Juno News - May 05, 2023


WHO says there's no more Covid emergency

Topics
Mentioned
The cost of speaking out as a teacher (Ft. Chanel Pfahl) UCP comes out ahead on bungled announcement

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

178.87

Word count

7,497

Sentence count

311

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A woman who is a Black and Indigenous Canadian delegate at the Liberal National Convention says things didn't go as she had expected at a party hosted by the Liberal Party of Canada. She says people get tired, but then they start drinking. And when they get drunk and tired, all the Liberals get racist.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by TrueNorth.
00:00:13 Hello everyone and welcome to you all.
00:00:15 Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show here Friday, May 5th.
00:00:19 It is Cinco de Mayo.
00:00:20 And I don't actually know what Cinco de Mayo is.
00:00:24 I'm told there may be tacos.
00:00:26 We have a mariachi band ready to play us out into the credits.
00:00:29 I don't want to get too excited about Cinco de Mayo because then I'll end up facing accusations that I'm culturally appropriating like Justin Trudeau does every time he goes to a party.
00:00:40 But we will get to that when we get there.
00:00:42 Speaking of Justin Trudeau and parties, this was a little bit of a clip from the Liberal Convention, which right now is underway in Ottawa.
00:00:53 Because the city of Ottawa said, what's the one thing we could do to make the city more boring than it is normally?
00:00:58 And they decided, let's host the Liberal Party of Canada convention.
00:01:03 But apparently, after Justin Trudeau spoke yesterday, as is the nature of any convention,
00:01:08 people go up to the hospitality suites, they start having a good time, they eat, they drink, they be merry and all that.
00:01:15 And apparently, according to this woman, who is a black and indigenous Canadian woman, a liberal delegate,
00:01:23 things did not go all convivially and congenially, as she might have expected anyway.
00:01:28 take a look. My name is Dawn Upshaw. I'm from Nova Scotia. I'm African Canadian and the black
00:01:36 loyalists. I'm also Miss Disney Cree from Bay James. I attended a reception last night. We're
00:01:45 here from different time zones. People are tired. People are hungry. And there was liquor served at
00:01:50 the event. So people were getting drunk and tired rather quickly. And that's when the racism come
00:01:56 out so i was here last night listening and reacting to racism from liberals so when you
00:02:05 respond to racism do not respond with food fun and fashion shows as you've done in the past
00:02:13 do something and let us do something and let us be the people who guide you thank you thank you
00:02:21 very much. I'm very, very sorry that that happened. And I think we all want to make sure that we
00:02:27 condemn any type of racism of any type. And we need to understand that actions matter more than
00:02:32 words. That is Anthony Housefather and Marcy Ian and Ahmed Hassen on the stage there. And the fourth
00:02:44 one, I forgot, Mary Ng. And this woman, and again, I have no idea if she was actually a victim of
00:02:49 racism. And who knows? Maybe she was, maybe she wasn't. But this woman is a black loyalist,
00:02:55 an indigenous Canadian. She's there. She says people get tired, but then they start drinking. 0.97
00:02:59 And when they get drunk and tired, all the liberals get racist. Well, maybe not all of them,
00:03:04 but at least some of them. Now, this, again, I don't want to downplay if she was a victim of
00:03:11 genuine racism or not. I certainly believe she felt aggrieved by it. But this is the problem,
00:03:16 is that you can't out-woke the woke.
00:03:18 So Justin Trudeau yesterday was making a whole big deal about how,
00:03:22 and we'll play the clip a little later in Fake News Friday,
00:03:25 but a whole big deal about how Pierre Polyev needs to get woker.
00:03:29 He says, you know, Pierre Polyev accuses the liberals of being woke,
00:03:31 but he needs to wake up.
00:03:33 And you have the liberals going all woke all the time,
00:03:35 saying we need to be the wokey, wokest, woke, woke, wokers.
00:03:39 And Wokistan is apparently no longer as woke as Justin Trudeau wants it to be.
00:03:44 So you get a woman who is black and indigenous who wants to go up and feel like she can party it up in a safe space and finds that all the other liberals there, in her view, are microaggressing her all day long and all the live long nights.
00:03:57 So whether she was actually a victim of it, I don't know.
00:04:02 In fact, like for all we know, that might have actually just been Justin Trudeau asking a question at the mic.
00:04:07 In fact, I don't think his flight has left for King Charles's coronation this weekend.
00:04:11 So you never know what goes down at the Liberal Convention.
00:04:14 The Liberals don't accredit us to their convention,
00:04:17 so I would like it noted that we had nothing to do with these allegations
00:04:21 of microaggressing misconduct that were afoot,
00:04:25 and the Liberals have to be held to account.
00:04:27 Poor Anthony, how's father there on the stage, is like,
00:04:29 I thought we were just talking about our tax plan.
00:04:32 But instead, the Liberals will perhaps double down on the drink service tonight.
00:04:37 But the Liberal Convention is underway,
00:04:40 And there was one proposal that went forward that I think is a little bit noteworthy.
00:04:47 Now, I want to make a couple of points here.
00:04:49 The first is that liberal conventions like conservative conventions, like NDP conventions,
00:04:54 they're kind of theatrical in a way.
00:04:57 So people will talk about all of this stuff and they'll even put policies forward.
00:05:02 But there's nothing legally binding about party policy on government.
00:05:06 So liberal members can vote for whatever they want.
00:05:08 It doesn't mean that Justin Trudeau is doing it.
00:05:11 Sometimes, in fact, often parties will try to manipulate
00:05:13 which policies can come before them for votes and so on.
00:05:18 But with that preface notwithstanding,
00:05:20 there was one that jumps out here that I think we need to take a look at.
00:05:24 Now, I saw this from Michael Geist,
00:05:26 who is one of the preeminent internet regulation lawyers in Canada,
00:05:31 a professor at the University of Ottawa.
00:05:33 And he plucked out this draft resolution,
00:05:36 a policy proposal that Liberal members will be voting on if they haven't already.
00:05:41 I'm going to read the preamble, because the preamble is sometimes just as fun as the resolution.
00:05:48 He writes, yada, yada, yada.
00:05:49 Mainstream media no longer employs as many reporters with extensive knowledge of particular subject areas.
00:05:54 This fills content with opinion programming rather than news.
00:05:58 And whereas this result has devalued mainstream media as a source of news and information,
00:06:04 Be it resolved that the Liberal Party of Canada request the government provide additional public funds to support ad-free news and information reporting by Canadian media through an arm's-length non-partisan mechanism.
00:06:19 So they want more money to the media bailout.
00:06:23 And then also request the government explore options to hold online information services accountable for the veracity of material published on their platforms.
00:06:34 and to limit the publication only to material whose sources can be traced, unquote.
00:06:41 So here's what they want.
00:06:44 They want two things.
00:06:45 They want those things, those things.
00:06:47 I got so excited I banged my microphone.
00:06:49 I apologize if, and I didn't even buy it a drink first.
00:06:52 It's a Friday show.
00:06:53 We let loose a little bit.
00:06:55 But be it resolved that the government provide additional public funds
00:06:59 to support ad-free news and information programs.
00:07:02 So they want more money, and then also they want online info services, so I think they mean news platforms, to be held accountable for the veracity of material published.
00:07:14 So they want state-mandated fact-checking.
00:07:18 So if you say something that Justin Trudeau gets up to the podium and says is false, that should be removed from the platform, the government thinks.
00:07:26 Phil, my colleague, is telling me that I have abandoned our ability to put the clean tag on the podcast
00:07:32 after my little impromptu joke about the microphone.
00:07:35 I didn't use a wordy-dird, a dirty word, a dirty-dirty-dird?
00:07:39 Anyway, I didn't use one of those. I think we can keep the clean tag.
00:07:42 The Liberals also want, according to this motion,
00:07:46 to limit publication only to material whose sources can be traced.
00:07:50 So what this would mean in practice, it's tough to say,
00:07:55 But it sounds like they're trying to ban internet anonymity.
00:07:58 Now, I may not like anonymity in online posting,
00:08:01 but I think you have a right to be on the internet anonymously if you'd like.
00:08:05 And also, I don't know how you trace foreign content,
00:08:08 which is not all just evil Russian bots or whatever.
00:08:11 Sometimes foreign content can be some random guy in India
00:08:14 that wants to comment on your post or tweet something.
00:08:17 So liberal members, regardless of whether the party itself
00:08:21 or the government picks this up,
00:08:22 liberal members are trying to expand even further the federal government's control of the internet
00:08:29 and control of news. And they want it only basically to be mainstream media or nothing
00:08:35 else. They want government funded media or nothing else. Anyone that falls outside of
00:08:39 those parameters, they have no interest in. And the reason I'm spending so much time talking
00:08:45 about the internet regulatory environment here is because we've seen in the last few years
00:08:49 how misinformation, fact-checking, how all of this stuff has been weaponized against debate
00:08:55 and against dissent. Today, big news that came out of Geneva. The World Health Organization
00:09:02 has said that there is no more COVID health emergency. Now, if you were going around
00:09:09 licking doorknobs this morning and not wearing a mask and eating your bat soup, you would have 1.00
00:09:15 been like, well, hang on. I didn't think there was a COVID emergency anyway. But the World Health 1.00
00:09:19 organization has claimed for three years and three months now, almost three years and four
00:09:24 months, that this emergency is still in effect. Now today, Dr. Tedros, the fake doctor who runs
00:09:32 the world health regime, comes out and says, yes, COVID is no longer an emergency. So yay.
00:09:39 But what's interesting here is that all good things had to come to an end. And for people
00:09:44 who are in the control business, COVID has been and continues to be a very good thing. This has
00:09:50 been a mechanism by which governments have expanded control, by which big tech has confined
00:09:56 debate, and by which all of us have been turned against each other. And when I have talked about
00:10:03 the fallout from COVID, which we still don't entirely know, all of the consequences that
00:10:09 we're seeing are not, you know, these perennial long COVID complaints, but the consequences of
00:10:13 the COVID era are almost overwhelmingly, sorry, are overwhelmingly and are almost always
00:10:19 consequences of government policy. I mean, I had the opportunity to witness a panel discussion not
00:10:25 long ago that was talking about just the education consequences alone and how children have been
00:10:32 stunted and basically three years they've lost, at least two, of education. You talk to university
00:10:38 professors who have first-year courses and they say that they're looking at essays from students
00:10:43 who have gone through high school without ever learning how to write, and they go to university
00:10:49 and get in, and they're trying to get their degrees in whatever, the next generation of
00:10:53 doctors, of lawyers, of gender theorists, all very important roles, and they are unable to
00:11:00 just fundamentally string together a sentence because their education has been denied.
00:11:07 And I mean, some of these problems existed before COVID in the education system, but they were
00:11:11 certainly exacerbated by COVID. And what's more concerning about this fallout is how much denial
00:11:20 there is that all of these things that we had to live with actually happened. You've got people
00:11:25 like Anthony Fauci, who you can find, you know, a dozen clips of him saying how important a lockdown
00:11:30 was. And now he's saying, literally, he used the words in an interview the other day,
00:11:34 I never recommended a lockdown. And I saw this juxtaposed with like five clips of him saying,
00:11:40 I advise the president to lock down. I've advised the president to lock down. We need to shut things
00:11:45 down. And the great walk backening, as my friend Laura Rosen-Cohen calls it, is in full force.
00:11:51 People that have been in many ways at the driver's seat of the most draconian measures we've seen
00:11:58 ever in the last hundred years, certainly, that weren't in wartime, that are now saying,
00:12:05 well, I never really did that. And they just sort of move on. And it's this push for
00:12:09 COVID amnesty that we saw a call for in the Atlantic a few months ago that a lot of people
00:12:14 may be willing to go along with because they just want to move on from the last three years.
00:12:18 But other people are saying, hang on, you don't get to just shirk accountability and pretend that
00:12:23 the last three years never happened. You don't get to pretend that you never divided family
00:12:28 members against each other, that you never locked the elderly in their homes, that you never locked
00:12:32 children out of their schools. And it's one thing for the WHO to say, yay, we've weathered the
00:12:37 storm, the emergency is over, it's quite another for us to actually look at the harms that
00:12:43 governments have caused, governments largely driven by WHO policy in that same time span
00:12:50 under the auspices of and in the name of this so-called COVID emergency, which if it existed,
00:12:55 it certainly didn't exist for three years and four months. I spoke in the previous show with
00:13:01 my colleague Rachel Emanuel about the Alberta election, which is currently underway right now.
00:13:06 We're getting all the press releases from all the candidates.
00:13:09 They're announcing their platforms.
00:13:11 Yesterday, Rachel Notley, the former premier seeking to return to the seat,
00:13:16 had a press conference in which she said she wanted to send a message to conservatives
00:13:21 that were thinking of voting NDP for the first time.
00:13:25 And I was like, well, this actually sounds quite interesting.
00:13:27 So I went on Zoom because you could connect via Zoom.
00:13:30 And I joined the press conference.
00:13:31 And you have to click the raise hand button if you want to ask a question.
00:13:35 And they never called on me, the only one on that press conference that has, I'd say, probably a larger share of conservatives in the audience that are the people Ms. Notley ostensibly wants to speak to.
00:13:48 But they called on one reporter twice.
00:13:50 So that was how much they really, really, really didn't want me to ask her a question.
00:13:55 But when we talk about this election, I think we need to also take a look back into four years ago, the election that elected Jason Kenney as premier of the UCP government, the first ever UCP government, and one particular story that may not be politically relevant to a lot of people now, but is culturally relevant and is incredibly relevant to the individual at the center of that story.
00:14:19 And that is Kaylin Ford, who I have interviewed in the past, and we'll talk a little bit about that in this show.
00:14:26 She was a star candidate, called a unicorn by some people in the 2019 election.
00:14:32 She was running for the UCP in a seat that wasn't a traditionally conservative seat, but they thought was within reach, incredibly well-educated, incredibly eloquent, and was the victim of a horrific smear campaign by someone who she once called a friend.
00:14:46 And that smear campaign was very much enabled by mainstream media outlets and by some alternative media outlets.
00:14:54 And Kaylin Ford has released a new documentary about this ordeal and also about the broader themes it touches on.
00:15:02 It's called When the Mob Came.
00:15:04 And Kaylin joins me now.
00:15:06 Kaylin, it's good to talk to you again.
00:15:08 Thanks for coming on today, firstly.
00:15:10 Thanks, Andrew.
00:15:11 and to clarify the documentary is as we speak being rendered and will be released later tonight
00:15:16 so okay but later this evening it should be uh should be public and um yeah wonderful i appreciate
00:15:24 that uh clarification and i had the the good fortune of being able to see an advanced copy of
00:15:29 it which was was quite compelling and and even having followed your story and and having known
00:15:35 you in in some capacity i i learned things from it and was forced to reflect on on certain things
00:15:41 then I don't want to rehash a lot of the details that the people can can find for themselves but
00:15:46 I'll ask firstly why you wanted to do this because for for someone that's gone through what you went
00:15:51 through it wouldn't surprise me if you wanted to just kind of shut the door and lock it on that
00:15:56 chapter of your life and and move on and I know you've done that largely you've started a fantastic
00:16:01 school in Calgary or you're trying to open one in Edmonton as well why go back to this time in your
00:16:06 life? Well, so in answer to that question, look, we talk about people being cancelled, and there's
00:16:12 obviously a spectrum, right? Some people might be deplatformed on one or several occasions.
00:16:17 In my case, my life was annihilated. I was on the front page of the Toronto Star four times,
00:16:24 they said I came from a trash heap, and that I would have been caught promoting white supremacy. 0.96
00:16:29 Three different CBC headlines said that I basically was a white supremacist. It was on 0.98
00:16:34 CBC's The National with Wendy Mesley, and it didn't stop for a month. So it was almost daily
00:16:40 coverage, making these claims about me. Any attempt that I made to try to tell my own side
00:16:46 of the story ended up suppressed. We can get into that. Employers wouldn't engage with me. I was
00:16:52 told I couldn't sit on charitable boards. Friends left me. They faced ostracism from their social
00:16:57 circles if they continued engaging with me. This was complete character assassination. I couldn't
00:17:03 livelihood. It took me almost four years before I was able to get new employment. And that was
00:17:10 through an organization that I founded. So I was persona non grata. I couldn't just move on. And
00:17:16 this is one of the misconceptions that I hope this documentary will maybe prompt people to reflect on
00:17:21 is when you are subject to this sort of like shame storm, the media will move on, the mob will move
00:17:28 on, that person's life has been completely torn through. And they can't just always pick up the
00:17:37 pieces and sort of reassemble it. So on the one hand, this was, I had no platform to tell the
00:17:42 story, and I had no employment. But I did have a background in documentary filmmaking, which is
00:17:48 very fortuitous. One of the interesting dynamics here is that you're obviously interviewing some
00:17:54 of the people in this documentary you're you're releasing it but you're you're featured in it and
00:17:58 it's about you and and there are other people that are being interviewed about you and I'm
00:18:03 wondering why just from a production standpoint you decided to approach it in in such a personal
00:18:08 way because oftentimes and I know this is someone who's written about cancel culture there can be a
00:18:13 temptation to deal with it in the abstract because it's a bit safer you can talk about other people
00:18:18 being cancelled and hope that that may you know in in a roundabout way kind of get people to sort
00:18:23 of take your side on it without having to really expose yourself again yeah so um making a
00:18:29 documentary about my own life is it is horrifying um you know it is i i was sharing with you it
00:18:36 feels to me like just the height of narcissistic self-indulgence and it's very obvious and i'm
00:18:40 very upfront about the fact that this is a persuasive piece that my goal is actually to
00:18:44 change people's minds about me and that's that's extremely personal i'm kind of like laying my
00:18:49 heart bare for the world. And I may or may not find that that's a cathartic event. You know,
00:18:57 but yeah, it is challenging. You'll notice in the film, I often slip into speaking in the third
00:19:01 person. And I think that's just a, that's a coping mechanism that I acquired to try to
00:19:05 intellectualize the experience because I found it, it's very difficult to talk about me in this
00:19:10 context. But yeah, so it's, it's really challenging. I had to, the way I tried to overcome that was by
00:19:16 dressing it up intellectually and sort of couching it in a philosophical framework. So the entire
00:19:20 documentary is actually kind of framed by Plato's Gorgias dialogue. And the central thesis, if I
00:19:27 might summarize, that comes from that dialogue is that we should take greater care to avoid doing
00:19:34 wrong than we should to avoid suffering wrong. And that above all else, we should care about
00:19:40 actually being good and rather than making people believe that we're good and this relates to
00:19:47 cancel culture in the sense that I think cancel culture it's obviously not culture it's an
00:19:51 anti-culture but it's a culture of intellectual and moral inversion where false virtues or the
00:19:57 performance of false virtues is celebrated at the expense of the real thing and so this is a
00:20:04 documentary about well is it is it better to strive for the real thing or to sort of perform
00:20:10 the counterfeit? And is it better to suffer injury or to do it from the vantage point of
00:20:16 the soul? So this is how I've tried to overcome the difficulty of turning the lens on myself in
00:20:22 my own life. One of the challenges that I believe you would presumably admit you faced is that you
00:20:29 are, as people can tell, I think from your answer there and from any of your other work, an incredibly
00:20:34 intellectual person. You're a very cerebral person. You're well-read. You have references
00:20:39 dating back thousands of years for things. And intellectual exercises are not really all that
00:20:44 fitting in modern politics, which is about soundbites and brevities. There's one, you know,
00:20:49 little illumination of this in the documentary when your former campaign manager is talking
00:20:53 about canvassing, which is when you go knocking on doors and your role in the party's view of
00:20:59 things is to knock on a door to find out if they're voting for you or not, and move on to
00:21:03 the next door. You're not trying to persuade them, you're trying to identify them. Whereas your view
00:21:07 was the one that would make campaign managers have an aneurysm,
00:21:11 which is let's sit and have a conversation for 20 minutes or 30 minutes.
00:21:14 And how difficult is that for you coming from an academic background
00:21:18 and an intellectual background where you believe
00:21:20 that everything can be approached with reason
00:21:22 and that every kind of conflict can be the start of a conversation
00:21:26 when I think the crux of the problem here
00:21:29 is that you have people that aren't interested in conversations,
00:21:31 that aren't interested in challenging their perceptions,
00:21:33 however wrong they are.
00:21:35 Yeah, and you see me struggle with that in the film, I think, because my general assumption is
00:21:40 that people are reasonable and they can be reasoned with. On the campaign trail, I actually
00:21:43 found that that assumption was usually borne out. Most, you know, generally people, when you meet
00:21:49 them face to face, they are quite reasonable, but... Yeah, that's the Twitter is not real life
00:21:52 thesis, which I generally agree with. Yeah, exactly. But, you know, I was really struggling
00:21:57 with this. And I think part of the explanation is people who deploy the tools of cancel culture
00:22:03 I just take for granted that most people assume that truth is good and that in the case of a
00:22:12 dispute or a sort of moral contestation, you can engage in dialectical conversation where
00:22:18 both parties are aiming toward truth. And this is the means by which disagreements can be adjudicated.
00:22:24 But if you're dealing with people who don't believe truth is good,
00:22:28 then it has no moral weight. You can't appeal to it. It doesn't make any sense to try to say,
00:22:35 you know, what you're saying is untrue. They don't care. The point is to suppress truth in
00:22:40 the hopes that by doing so, you will create some space for a new reality, a supposedly better
00:22:45 reality to flourish. And so that's why cancel culture sort of undermines the fundamental logic
00:22:51 of civilization. It destroys even the most sort of fundamental means by which we might adjudicate
00:22:57 disagreements. But yeah, I mean, you see me like struggling with that at a very personal level in
00:23:01 the film. Well, and you mentioned something which I think was incredibly astute, which I hadn't
00:23:06 really thought of, which is that, and I'm going to butcher your line, so I won't pretend I'm
00:23:09 quoting it accurately, but the premise of it was that cancel culture only works if there's an
00:23:15 institutional application of it. And that, you know, everyone just shouting in the void about
00:23:19 how you are X or Y is not really cancel culture. It's when some other organ, whether it's a
00:23:24 political party or an employer or a media outlet decides we're going to apply this to reality. I
00:23:30 was wondering if you could elaborate on that a bit. Yeah, well, so, you know, there's kind of
00:23:33 two dimensions of cancel culture. There's the public shaming and the deplatforming. And cancel
00:23:37 culture is sort of when these two things come together. So the public shaming, so having people
00:23:42 sort of say terrible things about you on a very large scale, that is a devastating experience.
00:23:48 And anyone who has gone through it will know, even when it's just online, it affects you very
00:23:54 deeply, you know, triggers a sort of fight or flight response,
00:23:56 it makes you question your perception of reality and your
00:24:00 beliefs about yourself. So it's devastating. But what the sort
00:24:07 of mob aims to do is not just to humiliate you or harass you, it
00:24:12 is to appeal to authorities to strip you of your platform, your
00:24:17 livelihood, your ability to speak your ability to defend
00:24:19 yourself. So they're asking institutions, they're asking
00:24:23 people in positions of power, whether it's your employer or
00:24:26 media outlet or venue or whatever, in my case, a
00:24:28 political party and others, they're asking them to sort of
00:24:32 deperson you. And so the actual cancellation is only affected
00:24:35 through an act of institutional capitulation, it is you have to
00:24:39 have someone willing to submit to the demands of the mob for
00:24:44 this to actually be for it to work.
00:24:47 One of the things that I found quite interesting is that I
00:24:51 don't know if it was intentional on your part but there seems to be a bit of conflict even in the
00:24:55 way you discuss it about whether you did anything wrong and i think generally speaking you you are
00:25:00 of the mind or should be of the mind that you didn't but it's very easy when discussing it
00:25:04 to fall into that trap of wanting to make amends still yeah so look when um from my vantage point
00:25:12 it looked to me like the entire world was saying that i was a terrible person that i was morally
00:25:19 abhorrent you know people if you if you read the tweets carefully that appear on the screen you'll
00:25:23 see people saying you know your family should be so ashamed you deserve to be exiled it's great
00:25:27 you'll never work again the person who outed you is full of courage we should have more people like
00:25:33 him in politics things like this um and moreover like i said employers wouldn't wouldn't touch me
00:25:40 wouldn't respond to me like media wouldn't engage with me so you start to really doubt your
00:25:45 perception of reality and what happens when the outside world has seems to have one view and you
00:25:52 hold an internal perception that's different this creates a deep dissonance that you're naturally
00:25:58 going to try to want to resolve somehow and there's sort of three main ways that you can
00:26:03 try to resolve that you can either try to persuade the world to see things as you do
00:26:08 or you can adopt the world's view of you or you can go a kind of stoical approach where you
00:26:13 separate the internal from the external and you no longer rely on any kind of external validation
00:26:19 to tell you what's true just sort of guided by you know sort of faith in things unseen um and uh
00:26:25 and i kind of oscillate between all three of those and so you'll you know you'll see me really
00:26:30 grappling with well why are thousands of people demanding apologies from me why is a premier two
00:26:35 premiers and a mayor of a city and all of these news you know sort of media figures why are they
00:26:40 they all asking me to apologize for what and and I really grappled with this question and I would
00:26:47 ask people in earnest you know what what have I done wrong because I don't understand and I never
00:26:53 got an answer when you talk about the employer aspect of this I mean the one thing that that
00:27:00 really is the most jarring about cancel culture defenders of it will often say well it's not
00:27:05 about cancel culture it's consequence culture they say that you know it's the they almost
00:27:09 appeal actually to conservative language where they say well no it's you know it's about justice
00:27:14 it's about consequences it's about the idea of the marketplace of ideas and and the problem with that
00:27:20 is that no one who fuels this is interested in proportionality they they don't say you know you
00:27:26 sped so you should get a speeding ticket and pay it and move on with your life it's like everything's
00:27:30 the death penalty basically to use uh an extreme well i'm actually to be honest it's it's not even
00:27:35 all that extreme in some cases with how they view. And that's the problem here. So it's that even if
00:27:41 people believed you were unfit to be a candidate, which I don't feel was the case, that's not what
00:27:46 they wanted. They wanted you stripped of your party membership. They wanted you prevented from
00:27:49 working again. There would be people that would have said, I'm sure her family should disown her 1.00
00:27:54 and her friends should disown her. And if you were to get a job as a barista at Starbucks, that would 0.75
00:27:58 be offensive to them. And I was wondering if you could, not if you could, but if you have come up
00:28:04 with an explanation for why. Why is that the case? Why is it so extreme in a sense that I don't think
00:28:10 anyone could, if you were to talk to them one-on-one, explain how saying this thing, even if it was what
00:28:16 they claimed, warrants this outcome? So you've touched on one big aspect of what's wrong with
00:28:23 cancel culture, which is that it's not actually an administration of justice. It's not justice
00:28:28 because there's nothing resembling due process. There's no rules of evidence. There's no right to
00:28:33 a defense or presumption of innocence or all of these things that we would associate with or to
00:28:38 face your accuser right my i had you know an anonymous accuser and uh and i was um i was
00:28:44 further publicly shamed for identifying him i now have a restraining order against him
00:28:48 my case led to the recognition of a new tort of civil harassment in alberta
00:28:53 that was the person accusing me who was trumpeted as a hero in the media
00:28:58 So that's the deeper problem, is that cancel culture reflects a complete failure of clear moral reasoning. If you start to think that sort of quasi-criminal harassment is okay and defensible and good, if their target is someone who has an opinion you disagree with, then you are morally, like, you're, it's not that you're morally, you're morally and intellectually bankrupt if you think that.
00:29:24 So it's that the crimes that they identify don't make any sense. You never see people being cancelled for actual criminal acts. You see people being cancelled for often extremely ambiguous violations of emergent social norms, or social norms that a small minority wants to see sort of in ascendancy.
00:29:45 So I think that's the deeper problem, is that having an opinion or observing a fact or asking
00:29:54 a question in good faith is just not really a transgression that merits this. But on the other
00:30:02 side, the people who engage in cancel culture, I talked earlier about how it celebrates false
00:30:10 virtues at the expense of the real ones what i mean is that cancel culture aims to snuff out
00:30:16 loyalty charity forgiveness a commitment to truth a slowness to judge um you know friendship
00:30:25 solidarity all of these kinds of virtues are are suffocated in the climate created by cancel culture
00:30:32 and the fake sort of performative virtues are outrage you know a quickness to judge to believe
00:30:38 the worst of other people to listen to slander to make sure that that person is injured permanently
00:30:44 so that's i think the real problem with this phenomenon and it and it leads to a complete
00:30:49 breakdown you were talking earlier on your show about the long effects of covid it destroys social
00:30:54 trust and solidarity and sort of social comedy and cancel culture has the same effect there is
00:31:00 obviously this cultural and social dimension to your story and there's also a media story and i
00:31:06 I know there's a lawsuit underway that you've waged that touches on this.
00:31:10 But to further the discussion of just the lack of proportionality, it wasn't enough that, you know, these allegations had you dethroned from your spot as a candidate in perspective MLA.
00:31:21 But the deplatforming continued long after that.
00:31:24 Anytime you popped up to tell your story, like on Danielle Smith's show with me, even that was seen as offensive to the mob for you to have the right, even after you've already paid the price, to discuss it.
00:31:36 Yeah. So this is a plot point in the documentary, but the first public interview I did was on now Premier Daniel Smith's show. And the sort of NDP acolytes Progress Alberta, which was basically a sort of third party advertiser or PAC for the NDP, they put out a petition saying she should be driven off the air.
00:31:59 she needs to apologize, you know, they're going to go after their advertisers. Former Calgary
00:32:04 Mayor Nahid Nenshi was apparently was agreeing with the premise of this petition, telling
00:32:08 reporters that they should boycott her show. And then the person who was behind the accusations
00:32:14 against me also threatened legal action against them, Karim Devraj. And eventually they capitulated,
00:32:19 Khorus took down the interview from all their platforms, and something very similar happened
00:32:23 to you yep that's your cue to elaborate well it's i i don't to be honest i i don't know what more i
00:32:32 i can say on that i i mean it was it was very difficult for me because when you and i did that
00:32:37 interview i think it was almost an hour in in length uh it was very difficult to do for me as
00:32:43 well because i had gone through my own uh experience not as national as yours was in in 2018
00:32:48 And there was a bit of a catharsis in that conversation.
00:32:51 And then to have that sort of interview and not just, you know, sort of threatened with
00:32:56 legal action, but then even when you re-uploaded it on your own platform, that sort of continued
00:33:02 of, you know, I was sort of asked, why are you letting her do it?
00:33:05 I was like, I had nothing to do with it.
00:33:06 But it's, it struck me as just so profound.
00:33:12 It goes back to what you said about the lack of justice in this, that, you know, even someone
00:33:16 being able to defend themselves or or even not even defend because the damage had been done but
00:33:21 to put on record their side of the story was something that was continually taken away and
00:33:29 it's no it it i don't have words for it it's terrible yes it is and i guess my question to
00:33:39 you would be how much of that when you had people disowning you when you had media that kind of
00:33:45 was doing what we just described how much of that was from people that in your view knew it was all
00:33:52 nonsense and went along with it versus people that actually believed maybe there was a kernel of truth
00:33:57 to it um yeah the the difference between the expression the the public versus the private
00:34:03 opinions that people expressed was very stark um cancel culture is uh it's a preference falsification
00:34:09 machine. Because when you see all these people on Twitter sort of saying terrible things about you,
00:34:16 attack anyone who dares to defend you, or even sort of withhold judgment about you,
00:34:22 it creates a climate of terror that leads people to believe, well, it's not safe to support this
00:34:27 person. Now, that's a false appearance, because Twitter isn't representative of real life,
00:34:31 media is not representative of real life. In real life, people were, for the most part,
00:34:37 exceedingly generous kind I still get people to this day who will come up to me and say sorry
00:34:43 that for what happened to me um and it was the complete opposite in the sort of online and and
00:34:49 public realm people felt that they could not do this so uh you know the one one of the journalists
00:34:54 who tried writing a kind of investigative feature story about what what had actually happened here
00:34:59 he found it was very very challenging to get people willing to go on the record um that they
00:35:05 would privately say, you know, what an injustice, this is so
00:35:08 terrible. And they couldn't say so publicly. So, you know, you
00:35:13 sort of, you know, and speaking of like, where's the kind of the
00:35:17 moral that you know, the damage, I expect the NDP to behave the
00:35:22 way they behave, right? In a way, and there's an I have legal
00:35:28 recourse there. So I've, I've launched a $7 million defamation
00:35:31 suit against the CBC, the Toronto Star, the NDP, Progress
00:35:34 Alberta, all the others. Where there's no recourse and where there's no comprehension
00:35:39 is the betrayal of friends. And I don't know if you've had analogous experiences, but betrayal
00:35:45 is one of the strangest forms of suffering. It's one that can really turn into an internal
00:35:51 affliction because it remains incomprehensible. You can never ask people, why did you abandon me
00:35:57 in my hour of need, right? So that's actually the one that kind of cuts deeper.
00:36:02 yeah and and it also i mean for in my case it i i was fortunate that it didn't happen hugely the
00:36:09 bigger issue was people that were the quiet friends but you know they're only quiet friends
00:36:14 and and the challenge that i experienced was that the way that i could sort of reconcile
00:36:19 what was happening was that well everyone who knows me knows it's nonsense so so when someone
00:36:24 who does know you doesn't behave the way most of the people who know you are it does force you to
00:36:29 sort of question, wait, maybe, and it goes back to what we were talking about earlier, and you start
00:36:33 to internalize some of what other people are saying. And just to be more precise on the media
00:36:38 side of things, I'll say, and I'm not proud of this by any stretch, but litigation and the threat
00:36:43 of litigation are very powerful forces. I mean, when a company, be it True North or Chorus, is
00:36:48 served with a legal notice, I mean, it very much triggers that political impulse of, well,
00:36:54 you know, making it go away, because not everyone has the capacity or the bandwidth or the funds to
00:36:59 make everything the hill to die on. So you've actually turned around and have used this process
00:37:05 to seek justice. And I'm wondering if you were optimistic that that would work.
00:37:11 With the litigation? Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, for context, you and Chorus and one other podcast
00:37:20 were served with legal notice from Jivraj. Other podcasters were threatened with legal action. He
00:37:24 never pursued any of that. It's a bluff because everything that I've said was true. And he knows
00:37:29 that um but uh but you know it's if you're a small outlet that's a potent threat and um but i'm uh
00:37:38 now two years into discovery uh against some of the nation's biggest media outlets and um obviously i
00:37:45 can't say too much about that i don't want to breach the implied undertaking rule but um
00:37:51 i am more optimistic now having learned what i've learned than i was when i started this process
00:37:56 but it is a long process and it's very costly and you know that's kind of one of the perverse
00:37:59 ironies of being cancelled is if you're defamed in such a way that makes it difficult to earn a
00:38:04 livelihood it may take a decade and a half million dollars to use litigation to try to seek redress
00:38:12 for that so um so that's challenging but like i said i'm optimistic that it's a meritorious case
00:38:19 we have a clip from the documentary i want to show people and then we'll uh we'll wrap things
00:38:23 up in a moment but people can take a look at that right now she's surrounding a united
00:38:27 conservative party candidate has caused her to step down yes uh kaylin ford has resigned as a
00:38:33 ucp candidate in the riding of calgary mountain view after report claiming she echoed white
00:38:38 nationalist rhetoric what was shared was her private messages she was engaged in a facebook
00:38:43 chat with somebody the accusation was that she had said something in a private conversation that
00:38:50 had echoed the words of white supremacists.
00:38:54 Kaelin Ford says those Facebook messages were taken out of context.
00:38:58 The statement did not have one word of contrition, apology, or backing down from those statements.
00:39:04 The NDP has now started running attack ads, framing the United Conservative Party as intolerant.
00:39:09 I was utterly shocked to hear of the comments that that candidate, who was of course a star candidate for the UCP, made.
00:39:18 that is a bit of when the mob came featuring and produced by kaylin ford it comes out tonight
00:39:27 uh congratulations on this i know this has obviously been four years of your life now and
00:39:32 as we've discussed the story is still unfolding in in some ways but i'm glad you're standing up
00:39:37 and talking about this kaylin thanks for coming on today thank you adrew all right that is kaylin
00:39:42 forward we are just about out of time for today but it is friday so let's go to fake news friday
00:39:49 roll that stinger
00:39:51 yes fake news friday making our way through the blizzard of bombast the hurricane of
00:40:08 hilarity. I didn't write the alliterations ahead of time, so sometimes if I pick a weird
00:40:15 weather event, I don't know where to go from there. So I am the purveyor of fake news right
00:40:18 now. But today we do a follow-up on World Press Freedom Day. I mentioned on Wednesday the
00:40:24 brazen hypocrisy of Justin Trudeau's celebration of it, but one more takes the cake. This was a 0.70
00:40:30 tweet from Seamus O'Regan, who is a liberal minister, a former journalist himself, celebrating
00:40:36 World Press Freedom Day. Let's put that up on the screen there. He says, we have a free press in
00:40:42 Canada. We don't get to tell them what to write. We don't get to tell you what to read. Hashtag
00:40:48 World Press Freedom Day. Well, perhaps we can show this CBC story. Do we have the CBC story?
00:40:59 I don't think we have the CBC story. Okay. Well, the CBC story I can tell you about is the one of
00:41:04 Lorne Gunter's column being subject by the Liberal government trying to have it spiked
00:41:11 from social media. So Seamus O'Regan says, we don't tell journalists what to write,
00:41:15 we don't tell you what to read. Just three weeks after the federal government tried to literally
00:41:20 censor, literally censor, not just figuratively censor, literally censor an unflattering column
00:41:27 about the government's immigration policy. So Seamus O'Regan may not be a mainstream media
00:41:32 journalist, but he is still peddling fake news as a cabinet minister. That does it for us for today.
00:41:38 We'll talk to you all next week with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True
00:41:42 North. Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton
00:41:48 Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.