Juno News - October 03, 2023


Yes, the CRTC is regulating online content

Topics
Mentioned
Liberals' firearm ban leaves Canadian gun retailers in limbo Toronto’s Asylum Seeker Crisis

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

170.74

Word count

7,125

Sentence count

289

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The new Speaker of the House of Commons, Elizabeth May, and the CRTC's takeover of your favourite podcast host's podcast. Also, the government takes control of the internet, and you can no longer access it in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all this is canada's most irreverent talk show just after
00:01:33 one o'clock eastern time here in the nation's capital of ottawa where i am going to be broadcasting
00:01:40 from this uh very nondescript generic ottawa hotel room for the next few days now i don't get too
00:01:47 excited. I'm actually not up here doing anything to do with the show. I'm working on another
00:01:52 project, which I'll have some details about in the near future. The only reason I'm telling you
00:01:57 any of this is so that you don't think this is actually my couch because it is not. Although
00:02:01 a funny thing about this couch, last time I stayed at this hotel was when I was in Ottawa covering
00:02:07 the Public Order Emergency Commission. And I did my show from like the, it was a different hotel
00:02:13 room but i like to say they're all you know nondescript and generic and i did my show from
00:02:18 this very same couch or that room's equivalent and i had the strangest request from a viewer of this
00:02:25 show that wanted to sleep on the couch they thought they would love to be up in ottawa to
00:02:31 cover or see the public order emergency commission as well and thought that maybe it would be a little
00:02:36 cost prohibitive and they could perhaps share my room with me and i try to be a nice easy going
00:02:41 person, but I had to draw the line in the sand there. So this time I'm just showing off by
00:02:46 taking the couch to myself for the purposes of the show today. Actually, a couple of blocks
00:02:51 from where I am, parliamentarians have voted on who the new Speaker of the House of Commons
00:02:57 is going to be. I've got no skin in the game. It to me is like the most uninteresting thing ever
00:03:03 because the Speaker of the House is meant to be bland and uninteresting. And the fact that
00:03:07 everyone knows who Anthony Roda is because of him honoring a Nazi veteran in the House of Commons
00:03:13 is a failure of the institution. The speaker is supposed to be the, I should say the gatekeeper,
00:03:19 I don't even mean it in a negative way, but they're supposed to be just the person that's
00:03:23 there to shepherd things along and be well-liked to everyone. And it was unfortunate that Anthony
00:03:28 Roda, who had done a pretty decent job in that role for however many years he had had it, now
00:03:35 gets thrust out the back door in the way that he did. Although I'd say deservedly, but at the same
00:03:41 time, it's an unpleasant end to an otherwise unblemished tenure. But you know what? I would
00:03:48 love to see Elizabeth May get the gig. Elizabeth May, the Green Party leader, is currently in the
00:03:53 running. And she was like the only one that couldn't be there in person for the speech. She's
00:03:57 dealing with some health issues, she said. So I don't think she's going to get the votes. But man,
00:04:03 would that be entertaining if Elizabeth May were the Speaker of the House. So I actually ran into
00:04:08 a couple of Conservative MPs this morning, and I said, I know you're going to vote for your guy,
00:04:12 the Conservative MP, but it would be great if you could actually put a vote for Elizabeth May as
00:04:19 well. I think Canadians deserve something to that effect, but we will have to see where things go 0.99
00:04:25 there. One thing I wanted to talk about today in a little bit more detail is the CRTC's takeover
00:04:32 of your podcast. Now I spent a fair bit of effort on the show yesterday talking about this and the
00:04:39 reason is this is important. This is the manifestation of Bill C-11 which is the government's
00:04:46 mass takeover of internet content coming to roost. This is not a particularly surprising
00:04:52 development. We've known this was coming but we didn't know exactly what it was going to look like
00:04:57 And why that's so important is that one of the warnings I gave when C-11 first came up,
00:05:03 one of the warnings I gave was that so much was left to the regulation.
00:05:07 So much was left to how the CRTC was going to interpret this law and put it into effect.
00:05:14 So we didn't actually get to see the full scope of what C-11 was going to do when the
00:05:19 bill was being discussed, debated, and eventually passed.
00:05:22 The announcement that came out just like on a Friday before a long weekend, which is
00:05:27 always how you know they want to bury it, was the CRTC putting out its requirement for podcast
00:05:32 networks and streaming services to register. Now, they had a few criteria. You have to operate in
00:05:39 Canada, which simply means you have to be accessible to Canadians. It doesn't have anything 1.00
00:05:44 to do with where you're headquartered or registered or where your CEO lives. It is,
00:05:49 are Canadians able to access it on the internet? Which basically means yes, because we do not live
00:05:54 in a repressive North Korean style dictatorship, at least not yet. The other part is that you have
00:05:59 to have $10 million in revenue. Now, I've spent a fair bit of time going back and forth with some
00:06:05 people on Twitter about this, because this is kind of being used by the government and by supporters
00:06:12 of what the CRTC is doing as an excuse to say, we're not going after the little guys. We're not
00:06:17 going after independent content creators. We're just going after companies that have
00:06:22 $10 million. We're just going after companies that have $10 million in revenue. Now, this is
00:06:30 impossible, impossible to separate from individual content. It's impossible to separate from
00:06:38 individual content. And the reason for this is because if you are a streaming service or a
00:06:44 network that offers podcasts, like let's be real here, the government is saying streaming service
00:06:50 because they're going to make you think about Netflix and Crave and all of that.
00:06:53 But when they say that, they also include any website that offers podcasts.
00:06:58 So that's Apple Podcasts, that's Spotify, that's Amazon, which has a podcast division,
00:07:03 all of these different outlets.
00:07:06 How can you offer to people a regulation of networks without offering regulation of the
00:07:15 content on those networks, the content available on those streaming services?
00:07:20 And that's the part that the government is leaving out here.
00:07:23 Pascale Saint-Ange, who's the new heritage minister, she has the unpleasant task of defending this legislation,
00:07:29 has tweeted out as though this is just like this perfectly fine, hunky-dory thing.
00:07:34 Oh, the Online Streaming Act is just giving you more Canadian stories.
00:07:37 It's supporting Canadian music, television, and cinema.
00:07:41 It gets global streamers to pay their fair share.
00:07:45 So they want Mr. Beast to pay his fair share, I guess, or something like that.
00:07:49 No, they're not just talking about Netflix and YouTube and Amazon and Spotify.
00:07:55 They're talking about anyone whose show is available on those platforms.
00:08:00 Let's just take the politics out of this entirely and focus only on the ideas that the government's using here.
00:08:10 Let's just take them at face value that this is about more Canadian content.
00:08:14 Well, all of a sudden we're talking about manipulating Canadian content.
00:08:18 On YouTube, it's easy to see how this would happen.
00:08:20 YouTube manipulates its algorithm.
00:08:22 They have to serve up a certain quota of Canadian content.
00:08:25 It's going to be government-approved Canadian content, of course,
00:08:28 and they want to include in that diverse voices and all of that.
00:08:32 But you also have beyond that the question of what it's going to look like on podcasts.
00:08:38 So right now, if you go on to Apple Podcasts,
00:08:41 which perhaps you've done to get to this show,
00:08:43 you'll see a whole laundry list of recommendations.
00:08:46 Maybe for Black History Month, they say, here are black podcasts, or for Pride Month, they say, here are gay-themed podcasts, or in general, they say, well, you might like true crime, so here's a true crime series, or something else you might like.
00:09:00 Okay, well, that's all fair and reasonable that they're trying to tailor their selections based on what they think people are going to like.
00:09:07 Well, now government's coming in and saying, you have to serve up a certain amount of recommended content that we like.
00:09:15 I joked yesterday about like the non-binary Franco-Indigenous quota or something, which
00:09:20 you know some variation of is going to exist.
00:09:24 But what's happening here is the reality of this.
00:09:28 The reality of this is that government is going to be picking and choosing winners.
00:09:32 So sure, maybe the government is not saying under C-11, the CRTC is directly regulating
00:09:38 the Andrew Lawton show.
00:09:40 but make no mistake by regulating the platforms on which this show relies to get to its audience
00:09:49 the government is regulating this show in the same way it's regulating Joe Rogan. Joe Rogan
00:09:56 one of the most popular podcasts in the world if not the most popular podcast in the world
00:10:01 it's not Canadian content so it's going to be on the losing end of this regulatory environment
00:10:08 so yes the CRTC is absolutely regulating content because they're regulating what content can be
00:10:16 accessed how content can be accessed that's exactly what they're doing here and they're
00:10:22 doing all of this while trying to tell us that they're not that's what's so disingenuous about
00:10:28 it and I'm afraid to say some people have bought into this hook line and sinker you take for
00:10:34 example, this one tweet that I try not to get into Twitter scraps, but Billboard Chris, who's a guy
00:10:40 who I know many of you may know because he walks around with a sandwich board with a slogan about
00:10:44 gender ideology and hormone blockers and stuff like that for kids. Billboard Chris was actually
00:10:50 taking aim at a lot of people in his own audience. He said, if we don't have freedom of speech in
00:10:54 Canada, why am I not in prison? Why am I free to say whatever I want, whenever I want, wherever I
00:11:01 want in defense, in defiance of what our government wants. And there was another long
00:11:05 tweet he shared in which he took aim at those who take essentially the conclusion I'm taking
00:11:10 from the Online Streaming Act. And I responded to say two things. First off, it's incredibly
00:11:16 facile to make the point that because I'm not in jail, we have free speech. To use the gender
00:11:24 comparison, that's like saying, because my son or daughter has not been put on hormone blockers,
00:11:30 no one in Canada is, which is I think incredibly disingenuous. And beyond that, it's also quite
00:11:36 ridiculous to not realize that there are degrees of censorship. There are degrees of freedom of
00:11:42 speech. You do not have to look at an environment in which we have North Korean style repression
00:11:47 to see that there are myriad restrictions on freedom of speech and freedom of expression
00:11:52 in Canada. These come about in a number of ways through human rights commissions and their
00:11:56 regulations through internet regulations, like we're seeing with C-11 and C-18 and the Future
00:12:03 Promised Online Harms Act, and through other means that we see. And I should point out that
00:12:09 the fact that you can distinguish the First Amendment in the United States, which has a
00:12:14 very rigid and ironclad defense of free speech, from the Section 2B Freedom of Expression Rights
00:12:20 in Canada, which are qualified by the so-called reasonable limits section of the Charter of Rights
00:12:27 and Freedoms. The fact that these two constitutional protections are different on the surface, on the
00:12:32 face, and in application shows that there is just between Canada and the U.S., not even looking
00:12:37 anywhere else in the world, a lesser free speech protection in Canada than exists in the United
00:12:44 States. Now, someone may say this is defensible or justifiable. I'm not even having that debate
00:12:49 right now. I'm just saying that it is completely foolish and wrong to say that we have complete 0.87
00:12:55 free speech in Canada and to use as the basis of evidence the sole claim that Billboard Chris is
00:13:00 not in jail. Billboard Chris is not in jail, ergo there is free speech in Canada. Now interestingly
00:13:06 enough, I was walking around Ottawa this morning and Ontario has this law that prohibits you from
00:13:12 demonstrating within a certain radius of an abortion clinic. And this was a law that was
00:13:19 put in place directly in response to pro-life protesters that were advocating against abortion
00:13:24 in and around abortion clinics. And in Ottawa, there's a clinic that's been the site of a great
00:13:29 deal of these protests on Spark Street. So you can actually see on the streets, there are signs
00:13:34 saying that you cannot protest inside that zone, that if you're on one side of the sign,
00:13:40 you're fine if you're on the other side you're not now as it happened this morning i saw this
00:13:45 lovely looking older woman i didn't speak to her but she was sitting down and she had a sign that 1.00
00:13:50 was and i to be honest i didn't even read the whole sign but it was to do with faith and abortion and
00:13:55 she was just sitting there quietly not minding her own business had she been across the street
00:14:00 she would have been arrested 100 she would have been arrested she would have spent time
00:14:06 in jail. Maybe she would have gotten a fine, but she would have because other people have. 1.00
00:14:11 So it is not actually fair to say that you can say whatever you want, wherever you want,
00:14:16 whenever you want in Canada. And again, some people may agree with that. You may say, well,
00:14:22 that's a reasonable restriction. We're not debating reasonableness. It is a restriction
00:14:27 on free speech. Anything after that is a matter of degrees, which is why I do take things like
00:14:35 what the CRTC is doing very seriously. This is a body which has existed throughout its history to
00:14:41 regulate airwaves, which are a public good. There is only a finite amount of radio frequencies,
00:14:48 of television frequencies. And I get that you need a regulator, a bureaucracy to start divvying that
00:14:53 up. And I get that you need to have some compliance, especially on technical issues.
00:14:58 The United Kingdom is a great example of what happens when you start adding a much more aggressive
00:15:03 and content-focused mandate to their telecom regulator.
00:15:09 Ofcom, as it exists in the US, does in fact regulate content.
00:15:13 The CRTC does not.
00:15:15 And that has not directly changed under C11,
00:15:18 but we're seeing a creep in that direction.
00:15:20 When they start talking about all of these qualitative things
00:15:23 that we need more of, beyond even simply Canadian content,
00:15:26 but specific forms, showcasing diversity, all of that,
00:15:30 There is a lot to take issue with in this bill. I want to welcome to the program here,
00:15:36 Peter Menzies. He is a former vice chair of the CRTC. Peter, it is always good to talk to you.
00:15:42 Thanks for coming back on the show. Thanks for having me. Always a pleasure.
00:15:45 Let me just go back to that distinction between Canada and the UK here. Has there been an active
00:15:52 push within the CRTC to try to have a more expansive mandate on content historically?
00:15:57 um i'm not quite sure what you mean by that expansive mandate on content they do regulate
00:16:03 content the the crtc does that it's through conditions of license and it's done you know
00:16:08 transactionally as you were saying as i caught the end of what you were saying you know that's
00:16:13 fair it's a the spectrum is a crown asset it's it's a limited resource uh the state has every
00:16:19 right to decide how it's used on behalf of canadians and when people apply for a license
00:16:24 they accept certain terms and conditions and one of those is that they will conduct themselves in
00:16:29 a certain way on air and in you know comply with things like the code of conduct for the Canadian
00:16:35 Broadcast Standards Council which at the end of the day can be appealed to the CRTC. So the CRTC
00:16:41 tries to keep has tried to keep a long arm on that content regulation but it is there because the
00:16:47 Broadcasting Act compels it to make sure that the system is, to use its terms, I believe it's high
00:16:56 standard, which is about as subjective as you can get. Yeah, but I mean, that right there is what I
00:17:01 was referring to in that, you know, in the UK, they don't really have their equivalent with as
00:17:07 much power as the Broadcast Standards Council, which I think has probably helped the CRTC keep
00:17:11 its nose clean on really getting into the nitty gritty where a lot of these large broadcasters.
00:17:17 And then you bring this into an internet context and we're taking this regulatory authority and putting it over what has been a space that is not completely unregulated.
00:17:26 You know, laws that exist elsewhere in Canada still exist on the internet, but you don't have that core requirement there of a limited public good that needs to be regulated as such.
00:17:38 Yeah, and that was one of the big problems I found in last week's decisions by the CRTC
00:17:43 was that they were making decisions like about online news organizations, online news,
00:17:49 and the other one that caught the eye was pornography or adult content, right?
00:17:54 And the reasoning was that, well, it wouldn't be fair to leave those guys unregulated
00:18:01 when the guys within the license system are regulated.
00:18:06 and that makes no sense at all to me because like i was saying if you're inside the license system
00:18:14 you it's a transaction you get the license and when you get the license you also get you know
00:18:19 you take on these responsibilities and you take on these conditions of license but you also get
00:18:24 protected you get you there's all kinds of benefits that come with a license in the
00:18:30 unlicensed area you're going to get the same regulation but where's your benefit 0.88
00:18:34 yeah i think that's a tremendously important question here and you know right now a lot of
00:18:42 the defenders of this are i think being very short-sighted they're talking about effectively
00:18:47 oh well all they're doing is asking for their name and phone number and address but it's like okay
00:18:52 to do what with it's basically to have the point of contact when they start expanding these
00:18:57 expectations and requirements i i think and it's not benign no it's not and and it's it's it's
00:19:04 funny how people can just shrug that off. All they're asking for is your name and phone number
00:19:08 and address, right? If you were walking down the street and an officer of the law came up and asked
00:19:12 you your name and phone number and address, right? That's, I mean, I don't want to over-exaggerate it,
00:19:17 but that's a papers, please society, right? I mean, it really is. I mean, it can sound benign
00:19:24 and it can be benign, but it can also be, you know, a bridge that you don't want to cross,
00:19:32 Right. Particularly when you're it's unclear to me as to what the benefit is of it occurring and what.
00:19:43 And just to go back to the limited public good aspect, because not only is there, you know, there are only so many radio stations that you could have conceivably because of the laws of frequencies.
00:19:54 But but even within radio programming and television program, you have programming, you have 24 hours in a day.
00:20:01 So I can understand and I would question whether Canadian content regulations are relevant today, but I could understand, OK, we have this many hours a day.
00:20:10 You need to devote a certain aspect of it to Canadian content.
00:20:12 The Internet is finite or is infinite, as we were talking about.
00:20:17 And by that, if you want to access Canadian content, you have it available to you.
00:20:22 If you want to access American content, if you're an immigrant that wants to access content from your home country or in a foreign language, you have all of that right.
00:20:30 And I've yet to hear from the government a compelling reason for how Canadian content is being underserved by the Internet.
00:20:40 There isn't really a compelling reason.
00:20:42 I mean, we went through this discussion a bit with Bill C-11 in terms of that, especially when people were talking about all we're trying to do is make sure that Canadian content is discoverable on the Internet.
00:20:54 Well, there's something called a search tool, right?
00:20:57 And all you have to do is open up your Netflix app, go into the search tool and type Canadian or type Canada and all kinds of stuff comes up, right?
00:21:07 So they're not really talking about giving people the ability to discover that.
00:21:12 What they're talking about is forcing the discoverability on people.
00:21:17 And that means suppressing the discoverability of other people.
00:21:21 So you end up with a favored group getting, you know, getting bumped up on your feed online and the less favored groups getting less exposure.
00:21:36 So, you know, you'll still be able to be free to do what you want to do, but your ability to find an audience for what you're doing will be impaired because of the government's preference for different types of content over others.
00:21:49 Yeah, I think that's a tremendously important point you raise, because one of the big challenges here is that it is like one's gain has to be at another's loss. If you assume that there's only so much space on the Netflix homepage, on the YouTube homepage, certain content has to be downgraded. And these tech companies, whatever criticisms you may wish to level at them, of which many have come from me, they are pretty attuned to their viewers as businesses.
00:22:18 They've invested millions of dollars in fine-tuning the algorithms and what people want and what they're going to respond to.
00:22:24 And this bill, by design, is a manipulation of that.
00:22:28 And I can't remember, I think it was Pablo Rodriguez a while back when he was still, the minister was saying that, you know, this isn't going to manipulate any algorithms.
00:22:36 No, but it's government forcing these companies to manipulate their algorithms. 0.98
00:22:40 Yeah, Ian Scott, the past chair of the CRTC, said that exactly.
00:22:45 senator pamela wallen asked him said sort of said well you're not exactly regulating but you're
00:22:50 you're re-regulating through the platforms right and he said yep that's exactly right we're not
00:22:58 we're not going to tell you what to do with your algorithm we're just going to tell you the outcome
00:23:01 we want and then we'll talk about how you do that in terms of your licensing so that's exactly what
00:23:06 happened the sad part about that too is that because because you know youtube and these other
00:23:12 products or sort of are global products if you if you monkey with those algorithms here and people
00:23:19 don't get the sort of visibility they they they want within canada that has an impact on their
00:23:26 opportunity to have visibility in global markets and the the best way for canadian producers of
00:23:32 any kind to make money like serious money is to have access to global markets i mean there's
00:23:38 There's 120 million Anglophones in India, right?
00:23:44 I mean, there's 350 million of them just next door.
00:23:49 Like you can get an audience of 30 million people in Canada,
00:23:53 or you can expand and have access to an audience of 350 million next door,
00:23:59 you know, speaking English.
00:24:00 And, you know, and we're choosing to build a wall between that
00:24:05 to make it more difficult.
00:24:07 I mean, I get the idea that you want to promote Canadian content, but there's ways to do that without hurting Canadian content and its global opportunities as an outcome.
00:24:17 Well, I was chatting about this a little yesterday with Chris Sims. I mean, the amusing part of this, I mean, it's not really amusing, I guess, if you think about it, is that the government would, I think, vehemently reject other countries blocking off the import of Canadian content.
00:24:33 Because I think, you know, the Canadian government would love nothing more than for more Canadian cultural exports, more shits creeks of the world that will achieve popularity overseas.
00:24:42 but if other countries were to do what canada has done that would never happen and you basically
00:24:47 become uh very siloed where denmark will have danish content predominantly and canada will
00:24:53 have canadian content predominantly and that really is the very opposite of what the internet
00:24:58 has ushered in that is good it is it is exactly the opposite i mean and that that's the big
00:25:04 difference that doesn't seem to have sunk in with the department of heritage at all on it
00:25:07 i really worry that they don't seem to understand the internet and the opportunity of it right
00:25:12 It's like with the Online Streaming Act, I get that there might have been concerns in, you know, in Quebec about francophone funding and that sort of stuff in the long run.
00:25:21 OK, but if they need more money, just give them more money.
00:25:24 But, you know, the Canadian film and television industry, its last 10 years have been has been it's been just flourishing.
00:25:32 They've had great years.
00:25:34 They've had the best years in their history.
00:25:35 And even the production of Canadian content is at record high levels.
00:25:40 but they still wanted to bring in this regulation because they were worried about
00:25:44 Canadian content. The problem is mystical at this stage, right? And you are now risking
00:25:53 bringing to an end this decade of incredible prosperity, all because of some political
00:26:01 manipulation. Like I said, I think the core issue was probably, you know, Francophone content,
00:26:07 that they weren't getting as much funding
00:26:09 as was coming through the private sector to Anglophone.
00:26:13 I get that.
00:26:14 But if they need a leg up
00:26:15 and the government wants to help them,
00:26:16 just give them more money, right?
00:26:18 You don't need to redo the whole internet
00:26:20 and create all these problems
00:26:24 and all this regulation to fix that problem.
00:26:27 We've seen with Bill C-18, the Online News Act,
00:26:30 what happens when these big tech companies decide
00:26:33 it's not worth their while to comply with legislation.
00:26:36 As a result, True North and countless other media outlets in Canada cannot share their content on Facebook.
00:26:42 We've heard this week that Google and the government have not really been able to reach any resolution on this.
00:26:48 So I don't know whether we're going to see a response like that from any of the players when it comes to streaming.
00:26:54 I'm curious if you think any will respond that way.
00:26:57 I mean, surely for a Netflix, there's enough of a Canadian market that it's worth complying in some way with this,
00:27:03 especially if it doesn't really cost them anything.
00:27:05 but do you see some c18 style response from any of the big players yeah i think that's certainly
00:27:11 possible um not so much necessarily from the big players although it is possible from say at disney
00:27:17 plus um and you know for reasons in addition to this this legislation in terms of how they're
00:27:24 positioning themselves but at a certain point you know this is interesting for the crtc because in
00:27:30 all of its hearings in the past it's everybody in the room pretty much everybody in the room
00:27:35 has a CRTC license or wants a CRTC license. They're all dependent on the CRTC. So all that
00:27:42 really is happening in the room is you're negotiating the terms of that relationship,
00:27:45 but the relationship is locked in. You are married to the CRTC. When it comes to now with
00:27:53 this next hearing, there's going to be a whole bunch of people in the room who have the option
00:27:58 just to leave. And that creates an entirely new dynamic. And I'm really, really curious to see
00:28:04 how the crtc is going to like respond to that because there will be people there who can say
00:28:10 well sure if you do that well then we'll have to you'll have to look at it from a business point
00:28:14 of view and some of the smaller streamers particularly could look at it and say you know
00:28:19 you know what i mean all this regulation and all this sort of stuff and if we have to make a
00:28:23 contribution into this fund and that sort of stuff you know there's a there's a anglophone
00:28:29 market of just over 30 million people it's not that big it's just not worth it right and they'll
00:28:34 just leave and they'll take their most popular shows and they will sell them most likely to crave
00:28:40 so this will work very well for bell if if that works because then they'll become an aggregator
00:28:46 of all these smaller channels britbox like i mentioned is is is one so i'm not saying nobody
00:28:54 can say what will happen because you don't know but it's certainly possible and they'll just do
00:28:58 a business analysis on it and say, okay, we'll just sell some stuff into Canada, but we don't
00:29:03 need to stream in Canada. And so Canadians will have us be living in a smaller world. 0.82
00:29:09 Well, it's an interesting dilemma you bring up. I mean, one that I've been trying to
00:29:12 sort of goad into this debate is Daily Wire in the US, which operates its own streaming service
00:29:19 for content behind a paywall. They've got Ben Shapiro and Jordan Peterson. It's a more conservative
00:29:24 of a line network, obviously. So I don't think it's particularly keen to do Justin Trudeau's
00:29:30 bidding. But beyond that, it's an outlet that would have very little interest in the Canadian
00:29:35 market. And it's probably not worth their time to focus on compliance with Canadian regulations.
00:29:41 So you take the Daily Wire as one example, and there are probably others that you could point
00:29:45 to in Australia or the UK or Europe that just do not invest in Canadian government relations or
00:29:51 compliance because it's so minuscule to them. And I'm wondering what will happen because a lot of
00:29:56 these organizations may not even think to register. And if they do, they may think that it's not worth
00:30:01 their while. Does the CRTC even have the capacity right now to start going after any outlet around
00:30:09 the world that doesn't register that under the letter of what they're doing operates in Canada
00:30:14 by virtue of being accessible here? Yeah, I'm still trying to figure that one out because I was
00:30:18 I was asking a couple of colleagues this morning
00:30:20 in anticipation of being asked that question,
00:30:23 how can they find out who makes $10 million in Canada
00:30:27 and who doesn't, right?
00:30:29 So like, I mean-
00:30:30 And does it have to be 10 million from Canada
00:30:32 or can it be just 10 million?
00:30:34 Because the way I read it,
00:30:35 it just said if they have revenues exceeding 10 million,
00:30:37 I wasn't even sure if it was geographically limited.
00:30:40 I think that maybe stands to be clarified as well.
00:30:44 But I mean-
00:30:45 But even so, how do they know?
00:30:47 how are you going to tell if i mean let's let's just assume that it's 10 million dollars in
00:30:51 revenue that you draw from canada that you are because it it sort of says you are active in
00:30:55 canada and you have revenues so it it probably needs to be clarified but let's let's assume
00:31:00 it's 10 million dollars and how do you find out right like um and and who wants to find out who
00:31:06 wants to sort of when you don't register does that mean everybody knows how much money you're not
00:31:11 making um you know you know that sort of stuff so i think the 10 million was a real mistake i think
00:31:19 they should have had a much bigger number in part to make life easier for everybody at least starting
00:31:24 down this path of internet regulation but secondly the whole purpose of this act was sold to
00:31:29 everybody is this is just about my getting money from web giants so go get my coat so what now you
00:31:35 make 11 million bucks that makes you a web giant like i don't i don't i don't get that at all so
00:31:41 Anyway, I don't know yet how they would find out, like if you don't register, how they would find out about you.
00:31:47 If they do find out, they have fairly limited powers at this point, but they would have to go to federal court and get a court order forcing your compliance.
00:32:01 They've done that in the past with other groups that are supposed to register that have refused to register, but they don't have a big hammer they can bring down on you.
00:32:10 So this could, you know, that gets immediate action.
00:32:13 So this is something that could drag on for years.
00:32:16 Well, and also, I mean, if we are talking about a player that's completely non-compliant
00:32:21 for whatever reason, you know, inevitably you have one tool in the toolkit, which is
00:32:26 block Canadians from accessing this.
00:32:29 You know, the government would have to.
00:32:30 And that's a road that I would hope no government wants to go down.
00:32:35 Yeah, you'd have to, you'd end up going to court to get a federal court to issue a
00:32:40 blocking order to isps yeah that says that you you may no longer show andrew lawton's show uh
00:32:47 you have to don't give them any ideas peter you have to get my 10 million i promise you
00:32:52 no you have to you have to block that right because they are non-compliant and that sort
00:32:56 of stuff and that gets you know that is really really draconian when you when you have to get
00:33:02 into that right so i think people's willingness to register i mean there will be a number of people
00:33:08 who will do so very nervously um and everybody says well right now you're just being asked to
00:33:13 register and that sort of stuff but no you're not you're being asked you're being asked to walk
00:33:19 through a door and you don't really know what's on the other side and that makes people nervous
00:33:24 and it'll it'll have a negative impact on investment it'll have a negative impact on
00:33:29 growth just as it has just as the facebook ban has had uh on news has uh you know had people
00:33:35 put expansion plans and growth plans on hold because everybody's right now it's two months
00:33:42 we're two months in and everybody's trying to get in the calculator out and trying to figure out
00:33:46 how much this has cost them so far and you know where are we at where you know how does this
00:33:50 impact our budget for this year do we have to where do we have to cut back do we have to cut
00:33:54 back can we make it up someplace else you know that's what you create when you do this and it
00:33:59 can go on for years and it does real harm especially at a time when we need a lot of
00:34:04 creativity. We need a lot of investment. We need to adapt to a new world. Yeah, very, very well
00:34:10 said. Peter Menzies, always a pleasure. Keep up the fantastic work on this. Really appreciate your
00:34:14 time. Thanks very much for your interest. Always happy to help. Take care. All right. Thank you
00:34:18 very much. Hopefully, again, you can still access this podcast. We haven't been taken offline just
00:34:23 yet. But I think the point that I made in my monologue is the enduring one of this show,
00:34:28 which is that if you're regulating the services people need to access podcasts, and I'm talking
00:34:33 about podcasts, but it's all content, all shows, you are regulating the shows themselves because
00:34:38 you are regulating which are worthy of being seen and which are not. And again, if we follow this
00:34:43 through to its natural conclusion, government has to be prepared to go and fight for a kill switch
00:34:49 to block access to certain sites, whether it's the Disney Plus or the Daily Wire or the Britbox or
00:34:55 whatever the case is, which is incredibly, incredibly authoritarian in nature. And I'm
00:35:02 not saying that Canada is on par with North Korea. I'm not making that claim, but I'm saying
00:35:07 that it is a government control of content, a government control of what people can say and
00:35:12 see online, which is absolutely egregious. We are going to move on from this for now. As I said,
00:35:18 we'll continue following this story. I'm especially keen to see if there is any movement, if any of
00:35:23 the free speech crusaders, people like the rumbles of the world will step up and speak out against
00:35:29 this. I think a lot of them are probably trying to look at what is actually expected of them,
00:35:34 what is actually required of them. But I do want to turn our attention to this. Now,
00:35:39 I mentioned just in passing at the beginning of yesterday's show that it was on the weekend,
00:35:43 the National Day for Truth and Reconciliation. Trudeau, I don't believe, went surfing in Tofino,
00:35:50 so he's learned his lesson after that first year. Conservative leader Pierre Polyev,
00:35:54 like a lot of MPs, decided to take the day to meet with some Indigenous leaders. He
00:35:59 posted this photo, which was him having a very somber moment with a woman by the name of Manitoc
00:36:05 Thompson. She is an elder who is Inuit, and she was at this event with Algonquin elders. Now,
00:36:14 at first, people looked at this tweet and decided it was worthy of dunking because, 1.00
00:36:19 oh, Pierre Polyev's an idiot. He's meeting with Algonquin elders, he says in the tweet, 1.00
00:36:23 but she's Inuit, and she's well-known, and you're such a moron. One of the people saying this 1.00
00:36:28 was Mark Miller, who is the Minister of Crown Indigenous Affairs for the Liberal government,
00:36:34 who decided to poke a little bit of fun at Polly Eve's expense here. He says in tweets of his own
00:36:41 that, oh, well, it's an opportunity for learning and growth. And for example, you might want to
00:36:46 know that this is not actually an Algonquin woman and so on. This was picked up in an article
00:36:52 written by the Canadian press that was not framed around anything other than trying to take this
00:36:58 weird Twitter dunk and convert it into real news. The Canadian Press story,
00:37:05 Polyev called out for tweet caption on Truth and Reconciliation Day photos with Inuk Elder.
00:37:11 Now, you may know Pierre Polyev from time to time likes to scrap with the media. This morning,
00:37:17 a reporter from the Canadian Press asked Pierre Polyev about, she asked him about the notwithstanding
00:37:22 clause in Saskatchewan, which is a perfectly legitimate question to ask, but he was more
00:37:27 interested in getting his shot fired at CP. Before I go any further, I think, you know,
00:37:33 CP is here today. CP conducted itself with great unprofessionalism over the weekend in
00:37:40 regurgitating a false tweet from a Liberal minister to politicize Truth and Reconciliation Day.
00:37:49 Really unfortunate that CP would allow itself to be used in this way. You know, it was really,
00:37:55 I want to say it was a beautiful, touching ceremony that I was able to participate in with Algonquin leaders.
00:38:01 The reason we didn't put the pictures of that ceremony is because based on their traditional custom,
00:38:08 photography is not allowed.
00:38:10 And so out of respect for them, we did not photograph that ceremony.
00:38:14 Instead, we photographed other Inuit leaders and an Inuit knowledge keeper in particular
00:38:19 who was present and who also participated in the Algonquin ceremony and we did so with great
00:38:27 respect and this knowledge keeper has now taken issue with both CP's story and Mark Miller's
00:38:33 appalling politicization of the truth and reconciliation day. I think CP should stop
00:38:38 acting as the communications arm of the PMO. That was the claim. I don't even think he
00:38:43 eventually got around answering the question. He just sort of moved on from there and I should say
00:38:47 the reporter in question who asked him that question is a very, very good reporter. And I
00:38:54 think in her case was probably a little frustrated because I was actually curious about his take on
00:38:58 the notwithstanding clause in general, but he was displeased with CP's coverage by a different
00:39:05 reporter on that photo. Now you may wonder, okay, well, let's put the Indigenous woman at the center
00:39:09 of this. We're told we should make space for Indigenous voices. Well, she was none too pleased
00:39:15 with Mark Miller's attempt to hijack the narrative here. Manitok Thompson, a rather well-known Inuit
00:39:22 elder who tweeted out in response to Mark Miller, at least I'm not a Nazi. Yeah, you go girl. And
00:39:30 she also tweeted later on about how she had tried to stand as a liberal and the liberals didn't want
00:39:37 her as a candidate. And she said, yeah, you know, where were all the liberals here? I would have
00:39:40 loved to have seen them, but it was the conservatives that showed up. So talk about a little attempt at
00:39:45 a dunk backfiring there, Minister Miller. That does it for us for today. We'll be back tomorrow
00:39:51 with more of Canada's most irreverent talk show. Big red couch. I was going to say big red comfy
00:39:56 couch, but I can assure you after sitting on this for 40 minutes, it is not comfy. So maybe I'll
00:40:01 like find a different spot in the room tomorrow from which I do the show. But I wanted to like
00:40:05 give you like, I can see the Supreme Court out the window, but then you just have, I'd be in
00:40:09 silhouette, which come to think of it, I'd probably look better in silhouette than I do with the light
00:40:13 head on. So I'll figure that out for tomorrow, but we'll talk to you then. Thank you. God bless
00:40:18 and have a wonderful day. Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:40:23 Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:40:43 We'll be right back.
00:41:13 We'll be right back.