Juno News - January 11, 2024


WHO's planned pandemic treaty threatens sovereignty and free speech

Topics
Mentioned
Journalist arrested while questioning Chrystia Freeland (ft. David Menzies) Rebel News suing Chrystia Freeland over reporter’s arrest (ft. Ezra Levant)

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

159.47

Word count

7,370

Sentence count

339

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

We're taking The Lawton Show on the road next week, but not to Davos, where we'll be covering the World Economic Forum, but in Austria, where you can't rent an Airbnb for $10,000 a night.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all canada's most irreverent talk show here on true north
00:01:30 the andrew lawton show on this thursday january 11th this is our last program for a week in the
00:01:38 lovely dominion of canada next week as you may have heard we are taking the show on the road
00:01:43 we'll be doing it live from sw actually i should probably tell you we are not going to be doing
00:01:49 the show from Switzerland, we are going to be, this is a funny story in a way, we're going to
00:01:54 be doing the show from Austria because we could not afford an Airbnb in Switzerland. This is like
00:02:00 how dedicated we are to bringing you coverage from Davos. So in the past, you've heard me lament what
00:02:06 happens here. The problem is that the World Economic Forum snatches up every hotel in Davos
00:02:12 in the neighboring town of Closters. And there are a smattering, I don't know what the quantitative
00:02:17 value is of a smattering, but I think smattering fits here. There are a smattering of Airbnbs.
00:02:23 And as you find, you have a couple of options. There is like some giant chalet that goes for
00:02:29 $10,000 a night, or there is like a stained mattress that's shoved in some creepy mountain
00:02:36 man's closet, which is like oddly also $10,000 a night. So there's like a going rate for these
00:02:41 things. But Sean and I didn't want to like bunk up with the mountain man in his closet. So last
00:02:47 time when we went, we found an Airbnb because we booked very early. I was literally at my computer
00:02:52 the day they announced the dates for Davos and was able to book an Airbnb at not a terrible price.
00:03:00 That Airbnb long gone this time around. This time, I think I hesitated like five minutes to book
00:03:07 and we could not find a place. Even places we were finding that on Airbnb were saying they
00:03:13 were available, we would go and do the booking and then be like, ah, no, sorry. We are reserving
00:03:18 this for the WEF. And I was like, well, I'm going to WEF, but they're like, no, no, no. The World
00:03:22 Economic Forum will tell us. We don't want you schlubs here. They'll tell us who they want to 1.00
00:03:26 put up there. So it ended up being where we were going to have to spend like some obscene amount,
00:03:32 like tens of thousands of dollars for five nights, or we could get very affordable accommodations,
00:03:39 accommodations. Not the next town over, not the next county over, but the next country over. So
00:03:44 we will be driving in and out on those lovely mountain roads in January every day. So we may
00:03:50 need to do a crowdfunding campaign to like just fish the car out of the bottom of the Swiss or
00:03:55 Austrian Alps from Lake Zurich to bring back home. But hopefully it won't come to that.
00:04:01 We will be very careful and cautious, but that's how dedicated we are to getting there and getting
00:04:07 the story so at least it should be a rather beautiful commute but this is all a long way
00:04:11 of saying next week we're doing the show in a different location and we're going to be doing
00:04:15 it in a different time as well so I believe we settled on 3 p.m eastern 1 p.m mountain time so
00:04:21 two hours later than normal just to give us time to you know drive to Austria which is a strange
00:04:27 sentence and get all situated after covering what's been happening in Davos during the day
00:04:33 But Davos is just one of many global summits where people come together and decide to put their agendas forward for the world.
00:04:41 There is also the World Health Organization.
00:04:44 Now, the WHO is a body that prior to three years ago, it was a much simpler, I guess four years ago now, it was a much simpler time.
00:04:53 We didn't really know of it.
00:04:54 If it popped up on our radar at all, it would be because every now and then they put out some press release about malaria or Ebola and they kind of keep their nose clean.
00:05:02 But then COVID came along. And just as the COVID pandemic empowered a wave of public health officials in this country who had only ever had meaning and purpose from distributing condoms to high school students found all of a sudden they had tremendous power and they effectively became the de facto heads of government in places across the country.
00:05:24 And now we have on a global scale, a World Health Organization that has had a similarly emboldened sense of self in the last four years, which is a bit of a wind up to what's happening in May when countries from around the world will descend on Geneva, Switzerland.
00:05:41 All world domination tends to start and end in Switzerland for some reason, but they'll descend on Switzerland, on Geneva, and they will put forward what they hope to become a pandemic treaty, a pandemic treaty.
00:05:53 Now, a treaty implies an agreement between states. This is what they hope to accomplish. So as of right now, it's a draft treaty. It's a proposed treaty. It's a proposed agreement. But if you look at what they have proposed, there are things that people should be very concerned about.
00:06:09 They talk about making the World Health Organization the body that sits at the helm and declares a public health emergency, which you may think, OK, what's the big deal?
00:06:19 Well, this also means that countries who sign on to this are saying they undertake to follow the WHO's recommendations.
00:06:26 If the WHO says shut down your border, countries are essentially committing to doing that.
00:06:32 If the WHO says, hang on, you need to mandate vaccination, countries are committing to doing that.
00:06:37 Now, any international relations expert will say, well, hang on, no, these agreements don't force countries to do anything. They're not binding. But at the same time, we are foolish to turn away and turn a blind eye to countries saying they want to do this and willingly saying they are going to do this.
00:06:55 What else does the draft agreement say? That countries will commit to censoring what they call disinformation misinformation. And this is something that we're all supposed to shrug our shoulders at. Now, when people like Lesley Lewis, who's a Conservative Member of Parliament, have spoken out about this, the media and the Liberals will just dismiss them as conspiracy theorists. Here's one exchange in the House of Commons where Justin Trudeau faces some questioning about this.
00:07:22 Mr. Speaker, May 22 to May 28, representatives from 194 countries will meet in Geneva at the World Health Assembly to discuss the WHO Global Pandemic Treaty and to vote on amendments to the international health regulations.
00:07:45 Why didn't this Prime Minister establish a public health inquiry into our COVID response
00:07:52 before considering signing amendments to the international health regulations?
00:07:59 The Right Honourable Prime Minister.
00:08:02 Mr. Speaker, as an active member of the WHO, Canada has always been there to push for better science,
00:08:08 to push for better impacts in the way we collaborate around the world.
00:08:13 Canada is a leading voice on ensuring not only that we make it through this pandemic,
00:08:17 which is continuing to be ongoing, but also that we prepare for future pandemics,
00:08:23 which unfortunately may well be the reality for decades and generations to come.
00:08:27 We will continue to be active, strong participants in international for around health,
00:08:33 while always respecting and protecting Canada's sovereignty and choices to make the right decisions for its own citizens.
00:08:40 that was a load of nothing it was a bit of a word salad perhaps there might even be listeria there
00:08:48 in that word salad and we can call it a public health emergency and trigger a shutdown of 0.91
00:08:53 speeches like that in the years to come why has there not been a public health inquiry maybe it's
00:08:58 because Justin Trudeau does not want an admission from Canadian officials under oath that there was
00:09:04 no scientific basis for much of what happened take for example this story in the New York Post
00:09:10 where Anthony Fauci, who was the Teresa Tam of the United States,
00:09:15 Anthony Fauci was testifying before the House Select Subcommittee on the coronavirus pandemic
00:09:20 that the Six Feet Apart recommendation, social distancing,
00:09:25 it was all the rage a few years back, was, quote,
00:09:28 likely not based on scientific data.
00:09:32 So, you know, those stickers, you still see them on grocery store floors every now and then.
00:09:36 It's a bit of an artifact of a bygone era.
00:09:38 But all of that, we had to orient our lives around it. Restaurants had to pull tables out because of it. And it was, oh, well, likely not based on scientific data, Anthony Fauci is admitting. And again, I don't think Justin Trudeau wants Teresa Tam to make those same admissions in Canada about social distancing, vaccine mandates, border closures, shutdowns, and so on.
00:09:58 Sean says someone should open a COVID-themed restaurant like 10 years from now.
00:10:04 Well, actually, I have opened a COVID-themed restaurant because it's no restaurant at all.
00:10:08 The restaurant's all closed during COVID.
00:10:10 So there you go.
00:10:11 A COVID-themed restaurant is just no food takeout only.
00:10:15 That's the COVID-themed restaurant.
00:10:17 But you could probably have some fun with it.
00:10:18 I think in Las Vegas, there's that Heart Attack Diner or Heart Attack Grill.
00:10:22 So yeah, I'm sure you could do that.
00:10:24 We could come up with in the comments your best menu items for the COVID.
00:10:28 I would say Fat in the Curve would be the name of the COVID restaurant,
00:10:33 if I just think of the first one that comes to mind there.
00:10:35 But nevertheless, we'll get to COVID nostalgia in time to come, I am certain.
00:10:41 Let's talk about this World Health Organization business here.
00:10:44 Bruce Pardee had a great piece in the National Post about this,
00:10:48 where he talks about why I think people in Canada and around the world should be very concerned.
00:10:52 He is a law professor at Queen's University and the executive director of Rights Probe,
00:10:57 And it is always good to see him.
00:10:59 Bruce, welcome back.
00:11:00 Thanks for coming on today.
00:11:02 Hello, Andrew.
00:11:02 Thanks for having me.
00:11:03 Good to see you.
00:11:04 So, I mean, there's always this battle whenever we see these international agreements where
00:11:09 anytime someone raises alarm bells, as you rightly have, you get people saying, oh, it's
00:11:13 non-binding.
00:11:14 What's the big deal?
00:11:15 Don't worry about it.
00:11:16 And I say, well, if it's so insignificant, why bother doing it at all?
00:11:20 But why is it you find this one to be of particular concern?
00:11:24 Well, this is part of the plan for the next time around, yes? So I think it goes like this.
00:11:33 The WHO takes responsibility for driving the boat. They get authority to declare when a public health emergency happens, and they get to make recommendations that will be binding.
00:11:47 And the countries will promise to put the binding recommendations into place in their own countries.
00:11:53 Now, as you say, the control is basically still in the hands of the individual governments in those countries, but the game here is that I think those governments will use the WHO's recommendations as cover for their own decisions, as in, well, I'm sorry, but the WHO has recommended lockdown, so you have to stay in your house, and we're sorry, but it's out of our hands.
00:12:21 So in this way, they're sloughing off responsibility for making the hard calls,
00:12:26 even though hard calls is what they want to make.
00:12:29 Governments are always anxious to avoid responsibility.
00:12:31 And this is one of the ways they're going to do it.
00:12:34 That's an incredible point.
00:12:36 And I think that was one of the big disgraces of the pandemic response.
00:12:39 I mean, around the world, but certainly in Canada,
00:12:41 is where you had governments hiding behind public health bureaucrats. 0.99
00:12:46 It happened federally with Theresa Tam.
00:12:48 it happened in pretty much every single province. And it, you know, one of the big issues from a
00:12:54 policy perspective is that public health bureaucrats, they have their place. I would say
00:12:58 it's a far smaller place now that I would give them than I would have given them five, six years
00:13:02 ago. But they're very singularly focused on one metric. They're not focused on constitutionality.
00:13:09 They're not focused on the economy. They're not focused on mental health. They're not focused on
00:13:14 child development, they're focused on, okay, getting cases down, even if we could agree on
00:13:18 what a case was and how significant it was. And yeah, it's very dangerous for people that we elect
00:13:24 to make the decisions, which we think are going to come from other experts, like a response should
00:13:28 have been, okay, we hear what the public health doctor has to say, we hear what the economist has
00:13:33 to say, we hear what the child psychiatrist has to say, and then we make a decision on balance.
00:13:38 Now, maybe they wouldn't make the right one, but at least there would be a clear delineation of who
00:13:43 made the responsibility it's incredibly dangerous as you point out to hide behind the experts which
00:13:48 is really what they're agreeing to do here that's exactly right it's it's it's a it's it's a plan to
00:13:53 hide and you know i i have i agree with what you said but i have an even more basic um objection
00:14:04 which is that there are some of these decisions that ought not to have been able to be made in
00:14:08 sense that they told people what to do with their own lives and and instructed them on what risks
00:14:13 that they were allowed to take themselves which is not a thing that any kind of official ought
00:14:18 to have in my books but yes this is going to change the focus from the local officials who
00:14:27 who are exercising their discretion to giving them an excuse for saying that they really have
00:14:33 have no choice which is which is absolutely not correct so there's one of the arguments against
00:14:38 this planned regime from the who is that it will override our sovereignty and it will suspend our 0.91
00:14:48 constitution and and those two things are really not quite true yes it will have it will affect
00:14:56 us detrimentally, yes, it will appear that we will lose control over the rules that are being
00:15:03 applied to us. All those things are true. But the real people to finger in this,
00:15:12 it's not just the who, it is actually our own officials, our own politicians, our own
00:15:17 government, who number one, are eager to sign on to this. And number two, who actually still
00:15:24 have the authority to decide and to decide to what extent they're going to recognize our rights
00:15:30 and freedoms, our civil liberties, and the ones who are failing to weigh all the factors that
00:15:37 you mentioned. They are the ones who are really at fault, and they are the ones who are democratically
00:15:42 accountable to us. The officials in the WHO, the bureaucrats in the WHO are not accountable to us.
00:15:48 They are accountable to the countries that put together this agreement. So our first line of
00:15:53 attack, if you like to put it that way, are the people who purport to represent us, and they are
00:15:58 the ones who are falling down on the job. Yes, and we've already seen in one notable way I'll
00:16:04 describe momentarily where our government is all too willing to go along with this, and that's on
00:16:08 regulating discourse. So in this draft agreement, it says that countries would commit to censoring
00:16:15 quote, false, misleading, misinformation, or disinformation, unquote. Now, these are terms
00:16:21 we've heard the federal government in Canada talk about warranting a government response already.
00:16:27 And we know that the government in Canada is doing an overhaul of internet regulations as we speak.
00:16:32 Well, here we have a prime example where these two agendas seem to be aligned already.
00:16:37 It's perfect. It's perfect. I mean, can't you just imagine the government saying,
00:16:41 well, you know, we were concerned about this, but the WHO basically has told us that this kind of
00:16:46 information should not be allowed because it interferes with global health global health my
00:16:51 goodness well we can't ignore that so we're going to have to put in in place regulations that require
00:16:57 you to or prohibit you from you know questioning the the the narrative that the who is put forward
00:17:04 as to what's important to keep people alive all right so that's it's it's a perfect excuse for
00:17:10 the government to do what it already wants to do and in that way make it appear as though they're
00:17:16 not the one making the call. I just checked on YouTube where we're streaming live right now
00:17:22 because every now and then we get like the big disclaimer that YouTube throws up on our shows
00:17:26 depending on what we're talking about and I don't know if they put it up live or if they put it up
00:17:29 after the fact we don't have one now but often no we didn't get it yet Sean but like if you talk
00:17:34 about climate change you'll get like a disclaimer if you talk about COVID you will and sometimes
00:17:39 it's like a disclaimer from health canada other times it's from the world health organization and
00:17:43 uh the the information they give you so we already have i mean there's an example of big tech
00:17:48 on its own deciding to outsource you know truth basically to the world health organization and
00:17:54 just imagine if you go one step further and make that a deputization by the state to do the same
00:18:00 thing and i i don't think you know being able to say it with a disclaimer will even satisfy
00:18:05 what countries want i think they want you to not be able to say it at all oh oh no question no
00:18:10 question and sure so so the the proponents of this will say quite rightly actually that this
00:18:20 does not suspend the constitution you know your rights and freedoms are still in place
00:18:24 the who doesn't have the power to to set the constitution aside that is true 0.94
00:18:29 but we've already seen that during the first round the charter of rights and freedoms
00:18:34 was not very useful.
00:18:37 The courts did not come to the conclusion
00:18:39 that a lot of these measures violated the Charter.
00:18:42 So just because the Charter is not being suspended
00:18:45 doesn't mean that you're going to have your civil liberties.
00:18:49 And if international norms change
00:18:52 and the cause is a global cause
00:18:56 and a Canadian court is interpreting what the Constitution means,
00:19:01 then it's just as likely that that court,
00:19:03 especially given the track record is going to say well of course you still have your rights but in
00:19:08 this case you're the infringement of your rights are are are either not existing or they're justified
00:19:15 under section one of the charter because after all we have this emergency and the who has said so
00:19:20 so this this this the the this it doesn't these this plan does not have to suspend our constitution
00:19:28 in order for the plan to be a very bad idea.
00:19:31 Yeah, I think that's a very valid point.
00:19:33 And I'd go back to where you mentioned a few moments ago
00:19:36 as being the first line of defense on this,
00:19:38 which is the nation state.
00:19:39 It's countries that need to have pressure put on them
00:19:41 by their citizens to perhaps change or scrap this process.
00:19:45 I mean, I'm looking around at the world here
00:19:48 and not to say I have a firm grip
00:19:50 on every domestic government around the world,
00:19:53 but if I look at the big players,
00:19:55 I'm not seeing anyone with one exception
00:19:57 that I think would push back against that.
00:19:59 And that one exception maybe is the Argentinian president.
00:20:03 I mean, I know he's an economic libertarian.
00:20:05 I don't know if he wants to be the bull in the China shop
00:20:08 on the world stage at some of these
00:20:10 and say, no, we're not signing on to this.
00:20:12 Who knows?
00:20:13 Argentina doesn't wield a huge amount of power,
00:20:15 but the United States does.
00:20:17 And I don't think Joe Biden is gonna say no to this.
00:20:20 I don't think Canada will.
00:20:21 The UK has a nominally conservative government,
00:20:24 but as you and I actually discussed in the UK,
00:20:26 not really.
00:20:27 when you talk about all these things.
00:20:28 So I don't see any countries
00:20:30 that are going to want to put their necks out
00:20:32 and say, whoa, I'm not signing on to this
00:20:34 in its current form.
00:20:35 Oh, I think that's a correct assessment.
00:20:37 And in fact, it's difficult to know
00:20:39 exactly what's going on behind the scenes
00:20:41 as this thing is negotiated.
00:20:42 But I would guess that a lot of these countries
00:20:45 are actually pushing for this
00:20:46 for the very reason that it's to their advantage
00:20:49 so that they are set up better than they were last time
00:20:53 to do the same kinds of things as last time and worse.
00:20:56 like like the like the more targeted prohibition on expression of dissenting views so obviously
00:21:04 we have to be a bit forward looking here and uh we hear i mean that clip i played from justin
00:21:09 trudeau earlier he's talking about oh pandemics for years to come so you know i've gone my entire
00:21:14 life without ever having a pandemic until the last few years as have you as have you know anyone who
00:21:18 was born after the spanish flu basically and now we're being told this is just going to be business
00:21:24 as usual, which I think is in and of itself a bit suspicious, because we've seen the public
00:21:28 healthification of everything. And I think that's another part here that is not really said in the
00:21:33 treaty, which is that what they decide to call a public health emergency is a big issue. I mean,
00:21:39 we hear people saying that you need to make obesity a pandemic, you need to make climate
00:21:43 change a pandemic. And all of a sudden, you take these powers and apply them to all of these other
00:21:48 things. And we've got a big problem on our hands. Yeah, no question. No question. This is very
00:21:53 broad, discretionary, vague
00:21:55 power to declare
00:21:57 an emergency when you feel
00:21:59 like it. People have referred to this
00:22:01 as the beginning of the biomedical
00:22:03 state, and I think they're right.
00:22:05 This is a new era.
00:22:08 They're normalizing
00:22:09 what happened during COVID.
00:22:12 And this
00:22:13 is bad news.
00:22:16 Obviously, you can
00:22:17 see it in Justin Trudeau's
00:22:19 comments. They're planning
00:22:21 for this to be the normal
00:22:23 thing where the powers that they exercised are going to be powers that they exercise
00:22:28 regularly whenever they think it's justified. And believe me, if you have power, the state is going
00:22:33 to use them. All right, Bruce Party, it is a fantastic piece in the National Post, WHO Health
00:22:39 Treaty, a convenient cover for more government overreach. You are the best one on the army
00:22:44 against the technocrats. So we're glad to have you, Bruce. Thanks so much. Thanks, Andrew. Good
00:22:49 All right. Thank you as well. And I should play this clip, by the way. So Tedros Adhanom is the non-doctor who, I mean, he's got a PhD, but he's not a medical doctor at the helm of the WHO. I wanted to play this clip from him for your benefit right now.
00:23:04 We cannot kick this can down the road.
00:23:11 If we do not make the changes that must be made, then who will?
00:23:18 And if we do not make them now, and when?
00:23:22 When the next pandemic comes knocking, and it will,
00:23:29 we must be ready to answer decisively, collectively, and equitably.
00:23:34 And for enhanced international cooperation, the pandemic accord, a generational commitment that we will not go back to the old cycle of panic and neglect that left our world vulnerable, but move forward with a shared commitment to meet shared threats with a shared response.
00:23:57 That's why we say the pandemic accord is a generational agreement.
00:24:01 That is Ted Ross teeing up the pandemic accord at last year's World Health Assembly now coming
00:24:09 this year. To be honest, we haven't made a decision. I was wondering if it would be worth
00:24:13 going to Geneva to cover it. And then I looked up the price and it was like even to stay at like
00:24:19 some weird mid-level like residence in, it was going to be like $750 a night. So maybe we skip
00:24:26 out the World Health Assembly in Geneva. You never know. We can, maybe I can stay in a,
00:24:31 on Geneva, we'd have to stay in France if we wanted to do the commute every day. But
00:24:36 nevertheless, that was Tedros. Now he's going to be in Davos next week. I was looking at the agenda
00:24:42 for what presentations people can see at the World Economic Forum annual meeting.
00:24:47 And one of them is this, preparing for disease X with fresh warnings from the World Health
00:24:54 organization that an unknown disease X, because X is like the menacing letter. If they called it
00:24:59 like disease blue, no one would give a hoot. But disease X could lead to 20 times more fatalities
00:25:09 than the coronavirus pandemic. So what novel efforts are needed to prepare healthcare systems
00:25:13 for the multiple challenges ahead? So here we have a bunch of people and we'll be monitoring
00:25:18 this session. You can follow it along from home as well. Them talking about this mystery disease
00:25:23 that no one's ever heard of, that WHO actually identified in 2018, that we're already saying,
00:25:28 oh, it's going to be 20 times worse than COVID, so let's get ready. Well, in the same breath,
00:25:33 we are hearing public health officials admit that their measures for COVID were not even rooted in
00:25:38 science in many cases. So we can look at the agenda just very briefly, because we are going
00:25:44 to be reporting from Davos next year, or next week rather, maybe next year, who knows. But next week,
00:25:50 And there are a number of sessions that I'm incredibly curious about.
00:25:54 One of them is talking about the future of freedom of expression.
00:25:58 Now, in the past, when they talk about freedom of expression, it's not spoken about as a positive, really.
00:26:03 It's spoken about as something that is getting in the way, these absolute rights and freedoms.
00:26:09 There is also one that sounds lovely.
00:26:13 It sounds great.
00:26:14 But if you look into the fine print, it might not be so great.
00:26:19 The session is called Protecting the Vulnerable Online.
00:26:23 The description, more than half of internet users worldwide, age 13 and older, face at least one potential online threat.
00:26:29 Cyberbullying, online harassment, hate speech, and misinformation pose significant challenges.
00:26:36 What are the key developments in trust and safety online?
00:26:39 And what measures should stakeholders, and that includes governments and corporations to them, embrace to foster a safer internet for all?
00:26:47 and one of the panelists on this one I should point out is Julie Inman Grant who's an Australian
00:26:53 online safety bureaucrat who two Davos meetings ago talked about how we need to recalibrate the
00:27:00 way we view freedom of speech so I mean I'm all for recalibrating free speech as well but I want
00:27:06 to recalibrate it to actually protect it not to get rid of it Sean has said he attempted to write
00:27:13 decalibrate, but wrote da alley rate, uh, whatever that means. So anyway, uh, I think he was going
00:27:20 for recalibrate. Uh, let's, uh, we will, we will put a pin in this and revisit it from the Swiss 1.00
00:27:25 slash Austrian Alps next week. But, uh, before we get there, I wanted to talk about the scourge
00:27:31 of antisemitism, which I am very ashamed to say as a Canadian has become the norm and the rule
00:27:37 rather than the exception.
00:27:39 We've had some little bits of change on this front.
00:27:43 Toronto police have decided now that no,
00:27:46 people shouldn't be shutting down a bridge
00:27:48 in a Jewish neighborhood to protest against Israel
00:27:51 because, you know, let's be real,
00:27:52 they're just protesting against Jews.
00:27:54 But at the same time,
00:27:55 we also see an increasing normalization of this.
00:27:59 All of the people who were tremendous supporters
00:28:01 of Israel and the Jewish people
00:28:03 on October 7th, 8th, and 9th, and 10th
00:28:05 have become less and less so as time has gone on, and the media has become a very key player in this.
00:28:13 Barbara Kay had a fantastic piece in the Epoch Times.
00:28:16 She said, to uphold the preferred narrative, the media will go to any lengths to demonize Israel.
00:28:21 Barbara Kay joins us now, and it's always good to see her.
00:28:24 Barbara, thanks for joining me today.
00:28:26 Pleasure to be here, Andrew.
00:28:28 So, I mean, the media's role in this cannot be at all overstated.
00:28:33 The media, I mean, when you're talking about something happening in the Middle East, the media is, to some extent, our only glimpse at what's happening there.
00:28:41 And we've seen the framing on Israel issues to just be absolutely disastrous.
00:28:46 And, you know, CBC not calling Hamas a terror organization, which is a statement of fact.
00:28:52 It's a statement of law in Canada.
00:28:53 It's not even an arguable point.
00:28:55 And, you know, media that does false equivalency. At one point, they referred to the agreement by Israel to release prisoners in exchange for hostages as a hostage exchange, which is just, again, an absurd thing here.
00:29:09 But you've talked about the media really being particularly brazen on this.
00:29:14 They're very brazen. We just saw, I don't know if you saw it on X, Honest Reporting had done an expose of some Reuters and Associated Press journalists in Gaza laughing about, you know, looking at some of the atrocities of October 7th and laughing.
00:29:38 Gaza is filled with so-called journalists. We know that some of the journalists that the New York Times employed actually accompanied Hamas on the rampage, the pogrom of October 7th.
00:29:51 7th. In other words, they knew about it in advance. They wanted to capture it as it happens.
00:29:57 And it was clear that from the familiar way in which they were palling around with the Hamas 0.96
00:30:06 fighters, that they are actually supporters of Hamas or likely supporters of Hamas. And
00:30:13 as I've said many times on social media, and in my column that you cited,
00:30:21 The very words from sources in Gaza should send alarm bells ringing in any mainstream news outlet because there is no such thing as a report out of Gaza that is inherently trustworthy. 0.66
00:30:38 Not that they always give false news, but you can never be sure that they're not giving false news because no reporter is allowed to report from Gaza without censorship by Hamas.
00:30:53 And so no reporter is free to publish what they want from Gaza unless it goes through Hamas censorship.
00:31:04 And as well, many of the journalists, the so-called journalists in Gaza are actually not journalists.
00:31:11 They are simply working for Hamas in the capacity of stringers for other, you know, bigger companies.
00:31:18 But they are, in fact, agents for Hamas.
00:31:21 I only speak about, you know, four or five lines of Arabic. So I have to rely on other translations when I see Arabic footage. But I have seen at least three or four clips from within the last few months, which are presented as some of one of those journalists that you were just describing interviewing people. And when they start to criticize Hamas, the interview gets quickly and abruptly ended.
00:31:45 So when the people in Gaza are saying, well, hang on, Hamas is using us as shields, the interview ends.
00:31:50 So you're right. There is no, you know, unbiased commitment to truth there, which is, I think, a big part of it.
00:31:57 A lot of these are activists wearing press vests.
00:31:59 Yeah. And of course, you know, you expect biased reporting from Al Jazeera.
00:32:04 You know, that's that's that's their job.
00:32:06 But when it comes to New York Times, BBC, CNN, we just saw a story out of CNN.
00:32:14 Some of their Middle Eastern stringers were posting disgustingly anti-Israel stuff on social media.
00:32:24 They've lost control of the journalistic situation over there, it seems to me, since they have decided to accept stuff coming out of Gaza without verifying.
00:32:35 And when you see the BBC doing that and the CBC, it's really sickening because there's a long history of this.
00:32:43 They know very well that a lot of reports are doctored or they're complete fiction, complete fiction.
00:32:51 And as we've seen in the whole Palestinian movement in the last several decades, you know, truth in journalism is not a value. 0.98
00:32:59 It's not a Middle Eastern value in regimes that are not democratic, and none of them are except Israel. 0.79
00:33:08 I mean, you'll get honest reporting out of Egypt and some of the bigger, the more stable entities there.
00:33:16 But from the West Bank or Gaza, you really have to verify anything you hear out of there.
00:33:22 And in fact, I remember in a column I wrote some time ago, I remember there was a report from Matty Friedman, one of the top journalists on this scene, who recounted the anecdote of a West Bank politician checking with an Israeli journalist to see if what he was being told by his own journalists in the West Bank was true or not.
00:33:47 He just, a rumor that there was an assassination plot.
00:33:50 He didn't know whether to believe it or not.
00:33:52 So he checked with Israeli journalists.
00:33:54 That's how bad it is.
00:33:56 You talk about this phenomenon, which I've heard before, and it sounds silly, but it's
00:34:00 actually a very serious thing, which is Pallywood.
00:34:03 And I'm wondering if you could explain that for people that haven't come across this term.
00:34:08 I guess not.
00:34:10 I guess she can't explain that.
00:34:12 Oh, there we go.
00:34:12 We got Barbara back.
00:34:13 I'm sorry.
00:34:14 This has happened before, Andrew.
00:34:15 Yeah, I'm having flashbacks now, like literal flashes and then, yeah.
00:34:20 And now you're freezing up again a little bit too.
00:34:22 I don't know.
00:34:22 I'm on Chrome.
00:34:25 I'm hearing you now.
00:34:26 Can you hear me?
00:34:27 I hear you very well now.
00:34:28 Okay, perfect.
00:34:29 So tell me what Pallywood is for people that aren't familiar.
00:34:33 Pallywood is an actual news producing industry in the West Bank and Gaza.
00:34:41 And it's like Bollywood in the sense that it's fake stuff, but it's an actual industry.
00:34:48 There are producers and directors and actors and extras, all kinds of industry norms going on that actually are producing fake news.
00:34:59 So if they want to show that an Israeli struck, say, a site, then they will produce it. 0.99
00:35:12 They will actually create a scene and produce it with fake dead people on stretchers.
00:35:16 And suddenly an ambulance comes screeching up.
00:35:19 You know, somebody hails an ambulance to come screeching up four seconds later.
00:35:23 so it's it's um it's it's and then they produced it as news uh the famous mohammed aldura affair
00:35:32 in 2000 um that was highly contested it was shot by a palestinian stringer who was also well known
00:35:41 in hollywood industry of making fake news but he had sent a 59 second clip that purported to show
00:35:48 that during the Intifada that Israeli snipers had actually targeted and killed a 12-year-old boy
00:35:55 by the name of Muhammad al-Dura. When the 23 minutes of raw footage was seen by other journalists
00:36:03 and skeptics presented a very different picture and eventually there were lawsuits over this and
00:36:10 eventually the IDF concluded and reported there was no way that child could have been hit by an
00:36:16 Israeli bullet because of the angle of the bullet and all that but that was one of the bigger stories
00:36:21 but they're very consequential these stories like the Janine massacre the Janine massacre you may
00:36:26 remember in 2002 when they were trying to get to the source of the all the suicide bombers
00:36:32 they had a ground operation into Janine the first reports out of the West Bank were a massacre of
00:36:38 500 civilians, and that story stuck. In the end, after many reports and many actual
00:36:46 investigations, it was concluded that 53 civilians were killed and 23 IDF soldiers who had done a
00:36:54 ground invasion in order not to kill civilians, and as a result were ambushed, their own soldiers
00:37:01 got killed, but they were trying to prevent civilian deaths. But these stories are used
00:37:06 as propaganda again and again and again. And the images are extremely emotive. So
00:37:13 this industry is extremely harmful. It's called lethal journalism. It is lethal because people
00:37:21 die over it. Osama bin Laden used the Mohammed al-Dura story in his own propaganda because he
00:37:28 could see that the picture of this boy huddling behind his father, apparently being targeted by
00:37:35 israeli bullets which was not the case they are made into martyrs they are remember that little
00:37:42 boy uh the syrian boy lying in the sand that little two-year-old boy and these images have
00:37:48 an incredible effect well and i recall i seem to recall that there was evidence that emerged later
00:37:53 that that boy had been moved i mean it was still a tragedy but the photo had been to some extent
00:37:58 stage to make a bigger point from that it's it's not hard to see that uh this whole palestinian
00:38:08 issue this whole israel is is a very much um an emotional thing and a lot of the people that are
00:38:16 active in it uh when you corner them and you ask them you know to state why they don't even know
00:38:23 why they're part of a herd uh in fact the toronto sun just had a piece out today saying some of
00:38:28 these protesters are being paid um to be part of these protests but anyways there's a lot of
00:38:33 hysteria involved uh in these protests because this issue has uh you know Palestinian activists
00:38:43 on campuses for example they're there for years and years not they're not very good at studying
00:38:48 but they're very good at propaganda this is this is they're paid for this uh you know there's a
00:38:53 lot of foreign funding of these movements in the West. It's a very deep rabbit hole, Andrew, and
00:39:01 you know we could spend hours on this. But in terms of the journalists, the irresponsible journalism
00:39:07 that is attached to this subject, it's just remarkable how far these media outlets will go
00:39:16 to push a narrative that is harmful to Israel. They are lock, stock and barrel,
00:39:22 committed advocacy journalists rather than um objectives it's just not journalism simply is not
00:39:30 what you it's not what it should be it's not what true north does uh it is it is uh pure it is
00:39:38 getting to be pure propaganda um in too many of formerly respectable uh outlets so it's yeah
00:39:46 we're lucky to have a few um outlets in canada like the national post true north uh the epoch
00:39:53 times that uh that is i what i consider to be journalism that verifies sources actually fact
00:40:01 checks you know does basic stuff well yeah what should be uh you know used to be basic and second
00:40:08 nature anyway and the only area where you could say uh that can rival the israel hatred in much
00:40:15 much of the media is in academia, as we've seen in the last few months. And I just very briefly
00:40:20 wanted to ask you about this story, because I understand you're writing about it this week in
00:40:23 another piece. There is now a class action lawsuit against so far six major Canadian universities,
00:40:29 Queens, York, Concordia and Montreal, TMU, which used to be Ryerson before Ryerson's name became
00:40:36 a hate crime, and the University of British Columbia facing claims that Jewish students
00:40:41 are unsafe on their campuses. I mean, look, that's a difficult thing to refute with just
00:40:48 raw footage we've seen of what's happened on these campuses, isn't it?
00:40:52 Yeah, I always felt that lawsuits were the way to go. I was promoting the idea years and years
00:40:58 and years ago. I said, the only way these universities are going to change if it hits
00:41:02 them in the pocketbook. These particular class actions are by a law firm, but they are in
00:41:11 in partnership with the Lawfare Project, which is a pro bono legal fund for fighting anti-Semitism
00:41:20 around the world. They do phenomenal work and they just had a very big success
00:41:26 against a restaurant in Toronto, an owner of a restaurant, for defaming in defamation suit
00:41:34 against a Canadian media personality who was also a Zionist and was targeted on social media.
00:41:41 So unless lawsuits make these institutions pay out big time, and the one against McMaster is what, $77 million, and the more that are targeted, the better, because just a couple have to win, and you'll see the whole culture of university will be forced to change, and that's the only way this is going to be happening.
00:42:05 Just as in the States, that president was not going to – Claudine Gay from Harvard.
00:42:12 She was not prepared to step down.
00:42:15 But donor, you know, when you lose a billion dollars in funding from your donor class, that talks louder than ideology.
00:42:27 And I can only pray that these lawsuits succeed because I think that's going to have a very abrupt –
00:42:35 and very um cleansing effect on on uh campuses in terms of anti-semitism i know you're you're
00:42:44 jewish yourself and you live in montreal which has always had a very vibrant jewish community
00:42:49 how have you what's your sense been i mean i know you are are not recognizably jewish like some
00:42:54 orthodox people in montreal are so i don't know if you personally feel unsafe walking around but
00:42:59 what's the mood been in the last few months there well i mean certainly there have been incidents
00:43:05 that are quite harrowing you know bullets in a door of uh of in school in in areas that are
00:43:10 intensely jewish i live in a very mixed and very diverse neighborhood uh i am known to be jewish
00:43:16 because i from my writings i'm a pub you know publicly identified as jewish uh but i don't feel
00:43:22 physically unsafe no my neighbor not in my neighborhood but i know that there are areas
00:43:28 uh where yes uh people do feel unsafe and and for reason uh so far nothing cataclysmic has happened
00:43:39 but there have been threats and and you know there have been incidents in malls and just like there
00:43:44 have been in toronto there there have been a lot of very unsettling uh incidents and i know on
00:43:49 campus. Concordia is known to be a hotbed of pro-Palestinianism, UQAM and McGill to a certain
00:43:59 extent, but Concordia has had a long time reputation of, that's where Laith Marouf got his start in
00:44:06 anti-Semitic. Yeah, anyone who said hate doesn't pay certainly didn't look at the business model
00:44:14 there. Barbara Kay, fantastic work in the Epoch Times and in the National Post as always. Thank
00:44:22 you so much for coming on today. Thanks for having me, Andrew. All right. That does it for us for
00:44:27 today. That means I am saying farewell to Canada for a little bit of time, but we will see you on
00:44:32 Monday from Davos. This is the Andrew Lawton Show, Canada's most irreverent talk show on True North.
00:44:38 Thank you. God bless and have a great weekend. Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:44:42 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:45:12 We'll be right back.
00:45:42 We'll be right back.