Juno News - December 05, 2025


Trump signals MAJOR SHIFT in Canada–U.S. trade deal

Mentioned
Ottawa’s $15B Stellantis gamble just BLEW UP Is Carney Losing His Grip?

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

149.64

Word count

2,760

Sentence count

166

Harmful content

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Could reading certain Bible passages in public soon be considered a criminal act? Well, advocates for religious freedom are sounding the alarm over changes to federal law supposedly aimed at combating hate. Bill C-9 would criminalize sections of the Bible, Quran, Torah, and other sacred texts. Conservatives will oppose this latest liberal assault on freedom of expression and religion.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 The trade is on the agenda as Prime Minister Carney meets with U.S. President Trump in
00:00:09 Washington, D.C. Trump says he will meet with both the leaders of Canada and Mexico today
00:00:14 to talk about the stalled trade negotiations. Here they are standing side by side at the
00:00:20 FIFA 2026 World Cup event. Carney's itinerary includes making a speech at the World Cup
00:00:28 celebration in tree lighting ceremony. He will also meet with Mexican President
00:00:33 Claudia Scheinbaum. Now Trump said this week he may allow the trilateral free trade
00:00:39 agreement between the three countries to lapse in favor of separate deals with
00:00:43 Canada and Mexico. Could reading certain Bible passages in public soon be
00:00:50 considered a criminal act? Well advocates for religious freedom are sounding the
00:00:54 alarm over changes to federal law supposedly aimed at combating hate. Now
00:01:01 this post by conservative party leader Pierre Polyev on X. Liberal and block
00:01:07 amendments to Bill C-9 will criminalize sections of the Bible, Quran, Torah and
00:01:14 other sacred texts. Conservatives will oppose this latest liberal assault on
00:01:19 freedom of expression and religion. Here is Mark Miller, Minister of Canadian
00:01:25 Identity and Culture, talking about sections of the Bible he considers hateful.
00:01:29 Mark Miller, Minister of Canadian Identity and Culture
00:01:30 If someone were literally invoking a passage from, in this case, the Bible, but there are
00:01:34 other religious texts that say the same thing, and somehow constantly say that this is
00:01:40 good faith, I mean, clearly there are situations in these texts where these statements are hateful,
00:01:44 they should not be used to invoke or be a defense, and there should perhaps be
00:01:51 discretion for prosecutors to press charges. Now in her op-ed in the National
00:01:55 Post, Christine Van Gein says changes to Bill C-9 aren't combating hate, they're
00:02:02 criminalizing faith. She writes, we do not want the government parsing religious 0.98
00:02:08 texts or religious speech, especially given that most of our political leaders are 0.81
00:02:13 absolutely ignorant of religion, including, in some cases, their own religion.
00:02:18 John Carpe, President of the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms, will be joining 0.95
00:02:23 us a few minutes from now to talk about that story.
00:02:26 Well, Industry Minister Melanie Jolie has formally served notice to Stellantis that it broke a
00:02:32 legally binding agreement. Let's listen.
00:02:34 I'm formally announcing that we're serving Stellantis with a notice of default under the contracts.
00:02:41 When it comes to protecting auto jobs, we will not let these industries down.
00:02:45 Well, the company announced last October its shifting production from Brampton to Illinois
00:02:51 and cutting 3,000 jobs. This after the government committed billions of dollars in tax money to
00:02:57 the company's manufacturing operation in Canada. Critics say the government has absolutely failed
00:03:03 to secure any commitment to protect those jobs, allowing Stellantis to move its operations south.
00:03:09 Speaking of jobs, Stats Canada is reporting that Canada created 54,000 jobs last month.
00:03:16 Now, the unemployment rate has fallen to 6.5%, all good news, but a closer look at the numbers
00:03:22 reveals most of the new jobs created were part-time. In fact, the country actually lost 9,400 full-time
00:03:29 positions. I'm now joined by John Carpe, President of the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms.
00:03:37 John, welcome to the show.
00:03:39 Glad to be with you, Mark, and with your viewers and listeners.
00:03:42 Let's talk a little bit about Bill C-9. Why is it so dangerous according to those who want
00:03:49 to protect, basically, freedom of religion?
00:03:55 Well, it's a step towards becoming like the United Kingdom, where currently over 30 citizens
00:04:01 are criminally charged every day for what they're posting on social media. Thousands
00:04:06 of people in jail for expressing their opinions about immigration, transgender ideology, controversial
00:04:13 topics. And so it's horrible. What used to be a free country is descending into all these
00:04:20 speech prosecutions. So what Bill C-9 does, the worst aspect of it is it removes a current
00:04:27 requirement that a hate speech prosecution has to be approved first by the attorney general
00:04:33 or the justice minister of the province. And it's kind of a check so that it's not just
00:04:41 the local police, local crown prosecutors who get to decide subjectively what they feel
00:04:46 is hateful. And that's another huge problem is hate is an emotion and it's next to impossible
00:04:52 to define. Bill C-9 tries to say that hate is worse than dislike and disdain. So dislike
00:05:00 and disdain are okay. That's not hate. But detestation and vilification are hate. It's
00:05:06 very, very challenging. So it leaves a lot of power with local police and local prosecutors
00:05:11 if Bill C-9 goes through and they can prosecute. We're going to see all kinds of new hate speech
00:05:16 prosecutions because there's no more review process in place by the justice minister.
00:05:21 Yeah. It's alarming to hear people like Mark Miller, minister for Canadian identity and
00:05:27 culture, talking about sections of the Bible he considers hateful. What did you make of
00:05:33 his statement on that?
00:05:36 So this is another, a new twist in Bill C-9 is that as of the past two or three days,
00:05:42 the liberals who are, of course, in a minority situation, they have made a deal with the Bloc 0.56
00:05:48 Quebecois to make Bill C-9 even worse by getting rid of one of the defenses that has been available
00:05:54 for decades, that if in good faith you are making an argument based on belief in a religious
00:06:01 text, there can be an exemption. Now, that's not a blank check to spew hatred at whoever you
00:06:08 want and then say, oh, well, you know, that's just my religious text. If you're advocating for
00:06:13 hatred, you can't camouflage that with religion. However, this particular defense, the belief in
00:06:21 a religious text defense would and does protect pastors and priests and Orthodox rabbis, Muslim
00:06:29 imams from hate speech prosecutions that are sure to come over what the Torah and the Quran and the
00:06:37 Bible have to say about homosexuality and about sexual intimacy between two people of the same 0.90
00:06:43 sex. This provision protects the religious leaders from getting prosecuted for hate speech
00:06:49 for having taught what their religions teach about human sexuality.
00:06:54 I mean, could the government use this as a pretext to censor parts of the Bible or even ban parts of
00:07:00 the Bible? Is that where they want to go?
00:07:02 The chilling effect is pretty obvious because even if you had a bunch of constitutional lawyers
00:07:09 looking at the legislation carefully and saying, well, you know, technically you still could in
00:07:15 your mosque, your church, your synagogue, your temple, you're still allowed to teach what your
00:07:20 faith teaches about human sexuality without that being hate speech. Even if that's technically true,
00:07:26 it is a chilling effect where people are going to do more of what so many people are already doing,
00:07:34 which is self-censoring, which is very harmful.
00:07:39 I mean, I can see where some of this might be used, say, to target certain imams who've suggested that
00:07:46 murdering people, heathens, or people who do not follow their particular religion might be justifiable. 1.00
00:07:54 But, I mean, considering the history of this government in terms of its views on Christianity,
00:08:00 I mean, all you have to do is look at how little they've commented about the church burnings that we've seen.
00:08:06 You know, a hundred last time I checked, they've said very little of it.
00:08:10 Even people like Justin Trudeau, Gerald Butts have suggested that certain activities are justifiable or
00:08:16 understandable, rather. I don't want to put words in his mouth, but he said it was understandable.
00:08:20 You know, you can't help but get the sense that Christianity will ultimately be the target here. 0.99
00:08:25 What do you think?
00:08:26 I don't see too many Muslim imams getting prosecuted under any legislation.
00:08:32 We already have a situation in Toronto where some Muslims were blocking, I think it was Young and Bloor,
00:08:40 but major intersection to take over a street with prayer meeting.
00:08:44 And to be clear, I strongly support the freedom of every person to pray in public.
00:08:50 If you're standing on a public sidewalk and you want to pray with your eyes open or closed
00:08:55 or whatever your faith might be, you know, that's fine.
00:08:58 But that's not an entitlement to obstruct traffic.
00:09:00 So Chris and Tamara, Chris Barber, Tamara Leach, and so many other peaceful protesters in Ottawa
00:09:07 were charged criminally because it is a crime to obstruct streets.
00:09:11 But here you see the law is not being applied equally when it comes to Muslims in Toronto
00:09:18 blocking the street for a prayer meeting and nobody gets charged.
00:09:23 And it is interesting, when Bill C-9 was introduced, the Justice Minister Sean Fraser said
00:09:28 that this is a response to rising anti-Semitism, Islamophobia, transphobia, homophobia, full stop.
00:09:36 Nothing said about the dozens of Christian churches that have been burned to the ground,
00:09:40 completely destroyed by arson, and then dozens more that have been desecrated and violated.
00:09:45 Nothing said about this obviously very serious problem.
00:09:51 No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
00:09:52 It's anti-Semitism, Islamophobia, transphobia, homophobia.
00:09:56 Nothing said about Christian churches at all.
00:09:59 And that's the mindset of the government.
00:10:01 That's also on the government's website.
00:10:02 These weren't just off-the-cuff remarks from a minister made once.
00:10:07 But the Government of Canada website on Bill C-9 references those four things
00:10:12 and says nothing about churches being burned to the ground.
00:10:16 Amazing.
00:10:16 We've seen attacks on Christians, certainly outside Canada.
00:10:22 All you have to do is look at certain African nations where a form of genocide
00:10:26 may very well be underway in certain countries, the Christian minority.
00:10:32 And then in Canada, you have a guy like Mark Miller, who the minister has come out and said,
00:10:37 well, I am a Christian.
00:10:38 I'm a devout Christian.
00:10:39 As if that's somehow supposed to give him a pass.
00:10:42 What did you think of the fact that he alluded to his own personal faith?
00:10:48 It's somehow a way to cleanse himself of any alligators that he is targeting Christians.
00:10:57 Oh, that's like this thing that's been around for decades. 0.96
00:11:02 But some of my best friends are black or some of my best friends are lesbian
00:11:05 or some of my best friends are whatever. 0.91
00:11:07 It's kind of a cheesy ploy.
00:11:10 I mean, look, I don't know what's inside the guy's mind or heart.
00:11:14 And he's certainly part of free speech.
00:11:16 If he wants to declare himself to be a devout Christian, he can go ahead and do that. 0.93
00:11:20 But back to this problem with Bill C-9, you've got a federal cabinet minister saying
00:11:28 that he thinks certain Bible passages are hate speech.
00:11:32 Interestingly, it doesn't say anything about the Koran, but okay, whatever.
00:11:36 So he says that, and then you've got Bill C-9 that says that a defense to a hate speech prosecution
00:11:43 can be if in good faith you are making an argument or expressing an opinion based on belief in a religious text.
00:11:52 So that's a defense to the hate prosecution.
00:11:55 The defense has been there for decades.
00:11:57 That defense, by the way, is one of the reasons why the Supreme Court of Canada narrowly upheld the prohibition on hate speech
00:12:06 as being a justified violation of free expression.
00:12:10 So in other words, Jim Keegstra, Alberta public school teacher, challenged the hate speech laws,
00:12:18 came to the Supreme Court of Canada.
00:12:19 He almost won, but in a 4-3 decision, the Supreme Court said, no, this restriction on hate speech
00:12:26 is a justified restriction on speech.
00:12:32 And part of that reasoning is that you've got these defenses.
00:12:36 Truth is another defense.
00:12:37 If you say that there's higher rates of pedophilia amongst a particular group,
00:12:43 you know, based on the group's religion or skin color or whatever, you know, grounds,
00:12:51 if you can defend yourself against a hate speech prosecution by saying what I said was true,
00:12:57 here's the evidence, right?
00:12:58 So truth is a defense.
00:13:00 So because of these defenses, the Supreme Court upheld it.
00:13:03 But now we see this Bill C-9 is going to get rid of one of these defenses.
00:13:09 Where does the government really want to go?
00:13:11 I mean, why are they even going there?
00:13:12 I mean, there's a criminal code provision in there that deals with hate.
00:13:19 Why are they even bothering with this?
00:13:21 Do you have any idea what's going on?
00:13:24 They naively and foolishly think that they will be in power forever
00:13:28 and that it will never be used against them.
00:13:30 So based on the current cultural climate and the current legal climate,
00:13:34 the hate speech laws, and the same thing with the Online Harms Act,
00:13:39 if they bring that back and give new powers to the Canadian Human Rights Commission
00:13:44 to prosecute Canadians over discriminatory speech,
00:13:49 look, the main targets are going to be conservatives, libertarians, Christians,
00:13:55 social conservatives, and people with unorthodox views
00:13:59 that are contrary to the mainstream narrative on climate,
00:14:04 on transgenderism, on Aboriginal rights.
00:14:07 That's who it's going to be used against.
00:14:11 But what these people don't realize is that if you empower the state
00:14:15 to go after your political enemies by silencing them,
00:14:19 that very same power the state can use against you in five years or 15 years
00:14:24 when there's a different government in power,
00:14:25 that same state power is going to be used to silence them.
00:14:28 So really, they're not seeing the writing on the wall,
00:14:32 but they are ultimately undermining their own freedom of expression as well.
00:14:36 If you attack somebody else's,
00:14:38 if you take away somebody else's freedom of expression,
00:14:41 you're ultimately, you're shooting yourself in the foot.
00:14:44 Well, maybe they think that by taking away freedom of expression
00:14:47 from conservatives and all these people that you mentioned,
00:14:49 Christians, gun owners, that they will be in power forever. 0.98
00:14:53 You know, maybe this is ultimately a power grab,
00:14:56 a way to silence permanently your enemies
00:14:59 so that you can hold on to the reins of power forever.
00:15:03 Maybe that's part of it.
00:15:04 I think it might be.
00:15:05 It might be, but thankfully, we've got independent media pushing back.
00:15:09 We've got podcasts and videocasts like yours.
00:15:13 We have, you know, Juno News, The Rebel, Epoch Times, Western Standard.
00:15:17 These are growing.
00:15:19 I had lunch a few weeks ago with a donor to the Justice Center
00:15:23 who told me that his 20-year-old grandson
00:15:25 never listens to or watches the CBC or Global or CTV.
00:15:30 He doesn't even know what they are.
00:15:32 He gets 100% of his information about what's going on in the world.
00:15:37 He gets it from Instagram and X and social media and friends.
00:15:44 And so these government-funded media are slowly dying a well-deserved death
00:15:48 and they're becoming less relevant every day.
00:15:50 Yeah, and that's why younger people in many cases
00:15:56 are gravitating towards more conservative views.
00:15:58 It's because they're not the ones getting brainwashed
00:16:01 and have been brainwashed for years.
00:16:03 It's the boomer generation that they're the ones voting for elbows up. 0.97
00:16:08 You know, they're the ones who supported Mark Carney,
00:16:10 you know, in a massive way.
00:16:11 And if you look at the basic people who, you know,
00:16:15 listen to CBC programming and the legacy media, that's where they are.
00:16:19 So it's the monolithic media pumping out that, you know,
00:16:23 left-wing propaganda on behalf of the liberals.
00:16:26 You know, that's really what has worked for the liberals up to this point.
00:16:30 But, you know, there's generational change, to your point.
00:16:34 And it was the cord-cutting generation that kind of began it all.
00:16:38 You know, when people started to say, I can't afford cable, I don't even need it.
00:16:42 I've got the internet.
00:16:43 That's when things changed.
00:16:45 And that's why you see the government pushing for internet censorship.
00:16:49 How do people support their organization?
00:16:52 Well, the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms
00:16:55 is a national organization, registered charity.
00:16:58 We've got a team of 10 lawyers across Canada
00:17:00 taking on dozens of cases in defense of our freedoms
00:17:04 of expression, association, conscience, religion, bodily autonomy, travel, and so on.
00:17:09 The website is www.jccf.ca.
00:17:13 So it's Justice Center Constitutional Freedoms, jccf.ca.
00:17:16 People are welcome to donate.
00:17:18 We also have a free email newsletter,
00:17:21 but we only send out one or two per month.
00:17:24 So if you sign up for our email newsletter,
00:17:26 you're not going to be drowning in daily emails.
00:17:33 John Carpe, thank you so much for coming on the show.
00:17:35 We really do appreciate it.
00:17:37 Thank you, Mark.
00:17:38 Have a great rest of the day.
00:17:40 You too.
00:17:40 John is president of the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms.
00:17:43 Thank you so much for tuning in, my friends.
00:17:45 Appreciate it.
00:17:46 We'll do it again real soon.
00:17:48 Bye-bye for now.
00:17:56 Bye-bye.