Juno News - July 26, 2023


Will Trudeau's cabinet shuffle change anything?

Topics
Mentioned
Is the Trudeau government a sinking ship? ‘THIS MAKES NO SENSE!’ Canadian becomes first transgender AND non-binary player at World Cup

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

181.97

Word count

7,804

Sentence count

341

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

It's cabinet day in Canada, and it's a day that will go down in the history books as one of the most significant shake-ups in Canadian politics in recent memory. Andrew Lawton is here to talk about it, and to point out that it's not as bad as you might think.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:22 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:30 hey everyone and welcome to you all this is canada's most irreverent talk show the andrew
00:01:36 lawton show here on true north it is cabinet shuffle day i know it is something that should
00:01:43 probably be at some point a statutory holiday i know all of you will remember where you were
00:01:49 on that fateful day in 2023 i think it's 20 is it 2020 yeah it is okay the last like four years
00:01:56 has basically been so much of a blur, I have no idea when it is.
00:01:59 I don't even know where I am.
00:02:00 So if you find me, rescue me.
00:02:02 But this is all going to be a day that will go down in the ages.
00:02:05 You'll remember where you were when you learned that Marco Mendicino was out of cabinet.
00:02:11 Not just him, also a few others, David Lamedi and Omar Al-Gabra, Mona Fortier,
00:02:17 who one time was, if you can believe this, and if I can do it with a straight face,
00:02:22 the Minister for Middle Class Prosperity, who never at any point during her tenure as Minister
00:02:29 of Middle Class Prosperity thought it would be suitable to learn what the definition of middle
00:02:34 class was. She gave that great answer where it was like, well, you know, people in the middle
00:02:40 class know what it means and that's what matters. So she's gone, as is the Minister of Middle Class
00:02:46 Prosperity. That was like a relic that we went and did away with two or three shuffles ago now.
00:02:51 This has been Justin Trudeau's biggest shuffle yet.
00:02:56 And the thing about this is that it is not really going to change all that.
00:03:02 My colleague Phil has just reminded me that we got rid of middle class prosperity,
00:03:06 but we got Minister of Citizens Services.
00:03:09 So if you are a citizen in need of servicing, there's now a minister for you,
00:03:15 whatever the Minister of Citizens Services is going to do.
00:03:18 Shouldn't all government be like a ministry of citizen service?
00:03:21 I guess that's the whole point here, but it's supposed to be anyway.
00:03:24 But we are going to talk a little bit about the cabinet changes we saw today.
00:03:28 But I want to focus on the bigger picture, which is that it's easy to look at the list of ministers and say,
00:03:33 oh, well, you know, Bill Blair went to defense and this guy went to emergency preparedness
00:03:38 and Anita Anand went from defense to treasury board and all of these things. 0.93
00:03:44 But it's less easy to look at this and say that none of it really matters, that this is not actually an issue that will change anything materially about the function or lack of functionality in this government.
00:03:59 Now, what was interesting here is that it wasn't just about the shuffling of the deck chairs on the Titanic, so to speak.
00:04:07 There were some pretty key promotions, some rookies.
00:04:10 It's now a backbencher, Arif Varani, that went up to be the Minister of Justice.
00:04:15 And then you had some pretty senior people who have been Trudeau loyalists for their time in cabinet
00:04:19 that are now finding themselves relegated to the backbenches.
00:04:23 And some of those did the whole face-saving exercise yesterday of saying,
00:04:28 oh, it's because I'm not running again.
00:04:31 That was Omar Al-Gabra's line.
00:04:33 But some of them have not actually said whether they're running again.
00:04:36 So Marco Mendicino, assuming he manages to find his way back to his office,
00:04:40 which I think is a stroke of luck every day if he does,
00:04:45 he hasn't actually done the whole I'm not running again thing.
00:04:48 He just gave this statement this morning in which he talked about how grateful he was
00:04:53 and how proud he was and how great Justin Trudeau is
00:04:55 and how he did so much good stuff in cabinet.
00:04:58 And oh, there we have the letter there. If you haven't read through it all and you can't see it and you can't read it, don't worry, neither can Marco. But the thing about it that I would point out is that it's like the guy was fired and he's somehow been head faked into writing this letter about just how great it was and how honored he was and all of that.
00:05:18 when he was like the biggest embarrassment in the Trudeau cabinet
00:05:22 who had to wear the Emergencies Act, the Firearms File,
00:05:25 Paul Bernardo, the Nova Scotia shooting, all of these things.
00:05:29 Every single one was bungled.
00:05:32 And he was the guy at the helm.
00:05:33 Like, I was convinced he was going to be the fall guy for the Emergencies Act.
00:05:37 But unfortunately, Justin Trudeau managed to hoodwink the media
00:05:41 and many Canadians into being A-OK with the Emergencies Act.
00:05:44 So they didn't actually need a fall guy.
00:05:46 But Marco Mendicino has finally left, as has David Lometti, the guy who, as I mentioned yesterday, believes that the mentally ill should be given the ability to kill themselves with the state's assistance.
00:05:57 He is now on the back benches.
00:06:00 And to all of the departing cabinet ministers, we will once again give you the somber send-off we did on yesterday's show.
00:06:16 Last time I added a repeat afterwards by singing along,
00:06:34 and I believe our numbers tanked the longer I sang.
00:06:36 So this time I'll just let you hear the original version there.
00:06:41 I want to give a little bit of an honest take on this.
00:06:44 So I'll let you hear in Trudeau's own words how he rationalizes why he fired the people he fired.
00:06:52 And again, it's odd he doesn't even mention their names.
00:06:59 Can you explain your decision to fire Marco Mendicino, Morna Forche, and David Lamedi and remove them entirely from your cabinet?
00:07:05 I want to thank everyone who has served this country and this cabinet so well over the past number of years.
00:07:14 This is a moment where putting forward the strongest possible team with fresh energy and a range of skills that are going to be able to continue the really important work of showing Canadians the positive and ambitious vision for the future that we're so committed to and that I know Canadians need and deserve.
00:07:37 I'm really excited about the work we're doing, and quite frankly, we have a huge team in caucus and across the country working really hard to deliver for Canadians in all sorts of great ways.
00:07:55 So the question was, why did you get rid of these three people?
00:07:59 The answer is a drink, water, juice, bottle, box, drink.
00:08:03 Oh, no, sorry, that was a different answer.
00:08:05 I sometimes get the meandering answers mixed up.
00:08:08 The answer is that, well, we have a great team and we're going to put the good team forward.
00:08:13 And this is the strongest possible team, by which he means to say that all of the folks he got rid of,
00:08:18 he believes were weak and were not part of the strong team that he believes he needs heading in to the next election,
00:08:25 which he, it sounds like from earlier in those remarks, is convinced will not be until 2025.
00:08:30 so Trudeau is basically saying that he thinks he has enough to go on to stick around for the next
00:08:38 two years and Jagmeet Singh once again today is tweeting about all the failures of the liberals
00:08:43 and conservatives and it's like it's my favorite running gag in Canadian politics when Jagmeet
00:08:49 Singh is all indignant and says oh man how dare the liberals do this it's like yeah if only there
00:08:54 were someone who had literally with the snap of his fingers and an email to his caucus the ability
00:09:01 to change that Jagmeet Singh is actually a guy who could topple the government I mean some people say
00:09:06 oh I should write a letter to the governor general or oh we should call an election and maybe Canadians
00:09:11 will oust him like Jagmeet Singh could actually single-handedly take down the liberal government
00:09:17 at least single-handedly insofar as his ability to lead his party which I think he probably could do
00:09:23 And he just doesn't know that or refuses to accept it because he knows that he has his last kick of the can in the next election and then he will be done.
00:09:35 So what do we have as far as highlights go in this new cabinet?
00:09:39 Well, we have the new fisheries minister, Diane Laboutier, who has decided to welcome
00:09:45 in the job with a brilliant and incisive analysis, a brilliant and incisive analysis of the role
00:09:52 of fishing and fisheries in Canada.
00:09:56 I can tell you that I like fish.
00:10:00 Yeah.
00:10:01 Well, if that is the position that our fisheries minister had, to be honest, actually, I don't
00:10:06 want a fisheries minister who likes fish unless he means to eat them.
00:10:09 Because, like, the animal rights fisheries minister who likes fish,
00:10:13 I mean, that seems to be antithetical to what fishing is all about.
00:10:17 But that was her brilliant observation on the way in that she likes fish.
00:10:20 Well, good, because, you know, if you had said, you know, you like taxes,
00:10:23 you might have to be stuck in national revenue where you were before.
00:10:27 And then we have Yara Sachs. 0.98
00:10:30 Now, Yara Sachs, a backbench member of Parliament from the greater Toronto area
00:10:33 that is now the Minister of Mental Health and Addictions.
00:10:38 the Minister of Mental Health and Addictions
00:10:40 now I don't know a lot about Yara Sachs
00:10:43 in fact I basically know one thing about her
00:10:46 which is the one thing that comes to mind when I hear her name
00:10:50 and this is a little bit of a reminder of what that thing is
00:10:53 how many guns need to be seized
00:11:00 how much vitriol do we have to see of honk honk
00:11:06 which is an acronym for hail hitler do we need to see by these protesters on social media
00:11:13 yes the minister responsible for the mental health file in canada who believes that honking
00:11:23 your horn is synonymous with a proclamation for hitler honk honk equals heil hitler says
00:11:31 yara sacks with a straight face she is now responsible for uh the mental health file 1.00
00:11:35 which is actually a very important file to me.
00:11:38 And I hope that she manages to come up with a greater hit that is more substantive
00:11:42 for the sake of those struggling with mental illness in this country.
00:11:46 We have a few other changes here.
00:11:48 I mean, you look at Pablo Rodriguez, the guy who I was talking about this yesterday,
00:11:52 has just done such a bang-up job on the heritage file
00:11:55 that now he's decided he wants to serve in the transport file.
00:12:00 So Pablo Rodriguez is going to be taking over as Minister of Transport.
00:12:04 I can only fear that the next time you take an Air Canada flight from, I don't know, wherever, Toronto to Hong Kong or something, the only options on the in-flight entertainment menu will be diverse and or Canadian content.
00:12:18 So you'll have to watch like Bon Cop, Bad Cop in English and French two or three times before you get to your destination because that's going to be the only option you have with the Pablo Rodriguez approach, the heritage turned transportation approach to government.
00:12:34 And then you look at the people who are staying still.
00:12:36 People like Stephen Gilbeau remains as environment minister.
00:12:40 People like Wilkinson adds environment to natural resources.
00:12:44 But basically there's some continuity there.
00:12:46 Patti Hajdu, who did, again, just such a phenomenal job as the health minister 1.00
00:12:51 who said border closures were racist before closing the borders.
00:12:55 She is remaining in Indigenous services.
00:12:59 Christia Freeland in finance.
00:13:00 Melanie Jolie in foreign affairs.
00:13:02 Francois-Philippe Champagne in innovation.
00:13:04 And, of course, Justin Trudeau remaining at the top.
00:13:08 Justin Trudeau remaining as the Prime Minister, the first minister of his cabinet,
00:13:12 which strikes me as though there won't be much of a change in focus at all.
00:13:17 Such was Pierre Polyev's approach on this.
00:13:20 He gave a bit of a response after Trudeau unveiled his cabinet.
00:13:23 Here's a snippet of that.
00:13:28 You know, it's funny.
00:13:30 Justin Trudeau has fired a lot of ministers today.
00:13:34 admitted his government is broken but the ones he didn't fire he didn't fire the minister of
00:13:39 inflation christia freeland who's caught who weeks after saying government deficits drive inflation
00:13:47 decided to introduce 60 billion more in government deficits he didn't fire the minister of the
00:13:53 carbon tax stefan gilbo who wants to hit people with another 61 cents a liter and he did not fire
00:13:59 the one minister who is most responsible, the one minister who has presided over the record increase in costs,
00:14:09 the doubling of housing prices, the growing crime and chaos in our street,
00:14:15 the doubling of housing costs so that nobody can afford a place to live,
00:14:19 that minister is the prime minister, and he needs to be fired
00:14:23 and replaced with a new common-sense conservative prime minister.
00:14:28 And that Prime Minister will be me.
00:14:33 So, yes, the point of this is that there may be some big changes.
00:14:37 We may see some big promotions.
00:14:39 There may be a lot to extrapolate about why certain people got the boot,
00:14:42 why the Marco Mendicino's and the Omar Al-Gabra's and the David Lamedi's are out.
00:14:47 But at the end of the day, the most prominent people in this cabinet remain in place.
00:14:50 Justin Trudeau remains in place.
00:14:52 and it stands to reason that Justin Trudeau's agenda will remain in place with no real sense
00:14:58 that anything is going to change there. Aaron Woodrick joins us now. He is the guru on all
00:15:05 things domestic policy at the McDonald-Laurier Institute. Now, that's not actually how it's
00:15:09 listed on his resume, at least not last time I checked. Aaron, good to talk to you as always.
00:15:14 Thanks for coming on today. Always great to be here, Andrew. I mean, look, you've been around
00:15:18 politics for a while you know the game here what are the reasons for a shuffle of this magnitude
00:15:24 well you know especially what i call late stage government any government that's getting into
00:15:28 second term or later um you know they need to put on a fresh face just because people are kind of
00:15:33 getting sick and tired of them um they want to present themselves as being able to uh you know
00:15:38 reform themselves right when the public you saw polls today there's a huge appetite for change
00:15:43 right and this happens you know to every government after a certain amount of time although i'd argue
00:15:47 this government's certainly speeding up the process more than other ones do.
00:15:52 So by presenting new people in cabinet, you can sort of at least superficially make the
00:15:56 argument that, you know what, we're technically a new government.
00:15:58 We have different people in charge.
00:16:01 But as I think, you know, Pierre Pauly just pointed out, really in our system of government,
00:16:05 it's the prime minister that matters.
00:16:07 People associate the prime minister.
00:16:09 He makes all the calls at the end of the day.
00:16:11 He's the one who picks all of the cabinet, handpicks them.
00:16:14 So unless the prime minister is actually being changed,
00:16:17 it's really hard to make the case that you've got a completely new government.
00:16:22 Yeah, and you're right when you talk about the longevity of a government.
00:16:25 I mean, Stephen Harper ran into this when he was running in 2015.
00:16:28 When you've been there for, at that time, nine years,
00:16:31 you don't really have much of an excuse for not having done something.
00:16:36 I mean, theoretically, you may be responding to a new challenge that's popped up.
00:16:39 And Harper had the refugee crisis, national security, stuff like that.
00:16:43 But it's a lot easier to be in opposition when you can look at the government and say they're doing this wrong, this wrong, this wrong, this wrong.
00:16:49 When you're a guy like now Justin Trudeau, who's been there for eight years, potentially 10 years by the time the next election rolls around,
00:16:57 it's very difficult for him to convincingly tell people he's going to do something when he's had at that point a decade in which he could have and should have done whatever that thing is.
00:17:07 Sure. And look, part of politics is just gravity, right?
00:17:10 I mean, you're there for a long time.
00:17:12 You pile up a lot of baggage.
00:17:13 And, you know, I've been a big critic of many, many things this government's done.
00:17:17 But part of it is sort of the death of a thousand cuts, right?
00:17:20 It just builds up over time.
00:17:22 And so governments, they see cabinet shuffles as a way to try and, again, I say superficially
00:17:27 because, frankly, I don't think they matter very much.
00:17:30 I mean, I was remarking to someone that, can anybody point to me, historically, a cabinet
00:17:34 shuffle that really changed the game, that had a, you know, a government that was tired
00:17:38 and unpopular and they shovel to some ministers and suddenly their fortunes reverse. I mean,
00:17:42 it just doesn't happen. And part of that is because, you know, folks like you and me and
00:17:46 folks tuning in, we're the weirdos. We pay a lot of attention to politics. A lot of Canadians don't.
00:17:51 They got busy lives. They could not name, pick out any of these people out of a police lineup,
00:17:56 maybe Chrystia Freeland. But the vast majority of these people, they just don't know who they are.
00:18:01 And so I don't think it really helps Justin Trudeau's fortunes when he changes them.
00:18:05 Yeah, and I would say generally are probably better off not needing to know, because the more you learn about politics, the less sane and less convivial you are in my experience on these things.
00:18:16 So I'll ask then about it in a bit of a different approach, because, you know, we may see at some point in the next couple of weeks mandate letters for these ministers, but are we expecting anything resembling a change in policy to go along with this?
00:18:30 Because if we are just, you know, changing around the faces, but you're actually making no change to your overall agenda, it's really not that convincing a fresh face, as you had put it earlier.
00:18:40 Yeah, I mean, I think what's more important is going to be mandate letters, because that signals what the prime minister wants.
00:18:46 And at the end of the day, especially under this prime minister, and I would argue under Stephen Harper as well, you know, ministers are only going to be as effective as their boss lets them be.
00:18:54 And so, you know, it doesn't really matter how great you are.
00:18:57 If Justin Trudeau puts you in a box and says you can only do these two things, you know, you're kind of limited in what you're able to do.
00:19:04 One thing I thought was interesting was the assignment of Sean Fraser to housing.
00:19:08 So this is everybody knows housing is a very important file.
00:19:12 I think it is the main going to be the main issue in the next election, if it isn't already.
00:19:17 I think the Liberals are tuning into this late in the game.
00:19:19 I think they realize that if they don't take some major action on this, Pierre Paulyab is going to eat their lunch on housing.
00:19:26 So, you know, John Fraser's, you know, by all accounts, been a pretty strong performer in cabinet.
00:19:31 He's generally well liked.
00:19:32 So I think that giving him this portfolio is a sign that they're probably taking it more seriously.
00:19:38 Yeah. And I think that's actually an important point as well that should factor into people's analysis on this is, you know,
00:19:45 who the stronger communicators are when you're putting them on a certain file.
00:19:49 And I mean, I was making a few cracks at Pablo Rodriguez's expense, but this is not a guy who I'd say has been a particularly good messenger on Bill C-11 and Bill C-18.
00:20:00 He has failed to understand, either by obstinance or just by not being particularly transparent, he's failed to understand what his bill does.
00:20:08 He's flip-flopped on what it will do and all these internet regulations.
00:20:12 and the fact that he's out of that file when the internet regulation file is still alive and well
00:20:17 in Canada I feel is actually quite noteworthy. Yeah look communications are obviously important
00:20:22 to every government very important to this government in many cases I would argue that
00:20:26 from this government's point of view the communications are the deliverable you know
00:20:29 actually following through and delivering what you promise doesn't matter it's the press
00:20:33 conference and the messaging that they value most because that's where they get their political
00:20:37 bang for the buck. And for, you know, Pablo Rodriguez, I mean, to be fair, there's only so
00:20:42 much lipstick you can put on a pig. And Bill C-18 is a pretty big pig. And I don't know that there's 0.99
00:20:48 any way to message that bill well, because it's a terrible bill that is doing a lot of damage
00:20:53 to Canadian media. So yes, I think there are other files on things like housing where, you know,
00:20:59 the Liberals are doing certain things. I don't think they're doing anywhere near enough on
00:21:03 housing, but there are a few things they're doing that. If they had better comms, they could probably
00:21:06 get a little bit more credit for. Now you had pointed something out on Twitter earlier, which
00:21:10 I found quite funny. It was, I don't know which TV network it was, but you were watching and they
00:21:15 had this like bold observation about the new cabinet that they might, you know, focus on the
00:21:20 economy now. Yeah. They said, you know, new, new cabinet to focus on economy. And I thought, well,
00:21:25 what have they been doing for the last eight years? That's like a John Madden style, you know,
00:21:29 political commentary there. I'm like, oh yeah, when the quarterback goes, that'll be a touchdown.
00:21:33 yeah yeah it's it's a little bit it just makes you think you know you've been there a long time
00:21:38 you would have thought they'd come around to the importance of the economy a little bit sooner than
00:21:42 today yeah so let's just be a little bit more forward looking here and I know that neither of
00:21:47 us has the the crystal ball but we've seen the poll numbers I mean Justin Trudeau can stand up
00:21:53 there and talk about how everything is sunshine and roses Christopher Ealing can go out and talk
00:21:57 about oh actually inflation is doing really well right now but Canadians are clearly not buying it
00:22:03 at least not at this moment in time in the snapshot and sample that was captured by the
00:22:08 latest polls. I mean, what would the turnaround be? If you were advising Trudeau, I mean, I might
00:22:12 not have you on as much, but if you were, what would the message be on how to steer that ship
00:22:17 in a better direction? Boy, it's tough. It would require a dramatic break from the past, right? And
00:22:23 this government has shown no capacity to do that. I mean, Justin Trudeau has been a prime minister
00:22:28 who likes to spend in the bad times and spend in the good times and then spend some more for good
00:22:32 measure. That's one problem. I mean, there's just a colossal lot of money that's been going out the
00:22:36 door. For what? I mean, spending is up something in the range of 30%. I don't think most Canadians
00:22:42 believe they're getting 30% government services or have a 30% quicker commute or 30% better
00:22:47 healthcare or any of these things. So I think there needs to be a big U-turn there. I think,
00:22:52 you know, the interesting thing to me was by even having this shovel, it signals to me that
00:22:57 Justin Trudeau is definitely running in the next election, right? There's been a lot of talk about
00:23:00 whether or not he's going to take a walk in the snow or I guess a walk in the sand because it's
00:23:04 summertime. I think the fact he had this shuffle suggests he's not going anywhere because why have
00:23:08 this shuffle now? Why try and reset and retool now? If he was even thinking remotely of leaving,
00:23:14 you know, he would have just let the cabinet sit as it is. So the fact he's done this tells me
00:23:19 he's going to be prime minister when the next election is called and it's going to be him
00:23:23 versus Pierre Polyev. Yeah, and I think you're right about that. And I think that it's not
00:23:28 necessarily wise to go in and try to assess what Justin Trudeau's mindset is on a particular issue.
00:23:37 But I do feel that putting Anita Anand, who is by all accounts actually quite a capable defense
00:23:41 minister in Treasury Board, which is certainly an important role to the functioning of government,
00:23:46 but is a much less public facing role, has been a bit interesting because she was one that has been
00:23:53 wildly rumored to be a potential leadership contender and not really tarnished in the way
00:23:58 that Chrystia Freeland are and some other folks are by the Trudeau brand.
00:24:02 So the fact that she's now being taken out of this file,
00:24:05 I actually think is quite interesting.
00:24:08 Yeah, one other observation I had of all the new faces that we see in cabinet,
00:24:12 they're all relatively low profile folks, right?
00:24:15 These are not the sort of high profile partisan attack dogs
00:24:18 that folks will see on social media.
00:24:20 I'm not going to name names,
00:24:21 but people can probably guess the MPs that we're talking about.
00:24:23 I was actually pleasantly surprised to see
00:24:26 that those folks were not the ones who were promoted, right?
00:24:28 Because there are some people who think that, you know, being a sort of partisan clown on Twitter all day is sort of, you know, doing a solid for the team.
00:24:36 And that gets rewarded by putting these people in cabinet.
00:24:39 But I think that would be a really perverse incentive.
00:24:41 So I'm happy to see that for the new people they put in, these are relatively low-key MPs.
00:24:46 They're not in there because they're like a big name or that they've been sort of lighting the world for you or ticking people off or sort of provoking anger for their opponents.
00:24:55 So, you know, we'll see if these are folks that are just quietly competent and, you know, agree or disagree with his government.
00:25:01 Whoever's in charge on a given day, it's better that they be competent than not know what they're doing.
00:25:06 Yeah, fair enough. You're saying you didn't want Attorney General Mark Gerritsen then, I take that.
00:25:10 I'm not going to name any names, Andrew. You may think that.
00:25:13 All right. Well, you're far more diplomatic than I am.
00:25:15 Aaron Woodrick from the Macdonald-Laurie Institute. Always a pleasure, Aaron. Thanks for coming on today.
00:25:20 Thanks a lot.
00:25:20 Yeah, I will say I did like a little joking thing yesterday where when we learned that what's his name or what's her name, Anita Anand was being shuffled out of defense.
00:25:30 I like just plucked three random names and I said, you know, pick your next defense minister, Canada.
00:25:35 And the options I gave were Patty Hajdu, Mark Gerritsen and Jennifer O'Connell.
00:25:40 And some people didn't know I was joking. That was the terrifying part.
00:25:43 I mean, like one of those three would easily be doing a speech in which you'd be like,
00:25:48 we need to talk less about Ukraine and more about We-crane.
00:25:52 I've made that up, but that's like the type of thing that the people kind government would probably give us.
00:25:58 We're going to talk a little bit about this in the closing moments of the show.
00:26:03 And I suspect next week we'll have a bit more in the sense of where things are going.
00:26:07 But I want to talk about the story that really piqued my interest at CBC, which I should
00:26:15 say I do so you don't have to.
00:26:17 I read CBC so that you don't have to.
00:26:20 And I just deliver you stuff that I feel might rise to the level of being relevant or at
00:26:24 least relevant in the sense of being fodder for why the pledges to defund the CBC are
00:26:30 increasingly compelling.
00:26:31 This was a story that was like framed as though it was alerting us to the existence
00:26:37 of some far-right radical Christian cultist conspiracy of some kind.
00:26:43 Breakaway believers warn PC party of dominionist religious movement. 0.68
00:26:49 Now, I'm, you know, a religious person myself.
00:26:51 I understand trends in the religious world and trends in the political world.
00:26:55 And they were using terms in this that I've really not been familiar with,
00:27:00 like Dominionist, and the other one that they acronymize as NAR.
00:27:05 I think it's like the, now I forget what it is, what it stands for,
00:27:09 but it's like Apostolic, there we go, the New Apostolic Reformation,
00:27:12 which is kind of used more as a smear than anything else.
00:27:15 But they talk about this group of folks that have been assembling,
00:27:18 that are generally people of faith, that have been mobilizing on a number of issues,
00:27:22 particularly in New Brunswick, where right now people of faith,
00:27:25 And I would point out people who are not at all connected to any religion organized or otherwise have been speaking up in support of parents' rights and in support of the New Brunswick government's defense of parental rights in school.
00:27:39 And there was a photo that I thought was quite lovely from the Canadian Prophetic Council,
00:27:45 which is one of the groups that has attracted the ire of CBC,
00:27:49 reenacting in front of the Lieutenant Governor's residence in Charlottetown,
00:27:54 this famous photo that you may recall from 1864 in the lead up to Confederation.
00:28:00 And Justin Trudeau should be very happy because unlike the original, we've got gender balance in this. 0.64
00:28:04 We've got women represented, unlike those old sexist, misogynist, white supremacist, homophobe, neo-Nazi fathers of confederation that Canada had.
00:28:13 These ones are gender balanced and ethnically diverse.
00:28:17 Do you think that would make Justin Trudeau and CBC happy?
00:28:20 But nevertheless, they are not.
00:28:22 And they've actually found a few religious dissidents to cast aspersions on this group and its motivations,
00:28:29 saying they want to make a Canada that's unsafe for marginalized communities,
00:28:33 which if you look at what they're doing is actually nowhere near what they're doing.
00:28:37 But I wanted to get to the bottom of this.
00:28:39 Fetine Grzeski joins us.
00:28:40 She is a fantastic television host and also the founder of a group that is very much name-checked in this.
00:28:47 That is For My Canada.
00:28:49 And I've had the great privilege of being on Fetine's show, and it's lovely to have her back here as well.
00:28:53 Fetine, good to talk to you.
00:28:54 Thanks for coming on today.
00:28:56 Hey, Andrew.
00:28:57 Always a pleasure to chat with you.
00:28:59 So just for context here, what is For My Canada?
00:29:02 and what is the Canadian Prophetic Council?
00:29:04 Because a lot of people, I think,
00:29:05 have only heard of these for the first time
00:29:07 through the CBC lens,
00:29:09 which is through the CBC lens.
00:29:12 Yeah, well, you know,
00:29:13 and then there would be a good reason
00:29:15 why people haven't heard of it
00:29:16 because we're actually not super, super active
00:29:19 on quote unquote the national stage.
00:29:21 So For My Canada, ironically,
00:29:23 was a group that we used to go down to the streets
00:29:27 in Vancouver and give out food,
00:29:29 give out chicken noodle soup and hot chocolate
00:29:31 to the poor and drug addicted on the corner of Main and Hastings there. And it was during that
00:29:38 time, this was like mid 2000s that we just got this desire. Like I was not a political kid at
00:29:45 all. My dad played NHL. I thought the senators were a hockey team, you know, so politically
00:29:50 illiterate. But we just got this burden to begin to speak to our leaders about issues we cared
00:29:55 about and so i took this little band we rented a minivan we went across canada and you know we
00:30:01 were covered in lots of media at that time the winnipeg press i think covered us and uh there
00:30:07 were different periodicals and and we just booked meetings with members of parliament and senators
00:30:11 and just talked to them about things that we cared about and there was a wide range of things that we
00:30:15 would chat about we talked about human trafficking we would talk about freedom of speech you know a
00:30:19 lot of the things that we're still talking about today you know in different capacities and that
00:30:24 began uh this basically almost a decade-long journey where we just started bringing teams to
00:30:29 parliament uh usually a couple times a year had over 1500 sit-down meetings with members of
00:30:34 parliament and senators i met with justin trudeau in his office uh when he was very first elected
00:30:41 and you know what he said to me right out of the gate sandra he said let's talk about my christian
00:30:45 faith that was that was his opening line you know yeah let's let's talk about it i would actually
00:30:51 accept that offer from him now if he made it and so i have to admit though we haven't been super
00:30:56 active the last couple years because those young people became older people and we have babies now
00:31:01 and jobs and you know we've gotten a lot busier but we still have an email list and we still push
00:31:06 stuff out you know when we feel people in our network need to know about something and be given
00:31:11 opportunity to take action i'm all about civic engagement i'm all about you know if you care
00:31:16 about something get involved you know that's why we worked with joy smith on our human trafficking 1.00
00:31:21 uh bills and that's why i do my tv show you know because i think there's a lot of stuff i care about
00:31:26 and so you know that's basically the heart of it in terms of the canadian prophetic council
00:31:31 honestly it's pretty benign as well it's just a group of leaders from across canada
00:31:36 uh some pastors people that lead different kinds of ministries that usually about once a year we
00:31:41 kind of got shut down during kobe usually about once a year we'll just come together and we'll
00:31:44 just pray together and share hearts together about what we're feeling about the state of our nation
00:31:50 and what we can do to be positive contributors so it's really as simple as that yeah and it's funny
00:31:56 and i and i don't mean this to besmirch any of the work that you're doing because i i think it's
00:31:59 wonderful but this doesn't come up on any of the discussions that i have as you know being these
00:32:04 like really top really hyperactive and hyper influential political groups because by your own
00:32:10 own definition, that's not really what you've strived to be. But the way CBC talks about it,
00:32:15 it's that, you know, it's you and a few evil, scary Christians just like pulling the strings 1.00
00:32:18 on the political system from behind the scenes. And I mean, it's like if you guys were running 0.96
00:32:23 the show, we wouldn't be in the problems we're in right now as a country.
00:32:28 Well, who knows, you know? But, you know, yeah, you're absolutely right. And like I said a few
00:32:35 moments ago, I'm just all about civic engagement. So when I see something that's happening, and
00:32:39 here. I live in New Brunswick. We actually moved here. We were part of the COVID exodus out of
00:32:43 Ontario. New Brunswick has had a real surge of people actually from Ontario and other parts of
00:32:49 the nation. And so we're here just raising our family. We moved here for community. And then
00:32:55 Premier Higgs, he sticks his neck out on this amendment to 713 saying, hey, we want to ensure
00:33:03 that things aren't being hidden from parents in terms of what's happening with their kids at
00:33:07 school in terms of their sexual health journey, right? And so, you know, I was talking.
00:33:16 Uh-oh, we lost Fetine. See, this is what happens when you, you know, get Bill C-11 is that anytime
00:33:21 something like this comes up, people all get suspicious that Justin Trudeau might be mucking
00:33:25 around in the engine room. We'll get Fetine back on the show in just a moment here. But I want to
00:33:31 just go back to the CBC article for a moment here. And the reason I want to is because
00:33:35 the framing of this is that they talk to three people that used to be Christians that now are
00:33:43 no longer Christians, that really just take out their grievances on religion itself and their 0.54
00:33:48 grievances on Christianity itself and Christian values and Christian communities. And then they
00:33:54 use that as sort of their wedge to criticize the stuff that this group is doing. I mean,
00:34:00 The one woman in particular here, again, a former Christian who says that now all of the things that these folks are doing are, quote, making a really unsafe place for a lot of marginalized groups, especially queer people, especially trans people.
00:34:15 I think we have Fetine back with us, and we're sorry about that brief interruption, but we have her back on the line now.
00:34:22 Fetine, that's one of the big concerns I have here, is that CBC is doing this thing that we often see from the media,
00:34:27 where they take former Christians, people that have had whatever their grievances are with the church,
00:34:33 and they use them as sort of authorities on what the church represents,
00:34:36 when a lot of the time, I mean, as we know, these stories come from a place of pain and any number of other issues
00:34:42 that really have nothing to do with the subject matter.
00:34:45 yeah and I you know my heart goes out to to anyone that's been hurt by anyone you know and
00:34:53 just to say that I'm not exactly sure uh what's happened with each of the individuals that were
00:34:59 interviewed uh one of the individuals uh did go to the same church that I went to I'm not exactly
00:35:04 sure all the stuff that might have happened there I wasn't directly involved um I did you know try
00:35:11 a love on her in different ways that i could but we were just really faint acquaintances really
00:35:16 like i would see her on a sunday or whatever but i i you know i i think we should all uh do whatever
00:35:22 we can to make peace right like the bible does say that blessed are the peacemakers um and so
00:35:28 i encourage people to pursue those that have been broken and and hurt in whatever way they have but
00:35:33 but that's not what we're talking about here like what we're talking about here with the current
00:35:38 situation is in new brunswick is that parents have a concern it's a legitimate concern our
00:35:44 parents actually have an appreciation a legitimate appreciation and that's an appreciation for what
00:35:49 premier higgs is doing and they're seeing him getting beat up in the media cabinet ministers
00:35:54 falling off the shake-up call for the leadership review and so you know parents organize you know
00:35:59 to support something that they appreciate in government this has nothing to do with religion
00:36:06 other than the fact that there might be a few of us that we happen to be Christian, you know,
00:36:10 in the mix. But we actually after we kind of felt the sense that CDC was starting to go this way and
00:36:15 others, we actually put a survey question on the petition and said, Hey, just let us know what
00:36:20 background you're from. You know, are you Jewish? Are you Muslim? Are you Christian? Are you from a 0.91
00:36:25 secular background? And, and I can verify now that there really is a cross section of support.
00:36:31 And so obviously, you know, it's disappointing to see the conversation kind of drug into the mud of what might even cross the line of religious discrimination, like coming at me for my faith.
00:36:42 You know, it's like, man, this is nothing.
00:36:44 What happened with these people really has nothing to do with me, though my heart goes out to them.
00:36:48 You know, but let's keep focus here because and I think if I could just say this, Andrew, like I long for a day.
00:36:55 I don't know about you, but I long for a day where we can just raise the water level of civil discourse in the media, where we can actually talk about the issues that Canadians care about.
00:37:06 Stop with the labeling.
00:37:07 Stop with the shaming.
00:37:09 You know, I heard somebody say once that if I can label you, I don't have to listen to you.
00:37:14 And, you know, we've seen that time and time again.
00:37:16 You know, we've seen that with, you know, I hate to say it, Justin Trudeau, you know, calling people that disagreed with his management of COVID-19 racist, misogynistic.
00:37:24 misogynistic you know a little Métis woman you get like how can you call a Métis woman you know
00:37:29 but if I can label you I don't have to listen to you right and that's like I just want to say as
00:37:34 media people let's take it higher like let's just stop with the labeling and and go a little bit
00:37:40 deeper with the listening and I think that's what was really disappointing about this but hey
00:37:44 I'm keeping my eye on the goal we're going to continue to encourage people to be a voice sign
00:37:48 the petition and support Premier Higgs in what yeah no you're quite right about that Fetine I
00:37:53 mean it was confusing because the article was conflating two organizations two movements I mean
00:37:58 obviously they they share a common participant in you and and by extension really trying to muddle
00:38:03 the discussion around an issue that has been tremendously unifying I mean the number of
00:38:07 Canadians uh that as you note not from religious backgrounds and even if they are religious not
00:38:12 necessarily from evangelical Christian backgrounds that are supporting what Blaine Higgs is doing
00:38:18 that are supporting in general, this cause of parental rights is massive. The governments that
00:38:23 oppose this are in minorities. And certainly the media's narrative on this is in the minority.
00:38:30 Yeah. Yeah. And I would just go back to, let's just do more, more listening. And there is an
00:38:35 overwhelming, this was actually one of the reasons that I felt to get involved in this. Because I
00:38:38 thought, man, if Blaine Higgs, excuse me, Premier Higgs falls on this mountain, so to speak,
00:38:44 this political mountain, it really will be an injustice to democracy because I really believe
00:38:49 authentically he is representing the majority of parents. I had one parent say, and I think it was
00:38:55 Chris Austin that actually said this in the legislative assembly, that parents, they need
00:39:00 to sign off on if their kids go on a field trip, if their kids go up the road to the zoo, and to
00:39:07 exclude parents from any part of their child's health and wellness journey at school, it just
00:39:14 feels so counterintuitive for so many. And so I, you know, I just think we need to stay focused
00:39:20 there. And, you know, it's unfortunate that some, you know, some people want to take it off of that,
00:39:25 but I'm committed to keeping my focus here, Andrew. Well, I certainly wanted your voice to
00:39:30 be out there to correct the record. You're doing a tremendous work on air and off. Fetine Grzeski
00:39:35 is the host of Fatin TV, the founder of For My Canada. And it's been my pleasure to be on your
00:39:41 show. And I'm glad to repay the favor. Thanks so much, Fatin. Thanks for your time, Andrew.
00:39:47 All right, all the best to you. And I think we have to have a bigger discussion in this country
00:39:51 about the relationship between faith and politics and faith groups and politics. But also this other
00:39:58 group that often gets left out, which is people that are motivated by values and motivated by
00:40:04 what we might call religious principles or religious tenets, but don't identify as religious.
00:40:10 Now, if you're talking about proselytizing, great.
00:40:12 Yes, if you want to go after those people, do it.
00:40:14 But if you're talking about building community, there are a lot of people that you would talk
00:40:18 to on the street that would agree with a lot of what I would as a Christian say are Christian
00:40:23 values, but they've reached that conclusion not because of faith necessarily or not knowingly
00:40:30 because of faith.
00:40:31 And this is why it's always so bizarre when the media tries to say, oh, this is just, you know, the religious right that cares about parental rights, whereas, well, actually, parents care about parental rights.
00:40:43 And parents who are not Christians, who are not Muslims, not Jews, not Sikhs, not Hindus care about this. 0.67
00:40:49 And parents who are those things often care about this.
00:40:51 And that doesn't mean 100%, no.
00:40:53 But when you looked at those numbers that our friends at Second Street put out a few months ago, it was the majority of Canadians across religious identification, across political identification that supported the idea of what Blaine Higgs is doing in New Brunswick, which is to say that parental consent is required for a child to change their gender, which is, I think, a pretty commonplace, uncontroversial thing to say that's been cast as like this horrendous assault on marginalized people.
00:41:23 groups, which is just absolutely baffling. So that does it for us for today. We'll be back
00:41:27 on Friday with another edition of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show. We'll be delving into
00:41:32 C-18 and internet regulations in a bit more of a comprehensive and perhaps educational way if
00:41:40 you've not been following it really closely. But even if you have, hopefully you'll take something
00:41:43 out of it and then lots more True North content in the days and weeks and hopefully years to come
00:41:49 as well. So that does it for me. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all.
00:41:53 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:41:57 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:42:23 We'll be right back.