Juno News - October 24, 2022


Why is Doug Ford so afraid of testifying before Emergencies Act commission?

Topics
Mentioned
Canadian influencers speak out about Trudeau’s internet censorship bill WHAT? Reuters "fact checked" True North?

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

171.23

Word count

7,331

Sentence count

172

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On day eight of the Public Order Emergency Commission hearings in Ottawa, Ontario Premier Doug Ford has been ordered to appear before the commission as a witness, but he has refused. Now he has asked for a judicial review to stop the hearing because he says it violates parliamentary privilege. Andrew Lawton asks why on earth Doug Ford doesn t want to testify.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by TrueNord.
00:00:13 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:00:16 This is Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:00:18 You're tuned in live to the Andrew Lawton Show,
00:00:20 Monday, October 24th, 2022.
00:00:24 Day 8 of the Public Order Emergency Commission hearings in Ottawa
00:00:29 and as we have talked about last week and two weeks ago on the show we're going to keep following
00:00:34 this talking about things that are happening in the hearing room and also things that are
00:00:39 happening outside the hearing room that have a great deal of relevance on what are what's
00:00:44 happening there and I want to just start right out of the gate on this there was a fascinating
00:00:49 development today where Ontario Premier Doug Ford and Ontario Solicitor General Sylvia Jones
00:00:55 who last week said Ford said specifically that he wasn't testifying before the Public Order
00:01:03 Emergency Commission because he hadn't been asked well this week the commission has said we've asked
00:01:07 you numerous times and you have not responded or you have declined so now the commission has issued
00:01:14 Doug Ford and Sylvia Jones a legal summons to compel them to appear before the commission
00:01:20 hearings as witnesses. Now you may think, okay, that's a little bit of a strange development for
00:01:26 a guy that just said he wasn't there because he hadn't been asked. But now Ford has applied for
00:01:31 judicial review to stop himself from having to appear. He says it violates parliamentary
00:01:37 privilege. So my question here, why on earth does Doug Ford not want to testify? Here's a guy
00:01:42 who by his own admission said he's a supporter of the Emergencies Act being used. He said he was
00:01:48 standing shoulder to shoulder with Justin Trudeau and his buddy Christia Freeland and they were all
00:01:53 working together and this was important and he was taking a stand against the terrible truckers
00:01:58 by supporting the emergencies act why does he not want to go under oath and talk about that
00:02:02 if he thinks it was so necessary is it maybe because last week we learned that the federal
00:02:08 government was trash talking him behind his back Justin Trudeau and Jim Watson weren't being as
00:02:13 buddy-buddy with him as he was with them or is it because he knows that the government didn't really
00:02:17 have the basis to do it, as we're hearing from countless witnesses that have been testifying
00:02:23 before this commission over the last eight days. I'm going to bring into the discussion in just a
00:02:29 moment's time Keith Wilson, who is a lawyer extraordinaire, a King's counsel, the first
00:02:34 King's counsel I've ever met because he was the first to change from the QC that he had had for
00:02:39 so many years. But before I bring in Keith, I just want to play one of the clips that has
00:02:43 been coming out of the many things today we've learned from Interim Ottawa Police Chief Steve
00:02:50 Bell and one of them I think is becoming the key theme here when we learned that police had a plan
00:02:58 police had a plan to deal with what was happening that didn't involve the Emergencies Act we were
00:03:04 told this last week by police representatives and we were told it again today by Interim Chief Bell
00:03:09 oh maybe we don't have that clip all right sorry about that we'll we'll get to that clip a little
00:03:21 bit later on in the show I've oversold but you know what the best way I can fix this is by
00:03:26 bringing Keith Wilson on now he is he's going to save any show before it goes off the rails
00:03:30 Keith it's good to talk to you thanks for coming on today thanks for having me on Andrew
00:03:35 So let me start first off with this business with Doug Ford here.
00:03:40 Why on earth is it that the Premier would have to be summonsed to appear when just last week he was saying,
00:03:48 yeah, I'm all for appearing, I'm all for coming, they just haven't asked yet?
00:03:52 Well, he's given the answer with the judicial review you mentioned that he doesn't want to testify.
00:03:58 And that, of course, raises some interesting questions.
00:04:01 What is he worried that he's going to be asked?
00:04:03 What is he worried that he might have to answer?
00:04:07 This is very surprising even to me, who, as you can imagine, with all the things I've been through,
00:04:13 I've got a pretty high threshold for surprise, and this one trips it handily.
00:04:18 Yeah, I mean, I would say that as far as people that we could benefit from hearing from here,
00:04:25 the Ontario government will be a fascinating one because this was the government that had to grapple with the Ambassador Bridge blockade.
00:04:32 And it's the government that managed to clear up that blockade without the Emergencies Act, using regular policing powers just in a matter of about 48 hours.
00:04:41 So I actually think hearing from Premier Ford about why you couldn't just apply what you did there to Ottawa would be a fascinating revelation for the commission.
00:04:52 Well, and for all of us, I mean, what's striking is compare it to something else.
00:04:57 the the premier ford's position as we now have learned in the last number of hours
00:05:02 which is compare it to the position of the prime minister
00:05:05 doug ford was not a decision maker with respect to the invocation of the emergencies act the
00:05:09 prime minister was and he's expressed a willingness to to testify is not requiring to be subpoenaed
00:05:16 he's coming under his own volition i think he realized he had no choice but you know why
00:05:22 why premier ford would do this to himself he's likely to lose his judicial review just because
00:05:30 the case law is so clear um he's not precluded from invoking a privilege when he's asked a
00:05:37 question if the question triggers privilege so this is um bad political strategy in my view he
00:05:44 would have been better off to just say yeah i'm happy to come and share whatever mission i have
00:05:49 and help Canadians get to the bottom of this.
00:05:51 It's a very important inquiry and happy to be here.
00:05:54 Instead, he's just embroiled himself in a self-imposed controversy.
00:05:59 When we talk about the witnesses that are slated to appear,
00:06:03 we've got members of the Convoy's board,
00:06:06 we've got more police representatives,
00:06:09 we've got some bureaucrats from all number of federal departments
00:06:12 and intelligence agencies, we've got federal cabinet ministers.
00:06:15 I know that this is fluid and more witnesses could be added here.
00:06:20 We also have that statutory cutoff where the report has to be tabled by February.
00:06:26 And I'm wondering, is it possible to cast too wide a net here and bring in more people than are needed for the commissioner to make the decision?
00:06:33 Or is your view that this witness list is actually so light that key details are being missed?
00:06:40 Well, you're right that it's a dynamic process.
00:06:43 the witness list that everyone's seen was the first preliminary witness list there will be a
00:06:49 new witness list coming out soon and it will have a lot more names on it and that's the nature of
00:06:56 this process we've been working with the commission's lawyers on on expanding the
00:07:02 number of witnesses that will speak on behalf of the freedom convoy protesters so it is and
00:07:08 And the other thing that's happening here is, which is really unusual for lawyers anyway,
00:07:13 is that normally before you go into something like this, all the documents are disclosed
00:07:17 and you have a chance to review them.
00:07:19 We're getting new documents disclosed every day.
00:07:22 And the last count we had, we were over 15,000 records, well over 20,000 pages of documents.
00:07:32 So the paper evidence just keeps coming in by the day that, depending on our review of it and what we find and other parties finds, then triggers a request.
00:07:44 So, for example, one of the things that our group and a number of other lawyers representing other groups made a formal application late last week to have the commissioner issue a subpoena to the head of the CBC to testify.
00:07:58 because one of the focuses in the ordering council for this public inquiry is to examine
00:08:05 misinformation and disinformation and given that we couldn't understand why the head of the cbc
00:08:11 wasn't at the top of the witness list so we know that mendocino and other ministers have routinely
00:08:18 referred to fake news stories as a basis of their decision making so this inquiry has been
00:08:26 fascinating since the first day as you know we're on day eight of 38 days of of evidence we still
00:08:33 have at least 30 days to go assuming we don't start sitting saturdays and i think we're going
00:08:38 to start sitting the hearing on saturdays very soon just on a on a this is not a question that's
00:08:44 coming from anywhere but my own mind here is there a mechanism at all to delay the production
00:08:50 of the report if for some reason they need more time for hearings they need more witnesses more
00:08:57 time to put it all together or is that a complete no-go under the statute well the what's the
00:09:04 statute simple says that you have to table your report before the legislatures of the provinces
00:09:09 and the parliament of canada and the senate within 365 days of the revocation of the invocation
00:09:17 okay so that puts us into february next year as to whether or not the commissioner decides so he's
00:09:24 got two blocks of time left hearing time and then review and writing time he may decide to chop a
00:09:31 week or two off of his his writing time for him and his commission staff and and extend the hearing
00:09:37 um the only other i've been asked this question many times the only other situation would be if
00:09:44 the parliament and the senate decide to amend the emergencies act to modify section 63
00:09:51 and change it from 365 days to some other number so we can all guess at what the mechanics of that
00:10:00 might be but the commissioner is running a very tight ship we put in a request each day by five
00:10:07 o'clock for the witnesses we're going to be cross-examining three days from now and that's
00:10:11 the rule we do every day we're working seven days a week uh many many hours a day and night
00:10:16 um and we have to identify all of the documents that we're going to put to the witness in cross
00:10:23 so we would have identified uh interim chief bell what i guess on friday of last week
00:10:28 um and then we so we may say we need an hour and a half to cross examine uh interim chief
00:10:35 bell and then the commissioner will say you get 15 minutes or you get 10 minutes or you get 20
00:10:39 minutes so that's how it works for all the parties and uh and he's got a stop clock up there
00:10:45 as you probably noticed he'll sometimes let you run over a little bit but he's running a pretty
00:10:50 tight ship and um uh you know right now we're assuming we're going to finish on time and but
00:10:56 we're very much alive to the fact that in the next couple of weeks we'll probably be sitting on
00:11:01 saturdays and holding the hearing on saturdays as well as going till eight and nine o'clock each
00:11:05 night i want to play a very brief clip here from uh today this is brendan miller representing
00:11:11 uh freedom corp uh during his cross-examination of interim chief bell earlier today talking about
00:11:18 this idea of there being a plan by police without the emergencies act but last question just because
00:11:26 i just want to get this clear but so you're saying that there was existing laws that you
00:11:31 could have done the same thing under. Is that right? We had a plan. We were going to execute
00:11:37 a plan. Thank you. Very clear question. You had existing laws. The interim chief says there was
00:11:43 a plan. We had a plan. You know, when these sorts of revelations came out last week, there was a
00:11:49 part of me that wondered if, you know, in very dramatic Hollywood-like fashion, Brendan Miller
00:11:53 could just say, I rest my case, nothing further and go home. Because really that seems to be
00:11:59 inherently inherently disqualifying for the emergencies act the way the act is written
00:12:05 well when brendan uh and you know we're thrilled to have him leading our team and being the lead
00:12:10 barrister that was to be my job but after i assessed brendan's skills and the role that
00:12:17 i'm taking in this inquiry and the fact that i'm likely to testify it simply wasn't proper to have
00:12:22 me be the barrister but brendan's doing a terrific job but when he did his opening statement you'll
00:12:27 You'll recall, Andrew, that he was very straightforward and he laid out, here's the four things that the government has to establish, you know, that there was acts of sabotage or espionage.
00:12:41 There will be no evidence of espionage.
00:12:44 There will be that they have to establish that there was threats of serious violence against persons and property.
00:12:49 There will be no evidence.
00:12:50 And he went through the list in his opening statement.
00:12:53 he reframed his opening statement at a cross-examination questions when he interviewed
00:12:58 the head of the OPP's intelligence unit and he answered each one of them you know in the negative
00:13:06 there what there there's no evidence of serious fights against property there was no evidence of
00:13:11 insurrection there was no evidence of of of terrorist activity all of these requirements so
00:13:16 after that cross-examination last week of the head of the OPP's intelligence
00:13:21 group we we we did kind of joke well you know time to pack our bags and head home to our families
00:13:29 but of course we got to see this thing out and we will because it's not just the legal test that's
00:13:35 at issue here it's the narrative and I'm really concerned about this element of misinformation
00:13:40 disinformation because in my view having cross-examined all the various government experts
00:13:46 and officials on the Peckford case with respect to the justifications for the mandates and
00:13:51 the vaccine approval process and all of these other issues I know where the disinformation is
00:13:57 it's it's it's from the government and so there's there's other narratives that need to be explored
00:14:03 and exposed and it's going to continue to be a fascinating inquiry in my view you mentioned the
00:14:09 the Peckford case you and I have spoken about this in the past and I covered the hearing that took
00:14:14 place on the federal government's application to dismiss the whole thing as moot because in their
00:14:19 words the mandates were gone you don't need to be vaccinated to get on a plane case closed and it
00:14:24 was quite disheartening the other day when the federal court justice the associate chief justice
00:14:29 approved that she granted that motion she said this is moot reasons that have not yet been
00:14:34 published here but even though the federal government in its own language has said this
00:14:39 was a temporary suspension they've managed to essentially convince the federal court of this
00:14:45 country that it's not worth hearing whether that mandate was unconstitutional to begin with now i
00:14:51 know uh premier peckford maxine bernier uh some of the other applicants as well i believe have said
00:14:56 they're going to appeal this but i was wondering if you could explain in the absence of decisions
00:15:01 why you think that went the way it did in the absence of reasons rather well i mean i hate to
00:15:08 be cynical but I have no choice given what I've seen and it's just clear to me when you look at
00:15:16 the decisions of our courts at the provincial level in the federal level they've just been
00:15:21 been unwilling lacking the judicial courage I believe to do the hard analysis I don't feel
00:15:32 that uh you know there's the the image of lady justice with the scales of justice and the
00:15:39 blindfold the blindfold's probably you know down over her nose right now is how i'm feeling
00:15:46 and um uh they're just when you look at the legal test for whether or not to grant a mootness motion
00:15:53 you know when there's a serious constitutional issue at play is one of the reasons not to strike
00:16:00 out a case for mootness and we have clear uncontroverted evidence that over six million
00:16:07 canadians fundamental right of mobility under section six of the charter were grossly violated
00:16:12 resulting in them being unable to be at the side of dying loved ones attend funerals be there for
00:16:19 their first grandchild to help a loved one be discharged and recover from hospital to go to
00:16:26 to weddings and other important celebrations that this was a violation of charter rights on a scale
00:16:34 that has never occurred in our history and is almost unimaginable but it happened and for the
00:16:40 court to say well you know nothing to see here they they suspended those travel mandates now move
00:16:47 along everyone is uh is not helpful um the courts as i said to the judge in my oral argument
00:16:58 provide a fundamental role in a modern democracy in a civil society they're the third leg of the
00:17:03 stool we have the legislative branch of government we have the executive branch of government and we
00:17:08 have the judicial branch of government and they're to perform checks and balances and what's happened
00:17:13 with this mootness ruling is the federal court is checked out and that doesn't make the stool more
00:17:18 stable. I've remarked on this on the program in the past but when in 2019 the Leaders Debates
00:17:25 Commission banned True North and Rebel from covering the debate we filed a case for an
00:17:30 injunction we won and our longer term case was dismissed as moot and then in 2021 the Leaders
00:17:37 Debates Commission does the exact same thing with Rebel. Rebel goes and files another case
00:17:42 wins again so as a matter of practicality when there is a significant risk that something like
00:17:48 this is going to happen again I think it should be heard but as you've mentioned even if we knew
00:17:52 that the mandates were done forever which I wish we could take for granted but we can't this was
00:17:57 such a significant breach of Canadians rights that it should absolutely have a declaration on record
00:18:05 that it was unconstitutional and I hope that appeal is successful Keith I do just going back
00:18:11 very briefly before we let you go to the Public Order Emergency Commission. This week, we're
00:18:16 hearing a bit more from police. I just got the list of expected witnesses for tomorrow. We've got
00:18:22 Russell Lucas from the Ottawa Police Service, Marcel Baudin from the OPP, Robert Drummond from
00:18:28 the Ottawa Police Service. Are we expecting more of what we've been hearing? Or do you think that
00:18:33 from law enforcement, there's still a little bit that could come out that might qualify as a
00:18:37 bombshell or a smoking gun to use the popular lingo uh there could be some bombshells in the
00:18:43 sense of contradicting uh early test earlier testimony from some of the other police officials
00:18:48 but i think we're going to see more of the same you know that i was um along with tom razo and
00:18:54 eva chipiak we were the ones that there's been a lot of evidence about the negotiations that
00:18:59 occurred at city hall and we were the ones in the room and um um we were we we just about had a big
00:19:09 success in the early days at sussex and rodeau which was a really tough intersection uh to deal
00:19:14 with um given the nature of the people who are protesting there and then we negotiated with the
00:19:20 help of former chief of staff to premier ford dean french the umbrella deal to actually de-escalate
00:19:27 the entire thing just before the invocation of the emergencies act and one of the things that's
00:19:33 occurring to us sitting there as eva and i and tom are listening to this testimony in real time is
00:19:38 that you know we know exactly now why these deals didn't ultimately be successfully implemented
00:19:44 it was due completely to policing competence like they just lacked the basic communication
00:19:50 competency to place the police in the right places and remove them from other places to allow the
00:19:58 deal to be implemented. We were constantly blocked by the police and seeing their handwritten notes
00:20:04 from the chief's meetings about knowing about the deal and the instructions and their frustration
00:20:09 with the communication not getting through. It's just remarkable in a very disturbing way the level
00:20:15 of incompetency of the police that's been revealed and i think well i'm pretty confident you're going
00:20:22 to see even more to come and this is many things but a national emergency it is not
00:20:30 it's a national embarrassment and that's not a reason to invoke the emergencies act keith wilson
00:20:36 i know you are plugging away daily in ottawa and we'll be sure to have you back as long as
00:20:40 as long as you can spare some time outside of the hearing room and also your colleague
00:20:44 eva chipiuk is welcome back anytime thanks so much sir always good to talk to you thank you
00:20:49 that was keith wilson the eminent barrister representing a lot of the members of the convoy
00:20:56 protest although as you just heard earlier not testifying or not appearing as a council of record
00:21:02 because he may be appearing as a witness instead which i very very much look forward to if that
00:21:08 happens as we expect it may in the weeks ahead here the question i asked at the beginning is
00:21:13 what on earth is Doug Ford afraid of? Because we've had, I mean, there are low-level bureaucrats
00:21:18 that are testifying. We've had city councillors. We've had Ottawa business representatives.
00:21:23 We've had a public servant that didn't like the sounds of horns honking that was testifying. Why
00:21:29 is Ontario Premier Doug Ford, who has been, to my knowledge, the only premier to be enthusiastically
00:21:36 in favor of the emergencies act why is he willing to go to court to protect himself from having to
00:21:44 appear to defend a piece of legislation that he supports that is going to be the key question
00:21:52 here now this as i mentioned it has become a bit of a subplot taking place outside of the commission
00:21:58 but doug ford initially last week said oh no they haven't asked me that's why i'm there
00:22:02 leaving the implication that he would go if they were to ask him so the commission and I don't know
00:22:07 what date said okay well let's ask him they asked him they asked him and he has not appeared in that
00:22:16 time and I want to pull up the exact wording that the commission used in its letter here because I
00:22:22 think it's actually quite important and I've like I just like had it like five tabs ago so I'll pull
00:22:27 that up in a second but what the commission said in its letter was that we've asked you
00:22:31 and now we're issuing a summons and that I think was so key so they said we asked you and you said
00:22:38 no so this means that Doug Ford was saying something that was patently untrue or maybe
00:22:43 this all was just a little misunderstanding that took place in the days since but one thing is for
00:22:48 sure he doesn't want to go and I don't know why that is if you have nothing to hide you shouldn't
00:22:52 be afraid to go under oath and defend this thing and as an Ontario voter and by the way an Ontario
00:22:59 citizen who stood as a candidate for Doug Ford's progressive conservatives in 2018 it is absolutely
00:23:07 shameful shameful that this man who calls himself a premier for the people is standing up and
00:23:14 standing by his own words shoulder to shoulder with Justin Trudeau on this heavy-handed crackdown
00:23:21 that suspended civil liberties all done to protect the narrative around a mandate that in and of
00:23:30 itself suspended people's rights and Doug Ford decides that this is how he wants to score his
00:23:36 brownie points with Justin Trudeau by standing shoulder to shoulder. It is absolutely shameful
00:23:41 and it's despicable that he is now too afraid to take a stand before the Public Order Emergency
00:23:46 Commission under oath and defend why it is exactly that Ontario supported that when Ontario didn't
00:23:52 need it to deal with the Windsor blockade which was widely regarded as being far more disruptive
00:23:58 than anything happening in Ottawa. I want to just before we close things out here talk about a few
00:24:04 more of the updates that have come out of the commission today. Obviously there have been a
00:24:10 number a number of revelations from interim police chief Steve Bell who we just learned the other day
00:24:16 is not going to be the permanent police chief so Ottawa has hired someone else but I want to play
00:24:22 one clip here where Steve Bell says that he had no knowledge of how police how his police officers
00:24:31 were dealing with the arrests of protesters and because Ottawa police and the OPP all of the
00:24:37 stakeholders involved they were doing this catch and release type thing just to get people out of
00:24:42 the core. But listen to Steve Bell say, well, you know, all of a sudden we had a plan. We knew what
00:24:47 was going on. But on this, oh, I had no idea what was happening. So you're going to hear evidence
00:24:54 eventually from some of the protesters when they eventually testify that some of the ones that
00:25:00 were arrested upon their release, they were essentially kidnapped by OPS officers, driven
00:25:05 out of town in the middle of February winter by OPS officers and left in various rural areas and
00:25:11 parking lots outside of town with no shelter or resources.
00:25:14 Are you aware of that?
00:25:17 No, because I don't know the specifics of what they're speaking about.
00:25:21 What I do know is that we, as part of our planning, and Inspector Lucas
00:25:26 Tamura will be able to provide more details, but we did have remote
00:25:30 arrest processing sites, not in rural Ottawa, in the south end of Ottawa,
00:25:35 in a residential mixed commercial area
00:25:40 where they were protested and then released
00:25:43 to be able to find transportation to wherever they needed to go,
00:25:48 which is common with the police.
00:25:51 Right.
00:25:51 So one of the areas, there was several, as I understand,
00:25:54 one of them was a municipal parking lot
00:25:56 where the trucks were being towed to.
00:25:59 That's correct.
00:25:59 That's in the South End.
00:26:00 Right.
00:26:00 And that parking lot doesn't have a building you drop them off at.
00:26:05 It doesn't have a phone.
00:26:07 It doesn't have any of that, does it?
00:26:09 So I don't know what the logistics at the building were.
00:26:14 I would imagine it would have needed to have a phone
00:26:16 because you have to be able to call your lawyer.
00:26:18 Well, I can tell you it didn't.
00:26:20 And these people driven out there,
00:26:22 they were already told they weren't charged,
00:26:24 and they weren't being charged, they were being released.
00:26:27 But they were driven and forced outside of Ottawa
00:26:32 or in the outer skirts and dropped off in the snow.
00:26:35 now are you aware this happened yes or no no i'm not aware and it wasn't outside of ottawa
00:26:40 still within the geographical boundaries of the city of ottawa
00:26:43 oh well what's in the geographical boundaries of the city so that that's fake news yeah well
00:26:50 you know like yeah three inches within the city limits we dump you in a patch of snow
00:26:54 and take your phone and all of that and well bob's your uncle everything's supposed to be fine
00:26:58 uh that letter that i referenced a moment ago i want to read a bit of here because it's from
00:27:04 the co-lead counsel Shantona Chowdhury for the Public Order Emergency Commission she writes the
00:27:10 information gathered by Commission Council in the course of the investigation made clear
00:27:14 that Premier Ford and Minister Jones would have evidence particularly within their knowledge that
00:27:20 would be relevant to the Commission's mandate. On September 19th 2022 Commission Council requested
00:27:28 an interview with them this request was refused commission council renewed this request multiple
00:27:35 times all requests were refused commission council then requested that premier ford and minister
00:27:41 jones agree to testify before the commission voluntarily as of last week the invitation to
00:27:47 attend to testify before the commission has been declined for the moment it is our hope
00:27:54 that it was our hope that premier ford and minister jones would agree to appear before
00:27:58 the commission voluntarily however given that the repeated invitations were all declined the
00:28:02 commission has issued summons this day to premier ford and minister jones pursuant to section four
00:28:08 of the inquiries act the commission thanks you for your request and your continued participation in
00:28:13 this inquiry so when doug ford said last week that no one had asked him that was fundamentally
00:28:19 untrue the commission says on september 19th they first asked him and have repeated and renewed that
00:28:25 request multiple times so i go back to what is it that doug ford is so afraid of in appearing before
00:28:34 this commission and i'm so challenged by how people are looking at this and coming out with
00:28:41 the conclusion that the emergencies act was justified police incompetence government
00:28:45 incompetence bureaucratic incompetence and jockeying for position between levels of
00:28:50 government does not constitute in the least a national emergency and a lot of the narratives
00:28:56 even that were put up to support this idea of violence have shattered for example there was
00:29:01 a rumor and i think it was reported in media early on of some threat against rito hall well
00:29:07 interim chief steve bell said that didn't actually happen somebody sent um information to the former
00:29:16 chief directly. Somebody wrote, I lay awake tonight as I read Twitter posts from the extreme
00:29:24 right vowing attacks on Rideau Hall this weekend. Some are calling for action akin to the happenings
00:29:30 in Washington on Capitol Hill. I understand the right to peaceful protest, but I'm writing as a
00:29:35 very concerned citizen as we're not hearing any reassurances from the city of policing
00:29:40 regarding the safety of residents surrounding these vulnerable and targeted spots.
00:29:45 There was national security representatives, including CSIS and the RCMP, in our joint intelligence group.
00:29:53 So, again, this was information that was taken in, assessed, evaluated, put towards our threat assessment.
00:30:03 And ultimately, this didn't bear out to be accurate.
00:30:07 There was no threats made against Rideau Hall.
00:30:13 Weird.
00:30:14 So that might have just been some of that misinformation we need to get to the bottom of.
00:30:18 No threats against Rideau Hall, just like there was no attempted arson by anyone connected to the convoy,
00:30:24 just like police exonerated convoy participants from the issue that happened at the Cenotaph early on with a woman dancing and so on.
00:30:31 But it's that old line about how a lie makes its way around the world.
00:30:35 I don't know what the original quote was, however many times, well, the truth is still putting its pants on.
00:30:40 I am not going to subject you to eight hours of Steve Bell because if you wanted eight hours of
00:30:45 Steve Bell, you could have watched today's hearings before the Public Order Emergency
00:30:48 Commission. But what I am going to talk about right now is the importance of language. Now,
00:30:55 police officers, and I have some in my family, are normally very precise about language because in
00:31:00 law, words mean things and words are defined in very particular ways. So Steve Bell was talking
00:31:07 about violence the violence that people in the convoy world that were living in Ottawa not part
00:31:15 of the convoy violence they were being subjected to and again we've heard reports from OPP intelligence
00:31:20 that violence wasn't actually taking place we didn't see from Ottawa police charges of violence
00:31:25 by and large so what is what where is this violence coming from if you're going to make a
00:31:30 drive-by comment like that what is it you actually mean well turns out Steve Bell has redefined what
00:31:37 violence means. So is it fair to say that when you use the phrase violence you're not actually
00:31:43 describing any form of physical assaults are you? I'm well physical assaults do contribute to what
00:31:50 I'm describing. I was specifically describing the violence that our community felt as a result of
00:31:56 the culmination of actions that the occupiers engaged in. So the violence that they felt not
00:32:02 actual violence is that what you're saying that is correct not not the criminal code definition
00:32:07 of violence but the violence that they felt by having an incessant horns blared right and having
00:32:12 trucks run 24 7 a day right by having people intimidate them and follow them and by having
00:32:19 people rip masks off their head by feeling sheltered in their homes well i i thank you i
00:32:24 understand what you mean but you're not talking about violence under section two of the cesus act
00:32:29 are you no I'm not thanks the the violence so he's talking about microaggressions now the violence
00:32:41 you feel it's like you know the violence grows from the heart outward to merge that with Justin
00:32:46 Trudeau the violence you feel so it's you could go to police and I would imagine if you were to call
00:32:53 up a 911 in Ottawa and say you know I feel murdered they'd be like well hang on a minute
00:32:59 if you you're making the call i don't think you were murdered no no i feel murdered i i feel like
00:33:05 someone has killed me okay i feel like my car was broken into was your car broken into no no but i
00:33:12 feel like i feel just like collectively the world around me has made it feel like that and then he
00:33:18 says no no i don't mean violence in the criminal code sense he certainly didn't mean violence in
00:33:23 the section two of the ceases accents he means the collective feeling of violence so take from
00:33:31 that what you will but we are just redefining words left right and center i will say good news
00:33:37 he didn't get anyone to have to translate that he was able to explain what his definition of
00:33:42 violence was in england so take that counselor matthew flurry i'm just going to take a step
00:33:48 side step away from the public order emergency commission here which we will certainly revisit
00:33:53 on the next program this week and i want to talk a little bit about alberta politics because it was
00:33:58 busy over the weekend when danielle smith premier danielle smith came out swinging
00:34:04 at the united conservative party agm and at this event she took a very firm and decisive position
00:34:12 to lay out her sovereignty act which she says will be ready by the time she takes her seat
00:34:18 after winning a by-election in brooks medicine hat but i want to play this clip which has gotten
00:34:23 like hundreds of thousands of views online even from other parts of the world who i don't even
00:34:29 know if they know what an alberta is or a sovereignty act is but are nonetheless inspired
00:34:34 by this message against the ottawa elites there can be no doubt that the current ndp
00:34:41 liberal alliance is just the latest in a long line of ottawa governments that have frustrated
00:34:48 the legitimate aspirations of hard-working Albertans.
00:34:52 That stops now.
00:34:54 When Ottawa announces policies and laws that attack our economy
00:34:57 or violate the rights of our people,
00:34:59 or when Ottawa seeks to take control of our sovereign areas of provincial jurisdiction,
00:35:06 our UCP government will not enforce those laws and policies in this province, period.
00:35:18 And let me be very clear.
00:35:46 I will never, ever apologize for standing up for the people of Alberta and the province that I serve.
00:35:58 So, we will pass the Sovereignty Act.
00:36:01 Work has already begun on crafting it.
00:36:03 We worked on it earlier this week at the caucus retreat.
00:36:06 We still have further work to do, but I've asked for it to be ready by the time I take my seat in the legislature.
00:36:11 We will then introduce it, and we will pass it, and we will use it to push Ottawa back into its own lane every single time that they step out of line and intrude on our constitutional rights.
00:36:22 Alberta will no longer ask permission from Ottawa to be prosperous and free.
00:36:34 Preach it, Premier, preach it.
00:36:36 And I will say on that that one of, like, the most bizarre law enforcement,
00:36:41 of Danielle Smith, if I can use that word, was from comedian Rob Schneider, who like retweeted
00:36:47 my tweet of that video and talked about how Danielle Smith is a real leader. And I was just
00:36:52 imagining Rob Schneider and a bunch of his movies just going like, you know, Danielle Smith, you can
00:36:56 do it. That was Rob Schneider to Alberta Premier Danielle Smith over the weekend. And it didn't
00:37:02 stop there. She did a press conference after and said something that I'm not sure any politician 0.98
00:37:08 has ever said when asked by a Rebel News journalist when she would apologize
00:37:12 to the unvaccinated for the discrimination they faced at the hands of Alberta's government.
00:37:20 A lot of the fines that were delivered were administrative fines that came out of Alberta
00:37:25 Health Services so I beg to differ. It was a political decision to throw all the Charter
00:37:30 of Rights and Freedoms and to put those fines in place in the first place and I think it can be a
00:37:33 political decision to make amends and apologize for it and eliminate them but I'm getting us
00:37:37 some legal advice on that. That was unfortunately not the right clip we'll try to get the right
00:37:45 clip pulled up in just a couple of moments time here but the reason I think this is important 0.99
00:37:50 to talk about is because Danielle Smith is coming in and she's got a very short runway here a very 0.99
00:37:56 short runway in which she can deal with the media attacks against her which are somewhat relentless 0.99
00:38:03 And in fact, I'd say no somewhat about it. 1.00
00:38:04 They are relentless and actually rebrand herself in the eyes of Alberta voters with an election 1.00
00:38:11 coming up next May.
00:38:13 So she does not have a lot of time, especially if you take into consideration that she'll
00:38:17 be taking her seat in the legislature probably by the end of November, early December at
00:38:24 the earliest here. 0.96
00:38:25 She's going to have a very limited window before legislature rises for Christmas. 0.99
00:38:30 and then she's going to have a bit of a break
00:38:33 and then she's going to have only really 0.96
00:38:35 four maybe five months total I think 0.96
00:38:38 of time in the legislature 0.98
00:38:40 before she's in campaign mode
00:38:42 and I think that's very important
00:38:44 but she is coming out of the gate swinging
00:38:46 she has not done this pivot 0.88
00:38:49 that we hear about from people
00:38:50 where they run for the leadership a certain way
00:38:52 and then once they win the leadership
00:38:54 they immediately pivot to something else
00:38:56 Aaron O'Toole did it in 2020
00:38:58 Andrew Scheer did it in 2017
00:39:00 And I think that is in and of itself the really important part of this divide,
00:39:08 that she is being as authentic as she is now.
00:39:12 She was in the leadership.
00:39:14 So I think we have the right clip now. 0.97
00:39:16 This is Danielle Smith on apologizing to the unvaccinated. 0.98
00:39:21 Hi, Ms. Smith.
00:39:22 Sleek Ellis with Rebel News.
00:39:23 During your campaign, you said that not only would you issue an apology
00:39:26 to those prosecuted during COVID restrictions,
00:39:29 but you would also grant them amnesty. When can we expect those apologies?
00:39:33 I can apologize right now. I'm deeply sorry for anyone who was inappropriately subjected
00:39:41 to discrimination as a result of their vaccine status. I'm deeply sorry for any government
00:39:48 employee that was fired from their job because of their vaccine status, and I welcome them 1.00
00:39:53 back if they want to come back. As for the amnesty, I have to get some legal advice on 1.00
00:39:58 So I've already asked my staff to request that advice so I can see how we would be able to proceed on that.
00:40:06 My view has been that these were political decisions that were made,
00:40:10 and so I think that they could be political decisions to offer a reversal.
00:40:14 But I do want to get some legal advice on that first.
00:40:17 Would that also have to do with the timeline for the proposed amnesty?
00:40:20 I would have to see. If I can do it, I would do it at the earliest opportunity.
00:40:25 So that was a clip courtesy of our friends over at Rebel News on the spot says yes I am going to issue us Premier of Alberta an apology to the unvaccinated for what they have suffered and again that was a very clear position that she took and I think it was a very important one and I think there's a reason that has done as well globally so well online.
00:40:55 Now, obviously, she's not after Rob Schneider's votes, unless Rob Schneider has some property in Grand Prairie I don't know about, but she is after the votes of ordinary Albertans that were put in an incredibly difficult situation by their government, which was so far unflinching in defending these mandates, even when they had previously said they would never, ever happen.
00:41:16 And Danielle Smith also said that despite that comment that the Calgary Herald reported on from her new health minister, Jason Copping, mandates and restrictions are not coming back for COVID.
00:41:26 We are moving beyond that, and I think that is a very clear message that Albertans needed to hear.
00:41:32 So I hope you'll forgive the little dalliance away from the Public Order Emergency Commission, but it was too big to not talk about, and I think this is what we'll do.
00:41:39 We'll spend most of the shows dealing with the Public Order Emergency Commission and then as other things come up that tie in or maybe they don't tie in, we'll bring them in and we'll try to do a well-rounded show for you.
00:41:50 But truly, I want to just say thank you to all of you who have been supporters of me, supporters of True North, not just throughout the last few weeks and months, but throughout the Freedom Convoy, throughout the last federal elections, whether you joined us four years ago or you joined us four minutes ago in the middle of this show.
00:42:06 I thank you so much for it. Please do. If you want to see more of this, head on over to donate.tnc.news
00:42:12 and you can make a one-time donation. You can sign up for a recurring donation and you can
00:42:17 keep the lights on, which is sometimes in this studio literal, not figurative. If the lights go
00:42:22 out midway through, I'm immediately pivoting to a fundraising pitch. But these ones we just got,
00:42:27 so I think we're good for a few months anyway. But to all of you, have a great day. Thank you
00:42:31 so much for tuning in. We'll talk to you on Wednesday with more of Canada's Most Irreverent
00:42:36 Talk Show. Thank you, God bless, and good day to you all. Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton
00:42:42 Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.