Juno News - June 06, 2023


WHO wants a global vaccine passport to "make travel easier"

Topics
Mentioned
Poilievre and Freeland spar over inflation Canadian corporations say digital ID is "necessary evolution"

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

180.27

Word count

7,392

Sentence count

309

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the wake of the World Health Organization's latest power grab, former Republican presidential candidate Michelle Bachman joins me to explain why she went to Geneva to speak out against it, and why the rest of the world should too.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by TrueNord.
00:00:10 Pretty much the only way to refer to it here.
00:00:14 It is a power grab by the World Health Organization.
00:00:17 Last week or two weeks ago, it might have been,
00:00:20 the World Health Assembly was, as the name suggests,
00:00:22 assembled in Geneva, Switzerland.
00:00:25 And they were talking about all these sorts of things
00:00:28 that on the surface sound nice they sound good they sound like the sorts of things that we are
00:00:34 all going to get behind they want to just facilitate movement around the world well
00:00:38 that's good who doesn't like traveling they want to talk about all of the ins and outs of making
00:00:43 life better or better protecting citizens and as we've heard time and time again over the last
00:00:49 several years when something is for your protection it generally comes at a cost a cost to your
00:00:55 mobility rights, a cost to your speech rights, a cost to your ability to make your own decisions
00:01:00 as a citizen. And to be honest, whatever you think of the COVID hysteria that has dominated much of
00:01:07 the world for much of the last three years, I would hope that everyone could kind of agree with
00:01:12 the fact that the World Health Organization has not been a credible voice on this or on anything.
00:01:17 It was great when their focus was on preventing malaria in the developing world, but now their
00:01:22 focus is preventing mobility everywhere in the world. This organization that would capitulate
00:01:29 literally and figuratively to China, that would literally hang up on a Taiwanese reporter that
00:01:35 dares to ask about Taiwan's inclusion in the World Health Organization, which in fairness,
00:01:40 if I were Taiwan, I wouldn't be pushing for at this point. And an organization that believes 1.00
00:01:45 it should be the sole decision maker on all of these things that affect the individual decisions
00:01:51 that should belong to individual people but increasingly we have governments that are
00:01:56 abdicating their obligation to their citizens and I would say their national sovereignty
00:02:00 to the World Health Organization so it's been curious that as the global leaders were talking
00:02:07 all about this stuff in Geneva there was very little mainstream media attention there was
00:02:12 very little attention at all I should say first and foremost I had been looking into going to
00:02:18 Geneva to cover it myself but when I looked at the agenda for the meetings and I looked at the
00:02:23 documents a lot of the stuff that people were interested in wasn't appearing there there wasn't
00:02:27 a lot of talk on the agenda about the global pandemic treaty that's coming into force next
00:02:32 year hopefully there wasn't a lot of discussion about global vaccine passports but the joke was
00:02:37 on me because all of these things were discussed they just didn't want to draw attention to them
00:02:42 well I'm glad that one woman who was there to shine a light on this is with us today Michelle
00:02:47 Bachman, former U.S. Congresswoman, former Republican presidential candidate, and now the
00:02:53 dean of the School of Government at Regent University joins me. She was in the belly of
00:02:58 the beast. And more importantly, she's also my cruise mate on the Mark Stein cruises the last
00:03:05 couple of years. And we're going to be sailing again in a few weeks time. Michelle, it is great
00:03:10 to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today. So good to be with you, Andrew. Thanks for having
00:03:14 me on today. So let's just start with why you went there, because I would imagine that you
00:03:20 were probably not a popular voice there as someone who is speaking out against a lot of the very
00:03:25 things that these people have been pushing for with, sadly, a fair bit of success the last few
00:03:30 years. Well, I wanted to go because of how consequential this meeting is. These kind of
00:03:36 meetings drive me crazy. I have no interest in being in meetings gobbledygook. Let's have a
00:03:42 bigger and better bureaucracy. But this is more than just changing a bureaucracy of the subset of
00:03:49 the United Nation dealing with health care. That's what this is. The United Nations health care arm
00:03:55 is called the World Health Organization. They've always been an advisory only body. And so countries
00:04:01 had the ability to just reject whatever they said or adopt it if they thought this was a good thing.
00:04:08 and it was fairly a fairly inconsequential organization you can see the good altruistic
00:04:14 purpose for it if there's an area in the world that needs help nations of the world can band
00:04:20 together to try and help that area that's all good but now this is a malevolent plan to take
00:04:27 the world health organization and supercharge it to the global surveillance system the global
00:04:34 tracking system uh the global tracing system of all people on earth and we had that not only in
00:04:41 geneva but an announcement was made yesterday andrew from the european commission basically
00:04:47 in brussels and the european union they made an announcement together with the world health
00:04:53 organization that the world health organization would adopt the global digital passports that
00:05:00 have been created in brussels for the use of the 80 nations in the european union but now the world
00:05:07 health organization is going to take that example of a global digital passport where everyone has
00:05:13 a digital id on their phone and they've got a qr code and then will be tracked and traced by all
00:05:20 of that that announcement was made yesterday this is very curious to me because at the g20 last
00:05:27 november the health minister of indonesia made this very casual offhand remark at the at the g20
00:05:34 that the top g20 nations have gotten together we've all decided we're going to have global
00:05:39 digital passports they will be put forth by the world health organization will adopt amendments
00:05:46 in may in geneva and we're just going to go ahead and have this surveillance well
00:05:50 it didn't happen in geneva and so they waited till after all of the votes were taken if they
00:05:57 took any votes they didn't take any votes on the proposed 307 amendments to the international
00:06:02 health rules they didn't take any votes on the global pandemic treaty they waited until about
00:06:07 a week after the whole shebang was over and then they announced in a press release oh by the way
00:06:14 we're going to empower the world health organization now they're going to be the
00:06:18 ones in charge of this digital health care passport and we will be and they'll be the
00:06:24 the ones in the process of tracking and tracing and surveilling the rest of us and giving
00:06:29 permission if we can get on a public conveyance like a plane and go somewhere while they also
00:06:36 call the shots on what literally what vaccines we have to have and boosters and whatever they
00:06:41 come up with. Yeah, I'm glad you mentioned that timeline because I was just saying in my intro
00:06:47 on this segment that I looked at the agenda and ultimately decided it wasn't going to be worth
00:06:51 going because the things they were talking about on the agenda were not the things that we're
00:06:55 talking about now. And as I said, I mean, foolish on my part, because ultimately this was exactly 0.62
00:07:01 the purpose. But you're right that they do it in this way where I have to assume that the public 0.89
00:07:06 agenda was taking place alongside this parallel agenda where these folks were all talking behind
00:07:11 closed doors and all agreeing to what then gets announced two weeks later that no one voted on,
00:07:17 was not subject to scrutiny, people could not really question it about. And this is really
00:07:21 the story of the WHO, is it not? That, you know, they say they're this democratic body,
00:07:26 the product of states, but really all the action seems to take place outside of that democratic
00:07:31 forum. Oh, it does. You're right. We're living in a post-democratic environment. That's what the
00:07:37 WHO is. They despise the issue of democracy and of the delegates that were there. As a matter of
00:07:43 fact, it was 194 nations, essentially all nations on earth who are members of the WHO, and they
00:07:51 were all like a bunch of bobblehead dolls. Every single one of the delegates were reading off of
00:07:57 basically the same script. They used the word urgent, inclusion, equity. In other words,
00:08:04 we're going to have outcome-based socialized medicine for the world, a concept known as
00:08:08 universal health. So socialized medicine for the world, everybody gets the same level of health
00:08:13 care. And so all these little poorer nations think, great, this will be wonderful. We'll all
00:08:19 get American style health care. What they don't realize is that health care is about to be
00:08:24 downgraded, particularly in the West, and it'll be outcome based. So no one is getting high quality
00:08:31 health care, except for the John Carey's of the world and the elites of the world will have their
00:08:37 own health care system. And as a matter of fact, that was one of the shocking things to me. You're
00:08:42 right. The main event didn't happen in conferences A or B or the plenary sessions, where the real
00:08:51 rubber hit the road. We're in these strategic round tables, kind of optional meetings. But
00:08:57 they clearly laid out their timeline, their content, their strategy. And they talked about
00:09:03 the 307 amendments to the international health rules. The fellow in charge of passing them is
00:09:09 Dr. Abdullah Asiri. And he said, well, during the next pandemic, and they all talked about the next
00:09:15 pandemic. Remember, it was 100 years from the Spanish flu until COVID. But they're talking 0.96
00:09:20 about the next pandemic. They talk about it as though it's like coming out next week. I mean,
00:09:24 they got excited about monkeypox because they thought they had like another thing that they
00:09:28 could get involved in. Yeah, no, exactly. And Dr. Asiri said, you know, we can't with the next
00:09:35 pandemic, we can't use the old international health rules. We have to have new, bold, strong
00:09:41 health rules. Because the problem with the last pandemic was civil liberties. People had too many
00:09:47 civil liberties. So we've got to diminish and take away people's civil liberties. You can find this,
00:09:54 you can go to who.int, click on 76 World Health Assembly, and then look at the strategic round
00:10:02 tables the very first one on monday and you too can hear dr siri say the problem is too many civil
00:10:08 liberties and we got got to get rid of them one of the amendments does just that they scratch out the
00:10:14 words in the international health rules human freedom human dignity protection of civil liberties
00:10:22 that's gone this is a post-democratic world all they care about is empowering the world health
00:10:29 organization. So it really is the global Gestapo is probably a terrible word, but the global police,
00:10:38 if you will, for health care, they call the shots, not the individual nation states anymore on
00:10:45 health care decisions, or the ability to call an emergency. Remember, in the United States,
00:10:51 for instance, we lived under emergency powers for three years, emergency powers were only recently
00:10:58 lifted may 11th of 2023 this would give the right to dictate emergency powers to the world health
00:11:06 organization and then they can virtually do anything they want let me ask you michelle why
00:11:13 countries are not more resistant to this because i mean theoretically a country could do what the
00:11:19 united states was going to do had donald trump been re-elected which is withdraw from the who
00:11:23 entirely. They have that right. But what we saw was countries increasingly abdicating their own
00:11:30 decision-making to the WHO. I mean, we also saw corporations do that. I mean, if you were
00:11:34 to have a conversation about COVID on YouTube, YouTube is going to throw up a misinformation
00:11:39 label and they're going to say, you know, you violated what the World Health Organization sets
00:11:44 out as being best practices. So why were countries doing this? Because surely individual nation
00:11:49 states realize that this is not in their best interest to give this much power to an unelected
00:11:54 non-doctor bureaucrat, that Tedros Adhanom guy? Well, it's a few things, Andrew. We all know that
00:12:02 the Communist Party of China has global reach and global ambitions, and they've been, with their
00:12:08 Belt and Road Initiative, buying off Latin American countries, South American countries,
00:12:13 African countries. So they go in. Even some European countries. The Belt and Road is global 0.98
00:12:18 now yeah it is it's a global effort and they will say well we'll we'll pay for this airport for you
00:12:24 we'll pay for this highway for you we will uh take care of this infrastructure with you you just sign
00:12:30 here on the dotted line for your loan wink wink and we'll put this in for you well a lot of these
00:12:37 countries are used to loan forgiveness the united states for instance has done a lot of loan
00:12:42 forgiveness china isn't quite there they're not the ones who are going to do the loan forgiveness 0.96
00:12:47 So the number one entity that calls the shots of the World Health Organization is the Communist Party of China.
00:12:54 And so this is something that they want because this is the Chinese system.
00:12:58 This is the Chinese social credit system.
00:13:02 It is how China controls their own people. 0.99
00:13:05 So now this system that China has in place, this digital surveillance, is exactly what's being implemented through the WHO, only it's meant for all nations globally.
00:13:16 Why would the United States do this? Joe Biden was the lead aggressor a year ago trying to introduce 29 amendments to completely pivot the purpose of the WHO away from being an advisory-only body to be a regulatory and enforcement body when it came to health emergencies.
00:13:37 So that was last year, then Botswana and a few African nations objected. So we got a reprieve for a year, but we really didn't because behind the scenes, they were putting all of this into place.
00:13:50 And then this year, when I went, I fully expected that they would pass these amendments and pass the Global Pandemic Treaty. It was clear from day one, they were not going to pass it, they were going to wait until 2024. But that's a head fake, Andrew, because one week after they ended the World Health Assembly, they had a press conference yesterday, or they issued a press release, and announced that the WHO would take over the Global Digital Passport.
00:14:20 And that's really all you need for effectively global governance or global surveillance, because if the WHO controls the terms and the enforcement, they really are creating a platform for global governance.
00:14:35 and they're doing it through the global digital passport
00:14:38 because you're not traveling.
00:14:40 You're not getting on a plane.
00:14:41 You're not able to do things you are used to doing
00:14:44 unless your QR code is up to date
00:14:48 and approved by the WHO.
00:14:51 Yeah, and the way they couch it in all of these things
00:14:54 is about being for your convenience.
00:14:57 They basically say that you do this
00:14:59 and it's gonna make it a little bit more helpful.
00:15:01 You know, the airline that I travel with more often than not,
00:15:03 they've done this digital ID pilot project where when you log in, they say, oh, if you'd like,
00:15:08 you can do a facial scan on your phone and then you can actually board the airplane more
00:15:13 conveniently because we'll just take a picture of your face there and that will open the gate. 0.98
00:15:18 And it's like, I'm looking at this and I'm saying, first off, the voluntary never stays voluntary.
00:15:22 So this little like thing you can try if you want is going to become mandatory and, you know,
00:15:27 six months time. But also when you trade away things in the name of convenience,
00:15:31 you will end up realizing that it had nothing to do with that.
00:15:35 That was just PR.
00:15:36 And that's the whole thing with these global vaccine passports.
00:15:39 We shouldn't be making it easy for states and IOs like the WHO to standardize this stuff.
00:15:46 Well, this is really serious, Andrew.
00:15:49 People need to understand how far down the road this is.
00:15:53 Global socialized medicine isn't pretty.
00:15:57 And that's what they plan.
00:15:59 universal health being global socialized medicine the criterion for health care decisions is a
00:16:05 concept known as one health and they had a diagram and the diagram includes man animals
00:16:12 the environment and so when you look into it the health care criterion is man is worth no more is
00:16:20 no more valuable than an animal man is no more valuable than a lump of dirt so it's essentially
00:16:26 man equals a cockroach each equals a lump of dirt but i have to jump in there so for canadians that
00:16:34 deal with wait times now we have to wait behind a tree for our surgery basically well basically
00:16:40 because now at this point the uh john kerry made an appearance at this uh world health assembly
00:16:47 and both dr tedros gibratius and john kerry said that you know we had focused on infectious
00:16:55 diseases. Well, yeah, three years, COVID-19, we'd focused on infectious diseases, but now we're
00:17:01 going to turn away from that. Now we're going to pivot and we're going to focus on climate change.
00:17:05 And really here's the bottom line. These climate change people have been desperate to put a
00:17:12 control system into place, effectively a global government on the basis of climate change.
00:17:17 Nobody bought it for 60 or 70 years. Nobody cared. They didn't buy it. But after COVID,
00:17:24 These climate change people saw how effective you could control people globally through health care. So on day two of the strategic roundtable, John Kerry comes in and he says, you know, I didn't realize that that health care is really driven by climate change.
00:17:43 I had no idea until my daughter told me.
00:17:46 And so Dr. Tedros Ghebreyesus said the same thing.
00:17:49 Yet we're going to pivot away from infectious diseases.
00:17:52 Our number one priority now at World Health is climate change.
00:17:57 And that's what John Kerry said.
00:17:59 So now the number one factor for the WHO will be, can we keep the earth's temperature at rising no more than 1.5 degrees?
00:18:09 so in that case the lump of dirt equals a cockroach equals mankind what that says is
00:18:17 the lump of dirt is going to win every time so whatever it is that the elites who control the
00:18:23 world health organization want they will make the decisions it's not up to the 194 nations anymore
00:18:31 it's up to these elites because in the global pandemic treaty they create this little group
00:18:36 of elites called like the council of the parties or the commission of the parties, something like
00:18:41 that. And they irrigate to themselves perpetual rulemaking authority. They never have to meet
00:18:48 again for the World Health Assembly. This little commission on the parties will meet with
00:18:54 perpetual authority and they'll just create the rules to give the WHR more power and more power 0.81
00:19:01 and more power and the sick thing is that led by joe biden in the united states all these nations
00:19:09 are willingly voluntarily giving up their sovereignty over health care decision making
00:19:15 it is a fatal ridiculous tragic decision and so you know you may have a global audience i hope you
00:19:24 do andrew because people in other countries people in canada this is the time now to wake up
00:19:30 and realize we're very far down the road with this thing because now the world health organization
00:19:37 is calling the shots for the eu and they're already announcing they're going to call the
00:19:42 shots for all of the other nations that join in on this global digital passport and the ability
00:19:49 to travel is contained in that our health records will be contained in it most likely our digital
00:19:54 currency will be contained in it perhaps even the right to buy and sell will be contained in it
00:20:00 It's extremely serious. And it's how you can control people. And it's already off the ground.
00:20:06 And yesterday they made the announcement that the WHO was controlling this without a vote.
00:20:13 They just grabbed the power. You know, if I were the leader of an African medical group, 0.99
00:20:18 I'd be very angry that no one cares about the HIV outbreak anymore. No one cares about the
00:20:24 malaria outbreak that they all care about, you know, shutting down oil refineries in Alberta
00:20:28 and West Virginia or wherever they are.
00:20:32 Michelle Bachman, I'm so glad you went there
00:20:33 when no one else in the world
00:20:35 was interested in covering this.
00:20:37 It's wonderful to see you again.
00:20:38 Thanks so much for coming on today.
00:20:40 Thanks, Andrew.
00:20:41 All right, that is former presidential candidate
00:20:44 Michelle Bachman.
00:20:44 As I said, my cruise mate on the Mark Stein cruise,
00:20:47 which I know a few folks are going to be coming along.
00:20:49 That's just in a few weeks time.
00:20:51 So when I'm away for a couple of weeks in a little while,
00:20:53 you'll know it's because I'm singing some duet
00:20:56 with Michelle Bachman up in the Crow's Nest,
00:20:58 which you think I'm joking, actually happened last time.
00:21:01 And hopefully there's no video of it, not because she was bad, because I was.
00:21:04 We are going to talk about this a little bit more.
00:21:07 And I think in the context that we were talking about with climate there,
00:21:11 it is a perfect segue into this other discussion.
00:21:14 We know that Canada has committed itself, as have many countries around the world,
00:21:19 to this idea of net zero, which means we are supposedly going to get down to net zero
00:21:24 in our carbon emissions by the number keeps changing 2035 2030 I think it's supposed to be
00:21:31 next week or something if you give them enough time they just keep moving it closer and closer
00:21:35 and the way we get there is always the key it's one thing to just set a target and set a date on
00:21:41 a calendar and say net zero by x time on x day of x year it's another thing when you talk about
00:21:46 what that actually means on the ground and we see no shortage of quite radical proposals put forward
00:21:52 in the name of achieving net zero, and most of them end up coming down to that idea of a just
00:21:58 transition, of just transitioning our economy away from one that involves oil and gas without any
00:22:04 real alternative proposed. Well, one that we have talked about, which has been proposed by folks in
00:22:10 the oil and gas sector, is this idea of carbon capture. Now, I am not going to insult you by
00:22:16 describing probably poorly the scientific basis of it but carbon capture is essentially this idea
00:22:23 of not ceasing the production of things that result in carbon emissions but rather finding
00:22:29 ways to harness and capture that carbon those carbon emissions and doing so in a way that they
00:22:34 still contribute to the overall goal of reducing emissions so let's talk about this in a bit of
00:22:40 context because there is a little bit of criticism of carbon capture and some of it was put forward
00:22:45 in a recent piece that was co-authored by a gentleman who joins me now, Dr. Kenneth Green,
00:22:51 who is a senior fellow at the Fraser Institute. Kenneth, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming
00:22:56 on today. Good to be with you. Now, I admit not being a scientist, I've bought into some of the
00:23:01 hype on carbon capture because it's kind of proposed by conservative politicians, by people
00:23:06 in the oil and gas sector as being this market-friendly way of achieving the government's
00:23:12 goals, which if you accept the goals or at the very least are not optimistic that those goals
00:23:17 are going anywhere, it's a better alternative than, say, just outlawing the industry, which is,
00:23:24 I think, where a lot of the activists want. But you're a bit of a skeptic.
00:23:27 Yes, I am. And I'd love to get back to the other topic you were talking about, which is
00:23:31 all the environmental measures that are coming on have the same pattern of implementation that
00:23:36 you can actually understand them by looking at how they're implemented rather than what they're
00:23:39 supposed to do. But back on carbon capture and storage, I am a skeptic of this. I view it as,
00:23:44 and I discuss it as a fig leaf that's appealing to many, many people. First of all, there is a
00:23:49 little grain of truth, a nugget of truth in there, which is oil companies have been using the idea
00:23:54 of taking carbon dioxide, re-injecting it into old wells and old fields to push up more oil and gas.
00:24:02 They've been doing that, that's carbon storage part. They've been doing that for decades and it
00:24:06 works well. And so there's a small reality there, which is somebody can say, look, they've taken
00:24:11 many, many tons of CO2 and put it into the ground and it stays there. And so it's technologically
00:24:17 feasible. But it's a fig leaf because really it's not feasible to capture carbon dioxide
00:24:24 emissions from power plants or from agriculture or from any other source, capture them, bind them
00:24:30 chemically, store them somewhere underground at any kind of scale that would have any impact
00:24:36 at all on global greenhouse gas emissions or air concentrations or warming or anything
00:24:42 else.
00:24:43 But it's a fig leaf because governments, as you said, when conservative governments get
00:24:48 to say, we have an alternative to your socialist net zero 2050 plan, which is technology made
00:24:56 by good old-fashioned, private Canadian companies,
00:24:59 carbon capture and storage is one of those things.
00:25:02 So they love it because it's a good figly for them.
00:25:04 The industry loves it because they get to say,
00:25:06 even though they know they really can't reduce emissions
00:25:08 very much anymore because of by efficiencies,
00:25:11 they've plumbed the depths of how efficient they can be
00:25:14 and they're way efficient, right?
00:25:16 But they've hit the limits on that.
00:25:17 So it's a figly for them to say,
00:25:19 we listen, we get it, we hear it.
00:25:21 You don't want us emitting carbon dioxide in the air.
00:25:24 So we'll do this carbon capture and storage thing.
00:25:27 And so now let us keep operating, let us stay in business, right?
00:25:30 So you'll like it.
00:25:31 The environmentalist groups like it because it's a figly for them that when they get to
00:25:34 a negotiation where companies are saying and have proven that a proposed environmental
00:25:39 plan is completely unaffordable and they'll simply have to go out of business, the
00:25:43 environmentalist can say, we'll give you this little loophole of you can pretend that carbon
00:25:47 capture and storage is going to work and that we're going to actually let you go ahead and
00:25:51 do it so that you can to take away your ability to claim that you're going out of business but
00:25:57 they really never have any intention of allowing the kind of environmental disruption it would take
00:26:00 to do carbon capture and storage so it's sort of a universal fig leaf everybody loves it but
00:26:05 nobody believes it's actually going to happen um and and there's with good reason it's never going
00:26:11 to happen now does your skepticism extend to kind of related phenomena like carbon recycling these
00:26:17 other things that we also hear about as being ways to just reduce the carbon in the atmosphere
00:26:22 without reducing it at source? Well, yes. I mean, I wouldn't call it skepticism. In this case,
00:26:28 it's really simply an understanding of physics, right? Carbon dioxide, the best way to understand
00:26:33 carbon dioxide, which you breathe out every time you exhale, is it's a waste gas. That means there's
00:26:39 no energy inherent in it. It's a stable chemical that really has no energy inherent in it that you
00:26:45 can you can exploit so to do anything with it you have to pump energy in to trap it to bind it to
00:26:51 split it apart in order to do anything with it and that means the very idea that you're going to
00:26:56 somehow use that to reduce your energy production is silly right you're actually going to have to
00:27:01 pump more energy in to to bind co2 than to leave it alone and so yeah i'm generally skeptical of
00:27:08 anything that claims to be taking co2 and making anything useful out of it because it is essentially
00:27:13 a planetary waste, which has no energy potential for exploiting, is mostly inert. It's chemically
00:27:20 inert. And so, yeah, I'm generally dubious, not to say skeptical, but I'm scientifically
00:27:27 and engineering dubious of those kind of claims. So what would be a better policy then,
00:27:34 if I can just put you on the spot there? Or is it basically challenging the premise
00:27:38 that we need to go after it this way in the first place?
00:27:43 Well, I think a better policy is moving our focus away from controlling the global thermostat
00:27:59 by indirect control of gas emissions. We can barely measure well, much less control,
00:28:05 that being greenhouse gases and CO2. And we should shift our focus to asking
00:28:10 if the climate is warming or cooling or is more variable than we ever thought it was,
00:28:15 which we know, how can we make ourselves as societies more adaptive, more resilient,
00:28:21 and better able to deal with whatever climate future eventuates, right? It happens to us.
00:28:27 And we can do a lot of that with conventional engineering, conventional economics.
00:28:31 We don't have to be using, invoking speculative technologies to do that.
00:28:35 Sea level rise. Countries, the Netherlands and others, have dealt with rising sea levels and
00:28:40 sea levels above their land decades and centuries. The Romans dealt with moving massive amounts of
00:28:47 water from areas that had water to areas that didn't have water. So we can deal with drought.
00:28:51 We can move things around. We can harden areas. California's earthquake damage. I grew up in
00:28:57 California. My first earthquake experience in 1969, I was eight years old, nine years old.
00:29:01 the Silmar earthquake destroyed massive amounts of the San Fernando Valley. By today's standards,
00:29:08 an earthquake much stronger than that, hundreds of times stronger than that, would not do anywhere
00:29:12 close to the level of damage that was done before because we learn. Engineering, technology, we do
00:29:17 learn. And so we could be addressing the risks of climate change, flooding, drought, heat waves,
00:29:23 cold spells, whatever you want to call it through conventional technology locally, globally as well.
00:29:30 But instead, the world, for reasons I can't get into, I'd love to, but for political reasons,
00:29:37 has chosen this laser focus on controlling the greenhouse gases and explicitly doing so
00:29:43 only through redistribution of wealth. That's the part I would get to on a whole program,
00:29:46 which is when you dig down into every program and you can ask,
00:29:50 what's the root thing that in this program the government will not do without? It's the
00:29:56 component that says we're going to take the money from these people and give it to our constituents
00:30:00 who will vote for us who like our agenda and so um well just to add to that that's also baked in
00:30:07 even at the global level as well it's you know within countries like canada it's redistribution
00:30:11 of wealth then on the global scale it's redistribution of wealth from canada to
00:30:15 tubaloo or something well it has been since the united nations framework convention on climate
00:30:19 change the very first treaty ever signed created the principle that developed countries would go
00:30:24 first and that developed countries would fund the transition for the developing countries by giving
00:30:30 them, giving being the operative term, technologies and money, massive wealth transfers in order for
00:30:36 them to build out their energy systems and things without producing greenhouse gas emissions.
00:30:43 That was actually the central operating principle of the very first climate agreement
00:30:47 and has stayed the central operating principle of every climate agreement ever since,
00:30:51 regardless of the fact that China moved from developing country to developed and is by far
00:30:56 the biggest greenhouse gas transmitter in the world and will be over time overwhelmingly the
00:31:02 world's largest contributor to the increase of greenhouse gases around the world, it's still
00:31:07 based. The Paris Accord, the previous UN Accords are all based. The central operating principle is
00:31:15 redistribution of global wealth. There is an aspect to this that you touched on a couple of
00:31:20 answers ago about the difficulty in even measuring objectively and accurately emissions. And I think
00:31:27 also global temperature is one I've seen some criticism about. So, you know, we pin so much
00:31:32 on those two metrics, the idea of, you know, global temperature right now, we've, you know,
00:31:36 got to get to no more than 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels is the goal. But
00:31:42 measuring global temperature is not as ironclad and objective as the UN likes to say, and nor is
00:31:47 the measurement of admissions no and it's funny you should mention that but we have a study coming
00:31:52 out of the fraser institute in oh the next couple of weeks a month well i'm excited comparing
00:31:57 comparing whether we should be using measurements of the climate or models computer models of the
00:32:01 climate in order to make our decisions about what policies to implement with regard to climate
00:32:06 change so you can look for that fraser institute uh www.fraserinstitute.com now they'll love me
00:32:12 even more, which is good. But back to your question, I mean, yes, measurement of climate
00:32:18 is a problem that you can't just stick a thermometer into the atmosphere and wave it
00:32:21 around to get the temperature of the earth any more than you can get the actual temperature of
00:32:26 a room you're in. If you think about the room you're in, it's warmer towards the ceiling,
00:32:29 it's colder towards the floor, near the air conditioning vents, it's colder still,
00:32:33 over by the window, it's warm. How would you compute just the temperature of your room?
00:32:38 Well, it'd be a huge exercise dividing your room into little squares,
00:32:41 taking in that temperature at the center of each square doing a spatial average and try to do that
00:32:46 for the globe so yes humility is definitely um required in in asking the question can we know
00:32:53 the earth's average temperature of the atmosphere the average temperature of the earth's atmosphere
00:32:58 on the other hand the modeling the question of can we model it with a computer is even more absurd
00:33:05 right so it is true the temperature measurements are i mean i i would not want to depend upon them
00:33:12 for some sort of industrial process that had to be tightly controlled like making chips i wouldn't
00:33:16 just say that level of measurement would be good enough for me but it's better than simply running
00:33:21 a computer model that looks like a video game and saying wow in this one in this scenario the rcp
00:33:26 8.5 uh the world gets super hot and zombies take over okay well yeah we'll go with that one so um
00:33:33 Well, and this brings the fact that the famous hockey stick graph, which I think it was a Paul
00:33:38 Martin that mailed out a copy to like every Canadian household. And it's been the subject
00:33:43 of, you know, vociferous debate and even litigation on that. But again, I mean, we've seen,
00:33:49 to go back to the COVID question, the perils of modeling, which, you know, what you get out of
00:33:54 it is no better and in some cases worse than what you put into it. And I'm even more glad you
00:33:59 mention that because I have a book out called The Plague of Models. That's by me, Kenneth P.
00:34:03 Green. You can get it on Google Play. I am proudly censored by Amazon, which is not allowing works
00:34:07 on COVID policy that are contrary to get through unless you have divine intervention or the
00:34:12 intervention of somebody like Elon Musk in order to get your book approved. But you can get mine
00:34:17 on Google Play, The Plague of Models. And basically, it talks about exactly this. In the 1970s,
00:34:21 here's the thing. In the 1970s, computers got cheap and labs got expensive. And so people
00:34:27 started replacing, and regulators wanted to move really fast on regulations and rules,
00:34:32 much faster than they could based on laboratory experiments done in traditional laboratories with
00:34:37 scientists working on liquid wet chemistry and biology and things. So models increasingly took
00:34:43 over as evidence, but they're not evidence. A model actually takes away information,
00:34:48 doesn't give you more, right? A picture of a supermodel doesn't tell you much about the actual 1.00
00:34:53 person. A picture of a truck doesn't tell you that much about the actual truck. A picture of
00:34:58 Bugs Bunny doesn't tell you anything about the actual behavior of rabbits, right? Those are
00:35:02 models. And so when we moved to models and away from research, we took this huge step into
00:35:10 speculation and it's across the board. It's on almost virtually any topic that you see a chart
00:35:16 or a graph on. Any model that actually projects into the future is inherently modeled, right?
00:35:22 since nobody has a crystal ball. So all of these things saying, by 2050, we're going to do this.
00:35:27 By 2050, our emissions are going to go like this. By 2050, the temperature is going to go like that.
00:35:30 By 2050, this is going to happen. That's going to happen. All of that is completely speculative
00:35:34 based on assumptions about the world. There's no data in it. It's right. It's originally a data
00:35:40 free exercise. And so we have to be very wary of anything based on modeling. As you said, COVID
00:35:46 being a case in point. Curiously, as people will notice in my book,
00:35:50 people are blaming the wrong models for the problem with COVID. The initial models of how
00:35:55 lethal it was were more accurate than you'd think. But the models suggesting that the
00:35:59 measures like lockdowns, masks, social distancing, that those things would work,
00:36:05 those models were horrible. And those models were relied upon for the governments to say,
00:36:10 yeah, we want to do these crackdowns because this model says, this will flatten the curve,
00:36:14 right? Trudeau would say, plank the curve. He had to get cutesy with the whole planking thing,
00:36:19 because you know he did that when he first ran for office yeah yeah so uh the whole plank the
00:36:24 curve flatten the curve thing was based on modeling that's that said that these measures
00:36:29 um of masking distancing staying at home closing schools would slow the spread of covid even though
00:36:36 historically we knew that the evidence from all previous infectious diseases and recorded where
00:36:43 where there is evidence, we knew those would not work. We knew those would not work. So
00:36:48 that's the COVID scandal part, which again, you can read about.
00:36:53 Yeah. And just, you know, I remember an episode of the West Wing a while ago where, you know,
00:36:57 the president was sitting with a couple of economists and asking them for their predictions
00:37:00 of what was going to happen. And, you know, one says, you know, we're going to, you know,
00:37:04 the economy is going to get better. One says, we're going to go to a recession. The third says,
00:37:07 we're going to hold. And he's like, two of you are going to look very stupid in six months time, 1.00
00:37:11 which I think is a pretty good way of summing up, you know, how unscientific some of these so-called scientific measures are. 0.83
00:37:19 Well, it's a fascinating piece and a fascinating topic, and I look forward to the ones that are coming down the pipeline,
00:37:24 especially as you've been able to tease some stuff I didn't even know about that's coming up.
00:37:28 Dr. Kenneth Green, Senior Fellow with the Fraser Institute, thank you so much.
00:37:32 A pleasure to be with you today.
00:37:33 All right. Thanks very much.
00:37:34 I didn't realize when I started off on the show today that there would be such continuity from the first topic to the second topic.
00:37:41 But as we were discussing with Michelle and then with Kenneth, the reality is the COVID playbook is now becoming the climate playbook.
00:37:50 And one of the things, I should have brought this up with Michelle, in the U.S. and specifically its military history for the last, I don't know, 30 years or so, you hear this term mission creep, which is basically when the mission just creeps from its stated objective to something else over time.
00:38:06 And World Health Organization, Politburo, mission creep is insane.
00:38:12 And I would say public health mission creep in general.
00:38:14 It used to be that public health offices were telling you, you know what, you should wear a condom so you don't pass chlamydia around.
00:38:22 Or they were saying you should get your flu shot every year so you don't get the flu.
00:38:25 And it was a fairly safe, stable, predictable message that you'd get time and time again.
00:38:32 And as soon as I say that, I know there are going to be people saying the flu shot's not safe.
00:38:36 The point I'm making is that public health really was an afterthought for many, many years.
00:38:40 And the World Health Organization was an afterthought for many, many years.
00:38:44 You didn't need to think about it.
00:38:45 Then they got a taste of power.
00:38:47 The World Health Organization, the public health bureaucrats,
00:38:50 they got a taste of power that they've never had in their lives before,
00:38:54 and they do not want to let go of it.
00:38:56 So it is no secret that there's been this public healthification
00:39:00 of pretty much everything since then all of a sudden climate is now a public health issue
00:39:05 the one that you see and the world health organization literally uses this word
00:39:09 an infodemic when they believe that information the flow of information should be treated the way
00:39:17 a virulent disease is and that's why they now think that misinformation is a new pandemic in
00:39:23 need of regulations you need to flatten the curve of misinformation by which they mean information
00:39:28 that runs contrary to their own edicts and proclamations,
00:39:32 even though their own edicts and proclamations run contrary to their edicts and proclamations
00:39:36 from three, four, five months earlier.
00:39:39 So all of a sudden, yeah, you have to be more worried about it.
00:39:41 I would love to go back to not having to think about it.
00:39:43 I would love to have to go back.
00:39:45 I would love to be able to go back to not even knowing the name of my local medical officer of health.
00:39:50 But you don't get that luxury.
00:39:52 And you look at some of them that were getting hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars a year
00:39:56 and providing some just insane recommendations.
00:40:00 The one up in Peel region that said,
00:40:03 if you have a sick child,
00:40:03 you should lock them in your bedroom, 0.56
00:40:05 in their bedroom, basically.
00:40:06 And this stuff was entirely normalized in the COVID era.
00:40:10 People saying don't have unvaccinated relatives over
00:40:12 for Thanksgiving dinner, for Christmas dinner.
00:40:15 This is what the public health bureaucracy brought us.
00:40:18 And now this level of power,
00:40:21 this level of intrusion,
00:40:22 this level of control is coming in the name
00:40:24 of flattening the climate curve.
00:40:26 So you better be warned.
00:40:28 Thanks to Michelle Bachman and Kenneth Green for coming on the show and sharing what, again,
00:40:32 I thought were going to be unrelated insights, but ended up weaving a common thread.
00:40:37 So we always enjoy when we get to have some continuity on the show.
00:40:40 That does it for us for today.
00:40:42 We'll be back tomorrow with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show here on True North.
00:40:47 Thank you.
00:40:47 God bless and good day to you all.
00:40:52 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:40:54 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.