeezing out the private daycare operators that vote for us looks to me like a step backwards and
01:28:22 And it's exactly the reason why we have to draw a hard line, say our jurisdiction is our jurisdiction under the Constitution, and stay out of our lane.
01:28:30 That's what the Sovereignty Act would do.
01:28:32 We'll get to bring up the rest here.
01:28:33 All right, audience, let's not start again.
01:28:36 Let's not start, folks.
01:28:38 Come on.
01:28:39 We've got a lot to get through tonight.
01:28:40 Every time we do this, I've got to stop and turn around.
01:28:43 So let's just dial it back for a minute, all right?
01:28:46 Okay, four minutes, open debate. 0.98
01:28:48 Ms. Schultz, we'll start with you.
01:28:49 I mean, I would say this.
01:28:50 When it comes to child care, we have private operators every single day that are grateful that we kept their businesses open and included in this plan.
01:28:58 We also, an article in the Financial Post, if we want to quote the media, highlighting private operators from other provinces right across this country saying that they wish we had a fair deal.
01:29:07 What would you have done, Ms. Smith?
01:29:09 Leave out Alberta parents and families. 0.98
01:29:11 What you're doing right now is writing checks you can't cash and making promises you can't keep.
01:29:16 That Sovereignty Act that you are running on, Ms. Smith, is a great fear for our energy industry.
01:29:22 They think that creating chaos is going to create additional investment uncertainty.
01:29:26 It's going to drive Albertans' investment jobs out of this province.
01:29:31 That's what they're afraid of.
01:29:32 They're afraid of additional economic uncertainty and additional economic crisis and constitutional crisis
01:29:38 six months before an election, which will, in fact, deliver us an NDP government.
01:29:43 That is what has our industry worried.
01:29:45 They want us to sit down and have smart negotiations.
01:29:48 You said it yourself.
01:29:49 They are leaders in environmental emissions.
01:29:52 Ottawa's created the chaos.
01:29:55 I sent out a fact, NFAQ, I encourage Rebecca to read it,
01:29:58 about what the Sovereignty Act would say.
01:30:00 It would say, given that the Constitution recognizes 92, 92A, 93, 94, 95
01:30:06 are our areas of jurisdiction, and given that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms
01:30:09 obligates us to protect the rights and freedoms of our citizens,
01:30:12 therefore we will not enforce any federal policy that violates Alberta's constitutional rights or
01:30:19 the rights of our citizens. It's very, it actually imposes lawfulness on a lawless Ottawa. Ottawa is
01:30:27 the one who started the constitutional war with us when they told us in November of 2015 that we
01:30:32 would not be allowed to sell our products in the open market with Bill C-48 and Bill C-69 and we've
01:30:39 been trying to play footsie, we've been trying to get social license, we've been writing certain
01:30:42 letters we've been going to the court. That's actually not true at all. When it comes to Bill
01:30:46 C-69, there are nine other provinces in this country that are standing up and supporting
01:30:50 Alberta in that fight. And that's why I am confident in that system. We absolutely have
01:30:56 to stand up and defend Alberta's rights. And I will say there are aspects of the Sovereignty Act
01:31:00 that do make sense. Aspects. Aspects of an overall bill in which other pieces of that bill
01:31:07 encourage breaking the rule of law, which is something else that many Albertans, especially
01:31:11 newcomers to this country are fearful of that is not something that albertans want to see we want
01:31:17 to see that rule of law upheld we are going to fight that doesn't mean sitting back and taking
01:31:22 a back seat to justin trudeau we absolutely need to continue to take steps and i would argue
01:31:26 albertans yes i understand they want us to see that action happen faster and we should do that
01:31:32 faster looking into tax points and credits and uh also i would say pushing forward on an alberta
01:31:38 a pension plan. But we also have to put that to Albertans to make the case. And it is a good one
01:31:43 where we have high average incomes, a young population, we have low unemployment rates.
01:31:48 That absolutely makes sense. Let's move. Let's move fast. Section 95 of the Constitution gives
01:31:54 us the first right to make rules regarding agriculture and the federal government from
01:31:59 time to time. So I just wonder with Rebecca, if the federal government comes through with a 30%
01:32:05 mandate to reduce fertilizer use among our farmers are we just going to say oh golly gee i wish you
01:32:10 wouldn't do that i'll tell you what i'd say and say no it violates section 95 of our constitution
01:32:15 which is our right and we will not enforce that we will make sure that our farmers have a steady
01:32:20 supply of fertilizer so that we can feed the world because food security is another issue that we're
01:32:25 dealing with right now and i'm going to sit and wait for ottawa to create economic corridors for
01:32:30 us all right we're going to start building those so that we can get our product and that is something
01:32:33 that you know i would actually absolutely agree with danielle smith on and we see other provinces
01:32:38 already fighting that fertilizer cap that's an area where absolutely that makes sense
01:32:42 that is an area of provincial jurisdiction that's a fight we can have but we should be careful before
01:32:47 making promises in other areas that we can't keep all right thank you very much for the open debate
01:32:52 all right okay mr lo will come to you miss it here you have 45 seconds you first then mr taves then
01:32:57 then I'll come to you, Mr. Long. Thank you so much. Albertans are leaders, and I'm Alberta's
01:33:03 number one fan. And if we want a legacy of rallying people up, we can certainly do that,
01:33:07 or we can work collaboratively. And I just wanted to say to Ms. Smith, you've mentioned several
01:33:12 sections out of the Constitution that you think that we can forward our agenda on, which I
01:33:16 completely agree with, but then that would render your Sovereignty Act completely redundant. So I
01:33:20 think we need to remove this action from all of the work that we're doing and actually work within
01:33:24 the constitution what we have available to us there's absolute ability to connect negotiate
01:33:29 learn and find wins massive wins rebecca has found one we've also worked on one with water with
01:33:36 respect to water infrastructure in alberta an 831 million dollar infrastructure build in alberta
01:33:42 that we did in collaboration with the federal government all right thank you mr tapes 45
01:33:46 seconds over to you all right you know here's here's the reality it would be great to just
01:33:51 wish away all our problems with this thing called the sovereignty act we're delusional if we think
01:33:56 that's going to happen it simply will not you know and and this is my observation over the last few
01:34:02 years i tend to like to work collaboratively but i've concluded with this federal government we
01:34:06 can't negotiate with them we won't win if we just simply negotiate but we'll win if we're strategic
01:34:12 my approach with ottawa is to be assertive and strategic because strategic we win and i want to
01:34:18 win for albertans you know the tired old approach a lot of political rhetoric over promising and
01:34:24 under delivering which is what the sovereignty act will do will not get a win in alberta's column
01:34:30 we need a strategic thoughtful approach that's how we win all right mr lowen 45 seconds on the
01:34:36 federal government yes thank you confederation is broken we can't have any more strongly worded
01:34:41 letters. We need to act. Asking hasn't worked. When we call, nobody answers. We need to start
01:34:49 saying no to Ottawa. We have things like a pension plan and Alberta constitution that we could do
01:34:54 right now. Myself, I drove to Ottawa to fight those rules that Ottawa came down on that were
01:35:00 hurting Albertans. I drove there to put my money where my mouth is and stand for Albertans and
01:35:04 stand for people across this country. The federal government isn't going to stop, but neither am I.
01:35:09 I won't stop fighting for alberts all right well thank you sir don't make me remind you there's no
01:35:16 applause you all know the rules all right we've got uh miss sonny 45 seconds to you and then mr
01:35:22 jean i'll come to you thank you jess so there is nothing about the sovereignty act that makes
01:35:26 sense i've consulted with constitutional experts and lawyers and it is going to be defeated in the
01:35:31 courts but while that is happening investors who are thinking of coming to alberta and putting some
01:35:36 of their hard-earned capital into this province are going to be swayed. They are not going to come
01:35:42 here. They're going to other jurisdictions. So I just want to be very clear about that. Alberta
01:35:46 must fight back. Absolutely. But we must not be risky and hot-headed. Now, Justin Trudeau relies
01:35:53 on confrontation, polarization, wedging, and division. And at least one of my opponents here
01:35:59 today thinks we should respond just like Trudeau. I don't think that way. I'm actually focused on
01:36:05 solving real world problems and when we respond with anger it feels good in the moment but it's
01:36:10 i gotta cut you off there all right i know it's all hard to not finish the sentence all right
01:36:14 mr gene over to you and then miss smith i'll come to you again thank you 10 years as a member of
01:36:19 parliament 10 years as a lawyer sovereignty act can't work folks it's fiscal fairytale it is not
01:36:25 going to work i agree with my friends here that we have to do something different and the equalization
01:36:30 referendum that started as a result of my wild rose leadership we brought that in and i will tell
01:36:34 you that step one is acting on the amazing mandate that albertans gave us in the referendum 62
01:36:39 we can force candidates to the constitutional negotiation table all these sections of the
01:36:44 constitution well try section 46 that's where you give legal notice to the rest of the country
01:36:49 that you are not happy with the situation because you have received a mandate from the people
01:36:52 without a mandate from the people it cannot happen there is a process involved and we are on that
01:36:57 process we need a leader that believes in it that's why i brought it out years ago because
01:37:01 i believe in that focus we need all right that's 45 seconds mr gene thank you miss smith i saw your
01:37:06 paddle up you wanted to weigh in here at the end 45 seconds over to you one of the last interviews
01:37:10 i did on the air was with a scholar by the name of jermaine belzile from the montreal economic
01:37:14 institute and i asked him the question why does quebec hate us so much and he said quebec doesn't
01:37:19 hate you they just don't think about you at all they're too busy thinking about themselves i think
01:37:24 you should think about yourselves for a change and i've been thinking about that a lot and it's
01:37:28 the reason why i've adopted the alberta sovereignty act because it puts ottawa on notice
01:37:34 that yes it just restates what's in the constitution and the charter but it says we
01:37:37 are drawing a hard line and you know when the last time this action was taken when the emergencies
01:37:42 act came through in quebec look what quebec did they convened their national assembly which as
01:37:46 they called it and they said we will not enforce that that is the kind of thing that quebec has
01:37:51 already done that is the kind of thing we absolutely can do and the thing that we must
01:37:55 All right, that's 45 seconds.
01:37:57 All right, hot topic, I suppose.
01:37:59 You all have waters below you, by the way, if you need to fill up.
01:38:01 Now is a good time while I get into question five.
01:38:03 Is it here?
01:38:04 Question five is for you.
01:38:06 The question is on energy and diversifying our economy.
01:38:10 Alberta's future depends on being driven by economics and job creation.
01:38:14 The word opportunity is synonymous with Alberta,
01:38:17 as our environment is ideal for growth and prosperity.
01:38:20 Diversification across the province is happening,
01:38:23 but must continue at an accelerated pace while energy is certainly the backbone of our economy
01:38:28 it should not hold us back from leading in new opportunities for growth in other sectors
01:38:33 how would you as leader continue to attract and diversify industry across our province
01:38:39 and address the significant talent shortage that many sectors are facing today and i want
01:38:44 specifics please thank you so much and thank you for this amazing opportunity to speak about
01:38:49 a sector that is so meaningful to so many of us the energy sector and diversification
01:38:55 is part of our family it's part of who we are when you think about those who are drilling
01:39:00 those who are doing the work the manufacturing the pipeline builds all of the work that goes
01:39:05 on in this province whether that's diversification in plastics there and there's so many things i'm
01:39:10 going to talk anecdotally a little bit about that in just a moment but families live right across
01:39:15 the streets from where they are drilling they care about their earth air and water and this is an
01:39:20 alignment between the environment and between energy and the incredible resource stewardship
01:39:25 that we have in this province and our ability to actually market that we have a global responsibility
01:39:31 to get our energy not only to canada but to the rest of the world we have burgeoning economic
01:39:37 populations all over the world that are seeking cheap energy like we have we have access to being
01:39:43 able to just flip on a switch to be able to go and turn on a light to heat our homes imagine what
01:39:48 is possible if we're able to work collectively with governments across this can across canada
01:39:53 to get our energy to these burgeoning economies where middle classes are coming out of the woodwork
01:39:58 and then be able to attract people to our province our province has attracted hundreds of thousands
01:40:05 of people because of the energy that we bring forward when we look at the powers of indigenous
01:40:11 growth in this sector the way that indigenous peoples are contributing to pipeline structures
01:40:17 to innovation in the energy sector leading towards emissions and fueling the economy and
01:40:23 exponential growth in clean energy we have such talent and innovation in carbon capture strategies
01:40:29 and new resources geothermal mine tailing saline from depleted resources the opportunities are
01:40:35 endless but also to be able to encourage those new skills that align with the environment and
01:40:42 with our energy to be able to look at that exposing that talent and all right that's two
01:40:46 minutes i'm going to cut you off there thank you all right thank you miss ahir who would you like
01:40:51 to debate on the topic i would like to debate rajin sani please all right miss sani i will read
01:40:57 the question again you'll have a minute and a half how would you as leader continue to attract and
01:41:01 diversify industry across our province and address the significant talent shortage that many sectors
01:41:06 are facing today and specifics please absolutely well i think everybody knows that i love talking
01:41:12 about energy but now i'm going to talk about agriculture we know that there is a food insecurity
01:41:18 issue look what's happening in ukraine their level of wheat production has drastically declined and
01:41:23 the situation is very serious but here in alberta we have everything that we need to create agri-food
01:41:30 corridors i talked about natural trade corridor funds and trying to get some of that funding
01:41:35 to develop highways can you imagine if we had a highway from fort mcmurray to peace river
01:41:41 how much investment that would open up that's critical infrastructure i was also at a pea
01:41:46 processing plant at the opening of it not too long ago and that is another idea we can actually do
01:41:53 value add here in our province to supply nutritious foods all across the globe
01:41:58 now i'm just looking at the time so we talked about labor shortages labor shortages are a
01:42:03 significant issue in every sector of our economy whether you're a trucker or you own a small
01:42:08 business or you're a restaurant operator it's very very difficult to get qualified and skilled staff
01:42:15 so quebec has more autonomy over their immigration when we talk about autonomy and independence
01:42:22 these are the kind of ideas that we need to pursue how can we get more qualified skilled labor
01:42:27 through the immigration system into alberta so we can actually grow our economy we cannot grow
01:42:34 unless we have talent and skilled talent so there are a number of ideas around this particular file
01:42:39 that i'd love to share with you all right i'm going to cut you off there four minutes of open
01:42:43 debate kick us off missa here thank you so much well skilled labor this is a perfect example of
01:42:48 exactly what needs to happen in alberta we are actually probably the biggest barrier to that
01:42:53 skilled labor being able to come into our province because of the red tape and not allowing people
01:42:57 with professional designations to actually pursue the jobs that they were intended to do my father's
01:43:02 perfect example in 1962 he came in here as an engineer and not only did he have to redo all
01:43:07 of his education but applied because the university that he came from was not accepted here in alberta
01:43:13 and in canada so if you look at all of those opportunities to be able to make sure that we
01:43:18 remove barriers for new talent to be able to come in we want to attract all of the talent from all
01:43:24 over the world and steal that talent into our province we're a teeny tiny province 4.3 million
01:43:29 people we need to grow by 2030 we could be as many as six million or seven million people
01:43:34 we need to make sure that we have our systems in place not only to attract that talent but also
01:43:40 um rajan was talking about agriculture food security is one piece of it but think about
01:43:46 agriculture from the aspect of energy and what they're producing with respect to all right jump
01:43:51 Jump in here, Ms. Sani.
01:43:52 I would absolutely agree that credentialing is critically important.
01:43:55 We all have stories.
01:43:57 I have stories of relatives who were very, very qualified
01:44:00 and could not find their place in the labor market here in Alberta
01:44:03 so that they could actualize their potential.
01:44:06 There is tremendous potential.
01:44:07 So one of the things that I plan to do as Premier
01:44:09 is to speed up the credentialing process.
01:44:12 We have a health care workers shortage in this province.
01:44:15 We've got a shiny new hospital in Grand Prairie
01:44:18 that doesn't have doctors and it's short of nurses it's a travesty so credentialing is something that
01:44:25 we do need to speed up and of course as we talk about labor shortages there are other sectors that
01:44:30 we need to support as well but i want to go back to the question all right let's let's see what
01:44:34 well i just wanted to add to what rajan was saying um and i want to give a shout out to
01:44:38 medicine hat actually right now because right here in this awesome city you guys started a
01:44:44 uh hydrogen task force in i believe it was in 2021 that hydrogen task force has taken light and and
01:44:54 has grown with the government and the opportunities to see what zero emissions would look like every
01:44:59 single large company corporation energy company is looking at zero emissions right now it is an
01:45:06 environment and energy collective that we do together to show our responsible development
01:45:13 we have to make sure it's not just about alberta folks we have to make sure that places like the uk
01:45:19 are not calling us dirty oil that places like other other countries in the world are not looking
01:45:24 at us as not even opportunity to be able to get our products to them we have to make sure
01:45:30 okay i just and i appreciate all these comments uh wonderful comments but i just want to get back
01:45:37 to the question on diversification um i was talking about agriculture and some of the key
01:45:42 messages that i'm hearing from farmers by the way we have the most sophisticated and smartest
01:45:47 farmers here in alberta in the world i'm not from a farming background but i hear that all the time
01:45:52 some of the key issues that they're having are around water water is an issue for economic
01:45:58 growth and it's certainly an issue for farmers they have issues around electricity and they also
01:46:04 have issues as i've mentioned before around agri-food corridors we need to invest in our
01:46:09 highways and we need to invest in our road system so some of that product can actually be delivered
01:46:15 i'd like to speak about water a little bit one of the biggest issues that we've had is the
01:46:19 government not investing enough into water and pivots into areas in order to create arable
01:46:26 fields in alberta in order to have irrigation available pivots are very very difficult thing
01:46:32 to come by right now because of the way that the world is working in the markets are going however
01:46:38 if we're actually talking about water consumption when we use pivots in in agricultural areas we
01:46:43 actually reduce water consumption by almost 80 all right that ends our four minutes of open debate
01:46:48 time okay miss smith i'm going to come to you for 45 seconds you're going to hold off all right
01:46:53 anybody else i just want to say mr caves and miss it here you only have one remaining rebuttal left
01:46:58 so just to remind you miss schultz you want to go 45 seconds yeah absolutely i'd like to just touch
01:47:03 on a couple of things as well you know when we're talking about obviously energy of today yes
01:47:07 we need to attract and retain in the highly skilled workers we have and i do want to thank
01:47:12 all of the energy workers across our province that obviously give us access to safe reliable
01:47:17 energy we also have to start talking about energy of the future co2 hydrogen we've got
01:47:22 to keep talking about lng this is the energy of the future this is what will help keep
01:47:26 some of our best and brightest minds right here in Alberta. Yes, we have to speed up credentialing.
01:47:41 Yes, we have to take more ownership over our immigration. But the other thing we have to do
01:47:45 is cut through some of the bureaucracy, whether it's talking about nuclear or ag. When I ask
01:47:50 people who's leading, oftentimes they say it's not us because our bureaucrats are still working
01:47:54 on the org charts and the other provinces are hustling investment all right thank you all right
01:47:59 that ends question five question six we're going to move on here quickly to mr taves it's for you
01:48:03 question is on unity and leadership at regional levels around the globe conservative movements
01:48:09 have faced internal struggles to main a thoughtful maintain a thoughtful big tent approach there's no
01:48:14 secret that many here on this stage have been early adopters of unity yet have struggled to
01:48:19 bring people together in an effective way the topic of unity is one of great importance to
01:48:24 the membership as many feel the infighting must stop
01:48:36 or it will lead to another harmful ndp government in a world of division
01:48:40 intolerance and lack of understanding how will you as leader unite the party
01:48:45 and move our province forward for the benefit of all albertans you have two
01:48:49 minutes yeah thanks for that question jeff i think
01:48:52 this is the most important question of the evening because consistent with my opening comments unity
01:48:57 is mission critical for this movement because if we're not united we will not beat rachel notley
01:49:12 in 2023 and friends leadership matters when it comes to unity it's absolutely critical
01:49:18 You know, I've been in the private sector right until 2019.
01:49:21 But even when I was Minister of Finance, I drew on some of my experience that I'd gained in the private sector in past leadership roles.
01:49:28 You know, whether it was leading our business teams or whether it was during the time that I served as president of the Canadian Cattlemen's Association,
01:49:45 a time post-BSE, when there was significant loss, emotion, and division.
01:49:52 I had to hold disparate provincial members together, all wanting to go their own way,
01:49:58 all wanting to do their own thing.
01:49:59 And had we lost those provincial members, we would have lost the war.
01:50:04 You know, right now we're in not a dissimilar time in this conservative movement.
01:50:09 And that has informed, my previous experience has informed my approach.
01:50:13 As a leader, I take a collaborative approach.
01:50:16 Every voice around the table matters.
01:50:20 You know, when every voice has an opportunity to speak, we make better decisions.
01:50:25 That's absolutely essential.
01:50:35 And friends, every MLA needs a full opportunity to bring the views of their constituents
01:50:43 to the table that's absolutely critical that's how Albertans are heard very often through their
01:50:58 MLA and when MLAs don't have that opportunity aberrant behavior occurs unity is critical but
01:51:05 to get there we need strong principled and friends proven leadership the type of leadership that I
01:51:12 provided in the finance ministry as I delivered on the objectives of
01:51:26 fiscal responsibility bringing the province to a balanced budget and positioning this economy
01:51:32 to lead the nation in economic growth this year and next. All right thank you Mr. Chaves. Who
01:51:37 would you like to debate on the topic of unity? Let's go with Brian Jean. All right Mr.
01:51:41 jane you have a minute 30 seconds over to you finally the debate moves to the right
01:51:47 usually you shouldn't need to talk about a potential premier's leadership and promote
01:52:00 that shouldn't be necessary that a premier should know how to manage caucus and their staff should
01:52:14 be a necessary item for success but we have not been good at this as conservatives we haven't
01:52:19 you promote unity by how you treat people by doing the right things in the right way
01:52:24 a leader must treat albertans the grassroots the caucus and the cabinet with respect that means
01:52:29 listening to them and i'm a good listener i have a track record of leading organizations and
01:52:42 businesses i have almost 15 years of elected experience
01:52:46 and over a decade practicing law i've led a caucus organized a unity effort
01:52:59 hey i am just letting you know here that this is with the ucp stream now this is an ongoing
01:53:14 problem they are supposedly trying to work through it here i know there are people in
01:53:19 the comments that are saying you know why are you not putting the stream out the way it should be and
01:53:24 And I would say that we're putting it out exactly as we're getting it.
01:53:28 We're trying to see if they are going to rectify this problem.
01:53:31 Early on, apparently, we heard from one source connected to the party.
01:53:35 They had to reset their router.
01:53:36 So this is a debate happening in rural Alberta in Medicine Hat.
01:53:40 I think it is unfrozen now.
01:53:42 Let's go back to the debate in progress.
01:53:52 15 years of elected experience.
01:53:54 and over a decade practicing law.
01:53:56 I have led a caucus, organized a unity effort.
01:54:24 Hey, so apparently there is now a stream unavailable. So the entire stream has died now. This is what
01:54:36 happens when you try to do a live event. Let's just get a little bit of our analysis going as
01:54:43 the debate continues. Now, we don't even know if the debate has actually continued or if they've
01:54:47 stopped it there. We'll try to get an update from our correspondent, Rachel Emanuel, in just a
01:54:52 moment. But right now, there is no debate to go to right now. The UCP feed has completely died.
01:54:58 So let's chime in with some early. We don't often get to do a halftime show on this. We're a little
01:55:03 over halftime. My colleague from True North, William McBeth, is with us. William, let's just
01:55:10 start early with what we were seeing here, which is that, as you and I discussed, this was really
01:55:14 the Danielle Smith show in a lot of ways. All of the candidates were, it seemed like, choosing to
01:55:21 go after Danielle Smith, choosing to put their questions to her, their accusations to her and all
01:55:27 of that. But the result, if I think of what happened, is just that, wow, I've just heard a
01:55:32 lot of Danielle Smith today. It didn't even seem like anyone really landed a knockout blow on her 1.00
01:55:36 for all of this. No, I think you're right. And at the beginning of this debate, if I thought it
01:55:45 would be Raiden Sonny and Danielle Smith back and forth, no, I wouldn't have thought that.
01:55:52 But, you know, certainly in the beginning that it would be an opportunity for the other
01:55:59 candidates to take an attack against the front row.
01:56:02 I don't know if that's a good strategy.
01:56:03 I don't know. 0.88
01:56:04 One thing I think people have seen from Danielle tonight is she's been in many debates in her
01:56:12 time.
01:56:12 She debated in a provincial leaders debate.
01:56:15 brian mason way back in the day and you saw that and not to make mention by the way hosting a radio
01:56:21 for many many years all of those skills on on display tonight and i don't know if the decision
01:56:28 that's to give her so much air time was an actually good idea yeah well that's a good
01:56:37 point william we'll check back in with you in a couple of moments i think we're having some
01:56:40 internet issues on your end too. So maybe you and the UCP might share an internet service provider,
01:56:45 but thanks for chiming in with that. We will pop back in with you very shortly. Let's go to my
01:56:51 colleague Ellie Kenton-Nantel on this. I know you have been monitoring Ellie the, well I should say,
01:56:57 I mean Ellie has been monitoring the social media reaction to this and I'm going to ask him when he
01:57:02 joins us to filter out the people complaining about the UCP live stream and focus on the substance
01:57:08 and content here but what is it that people have really been focusing in on from what you've
01:57:14 analyzed here uh sure so so first of all we were kind of cut out at first and i would say
01:57:20 really before this debate started the biggest issue seemed to be covid and people were you know
01:57:26 as we said earlier the pastors the lockdowns that that seems to be an issue uh really what
01:57:32 has taken center stage of this debate and i've seen chatter online is the alberta sovereignty act
01:57:36 So I actually went and I asked my Twitter followers, what do you think of the Alberta Sovereignty Act? And a lot of them seem to have a pretty positive response about it. There was one tweet that I thought was pretty interesting. It was from Aidan. He said, I've heard more about how terrible the Sovereignty Act is compared to from these candidates versus Daniel Smith talking about it.
01:58:00 that are a lot of them are talking about this sovereignty act uh a lot of people say you know
01:58:06 what else can we do because ottawa is mistreating alberta so badly uh one cure from twitter user
01:58:12 mountain man i just want to live my birthday life without ottawa so it's clear that albertans are
01:58:18 are clearly very frustrated with the way that they've been treated by the trudeau government
01:58:23 and other governments in the past i remember when i was in alberta working there uh the trudeau
01:58:29 senior trudeau's junior there's this legacy with the trudeaus and how they were being mistreated
01:58:33 so i think an idea like the sovereignty act even if if if there's legalities and questions around
01:58:39 it i think it's very popular with the base the grassroots that they're just fed up and they want
01:58:44 something different they want something new especially i gotta cut you off there ellie it
01:58:49 sounds like the debate stream is back so we're gonna cut immediately back to medicine hat for
01:58:54 the UCP leadership debate.
01:59:08 My colleagues, including our local MLA, MLA Fry, you know my friends this comes
01:59:13 down to a few things. Discipline, teamwork, loyalty, these things
01:59:17 mattered. They mattered in 2012, they mattered in 2015,
01:59:22 and they will matter in 2023 we absolutely have to pull together it starts with our team it starts
01:59:28 with making sure that our caucus who represent the diverse voices of albertans are the main
01:59:34 decision makers in government we can't do things the same way we've done them not in the last three
01:59:40 years where some voices are heard louder than others and there's different sets of rules for
01:59:44 different people i made that commitment to my caucus colleagues of how we're going to do things
01:59:48 different and what they can expect in me as part of this amazing team all right thank you mr lowland
01:59:55 thank you there's no question that unity is vital for success but we need to rebuild the trust of
02:00:00 albertans and the members of the party now i said what was true when there was a price for saying it
02:00:06 and those in cabinet said nothing mr tabes you said you unequivocally supported the premier and
02:00:13 i never once heard you in caucus speaking against the premier any of the actions that were happening
02:00:17 in government jason kenney's record is your record i stood up i did what everybody seems to call the
02:00:26 tough thing so i am that leader because my loyalty is to the constituents that i represent and to
02:00:32 albertans all right well thank you oh great uh mr james you have one more so this is your last one
02:00:40 no no i was called out on that one all right okay i'll give you 30 seconds
02:00:44 all right um i i just simply need to respond to uh to todd's assertion there because here was
02:00:52 here was where i spoke out i was around that cabinet table and that's where i spoke out i
02:00:58 represented the views of my constituents rural alberta and i represented the views of todd's
02:01:03 constituents while i was there around the table making a difference instead of standing on the
02:01:09 the outside sniping again real leadership is not cutting and running real leadership is serving
02:01:15 under the burden of leadership at a time when there's much pressure and bringing the views of
02:01:20 constituents forward to ensure they were heard that's what i did and i'm proud of delivering
02:01:27 that kind of a voice to my constituents all right thank you okay we're going to move on to our last
02:01:33 question of the night and so as far as 45 second paddles go mr taves you have one miss smith you
02:01:39 have one miss sonny you have one and mr gene you have one all right the rest of you have used up
02:01:42 all your time so hopefully you get called out all right the question for you mr gene is on
02:01:47 provincial surplus many albertans are tired of expensive bureaucratic roadblocks that prevent
02:01:53 things from getting done efficiently value for money means creating returns we can all benefit
02:01:58 from with record surpluses on the horizon driven by high commodity prices and a growing economy
02:02:06 coupled with an increased cost of living many feel a reduction in taxes is appropriate at this time
02:02:13 others believe that a significant reinvestment into the heritage savings fund or a rainy day fund
02:02:18 is more appropriate specifically how do you as leader plan to balance savings versus investing
02:02:25 in order to maintain long-term value and sustainability for albertans while meeting
02:02:29 the demands of a growing population you have two minutes sir thank you this isn't complicated
02:02:36 In an age of increasing interest rates, you have to use the surpluses to pay down debt as it becomes due.
02:02:42 The last thing we should do is roll over any old debt to new higher interest rates because we've seen what's going on.
02:02:47 And we know ultimately if we've lived through the 80s as I did, what can happen if you have high interest rates?
02:02:52 You have a lot of people that are very uncomfortable and many people going bankrupt.
02:02:56 The good news is that our debt will be coming due slowly just over the next decade.
02:03:00 And our financial circumstances have changed because so many royalty-paying oil projects are actually at full payout.
02:03:08 About 80% of all oil sands projects are now paying full royalties.
02:03:12 That's great news.
02:03:14 That means we have the largest surpluses we will probably ever see.
02:03:18 We should save those surpluses, pay down debt as it becomes due.
02:03:21 In the meantime, we should use the income from those surpluses to actually reduce the cost of transmission and distribution charges to families in Alberta.
02:03:28 I'm telling you this.
02:03:29 I'm not going to reduce taxes on businesses, that's for sure.
02:03:31 In the long run, as we retire more and more debt,
02:03:35 we should look at using the surpluses to pay for other things.
02:03:37 That will reduce Albertan's costs, the day-to-day costs for consumers,
02:03:41 the day-to-day costs for you, because that's what we need to do right now.
02:03:46 We don't need new government projects.
02:03:48 We need to run and manage government better.
02:03:50 We need to be a boring government that you forget is there,
02:03:53 because they're not in your way.
02:03:55 They get out of your way and remove the obstacles from your way.
02:03:57 We have to avoid the old trap of making our government so expensive in good times that we can't afford it in bad times.
02:04:02 I've seen it in Fort McMurtain.
02:04:04 And folks, we're very poor in infrastructure right across the province and especially there.
02:04:09 We need to do whatever we can do in order to make sure that we take those surpluses, pay off debt,
02:04:14 and support people that can't afford to live right now because of inflation.
02:04:18 Private sector economists actually suggested that our surpluses could be $15 billion a year for the next three, four, five years.
02:04:27 According to the government website, we have almost $5 billion in bonds coming due this year, about $3 billion next year.
02:04:32 And the year after that, more than $50 billion of our bonds are not due until 2030.
02:04:36 So we can use that to support Alberta's.
02:04:38 All right, Mr. Jean, I've got to get you off there.
02:04:40 But I will ask you who you'd like to debate on this topic.
02:04:43 Mr. Taves.
02:04:43 All right, Mr. Taves, minute and a half.
02:04:45 Over to you.
02:04:46 All right, good.
02:04:46 Thanks, Jeff.
02:04:48 Certainly my thoughts around the surplus, I'm going to start my, predicate my comments with this.
02:04:53 When I presented Budget 2022, I was clear with Albertans.
02:04:58 Any surplus up to the earnings level in the Heritage Savings Trust Fund,
02:05:02 I would categorically reinvest in that Heritage Savings Trust Fund.
02:05:05 The first thing we'll do is stop robbing that trust fund from future generations.
02:05:11 But, you know, as we take a look beyond there,
02:05:13 I do agree that we need to pay attention to our debt.
02:05:16 We have $93 billion in taxpayer-supported debt in this province,
02:05:20 And it will be coming due over the next number of years.
02:05:25 Here's what we need to do with surpluses.
02:05:27 Ensure we're setting cash aside to pay that debt off as it matures.
02:05:32 Because if we don't, we could well have to go into capital markets
02:05:36 with a cost of capital perhaps double than what the cost is for the debt that's been currently placed.
02:05:43 That would double our debt service costs.
02:05:45 We are projecting about $2.6 billion in debt service costs right now in this budget.
02:05:51 If we double those, that's $5 billion.
02:05:53 That comes right out of program spending or would require a tax increase.
02:05:58 Friends, fiscal discipline will remain important.
02:06:01 We can't make irresponsible decisions during the good years that will put us in trouble during the poor years.
02:06:07 Again, reinvest any surplus up to the earnings of the Heritage Savings Trust Fund.
02:06:12 in that trust fund set cash aside to pay down debt as it matures all right well thank you
02:06:18 okay that opens four minutes of debate mr gene kick us off well i want to point out and highlight
02:06:25 mr taves and our policy it's very similar that's why i believe that mr taves would be a great
02:06:29 finance minister in a brian gene led government i do folks he's had three years of experience
02:06:35 he's been a good finance minister and i think we can make him great if we work together as a team
02:06:39 But, Tavis, I really want to know, isn't it true that government spending increased a lot since 2019?
02:06:44 We've seen that. We know that's happened.
02:06:45 But I'd like you to explain to Albertans exactly what took place.
02:06:48 And that the wage settlements that you gave to our public sector unions, of course, after you started negotiating,
02:06:54 some time after you started negotiating, were actually larger than the ones the NDP gave them from 2015 to 2018.
02:07:00 And that does bother me.
02:07:02 And I think that we have to look at that because, folks, with inflation now, we're going to be able to catch up.
02:07:07 but the truth is we have to make the decisions at the time based on the history and where we are at
02:07:12 that time and and frankly i don't think we can look at catering to the unions every time they
02:07:16 come to the door and start knocking and in fact they're going to start knocking a lot i would
02:07:20 like to i'd like to respond to that please because uh further to the question what did we do in terms
02:07:25 of spending now one one direction that i gave my department when we started dealing with all the
02:07:31 additional pressures um of covid the last two years knowing that our health care costs were
02:07:35 going to go up specifically because of a lot of personal protective equipment and other health
02:07:40 care policies i asked my department to break out those expenditures in other words don't include
02:07:46 them in our regular operating expenditures for two reasons number one we can't know the progress
02:07:51 we're making or not number two i was concerned that department heads would want to build that
02:07:55 extra spending into baseline budgets so our basic operating expenditures the cost to deliver
02:08:02 government services we actually kept flat for the first three years and that was no small feat
02:08:07 because we inherited an upward trajectory of four percent per year friends if we would have
02:08:13 continued with the spending trajectory we inherited from the ndp and the previous pc government we
02:08:19 wouldn't have been projecting a 500 million dollar surplus in this fiscal year it would be a six
02:08:24 billion dollar deficit isn't that a great way to see a team working together folks this is a team
02:08:30 up here we're all friends or want to be friends and we soon will be because most of us will be
02:08:35 working together and hopefully we'll get somebody elected and then we'll be able to go back and take
02:08:39 over the province because this can't happen unless we work together can't happen unless we
02:08:44 have great ideas and that's why all these people are up here today to give great ideas but they do
02:08:48 need a leader folks and they need a leader that has experience dealing with ottawa a leader that
02:08:52 has experience dealing with the constitution and courts a leader that has been a leader before and
02:08:57 and that is me. I would like to just make a couple of comments on the public sector because those
02:09:03 were, you know, we need to talk about the public sector. Shortly after I was tapped to be Minister
02:09:09 of Finance, and it's certainly been a privilege to serve Albertans as their Minister of Finance
02:09:13 over the last three years, you know, I found out what I believe to be true, and that was we had a
02:09:19 bloated public sector. We had a bloated public service, and so I worked with other ministers,
02:09:24 other ministries at the time and we thoughtfully carefully and I would
02:09:29 suggest compassionately reduced the size of the public service friends by 8% in
02:09:34 the last two years we've gone a long ways to right-sizing government right
02:09:40 sizing the public service and yes we did get a collective bargaining agreement
02:09:45 with virtually all of our public sector partners and here's here's here were the
02:09:51 objectives that i had number one we had fiscal objectives to ensure that alberta was not an
02:09:56 outlier in remuneration relative to other provinces i actually want to hear that but i just want to say
02:10:01 that running out of time folks and i do want to hear that we'll have a conversation afterwards
02:10:05 because i do want to hear that that's innovative but the truth is what we need to do is we need to
02:10:09 open up the constitution folks we do and i know you see that as a site out there that can't be
02:10:13 attained it can be the constitution the supreme court of canada has laid it out and without that
02:10:17 we're not going to be able to deal with our issues of money and fiscal balance or health
02:10:21 I have to say, our collective bargaining agreements met our fiscal objectives.
02:10:26 Okay, we're done, folks.
02:10:27 Just a quick side.
02:10:28 So that was a great debate.
02:10:31 Unfortunately, the screen dropped on us twice on the digital feed.
02:10:34 However, I have been told we have a clean copy of this recording,
02:10:37 and that will be posted to the website.
02:10:39 So everybody else across the province, if you missed it, we apologize.
02:10:43 I'm not in charge of the technology.
02:10:44 I'm sorry.
02:10:45 But we will have a clean recording, so you will be able to get that.
02:10:48 In terms of 45-second rebuttals, I have Ms. Sani, Ms. Smith, anybody else?
02:10:53 Mr. Lowen?
02:10:54 Okay, Ms. Smith, Mr. Lowen.
02:10:57 All right.
02:10:58 And Mr. Taves, you still have one rebuttal you can use in this somewhere.
02:11:02 And Mr. Jean, you actually have two, but you can't use them back-to-back.
02:11:05 That's okay.
02:11:06 All right.
02:11:06 Thank you.
02:11:07 Okay.
02:11:08 Ms. Sani.
02:11:10 Thank you, Jeff.
02:11:11 And folks, I fear for where our country is headed, which is why we need serious and stable leadership,
02:11:17 not risky and hot-headed ideas. And that's why when it comes to the provincial surplus,
02:11:22 I'm an economist. I know how to do forward planning. We must absolutely pay down debt.
02:11:28 We must absolutely put some funds into the Heritage Savings Trust Fund. We must strategically
02:11:33 invest and target investment in infrastructure. I had talked about infrastructure earlier,
02:11:39 health and education. But I had also mentioned that when governments can help, they should.
02:11:44 there are many people in this province who are hurting who cannot make their grocery bills
02:11:49 and that is why i had talked about indexing seniors benefits age benefits and income tax
02:11:54 brackets all right miss smith you have 45 seconds um some of my friends on the stage
02:12:01 here have been digging up old columns i wish they dug up the column from 2001 when i wrote about how
02:12:06 we could grow our sovereign wealth fund to a significant level when i look at why i'm a
02:12:12 conservative. I look back on the history with Peter Lougheed, setting aside 30% of our resource
02:12:16 revenues. And then when Klein took over, how he made us debt-free. That's part of my conservative
02:12:21 identity. And then, of course, with Premier Stelmack, when he came in and did a major investment
02:12:26 in infrastructure. Those are the three things that I think are the most important for us to do right
02:12:30 now. I would like to see us set aside a dedicated portion every single year so we can grow that
02:12:36 Alberta Sovereign Wealth Fund to a significant level where we can start reducing taxes. We just
02:12:41 have to get started now and i think that that is a policy that we i look forward to discussing
02:12:45 let's move on to mr long mr long you have 45 seconds yes thank you government is very bad
02:12:49 at predicting uh cyclical cycles when it comes to booms and busts as a result we see overspending
02:12:56 when times are good and we see debt when times are bad and i believe the government needs to
02:13:01 develop a legislative plan for how to handle surfaces and i believe that should be paying down
02:13:06 debt we have an enormous debt in alberta we have a huge interest rates a interest that is costing
02:13:12 taxpayers billions of dollars each year and that needs to be spent on the services for albertans
02:13:17 instead of banks and bondholders so obviously we have we could be doing more by reducing income
02:13:25 tax for average albertans and raise the uh the basic personal exemption so that'll affect all
02:13:31 All right. Thank you, Mr. Loewen. Okay, Mr. Gene, 45 seconds, then I'll come to you, Mr. Taves.
02:13:37 There's two people on the stage that still haven't talked about PST and why they thought about putting
02:13:43 it in and why they talked about putting it in. And more than that, I'm interested about why they
02:13:47 changed their mind because tax does have a lot to do with people's ability to pay things.
02:13:52 And having a consumer tax means that a lot of people are going to have their costs increased.
02:13:57 And that's why I think it's so important to talk about what people do want. They don't want
02:14:01 tax credits that you might get back after you spent the money a year later, they don't want
02:14:05 tax credits and you know are a thousand dollars and may give you a 300. They don't want that. What
02:14:10 they want is they want their costs lowered on a daily basis. They want to see their gas less
02:14:15 expensive. That's why I've suggested a permanent reduction of 30 cents a liter at the gas prices
02:14:20 today. That's why I've suggested a third off their transmission distribution charges. All right. Those
02:14:24 things help people on a day-to-day basis. All right there's only one person again on this stage
02:14:30 that I'm aware of that has talked about implementing a PST and raising taxes on Albertans
02:14:36 by $5 billion as recently as about 20 months ago.
02:14:40 And that's my leadership colleague, hopeful colleague here, Ms. Danielle Smith.
02:14:45 I have never suggested a PST.
02:14:48 In fact, again, if you want to see what I would do fiscally and economically as Premier,
02:14:53 look at what I've done as the Minister of Finance.
02:14:55 I lowered taxes, that which resulted in expanded fiscal capacity and expanded government revenues.
02:15:03 We brought fiscal discipline to government spending.
02:15:06 That combination gave me the privilege of presenting the first balanced budget in over a decade.
02:15:11 Gone are the days when we robbed from our children.
02:15:14 All right. Ms. Smith, you were called out there. I'm going to give you 45 seconds.
02:15:17 You know, I thought I answered this because the context that I wrote the column,
02:15:20 and that's kind of what you do when you're in the media,
02:15:22 is that you write columns on topical issues and try to find solutions.
02:15:26 It was when we had a $24 billion deficit.
02:15:29 I guess there's only two options.
02:15:31 Either the stories are untrue, where it was saying that Travis Davis was floating the idea of a provincial sales tax,
02:15:38 or he was just going to wait, I guess, until oil and gas revenues bailed us out.
02:15:42 And that's kind of what's happened.
02:15:44 We now have $16 billion worth of resource revenue, spending almost all of it.
02:15:47 We've got to do a better job stewarding that for the future.
02:15:50 All right.
02:15:51 Okay, Mr. Jean, you have one last paddle.
02:15:53 One last paddle.
02:15:55 Well, I'm very interested in what takes 42% of our tax dollars and 42% of everyone's tax dollars, and that's healthcare.
02:16:02 We need to spend a little bit better on that and get better investments.
02:16:05 It's not about the money, it's about the outcomes.
02:16:06 It's about making sure that people receive not just less expensive goods as they travel,
02:16:11 and that's why I reduce gas, because that reduces groceries, it reduces appliances,
02:16:14 it reduces everything that we get pretty much in Alberta.
02:16:17 We need leadership to drive change.
02:16:20 we need better management better executive decisions better decisions
02:16:24 leadership is not about great talkers it's about making good decisions and
02:16:28 having to track record of good decisions or having bad decisions as a tracker I
02:16:32 need to hear from Daniel Smith to commit today that you won't give bad medical
02:16:37 advice or cancer advice again because you heard a lot of people with what you
02:16:40 said you said it was a misunderstanding you haven't taken a lot of this
02:16:43 understanding is over 45 seconds is over and we've been over this topic all
02:16:48 All right. We're going to end a little bit late anyway, so we're not going to get back into it.
02:16:52 And maybe that's something for a closing statement.
02:16:53 Ms. Smith, I don't want to get back into it because Ms. Caves has called out.
02:16:56 No, I don't want to get back into it. I just want to tell Brian.
02:17:00 Let's move on. You can deal with it in your closing statements.
02:17:01 No, I just want to tell Brian I'm sorry for the loss of his son.
02:17:04 All right, Ms. Smith, I'm going to stop you.
02:17:05 I've heard the story and it's heart-wrenching and I know exactly how he feels.
02:17:09 I think we all understand and you can address that in your closing statements,
02:17:12 which I'm now going to give everybody two minutes to do because we do have a little bit of extra time.
02:17:17 All right. This has been drawn at random, and that's how we're going to close tonight.
02:17:22 And Ms. Schultz, you will kick us off with two minutes. Please go ahead with your closing.
02:17:26 Thank you. Nine months from right now, the question Albertans will be asking themselves is who do we trust?
02:17:34 Who do we trust to drive our economic growth? Who do we trust to transform health care and education?
02:17:41 Who do we trust, based on their record, to take on Justin Trudeau?
02:17:46 So as a party, who do we trust to ensure the NDP never sees government again?
02:17:54 Trust is built over time.
02:17:56 A few candidates on this stage, they have records of their own.
02:17:59 We absolutely cannot go backwards or stick to the status quo.
02:18:04 We need a leader not just for the next year to get us through the next election.
02:18:09 We need a leader who can take us into the next generation of our conservative movement
02:18:13 by bringing Albertans along with a vision of the future,
02:18:19 a vision for jobs and economy, yes,
02:18:21 not leaving our children, my children, yours, with debt
02:18:26 so that they can't meet the demands of their time
02:18:29 because they're paying off the choices made in ours.
02:18:32 We know that, but we also need a vision of hope and optimism
02:18:38 and opportunity and a plan for our future.
02:18:41 I will lead a party that you, Albertans, party members, can be proud to vote for.
02:18:49 So I ask again, in May 2023, who do you want to see running against Rachel Notley and the NDP?
02:18:58 I am asking you for your vote as I run to be the leader of the United Conservative Party,
02:19:04 a party and a team that I am proud of and proud to run alongside.
02:19:08 and as I ask for your support to be the next Premier of this amazing province of Alberta.
02:19:15 Thank you, Ms. Schultz. All right, Ms. Ahir, sorry, you have two minutes.
02:19:21 You're right, we do need to build trust. That is the work that is being done right now,
02:19:26 to get in front of you, to engage with you, to give you something that you deserve,
02:19:30 a government that is accountable and honourable, not something that you should ask for.
02:19:34 It is a positive and empowering campaign that is going to build a government that you can be so proud of.
02:19:41 And I'm very proud to stand with my colleagues here on the stage.
02:19:45 But I want you to understand that this is not about me.
02:19:48 This is truly about Albertans.
02:19:50 And we cannot use ideology or personal agenda to get there.
02:19:54 Those who just arrived yesterday to homesteaders, First Nations, no matter who you love or who you pray to.
02:20:00 this province is welcoming and amazing and we have to grow our population we are looking for
02:20:06 governments that will have a strong team empathy and insistence on customer service education and
02:20:11 health care and working constructively on all levels of government to show a capacity to learn
02:20:16 and to grow and we will listen and we will collaborate and we will lead with humanity
02:20:21 and we will look at a shift in the culture that will actually bring us forward so it's not just
02:20:27 about winning in 2023 you win in 2023 we lead together leadership is not about being at the top
02:20:36 it is this collective wave of energy and strength and all of the people that build this amazing
02:20:43 province this tapestry of culture it's not about division it's about building if we benchmark our
02:20:50 budgets against population growth growth and inflation in the last balanced budget
02:20:55 and each year use that guidance to inform our spending we get off that tax and spend roller
02:21:00 coaster we have stable budgeting long-term planning and it enables savings of our resource
02:21:06 of our resources and we grow the heritage fund and we protect our services and we reduce inflation
02:21:12 and we maintain low taxation and pay down the debt prudently this is the plan that will bring
02:21:18 us forward and i would be honored to be your leader thank you so much thank you miss ahir
02:21:23 all right miss sonny over to you two minutes for closing thank you i have a question for all of you
02:21:29 why do we do the things that we do why do we get up in the morning and go to work or make decisions
02:21:35 about how to spend our days we do it for our children our families and our communities and
02:21:41 that is why i got into politics in the first place for my children and family and for your children
02:21:48 and families and folks i have already mentioned several times today that canada is going down
02:21:53 a dangerous path led by destructive policies from the trudeau liberals we can respond impulsively
02:22:01 with anger that would feel good but it is risky i have experienced the economic turmoil caused by
02:22:08 unstable and unpredictable government i talked about that today as well the answer the answer
02:22:14 isn't to threaten sovereignty or separation and i'm going to say something right now and i want
02:22:21 everyone to listen closely a danielle smith victory today means a rachel notley victory tomorrow
02:22:28 there is a better way our ucpt all right let's keep it down audience this is closing in alberta
02:22:34 i've lived and worked in alberta all my life and i know the energy industry and
02:22:39 i know how to lead a team we do have a choice one choice is to roll the dice on risky and
02:22:46 hot-headed ideas but if we lose that gamble the losers are albertans it's all of us
02:22:54 so in closing what i would say to all albertans who are listening right now on the live feed
02:23:00 is please do make sure that you go out and purchase a membership this election is
02:23:05 consequential it will determine the course that our province goes in for at least a decade don't
02:23:12 be complacent don't be forgetful please do pick up your membership and i would say please do visit my
02:23:19 website voterajan.ca to learn more about me and don't hesitate to reach out i would love to talk
02:23:25 to you all right thank you mr jean over to you two minutes to close thank you for listening tonight
02:23:32 i agree with rajan i do have a three and a half year old and a 38 year old and i'm doing this for
02:23:36 my kids just like i'm doing it for your kids and all of us are here there are many good people on
02:23:40 the stage in fact i would say great people and there's many good people who want to leave our
02:23:44 party and be part of our party we should be pleased with that but i'm the only person right
02:23:48 now that is talking about renewing the party and returning it to what it was meant to be
02:23:54 a party that represents the vast majority of albertans you who want a conservative government
02:24:00 that respects their autonomy in a realistic way.
02:24:04 I want this party to make Albertans happier.
02:24:07 That involves changing the way we treat each other and other Albertans.
02:24:11 It means civility.
02:24:13 It also means that we have to be honest when we make mistakes and apologize.
02:24:17 I want this party to make Albertans healthier.
02:24:19 That means working with our wonderful doctors and nurses and technologists
02:24:22 to reform our health care system and make it the best in the world.
02:24:26 I want to make Albertans freer.
02:24:27 That means correcting the mistakes of the last two years and making sure that our rights are
02:24:34 actually protected. And I want to make Albertans prosperous. That means fighting the Trudeau
02:24:39 liberals, fixing the constitution, which we can do. It is reality. Growing and diversifying our
02:24:46 economy and taking advantage of the can-do spirit of Albertans. If we do these things, we can and
02:24:53 will renew our party and win the next election. If you believe in these things, if you want
02:24:59 a better hope for the future for your children, for your grandchildren, then please consider
02:25:04 voting for Brian Jean. I will prepare. I will have an excellent team around me and surrounding
02:25:10 me. I will listen. I will make sure that I always do what's best for Albertans, what's
02:25:15 best for our future. I will make us the happiest, the healthiest, the most free and most prosperous
02:25:21 people on the planet. Please go to brianjean.ca, buy a membership, support any one of these
02:25:27 candidates, but get involved. Please, thank you for your time. Thank you, Mr. Jean. Ms. Smith,
02:25:33 over to you. You have two minutes for your closing. I just want to say that even though I think I
02:25:37 should be leader, I must say I agree with Brian that every person on this stage has had an amazing
02:25:44 input on cabinet decisions, and I think that every one of them is cabinet material. Todd, of course,
02:25:50 has done amazing work standing up for the rights of individual MLAs. Rajan has done terrific work
02:25:56 on transportation corridors. Rebecca has always got the interests of families at front and center
02:26:02 with her activity tax credit. I think that's a great idea. We've got Lila, who I think has got
02:26:07 some wonderful ideas she put on the table tonight about immigration. Travis has done terrific work
02:26:12 on insurance. I mean, our energy industry now has the ability to self-insure, which is going to be
02:26:17 hugely important in this world of disinvestment and Brian Jean I think I'm surprised he didn't
02:26:22 talk about his gasoline and diesel uh proposal tonight to remove the royalties because I think
02:26:26 it's a pretty darn good idea as well but I think we have to also be honest about why it is we're
02:26:30 here this evening we're here this evening because conservatives win elections when they talk and act
02:26:36 like conservatives rather than a bunch of watered down liberals did you start to think about why it
02:26:41 is we're even here tonight why we're having this debate why we had a leadership opening
02:26:46 it's because the premier and his team lost the confidence of members and of most MLAs
02:26:53 is because our members saw a government that wasn't effective in dealing with Trudeau's
02:26:58 attacks on our province complaining sending letters with no results that to me is the
02:27:06 issue of this campaign is who is going to stand up to Ottawa. I found it really interesting in
02:27:13 a caucus communications that came out July 18th. This is UCP caucus. It says Alberta's government
02:27:18 will not accept any plan from the federal government that seeks to interfere in our
02:27:22 constitutionally protected ability to develop our resources. That's what MLAs are told to say.
02:27:27 That kind of sounds like the sovereignty act. So I think what you're seeing here is just a little
02:27:31 bit of posturing tonight because I know that I'm going to fight for you. We're going to stand up
02:27:35 ottawa go to danielsmith.ca thank you to put alberta first thank you mr tapes two minutes
02:27:42 over to you for closing all right it's uh it's really been a pleasure to join all of uh my my
02:27:47 leadership colleagues here on the stage tonight uh look you know prior to 2019 i was in the private
02:27:53 sector uh my whole life and i have to say that during those years i was a typical conservative
02:27:59 minded alberton my best day was the day i didn't notice government i didn't notice government in
02:28:04 my businesses and certainly didn't notice government between me and my family but it was
02:28:09 when our province took a sharp left turn in 2015 and we elected in alberta an ndp government that's
02:28:17 when i sat up and took note because i was afraid i was concerned that the opportunities and
02:28:22 prosperity the freedoms that we'd enjoyed may not be there for our children and grandchildren
02:28:27 and friends again i want to draw us to really the question the pertinent question in this
02:28:34 in this leadership race and who is that leader that can bring us to victory in 2023 because
02:28:40 friends that's why i got into politics in 2019 and it's because of that question i joined this
02:28:47 leadership race only a few weeks ago it's also about having real solutions to the challenges we
02:28:55 face we face real challenges around inflation and affordability it's about having real solutions
02:29:02 when we deal with a government in ottawa who consistently attacks alberta's vital economic
02:29:09 interests and friends i am not about political bluster and rhetoric over promising and under
02:29:15 delivering i'm about winning and we win when we're strategic but it's also about continuing
02:29:22 to position this province for economic growth diversification and friends we're seeing that
02:29:27 growth and diversification right now at record rates across sectors we cannot see the gains we've
02:29:34 made eroded right now we need strong principle proven leadership i would ask for your support
02:29:40 so we can win in 2023 thank you mr taves all right mr lowen you have the final two minutes
02:29:46 for closing please go ahead thank you very much it's been a great debate i've enjoyed learning
02:29:51 all sorts of ideas that they've been expressed so far and I want to thanks
02:29:54 give thanks of course to the organizers this event we know it takes a lot to put
02:29:58 on a big event like this and but what I want to do is I want to just look back
02:30:03 at some of the comments made here we I think every single person at this table
02:30:08 talked about restoring trust and unity but no one seemed to talk about how it
02:30:14 was lost and I think that's important to think about losing trust doesn't just
02:30:19 happen it comes from broken promises now some think that unity is kicking people
02:30:25 out and then calling them representing their constituents sniping but that's
02:30:30 not true we're here today because members spoke members wanted to change
02:30:35 and that's why we're here today my campaign is focused on trust transparency
02:30:41 and accountability and I believe leading is serving so this is your Alberta and
02:30:48 and I'm committed to doing it your way.
02:30:50 Thank you.
02:30:51 Thank you, Mr. Lohan.
02:30:52 All right, the candidate's closing remarks
02:30:54 ends the official debate.
02:30:55 It has been my privilege to be your moderator
02:30:57 for this evening.
02:30:58 Ladies and gentlemen,
02:30:59 please give the candidates a round of applause.
02:31:06 All right.
02:31:07 All right, on behalf of all UCP party members,
02:31:11 I wanna thank all the candidates for being here tonight.
02:31:13 I do know this is, it's a lot of stress getting here
02:31:16 and I wanna thank all of you.
02:31:17 I also want to thank the party, specifically our party president, Cynthia Moore,
02:31:20 and the entire UCP party team who helped put tonight on and make it possible.
02:31:24 And a huge thanks to the people of Medicine Hat for hosting us here tonight.
02:31:27 If you don't yet have your party membership to vote on October 6th,
02:31:30 visit www.unitedconservatives.ca for more information.
02:31:34 And as mentioned in my introductory remarks,
02:31:37 the Medicine Hat debate is the first of two official debates.
02:31:40 Please tune in to the next one in Edmonton on August 30th at the Citadel Theatre.
02:31:44 Thank you, and good night, Alberta.
02:31:46 Thank you.
02:32:16 oh my goodness I was nodding off a little there I think it might have been the question about
02:32:26 well I think all of them actually for the first half of the debate we are coming to you live this
02:32:33 is true north's coverage of what was a glitch filled united conservative party debate as people
02:32:40 square off in medicine head Alberta for who gets to be the next leader of the UCP
02:32:45 replacing Jason Kenney, but also who gets to be the next Premier of Alberta. And I was talking
02:32:54 about this on my show the other day. It's very interesting when the stakes are a lot higher than
02:32:58 they are, say, in the Conservative Party of Canada leadership race underway right now,
02:33:03 that once you win this leadership race, you are the Premier of Alberta. So you are seeking
02:33:09 re-election in the election coming up in nine months time rather than just trying to seek
02:33:15 election for the first time. And I think that actually is important because whoever comes in
02:33:20 is going to have an existing caucus. They'll have to manage heading into an election,
02:33:25 which means they'll have to set a tone very quickly. They'll have to assemble a cabinet
02:33:30 very quickly. And they're going to have to do this in a way that gives them enough momentum
02:33:35 and puts them on solid enough footing that they are able to win an election in nine months time
02:33:39 against Rachel Notley, who's running again for the NDP. I want to explain here a few different
02:33:46 things that have happened here. So the rules of the debate were a little bit chaotic, but basically,
02:33:53 as mentioned, it prioritized having people debate each other, that one-on-one debate.
02:33:58 But the result of this is that it gave Danielle Smith a lot more time. It was the frontrunner 0.91
02:34:02 pile on. All of the candidates virtually tried to devote their time asking questions to her with 0.97
02:34:08 the exception of maybe Brian Jean, which means they were trying to sink her. And whether they
02:34:13 did sink her, it is tough to say. My colleague William Macbeth is standing by. We'll get to him
02:34:18 in just a moment. But first, I want to check in on the social media desk with Elie Kendenantel.
02:34:24 Obviously, we spoke at the beginning, Elie, about what people were thinking about who was going to
02:34:28 win. Looking back on it, did people articulate a clear winner or at least who they think the winner
02:34:34 was? Yes, there's actually quite a consensus in the chat. People say it's Danielle Smith is number
02:34:43 one. Despite her being attacked constantly tonight, we heard a lot about Danielle Smith
02:34:48 and the Sovereignty Act. People think she did a good job at fighting back. And Todd Lowen also is 0.57
02:34:53 a popular one. And honestly, I'm not surprised. Well, he might not be known outside of Alberta
02:34:58 very much people have a lot of respect because he stood up to jason kenny as he was locking down
02:35:03 the province i remember that letter that very strongly worded letter telling kenny he should
02:35:08 resign um some people said brian gene but there's mixed comments on brian gene somebody uh wrote
02:35:14 gene is annoying me no longer my second choice it's low and uh i was a little i i found gene
02:35:21 kind of underperformed especially at the beginning of the debate i was wondering where is brian gene
02:35:24 how come we're not hearing from him i mean this is somebody who like kind of started the whole
02:35:30 revolution against this the revolt against kenny and the lake uh lake uh fort mcmurray lake lavish
02:35:35 uh by election and he seemed a little bit quiet for somebody who you know clearly wants to be
02:35:40 premier he's this is his third time trying to basically be premier uh as yeah just to jump in
02:35:46 on brian gene there ellie the thing that was interesting so by the end of it i mean let's
02:35:50 let's just look at the numbers. He had two of his little rebuttal paddly things left, which means
02:35:54 that he was a lot more judicious and a lot more restrained about jumping in and getting into the
02:35:59 debates at the beginning. And yeah, I would agree for the first half, I kind of forgot he was in
02:36:03 there. And he was affected by the dropout of the stream as well. So it was when he was speaking
02:36:10 that one of the longer dropouts took place, which is when I jumped back in. He did speak a little
02:36:15 bit more near the end uh but one thing i would point out about brian gene's performance i mean
02:36:20 he had i'd say the strongest or one of the strongest in terms of delivery like when he
02:36:26 spoke it sounded very natural it sounded very authoritative but it also if you looked past
02:36:31 the style i i don't know how much he was saying so what were what were people specifically raising
02:36:37 with brian gene that they weren't fans of well it appears that people were kind of i guess a bit
02:36:43 unimpressed uh in total i will say personally on my personal observation he came off again as you
02:36:50 said he was very he can't he seemed to know what he wanted to do you know when he said like about
02:36:54 the sovereignty act he said look this is not you know he came off as somebody who kind of knew his
02:36:58 stuff a bit you know uh but as i said doors i asked my supporters my my followers what they
02:37:05 think of the sovereignty act they all support it and unfortunately in politics often it's not
02:37:09 about the quality or the substance of an idea, but more about the cover of the book and what
02:37:16 something sounds like on the outside. And that's what people like. And again, the Alberta Sovereignty
02:37:20 Act, given how Ottawa has been treated, is very popular. Yeah. And one thing I would say,
02:37:27 just looking back on the context, I know a lot of people were jumping up about the Sovereignty Act.
02:37:35 The challenge that I would raise just as far as strategy goes is that whenever Travis Taves and Rajan Sani were criticizing it, they were saying it, they were repeating it, they were saying sovereignty act, sovereignty act, sovereignty act. And anytime you hear that, it's like, well, that actually sounds like a good thing. And it actually gives more name recognition for what is really Danielle Smith's flagship policy.
02:37:58 Now, again, if the policy is unpopular, then maybe it's a good idea to keep tying it to her. But I think that people actually are going, I think it's going to backfire on them. Let's bring in William Macbeth on this. Because William, I know you've covered as an Albertan, the Alberta independence discussion, and no one was coming out and saying we need separatism.
02:38:17 But certainly, Danielle Smith's Sovereignty Act is really directed at that growing movement of people that are dissatisfied with Ottawa, that want a more autonomous and a more sovereign Alberta.
02:38:29 Do you think the blows on the Sovereignty Act landed?
02:38:32 uh to be honest no i i think what's interesting about the sovereignty act context of what the
02:38:43 kenny government had done previously on discontent and they had a series of provincial uh town halls
02:38:53 this process but i think a lot of people felt it didn't really result in anything it didn't result
02:39:00 concrete measures being taken. There was no Alberta Provincial Pension Plan. There was no
02:39:07 of course. There was a referendum on equalization but the moment the
02:39:12 referendum was heard about it again. So I think there's a pent-up concern that
02:39:18 not enough with the Act is a very politically visible response to what
02:39:28 people are asking about. Yeah, thank you very much, William. And I'll also say thank you as
02:39:33 well for your contributions this evening. It's been very welcome. So we appreciate that very
02:39:37 much. And of course, when we touch back on these issues at the next debate, we'll be sure to have
02:39:42 you back on. So thanks again to my colleague, William McBeth here. I will say as well, I mean,
02:39:47 we did a live show the night of the referendum. We did a live show because it was on the Calgary
02:39:53 and Edmonton and other municipal elections as well. And the results, I don't think were all
02:39:57 that surprising. We knew that, you know, 62%, roughly, of Albertans were probably going to
02:40:02 support it. It was going to be around there. But I think William's point is right, that
02:40:06 it is a big question mark of how you leverage that into something. And I'm curious if Western
02:40:14 independence, Western separatism were things that you were seeing in the social media chatter, Ali?
02:40:20 I was seeing a bit of it. I was seeing a lot of Western alienation. Some people are telling me,
02:40:26 Oh, Alberta's been left behind.
02:40:28 Some people showing pessimism, being like, oh, it doesn't matter who wins.
02:40:33 We will continue to be betrayed.
02:40:34 And so there is a pessimism.
02:40:36 And I saw this pessimism when I was in Alberta, too.
02:40:39 It's really because they've been through a lot of hard time and lots of governments that don't listen.
02:40:44 So that's kind of what I've noticed there.
02:40:46 I would say, too, I think the crowd that maybe watches the UCP leadership debate are maybe not your Alberta separatists.
02:40:51 They're more your Alberta, your more classical Alberta conservatives.
02:40:54 So I think we're bound to not see as much discussions on separatism there.
02:40:58 But there's definitely a lot of talk about sovereignty and independence and freedom.
02:41:02 You know, freedom is a popular, has been a very popular thing in Canada in the last few months.
02:41:07 He wrote a book about the Freedom Convoy, Andrew, which, by the way, you can get online.
02:41:12 Just Indigo won't sell it.
02:41:13 That's a shame.
02:41:14 But all right, you're getting invited back next time.
02:41:18 Good job.
02:41:19 You know, it's true.
02:41:21 Like sovereignty, freedom, these things are intertwined.
02:41:23 And I think, again, that is why the Alberta sovereignty is so popular, because it's a form of independence, a form of freedom without going full independence, which, you know, would be challenging, given Alberta doesn't have any ocean or doesn't have any ports to export his oil.
02:41:37 yeah one one interesting thing and this just sort of goes to the danielle smith question more
02:41:42 broadly is that she is not well liked it sounds like certainly not widely supported by a lot of
02:41:49 the people in the ucp caucus and i mentioned a few moments ago that whoever wins this leadership
02:41:54 race is going to become the leader of caucus have to lead that caucus through the next i mean it
02:41:59 won't be the next nine months but the next several months and then lead that caucus into an election
02:42:04 And, you know, the the big question mark will be for all they talk about unity, how much will the party and specifically the MLAs unify behind the next leader?
02:42:15 Are they going to unify behind Danielle Smith? Are you going to have candidates that say, I don't want to run for the party anymore if Danielle Smith's the leader?
02:42:22 So I think that's the big question. And again, I'm not talking about this as though it's a fait accompli, because there is a lot that still is going to happen.
02:42:28 And this is the first debate, but I bring it up just as we talk about the themes here
02:42:32 that are coming up.
02:42:34 So that's going to do it for us.
02:42:35 I want to thank you, Lee Quentin Nantel, for all your work this evening and with True
02:42:40 North more broadly.
02:42:41 It's been an absolute pleasure.
02:42:42 So you have a good evening, sir, and we'll get you back on for the next one.
02:42:45 And I want to thank you, the audience, for tuning into this live show.
02:42:49 I know there were, I mean, on one hand, it's always good when the technical glitches are
02:42:53 not our fault, but I know to the audience, it's a moot point.
02:42:55 So we thank you very much for your patience.
02:42:58 We were just as frustrated as you were by it, but we're going to get things together
02:43:03 for the next debate.
02:43:03 Hopefully the UCP will buy a new modem by then.
02:43:06 Maybe we can fundraise for it, but I will say doing these shows, doing the coverage
02:43:12 that we do, we have a reporter in the ground in, not in the ground, on the ground.
02:43:15 She's in the ground.
02:43:16 That's a whole other story, but she's on the ground in Medicine Hat.
02:43:19 That is Rachel Emanuel.
02:43:21 And, you know, there's a lot of overhead to do the work that we do.
02:43:24 We have to pay reporters and videographers and travel costs.
02:43:28 So if you can chip in to do this journalism,
02:43:31 to let us do this journalism, please do.
02:43:33 You can head on over to donate.tnc.news,
02:43:36 donate.tnc.news.
02:43:38 If you're watching on YouTube,
02:43:39 you can give us a little super chat there.
02:43:42 But truly, thank you so much for your support,
02:43:44 not just for tuning into tonight's show,
02:43:47 but throughout the year,
02:43:48 we are only able to do the work we do
02:43:50 because of the generous support of people like you.
02:43:53 And I know I'm sounding like a PBS commercial, but I do mean it.
02:43:56 That does it for us for today, everyone.
02:43:58 Thank you so much.
02:43:59 We'll talk to you soon.
02:44:00 Have a great evening.
02:44:23 Thank you.
02:44:53 Thank you.
02:45:23 We'll be right back.
02:45:53 Transcription by CastingWords