Juno News - June 01, 2023


Woke corporate virtual signalling month begins

Topics
Mentioned
Jagmeet Singh says he’ll keep supporting Trudeau until elections can be trusted The truth about "harm reduction". They are hiding this from you!

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

179.8

Word count

7,238

Sentence count

318

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

18

sentences flagged

Hate speech

20

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

It's Pride Month, which means it's time for another episode of The Andrew Lawton Show. This week, we're talking about Justin Trudeau's former West Point drama teacher, Pierre Polyvenc and why he might have a beef with the Prime Minister.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome to Canada's most irreverent talk show.
00:00:05 This is the Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:00:14 Hey, welcome along. This is the Andrew Lawton Show here on True North.
00:00:19 Happy beginning of Pride Month. Sorry. No, I got it all wrong.
00:00:24 It's not Pride Month anymore. I just learned today, believe it or not,
00:00:28 It's extended and has effectively colonized the rest of the season.
00:00:34 This is a page from the Government of Canada, the Department of Women and Gender Equality.
00:00:39 It is no longer Pride Month.
00:00:41 In fact, it is Pride Season. 0.86
00:00:44 Yeah, right there.
00:00:45 And if you read it, it's a Pride Season is a term that refers to the wide range of Pride events that take place over the summer, June to September.
00:00:55 when 2SLG, I don't know all the letters here,
00:00:59 and it's too small for me to read,
00:01:01 communities and allies come together to spotlight the resilience,
00:01:04 celebrate the talent.
00:01:06 May to September, that's longer than summer, actually.
00:01:09 So that is basically the entire, a third of the year,
00:01:13 May, June, July, August, September, more than a third of the year,
00:01:16 pushing half of the year.
00:01:17 And this is now what it is.
00:01:19 I remember when I was younger, I think it was Pride Week,
00:01:22 and then it was Pride Month and now it's Pride Season.
00:01:26 In fact, give it a couple of years and it'll just be Pride Year 1.00
00:01:28 where instead of watching the ball drop, we'll just have a progress flag hang
00:01:33 and it'll be the whole year until we get around to January 1st again.
00:01:37 We'll talk about that in just a moment.
00:01:39 Let me first off, though, talk about this video that was making its way around the Internet,
00:01:44 partly because of me and True North yesterday,
00:01:47 of Pierre Polyev and Justin Trudeau going at it with each other
00:01:51 in the House of Commons yesterday.
00:01:53 Pierre Polyev, you know, talked about Justin Trudeau being a drama teacher.
00:01:57 Trudeau had, I'd say, a fairly good response.
00:02:00 He said, yeah, I was a teacher before,
00:02:03 but I'm having trouble remembering what Pierre Polyev did
00:02:06 before entering politics.
00:02:08 You know, Polyev's been in politics his entire adult life,
00:02:10 so that's a good joke. I'll give him that.
00:02:12 And then Polyev just, like, comes out swinging, 0.69
00:02:15 shots fired, hits the red button and says, I'm having trouble remembering why Justin Trudeau
00:02:22 left in the middle of the semester. Cue the, oh, from the House of Commons. Now,
00:02:29 if you were watching this thinking that the House of Commons is a place where matters of state are
00:02:34 discussed, you were sorely disappointed. I mean, exchanging barbs is great for clips. It's not
00:02:39 exactly good for democracy but it has also spawned huge huge huge waves of speculation rumor and
00:02:49 discussion online about what it is that people are saying Pierre Polyev was intimating or alluding to
00:02:56 about Justin Trudeau and I don't want to talk about this for a long period of time here because
00:03:00 this was actually a fairly poignant and potent discussion in 2019 during the election campaign
00:03:07 when a lot of people were talking about Justin Trudeau's time teaching at the West Point Grey Academy in BC,
00:03:14 which he did, by all accounts, abruptly depart and has given very conflicting reasons as to why.
00:03:21 But I have to, in having this discussion, say that anyone who is definitive and speaks as though it's fact
00:03:29 about the existence of an NDA, about sexual misconduct allegations,
00:03:35 about you know oh Justin Trudeau spent 2.5 million dollars to silence a former student
00:03:40 there is no evidence supporting any of it and I'm very serious about this I believe facts matter
00:03:46 you can think Justin Trudeau is creepy you can think he's a bad prime minister you can think
00:03:50 all of these things about him but in all of the time that was spent on this story in 2019 there
00:03:57 was never anything even remotely resembling proof a lot of the allegations came back to
00:04:04 stories that were published in something called the Buffalo Chronicle, which is not
00:04:08 a legitimate news organization by any stretch. And I don't mean that, you know, I don't like
00:04:13 their bias or their standards. I mean, it's literally just a clickbait mill. There's no
00:04:17 journalistic rigor to anything they do. And I put questions about this to Justin Trudeau directly.
00:04:23 I said, you know, look, you've talked about people experiencing things differently. Have you
00:04:28 ever done anything that looking back, you might think maybe could have been construed differently?
00:04:34 He said, no. Marika Walsh from the Globe and Mail, she questioned him about this and said,
00:04:38 point blank, are there any NDAs with anyone that you have? And he said, no. Now, obviously you
00:04:44 can't prove a negative. You can't go up and say, I can 100% affirm that nothing like what people
00:04:50 have rumored about has ever happened, but there is zero evidence that anyone has put forward
00:04:56 suggesting it has. And I have to say that anyone saying otherwise is making it up or is reading
00:05:05 someone who made it up. So I believe facts still matter. And you know me, I'm not one to carry
00:05:10 water for Justin Trudeau, but I think that people need to be honest about this sort of stuff.
00:05:13 And yeah, I'm all for, you know, little fun barbs that are sent on across the aisle in the House of
00:05:19 Commons. But, you know, I've been seeing so many people on Twitter saying, oh, Andrew, are you going
00:05:22 to focus on this story and talk about this there is no story there and if someone presents evidence
00:05:27 of something great I'll look into it but it's not been there but all that aside I want to talk about
00:05:32 the beginning as I said at the outset here of pride season which is now extended from the week
00:05:39 to the month to the entire May to September period and we'll soon probably just creep out from there
00:05:45 because we are now in the midst of the great rainbow washing of western civilization which
00:05:52 means everywhere you look you're going to see not even the old school rainbow flag which like a year
00:05:57 ago was replaced by this other thing called the progress flag because the rainbow flag which has
00:06:02 the colors of the rainbow was deemed insufficiently inclusive so they had to add they had to add like
00:06:08 a triangular insert that had colors for transgender people and black people and other groups as well
00:06:16 and at a certain point I mean we'll have a belief that this is probably not sufficiently inclusive
00:06:21 and we'll add an insert on the other side
00:06:23 and it'll be an abomination of graphic design.
00:06:26 But the reason I bring this up is to say
00:06:28 that all of the corporations who right now
00:06:31 are washing their logo in rainbow colors
00:06:35 are only interested in doing it in some markets.
00:06:39 They're going for the low-hanging fruit
00:06:41 of pride observances here.
00:06:43 And I want to just focus on a couple of the highlights here.
00:06:46 Take a look at the Mercedes-Benz Twitter page.
00:06:49 Oh, look at that.
00:06:50 A little rainbow hue around the Mercedes-Benz logo.
00:06:53 A global brand, a luxury car.
00:06:56 Obviously, this is something they are very passionate about.
00:06:59 They want everyone to know that you can be who you are and be proud of who you are and celebrate it.
00:07:03 And they must be doing this on all of their brand pages, right?
00:07:07 Let's look at another one.
00:07:09 Weird.
00:07:10 Weird.
00:07:11 The Mercedes-Benz Middle East social media manager doesn't seem to have gotten around to fixing that up yet.
00:07:18 All right, let's try another one.
00:07:20 Cisco's a big tech company.
00:07:21 Let's look at Cisco's Twitter page.
00:07:23 Okay, yeah, the little waveform there, rainbow.
00:07:27 Let's look at Cisco Middle East.
00:07:30 Strange.
00:07:31 I don't see any multiple colored things there.
00:07:33 All right, this must just be a mistake.
00:07:35 How about General Electric?
00:07:37 This is, again, another big global brand.
00:07:38 How's General Electric bringing in Pride season,
00:07:41 the arrival of it starting June 1st?
00:07:44 Oh, wow.
00:07:44 See, they've gone the full progress flag there.
00:07:47 Every minute of every day, GE rises to the challenge of building a world that works.
00:07:52 A global brand.
00:07:53 Well, they must want progress and pride around the world, right?
00:07:56 How's GE Saudi Arabia's Twitter account looking?
00:08:01 Huh.
00:08:02 That is as grab and gray as it gets, but still committed to building a world that works.
00:08:08 My goodness, it's almost as though these big giant corporations
00:08:13 that want to just cloak themselves in the rainbow flag of the progress
00:08:16 like don't actually care about it.
00:08:18 Perhaps it's just because they're scared of being bullied
00:08:21 if they don't change their colors for the month of June.
00:08:24 Maybe it's like what happened with Black Lives Matter 1.00
00:08:27 where any company that didn't do the blackout of its social media 0.94
00:08:30 was deemed to be a Haiti hateful, white supremacist, racist, bigot and all that.
00:08:35 Or maybe some of these companies only care until it's difficult. 0.83
00:08:40 And that is why I think it's such a problem here.
00:08:43 Right now, you have this culture in which people will go for the lowest hanging fruit possible.
00:08:49 What's easier than changing your Twitter profile picture?
00:08:53 That is the easiest thing you can do to say, I stand with you.
00:08:56 If you really wanted to take a stand, you'd stand up for gay rights in places like, oh, I don't know, Uganda, 0.92
00:09:02 which a couple of days ago passed stricter laws restricting homosexuality.
00:09:07 You could even have the death penalty in Uganda if you are guilty of quote-unquote aggravated homosexuality. 0.63
00:09:14 Whatever that means. Does it mean being gay and angry at the same time? Who knows? 0.97
00:09:18 But this is what Uganda believes passes for justice. 0.68
00:09:21 Now, five years ago, when Uganda had similar restrictions on homosexuality,
00:09:26 Justin Trudeau sat down with him in New York, the head of state of Uganda, and oddly didn't bring it up.
00:09:34 It didn't come up when Justin Trudeau was talking to his counterpart in Uganda,
00:09:37 perhaps because Trudeau was courting votes for his United Nations Security Council seat,
00:09:42 and all of a sudden it didn't matter who in the world, 0.53
00:09:46 which of these African tinpot dictators had these horrendously antiquated 1.00
00:09:51 and offensive and bigoted views on homosexuality and other things 0.96
00:09:55 and how they wanted to throw the arm of the state against these people,
00:09:58 but that doesn't come up.
00:10:00 We don't get condemnation of gay rights violations in the Middle East from these big corporations.
00:10:06 They just stick to the old standard logo there.
00:10:09 But in the West, say, we stand with you.
00:10:12 People are being lied to and pandered to by these corporations who are doing the bare minimum.
00:10:19 If they actually cared, they would take a significant stand.
00:10:23 So the problem that we have is that there is a mob-like effect here.
00:10:27 Take a look at Anthony Bass, who I don't cover sports often.
00:10:31 I'm told he is a baseball player.
00:10:33 I don't know if he's a quarterback or a defensive end or anything like that,
00:10:37 but those are baseball positions, I think.
00:10:39 But Anthony Bass made the mistake of sharing a Christian influencers video on YouTube
00:10:44 that had nothing to do with gay rights.
00:10:47 It was about the boycotts taking place in the U.S. of Target
00:10:50 over its embrace of gender ideology, including for children.
00:10:55 And he shares a video saying,
00:10:56 you know what Christians it's biblical to not want anything to do with Target and here's why 1.00
00:11:01 it's an inoffensive video people may disagree with it he then has the mob descend on him to
00:11:07 such a point where he has to give this horrible apology that the Toronto Blue Jays trots out in
00:11:13 which he apologized commits himself to re-education whatever that means and then he comes out and
00:11:20 yesterday his first appearance since this whole controversy he is booed now all the media that 0.99
00:11:25 reported on that, said Anthony Bass was booed because he was a big, dirty, homophobe transphobe. 0.95
00:11:31 I think, you know, knowing sports fans, and I've met a few of them, he may have been booed because 0.96
00:11:35 of his apology, which seems to have angered far more people than the initial so-called infraction
00:11:42 did. But all of the people that get outraged about the Blue Jays and Anthony Bass, the people
00:11:46 that get outraged about a Twitter account not having a rainbow flag, these are the people who
00:11:52 oftentimes are turning a blind eye to real injustice around the world and neglect as one
00:11:57 gay friend and colleague of mine said to me earlier today that Canada is one of the best
00:12:02 places in the world to be a member of the LGBT community which is why people from around the
00:12:08 world who face real bona fide oppression for their sexual identity like places in Iran in Chechnya
00:12:15 Russia in African countries why they all risk life and limb to come to Canada so anyone who 1.00
00:12:22 says Canada is the problem here needs to look in the mirror and look around and see are you taking
00:12:29 the easy stand or are you going after the real injustice here Sue Ann Levy my colleague who has
00:12:34 been a very outspoken member of the gay community herself a lesbian woman joins me and I normally
00:12:40 don't introduce anyone by their sexual identity except in this case I think it is relevant
00:12:44 because suanne you see companies all the time uh in your name and in the name of of other people
00:12:50 in who are lesbian gay bisexual transgender say we're with you but only when it's easy to do so 1.00
00:12:56 i'm wearing my rainbow watch so in honor i mind i see i'm doing like the saudi arabia thing i 0.59
00:13:06 just have the black you're blacked out yes well you know it's interesting because you're you're 1.00
00:13:13 absolutely right. I was listening to your narrative and you're absolutely right. And this is exactly
00:13:19 what I wanted to talk about is that, you know, particularly radical queer people who are trying
00:13:27 to foist either gender ideology or any other, you know, the numerous letters in the acronym LGBTQIAST,
00:13:40 You know, they are just willfully blind, I think, to the human rights abuses in many countries where gays and lesbians are thrown off roofs. 0.67
00:13:53 They could suffer the death penalty. You named some. Uganda is a most recent example. 1.00
00:13:59 Yemen, Nigeria, many Muslim countries in the Middle East.
00:14:03 And this is the thing that always got me, is that Israel is always picked on for its human rights abuses.
00:14:10 Meanwhile, all the Arab countries around it do not tolerate homosexuality in the slightest, including Saudi Arabia.
00:14:21 And many of the gays and lesbians from those countries will find safe refuge in Israel or in Canada or wherever.
00:14:29 It's a huge democracy.
00:14:31 But, you know, these, these companies, I mean, I think I'm rather sick of all the, you know, the virtual signaling that they've, you know, the comments on Twitter, the comments on social media. You know what it's all about, Andrew? It's about appealing to the pocketbooks of gays and lesbians. 1.00
00:14:51 because you know you've heard of dinks double income no kids although that's changing because 0.72
00:14:56 many gay and lesbians have children now but they see a huge resource there i saw it in the pride
00:15:02 parade many many years ago in toronto pride parade where all the corporate sponsors would be marching
00:15:07 handing out freebies uh beer companies banks whatever one of the banks that actually i find
00:15:15 most obnoxious about oh this is the one i bank at td bank okay i know you are accepting but
00:15:23 everybody forgets about all the abuses around the world and that's what we should that's the fight
00:15:29 we should be having right now because when 70 countries don't allow homosexuality in some form 0.99
00:15:36 we've got a problem yeah i agree and and the problem with that argument i i realize is that
00:15:43 you know, there are gradations in injustice.
00:15:47 You know, you can have a smaller injustice in Canada
00:15:49 and a larger injustice in Uganda.
00:15:51 And I don't think you should have to turn a blind eye
00:15:53 to the smaller one just because there is a larger one.
00:15:55 But I also do think context is important.
00:15:58 And I've heard stories, I've heard interviews
00:16:00 with people who literally faced the death penalty
00:16:03 because of their sexual identity in another country.
00:16:06 And Canada was the place that welcomed them with open arms,
00:16:09 that gave them asylum,
00:16:10 that gave them the right to have, you know, to marry, to live their lives.
00:16:15 And people who do this, I think, have a lot more insight than those who look around and
00:16:23 say that the big problems are if a company doesn't, you know, put up the pride flag or
00:16:27 if a school, a Catholic school doesn't put up the pride flag.
00:16:30 And that's why I don't like the idea that everyone has to have the exact same lockstep
00:16:36 view on this thing.
00:16:38 Yeah, you know, it's interesting.
00:16:40 I think there's a big divide because the big divide in the community now, certainly in Canada,
00:16:45 and I live a charmed existence here in Canada. I married my wife in 2009. We have no issues.
00:16:52 We're accepted as a couple at our synagogue, wherever. In fact, my synagogue just invited
00:16:58 me to a pride service on June 17th to mark Pride Month. I mean, that's how far we've come. But
00:17:04 But there are, I mean, I'm in my 60s, and there are people in my age group and older who had to fight for incredible rights way back in the 80s and 70s and 80s.
00:17:18 And I lived in the closet for 20 years, so I know, I mean, I wasn't fighting, I was hiding.
00:17:24 But the ones who are now gay and living in a very accepting environment, they are the ones who get their noses out of joint with all this stuff. 1.00
00:17:33 they're the ones who engage in mob rule about flags and about you know flags not being flown
00:17:41 at a catholic high school i think people of my generation who had to fight the good fight or
00:17:46 lived in the closet or were afraid to come out they understand the difference they understand
00:17:52 they're more understanding of the it's a complicated you know that complicated decision
00:17:58 sometimes about the intricacies and i absolutely hate the mob rule when it comes to you know
00:18:05 foisting this down people's throats you and i have talked about this in other contexts than just
00:18:10 you know issues to do with sexual orientation and identity but the one thing that strikes me here is
00:18:16 that there is a subset an activist subset whose goal is not just breaking down barriers to civil
00:18:23 rights and general discrimination and even systemic discrimination. But there's a group who
00:18:28 seems they will never be satisfied until every single person doesn't just tolerate, but embraces
00:18:35 every single aspect of this. And by that, I mean, you know, there are people that will never be
00:18:40 comfortable with the fact that, you know, some Christian denominations, Jewish denominations,
00:18:45 Muslim denominations don't respect gay marriage, may view same-sex relationships as sinful. And
00:18:50 And I'm curious what you think about that, because my view, and I say this as someone who's not a member of this community, is that, you know, if you have all of the legal rights available, and generally speaking, I've seen people walking around, even in Calgary last week, you know, gay couples holding hands that didn't seem, to my view, they were being harassed, that if there are individual people in society that are intolerant, that is never really going to go away.
00:19:17 Like, there are still some people, I believe, that are probably uncomfortable with interracial relationships, even though those, I think, have been legal and widely accepted.
00:19:25 And am I being too accepting of intolerance, or do you agree that there's always going to be that, and our goal can't be 100% complete tolerance in society?
00:19:35 Well, there are people who, there are religions, for example, the Orthodox sect of the Jewish religion still doesn't accept really gay marriage.
00:19:46 I couldn't get married in an orthodox synagogue. Islamic religion, most Muslim people do not accept gay marriage. And, you know, this particular Catholic high school you're talking about, our Catholic education center, the York Region Catholic Board, they, you know, they have children who've come to their schools to get a religious education.
00:20:11 it's not that they're not accepting they just don't have to beat the drum about it and I think
00:20:16 the activists expect everybody to beat the drum about it well I the way I feel is I walk with my
00:20:24 wife we do our we live our lives like very normal people like we fight like you know heterosexual
00:20:32 couples we have you know make up like uh heterosexual couples and the fact that no one 0.55
00:20:38 bothers us and no one says anything and no one cares no that's the operative word no one cares
00:20:45 like i don't understand these activists why they have to make a big deal about it they want to yeah
00:20:51 yeah because that to me is the very definition of tolerance if people go around and they don't
00:20:58 care people who say well you know i you know maybe i don't like uh you know this or that but i don't
00:21:02 really care live your life be who you are i mean that because that ideally should be the goal but
00:21:07 but you are right i mean the mob has basically made it where unless you're out there waving the
00:21:12 progress flag you're a bigot well i thought we had reached that you know i thought we had gotten 0.54
00:21:18 over all of that the big fight see what's happened and you know i alluded to it is that i think
00:21:24 there is a real divide between mainstream members of the gay community like myself and my friends
00:21:30 and the radical activists who now are espousing queer theory and much of that relates to gender
00:21:39 ideology and the trans ideology and the organization for example a gal which is right 1.00
00:21:47 across canada and fought for my rights and i'm very appreciative appreciative of what they've
00:21:53 done have now they they have no more fight for lgbt lgb rights now they have to find another
00:22:01 cause and that's what's happened is that all these queer activists they don't have a fight because
00:22:06 you know most of these gays and lesbians uh have rights so it's people of color are more oppressed
00:22:14 trans people are more oppressed i mean you know screaming and shouting uh to me is just
00:22:22 unpleasant it really is unpleasant yeah when you're and the intersectionality you're right 0.51
00:22:28 about here i mean now the idea of you know an upper middle class white gay male couple like
00:22:34 they they're barely they're barely less oppressed than me to some of the activists that say no we
00:22:39 need to prioritize black trans lives indigenous two-spirit lives and all of that and i do think
00:22:45 and you and i have talked about this before adding the t to the lgb has has really muddled this for
00:22:51 a lot of people because it is a very distinct issue with different political consequences
00:22:56 certainly when you're talking about you know gender affirming care for children about women's
00:23:00 only spaces definitely definitely and i think that's the pendulum has swung so far on that
00:23:07 um i mean we could talk for an hour about our feelings about that and i certainly think that
00:23:12 you know what's happening with ramming gender ideology and pronouns out kids throats at the 0.96
00:23:19 age of five, six, seven, I've written a number of stories about that, which is happening in the
00:23:24 school system, is just so inappropriate. It borders on obscene, I think. And, you know, so that,
00:23:31 and many of the mainstream gay people would agree with me, would feel the same way. So
00:23:37 you've got this bunch of activists who are very loud and are making noise and holding everybody 0.92
00:23:47 up to these ridiculous and impossible standards. 0.57
00:23:51 And, you know, it's a bad time, I think, 0.99
00:23:55 because of the division in the gay community.
00:23:59 Sue Ann Levy, my colleague at True North,
00:24:01 thanks so much for coming on and enjoy.
00:24:03 You don't get a month now.
00:24:03 You get a whole season, the government of Canada says.
00:24:05 Oh, my God.
00:24:06 I'm going to be wearing my stripes for months.
00:24:10 All right.
00:24:10 Well, I'm still sticking with the black watch band.
00:24:13 It's the only one I have.
00:24:14 Thanks very much, Sue Ann.
00:24:15 Thank you very much. We are going to turn away from the culture wars for a moment here and go
00:24:22 back to Alberta politics. We talked about this last week. I talked about it for hours and hours
00:24:27 and hours on Monday night in Calgary, where the UCP was crowned victorious in this year's Alberta
00:24:34 election. Danielle Smith returns to the Alberta legislature with another majority government,
00:24:39 albeit a bit more narrow than the one the UCP heading into the election. I want to welcome
00:24:44 into the show here, Chris Sims. She is the Alberta Director with the Canadian Taxpayers
00:24:49 Federation and obviously has been covering this extensively. We saw her with my colleague
00:24:54 Rachel Emanuel on True North. Chris, what are your first thoughts on the election results?
00:25:01 Nice to be on here and it was nice to see you on Monday night, of course, during our
00:25:05 big election coverage. We're pretty pleased with the policies that the UCP was promising
00:25:11 during the campaign. So to back up a little bit, even before the election, the UCP government
00:25:18 passed a law saying that they would have balanced budgets and that they would rein in their spending
00:25:24 and tie it to the rate of inflation and population growth. Now, that's a big deal. It sounds kind of
00:25:31 dry, but it's a really big deal because that keeps the government from just splurging. If they get a
00:25:37 big surplus, if oil is good that year, it keeps their spending in check. It's something that the
00:25:42 CTF has been asking for since the 90s. Like the Backstreet Boys were topping the charts when we
00:25:47 were last asking for this. So we were super happy to see that. They also agreed to seriously pay
00:25:52 down the debt in a big way. So again, this is all law. This wasn't even something they had to
00:25:56 campaign on. They're going to put 50% of their surplus down on the debt every year. That's
00:26:02 really similar to what the late Premier Ralph Klein did when he put 75% down. That's how he
00:26:07 held up that paid in full sign. And so we're really pleased to see the promises that now that
00:26:12 they've made during this election, including things like strengthening the Taxpayer Protection Act
00:26:17 by saying, hey, you know what? If we want to increase your personal income taxes or business
00:26:22 taxes, you need to have a referendum on it first and the government needs to win it. So there's
00:26:29 some pretty serious promises we're seeing so we're pretty happy with that yeah let's talk about the
00:26:33 referendum aspect because stuff like this i i find it is useful in some ways but not in others
00:26:40 because governments that want to get around it can get around it i mean it's not a constitutional
00:26:44 requirement so theoretically a future government could say we're just going to change the law
00:26:48 requiring the referendum and pass the tax on our own but i guess my hope would be that it either
00:26:53 reflects or creates a culture where governments in Alberta do not look at the taxpayers as ATMs.
00:27:00 Exactly. And I think especially in Alberta. Now, I'm a transplant. Our family moved out here in
00:27:07 the summer from British Columbia. And I will say one of the biggest differences I've noticed here
00:27:12 in Alberta is the grassroots activism and how engaged people are. I mean, you can send out an
00:27:20 email with a heads up of like a few days saying, hey, come to this pub in Red Deer if you want to
00:27:25 hear about balanced budget legislation, like the cost of just transition, and 200 people will show
00:27:32 up. Like, it's really remarkable. I've never seen anything like it. And apparently, it's just par
00:27:37 for the course here in Alberta. And what's interesting is that right now, the Taxpayer
00:27:42 Protection Act in Alberta is the reason why we have no PST. It's currently the only element of
00:27:49 the Taxpayer Protection Act. It is that you will have to win, government, a referendum before you
00:27:55 put in a sales tax. Good luck with that. So that's why we have no PST. So we're hopeful that it'll
00:28:01 have that same level of sharp teeth when they expand it. Well, and just on that note of direct
00:28:08 democracy here and of citizen engagement, the Kenney government also passed, I think it was
00:28:12 Bill 52, if I'm not mistaken, which allowed for recall of politicians. And I think even of specific
00:28:18 bills, if I'm not mistaken. So again, you know, there's another level of democracy. If a politician
00:28:23 goes against their word, goes against their promise, there's a very high bar. But there is
00:28:28 a bar nonetheless that groups of people that get together in Red Deer and across the province can
00:28:32 say, no, we are recalling you because you have failed to uphold your mandate to us as an MLA.
00:28:37 That's right. And before that, the only jurisdiction in Canada that had that rule
00:28:41 was British Columbia. And it was used almost successfully one time. Basically, the MLA
00:28:47 realized he was going to get recalled and then quit. And so it worked well that way. And so
00:28:52 Alberta, not to be outdone, did pass that law. But what's really interesting is that they did BC1
00:28:57 better. It's extended to city level too. They did it as a two banger with that law. So now
00:29:04 municipal city councils can get recalled as well. It's a really important tool. Like you said,
00:29:11 the threshold is high. It's not as if you get a couple of disgruntled people in Red Deer somewhere
00:29:16 that they're going to pull down the whole government, but it's that tool in the toolbox.
00:29:21 It's that little tap on the shoulder so that if an MLA or a premier or whatnot, or a city
00:29:26 council or a mayor starts messing around. Exactly. Or exactly. Or a school trustee starts messing
00:29:32 around and getting into hot water. There's that extra, oh man, I could lose my job. But there's
00:29:38 a flip side too, which I find really interesting and fair. It doesn't just fire them. It holds a
00:29:44 by-election so that say there were some group that was really mad about whatever reason and a lot of
00:29:51 people perceived it as being unfair and they fomented this big campaign and they said let's
00:29:56 have a by-election hey if that person's voters and that riding says you know what bob did a good job
00:30:02 we still like bob he can keep his job he just needs to win the by-election and that's happened
00:30:07 in the states in a couple instances so it's a really interesting tool yeah that is actually
00:30:13 an interesting point. And I think it's actually quite a valid one. I mean, there have been
00:30:18 arguments in favor of anyone who crosses the floor should have to be reelected under that party's
00:30:23 banner. And again, I mean, whether there's a legal mechanism that should do that or not is something
00:30:27 that other people can decide. But I don't think there should ever be a case where MLAs lose sight
00:30:33 of what they're there to do. And I feel oftentimes, especially in minority governments, where you
00:30:38 don't have like the sort of Damocles over your head, there can be a very easy way for an MLA
00:30:43 to get there. They've got a four-year blank check. They know that voters aren't going to
00:30:47 start paying attention for maybe another three years so they can do what they want. And certainly
00:30:51 at the federal level, we've seen that. I mean, what's happened when we've given the government
00:30:54 the credit card without a spending limit? Yeah, exactly. It's that, you've probably
00:31:00 seen that cartoon where this, the couple is standing there and Justin Trudeau is running
00:31:03 around flinging money everywhere. And one of them's happy. And then the wife is telling the
00:31:07 husband, he's got your wallet because he's flinging it everywhere. Yeah. I got my climate
00:31:13 action is sent of a few weeks back too and i was like oh money i was like wait wait i already paid
00:31:17 them this is my money exactly it's your money that having been washed through levels of bureaucracy
00:31:23 thank you very much for your donation um but here in alberta we have those swords built in now at
00:31:29 every level of government and so we're really happy about it and you know the reason why we're happy
00:31:34 about it is because the taxpayers federation we're grassroots you know we take you know non-refundable
00:31:39 you know non-receidable donations we don't take money from taxpayers you know we have thousand
00:31:43 supporters across the country most of them are you know small town farmers those sort of folks
00:31:48 and they often will email us with things like you know i i want lower taxes i'm worried about
00:31:54 my neighbors because they're using a food bank like really direct stuff and so to see this kind
00:32:01 of direct democracy and these tools being put in the hands of the people of alberta it's just a
00:32:06 very good thing. I know conservatives, some conservatives, and I use that with the capital
00:32:11 C here, not the lower C, have come to fear the CTF because the CTF is unafraid to call out when
00:32:17 so-called conservative politicians go against their pledges. You know, Aaron O'Toole comes to
00:32:22 mind, you know, running as the big true blue conservative and then all of a sudden find some
00:32:26 weird like air miles carbon tax hybrid to run on in 2021. I know you, like anyone else in media,
00:32:34 has come across Danielle Smith on many, many avenues over the last several years,
00:32:39 when she was in media, when she was a business advocate.
00:32:41 As premier, has she been receptive to the issues that CTF has tried to put forward?
00:32:47 Very much so.
00:32:48 So like you, yes, of course, we've interacted with Danielle personally over the many, many years.
00:32:53 I think actually you were there when Danielle and I were like concocting plans for world domination at Red Lobster or something.
00:32:58 I was sitting right there at the table.
00:33:00 I happen to remember that conversation. And here she is. Premier, can I just take my CTF hat off for just a second? And just as like a human being, it's pretty remarkable. Like this political comeback. She was, you know, all that stuff that happened with Wild Rose, the floor crossing. She lost her seat during that time. And now here we are one year from when I think you and I were talking about this.
00:33:27 And she's elected to a majority as premier. It's a pretty remarkable comeback. And I would say the same thing if she were wearing like a red or orange jersey, just objectively speaking. It's a pretty remarkable comeback politically here in Canada. And so to put the CTF hat back on, yes, she has been very receptive.
00:33:44 Interestingly, one of the first things we did is we asked all of the UCP leadership candidates to sign our pledge, promising, if I'm premier, never, ever a PST.
00:33:55 Uh-uh, not going to happen.
00:33:56 And she signed it right away.
00:33:58 And what's interesting is during the signing, and I hadn't mentioned this to her at all.
00:34:02 It was just her kind of nerding out, as she would put it.
00:34:05 she's signing it and she says hey I really liked the paper you guys did like 15 years ago where
00:34:11 you said if you put enough money into the heritage savings fund we could get rid of an income tax
00:34:16 like wouldn't that be neat in the future I'm just like yeah that would be neat did she write that
00:34:22 on the pledge as well because that might have been a good appendix to uh to try to bring up with
00:34:26 I should have called her on it and said put a writer on that you know yeah yeah exactly but
00:34:30 yeah to you know yes the short answer is yes and even during the election campaign they agreed to
00:34:37 a lot of things like opening up the taxpayer protection act and before that they agreed to
00:34:42 balance budget legislation debt repayment saving money in the heritage fund a lot of the meat and
00:34:47 potato things that the ctf has been asking for there's one little thing if we could push it for
00:34:52 one more thing we would really like to see put in the taxpayer protection act and that's the carbon
00:34:57 tax. So it's going to sound weird, but of course, right now, there's just a federal carbon tax.
00:35:04 What happens if that gets scrapped? What prevents whatever provincial politician is here in Alberta
00:35:10 from creating a provincial one here again? It was awful when Premier Rachel Notley had sprung one
00:35:16 on Albertans, but they got their say-so on that. Now we're forced to pay Justin Trudeau's
00:35:23 mandatory minimum carbon tax. And people here really don't like it. And so we would like one
00:35:28 more change to the Taxpayer Protection Act. And that is to put a provincial carbon tax shield
00:35:34 in there. Yeah, that would be, I think, a very, very good one. And if I have the chance to sit
00:35:39 down with the Premier in the coming months, I'd like to ask that. So do remind me if you get wind
00:35:43 that she's coming on the show. I will. Before I let you go, Chris, I want to ask you about that
00:35:47 Ralph Klein paid in full? Because I think that it's very difficult to unwind government, which
00:35:54 is why putting a PST in place, for example, would become permanent. I just know it. I know that it's
00:35:59 going to become very easy for a government to look at the numbers when something like that was in,
00:36:04 if it were ever in and say, you know, to roll this back would just be too costly. Is it possible to
00:36:10 get back to that paid in full? Or has debt just become such an accepted part of doing business
00:36:16 now as government that there's no real appetite to make those tough calls anymore that's a great
00:36:21 question and again i would say the same thing if the numbers were there for an ndp or liberal
00:36:26 government but here in alberta the debt clock is going backwards like i've never seen it happen
00:36:34 before so rewind about six or eight months or so ago uh the government at the time before the
00:36:40 election, put down the biggest one-time payment on the debt. So they got a surplus, they had some
00:36:46 savings, they had some money to actually use. And instead of just blowing it, now I'm sure they
00:36:52 wasted money on the margins here and there that we haven't found yet, but they put a big chunk
00:36:57 down on the debt. And so now the debt, again, it's an astronomical number, it's around 73 billion
00:37:03 dollars, but it's going down. They're reducing the debt. And they already passed legislation saying
00:37:09 50% of the cash surplus must now go down on the debt, or they'll penalize themselves, or, you know, we're allowed to chase them around in a fibra costume, or I can bicycle lock my neck to their leg. Like, you know, we will make them keep their promises. And so here, debt is on the radar. I don't think that's quite broken through at the federal level yet.
00:37:34 like the the folks in the parliamentary press gallery aren't really paying attention to that
00:37:38 yet but i'll tell you when that debt servicing cost also known as your interest payment on the
00:37:45 federal debt eclipses line items like national defense or health care or something like that
00:37:53 they'll start paying attention then do you guys have i you lived in ontario previously i know so
00:37:58 you may know this do you guys have the uh an alberta equivalent of the ontario opportunities fund
00:38:03 which is this stupid thing in ontario where you can like voluntarily donate your tax refund to
00:38:08 pay down the provincial debt oh which is like mike harris did it and apparently it gets like 0.94
00:38:14 i don't know forty thousand dollars a year or something but i'm like but in alberta i might
00:38:18 actually trust that the government would be responsible with that in ontario i don't i was
00:38:22 never going to give kathleen winn my tax refund or anything here's a bag with no no hole on the
00:38:28 end of it right yeah um but yeah yeah promise but probably um but in all seriousness anyone can make
00:38:36 a donation they would just have to contact the treasury board yeah it's for real find out their
00:38:42 direct deposit or their mailing address and give money to them in fact i don't recommend that ever
00:38:48 no no i'm not but it's like i really believe in alberta and i want alberta to be able to do that
00:38:53 again because it sets the standard for every other province in the country that you don't get to just
00:38:57 run your government and run your affairs on debt and pretend that that's the only way of doing
00:39:01 things. Yeah, exactly. And it's an example I actually give to a lot of folks when I'll be
00:39:06 online or whatever and post something like, hey, we've got tax cuts or reductions here. And they're
00:39:10 like, I'm happy paying more taxes. And I'm like, well, here's the address of Revenue Canada.
00:39:14 Feel free. You know, take my portion. And so we're very hopeful, but we're also practical.
00:39:22 They made a lot of big promises during this campaign. So we're going to have to work really
00:39:27 hard on the ctf side of things to hold them accountable for those promises and we will 0.91
00:39:32 all right chris sims from the canadian taxpayers federation good seeing you monday thanks for
00:39:37 popping in today really appreciate it thank you all right that does it for us for today we've got
00:39:43 to wrap things up there tomorrow we will have a special interview with aaron gunn that you won't
00:39:48 want to miss that's going to be in depth about his new documentary canada is dying which again
00:39:53 has been making waves
00:39:54 and I think is a very important one to watch,
00:39:56 plus Fake News Friday,
00:39:57 and then we'll be back
00:39:58 with regular programming next week.
00:40:00 So thanks to all of you
00:40:01 and have a lovely, lovely afternoon.
00:40:04 God bless and good day to you all.
00:40:07 Thanks for listening to The Andrew Lawton Show.
00:40:09 Support the program by donating to True North
00:40:11 at www.tnc.news.