Juno News - October 07, 2022


United Conservative Party leadership results

Topics
Mentioned
Poilievre and Trudeau spar over planned carbon tax increases Danielle Smith becomes the next Premier of Alberta

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 58 minutes

Words per minute

171.79

Word count

30,698

Sentence count

1,387

Harmful content

Misogyny

83

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The United Conservative Party in Alberta is electing a new leader, which means it s electing the next premier of Alberta. And the stakes are quite high. Andrew and William MacBeth are joined by True North's Rachel Emanuel in Calgary to break down the results.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 hello everyone i am so sorry for that like terrible terrible attempt at a saturday night
00:00:09 live cold open it's like the anti-cold open where like you don't even say anything or look there you
00:00:13 think you're just minding your own business we are having some technical difficulties that i
00:00:18 believe have been resolved now i was actually uh texting just like firing everyone involved so no
00:00:23 no we're all good now i apologize very much for that slight hiccup but we wanted to make sure we
00:00:27 got it right because it is a big night in conservative politics and in Canadian politics
00:00:32 right now. The United Conservative Party in Alberta is electing a new leader, which means it's
00:00:38 electing the next premier of Alberta. Very big. The stakes are quite high here. I'm joined by my
00:00:44 colleague from True North, William Macbeth, and also in Calgary at the UCP Leadership Results
00:00:49 headquarters, Rachel Emanuel, who is our Alberta reporter. And we'll throw to her as soon as we
00:00:54 have some information on the ground there. But I do want to just give you a brief primer of what's
00:01:00 happening here. This race has been delayed. The results, rather, have been delayed by two hours
00:01:05 for issues that we haven't quite heard the scope of. But basically, the party said they had a lot
00:01:11 of ballots. They needed more time. People could be voting in person today. So that was part of it
00:01:16 here. Let me just ask you generally, William, why do conservative parties in particular even bother
00:01:22 telling us time frames. It seems like they get this wrong more often than they get it right as
00:01:27 far as keeping these things tight and on schedule for results. I mean, I don't think they obviously
00:01:33 set out with the intent to keep us all waiting. And what we see is only a fraction of the work
00:01:43 that has to go into successfully executing something this big. I mean, if you think about
00:01:47 it. They had a lot of mail-in ballots. I think something like 90,000 were mailed in from one end
00:01:54 of the province to the other. They also had five in-person voting stations, four or five in-person
00:01:58 voting stations set up that were taking ballots this morning. And to logistically get that all
00:02:03 together, that's obviously quite the challenge. But I think we're all quite excited about the
00:02:07 announcement that's going to happen about who will could become Alberta's next premier and
00:02:11 the challenges that that individual will face with less than a year. In fact, I think just really
00:02:17 about six or seven months until the next provincial election. Yeah, I think that is actually
00:02:22 quite a significant thing here. And I want to bring in Rachel Emanuel in Calgary, if she is
00:02:28 ready to get her take on this. But I'll ask you in the meantime, William, because this is a fairly
00:02:33 young party. The UCP was born largely because of Jason Kenney's efforts in the Unite the Right
00:02:39 movement, uniting the PCs and the Wild Rose Party. And I don't think anyone imagined that he would
00:02:44 be out the door so quickly, not even through his first term as premier. So what do you think this
00:02:49 says in general about the UCP experiment and about Jason Kenney and about Alberta?
00:02:55 Well, I think you're certainly quite right, Andrew. I mean, if you had looked at election
00:03:00 night a few years ago when the United Conservative Party won a very strong majority government,
00:03:05 it ended the one-term premiership or government of Rachel Notley and the New Democrats,
00:03:10 Alberta's only new Democrat government. And really, Jason Kenney looked like he was a political
00:03:17 juggernaut in Alberta politics. And of course, before being a premier, he had been a Harper
00:03:23 cabinet minister and an MP for years and years and years. So for him to have faltered or to
00:03:31 encounter the kind of problems he did, I think paints a picture of just how hard it is to be
00:03:37 premier of Alberta these days. And certainly the fact that we've had so many premiers over the past
00:03:42 six or seven years reflects the fact that keeping this job for more than one term has become very
00:03:47 difficult. One of the big challenges, I think, and this certainly weighs heavily in any leadership
00:03:52 race, is that you've got in Alberta more than anywhere else a province that you can easily say
00:03:59 is a conservative province. It's an inherently conservative province. There are a lot of
00:04:04 Conservatives and Libertarians in the general population. The Overton window is much further
00:04:08 to the right than, say, in British Columbia or Ontario. So I think people expect a lot more as
00:04:14 a result from the Conservative Party in Alberta, whichever party that is at whichever stage in its
00:04:19 history. No, you're certainly right. And it poses a real challenge, I think, for anybody who steps
00:04:26 in as Premier and leader of a party to try and meet the expectations that Albertans have for
00:04:32 what they want to see out of a conservative government. And, you know, even the vaunted
00:04:37 premiers of conservative premiers of the past, I think, for example, of Ralph Klein, he was
00:04:43 actually pushed out of his position as premier, because people thought he had maybe started to
00:04:50 rest too much on his laurels or wasn't really advancing on some of the major issues that
00:04:55 people wanted to see. And, you know, I would say here in Alberta, it's things like changing the
00:05:00 healthcare model? What, you know, is there room to have something other than a one size fits all
00:05:07 public system? And if any innovation is going to happen on some of these policy areas, I think
00:05:13 people expect it to come from Alberta. And certainly that's an expectation I think that
00:05:17 United Conservative Party members have and other small C conservatives have across the problems.
00:05:21 They want to see real change in innovation, not, you know, more of the status quo or moving along
00:05:27 at a snail's pace when it comes to
00:05:29 building policy. I want to check
00:05:31 in with Rachel Emanuel,
00:05:33 True North's Alberta reporter who is in
00:05:35 Calgary right now at the
00:05:37 live results show. Rachel,
00:05:39 what's the plan for tonight? What's happening?
00:05:46 Oh, I'm not hearing
00:05:47 Rachel's audio.
00:05:57 All right, we're not getting Rachel's audio. So we'll get that sorted out in a moment. Again, I apologize for the technical issues here. But at the same time, we are a bootstraps operation. So we will get this to you as soon as we can. Let's just talk about the road forward here, William, because obviously there's been a lot of confusion about the I don't even want to say confusion, but a lot of conflict in the race about the Sovereignty Act.
00:06:21 This was Danielle Smith's flagship policy, and it really became, I think, the punching bag that everyone in the race really started to take their swings at.
00:06:30 And I'm wondering, it's not a fait accompli, of course, but if Danielle Smith is the leader and if this is, as she promises, Bill 1 under the Danielle Smith government, a lot of these people that were railing against this bill will have to support it, will they not?
00:06:44 So how does the unity question work after a race like this? 0.68
00:06:47 Oh, absolutely. I mean, I think that will be probably, if it is Danielle Smith who's elected tonight, that will be a big challenge she has, is uniting her caucus, her new caucus, of which she is not yet a member.
00:07:01 She doesn't have a seat in the Alberta legislature. She would have to spend an awful lot of time making sure that caucus got on board with what she's been proposing. 0.63
00:07:14 And given how many of the leadership candidates came out very strongly against her signature policy, that unity is going to pose quite a challenge for her.
00:07:24 And caucus unity has been what has spelled the death knell for so many Alberta conservative leaders, if you think back to...
00:07:32 Including Jason Kenney. I mean, part of the reason we're here.
00:07:36 Exactly. But the reason we're all here is because he couldn't keep his caucus united and together.
00:07:42 And then before him, Alison Redford was pushed out by a caucus revolt.
00:07:47 Ed Stelmack really had to step down as premier because of a caucus revolt.
00:07:51 And, of course, at one point, Danielle Smith faced a very famous caucus revolt.
00:07:55 So the question will be, has she learned from some of these things in the past?
00:07:59 Has she learned from Alberta's political history?
00:08:01 And can she avoid repeating some of the mistakes that have been made by so many who came before her?
00:08:06 Yeah, very well said.
00:08:07 I think we have the feed set up with Rachel Emanuel again.
00:08:10 Apologies for the delay.
00:08:11 never want to deprive the people of Rachel Rachel tell me what the mood on the ground there is right
00:08:17 now what's happening people are just sort of slowly trickling in I think everyone as William
00:08:22 mentioned you know we've seen the polling people are expecting a Smith victory tonight the question
00:08:26 is really you know is she going to take it on the first bout is she going to take it later on but
00:08:30 people are excited for the results tonight as you mentioned it is a historic vote it's one of those
00:08:34 rare occasions when you're not just voting for the leader of a party but you're also voting for the
00:08:38 premier so certainly an electric feeling in the room tonight you know it's been a couple years
00:08:42 since we've been able to do these types of events and we're and we're getting back into them now
00:08:45 after covid but people are happy to be here today and excited to see who's going to be the new
00:08:49 premier of alberta you've been covering this race you've been keeping in touch with the campaigns
00:08:54 and the candidates has there been like one defining issue of the race apart from the alberta
00:09:00 sovereignty act that everyone's tried to you know get their piece of either it's danielle smith
00:09:04 pushing it or the others beating up on it has there been like one other issue that's really
00:09:07 been dominating here? Yeah, as you mentioned, of course, there's been so much discussion about the
00:09:12 Alberta Sovereignty Act. It has been one of the defining issues. But besides that, I think one of
00:09:16 the defining issues has really just been COVID-19 and the way that it's impacted Albertans and the
00:09:21 way they want their government to change going forward. Danielle Smith has positioned herself
00:09:24 as an anti-establishment candidate who's not afraid to shake things up. So we've seen that 0.78
00:09:29 come forward with her promises, for example, to never lock down Alberta again, to resist federal
00:09:33 pressure to do so, to never mandate vaccines and to change all the stations so that it becomes
00:09:37 illegal to mandate vaccines going forward. As well, another issue that I've heard brought up
00:09:42 at every single campaign rally that I've attended across the province is AHS, Alberta Health
00:09:46 Services. Albertans are absolutely not happy with the way that AHS operated throughout the COVID-19
00:09:51 pandemic. And, you know, we've even heard some complaints from the Kennedy government from it
00:09:54 that they asked for intensive care unit beds to be built. Those beds were not built during the
00:09:58 pandemic. And of course, fighting against Ottawa, there's a lot of Albertans who are not happy with
00:10:03 Kenny's record on getting a fair deal from Ottawa. And we've heard a lot of discussion
00:10:06 about that throughout the leadership race. So I would say those three things are sort of the
00:10:09 defining topics throughout the UCP leadership race. You've got, as you just mentioned, Danielle
00:10:15 Smith, who's been running as in a lot of ways, the anti-Kenny. Brian Jean, one of the reasons
00:10:20 he got back into politics was to take aim at Kenny. Todd Lowen, a former UCP MLA, kicked out
00:10:26 a caucus and now running for leadership. And then you've also got people like, for example,
00:10:31 Travis Taves, who was the finance minister, Rebecca Schultz, who was the children's services
00:10:35 minister, very key Kenny allies. So has this race really been split into the anti-Kenny candidates
00:10:41 and the Kenny continuity candidates, for lack of a better term? You know, it sort of has, but I would
00:10:47 say the split isn't quite, as you just mentioned, I've sort of seen people pairing Todd Lowen and
00:10:51 Danielle Smith together. A lot of people are saying, you know, vote Todd or Danielle one and
00:10:55 second. I haven't heard a lot of like commentary about Brian Jean fitting into an anti-establishment
00:10:59 candidate, although he has been very critical of Jason Kenney. And as you mentioned, he even got
00:11:03 into politics because he said he wanted to see a change in the premiership. We've also seen efforts
00:11:08 from some of the candidates to distance themselves from their record while they were in Kenny's
00:11:12 cabinet. Of course, Travis Taves, you know, he sort of hinted at it. He said, I can't talk about
00:11:15 what happened in those private COVID discussions, but, you know, I'm a farmer from rural Alberta,
00:11:20 and you can only imagine that I was speaking up for rural Albertans when we were talking about
00:11:23 lockdown. So, you know, he won't come out and say what he said during the committee meetings because
00:11:27 He doesn't want to break cabinet confidence, but he sort of, you know, pushed people in that
00:11:30 direction. He's alluded to it. And of course, as well with Rebecca Schultz, you know, we've seen
00:11:34 her say, I'm not from the boys club. You know, I might've been, you know, in Kenny's cabinet,
00:11:38 but I was never part of the inner circle. I was never part of the boys club. So certainly they've
00:11:42 all done their part to distance themselves from Kenny's record. I think they all know it is a
00:11:46 tough record to be up against right now because he is so low in the polls, but I would say a lot
00:11:50 of them haven't done so successfully. We just came off the federal conservative leadership race.
00:11:56 we did a show much like this one there are you seeing parallels between the two races or the
00:12:01 dynamics just completely different I am seeing parallels in the two races in the sense that
00:12:07 Pierre Polyev was sort of the obvious front runner and people were pretty sure he was going to take
00:12:11 the victory of course he won by a landslide victory you know even surpassing Stephen Harper's
00:12:15 numbers when he won the conservative leadership victory and we really saw for the first time that
00:12:19 conservatives were able to rally around someone now of course here in Alberta Polyev made some
00:12:23 campaign stops I went to those stops there were thousands of people there now of course when we're
00:12:27 looking at provincial politics we're dealing with you know less people are going to be engaged in
00:12:31 provincial politics a lot of times and certainly that was the case but I saw huge crowds rally 0.96
00:12:35 around Danielle Smith throughout the campaign she was pulling crowds in the hundreds I just didn't 1.00
00:12:40 see that with some of the other candidates it wasn't at least a consistent thing for them where
00:12:43 they were pulling crowds in the hundreds but I mean like as I mentioned before I think the main
00:12:47 question here is is she going to be able to pull off a victory in the first ballot and I think what 0.76
00:12:51 we're going to see if she doesn't win on the first ballot is there's going to be knives out for her 0.70
00:12:54 pretty quickly because she was so controversial and because she is so anti-establishment and
00:12:59 because most of the ucb caucus backs travis daves they didn't endorse danielle smith now some of 0.92
00:13:04 them switched their endorsement to danielle smith throughout the leadership race but she certainly
00:13:07 wasn't the caucus favorite and many of the caucus including jason kenny including his finance
00:13:11 minister jason nixon even came out and said they didn't support the alberta sovereignty act
00:13:15 i'll let you get back to the room in a moment but let me just ask you rachel what's planned
00:13:21 format wise i know there's obviously been this two-hour delay so technically they're supposed
00:13:25 to be starting up i believe in about three minutes time i don't think that's going to be happening so
00:13:29 what is the plan as you understand it so i'm told that we were supposed to begin at seven as you
00:13:34 mentioned it looks like that's going to be delayed now and then we're supposed to you know have sing
00:13:38 the national anthem the canadian national anthem then they're supposed to be a couple speakers and
00:13:42 then we're going to get right into the vote results very quickly so sounds like they're
00:13:45 running a little bit late even from the two hours that they push back but the good news is that once
00:13:49 the program does get started it doesn't seem like it's going to be that long of a program.
00:13:54 All right well I know you are going to be hunting down some movers and shakers to
00:13:58 interview them so we'll see you back throughout the evening. Thanks very much Rachel we'll check
00:14:03 in in a bit. Sounds good thank you. All right let me go back to you William on this so obviously
00:14:09 we've just heard from Rachel that this hasn't really been an exact clone of the federal
00:14:14 leadership race, but some very similar dynamics. I don't know if there's going to be in this race.
00:14:18 I don't think there is this really decisive first ballot Polyevre-esque victory. But in general,
00:14:24 where do you see moving forward? Because we were talking about the unity issue earlier,
00:14:28 and we've also seen a province that has been unafraid, generally speaking, and MLAs have
00:14:33 been unafraid to criticize their leaders. So do you think they are going to be able to unify?
00:14:37 Well, I mean, that is the, you know, tremendous question that will face whoever does win this
00:14:44 leadership race. I think a key difference, of course, between Polliver, who, when he won,
00:14:49 was the front runner for sure, but he also had an overwhelming amount of caucus support.
00:14:54 And I think that's a big difference is, as Rachel mentioned, Daniel Smith, if she does become
00:14:59 a premier designate tonight, a new leader of the United Conservative Party,
00:15:03 she won't have had a lot of caucus support going into it. So she's going to have to work quite hard.
00:15:09 One thing I think that she also has to do is unite some of the different factions within the 0.82
00:15:15 United Conservative Party. Because whereas I think a lot of people maybe agreed it was time for a
00:15:21 different leader than Jason Kenney, I don't think there's a lot of agreement right now on what the
00:15:26 future of the United Conservative Party looks like. So she's going to have to spend some of
00:15:31 her time and effort, really bringing those people back into the united conservative fold and making
00:15:37 sure that it's a cohesive party and team. And I think you're going to hear a piece of advice from
00:15:43 some other people that says things like she's going to have to, you know, pivot to the center 0.99
00:15:47 and she's going to have to abandon some of her core policies and things. Well, I can tell you 0.85
00:15:52 that in my opinion, that would be really quite a big mistake. You only have to look at when Erin
00:15:57 O'Toole ran on a pretty conservative platform for leader. And then after he won, he tacked to the 0.68
00:16:03 middle. Nobody was happy about that. So she's going to have to not get rid of the things that
00:16:08 successfully brought her to the leadership, but build a bigger coalition. And I think those
00:16:14 issues are like cost of living, Alberta's relationship with Ottawa, getting a fair deal
00:16:18 for our fiscal transfers, all of that sort of thing. And maybe, you know, some innovation in
00:16:23 Alberta Health Services and Alberta's health care system.
00:16:26 Sounds good. I want to check back in with Rachel Emanuel here.
00:16:29 I know Rachel has a couple of folks she's interviewing, 0.90
00:16:31 and one of them is Senator-elect Erica Barutti,
00:16:35 formerly the president of the UCP.
00:16:38 We'll go now to Rachel and Erica in Calgary.
00:16:42 Hi, yes. So I'm joined with Erica Barutti.
00:16:44 She's the vice president of the U.S. Department of Health and Health Group.
00:16:48 And I'm just going to ask her some questions today.
00:16:50 So what are you hoping for today?
00:16:52 What do you think is going to be the results of the leadership race?
00:16:54 Yeah, I mean, in an ideal world, we do have a first ballot, regardless of who's the leader,
00:16:58 because of the struggles that we've seen within unity of the party.
00:17:01 I do not think that's the case.
00:17:03 I think, you know, from what we've seen in the polls, as well as, you know, just the membership engagement,
00:17:10 I do think Danielle Smith will come out on top on the first ballot.
00:17:13 Well, we'll probably go through a few rounds before we figure out who's the next leader of the United Conservative Party.
00:17:19 And if Danielle doesn't have a first ballot victory, you know, we've seen a lot of her candidates, her opponents and other UCP MLAs attack her throughout this leadership race.
00:17:28 If she doesn't have a first ballot victory, is her ability to unify the caucus going to be that much harder or do you think it won't matter?
00:17:34 I don't think it'll actually matter.
00:17:36 You know, leadership races, many of us have lived through a lot of them.
00:17:40 She was the front runner from the beginning. 1.00
00:17:41 She was the only candidate that came out with a lot of pretty aggressive policies. 0.80
00:17:46 And that's kind of the theme of the campaign.
00:17:48 you know even across canada people are like oh the sovereignty act right it's not about names or
00:17:53 anything like that but a piece of policy uh that hasn't you know even been presented or written in
00:17:58 the ability for caucus to review so i think that a lot of it was the policy or the political tactics
00:18:04 as opposed to how people would feel when if she's actually the successor and the leader of the party
00:18:09 i think there'll be a little bit of a change um and i also think that you know every individual
00:18:15 that's in this race knows the sensitivities of unity and the challenges that caucus faced
00:18:20 and know that that's the biggest uphill battle to win the next election. We need to get the
00:18:25 internal team in order to be able to find the real enemy, which is Rachel Notley. 1.00
00:18:29 So you mentioned some of her pretty aggressive policies. Obviously, the Alberta Sovereignty Act 1.00
00:18:33 was something that Smith put forward. For those of our viewers who aren't aware of what it is,
00:18:37 it would essentially seek to bar federal legislation deemed harmful to Alberta's interest.
00:18:41 Now, I'm wondering if you think that the fact that so much of the leadership race was dominated
00:18:44 around discussion of this proposal was that beneficial for smith or did it actually put
00:18:48 her in a negative light for the general election with now a lot of albertans having pretty negative
00:18:52 views of this piece of policy i don't think it hurt her in the leadership race uh it is a pretty
00:18:57 like um party forward type of piece of legislation like the red meat for the base of the party so i
00:19:04 don't think it hurts her in the leadership race but yes the pivot is going to be um you know
00:19:08 probably be more challenging for her than maybe another uh leadership candidate however um i do
00:19:14 think there's a lot of process that goes into it there's gonna be onboarding and the drafting of
00:19:18 the legislation which i always say is like the part that makes none of this stuff that you you
00:19:23 run on super sexy um so no i think that there's still opportunity but it did definitely get hit
00:19:30 the airwaves um but i also think that you know unfortunately for the unity of the party that
00:19:35 That was kind of the attack by all other candidates to the front runner and on a piece of policy that she was running off of.
00:19:43 So it does make it a little bit more challenging for the internal inside baseball politics and also kind of the larger Alberta vote.
00:19:51 But I think when it actually comes to fruition, it's probably going to be less intimidating.
00:19:56 And, you know, even we've seen lately on something like the gun regulation or the clawback.
00:20:03 So, and you have Manitoba and Saskatchewan on side.
00:20:06 So there's some things in the Sovereignty Act that have already actually already been put in place
00:20:09 and stuff that we've now seen unity across Western Canada that will help Smith achieve those goals.
00:20:16 For sure.
00:20:17 You know, on the Sovereignty Act, we saw Alberta Premier Jason Kenney sort of waited and he commented on it.
00:20:21 He said he thought it would make Alberta a laughingstock.
00:20:23 Of course, then Kenney's third party advertiser Shaping Alberta's Future,
00:20:26 which on its website said it was created to promote Kenney.
00:20:29 It came out and was also attacking Danielle Smith.
00:20:30 It said she wasn't a real conservative and sort of critiqued some of her stances in the past.
00:20:35 I'm wondering if you think, you know, Kenny's decision to take a position in this UCB leadership race
00:20:38 impacted the outcome of the leadership race, and if so, how it did that?
00:20:42 Yeah, well, first I want to disclose, like, Jason Kenney is a friend and someone as party president
00:20:46 that I work closely with, but I don't think it's appropriate for a current leader to interfere in a leadership race.
00:20:54 So I do think that it was probably because there wasn't a strong effort or a success
00:20:58 by some of the other leadership candidates that he felt he needed to step in for whatever reason he
00:21:03 chose to. And I actually think it helped Smith. I think it helped Smith in a lot of the rural
00:21:07 ridings. I think it helped show that, you know, she is not so much of the same, which I think
00:21:12 people were frustrated with. And so, you know, obviously, again, on the broader population,
00:21:18 that didn't help because he has such a large voice across the province as opposed to just
00:21:22 the party. But I don't think it's going to hurt her in this leadership race.
00:21:26 Sure. Great. Well, thank you very much, Erica. I'm just going to throw it back to the room and see if there's any questions Andrew would like to ask.
00:21:32 One thing I would just ask, purely on a self-indulgent level, Erica, obviously you are a senator-elect and we know that the federal government has not regarded the Senate elections in Alberta as being legitimate here.
00:21:44 Are all the candidates generally in alignment that they want elected senators in Ottawa?
00:21:50 Are all the UCP leadership candidates generally in agreement that they want elected senators in Ottawa?
00:21:55 I mean, selfishly, I would really like that to happen, as I'm sure, well, you know, I'm not sure if all of the viewers know, I was one of the elected senators that was chosen by Albertans in 2021.
00:22:08 So I do think that they believe in that process.
00:22:11 I think that's a big sign of having our right to choose and having, you know, that regional representation that the Senate was actually designed for.
00:22:20 I haven't personally asked them, but I'm pretty confident that, you know,
00:22:23 passing that piece of the act and all of them voting in favor of it shows that they do believe.
00:22:28 I mean, we want to take, I think as UCPers, we want to take less power from,
00:22:32 take power, sorry, take power away from Ottawa and put it to our population.
00:22:37 So I can't see how under the party banner they would not support it.
00:22:41 Well, absolutely. All right. Well, thank you very much, Erica. I appreciate your insight.
00:22:43 Thank you.
00:22:45 All right. Thank you, Erica Baroudis. And thank you, Rachel Emanuel.
00:22:48 We'll check back in with them in a few moments time as things unfold.
00:22:52 Now, just to give you the lay of the land here, there were supposed to be results a little over two hours ago.
00:22:57 They've delayed their UCP program to start at 7 p.m. Mountain Time, which is coming up in negative six minutes.
00:23:04 So they are still running behind. Conservatives, generally speaking, do this often at leadership.
00:23:10 And Jason Kenney's press conferences, I should say.
00:23:12 Jason Kenney always gives good answers at his press conferences, but they never start on time.
00:23:16 I'm joined by William Macbeth, my colleague at True North, long time Alberta Politico.
00:23:22 I want to pick up where Erica and Rachel left off a little bit here, William,
00:23:26 and talk about Jason Kenney's decision to get involved in this race.
00:23:30 Very critical of Danielle Smith at the very beginning,
00:23:32 even when there was a challenge mounting over his leadership.
00:23:35 And now through the race, he's criticized her as well.
00:23:37 And this isn't typical.
00:23:39 Stephen Harper didn't criticize any of his successors.
00:23:42 Erin O'Toole wasn't criticized by Andrew Scheer.
00:23:45 and Pierre Paulyev, we hope, is not going to be criticized by Aaron O'Toole, and none of these
00:23:49 people got involved in the races. What do you make of Jason Kenney, who fancies himself a unifier,
00:23:55 generally, doing this and getting into this trench? Well, you're absolutely right that it's
00:24:00 highly unusual that a lame duck premier, lame duck party leader who has been, he didn't really
00:24:10 go for a voluntary walk in the snow. Party members did send him close to packing. If you recall in
00:24:16 the vote, he scratched through with something like 51% of support, but he deemed that not enough.
00:24:23 So it is very unusual for a sitting party leader to take swipes at any of the leadership
00:24:29 contestants, particularly the likeliest person to succeed him in the job. But I think one of
00:24:35 the points that that both erica and rachel made that's so good is i think he felt that the
00:24:41 candidates were the other candidates in the race were not doing a good enough job of raising
00:24:47 concerns and issues about danielle smith and about uh her sovereignty act proposal and about some of
00:24:54 her political history so i think he felt that since they weren't doing it we weren't seeing it
00:24:59 from effective opponent campaigns, he would take that responsibility on himself. Now, I don't think
00:25:05 it was a particularly great decision just because it's going to lead to bad blood. If it is Danielle
00:25:11 Smith, who's the winner in a couple hours tonight, then, you know, she knows that this is not who
00:25:17 Jason Kenney wanted to succeed her. And I also think it diminishes Mr. Kenney's record a little
00:25:23 bit because it shows again that he's offside with where his own party is by criticizing the
00:25:29 person who members could well make his successor in just a little bit. So one thing I want to ask
00:25:37 about Jason Kenney, and it may be too early to answer this question, is effectively about
00:25:41 what his legacy will look like. We know that COVID was very difficult, very difficult for
00:25:47 a lot of premiers. He's elected with an agenda. He gets, you know, maybe a year into it, a year
00:25:52 and a half into it, and he's got this pandemic to deal with here. Do you think generally people
00:25:56 will come back into a more moderate view of him as time goes on? I do think in the fullness of
00:26:03 time, he will improve in the eyes of history, that people will look at some of the things he did,
00:26:10 helping to kickstart Alberta's economic growth, getting Alberta back into growth and job mode,
00:26:17 cutting business taxes in order to attract
00:26:20 new businesses, diversifying
00:26:21 Alberta's economy. We're seeing lots
00:26:23 of great companies choose to set
00:26:25 up shop in Alberta because the government
00:26:27 did its best
00:26:29 to go out and recruit these people.
00:26:32 There's a famous advertising campaign
00:26:34 running right now in Toronto
00:26:35 urging young Torontonians
00:26:38 to come to Alberta. They can afford
00:26:40 houses. They'll find jobs.
00:26:42 They won't have to sit on the 401
00:26:43 for an hour and a half every
00:26:45 every morning to go to work. So I think history will be kinder. I do think he will suffer some
00:26:52 problems around how he managed COVID. And I think, to be honest, he hasn't really understood himself
00:26:58 where the problems were with what he did. And, you know, sometimes it's hard when it's you
00:27:04 to be, you know, introspective on your own actions. But, you know, the handful of things
00:27:10 that I'm thinking of was pursuing public health orders against pastors, for example, the flip
00:27:17 flopping on vaccine passports saying there wouldn't be one. And now they're and then making
00:27:22 it mandatory. So I think things like that, it's his COVID management that I think is going to
00:27:26 linger in some people's minds as the problem. But if you look at the non COVID things, I think
00:27:32 Kenny, JC Kenny actually has quite a record to be proud of. Yeah, I've heard of these ads trying
00:27:38 to woo Ontarians to Alberta and I worry for your sake and the sake of a province that I love dearly
00:27:44 Alberta it's going to be Florida where like they're going to import all their voting tendencies
00:27:48 as well but we'll we'll cross that bridge when we get to it I want to go back to Rachel Emanuel
00:27:53 in Calgary who has I believe someone from Danielle Smith's campaign with her we're going to do this
00:27:58 with all the campaigns take it away Rachel yeah hi thanks Andrew I'm here with Matthew Alltime he
00:28:03 was the campaign manager for Danielle Smith thanks for joining us Matt I'm wondering if
00:28:07 you're hearing anything so far if you have any predictions for what the vote result is going to
00:28:10 look like tonight my predictions are still the same as this morning where you still got to wait
00:28:14 for them all to come in and hopefully uh the hard work of daniel smith she's been a great candidate
00:28:19 to to work for hopefully that's results in a victory tonight sure great so i'm wondering if
00:28:24 you think there was any sort of fatal flaws in the campaign is there anything you wish that you had
00:28:27 done better you know big mess ups that you saw tonight that could lead to a lower turnout tonight
00:28:32 than you were hoping for i don't think so i think i have a sincere candidate who puts it all all
00:28:36 the cards to the table and really means what she says when she speaks and so she's in a great job
00:28:41 I think I we all stand behind her the entire campaign team 110% and what we've accomplished
00:28:45 and uh there's nothing we would change we've spoken about this a little bit on the show tonight
00:28:50 the Alberta Sovereignty Act dominated so much discussion throughout the you know the leadership
00:28:54 race you saw I'm sure at all the events that you were at I saw it at all the events that I was at
00:28:58 do you think that this benefited Danielle Smith or do you think that it was negative in the sense
00:29:02 that so many of her opponents painted it so negatively and that's a record that she's going
00:29:06 have to run against in the spring general election no i think i think we saw the first uh kind of
00:29:12 invocation of the sovereignty act uh last week when the justice minister kind of used it in a
00:29:17 way on the rcmp gun grab so and uh kind of a shocking turn of events vaskatchewan and manitoba
00:29:22 feel the same way so i think daniel's sovereignty act is exactly what alberta needs uh you know if
00:29:27 the toronto star hates it it must be working and i think albertans want a premier that's uh that's
00:29:32 it's strong and stands strong and means what she says and has strong policy to back it up.
00:29:36 Something that we've seen from some of Smith's critics as well is that she's going to struggle
00:29:40 with caucus unity. I'm wondering if you feel this way as well or you know you you've known her
00:29:44 better than most people would. Have you seen efforts from her in recent days to sort of unify
00:29:47 the caucus? Has she already begun working on building some of those relationships?
00:29:52 You know I think she's been reaching out to MLAs from day one and she's been able to attract a lot
00:29:56 of MLA endorsements including two who have switched from other campaigns. So I think it's a testament
00:30:00 durability to listen to sit down with people say hey what's going on what are your ideas and
00:30:04 policies for government i think that was refreshing for them to hear you know it's been a couple years
00:30:08 of division and a lot of emily's felt left out of the policy making process in government so i think
00:30:12 she's willing to bridge that and show them that she's genuine bring your policies and good ideas
00:30:16 to the table and let's let's roll all right well thank you very much matt back to the studio
00:30:22 all right thank you very much rachel and thank you matt we're going to have lots of interviews to
00:30:28 come with representatives from other campaigns as the evening proceeds Andrew Lawton here with
00:30:34 William Macbeth for True North and I just want to tell you here I mean this is one of many
00:30:39 opportunities that we take throughout the year when big things are happening to host a live show
00:30:43 around them sometimes we do them in the studio sometimes we have people on the ground and all
00:30:47 over like tonight and we cannot do any of this without your support and I truly truly mean that
00:30:53 that true north is a grassroots operation uh the reason we don't get the 1.4 billion dollars a year
00:30:58 uh if so we'd be doing it from like a private jet flying over the maldives or something not from
00:31:02 uh where we are but we are always always always striving to be on the ground for the story and
00:31:07 we need the people that value the work we do to support us so we can continue doing that so if
00:31:12 that is you please do head on over to donate.tnc.news donate.tnc.news and you don't need to be
00:31:19 from Alberta, we cover Ontario elections, federal elections, all sorts of stuff. And I think the
00:31:24 general tenor of this night is that the Conservative movement is having it say, not just
00:31:29 one particular party. And I think this has been a shift we've seen really in the last year. And I
00:31:35 want to just, I'll get back to the Alberta specific focus here, but I wanted to ask you about that
00:31:40 more generally, William, because there are, I think, a lot of parallels if you look at the
00:31:43 people that are being engaged in the process here in politics this year, from the convoy to
00:31:49 Pierre Polyev's leadership campaign to, I'd say, largely Daniel Smith, but in general,
00:31:54 the UCP leadership race as well. Are we seeing this significant turning point in conservative
00:31:59 politics in Canada in general right now? Yeah, I mean, I think it's so fascinating to look at,
00:32:06 you know, how conservative parties have changed and how their membership base has evolved. And
00:32:12 And I think you are seeing a pretty fundamental shift that actually started in other countries a bit earlier.
00:32:20 I think you saw with the election of U.S. President Donald Trump, there was very much this move away from establishment politics towards, you know, outsiders and, you know, getting rid of maybe some of the traditional alliances that had existed.
00:32:37 I think Republicans would have thought of themselves as the party of big business.
00:32:43 But in the last couple of elections, they've been really focusing on blue collar workers, people who live and work in middle America, who have seen their jobs exported to foreign countries.
00:32:54 You saw the same thing with the defeat or the successful Brexit vote where Britain decided to leave the European Union and the election of Boris Johnson with a huge then majority election.
00:33:07 And now I'm thinking Canada with the Freedom Convoy protest, you're starting to see this idea that too much of establishment government politics and society isn't working for ordinary people.
00:33:19 Jason Kenney's ads inviting young Torontonians to come to Alberta because they can actually afford a house reflects the fact that how did we get into this mess where people living in Canada's largest city can't afford to buy homes in that city?
00:33:33 that they're having to wait 30 or 40 years before they can actually get onto the property ladder
00:33:39 because of climbing house prices.
00:33:41 So I think that's why you're seeing a lot of the difference in who people are choosing
00:33:45 and why establishment candidates are having such a hard time connecting
00:33:50 because there is a very energetic, motivated base,
00:33:53 and populism is a factor that will stay in Canadian politics
00:33:56 and especially within conservative politics.
00:33:59 Yeah, that is fair.
00:34:01 And just to bring it back to an Alberta context, in Ontario, we had two parties that popped up that really didn't make a dent, that were trying to be the true conservatives, the alternative conservative option.
00:34:13 You had the New Blue and the Ontario Party in the polls didn't really translate to anything.
00:34:18 Alberta is a bit different.
00:34:20 The Wild Rose Independence Party has a leader who is a former or had, I guess.
00:34:24 I mean, there's a lot of internal turmoil there that we don't need to get into right now.
00:34:28 But they had in Paul Hinman, a leader that had been the previous Wild Rose leader.
00:34:33 They have in by-elections had a chunk of support.
00:34:36 They haven't elected anyone.
00:34:37 Now you've got an Alberta independence party with Archer Pulaski at the helm.
00:34:42 So you're always going to have, it sounds like, these aggrieved parties.
00:34:45 But in Alberta in particular, it does seem like it's harder to get everyone to play on the same team.
00:34:50 So do you think there is going to be an issue from these smaller parties in the next election?
00:34:56 I mean, I think that's a critical question. When I talked a little bit earlier about uniting the factions of the United Conservative Party, putting the word united back in that party name is going to be a tremendous challenge, because how do you square some of the different coalitions?
00:35:12 Like if you look at the slate of candidates running to be leader, you've got everyone from Lila Ahir to Todd Lowen.
00:35:21 And how can they both be in a single political party when they seem so opposite on so many policy areas?
00:35:29 So in some ways, I think the United Conservative Party will have to think about what it wants to be.
00:35:34 You know, who does it want to appeal to? What policies does it want to have?
00:35:37 And how can it build a broad enough coalition in order to win an election, but not become so big that it turned into the old PC party where it really stopped being conservative in many, many ways.
00:35:50 And why, you know, the Wild Rose Party, which is a party I worked for for four years, trying to make government, why that got the boost of support it did that even at one point looked like we might win an election.
00:36:01 Just one point I do want to make, which I think is interesting, was when Danielle Smith first announced her candidacy, I didn't know if Albertans were going to accept her return from kind of political exile after the floor crossing and after she had kind of blown up politically and was regarded as almost a pariah.
00:36:24 I didn't know how it was going to be that she could come back.
00:36:27 The fact that she has come back and faced relatively little opposition for it,
00:36:32 to me, tells me that she does have a very good chance of putting forward an option to voters
00:36:37 because they aren't going to, if her own party can forgive her for what had happened
00:36:41 and elect her leader, I think everyday Albertans can make that leap as well.
00:36:46 Yes, and I used to guest host for Danielle Smith when she was on the radio at 770 CHQR in Calgary. 0.94
00:36:53 And I remember when she started that show, I mean, the audience hated her.
00:36:57 It was very raw at the time.
00:36:58 And she's spoken about this as well.
00:37:00 And she did do a lot of work.
00:37:02 And one thing that I've said about Danielle Smith, and I'm not saying this against other
00:37:06 candidates, I've just specifically seen it with Danielle.
00:37:09 I would run into her at everything.
00:37:11 She was at every event, every conference, every meeting.
00:37:14 She really did, over the last several years, put in a lot of the legwork to meet these
00:37:19 people.
00:37:20 And a lot of those people, the ones that I was talking about a moment ago that might be inclined to support the Wild Rose Independence Party or the Alberta Independence Party, she's actually listened to their concerns and shares some of them, although believes that the UCP is clearly the vehicle to advance that.
00:37:35 So I think a lot of people who did have an open mind really did see in Danielle someone that was prepared to own that mistake and move forward.
00:37:46 No, you're quite right.
00:37:47 And I mean, I think if you have a leader who is prepared to consider alternative points of view, even if they don't necessarily 100 percent agree with them, I do think you have a lot of an easier time in keeping people inside the coalition.
00:38:01 I think to our illustrious prime minister, Mr. Trudeau, and how he handled the trucker convoy protests and something that people have really pointed to as why they disliked the federal government's handling was he simply wouldn't meet with the protesters and he wouldn't listen to their concerns.
00:38:20 And if he had done that, I suspect a lot of the wind in the sails of that protest would have gone, and it would have ended probably a little bit sooner and maybe wouldn't have involved the invocation of the emergency act.
00:38:34 But he wouldn't do it.
00:38:36 And I think Danielle hopefully has learned from that and said, I'm going to meet with everybody who is part of our coalition.
00:38:43 I won't necessarily agree with all of them, but I'll be respectful to them, and I'll be respectful of their views and their opinions.
00:38:48 uh just while we are waiting here i wanted to do a little bit of a throwback we interviewed
00:38:54 several of the leadership candidates uh over the course of the campaign on my show and obviously
00:38:59 rachel emmanuel has done some fantastic coverage on her end of it and i want to share one clip
00:39:04 we've been talking a lot about danielle smith i want to talk about one of the other contenders
00:39:07 here uh we have a shorter clip i think it's only a couple minutes or so but this is an
00:39:11 excerpt from my exchange with former kenny cabinet minister rebecca schultz
00:39:21 oh maybe we don't have the why is it that you want to be the leader of your party and the
00:39:27 premier of alberta you know i would say that first and foremost i believe in the future of our party
00:39:33 but also in the province of alberta we have so much to offer and we need somebody who can stand
00:39:41 up and defend the constitutional rights of Albertans, make sure that we continue to drive
00:39:46 economic growth and keep our party united so that we can defeat the NDP in 2023. Our provincial
00:39:53 election next year is in the spring. And so I think, you know, it's been a really difficult time.
00:39:59 You know, I think obviously everybody knows that. And I think instead of vilifying each other and
00:40:04 as conservatives, you know, you know, focusing on some of the things that divide us, we really need 1.00
00:40:09 leader who can bring us together remember who our true opponent is which is the ndp uh and take them
00:40:15 on here in alberta next year you know we had a leadership review for premier kenny that was very
00:40:21 close virtually 50 50 so no matter which way someone goes the party is divided the party is
00:40:27 split down the middle how do you not just build a winning coalition from that in the leadership
00:40:33 race but beyond that when you have that division in your party you know and it's tough and i think
00:40:39 you know everybody largely whether i'm talking to party members or albertans i think people agree
00:40:45 that they fully expect governments are going to make decisions that they disagree with
00:40:50 um you know i i don't think it's that what we've heard is that you know we've we've gotten off
00:40:55 track our government has done a lot of really great things our economy here in alberta um is
00:41:02 kind of on fire we're taking off coming out of you know like i said an economic recession a tough
00:41:07 two years our unemployment is at the lowest rate since 2015 more jobs created every day things are
00:41:13 looking up but we did get off track oftentimes people say it was our tone we felt like how you
00:41:19 were communicating decisions um didn't show that you heard what we were saying we we didn't feel
00:41:25 heard we didn't feel listened to um and so i think a we have to switch the tone b i am so dedicated
00:41:32 to the conservative movement um that is not something that's new for me i think we need
00:41:37 somebody who understands that the grassroots party members engaging with people uh door knocking
00:41:43 getting out there listening and taking action that's important that's just as important as
00:41:47 governing is keeping our coalition together and so i think you know it takes somebody that's
00:41:52 highly motivated very committed um the first thing i committed to do is door knock in every single
00:41:58 constituency across this province, meet with our local UCP community boards and those presidents,
00:42:04 make sure that they know that they have a seat at the decision-making table and that they're heard.
00:42:10 I'm willing to do that. Our opposition here, they are highly motivated. They are working
00:42:15 very hard. They are very disciplined and we need a disciplined team. We have an awesome team. We
00:42:22 have amazing, talented MLAs and they want their talents and strengths to be used as well.
00:42:28 that was my interview early on in the campaign with rebecca schultz one of the candidates vying
00:42:37 for the ucp leadership tonight as i've said we're checking in with the campaign teams in calgary i
00:42:43 want to go now to rachel emmanuel who's on the ground with vitor marciano from brian jean's
00:42:49 campaign hey yeah i'm joined right now by vitor marciano he is the campaign manager for brian
00:42:54 Gene, as you just mentioned. How are you doing, Vitor? I'm wondering what you're hearing so far
00:42:58 tonight. Do you have any results for us yet? No one has results yet. So we have little bits
00:43:03 and pieces of rumors from what our scrutineers saw in the count in the five different regional
00:43:08 counts. We're hearing some sense from the people who've been in the room watching the scrutineering
00:43:14 happening. It's going to be a tight race. There are three front runners. The other candidates
00:43:20 have you know run good hard campaigns but they're not as far ahead as the three front runners and
00:43:25 it's it's going to be it's probably going to come down to a fifth or a sixth ballot you said it's
00:43:30 going to be a tight race is there still a path to victory for Travis Taves and you know your
00:43:34 candidate Brian Jean who is usually pulling third and most of the polls I saw throughout the race
00:43:38 um for Brian we need to have uh have some of the people underneath us get a good result and get
00:43:43 some bounce back from that. That's still possible. For Travis, he needs to close in on Danielle
00:43:51 and stay ahead of us with our bounce back. And then there's a path. I mean, it comes down to
00:43:57 a lot of things. It comes down to the undervote. It's a preferential ballot. So on the final vote,
00:44:03 the denominator is different than it is on the first vote. So you can end up in a circumstance
00:44:08 where you can win on the final ballot with the number of ballots
00:44:13 that wouldn't have won it for you on the first ballot.
00:44:15 So it's a complicated system.
00:44:18 It's still available.
00:44:20 It's not a foregone conclusion who's won this thing.
00:44:22 You said it's a tight race right now.
00:44:24 It's shaping up to be won.
00:44:25 You know, some people in the room have been speculating.
00:44:26 People think it's likely a Danielle Smith win based on the polling that we've seen.
00:44:30 But, you know, some people even thought it was going to be a Danielle Smith win
00:44:32 on the first ballot.
00:44:33 Do you think that you're surprised by the results tonight,
00:44:35 or is this pretty much what you were expecting?
00:44:36 I would be very surprised if it's a Daniel Smith win on the first ballot.
00:44:41 I think Daniel is in the lead.
00:44:44 I don't completely buy all the polling because there's flaws in the polling when you're polling such a segmented type list.
00:44:51 But I do think she's the front runner.
00:44:53 But it's hard sometimes for a front runner to get over the top.
00:44:58 You know, front runners create their own weather pattern and they create a little bit of an opposition against them.
00:45:03 And if you don't finesse that exactly right, it gets a little hard to put the pieces together.
00:45:08 So, you know, if I had to bet today, it's probably more likely that Danielle wins than not.
00:45:14 But it's by no means certain.
00:45:15 And there's still a path for Brian.
00:45:17 There's still a path for Travis Tames.
00:45:19 Sure.
00:45:19 Something else we've heard a lot about in this leadership race is caucus unity.
00:45:22 You know, we need a leader who is going to be able to unite the party.
00:45:25 Do you think that if Danielle Smith doesn't win on the first ballot, she wins later on, on the fifth or the sixth ballot, as you mentioned, is still a possibility?
00:45:31 Will it make it harder for her to unify the caucus, you know, showing she doesn't have as much support as people perhaps thought she did?
00:45:38 When you win on the first ballot and you win big, you do a Pierre-Paulie Evers style win.
00:45:42 You get to claim a mandate that tells people, line up behind me, do what I tell you to do.
00:45:47 I won big.
00:45:48 When you win small, you've got to do different things to create caucus unity.
00:45:51 So you've got to take extra steps.
00:45:53 You've got to do more consultation.
00:45:55 You've got to listen to people more.
00:45:56 You've got to engage more.
00:45:57 there's an opportunity to build caucus unity in both circumstances it just requires different
00:46:05 efforts to do those things. Sure I just give a notice that we heard a five minute warning to
00:46:09 take our seat so that's good news we'll hopefully be getting some results pretty quickly but I have
00:46:13 just a couple more questions for you here you know you just mentioned some of the things Danielle's
00:46:16 going to need to do some different steps have you seen her making those steps already you know 0.89
00:46:20 has she been reaching out to your campaign has she been showing a coordinated effort to work
00:46:24 with you guys after today's vote? One of the disappointments of this race is the team Danielle
00:46:29 was probably a little bit more insular than the other teams. So they've got some work to do on
00:46:34 that front. There were open lines of communication amongst the other six teams. The lines of
00:46:41 communication with team Danielle were a little bit weaker. She's got to fix that. Doesn't mean
00:46:47 she can't doesn't mean that she won't if she wins but it's it's something that she needs to start
00:46:54 working on tonight if she wins um because they weren't working on it very much for the last two
00:47:00 weeks. Another thing that Danielle is going to be facing in addition to needing to unify the 1.00
00:47:04 caucus is of course she's going to be up for a general election in just a short matter of months 0.81
00:47:07 you know the Alberta Sovereignty Act has received so much attention throughout this leadership race
00:47:11 and a lot of it very negative attention even from within you know her own party some of the
00:47:14 opponents in this leadership race. Is that going to be a detriment against her in the general 0.99
00:47:18 election? I think that Danielle will have to refocus the UCP's campaign on the issues that 0.54
00:47:26 matter to Albertans. I think that's going to be a lot about health care. I think that's going to
00:47:29 be a lot about cost of living. I think that's going to be a lot about broader energy policy,
00:47:34 a lot of pocketbook issues. If she does re-establish her connection with Albertans on
00:47:39 those issues, they'll move past the Sovereignty Act. The Sovereignty Act, we're still unclear as
00:47:45 to what and how it is, and we'll get to see what becomes of it. But there's lots of room to pick
00:47:51 issues that move Alberta voters. Great. Thanks so much, Vitor. I'm just going to throw it back to
00:47:55 the studio. Thank you very much, Vitor Marciano and Rachel Emanuel in Calgary. That event is
00:48:03 going to be starting up in just a couple of moments. So if you're just tuning in, I'm Andrew
00:48:07 Lawton. Hi, thanks for being with us. Joined by William Macbeth. This is the True North results
00:48:12 show for the United Conservative Party leadership race, the second leadership race the UCP has ever
00:48:18 had. The first one, of course, seeing Brian Jean running again, going up against Jason Kenney,
00:48:23 who won very decisively. And the big question is going to be unity. And I know that we're talking
00:48:29 about Danielle Smith, who has been a clear front runner. She is not the winner yet and technically 0.88
00:48:34 may not be the winner. The reality is these ranked ballots can make a lot of different things happen
00:48:39 in the race. And you have to get over that 50% plus one threshold. And if, you know, let's say
00:48:46 Lila here and Rajan Sani and Rebecca Schultz do very well and their votes go to Travis Tavesay
00:48:53 or Brian Jean, this is a way that Danielle Smith could find herself in the lead on every ballot
00:48:58 except for the last one. And that's what happened federally to Maxime Bernier. He led every single 0.99
00:49:04 round of balloting except for the 13th which ended up being the final round and that was the round
00:49:08 that gave Andrew Scheer the win. So just as we're waiting to get things rolling here I want to kick
00:49:15 over to you William and ask you generally about you're a political strategist you've got a good
00:49:21 mind for this thing no matter who the leader is how do they get that runway clear and start
00:49:28 immediately from day one campaigning. So what is your if you're the chief of staff to the new
00:49:33 premier, whoever it is. What's your advice to them on the first seven days, the first 30 days,
00:49:38 and then the next nine months? So, I mean, I think these are critical questions and they're
00:49:43 the ones that every one of the candidates should be thinking about right now. At least initially,
00:49:49 caucus unity is going to have to be the very first job of the new leader. If it's Travis Tades,
00:49:56 that'll probably be a little bit easier in order because he had so much caucus support. But of
00:50:00 course, he was also in the Kenny cabinet that a lot of MLAs had concerns and issues with. So I
00:50:06 think he's going to have to try and explain and convince that some of his caucus that he is not
00:50:11 just more of the same when it comes to Jason Kenney and how business was before. And obviously,
00:50:18 we talked about Danielle and needing to bring in people who maybe haven't supported her in this 0.58
00:50:23 leadership race. They endorsed other candidates. She's going to have to really work hard to bring
00:50:28 them on board. But once she gets caucus unity done, I think she's going to have to spend a lot 0.56
00:50:33 of time traveling Alberta, meeting with groups of voters, meeting with, you know, the stereotypical
00:50:39 meetings in the church basement and sitting down with these groups and really listening to their
00:50:45 concerns and understanding them. And, you know, it's something she's done in the past. I mean,
00:50:50 I worked for Danielle Smith for four years and she loved to tour. And I think that's a real
00:50:55 strength. And it's something she had in common with Jason Kenney, who also loved to travel around
00:51:01 and meet with groups of people. So I think that's it. And then it'll be important to understand the
00:51:06 best way to fight and win an election in Alberta right now. And if it were up to me, I don't think
00:51:12 Rachel Notley is the primary opponent in an Alberta election. I believe it's Prime Minister
00:51:19 Justin Trudeau. So if I were the new leader, I would be talking about fighting back against the
00:51:25 Trudeau liberals fighting GAC against Prime Minister Trudeau. And I would try and sideline
00:51:30 Rachel Notley and the Democrats. Or if I do talk about them, I talk about them as part of that
00:51:35 liberal NDP coalition. So I think that was a mistake Kenny made was focusing a little too
00:51:41 much on Notley and not going hard enough against Justin Trudeau. I think that the new leader really
00:51:46 does have to understand there is little love in Alberta for the Trudeau family as a whole. Maybe
00:51:52 maybe his children. We don't know him that well, but we don't love him. We don't love his father.
00:51:58 And I think, you know, making him public enemy number one, really having him be the antithesis
00:52:03 is going to be a smart political strategy for whoever wins. I would agree with that. And it's
00:52:08 interesting because on the surface, I mean, any Alberta conservative I know just hates the very
00:52:12 idea of the NDP. But as a person, Rachel Notley does not have the negative association that Justin
00:52:19 Trudeau does on personality, on policy, on anything. And her government, I mean, did a lot
00:52:24 of very harmful things, but it wasn't a scandal-plagued government. I mean, as far as
00:52:28 integrity, I think Rachel Notley probably wins over Alison Redford, say. So you are right that
00:52:34 I think there needs to be this square focus on our enemy is not the NDP, our enemy is Ottawa.
00:52:40 Yeah, absolutely. And, you know, the good thing, of course, is that there is that ready-made
00:52:44 opponent in the form of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who has maintained an opposition to
00:52:50 oil and oil and gas and pipelines and all sorts of things which are important to the livelihood
00:52:55 of Albertans. So there is plenty of opportunity to push that. And I think that's how Danielle
00:53:00 sells her Sovereignty Act, maybe not in the fine details of how it stops a law or may stop a law
00:53:07 or doesn't stop a law, but in sending the clear message to Ottawa that they need to get out of
00:53:12 Alberta and stop hurting our province. Yeah. And let me just, I mean, ask you just,
00:53:19 what are your top three issues on the agenda that you think the next premier needs to put
00:53:23 at Justin Trudeau's feet at the negotiating table? I mean, I think we're going to have to
00:53:28 have an important conversation about equalization. I think Albertans believe it is an unfair formula
00:53:34 and, you know, the left often likes to point out that it was negotiated under Stephen Harper.
00:53:38 Well, the world was very different when that negotiation last happened. And now we think that Alberta is penalized for having to send so much money to other provinces who aren't particularly grateful for the financial contributions Alberta makes to the Federation.
00:53:55 Quebec has has in particular maintained a very anti-energy policy towards Alberta. So I definitely think that's on the topic.
00:54:02 I think there are conversations around energy infrastructure. You know, the prime minister has said things like phase out oil and gas or end oil and gas. And I think Alberta has to be absolutely strong and say, look, we have this brilliant advanced sector that does a great job.
00:54:19 It is making improvements to how it does its business of extracting oil and gas.
00:54:25 And we are world leaders in some of that.
00:54:27 Why would you strangle something which brings wealth and energy security to not just all of Canada, but it could be to bring it to international countries as well?
00:54:37 And then I think if it were me, I would probably want to start to tackle health care because I think there's a real dissatisfaction amongst Albertans with the status quo on their health care system.
00:54:46 The Liberals have always said they will not tolerate anybody deviating from a single publicly funded universal health care system.
00:54:55 They don't want a 1.5 system. They don't want any form of innovation.
00:54:59 I think Danielle or whoever it is could take a firm stand and say, well, no, health care is a provincial jurisdiction.
00:55:06 We are going to innovate in health care.
00:55:09 Just if you're tuning in now, we are carrying the United Conservative Party leadership results.
00:55:14 results. They'll be starting up any moment now. The official program it sounds like is just about
00:55:20 to get underway. They're just doing some housekeeping and formalities right now and
00:55:25 once the the actual program and presentations begin we will throw live to it as soon as that
00:55:31 happens and that is is taking place in Calgary and what we understand is that after the issues
00:55:37 that they encountered today the the one thing that I would point out is that they are delayed
00:55:43 but they've promised, it sounds like, and we're keeping our fingers crossed that the results are
00:55:47 going to be delivered very quickly. So as I understand it, the ballots have been counted.
00:55:52 They have the result. They're not going to be needlessly going through the process of keeping
00:55:57 us all in suspense, which, as we know from the 2020 federal conservative leadership race, can
00:56:03 sometimes last quite a bit. That was the infamous broadcast that went to 3 a.m., but even the last
00:56:08 one was quicker for Pierre Paglia. But still, they did drag it on, even though they had the
00:56:13 answer. So we are going to go live to the events in Calgary. I believe they're just doing the
00:56:18 national anthem right now. But we'll go to that feed.
00:56:38 We see thee rise, thou true life's strong and free.
00:56:48 From far and wide, O Canada, we stand and guard for thee.
00:57:01 God keep our land glorious and free.
00:57:13 Oh, we cannot all, we stand on guard for thee.
00:57:23 Oh, we cannot all, we stand on guard for thee.
00:57:43 Thank you, Elizabeth. It's an exciting night to be together. The United Conservative Party
00:58:03 is a coalition built on a strong set of principles. Support for a robust civil society, free speech,
00:58:12 economic freedom, limited government, fiscal responsibility, protecting public safety,
00:58:21 and supporting the family. Support for these principles and the hard work of our leader
00:58:27 and our team led to our overwhelming election victory in 2019. Over 1 million Albertans supported
00:58:36 a platform that laid out exactly what we would do. And the UCP government has now completed
00:58:43 nearly 95% of those campaign promises. As a result, we live in a province with the fastest
00:58:56 growing economy in this country, with all of its advantages. Our leader, Jason Kenney,
00:59:04 has put his heart and soul into advancing the livelihoods of Albertans.
00:59:09 We intend to do a more fulsome tribute to him
00:59:12 at our upcoming annual general meeting in Edmonton,
00:59:15 but tonight, on behalf of the UCP Board of Directors
00:59:19 and all of our members, I want to thank him for his service.
00:59:24 Thank you.
00:59:34 we are better for his enormous commitment and wish him success in the future
00:59:40 it's an extremely exciting time for our party the leadership candidates have helped grow
00:59:46 our membership to historical levels they met tens of thousands of members at events
00:59:52 forums and our two official debates they have traveled from lethbridge to medicine hat
00:59:58 Calgary to Lacombe, Edmonton to Grand Prairie and Fort McMurray, and everywhere in between,
01:00:04 speaking with Albertans on issues that matter to them.
01:00:08 This leaves our party in a great position to take on the NDP in the upcoming provincial election.
01:00:21 While our economy is booming with the largest in-migration in our history,
01:00:25 we know that not everyone is benefiting equally the challenges we face are well
01:00:32 known the discussions have been robust congratulations to our leadership
01:00:38 candidates Leela here Brian Jean Todd low and Raj and Sonny Rebecca Schultz
01:00:59 Daniel Smith and Travis Taves for their thoughtful and caring discussions of our future.
01:01:17 To the campaign teams, all of you here and at home, you worked hard, played by the rules,
01:01:24 engaged in the process, scrutiniered in the verification center, and for the vote and count
01:01:30 today. You joined hundreds of volunteers who risked serious paper cuts, spending hours checking IDs
01:01:38 and making sure that every eligible vote could be counted. Thank you for your service.
01:01:44 We are pleased to report that close to 85,000 of our eligible members
01:01:54 have participated in electing our new leader, an incredible level of engagement.
01:02:04 Tonight, you will hear from both our Leadership Election Committee Chair, David Price,
01:02:09 and our returning officer, the Honourable Rick Orman, who we owe a deep sense of gratitude.
01:02:16 This process was executed under their leadership.
01:02:20 David was joined by a diverse group of experienced UCP members on the Leadership Election Committee.
01:02:26 We are grateful for their hard work.
01:02:29 The staff, under the direction of our Executive Director, Dustin Van Voet,
01:02:33 continues to work in the best interests of our membership.
01:02:37 We have one of the strongest political teams in Canada.
01:02:45 We are not quite ready for the results, so before I bring up David and Rick, let's talk about the days ahead.
01:02:51 We know why we are all here.
01:02:54 To ensure the re-election of a united Conservative government so that this province continues to move forward
01:03:01 and we don't lose all of the gains that have been made.
01:03:06 That's right. Albertans want to see this government re-elected, but in order to earn
01:03:12 their support, we need to be a disciplined party that Albertans can trust. We need to be united.
01:03:25 I've been listening to you, and I know you want to be united in fighting the next election.
01:03:31 Now, let me remind you that there are just under 250 days before that election,
01:03:36 I ask each and every one of you to think about how you can contribute to a successful campaign
01:03:42 in 2023. Whether you're a party volunteer or a candidate, whether your contribution can be big
01:03:49 or small, every part of our team is needed. One more thing, please join us at our annual general
01:03:58 meeting at the River Cree Resort at Enoch in Edmonton later this month. We'll be doing important
01:04:04 party business including board elections policy and government governance and election readiness
01:04:10 training and perhaps most importantly our new leader will be giving an address to our membership
01:04:18 you won't want to miss it it's a huge milestone we're choosing the next leader of our party
01:04:26 and the next premier of the province to all of our leadership candidates here tonight
01:04:37 the message from our party and members is simple we're behind you we're united
01:04:45 and we'll do whatever you need to win the next election and keep alberta on the right track
01:04:50 thank you I will now invite David Price chair of the leadership election
01:04:59 committee to say a few words about the committee's work David well thank you
01:05:13 very much Cynthia and thank you all for coming here tonight
01:05:17 Dear friends, our Leadership Election Committee was called upon in May earlier this year to
01:05:24 put in place the rules and procedures of our Leadership Contest.
01:05:28 The membership of our committee included 12 individuals from across our province and from
01:05:33 very diverse backgrounds representing an excellent cross-section of our membership.
01:05:39 I'd also like to note that every member on our committee served as a volunteer.
01:05:46 Every single member of our committee dedicated hundreds of hours to our task, sacrificing
01:05:51 time with their families and taking time away from their jobs and other commitments to serve.
01:05:58 These are some of the finest people that I have had the pleasure of working with in my
01:06:02 professional career, and I could not be more proud of the work of our committee.
01:06:09 Thank you.
01:06:13 Here our committee delivered robust rules for a fair, open, secure, and transparent
01:06:20 leadership election.
01:06:22 We did not promise we would be running on time though.
01:06:26 But our overriding ethos during this whole process has been that of integrity, accountability,
01:06:32 and fair play.
01:06:34 Our every decision has been governed by one simple question.
01:06:38 How do we do right by our members, by you?
01:06:42 Our balloting process flexibly provided for both mail-in and in-person voting.
01:06:48 The verification of ballots, the counting of ballots, and the calculation of results
01:06:52 today has taken place under the supervision of our Returning Officer, our Neutral Returning
01:06:59 Officer Rick Orman, and his team of Deputy Returning Officers and an army of volunteers.
01:07:06 In addition, all campaigns have been consulted throughout this process and have been invited
01:07:11 have their volunteer scrutineers observe both the verification and counting processes.
01:07:18 Of course, I want to thank the candidates and their teams for all their hard work. Each candidate
01:07:24 and all their volunteers should be proud of the energetic campaigns they've run,
01:07:29 the vigorous ideas and platforms that they've put forward, and their significant efforts
01:07:35 to recruit tens of thousands of new members to our party.
01:07:38 Most importantly, though, I want to thank all the candidates for standing behind our
01:07:44 process and respecting our rules.
01:07:48 In addition, I want to thank the party staff and all of our volunteers who helped get us
01:07:53 to this point this evening.
01:07:55 It's been hard work, and they have not only processed all those new memberships, but they've
01:08:00 ensured that we got over 120,000 ballots to our members in plenty of time to get them
01:08:07 mailed back and counted, and all said, we had approximately 85,000 ballots cast in this
01:08:14 election.
01:08:17 That is a huge turnout, folks.
01:08:20 And we could not have had a smoother process, and we are very grateful to the hard work
01:08:26 and the dedication of our staff and volunteers.
01:08:29 And finally, I do want to thank the party board, especially Cynthia, for their resolute
01:08:34 support of our committee and the trust that they placed in us to independently shepherd this process
01:08:42 it has been an absolute pleasure to have participated in this endeavor
01:08:46 as we close out this long process tonight thank you so much thank you
01:08:51 you. Thank you, David, and thank you to all of the dedicated members of the Leadership Election
01:09:04 Committee for doing such a great job. Okay, we are very close to getting the results.
01:09:12 We'll take a quick break before being joined by the returning officer, Rick Orman,
01:09:16 and the auditor from Crow McKay.
01:09:20 Five, ten minutes, and we'll be back.
01:09:31 Well, as you see there, they're doing the suspense thing
01:09:35 where they make his way for the obligatory five to ten minutes
01:09:38 before they come back and start reading the results.
01:09:40 That was David Price, who very well-regarded member
01:09:44 of the conservative movement.
01:09:46 I've actually, years and years ago, I worked with him very briefly.
01:09:49 Very great guy.
01:09:50 He is the head of the, basically the head of the election.
01:09:53 So he's been the one overseeing this.
01:09:55 He was just giving predominantly a thank you to this volunteer run effort.
01:09:59 And I just want to make a point here.
01:10:01 Obviously, you can do a leadership race on a very expedited timeframe.
01:10:05 I think the record goes to the Ontario PCs in 2018,
01:10:08 when they basically had to do the whole thing in about six weeks.
01:10:11 The UCP took about five months, but still, they weren't planning for a race.
01:10:15 They were planning to be getting ready for a general election right now.
01:10:18 So generally speaking, William, let me just ask you that.
01:10:21 Do you think that it has been a race that has been effectively and well organized and well run by the candidates and by the party itself?
01:10:31 Yeah, I mean, I haven't particularly heard a lot of concerns about the administration of the leadership race.
01:10:37 You know, the only grumbling I heard was the decision of having Premier Kenney remain as premier up until the new premier is chosen.
01:10:47 Although personally, I think bringing in an interim premier adds some instability when we were still in a time of dealing with, you know, a public health issue.
01:11:01 But no, I really haven't heard concerns that the race wasn't run in a fair and equitable manner.
01:11:07 Um, I, I think the campaigns of the different candidates, um, probably weren't the strongest
01:11:15 I've seen from some of them.
01:11:16 I think they fell into a bit of a trap that Danielle Smith set for them.
01:11:21 And that was, they spent almost all of the election talking about the policy issue that
01:11:27 she wanted to talk about.
01:11:28 And, uh, that when, when you're talking about your opponent's preferred policy, even when
01:11:33 you're attacking it, it's not good for you and your campaign. And so I do think that was a trap
01:11:40 a lot of them fell into. And I think if she is victorious later on tonight, I think there will
01:11:44 be people who look back on that and think that was a tactical error. Yeah, you are right. The
01:11:49 Alberta Sovereignty Act, like the name recognition, the name ID on that now is quite significant,
01:11:54 just mainly because of all the criticisms of it. Let's go back to Rachel Emanuel, who is at
01:11:59 UCP headquarters in Calgary 0.64
01:12:01 right now. Rachel, I understand
01:12:04 you're chatting with someone here.
01:12:06 Yes, thanks. I'm joined by John Horseman.
01:12:08 Horseman was a former UCP leadership
01:12:10 candidate, actually. He was in the race for about
01:12:11 a month, but he ended up dropping out and endorsing
01:12:14 Travis Tate. So, John, I'll just let you say
01:12:15 in your own words, why did you drop out of the UCP
01:12:18 leadership race, and why did you decide to
01:12:19 endorse Travis Tate? Yeah, so
01:12:21 it turned out I actually didn't have enough
01:12:23 time to build the momentum I
01:12:25 needed to be a credible
01:12:27 candidate in this race.
01:12:29 And when I saw eight great candidates moving forward, I just thought being the ninth on the table was just really too much.
01:12:37 The reason why I endorsed Travis Tays is I'd worked with him.
01:12:39 I'd worked with him as he was in the Department of Finance, and I knew he was a principal leader.
01:12:45 I knew he would create stable leadership for Alberta, which I thought was really, really important for the business conditions that we currently are living in.
01:12:55 And so he was my top candidate.
01:12:57 He, you know, for me, brought the most responsible government to the table.
01:13:02 You know, some of the interviews that we've had today with Vitor Mocciano, for example,
01:13:05 he's the campaign manager for Brian Jean.
01:13:07 He said he thinks there's still a path to victory for Travis Daves.
01:13:10 Do you agree that there's still a path to victory for Travis?
01:13:12 Or do you think it's more likely to go to Danielle Smith, who, you know,
01:13:15 everyone else is expecting to take home the win tonight?
01:13:18 I think there is a path, but I would concede it's a narrow path.
01:13:23 You can't say no until it's over, and you just don't know what happened today with the physical turnout,
01:13:28 and you don't know what's going to happen with the seconds and the folks that actually only filled out one name on their ballot.
01:13:36 And as those candidates drop away, it's very hard to predict.
01:13:39 Sure. And John, you've told me before that you're interested in running for the UCP nomination in Calgary Elbow.
01:13:45 Calgary Elbow is Doug Schweitzer's riding. He was the Kennedy Cabinet Minister.
01:13:48 He actually resigned. That seat is going to be open, but they're not going to do the by-election.
01:13:51 You know, if you put your name forward for that seat, does it depend on who's the leader or if Smith wins?
01:13:56 Are you still interested in going for the UCP nomination in that riding?
01:13:59 Yeah, it's a good question. I truly believe that I can help the UCP.
01:14:04 I can help Alberta and irrespective of who the leader that gets chosen tonight,
01:14:10 I can be helpful to actually move the province forward and also move the party forward.
01:14:17 And so, no, I'm committed to being a part of this.
01:14:22 If I can win the nomination, that would be lovely.
01:14:24 They haven't called the nomination yet, and I haven't submitted my paper,
01:14:28 so there's a couple hurdles yet to go, but I'm ready, and I'm in motion.
01:14:34 All right. Well, thanks very much, John.
01:14:35 We're going to go back to the studio now.
01:14:39 Thank you very much, Rachel and John.
01:14:41 The UCP is just taking a little bit of an intermission
01:14:44 while they prepare themselves to give us the results so we'll cut back to that in Calgary
01:14:50 as soon as we are able to as soon as we have a program to go to so don't worry you're not missing
01:14:55 anything there is right now nothing to be missed as far as results go but hopefully we'll have
01:15:00 those in the coming moments here and obviously John just mentioned in that interview with Rachel
01:15:07 that regardless of who the leader is he sees himself as being able to play a role and move
01:15:12 beyond this and I mean the theme of the night William you and I have been talking about it
01:15:15 since the beginning is unity do you think by and large that's going to be the message from a lot
01:15:20 of people that yeah they swap their blows during the leadership race but when push comes to shove
01:15:24 they want a strong conservative Alberta government to go up against the NDP to go up against Trudeau
01:15:30 and and they'll go along with whoever the leader is oh I I absolutely think you're going to see
01:15:35 a very coordinated message of unity from every public actor in this race. I mean, it will be
01:15:43 challenging for some of them, I think. I think, for example, Brian Jean kind of feels like he may
01:15:50 have been robbed of this leadership that, you know, when he put out his autonomy for Alberta plan
01:15:56 and had it compared to Daniel Smith's sovereignty for Alberta plan, that he probably wasn't thrilled
01:16:04 that that, you know, kind of captured his entire top line messaging. But yes, no, I think you're
01:16:09 absolutely going to see a lot of talk about unity, about talking, you know, getting back to
01:16:13 where we were, you know, doing things in the interests of everyday Albertans, all of that
01:16:19 kind of messaging. I think it's interesting, too, that you're probably going to start to see
01:16:24 a lot more targeted politics, because in Alberta, there's Edmonton, there's Calgary,
01:16:32 and there's kind of all of the rest.
01:16:35 But if you want to win an election in Alberta,
01:16:38 you really need at least two out of those three zones.
01:16:42 And Rachel Notley, very strong,
01:16:43 and the Democrats very strong in Edmonton,
01:16:45 very not strong in rural Alberta,
01:16:48 in the areas outside Edmonton and Calgary.
01:16:51 And I think Calgary will be a battleground.
01:16:53 So I suspect that the new premier and his or her team
01:16:56 will be spending an awful lot of time in Calgary,
01:16:59 talking to Calgarians and showing not just the successes that have happened under the UCP,
01:17:04 but putting forward an agenda that will appeal to Calgarians.
01:17:08 This, I believe, will be the city where the next election, the next government is decided.
01:17:12 We are, throughout the course of the evening, just playing some clips from our coverage and interviews
01:17:17 with the leadership candidates throughout the race.
01:17:20 I want to go to a clip now of my interview, just, I think it was about four or five weeks ago,
01:17:24 with Brian Jean, one of the candidates who we heard from his campaign team member Vitor Marciano
01:17:30 a few moments ago. Let's talk about the equalization aspect specifically. We know
01:17:37 that Albertans overwhelmingly voted to really re-evaluate the equalization system that we have
01:17:43 right now. And obviously the prevailing thesis is that when a province comes together like that
01:17:48 and votes in such a way, the federal government has to negotiate. But a duty to negotiate,
01:17:53 A constitutional duty to negotiate is not a duty or requirement to give any concession.
01:17:59 And the Liberals have been consistently resistant to, I think, respecting a lot of the concerns that Albertans have.
01:18:06 So what would you do differently or what would you do to actually get what it is that Alberta wants and needs from the federal government at that negotiating table?
01:18:15 I'm glad you asked that because other candidates are talking about getting angry and what we're going to do up to a certain point.
01:18:20 But they have no answers for what happens afterwards.
01:18:23 So they're riling people up, getting people mad for no reason.
01:18:27 We live in an amazing country, it's a free country, and the Constitution clearly lays
01:18:34 out that under Section 46, if a majority of a population in a certain area is dissatisfied
01:18:39 with the current Confederation and how they're being treated under Confederation, we can
01:18:43 send notice after receiving a clear mandate from the people, a majority of the people,
01:18:48 a good majority, we can send that mandate to the people under the Section 46 notice
01:18:53 then they have to sit down and negotiate with us and if they don't then we go to the supreme
01:18:55 court of canada and ask for reference listen you know let's be clear here i'm the only lawyer
01:19:00 litigator person that spent 10 years practicing the law here in alberta i know how it works i'm
01:19:04 not guessing that i don't have to talk to another uh government bureaucrat lawyer to tell me how to
01:19:10 pursue this and how to go forward i've spent enough time understanding both 10 years federally
01:19:14 as a member of parliament as a parliamentary secretary and as a practicing law in alberta
01:19:18 for 10 years and then as a business person i know what albertans want they want want more autonomy
01:19:22 more freedom less oversight and overwatch from ottawa i mean that's where all the gatekeepers
01:19:27 are that's what we have to remove from but but if the constitution gets them to the table what
01:19:31 do you do at the table that will get that change you need get the rest of the provinces on side to
01:19:37 get better hospital better health care funding get more rights in the senate and the house of
01:19:42 commons so we actually have equal votes across the country there are so many things that we need to
01:19:47 change the fiscal imbalance is clearly there equalization is one of those things the rest of
01:19:51 provinces premiers are ready to go to the table over the pipeline ban we're ready
01:19:59 that was my interview with brian gene in this campaign just a little while ago and we were
01:20:05 touching on in that interview the idea of getting a fair deal from ottawa and this was uh to your
01:20:11 point earlier william before covet came into the discussion here one of the big grievances i was
01:20:17 hearing from a lot of the conservative base in Alberta about Jason Kenney is that he wasn't
01:20:22 going to Ottawa banging his fist on the table and really standing up as forcefully as they wanted.
01:20:28 And Danielle Smith's answer to that has been the Sovereignty Act. Brian Jean's answer to it has
01:20:32 been autonomy. There is still a pocket of Alberta generally conservatives that want separation.
01:20:39 They're done playing. They want out of Canada. And I don't know how large that group is versus
01:20:44 how many of them are accessible UCP voters if someone is taking that issue seriously?
01:20:51 Yeah, I mean, it's an important question. I don't think support for sovereignty is quite as high as
01:20:57 it once was. I think when there was a NDP Premier in Alberta and a Liberal Prime Minister in Ottawa,
01:21:05 that was a breeding ground for separatist sentiment. I think certainly there was a belief
01:21:10 that none of our governments were on the side of everyday Albertans or the energy sector,
01:21:15 things like that. I think there is a sovereignty movement out there, but I think a lot of it is
01:21:21 probably just wanting to see concrete steps taken to try and protect Alberta from Ottawa's
01:21:28 intervention. So things like creating an Alberta provincial police force or having an Alberta
01:21:34 pension plan, or having Alberta collect all of the taxes, remitting only the federal share to
01:21:41 Ottawa rather than having Ottawa do the collecting. And so it's some of these things, some of which
01:21:46 will have a very big impact, others of which are a little bit more symbolic. But I think as long as
01:21:54 whoever becomes a new premier is seen to be actually making concrete progress on it, I don't
01:21:59 think you're going to see full-on separatist settlement really bubble up and become a motivating
01:22:05 political force in Alberta again for at least right now. Our colleague Rachel Emanuel has been
01:22:11 keeping very busy in Calgary and I understand she's got with her Rebecca Schultz's campaign
01:22:17 manager so we'll go to Rachel now if she's up and run no she's not ready we'll go to her in a moment
01:22:23 and she'll be with Rachel with Rebecca Schultz's campaign manager when we do go there. One thing 0.96
01:22:29 I will note here is that a lot of the time, and this happened in the federal election campaign
01:22:35 as well, we think things are a lot more acrimonious than they are. And then everyone does get under
01:22:41 the banner. So, you know, nominations, leaderships, they're supposed to be tense. So it's not the end
01:22:46 of the world when it is there. But the whole point is you also don't want like a liberal situation
01:22:49 where you give so many and so bloody attacks in the leadership race that they become the attack
01:22:55 ads in the general election. That was what happened with the famous, do you think it's
01:22:59 easy to make priorities line from Stefan Dion. We have Rachel with Rebecca Polak now, I believe.
01:23:06 Thanks, Andrew. I'm joined by Becca Polak, who, as I mentioned, is the campaign manager for Rebecca
01:23:10 Schultz. Thanks for joining us, Becca. I'm wondering if you have any speculations, if you've heard
01:23:14 anything about what we're expecting for the results tonight. You know, I don't know if I have
01:23:19 any speculations, but you know, I think over 85,000 of our members came out tonight. So I think that
01:23:24 says something about participation all I can say is I'm really proud of our team and where I think
01:23:29 that we are but no speculations quite yet. Sure and you know Rebecca was polling sort of in the
01:23:34 midway range throughout the campaign do you expect her to sort of fall in that in that voting area
01:23:39 tonight or you maybe expect her to surge ahead a little bit fall behind where do you actually 0.97
01:23:42 expect her to end up on the vote tonight? Well you know what I always like to think that I don't
01:23:47 follow polls because I think although it's it's a good measure I think Rebecca's going to do well
01:23:54 And you know what? We grinded to the very end.
01:23:57 We started this thing, and almost nobody in Alberta knew Rebecca's name.
01:24:01 And here we are tonight, and I think she's going to do well,
01:24:03 and I'm proud of her regardless of the outcome.
01:24:06 Something that I think was interesting about Rebecca Schultz 0.69
01:24:08 is so many of the other candidates were very keen to target and attack Danielle Smith, 0.95
01:24:12 the perceived frontrunner. 0.96
01:24:13 You know, people are expecting a Danielle Smith win tonight. 0.80
01:24:16 A couple weeks before the vote, there was a press conference
01:24:18 where four candidates decided to hold a press conference
01:24:20 and basically criticize the Alberta Sovereignty Act
01:24:23 and say that it was dangerous for Alberta and it would wreck investment in our province.
01:24:27 Rebecca did not join that press conference.
01:24:29 Why didn't she join?
01:24:30 And do you think it was the right move?
01:24:32 Well, I think that a lot of the campaign was spent talking about the Sovereignty Act.
01:24:38 And I think everybody had their opportunity to explain themselves,
01:24:41 if they supported it, how they would do things differently. 0.99
01:24:45 Rebecca had a 100-day plan. 1.00
01:24:47 I thought it was a great plan.
01:24:49 We talked a lot about the Sovereignty Act.
01:24:51 And I think there are other things that Albertans really, truly are looking for changes in health care, changes in education, affordability.
01:24:58 And and I think that that's where our campaign really stood out, was just sticking to those things that we kept hearing.
01:25:04 And so for that, I think that that was probably why we didn't show up on that stage.
01:25:09 You know, and I think that's a very fair argument because the Sovereignty Act did dominate so much discussion of the UCP leadership race and some of the other issues and policies didn't actually have a chance to to break through.
01:25:19 You know, on that point, we've been talking a little bit about how Daniel Smith was running sort of as an anti-establishment candidate.
01:25:24 And some of the other candidates, you know, they work for Kennedy.
01:25:26 They were one of Kennedy's ministers, including Rebecca Schultz, who was, you know, the children's service minister.
01:25:30 She often touts her record and the great child care deal that she got from Ottawa in that role.
01:25:35 She early on in the campaign said, you know, I'm not part of the boys club.
01:25:38 I was never part of the inner circle.
01:25:40 Do you think that she was successful in positioning herself as a candidate who was, you know, not associated with Jason Kennedy and didn't carry his record?
01:25:47 Well, you know, I don't know if it was disassociating from Jason Kenney
01:25:51 because I can't say that our record was all that bad.
01:25:54 Obviously, there's a reason why we're here tonight.
01:25:57 We didn't get everything right. 0.83
01:25:58 But I do think Rebecca was different than all of the other candidates in her own way. 0.73
01:26:03 She thought common sense. 0.96
01:26:04 She had ideas.
01:26:05 She took her platform from everyday Albertans and really listened to people.
01:26:09 And I think she has something to offer the entire group and Alberta that other people don't.
01:26:13 So I think on her own, and this team did a great job differentiating as just a good common sense conservative candidate.
01:26:21 For sure. And that was Becca Polak, the campaign manager for Rebecca Schultz. 0.89
01:26:24 I'm going to throw it back to the studio now.
01:26:27 Thank you very much for that, Rachel Emanuel, with Becca Polak from Rebecca Schultz's campaign.
01:26:33 So we've had representatives from Daniel, well, we've had representatives of a lot of the campaigns now.
01:26:39 I think we have not had anyone from Lila Ahir or Rajan Sani or Todd Lowen's campaign just yet.
01:26:45 But obviously, Rachel is working the floor there very well, and she'll be pulling people over to chat as best as they can.
01:26:53 William, let me get your reaction to that, because there was a little bit of, I don't want to say tap dancing in a negative way,
01:26:59 but I think there's a little bit of apprehension in the party on how to deal with the Jason Kenney question,
01:27:05 because he's very well-liked and well-regarded in the conservative movement broadly,
01:27:09 certainly if you just pluck the last two years out of the picture.
01:27:13 And I think that in the UCP, there is a little bit of a mixed emotion about him.
01:27:18 A lot of people very frustrated with what happened in the last two years,
01:27:21 but they also don't want to treat him as though he's toxic,
01:27:24 which I think would be incredibly unfair.
01:27:27 Absolutely.
01:27:27 And I think probably politically really unwise to tarnish the guy in the government
01:27:33 who's been in power for, you know, coming on three and a half years.
01:27:36 And Becca's points, which I think are well made,
01:27:39 are that the Kennedy government did a lot of good things too.
01:27:43 And I think, as I talked about a little bit earlier,
01:27:46 there might be a danger that a new premier goes too fast and too far
01:27:52 jettisoning either the legacy of the Kennedy government
01:27:57 or some of the policies that got them the win.
01:28:01 I think to be the anti Kenny, basically. Yeah, exactly. Either just to be the anti Kenny or to pull an Aaron O'Toole and drop the key things that got your base excited for you. And I think specifically, you're going to see a lot of pressure for Danielle Smith to maybe water down or even repudiate the Sovereignty Act. And in my personal opinion, that would be a politically very damaging move for her to make.
01:28:25 I think it would consign her to defeat.
01:28:29 Where candidates, and sometimes we're all guilty of this if we are on Twitter, we have
01:28:34 to remember that the people on Twitter are not real people.
01:28:38 They are a tiny fraction of hyper-engaged, usually very partisan people who you will
01:28:45 never win their votes.
01:28:47 But that won't stop them from telling you you have to do things to try and win their
01:28:51 vote.
01:28:52 You have to apologize for this.
01:28:53 You have to give up on that.
01:28:55 Whereas what it's really about is winning the hearts and minds of ordinary people from one end of the province to the other. Those people are not on Twitter. They are at their jobs. They are taking care of their families. They're living their lives. They're not hyper obsessing about all of the minutiae on Twitter.
01:29:12 So I think that's also something that candidates really have to bear in mind.
01:29:16 The people telling them to apologize, to drop their support for things, or to demonize the
01:29:22 Kenney legacy, these are not the voters that are even accessible to a re-elected United
01:29:28 Conservative government.
01:29:29 Yeah, and I also think it's very true, certainly in Alberta politics, that you can't win a
01:29:34 war on two fronts.
01:29:35 And Jason Kenney, I thought, did very well at pushing back against the media a lot of
01:29:40 the time.
01:29:40 I think he did very well at pushing back against the left.
01:29:44 I mean, the way he speaks about some of the environmental activists is stuff that I wish
01:29:48 conservatives were saying 10, 12 years ago, because even Stephen Harper was more subdued
01:29:53 in his criticism to a large extent compared to Jason Kenney.
01:29:57 And I've actually faced criticism for giving Kenney any credit at all, because there is
01:30:02 a lot of just very vicious, vicious hatred.
01:30:05 And I can't share in that.
01:30:06 If you want to if you want to take that approach, that's completely your choice.
01:30:10 But I think this guy has been a conservative stalwart and is frustrated and annoyed.
01:30:15 And I'll say, yes, angry at times, as I was with how the Kenny government responded to
01:30:20 COVID.
01:30:21 I also don't like refuse.
01:30:22 I refuse to judge people by the very worst moments and by their worst decisions.
01:30:28 And I think you have to look at a longer picture of service here.
01:30:31 And the fact that without Jason Kenny, there may well be an NDP government right now in
01:30:36 Alberta.
01:30:37 And I don't think that's an unfair claim to make.
01:30:39 Absolutely.
01:30:40 I mean, if you think about it, we were heading into another election cycle where there were going to be two strong conservative, small C conservative parties, the PC party and the Wild Rose party.
01:30:52 The Wild Rose party winning primarily votes in rural Alberta, the PC party winning primarily votes in Calgary.
01:30:59 But if they're splitting the votes in rural Alberta and in Calgary, it offers all the opportunity for Rachel Notley to win in one of those regions.
01:31:08 And that is largely why she won in 2015 was a big chunk of Calgary ended up voting for her.
01:31:15 So I do think that Kenny needs to be remembered as someone who made sure that, as he would like to say, the NDP were one and done in Alberta.
01:31:24 We only had we kept them to a single term. So, yeah, no, you're totally right.
01:31:28 And well, I didn't agree either with all of his management and COVID. I think there are obviously big examples we can think of how he approached some pastors and religious services, the decision to to call it the best summer ever.
01:31:42 you know, Alberta was open forever, except then we locked down again and brought in a vaccine
01:31:47 passport, things like that. And possibly he had taken a little bit more time to reflect and
01:31:55 apologize for some of those things. Maybe it wouldn't have gotten to the crisis point it would.
01:31:59 But certainly I do think there were a lot of great things he did, you know, part of which is
01:32:04 the rewriting of Alberta's curriculum, which had gone completely crazy under the Democrats.
01:32:09 And Alberta students were at risk of being able to neither do basic reading or basic arithmetic because of just education fads that the last government brought in.
01:32:19 So we did have a major curriculum reform, and now Alberta students are once again improving in core areas like mathematics and reading.
01:32:27 One thing that I will say is that we were talking earlier about how Jason Kenney was getting involved, I think, against most people's expectations in the leadership race.
01:32:36 I think in general, one of the things that's very interesting to look at here is the fact that Jason
01:32:42 Kenny's not going out quietly in terms of what he's doing as a premier right now. Like I can't
01:32:48 share my screen at the moment, but I have had like more Alberta government press releases
01:32:53 in the last few days than I think I've had in the last three years. So it just seems like there's
01:32:59 announcement, announcement, announcement, announcement. And I don't know if this is
01:33:03 just Jason Kenney getting things that were on his bucket list, off the bucket list, or if this is,
01:33:08 you know, in a lot of ways, just an effort to build momentum. But it's some, it does sometimes
01:33:15 actually, you know, give a bit of a complicated look at, are they committing the next leader to
01:33:22 things that they don't want to do? Are they committing the leader to a path that they aren't
01:33:26 necessarily ready to go down on? So I think we're going to have to explore these and many other
01:33:31 questions as the program continues. I'm getting the word that we are just about to go back to the
01:33:38 show in Calgary. So once I'm told to throw away, I'll do that. But just very, very quickly,
01:33:44 William, do you think Kenny is trying to just like do as much as he can in these last few days
01:33:49 that he's the premier? Yeah, I mean, I do think there is something to that. Maybe he just wants
01:33:56 to burnish that record, that legacy a little bit as he's in his final days of office.
01:34:01 But also as a premier who, when you do have that finite shelf life, you do want to get
01:34:06 things done.
01:34:07 And Jason Kenney has always been a politician who was about getting things done.
01:34:11 He wasn't, he was never just doing the bare minimum and letting the days flood by.
01:34:15 Jason Kenney was always active.
01:34:17 And even when he was a Harvard minister, very much the same.
01:34:19 So I think he just didn't want to go gently into that good night, as the poem says.
01:34:24 yeah fair enough i appreciate that and uh the feed that so as i understand there there is
01:34:31 someone on stage uh the feed is just getting caught up so we'll go back to that feed right
01:34:37 now this is live in calgary for the results
01:34:39 editor for this process to say a few words and i want to thank sam they spent hundreds and
01:34:49 hundreds of hours both in the verification center and during the count today
01:34:53 thank you everybody our firm uh chroma kai llp was engaged by the ucp to oversee and conduct
01:35:05 various agreed upon procedures over the duration of this ucp leadership race and election day
01:35:11 itself to begin with i would like to confirm that our team was independent at the start of the
01:35:17 engagement and has remained independent throughout the process the end goal was for us to be to
01:35:22 validate the election process and the tabulation of the election results based on the agreed upon
01:35:28 procedures that we performed to that end the procedures we performed covered custody and
01:35:33 security of the of the mail-in ballots the verification process of the ballots the in-person
01:35:40 voting process and finally the process over the security integrity and logic of the tabulation
01:35:45 software providing the election results thank you
01:35:57 thank you sam and to the entire team at chroma k for your support
01:36:01 and professionalism now i would like to invite our chief returning officer
01:36:07 Rick Orman to explain the voting process.
01:36:37 welcome ladies and gentlemen my name is Rick Orman and I'm the chief returning officer
01:37:07 and our job is to oversee the leadership election and ensure compliance with all the rules and all
01:37:13 the procedures i was assisted in this task by three exceptional deputy returning officers
01:37:20 doug caswell ken bradley and from edmonton annie travoy and by five excellent in-person dro's
01:37:29 those that were in the remote sites ian brody linda lowe stephen butt dale langford
01:37:36 and don hubble and we were supported by over 250 party volunteers who dedicated
01:37:45 countless hours in helping with our verification process
01:37:49 for the mail-in ballot and as poll clerks at our five polling locations
01:37:59 I'd like to thank all of these volunteers for their hard work and their loyalty to their
01:38:11 party.
01:38:12 And let me tell you, if anybody thinks this party is in trouble, they ought to come and
01:38:18 talk to me because I saw over, I saw 2,000 hours of volunteer time to make this process
01:38:26 work. The bylaws of the United Conservative Party require that a
01:38:36 leadership election be conducted via a one-member, one-vote system. Unlike the
01:38:43 federal party, we do not have a riding-by-riding weighted system. In Alberta,
01:38:49 one membership means one vote no matter where you live to be named leader a
01:39:02 candidate must win a majority of the valid votes cast if after the first
01:39:08 round no candidate receives a majority then the lowest place candidate will be
01:39:13 dropped from the race and we will relocate their ballots based on their
01:39:17 second choices and add them to the totals this process is repeated until a candidate receives
01:39:27 a majority 50 plus one vote and now ladies and gentlemen the time has arrived
01:39:34 we have the results for the first ballot no candidate has received a majority of
01:39:49 the valid votes cast so we will go to another ballot Lila here has dropped off from the race
01:40:00 and the next choice on those ballots will be redistributed to the other 0.93
01:40:04 candidates we had eighty four thousand five hundred and ninety three ballots
01:40:12 cast and I will read to you the percentage received by each candidate
01:40:21 Leela Ahir 1.65% Brian Jean 10.99% Todd Lowen 7.68%
01:40:35 Rajan Sani 2.11% Rebecca Schultz 6.9% Danielle Smith 41.31%
01:40:49 percent. Travis Taves 29.35 percent. So those are the results of the first ballot and I'll be back
01:41:03 in five minutes with the redistributed numbers. Thank you.
01:41:19 That was the first round of results in the UCP leadership race.
01:41:40 Now, I have to assume what they're doing is keeping us in deliberate suspense when they have the results in an envelope back there.
01:41:48 But they're going to do this thing where every round they're going to come out and take five, six minutes, 10 hours, who knows how many between them.
01:41:54 But I just want to give you those numbers here very quickly.
01:41:58 Leela Ahir, 1.65%. 0.98
01:42:01 She was eliminated on the first ballot.
01:42:03 This is an MLA, a very fierce critic of Jason Kenney.
01:42:08 Brian Jean, 10.99%.
01:42:10 Todd Lowen, 7.68%.
01:42:13 Rajan Sani, 2.11%.
01:42:16 rebecca schultz 6.9 percent danielle smith 41.3 percent and sorry 41.31 percent and travis taves
01:42:25 with 29.35 so danielle smith in a clear lead she's got a 12 point lead over travis taves but
01:42:32 not a runaway they go on to the next round and uh we'll crunch the numbers a little bit in a moment
01:42:38 but first i want to go to rachel emmanuel who's back in calgary with drew barnes uh formerly of
01:42:45 the UCP caucus now an independent MLA. Rachel go ahead. Thanks Andrew. As you mentioned I'm here 0.66
01:42:53 with Drew Barnes a man who really needs no introduction if you're an Albertan. He's quite
01:42:57 infamous in these parts. Drew we've just got the first ballot results. Lila Ahir has dropped off.
01:43:01 You're not too far from her and you're riding. Are you surprised by the results or is it pretty
01:43:05 much what you've expected? Oh it was exactly what I expected. You know Cyprus Medicine Hatters have
01:43:11 been very engaged and they've been proactive and they've been going out to the candidates meetings
01:43:15 as they've come through Medicine Hat and Leela just didn't seem to share the values support
01:43:21 their ideas I a lot of us expected her to be the the lowest and the first one to drop off
01:43:27 so thanks to Leela for for good effort and hard work but but her ideas weren't selling with the
01:43:32 UCP membership sure and you know Leela actually recently lost her board are you familiar with
01:43:38 this story at her the UCP AGM and her riding she lost her board are you aware of that happening
01:43:42 if you can just tell our viewers a little bit about that and what the implications of that are
01:43:46 well the implications are certainly we want to be grassroots we want to have as much local
01:43:50 engagement as we can but your board is your local volunteers your hard-working people the people that
01:43:56 help you develop your ideas and and your grounding as to what's to do at certain
01:44:01 times your kitchen table cabinet and the fact that she lost her board means that even in her
01:44:07 local area her support was waning and it would have made it very very hard for her as a matter
01:44:11 fact it may make it hard for her to win a nomination to actually just be the ucp candidate
01:44:16 in the next election and and we'll see where that goes um you know there was times during
01:44:21 the campaign as well where she shared some ideas that were considered conservative uh at one point
01:44:26 she her and danielle smith the front runner had a very public uh disagreement uh about things that
01:44:33 were said and and some labeling and so yeah let's uh you know let's move on to to making alberta
01:44:39 to the freest and most prosperous place the only way to do that is with true conservative ideas
01:44:43 for sure and speaking of those true conservative ideas drew you and i have spoken a couple times
01:44:48 about how property rights are very important to you they're important to your constituents
01:44:52 they are needed for rural albertans who need to be able to protect their land you know i'm
01:44:56 wondering if you're disappointed in the lack of discussion that we've seen in property rights
01:44:59 throughout the leadership race oh more than disappointed uh you know i was elected in 2012
01:45:05 with Danielle Smith and the Wild Rose,
01:45:08 one of the main proponents at that time was a Property Rights Preservation Act
01:45:12 and strengthening property rights to increase economic freedom,
01:45:17 individual opportunity, and the values that are important.
01:45:20 Jason Kenney even promised us a referendum to enshrine property rights
01:45:23 in the Alberta part of the Canadian Constitution.
01:45:26 He promised us a Property Rights Preservation Act, and so didn't deliver.
01:45:30 There's thousands of people in this room tonight
01:45:32 because Premier Kenney didn't meet expectations,
01:45:34 And the fact that this leadership campaign missed that as well is very, very concerning.
01:45:40 Property rights, although they're a bit out there in terms of how they affect your day-to-day life,
01:45:45 they're how we build wealth.
01:45:47 They're how we keep the government at bay.
01:45:49 They're how we pass things on to the next generation.
01:45:52 It's so time to get back to Alberta being the freest, most prosperous place.
01:45:56 Sure. And you know, Drew, I guess sort of the elephant in the room is that you were kicked out of the UCP caucus
01:46:00 at the same time as Todd Lowen, who is still an independent MLA,
01:46:03 but he's now running for the leadership so you know they allowed him to run for the leadership
01:46:06 despite having kicked him out of the party obviously you know not the same people making
01:46:09 those decisions but it is sort of you know an interesting an interesting tidbit now i'm
01:46:13 wondering are you hopeful do you want to get back into the ucp caucus and are you hopeful that you'll
01:46:17 be able to after this leadership race well well thanks for that um i'll start with i pulled my
01:46:22 constituents cypress medicine hat and about a third of them want me to stay as an independent
01:46:27 about a third of them want me to get back into the ucp caucus but to me what it's really about
01:46:31 rachel is as long as the new premier which will be just an hour or two from now is focused on
01:46:38 smaller government lower taxes more economic freedom and more individual opportunity absolutely
01:46:43 i want to be part of that you know everybody's fearful of another rachel notley ndp government
01:46:48 and of course the damage was severe the first time who knows what it would be the second time
01:46:52 but it's as important to work for our values our values of lower taxes smaller governments
01:46:58 more family involvement, and more choice in health and education.
01:47:02 I want a leader that will promote those for Albertans,
01:47:06 and I will absolutely support that within the UCP if that option is there.
01:47:10 Have you had any discussions with Danielle Smith about the possibility of rejoining her caucus?
01:47:14 I mean, obviously, I'm sure it would come down to a caucus vote,
01:47:17 but have you mentioned your interest to the potential new leader?
01:47:20 Well, thank you for that.
01:47:21 And again, I was elected with Danielle in 2012, and that was a good opportunity.
01:47:26 and I've been talking to Danielle quite a bit,
01:47:28 but I, for one, don't think it should come down to a caucus vote
01:47:31 because let's be clear, when I was kicked out,
01:47:33 Jason Kenney had his thumbs on the scales of that decision totally.
01:47:38 It wasn't a secret ballot.
01:47:39 Yeah, it was a caucus vote, but it was orchestrated by the leadership
01:47:42 and it wasn't a secret ballot.
01:47:45 So why should I be subject to something else on the other way back in?
01:47:50 And again, I've talked to a lot of my caucus colleagues even here tonight.
01:47:54 I have considerable support, and a lot of them are with me in the fact that I'm put in place by the people of Cypress Medicine Hat,
01:48:01 the 50,000 people that pay me to speak for them and pay me to represent them.
01:48:05 And if the people of Cypress Medicine Hat want me back in, I should be back in.
01:48:09 All right, absolutely. Well, thank you very much, Drew. We appreciate your perspective tonight.
01:48:13 Thank you.
01:48:13 And just before we throw back to Andrew over at the studio, I just want to mention that Raj and Sonny did have a little scrum a couple minutes ago,
01:48:21 actually before they gave the first ballot. She said she had no regrets about the way that she
01:48:24 ran her campaign and she was at peace with all those decisions. She also said something that I
01:48:28 thought was very interesting. She said, I will support the leader, whoever it is. Now, the reason
01:48:32 I think that's interesting is because Rajan Asani had sort of positioned herself as the Danielle 0.98
01:48:36 Smith attack dog throughout the campaign. She was very critical of Danielle Smith's Alberta
01:48:41 Sovereignty Act. And during the first UCP, official UCP debate, she was going after Smith at every
01:48:47 opportunity candidates sort of had the opportunity to pick which other opponent they wanted to spar
01:48:51 off with and you know rajin was consistently picking danielle and sort of tearing her to
01:48:56 pieces and even made some really personal attacks like you know alberta doesn't need a talk show
01:49:00 host so i do think it's interesting that she's now saying she's willing to throw her hat behind
01:49:04 the leader and you know could be a sign of things to come if danielle does win the leadership tonight
01:49:08 for that Rachel and thank you to Drew Barnes as well I've had Drew on my show a number of times so
01:49:17 it's good to see they let him in the building because when you get kicked out of your party's
01:49:21 caucus you never know if they're going to let you get around but obviously Todd Lowen has been
01:49:25 allowed to run as a leadership candidate and so far has outlasted Lila here a former Jason
01:49:31 Kenny cabinet minister which I think is quite significant now I just want to give you a bit
01:49:36 of a heads up here. We're about to go back to the results in a moment. The feed is going to kick
01:49:43 back in in just a couple of moments here. But I just want to point out again the numbers here
01:49:48 because the numbers are very important. Danielle Smith has 41.3% of the vote on the first ballot.
01:49:55 We are going to be in this for at least, at least three more rounds. And let me tell you how I know
01:50:03 that because the bottom tier candidates right now have very small numbers. Rajan Sani, 2.1%.
01:50:10 Even if every one of her people put Danielle Smith as their number two, Danielle Smith would still 0.99
01:50:14 only be at 43.4%. And then Rebecca Schultz, same sort of thing. If every single one went for Danielle 1.00
01:50:22 next, she'd be able to go. So the reason I think this is important is because the second ballot
01:50:29 is not going to be enough.
01:50:30 It can't be enough at this point
01:50:32 to deliver a victory on this round 0.93
01:50:34 to Danielle Smith or to anyone else.
01:50:37 And this is something we just get
01:50:38 from looking at the raw numbers.
01:50:40 So we'll go back to the feed
01:50:41 and get those numbers
01:50:42 to find out what they are though.
01:50:59 our party and even though we will be dropping one candidate off at a time we
01:51:05 cannot forget the contribution that they've made to this process
01:51:17 the hundred and twenty four thousand memberships that we have in our party is
01:51:23 to a large extent because of the hard work of the candidates and the people
01:51:29 that supported them. I now have the results for the second ballot. No
01:51:40 candidate has received a majority of valid votes cast so we will go to
01:51:45 another ballot. Rajan Sani will drop off with 2.66 percent. Thank you Rajan for
01:51:59 your hard work. Brian Jean, 11.25 percent. Todd Lowen, 7.71 percent. Rebecca
01:52:19 Schultz 7.32% Danielle Smith 41.41% Travis Taves 29.66%
01:52:35 so I will go back we'll redistribute the the second choice ballots of Raj
01:52:41 and sign-ease and we will then be back with those results so as mentioned just
01:52:55 the math there and I'm not a math person but thankfully I can do the basic
01:52:59 arithmetic not always the complex stuff but there just is not enough in that
01:53:03 ballot pool to redistribute to get anyone even Danielle Smith who right now
01:53:07 is in the lead over that 50 threshold but the round two results have danielle smith at 41.4
01:53:15 travis taves at 29.7 brian gene at 11.3 todd lowen at 7.7 followed by rebecca schultz at 7.3
01:53:26 and rajan sani dropped off at 2.7 now uh william i want to get your take on on the numbers here and
01:53:34 And I want to talk about the redistribution. 0.91
01:53:36 So Lila here, who was eliminated in the first round, had 1.6%. 0.95
01:53:40 And if you look at how her votes were reallocated, Danielle Smith went up 0.1%.
01:53:47 Travis Taves went up 0.3%.
01:53:50 Brian Jean went up 0.3%.
01:53:53 Todd Lowen stayed the same.
01:53:55 Rebecca Schultz went up by 0.4%.
01:53:58 And Rajan Sani went up by 0.6%, it looks like.
01:54:02 So obviously, Lila tended to flow to Rajan more than anyone else.
01:54:07 And we're talking about small numbers here.
01:54:09 So I don't want to extrapolate too, too much.
01:54:11 But it does seem like Danielle Smith, except for Todd Lowen, is benefiting the least so
01:54:17 far from eliminations.
01:54:19 Yeah, I mean, I don't necessarily think it would come as a huge surprise that if your
01:54:24 first choice in this leadership race was Lila here, you probably didn't have Danielle Smith 0.69
01:54:28 very high up on your ballot.
01:54:30 I, you know, what is interesting is I suspect a lot of people or at least a not insignificant number of people put no second choice.
01:54:39 They voted for Leela and did not appear to have a second choice.
01:54:43 That explains it to some degree why everyone's percentages also went up, because there are now fewer votes, total votes in the race.
01:54:51 The two things, though, that leapt out at me were, first of all, Todd Lowen, who I think everybody kind of thought was, you know, not going to be a major force in this.
01:55:03 He ran, I think, a pretty good campaign and did a pretty good job in the debates that I'd seen.
01:55:08 And I think his score is actually quite respectable.
01:55:11 He came far ahead of two current or former cabinet ministers.
01:55:17 he was a before he was expelled he was a backbencher as i understand correct
01:55:21 i believe he it's possible he may have had a position in caucus leadership to some degree but
01:55:26 don't don't quote me on that i don't recall exactly but no he wasn't a minister uh in the
01:55:32 kenny government um the other thing that really leaps out i think it's got to be a very disappointing
01:55:37 evening for brian gene uh you know this was someone who uh on the last vote for leadership
01:55:43 of the United Conservative Party. There were fewer candidates, but he had won in the 30s
01:55:49 in terms of total support. And to see him barely cracking that 10% threshold, I think,
01:55:57 is probably going to be quite disappointing for him and his team as the night goes on.
01:56:03 Yeah, I'm inclined to agree. And it's been weird. It's been a bit of a weird coalition. And we were
01:56:08 talking about this you and I earlier and also with Rachel it hasn't exactly been the Kenny camp
01:56:14 versus the anti-Kenny camp like Brian Jean was a big critic probably one of Jason Kenney's loudest
01:56:20 critics for quite some time but he also has tried to distinguish himself from Danielle Smith who
01:56:25 similarly has I think picked up a lot of the people that had a lot of angst about Jason Kenney
01:56:30 and I think this has been a little bit confusing and arguably this is the sort of situation without
01:56:35 a ranked ballot that could have led to a significant vote split. But as you mentioned,
01:56:40 there's been, it seems like a relative collapse in Brian Jean's vote. Now, obviously, he may
01:56:45 be the beneficiary of, you know, some of Raj and Sonny's down ballot support or that of Rebecca
01:56:50 Schultz or even Todd Lohan. We don't know until that happens. But it is interesting for a guy
01:56:55 that I think at one point saw himself as the heir apparent to the premiership of Alberta. And now
01:57:01 he's in a, not just third, but a very distant third on the leadership ballot. Yeah. I mean,
01:57:07 I will say that his decision to immediately quit as a MLA after Jason Kenney won the leadership
01:57:16 race, I think was probably in retrospect, not the greatest move because he could have been,
01:57:23 and I think would have been a senior cabinet minister in a Jason Kenney government. And he
01:57:28 would have had the ability to have a portfolio, to have consistent public profile. Instead,
01:57:34 he's been away and you would see the odd op-ed from him, but you really didn't hear and see
01:57:41 from Brian Jean that much after he left. So I think probably in retrospect, him getting a little
01:57:47 bit, I mean, I won't say he left in a huff, but he certainly left quite quickly after he didn't win
01:57:52 the first leadership race. I suspect maybe not have been the best move to win the leadership
01:57:57 in the future. We are waiting for third ballot results, but let's just go to Rachel Emanuel in
01:58:03 Calgary, who is right now with Conservative Member of Parliament, Chris Warkenton. Yeah, thanks very
01:58:09 much, Andrew. I'm joined by Chris Warkenton, who is a Conservative Member for Parliament for
01:58:13 Ram Prairie McKenzie, as well. He's also the campaign co-chair for Travis Daves. Thanks so
01:58:18 much for joining us, Chris. We have some of the results so far. What do you make of them? Are they
01:58:22 pretty much what you were expecting to see, or have you been surprised at all yet tonight?
01:58:25 You know, it really is a close race, as we expected. Obviously, this is tighter than, of course, had been forecasted, but it was very close to what we expected.
01:58:34 Do you think that Premier Jason Kenney wading into the leadership race had any impact on it?
01:58:39 Pardon me? I'm just not overhearing you here. Sorry about that.
01:58:42 Yeah, sorry. The feed has just started a little bit behind us. They're announcing their results right now. I think the feed is going to be a little bit delayed for them.
01:58:48 I was just asking if you think, you know, Premier Jason Kenney wading into the race and commenting on things like the Sovereignty Act, did that impact the outcome at all?
01:58:55 well i don't know i didn't hear from anybody that really felt that it did obviously there
01:58:59 were many people that were commenting on the race and you know i don't think that that had
01:59:03 significant impact on the intentions of people voting okay great thanks very much chris we're
01:59:07 just going to throw to the stream now but hopefully we can get you back a little later
01:59:10 for some more time thanks throw it back to you andrew thank you very much rachel and chris
01:59:16 workington and i i should say for those who aren't familiar uh chris workington was one of the very
01:59:22 instrumental figures in Alberta conservative politics who was driving the Unite the Right
01:59:28 movement. He was touring Alberta alongside some other members of parliament and alongside
01:59:34 surrogates for Jason Kenney. Jason Kenney himself trying to drum up support for Jason Kenney's PC
01:59:40 leadership bid, which then became the merger votes in the PC and Wildrose parties, which then became
01:59:45 the UCP leadership vote. So a lot of people forget all of the steps that Jason Kenney had to go
01:59:51 through to get to the UCP. But we're getting third ballot results right now.
01:59:58 Todd Lowen has dropped off from the race, and the next choices on those ballots will be
02:00:05 redistributed to the other candidates.
02:00:12 Brian Jean, 12.07%.
02:00:17 Rebecca Schultz, 8.02%.
02:00:25 Danielle Smith, 41.70%.
02:00:32 Todd Lowen, 30.41%.
02:00:38 And Todd Lowen had 7.81%.
02:00:42 So we will be back.
02:00:47 so that right there was a bit confusing i think they flubbed the numbers there but as i understand
02:01:03 from looking at uh what uh rachel has uh sent me here in in writing danielle smith still in first
02:01:09 place at 41.7%. So again, just a 0.3% bump in the last round. Travis Taves, he is now at 30.4%. 1.00
02:01:19 So he's gone up about seven points, it looks like. Brian Jean, 12.1%. So he's gone up 0.8 points.
02:01:28 And let's see, Todd Lowen now has dropped off the ballot. He had 7.7%, only went up to 7.8%.
02:01:35 So he's just shy of Rebecca Schultz, who is now in fourth place at 8%.
02:01:41 So here's where it starts to get a bit interesting.
02:01:44 Now, I should say, even if with four candidates left, Rebecca Schultz is eliminated and every one of her votes went to Danielle Smith, which is unlikely to happen,
02:01:55 Danielle Smith would still be at 49.7%.
02:01:58 So not yet at that 50% plus one threshold.
02:02:02 So, William, I mean, this is going to be, it looks fairly decisive, but she's having to work for her victory if it goes the way we think it's going to go.
02:02:12 Yeah, and I think to be clear, though, the next round we'll see Todd Lowen's votes redistributed.
02:02:19 So, Rebecca will be, we'll get.
02:02:21 Yeah, sorry, you're right.
02:02:22 I was getting ahead of us here. 1.00
02:02:24 But that's interesting because I think we will expect to see Danielle actually get a sizable bump in the next round of redistribution.
02:02:32 I think people who voted Todd Lowen one are very likely to have made it Danielle Smith number two.
02:02:38 And so that would take her not not into winning territory.
02:02:41 But if a majority of the votes did go to her, it puts her pretty close to it. 1.00
02:02:46 She doesn't need that many more votes in order to to go over the top.
02:02:51 And so the question is now, assuming there isn't anything particularly crazy in the next round and Rebecca Schultz is eliminated from the ballot.
02:03:01 where do her second or third or fourth choices go?
02:03:04 Like, where did the people who had other candidates go?
02:03:07 And I don't know.
02:03:09 I think she's, more than many of the others,
02:03:12 she didn't go after Danielle Smith Quaggis Hart,
02:03:15 as several of the other candidates did.
02:03:17 She didn't join that group press conference attacking the Alberta Sovereignty Act.
02:03:22 And so I don't really know.
02:03:25 But assuming Danielle does pick up a majority of the votes from Todd Lowen, 0.95
02:03:30 she is going to be pretty close on that next round. And it's possible we would see
02:03:36 Rebecca's votes redistributed and that would be enough to get her over the top. 1.00
02:03:41 Yeah. And thank you for correcting the numbers there. So the 7.8%, even if every single one of
02:03:48 those went to Danielle Smith, she would be at, just to do the quick math here, 48.5%, I believe,
02:03:57 48.5%. So still, we can't get 50% plus one. You're right, though. I mean, after that,
02:04:03 it definitely does look like it's all but certainly a Danielle Smith victory. But
02:04:08 you still have to wonder how it's going to get there. And I wouldn't be surprised if
02:04:12 even assuming Rebecca Schultz is the next one to go. I mean, something weird could happen. But
02:04:18 even if that happens, it's possible that if a small, small share of Rebecca Schultz votes go
02:04:24 to Danielle Smith, they could go to yet another ballot. So that'll be the thing to watch here. 0.57
02:04:28 But I just want to kind of ask you a bit more broadly about your take on some of these players.
02:04:35 I mean, Rebecca Schultz has always struck me as a team player. She's been a movement conservative.
02:04:40 I've been on stage with her at Canada Strong and Free networking conferences in the past. So
02:04:45 I think she's definitely going to be one that will happily support whoever the next leader is.
02:04:51 Brian Jean is the one that I find quite interesting here because he and Danielle Smith have both really tried to be and saw themselves as the alternate Kenny.
02:05:01 So can those two work together in your view?
02:05:04 Well, I think it's a very interesting question.
02:05:06 I would absolutely agree.
02:05:08 Rebecca Schultz, I think she's done also well enough in this leadership race, improving her name recognition and her overall profile that I would expect to see her as a senior cabinet position in, say, a Daniel Smith-led government. 0.90
02:05:22 Certainly, I think if it's Travis Tades, we would expect the same thing to have Rebecca Schultz there.
02:05:29 Brian Jean, I don't know.
02:05:30 I don't know what the personal dynamic is.
02:05:32 Vitor talked a little bit about how the Danielle Smith team was a little bit cut off from some of
02:05:38 the inter-campaign communications that have been going on. So I don't know. It will really be up
02:05:43 to Brian if he decides, if he wants to work and be part of it and stay as a UCP MLA. Of course,
02:05:51 he's only been an MLA for quite a short period of time, having won a by-election. Or does he do
02:05:58 what he did last time. And he says, well, I'm going to resign. I'm going to wait a little bit
02:06:03 and step down. I think if he were to do that second option, we would have a very hard time
02:06:08 seeing him try and mount a third leadership campaign. Because at some point, it would become
02:06:13 a bit of a game of, you know, Brian doesn't win, so he quits. And then a few years go by,
02:06:19 back he comes, he doesn't win, so he quits. And I think that little routine might start to get
02:06:24 very old for UCP members. Let's bring Rachel Emanuel into the discussion here now. She's been
02:06:32 working furiously on the ground, bringing over pretty much anyone and everyone to the microphone 0.50
02:06:37 there and interviewing them. And you've been doing a bang up job, Rachel. But just in the lull here,
02:06:42 has it seemed like everyone in the room, just from the shocks and gasps or lack thereof,
02:06:49 that this is going pretty much how everyone thought, even if they were on different campaigns?
02:06:54 Yeah, well, I would say it's a little harder to get guests as the night goes on.
02:06:57 I think people are drinking a little bit more and more,
02:06:59 and people are less interested in coming on and giving their takes.
02:07:02 But no, I don't think...
02:07:03 They should be more interested in coming on when they're like five beers in.
02:07:06 Come on.
02:07:07 You would think, you would think, yeah.
02:07:08 No, I don't think people in the room have seemed very surprised yet.
02:07:12 They've seemed, you know, pretty excited with the results people are cheering.
02:07:14 You have to remember there's a lot of different people
02:07:17 from a lot of the different campaigns here.
02:07:18 So we're seeing a variety of perspectives.
02:07:20 And they've just announced behind me now, as we sort of expected,
02:07:23 rebecca schultz has dropped off the ballot and the rest of the candidates are remaining so you
02:07:28 know we still have a few rounds to go here people in the room seem very energetic they seem very
02:07:32 excited about the results as they're coming in and you know i think the fact that it's getting
02:07:35 down into the later ballot is making it more of an exciting race so andrew i'll throw back to you
02:07:39 now because i'm sure your stream's going to catch up soon and you guys can throw back to the live
02:07:43 stream as well thanks very much for that certainly we heard some raucous cheering there we'll pick
02:07:49 that up. The delay in the stream is, by the way, the United Conservative Party's stream. So I can
02:07:56 tell you we're giving you such a fast stream that Rachel Emanuel can give you the results even
02:08:00 before the UCP does just with that delay. So I appreciate your patience there. We're going to go
02:08:05 to that right now. But it sounds like, and I haven't seen the specific numbers, exactly like
02:08:10 we thought was going to happen. Rebecca Schultz has now been dropped off the ballot and we'll go
02:08:15 to the feed now.
02:08:19 Ballot. 0.97
02:08:32 Rebecca Schultz with 8.37% of the vote drops off the ballot.
02:08:40 The remaining candidates percentages are Brian Jean, 13.5%, Travis Taves, 31.92%, Danielle
02:08:55 Smith 46.21 percent so not really any surprise in these numbers pretty much exactly like we were
02:09:21 anticipating. This latest round, which had Todd Lowen's votes reallocated, puts Danielle Smith
02:09:26 at 46.2%, Travis Taves at 31.9%, Brian Jean at 13.5%, and Rebecca Schultz at 8.4%. She's now
02:09:37 been dropped off the ballot, and her votes will be reallocated in the fifth round. Now,
02:09:43 just looking at the raw numbers here. So in the last round, Danielle Smith was at 35,095 0.96
02:09:50 votes. On this round, she's at 38,496 votes. So she went up from 41.7% to 46.2%. So she didn't get
02:10:04 all of Todd Lowen's support. Todd Lowen had 6,500 votes. And as we see, Danielle Smith just went up
02:10:10 by about roughly half that. So again, it's tough to say because you don't know why people vote
02:10:16 certain ways and if ballots were spoiled. But it does seem like there were a lot of people that
02:10:21 were not willing to go to Danielle Smith, even if she was the most similar to Todd Lowen,
02:10:26 who was their preferred candidate in this case. No, I think you're absolutely right. I had
02:10:31 wondered if, as the night went on, would we ever see any factor of anybody but Danielle? Because
02:10:38 in the minds of some conservative voters, her decision to cross the floor, lead the
02:10:44 Walrose floor crossing and joined the PC government of the late Jim Prentice, possibly some people
02:10:52 see that as an unforgivable sin. And therefore, even if you like many of the things that she
02:10:58 stands for, you like her Sovereignty Act, you like her be tough with Ottawa commentary,
02:11:06 maybe there is that cohort of people who just say, I'm sorry, I cannot get over what happened
02:11:11 way back in 2014, 2015. So that might explain it. I don't know. Certainly Northern Alberta,
02:11:19 Northwestern Alberta is an interesting part of the province and doesn't always go exactly how
02:11:26 you might think in nominations or in leadership votes. So we're definitely having an exciting
02:11:31 night. That's for sure. Yeah. And just to, again, crunch some of the numbers here. So 46.2%
02:11:37 is what Danielle Smith is at now. 1.00
02:11:40 She needs to get to 50% plus one. 1.00
02:11:43 Rebecca Schultz at 8.4%. 0.99
02:11:45 So if half of the voters, or I mean less than half,
02:11:50 but if just under half of the voters for Rebecca Schultz
02:11:52 have Danielle Smith as their next choice, 1.00
02:11:56 she'll win on the next ballot.
02:11:58 I guess the question I put to you, William,
02:11:59 do you think that's gonna happen?
02:12:01 Because I didn't see, I mean,
02:12:02 even if Rebecca Schultz didn't get in 1.00
02:12:04 on the beat up of Danielle Smith, 0.99
02:12:06 I don't see on the surface a lot of crossover between those two candidates.
02:12:11 Certainly, I think you're right.
02:12:13 I mean, if Danielle is able to win on the next ballot, I suspect it won't be by a huge margin.
02:12:20 I suspect that it will be a mathematically, it'll be a mathematical win, but it'll be a very narrow margin for her. 0.83
02:12:27 The only thing I can think of is maybe going to influence the vote is she now is the only female candidate who is running still on the ballot. 0.97
02:12:36 If you were voting a slate of candidates that was all female, then you would have to make Daniel Smith your next choice. 0.75
02:12:42 So I have no idea if that is something that people do when they vote. 0.93
02:12:48 But, you know, people vote for all sorts of reasons, and they're not always the logical or obvious ones that you might assume.
02:12:55 So I do think it'll be interesting, but I think we're either going to see Daniel Smith come within a handful of percentage points of winning or possibly even take it with a very razor within margin on the next ballot.
02:13:09 Well, we're going to carry those results live as they come in.
02:13:13 Rachel Emanuel is in Calgary at UCB headquarters.
02:13:16 And I understand now she's with Tarek El Naga, who I've had on the show.
02:13:20 And I've actually been on Tarek's horse before, which come to think of it might be animal cruelty.
02:13:26 Andrew, I just got to interrupt.
02:13:27 We got more results.
02:13:28 Tarek El Naga has done lots of great stuff in Alberta.
02:13:31 Take it away, Rachel.
02:13:34 Sorry, they announced that the results were coming.
02:13:35 we thought no candidate receives a majority yet i'm not sure if you guys can hear over there
02:13:41 we're going to another ballot brian gene has dropped off from the race
02:13:50 we're just waiting for some more information here i'll read it to you live as it comes
02:13:53 here are the percentages for candidate brian gene had 14.83 so brian gene had 14.8
02:14:05 travis taves had 37.43
02:14:14 and daniel smith with 47. i didn't catch the final percentages of that but very close now
02:14:19 we should have the final results on the next round obviously but we're taking it to the very
02:14:24 end here so there's definitely a lot of excitement in the room for sure thank you for that rachel so
02:14:31 i just we're going to get those numbers in writing here and once the the party feed catches up we'll
02:14:37 actually run that so you can hear it directly and we'll get the graphic up on the screen there but
02:14:42 again as william and i were just talking about sounds like danielle smith did not get that 0.99
02:14:47 margin she needed from 1.00
02:14:49 Rebecca Schultz. Let's go to the feed. 0.75
02:14:54 Ballot votes cast
02:14:55 so we will go to another ballot.
02:14:58 Brian Jean
02:14:59 drops off from the race
02:15:00 and the next choices on those
02:15:03 ballots will be distributed
02:15:05 to the remaining two candidates.
02:15:12 Here are the
02:15:13 percentages per candidate.
02:15:16 Brian Jean
02:15:17 had 14.83%, Travis Taves 37.43%, Daniel Smith 47.73%.
02:15:31 We'll be back in a minute.
02:15:40 Thank you very much.
02:15:42 I feel bad.
02:15:43 I don't know if we still have Tarek Elnega.
02:15:46 If we do have Tarek, let's get him back, please.
02:15:50 Rachel, I feel so bad.
02:15:51 Tarek was like, you need to get Tarek's like rodeo rope and bring him back.
02:15:55 That's how he would do it.
02:15:56 So Tarek is great.
02:15:57 I will just give a bit of an introduction because he's one of the most fascinating people in Alberta politics.
02:16:01 He is from Dubai and he went to the Calgary Stampede on vacation once and just fell in love with the West.
02:16:08 So he sold his house in the United Arab Emirates, moved to Calgary and got or moved to Airdrie.
02:16:13 I think he got a truck and power tools and a cowboy hat and now is like a professional on the
02:16:19 rodeo circuit. And he gave me a tour of his acreage out there where he does the work with
02:16:25 his horses. So Tarek is fantastic and has been a very strong voice for an independent Alberta.
02:16:30 And I'm very curious, as you and I were discussing earlier, William, how many of those people Danielle
02:16:36 Smith is able to bring back into the fold, assuming she becomes the leader and we don't
02:16:40 have some just by some magical twist of fate, you know, Jeb Bush on the seventh ballot or something 0.79
02:16:45 like that. But I mean, the numbers here, it's great for suspense, but what do you make in the
02:16:50 numbers here? What are their significance beyond just, you know, how long it takes us to wrap up
02:16:54 the show? Yeah, I mean, I think there's some really interesting things. Danielle really only
02:16:59 got a sizable bump from when Todd Lowen dropped off the ballot. Otherwise, all of her increases 1.00
02:17:06 were pretty marginal throughout the thing.
02:17:09 But obviously in the last round, 1.00
02:17:11 a large majority of Rebecca Schultz's second choices 1.00
02:17:16 or later choices did go to Travis Tate's.
02:17:19 And that is reflected in the fact
02:17:20 that he gained a very sizable chunk.
02:17:22 That being said, he's at 37.4% and needs 50% plus one.
02:17:29 There's 14.8% up for offer on Brian Jean.
02:17:33 He would have to win almost all of it in order for him to beat Daniel Smith on the on the final ballot.
02:17:40 I think I mean, it's not impossible, obviously, mathematically, but it would be extremely difficult for him to capture that large a share.
02:17:48 I would say there's probably a decent argument that Brian Jean voters did rank Daniel Smith ahead of Travis Davis.
02:17:55 But but you are right. If there is like an anti Daniel Smith sentiment forming some that that would be the path to victory.
02:18:01 Now, I don't think that is going to be what happens, but we've always said it hasn't been a lock for Danielle Smith.
02:18:07 Like in the federal one, it was a lock for Pierre Polly F.
02:18:09 In this case, I saw there was a path for Travis Taves.
02:18:12 I think we do have Tarek Elnega back with Rachel Emanuel now.
02:18:17 Sorry about that, Tarek.
02:18:18 So I was just in the middle of introducing him.
02:18:20 Tarek Elnega, he ran for the leadership of the Maverick Party.
02:18:23 He also ran to be MP for the Maverick Party in the last federal election.
02:18:27 You were unsuccessful in both those bids.
02:18:28 But I know that a lot of people wanted you to put your name for it for the UCP Leadership Contest.
02:18:33 Did you ever consider it?
02:18:34 You know, it wasn't the right time.
02:18:36 What I'm really excited about is to see, I mean, the Maverick platform is all about pro-Western autonomy.
02:18:41 And it's really exciting to see candidates that are pro-Alberta autonomy, predominantly Danielle Smith here,
02:18:47 really pushing that Alberta sovereignty and that Alberta autonomy message.
02:18:51 And I'll take it. That's good news for Alberta, for sure.
02:18:54 You know, we've got two candidates left. It's between Danielle Smith and Travis Taves.
02:18:58 It's Taves when, you know, do you think that he's been an Alberta sovereignty candidate, you know, pro Alberta, or you're not really getting that messaging from him?
02:19:04 Well, I think whoever wins it now realizes that half the base, give or take, is pro-sovereignty and pro-the-sovereignty act.
02:19:12 So you're going to have to need to bring them in.
02:19:14 So if Danielle is not the one that wins and Travis Taves wins, then he's going to have to bring that in.
02:19:19 It's a pretty divided party, not dissimilar to how it was a 50-50 split with Kenny.
02:19:23 so it's it's time to unify that party and and not discount the sovereignty movement of the party
02:19:29 sure so you're mentioning you know the party you know people who are running they're kind of
02:19:33 realizing that this is something that's important for the base you know i mentioned a bunch of people
02:19:36 wanted you to run which shows that it is important for the base people wanted you to run you decided
02:19:40 against that do you have any interest in running for a ucp nomination at any point you're going to
02:19:44 step back from politics for the time being you know what i'm not going to close the door uh to
02:19:48 running again. Right now, I've got a vested interest on making sure the NDP loses. So that's
02:19:55 where I'm at. So whether Danielle wins or Travis wins, I want to see the NDP lose. There's no room
02:20:01 for socialism in this province or in my life. And that's what I'm focused on. Whether I personally
02:20:06 run or not, I'm not going to close the door on that. You mentioned that you want to make sure
02:20:09 the NDP loses. We're talking a little bit about, oh, I'm sorry, we have the results again. At least
02:20:13 we got a couple minutes this time. All right. Thanks very much. Yeah. Yeah. Take care. All
02:20:18 right. All right. That was Tarek. We have some more results, so we're going to go to live.
02:20:28 It's Danielle Smith. She's the premier and the crowd goes wild behind me. You can hear
02:20:32 the excitement in the room. Danielle Smith has won with 53.77% of the vote. Travis Taves
02:20:40 has come in second with 46.23% of the vote and you can just hear the excitement in the room
02:20:46 it came all the way down to the end but Daniel Smith was able to pull a victory off at the end
02:20:51 the question now will be whether the fact that she waited so long you know she didn't get that
02:20:55 first ballot victory as many of us expected she didn't get that victory later to the end will
02:20:59 that impact her ability to unite the caucus going forward and I'm sure your stream is just about
02:21:03 up now so I'll throw back to you Andrew. Yeah thank you Rachel we will go to that feed when
02:21:08 it comes in but uh danielle smith has won the ucp leadership race will be the next premier and uh
02:21:15 just it sounds like from the raw numbers there that roughly half of brian gene's votes went to
02:21:21 danielle smith and roughly half went to travis taves and as william and i were saying uh it
02:21:26 would have needed to be more much more lopsided than that uh here are the official numbers
02:21:30 Ladies and gentlemen, we have the results of the sixth ballot.
02:21:40 Our members have elected a new leader.
02:21:42 Please welcome the next Premier of our province, Danielle Smith.
02:22:00 .
02:22:30 Thank you.
02:23:00 Thank you.
02:23:30 I'm back.
02:23:41 Well, if you're wondering why I wasn't nervous tonight,
02:23:45 I must thank Layla Fole,
02:23:47 whose grandma's watching from the Good Fish Reserve,
02:23:50 and she gave me these peace feeds
02:23:51 at the very beginning of the evening,
02:23:53 and Layla, they worked.
02:23:54 So thank you so much for your support.
02:23:57 I appreciate it.
02:23:57 And you should also know the family connection that we have with our returning officer, Rick Orman, was the very first campaign that I worked on in 1992 when he was running for leadership of the Progressive Conservative Party.
02:24:12 and the reason I supported him is because he and my dad played football together at Crescent Heights
02:24:17 and dad is here this evening as well Rick if you want to go over and say hello so I'm just so
02:24:21 delighted that our big conservative family is all together in one room united and strong
02:24:29 my fellow albertans over the last 117 years we have written a remarkable story together
02:24:43 it's a story of pioneers and farmers entrepreneurs and innovators communities and families a place
02:24:52 where the best and brightest come from every corner of this world to join with us in building
02:24:58 one of the greatest places on earth to live to work and to raise our families
02:25:07 tonight marks the beginning of a new chapter in the alberta story it is time for alberta
02:25:14 to take its place as a senior partner in building a strong and unified canada
02:25:19 no longer will alberta ask permission from ottawa to be prosperous and free
02:25:31 we will not have our voices silenced and censored
02:25:39 we will not be told what we must put in our bodies in order to work or to travel
02:25:49 We will not have our resources landlocked or our energy phased out of existence by virtue-signalling Prime Ministers.
02:26:05 Albertans, not Ottawa, will chart our own destiny on our own terms,
02:26:10 and we will work with our fellow Canadians to build the most free and prosperous country on Earth.
02:26:19 before speaking further i wanted to thank first and foremost my husband david it's funny when i
02:26:26 started running again somebody asked me if i'd gotten divorced because david standard answered
02:26:32 when anyone asked me if i was getting in politics again was yeah she's welcome to get back into
02:26:37 politics with her new husband he still loves me after all this imagine that my wonderful parents
02:26:45 doug and sharon are here this evening as my uncle blaine and my brother carrie my brother doug and
02:26:50 his wife carrie i'm delighted to have my family with me but i do also want to congratulate and
02:26:55 thank my fellow leadership candidates not only for their commitment to the party but also to
02:27:01 democracy over the last several months these great men and women have placed their lives on hold and
02:27:07 sacrificed greatly because they love this province with all their hearts they want to see our
02:27:12 province move forward with strength and prosperity as much as anyone in Alberta. I want to thank
02:27:19 Travis Chaves for his integrity and for leading the charge and bringing our province's budget
02:27:28 back to surplus from the brink of disaster under Rachel Notley's NDP.
02:27:33 Alberta and our caucus are going to lean heavily on your strength and experience in the months
02:27:43 and years ahead. I also want to thank Brian Jean for his passion and commitment to the grassroots
02:27:49 and to making life more affordable for millions of Albertans suffering from the inflation crisis
02:27:54 brought on by the NDP Liberal Coalition in Ottawa. Thank you.
02:27:58 and on a personal note i want to thank brian for showing leadership after i made a mistake
02:28:07 in judgment in 2014 learning from your example has prepared me for today and this party will
02:28:13 always owe you a debt of gratitude as one of the founders of this united conservative party thank
02:28:19 you Brian I also want to recognize Rebecca Schultz for her compassion class
02:28:28 and innovative ideas Rebecca you are one of the brightest lights in our province
02:28:37 and I can't wait to work with you to ensure so many of those great ideas
02:28:40 become a reality to Todd Lowen thank you so much for reminding us that MLAs are
02:28:54 the voice of the people in government not the government's mouthpiece to the
02:28:59 people and I look forward to working with you to ensure caucus lives by that
02:29:06 that principle moving forward. And on that note, I understand that over this last week, Todd,
02:29:12 your fellow UCP MLAs indicated overwhelmingly in favor of you to rejoin the UCP caucus.
02:29:22 And I invite you to attend our caucus meeting tomorrow morning so we can get back to work.
02:29:26 So thanks so much and welcome back, Todd. I also want to thank Raj Ansani for her class
02:29:35 and commitment to vulnerable and senior Albertans and I look forward to advancing those causes
02:29:40 together Rajan and to Lila here thank you for your passion and commitment to serving Albertans
02:29:48 even if that means fighting a cowboy who's fallen off a uh a bull or fighting no other way fighting
02:29:55 a bull to save a fallen cowboy thanks Lila I want to thank each and every one of you who ran
02:30:04 You're all great Albertans, and I look forward to serving alongside you.
02:30:08 I would be remiss as well if I did not thank my friend, Premier Jason Kenney.
02:30:18 Let us remember that Premier Kenney has fought for Albertans for decades,
02:30:23 first as an advocate for taxpayers,
02:30:25 then as one of the most effective and influential Conservative Cabinet Ministers in Canadian history,
02:30:31 then leading the charge on unifying the conservative movement, running and beating
02:30:36 Rachel Notley's NDP, and then governing as premier for one of the most tumultuous times in Alberta
02:30:41 history. Although we may have had our differences these last couple of years on a couple of matters
02:30:46 of policy, I want him to know that I admire and respect him. Thank you, Jason, for being
02:30:52 such a loyal Canadian and a giant in the conservative movement. Thank you, premier.
02:31:01 And a special thanks to my campaign team who dedicated the last few months of their lives to helping us get to this moment. I simply wouldn't be here without you. And I should name just a few. The leadership of Matt Altheim, my campaign manager from Edmonton.
02:31:17 yeah you'll be happy to know he knows how to beat nvp in their own backyard that's why we've got
02:31:24 him on our team and rob anderson who's been such a great support for me over the years an incredible
02:31:30 policy advisor thank you and also the the other team i have to tell you one one of my campaign
02:31:37 members would always introduce our team saying we've got an lpn an electrician at home moms a
02:31:42 single mom, a PhD, and a yak farmer. And that is no joke. Every campaign needs a yak farmer. 0.91
02:31:51 And finally, thank you to our almost 125,000 UCP members and the thousands of volunteers from 0.99
02:31:57 every campaign in all corners of our province. Thank you for loving and serving our province.
02:32:03 Thank you for the hours spent fighting for your party, your candidate, and for the values that
02:32:09 they represent. If there's one thing I've learned about Albertans, it's that we don't expect our
02:32:13 leaders to be perfect, but we do expect them to stay humble, admit when they're wrong, and to
02:32:19 learn from their mistakes. I love that about our province, and I'm grateful to have earned this
02:32:28 second chance from you. I will never forget it, and I pledge to you tonight, I will not let you down.
02:32:39 My friends, tonight I invite all United Conservative Party supporters, our party, our caucus, fellow
02:32:48 leadership candidates, all of us, regardless of who we supported during this leadership
02:32:52 race, to come together and unite for the good of our great province.
02:33:01 Albertans want us to be unified.
02:33:04 They want us to succeed.
02:33:06 Albertans don't want to elect a socialist NDP government any more than they want to see the
02:33:11 Toronto Maple Leafs win the Stanley Cup. Sorry, honey, David's a Toronto Maple Leaf fan.
02:33:23 However, my friends, Albertans will no longer tolerate infighting and disunity. They rightly
02:33:28 expect their provincial Conservative Party to be competent, cooperative, and unified against
02:33:33 the constant threat posed to our economy by the NDP liberal coalition in Ottawa. Unity is not a
02:33:40 talking point. It is an action. It is something you practice rather than preach. Now is not the
02:33:45 time for settling old scores or rivalries. It's not the time to punish our fellow conservatives
02:33:50 for past mistakes. This is why as premier and leader of this party, I am wiping the slate clean.
02:33:57 The membership is spoken.
02:34:03 They have given us direction on how they want us to stand up to Ottawa and protect our freedoms.
02:34:08 And we will follow our members' direction on this without delay.
02:34:14 However, every single UCP MLA, regardless of who they supported or what they have said
02:34:20 or what decisions they have made in the past, good or bad, is not important at this moment.
02:34:25 All that matters now is that what we do to serve Albertans from this day forward.
02:34:30 And I want to invite each of our MLAs, our members, our volunteers, our supporters, every single one of you to join me to govern with strength and compassion, to protect our fellow Albertans from the NDP-Liberal coalition in Ottawa, and to lead this party to a resounding victory against the NDP in 2023.
02:34:48 to win in 2023 we need to focus on the issues Albertans are most concerned with as you know
02:35:01 Canada and Alberta are in the midst of an inflation and affordability crisis that has
02:35:05 been primarily caused by the fiscally destructive policies of the NDP coalition with the Liberals
02:35:11 in Ottawa when you flood the money supply with hundreds of billions of new spending
02:35:16 and pursue policies that spike the price of energy and transportation,
02:35:21 the result is crippling inflation that is hurting a sizable majority of Albertans. 0.95
02:35:26 The 30-year-old university graduate living in her parents' basement
02:35:30 because she can't afford the damaged deposit on a rental.
02:35:33 The single mom who has to resort to smaller and less nutritious meals 1.00
02:35:37 for her young son and daughter because she can't make the budget stretch any further.
02:35:41 The working father forced to take extra shifts in overtime
02:35:44 because if he doesn't he won't be able to pay for the extra interest being charged on the family's
02:35:49 mortgage from repeated interest rate hikes and the senior living on a fixed income anxious about how
02:35:56 they're going to afford to pay for their needed prescriptions when their power and heating bills
02:36:01 increase this coming winter these are not uncommon stories they're they are not exceptions to the
02:36:07 rule i've been speaking with hundreds of these albertans for months albertans and all canadians
02:36:13 are suffering terribly every day at the hands of an inflation and affordability crisis
02:36:18 and that is why i find it so callous that in the middle of this crisis
02:36:22 the ndp liberal coalition in ottawa just decided to triple the carbon tax
02:36:30 this will only make energy and groceries and food and fuel and housing more expensive
02:36:36 everything we need to live and i find it incomprehensible that rachel notley has so
02:36:41 so far refused to call on her federal NDP leader Jagmeet Singh to lobby his taxing cohort Justin
02:36:48 Trudeau to reverse that terrible decision hurting Alberta families. There is no excuse for any party
02:36:58 leader seeking to be Premier of Alberta to sacrifice the welfare of Albertans for the sake
02:37:03 of towing the line of her federal party. It is time for Ms. Notley to put the welfare of Albertans
02:37:09 above the anti-Alberta policies of her federal NDP leader.
02:37:18 She is not putting Alberta first, and that's the difference between us.
02:37:22 I will always, always put Albertans first. No apologies.
02:37:32 Clearly, Albertans want nothing to do with the Notley Singh-Trudeau alliance of economic destruction.
02:37:38 But to earn the trust of Albertans, we need to do more than just stand up to the NDP Liberal
02:37:44 Coalition. We must do more than be the party of economic growth and balanced budgets and debt
02:37:49 reduction and lower taxes. That's just part of who we are as a party and as a government.
02:37:54 But we also need to show Albertans that we can be trusted to compassionately care for our vulnerable
02:37:59 and our seniors, especially in this time of crippling inflation. We need to reform the
02:38:04 dysfunction of Alberta Health Services and repair our broken EMS services with
02:38:10 swift decisive action. That also means repairing our relationship with nurses
02:38:17 and doctors. It means replacing managers with frontline staff. It means attracting,
02:38:23 exactly, it means attracting additional health professionals from around the
02:38:28 world and it means that as premier when I direct AHS management to double ICU
02:38:34 capacity by a specific date and give them the resources to do so, that direction is followed
02:38:40 immediately. And if they can't do that, then we will find others who can do it for them.
02:38:53 Although we will always balance the budget and control increases in spending, we must also
02:38:57 demonstrate the compassion Albertans expect of us by ensuring the vulnerable can afford the
02:39:03 necessities of life during this inflationary crisis. We must ensure our teachers, our children
02:39:09 have the teachers and education assistants and tutors that they need to succeed, especially
02:39:15 after the disruption to education over the last couple of years. We must address the mental health
02:39:20 and opioid crisis that is stealing our young people from us. And we must give a hand up, a warm
02:39:26 hug, real hope and real help to those on our streets who don't know where else to turn. We are
02:39:32 Albertans. Yes, we are entrepreneurs and business people and fiscally prudent, but we also have
02:39:42 heart and compassion that matches the size of our mountains. Our generous compassion is the
02:39:47 very soul of Alberta, and Albertans demand a government that reflects that compassion,
02:39:52 especially in times like these. As premier, I will ensure we act swiftly to demonstrate exactly that.
02:40:02 Now, friends, in the months ahead, we must recognize that there are those in Ottawa and the establishment, even some in Alberta, that don't want to see our party be unified.
02:40:12 They don't want us to succeed. And sadly, these folks will do and say almost anything to keep us from succeeding.
02:40:19 They will dredge up old statements and mistakes from the past.
02:40:22 They will use cancel culture and fear mongering in an attempt to scare and dissuade Albertans from supporting our MLAs and me.
02:40:29 For example, it is safe to say that many in the not-leasing Trudeau alliance will claim that my plan to stand up to Ottawa with the Sovereignty Act is somehow meant to move Alberta toward leaving our beloved Canada.
02:40:41 That is a lie.
02:40:43 What Albertans want is for our province and all provinces to have our rights under the Constitution of Canada protected and respected by an increasingly hostile Ottawa regime that seeks to control every aspect of our lives.
02:40:59 From health care to education, to free speech, to delivery of our social programs,
02:41:07 they want to control it all, because that makes it easier for them to impose their agenda
02:41:12 on Albertans and on Canadians. That is not the way to unify a country or secure prosperity.
02:41:18 That is a road to division and economic ruin, which is why, in closing tonight, I want to speak
02:41:24 to our fellow Canadians. Albertans love Canada. It is our country, our home. All we want is to
02:41:32 live, grow, and prosper in the manner that we choose. We want to set our own course,
02:41:44 develop our resources and economy, and run our social programs and society as we think best.
02:41:50 We also want to share our prosperity with the entire country.
02:41:54 So tonight, I invite every Canadian to partner with us, partner with Alberta.
02:41:59 Let's work together to build a strong, prosperous, and unified Canada that we know that we can be.
02:42:10 A Canada where provinces work together and empower one another to reach our unique individual goals and aspirations.
02:42:17 A Canada that celebrates our great diversity of opinion and thought, rather than one that demonizes and sanctions one another for expression and speech deemed unacceptable by woke politicians in Ottawa.
02:42:32 A Canada that respects all of our citizens, regardless of their religious, cultural, or political beliefs.
02:42:38 Together, we can be the solution to the world's energy crisis and wrestle away the leverage
02:42:45 that thug dictators are using against an energy-starved Europe.
02:42:53 Together, we can be the energy superpower that provides billions of people in Africa
02:42:58 and in Asia with the clean LNG needed to replace their reliance on coal, wood, and other high
02:43:05 emission fuel sources, saving billions of tons of emissions and replacing them with billions
02:43:10 of dollars for our citizens and our economy and our social programs.
02:43:17 We can become the nation that develops the breakthrough technologies that make continued
02:43:22 fossil fuel use not only possible but preferable for fueling the energy needs of this generation
02:43:28 and the next. And we can feed the planet with our world-class food producers and technologies.
02:43:34 We can build the most innovative, entrepreneurial, and well-educated workforce in the developed world where students are taught to create and build and innovate rather than to conform, obey, and profess allegiance to failed and outdated ideologies.
02:43:49 Alberta wants to play a central role in building that Canada with you as an equal partner and I
02:43:59 invite you and those you elect to join us in building the most prosperous and free country
02:44:04 on earth. My friends, tomorrow I'm going to be meeting with our MLAs and we will discuss unity
02:44:15 and how to best meet the massive responsibility in front of us.
02:44:18 And like you, we will all be returning home to celebrate Thanksgiving,
02:44:22 to give thanks for our families and loved ones that for too long were kept apart,
02:44:28 to give thanks for our freedoms and the opportunities ahead,
02:44:31 and to give thanks for our great province, her wide open spaces, pristine landscapes, and amazing people.
02:44:38 And after Thanksgiving next Tuesday, I will travel to our capital city to be sworn in
02:44:43 as the next premier of Alberta.
02:44:52 And I can't wait to get started.
02:44:54 Thank you, and may God keep our land glorious and free.
02:45:13 That is Alberta's Premier-designate, Danielle Smith, now the leader of the United Conservative Party.
02:45:31 As she just said at the end there, as of Tuesday, she will be the Premier of Alberta,
02:45:36 getting sworn in at the Alberta Legislature in Edmonton on Tuesday,
02:45:40 although getting right to a business meeting with caucus tomorrow
02:45:43 And before I bring my colleague, William McBeth, back in, I want to just point out the, I guess, the breaking news that came out of this is that she has extended the hand to Todd Lowen, the expelled former UCP MLA and her competitor in this race and said, you know, come on back tomorrow morning.
02:46:00 And that's, I think, a very big step, not necessarily a surprising one, but I think a very important one.
02:46:04 Yeah, absolutely. I think if you listen to large sections of her speech, she went out of her way to talk about her fellow candidates and a lot of the work they had done. And that, of course, is very important when you're trying to put together a sometimes fractious group of MLAs and leadership candidates who didn't win, who won't be getting sworn in as premier on Tuesday.
02:46:25 So I definitely think she said a lot of very interesting things in her speech.
02:46:29 It's pretty clear what her key talking points are going to be, the freest, most prosperous place in the world.
02:46:37 But I would say you also heard her talk about a lot of things that maybe people wouldn't have assumed or associated with Daniel Smith.
02:46:44 Things like caring for the less fortunate, for our seniors, or people who are having trouble buying food or medication or paying for their heat.
02:46:52 So I think you will see a clear, gentler gang out on the domestic front, even as she maintains a fairly aggressive posture against Ottawa.
02:47:04 Yeah, I think that's a very reasonable analysis.
02:47:06 And I want to bring in Rachel Emanuel, our Alberta reporter, who's been doing some tremendous work on the ground in Calgary and gave you the leadership results even before the UCP feed did.
02:47:17 She's that quick.
02:47:17 She's like faster than the Internet, which is fantastic.
02:47:20 So although not saying much sometimes if you're a customer of some companies.
02:47:24 But in any case, Rachel, let's talk a little bit about your sense overall now.
02:47:30 Not a huge surprise in terms of the results.
02:47:34 In fact, even when you were talking to people from other campaigns, there seemed to be an understanding earlier on that this was headed towards a Danielle Smith victory.
02:47:41 But as someone who's been following her campaign in Alberta politics, when you heard her speech, what was your take on it?
02:47:48 Anything that you were surprised that she included in there or anything noteworthy that maybe you weren't surprised by, but you think it's something that people need to pay attention to?
02:47:57 You know, I think she came out really strong in her speech just now.
02:48:00 We heard a lot of the points that she's been making throughout the campaign.
02:48:02 And I think I noted in my coverage of it in my written article that she really started this crusade against, you know, COVID-19 and against some of the policies that we've seen regarding COVID-19.
02:48:12 She started that when she was on the radio during her sort of exodus from politics, if you will.
02:48:16 She was really pushing back on a lot of the government narrative on COVID-19.
02:48:20 You know, she interviewed Jason Kenney at some points and disagreed with some of his decisions, including decisions like to imprison pastors.
02:48:26 And we saw a lot of those early conversations that she had translate itself into the UCP leadership race, into her policy in the leadership race, and a lot of the policies that she put forward.
02:48:36 And, you know, I think that's, to her credit, one of the reasons she was able to set herself apart from the other candidates, because some of the candidates that were with Kendi when those decisions were made, you know, understandably probably didn't feel comfortable making those decisions because it would have looked rather silly given their record being in the Kendi government.
02:48:50 And I think now, during her final speech just now, we just saw a stronger version of that.
02:48:54 you know she came out and she reiterated a lot of the points that she made during the campaign and
02:48:59 you know she just was really solidified her promises to protect people's ability to put 0.95
02:49:03 what they want to in their bodies and again to fight back from ottawa she of course has positioned
02:49:08 herself as someone who will go toe-to-toe to ottawa if she won the premiership now she has
02:49:12 and she's made it very clear that that will be a number one priority for her from the get-go and
02:49:16 that's been evidenced by her promise to make the alberta sovereignty act to be her first piece of
02:49:21 legislation when she's in government so I thought we heard a lot of things here from her speech
02:49:25 today that she's been saying the last couple of weeks you know at many campaign events that I've
02:49:29 been to I see similar messaging from her since I started covering her campaign in the early days of
02:49:34 May. Before I ask you another question there Rachel Justin Trudeau has just tweeted I would
02:49:41 like to congratulate Danielle Smith on becoming the next Premier of Alberta let's work together
02:49:46 to build a better future for Albertans by delivering concrete results,
02:49:50 making life more affordable, creating good jobs, and more.
02:49:54 So we'll see if the pleasantries last to their first meeting. 0.96
02:49:58 One thing that has come up here is that she does not have a seat.
02:50:02 She is not an MLA.
02:50:03 She's the only candidate in the race who's not an MLA.
02:50:05 She was going to be running for a seat, although now that she's the leader,
02:50:10 she's signaled that she has a couple of MLAs that have offered to step down 0.82
02:50:14 so that she can run immediately in a by-election
02:50:16 and have several months in the legislature before the next election. 0.56
02:50:20 Do we know yet where she will be running?
02:50:22 She has not announced yet where she's going to be running,
02:50:25 but as you mentioned, some MLAs have offered to step down for her.
02:50:28 That being said, there are a few MLAs who have already stepped down
02:50:31 and their seats will become available,
02:50:32 so I think we're probably going to see Smith running in one of those ridings fairly soon.
02:50:37 So I don't think she's going to be waiting until General Electrum.
02:50:39 I think she wants to get into the legislature as soon as possible,
02:50:42 and I've heard some speculation about ridings that she's going to be running in,
02:50:45 but nothing confirmed yet.
02:50:46 So I won't give those reports, you know, quite yet,
02:50:48 but I can assure you that I will let the people know
02:50:51 as soon as I get them confirmed in the coming days.
02:50:53 Well, I know everyone is celebrating there,
02:50:55 so I don't want to take up too much more of your time.
02:50:58 Any closing thoughts for this evening, Rachel?
02:51:01 You know, I think it's been an interesting race.
02:51:03 I think Vitor's comments were sort of right on the mark
02:51:04 that at the end there, you know, it really could have been anyone's to take.
02:51:07 I don't think Danielle had the victory by such a wide margin
02:51:10 as I was maybe personally expecting based on some of the crowd sizes
02:51:14 that I've seen at campaign events per Smith
02:51:16 compared to some of the other campaign events that I see.
02:51:18 But, you know, the question has really been circulating as one of unity.
02:51:21 Will Danielle Smith be able to unify the caucus going forward?
02:51:24 And now that question is even more prominent
02:51:25 considering that it took her all the way to the final ballot to pull off that victory.
02:51:29 So I'm curious to see what's going to happen in the days to come.
02:51:31 I was looking forward to maybe a little bit of a rest.
02:51:33 It's been a long UCP leadership race since May.
02:51:35 I've been covering it for a long time.
02:51:37 But I suspect that there will be plenty more to cover in the days to come.
02:51:39 I don't think that rest is going to be coming anytime soon.
02:51:42 Well, I think you probably deserve a bit of a break as well,
02:51:45 but I'll let you get back to the festivities.
02:51:47 Fantastic work tonight. 0.90
02:51:48 Rachel Emanuel, Alberta reporter for True North.
02:51:50 Thank you and have a good night.
02:51:51 Thank you.
02:51:53 And just heading back to my colleague, William Macbeth,
02:51:57 here in these closing couple of moments.
02:51:59 William, just any thoughts that you have burning
02:52:02 that you'd like to share just before we say farewell?
02:52:04 well. I would say she's already sort of anticipated where she expects to be attacked. And I think she
02:52:12 expects those attacks to come pretty fast and furious over the coming weeks. She's talked about
02:52:18 how they're going to pull statements she's made out of context. They're going to find
02:52:21 old things she's written. Of course, she was an editorial writer for quite a while.
02:52:26 And a talk radio host. 0.99
02:52:28 And a talk radio host. She's espoused a lot of opinions. And whereas I don't think her 0.99
02:52:32 opponents really made use of a lot of that material, I don't expect the New Democrats
02:52:39 to pull their punches. So I think she's already telegraphing to Albertans, look, you're going to
02:52:44 hear some things that maybe don't rub you the right way, but we're not going to let it throw
02:52:49 us off our game. We're not going to give in to cancel culture. We're not going to apologize
02:52:53 every single time somebody makes an outrageous claim against me. So I think that'll be an
02:52:58 interesting thing to watch uh over the coming weeks yeah and i i will say not to belabor the
02:53:04 point but it is i think important to note here that she was a pariah when she when the whole
02:53:11 issue happened with the floor crossing she lost a nomination uh when she started in talk radio i
02:53:17 said earlier she she was really hated by a lot of people and and i liked how she approached that
02:53:23 was such humility in her speech. She thanked Brian Jean for building the party, for building
02:53:29 the Wild Rose Party in her absence, and then for becoming part of the solution and founding that
02:53:34 United Conservative Party. And she, I thought, very humbly said thank you to Albertans for giving her
02:53:40 a second chance. And I think that's very important because that really, of all the criticisms I heard
02:53:46 about her in this particular race, that was not one of them, that people honestly did seem to move
02:53:52 on from that? Yeah, I think you're absolutely right, which is truly remarkable. I mean, I
02:53:57 had worked for Danielle and left right before that floor crossing happened. It turned out to be...
02:54:04 Well, that's awfully convenient. Very good timing. But, you know, I had met with her a few days after
02:54:10 that had happened. And, you know, to me, I couldn't think of someone in politics who had
02:54:17 been more hated by her own party, by Albertans in general, and they felt very hurt and personally
02:54:23 betrayed by her actions. So the fact that she's recovered from that is really remarkable. It also
02:54:31 shows Albertans are forgiving, that we will let you recover back from a big mistake as long as
02:54:38 you say, I'm sorry, and I messed up. And I think, you know, Jason Kenney probably needed to take
02:54:44 that lesson a little bit more to heart. And we may not have had the citizenship race if he had said
02:54:49 a couple more times, I goofed or I made a mistake and I'm very sorry. Yeah, very much so. And again,
02:54:56 I know that this sometimes puts me offside with our audience, but I have had a number of very
02:55:02 cordial exchanges over the course of Jason Kenney's political career on the radio, off the radio, on
02:55:07 the podcast, off the podcast. And I think he has been a net positive figure for the conservative
02:55:14 movement. So I do humbly say thank you to Jason Kenney for your service. And obviously, it's a
02:55:20 period of transition. And Danielle Smith is the new UCP leader and as of Tuesday will be the
02:55:25 premier. But I can't get in on the complete obliteration of Jason Kenney's legacy, despite
02:55:36 my frustrations in the last couple of years. I always feel the need to clarify that because I
02:55:40 find often it becomes a bit too tribal on that. But we will certainly cover the race. I've known
02:55:46 Danielle for many years, but at True North, we will do the work that is needed and cover things
02:55:51 that matter to people on the right in a way that the mainstream media simply doesn't. We'll ask
02:55:56 them questions about things that actually matter, not about, you know, why aren't they quadrupling
02:56:00 or quadrupling the carbon tax or something, which I think is the first question that she'll get from
02:56:06 CBC at her inaugural press conference. But if you want to support the work we're doing at True North,
02:56:12 please do head over to donate.tnc.news. We are a national publication, but we pay attention to
02:56:20 Alberta, we pay attention to the West, and we pay attention to the moving and shaking of the
02:56:25 conservative world. And that includes covering the UCP, the CPC, the PPC, the Wild Rose Independence
02:56:31 party and and also justin trudeau we cover him a fair bit as well so uh fear not but we we don't
02:56:36 get the poutines which i think is important so uh donate.tnz.news is how you can contribute to that
02:56:42 and i want to give a big thank you to all of you for tuning into the show tonight and thank you
02:56:47 for your patience through the early tech glitches but we uh we got through those in the first few
02:56:52 moments thank you to rachel emmanuel and uh the team in calgary uh notably sean and also to uh
02:56:58 Those on the back end here, Harrison and Andrew and Noah, and of course, William, for your contributions today.
02:57:05 Thanks to everyone for all your help.
02:57:08 Have a great evening.
02:57:09 God bless you.
02:57:28 Thank you.
02:57:58 We'll be right back.
02:58:28 We'll be right back.