Juno News - April 13, 2024


Why conservatives should reject the left's premises on climate | CSFN Day 3

Topics
Mentioned
What's happening to Canadian cities? | CSFN Day 2 Conservative plan could lower immigration levels

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 3 minutes

Words per minute

174.76

Word count

11,013

Sentence count

385

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Franco Tarazzoni of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation and Chris Sims of the Tax Foundation joins the show to talk about the federal government's massive deficits and the impact they're having on our everyday lives. Andrew Lawton is the host of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show on the Global Bureau of Reverence's annual rankings.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 Thank you.
00:04:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:04:30 Thank you.
00:05:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:05:26 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:05:30 Hello and welcome to you all, Canada's most irreverent talk show here.
00:05:37 We once again renewed our irreverence on the Global Bureau of Irreverence's annual rankings.
00:05:43 We are out irreverenting everyone, and we are so irreverent we're doing a rare Friday show.
00:05:48 We're going to kick back and let loose from the exhibition hall at the Canada Strong and Free Network's annual conference in Ottawa.
00:05:55 Now, as you saw from the arm that protruded in front of my shot there,
00:05:59 we have a special guest with us, none other than Franco Tarazzoni.
00:06:02 You couldn't have just waited for the intro,
00:06:04 but we love having Franco on the show as our regular tax fighter from time to time.
00:06:09 He works with our good friend Chris Sims at the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:06:13 And the one thing that we all know about the conservative movement,
00:06:15 you know, red Tories, blue Tories, social conservatives, libertarians,
00:06:19 all tend to converge on this idea that government should not spend so much.
00:06:23 So with this government, you have probably had a fair bit of work in the last few years, have you not, sir?
00:06:28 Yeah, yeah. I mean, unfortunately, business is booming in a bad way for taxpayers.
00:06:32 I mean, the government is spending like crazy.
00:06:34 We have a budget that's going to be announced on Tuesday.
00:06:36 And so far, this government's approach to budgeting has been spend more on everything forever.
00:06:41 You know, that's not a good way to manage your household finances.
00:06:44 It's not a good way to manage a business.
00:06:45 And it's definitely not a good way to manage the finances of a country.
00:06:49 this upcoming budget's a bit interesting because normally a budget is this closely held state
00:06:54 secret where the government waits until markets close to come out and release it because it is
00:06:59 market moving information in this one we've had the government doing this like campaign style
00:07:03 rollout making budget announcement after budget announcement and so far all i've heard in this
00:07:08 has been more spending and i don't know you've been keeping a tally on it but but what do we
00:07:12 know about the budget so far from what has been announced well okay so we know that the government
00:07:16 is just going to keep diving into debt, right? Spend, spend, spend billions of dollars likely
00:07:20 in additional spending. And what's so worrisome about that is that even before all these spending
00:07:25 announcements, the parliamentary budget officer says, you're looking at a deficit of around
00:07:28 $40 billion. Okay. We're in what? 2024, right? We're not in these pandemic years. And the
00:07:34 government is still running these massive deficits that were like unthinkable, unthinkable only a
00:07:39 couple of years ago. Right. And one of the big problems with these massive deficits is the
00:07:44 massive amount of money that's being wasted on interest charges okay so like this year federal
00:07:49 interest charges are probably going to cost more than what the federal government sends to the
00:07:54 provinces in health transfers wow like how ridiculous is that right and in a couple years
00:07:59 time let's look at 2028 uh debt interest charges will probably cost more than the amount of money
00:08:04 the federal government brings in its gst okay so let's put that into perspective every time you go
00:08:09 to the store and you pay the federal sales tax in a couple years time every penny collected through
00:08:14 that sales tax will go to paying uh interest on the federal credit card that's so crucial and it's
00:08:20 something that i can't stress enough whenever i talk about this with people is that it's not just
00:08:23 about spending outside your means it's that it it limits your buying power as a government which is
00:08:28 you know taxpayer money obviously forever i mean when you talk about that health transfer anyone
00:08:32 who's ever had a health care issue in any province in canada just think of what government could
00:08:37 spend the money that went on debt service on hospital bed, on an MRI machine, on any of these
00:08:43 things. And that's such a point that seems to be completely absent from the discussion from
00:08:46 government, certainly this government. Well, you know, what's always in the conversation,
00:08:50 unfortunately, with this federal government? Taxes. Yeah. Right. We already know that taxes
00:08:55 are making life more expensive. We just saw the carbon tax increase that really impacts all of
00:08:59 the necessities of life. It makes it more expensive for you to fuel up your car. It makes it more
00:09:03 expensive for you to stay warm during the winter months. And it makes it more expensive for you to
00:09:06 buy groceries. And on that, we've seen not just the NDP in Singh, but also some liberal MPs
00:09:12 musing about a grocery tax. Now, hello, a new tax on groceries is not going to bring down the price 0.64
00:09:19 of food. It's going to make your life more expensive. And, you know, only a couple of years
00:09:23 ago, Trudeau was asked about the possibility of a grocery tax. And he said that they don't want to
00:09:28 bring a tax in that will be passed on to the consumer. And that's exactly what these types
00:09:33 of so-called excess profit taxes, especially on the grocery sector, would do. It would just make
00:09:38 life more expensive. And Andrew, you know, if the federal government really wanted to bring down
00:09:42 food prices, scrap the carbon tax. Yeah. Well, that's the thing. I mean, you can look at all
00:09:47 of these different levers that government has available to it. And some parts of inflation are
00:09:52 global in nature. They aren't things that government can necessarily take responsibility
00:09:56 for. Other things governments can. And, you know, when you're talking about families that are
00:10:00 struggling to make ends meet. And every now and then we see consumer spending surveys that show,
00:10:05 I forget the exact number I saw on the recent one, but a large volume of Canadians are within
00:10:09 $200 of not being able to meet their monthly expenses. So for people in that, a 10%, 12%
00:10:15 increase on something is quite significant. Yeah. And let's bring this back to the budget
00:10:20 and the deficit, right? Because you're so right to point out that inflation comes from many factors,
00:10:25 But you know what the government can control? How much it taxes, how much it spends, and how much it prints money.
00:10:32 Now, what happened during the COVID years?
00:10:34 Well, there was something that was different than normal times.
00:10:36 Well, many things, but one of them is that the central bank, the Bank of Canada, had the money printer on overdrive.
00:10:43 Okay, so during the pandemic years, the Bank of Canada printed more than $300 billion.
00:10:48 New dollars, right out of thin air, dropped into an economy that had revolving lockdowns, right?
00:10:53 So it created too many dollars chasing too few goods.
00:10:55 That's one of the reasons that you saw prices across the board skyrocket.
00:10:59 Now, going back to the taxes, we could see a different excess profits tax go in,
00:11:05 and we already know that the economy is struggling, and this would chase away investment,
00:11:09 this would hurt Canadian businesses, and would cause a whole lot of economic damage.
00:11:13 Now, you used a line there that we've heard Conservative leader Pierre Paliyev use as well,
00:11:18 about chasing few goods.
00:11:20 And I was wondering if you could explain, is he using your language, or are you using his?
00:11:23 Or is it a bit of both? Because I'm curious if you're actually finding that you've been leading the conservative movement in some ways on this.
00:11:29 Well, you know, I think the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, we've been really pushing the needle.
00:11:33 We've been banging the drum against the crazy overspending and how that drives up inflation.
00:11:37 We've been talking about the carbon tax for so many years.
00:11:39 We've been talking about the fact that the government raises its alcohol taxes.
00:11:43 I know this conversation could probably drive you to drink, but sorry, folks, they're taking more money out of your pocket when you go buy a bottle of beer as well.
00:11:51 So we've been banging the drum on this forever,
00:11:53 so it's good to see at least one party, some other MPs,
00:11:56 maybe some independent MPs, really get on the bandwagon here
00:11:59 and just understand that the federal government's overtaxing,
00:12:03 overspending, and that money printing is really making life harder for Canadians.
00:12:07 We have heard the federal government say that there's not going to be a tax on the middle class,
00:12:11 an increase in a tax on the middle class.
00:12:13 Now, the definition of the middle class is one that the government has infamously not provided,
00:12:17 even when it had a minister for the middle class.
00:12:19 but they aren't ruling out tax increases in general.
00:12:23 And I would say if people jump up and down and say,
00:12:25 well, yeah, I'm middle class, so I'm not too worried about it,
00:12:27 why should that be a cautious or concerning position?
00:12:31 Well, first of all, hey, you guys hear about that story?
00:12:34 Just last year, Trudeau took a six-day trip to the Indo-Pacific region,
00:12:38 spent, what, $2 million on a six-day trip, including $200,000 on airplane food?
00:12:43 Ask yourself this.
00:12:44 Why do you want to give the government any more money from any Canadian, right?
00:12:47 They're just going to waste it on themselves.
00:12:48 but the second thing is like look you bring in business taxes you bring in wealth taxes you
00:12:53 bring in excess profit taxes or a grocery tax two things happen number one like a grocery tax
00:12:59 that just flows through to the consumer right so there's higher prices at the store every time you
00:13:04 go do your grocery haul but number two taxes on like business or a wealth tax that drives away
00:13:09 investment that hurts the Canadian economy and right now we all know that the economy is already
00:13:14 struggling canadians are already struggling so this is probably the worst possible time to bring
00:13:19 in these very damaging taxes like i said create a lot of economic damage yeah no they do and and
00:13:24 i mean it was ironic because you go back uh two years and there was the freedom convoy protest
00:13:28 and the government when it was defending that said that economic harm was a national emergency which
00:13:33 means we need like the emergencies act on the federal budget uh with how things are going like
00:13:37 how bad are you expecting it to be because on one hand it's a government that wants to win
00:13:41 re-election next year so you'd think they'd have to put forward some vision that will be palatable
00:13:46 to canadians but what are you anticipating i'm anticipating massive deficits but look um a lot
00:13:52 pretty much all of these budgets have been pretty bad right yeah i feel like mr trudeau has not met
00:13:57 a budget target that he could just blow by right remember when he was first running to be prime
00:14:02 minister in 2015 he said they'd run you know these tiny little deficits of about 10 billion
00:14:07 a year don't worry folks we'll balance the budget in 2019 will it happen yeah they miss that target
00:14:15 by about 20 billion dollars even before the pandemic um and look like the parliamentary
00:14:19 budget officer shows that the next time under the current trajectory that we would see a balanced
00:14:24 budget from ottawa is like 2035 but that doesn't even consider any additional spending and so when
00:14:31 we see them announce spending spending spending borrowing borrowing borrowing i honestly think
00:14:35 it's going to be bad news for Canadians and you know let's not forget that if this government
00:14:40 doesn't find the spine to actually save money actually cut spending they're going to clobber
00:14:44 taxpayers. I have a feeling that when we see you know this it's going to get a lot worse and
00:14:51 the challenge will be for a conservative government that comes in or theoretically a
00:14:55 government that is going to be different from this one that they're going to say listen our
00:14:59 hands are tied we can't do anything here it's just so bad and I know you've always been as an
00:15:04 organization very good at not letting conservative parties off the hook either and i wanted to ask
00:15:08 what your realistic expectation would be of a conservative government on balance the budget
00:15:14 how long would you give them before you start to say hey listen guys you're part of the problem
00:15:17 now well we need a complete detailed plan to balance the budget immediately and why i say
00:15:22 right away is because well if you give them a couple years they're going to drag their feet
00:15:26 they're going to keep pushing the goalposts further and further it's like hey andrew i'm
00:15:30 to go on a diet next week yeah what happens i know i've been saying that for the last 10 years
00:15:34 so like so here's the thing right that's this is why it's so important to actually balance the
00:15:38 budget immediately stop this deep dive into debt and here's how they should do it number one stop
00:15:43 the wasteful spending right the fed spent eight million dollars building a barn at redo hall now 0.63
00:15:48 i don't know the first thing about farming but i'm pretty sure my buddies in brooks know how to build
00:15:52 a barn for less than eight million bucks okay then you got to go after the big things stop the
00:15:56 corporate welfare this government isn't seemingly giving billions of dollars to everybody and their
00:16:01 dog who wants to build some batteries number three you got to cut down the bureaucracy okay
00:16:05 the trudeau government has added a hundred thousand new bureaucrats since taking office
00:16:10 they've handed out a billion dollars in bonuses despite federal departments not even being able
00:16:15 to meet half of their own performance targets so you got the little things you got to do
00:16:18 and you got to do the big things right as well yeah and i mean and defunding cbc that's become
00:16:23 like a defund the cbc liam liam throw me throw me one of those baseball caps there i gotta
00:16:27 this is a new one that i haven't seen so uh there's defund the cbc and you guys also have
00:16:33 this one at your booth here um so it says defund the cra exactly i wish i could take credit for it
00:16:39 but this is actually not a ctf hat oh but let me tell you folks people are getting even more
00:16:43 frustrated with the cra right you got a problem good luck trying to get them on the phone um you
00:16:48 know we do hear more rumblings about this automatic tax filing and my first thing is like these guys
00:16:53 can't even do the basics things right like why do you want to give the cra more power over your
00:16:57 lives yeah yeah fair enough all right i thought it was yours it was on your booth but i guess it
00:17:00 was like a generous contribution yeah get rid of that thing all right well franco terrazano good
00:17:04 to see you in person sir and thanks so much for coming on i look forward to probably having you
00:17:07 on around the budget time oh that'd be great man thank you so much all right that was franco
00:17:10 terrazano federal director for the canadian taxpayers federation and like i have said time
00:17:16 time again a conservative man does not live on tax policy alone you can't just win an election
00:17:21 by trying to be a fiscal conservative i think we've seen in the past when conservatives narrow
00:17:26 the debate a little bit too much so i wanted to look outside of canada for this next segment
00:17:31 earlier today i caught up with the former prime minister of australia tony abbott
00:17:34 well the canada strong and free networks annual conference isn't just an assembly of
00:17:43 conservatives from across the country but also from around the world one of the fantastic speakers
00:17:49 this year kicking things off on the first night was the former prime minister of australia tony
00:17:54 abbott who has been an unflinching and unapologetic conservative throughout his career and as always
00:18:00 former politicians tend to get even more candid but he was pretty candid when he was in office as
00:18:04 well it's my great pleasure to have tony abbott on the show now tony thank you for being with us
00:18:09 And welcome to Canada.
00:18:11 Andrew, it's wonderful to be here.
00:18:12 And I've got to say, this has been a bracing and invigorating conference.
00:18:18 Good to see so many hundreds of often young Conservatives,
00:18:22 very enthusiastic and ambitious for the next government here in Canada.
00:18:28 Let me ask you about, and just for some context for those not familiar with Australian politics,
00:18:33 the Liberal Party there with a capital L is the Conservative Party with a small c.
00:18:37 But that party, how does it situate itself, if you were to compare it against the Tories of Canada, the Tories of Britain, and that global conservative landscape on what Australian conservatism is?
00:18:50 We are very much the Australian equivalent of your Conservative Party or the British Conservative Party.
00:18:56 But, like your party and Britain's party, we go through more conservative and more progressive phases.
00:19:03 under me the party was more conservative under my successor the party was less conservative
00:19:09 but under Peter Dutton the current leader of the Liberal National Coalition in Australia
00:19:14 the party I think has gone back to being a proper small c conservative party and look we're in
00:19:23 opposition now and as I said constantly as opposition leader the job of an opposition
00:19:29 is to be a strong alternative not to make weak compromises with a bad left-wing government
00:19:37 one of the fascinating things when we look at these shifts is that in canada there's been a
00:19:43 great realignment over the pandemic era and i think in australia where some of the covid
00:19:47 restrictions were worse than anywhere else totally over the top uh that that was a particular flash
00:19:52 point in canada we had the trucker protest in australia has there been a similar resurgence
00:19:56 from that? I think that a lot of people on the centre-right were very dismayed by the way even
00:20:06 supposedly conservative governments connived at restrictions on freedom and increases in the size
00:20:13 of government which were simply unprecedented even in wartime. So I think that the pandemic
00:20:19 while deeply dispiriting in so many ways and culturally weakening in so many ways has certainly
00:20:28 reminded conservatives of the fact that these values these important enduring I think eternal
00:20:35 values that are in the marrow of our bones have to be asserted and defended not watered down
00:20:43 because too much of that happened during the pandemic and too often that's happened
00:20:49 in periods of government.
00:20:51 We've split the difference
00:20:52 rather than standing up for the smaller government,
00:20:56 lower taxes, greater freedom,
00:20:59 respect for the family, small business,
00:21:03 and institutions that have stood the test of time.
00:21:05 And above all else, love of country.
00:21:08 Because at the heart of our political tradition
00:21:10 is freedom, tradition,
00:21:14 and above all else, patriotism.
00:21:16 One distinction I was wondering
00:21:18 if you could help demystify for for me and the audience is on firearms policy because in canada
00:21:23 the conservative party's position on firearms is generally about uh less controls less restrictions
00:21:29 certainly not the american model whereas uh some of the big gun control in australia came about
00:21:34 under john howard who's a otherwise very stoic stalwart conservative so how in the political
00:21:40 culture has that happened in a party that otherwise supports property and freedom look um
00:21:45 We just have a different approach to guns. We always have. Maybe it's because the settlement process was different in our country than in North America, but we've just had a different approach to guns.
00:22:05 and look i'm all in favor of farmers having guns if you've got a property you may have pests that
00:22:13 you need to shoot there may be animals that you need to put down as humanely as possible and
00:22:18 quickly and obviously if you've got an old 303 it's a very good way of doing that and if you're
00:22:23 a sporting shooter fine by all means have access to guns so i'm not in a sense anti-gun but i
00:22:30 I don't have this thing about an armed population.
00:22:36 I suspect a heavily armed population is more danger to itself than it is to any bad guys.
00:22:43 Let's talk about what you and Boris Johnson on Wednesday had actually a very lively and spirited exchange on,
00:22:49 which was climate policy.
00:22:51 And just for a bit of context, when we hear this discussed in Canada,
00:22:54 oftentimes the Liberals and the Conservatives start from the same core premise,
00:22:58 which is that yes climate change is serious it's predominantly caused by man we've got to reduce
00:23:03 emissions and they differ on on how to do that and how much to do that you went actually a step
00:23:09 further and challenged that core premise you said actually i'm not convinced it's predominantly
00:23:12 man-made and that's a position that i would love for a canadian politician to have the courage to
00:23:17 utter on stage well it's a position that i've pretty consistently had when i was prime minister
00:23:25 i had a little mantra if you like and my mantra was climate change happens we have to assume that
00:23:33 mankind makes a contribution we should do what we can to reduce emissions but not if it costs jobs
00:23:40 drives industries offshore and adds to people's cost of living now we know that climate changes
00:23:48 the ice ages classic case of climate change the roman warm period the medieval warm period
00:23:55 classic cases of climate change and ask yourself what caused them i mean seriously ask yourself
00:24:02 what caused the ice age now it plainly wasn't mankind's carbon dioxide emissions because there
00:24:08 were hardly any of us there was no factories or anything like that now if the most dramatic
00:24:15 example of climate change that we're familiar with had absolutely nothing to do with mankind's
00:24:20 emissions obviously there are many factors in climate change and there's no real reason to think
00:24:26 that the most significant one is mankind's carbon dioxide so look on on sort of good
00:24:36 prudential principles and as someone who appreciates we've only got one planet we've
00:24:41 got to look after it i'm all in favor of resting lightly on it but it's not just sensible in fact
00:24:50 its utter folly to turn our world upside down in this mania for reducing emissions why shouldn't
00:24:58 we continue to drive v8 cars why shouldn't we continue to eat beef why shouldn't we continue to
00:25:05 enrich our countries and help other countries by mining and exporting coal and by drilling and
00:25:12 exporting gas. Why shouldn't we keep flying for business and pleasure? And what's behind
00:25:22 a lot of the more extreme climate activism is actually a hatred for our way of life.
00:25:28 And in many ways, this is a cause that's been adopted by quasi-Marxists who have been much
00:25:35 more successful at getting the middle class to revolt in the name of saving the planet 0.93
00:25:40 than they ever were, getting the working class to revolt in the name of economic equality.
00:25:46 And where I really diverge with Boris Johnson's perspective on this
00:25:49 is that he distilled it to the old thought experiment of Pascal's Wager,
00:25:53 where he said, you know, maybe it's true, maybe it's not true,
00:25:56 maybe it's really bad, maybe it's not.
00:25:57 But effectively, he said it costs us nothing to act as though...
00:26:01 Which is complete nonsense.
00:26:02 This is where his argument completely fell down,
00:26:06 where the analogy didn't work because it's cost us already trillions of dollars to make
00:26:15 all these changes to combat climate change, as we think. And to what end and to what benefit?
00:26:25 Emissions are going up because whatever India and China say, for all sorts of reasons,
00:26:31 quite sensible reasons they are continuing to burn coal to to use gas to use oil and frankly
00:26:39 modern life is absolutely impossible without fossil fuels at enormous expense and massive
00:26:48 inconvenience and economic weakening and strategic weakening of ourselves we could move to wind and
00:26:56 solar power. But we can't do without steel. We can't do without plastic. We can't do without
00:27:03 fertilizer. And these are all critically dependent on fossil fuels. And there is no likely medium
00:27:13 term substitute without, again, massive expense. And this idea that we should impoverish ourselves
00:27:20 in the name of reducing emissions when nothing we do in our countries is going to make a
00:27:25 difference to overall levels of carbon dioxide because China and India are not doing the same
00:27:31 thing. It's it's crackers. It's absolute crackers. It's an act of economic and ultimately social and
00:27:41 strategic self-harm. And the sooner we wake up to ourselves, the better. But I notice just
00:27:49 overnight the un climate chief has set a new deadline of doom we've got just two years oh
00:27:56 only two years now to save the planet well i mean all these deadlines have come and gone
00:28:01 uh and the planet seems to be rocking along yes yes uh we're still here and and the very best
00:28:12 thing we can do to deal with whatever comes including any changes in climate down the track
00:28:18 is to keep ourselves strong and free.
00:28:22 That's what we should do, keep ourselves strong and free.
00:28:27 And policy that makes us less strong and ultimately less free
00:28:30 is no good thing, whatever the supposed justification.
00:28:35 Perhaps you can explain from your experience as a head of government
00:28:38 how politicians who are elected in Western democracies around the world
00:28:42 from liberal parties, conservative parties, more socialist parties,
00:28:46 all tend to sound the same when they're at the global forums and the global summits talking about this.
00:28:51 I mean, the Paris Agreement, the COP summits, I mean, even Boris Johnson when the UK was hosting the COP summit.
00:28:57 It seems like all of these domestic realities tend to lose when that amorphous global community gets together. 1.00
00:29:04 Well, let me tell you this, Andrew.
00:29:06 Lots of people in my party, when I became opposition leader back in 2009,
00:29:12 and lots of people in the commentariat said that I was unelectable,
00:29:16 because I wasn't prepared to accept the consensus, in inverted commas, on climate change.
00:29:25 And what I was able to do as opposition leader, and I think to some extent as prime minister as well,
00:29:32 was to turn this from an environmental issue and a moral issue into an economic issue and a pragmatic issue.
00:29:41 Which is what it is for ordinary people.
00:29:42 And let me point this out to the benefit of any nervous Canadian Conservatives.
00:29:52 Three elections in Australia were largely fought on the issue of climate and our response to climate
00:29:58 and energy resulting from climate policies.
00:30:02 2010, 2013 and 2019.
00:30:05 And in every single one of them, the more sceptical party did extremely well
00:30:11 and campaigning against a carbon tax,
00:30:15 I won a landslide victory in 2013.
00:30:20 Sure, if you look at the opinion polls,
00:30:23 people will say we want to see emissions reduced
00:30:26 and we think climate change is important.
00:30:29 But if you then ask them how much are they prepared to pay,
00:30:32 $100, $1,000, $1 million,
00:30:34 the answer is we are not prepared to pay.
00:30:37 And this is why the green zealots, the climate cultists, 0.97
00:30:41 have constantly promised us
00:30:43 that renewable energy is cheap, even free.
00:30:48 Well, it might be cheap when the sun is shining
00:30:50 and the wind is blowing,
00:30:52 but we need electricity 24-7.
00:30:55 And that means that intermittent wind and solar power
00:30:59 has always got to be backed up at massive expense,
00:31:02 at massive expense,
00:31:04 and as well, you need a gargantuan new transmission grid
00:31:10 transmission system to cope with this decentralized grid. But all of the new
00:31:17 transmission infrastructure is only being used 30% of the time, given that it's only on average
00:31:23 30% of the time that the sun is shining and the wind is blowing. And I think the caution in that
00:31:29 in and we saw this in the Canadian election in 2021, where a conservative party tried to
00:31:35 do the carbon tax thing and was resoundingly defeated because voters didn't want it, didn't
00:31:40 buy it, and if they wanted that, they would have voted for the left in general. 0.63
00:31:42 Politics is a contest. It's a contest of ideas. And quite apart from the fact that I think that
00:31:48 carbon taxes and this whole emissions obsession is wrong in principle, absolutely wrong in
00:31:55 principle, why would you do something that's wrong in principle, which actually blurs the
00:32:02 difference between you and the other side of politics particularly given that these emissions
00:32:08 obsessive policies are so damaging to aspirational working class people who need their pickup truck
00:32:18 who want to heat their house in winter and cool their house in summer who want to have a good
00:32:25 honest blue collar job in a car factory or a steel mill or a timber mill or something like that. I
00:32:33 mean, you know, why are we attacking the working class the way we are? And one of the reasons why 0.94
00:32:40 over the last generation, you've seen more, if you like, poorer people moving to the right
00:32:48 and richer people moving to the green left is because in the end, this whole climate thing
00:32:54 is the ultimate first world problem when you don't have anything else to fret about
00:32:59 you suddenly worry about maybe the planet might be a couple of degrees warmer in three or four
00:33:08 decades time well look maybe it will maybe it won't if it is I think it's unlikely to be mankind
00:33:17 that's driven that much more likely to be sunspot activities or oscillations in the earth's orbit
00:33:23 around the sun, and given that there are other far more pressing problems right now, in particular
00:33:30 Islamist aggression in the Middle East, in particular the ongoing aggression by dictatorships
00:33:40 such as Russia and the Chinese communists, we have challenges all around the world right 0.50
00:33:48 now, and the last thing we should be doing is weakening ourselves in dealing with those
00:33:53 challenges by obsessing over climate i mean ask yourself this are the ukrainians worried about
00:33:58 their emissions at the moment are the israelis thinking about how we can put in more wind and
00:34:06 solar power no they have got existential issues to worry about and we have to remember that we're not
00:34:14 necessarily entirely free of having to deal with the same things ourselves just in closing tony
00:34:20 you've spent now a few days with canadian conservatives what can the australian right
00:34:24 perhaps learn from canada and what can the canadian right learn from australia
00:34:29 well i hope that people in canada might look at my experience in opposition and in government
00:34:39 and be confident that you can take on tough issues go against the elite consensus and win
00:34:46 thumping majority and without wanting to put tickets on myself so far the abbot government
00:34:55 is the only government in the world that has repealed a carbon tax and which stopped successfully
00:35:02 stopped a wave of illegal migration by small boat and if we can do it others can do it now as for
00:35:11 Canada teaching us good lessons. I'm really impressed at the way Pierre Polivare has really
00:35:21 galvanized conservatives in this country. And I can sense at conferences like this,
00:35:28 a real passion and a strong ambition to get into government and to make a difference. Now,
00:35:35 I think that Canada has to some extent been in the doldrums one way or another for the last decade.
00:35:41 So I think it needs reinvigoration, but there's a real sense of purpose about your opposition leader
00:35:51 and a real sense of enthusiasm at conferences like this.
00:35:55 And frankly, the Anglosphere needs a strong conservative government to succeed
00:36:03 because it's a while since we've had one which has unambiguously succeeded
00:36:09 and let's hope Canada is the start of a new wave.
00:36:13 Former Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott, thank you so much, sir.
00:36:16 Thank you.
00:36:18 The former Prime Minister of Australia, an Anglophile,
00:36:21 a big advocate for the Conservative movement,
00:36:23 not just in his own country but around the world.
00:36:26 And I would also point out there that you can agree or disagree with his position on it,
00:36:30 but there's something in politics that we often call the Overton window,
00:36:34 which is in society really the realm of acceptable opinions within civil discourse.
00:36:39 And I think Tony Abbott has done a lot in Australia, and even he's shared it in that interview, to kind of extend the boundaries of that so that you can have certain discussions that, again, even in a Canadian political context, you'd be unlikely to see from any party.
00:36:52 So perhaps some lessons there that politicians can take.
00:36:55 But what a wonderful warm-up act Tony Abbott is to my next guest, Paige McPherson, who is with the Fraser Institute.
00:37:03 She's an expert and all-seeing eye on all things education.
00:37:05 We've had her on the show a number of times on this,
00:37:07 and I wanted to take it in a little bit of a broader way today
00:37:10 and talk about education and educational policy
00:37:14 in a context of family policy
00:37:16 and an issue that we'll be touching on as well with Ginny Roth
00:37:19 in an interview that we'll share with you next week.
00:37:21 But Paige McPherson, always good to see you.
00:37:23 Thanks so much for coming on today.
00:37:25 Yeah, thanks so much for having me, Andrew.
00:37:26 You and I have spoken because you're a great advocate for school choice,
00:37:29 for parents to have choices to send their kids to schools,
00:37:32 not just this weird binary that we have in Ontario
00:37:34 where you can do, you know, public or Catholic,
00:37:37 but in Alberta, perhaps, where you have charter schools,
00:37:40 you have this independent schooling mentality
00:37:42 baked into the public system.
00:37:44 I was wondering if you could extend that a little bit
00:37:46 because you touched on it in a discussion here
00:37:48 about really what choices are available,
00:37:51 and I'd say more pressingly what choices aren't available
00:37:53 to families and mothers who make a lot of these decisions.
00:37:57 Yeah, absolutely.
00:37:58 So, you know, I think that it's important to kind of frame it
00:38:01 in the question of do families and women, if you want to talk about it from a sort of female 0.60
00:38:06 empowerment point of view, do we actually have the freedom to make the choices that we want to make
00:38:11 with our kids from day one, looking at sort of family policy, maternity leave, where you're going
00:38:17 to send your kids to child care, and then, of course, as they get older, where you're going to
00:38:21 send your kids to school. And in certain provinces, as you've mentioned, when it comes to educational
00:38:25 choice, as an example, in the Maritimes, where I live, and in Ontario, where you live, no,
00:38:30 Educational choice is extremely limited.
00:38:32 In Quebec and in Western Canada, from Manitoba West,
00:38:36 yeah, you've got more funded options.
00:38:38 A portion of the parents' tax dollars will follow their children to the school of their choice.
00:38:44 But I think it's an important question to ask right now in the context of the rising cost of living.
00:38:50 Even when these choice avenues are available through policy,
00:38:55 it's still a lot easier to make the prescribed government choice.
00:38:58 So in the context of child care policy, with the new government day care program, that's sending your child to a $10 a day subsidized day care center.
00:39:07 In the context of schools, that's sending your child to the local government public school.
00:39:11 And of course, you can make another choice for your family.
00:39:16 But looking at the data and asking the question, how easy and how feasible actually is it to make those choices for many families, I think is another question altogether.
00:39:24 And certainly when you talk about it in a healthcare context, and I've had this discussion with some of your colleagues at the Fraser Institute, we see that universalization limits choice. It limits options. And anytime government tries to take this universal approach to something, it ends up where you have this one-size-fits-all position.
00:39:40 And I think the Ontario schooling example and the Eastern Canada schooling example is there.
00:39:44 That's kind of the child care approach as well.
00:39:45 All of a sudden you force people into this government constraint.
00:39:49 And, you know, I'm wondering how we break out of that.
00:39:51 Because I can't imagine if you went around and polled the average parent that you would get much resistance if you said,
00:39:57 hey, should you have more choice?
00:39:59 Should you have more options?
00:40:00 You're not saying you have to take your kid out of the public system.
00:40:03 And yet still these policies are pretty firmly in place in these provinces.
00:40:07 So I know in health care why that happens, because people have this very fearful scenario that any change to the status quo will mean a dilution of care, a dilution of access, a dilution of being able to get something at low or no cost.
00:40:22 Is that the same thing in health care? Is that why nothing's really changing?
00:40:26 Well, I think an interesting distinction between education and child care policy and then health care policy in Canada is that in Canada in health care,
00:40:33 You often don't have any other option unless you're going to go to another country to seek that option, right?
00:40:38 Yeah, the out-of-pocket private school doesn't exist for health care.
00:40:41 Exactly. So, yes, there are independent schools in Canada.
00:40:43 There are child care options you're permitted by the government to do, right?
00:40:47 You can send your child to a private day home, for example, that doesn't fall under the government regulation and subsidy program.
00:40:53 You can get an aunt or a grandmother to work less and, you know, split child care with you.
00:40:58 You can choose to stay home with your children.
00:41:01 It's just it's become very difficult to make that choice, to take the road less traveled.
00:41:07 That isn't the government avenue that they've created by this massive expanding state, essentially, becomes difficult.
00:41:16 And that's for a number of reasons.
00:41:17 On the one hand, if you look at child care policy, for example, OK, if you're going to go back to work when you have a child and you're going to need child care for them, you probably are going to make more than $10 a day.
00:41:30 right? And if you've got a $10 a day daycare option, then sending your child to that daycare
00:41:35 is probably going to be the financially better scenario for you in the short term. Even if it's
00:41:41 not really your preferred option, even if as a woman, you'd love to stay home in the early years
00:41:45 with your child, it becomes less expensive in the shorter term for you to do that. The other thing
00:41:51 is that when you have these massively expanding government programs, you've got the debt and tax
00:41:55 burden to go along with that. We know that government spending is at record highs. We
00:42:00 know that debt interest payments at the government level that Canadians are of course responsible
00:42:05 for paying via their taxes, they're at record highs. We know that the debt or rather the
00:42:12 tax burden for Canadian families, that Canadian families on average are now spending more
00:42:16 of their income on taxes than they are on the necessities of life on food, clothing
00:42:22 and shelter. And you've been to a grocery store, you know that you're spending a heck
00:42:24 of a lot of money on food clothing and shelter not to mention housing costs right but you're
00:42:29 still spending on average about 45 percent of your income on taxes and that's to pay for these
00:42:34 large government programs so again yes in theory you can send your child to a different child care
00:42:41 option you can make that choice for your family you can send your child to an independent school
00:42:44 that you're going to have to pay for in ontario where the maritime is fully out of pocket but
00:42:48 even in alberta you're going to have to pay some cost in addition to you know the tax dollars that
00:42:53 following your child to that school so it really becomes the question of okay families can in theory
00:43:00 make this choice but how realistic is it well and i think that it touches on an important point
00:43:05 because i i was raised i went briefly to a catholic school in ontario which is part of the
00:43:09 the public system and then i did most of my schooling uh primary and your elementary and
00:43:14 secondary in the public school and i had always been raised with this mindset that a private school
00:43:20 was really just a wealthy elite thing that you do it because you could and
00:43:23 it was only older that i started to realize that there are different motivations for it and actually
00:43:28 you and i have spoken about some of the data on this overwhelmingly the people that choose private
00:43:32 schooling options or homeschooling are certainly not wealthy and they do it because they feel that
00:43:37 their needs are not being met by the public school system either their needs on a quality of education
00:43:43 or or even the content of education and i think that part's also missing is why parents feel so
00:43:48 underserved or unserved by the public system in the first place yeah it's a great point so we have
00:43:54 research on this particularly in alberta and bc where we drill down on the average incomes of
00:43:59 families who send their kids to independent schools or send their kids to the government
00:44:02 public schools and really those incomes end up being extremely similar especially when you remove
00:44:09 the very small proportion of independent schools that are those sort of elite prep schools that
00:44:15 sometimes that's the image that is sometimes yeah that was all i thought a private school was for
00:44:19 most of my life right so and but but in reality as you say you know the majority of of independent
00:44:24 schools in canada are cultural or religious schools you know you've got schools that are
00:44:29 have a typical or an interesting sort of philosophical approach like a montessori school
00:44:33 waldorf school that a forest school is a growing movement in canada so elite prep schools is
00:44:38 actually quite a small proportion of that but what's interesting i think about what you're
00:44:42 saying is that a lot of people don't know that the sort of government avenue is not going to be the
00:44:47 best choice for their family until they take it right until they have their child in a government
00:44:51 public school classroom and they realize okay this is not working my it could be for a whole
00:44:56 number of reasons right we hear from people who are experiencing bullying or violence
00:45:00 in school and it's just not the right fit for them it's the the curriculum is not getting to
00:45:05 them they're not reading they're not able to to do math they may maybe have a different learning
00:45:09 style maybe they have special education needs there's a whole host of reasons why families
00:45:15 might decide that the government public school is not the best fit for their child and want
00:45:20 to put them in another school and they might not realize that right off the hop but once
00:45:25 they do realize that the idea that only a family that is of significant means that can
00:45:30 afford a nanny or can afford to pay out of pocket for independent school tuition on top
00:45:36 of paying for subsidized daycare and government schools for everybody else and you know via their
00:45:41 very large tax burden that we've already discussed that's really not fair if that your family really
00:45:46 shouldn't have to have that level of income um to be able to do that what is interesting though in
00:45:53 our data as well is that a lot of families they're certainly not wealthy they're making these choices
00:45:58 they involve tremendous sacrifices and they're still making those choices we know that homeschooling
00:46:04 is going up as a share of students in nine out of ten provinces.
00:46:08 We know that independent schools' enrolment is growing as a proportion of total students
00:46:13 in every single province in the country.
00:46:14 So people are making these choices despite the cost of living going up,
00:46:18 but we also know that it involves a tremendous level of sacrifice for a lot of these families.
00:46:22 I know your focus is on the policy and not the politics,
00:46:24 but is there any real movement in any province?
00:46:28 Let me back up.
00:46:29 Is this issue on the agenda for any opposition parties in any province in Canada?
00:46:34 Is there any movement to the status quo that's really being championed anywhere?
00:46:38 I mean, so like you said, I mean, I really look at the policy, not the politics as much.
00:46:43 I mean, I know Danielle Smith in Alberta has talked about potentially expanding school choice in that province.
00:46:48 But they're already the one that's furthest ahead, right?
00:46:49 I know, they offer already the most choice.
00:46:51 There's no one in Ontario trying to blow up the system here, and certainly in your province, I don't think there is either.
00:46:55 No, there's really not a lot of movement, but there are a lot of parents that are dissatisfied, I think, with what their kids are getting in government public school.
00:47:01 You know, there's a lot of parents that are, they want to have more of an ability to be active in their child's school, to be informed about what their child is learning in school, understand, again, and this is one of those things that sometimes you don't realize it's an issue until it's too late.
00:47:16 Your child is suddenly entering third grade, and they can't read, and that's the critical age at which we know it switches from learning to read to reading to learn.
00:47:24 Your child's going to have to know how to read in order to succeed educationally, and yet here you are, and you don't have any other options.
00:47:31 So, of course, there's a lot of parents, and I would say there is, you know, in political terms, the political constituency there that absolutely does care about this issue.
00:47:41 And sometimes it's just the case that people don't really even know that there are these other options.
00:47:45 I don't know that people in Nova Scotia necessarily know the educational choice policy structure in British Columbia, right?
00:47:51 And so, of course, that's a part of the work that we do.
00:47:53 Well, we look forward to seeing more of it.
00:47:56 You always produce very interesting facts and figures on this.
00:47:58 Paige McPherson from the Fraser Institute, always a pleasure.
00:48:01 Thank you so much.
00:48:02 All right.
00:48:02 Thank you very much, Paige.
00:48:04 We will certainly check in on that.
00:48:06 And as I said, on Monday, we're going to have a discussion with Ginny Roth on birth rates,
00:48:11 which are a very key part of this.
00:48:12 And basically, what, if anything, government and governments should be doing to start promoting families.
00:48:19 And a lot of what Paige was talking about there was the idea of family first policy.
00:48:23 It's not government centrally planning the composition or structure of family.
00:48:26 It's about giving options or at the very least not taking options away.
00:48:30 But in the vein of birth rates, we can't talk about Canada's population
00:48:33 without talking about immigration, which has long been relied on
00:48:36 as really the lone avenue for population growth in this country.
00:48:41 We hear time and time again politicians say, well, birth rates are too low,
00:48:44 we've got to boost our numbers through immigration.
00:48:46 And as we've seen in the last couple of weeks in particular,
00:48:50 Canada's immigration has led to an unsustainable path. 0.98
00:48:53 We have the federal government itself even admitting that it has had far beyond,
00:48:58 those were its words, far beyond what Canada is able to absorb
00:49:01 in terms of temporary residents combined with new permanent residents.
00:49:05 And to give you some context on this,
00:49:07 government has committed to about half a million new permanent residents a year,
00:49:10 but the number of new temporary residents a year is over a million,
00:49:14 and that includes foreign students, temporary foreign workers,
00:49:18 people that come in through other channels.
00:49:19 So you have a large volume of people coming to Canada
00:49:22 and a country that economically cannot sustain even those who are here already.
00:49:27 So let's talk about this in context of what a conservative government would do about it.
00:49:31 I spoke about this with Pierre Pollyev in December,
00:49:34 and he was hesitant to give a specific figure for what a conservative government would advance.
00:49:39 But he also did say there'd be a formula in place,
00:49:42 and I wanted to delve into that a bit more detail with the Conservatives' immigration critic, Tom Kamich.
00:49:51 I'm speaking right now with the Conservative immigration critic,
00:49:54 Also, Calgary MP, the MP for Calgary Shepherd, Tom Kamich.
00:49:58 Tom, always good to talk to you.
00:49:59 Thanks for joining me.
00:50:01 Thanks, Andrew.
00:50:01 Thanks for having me.
00:50:02 So, obviously, immigration has become a hot-button issue in politics.
00:50:06 What's been fascinating is how the Liberals have decided to do a complete about-face
00:50:10 on what's really been their position for quite some time.
00:50:13 How did you feel when you got that concession from Justin Trudeau
00:50:17 within the last couple of weeks that Canada has actually bungled this,
00:50:21 that Canada has actually admitted through temporary residency
00:50:24 far more than what he said the country could absorb.
00:50:28 So, I mean, it's a bit ridiculous for the Prime Minister to claim
00:50:31 that he suddenly discovered that things aren't going the way that he maybe thought that it was.
00:50:36 He's the one that's been appointing all these immigration ministers.
00:50:39 I guess he doesn't read any of the briefing notes or documents that come up his way.
00:50:41 We found that out at the inquiry.
00:50:43 He doesn't read national security documents.
00:50:45 He's not reading immigration documents. It's obvious.
00:50:47 And, you know, this is just a continuation,
00:50:48 because back in august when he reshuffled his own cabinet you had this bizarre situation where the
00:50:53 previous immigration minister could not let go of his department he was saying that things are a
00:50:58 mess that's a direct quote and the new minister said things are out of control and they've been
00:51:02 fighting it out in public between the senior immigration minister and the junior immigration
00:51:06 minister and other prime ministers weighed in and accused this government of basically failing on
00:51:10 the job that they they're not competent obviously except he's the one that's appointed everybody
00:51:15 He's been in charge for almost nine years now, and they broke the immigration system. 0.78
00:51:19 It's nice of him to recognize that he broke it.
00:51:21 Pierre Polyev, on my show and now elsewhere, has talked about what his approach to immigration will be.
00:51:27 He said that immigration should be tied to a couple of key indicators,
00:51:30 such as job availability, health care resources, and also, I think, in general,
00:51:35 when you're looking at just the well-being of the country,
00:51:37 those economic focal points have been where he's gone.
00:51:40 Can you give any more clarity on what a conservative immigration plan would look like
00:51:45 and a platform or what you would like to do in a Conservative government on this?
00:51:49 So, I mean, what I'd love to do in a Conservative government
00:51:52 is help the next immigration minister figure out what the formula should be.
00:51:56 And right now it's, you know, broad terms,
00:51:58 health care, housing, jobs, equals, that will be whatever it equals to.
00:52:03 And then we'll have to create that, you know,
00:52:05 very objective way of calculating how many people should be allowed to be in Canada
00:52:11 to be working here, studying here, reuniting with families,
00:52:14 all of it, all of it together.
00:52:16 And I think those are three very reasonable metrics to have.
00:52:19 And what are the inputs into those metrics,
00:52:21 like how exactly we'll look at closer to the election,
00:52:24 we'll obviously give it to the public so they can make a determination.
00:52:27 Do we have a better way of doing and managing our immigration system 0.99
00:52:30 or do they prefer the chaos and the brokenness
00:52:33 that the Liberals have created over eight years?
00:52:35 If that calculation leads to a permanent resident number
00:52:38 that is lower than the target now,
00:52:40 is that something that you would be willing to stand behind?
00:52:42 So it's going to be more than just permanent immigration.
00:52:45 It's going to be also temporary resident immigration because the problem isn't the permanent residency ones.
00:52:50 Like those PR numbers are often quoted by individuals in Canada.
00:52:54 About 45 to 55 percent of those, depending on the year, actually people who are physically in Canada already,
00:53:00 they're just changing their status from studying, from working here on a temporary foreign work permit,
00:53:05 and they're becoming permanent residents of Canada, hopefully on their pathway to becoming citizens and, you know, joining the Canadian family.
00:53:11 So half of those are already here.
00:53:12 We're talking about everybody.
00:53:13 It will be an all-encompassing number, including everyone.
00:53:17 So I don't want to limit it just to PRs.
00:53:19 But to be direct about that, do you think that number is going to have to be lower than what it is right now?
00:53:23 It'll be whatever it comes out to, that will be the number.
00:53:25 If it's lower, it's lower.
00:53:26 If it's higher, it's higher.
00:53:28 But we see what the housing construction is looking like.
00:53:31 The number is going down in terms of the number of dwellings being completed per year.
00:53:35 Health care services are stretched in some provinces, sometimes beyond the limit.
00:53:39 That's what I heard in Vancouver when I was there a few weeks ago.
00:53:42 That's what I hear in Toronto when I'm there.
00:53:44 Like, we don't have a family doctor crisis in Calgary.
00:53:47 There are actually signs saying family doctors accepting new patients.
00:53:50 So this is my pitch to your listeners and viewers.
00:53:52 Like, if you want a family doctor, know Calgary is a beautiful place.
00:53:55 It's the most beautiful city in Canada that they can move and find a family doctor.
00:53:59 But also jobs, job vacancy rates, job unemployment rates.
00:54:02 In specific sectors of the economy are looking for more people than others, such as construction.
00:54:08 All of that will be affected.
00:54:09 There'll be a total number at the end, and that will be the final number.
00:54:13 Do you think that it's reasonable to restrict the immigration calculation to economic indicators?
00:54:18 I know the previous Conservative government looked at values-based things,
00:54:21 and certainly since October 7th, we've seen some examples of people
00:54:26 where there is not a consensus on core beliefs.
00:54:28 And I'm wondering how that would factor into your ideal scenario for immigration.
00:54:32 I'm always worried about introducing things that are not fixed, like values,
00:54:36 because that should be a specific society to decide.
00:54:38 Like, I don't want my government determining which values it supports, which doesn't.
00:54:42 And the reason I don't like it is because for the last nine years, that's the Liberal government of Canada.
00:54:46 That's what they've been doing.
00:54:47 They've been telling you if you ran, you know, a school camp program and you thought that it should be based on, like, Bible teachings,
00:54:55 that you were a bad person and they applied a values attestation test to whether you could receive a bit of taxpayer funds to hire a couple of camp councillors.
00:55:03 and if you were running you know like a resettlement program they made you tell
00:55:06 them do you support certain values or not so that's what I'm always worried
00:55:10 about is when you allow the government to determine which values it's going to
00:55:13 promote which it doesn't then you get the Liberal Party of Canada doing what
00:55:16 it's done for the past nine years so I believe like things like health care
00:55:20 housing jobs all Canadians can get behind that and be like yeah those are
00:55:24 reasonable objective metrics there's no subjectivity to them you either have
00:55:28 those services or you don't and there'll be a number and we can then debate
00:55:31 whether the inputs are correct or not and then it's a debate about what are the inputs that
00:55:36 should be going into it you want more immigration build more housing get the policies into place to
00:55:40 make housing cheaper so that people can get into more housing you want more doctors more
00:55:44 healthcare services well make it easier for doctors to practice we have over 20 000 internationally
00:55:49 trained doctors who cannot practice their profession in fact there are less doctors
00:55:53 practicing today than there were like 20 30 40 years ago as a percentage out of it like per
00:55:58 thousand uh and same thing for nurses there's over i think 32 000 internationally trained nurses who 0.98
00:56:04 can't practice the profession the occupation that they love because colleges are blocking them from
00:56:08 doing so so the country of origin lost a nurse we didn't gain a nurse we just have people who
00:56:13 are disgruntled because they can't practice their profession likely working a survival job
00:56:18 election currently scheduled for fall of 2025 if you had your way when would you be going to the
00:56:23 the polls uh the same thing my constituents are saying immediately right now non-confidence as
00:56:29 many non-confidence votes as it takes to topple the government let's have an election a carbon
00:56:33 tax election and let the liberals defend raising the cost of living on everyone tom committs thank
00:56:37 you thank you andrew that was my interview with the conservative immigration critic calgary shepherd
00:56:45 mp tom committs now one thing i'll point out there is that the conservative's position now
00:56:50 which is we won an election yesterday, is a nice departure from in 2021 where Justin Trudeau called an election and the Conservatives were wondering why.
00:56:57 And they're like, no, no, no, stay in power. You're doing a great job. We don't we don't want to campaign right now.
00:57:02 So that is in and of itself quite interesting.
00:57:04 And it's the Liberals who are a bit hesitant to go to the polls, perhaps because the polls show their numbers to be lower than Stephen Gilbeau's IQ,
00:57:12 which is actually quite a feat if you think about it. But that's actually the real net zero, by the way, Stephen Gilbeau's IQ.
00:57:18 But one thing I wanted to talk about on this is that this is the first time I've heard a Conservative official, a senior Conservative MP, talk about the possibility that Canada's immigration targets could be lower.
00:57:30 Now, he says, look, we'll run the formula. If it's lower, it's lower, it's higher, it's higher.
00:57:34 But they're actually willing at this point to say what Pierre Polyev didn't really, when I spoke to him in December about this, admit that that could be lower.
00:57:42 So I think that in and of itself has been a movement, and I think it's also a sign that the immigration consensus in Canada has shifted dramatically on this.
00:57:50 Again, when the Liberals came out in, I forget it was, beginning of last week or two weeks ago, and said what a lot of Canadians have said, which is, okay, we've got a little bit of a crunch here.
00:58:00 We don't have enough houses. We don't have enough jobs. We don't have enough in the way of health care resources.
00:58:05 That is a big problem. But the Liberal problem here is that they are neglecting to address the fact that they have been the ones at the helm.
00:58:13 They've been the ones there in power for the last eight years. So any problems that exist have happened on their watch.
00:58:20 Now, I wanted to, as we wrap up our week here at the Canada Strong and Free Network's annual conference in Ottawa,
00:58:26 just share a bit of a final thought, if you will, because it's been a great time.
00:58:30 And I've met a lot of people that are big members and supporters of True North Nation out there
00:58:34 and have had lots of great things to say about our work and our coverage and our team,
00:58:38 and I'm so grateful for that.
00:58:40 This is an event that I realize is only a subset of the conservative movement.
00:58:44 I had a message from someone yesterday, actually, that took a very anti-CSFN look
00:58:49 and said, well, this is just for the rich who can go to Ottawa.
00:58:51 And I'd say it's actually for the, what is it, if you like pain, are you a sadist or a masochist?
00:58:57 I always forget, but I think you're a sadist, whatever one,
00:59:00 whatever one means you like inflicting pain, that's the type of person that goes to Ottawa voluntarily.
00:59:04 But the thing about it that I will point out here is that there is a group that comes here,
00:59:09 and you've obviously got your lobbyists and your political staffers and your politicos,
00:59:13 but I have met people that are more grassroots populist from the West.
00:59:17 I've met people that are young up-and-comers, keen conservatives.
00:59:20 I've met Red Tories.
00:59:21 So there is a coalition here, but I'm very keenly aware of the fact that the people I've been meeting in the halls here
00:59:26 do not represent the totality of the right-of-center movement.
00:59:30 And by that, I include, you know, the red Tory, blue Tory, fiscal conservatives, libertarians, social conservatives, fiscal hawks, property rights, rurals, all of these types of people that I think are a part of this coalition in the country that doesn't often agree on everything and in some cases might not even agree on most things.
00:59:49 And what's fascinating is that everyone has their red line.
00:59:52 And over the course of the pandemic, we saw a lot of people who might be economic socialists
00:59:57 that saw their red line was personal freedom and bodily autonomy.
01:00:01 People that would never identify as being on the right that all of a sudden found no home on the left
01:00:06 because of what that was happening through the COVID era.
01:00:09 I did an interview earlier with a former Liberal member of Parliament, Dan McTagg,
01:00:13 that I'll share with you next week, in which he talks about his departure from the Liberal Party.
01:00:17 But as he describes it, it was actually the Liberal Party's departure from him.
01:00:22 And I think that's a fascinating thing we need to keep an eye on in the conservative movement and coalition.
01:00:27 Now, just to do the shameless plug here, I have a biography coming out in the next month about conservative leader Pierre Polyev.
01:00:34 And one of the fascinating things I sort of touched on in that book, I think it's fascinating anyway,
01:00:39 is that Polyev's development as a politician, as a political leader,
01:00:44 has really tracked the development and evolution of the modern conservative movement.
01:00:49 He was a young reform activist in Alberta in the 1990s.
01:00:52 He was part of the fight to change that into the Reform Party.
01:00:55 He was part of the fight to merge the Reform Alliance Party with the PC Party
01:01:00 and then form the Conservative Party of Canada,
01:01:02 which he contested a seat in as he was elected and was a member of parliament
01:01:06 and has been for the 20 years that party has been in existence.
01:01:10 So that's in and of itself a fascinating story here.
01:01:13 And you look at how Preston Manning, who founded the Canada Strong and Free Network
01:01:17 as the Manning Centre some years back, how Preston Manning has influenced this.
01:01:22 So I don't think it's an elite gathering.
01:01:23 I think you can say it's a gathering that has some elites,
01:01:26 just as the Conservative movement in this country has some elites.
01:01:29 But one thing that is fascinating here is the level of enthusiasm and momentum.
01:01:33 It has been a very dark period of time for people that don't like Justin Trudeau for the last several years
01:01:39 because they keep seeing Justin Trudeau get elected and re-elected and re-elected and wonder how.
01:01:44 This past year has been the first time I've seen a monumental shift where Conservatives don't just seem happy to vote out Justin Trudeau,
01:01:51 but seem to be more secure in voting for something else and putting forward a positive vision that isn't just an opposition-based thing.
01:02:00 And again, not everyone is going to rally behind Pierre Polyev
01:02:03 and the Capital C Conservative Party of Canada.
01:02:05 But there does seem to be a lot more of a grounded sense
01:02:08 of what Conservatives are fighting for with a small C,
01:02:11 what people in the movement are fighting for.
01:02:13 So we'll leave it there for this week.
01:02:15 We'll have more interviews from the Canada Strong and Free Networks Conference
01:02:18 as the show progresses next week.
01:02:20 I'll be back in the regular studio then.
01:02:21 But thank you to all of you who have been tuning in.
01:02:23 And if I can just say, being here is important.
01:02:26 There are a lot of people that we really don't get the chance to speak to,
01:02:29 like Tony Abbott for example
01:02:30 but there is a cost in doing this
01:02:32 we have a great video set up
01:02:33 it's been phenomenal
01:02:34 it is expensive though
01:02:36 if you can support the work we're doing
01:02:37 please head on over to
01:02:38 donate.tnc.news
01:02:41 donate.tnc.news
01:02:43 but thank you
01:02:43 we'll talk to you soon
01:02:44 thank you
01:02:44 God bless
01:02:45 and have a wonderful weekend
01:02:46 thanks for listening to the Andrew Vaughn Show
01:02:49 support the program by donating to True North
01:02:52 at www.tnc.news
01:02:59 You