Juno News - September 18, 2023


Unions declare war on parental rights protest

Topics
Mentioned
Feds’ “decarbonization” policy could further spike home prices (ft. Prof. Ross McKitrick) Grassroots group pushes back against Liberal energy policies

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

165.66

Word count

7,602

Sentence count

407

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

14

sentences flagged

Hate speech

14

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Canadian Taxpayers Federation, the Campaign Life Coalition, and the Ontario Federation of Labour join us to talk about the Million Person March on Wednesday, and why they believe there is a crisis of hate within the parental rights movement.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:20 Hello and welcome to you all, Canada's most irreverent talk show,
00:01:29 The Andrew Lawton Show here on True North, kicking off another week.
00:01:33 It is Monday, which means we have our good friend Chris Sims
00:01:37 from the Canadian Taxpayers Federation joining us in just a little bit of time.
00:01:42 And Jack Fonseca from the Campaign Life Coalition
00:01:44 will be here to talk about the million-person march.
00:01:48 I should clarify, it seems to have like five different names.
00:01:52 At first, it was like the Million Man March, and then the Million Person March, and then
00:01:55 the Million March for Children, and the March for a Million Children, and the Milching, 0.99
00:01:59 Milching, Milking, Milking, Marching Millions.
00:02:02 I don't know.
00:02:02 I've seen like a whole bunch of different names for it.
00:02:04 But we're going to go with the Million Person March on Wednesday, taking place at 9 a.m.
00:02:08 across the country in cities from London to Ottawa to Calgary to Toronto to Kelowna to
00:02:14 Chatham to, I think, Kamloops has one as well.
00:02:17 And at its core, it is a protest for parental rights.
00:02:21 People are going to be pulling their kids out of school.
00:02:23 And as a result, it's a little bit interesting to see how many of the unions have decided to get up in arms about this and start pushing back.
00:02:32 You may have seen circulating on social media, there was a Zoom call that took place over the weekend
00:02:37 in which several union reps from CUPE Ontario, the Ontario Federation of Labour,
00:02:43 the Canadian Labour Congress, all got together to put their heads together, such as they are,
00:02:49 and come up with ways to push back against this. As one trans activist said, they want to stop it
00:02:55 dead in its tracks. Now, this call leaked and everyone's like talking about it as though it's
00:03:00 some big, huge bombshell. I mean, the reality is they wanted people to be involved. They wanted
00:03:05 this thing to be seen. They're not talking about anything that you didn't already know they were
00:03:09 talking about. But the thing is, they believe there is a pressing crisis afoot right now. They
00:03:15 believe it is a crisis of hate, that there is hate, hate, hate, hate, hate going on. And that it is
00:03:20 the parental rights movement that is the great purveyor of hatred. And it was an interesting
00:03:26 little thing to see. This is Patty Coates, who was one of the union organizers outlining why they
00:03:32 were having this rapid response call. To kick us off, I'm going to turn it over to OFL President
00:03:38 Patty Coates, for a welcome and a land acknowledgement. Patty.
00:03:44 Thanks, Rob. I want to thank everyone for being here on such short notice. As you saw from our
00:03:53 memo that we sent out, there's a number of protest events that are taking place all across Canada.
00:04:02 We can't just let this be idle. We need to be able to organize. We need to connect with our communities in Ontario. From what I know, there's approximately 22 different events that are taking place, and there could be more now.
00:04:20 But as allies and those that protect workers' rights, protect our kids' rights and the rights of trans and our 2SLGBTQ plus community, we felt it very important that we do come together to fight against the rise of hate.
00:04:41 and we're seeing it in province across province across province we're seeing it now in our
00:04:46 education system with our premier and education minister has put forward with regards to the
00:04:55 obligations of teachers and school boards educators and school boards and so that's why we're here
00:05:03 we're trying to connect with all of you to talk about what's happening in our communities and
00:05:09 what we can do as allies and supporters uh to fight against the hate uh within our communities
00:05:17 i should have poured a bunch of shots and we could have all done a drinking game that you 0.99
00:05:21 could play along with at home it's one o'clock i'm sure it's you know five o'clock somewhere
00:05:25 of course actually it's not really five o'clock anywhere it's five o'clock like over the atlantic
00:05:28 but uh it's six o'clock in the united kingdom right now so there we go the then every time they
00:05:34 say the word hate you could have just taken a shot and you actually would have been just passed out
00:05:37 drunk already after that two-minute clip yeah poor sean he says he was doing the drinking game and
00:05:42 he's already too drunk to continue the show so if the remaining clips don't fire it's because sean
00:05:47 was doing the drink every time they say hate uh and then we have shawnee paul or chandra lee paul
00:05:55 who i i don't know the affiliation or title uh who weighed in as well and again talks about
00:05:59 coordinated hate this is scary i'll be honest with you as a member who is a proud queer individual
00:06:09 and activist who's been doing this work for days over 30 years now um it is in my experience my
00:06:17 personal experience the first of this time that i've seen here in canada of this super broadly
00:06:24 and coordinated hate right across the country of this time.
00:06:33 We are seeing a set of protests that are all being done simultaneously.
00:06:40 They're all being set for 9 a.m. in each of their time zones in every single province
00:06:47 of this country in multiple states of these provinces and it is really scary it is extremely
00:06:56 similar as to what has been happening in the u.s and we are very very worried about what
00:07:04 could be coming next um i am zooming in from takaranto uh otherwise known as toronto the
00:07:11 place in the water where the treaties are standing and uh i'm i'm extremely worried about what's
00:07:16 and so what what we're seeing is um a a far right extreme response to uh inclusive education
00:07:30 oh a far right extreme response that is in addition to the coordinated hate
00:07:37 now let's not mince words here what we're talking about are parental rights the protests have been
00:07:45 for parents to have more oversight and authority as they've always had and as they're supposed to
00:07:49 have over their children's education they're not resisting inclusive education they're not 0.74
00:07:54 resisting the fact that trans people are going to be taught in schools that gay people are going to 0.97
00:07:59 be taught in schools that they're going to be gay teachers and trans teachers uh they're resisting 0.98
00:08:03 the i mean look most of the people on this call are teachers and many of them as you can see on
00:08:08 the zoom call they all have the various pronouns in their bio this is already an inclusive education
00:08:14 system as evidenced by all of these people on this call who work within the education system.
00:08:20 That's the part here that I find so baffling is that they've already basically won. But when in
00:08:26 New Brunswick, the premier says, you know what, if a kid wants to change their gender and pronouns
00:08:30 at school, maybe we think parents should have a say in that and be able to consent and have to
00:08:35 consent. And then similar pushes in Saskatchewan and Manitoba, and finally in Ontario, the
00:08:41 conservative government that conservatism forgot, or that forgot conservatism, I guess, has also
00:08:46 started talking about this with Doug Ford railing against indoctrination, because it is a popular
00:08:52 policy. Parents believe they should have autonomy over how their children are raised, that parents
00:08:59 are the first, best, and primary educators for their children. And it isn't just about a disagreement,
00:09:06 and, oh, we disagree on this part of it, they actually despise.
00:09:10 They despise the very people who are raising these issues,
00:09:14 who are planning to protest on Wednesday.
00:09:16 This is a clip from Emily Quayle.
00:09:18 Now, she's been an activist and organizer in Ottawa.
00:09:21 She's not a teacher, but she's a graduate student, I believe, at Carleton,
00:09:25 and that's why she's a member of CUPE.
00:09:27 And just listen to her rhetoric about the protesters
00:09:31 that believe in parental rights.
00:09:34 The fascists are organizing in the streets.
00:09:36 I'm a researcher at Carleton and my focus is fascism in Canada and the signs that I've seen that we're rising that this is far more than just like a far-right transphobic protest. 0.80
00:09:47 They are fundamentally racist. They're fundamentally anti-union. They are fundamentally queer and transphobic.
00:09:53 And it's just a matter of time before they come to us. 0.72
00:09:55 And the only way, the best way that the fascists have been stopped in the last hundred years has been when we unite in massive numbers in the streets. 0.99
00:10:04 they're fascists they're fascists they're racist they're fundamentally transphobic now 0.96
00:10:12 i actually they're fundamentally racist she said now i actually interviewed a couple of the 0.99
00:10:17 fundamentally racist organizers of this protest a couple of weeks ago sean do we have an image
00:10:23 from that interview oh my goodness look at how fundamentally racist they look that's the
00:10:29 fundamentally racist Kamil al-Sheikh and the fundamentally racist Bahira Abdul Salam. You can
00:10:36 see they're just white supremacists, the kind that are Middle Eastern and wear a hijab, that kind of 0.98
00:10:41 white supremacists. You may not be familiar with them, but according to the great union activists,
00:10:46 these are racist white supremacists because how else could they ever be engaged in the dialogue 0.87
00:10:52 around parental rights? And it was interesting. One of the speakers actually spoke about the need 0.98
00:10:57 to stand up against oppression in the same way that they stand up against, like, anti-Muslim
00:11:04 oppression. And I'm like, you guys are the ones oppressing the Muslims right now. Because when 0.94
00:11:07 the Muslim families get up and say, ah, you know what, we love tolerance and diversity and all of
00:11:12 that, but maybe we're not too keen on this gender stuff in schools. Now, all of a sudden, they're 1.00
00:11:17 lumped in. I mean, the Muslim community must be very confused right now. These people that were 1.00
00:11:21 welcomed with open arms by Justin Trudeau seven years ago, and now are being denigrated as, like,
00:11:26 white supremacists. And they're like, is this like a mistranslation? No, these people are just
00:11:31 absolute lunatics. That's all that's going on here. And if you look at this, I'll share one 1.00
00:11:36 more clip for you because it explains why they're so scared. I mean, this whole crisis call that
00:11:42 these union folks had a hundred and some odd people gathering. I mean, when union people
00:11:46 gather on a weekend, you know, you know, it must be serious business because well, anyway, you get
00:11:51 the joke. But this is Vicki Smallman, who talks about why it is that they're so worried.
00:11:57 And the disturbing thing I have to say about all of this is while it's really easy to sort of say,
00:12:02 well, these are fringe voices, these are, you know, the convoy, you know, writ large, etc.
00:12:09 All of it is being validated and platformed and echoed by provincial governments and by the
00:12:16 federal conservative party right which offers a bit of a legitimacy and they
00:12:21 have decided that it is politically expedient to essentially throw trans 1.00
00:12:28 kids families queer families queer people queer workers kids under the bus 1.00
00:12:33 in order to win votes I mean we see in Manitoba right now actual bus ads from
00:12:40 conservative candidates because they're in a provincial election using parents
00:12:45 rights rhetoric as the hook. It's really crappy. Now, I'm not one of these people that believes 0.98
00:12:53 that the popular is always the right. You know, something could be popular and wrong. Vaccine
00:12:58 mandates are a great example of that. But there's a little bit of an interesting takeaway in what
00:13:03 she's saying, which is that they're concerned by how many people disagree with them. They're
00:13:08 concerned by how many people are taking up the mantle of parental rights. They're concerned about
00:13:13 how common these views are that they're railing against and going to the walls for. And if you
00:13:19 look at some of the rhetoric that you've been getting from the NDP, in all honesty, it's
00:13:22 actually quite baffling. These people, the hill they're prepared to die on is sex changes for
00:13:27 children, which is why the rhetoric against the Conservative Convention and the policy resolution
00:13:32 opposing gender affirming care, as they call it for children, was so unhinged. And in this particular
00:13:38 case, we're not even talking about anything that is out of the norm of what parents expect. And
00:13:44 it's not just conservatives, far rights, white supremacists, racists. It's just normal parents
00:13:49 that want to have some level of oversight on what their children are being taught and more
00:13:53 importantly, how it's being taught. And when you see a group that includes a lot of teachers
00:13:59 gathering together and they're so offended, so offended that parents may want to exercise more
00:14:07 authority over educating than they do, that should be a huge red flag. Why do these people think they
00:14:13 deserve that much power over what happens with your kids in the classroom? And that I think is
00:14:19 the problem here. Now, one thing I'll point out just on a lighter note before we go to our next
00:14:23 guest here, our first guest, I guess, is also our next guest, is that all, I mean, this is, I'm just,
00:14:29 this is indulgent on my part, so you'll have to bear with me, but we've all had to deal with the
00:14:33 land acknowledgements, which are supposed to be a part of Truth and Reconciliation. At union events,
00:14:38 I learned that the land acknowledgement is like half of the meeting. Take a look.
00:14:43 So with that, I'm going to go to the land acknowledgement, and then I will pass it back
00:14:50 so we can start our conversations. Today, because we are joining this meeting from places across
00:14:57 indigenous territory. I'd like to begin this acknowledgement by honoring the
00:15:02 lands each of us are on, which has been the site of human activity since time
00:15:07 immemorial. It is a traditional territory of First Nations, Métis and Inuit
00:15:12 peoples from across Turtle Island. I'm attending this meeting from Innisfil in
00:15:17 the community of Alcona, which is the traditional land of the Anishinaabeg
00:15:22 people. The Anishinaabeg include the Ojibwe, Ottawa, and Potawatomi nations,
00:15:28 collectively known as a Council of Three Fires. Please share in the chat the
00:15:35 indigenous territories that you are joining this meeting from. But as we
00:15:40 gather here today, these nations continue to experience ongoing colonialization
00:15:46 and displacement where land acknowledgments are offered in place of
00:15:50 land itself this territory is part of the dish with one spoon wampum a treaty made between the
00:15:57 Anishinaabe Mississaugas and Haudenosaunee where nations entered into an agreement to protect the
00:16:02 land and responsibly care for its resources in harmony together and I think you know that's all
00:16:10 very fitting because we all need to be working in harmony as we move forward and as we know
00:16:18 you know, our Indigenous peoples have been oppressed for years and years, millennium in time,
00:16:32 and we're seeing that oppression again with two-spirited people, with our 2SLGBTQ communities,
00:16:41 so coming together at a meeting like this I think is very important, and we're very
00:16:48 appreciative of the treaties that are on our lands uh the treaties that we should all be following
00:16:54 uh and that we all become uh stewards of our land so with that i'm going to pass it over
00:17:02 back over to rob and uh we'll uh
00:17:07 that was the longest land acknowledgement i've ever i mean the land acknowledgement lasted longer than
00:17:12 confederation has basically up to that point uh which is uh particularly odd because i kind of
00:17:17 of thought at virtual events, you didn't have to do the land acknowledgement because you're all
00:17:20 gathered. But the loophole there to the Ontario Federation of Labour is everyone has to do their
00:17:25 own land acknowledgement in the comment section. So for like the next, if you watch the video for
00:17:29 the next half hour, the chat is just like popping up with everyone's land acknowledgement when
00:17:33 they've already like moved on like seven topics by then. So the reason I poke fun of those because
00:17:38 they're all just theatrical. I mean, they all cloak themselves in this language that has nothing
00:17:44 to do with any real problems that exist in the world. And even Indigenous people are often the 1.00
00:17:49 ones who call these things empty words more than anything else. But to talk about the more serious
00:17:55 point here is that we have parents that are coming together and people in this country from all walks
00:18:01 of life, all backgrounds, faith groups, in many cases, political groups. And to these union
00:18:06 activist. It's just a far right, convoy 2.0, white supremacist. And at its core, what is it that is 0.94
00:18:14 being debated? I'm not saying there aren't different belief systems that exist and different goals and
00:18:20 all of that. But for the most part, the call is we want the schools to back off on the aggressive
00:18:26 teaching of gender ideology in classes. We want this to be something where parents have the right
00:18:31 to tell kids these are contentious issues. There is debate in the medical community, debate in
00:18:36 academia, debate in the law. So the idea that teachers should be able to just take this very
00:18:41 uber-progressive pro-gender ideology position and teach it in schools without parents having a say
00:18:49 is fundamentally wrong. That is what's being discussed here. It's not anti-inclusion. It's
00:18:54 pro-parental rights. It's that simple. Jack Fonseca is the political operations director for
00:19:00 the Campaign Life Coalition, which has been a supporter of this big event coming up. And he
00:19:05 joins me now. Jack, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today. You're welcome. Thanks for
00:19:09 having me on. Just to back up here for a moment, I mentioned earlier in passing the Conservative
00:19:14 Convention, which I timed very well with this march we have coming up. And a lot of the response
00:19:20 we saw to those anti-gender ideology motions being passed were just hysterical from people.
00:19:28 Yeah, it was, you know, it came from the left, from the far left, the media and some LGBTQ2S plus activists.
00:19:38 But essentially, what those two motions consisted of that passed or those two policy resolutions, I should say,
00:19:45 which are now official Conservative Party policy and passed by a very large majority,
00:19:50 was that the first one was that basically that the Conservative Party opposes sex changes for
00:19:58 children under the age of 18, that we oppose chemical or surgical mutilation of children
00:20:07 under the age of 18. And that's just common sense. I mean, kids under 18 can't get a tattoo without
00:20:12 the consent of their parents. They can't drive. They can't have sex. They can't get married.
00:20:17 You know, so all of this makes sense. Why it would be controversial to anybody to say that a child whose brain, the prefrontal cortex that's responsible for making decisions, which doesn't develop until the early 20s for human beings,
00:20:36 um why they should be allowed to to make a decision to cut off uh perfectly healthy body
00:20:43 parts or to take puberty puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones that are have irreversible
00:20:49 damaging effects to the body it's crazy it's crazy that anyone would say yeah yeah that should be
00:20:53 totally permitted and then the other uh oh sorry go ahead no i was just going to add to that point
00:20:59 and and we have people that are part of this growing and it's quite a heartbreaking group
00:21:03 called detransitioners, people that have gone through this because they had enthusiastic
00:21:07 doctors or parents when they were children and have lived to regret it because this thing that
00:21:12 was driving it was a sense they outgrew when they did reach maturity. Yeah, absolutely. And,
00:21:18 you know, the science has always backed that up. Even the American Psychiatric Association in the
00:21:23 Diagnostics and Statistics Manual admits that if children are just left alone, by the time they
00:21:32 enter into adolescence, they will have 88% of, I believe it was 88% of boys or 88% of girls and
00:21:40 up to 95% of boys will no longer persist in the belief or the concern that they're of the opposite
00:21:48 sex, that they will outgrow that sexual confusion. And that's if we just leave them alone. And that's
00:21:54 from the American Psychiatric Association. So this is fact. This is real science. And what
00:22:01 the gender activists, the transgender activists are throwing at our children, indoctrinating kids 1.00
00:22:07 in the schools, right in the classroom, as young as kindergarten, five years old. It's absolutely
00:22:12 criminal. It is child abuse, telling them that they might be the opposite sex, that they might
00:22:17 be trapped in the wrong body, and that they need medical or surgical interventions to be fully
00:22:26 human or to be fully who they are that is just child abuse it's crazy to fast forward to the
00:22:33 march this week you have communities across the country it started with a couple of muslim
00:22:38 organizers but they were very clear they wanted evangelicals and catholics and atheists and jews
00:22:44 and anyone that believes in this core message here you know i think for me at its core is that these
00:22:50 are very live issues the fact that it was being debated at the conservative convention the fact
00:22:54 that there is debate in the medical community, suggests that we're not at the point where we have
00:22:58 this universally accepted approach to this issue that can be taught to children in the same way
00:23:04 that, you know, one plus one equals two, or the alphabet starts with A and goes to Z can be,
00:23:09 right? Yeah, that's right. It's, and this, you know, the fact that there, that this march is
00:23:16 happening with close to 100 locations, perhaps it's surpassed 100 locations by now in, I believe
00:23:22 it's all of the provinces and one of the territories. And this is going to be huge
00:23:28 across the country. It demonstrates that no, the average Canadian and especially parents
00:23:33 don't agree. The consensus is not settled by any means. And in fact, it's rejected. The
00:23:39 notion that children can declare themselves to be the opposite sex, opposite from their
00:23:45 biological reality, it is rejected by parents. And that's going to be borne out in this protest
00:23:51 across the country on Wednesday.
00:23:54 I don't know if you saw that whole union confab
00:23:57 that took place in which all of these labor people
00:24:00 got together.
00:24:01 I mean, the level of venom they have towards parents
00:24:05 really is what it comes down to.
00:24:07 It was quite astonishing, not all that surprising.
00:24:09 And again, I don't want to say this is representative 1.00
00:24:11 of all teachers, but many of these people are teachers.
00:24:14 And I really asked the question of
00:24:16 why should we not be calling them out?
00:24:20 And why are more people not calling them out for believing that they should be the ones that make these decisions?
00:24:25 Because that's really what they're saying. They're saying they know better than parents.
00:24:28 Yeah. Yeah. You know, schools have become toxic.
00:24:31 The truth is the reality of the matter is that our public education system, both public schools and Catholic schools, too, that are government run have become indoctrination centers.
00:24:40 They're brainwashing centers. They're run by Marxists.
00:24:43 Most of these, you know, there are some good teachers.
00:24:45 I know I talk to them privately, the minority of good teachers who don't agree with what's being with the brainwashing that's happening in the schools and they feel alone and they feel, gosh, if I speak out against this anti-scientific nonsense, I'm going to be fired.
00:25:01 I'm going to be disciplined. But the problem is that the Marxists who run the colleges that teach the teachers, they are Marxists.
00:25:10 They want to fundamentally, they want to undermine Western society, which is built on Judeo-Christian beliefs, and they even want to undermine science and the belief in truth and reality because it serves the Marxist agenda.
00:25:29 And unfortunately, you've got young teachers now, the ones who get taught at these teachers' colleges are indoctrinated with this ideology, this transgender and gender fluidity, all of this ideology.
00:25:42 They're brainwashed to believe that it's human rights, that they're fighting for civil rights somehow if they're teaching this in the classroom and hiding it from parents.
00:25:51 if they're actually helping children to impersonate the opposite sex and use opposite sex names and hide it from the parents,
00:25:58 these teachers are being taught that they're doing something good, that they're actually being good people and good teachers.
00:26:06 And the opposite is true, that what they're doing is they're participating in child abuse.
00:26:10 And the reality is, if you look at what transitioning at school leads to, where, you know, teachers are saying,
00:26:17 yeah, okay, we'll hide it from the parents. We'll let Johnny call himself Susie at school
00:26:24 and live a double life that's separate to the life that he lives at home. What they're doing
00:26:30 is putting children on the path to puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and for many of
00:26:35 them, gender mutilation surgery, the amputation of perfectly healthy body parts. And I don't want 0.99
00:26:42 to skip over the dangers and harms of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones. These are not
00:26:46 harmless, you know, like taking an Advil. Puberty blockers are extremely dangerous.
00:26:52 They're very harmful. They make bones brittle. They bring on osteoporosis.
00:26:57 They stunt the growth of children. There's many, many studies that have shown that they produce
00:27:05 infertility, so sterilization. Can a child at 10 or 11 or 12 years old when puberty blockers are
00:27:11 typically given can they truly understand the decision to become permanently sterile to never
00:27:16 be able to have children of course not of course not and um you know dr john whitehall a professor
00:27:23 in pediatrics at western sydney university in australia um he he he has cited from his research
00:27:31 that while on puberty blockers quote the volume of the brain decreases at 10 times faster than
00:27:37 the aging process end quote so you think about that we're putting kids on puberty blockers
00:27:43 which causes the volume of their brains to decrease 10 times faster than the natural aging
00:27:49 process and then the next step is uh is um hormone therapy cross-sex hormones and you know that is
00:27:58 linked to uh all kinds of cancers um you know cancer of the breast prostate um ovaries uh the
00:28:05 the vagina, cardiovascular problems, you know, this is, it's really butchery of children. This 1.00
00:28:14 is child abuse. It's inhuman. And this is why parents are coming out of the woodwork and joining
00:28:20 this Million March for Children to protest this form of child abuse that is happening right in
00:28:27 our schools. And which one are you, which one are you going to be at, Jack? I think I'm going to be
00:28:33 at the possibly the Kitchener one. Okay, wonderful. Well, they're all over the place. I was seeing
00:28:39 this morning on the website, I was looking at the list of them. And I think like, as I refreshed the
00:28:44 page 10 minutes later, they had added another one or two of these. So it's going to be large.
00:28:48 I know they were using the term million. I don't know if it's going to be a million people. But
00:28:50 certainly, if you look at the polling that's been done on this, it's a majority of parents that I
00:28:55 think fundamentally align with the policy we're seeing in New Brunswick that we're hearing discussed
00:29:00 in Ontario that Manitoba and Saskatchewan are talking about. So definitely this is not the
00:29:05 fringe minority, as Justin Trudeau and some of those union folks would have said. Jack Fonseca
00:29:11 is the political operations director with the Campaign Life Coalition. Good to talk to you,
00:29:15 Jack. Thanks for coming on today. Thanks very much for having me. All right. We'll have a little
00:29:19 bit more on this tomorrow and a bit of a postmortem on Wednesday. Some of the marches are going to be
00:29:25 going probably still while we're on air on Wednesday. So we'll try to get some of the early
00:29:30 footage and talk about that. I won't be out there because I have to be back at the show. So I won't
00:29:35 be covering it on the ground. I do want to turn to bread though. I was trying to think of like a
00:29:40 witty transition. Well, transition. There we go. We'll transition to bread. There we go. It wasn't
00:29:45 like a segue about yeast or dough or anything like that. I was trying to come up with like a
00:29:48 clever one, but I couldn't in the interim. But we will talk about the grocery crisis. Now you
00:29:55 already know as Canadians that there is a crisis at the grocery stores. You go like we all do. You
00:30:00 see the prices on the shelves. You know how they've been going up and up and up. And the government
00:30:05 has seen its poll numbers go down, down, down. So the result is simply that, oh, well, we have to
00:30:13 find a new bogeyman. So the federal government did the big tough thing. They've summoned all of the
00:30:18 grocery executives to Ottawa for a finger wagging, which is taking place right now, believe it or not,
00:30:23 about 30 minutes ago. They all started walking in and the media was trying to get them. And
00:30:29 oddly, the grocery companies were doing this all wrong. They should have been coming out and
00:30:34 chatting with reporters and saying, yeah, this is terrible. We hate this. You should know about all
00:30:38 the costs we have to deal with and the carbon tax. But instead, one guy, the head of Costco says no
00:30:44 comment. Galen Weston of Loblaw just walks by silently. There was a guy from Metro that stopped
00:30:51 and chatted for a little bit and just said, oh, I'm looking forward to a good meeting and an
00:30:54 exchange of ideas. The head of Sobeys, I don't think said anything. So these people are letting
00:30:59 themselves be portrayed as the villains here, which is what the government wants. This is what
00:31:04 Justin Trudeau said when he announced this grand summons. It's not okay that our biggest grocery
00:31:12 stores are making record profits while Canadians are struggling to put food on the table.
00:31:18 So Minister Champagne will be calling on the heads of large grocers to come to Ottawa
00:31:23 with a plan to address the rising cost of food.
00:31:27 And we expect to hear from them by Thanksgiving on what their plan is to stabilize prices.
00:31:43 And let me be very clear.
00:31:46 If their plan doesn't provide real relief for the middle class and people working hard to join it, then we will take further action and we are not ruling anything out, including tax measures.
00:32:01 It is not acceptable.
00:32:04 It is not acceptable and we will not stand.
00:32:08 Oh, well done, sir.
00:32:11 Well done.
00:32:12 He offered nothing.
00:32:14 He said it's terrible and we're bringing them here.
00:32:17 It is unacceptable.
00:32:19 It is unacceptable.
00:32:21 I'm doing my, I can't do it
00:32:22 because every time I do a Justin Trudeau impersonation,
00:32:25 I can like just feel the testosterone seeping out.
00:32:27 And I don't think I have that much to begin with,
00:32:29 to be honest.
00:32:29 But in any case, we are looking at the landscape here.
00:32:33 He's promising unspecified tax measures, tax measures.
00:32:38 So just think about that for more than five seconds here.
00:32:43 What are those tax measures?
00:32:45 Are you going to tax groceries to make groceries cheaper?
00:32:48 No, you're going to tax grocery stores. 0.99
00:32:50 And what are grocery stores going to do when they have this extra burden that they have to spend on their taxes?
00:32:56 They're probably going to pass it on to their consumers.
00:33:00 It's easy to look at the corporations and be like, oh, the big profits are scary and evil and all of that.
00:33:05 But if you look at the overhead that any business in Canada operating needs to contend with,
00:33:10 certainly grocery stores, you are going to see they're dealing with inflationary pressures as
00:33:15 well. And they're entitled to make a profit because they are private companies. So the NDP
00:33:20 plan, if you look at Jagmeet Singh's proposed law here, is basically that we need to ban
00:33:25 grocery store profits and ban price gouging and price fixing. Oh yeah, those things are already
00:33:30 illegal. So your proposal to ban price fixing to lower groceries is not going to do anything.
00:33:35 You know what they're not talking about? Getting rid of the carbon tax. Maybe they should be.
00:33:40 Chris Sims is the Alberta Director for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation
00:33:44 and our regular Monday contributor starting last week.
00:33:48 It's good to have you back, Chris.
00:33:49 Thanks for coming on.
00:33:50 Thanks for having us on.
00:33:51 So, I mean, the elephant in the room here,
00:33:53 like the one thing that government is doing,
00:33:55 like you can't control what Galen Weston does
00:33:58 and what all these other no-name, no pun intended,
00:34:00 what these no-name grocery executives do,
00:34:03 but you can control what you as the government of Canada do.
00:34:06 And hey, you've got this big giant thing that everyone agrees
00:34:08 is driving up the cost of groceries. Yeah, for sure. I was watching that press conference last
00:34:14 week and just wanting to bang my head against the steering wheel as I was listening to it.
00:34:19 Prime Minister, the call is coming from inside the house. Okay, this is on you. Your carbon tax
00:34:27 is making groceries cost more. And to break that down, a lot of people will say, oh, well,
00:34:32 farmers get an exemption. Yes, they do for their vehicles, but they don't for their barns or for
00:34:40 grain drying. Okay. So the very, the parliamentary budget officer themselves has explained that the
00:34:47 carbon tax is going to cost Canadian farmers around a billion dollars extra between now and
00:34:55 2030. So within the next seven years, Andrew, that's an extra billion dollars of cost. And
00:35:01 And that's because, of course, they use natural gas and propane to dry their grain.
00:35:05 They also use natural gas and propane to heat their barns.
00:35:09 So all those chickens and pigs and cows that need to survive the Canadian winter, guess
00:35:15 what?
00:35:16 They live in heated barns and we eat and use them all the time.
00:35:21 And then, of course, it's the truckers who are bringing the groceries from the farm to
00:35:26 the stores.
00:35:27 then it's the stores themselves that have to keep the lights on, and quite often that's using
00:35:31 natural gas. And so it's very clear that the carbon tax, Trudeau's carbon tax, makes stuff
00:35:38 cost more, including groceries. And to hear him float this idea of a tax measure is just
00:35:45 mind-boggling because taxes make things cost more. And this reminds me, that was that old
00:35:52 Reagan quote remember what is it if it moves tax it if it stops moving regulate it like if it stops
00:35:58 moving subsidize it and I think if it keeps moving regulate exactly like there are some ideological
00:36:04 politicians that just think more government is the answer and in this case it just certainly is not
00:36:11 yeah and look I'm not going to look at Galen Weston and say that he is lily white in this
00:36:15 I mean a lot of corporate executives have to be very ruthless and they are making a lot of money
00:36:20 on this, but they're also doing what the system requires and allows, which is to make money. And
00:36:25 the profits have not actually increased as much as the government likes to claim that it is,
00:36:31 because the reality is it's their costs as well that are increasing. They're dealing with any
00:36:35 inflationary pressures that exist outside of the grocery stores. It's not like everything has
00:36:41 stayed the same and then boom, the retail cost has been jacked up because of inflation.
00:36:45 Exactly. There's no magical supplier that these people are using. We all get them from the same sources and from the same places. They don't have an inflation free store that these planners and these folks get to go to. And yeah, think about it. What we just watched was a handful of people go into a building. Are we really to believe that it's these handful of people that are maniacally making food cost more? Are we older than 12 years old?
00:37:13 We all know how these systems work, or at least we should. And the idea that we have a government now that's been in power for eight years, and by the way, they've got ministers, they've got deputy ministers, they've got staff who are supposed to know the basic economics of this stuff.
00:37:30 for them to turn around and just use this as a scapegoat when it's they who are largely causing
00:37:36 this problem also due to inflation because they've been printing money. Remember, the Trudeau
00:37:41 government printed $300 billion out of thin air. That is going to make inflation much, much worse,
00:37:49 which of course increases the cost of food. And so we can all see them. We should all know this.
00:37:55 It reminds me of Dr. Thomas Sowell, who, by the way, is still with us. He's 93, Andrew, and just put out his latest book. He recommends asking three questions of a politician or bureaucrat who comes up with a great new idea, like a grocery tax or regulating the price of groceries.
00:38:15 He says you should ask three questions. You should ask at what cost, compared to what, and what evidence do you have? This fails on all three of those questions.
00:38:27 we've heard some ridiculous ideas that are likely to be bandied about by the government
00:38:33 because they're going to grocery stores and saying you need to come up with a solution by 0.56
00:38:36 thanksgiving so they should basically just announce a sale on turkeys and say that's our
00:38:41 plan we've marked down turkeys 20 so canadians can have their thanksgiving dinner and then tell
00:38:46 the government to a pound salt i mean a pound of salt might be too expensive now but the thing that
00:38:51 i would point out is that there are going to be ridiculous ideas like jagmeet singh's whole thing
00:38:55 of pass a law to lower prices.
00:38:56 You basically have to either legally cap prices,
00:39:00 which does not solve the problem at all.
00:39:03 And, or you have to do something insane
00:39:06 like nationalizing a grocery store
00:39:08 or creating a national one,
00:39:10 like basically just bringing back the bread line.
00:39:12 You know, it's been out of vogue for the last 30 years,
00:39:14 but we can bring back the bread line.
00:39:16 The Soviets have nothing on Trudeau's Canada.
00:39:18 Like, I don't know what other options
00:39:20 are on the table, really.
00:39:21 I've heard that language and it's scary.
00:39:25 It's scary. They shouldn't even be thinking about those sorts of things. Ask anyone who lived in the Soviet Union or in one of those Eastern Bloc countries what it's like to line up for onions and bread.
00:39:38 I have a friend who lived in the Soviet Union, and they used to take a train for nine hours in one direction with these large oilcloth sacks on their backs, Andrew, to gather sausages because they were so salty and so full of spices that they wouldn't have to be refrigerated.
00:39:55 They had to do this just to get meat.
00:39:57 This was in the 80s.
00:39:59 This was not back in the 1950s.
00:40:02 And this is because they were controlling the price of food.
00:40:05 We mustn't do this. Just to give people an example, think of what the government controls in your life right now. The healthcare system, the passport office, things called Service Canada, etc. Do you get awesome prices and great service at those places? No?
00:40:22 Well, you probably don't want them controlling the cost and price of your food and the stores
00:40:28 where you can buy your food. That's a really bad idea. And a grocery tax is a super bad idea.
00:40:36 What needs to happen here is the government needs to climb down. They need to realize,
00:40:41 okay, we had the best of intentions to help the environment or give them whatever out they need,
00:40:46 but it isn't working. We realize now, we didn't mean to, we realize now we're making food costs
00:40:52 go up. So we're going to scrap these carbon taxes and use technology to help clean the air
00:40:58 and help the environment. That's what needs to happen here. Egos need to be checked and they
00:41:03 need to make a better decision. We've spoken about the carbon tax, which is obviously a big
00:41:07 one. The other one that no political party in Canada will touch is supply management, which
00:41:12 I know tends to anger my rural Ontario audience, but I'm sorry, generally speaking, no one outside
00:41:18 of dairy farmers supports supply management. Canadians have to pay for it. It is something
00:41:23 that the government would have to deal with the transition of pretty significantly. You have to
00:41:28 buy back a quota that farmers have in good faith purchased and spent a lot of money on. But also
00:41:34 So this is driving up the cost very much in a very easily calculated way of milk, of eggs,
00:41:42 of poultry to some extent.
00:41:44 And this is something the government could do.
00:41:46 And to be honest, I'm actually amazed the liberals have not taken up the supply management
00:41:50 cause because for them, they don't really lose votes like the conservatives do, because
00:41:54 let's face it, they're not winning in farm country as it is.
00:41:57 That's a great point.
00:41:58 And anytime you start getting into people's food and how it is supplied and what kind
00:42:03 of food they can get here in Canada, you get into some really choppy waters. I'll put it this way.
00:42:09 This government doesn't seem to do homework, complexity, and nuance well. They just seem to
00:42:16 kind of reach for goals that they think are attainable, and all that stuff in the middle
00:42:22 is just going to take care of itself. If you started looking at something as heavy and complex
00:42:27 and long-lasting as supply management, you're going to have your best and brightest in the room,
00:42:31 and it's going to take years.
00:42:33 I don't see that happening with this government.
00:42:35 It's more like you said at the top of this,
00:42:38 the easy bogeyman, the easy photo op.
00:42:41 And yeah, to your point, folks,
00:42:43 if you're running a massive corporation,
00:42:46 like a major grocery store chain,
00:42:48 you need to get some media training because-
00:42:51 Oh yeah, no, if you saw that,
00:42:52 like they blew this.
00:42:54 They should have been the nice guys
00:42:55 and been like, yeah, this is, we agree.
00:42:58 This is terrible.
00:42:59 You should know all the things that we're doing.
00:43:01 And this is what we need the government to do.
00:43:02 Instead, when they just walk by without blinking, it lets the government framing of them stick.
00:43:09 Yeah, it makes them look like the bad guy.
00:43:11 And hey, I'm not a grocery expert.
00:43:13 I don't work for a grocery store, but I am pretty good at media.
00:43:16 And you shouldn't do that.
00:43:18 You should be more open.
00:43:19 You should be more forthright.
00:43:21 You should say something like, I last saw an economist say that the grocery portion,
00:43:26 the grocery portion, mind you, of their profit is around 3%.
00:43:29 so not including the add-ons like the frying pan that you're impulse buying because you forgot to
00:43:34 get some earlier or the pharmacy element just the groceries they should have had a really easy stat
00:43:40 like that like three percent right on the top of their head and say you know what we're here to
00:43:44 help we're making about this amount but we're gonna listen real hard and you know we'll let
00:43:49 you know how it goes that took 15 seconds yeah no very well said chris sims alberta director
00:43:57 for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:43:59 Always good to talk to you.
00:44:00 We will see you next Monday.
00:44:01 You betcha.
00:44:02 All right.
00:44:03 Thanks very much.
00:44:04 That does it for us for today.
00:44:06 We'll be back in just, what, I don't know,
00:44:08 23 hours and 15 minutes
00:44:09 with more of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:44:12 Make sure to check out donate.tnc.news
00:44:15 if you are minded to support independent media.
00:44:18 And if you are in Alberta
00:44:19 or you are willing to travel to have a good time,
00:44:22 we are hosting our first ever live in-person event
00:44:25 on Saturday, October 21st in Calgary.
00:44:28 It is called True North Nation.
00:44:31 I'm going to be there.
00:44:32 Rupa Subramania is going to be there.
00:44:34 Harrison Faulkner, Rachel Emanuel,
00:44:36 and some other special guests still to be announced.
00:44:39 You won't want to miss that.
00:44:40 It's going to be a lot of fun.
00:44:41 And if it works, we will do it again,
00:44:43 hopefully in a city near you.
00:44:44 But if it doesn't work,
00:44:45 you'll have wanted to be at this one
00:44:46 just so you had your chance and didn't miss it.
00:44:48 But I hope to see you there.
00:44:50 We will talk to you tomorrow.
00:44:51 Thank you.
00:44:51 God bless and good day to you all.
00:44:53 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:44:56 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:45:23 We'll be right back.