Juno News - April 21, 2022


US extends border ban on unvaccinated, so some Canadians are still trapped

Topics
Mentioned
What Trudeau's censorship legislation means for Canadian content creators Trudeau wants to tax your pickup truck

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

161.48

Word count

6,558

Sentence count

303

Harmful content

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A 28-year veteran of the Canadian Armed Forces, James Topp, has been marching from west to east across the country for the past 7 months. He's been on the road for most of that time, covering the length of the country, and he's doing it on foot.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 We'll be right back.
00:00:30 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:58 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:05 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:01:08 This is The Andrew Lawton Show here on True North.
00:01:10 You're tuned in live to Canada's most irreverent talk show.
00:01:14 It is April 21st, Thursday, and I think we're at about 3.01 p.m. Eastern time.
00:01:20 So traffic and weather will be coming up momentarily, just like my old radio days.
00:01:24 It's good to have you aboard what's going to be a bit of a packed program.
00:01:27 We'll be talking to Barry Cooper later on about Quebec wanting more representation despite a shrinking population.
00:01:36 Also going to be talking about the United States indefinitely extending its closure of its land border to unvaccinated foreign nationals,
00:01:44 including that means unvaccinated Canadians, which combined with the indefinite vaccine mandate for Canadian air travel
00:01:51 means people in this country who are unvaccinated are still effectively trapped in Canada. So we'll
00:01:58 talk about that later on. But I first want to do something we don't get the opportunity to do,
00:02:02 which is go to a live guest on the road as we speak at this exact moment. You may have seen
00:02:08 footage of this man, James Topp, a 28-year Canadian Armed Forces veteran who has been
00:02:14 marching west to east across this great country, starting in BC. I believe if we can put up the
00:02:19 map now i'm going to get his confirmation but you can track his journey at canadamarches.ca
00:02:24 and i i believe he's somewhere on the trans canada highway just west of balgonie saskatchewan and my
00:02:31 apologies to the people of balgonie if i've mispronounced that uh james top joins us now
00:02:36 literally from the road uh james good to be with you thanks very much for coming on today is they
00:02:40 am i correct on that you're on the trans canada highway in saskatchewan that's correct we're
00:02:45 actually east of Goni now, we're on our way to Capelle, Saskatchewan.
00:02:52 Okay, so you're making quite a bit of ground here,
00:02:54 because I took that screenshot, I think, about 15 minutes or so ago.
00:02:58 How much are you covering every day on this journey of yours?
00:03:02 Well, we were a little bit slower at the start because we were getting into our condition.
00:03:08 It was a conditioning phase physically.
00:03:11 And now we're up to about 50 kilometers a day.
00:03:14 uh but the terrain here is more conducive to that kind of thing and i know we've had a fair
00:03:25 bit of bad weather in the last few days certainly in ontario i know in alberta as well so it's not
00:03:30 necessarily the pleasant spring jaunt you might have anticipated but it looks like you've dressed
00:03:34 for it at least yeah yeah we had some interesting weather experiences on uh over the last couple of
00:03:40 days so so what is it you're doing why are you walking this isn't just about
00:03:45 fitness for you you're trying to make a point what is that point yeah well the
00:03:49 reasons why I'm marching so that's a distinction that needs to be made
00:03:53 because I'm marching with a purpose and a formed body of people and we're there
00:04:00 we're going to complete a mission and that mission is this is a there's two
00:04:04 things well actually several components of this mission so number one I
00:04:09 I transferred from the regular army to the reserves in 2019, so I basically went from
00:04:18 full-time army to part-time. That enabled me to pursue a career in the public service as a
00:04:28 civilian with the RCMP, where I had a great job working in Chililac, British Columbia.
00:04:35 then
00:04:37 we've lost James' audio there.
00:04:55 James, do we still have you?
00:04:58 Okay, we don't have your audio, James,
00:05:00 so we'll have to get that reconnected here.
00:05:03 My producer will work with you,
00:05:04 and we'll try to get that sorted out.
00:05:06 And once we get you back on, we will.
00:05:08 Because what I find fascinating about this
00:05:10 is that you see,
00:05:12 and I want to hear the end of that story here,
00:05:14 but just from other bits I've seen of James's story
00:05:16 and of what he's doing here,
00:05:18 the whole point of what we are seeing now
00:05:21 is ordinary citizens rising up.
00:05:23 And I don't mean that in a derisive way,
00:05:25 but people rising up
00:05:26 because they feel that the problems facing society,
00:05:29 facing them as individuals
00:05:30 are not being solved by government.
00:05:33 And this was a big part of the thrust behind the Freedom Convoy.
00:05:36 You had a lot of people who were, and we'll talk to James about this, were as individual
00:05:40 truckers, activists, social media people just saying, we've had enough.
00:05:45 And that was born of an appetite for someone to do something because the people that are
00:05:50 elected to solve these problems weren't doing it.
00:05:53 The people in the Conservative Party weren't opposing the government.
00:05:56 The people in the government were certainly putting more barriers on people rather than
00:06:00 taking them away.
00:06:01 And I think that's been the tremendously significant part that we're seeing in just basically this era in Canadian politics.
00:06:09 I think I see we have James again.
00:06:11 We'll try to get him back on, and hopefully the audio has been sorted out here.
00:06:15 James?
00:06:16 Yeah, can you hear me now?
00:06:17 All right, I can hear you now.
00:06:19 So when we lost you, you were telling us about what this mission is that you're on.
00:06:24 Yeah, so basically, I was placed on leave without pay for my public service job.
00:06:29 I'm still employed in the military as a reservist, and the mandates affected me because, personally, I have strong feelings about disclosing my medical status.
00:06:43 Number two, I don't feel that the government has the authority to tell me how to be healthy and what I need to do to be healthy.
00:06:52 So that was my issues with the mandates that affected federal government employees.
00:06:57 Because I pushed back on that, I refused to disclose my medical status.
00:07:07 I was placed on leave without pay back in November, and then I was informed by the military that it would be released on an item 5F.
00:07:15 So are you still hearing me?
00:07:16 Yep, I can hear you.
00:07:17 And what is that item 5F?
00:07:20 So an item 5F is an inability or unwillingness to change your behavior.
00:07:25 and my behavior was not complying with the chief defense staff direction on vaccination so
00:07:32 um that is a threat that has been hung over the heads of a number of canadian forces personnel
00:07:40 i don't think it's uh widely known in the public that this kind of coercion is going on so
00:07:45 basically the federal government you have comply or you lose your paycheck um what happened to me
00:07:54 personally was that uh it affected me deeply psychologically and i was kind of in a state
00:08:02 of despair i do receive a pension from my regular fourth service and um that paid my mortgage but i
00:08:12 need to supplement it i end up getting a job as a tow truck driver in hope bc where i live
00:08:18 and what ended up happening was i came to the uh i came to realize just how hard the canadian
00:08:24 public is working out there and it's the canadian public that is paying for the federal government
00:08:29 which was in turn paying my paycheck and it was what allowed me to pursue a career in the armed
00:08:35 forces for 28 years so uh i saw protests going on i saw a group of people coming together to voice
00:08:44 the same concerns i had i saw them in ottawa it inspired me and at the same time i was outraged
00:08:52 by their treatment and now we had a federal government that was not willing to listen to
00:08:57 its own population not even willing to entertain a dialogue of sorts so and when the people you're
00:09:06 referring to there you're talking about the convoy protest correct yeah that's right that's right
00:09:10 yeah now let me ask you then james because that convoy brought thousands of people to ottawa
00:09:16 truckers non-truckers vaccinated unvaccinated and even with that showing the government didn't
00:09:21 relent they didn't drop the vaccine mandate so with all due respect why do you think your march
00:09:26 which is a lot smaller it's you and a small group there not hundreds of trucks why do you think this
00:09:31 is going to be the thing that can make that difference because what I'm hearing now from a
00:09:37 lot of veterans uh they're supporting me on this and they have plans to meet me in Ottawa
00:09:41 so my this isn't just me marching to Ottawa to announce that you know I've arrived I'm not going
00:09:49 there to throw a tantrum or call people names. I'm going there with a purpose. And the purpose
00:09:54 is to reestablish communication with the federal government so that I can remind them who they
00:09:59 work for. Why is it going to make a difference? Because I have taken pages from the convoy
00:10:09 strategy and talked it over with some folks. How can we make a difference? So we're engaging
00:10:16 right now directly with members of parliament through letter writing and emails and we are
00:10:22 getting responses from them and we are asking them to come and meet with us when i arrive there
00:10:27 in uh in near the end of june yeah now obviously you don't know i mean you said earlier you're
00:10:34 doing about 50 kilometers a day there i'm assuming you're going to have good days and bad days so you
00:10:38 don't necessarily have a precise arrival time but you're expecting to be there by the end of june
00:10:43 i don't but i have what's called we back in the day in the military we have nlt or a no later
00:10:47 than date and i want to get there no later than june 30th so that means um whatever happens
00:10:53 between now and then um i have calculated that it's doable as long as i can achieve that
00:11:01 between 40 and 50 kilometers a day and then take appropriate rest days when necessary
00:11:06 so the thing is that gives the members of parliament now plenty of time
00:11:13 to try to mull over this and think about the optics of what it's going to look like
00:11:20 for them to ignore a veteran and a group of people who feel the same way including the
00:11:27 veterans that are going to arrive in ottawa to meet me what the optics of that ignoring
00:11:34 that type of peaceful protest are going to be?
00:11:37 The treatment of truckers was obviously the force and the spark
00:11:43 that galvanized the trucker convoy.
00:11:45 The veterans, I saw a lot of veterans that were out in Ottawa
00:11:48 and veterans that were supporting the convoy movement
00:11:51 because in my view, veterans are very similar.
00:11:55 And I'm not saying that the sacrifice that veterans have made is similar,
00:11:58 but the dynamic is similar to the essential workers dynamic
00:12:01 in that on one hand, you have people in government saying
00:12:03 these people are so great. We need to support them. We need to be grateful. And then on the
00:12:07 other hand, you have these punitive vaccine mandates that for active duty soldiers and
00:12:11 people like yourself, reservists that are just saying, you know what, all of the stuff you've
00:12:15 done doesn't matter if you're not going to disclose your medical status here. Would you say
00:12:20 that the support from veterans has been as strong as you'd like it to be? Or do you think there are
00:12:24 some people that are still saying, yeah, you know, we had to do, because again, the military has a
00:12:29 number of vaccine mandates that are required depending on duty the COVID vaccination is just
00:12:34 one more the government has said in defense of it. Sorry so the question is do I have the support
00:12:41 from the veterans community? Well the question is are you are you confident that you have a lot
00:12:46 of support from veterans or do you think that veterans are invited on? I am I am hearing from
00:12:51 them number one I only need the support of one veteran and that's my best friend that I'm going
00:12:58 hoping to be meeting near winnipeg to be honest but um i the veterans who i have to stop to
00:13:06 as part of um they are forming a new group called vets for freedom um and this is uh these are
00:13:15 folks who are directly involved in the protests earlier this year from the veteran community
00:13:20 and I'm hearing from the founders
00:13:27 and the board of directors from my organization.
00:13:32 I'm in contact with them.
00:13:35 They're in support of me
00:13:36 and I'm pretty confident that I'm going to get the support
00:13:44 from the veterans community that I need
00:13:47 because I think this is where we're at
00:13:50 in this country is it's going to take the veterans to stand up
00:13:54 to kind of show the rest of the country
00:13:58 how it's done.
00:14:01 Where are you staying along your journey?
00:14:06 Yeah, we are getting accommodations from folks
00:14:10 who open their homes to us or they arrange for us to stay in
00:14:14 like a town hall or a church basement
00:14:18 or they were putting their funds together to get us into a motel or something.
00:14:23 When this originally started, I had thought this was going to be a kind of a one-man show
00:14:30 and I would be able to self-finance.
00:14:34 But as there was obviously a need or a response for this kind of activity,
00:14:40 this has become a lot bigger than I had imagined with the group I have on the ground with me.
00:14:46 There's nine of us right now.
00:14:48 And then plus I have a bunch of online volunteers managing the website and social media.
00:14:54 So just to answer your question, that's where we're staying.
00:14:59 And it's been a demonstration of the generosity of Canadians.
00:15:04 And their support and encouragement has been the driving force in this
00:15:10 because I wouldn't have made it this far, this fast,
00:15:14 without the ability to be able to put my head down at night on a mattress yeah and is anyone
00:15:21 allowed to walk with you or do you have a pretty organized group oh no i get folks like weekdays i
00:15:29 get it you know folks are got they got jobs and they got commitments but during the weekends uh
00:15:35 interested people will show up like uh like in a soy is british columbia for example
00:15:45 uh i think we had about 20 or 30 people marching with me for about you know a good
00:15:52 20 kilometers and that's that's the kind of uh that you know folks who are interested you know
00:16:00 just showing up marching for a day for a few hours like I got Dennis here he's from the area
00:16:08 he's uh also volunteers and helps us with the management of our online activity so he's going
00:16:17 to be here for a couple hours just before we got online a dad a fellow named Ram and his dad
00:16:25 joined us for a couple of kilometers so anybody can join in as long as they realize that we're
00:16:32 moving pretty quick and they're both really dressed and they have some way of getting picked
00:16:37 up when they get tired out. Yeah try to do some laps around your city block first just to make
00:16:44 sure you can keep up with them. I'm even looking right now and impressed at how much even while
00:16:48 you do the interview you're moving along there. You can track James and learn lots more about his
00:16:53 journey at canadamarches.ca. I know you've still got a couple of months left on your way to Ottawa,
00:16:58 but I appreciate so much you doing this and taking some time with me today, James. Thanks
00:17:02 very much and best of luck. Thank you. All right. That was James Taub marching to Ottawa with a
00:17:08 very similar message to the message that the Freedom Convoy brought. And again, he's not
00:17:13 being explicitly political in that. He's talking about values that are supposed to be above
00:17:18 politics, things like freedom, things like patriotism. If you look on his website, he's
00:17:22 talking about the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. And as I mentioned at the beginning, and I'll talk
00:17:27 about very shortly in this show, as of today, there's still no end in sight for when unvaccinated
00:17:35 Canadians will be allowed to leave the country. The U.S. restriction on unvaccinated foreign
00:17:40 nationals has been extended indefinitely. Earlier this week, Justin Trudeau and the
00:17:45 Transport Minister Omar Al-Ghabra would not give a deadline at all for when unvaccinated Canadians
00:17:51 would be able to board planes again, which means even if there's another country that doesn't have
00:17:56 a vaccine mandate or testing requirements or whatever, a Canadian who's not vaccinated has
00:18:01 no way of getting there. And that's a big problem in a country with a charter of rights and freedoms
00:18:06 that guarantees the right to freely enter, remain in or leave Canada. But again, as we've talked
00:18:12 about on this show on a number of occasions. We simply don't have a basic and fundamental respect
00:18:18 for a lot of these core freedoms. So thanks to people like James for taking a stand. And we'll
00:18:22 talk more about the U.S. border restriction very shortly. But I want to pivot to an issue which,
00:18:27 again, some people may think is a bit inside baseball, but is very significant when we talk
00:18:31 about representation in this country. Because Quebec is right now facing a bit of a demographic
00:18:37 challenge. Its population is sagging. A big part of that has been because Quebec is basically
00:18:43 enacting policies that force a lot of English speakers out. They're restrictive towards
00:18:47 immigration and less people are coming with the French language as their mother tongue.
00:18:53 But even in spite of that, they want more representation in the House of Commons. So
00:18:58 less people, more influence, which in a population-based House of Commons makeup doesn't
00:19:02 seem to make sense there there was a great piece about this in the c2c journal cal surprise quebec
00:19:08 wants more seats in the house of commons that is it was written by university of calgary professor
00:19:14 barry cooper who joins me on the line now professor it's good to talk to you thanks very much for
00:19:19 coming on today you bet andrew so i mean the basics of democracy in this country fairly
00:19:25 representative in nature why is it that quebec thinks it has a justification for more representation
00:19:32 Well, this actually goes back to a period before Confederation.
00:19:39 It goes back to the period of the Act of Union in 1840.
00:19:44 And interestingly enough, although we never talk about this, this was basically a kind of mainstay
00:19:50 of British imperial domination of other people in the overseas empire.
00:19:58 then the argument was that there were two founding races as they call them uh french and english
00:20:07 which is ridiculous canada was not founded it was created by an act of the imperial legislature
00:20:13 uh the americans might have they can make a case for a founding because they had a revolution we
00:20:18 never did anything like that but the argument was essentially political that if you had a french
00:20:25 and a, let's say, non-French, since they weren't just English,
00:20:29 they were Irish and Scots and, you know, heaven knows what else,
00:20:33 as the founding peoples, then that had to be represented somehow.
00:20:40 It was certainly not a democratic idea, which was one person, one vote,
00:20:46 or what back in the 19th century they called it representation by population
00:20:49 or rep by pop.
00:20:51 And interestingly enough, in the early days, Quebec, or what was then Canada East,
00:20:58 had a larger population than Canada West, or was bigger than Upper Canada.
00:21:05 So they were quite happy with representation by population.
00:21:09 But in the decades prior to Confederation, what's now Ontario became more populous than Quebec.
00:21:16 And then suddenly we had to have this kind of ethnic equality.
00:21:22 And it's been there ever since.
00:21:23 It's something that seems to have obsessed Laurentian Canada from, as I said, before Confederation.
00:21:30 It's never made much sense in this part of the country.
00:21:34 But, you know, not much in this part of the country makes sense, I think, to Laurentians either.
00:21:39 So, you know, there we are.
00:21:41 Yeah.
00:21:41 I mean, well, going back before the Act of Union, you had Lord Durham's report and that famous line of two nations warring in the bosom of a single state.
00:21:49 And in a lot of ways, we haven't moved much beyond that, it feels.
00:21:53 Well, certainly not in your part of the world.
00:21:55 That's for sure.
00:21:56 Otherwise, you know, these these kinds of statements and if you actually look at some of the some of the remarks that I quoted in that C2C piece, it's for normal Democratic Canadians.
00:22:11 I would say it's incredibly offensive.
00:22:15 What these Quebec politicians are saying,
00:22:18 we are really, really special,
00:22:20 and we don't want to give up one little bit of power.
00:22:25 And it was all about power.
00:22:26 It was really clear from when they were criticized
00:22:29 about what about the democracy, what about Repai Pop?
00:22:33 They said it has nothing to do with that.
00:22:35 It has to do with the percentage that we have now
00:22:38 as a founding people in this country.
00:22:41 none of which makes sense to, at least not to Westerners.
00:22:46 Yeah, and I think the important takeaway from that
00:22:49 is that Quebec doesn't view itself as one province of 10.
00:22:53 And every other province would see,
00:22:55 even if there are some regional blocks like Atlantic Canada,
00:22:57 like the prairies, every other province sees it itself
00:23:00 as being one province in 10, whereas Quebec doesn't.
00:23:04 And I think that's a key part of the problem here.
00:23:07 Yeah, no, absolutely it is.
00:23:08 uh i mean this is uh this is why um well a few years ago dave bergerson and i wrote this book
00:23:14 deconfederation canada without quebec and it it was it was pretty clear what the argument i mean
00:23:21 it's in the subtitle of the book uh we ended it with a nice french phrase bon voyage and bon chance
00:23:28 and it was not received well in Quebec, particularly by Francophone Quebecers. 0.86
00:23:42 They could not believe that these two rednecks from Alberta said, 0.95
00:23:47 you know, buy. Do what you wish. Just don't involve us in your undemocratic special 1.00
00:23:56 status requirements because we're not interested. Let's talk about the political response to this
00:24:03 here. And I want to make sure I'm getting the facts right here. But the Bloc Quebecois put
00:24:06 forward the motion to reject, quote, any scenario for redrawing the federal electoral map that would
00:24:13 result in Quebec losing one or more electoral districts or that would reduce Quebec's political
00:24:18 weight in the House of Commons. So even if everyone else went up and Quebec stayed the same,
00:24:23 they would object to that because of the relative proportion. But what's astonishing is that the
00:24:29 Bloc, the NDP and the Greens all voted unanimously for this, as did the Liberals. And a lot of
00:24:35 Conservatives, though, also voted for it. Yeah, it's and that's where I think it was it was chiefly
00:24:41 a regional division. There were some Western conservatives who voted for it, and they were
00:24:47 people, so far as I could tell anyway, who thinks that the kind of Laurentian focus of
00:24:55 the Conservative Party should be the most important part. Most of the dissenting votes in the
00:25:03 conservative party were from the west uh and it's it was a kind of instinctive um response you know
00:25:11 there goes quebec again you know they just want more stuff and uh uh you know quite frankly i
00:25:18 think a lot of westerners are kind of fed up with that so explain to me where this goes from here
00:25:25 because i i think there's this general fear that a lot of people have of of a revival of quebec
00:25:30 separation or separatism and Quebec secessionism. And I think there's probably an increasing number
00:25:36 of people in the left that would say, as you say, bon voyage, just, you know, okay, get on with it
00:25:40 already. But no one wants a country that's significantly divided if that division is
00:25:45 coming from Quebec. I think Western alienation is probably attracting a lot less sympathy from
00:25:49 the Laurentian elites. But where do you think this goes if Quebec doesn't get its way? Or do you
00:25:54 think that it's a given that will? Well, they've already got their way. They've got, this is going
00:26:00 be the law. I suppose the question is what the next conservative leader does about this,
00:26:11 particularly if the conservatives form the next government. That will be very interesting to see.
00:26:17 I suspect since in order to object to it in principle, you have to be willing to face down
00:26:25 or face up to uh the implications with respect to the independence of quebec or eventually
00:26:31 you might even say the independence of albert and saskatchewan you know it's it's it's a very
00:26:36 divisive uh matter of principle uh and it's it's one that is i don't think it's going to go away
00:26:43 uh it'll be papered over for a while but you know after a while even the paper gets a bit
00:26:48 thin and you can see through it what strikes me too barry is that it's self-reinforcing because
00:26:55 you have the conservative party notably which always has these delusions of a restoration of
00:27:00 some significant quebec coalition which it never manages to materialize but the more seats you have
00:27:06 in quebec the higher the stakes are of not kissing the ring of quebec politics and quebec politicians
00:27:14 and and that is again just very cyclical in nature yeah it's it's it's really quite interesting and
00:27:20 I would say that this follows directly upon the various Laurentian myths that I've written about
00:27:28 elsewhere, that how this is the center of the country. And as Sir John A. himself said,
00:27:37 the Northwest and Rupert's land are, quote, our crown colony. That attitude has not gone away
00:27:43 in the 150 odd years since confederation uh and it's particularly a problem uh when western
00:27:52 canada has not only an increased population but a much greater uh wealth and resources
00:27:59 than it ever had ever had in the past even though it was certainly the source of a lot
00:28:03 of wealth for canada through grain and before that through the fur trade
00:28:08 i i don't know if you you've delved into this in any substantive way but but what are what
00:28:12 are the internal migrations that we're seeing in this country? Because I know in the US there's
00:28:16 been a lot, especially in the last few years, of people fleeing New York and California for lower
00:28:21 tax and ultimately more conservative jurisdictions like Texas and Florida. Do we see it as starkly
00:28:28 in Canada and for the same reasons? Well, we did before the Liberal Party made its, so far,
00:28:36 fairly successful attack on the resource economy of particularly this province, but also Saskatchewan.
00:28:41 And then COVID messed things up, too. But there was an enormous amount of in-migration to Saskatchewan and Alberta, not just from Ontario, but also from the Atlantic Canada.
00:28:56 I mean, for a while, they were saying that Fort Mac was the largest Newfoundland population in the world because there were so many Newfoundlanders who were working there.
00:29:08 So I'm not sure that that's true anymore since the oil sands have had an awful lot of damage done to them in the past couple of years.
00:29:18 So and demography, I mean, Quebec is just not seeing the growth.
00:29:23 And we've talked about, you know, well, we've talked about immigration, birth rates, another factor.
00:29:27 So they are facing, I wouldn't say it's a demographic crisis, but they are facing a challenge that's not really with an immediate solution.
00:29:34 So just holding on to their political influence is, I guess, the counterbalance against that.
00:29:40 Yeah, that seems to be the kind of default position.
00:29:44 When you are losing on a regular playing field, then you play the political card.
00:29:50 It's certainly true that Quebec is under a lot of stress demographically,
00:29:56 partly because of their, let's say, not exactly hostile,
00:30:01 but not entirely welcoming uh position with respect to immigrants uh and the the effective
00:30:07 of quebec nationalism uh it always has the the consequence of of driving fairly productive
00:30:14 members of that province uh to uh let's say happier happier places well it was a fascinating
00:30:22 read in the c2c journal kel surprise quebec wants more seats in the house of commons that
00:30:27 is and i i've said it many times barry i'll say it again i think more columns need to cite the
00:30:31 1840 Act of Union. You didn't slip Lord Durham's report in there, but I made sure to for the
00:30:36 interview here. Thanks very much for coming on. You bet, Andrew. All right. Professor Barry Cooper
00:30:41 from the University of Calgary. No, it was a fascinating piece. And again, we talk about
00:30:46 separation and separatism as being these big things that Quebec used to use as the Trump card.
00:30:54 And understandably so. No one wants to see the country just completely ripped up. But again,
00:30:58 the capitulation only seems to go towards Quebec when you have Albertans that are raising quite 0.96
00:31:04 significant grievances and everyone's like oh yeah they're just a bunch of angry rednecks oh yeah we 0.98
00:31:08 don't need to care about them and I say Albertans more broadly it's the west I mean Saskatchewan 1.00
00:31:13 most of BC we often think of BC as being Vancouver and Victoria but the bulk of British Columbia as
00:31:20 far as land goes and even a lot of the population is not in that which is why if you look at a map
00:31:26 of BC politically. Conservatives do quite well there, just not in, you know, the lower mainland
00:31:31 and on Vancouver Island and so on. But some parts they do. We'll talk about this more. And I'm
00:31:38 actually headed out, as I'll share a little bit more about at the end of the show, to Calgary,
00:31:43 just, I mean, like in about an hour, actually, I'm leaving. So I got to race off the race off
00:31:47 camera pack and then go. But before I do, I went along with James and then I had Barry lined up.
00:31:52 So I didn't get a chance to talk about this as much earlier. But what's happened today,
00:31:56 There was a bit of hope, I think, this morning when people saw that the United States' ban on unvaccinated foreign nationals entering through its land border was set to expire today at 11.59 p.m.
00:32:10 So folks were looking and being like, wow, is an unvaccinated Canadian finally going to be allowed to cross the U.S. border legally by land as of tonight at midnight?
00:32:20 And that means you could essentially have access to the world because the U.S. doesn't have a vaccine mandate for air travel.
00:32:27 So if you were a Canadian who's not vaccinated, you could drive across the Windsor-Detroit border, head on over to Detroit-Wayne County Airport, hop on a Delta plane, and you'd be in Amsterdam before you know it and you'd have the whole world at your fingertips.
00:32:41 But of course, that did not last. The U.S. sent out a fact sheet today through the Department of Homeland Security, which you can see on your screen there.
00:32:50 As of Thursday, April 21st, DHS will extend COVID-related land border entry requirements.
00:32:57 Non-U.S. travelers seeking to enter the United States via land ports of entry and ferry terminals are required to be fully vaccinated and provide proof of vaccination upon request.
00:33:08 This applies to non-U.S. travelers who are traveling for essential or non-essential reasons.
00:33:14 So there's that old trucker mandate.
00:33:16 Doesn't matter if you're a nurse, a doctor, if you have a visa that puts you in a category of essential worker,
00:33:22 if you're there because you want to go visit grandma.
00:33:24 It doesn't matter if you are not vaccinated.
00:33:26 You cannot cross into the United States.
00:33:29 Now, I will say that I know of Canadians who have gone into the U.S. who are unvaccinated because it hasn't been asked or they haven't checked.
00:33:36 So I'm not saying you can't do it, but technically the law as it stands says you cannot.
00:33:42 Now, I will say I'm a big believer in countries having the right to set their own immigration
00:33:48 policies.
00:33:48 I do not have a right to say that the U.S. is wrong.
00:33:52 Well, I do have the right to say that the U.S. is wrong, but I as a Canadian do not
00:33:55 have the right to demand entry into another country.
00:33:59 I have to respect those countries' rules.
00:34:01 I can criticize my own country, which I do quite a bit.
00:34:04 because Canada's immigration policies, Canada's border restrictions on unvaccinated people,
00:34:10 I think quite significantly are the cause of these U.S. policies. Remember, the U.S. closed
00:34:15 its border in response to Canada closing its border. And even then, you could always fly
00:34:21 into the U.S. Even when the Canada-U.S. land border was closed for, what was it, a year and a half,
00:34:26 you could get on a plane if you were a Canadian and fly to Florida if you wanted. And in doing so,
00:34:32 Canadians actually had more rights to enter the United States than the reverse because no American
00:34:38 tourist could fly into Canada when the border was closed. And it wasn't until August of last year
00:34:44 that it only opened to vaccinated people. So right now, if you're an American, you still can't go into
00:34:49 Canada as a tourist or an essential worker unless you are vaccinated. So all of these U.S. policies,
00:34:56 I think are responses to, are retaliations to Canadian policy. And we know that the Trudeau
00:35:03 government and the Biden government have been very tight on a lot of these things, like the
00:35:07 trucker mandate. But even if I don't have a trump card and I don't have the right to say to the U.S.
00:35:13 that you have to change your policies because I, as a Canadian, think you must, I will point out
00:35:18 that this means Canadians who are unvaccinated are still trapped in their country. If you are 0.89
00:35:25 an unvaccinated Canadian, you cannot drive into the US legally, technically. If you are an 1.00
00:35:31 unvaccinated Canadian, you cannot get on a plane in this country. You cannot take a commercial 0.99
00:35:37 ferry to go somewhere. You could technically canoe across the Atlantic. You could technically canoe
00:35:43 across the Pacific. If you really, really wanted to, you could probably swim and make it to Japan
00:35:49 sometime around when James Topp is going to end up in Ottawa. So technically you could say,
00:35:55 well, no, no, no, there's nothing technically stopping you from leaving. Well, when government
00:35:59 closes off your means of travel, let's not talk about swimming across the Atlantic and the Pacific
00:36:06 as being viable options here. So Canadians, despite a constitutional right to enter, 0.91
00:36:11 remain in, or leave Canada, are not allowed to leave Canada. And let alone, by the way,
00:36:17 travel internally. You can't very easily go from St. John's, Newfoundland, to, oh, I don't know,
00:36:24 to Vancouver, to Victoria. You could do it. It's going to be tough. You could do it though.
00:36:29 But it's not practical. Maybe, maybe the best way to go is to take a ferry to St. John's. Then you
00:36:36 can canoe from St. John's to St. Pierre and Michelin. And maybe you can take an Air France
00:36:40 flight from St. Pierre to Charles de Gaulle. And that's your way out of the country. But again,
00:36:45 this is facetious because the whole point is the Canadian government
00:36:48 is restricting mobility rights internally and externally for Canadians. And there's no end
00:36:54 in sight for this. We talked about this a little bit on Tuesday's show. And that day, Justin Trudeau
00:36:59 and Omar Al-Ghabra came and said, well, we're going to continue listening to the science. Well,
00:37:04 the science. How is your science different than every other country's science? How is your science
00:37:10 saying that we need to keep denying people the right to move when every other country is not
00:37:16 just reducing restrictions, but eliminating, obliterating them? Uber Canada, I think this
00:37:23 week said that masks are no longer going to be mandatory in Canadian Ubers. But, you know,
00:37:27 you get on a Canadian plane and the mask is there. So is Uber using shoddy science?
00:37:32 Are all the provinces that are lifting vaccine mandates, are they using the wrong science?
00:37:38 The most lockdown happy provinces, places like Ontario and British Columbia,
00:37:42 they're getting rid of their vaccine passports. They're getting rid of their mask mandates. 0.98
00:37:46 Why is their science different than Teresa Tams and Justin Trudeau's and Omar Al-Ghabra?
00:37:51 show us this science. Show us this mythical, mystical science, which is about as real as
00:37:58 Quebec's claim to deserve more seats in the House of Commons. It doesn't exist.
00:38:03 It's the politics of fear, but it's beyond that because I don't even think that Justin Trudeau
00:38:08 thinks COVID is a threat. I don't think Justin Trudeau thinks that COVID is an issue. I think
00:38:14 he actually just despises the unvaccinated. He just despises and holds in such contempt people
00:38:21 who are not vaccinated. It's not about the science. If it ever was on a lot of these
00:38:27 restrictions, which is a big if, it certainly isn't now. It is about punitive measures. He
00:38:33 doesn't want to give a single win to the people that made him look like an absolute fool when 0.98
00:38:40 they camped out on Wellington Street in downtown Ottawa for three weeks. He doesn't want to give 0.94
00:38:44 an inch to these people that prove just how poor a leader he really is. Because if he does, if he
00:38:52 gives an inch to these people, it's going to prove that they were right. When the unvaccinated are 1.00
00:38:59 either A, just getting out of this country in droves, or B, boarding planes that then have 1.00
00:39:04 no subsequent issues, no uptick in cases, no uptick in hospitalizations, it will prove that
00:39:09 the government was wrong and they can't have that. We've got to end things there. I'm going to be out
00:39:15 in Alberta this weekend at the Freedom Talk. I'll be speaking on covering the convoy. So a lot of
00:39:21 the themes we've talked about on the show, but I'll try to put it into a neat little speech form
00:39:25 and give some new material there. You can get information on that at freedomtalk.ca. And if
00:39:30 you are in there in person, do come out and say hello. We'll talk to you soon. Tomorrow, we've got
00:39:35 a one-on-one interview with conservative leadership candidate Scott Acheson and lots
00:39:39 more of The Andrew Lawton Show next week here on True North. Thank you, God bless, and good day to
00:39:44 you all. For listening to The Andrew Lawton Show, support the program by donating to True North
00:39:51 at www.tnc.news.
00:40:05 Thank you.
00:40:35 Bye.