Juno News - May 12, 2022


True North’s LIVE coverage of the Conservative Leadership Debate

Topics
Mentioned
Can Doug Ford still rely on 'Ford Nation' for electoral success? The pro-life movement in Canada reacts to Roe v Wade case

Episode Stats


Length

3 hours and 17 minutes

Words per minute

170.03

Word count

33,497

Sentence count

2,002

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

45

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Conservative Party of Canada is holding its second leadership debate in two weeks, and we're here to cover it. We're joined by reporter Harley Simms and producer Harrison Faulkner to discuss what to expect from tonight's event.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you for joining us.
00:00:30 Hi, everyone, and welcome to True North Live.
00:00:51 It is my great pleasure to be joining you tonight.
00:00:54 I'm your host tonight, Candice Malcolm, and we're here for the Conservative Party of Canada
00:00:59 leadership debate i'm very pleased to be joined by two of my colleagues here first harley sims
00:01:04 who is an editor and senior reporter here at true north he's based out of somewhere around
00:01:10 vancouver i think one of the suburbs in vancouver uh harley great to have you great to see you
00:01:15 and also we have harrison faulkner who is a producer on the canister malcolm show
00:01:19 and also a reporter harrison great to see you as well great to see you so so here we are
00:01:25 at the second debate in two weeks.
00:01:29 And, you know, for me, I moderated the last one.
00:01:31 So I have a newfound sort of respect
00:01:33 for the entire sort of operation
00:01:35 of putting one of these events together
00:01:37 and the sort of nerves that you feel
00:01:40 before the event starts,
00:01:42 not just for the candidates,
00:01:43 but for everyone who's organizing it
00:01:44 and the moderator.
00:01:46 Tonight's event out in Edmonton, Alberta,
00:01:48 is moderated by Tom Clark,
00:01:50 who is a former legacy media reporter, journalist,
00:01:52 who was with Global News for a long time.
00:01:54 And I think now he is a consultant. So a little bit of a strange pick, given that this is the only debate in Western Canada.
00:02:01 It's the debate in Alberta. And they didn't they didn't have an Albertan or a Westerner to to demoderate it.
00:02:07 And interesting because, you know, that we have five candidates in this race and they're all from Ontario or Quebec.
00:02:13 We all represent Quebec. I know Pierre Polyev was born in Calgary, raised in Calgary.
00:02:17 And I'm sure he'll mention that many, many times tonight. But we'll go to you first, Harley.
00:02:21 What are you expecting? What are you excited about? And what do you think is going to happen
00:02:25 tonight? Well, all things at stake, Candice. I'm not ashamed to say I'm looking for an
00:02:31 entertaining debate. I don't think a lot of people other than political junkies watch these things
00:02:35 expect, you know, expecting to be entertained. But I mean, the last one was pretty fiery. And
00:02:41 I don't think it's right to say this is a normal debate. I mean, there are a lot of things that
00:02:49 these candidates will be putting forward tonight that will shape the direction of our country
00:02:53 going into the next election. I'm looking for just an honest recognition of the issues that
00:03:01 are facing Canadians rather than just the usual politics. And I think those issues include
00:03:05 the economy, namely affordability and civil liberties. I mean, we are over a trillion
00:03:11 dollars in debt. Gas here in BC hit 220 a liter. Our housing has become unaffordable for the next
00:03:18 generation and beyond that we just went through two years of a pandemic that saw people uh
00:03:25 people's businesses shut down people denied entry to certain places people still unable to leave the
00:03:30 country due to vaccination status uh peaceful protesters who were uh arrested and uh had their
00:03:39 bank accounts and uh their vehicles uh seized i mean we're in a crisis right now i don't think
00:03:44 think there's any way around that. So I'm looking forward to seeing which candidates take that head
00:03:49 on and which ones want to just pretend it's business as usual. Well, it's interesting because
00:03:55 at the last debate in Ottawa, I think one of the rowdiest moments of the whole debate was
00:04:01 exchange between Pierre Polyev and Jean Charest. And I was really surprised because Jean Charest
00:04:06 just took a direct shot at the trucker convoy. And you're in a room full of 800, 900 people.
00:04:13 sure, you're in Ottawa, and that's sort of the establishment capital of Canada, the fake news
00:04:17 capital of Canada, we called it on my show last week. But the room gave him a resounding set of
00:04:22 boos, like it was loud, it was intense. And it was like, that, you know, that is one of the issues
00:04:27 that even though the trucker convoy became controversial, even though there was a lot of
00:04:31 stuff that happened that I think a lot of people don't agree with that sort of lawlessness and some
00:04:35 of the more extreme characters that the media focused on, of course, that wasn't the broad
00:04:39 sentiment uh but but but there was one thing it seemed that the conservative base was really
00:04:44 behind and that was that these truckers were doing something righteous they were doing something
00:04:48 good and that they deserve respect and attention empathy all of the things that justin trudeau
00:04:54 should have done we've been talking a lot about harrison you were you were the tracker convoy do
00:04:57 you think that's going to be a sort of main theme of the debate tonight or do you expect them to
00:05:01 talk about something a little different i think the moderators are probably going to do their
00:05:05 bad or the moderator is going to do his best to avoid making it all about the convoy but it's
00:05:10 really the i think that's really where all of the big ticket big sort of red meat items at the base
00:05:16 um want to hear that's kind of where it all comes from a lot of the civil liberties discussion will
00:05:21 stem from the convoy protest and i think that it was a a total flash point in in the country and
00:05:28 and really emblematic of where we find ourselves like harley i think the last thing i want to see
00:05:33 tonight is a boring debate we have two hours they have to fill two hours which is not not easy it's
00:05:38 gonna be a long a long debate but it'll make it a lot better if they really go after each other
00:05:43 really carve out a space for themselves and i've written down some notes about what i'm expecting
00:05:48 to see and i know we'll get into this before the debate starts but yeah i i hope it's not i hope
00:05:54 it's not um totally dominated by the convoy itself i think there was a lot of opportunity
00:05:59 for the candidates to make their pitch on that issue in the last debate. I think what we're
00:06:04 going to see is a lot of resource-related debate, a lot of conversation on who has a better track
00:06:12 record when it comes to supporting natural resources and supporting the oil and gas sector.
00:06:17 And of course, I think the big takeaway will be how Patrick Brown performs, how he receives a lot
00:06:23 of the heat that I'm sure he's going to get from the candidates, and how he dishes it.
00:06:26 yeah absolutely well i i will be the third one to echo that i hope it's an entertaining
00:06:32 debate two hours is a really long time to fill but we do have a new uh campaigner debater that
00:06:39 will be on the stage and that is patrick brown he was absent uh from from the last debate he
00:06:43 seems to be laying pretty low his strategy is sort of to not really do any interviews not really
00:06:49 have any presence and kind of maybe hope to slide through without scrutiny and uh should be
00:06:55 interesting just you know a lot of people getting their first glimpse of him tonight i i want to
00:07:00 talk a little bit about the legacy media and how they respond to things because what i noticed in
00:07:06 the in the coverage and the feedback from the first debate was that a lot of media a lot of
00:07:10 journalists were commenting were not very happy with the tone they call it angry and bitter and
00:07:16 you know even even uh my friend over at the toronto sun brian lily uh he didn't like the
00:07:22 tone of the debate and he thought it was unbecoming. To me, you know, this moment in the country,
00:07:26 and I'll sort of circle back to what you said off the start, Harley, you know, our country has gone
00:07:31 through something really incredible the last two years. And there's a lot of, there are a lot of
00:07:36 people out there that are feeling just completely angry, completely disaffected, outside, left behind.
00:07:44 I mean, there's so many words to describe it. And I think you want your politicians to reflect that.
00:07:49 I think that a lot of the anger wasn't coming because Pierre Polyev and Jean Charest and
00:07:53 Roman Bavar, thank goodness that he's part of this debate because he's raising so many
00:07:57 of these important issues.
00:07:58 You know, they're not bitter and angry people.
00:08:00 They're actually, each of them in their own way, quite positive and optimistic.
00:08:04 But the reason that I think that the tone of the debate was so aggressive is because
00:08:09 they're tapping into the anger and resentment and the sort of growing divides that are very
00:08:15 evident under the surface in our society.
00:08:17 We're basically just lived through two years where almost every institution that we rely on has failed us in some way, shape or form.
00:08:24 So, Harley, I'm wondering what your thoughts are on that.
00:08:28 Yeah, I don't know what place civility has right now.
00:08:32 Non-violent for certainly, but Justin Trudeau was the first person to throw civility out the window.
00:08:38 I mean, the September 2021 election, he started using hate to wedge people.
00:08:43 He used the unvaccinated issue as a way of gaining votes and demonizing Canadians.
00:08:50 Before that, if you actually heard him talk about mandating vaccines, he said he was concerned.
00:08:54 He didn't want to create divisions.
00:08:56 He knew there were people who weren't going to take it.
00:08:58 But the election came along and obviously he thought he had an edge by speaking about Canadians in a hateful way.
00:09:04 And it was hateful.
00:09:04 So now we need a leader, a conservative leader, who are willing to accept that Justin Trudeau is hateful towards a certain segment of his own population.
00:09:13 and come in aggressively and and i mean it's it's not a matter of shaking hands anymore um
00:09:18 like the gauntlet has been thrown down uh we have a prime minister who basically showed uh canadians
00:09:24 that that uh protesting peacefully and talking isn't good is it doesn't work with him i don't
00:09:30 know what message that sends uh but like i said i think we need someone who's willing to show his
00:09:36 fangs come out and tell the canadians that desperately want to see some opposition um what
00:09:41 what he's made of and that he's not going to mince words come election time. I think you're
00:09:46 right. I think so many Canadians just want someone who can take on Trudeau, someone who won't be
00:09:50 deferent to him in the way that the media are and won't be too polite to him because he doesn't
00:09:54 frankly deserve our courtesy and our politeness given the way that he's treated us. I want to
00:09:59 bring in True North's Andrew Lawton. Andrew Lawton is on the ground at the debate in Edmonton. There's
00:10:05 Andrew. Hey, Andrew, welcome to the live broadcast here. You're in Edmonton. Why don't you tell us a
00:10:10 bit about what is going on at the debate uh set the stage for us about the event over there
00:10:16 yeah i will do so right now i'm actually just outside of the foyer where they've had a nice
00:10:20 little reception area and as much as i love the cash bar in there it was a little bit too noisy
00:10:25 to dial into the broadcast from there uh they're expecting about 800 well actually i should say
00:10:29 they have room for 800 they had about a thousand people register so i don't know if it's going to
00:10:33 be standing room only but a lot of enthusiasm here people in western canada especially in
00:10:39 in Conservative politics, often feel like everything is very Eastern-focused, Ontario-centric.
00:10:44 So they're very happy that the party is having this debate out in Edmonton. They're very happy
00:10:49 to have the opportunity to hear from the candidates here. And when I was chatting with people, one of
00:10:53 the big questions I was asking is, do you have a candidate in mind? Met a couple of people who
00:10:57 were undecided, but every single person but one who was not undecided was saying they were here
00:11:04 for Pierre Polyev. And I don't share that because I'm endorsing Pierre. I share that just because
00:11:08 when the debate starts, I think you can expect to see a home field advantage from Pierre Polyev
00:11:13 here, who was born in Alberta. And I was wondering if that would actually give him enough cred to be
00:11:19 recognized as a Westerner. And a lot of people are saying, yeah, he's Albertan enough for them.
00:11:25 Well, I mean, it's true. And I think that a lot of people at West are just excited that,
00:11:29 you know, Pierre has the momentum, he's got, you know, he's kind of has the ability to go viral
00:11:35 online and you know the fact that he is elected in ontario kind of shows that he can be elected
00:11:41 in multiple parts of the of the of the country so i think he certainly has a lot going for you
00:11:46 going for him andrew i wonder though like you know the the sort of heart and soul of the
00:11:51 conservative movement the conservative party has always been alberta and it was sort of strange
00:11:55 that you we didn't see any alberta mps uh throw their hat in and and try to run for for leader
00:12:01 Do you hear any grumbling about that? Is there any reason why we don't have any Alberta MPs
00:12:07 trying to become leader of this party at this point?
00:12:10 It's a tough question. And I think that one of the big things that a lot of people are latching
00:12:14 onto is whether they have Alberta-centric policies or policies that are friendly to
00:12:20 Albertans in Alberta. And a big part of that comes down to energy, oil and gas, that sort of stuff.
00:12:24 But it isn't exclusively that. And I think that's the big thing. There are a lot of challenges that
00:12:29 people in Western Canada are raising about sovereignty, about independence on taxation
00:12:34 and other government policies, about equalization. That's a big one. People that want a prime
00:12:39 minister and a leader that's going to advocate for a renewed equalization formula. So there are
00:12:43 other challenges that I hope will be raised tonight and that a lot of people here hope will
00:12:48 be raised tonight. And to go back to the discussion you were having before you brought me in about
00:12:52 what we can expect from the moderator, that's the big thing. A lot of the time, the legacy media
00:12:55 folks don't care about the West or don't know about the West. We're talking about the conservative
00:13:01 heartland here. We're talking about a debate in Alberta for the leadership of the Conservative
00:13:05 Party of Canada, a party that wouldn't even be in play if it weren't for Alberta and Saskatchewan
00:13:10 seats. So there need to be questions about the West and its place in Canada that go beyond just
00:13:16 pipelines. Well, I certainly, you know, I think that Tom Clark has his work cut out for him. I'm
00:13:22 certainly cheering for him just in terms of you know doing exactly that you being in touch with
00:13:26 what conservatives care about what issues are important in western canada because there's
00:13:30 certainly a big divide we saw this a lot both in 2019 and 2021 andrew where you know the media
00:13:36 would fixate on these really little minute issues and you'd have like 20 questions about critical
00:13:43 race theory or systemic racism and it's like you know they don't they don't talk about the issues
00:13:48 um that actually matter and so i i really hope um i am cheering for tom clark and i hope he he
00:13:53 does a good job i'm sure he will i want to ask you about patrick brown because he is sort of
00:13:57 making his first appearance you know he doesn't do a lot of media he doesn't do a lot of interviews
00:14:01 he didn't bother to show up to the canada strong and free debate last week he was the only one that
00:14:05 didn't and i i'm wondering you know does he have support out there uh have you had a chance to
00:14:11 talk to him or any of his people and and what do you sort of expect him to do i think the pressure
00:14:15 on him to do something and everyone's gonna be watching him. So I'm wondering what your take is
00:14:20 on that. Yeah, I mean, all of the candidates, each of the candidates was given a table on which they
00:14:25 could have volunteers and put up signs and give out pamphlets and that sort of stuff. And one of
00:14:30 the interesting things that happened is all of these tables were full of volunteers handing it
00:14:35 out except Patrick Brown's. When I was last in the room about 15-20 minutes ago, his table was empty
00:14:40 and just had a little placard on it that the party had sat there that said Patrick Brown. Now, maybe
00:14:43 they've loaded it up since then. But at the time that I was in there, they weren't really interested
00:14:47 in doing that politicking that all of the other candidates are doing. Now, I should say the one
00:14:52 person I spoke to who is a decided voter that wasn't a Pierre Polyev supporter was a Patrick
00:14:57 Brown supporter. So he does have some support if some is greater than zero in Alberta. But, you
00:15:03 know, he can surprise a lot of people because his strategy has been don't worry about debates,
00:15:07 don't worry about media, focus on selling membership, selling, selling, selling. And if
00:15:12 you're a local candidate seeking the nomination in a riding like Brampton West or a Bitsy Beach
00:15:17 and Miskaming that's the strategy you you aren't going to get votes doing radio interviews and all
00:15:21 candidates forums but in a leadership contest in a national contest I don't know if that's enough
00:15:27 I don't know if you can win people over unless you're prepared to take the stage and answer
00:15:31 questions I mean maybe the joke will be on all of us and he'll have outsold everyone but that's
00:15:35 going to be the big question is you know at a certain point you lose support by not being there
00:15:40 and I worry that was the case for him last.
00:15:42 I mean, I know he said he won the debate last time
00:15:44 by not being there.
00:15:45 This one, the party requires them to be at.
00:15:47 They get fined $50,000 if they're not there.
00:15:49 So he's got to be here.
00:15:51 Oh, that was a pretty arrogant comment
00:15:52 from my perspective that you won by not showing up
00:15:56 because no one knows you.
00:15:58 You haven't had an opportunity to show yourself.
00:16:00 So I'm pleased, hopefully he will be there.
00:16:03 Now, Andrew, why don't you just quickly walk us
00:16:05 through the evening, what we can expect?
00:16:06 I know we're going to be streaming the debate
00:16:08 live on this channel.
00:16:09 So some people in the chat are wondering, where can I watch the debate?
00:16:12 When does it start?
00:16:13 Well, we're going to have it for you right here.
00:16:14 Just keep watching.
00:16:15 But Andrew, why don't you sort of walk us through what to expect,
00:16:18 both during the debate and then afterwards as well.
00:16:21 Just to give you a little behind the scenes, I don't know if you saw,
00:16:23 but Jean Charest just walked by to walk in the debate hall,
00:16:26 Roman Baber a few moments before him.
00:16:28 So that means I'll have to be following quickly behind them.
00:16:31 The candidates are going to be taking the stage in just 14 minutes.
00:16:34 It is, as you mentioned, a two-hour debate.
00:16:36 Tom Clark is the moderator.
00:16:37 we know some of the broad themes that are going to be there but we don't know
00:16:41 the questions the candidates don't know the questions and afterwards that there
00:16:44 are going to be opportunities for the candidates to do what are called scrums
00:16:48 which are these these post-debate press conferences that they do and this is
00:16:52 what you know I participated in after the federal leaders debate in the last
00:16:56 election and I will say at that debate each candidate stood up and took ten
00:17:00 minutes of questions here each candidate is doing five minutes of questions so
00:17:04 after the debate, there's going to be no more than 30 minutes of these scrums combined
00:17:08 among all six candidates. So if you've got a candidate that is pretty long-winded,
00:17:13 gives longer answers, they might only take one or two questions. Some that can do rapid fire
00:17:18 soundbites might burn through a whole bunch of them. But there are going to be lots of
00:17:22 opportunities for the candidates to talk to each other on stage, a little bit less to talk to media
00:17:26 offstage afterwards. Oh, that's really interesting. Well, Andrew, I know you have to go because the
00:17:30 debate starts in 13 minutes. Just one final question for you though. You know, obviously
00:17:35 independent media is a really important issue to us and there is sort of this growing divide between
00:17:39 legacy media and independent media. Are there other independent media there? Are there other
00:17:44 journalists that are not part of legacy media or what have you seen so far? Yeah, I've seen
00:17:48 Rebel News has a couple of people here. I've seen someone from the National Telegraph as well. I've
00:17:53 seen some other reporters who I didn't have identification on them. So I didn't know which
00:17:56 outlets they were from. They may have been mainstream media or they could have been, you
00:17:59 know, the 27 people from CBC. But we do have a lot of media interest here. And I will say I was
00:18:05 talking to one legacy media reporter who was telling me about just streeters that she was
00:18:09 doing earlier. And she found similar to what I found that Pierre Polyev was really the only one
00:18:14 that she could get anyone to say here that they were supporting. So, you know, a lot of people
00:18:19 would look at that and say, great, you know, it's a runaway for Pierre. The problem is this early in
00:18:23 the race, if you're the one in the front, you're the one everyone wants to attack. So that'll be
00:18:26 the interesting question. I mean, front-runner syndrome is very real in politics. We saw that's
00:18:31 what happened with Peter McKay last time, and it may be what happens to Pierre Pauly of this time,
00:18:36 but we will have to see. Well, Andrew, I appreciate your insight, and it's great to have you on the
00:18:40 ground. We're looking forward to seeing you during the scrums, and hopefully you get some good
00:18:44 questions into the candidates. So we will let you go so you can get positioned for the debate,
00:18:49 which again is starting now in 11 minutes. So that's Andrew Lawton on the ground in Edmonton
00:18:53 at the Conservative Party debate. Well, we've got Harrison Faulkner joining us again. And I don't
00:19:03 think I mentioned it before, but Harrison, you're based in Toronto. And we were talking a little
00:19:08 bit there, Harrison, about Patrick Brown and the fact that he's making his first appearance,
00:19:12 the fact that Pierre Polyev is sort of the front runner. And so expectations around him are really
00:19:17 high. We did see in the last debate, a lot of the candidates were going after him. We saw direct
00:19:22 sort of challenges from Roman Babber on saying that the federal conservatives weren't there
00:19:27 during COVID. They weren't standing up for Canadians. Leslie Lewis claimed that he wasn't
00:19:32 at the trucker convoy, that he was only pretending to be. And then, of course, Jean Charest had a
00:19:36 number of attacks against him. So I'm wondering, what do you expect from both Pierre Polyev
00:19:42 and Patrick Brown specifically in this debate? Well, I think that obviously Pierre Polyev is
00:19:48 to try and do what he did last time, which was continue to get as much attention as he can,
00:19:53 go out swinging, obviously take his opportunity to swing at Patrick Brown and return some of the
00:19:59 shots that Brown has been sending his way. I think what we're likely going to see from Patrick
00:20:05 Brown is criticism of Pierre Polyev on being softer on the Quebec 21 bill. Brown is probably
00:20:16 going to go back into the uh call criticism into the hot into the um what is it the tip line from
00:20:22 2015 i mean those are the kind of issues that he's relying on because of his his his strategy at uh
00:20:28 appealing to diaspora politics is appealing to these immigrant communities i i don't think it's
00:20:32 going to be um i don't think it's going to be as policy focused i imagine it's going to be just like
00:20:37 a good fist fight that we saw the last debate interesting what are your thoughts harley
00:20:42 well uh you don't hear many people talk about um leadership candidates of a party at a gas station
00:20:51 and i've heard a lot of people talking about pierre polliver everywhere i've gone a lot of
00:20:56 people they don't even know his name that pierre guy that they don't know how to pronounce his last
00:21:00 name but they're into it so he's got the momentum and i think uh it's up to the other candidates to
00:21:06 distinguish themselves at this point i mean strange things can happen at leadership elections
00:21:10 people can come up the middle. You saw that with Aaron O'Toole. You saw it with Stéphane Dion with
00:21:15 the Liberals. So, I mean, right now, I think Pierre just has to keep nailing his points home,
00:21:21 keep saying the same things that's gotten him all the attention. And I think it's really just
00:21:25 a race between the people that recognize that Canada is in an unprecedented situation
00:21:32 constitutionally, legally, and the people that, like Jean Charest, who are constantly accusing
00:21:38 poliver of supporting illegal activities. So to me, it's just that it's two completely different
00:21:46 streams. And it's interesting to see those two heads go at it. Sorry, go ahead.
00:21:54 Well, I was just going to say that one thing I'm also looking forward to seeing is how Roman
00:21:58 Baber performs. I think that he surprised a lot of members in the debate last week. I know in the
00:22:03 comments, people are, are supporting Roman Baber. And I think that he has a really unique opportunity
00:22:09 to, um, obviously he's one of the only candidates that has a different, a different sort of
00:22:14 perspective comes from a different place from the provincial level. And he's got a very strong
00:22:19 record on the issues that a lot of conservatives are looking to hear him speak on. And, and, um,
00:22:23 I thought he came out measured. Um, he was, he was very well-spoken and I do think he surprised
00:22:29 a lot of people. I'm looking to see how he surprises members tonight. I felt that too.
00:22:34 Like I know, just to echo what Andrew said earlier that, you know, he's walking around
00:22:37 trying to look for people to interview and asking who you're supporting. When I was in Ottawa,
00:22:42 the last debate, almost everyone I talked to was a peer supporter. Like that was, you know,
00:22:47 they were interested in some of the other candidates and they thought so-and-so did a
00:22:50 good job, bad job. But when people were willing to say who they supported, it was usually Pierre.
00:22:55 However, I just felt the energy in the room and during the debate that it was Roman that was really hitting the applause lines. It was really getting people behind him. Like when he was talking, there was just a sort of organic agreement with him and people shouting out and people applauding him throughout the debate. So he is definitely onto something with the issues that he talks about.
00:23:16 and you know it'll be interesting to see whether he can kind of drive on that momentum because
00:23:22 I do think that a lot of people just simply don't know him you know he's not a federal politician
00:23:25 he's he's on the scene in Ontario and you know even for for us and for me personally you know
00:23:32 I had him on my show during the pandemic because he was he was sort of a lone fighter speaking out
00:23:37 against some of the craziest you know policies and and and the harmful impact was having on kids
00:23:43 and schools and, you know, people at the margins and people who suffer, could suffer from falling
00:23:49 through the cracks. Like he was really an advocate for those people at a time when there weren't very
00:23:53 many. And I think a lot of people really admired him for that. I certainly did, especially leaving
00:23:58 a conservative government, right? Like it's not like he, you know, he had to go it alone. He took
00:24:03 incredible risks. And I think that the fact that he's in this race, he adds so much just because
00:24:09 he is so willing to talk about his issues. It's like, you know, he doesn't really have a lot to 1.00
00:24:13 lose, right? He's still trying to establish himself as a sort of federal figure. And he can
00:24:19 really speak out in an honest way that you can't really when you're part of a caucus or when you're
00:24:24 really the front runner, right? So I feel like Roman brings a lot of honesty and attention to
00:24:30 some of the most important issues that I think many in our political elite class, and unfortunately
00:24:34 that does include Pierre would rather not talk about because it's uncomfortable to look in a
00:24:40 mirror and say, you know, you let this happen. You let kids suffer not going to school. You were
00:24:44 responsible for churches closing and AA meetings shutting down and all of these people, you know,
00:24:49 falling again through the cracks. So I'm happy to see him here. Harley, I know this is sort of
00:24:56 your beat and the thing that you cover the most with True North is civil liberties and all of the
00:25:00 different ways that our country has failed us over the last two years. What did you think
00:25:05 specifically about Roman Baber and his presence at the last debate? I think you're right. I think
00:25:11 he's in a privileged position where he can say exactly how he feels. I think he's a fast-running
00:25:16 pace setter. I think he can set the stage. He was born in the former Soviet Union. We've had a few
00:25:23 Canadians who supported the protests, the convoy protests from the former Soviet Union,
00:25:29 including a police officer in Edmonton who said, you know, people need to recognize what's happening
00:25:33 because I see it. Roman Barber is one of them. I have friends who like him a great deal. I think
00:25:38 he's doing really well. And you're right. Pierre Polivar, sorry, Andrew Scheer pronounced it
00:25:44 Polivar, Polivar, has been around a long time, close to 20 years. He's not a new face. So this
00:25:51 kind of wave he's riding is new for him as well. And he has to be careful at the same time as he
00:25:57 he really has to you know he has to grab the red meat when it's thrown at him so he's actually in
00:26:02 a pretty precarious situation as well it's almost like he has to be careful but he has to jump at
00:26:06 the same time so I think Baber is in a great position to debate Pierre into making the stands
00:26:11 that he'd be otherwise a little bit careful about making well that's kind of also the fun of these
00:26:17 you know leadership races and you see this in primaries in the U.S. and Republican side that
00:26:22 you know, what ends up happening is that, you know, you're talking to a conservative base,
00:26:27 you're talking to an audience of people who fundamentally share your values, and you can go
00:26:31 a lot further than you than you might when you're talking on a federal stage or a federal election.
00:26:35 So it's, it's really interesting, to your point to see maybe if, if Baber and Leslie Lewis can
00:26:41 kind of push Pierre into more of the populist red meat conservative stuff, and, you know, pull that
00:26:47 out of them, because maybe you'll have to go down that path in order to be leader. And then and then 0.82
00:26:52 you know, it's a fun part for us as independent journalists to make sure we hold these guys to
00:26:55 account because as we've seen far too often in the last couple of years, conservatives say one
00:27:01 thing over here to get elected from their base and you get put in as leader. And then when it
00:27:07 comes to the national stage, they change their tone and they're afraid of the media and they
00:27:10 just want everyone to like them. And it's a totally different thing. Harrison, do you think
00:27:15 we run that risk with this crop of candidates? And what specifically are you looking out for
00:27:21 tonight? Well, I think tonight what I really want to see is Leslyn Lewis break out of what I felt
00:27:27 was a bit of a hole she found herself in. She was really hammering on the Freedom Convoy and 0.99
00:27:32 laying into that message. I think she has more to offer. And I'm looking forward to seeing what
00:27:36 she has to say on some of the, specifically some of the Western issues. I think that's a place
00:27:42 where she lacks. And I think obviously from my opinion with Roman Babber, I don't know if he's
00:27:48 necessarily expecting to win the leadership, but he was part of the race to make sure that he puts
00:27:53 himself on the federal level. In many ways, I think he's already done that and proven to be
00:27:58 successful in that. So if Roman Babber can have a similar performance as he did last week,
00:28:03 I think he'll continue to ride this momentum. I'm looking to see how Patrick Brown handles some of
00:28:08 the heat I'm sure he's going to receive on stage. And yeah, like I said, I'd like to see what
00:28:12 Leslie Lewis has to offer that is outside of what we know about her stance on the Freedom Convoy.
00:28:18 Yeah, I'll echo that. I hope she sort of expands and touches more on some of the great
00:28:23 policies. She's putting out some great stuff in terms of her ideas for the party. I know
00:28:28 that she put out a whole sort of pro-natalism, pro-mother, pro-family set of policies that
00:28:35 include doubling your CCB Canadian child care benefit if you don't enroll your children
00:28:42 in one of these government daycare schemes. She wants to offer women two years maternity 0.94
00:28:46 leave. She wants to start paying this child benefit when the mother is pregnant 12 weeks in 0.91
00:28:51 just to help with costs that come with bringing a little one into the world. And I think those 0.94
00:28:58 are the kind of things that conservatives really need to be talking about and promoting our own
00:29:03 policy agenda, conservative policy agenda. One name we haven't mentioned yet is Scott Aitchison.
00:29:08 Do either of you gentlemen want to comment on his performance in the last debate and what you
00:29:12 expect from him tonight maybe maybe harley you can take a crack at this one well he's a fellow
00:29:18 british colombian uh i felt scott uh the really the only thing that stuck out to me is he just
00:29:25 was kind of like one of those let's all get along guys i mean he kind of every time somebody's two
00:29:29 people started going at it or three people he'd be like let's let's just calm down let's all let's
00:29:33 all play it nice um i don't think that's going to cut it here i think he's going to have to jump in
00:29:38 And he's going to have to take the gloves off and start swinging with the rest of them, because that's not the situation we're in as a country and certainly as a leadership election campaign.
00:29:48 What about you, Harrison? What do you think?
00:29:50 Yeah, I mean, I think Scott Aikerson is one of the only candidates to really come out strong on supply management.
00:29:56 And that seems to be the one thing he's very confident about.
00:29:59 And it is a it is a touchy issue, especially even in the conservative base.
00:30:02 So he's in Alberta. He's got a chance to pick up on the performance. I think he came out as sort of one of the softer candidates on stage. And maybe he can lean into that one policy on supply management that he seems really to be quite strong on.
00:30:19 Yeah, it's almost to me a little off-putting because Scott HSC seems like a really great
00:30:25 guy, nice guy interpersonally and sort of has that quaint, quirky sort of small town
00:30:29 mayor type feeling, which I think he was a small town mayor before he became a federal
00:30:33 politician.
00:30:34 And even his message will still get along.
00:30:37 But as we all know, the supply management is such a precarious issue in the party and
00:30:42 it's so divisive.
00:30:43 And I just remember this really cringey moment from Andrew Scheer because he infamously
00:30:47 supported the supply management policy and was able to beat Maxime Bernier in his own riding
00:30:52 during the 2017 leadership race. And then he and then at one of the whatever press gallery dinners
00:30:58 or whatever, he pulled out a big jug of milk and started drinking it. And it was like, just to rub
00:31:03 it in, like add insult to injury that he wasn't really a free marketer. But, you know, I find it
00:31:08 a little surprising that Scott Aitchison, who is this sort of very establishment, very like centrist
00:31:13 sort of uh tory from ontario or harley you said he's from bc i thought he was from ontario
00:31:18 but he represents a riding in ontario and it just seems like i mean i'm for free market so i think
00:31:27 it's great that he's he's he's taking that position but i barely hear him talk about he
00:31:30 didn't bring it up once at the last debate so it's interesting yeah he's on he's ontarian you're
00:31:35 right i just i just double checked myself okay found himself in a position where he knows that
00:31:41 he you know he's probably got the smallest profile out of all the candidates and he needed that one
00:31:46 policy that he was going to basically make his name on it's uh it's it's a bold strategy as you
00:31:52 said um but if he's not going to bring it up now in this debate when when will we have a great
00:31:57 chance to get some sound bites out of it otherwise i think it's i think it's kind of a wasted move
00:32:02 yeah absolutely so people are just wondering uh you know the debate's supposed to have started
00:32:06 it's 8.02 eastern time here and my understanding is that they are just doing an intro of the
00:32:12 candidates they're playing uh videos so we have a few minutes but I promise as soon as the debate
00:32:18 is introduced and and and they get going uh we we will cut to that and and and just to sort of fill
00:32:25 you in again for for anyone who's just tuning in so the debate is two hours long it's uh being
00:32:30 it's live location out in Edmonton Andrew Lawton told us that there were about 800 to 1000 people
00:32:35 in the room. So it's going to be a big room full of conservative activists and volunteers and the
00:32:41 sort of grassroots of the party in the sort of heartland of the party and the movement, which
00:32:46 is Alberta. So really, you know, it's going to be fun just to watch it, witness it. And then
00:32:53 afterwards, we'll be back. We'll do a live show. We'll have Harrison Faulkner, Harley Sims, I
00:32:59 believe our colleague Ellie is also going to be jumping on for that. And then of course,
00:33:04 Andrew Lawton will be in those scrums. So following the debate, six candidates, they'll each have five
00:33:09 minutes to what we call scrum, answer questions from the media, the media will be jumping in and
00:33:14 asking them follow up questions. So we've got a long live broadcast planned for you. And you know,
00:33:20 keep up the conversations. It's fun to watch. We can we can see both the Facebook and the YouTube
00:33:25 comments popping up in our stream. So you know, let us know where you're watching from. Let us
00:33:30 know if you have any specific questions that you'd like addressed. And we will be back after
00:33:38 the debate to give sort of live reaction and then we'll cut to the scrums as they happen. So thank
00:33:44 you so much for tuning in. We really appreciate everyone for watching. We are going to head on
00:33:50 over to the debate. We'll cut the camera over to the live stream of the debate in Edmonton. And
00:33:56 then we will be back uh in two hours time so enjoy the debate and uh thanks thanks everyone
00:34:03 for joining us thank you to harley and harrison thanks to the behind the scene team uh true north
00:34:07 for throwing this event together we appreciate that and yeah let's have a good debate here we go
00:34:26 .
00:34:49 ...during the debate so that we can get through a very busy agenda.
00:34:54 In the debate rules, we were very clear that there were to be no signs or noisemakers and this is the one rule
00:35:01 We really plan to enforce so if anybody disrupts the room you will be removed
00:35:06 So please no clapping booing cheering or jeering. Let's have a great evening tonight
00:35:12 It is now time to introduce our moderator
00:35:15 For the last seven years he's been the chair of global public affairs
00:35:19 but for 45 years he was a fixture in the living rooms of Canada as one of this
00:35:24 country's most distinguished journalists. He's interviewed every Prime Minister
00:35:28 since John Diefenbaker. Please welcome Mr. Tom Clarke.
00:35:35 Thanks very much, Rick and Diane, and good evening, Edmonton.
00:35:47 How are you?
00:35:49 Terrific.
00:35:52 And in fact, good evening, Canada, because this event is being broadcast live right across the country by CBC and by CTV,
00:36:01 so this is for everybody.
00:36:05 I want to thank all of you to start off with and, of course, the organizing committee for
00:36:11 inviting me to participate in what is going to be a very important evening.
00:36:16 And frankly, I don't know who was more courageous, them or me, but anyway, here we are.
00:36:23 This is going to be a very big night for conservatives, obviously, for all of you in the room and conservatives
00:36:28 across the country because you will have the opportunity to listen, to assess, and ultimately
00:36:34 to judge who among these six candidates is the best one to lead the party into the future.
00:36:41 I would also say that this is a very big night for Canadians everywhere in Canada, regardless
00:36:47 of political stripe or affiliation, because good, healthy, informed, and yes, passionate
00:36:55 debate is the very lifeblood of a good healthy democracy and therefore everybody has a real
00:37:11 stake in what happens on this stage tonight so a couple of quick notes before we begin I want to
00:37:19 back up what Rick and Diane said as they say in the theater business please remain seated for the
00:37:24 entire performance no clapping no booing nothing nothing nothing you know the
00:37:31 consequences of what will happen if you do but honestly tonight let's just leave
00:37:36 the stage to these six people I think that's the right way to go I'm gonna be
00:37:41 calling a pretty tight game tonight there is going to be no mushiness on
00:37:50 time we're going to keep to a tight schedule and also I'm going to be
00:37:57 expecting some pretty clear answers to some pretty clear questions and I hope
00:38:03 you are expecting the same final quick note there are five distinct parts of
00:38:13 this debate and as we begin each part I will be reminding the candidates of what
00:38:21 the rules are what the format is and what the timing is and through them
00:38:24 you'll be hearing the same thing so you'll know at the beginning of each
00:38:28 segment exactly where we're gonna go and what we're going to be doing buckle up
00:38:34 everybody now please welcome your candidates for the leadership of the
00:38:41 Conservative Party of Canada.
00:39:11 Good evening, candidates. Everybody well? I do believe this is my problem.
00:39:25 I'll be right with you. There we go. Thank you so much. Okay. So, good evening. To remind you of what we are going to do right off the top, as you know, we gave you, in a sense, a little assignment before you came here.
00:39:38 You've been working on this, no doubt diligently, for a couple of days now.
00:39:42 But what we asked you to do was to finish this sentence.
00:39:47 My vision for Canada is...
00:39:51 You will have 45 seconds in which to tell us what your vision is.
00:39:56 But there's a twist, and you know it.
00:40:00 You can't mention any other candidate on the stage, and you can't mention any other federal leader.
00:40:05 If you do, there's going to be trouble, and here's what you're going to hear.
00:40:08 Now, I will then, after you've done your segment, I will engage you.
00:40:19 You have 30 seconds to engage with me, and then we'll move on.
00:40:23 The draw has been done, and we are going to start this debate with Mr. Scott Acheson.
00:40:30 Mr. Acheson, the floor is yours.
00:40:32 Thank you very much.
00:40:33 My vision for Canada is to renew the promise that the next generation will be better off than today's.
00:40:39 High grocery bills, a housing crisis, inflation, all make life harder.
00:40:44 Millions of Canadians are struggling to make ends meet, and a Liberal government does little more than make inflation worse.
00:40:51 Divisive rhetoric leaves millions of Canadians feeling frustrated and even demonized by their own government.
00:40:57 own government. The answer to today's challenge is not to fan the flames of
00:41:01 those frustrations and make Canadians more angry. Those politics of division
00:41:05 have left you behind. You deserve leaders who care more about your success than
00:41:11 our own. I seek to lead the Conservative Party and our team to form a government
00:41:15 that delivers more than just photo ops but real solutions to the challenges we
00:41:20 face. We will build that future together.
00:41:23 Thanks very much.
00:41:24 Quick question to you.
00:41:25 You were saying you want to take the politics of division
00:41:29 out of the equation.
00:41:30 How do you do that?
00:41:32 I repeat the question, please.
00:41:33 How do you take the politics of division
00:41:35 out of the equation?
00:41:37 It's the divisive rhetoric that we need to take
00:41:39 out of this, out of our discourse.
00:41:43 And all parties are guilty of it.
00:41:45 I'll give you the most obvious example,
00:41:46 and I'm gonna use the name of another party leader now
00:41:49 because I think I'm allowed to.
00:41:50 But if you look at the way the prime minister
00:41:51 used vaccine mandates and actually divided Canadians by demonizing one group over another.
00:41:57 You know the rules.
00:41:58 You just broke them.
00:41:59 We're moving on.
00:42:00 Okay.
00:42:01 All right.
00:42:02 Roman Baber, your vision of Canada is.
00:42:06 Thank you.
00:42:07 My name is Roman Baber.
00:42:09 My vision for Canada is a return to be an incredible democracy, that we don't censor
00:42:14 people or speech, that we end 21st century segregation and let people make their own
00:42:19 medical decisions.
00:42:20 that we restore Canadian kindness and respect diversity of opinion my vision
00:42:25 for Canada is that we unleash our economic opportunity by making us a
00:42:29 natural resources superpower my vision for Canada is that we let Canadians work
00:42:35 love their families and that government finally leave us alone thank you
00:42:44 quick question and we're gonna get into this into the debate but mr. baby you
00:42:48 want to turn us you want Canada to become an energy superpower in the
00:42:52 world in 30 seconds tell me how do you do that yeah so I think that our natural
00:42:57 resources are a blessing and I'm not gonna let oil and gas be cancelled and
00:43:01 it's good for a strategic interest for economic bottom line and it's also good
00:43:05 for our planet because Canadians can derive and clean clean and safe energy
00:43:10 better than any other nation in the world we need to work with our provinces
00:43:14 we can restore the right balance, but that is the way out of the economic mess that we're in.
00:43:22 I'm going to turn Canada into a natural resources superpower.
00:43:30 Patrick Brown.
00:43:31 Sorry, Patrick Brown. My vision of Canada is...
00:43:35 My vision of Canada includes a Conservative Party that builds a broad, multi-faith, multicultural coalition that can win.
00:43:41 We've lost three elections in a row and we've forgotten how to win in areas like
00:43:46 suburban Canada in the GTA where I get elected. We'll never win with a divisive
00:43:51 leader who repels voters and doubles down in discriminatory policies that
00:43:55 trample over the religious freedoms of Canadians. The choice before the party is
00:44:00 clear. Do we want an unelectable party leader who drives voters away, walks
00:44:05 straight into liberal traps giving unclear answers on divisive issues like
00:44:09 abortion and wedges conservatives against each other are we ready to win
00:44:14 I'm Mayor Patrick Brown and I'm ready to win and we need your help now I just
00:44:23 want to remind the audience you're you're all crossing a red line here so
00:44:27 you want to be careful I just let me pick up Patrick you're talking about
00:44:32 like mr. Acheson did the politics of division you skated pretty close to
00:44:37 mentioning the name of somebody on here which you know was against the rules so
00:44:41 that's fine but how do you how do you take suburban Canada and make it
00:44:50 conservative blue with the background that you've been talking about and the
00:44:55 failures in the past we know I look at suburban candidates a mosaic of the
00:45:00 country and I truly believe and I've shown you can convince you convince
00:45:05 residents who have traditionally voted for other parties that their values
00:45:08 are our values, conservative values. I've seen that in Brampton, I've seen that
00:45:12 across the GTA, so it's really about building those relationships and telling
00:45:16 our story that we're the party that will fight to make sure we don't spend
00:45:21 beyond our means, balance budgets, and fight for every Canadian. And that's key.
00:45:25 We need to send a message we'll fight for every Canadian no matter their walk
00:45:29 of life. Thank you very much. Mr. Polyev, your vision of Canada is?
00:45:37 Is one where you, the citizens, are masters and your government is servant. It is one where people
00:45:44 have the freedom to take back control of their lives. That means freedom from inflation so that
00:45:49 hardworking single mothers can afford nutritious food for their kids. Freedom from inflation so 1.00
00:45:56 that 32 year olds don't have to live in their parents basements that they can
00:45:59 actually afford their own homes freedom from inflation and carbon taxes that
00:46:05 have made it in unaffordable for working people to fill their trucks with gas the
00:46:10 freedom to speak without fear and censorship and the freedom to make your
00:46:14 own medical decisions in other words the freedom to be master of your own destiny
00:46:19 and a captain of your own life.
00:46:21 Thank you.
00:46:28 Folks, here's the deal.
00:46:30 Supporters of any candidate,
00:46:32 the time that you cheer
00:46:33 is going to be taken away from your candidate.
00:46:35 Just so you know, that's the way the deal works here.
00:46:37 Mr. Polyev,
00:46:38 you talked about inflation
00:46:41 and freedom from inflation.
00:46:43 How many years is it going to take you
00:46:44 to bring inflation down to what?
00:46:46 1% or 0%?
00:46:47 Well, it's hard to say how high it will be when I take office, but there's no question that we have to hold those accountable who have caused it.
00:46:56 You know, money printing government deficits have caused more dollars chasing fewer goods driving higher prices,
00:47:03 and the Bank of Canada governor has allowed himself to become the ATM machine of this government.
00:47:08 And so I would replace him with a new governor who would reinstate our low inflation mandate, protect the purchasing power of our dollar, and honor the working people who earn those dollars.
00:47:25 Okay. I have a feeling we'll be getting back to the point you made in a minute.
00:47:30 Dr. Leslyn Lewis, your vision.
00:47:32 My vision for Canada is to once again make Canada a beacon of hope and opportunity for
00:47:39 all.
00:47:40 A nation where we respect our charter and where our government never has the opportunity
00:47:46 to freeze our bank accounts without a court order.
00:47:50 National unity is at an all-time low.
00:47:53 Many people have been traumatized by COVID lockdowns and government mandates.
00:47:57 I'm running to be a bridge builder, to unite the party, and to unite the country.
00:48:03 Business owners will have the confidence to take chances again.
00:48:07 We will develop our natural resources while protecting the environment without a carbon
00:48:12 tax.
00:48:13 We will respect freedoms and uphold our charter of rights.
00:48:17 I'm running to make Canada one of the freest and most prosperous countries in the world.
00:48:23 Dr. Lewis, you're out of time.
00:48:25 Let me quickly pick up on one thing that you said.
00:48:27 said that we have never been so divided or national unity has never been so challenged
00:48:33 what are you basing that on if you look at the last two years we have seen families torn apart
00:48:41 by covid we see parents not talking to children we've seen a government that has pitted canadians
00:48:48 against each other there are millions of people who cannot travel in their own country people who
00:48:54 are unemployed the government has used covid to divide canadians and it's time for us to heal
00:49:04 uh folks i've really got to i don't i don't want to stop the debate but we will
00:49:10 if necessary you've been asked a number of times now please don't do that
00:49:15 so i'm asking you once again please don't do that or your candidate will get penalized
00:49:19 Finally, Jean Charest, your vision of Canada is?
00:49:24 Well, thank you, thank you very much.
00:49:26 And first, let me say how delighted I am to be here in Edmonton, Alberta, and to join
00:49:31 with my fellow candidates on this stage.
00:49:34 You're asking the fundamental question of this leadership campaign, and the reason I'm
00:49:38 running is because I see a country that is deeply divided.
00:49:43 And I am running because I believe that national unity is the number one challenge of any prime
00:49:51 minister in this country.
00:49:52 That nothing big, nothing of substance gets done unless we're able to bridge the country
00:49:59 between the east and the west.
00:50:02 And that's what I've done all my life.
00:50:03 It's what I've fought for.
00:50:05 And that's what the Conservative Party needs to be about in the next election campaign
00:50:09 to offer that national vision.
00:50:10 Let me just pick up on one thing that you said. You're talking about East and West.
00:50:15 You know, in the battles gone by, it was always Quebec and is Quebec in or is Quebec out.
00:50:20 How much of the East is about Quebec and that national unity piece is about Quebec?
00:50:25 It isn't just about one province. It can never be about just one province.
00:50:29 It's about the whole country, Tom.
00:50:32 And, you know, on issues like energy, for example, whether it's oil, gas, or pipelines, or mining,
00:50:38 We, as a country, need a national leader who is going to stand up for the resource industry.
00:50:43 When have we ever heard the Prime Minister say,
00:50:47 I believe in this project, I think it should happen?
00:50:50 And yes, please, I'm delighted to name them if you want me.
00:50:53 You heard that.
00:50:55 I did.
00:50:56 You broke the rules.
00:50:57 Well, and I did it deliberately. Thank you.
00:51:00 We're moving on to the second section of the debate now,
00:51:03 and let me just quickly remind the candidates of what this is all about.
00:51:07 we are asking you a series of rapid-fire questions on a number of policy issues
00:51:12 and we're looking for a yes or no the question will be very clear there will
00:51:16 be no doubt about the yes or no answer but there's also 15 seconds right away
00:51:20 for you to expand a little bit or qualify your yes or no if you wish you
00:51:25 don't have to but you can if you want to once everybody is answered I will choose
00:51:29 two of the candidates who perhaps have opposing views and query it a little bit
00:51:34 more and let you talk a little bit uh and uh we will be moving on the draw has been done for this
00:51:40 as well uh and i'm just looking for how much time you've got here uh 15 seconds then 30 seconds when
00:51:47 we come back when i pull the two people out okay rapid fire question here we go and we're starting
00:51:53 with dr lewis and then we'll work down the line from there dr lewis the war in ukraine as we all
00:52:00 know has been an unspeakable tragedy and it continues as we speak tonight carnage and
00:52:07 destruction are unimaginable do you support creating a no-fly zone over ukraine
00:52:14 the attack on ukraine should be taken seriously we have to ensure that we do not exacerbate
00:52:25 the tensions that are already there.
00:52:27 Is that a no?
00:52:29 Oh, that's right. No.
00:52:31 No. Thank you very much. Moving on.
00:52:33 Mr. Baber.
00:52:34 No. You know, my mother's family is from Ukraine.
00:52:37 I'm heartbroken. We're witnessing a catastrophic loss of life 1.00
00:52:39 and infrastructure. There needs to be
00:52:41 a greater effort to end the conflict.
00:52:43 Escalation will not get us out of it.
00:52:45 The only way to end it is to bring
00:52:47 the sides to a ceasefire.
00:52:50 Mr. Charest.
00:52:51 We could only do that if our NATO
00:52:53 allies agreed. Canada can't do that alone. We all admit that. What we need to do in Ukraine is three
00:52:59 things. Lethal weapons for Ukraine. That's what they need and that's what Canada should do more 1.00
00:53:04 of. More aid and bringing Ukrainians who want to come to Canada here in this country so that they're
00:53:10 secure. I'm not sure whether that was a yes or a no. It's a no. Our allies are not there Tom. We
00:53:15 can't do it. Mr. Aitchison. No and I'll build on what Mr. Sherey said. Part of the problem of course
00:53:20 says that we've never met the two percent of her GDP in terms of military funding to meet our
00:53:24 commitments to NATO. Canada is not a reliable partner in the world and we need to do a lot
00:53:28 better than we are. Mr. Brown. Yes, I believe Canada should push and actively advocate and be
00:53:37 part of it to show that NATO is serious about these encroachments. We need to stand steadfast
00:53:43 with our allies in Ukraine?
00:53:46 Mr. Polyev. 0.90
00:53:47 No, but I believe we should provide more lethal weapons 1.00
00:53:50 to our Ukrainian allies 0.98
00:53:52 and offer refuge to Ukrainians who are fleeing.
00:53:57 We also need to unleash Canadian energy production
00:53:59 so that we can help break European dependence on Putin.
00:54:03 Okay, thank you very much.
00:54:05 I'm just going to go with Patrick Brown and Mr. Polyev on this
00:54:08 because you have opposing views.
00:54:09 Mr. Brown, you said that we should encourage
00:54:11 and participate in a no-fly zone over Ukraine you Mr. Polyev say no so Mr.
00:54:16 Brown let me ask you about the concerns that people have about escalating a war
00:54:21 by doing such a thing as a no-fly zone which would require offensive fire
00:54:25 against for example radar stations and installations I certainly don't believe
00:54:30 we should abandon our allies and you know the pleas from Ukraine need more
00:54:35 than promises and best wishes. 0.99
00:54:39 We are seeing an encroachment in Europe 0.92
00:54:43 that has not been seen in the modern era, 0.99
00:54:46 and we need to make sure they know
00:54:49 that Canada stands with them
00:54:50 more than our wishes and photo ops
00:54:54 with the prime minister showing up in Ukraine.
00:54:56 We need to give them all the support they've asked for,
00:54:58 which includes, and that's the request from Ukraine.
00:55:00 and mr polyev if i could just play off of that you say no and yet it's the very thing that the
00:55:08 ukrainian government has asked for over and over again the no-fly zone right that the reason is
00:55:14 that if we bring in a no-fly zone it could very quickly escalate to canada being in a war with
00:55:18 russia and i'm not standing on the stage today promising to declare that war i'm making the
00:55:24 responsible position that will provide the material support necessary uh that we can as
00:55:30 Canadians, both to the population and to those fighting against Russians, but also do what
00:55:35 we can strategically to provide Europe with an alternative source of energy so that the
00:55:39 Europeans no longer have to fund Russia's war with the machine by buying all it is oil
00:55:45 and gas.
00:55:46 Thank you very much, both of you.
00:55:48 Next question, Mr. Baber, it goes to you.
00:55:51 Way back in the 1970s, you may not be able to remember that, but nevertheless, ancient history, but Pierre Truro brought in supply management, basically a state-run system to manage dairy and poultry industries in this country, setting huge tariffs for foreign products and in the process, inflating prices here at home.
00:56:13 Do you support the current supply management system? Yes or no?
00:56:17 No, there is no free country when you have centrally planned economy.
00:56:21 Instead of protecting supply management and central political planning,
00:56:25 we should not cap how much dairy Canadians may produce.
00:56:29 It's utter nonsense. I oppose supply management.
00:56:33 Mr. Charest.
00:56:35 I fully support supply management. I always have.
00:56:39 And in this era of supply chains that are disrupted,
00:56:44 This is, in fact, a policy that guarantees us access to food that we need.
00:56:50 So I unequivocally support supply management.
00:56:54 No, I don't.
00:56:55 In fact, supply management costs the average Canadian family about $600 a year.
00:56:59 I think it's important in an affordability crisis that we actually help Canadians make food cheaper to eat.
00:57:04 That's the problem with supply management.
00:57:06 It's costing too much for Canadians.
00:57:08 Thank you. Mr. Brown.
00:57:10 Yes, the party has a history of supporting supply management.
00:57:14 But I think it's fair in this affordability crisis to have a broader consultation with our membership.
00:57:20 Mr. Polyev.
00:57:22 I do support supply management.
00:57:24 The alternative would be to buy out the quota, and that would cost $10, $20, $30 billion,
00:57:30 and that would have to be done through a tax on consumers, which could be more expensive than the alternative.
00:57:35 We should lower food costs by getting rid of the carbon tax and other taxes that are driving up the cost of food.
00:57:41 Mr. Aitchison and, oh, I'm sorry, Dr. Lewis, my apologies.
00:57:46 Supply management.
00:57:47 I do support supply management.
00:57:49 Our dairy and egg producers give us superior products. 0.89
00:57:54 Without supply management, our industry would be overrun by U.S. producers.
00:58:00 I prefer to have a superior product that we'll pay a little bit more for,
00:58:05 and if we want to bring down the price, cut the carbon tax.
00:58:07 Okay. I'm going to ask Mr. Baber and you, Dr. Lewis, because you hold opposing views on this.
00:58:14 Mr. Baber, why don't you tell Dr. Lewis exactly why it is that we should not have supply management
00:58:19 and perhaps, as the critics of your position would say, put those industries into jeopardy.
00:58:26 So one of the themes today is cost of living.
00:58:30 At a time when cost of living is so high, visit a grocery store, life is becoming unaffordable.
00:58:36 Why not to increase more supply instead of telling farmers how much milk they can produce?
00:58:41 We should encourage the creation of more goods, especially if we're worried about inflation.
00:58:46 But I support a gradual phasing out of supply management because, yes, we do have quotas and we have concessions that people bought.
00:58:53 We have to provide them with some ease down, but we should not cap how much Canadians can produce.
00:58:58 Okay. And Dr. Lewis, critics of your position might say, what is a conservative doing supporting the policies of Pierre Trudeau on a state-imposed mechanism?
00:59:09 Well, from a free market perspective, supply management, of course, is not a free market ideology.
00:59:18 However, we have to ensure that we support our farmers and we have to ensure that Canadians get the best product on their table.
00:59:27 If we want to cut costs, we can cut the carbon tax, and that is what is bringing up the cost of food for Canadians.
00:59:35 Thank you very much, both of you.
00:59:37 Mr. Charest, you get the first swing at this next question.
00:59:42 As we've seen in the United States in the last couple of weeks, there are no laws around abortion.
00:59:48 Abortion is only allowed by the Supreme Court decision known as Roe v. Wade,
00:59:53 and courts, as we are seeing, can change their minds.
00:59:58 In Canada, we don't have any laws either on this.
01:00:00 We depend on the Morgenthaler case,
01:00:03 which essentially decided that it was not illegal.
01:00:06 So the question is this.
01:00:08 Would you support legislation around abortion?
01:00:12 I am pro-choice, and my government would not bring in legislation
01:00:16 or support legislation to change or to restrain the rights of women.
01:00:21 the situation we have now is what we should maintain and that is a very clear
01:00:26 I mean they're all candidates except one on this stage okay has stated their
01:00:30 position on I got mr. Richardson I will always defend a woman's right to her
01:00:37 personal reproductive health choices period always thank you sir mr. Brown I'm
01:00:45 pro-choice I support a woman's right to choose and any government that I lead
01:00:48 would not revisit this issue. Mr. Polyev? A Polyev government would not introduce or pass
01:00:56 legislation restricting abortion. Dr. Lewis? I am pro-life and 0.94
01:01:05 women in Canada can have an abortion up until nine months and so there is no restriction on abortion.
01:01:15 What we need to do is have conversations about what we believe in, what we agree on.
01:01:20 Mr. Beiberg.
01:01:21 I don't believe that government has a role in how people start and grow their families.
01:01:25 If it's conservatives who want to stay out of people's lives, then we should stay out of the most intimate areas of their lives.
01:01:30 But that doesn't mean that we don't respect parliamentary democracy, that we gag our MPs, that we don't allow people to contest nomination.
01:01:36 I'm wondering how all my friends feel about others in caucus who have different views.
01:01:40 we're okay let's just further explore this a little bit mr shere i want to start with you
01:01:47 and mr aitchison i want to bring you into the conversation as well i you say you know everybody
01:01:52 interpreted the question of a law around abortion as restricting it what if it was a law enshrining
01:01:59 it well it's it's not what's anticipated i mean it's clearly not the case but on this issue let's
01:02:06 can we be clear on one thing every candidate in this race needs to tell the women of canada where
01:02:12 they stand whether they're pro or against they the women of canada deserve to know where they
01:02:17 stand and mr poliev's answer quite frankly does not fit that test okay
01:02:26 uh we will be taking 10 seconds away from mr poliev but mr aitchison get in
01:02:30 I think it's important for us to always be respectful of each other. There are really
01:02:42 strong views and deeply held beliefs on this issue, and this is one of the problems that
01:02:46 I see in our party today. We've become factions, and we don't listen to each other and respect
01:02:53 each other as we debate ideas and differing opinions. The Canadians will never trust us,
01:02:58 And so this to me is about respect, and really I don't see a lot of that, unfortunately,
01:03:03 on this issue.
01:03:04 Right.
01:03:05 Thank you very much.
01:03:06 Next question, Mr. Acheson, we're going to start with you.
01:03:10 Last year, Canada took in more immigrants than at any other time in our history, doubling
01:03:15 the usual number of about 200,000, 250,000, and we're planning to increase that number
01:03:21 even more.
01:03:22 So looking at the latest numbers of around just over 400,000, is 400,000 or a little
01:03:29 bit more the right number to be bringing in every year into Canada?
01:03:33 Well this much I know we need more Canadians, we need more workers, we need more skilled
01:03:37 workers in our economy.
01:03:38 It's one of the reasons we have a housing shortage in this country.
01:03:42 We need 200,000 skilled tradespeople in this country today.
01:03:45 So we need more workers whether 400,000 is the number or not, it should be targeted though.
01:03:51 Mr. Brown.
01:03:52 No, it's not enough. We're not meeting our skilled labor shortage, not even close.
01:03:56 And the backlog right now under Justin Trudeau, under the current Prime Minister, is the largest it's been in Canadian history.
01:04:02 He's not properly resourcing our immigration department. It's been an abysmal failure.
01:04:07 Mr. Polyev. 1.00
01:04:10 We need the workforce, frankly, but when we bring immigrants here, we need to make sure they have the freedom to own a home
01:04:16 by getting rid of the gatekeepers that prevent housing construction and the freedom to work in their field
01:04:21 by getting rid of the gatekeepers that prevent them from getting licenses in their professions
01:04:24 and trades. So I will get rid of those gatekeepers and give them that opportunity.
01:04:28 Dr. Lewis.
01:04:29 The issue is not about quantity. It's about quality. We need to make sure that we bring
01:04:35 immigrants here who can contribute to our society. I came here when I was five years
01:04:41 old, and we need a compassionate immigration system that will have jobs for people.
01:04:46 All right. Thank you. Mr. Babe.
01:04:47 I'm an immigrant to Canada, and I had every blessing our country has to offer.
01:04:52 And I think that Canada's multiculturalism is beautiful.
01:04:55 We have an aging demographic, a shrinking labor force.
01:04:59 We need to encourage lawful immigration. 0.99
01:05:01 Democracy and opportunity is why immigrants come to Canada.
01:05:04 Those are conservative values. 1.00
01:05:05 Thank you.
01:05:06 Mr. Chouret.
01:05:07 400,000 may be within the right zone, but it is very much dependent on our ability to
01:05:12 integrate people.
01:05:13 And how do we integrate?
01:05:15 We integrate through a job.
01:05:16 We integrate through language.
01:05:18 We integrate by allowing people to integrate into communities.
01:05:22 And credentials is one of the key elements to integrate Canadians.
01:05:27 Let's pick that up.
01:05:28 Mr. Brown, I want to just explore a little bit more of your thinking.
01:05:33 400,000, 405,000, it's a record number for this country.
01:05:36 But should it be 500,000, 600,000?
01:05:39 We know that we've got a labour shortage.
01:05:41 What's the right number?
01:05:42 You know, I was speaking to a friend of mine, Joseph Mancinelli, who's the head of
01:05:45 Leona Canada and he told me today just today they're short 30,000 workers and
01:05:51 these are in the skilled trades great jobs good paying jobs and you could
01:05:56 change the education system but that takes you know 10 years to in terms of 0.98
01:06:00 creating a new stream of workers in the skilled trades we need that immigration
01:06:03 we need that talent right now there are jobs that they can't build houses we
01:06:07 can't build bridges we can't build because of the lack of labor we need to 0.52
01:06:11 unleashed the Canadian economic potential through immigration. 1.00
01:06:14 Thank you very much. We're going to move on to the next question now.
01:06:21 And Mr. Brown, this goes to you actually. In 2014 at a NATO summit in Wales, the Canadian
01:06:29 government led then by then Prime Minister Stephen Harper, agreed, promised to spend 2% of our GDP
01:06:37 on national defense since then as you know we haven't even come close with war on europe's
01:06:43 doorstep right now and with our vast northern regions now vulnerable would you meet the pledge
01:06:50 of two percent that is our nato commitment yes absolutely frankly we're not taken seriously on
01:06:57 a world stage and we can't even meet the the obligations that we've committed to and it's
01:07:02 It's not just about a peacekeeping role abroad.
01:07:05 It's about our own sovereignty, the Arctic, and so 100%.
01:07:08 Mr. Poglio.
01:07:10 We need to work towards hitting that goal, and we need also to make sure the money we
01:07:14 spent gets results.
01:07:15 Right now, too much of the procurement of equipment is tied up in politics and political
01:07:20 favoritism.
01:07:21 That's why billions of dollars have wasted, and products are not delivered to the front
01:07:25 line for our soldiers, sailors, and airmen.
01:07:27 So not only will we increase it, we will spend it well.
01:07:30 Dr. Lewis.
01:07:31 Unfortunately, we have not invested enough in our military.
01:07:34 Yes, I would commit to meeting that 2%.
01:07:37 Right now, we are underfunded, and that is one of the reasons why we have not been able
01:07:41 to supply the needs that Ukraine could use to assist them.
01:07:46 Mr. Baber.
01:07:47 Yes, we need to increase our defense spending by 50% in order to meet our NATO commitment.
01:07:53 If we're going to ask men and women in uniform to risk their lives, then they must have the
01:07:57 best equipment and the best training. 0.71
01:07:59 But I believe that our defense policy should be limited to safeguarding our country and
01:08:02 meeting our treaty commitments.
01:08:04 Thanks very much.
01:08:05 Mr. Charest.
01:08:06 Well, the answer is yes.
01:08:07 This is an issue of sovereignty for Canada.
01:08:09 And I put out a defense policy that's very detailed.
01:08:12 One thing that I think we need to do urgently is assume our sovereignty in the Arctic.
01:08:17 And I would open two bases in the Arctic, one with a deep sea water port to defend our
01:08:23 sovereignty against Russia in particular.
01:08:25 Okay.
01:08:26 Mr. Aitchison.
01:08:27 Yes.
01:08:28 The sad reality of this is that our military procurement system has become a joke in the world, and we waste money, and we don't have the right equipment for our men and women in service, and our partners, our allies, are making new alliances without us because we're not a reliable partner.
01:08:44 Mr. Polyev, I just want to dig a little bit deeper into your answer.
01:08:48 You said that we should work towards it, so not necessarily meeting it.
01:08:53 But as you know, this is one of the main irritants in Canada-U.S. relations, regardless of the administration.
01:08:59 When you say work towards it, have you got a time frame in mind as to when we get to 2%?
01:09:05 Look, it will take a progressive move because it's roughly an extra $14 or $15 billion a year.
01:09:11 If you up the budget in one year, well, then you're going to have a bunch of bureaucrats at the Defense Department trying to shovel the cash out the door without getting proper results.
01:09:20 In fact, they can't spend the budgets they have right now and get results.
01:09:24 So I will increase it as fast as we possibly can within the confines of our accosted budget and towards putting those dollars into getting results for our soldiers, sailors, and airmen.
01:09:36 Thank you very much.
01:09:37 And Mr. Baber, I want to come back to you on this because you have a slightly different view as to what we should be doing.
01:09:45 Yeah, I think that Canada's credibility in the world is eroded right now because some countries don't believe we're an actual democracy anymore.
01:09:53 And so we need to focus on resolving our issues at home while increasing our NATO commitment, to meet our NATO commitment, and that's about 50%.
01:10:01 But we should not go beyond our treaty commitments at this point.
01:10:05 I appreciate the role that Canada played traditionally in peacekeeping, but now it's time for other countries to step up and take the lead.
01:10:12 God knows we have enough problems at home at this moment.
01:10:15 Thank you all very much.
01:10:17 We're going to go to the final question now.
01:10:18 It's Mr. Polyev.
01:10:20 Mr. Polyev, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission presented its final report in 2015.
01:10:25 That is seven years ago, and it contained 94 recommendations.
01:10:29 would you make
01:10:31 a commitment to
01:10:33 implementing all 94 recommendations
01:10:35 I can't make the commitment to
01:10:37 100% of the recommendations but what I
01:10:39 can is to address the structural
01:10:41 unfairness that leads to the injustice
01:10:43 and that is fundamentally in the Indian Act 1.00
01:10:45 we have to give First Nations communities control
01:10:47 of their money, their land 1.00
01:10:49 and their resources
01:10:51 that is the only way that they will be able to have
01:10:53 prosperity and paychecks for their people
01:10:55 Dr. Lewis
01:10:57 We need to make sure that First Nations people are at the table where the decisions are being
01:11:03 making. And we also need to make sure that we keep our promises. We have been promising
01:11:08 year after year clean water on reserves, and we have not delivered. If we cannot deliver on
01:11:14 simple promises. We have to be honest and learn our history so we don't repeat it.
01:11:19 But dividing Canadians is actually hurting reconciliation. The best thing we can do
01:11:25 for reconciliation is to improve the lives of Indigenous peoples.
01:11:30 Thank you.
01:11:30 And Mr. Chiraj, just in case people forgot, the question is,
01:11:33 would you commit to the 94 recommendations in the Truth and Reconciliation Report?
01:11:36 Well, the 94 recommendations, you can't commit to all of them.
01:11:40 But, Tom, Indigenous Canadians deserve respect
01:11:44 and a lot better than virtue signaling and false promises.
01:11:47 They should be part of our resource economy. 0.91
01:11:49 They should own equity.
01:11:51 And I would put together a Crown Corporation that would allow them to own equity.
01:11:54 Okay. Dr. Lewis, I just want to come back to you because I didn't hear whether you
01:12:02 were going to support all 94 recommendations, but can you tell me if you're not going to
01:12:07 support all 94 recommendations? Oh, I didn't know you were here. I'm terribly sorry. I'm terribly
01:12:16 No, he's going to take time away from me! Stop, stop, stop!
01:12:23 Mr. Atchison, my apologies, please.
01:12:28 My answer is yes, I would, but I would also make sure we eliminate all boil water advisors.
01:12:33 I would expedite the installation of broadband internet.
01:12:36 And my approach to reconciliation is a journey,
01:12:39 but it will be about fewer conferences in Ottawa and more action on the ground.
01:12:44 Thank you very much. Mr. Brown.
01:12:47 Yes, having a strong collaborative relationship with indigenous communities will be essential if we are committed to building pipelines in this country.
01:12:55 We need to have that strong collaboration. We need to get pipelines built. We need to create prosperity in indigenous communities and across the country.
01:13:03 Okay, and I just want to bring you and Dr. Lewis in because there was just one thing I didn't quite understand.
01:13:09 Would you, Dr. Lewis, implement all 94 recommendations?
01:13:12 I will implement any recommendation that uplifts the lives of Indigenous people.
01:13:19 We have let them down. 0.98
01:13:21 Even our missing and murdered Aboriginal women, we have not committed to even dealing with that issue,
01:13:27 which is a fundamental issue that affects the core of the society on reserves. 0.64
01:13:34 Okay.
01:13:34 Mr. Brown, if we don't implement all 94, what ones would we not implement if the 94 choose
01:13:43 one that you would not implement?
01:13:44 Well, my answer was that I would support the recommendations.
01:13:47 So I said yes, and I believe it's integral for us to have that strong collaboration if
01:13:53 we're going to have the joint prosperity through the construction of a national energy corridor
01:13:57 and pipelines. 1.00
01:13:58 I just don't see how you can build partnerships with indigenous communities to get pipelines
01:14:02 built if you ignore the recommendations that are so important to indigenous
01:14:06 communities across the country thank you all very much on that that ends this
01:14:11 section of the spontaneous yes or no answers we are now moving towards the
01:14:17 lightning what we call the lightning round now let me explain you you have
01:14:21 been informed of this I believe it or not there are Canadians who don't know
01:14:27 you guys and Dr. Lewis yet. So this is a chance just to get to know a little bit
01:14:32 about who you are and character and likes, dislikes and that sort of thing.
01:14:38 I'm gonna ask everybody the same question. We're just gonna go down the
01:14:41 line. Everybody gets a chance. It's a very fast answer. You'll see that these
01:14:47 things are, you know, you got 15 seconds to answer this and we're gonna be
01:14:51 starting with Mr. Charest. And Mr. Charest, the very first question I have for you is
01:14:56 what book are you reading now? What book are you reading now? Oh, I was reading the most recent
01:15:04 book that I've been reading has been about Russia, and I forget the title right now, but it's been
01:15:09 about Russia. Very good. Mr. Aitchison. I'm actually reading a book that Dennis Mills,
01:15:16 former member of Parliament for Toronto Danforth, gave me on water. Do you remember the title?
01:15:21 called water oh it's called water okay you would like to know what it's about
01:15:25 okay it's about water yeah I get it it's about the future of water and the
01:15:31 importance of water and geopolitical issues anyhow mr. Brown what are you
01:15:37 reading these days let's say on the leadership campaigns be honest there's
01:15:39 no time to be laying around reading books but historically I've loved you
01:15:43 know legal novels the John Grisham books growing up I loved Horatio Alger the
01:15:47 you know the rags-to-riches stories which is you know our Canadian dream
01:15:52 Mr. Poliev, what are you having time to read these days?
01:15:56 Well, Jordan Peterson's 12 Rules.
01:16:00 Great book and a lot of good lessons.
01:16:03 We all need to improve ourselves,
01:16:05 and I think he has a lot of good wisdom in that book that could help anybody.
01:16:10 Dr. Lewis.
01:16:11 Shackleton's Way, it's about sacrificial leadership.
01:16:14 It's about lending yourself to service for others
01:16:18 and being a leader that people can admire and aspire to.
01:16:23 Thank you. Mr. Baber.
01:16:24 It's been difficult since the leadership started,
01:16:26 but before that, a friend suggested that I read David and Goliath,
01:16:31 and that's been a theme that throughout our campaign,
01:16:35 we continue to exceed expectations.
01:16:37 Sometimes people might surprise you, and you might have an unlikely result.
01:16:42 Mr. Acheson, I wanted to ask you and give everybody a chance.
01:16:46 There's a question and there's a twist to the answer.
01:16:49 I want to know who your political hero is, and you cannot say Winston Churchill.
01:16:57 Prime Minister Diefenbaker.
01:17:01 Prime Minister Diefenbaker, he was a tremendous orator, he brought us the Bill of Rights.
01:17:05 He was an amazing Canadian who defended Canadians' freedoms and enshrined them in law.
01:17:13 Mr. Brown.
01:17:14 Absolutely.
01:17:15 former Premier Bill Davis. I felt he radiated decency. I learned more from
01:17:20 him than than anyone else. He lived only a few doors down from me in Brampton,
01:17:24 Ontario and I think his legacy is one that is enormous in our country.
01:17:30 Mr. Polyev. Well, Wilfrid Laurier. He opened up the West to immigration that
01:17:37 brought many of my ancestors here. Though he was a Catholic, he made a point of
01:17:41 reading a Protestant Bible so he could understand the other side. He said that
01:17:45 he used to pick fights with the Scottish boys and flirt with the
01:17:48 Scottish girls and managed to bring all the Canadian nations together into this
01:17:53 wonderful country we call Canada based on the principle of freedom.
01:17:56 Thank you. Dr. Lewis. Point of clarification was it did it have to be
01:18:02 Canadian? I didn't hear. Just your political hero as long as it's not Winston Churchill.
01:18:06 William Wilberforce. He spent his life fighting for the abolition of slavery, even though he never knew whether or not he would see that materialize. But he had convictions to stand up for what he believed in, and he did not matter if it sacrificed his political career.
01:18:25 Thanks very much. Mr. Baber.
01:18:27 Margaret Thatcher, we will either stand on principles or we will not stand at all.
01:18:33 She was not afraid of making difficult decisions.
01:18:35 She stood up to the radical left-wing mob.
01:18:38 This is something that I hope we're going to restore to the Conservative Party of Canada.
01:18:42 Courage to say what we believe and do what we believe is right.
01:18:45 Mr. Charest.
01:18:46 Darcy McGee, born in Ireland, went to the United States, chose to come to Canada, renounced
01:18:53 Irish nationalism and gave his life for his country because he was assassinated, one of
01:18:57 the only political assassinations in the country, by Finians. 0.53
01:19:01 Thank you all very much.
01:19:03 That was actually really interesting to hear all that.
01:19:06 Dr. Lewis, I'm going to start with you and then of course everybody else gets a chance.
01:19:11 I know you're all busy.
01:19:12 I know that you've got stuff that you're doing right now, but when you have the opportunity
01:19:17 to sit down and listen to some music, what do you listen to?
01:19:22 I would say probably jazz is my go-to, but I like to.
01:19:26 Who's your favorite jazz artist?
01:19:29 Coltrane.
01:19:32 Cool, okay.
01:19:33 Mr. Baber.
01:19:35 Amy Winehouse.
01:19:36 When I hear Amy Winehouse, I can see into her soul.
01:19:40 She speaks to issues of addiction and mental health,
01:19:43 something that people know that I'm very, very passionate
01:19:44 about, and she left us too early.
01:19:47 But yeah, Amy Winehouse, back to black. 0.73
01:19:50 Okay.
01:19:51 Mr. Charest?
01:19:52 Well, for jazz, Pat Metheny,
01:19:53 but my family and I are also great lovers
01:19:57 of Chalas Neville.
01:19:59 There we go.
01:20:00 Mr. Acheson?
01:20:02 Well, I play the piano,
01:20:03 so I love to listen to Oscar Peterson,
01:20:05 but since my assistant, Parker,
01:20:07 has been driving around with me,
01:20:08 I'm starting to listen to a little more country music,
01:20:10 so I'm learning a bit more about that.
01:20:13 Okay, Mr. Brown?
01:20:14 Well, I think I have to say Alessia Cara,
01:20:16 because I'm from Brampton,
01:20:17 and Alessia Cara is our most famous musician right now,
01:20:20 But I should also say, MIA, we're trying to get them for our candidate party.
01:20:24 A great story of overcoming adversity.
01:20:27 Terrific. And Mr. Polyev?
01:20:29 Well, pick a local hero, Paul Brandt, Alberta Brown.
01:20:33 You've got to let them applaud that, Tom. Come on.
01:20:39 Okay.
01:20:42 I'll allow the applause because it's for Paul Brandt, okay?
01:20:46 You'll have to take it off his time.
01:20:48 Yeah, I'll take it off his time, yeah.
01:20:51 Mr. Brown, I want to start with you.
01:20:55 What do you think is, and remember 15 seconds,
01:20:59 what do you think is the single biggest threat to Canada today?
01:21:06 Our financial chaos right now, we're $1.2 trillion in debt.
01:21:10 And if you allow the finances to get out of control of the country,
01:21:13 you lose all capacity to deal with the challenges in your country.
01:21:17 $1.2 trillion, $2 billion a month in interest.
01:21:21 Thank you very much.
01:21:22 Mr. Polyev.
01:21:23 Well, I would build on that.
01:21:25 It's not just the $1.2 trillion federal, but the other one-plus trillion provincial,
01:21:30 and then the other $7 trillion of private debt that is about to collide with higher interest rates.
01:21:35 The government and the central bank have set us up for a massive debt crisis,
01:21:39 and we don't have time to avoid it.
01:21:40 Thank you.
01:21:41 Dr. Lewis.
01:21:41 I think our declining democracy, people have lost trust and confidence in our democracy.
01:21:48 The invocation of the Emergency Measures Act and freezing of people's accounts without
01:21:53 a court order has led people to question our institutions such as the media and our political
01:21:59 institutions.
01:22:00 Thank you.
01:22:01 Mr. Baber.
01:22:02 100% with Dr. Lewis.
01:22:03 The erosion of our democracy is the greatest threat to Canada right now.
01:22:06 Government is passing law to censor speech.
01:22:09 of Canadians are treated like second-class citizens, state-funded media bailouts, and
01:22:14 state-funded media, an unlawful declaration of the Emergency Act, I'm going to defend
01:22:18 Canada's democracy.
01:22:20 Mr. Charest, the single greatest threat to Canada is?
01:22:22 Well, it is national unity.
01:22:25 The greatest mistake we all could make as Canadians is to take this country for granted.
01:22:29 And of all the things you've named on this stage at Colleagues, none of them can be addressed
01:22:34 unless there is a national conservative government that includes Alberta at the table.
01:22:38 That's what is the most important threat, our national unity.
01:22:41 Mr. Aitchison.
01:22:43 And I'll build on that.
01:22:44 I think the greatest threat to Canada right now is division.
01:22:47 It's our political rhetoric and a political system that's designed to divide us to win votes.
01:22:52 It's short-sighted and doesn't build a country up at all, and I think it's dividing our country.
01:22:58 Thank you all very much.
01:22:59 I want to go to a question maybe a little more lighthearted, getting to know you a little bit more.
01:23:04 and there were a lot of people who want to know this.
01:23:08 It's not just me, trust me.
01:23:11 But Mr. Baber, what was the last thing that you binge-watched on TV?
01:23:21 Married with children.
01:23:24 I was at the cottage, and, you know, that was some time ago.
01:23:29 I learned the English language watching Married with Children, with subtitles.
01:23:35 It's a great tool for new Canadians to learn English. Watch a good TV show.
01:23:40 Okay, thank you. Mr. Charest.
01:23:42 There was a French series that was absolutely fantastic because it speaks to relationships.
01:23:49 They say, Appelle mon agent, call my agent in English. It was absolutely spectacular.
01:23:54 I like that one too. Mr. Aitchison.
01:23:57 My parliamentary colleague Eric Melillo got me hooked on Brooklyn Nine-Nine while we were
01:24:02 doing French Immersion in Quebec.
01:24:06 Mr. Brown, yeah.
01:24:07 You know, normally if I have free time, I love watching hockey, no surprise there.
01:24:11 But my wife got me into Ozark and we binge-watched it and I'm told there's a new season out
01:24:16 right now and I'm too busy to watch it, so I'm in trouble with my wife.
01:24:18 I've seen the final season and I won't tell you how it ends, but you can imagine.
01:24:26 Mr. Paulyev?
01:24:27 Well, I think it was Netflix had a series on Trotsky, actually, and it helped me to
01:24:33 better understand the diabolical evil of communism and to tell her socialism, but the bright
01:24:41 side is it helped me appreciate the freedom that we have in Canada that we have to stand
01:24:44 up for and defend.
01:24:45 Thanks very much.
01:24:46 Dr. Lewis?
01:24:47 Bridgerton.
01:24:48 Bridgerton. And what I loved about that is that people, it was a different era, and people did not see race.
01:24:57 They just existed and coexisted, and it was very beautiful because I also watched it in French and also improved my French.
01:25:06 Okay, excellent. Thank you all very much. We've got one question left, and then we're going to go back to some other stuff.
01:25:12 But this is a good one, and Mr. Polyev, I'm going to throw this one to you.
01:25:15 What historical figure from any time, anywhere, would you most like to have dinner with?
01:25:24 Abraham Lincoln. I think through principle and courage, he saved the American Union and ended slavery.
01:25:33 He did so at great, obviously, ultimate personal sacrifice with his eventual assassination. 0.59
01:25:39 But he had an incredible brain that he brought, that he taught himself as an autodidact, coming from humble beginnings as a working class person.
01:25:48 Thank you very much. Dr. Lewis.
01:25:50 Nelson Mandela. He existed at a time when his country was divided, torn apart by racial hatred, and yet he fought against it.
01:26:01 He was able to overcome and bring people together.
01:26:05 Mr. Baber.
01:26:06 Ronald Reagan. He opposed one of the greatest evils of the 20th century, opposed the radical left and communism and did it with grace and with courage.
01:26:17 And we need to be resolute in the face of all those that would seek to erode our democracy. I admire him very much.
01:26:23 Thank you very much. Mr. Sheray.
01:26:25 I'm a great fan of the partnership of Sir John A. MacDonald and Georges Etienne Cartier.
01:26:30 and my son and I wrote a chapter in a book about Georges Etienne Cartier
01:26:34 who showed extraordinary resilience, promoted property rights
01:26:38 and was one of those who allowed this country to actually come to be.
01:26:42 You know, Sir John A. would probably stick you with the bill for that dinner
01:26:45 but that's another thing altogether.
01:26:47 Mr. Aitchison.
01:26:49 Mine is actually Nelson Mandela as well.
01:26:51 He's a hero.
01:26:52 How he brought South Africa together
01:26:55 and ended apartheid is nothing short of miraculous and incredible.
01:27:00 Final word to you, Mr. Brown. Dinner. 0.56
01:27:03 I'll agree with Mr. Shray.
01:27:04 Johnny MacDonald, I resent the cancel culture we're seeing on great figures who built our country,
01:27:10 and the adversity, the challenges of uniting our country, building Canada.
01:27:15 That would be a fascinating dinner.
01:27:20 Sorry, I'll figure this out by the end of the debate.
01:27:23 My microphone.
01:27:23 Thank you all very much.
01:27:24 That was fascinating.
01:27:25 I know it was a weird little journey to go on, but I think it was interesting.
01:27:29 We are now moving on to the next segment of the debate, which is called Face-Off.
01:27:35 And before we start that, I'd like to bring Em up, who is going to give you all a prop.
01:27:41 And I'll explain to everybody what this is all about.
01:27:45 So as we are handing these out, this, in a way, is the segment that you've all been waiting for
01:27:51 when the candidates can choose who they want to debate on any particular issue.
01:27:57 And here's the way it's going to work.
01:27:58 I'll introduce the topic of the debate to a candidate.
01:28:03 Not the question, just the topic.
01:28:05 And then you decide, you tell the audience
01:28:07 who you want to debate this with.
01:28:10 Once you've chosen your opponent,
01:28:12 I will then tell you what the question is.
01:28:15 There will be three rounds of the person
01:28:18 you have chosen to debate.
01:28:20 The first round, each person gets a minute each.
01:28:23 The second round, you get 45 seconds each.
01:28:26 The third round, you get 30 seconds each.
01:28:28 Now, this is where it gets interesting in why you have the prop in your hand.
01:28:32 After we've done the three rounds between the two people,
01:28:37 anybody else can answer this by simply raising your paddle.
01:28:41 And you will have a guaranteed 30 seconds to put your 30 seconds in with.
01:28:48 Here's the trick.
01:28:50 There are six questions, and you can only use your paddle five times.
01:28:54 you can use it all on one question if you want or you can use it wherever you
01:28:59 think you have the greatest advantage so there is some strategy involved here
01:29:03 and I wish you good luck with this. Now unless there are any questions we are
01:29:11 going to start and question number one Mr. Polyev the topic is law order and
01:29:18 blockades who would you like to debate patrick brown patrick brown okay here then mr polyev is
01:29:25 the question and remember you have one minute in the first round to uh say your piece we've seen
01:29:31 over the past few years blockades at our borders blockades on rail lines blockades of construction
01:29:36 blockades at logging sites and a blockade in an occupation of our capital city law enforcement
01:29:42 experts say we will likely encounter more and more of this as the years progress how do you decide
01:29:50 when a protest becomes a threat to our national security and our national economy and would you
01:29:57 outlaw any protest that disables critical infrastructure and that includes our cities
01:30:04 and that includes our cities i believe that that blocking critical infrastructure should be
01:30:09 illegal and that's why before the truckers even arrived on parliament hill i said i supported
01:30:14 their peaceful and law-abiding efforts to restore their liberties and their livelihoods while
01:30:21 condemning any individuals who broke laws blocked critical infrastructure or behaved badly that's
01:30:27 what individual responsibility actually means now i just find it interesting that you didn't
01:30:33 include in your list of threats the axe-wielding terrorists who've been attacking our pipeline
01:30:38 workers in western canada i don't know why that doesn't seem to be a trouble to you but nor or
01:30:44 the rest of the national media because you're more concerned about truckers who lost their jobs
01:30:49 because of an unfair vaccine mandate imposed on them by a prime minister who was targeting them
01:30:55 without any scientific basis than you were about holding accountable people who've actually done
01:31:01 violence and most recently just set the car the car on fire of someone who was investing in the
01:31:06 energy sector thank you mr brown you have one minute tom i don't support illegal blockades
01:31:13 whether it's at the ambassador bridge um whether it's against a pipeline i think conservatives
01:31:17 need to stand for law and order full stop and illegal blockades have a massive um cost on the
01:31:23 country you look at the cost when there was the blockade on on ambassador bridge in windsor
01:31:28 i was just visiting mayor drew dilkins in windsor just last week and he was talking about how it
01:31:33 affected their economy, Ontario's economy, Canada's economy, and I think
01:31:38 Conservatives are the party of law and order, and we can't give exceptions to
01:31:42 that. Full stop, no illegal blockades. You haven't used your full time, but if you
01:31:48 want to give it back, that's fine. We can always use it. Well, in terms of law and
01:31:52 order, I would just add that there are areas that the Conservative Party have
01:31:55 not focused on enough in Parliament. I look at bail reform. You know, I see it in
01:31:58 the GTA. There is a giant loophole in our criminal justice system, and you've got
01:32:02 Frequent flyers, literally the same people getting arrested and released again and again.
01:32:07 And there's a cost to public safety with that.
01:32:11 Mr. Polyev, you have 45 seconds.
01:32:13 Well, there is, and there's also a cost to the approach taken by Mr. Trudeau and Mr. Chiray.
01:32:18 They both believe in targeting law-abiding people who use firearms responsibly after having been vetted, licensed, and are already in possession of a license and training.
01:32:31 If Ture went after them with a long gun registry in Quebec, Trudeau wants to spend a billion dollars targeting these same people.
01:32:37 That money that Ture and Trudeau spent going after law-abiding people could have been spent reinforcing border security
01:32:45 to stop the 80% of gun crimes that actually come in through smuggling.
01:32:50 And we could also, instead of going after the lawful, target the criminals who would do the crimes with mandatory prison sentences to take them off our streets.
01:32:59 Thank you. Mr. Brown, 45.
01:33:01 you know what we do have a huge problem at our border and I get briefings almost
01:33:06 on a weekly basis by the chief of police in Peel and we've had meetings with all
01:33:11 the chiefs of police in the GTA to talk about smuggled firearms 90% of our
01:33:15 homicides last year in Peel were from firearms smuggled across the border and
01:33:21 we need a government of Canada that would take that seriously criminal
01:33:24 organizations are becoming more sophisticated than ever before in terms
01:33:28 of getting firearms into our country using new technology and we need to actually listen
01:33:33 to our law enforcement.
01:33:35 In Ottawa, we have a government that announces photo ops and press releases when it comes
01:33:39 to firearm policy.
01:33:40 They're not listening to law enforcement and we desperately need them to.
01:33:44 Mr. Polly, you have 30 seconds.
01:33:46 Remember the state needs to be under the law and what Trudeau is now doing is unlawful
01:33:51 censorship.
01:33:52 C11 is an attempt by him to give his bureaucrats the power to control what you see and say
01:33:57 online and to take down things that he doesn't agree with. That is not lawful,
01:34:02 that is not democratic. I will repeal those laws and I will restore the
01:34:09 freedom of speech as a principle for the federal government and also bring
01:34:13 financial penalties to universities that shut down open and free debate on
01:34:18 campuses. And Mr. Brown, 30 seconds to you. You know I would just add that when it
01:34:23 comes to firearm legislation in this country we have bad legislation on top
01:34:27 of bad legislation and we've got a government that is that is missing the
01:34:30 mark one of the reasons we've had a proliferation of gun and gang violence
01:34:35 where there's no respect for postal codes and jurisdictions is there isn't a
01:34:39 concerted national approach under Prime Minister Harper there were serious
01:34:43 consequences we understood that we had to draw a line when it when it came to
01:34:46 gun crime in our country and we need the same strict approach again thank you
01:34:51 very much the two of you mr. Sharae your first up and anybody else if you want
01:34:55 again, just raise your paddle. Mr. Charest. Thank you. And since I've been brought into
01:34:59 this debate, let me start by pointing out that Mr. Poitier is very conveniently rewriting
01:35:04 history tonight. The fact of the matter is he did support illegal blockades. We all admit
01:35:10 that this was a mess created by Mr. Trudeau, unnecessary, a total mess. But I disagree with
01:35:17 anyone who has a privileged position of making laws supporting illegal blockades that have
01:35:23 cost us millions of jobs and cost us investment in this country.
01:35:28 Thank you, sir. Mr. Baber and then Dr. Lewis.
01:35:30 This is a good opportunity to set the record straight. Everything that Justin
01:35:34 Trudeau said about the protest in Ottawa turned out to be false. There was no
01:35:38 foreign collusion. There was very little foreign funding. The arson was not
01:35:43 connected and there were no weapons found anywhere near the site. And on
01:35:47 February 18th we saw as the government was breaking the rule of law with an
01:35:51 unlawful declaration of emergencies, the protesters remained peaceful. There was
01:35:55 no resistance, no assaults, and on February 18th we saw this was a truly
01:35:59 peaceful movement. Thank you very much Dr. Lewis. Go ahead. I think we're missing the
01:36:06 point about the illegal blockades. If elected officials had just listened to
01:36:11 the truckers, they would not have been there that long. In addition, the
01:36:16 The vulnerability that Canadians face knowing that Big Brother can go into their account
01:36:22 and freeze their account without a court order.
01:36:26 That has set our democracy into a declining state.
01:36:30 We need to uphold our charter of rights.
01:36:33 We need to uphold our freedoms and ensure that governments never do that again.
01:36:38 Thank you very much.
01:36:39 Anybody else want to get in on this going, going, gone?
01:36:42 You want it?
01:36:43 Okay.
01:36:44 Mr. Baber, second chance.
01:36:45 I just want to talk about an important issue.
01:36:46 My first law job was at a community legal clinic where I picked up a lot of compassion
01:36:51 and love for people.
01:36:53 Far too often, our criminal justice system criminalizes addiction and mental health.
01:36:57 I'll come down hard on sex offenders, on gun violence and traffickers, but imposing
01:37:01 strict criminal penalty for possession does nothing to deter drug addiction or heal addiction.
01:37:08 We have a mental health and addictions catastrophe in our country, and we need a justice system
01:37:13 that recognizes it and offers Canadian a treatment 0.78
01:37:16 and a way out.
01:37:18 Thank you very much.
01:37:19 And Mr. Polyev.
01:37:20 I think Dr. Lewis raised an excellent point
01:37:22 about the government's abuse of the Emergency Act
01:37:26 to freeze bank accounts.
01:37:27 Well, now there's a proposal to create a central bank
01:37:30 digital currency, which would involve people depositing
01:37:34 their accounts, their money, with the government itself.
01:37:37 This gives massive new powers for surveillance, control,
01:37:40 and censorship and gives the state far too much control over our money and that's why
01:37:46 I would ban a central bank digital currency and give people back control of their money
01:37:50 from bankers and politicians.
01:37:51 Dr. Lewis?
01:37:55 Mr. Poliver encouraged people to buy bitcoin which is a digital currency so I'm quite surprised
01:38:01 that he is saying now that he would ban digital currency as if he does not know that bitcoin
01:38:07 is a digital currency.
01:38:09 He also encouraged people to cash in their fiat currency, their paper money and buy Bitcoin.
01:38:15 If they had done that, they would have lost $37,000 by the time he had said to do that
01:38:22 to today.
01:38:23 So I'm very concerned about that.
01:38:25 Mr. Polioff.
01:38:26 Well, that's just false.
01:38:28 One, Bitcoin is not a central bank digital currency.
01:38:32 It is obviously not.
01:38:34 It's not controlled by any central bank anywhere in the world.
01:38:37 Two, people can make their own investment decisions.
01:38:40 I've simply said they should be free to decide whether or not they want to use Bitcoin. 0.74
01:38:45 I don't want to be like Communist China and ban Bitcoin or other technologies
01:38:51 because in a free market, people should have the opportunity to make those decisions for themselves.
01:38:56 That's my position.
01:38:57 Thank you very much.
01:38:59 Are we done?
01:38:59 Go, Dr. Lewis, one more time.
01:39:01 In fact, Mr. Polyverse said that you could hedge against inflation, which is not true.
01:39:07 So Mr. Polivar is promoting a decentralized currency over his own government's currency.
01:39:14 That is a problem for someone who held a shadow cabinet position as a finance minister.
01:39:22 Sorry, Mr. Shere and then Mr. Brown.
01:39:25 Well, on Bitcoin, I mean, everyone just finds it totally bizarre what Mr. Polivar is suggesting.
01:39:31 We all get it on blockchain. That's fine.
01:39:34 Bitcoin has lost 60% of its value since November of last year, 20% in the last month.
01:39:39 Anyone following his advice that we saw on YouTube would have lost 20% of their earnings.
01:39:45 Do you actually think your parents enjoy having your parents lose 20% of their retirement funds? 0.83
01:39:50 I mean, this is ludicrous, and it doesn't make sense at all. 0.67
01:39:55 Mr. Brown. 0.76
01:39:56 I have to agree with Dr. Lewis and Mr. Sherey.
01:39:59 I disagree with Mr. Polyev's approach that you can opt out of inflation with cryptocurrency.
01:40:05 Magic internet money fluctuates vastly, 30% or more in one day.
01:40:10 And the last thing we should be doing is encouraging our parents and grandparents,
01:40:14 along with vulnerable families, to gamble their savings, their retirements,
01:40:18 in something this risky that's been learned watching late-night YouTube videos.
01:40:24 Mr. Polyev.
01:40:26 Well, Mr. Brown, that's not what I said.
01:40:28 you're misleading the public. I clearly stated that people should have the freedom. Now, the
01:40:33 reason why many people have chosen to exercise that freedom is because central banks have been
01:40:38 attacking the value of our national currencies by printing $400 billion here in Canada, leading to
01:40:45 30-year highs in inflation, doubling the house prices, leading to massive volatility in many
01:40:50 sectors of our economy. And that risk is one I pointed out earlier on and could lead to another
01:40:56 debt crisis. So frankly, we should protect the value of our traditional money rather than banning
01:41:01 private money. Mr. Brown, you're up. So Mr. Paul, I've just said that he didn't say that. No one in
01:41:06 this room and no one in Canada will believe that you didn't say you can opt out of inflation
01:41:10 through cryptocurrency. That is misleading. Your words are there. You can Google it yourself and
01:41:16 watch it on the internet. And I have to say, it is bad advice to be giving to Canadians that is so
01:41:22 risky. And you should know that. As a former finance critic, that's not the advice you should 1.00
01:41:25 be giving to the country and mr. Polly have you raised your your paddle for one more time mr.
01:41:32 mr. brown if you want to talk about risks to people's finances you were the one who said you
01:41:38 promised when you ran for the leadership of the progressive conservative party of Ontario you
01:41:43 would oppose the carbon tax and then as soon as you got in you reversed yourself entirely not
01:41:48 only you did you endorse just any carbon tax you endorsed the carbon tax of Justin Trudeau which
01:41:54 is in place today and recently increased and is one of the reasons why prices are so high across
01:42:00 this country. That is a threat to our money. That is a decision you made after you promised not to.
01:42:05 People can't believe a word you said. Mr. Bever. I can't believe that you have a bunch of politicians
01:42:10 here, career politicians, giving people investment advice. Let's distinguish the issue, okay? There's
01:42:15 digital currency controlled by government that has government friction potentially and compromises
01:42:20 our privacy. And then there are investment decisions that people make. Human ingenuity
01:42:24 is great. We should encourage research and development and diversified portfolios. But
01:42:29 we should behave like conservatives again and not tell people what they should and should
01:42:33 invest in. Maybe we should oppose supply management. Maybe we should oppose equalization. We should
01:42:37 not be afraid of being who we are. Enough. Mr. Baber, that's great. Are we all done?
01:42:43 Okay. I do remind you, you've only got five. So, talking about bank accounts. I don't know, but somebody over there does. And they will tell me and I will tell you. All of this conversation, though, leads neatly to my next question. And the topic is the future of the party. Mr. Charest, who would you like to debate on the future of the party?
01:43:06 Mr. Poliev.
01:43:08 Mr. Poliev, there we go.
01:43:10 The question.
01:43:12 The leadership campaign, this leadership campaign has been particularly vicious on a personal level.
01:43:18 We've seen that.
01:43:20 We've heard candidates call each other liars, accuse others of having no integrity.
01:43:24 One of you even says it sounds like a kindergarten class.
01:43:27 There are also deep divisions on a lot of policy issues from abortion to zero emissions.
01:43:32 The conservative movement has split before in the recent past.
01:43:36 We know that.
01:43:38 So the question to you, Mr. Charest and Mr. Polyev,
01:43:42 how do you make room in the conservative tent for all those who hold opposing views to yours?
01:43:48 How does the party enter the next election?
01:43:51 How can the party enter the next election united?
01:43:54 Mr. Charest, you have one minute.
01:43:55 And Tom, this is, for all those listening to us tonight and in the room, this is the key question.
01:43:59 Everyone knows that the Trudeau government needs to get out of office and they're looking
01:44:05 to the Conservative Party of Canada as a national alternative.
01:44:09 And the question they're asking themselves is this, are you up to the task?
01:44:13 Are you, yes or no, going to be a national conservative alternative and party?
01:44:19 That's our challenge, ladies and gentlemen.
01:44:21 And what is that party?
01:44:22 It's based on core values that we all agree on.
01:44:26 conservatism, a market-based economy, economic policies that promote economic growth, including
01:44:32 oil, gas, pipelines and mining, families also, all sorts of families, plus respecting the
01:44:40 rule of law, a foundation of our society.
01:44:44 There is no freedom if you do not respect the rule of law.
01:44:48 There is no freedom.
01:44:49 And it includes a federalism that conservatives practice, that includes Alberta, includes
01:44:54 Ontario, Quebec, that actually makes this country work.
01:44:59 We need to unite the party around freedom.
01:45:02 Social Conservatives want the freedom to raise their kids with their own values and preach
01:45:06 their faith without censorship.
01:45:09 Fiscal Conservatives want the freedom to make their own financial decisions, control their
01:45:13 own money, including without excessive taxes or carbon taxes.
01:45:19 Rural Conservatives want the freedom to own and control their own property.
01:45:23 conservatives want for women, minorities, first nations to have the freedom to make their own
01:45:28 decisions without discrimination. Libertarian conservatives want freedom of speech, freedom
01:45:33 to make their own decisions online, and freedom to speak without the government censoring them.
01:45:40 So when we unite the party along that consistent principle of freedom, then we bring all the
01:45:46 various parts of our party together, and we electrify and excite a new generation of young
01:45:53 people that I've been bringing into the coalition so that we can form the next government and beat
01:45:57 Justin Trudeau. Mr. Charest, you have 45 seconds. I want to be very clear. I'm not running as a
01:46:05 hyphenated conservative, ladies and gentlemen. We've had enough. We'll leave that to the Trudeau
01:46:09 and the left to hyphenate everyone. I am not a hyphenated conservative. I am a conservative,
01:46:15 period. You know what values I espoused and practiced all my life. And once we are rallied
01:46:22 around those values, and we're together, you also know that we will respect those who don't agree
01:46:28 with us, who may have different views. And Mr. Poirier talked about social conservatives. Let's
01:46:33 talk about that. He still won't tell you his position of whether he is pro-choice or pro-life.
01:46:39 I respect social conservatives. They will always have a place in our party.
01:46:44 They are good people, faith-based people, who deserve a place at the table and in the family.
01:46:50 Mr. Paul, you have 45.
01:46:51 I believe in freedom of choice on that issue. I already said that at the very beginning.
01:46:54 So I don't know what you missed. I don't know if you were listening.
01:46:59 Yes, it is. That's what I said.
01:47:01 But Mr. Charest, why didn't you take a moment to acknowledge that you're the only one on this stage
01:47:05 who actually voted for a law that would recriminalize abortion when you were part of the Mulroney
01:47:09 government.
01:47:10 You did.
01:47:11 You did.
01:47:12 And you can take a moment now to renounce your earlier vote if you've changed your mind,
01:47:15 but that was your position.
01:47:17 You seem to have forgotten it.
01:47:18 You've forgotten a lot of things about your record.
01:47:20 You forgot that you brought in a carbon tax.
01:47:22 You forgot that you raised the fuel tax, the sales tax, the health tax.
01:47:26 You forgot that you banned natural gas development in your own province.
01:47:30 You forgot you brought in a long gun registry.
01:47:32 You seem a little bit forgetful about your record, Mr. Charest, but Canadians now remember.
01:47:36 I... hang on. No, no. No, no, no, no. You know, you guys know the rules. You know the consequences.
01:47:45 Mr. Charest, 30 seconds.
01:47:46 I am very proud of my record as a Conservative that stands on its own merits, on fiscal conservatism,
01:47:55 on reducing the size of government, reducing taxes, which I did when I was Premier, by the way.
01:48:01 Quebecers had a billion dollars less taxes paid and higher disposable income after I finished in government, ladies and gentlemen.
01:48:10 And by the way, Mr. Poliev, thank you for at least now telling us that you are pro-choice.
01:48:16 We understand that's what you're saying tonight. Please, confirm that for us.
01:48:19 Mr. Poliev, you have 30 seconds.
01:48:21 I did confirm my position that I will not introduce any law on abortion as Prime Minister. I made that very clear.
01:48:26 very clear. But Mr. Charest, you're wrong about your tax record. You raised the sales tax, the
01:48:30 carbon tax, the fuel tax. Just like Patrick Brown, you're trying to flip-flop on it and say one thing
01:48:35 on the stage different than what you said before. And the overall tax burden in Quebec went from 19%
01:48:40 of the economy to 25% of the economy under your government. That is your record. You can't run
01:48:47 away from it. I have a clear, solid record as a tax cutter that leaves more money in people's
01:48:51 Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Brown, you have 30 seconds.
01:48:55 First of all, Pierre Pauly have just ran on a carbon tax on a carbon tax and knocked on doors in Carleton literally six months ago, literally in the last election.
01:49:04 Now, but let's talk about the future of the party.
01:49:06 The future of the party, we have to win where we've lost.
01:49:09 We've lost in suburban Canada, and I don't see us winning any new seats.
01:49:13 Actually, I see us losing seats if we run on the same discriminatory policies that Pierre Pauly has had a history of supporting.
01:49:19 We must be the party that celebrates and supports religious freedom, not tramples it.
01:49:23 Full stop.
01:49:24 Thanks very much.
01:49:25 Dr. Lewis.
01:49:26 Well, Mr. Poliev said that no pro-life bill will pass in his caucus, but he believes in freedom.
01:49:32 Are you going to give your MPs the freedom to vote their conscience on issues of life?
01:49:39 Am I allowed to answer?
01:49:40 If you use your paddle, you can.
01:49:42 that's well he he he's he's been silent on on the issue so mr. Polyev you've
01:49:53 raised your paddle you have 30 seconds I do believe in free votes so there's
01:49:56 your direct answer and as for mr. Brown sorry Patrick you told the members of
01:50:02 the Conservative Party in Ontario that you were against a carbon tax then you
01:50:04 flip-flop and embraced a carbon tax you said that you were a pro-life social
01:50:08 conservative. And then after you became leader, you said that social conservatives were intolerant
01:50:14 dinosaurs. You said that you would get rid of the sex ed program in Ontario, and then you embraced
01:50:19 it. You now attack all the Harper government policies that you enthusiastically supported
01:50:24 and embraced when you were part of his caucus. Thank you, Mr. Paulyab. Is anybody else wanting
01:50:28 to get involved in this? Mr. Aitchison, 30 seconds. Well, I appreciate everybody talking
01:50:35 about the importance of, you know, all the different types of conservatives. I think
01:50:37 Mr. Poliab gave us a great list of all the different types of conservatives.
01:50:40 It is important for us to respect each other and have respectful dialogue, but it's not
01:50:45 enough just to unite conservatives.
01:50:47 We need to win over swing voters, people who aren't part of our party, and I think that's
01:50:52 going to be extremely difficult, especially if they watch some of the nastiness on this
01:50:56 stage tonight.
01:50:57 Mr. Baber.
01:50:59 I'll unite the party by restoring democracy in the conservative party, but most importantly
01:51:06 bring back disillusioned voters our party failed to stand up for many 0.99
01:51:10 Canadians against lockdowns against mandates until the truckers came to town
01:51:14 many Canadians felt that we've abandoned them so they voted for another party or
01:51:18 they didn't vote at all another disillusioned with our party I'm the
01:51:21 only one on the stage who stood up for Canadians for two years for year and a
01:51:25 half before it was popular and I'll bring back disillusioned voters we cannot
01:51:30 win if we're not united right of center. Anybody else? Dr. Lewis? Mr. Baber was
01:51:38 not the only one who stood up for Canadians who lost their jobs due to
01:51:43 mandates, who were discriminated against, who cannot fly. I also stood up for those
01:51:49 Canadians and I wanted to make that point. And Mr. Brown, I believe you've got one
01:51:56 left okay well let me be very clear i was one of the only big city mayors in the country that didn't
01:52:01 impose vaccine mandates no firefighter no police officer no long-term city employee lost their job
01:52:07 in brampton i stood by the right to have personal health choices and i have to say it's surprising
01:52:11 during the leadership campaign that all of a sudden pure poly comes out against mandates
01:52:16 because in the heat of the battle he didn't say a word he was hiding in his basement at a time that
01:52:20 I had longtime municipal employees in Ottawa calling me asking for help. I give Roman Baber
01:52:26 credit. He was there. He was hurt. Dr. Lewis was hurt. Disappeared.
01:52:31 Thanks very much. It would seem appropriate for me at this point, and I'm getting the information
01:52:38 in my ear, but I want to pass it on. Mr. Brown, you've got one intervention left. Mr. Polyev,
01:52:44 you're out you're you've used your five uh dr lewis so have you um and uh i'm waiting to hear
01:52:52 mr baber you've got four four oh you've got one left mr baber mr chariot you've got three
01:53:02 left oh god you're keeping count and you've got four left is everybody clear on what you've got
01:53:09 and what you don't okay thank you very much i miss lewis this next question is for you
01:53:15 and the topic is energy and who would you like to debate
01:53:23 i'll debate mr aitchison mr aitchison and dr lewis excellent here's the question
01:53:28 for both of you starting with dr lewis uh oil and gas as we know in canada has seen a price
01:53:35 rebound in this year but the export growth of these commodities has been constrained by
01:53:39 pipeline infrastructure you've all said that you would boost the building of pipelines there are
01:53:46 multiple jurisdictions as we know that need to be involved in that process so the question is this
01:53:52 how would you do this who would pay for these pipelines and how would you deal with indigenous
01:54:00 or provincial opposition. Dr. Lewis. Investing in Canadian oil and gas is the
01:54:06 best way to grow our economy. We can enter into agreements with indigenous
01:54:12 populations that will actually enrich those populations and many of those
01:54:16 agreements have been entered into and and it has been beneficial in uplifting
01:54:21 those populations. We also need to ensure that we eliminate these Bill C-69 and
01:54:29 Bill C-48, which is really crippling our local capacity to develop our oil and
01:54:36 gas. We have to get our products to market, build pipelines, we could go
01:54:41 through Churchill and out get to get our products to Tidewater and offset
01:54:46 dictatorship oil. You haven't used all your time but if you're conceding it
01:54:52 I'll go to you Mr. Aitchison for one minute. Well I mean I think it's safe to
01:54:56 that everybody on this stage is pro-pipeline, but we do need a real plan. You know, Mr. Polyev talks
01:55:02 about the gatekeepers and the federal bureaucracy, and of course there are a lot there, and so
01:55:06 probably the first thing I would do as leader of a party, and as the prime minister, is I'd make
01:55:11 Payal Polyev, my minister of natural resources, to deal with the gatekeepers and solve that problem.
01:55:18 Gatekeepers he can fire. Second, we need to create a framework that allows more building.
01:55:24 clear and concise rules we need clear guidelines timely approvals set timelines on these things
01:55:30 and get the process moving and make sure it's not delayed we must simplify and speed up this process
01:55:34 stop dithering and provide certainty this is one of the biggest challenges that we face if their
01:55:40 investment doesn't like uncertainty and this is part of the problem we face here is uncertainty
01:55:44 we need to make it clear concise and put timelines on it and i think pierre would be perfect at that
01:55:49 Dr. Lewis, you have 45 seconds.
01:55:53 I think it was very short-sighted for us not to invest in pipelines,
01:55:57 and we're seeing the implications of that now. In Europe, 40%
01:56:01 of all the oil that's purchased is purchased from Russia. We're
01:56:05 actually financing the war between Ukraine and Russia
01:56:09 by not getting our products to offset dictatorship
01:56:13 oil. Every day we import 555,000
01:56:17 barrels of oil we have the third largest accessible oil reserves on the planet which we are leaving
01:56:23 untapped it is a great resource that we could use to rebuild our economy develop our infrastructure
01:56:30 for every job that's created from the oil and gas sector seven splinter jobs are created across the
01:56:36 country this could help us out of the recession mr aitchison to you for 45 yeah i just i would
01:56:44 also add that of course i think we all agree that one of the reasons we're all so pro pipeline is
01:56:47 because canada's energy is the answer to a lot of problems in this world today i mean we see what's
01:56:52 going on in ukraine right now in canada we don't even have the capacity to scale up to help countries
01:56:58 like ukraine and countries like germany and and europe because because we're not ready we haven't
01:57:03 been doing the work we've had a liberal government that's just gotten in the way and made things more
01:57:07 difficult every step of the way it's good for our economy it's good for our environment and it's
01:57:12 good for advancing foreign policy canadian energy is some of the cleanest in the world people don't
01:57:16 realize that that the that fort mac has reduced their carbon output from their production by over
01:57:23 30 percent that's incredible i guarantee a venezuela is not doing that uh mr lewis back to
01:57:29 you for 30 and i just underlined part of the question which is who pays for this i'm sorry
01:57:34 part of the question is who pays for this well if we are building pipelines and we are selling our
01:57:41 products and we're getting our products to market, we will have enough resources that we can
01:57:47 reinvest back into our economy and actually improve the lives of certain regions. Even in
01:57:52 the north, we could invest in improving those individuals' lives and making sure that we build
01:58:00 critical infrastructures in the north, bring down the cost of fuel, assist with the high cost of
01:58:07 food and and cancel the carbon tax thank you mr. ageison 30 seconds left for you and you're asking
01:58:14 me who pays for the pipelines yeah yeah industry should pay for the pipelines there's no question
01:58:18 about that and if there is certainty in the process there's certainty in the system they're
01:58:21 more than happy to make those investments but it is the industry that should be doing it
01:58:26 terrific anybody else want to get involved in this discussion going going gone well i think
01:58:31 only two of you have battles left so let's move on to the next one uh and mr. ageison this is a
01:58:36 question to you and the topic is the north who do you choose to debate mr.
01:58:47 baby mr. baby it is okay and here's the question mr. Richardson the largest part
01:58:52 of our landmark landmass in this country is north of where most Canadians live
01:58:57 and while incredibly beautiful as we all know the north is struggling
01:59:02 economically demographically and now with melting ice its very security may be at risk as hostile
01:59:08 nations move to take advantage of that area one could argue that the north is our biggest challenge
01:59:13 but it's also our biggest opportunity so what is your vision for the north
01:59:20 my vision of the north includes actually engaging in the north i think mr shere made a very good
01:59:25 point about making sure we have not just one but two deep water ports in the north uh you're quite
01:59:30 correct that ice is melting and there are other nations that are cruising through our our northern
01:59:35 waters and not all that interested in what we think about it we need to defend uh the north
01:59:40 we need to engage with the north and we need to be making investments in the north but that includes
01:59:44 of course uh our military commitments we need to be we need to be making sure that we're not just
01:59:50 committing two percent of gdp uh on military spending to meet our nato commitments but we
01:59:54 also need to be making sure we're meeting commitments to protect canada and and it's
01:59:59 It's not just enough to be protecting the east and the west coast, we have a north coast.
02:00:03 And it's been neglected and we need to invest more there.
02:00:05 And so I fundamentally think that this is about engaging all parts of our country
02:00:10 and making sure that we can secure it at every port, at every coast.
02:00:16 Thank you. Mr. Baber, for one minute.
02:00:19 Thank you. The best way to help northern communities is to unlock their natural resources potential
02:00:25 and not just soil and gas.
02:00:27 I'm very interested in mining. There's an insatiable appetite right now around the world for precious metals and precious
02:00:33 minerals and Canada and the north are blessed with them and we can do this. We can strike the right balance.
02:00:40 We can consult stakeholders and we can protect the environment, but we need to end this resistance to the development of natural resources and
02:00:48 Northern communities are going to be the greatest beneficiaries of that. That also means we'll improve infrastructure and build roads and highways in the north.
02:00:55 let's bring northern communities a true economic opportunity let's build roads
02:01:01 let's start building and and working in our country again let's get back to work
02:01:08 mr. Acheson back to you for 45 I think speaking about the north also provides
02:01:13 an opportunity to talk about housing which is an issue that has not come up
02:01:16 in this debate yet and it is it's a crisis in this country and it's
02:01:19 particularly a crisis in the north and we need to commit as a federal government
02:01:23 not just to ensure that big cities and southern Canada is getting things built,
02:01:29 but we need to make sure that we make a commitment to the north as well
02:01:31 because the housing situation there is as much of a crisis or worse
02:01:35 than anywhere else in Canada.
02:01:37 And so housing would be a crucial investment to make sure that we're engaged
02:01:42 and making sure that the health of residents in northern Canada is sound.
02:01:47 Mr. Baby?
02:01:48 I won good-paying jobs in the north.
02:01:50 I had a gentleman approach me a couple of months ago
02:01:52 who I didn't know and he told me that his company owed a mining permit for 15
02:01:56 years and they weren't able to go ahead because local stakeholders would not
02:02:00 consult I know that the Supreme Court recognized that there's a duty to
02:02:04 consult but it doesn't mean that we can't strike a balance we can be
02:02:08 reasonable again let's mitigate environmental risk let's agree on on
02:02:12 profit sharing but I will not allow to hold up the development of Canada's
02:02:17 natural resources we need them for the well-being of our northern communities
02:02:21 And most importantly, we need them to get out of the fiscal mess that the Liberal government is leaving us in.
02:02:28 Mr. Acheson, you have 30.
02:02:31 Some debate between Roman and I. I think we were agreeing on almost everything here.
02:02:34 And I think that that's kind of nice.
02:02:38 I don't really have much more to add on the issue.
02:02:40 I think that there's been a lot of talk over the years about engaging in the North.
02:02:46 And not a lot of action.
02:02:47 I think that that's pretty typical of this Liberal government.
02:02:49 we've seen you know when it comes to housing lots of photo ops but not a lot of ribbon cuttings
02:02:54 and i think that's disgusting and and we need to do better and conservatives are
02:02:57 are a party of action and so we will get these things done and we will engage with the north
02:03:01 and actually do it okay mr polyeth oh i'm sorry this is a very complicated show okay mr paper go
02:03:11 ahead thank you i i appreciate my friend scott for his kindness and and for his gracious approach to
02:03:17 this race perhaps it will give me an opportunity to politely respond to dr lewis um i'm the only
02:03:23 one on the stage that opposed lockdowns i was removed from the dr doug ford caucus in january
02:03:28 2021 when i spoke up about the collateral harm that we're causing our health and mental health 0.54
02:03:34 by way of locking down healthy people instead of a focused approach against a very transmissible
02:03:39 virus but i appreciate that she joined against mandates subsequent to the last general election
02:03:44 Thank you.
02:03:46 Mr. Charest, did you raise your paddle?
02:03:48 May I respond?
02:03:50 I'm sorry.
02:03:51 No, you can't.
02:03:52 Mr. Charest, go ahead.
02:03:54 Well, thank you.
02:03:55 And Scott and Roman have both said things that I totally agree with.
02:03:59 And thank you for a very constructive discussion on the north, to which I want to add.
02:04:04 Yes, I would build two military bases in the north, one with a deep water port.
02:04:09 This is one of the most important issues facing our country.
02:04:11 And this is a good city to talk about.
02:04:13 Edmonton has a very deep connection to the North, but it also includes
02:04:17 affirming our sovereignty, it includes things like icebreakers and armed ice
02:04:22 breakers, submarines that we also need to build to be able to patrol the North, it
02:04:26 includes solidifying our agreement with the Americans on NORAD. We're done.
02:04:31 Anybody else want to... no? Okay, we're gonna move on to the next question. Thank
02:04:36 you very much. Mr. Baber, this is for you. The subject is cost of living and who
02:04:41 would you like to debate? Mr. Charest. Mr. Charest and Mr. Baber on this
02:04:46 question. We have seen a rapid rise in the cost of living for Canadians at
02:04:51 levels we haven't seen in 40 years and we are certainly not alone. Every
02:04:56 Western country is going through this right now. Under your leadership, is there
02:05:00 anything a Canadian government can do to reverse the worldwide trend without
02:05:05 making the wealth gap any larger in Canada than it already is today? So
02:05:11 So I think it's important that we acknowledge the cause of inflation and the rising prices.
02:05:15 It's not just a half a trillion dollars in debt that we printed in the last two years.
02:05:19 It's lockdowns, something no one on the stage other than myself was willing to acknowledge.
02:05:25 We stopped the global supply chain at its tracks numerous times and then restarted demand
02:05:30 again.
02:05:31 Supply is not catching up to demand.
02:05:33 The best thing we can do right now is to provide the market with some certainty.
02:05:36 I will never allow for any lockdowns or any stoppages.
02:05:39 I'm also going to restore discipline to government.
02:05:43 We're spending way beyond our means, but in terms of affordability,
02:05:47 I'm going to repeal the carbon tax on day one,
02:05:51 and I will cut income taxes across the board with money saved from equalization payments.
02:05:56 I would rather that Canadians spend them instead of provincial governments.
02:06:01 We are the conservative government.
02:06:03 We should not be afraid to be talking about cutting taxes.
02:06:07 Mr. Baver, thank you. Mr. Charest.
02:06:09 Well, Roman, on the issue of lockdowns, and I agree, I think one of the things we need to do if we don't want to have the lockdowns and the restrictions we had the last time is change our healthcare system so that we have capacity.
02:06:21 That's one of the reasons why Canada had more restrictions than anywhere else in the world, because we don't.
02:06:27 So we need to open up this healthcare system so there's more flexibility, more private sector participation in this.
02:06:34 on inflation, we need to reduce spending, and we also need to, I think, reduce the income tax load
02:06:41 of Canadians. I did that during the Great Recession, and we had a better performance
02:06:46 than Ontario, Canada, the United States, or Europe. Lower unemployment and stronger economic growth.
02:06:52 Those are the things that we can do to increase the disposable income of people, which is exactly
02:06:58 what happened after I was Premier. The disposable income, especially of lower-income people,
02:07:04 increase substantially because we reduce taxes and controlled spending thanks very much mr
02:07:11 baber you have 45. we should never lock down mr shere no matter what the circumstances are
02:07:18 we have to acknowledge the toll that this took on people a mental health pandemic uh
02:07:23 in ontario alone more than 300 000 surgeries were delayed more than a million cancer screenings
02:07:28 missed the whole point is that the toll on our health was considerably greater instead
02:07:34 we should have been protecting vulnerable populations, beefing up our resources in
02:07:40 congregate settings where 80% of the risk was. We should have been increasing the healthcare
02:07:47 capacity we had, but we should acknowledge lockdowns, the effect on our children, the effect
02:07:53 on small business. This is something that we cannot escape and we need to think about and resolve
02:07:58 going long long term well and you know we agree we agree that we need to avoid the lockdowns and
02:08:04 that's why i would change the canada health act i do introduce a new hat because canada's issue
02:08:10 has been capacity we're the country in the world who's had that problem capacity able to absorb
02:08:15 people but let me also talk about something else in relation to inflation mr pollier's suggestion
02:08:20 of firing the governor of the bank of canada his suggestion that i'm saying that the bank
02:08:25 in Canada is financially illiterate is irresponsible. It creates doubt. If you're
02:08:31 an investor looking at coming to Canada and you hear that kind of a statement
02:08:35 coming from a member of the House of Commons, you'd think you're in a third
02:08:39 world country. We cannot afford to have any leader who goes out there and
02:08:44 deliberately undermines the confidence in institutions. Conservatives do not do
02:08:49 that. Mr. Baber you have 30 seconds. Thank you. I'm going to go back to the cost of
02:08:54 living the political class is out of touch with Canadians prices for produce
02:08:59 for instance have tripled this may be one of the greatest challenges that
02:09:03 Canadians are facing right now and we need to do everything possible to make
02:09:07 life more affordable for them not more expensive let's repeal the carbon tax
02:09:13 it's increasing the price on everything let's cut the income tax and let's stop
02:09:19 developing the loonie. Well on the on the carbon tax I agree with Roman that we
02:09:26 need to get out and repeal the Trudeau carbon tax on consumers and I would be
02:09:32 inspired by Alberta. Here in Alberta since 2002 and you renewed this in 2019
02:09:39 there is a price on carbon for large emitters and let me point something out
02:09:44 here this is extremely important to get it right otherwise we will not be
02:09:48 elected as a political party if we're not credible on this, A, B, we will not get
02:09:53 investment unless there is a predictable investment environment on an issue like
02:09:57 pricing carbon. Thank you. That round is finished. Would anybody else like to join
02:10:04 in? Mr. Brown, you've still got points as do you. We don't have any more points. No, I know you're out.
02:10:11 yeah sorry about that okay we are now going to move on to the next question
02:10:19 then mr. Brown the issue is climate change who would you like to debate my
02:10:25 friend dr. Leslie Lewis okay dr. Lewis and Patrick Brown mr. Brown here is the
02:10:32 question in 2015 almost every country in the world including Canada signed on to
02:10:40 Paris Accords to fight climate change. To date not a single G20 country is on
02:10:45 track to meet that obligation. Should the Paris Agreement still be the benchmark
02:10:51 for Canada in measuring itself by and if yes would you commit to meeting the
02:10:56 initial Paris Agreement by 2030 and who will bear the cost of getting us there?
02:11:02 So first of all I should say that the Liberals promise Canada to targets they
02:11:06 have no intention no plan to meet and that's part of the problem we need to
02:11:11 have a credible environmental plan to actually achieve the targets the Canada
02:11:15 commits to I don't believe in Canada committing to targets that were unable
02:11:19 to commit and frankly it is it is photo op environmentalism how is it better for
02:11:24 the environment to be importing foreign dictator oil into Canada I find it
02:11:30 infuriating that I can't use when I want to fill up the pump in Brampton Ontario
02:11:35 can't use and be a wealth generator for the Canadian energy sector and I and I
02:11:39 have to say at the fact that our Prime Minister this Prime Minister doesn't
02:11:46 understand that it is a huge toll on our economy it's costing Canadians more you
02:11:51 know looking at the latest stats 73,000 barrels from Saudi Arabia the loss to
02:11:57 our economies he hasn't invested into our energy corridor 14 billion you know
02:12:02 We, thank you.
02:12:04 Thanks very much, Mr. Brown.
02:12:05 Dr. Lewis.
02:12:07 Canada signed on to the Paris Accord.
02:12:10 They didn't meet their targets.
02:12:12 The US pulled out of the Paris Accord.
02:12:17 They met their targets under Donald Trump.
02:12:19 The issue is not whether or not we sign on to the Paris Accord.
02:12:24 The issue is the resolve to make sure that we leave for future
02:12:29 generations better environment than what we inherited. There is no partisanship in the
02:12:36 environment. We must work together to make sure that we are protecting the environment. The carbon
02:12:42 tax doesn't reduce emissions, it just increases revenues. We need to ensure that we adopt technology
02:12:50 that will bring down emissions, that will increase conservation, and we have to have a
02:12:57 Incredible environmental plan and that plan has to have a component of education to change the way we interact with the environment
02:13:08 Mr. Brown 45 seconds. Yes, so you look at China one of the greatest polluters in the world 30% of the global emissions
02:13:15 To help with environment we need to export clean
02:13:19 Canadian energy to the world, you know since 2014 18 LNG projects none approved at the same time in the US
02:13:27 seven were built and now they have 22% of the global market share so the
02:13:31 question about helping countries reliant on coal have clean Canadian energy
02:13:35 should should be how Canada could help abroad and right now you know we need a
02:13:41 conservative government that can get pipelines built and the reality is
02:13:45 there's some candidates on this stage who would have no chance to get
02:13:48 pipelines built because of derogatory remarks they've made about indigenous
02:13:51 Canadians dr. Lewis well that's that person certain I know that mr. Brown does
02:13:59 not refer to me on that one so it is very important that we look at the entire
02:14:07 lifecycle of a product so even when we commit to something like net zero we
02:14:12 should not be virtue signaling to use the environment as virtue signaling we
02:14:21 We have to ensure that we look at the entire life cycle of a product.
02:14:25 So even if we have a green product, we have to look at the entire production from the
02:14:32 start to the finish, such as green energy, such as green cars, electric cars.
02:14:39 What is the entire product?
02:14:41 Mr. Brown, you have 30.
02:14:45 So if the premise to get pipelines built is indigenous collaboration, I have to ask Pierre
02:14:50 Pauli of the question how he believes he could ever get a single pipeline built in this country
02:14:55 when on the heels of Prime Minister Harper's historic residential school apology, he attacked
02:15:01 in a disgusting manner Indigenous Canadians saying they lacked work ethic. Someone who attacks
02:15:06 Indigenous partners who we require to build pipelines will never be able to build a single
02:15:11 pipeline in this country. And Dr. Lewis, you have the last 30 seconds. I just wanted to expand on 1.00
02:15:18 my comment about the entire life cycle.
02:15:22 I'm very concerned with things like electric vehicles
02:15:26 that we do not consider the fact that it starts off
02:15:30 in poor countries, in some African countries
02:15:33 where children as young as five years old
02:15:36 are working in cobalt mines.
02:15:38 So when we think of protecting the environment,
02:15:41 we must think of the entire impact,
02:15:43 the entire life cycle.
02:15:45 Thank you. Would anybody else like to say anything? Mr. Charest.
02:15:52 Well, this is a key issue for us. We need to do a lot of things, including carbon capture and storage, hydrogen, blue-green, biofuels, small modular reactors.
02:16:03 Alberta, Ontario, New Brunswick, Saskatchewan are working together to develop those technologies.
02:16:09 replace the carbon tax of Mr. Trudeau with something similar to what Alberta is doing for large emitters
02:16:16 and have a credible policy on this in the next campaign, ladies and gentlemen.
02:16:21 Otherwise, our government will not be elected.
02:16:25 Mr. Aitchison.
02:16:27 Thank you. I actually wouldn't propose a similar plan to what former Prime Minister Harper had in 2008.
02:16:32 It's similar to what Mr. Charest has proposed in this campaign.
02:16:35 In fact, I'm making my cabinet right here as we go. I'd make him minister of the environment probably.
02:16:39 And I think we need to offer a balanced regulatory approach.
02:16:44 I do agree with taxing or the large industrial emitters, but I think it's too important
02:16:50 to point out what's going on right here in Alberta.
02:16:53 The innovative work going on in the economy here is something we need to take an opportunity
02:16:57 to sell our products to the world to help countries like China reduce their emissions.
02:17:03 I think that's it, and I see no more paddles being raised.
02:17:07 I just want to say that you have been all so incredibly
02:17:10 disciplined with your time that we
02:17:13 find ourselves in the lovely position of me
02:17:15 being able to offer some time back to all of you.
02:17:19 Throughout this debate, no doubt,
02:17:21 you have been dying to say something
02:17:24 about what has been discussed here today.
02:17:27 So I want to go down the line.
02:17:29 And we'll just take it in geographical order here,
02:17:33 starting with Dr. Lewis, and go down the line.
02:17:36 30 seconds to say anything that you have wanted to say that you didn't get to say so far.
02:17:41 30 seconds each.
02:17:42 Dr. Lewis, up to you.
02:17:43 I wanted to add on my point for the environment that we can protect the environment without
02:17:49 punishing average Canadians.
02:17:51 Every time they're filling up their gas tanks, they're heating their homes, they're putting
02:17:55 food on the table, they're being punished with the carbon tax.
02:17:58 I would cancel the carbon tax.
02:18:01 Thank you very much.
02:18:02 Mr. Faber.
02:18:03 First of all, I really enjoyed today's debate, and of course I appreciate the tone.
02:18:10 I think it's okay to have a little bit of fun as we did last time around.
02:18:15 And also I think that we should encourage people to speak more freely.
02:18:18 A lot of candidates may wish to respond to one another.
02:18:21 We should perhaps accommodate such opportunity.
02:18:24 And finally, if I may, in the 10 seconds they'll give me, I think that we should not be afraid
02:18:31 to stand for what we believe is the Conservative Party.
02:18:34 And unfortunately, I'm out of time.
02:18:36 You're out of time.
02:18:37 Mr. Charest.
02:18:38 I look forward to working with everyone on stage here,
02:18:41 and Mr. Aderson, I appreciate the invitation.
02:18:44 I want to talk about resources
02:18:46 and point something out here about Canada.
02:18:48 We have a knowledge-based economy,
02:18:50 but a good part of our exports are resources.
02:18:53 Whether it's mining, oil, gas, whether it's pipelines,
02:18:56 we need to stand up for the development
02:18:58 of our resource industry.
02:19:00 We need a Prime Minister who's actually going to say this is a good idea.
02:19:03 We can do this in transition to zero emissions in 2050.
02:19:07 It is possible to do it, and only the Conservative Party of Canada has the ability to offer that
02:19:12 leadership.
02:19:13 Thank you, Mr. Chere.
02:19:14 Mr. Aitchison, what have you been dying to say?
02:19:17 Well, I guess I really think it's important to say that as Conservatives, we need to have
02:19:21 the courage of our convictions to defend our values and our principles.
02:19:26 values and principles as conservatives are timeless and if we stick to those
02:19:29 and if we offer a principled consistent message to Canadians we can form the
02:19:34 next government. Thank you very much Mr. Brown. I believe in technology not taxes
02:19:40 in Brampton will be the first big city in Canada to have a fully electrified
02:19:44 transit fleet clean green and no emissions I should also say you know we
02:19:49 need to have a conversation about a carbon tariff at the border the fact
02:19:52 that some candidates on this stage are okay to allow India and China to flood the market
02:19:57 where they have no environmental standards, they have no labor standards, and compete
02:20:01 with Canadian goods is wrong. We need to create a Canadian advantage and protect against product
02:20:06 being dumped with no environmental cost. Thank you very much. Mr. Polyev. The biggest
02:20:12 issue I've heard about that people haven't talked about today is housing. Our 32, 33-year-old
02:20:18 people living in their parents' basements. We have the fewest houses in Canada per capita
02:20:23 in the G7. At the same time, our central bank has been printing money to inflate prices.
02:20:28 The solution is, of course, to fire the gatekeepers. I've already announced that I will fire the
02:20:33 governor of the central bank to get inflation under control. But I will also tie infrastructure
02:20:38 dollars for cities to the number of houses they allow to get built by removing the red
02:20:42 tape and allowing builders to build home for homes for our young people to live in thank you very much
02:20:49 we are now going to the final section of the debate and uh once again uh all the candidates
02:20:58 have been advised in advance of of this uh and it is simply to and we started the debate with
02:21:04 the question what is your my vision for canada is dot dot dot this question is why should i be
02:21:11 the leader of the Conservative Party of Canada, dot, dot, dot. 45 seconds to each
02:21:17 of you to answer that question and we are going to start with Scott Aitchison.
02:21:23 We've increased it to 45. I got my 45 back. We must welcome more people to our
02:21:32 party if we are to succeed, but we cannot do it with angry rhetoric and attacks on
02:21:36 each other. Leaders always engage, empower, and inspire the team around them. As
02:21:42 leader, I will bring Conservatives together and we will learn the trust of
02:21:46 all Canadians to govern again. I know our best days lie ahead. With our team
02:21:51 focused on all that unites us, we will fulfill the promise of a brighter
02:21:55 tomorrow. And if you seek a Conservative government focused on making life more
02:21:59 affordable, join me. Join me at votescott.ca. Thank you.
02:22:04 Thank you very much Mr. Acheson. Mr. Brown. Thank you Tom. I want to be leader
02:22:10 of the Conservative Party of Canada because we need a leader who can defeat
02:22:13 Justin Trudeau not just yell at him. We need to expand our party with new
02:22:18 members, new supporters, new volunteers and most importantly new voters. But it'll
02:22:23 never happen if we choose a leader who repels voters and supports failed
02:22:27 election losing policies that trample over the religious freedom of Canadians.
02:22:32 I won in the GTA by proving to voters who have traditionally not supported the
02:22:37 Conservative Party that their values are our values, conservative values. With
02:22:43 your support we can do that on a national scale from coast to coast to
02:22:47 coast and win. Thank you very much Mr. Brown. We are now going to Dr. Lewis. 45
02:22:53 seconds. Are we not doing Mr. Poli yet? No? Okay. We drew for these slots and you
02:22:59 drew number three so thank you there you go. Canadians are tired of legacy 1.00
02:23:05 politicians that will say anything to get elected. Wokeism and cancelled
02:23:10 culture are robbing people of their voices. Our Charter of Rights needs to be
02:23:15 defended. As your leader I pledge to work tirelessly to heal our institutions and
02:23:22 win back the trust of Canadians but I can't do it alone. I hope you will join
02:23:28 this movement to restore our declining democracy and return prosperity to Canada
02:23:36 because only then will we remain glorious and free. Thank you very much
02:23:43 Dr. Lewis and Mr. Chiray. Thank you Tom. There are millions of Canadians who are
02:23:49 orphans in this country right now. They're political orphans and they are
02:23:53 looking for a national alternative and a conservative alternative. We need to be
02:23:58 that party. I want to lead that party. I want to unite the party and I want to offer a national
02:24:05 vision not based on anger, not based on tearing down institutions, but on building our country.
02:24:13 We are the most privileged citizens in the world. We won the lottery of citizenship.
02:24:18 We should be living up to that aspiration, passing on to our children the country that we received
02:24:24 from our parents it is your responsibility and mine to do that and as leader of the conservative
02:24:29 party of canada i will give you a national majority government thank you mr shere uh mr paulia
02:24:38 people feel like they've lost control of their lives elderly people who have to choose between
02:24:43 heating and eating single moms who can no longer afford sporting for their kids full of grown adults 0.85
02:24:50 stuck in their parents' basement, not able to start a family or build home equity for the future. 0.98
02:24:56 Inflation out of control at a 30-year high, and a government that instead of hearing these concerns
02:25:01 tries to censor them by cracking down on the population.
02:25:05 I'm running for Prime Minister to put you back in control of your life by making Canada the freest nation on Earth,
02:25:11 by removing the gatekeepers so that we can build more homes for our young people,
02:25:15 unleash opportunity for our energy workers reduce our energy costs so
02:25:19 everyone can go where they want and heat their home make this the country that is
02:25:23 the freest on earth so you can take back control of your life thank you thank
02:25:27 you mr. Polyev and final word goes to Roman Bavor thank you my name is Roman
02:25:34 Bavor I was born in a communist regime and I'm very scared for what is happening
02:25:37 to Canada's democracy and I'm running to become Prime Minister so I can defend
02:25:41 Canada's democracy. With me, what you hear is what you get. For the last two years
02:25:45 I've been standing here trying to defend Canadians because I'm not afraid to say
02:25:51 what I believe. I'm not afraid of cancel culture or the left-wing lockdown mob. I
02:25:55 love Canada and I love Canadians and you can always count on me to defend you and
02:26:00 your family. No matter how hard it gets, you will always know where I stand. I ask
02:26:06 that you become eligible to vote at joinroman.ca and that you rank me number one thank you so much
02:26:13 for welcoming all of us tonight thank you candidates very much it was a challenging format
02:26:21 but i think that we uh we did well i just want everybody to know that you will all be the band
02:26:27 we're getting the band back together again on may 25th in laval quebec for the french debate
02:26:31 You can all tune into that as well.
02:26:34 On behalf of myself, I just want to thank all of you
02:26:38 for a superb debate tonight, an exchange of ideas.
02:26:43 As I said, good, passionate debate
02:26:46 is the lifeblood of good democracy.
02:26:49 Thank you all very much.
02:26:50 Ladies and gentlemen, that is tonight's debate.
02:27:01 Thank you.
02:27:31 Well, that was the last leadership debate.
02:27:55 I don't know about you guys,
02:27:56 but I think I'd rather watch the one
02:27:58 that Candice Malcolm and Jamil Giovanni hosted for the next 10 hours
02:28:02 and watched another half hour of that one.
02:28:04 So the first topic to discuss with the debate should never be the format,
02:28:13 but I think we'd be remiss to jump over that.
02:28:16 So let's start with that.
02:28:17 I'm Harley Sims, Senior Editor with True North.
02:28:20 We're joined by Elie Kenton-Nantel, who's one of our reporters,
02:28:24 and Harrison Faulkner, producer and reporter as well.
02:28:27 So Elie, let's start with you.
02:28:29 Let's talk about this format.
02:28:31 Go.
02:28:32 Well, I've seen a few debates since getting interested in politics,
02:28:36 and I do have to say that it was probably the worst that I've seen
02:28:39 in terms of this format.
02:28:40 I thought the format wasn't very good.
02:28:42 It was quite subpar.
02:28:44 The rules, like the no clapping, that didn't make a lot of sense.
02:28:47 I feel as part of a democracy, like clapping and seeing people
02:28:50 agreeing with policies is important.
02:28:52 The time they had to answer was also way too short.
02:28:54 like people have to have time to express their ideas if politics is about 15 second pitches and
02:28:59 i think that's a problem that needs to be addressed we need to have longer conversations
02:29:04 about policy ideas not just 15 seconds clips that maybe will look good on a facebook post
02:29:12 yeah i mean i think we need more than 15 seconds to discuss the fundamental issues of our country
02:29:17 and our democracy absolutely harrison what do you think well where do you start harley it's uh
02:29:23 it was really it was really quite embarrassing i think for um people who take these sorts of
02:29:29 things very seriously canadians who want to actually hear who the potential next leader of
02:29:35 our country is and what they have to say and the way that it was moderated the way that it was
02:29:39 formatted was was horrendous it's so bad in fact that the moderator who i thought was incredibly
02:29:45 poor couldn't even keep up with his own rules i mean he had to ask the candidates on stage
02:29:50 what the rules were so he could he could follow along himself and i think one thing that just
02:29:55 jumped out at me was on top of the fact that obviously most conservative party members were
02:30:00 let down by that debate they didn't even touch on housing which i think is a key issue in this
02:30:05 entire uh campaign and also the front runner didn't get to speak for the last 45 minutes of
02:30:13 the debate because the way the format worked out he had something to say he had something
02:30:17 challenge the uh the person who i think most would agree that is in second place john charay
02:30:22 that's pierre paulia but he went back and forth with john charay and then he lost the rest of
02:30:26 his chance to speak so he couldn't even speak for the last 45 minutes of the debate and i think it
02:30:30 was a huge waste yeah i was watching it um and i i couldn't understand why uh pierre paulia wasn't
02:30:38 speaking towards the end and then i had to be reminded he right he'd run out of paddle points
02:30:42 because people in the audience had cheered him and he was personally punished for that so i think
02:30:47 you're right like what is this this is this a democracy or dictatorship i think you're
02:30:50 you're right on with that uh but but let's get past that i mean uh the the format's taken up
02:30:55 enough of our time so uh how do you think though the performances went um you know they didn't have
02:31:01 a lot of time to go face to face with things i think uh the moderator tom clark kind of steered
02:31:06 them in the directions he wanted but as far as their ability to to debate ideas how do you think
02:31:11 that went early well i do have to say i wasn't as impressed as i thought i would be with certain
02:31:17 candidates i mean of course i think just like the last debate the one that really stands out
02:31:21 is roman babber and it's uh because of his ideas roman babber has very kind of wealth
02:31:26 thought through ideas he uh has said the same thing since uh when he came out against the
02:31:32 lockdowns i mean i want to remind everybody that roman babber uh was kicked out of the pc doug
02:31:37 for his caucus when he opposed his lockdowns and then stood in the legislature and fought for the
02:31:43 reopening of Ontario, fought for unvaccinated people that wanted to lose their jobs. Meanwhile,
02:31:47 I don't personally recall Pierre Polyèvre saying anything while O'Toole was clamping down on the
02:31:52 civil liberties caucus that MPs like Marilyn Gladoux tried to form. So I think, again,
02:31:58 Roman came up as very genuine. I will also give a bit of credit to Jean Charest. While I don't agree
02:32:05 with some of his policies for someone his age he he is very charismatic he's very passionate and and
02:32:12 i for also somebody who is not anglophone he's like me he's french canadian he expressed himself
02:32:17 i thought very well tonight i agree i think baber came out on top actually just uh he didn't miss
02:32:24 any opportunities to get some punches in yeah he stood up for the freedom convoy pointed out
02:32:29 everything had been debunked he didn't seem afraid to make a stand for anything so i definitely agree
02:32:34 with you there uh harrison how do you think the candidates did who do you think came out on top
02:32:38 and who do you think uh came out near the bottom yeah well i i it's it's a shame um because i do
02:32:45 hold leslie lewis in high regard i do think that she is an is an important figure in the
02:32:49 conservative party but i was disappointed by her debate performance tonight i thought that
02:32:54 um it was a little rocky and that she didn't sound very confident in what she had to say now
02:32:59 Now, in regards to Roman Babber's performance, as we talked about in the pre-show, Roman Babber is clearly the breakaway surprise of this campaign.
02:33:09 And even on the issues where you don't expect him to perhaps put forward the best policy, I thought, for example, on the northern issues and his ideas for developing the north, I was actually quite surprised to hear his take on it.
02:33:26 And it appears to me that, as Ellie said, he's got all of the key issues that he was asked about today well thought through.
02:33:35 He's deeply thought about these issues and has come forward.
02:33:39 Now, I also think that Patrick Brown didn't shake up the debate as much as I think people were expecting him to,
02:33:46 given that he was not at the first debate and the way that his campaign has sort of taken the direction it has.
02:33:53 I think a lot of people were expecting him to throw some more shots to some of the candidates.
02:33:58 Obviously, he went after Pierre quite strong.
02:34:02 But I also just think that it was a missed opportunity.
02:34:05 Because of the format, we weren't able to hear a really good exchange between Patrick Brown and Pierre Polyev.
02:34:12 The only good exchange we got was between Jean Charest and Pierre Polyev.
02:34:15 And Pierre was the only person to land a zinger, which I think is going to be the lasting clip of the debate.
02:34:21 i i agree uh i guess i would go to um what stood out i mean it's it's tough to tweeze anything
02:34:31 really you know scintillating out of that debate uh one thing that stood out for me though where
02:34:35 uh parapoly have really stood out was when he was answering the question about uh blocking
02:34:41 critical infrastructure and uh he actually took issue with the question which i thought was great
02:34:47 He said, you know, you know, you guys, you're grouping these all into one thing.
02:34:51 You're calling them all blockades.
02:34:52 You're calling the freedom convoy blockade the same thing as the attacks on LNG sites in northern B.C.
02:34:59 And, you know, that's not right.
02:35:00 And you and the legacy media keep pretending it's all the same thing.
02:35:03 That, for me, stood out.
02:35:05 I know there were some other things.
02:35:07 But, Eli, what were some moments in that debate that actually stood out for you that way?
02:35:11 Well, Harley, I think I agree with you that that definitely stood out.
02:35:16 I mean, the moderator called the Freedom Convoy in Ottawa an occupation, which is personally
02:35:21 as somebody who covered it, not how I refer to that, the Freedom Convoy, I thought it
02:35:26 was a peaceful protest.
02:35:28 When it comes to things that stood out, there's that moment, I think, too, the whole exchange
02:35:33 on the crypto and the Bitcoin was pretty interesting.
02:35:36 And when Roman said, why do we have career politicians giving us investment advice?
02:35:42 I thought that was a pretty fair point.
02:35:43 But again, I do have to kind of go back to the format. What really stood out to me were these questions about what book people read or what music they listen to. I kind of had almost had to like pinch myself like, is this for real? Because there's so many pressing issues going on in Canadian society right now. And things like that stood out because to me, this downplayed the seriousness of Canadian democracy.
02:36:09 Yeah. Not only what are you reading, what are you binge watching? You're right. I couldn't
02:36:13 believe this. There are people who have committed suicide due to the government response to the
02:36:18 pandemic and the effects it's had on them. Kids have lost two years of schooling. Their grades
02:36:23 have plummeted. Diseases of despair. This is not something to have fun with. So I completely agree
02:36:28 with you there. Harrison, what stood out for you? Well, I mean, the unfortunate reality is that
02:36:35 Ellie is right. The fact that the moderator, the organizer of this debate, which was the
02:36:40 Conservative Party, which I think is something that I think a lot of Conservative members should
02:36:45 take issue with. They tried to get the candidates to explain the biggest threat to Canada and to
02:36:51 Canadians in 15 seconds. And to me, as you said, Harley, it makes a mockery of the suffering,
02:36:59 the real suffering that Canadians have had to go through unnecessarily, I would say,
02:37:05 throughout the past few years, it makes a mockery of the hard work that a lot of people
02:37:12 are trying to do to help the country get on the right path. Yeah, you know, it's really
02:37:18 disappointing because we know from watching the Canada Strong and Free Network debate
02:37:24 moderated by Candace Malcolm and Jamil Giovanni, we know exactly, well, first of all, we knew we're
02:37:29 going to get before that, which is going to be a good debate on the issues that allows the candidates
02:37:33 to have a legitimate back and forth in a conversation and we know that's what we're
02:37:37 going to get with the independent press gallery debate but the candidates have to go through
02:37:41 another one of these uh party-led debates this time in french and based off of this performance
02:37:46 i'm afraid unless it might be people like you ellie but i don't know how many people are going
02:37:50 to tune into the french i think i i think based on the last two french debates of the last two
02:37:56 leadership races uh the french debates tend to uh have a reputation for not being of quality
02:38:03 uh i'm not sure what the french level of all the candidates are i know that some of them who
02:38:07 struggled last time like leslie lewis has been improving her french but uh i will just say i i
02:38:14 do not look forward to watching french debates in the leadership race because to see people butcher
02:38:19 your your your maiden language it is somewhat disappointing people are running for the prime
02:38:27 minister at least their mother tongue french that's great but when you want to be when you
02:38:31 want to be prime minister and you can't even speak one of our official languages i think that
02:38:37 personally that kind of like disqualifies you well as far as the book question go i don't think
02:38:43 you can go too wrong with jordan peterson i just wonder why he took so long to read it that book's
02:38:48 has been out for a while now. But I mean, let's face it, people are watching True North's coverage
02:38:54 of this. They know what's going on here. So why don't we just get right down to it and talk about
02:38:59 the issues that were brought up for debate? I mean, Candace and Jamil hosted a great debate
02:39:05 at the Strong and Free Conference. They got into the issues of civil liberties and
02:39:08 costs of living. And these are the issues that the conservative leadership candidates want to
02:39:13 talk about themselves because they matter and we know they matter. So give me an example of some
02:39:19 of the issues that they were steered to talk about that kind of expose the kind of, I guess,
02:39:25 the line of thinking of the moderator and why we should probably look to better opportunities to
02:39:33 understand their positions in the future. Well, I think right off the bat, the very first question
02:39:39 of the debate, which is when everyone's paying attention, could have been about these issues
02:39:43 that conservatives really care about, that they really want to know about.
02:39:46 But instead, it was an odd question about whether they would impose a no-fly zone over
02:39:53 Ukraine, which I think no one except for Patrick Brown disagreed with.
02:39:59 Everyone was in agreement on that.
02:40:01 I think most people would be, that would be an unnecessary maneuver.
02:40:04 Again, it shows you that, I honestly believe, part of me wants to think that they chose
02:40:11 questions that conservative voters, frankly, weren't interested in. And they forced the
02:40:17 candidates to avoid getting into the issues that they care about. And I can't understand why,
02:40:21 because to lead the debate off with a question about whether they would impose a no-fly zone
02:40:25 over Ukraine, when we've just spent the last, what was it, the last 10 minutes or so explaining
02:40:31 exactly what the issues Canadians are facing are, shows to you, Harley, that they never had
02:40:37 any real intention of giving conservative voters what they wanted, a debate on the serious problems
02:40:43 that are facing Canadians. I think the only time that anyone veered into it, Pierre Pauly veered
02:40:48 into just briefly the central bank digital currencies and the digital encroachment on the
02:40:54 lives of Canadians. That could have led to a great conversation about some of the issues that a lot
02:40:59 of people are worried about, digital ID, things like this, giving Canadians their own sovereignty
02:41:05 back but instead of course it just goes back to um what paris climate targets and ukraine no fly
02:41:12 zones it's it was a huge disappointment no lee you put out a good story today you went to a
02:41:19 parliamentary press conference and you asked a liberal minister about uh whether or not they
02:41:24 would uh let unvaccinated u.s women into canada to have abortions because of course uh the trudeau
02:41:31 government declared that if the Roe v. Wade is overturned, they would welcome American women up
02:41:36 here to have their abortions. So you asked them, what about unvaccinated women? What about women 0.83
02:41:40 from marginalized communities who disproportionately access abortion services? I mean, 0.97
02:41:47 these are all gotcha issues. I mean, what do you think is the reason that they keep bringing this
02:41:53 issue up and throwing it in conservatives' laps? When does it end? What's the point?
02:41:57 Well, I think as somebody who is personally pro-life, I always kind of find it disappointing, the lack of courage to take on this issue head on.
02:42:09 I mean, I believe that you could be pro-life and promise to reduce abortion in Canada without banning abortions, because there's a lot of abortions that are taking place due to economic factors or social factors that I think the government could try to improve.
02:42:23 the liberals have created such a stigma around this issue where, I mean, we saw it Andrew Scheer.
02:42:29 Andrew Scheer said that he would not bring in any abortion regulation. He said he was personally
02:42:35 pro-life, but he made it very clear that he would not do that. And they basically made it seem as
02:42:41 you were not allowed to even be personally pro-life. So I think liberals are taking advantage
02:42:48 of conservatives here because a lot of conservative leaders lack conviction. And even, you know, I will
02:42:51 give some criticism to Pierre Pellievre. Pierre Pellievre is very outspoken on a lot of issues.
02:42:59 He talks about a lot of issues, just says it like it is. But when it comes to this issue,
02:43:03 he never said, I am pro-choice. He said, I support free choice or I will not be open.
02:43:07 But Jean Charest tried to make him say, I'm pro-choice and he couldn't. Pierre Pellievre
02:43:11 had a pro-life voting record for many years as an MP. I have friends who go to the same
02:43:17 Catholic churchism, suddenly he says he's pro-choice. To me, this is, again, he is falling
02:43:23 into this trap. He's got to be honest with people where he stands. And I think politicians should
02:43:28 be able to state their personal conviction. It comes off as more genuine to say, look,
02:43:33 I'm pro-life, but I do not want to divide this country at a time where it's already divided and
02:43:38 bring in more polarizing policies like what's going on in the United States. We will focus on
02:43:42 canadians and improving life i think they like asking us these questions because they like to
02:43:48 watch conservatives squirm uh it's the same thing with uh the with the uh you know carbon taxes we
02:43:55 live out here in bc they keep raising the taxes climate uh carbon keeps uh rates uh keep going up
02:44:02 it's not working right but they want to see people say the right things they put them they put the
02:44:06 crosshairs on them i'm just getting noticed that we're about ready to head over to the scrums
02:44:11 uh our uh colleague andrew lawton will be asking the candidates uh questions um i'm going to see
02:44:19 if we're about ready to go there um not quite yet uh harrison yeah i'll just say yeah i'll just say
02:44:30 that ellie was bringing up a point and you harley touched on it about making conservatives struggle
02:44:36 in front of the camera, forcing conservatives into the liberal debate. Instead of setting the
02:44:42 debate ourselves, very few conservatives have the courage and the fortitude to stand on the
02:44:47 principles that they believe in. Instead, they'd much prefer just to basically fall in line with
02:44:54 the legacy media, fall in line with the liberals. And it's very obvious, you know, there was nobody
02:45:01 on the stage. Lesley Lewis is very open and admits her pro-life stance. But then when it comes down
02:45:09 to defending it with strength, no one can really defend it with strength. And it's an example of
02:45:14 conservatives constantly losing the cultural battle of setting the debate and setting the tone.
02:45:20 Until such time as conservatives can regain the cultural ground and set our own debate and set
02:45:27 own tone uh we're gonna forever be in the shadow uh of the liberals and we're gonna dance to their
02:45:32 tune just like they want us to yeah that's very well said that's i i don't know i agree it's very
02:45:38 well said uh i guess uh from there i think i would ask which which issues were completely avoided in
02:45:46 this i never heard a you know things like globalist organizations brought up i mean i know the legacy
02:45:51 media likes to call it all conspiracy theories. But what else were some issues that were not
02:45:58 brought up at all that you think were things that the conservative audiences really wanted to hear
02:46:04 about? Billy? Well, I mean, this debate was taking place in Western Canada. I worked in Western
02:46:11 Canada for a year last year, and I saw a great deep alienation. I personally did not see a lot
02:46:17 discussion about this. I wish they would have talked more about Western issues. People in the
02:46:24 West have lost complete hope and faith in Ottawa and in Eastern Canadian institutions. And it's
02:46:31 a big problem. I didn't realize how serious it was until I flew to Alberta and stepped foot on the
02:46:38 ground. Sorry, Ali. I like nothing more than seeing a Quebecer stick up for the West, but I 0.60
02:46:43 think we're up. Scott Aitchison is up and we're going to throw to Andrew Lawton. Thanks a lot.
02:46:47 Sounds good.
02:47:13 Please vote in French and English.
02:47:26 How can Conservatives win if they don't have an environmental plan,
02:47:30 if their members don't vote for a motion recognizing climate change?
02:47:37 Well, I think you're referring actually to an event that occurred during our last convention.
02:47:43 And the situation is a little more different than what you've just described.
02:47:47 In fact, what that motion did was amend a motion that was kind of poorly worded,
02:47:52 but does in fact acknowledge climate change exists, and the amendment itself was poorly worded.
02:47:56 So in our materials, in our policy documents, we do in fact acknowledge that climate change does exist.
02:48:05 It is a reality.
02:48:06 And I think you heard tonight some great ideas about how we can move forward with a credible climate change plan
02:48:12 that doesn't actually punish the most vulnerable in our society.
02:48:14 But how can Conservatives win on the environmental plan
02:48:18 if those members are not backing up any kind of plan on climate change?
02:48:22 And if you can also try to answer in French, please.
02:48:24 I think they do, in fact, agree that climate change is a reality,
02:48:29 and it already is in our policy documents,
02:48:31 that it is something that exists and that we need to address it.
02:48:34 So, sorry, and I'm not going to be able to answer that in French now.
02:48:37 Is it one or two?
02:48:39 We're just pulling by now.
02:48:42 Hi, Mr. Acheson, Celine Gallus for Rebel News.
02:48:51 The Liberals have imposed a backdoor gun registry through an order in council
02:48:56 which changes regulations to require retailers and sellers to collect data on purchasers.
02:49:01 New rules come into force May 18th. Will you commit to repealing these?
02:49:06 I will. Canada has among the most regulated firearms industry in the world.
02:49:10 The problem that we have in this country is the issue of illegal guns coming across our border and getting into the hands of gangs.
02:49:18 That's a much difficult challenge to deal with.
02:49:22 And you see the Liberals time and again using firearms and legal law-abiding firearms owners in this country as a whipping tool
02:49:29 to try to lather up their base and generate votes while not dealing with the real issues.
02:49:36 It's the wrong approach for Canada.
02:49:38 What we need to do is address the real problem, not not demonize law-abiding firearms owners.
02:49:58 We're good? Great. Thanks very much.
02:50:08 Good evening, Andrew Lawton, True North.
02:50:33 You've been unequivocally against vaccine mandates.
02:50:36 that obviously includes mandates for public sector workers if you were prime minister would you
02:50:41 rehire anyone who was fired because of vaccine mandates and if so would you give them retroactive
02:50:47 pay for time they missed uh so 100 i would mandate i i try to pass similar legislation in ontario the
02:50:53 jobs and jabs act that would retroactively protect workers we have to think about how we're going to
02:50:58 go about that we certainly want to try and put them in the position that they would have otherwise
02:51:03 been. I'm not sure if we're going to do that through EI. I'm also not sure how we're going to
02:51:06 go about that when it comes to those that are not unionized. Those that are unionized should be
02:51:11 a lot easier. Those that are not unionized, going to have to give that some thought. But
02:51:14 I think that it's inhumane to make someone choose between their ability to put food on the table
02:51:19 and their personal health care choice. We've got to do right by all Canadians.
02:51:23 As a follow-up, there are a number of legal challenges against the Emergencies Act, vaccine
02:51:28 passports, vaccine mandates. A lot of these are going to take years and years to litigate. They
02:51:33 could span into another government. What directive would you give on these legal challenges if you
02:51:38 were prime minister? So I know what I would do, which is I would outlaw all mandates and passports 0.99
02:51:46 and those that are beyond the reach of the federal government. I would be very, very hard on the
02:51:51 provinces that allow for any semblance of that in place. I will not permit 21st century segregation in Canada.
02:52:06 Sidney Fisard with Rebel News. Former Conservative Party heritage critic MP Alan Reyes actually pushed for more censorship from the government.
02:52:12 Sorry, I can't hear you, sir.
02:52:14 Sorry.
02:52:14 Okay. Former Conservative Party heritage critic MP Alan Reyes actually pushed for more censorship from the government, calling out the Falun Gong-founded Epoch Times by name, calling it a conspiracy site.
02:52:27 Now the party opposes Trudeau's call to regulate the Internet. What changed, and why didn't you speak sooner?
02:52:33 I apologize. I'm having difficulties hearing you, but I think I understand that, General, Toner, your question.
02:52:38 Look, I think that there is no freedom of speech in Canada without a free and independent media.
02:52:42 And that means that we need to stop subsidizing mainstream media, we need to stop the bailouts, we need to defund the CBC, and also we should not having some sort of lip-intest test by government bureaucrats saying who's a journalist and who's not a journalist.
02:53:01 I think that independent media provides available perspective and it should be encouraged.
02:53:12 Hello, Rachel Emanuel with the Western Standard.
02:53:24 Mr. Baber, you had a news release today about ending equalization payments.
02:53:27 I'm wondering how you think this will bode with voters in central and eastern Canada?
02:53:31 Yeah, I think it's time to end dependency and equalization.
02:53:37 Equalization is basically redistribution, and I'm against redistribution.
02:53:41 And look, I'm not satisfied that any province can come to the table and say that they're
02:53:46 unable to provide an equal, a comparable level of services given what their succession now
02:53:51 is at this time.
02:53:53 And should there not be able to be, I would like to work with them in terms of enabling
02:53:58 them and empowering them.
02:54:00 And that begins with unleashing their natural resources.
02:54:04 I would propose that we work together to make our nation the natural resources superpower
02:54:10 that we ought to be sure you've been speaking a lot about equalization payments and making canada
02:54:15 natural resource superpower i'm wondering you know you're clearly appealing to the west here i'm
02:54:18 wondering if you think your focus on western issues will make other candidates really take
02:54:22 alberta seriously and bring those issues to the forefront for them as well look of course we
02:54:28 appreciate regional disparity and and we appreciate the effect of equalization on on various provinces
02:54:33 But I believe that my plan to empower our entire country to develop our natural resources stems beyond
02:54:42 the Western provinces. We see Newfoundland, for instance, that used to be a have-not province that no longer receives equalization.
02:54:51 Brian Higgins, the premier of New Brunswick a couple of years ago, came out against equalization.
02:54:57 And so I think that we can accomplish this coast to coast.
02:55:00 we can unite behind the fact that we should make ourselves more competitive
02:55:04 and encourage economic opportunity rather than dependency.
02:55:08 Thank you very much, everyone.
02:55:11 Mr. Baber? Hi.
02:55:15 I got one for you. The same as for Mr. Aitchison.
02:55:19 I'm Audrey with Nervy with French CBC.
02:55:22 How do you think that Conservatives can win on the environmental aspect
02:55:26 if a majority of their members vote against a motion recognizing climate change?
02:55:32 Look, I think it's important that we recognize what the membership thinks,
02:55:37 but at the same time, I think that we need to have a pragmatic approach to the environment.
02:55:41 I do not believe that taxing Sally $10 at the gas pump is going to move climate change.
02:55:48 And I think that making life more affordable for Canadians
02:55:53 is not something that they would seek to do at this time.
02:55:56 I think that we need to be clear about where we stand on this, and I'm comfortable taking it to the general election.
02:56:03 Thank you.
02:56:26 I was going to ask the same thing, if everyone can just look forward, even though we're
02:56:41 the ones asking the questions.
02:56:43 I'm curious for your thoughts on the format of this debate.
02:56:45 It was a bit unique, and in some cases, there was only 15, 30, 45 seconds to answer questions.
02:56:51 In your opinion, was that enough, or did you feel sort of handcuffed, like you weren't
02:56:54 able to fully get your thoughts across well I guess you never have enough time
02:56:58 to get in everything you want to say but I thought we were able to cover a lot of
02:57:02 topics so it was a fun night and appreciated the opportunity to have a
02:57:07 feisty discussion tonight
02:57:16 Sheila Gunn-Reed Rebel News you have given some confusing statements around
02:57:21 moving the embassy to Jerusalem will you commit to moving the Canadian embassy to
02:57:29 the Israeli capital of Jerusalem no I will not move the embassy I support the
02:57:33 position that was articulated under Stephen Harper's government which was
02:57:37 not to move the government as it would make the peace process more difficult
02:57:42 and a second question you have said that now is not the right time to raise the
02:57:48 carbon tax. However, you have been a proponent of the carbon tax. So when then would be the
02:57:54 right time to raise the carbon tax? So I don't support raising the carbon tax, period. And I
02:57:59 believe that we should respect provincial jurisdiction. What I would say is I think
02:58:04 there needs to be a serious conversation about carbon tariffs at the border, given the fact that
02:58:09 we continue to see product dumped in Canada from China and India that competes with Canadian goods
02:58:16 and, frankly, product that doesn't have the same environmental or labour standards.
02:58:21 Hi, Stephanie Taylor with the Canadian Press.
02:58:24 You're going after Mr. Paglia for policies that he's actually not talking about.
02:58:28 The 2015 campaign was a long time ago.
02:58:31 He's not talking about things like in the Cobb ban.
02:58:33 He apologised for the comment he made about the residential school settlement.
02:58:38 Why are you bringing this up, and why do you think Conservatives today want to be reminded of this? 0.73
02:58:45 Well, frankly, I don't believe Mr. Polyev is electable, particularly in suburban Canada.
02:58:50 And these policies, these discriminatory policies still haunt the party.
02:58:54 Look at the results in the last three federal elections in suburban Canada.
02:58:58 We've been blown out for policies that Pierre Polyev refuses to disavow.
02:59:05 And some more recently, the vote where he refused to condemn hate against Muslims and Islamophobia,
02:59:10 that was only a few years ago.
02:59:11 And so, unfortunately for Mr. Polyev, his voting record and his past make it very difficult for him to be a champion of religious freedom,
02:59:20 which I believe is important if you're going to make breakthroughs in suburban Canada.
02:59:26 As a follow-up, it seems that your campaign, and correct me if I'm wrong, is so focused on bringing in new members.
02:59:32 You're not necessarily talking to the grassroots.
02:59:35 You skipped out on the Manning conference last week.
02:59:37 Didn't seem that necessarily your message was resonating that much with people in this room. If you become the leader
02:59:43 How do you expect to be able to stay in the role when you have so few support within caucus and within the existing membership?
02:59:50 So first of all, I'd say we're very encouraged by the
02:59:54 Support in the existing caucus and and also within the existing membership. We're gonna do just fine
02:59:59 Amongst existing members, but my point is we need to grow the tent if we're gonna win
03:00:04 I'm not interested in a fourth losing election I want to make sure and I'm
03:00:08 laser focused on this that we're electable in suburban Canada electable
03:00:12 in the corners of the country where we've lost and to do that we need to
03:00:16 grow the size of our party to make sure our party reflects the beautiful mosaic
03:00:20 of the country you know I've gone into riding associations in seats where we
03:00:24 have a hundred members there's no chance you can win a seat when you have no
03:00:28 connectivity with the communities in that riding and so that's what I plan to
03:00:32 change to make sure we have the type of infrastructure that I developed provincially in the 905 where
03:00:38 frankly the the PCs were able to sweep because we built real meaningful relationships and
03:00:43 infrastructure in rodings that had a strong liberal foothold. Bonjour M. Brown, Audrey Neveu
03:00:49 de Radio-Canada. Comment est-ce que vous croyez que le Parti conservateur peut gagner sur le plan
03:00:54 environnemental si une majorité de ses membres vote contre une motion qui reconnaît l'existence
03:01:00 I think it's important to have a full policy that understands that there is a crisis in our country, but in the same time, to support the challenges where we can fight climate change.
03:01:22 J'ai, à Brampton, avec notre système de transport, j'ai un record où je vais faire ça.
03:01:30 Et c'est sauf les nouveaux impôts, c'est avec les nouvelles technologies.
03:01:35 Mais en tant que chef du Parti conservateur, est-ce que vous mettriez de l'avant une plateforme plus forte pour la lutte contre les changements climatiques?
03:01:44 Je pense que tu peux faire le deux.
03:01:46 Now, with the Liberals, they talk a lot about climate change, but every time there is a
03:01:55 gap, they lack gaps. I think it's important to see a Conservative Party
03:02:03 support the two challenges, the sustainability and in the same way to fight climate change.
03:02:16 Thank you.
03:02:39 Good evening, Andrew Lawton, True North.
03:02:41 Earlier today, the Correctional Service of Canada
03:02:43 confirmed its policy that biologically male inmates can be reassigned to women's prisons
03:02:50 based on preference alone. I was wondering what you think about that policy and if you would
03:02:54 reverse that as Prime Minister. Well I think it's very important that people whatever their gender
03:03:02 has a certain level of comfort in certain situations. I also think that there are situations
03:03:10 where biological females may feel a sense of vulnerability
03:03:18 because of the situations that they may have been in,
03:03:23 for example, if they were sexually assaulted by a male, et cetera.
03:03:28 And so we have to make sure that we find compassionate ways
03:03:32 to accommodate the diversity of individuals that will find themselves in a facility,
03:03:43 whether it is a shelter or whether it is a correctional facility.
03:03:48 You were the only candidate tonight on a question about abortion to say that you were pro-life.
03:03:54 Do you have confidence that if any one of your opponents on this stage were the leader of the Conservative Party,
03:03:58 that you would have a place and have the latitude to express your values as a Conservative MP?
03:04:04 Well, I would hope that everyone that's speaking about how important freedom is would honour that.
03:04:10 And I think it's very important that in a free and democratic society that MPs are not forced to vote against their conscience.
03:04:19 And so I'm confident that the individuals on the stage, I'm confident and I'm hoping sincerely that because they believe in our charter, they believe in freedom, that they will also believe in the right to have free votes.
03:04:38 Adam Sose here for Rebel News.
03:04:40 The Allen inquiry found that foreign funding for Canadian-based environmental initiatives totaled $1.28 billion from 2003 to 2019,
03:04:50 most of it largely untraceable, and a substantial amount of it was dedicated to blocking Alberta oil and gas development.
03:04:57 Do you see this as a problem, and if so, what will you do to change it?
03:05:00 Absolutely. I think it's important that we have the courage and conviction to develop our natural resources,
03:05:07 even in the face of foreign interference.
03:05:11 And where we can detect that foreign interference does exist
03:05:17 and that it's preventing us from realizing our potential,
03:05:23 building pipelines, developing our natural resources,
03:05:26 getting our product to market, offsetting foreign dictator oil,
03:05:31 we should definitely ensure that those individuals and those organizations are stamped out
03:05:41 and comply with our laws, which means not blocking critical infrastructures.
03:05:51 Hello, Wyatt Claypool from the National Telegraph.
03:05:54 I just wanted to ask what your opinion is on, because a lot of the times the media and other candidates
03:06:00 and just other people in general
03:06:02 make you kind of justify your pro-life positions,
03:06:05 whereas nobody has to justify their opposition to abortion.
03:06:09 And I'm wondering what you feel about the current status of the debate
03:06:13 where people never have to come out and explain
03:06:16 why they're okay with late-term and sex-selective abortion
03:06:19 and whether or not you think you're getting fair treatment on the issue.
03:06:22 I think that's a very good question.
03:06:26 The abortion issue is so polarizing,
03:06:28 And I think it's very important that we get to the point where we could talk about what it is that we agree on.
03:06:37 The media, I believe, is just genuinely curious with someone who has the conviction to come out and say,
03:06:44 yes, I'm pro-life.
03:06:46 And because of cancelled culture, many people are afraid to say what they stand for.
03:06:54 I think that it's important to recognize that whether you're pro-life or pro-choice,
03:06:58 that we can have conversations and we can find things that we agree on.
03:07:03 And because it's such a polarizing issue, it's important that we start by looking at what it is that we agree on.
03:07:12 Hi, Ms. Lewis. Stephanie Taylor with the Canadian Press.
03:07:14 Pierre Polyev said he would fire the Bank of Canada governor.
03:07:18 Do you agree with him? Do you support? Would you do the same?
03:07:20 I'm very concerned about any speech on behalf of an elected official that undermines credibility in our economic system.
03:07:34 And I don't agree that members of Parliament should be meddling in the Bank of Canada.
03:07:43 The Bank of Canada has long-term plans in Parliament.
03:07:49 Their budgets are of a short-term nature.
03:07:52 I respect the division of powers there.
03:07:56 I respect the Bank of Canada having the capacity and their officials having the capacity to make long-term projections that are not based on partisanship.
03:08:13 That's time. Thank you.
03:08:15 Thank you.
03:08:17 Mrs. Lewis, can I ask a question? Same as the others.
03:08:21 Yeah, it was five minutes. They're each doing five. Sorry.
03:08:24 Oh, I would have asked the same question as the others.
03:08:43 Thank you.
03:09:13 Audrey Neveu de Radio-Canada.
03:09:15 Si vous pouvez regarder après vers la caméra,
03:09:17 ça aidera tous les réseaux de télévision.
03:09:19 Vous savez, le son est très mauvais dans cette salle-là.
03:09:21 Le son était mauvais ce soir.
03:09:23 Alors, ça n'a pas aidé, mais allez-y.
03:09:25 Alors, vous voulez que je regarde votre caméra,
03:09:27 mais c'est où votre caméra?
03:09:29 Monsieur Charest, comment...
03:09:33 Just pull cameras right down the middle.
03:09:36 D'accord. OK, I got it.
03:09:38 That's fine.
03:09:40 Monsieur Charest, comment est-ce que vous croyez
03:09:41 Do you think the Conservatives can win on the environmental plan if a majority of members vote against a motion that recognizes the existence of climate change?
03:09:51 Well, the course of leadership is a choice. And, just, it's the opportunity to debate these questions.
03:09:57 And the next chief will, on the basis of the choice which will be made, the process of proceeding with the policies that he or she will propose.
03:10:05 And what will be your plan there-dessus?
03:10:07 Well, I've made public my plan.
03:10:09 My plan, I've made public.
03:10:11 It includes the carbon capture, the hydrogen blue, the green, the blue, the green, the big central nuclear, the biogaz, the renewables.
03:10:26 So, there is a global approach, a approach that allows us to achieve real results.
03:10:30 And above all, I get rid of the tax on the carbon carbon of Mr. Trudeau.
03:10:37 We put in place a tax on the large emitters, which is very constant with what we have done in Quebec,
03:10:42 with the system of exchange permits, with the California one part,
03:10:47 and with the other part, with what is happening in Alberta.
03:10:50 And thirdly, even the Commissioner of the Environment,
03:10:53 And in the meantime, our politics said that Mr. Trudeau's tax was wrong to the PME and
03:11:01 people who were less fortunate.
03:11:03 So, all of that is constant.
03:11:23 bad thing? I'm just wondering what you think. You know, every time there's debate, people look for
03:11:28 formats that is going to give the balance between equal time, fair time, and a debate. And it was an
03:11:35 unusual format. I mean, none of us expected the questions that were a more personal level. So you
03:11:42 do your best when you're on the stage to try to convey what it is that you want to propose. I come
03:11:47 into these debates trying to do that every time and say, at the end of the evening, I'd like folks
03:11:52 to, you know, come away and say, well, this is what Mr. Charest would do if he becomes the leader.
03:11:58 And that's what I believe in.
03:12:00 But I did see something tonight that I have never, ever seen in a debate in my lifetime.
03:12:04 Never, ever have I seen someone flip-flop on stage on something like abortion.
03:12:12 I mean, Mr. Poilievre, to flip-flop in one answer to the other is unprecedented on an issue like that.
03:12:19 I've never seen that happen before.
03:12:20 I think that says a lot about him.
03:12:22 So, Prochain.
03:12:24 Mr. Sherry-Adams-Sos from Rebel News.
03:12:27 I know this is a question you've been asked a number of times, and I completely respect
03:12:31 and appreciate your sentiment that no one should have to apologize for work that they
03:12:35 have done in the past.
03:12:37 But I just wanted to give you an opportunity to address the fact that Huawei was developing 0.99
03:12:41 AI technology to enforce the CCP's social credit system and to identify Uyghurs for 0.99
03:12:47 internment. 0.63
03:12:48 of this do you have any apprehension or criticism of the party aside for of the company aside from
03:12:53 the work that you yourself were doing all the work that i've done in my lifetime has always been
03:12:58 aligned with the interest of canada private public sector period it's that simple and for huawei i
03:13:06 would ban huawei i'm very clear on that and and just to remind you how things evolve it was a
03:13:13 conservative government that brought Huawei into Canada. A conservative
03:13:17 government of which Mr. Poitier was a member of. I mean Huawei was actually a
03:13:21 sponsor on Hockey Night in Canada. So my position is very clear. Thank you.
03:13:29 Good evening. Andrew Lawton, True North. You've said that the convoy is an illegal
03:13:34 blockade. Obviously you've been very open about your position and you've
03:13:38 distanced yourself from other candidates. Could you in good conscience
03:13:42 vote for a candidate in your local riding
03:13:44 that supported the convoy,
03:13:46 given the comments you've made
03:13:47 about how Mr. Polyev's support for the Freedom Convoy
03:13:50 is, in your words, disqualifying?
03:13:52 And Andrew, I'm glad you asked the question
03:13:54 because this whole story has parts to it.
03:13:58 First part is, people do have a right to protest.
03:14:01 There should be no doubt in anyone's mind about that.
03:14:05 Peaceful protest is part of democracy,
03:14:07 and if someone knows about that
03:14:09 because I've been on the other side of it in my lifetime,
03:14:11 it's me.
03:14:12 And I've never, ever questioned that.
03:14:14 So that's the first part.
03:14:16 Second part, you know, the whole mess was very much on Mr. Trudeau.
03:14:21 I mean, how come this happened?
03:14:22 I mean, and by the way, when you return to that whole story, it's just, I mean, it was incredible.
03:14:27 How could the situation degenerate the way it did?
03:14:32 Now, that being said, that is not an excuse for those who go out there and support an illegal blockade.
03:14:39 and when I'm saying that I'm not trying to I am NOT at all criticizing
03:14:44 truckers and people who have their legitimate jobs to who we owe a lot
03:14:48 because during this whole COVID period they stepped up and they did their job
03:14:52 and they deserve nothing less than our very deep respect and gratitude but
03:14:57 illegal blockades at borders or anywhere else but especially borders we lost
03:15:03 hundreds of millions of dollars folks in the automotive industry question
03:15:07 whether they should be investing in Canada.
03:15:09 The American president would have to call up Mr. Trudeau
03:15:11 to ask him whether he needed an American intervention
03:15:13 to clean up a blockade in Canada.
03:15:15 That's embarrassing for us.
03:15:18 My point is simple.
03:15:19 If you have the privilege of being a member of parliament,
03:15:23 you make laws, you change laws,
03:15:25 you can't treat the laws of the land like a buffet table
03:15:28 from which you choose what's popular,
03:15:30 what's popular or non-popular.
03:15:32 And sometimes you have to resist, that's leadership,
03:15:35 what may be popular in the instant for what is a more fundamental principle so
03:15:39 I'm sorry if I went on longer than I usually do and I certainly did in this
03:15:43 debate but I was allowed time to do that thank you Andrew what about the
03:15:50 blockade well it's a hypothetical question I mean we'll we'll get to after
03:15:55 I become leader there'll be plenty of time to debate these things thank you
03:15:58 Andrew. We're out of time. We're out of time. Thank you very much. Merci.
03:16:28 Thank you.
03:16:58 You