Juno News - August 24, 2019


Where are the ethics on the ethics committee?

Hosted by
Mentioned
Grown man files human rights claim after not getting babysitting job Liberals are growing bolder with their ethics violations

Episode Stats


Length

5 minutes

Words per minute

173.7

Word count

883

Sentence count

48

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Ethics Committee blocked a motion that would have allowed the Ethics Commissioner, Mario Dion, to take the stand to speak about his damning report on the Trudeau administration's handling of the SNC-Lavalin bribery investigation.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 The House of Commons Ethics Committee clearly needs a new name. This committee, after all,
00:00:15 with its Liberal majority decided to band together to block a motion that would allow
00:00:20 Mario Dion, Canada's Ethics Commissioner, to testify. The reason, of course, is that the
00:00:25 Liberals didn't want Dion to take the stand because they probably didn't want to hear what
00:00:29 he had to say about that 63-page report he tabled last week that found Justin Trudeau
00:00:35 violated Canada's federal ethics law when he put and his office put pressure on
00:00:40 Jody Wilson-Raybould, at the time the Attorney General in Canada, to interfere
00:00:45 in the supposedly independent prosecution of SNC-Lavalin. Now, this report was
00:00:51 damning. It had a number of allegations. We know that the government was trying to
00:00:54 block several witnesses from being able to testify, which is why Justin Trudeau
00:00:59 and the Privy Council Office didn't expand cabinet confidence waivers and the
00:01:04 Ethics Commissioner said he was up against a wall in this respect of his
00:01:08 investigation. But instead of being able to answer questions, talk about what he
00:01:14 found, talk about the process, Dion has not been invited. He was willing, he was able, he
00:01:19 was eager to make that date with the Ethics Committee. But no, no, no, the Liberals on
00:01:24 the committee, with one exception, Nathaniel Erskine-Smith, decided they were not going
00:01:29 to allow it to happen. Now, if this all sounds familiar, I'm not recycling an old
00:01:33 video here. The Liberals have done this with the Justice Committee when Jody
00:01:36 Wilson-Raybould herself wanted to make a second visit to the committee to testify.
00:01:41 The MPs, again, Liberals said, ah, we've heard enough. We don't need to have her back.
00:01:45 And now with Dion, they're not even giving him a single opportunity to speak. Now, to be
00:01:51 fair, he has had the opportunity to put forward his results. He's tabled the report.
00:01:56 They can't block that. But you'd think that a report finding the Prime Minister of Canada
00:02:01 has violated federal law might be worthy of a few questions. This is not a radical concept.
00:02:07 In fact, it's entirely routine for an officer of Parliament, as Dion is, to speak to parliamentarians
00:02:14 after tabling a report, especially one as significant as this. But again, ethics have
00:02:20 no place on the Ethics Committee. The government is more interested in protecting Justin Trudeau's
00:02:25 political ambitions than actually investigating the law-breaking that has now been found by
00:02:32 Trudeau. Canadians deserve better than this. The process has been abused to protect the 0.90
00:02:37 Prime Minister, which means political interests have trumped the rule of law. And that was the
00:02:42 whole point of the SNC interference, is that, again, the rule of law, the prosecution of SNC-Lavalin,
00:02:48 was less significant than the liberal ambitions, which were also SNC-Lavalin's ambitions, of
00:02:54 protecting jobs, allegedly, a political purpose. Let's be real. But this is why it's so important
00:03:00 that Dion had had the opportunity to testify. There are still, even after that report was
00:03:06 tabled, unanswered questions. Like, what was he trying to figure out when he saw that he was unable to
00:03:12 interview and get documents and evidence from those nine witnesses? What is it that Trudeau said
00:03:17 as far as the justification for why he wouldn't allow those nine witnesses to testify? What is it
00:03:23 that Jody Wilson-Raybould had to say that, again, might have been protected by Cabinet confidence
00:03:28 had that been waived? If this was an exhaustive investigation that picked up every rock, looked
00:03:34 in every nook and cranny, then sure, maybe we could say that he has said his piece and we have all the
00:03:39 facts. But we don't. And the report itself acknowledges this. It says quite clearly that
00:03:45 there was more information that Dion would have liked to have brought to light, but he just couldn't.
00:03:50 And again, that should, to any respectful politician, be an indication that, hey, we have more questions
00:03:57 that we need to ask. But what the liberals on the committee have done, in some respects, may backfire.
00:04:03 Because they've now said they have no questions about the report. They have nothing to challenge,
00:04:08 nothing to question, no holes that they can poke in it. Which means that by the liberals saying they
00:04:12 don't want to talk to Dion, there is, in some respects, a tacit endorsement or approval of the
00:04:18 report. After all, if they disputed it, if they wanted to take issue with it, maybe, just maybe,
00:04:24 they would want to have some opportunities to question the person who wrote that report.
00:04:29 So if I were the conservatives or anyone trying to oppose the liberals right now,
00:04:33 that would be the argument I'd put forward. Well, if the liberals don't want to ask Dion any
00:04:38 questions, clearly they take at face value what it is that he has to say about Trudeau,
00:04:43 which is that he broke the law and behaved unethically. And the report shows that very
00:04:48 clearly. We are still asking the questions at True North, one of the reasons that we're crowdfunding
00:04:54 our election coverage. If you can chip in a few dollars and get a tax receipt, please do.
00:04:59 There's a link in the description box to support True North's election coverage fund.
00:05:03 For True North, I'm Andrew Lutton.